ကူးယူချက် 🔗
WEBVTT
00:00:00.000 --> 00:00:04.900
So Mike, to borrow from the famous X/Twitter post prompt.
00:00:05.320 --> 00:00:08.179
What is happening question mark exclamation mark
00:00:10.240 --> 00:00:17.429
What is happening is that we have this new podcast out and it turns out that it's a lot of work to do a podcast.
00:00:17.679 --> 00:00:19.519
So I'm kind of exhausted.
00:00:20.850 --> 00:00:21.440
Me too.
00:00:21.559 --> 00:00:23.339
what, what is happening?
00:00:23.489 --> 00:00:25.550
Question mark, exclamation point, with you?
00:00:25.660 --> 00:00:44.465
Yeah I too, am Finding the world of a content creator, in audio form pretty, invigorating but also tiring Um, but yeah, I think this week i'm super interested in how content moderation actually might be having a bit of a mini renaissance and we'll talk about that in a bit
00:00:44.465 --> 00:00:44.825
What?
00:00:45.604 --> 00:00:46.435
Incredible.
00:00:46.450 --> 00:00:47.390
How could that be?
00:00:57.359 --> 00:01:30.069
Hello and welcome to Ctrl-Alt-Speech your weekly roundup of the major stories about online speech,, content moderation and internet regulation This week's episode is brought to you with financial support from the Future of Online Trust and Safety Fund and by today's sponsor Block Party We've got a great chat with Tracy Chou in our bonus chat later on today and she'll be talking about the impacts of harassment on users on platforms and how it can lead to self censorship and what she's doing about it, particularly around how she thinks about privacy and safety setting.
00:01:31.118 --> 00:01:50.293
She has a really interesting kind of little fun anecdote about her tool being a privacy conscious techie best friend Which is something that I have been referred to myself and but would always always like one more of in my life Which is a nice segue, I think On to introducing my co host for today's podcast, Mr.
00:01:50.293 --> 00:01:53.034
Mike Masnick from Techdirt, how are you doing today, Mike?
00:01:53.813 --> 00:01:54.924
I am doing very well.
00:01:54.924 --> 00:01:58.513
You say that as if I am only the co host for today.
00:01:59.683 --> 00:02:01.353
And always, thankfully,
00:02:03.304 --> 00:02:03.623
Yes,
00:02:03.834 --> 00:02:04.623
please don't leave.
00:02:07.103 --> 00:02:07.683
I'm doing well.
00:02:07.683 --> 00:02:08.243
How are you?
00:02:08.463 --> 00:02:08.894
I'm good.
00:02:08.933 --> 00:02:09.463
I'm good.
00:02:09.574 --> 00:02:09.894
Yeah.
00:02:10.283 --> 00:02:12.584
For those who are listening for the first time today, I'm Ben Whitelaw.
00:02:13.264 --> 00:02:19.114
I'm the founder and editor of Everything in Moderation, which is a newsletter about trust and safety and content moderation.
00:02:19.514 --> 00:02:21.644
And, uh, yeah, Mike, we're in this together.
00:02:21.644 --> 00:02:22.424
Don't worry about it.
00:02:22.723 --> 00:02:24.713
I'm here for the, I'm here for the ride.
00:02:25.993 --> 00:02:26.713
Okay, good.
00:02:28.563 --> 00:02:32.433
But yeah, I mean, the first episode of the podcast came out last week.
00:02:32.433 --> 00:02:34.454
This is the second one that you're now listening to.
00:02:34.484 --> 00:02:40.614
If you are just listening to this and you didn't listen to the last week's, I think, I think you can still go back and listen to it.
00:02:40.614 --> 00:02:41.683
I think it's still relevant.
00:02:42.183 --> 00:02:50.193
We're, you know, we're, we're keeping it newsy and, and, and specific to the week, but I, I, I don't think that it's gone rotten in just seven days.
00:02:50.213 --> 00:02:54.834
No, no, I think that we did well in that regard.
00:02:54.883 --> 00:02:57.024
The TikTok story is still alive and well.
00:02:57.394 --> 00:03:07.484
and um, as we'll find out later on, you know, the EU is, is taking aim at other Chinese platforms which they deem to be of a significant size to regulate.
00:03:07.493 --> 00:03:09.174
So it's all good stuff still.
00:03:10.074 --> 00:03:11.354
Yes, yes, yes.
00:03:11.674 --> 00:03:14.493
And I think we really appreciate everyone who's been listening.
00:03:14.544 --> 00:03:17.014
And we've had really great response.
00:03:17.014 --> 00:03:21.604
We've gotten some really great feedback, including that Ben was too quiet on the last podcast.
00:03:21.633 --> 00:03:23.984
So Ben, be louder.
00:03:24.653 --> 00:03:27.804
lean in to quote Sheryl Sandberg, lean in.
00:03:27.984 --> 00:03:31.813
And, uh, you gave me some great advice, Mike, which is eat the mic.
00:03:32.253 --> 00:03:36.294
And so I'm, I'm, I'm full, I'm full of mic right now.
00:03:36.574 --> 00:03:38.883
And hope, hope people can hear us.
00:03:38.984 --> 00:03:41.403
And particularly me in this episode today.
00:03:41.403 --> 00:03:43.554
So thanks for the feedback, everyone.
00:03:43.554 --> 00:03:43.623
Excellent.
00:03:45.163 --> 00:03:58.524
And if you are listening to this I, I hate to do this because I am just sort of naturally inclined not to be self promotional, but as everybody tells you on every podcast please go rate review.
00:03:58.734 --> 00:04:00.403
And subscribe to the podcast.
00:04:00.403 --> 00:04:01.834
So it helps us.
00:04:01.843 --> 00:04:02.283
It helps.
00:04:02.283 --> 00:04:05.903
If you like the podcast, it does help get it more attention elsewhere.
00:04:06.163 --> 00:04:11.493
So depending on the platform that you're on there are usually options to rate and review it.
00:04:11.864 --> 00:04:15.313
Apple podcast is the main one and apparently the most important one.
00:04:15.334 --> 00:04:22.689
So people tell me if you like the podcast, please go rate, review and obviously subscribe to the podcast.
00:04:22.689 --> 00:04:23.449
It really helps us out.
00:04:23.569 --> 00:04:24.028
Definitely.
00:04:24.329 --> 00:04:32.959
And if you, leave a particularly good review whether it's, whether it's bad or positive, we may even read it out on the podcast in the future.
00:04:33.209 --> 00:04:38.168
That's our promise to you,
Load full transcript
write a well crafted, interesting review and it may even feature.
00:04:38.319 --> 00:04:38.769
How about that?
00:04:39.668 --> 00:04:41.699
Ooh, such promises.
00:04:42.879 --> 00:04:43.098
Great.
00:04:43.119 --> 00:04:45.358
Let's dive in there, Mike, enough of the preamble.
00:04:45.629 --> 00:04:47.908
We've got a couple of big stories today to talk through.
00:04:48.178 --> 00:04:56.149
One kind of US legal story as was the case last week and a big platform story for us as well.
00:04:56.149 --> 00:05:07.199
We're going to start as really the week did with the story you've been looking at the Murphy oral arguments and, I'm trying to keep tabs on the importance of this case.
00:05:07.624 --> 00:05:17.853
And i've been reading a bunch of analysis on it But can you talk us through kind of what it is and why it's important first of all before you try to read the runes and what this is all gonna mean
00:05:19.358 --> 00:05:20.309
Yeah, this was a big case.
00:05:20.309 --> 00:05:25.619
It was heard in the Supreme Court on Monday and when the case was initially filed, I didn't think it was that important.
00:05:25.619 --> 00:05:30.949
In fact, I thought it would just be tossed out of court really quickly because The framing of the case was kind of silly.
00:05:30.949 --> 00:05:47.238
And it was this idea that was originally brought by two states Missouri and Louisiana against the Biden administration claiming that they were censoring people online by convincing social media to censor conservatives is the way it was framed.
00:05:47.478 --> 00:05:50.038
The whole setup of the lawsuit was weird too.
00:05:50.038 --> 00:05:51.968
And, and that there are questions about.
00:05:52.298 --> 00:05:54.428
Are the states being injured here?
00:05:54.689 --> 00:05:58.519
Do they even have, you know, what's known as standing to actually bring this lawsuit.
00:05:58.838 --> 00:06:39.774
They sort of tried to fix that by throwing in a bunch of anti vaxxers, um, as, as co plaintiffs in the lawsuit to say who, who did get, you know, either had content pulled down or were suspended briefly from various social media platforms to, to make the case, Acceptable under the law, um, there were some weird things to where, you know, part of the lawsuit also blamed the Biden administration for the very brief decision by Twitter to block links to a New York Post story about Hunter Biden's laptop, which occurred when the Biden administration did not exist because it was the Trump administration at the time.
00:06:40.134 --> 00:06:43.233
So it felt like sort of an odd thing to, claim in the lawsuit.
00:06:43.434 --> 00:06:47.434
And that was just sort of like the beginning of the problems of the lawsuit.
00:06:47.463 --> 00:06:54.584
And it's sort of loose understanding of like, what is truth and what is factual, but the, the.
00:06:54.733 --> 00:07:04.403
Underlying concept behind the lawsuit is actually a really interesting and somewhat thorny legal question, which is especially in the U.
00:07:04.403 --> 00:07:04.553
S.
00:07:04.553 --> 00:07:09.733
Context where we have a First Amendment that says, the government cannot do anything.
00:07:09.774 --> 00:07:12.423
That is an attempt to suppress speech.
00:07:12.774 --> 00:07:15.283
That where is the line?
00:07:15.579 --> 00:07:18.788
Between persuasion and coercion by the U.
00:07:18.788 --> 00:07:18.939
S.
00:07:18.939 --> 00:07:30.418
government, I think most people recognize that the government can speak out on its own opinion about something that they think is problematic or bad that that needs remedy of some sort.
00:07:30.988 --> 00:07:45.134
They can't take legal action if it is specifically like to, to try and suppress speech, you know, there is this sort of questionable line of what happens when they threaten a private actor to take action.
00:07:45.584 --> 00:07:54.024
And the classic Supreme Court case on this is a case called, known as Bantam books, where you had basically like.
00:07:54.369 --> 00:08:19.829
This commission on, you know, obscenity, I forget the exact, uh, and I haven't read the band of books case in a while, but like the, you know, the basics of it was like this commission on obscenity would send these semi threatening letters to booksellers about books that they had and, and basically say like, Hey, this is, this is potentially obscene and, and effectively pressuring the company, the book, the bookshops to pull those books.
00:08:21.024 --> 00:08:24.783
And the Supreme Court found that that was a violation of the First Amendment.
00:08:25.204 --> 00:08:43.438
But it was never quite clear, and there was never a very defined test of, where is the line between just going out and publicly saying, we don't like these books, versus going to the store and saying, if you don't take these books, off the shelves, you're going to be in trouble.
00:08:44.989 --> 00:08:50.089
And there have been other cases that have, have dealt with this, but none of them have created a really, really clear test.
00:08:50.408 --> 00:08:52.068
And so it would be interesting.
00:08:52.109 --> 00:09:02.708
And in an ideal world which we do not live in, it would be really nice if the Supreme court showed up and said, here's the test to figure out what is persuasion, which is allowed.
00:09:02.708 --> 00:09:08.698
The government is allowed to use what's called this bully pulpit to go and talk about these things and try and convince you.
00:09:08.803 --> 00:09:15.933
And what is not allowed as coercion, which is we are threatening you and you're going to be in trouble if you don't do what we say.
00:09:16.244 --> 00:09:20.374
And so this whole space is known as jawboning.
00:09:20.583 --> 00:09:26.854
And you know, it's the government jawboning the, the companies to do what they cannot do under law.
00:09:27.144 --> 00:09:39.994
And the history of jawboning and the term has a sort of biblical references, which we don't need to get into, but So it'd be really nice
if the Supreme Court came down with like a clear rule and a clear way to figure this out.
00:09:40.004 --> 00:09:42.823
The problem with this case is that it is a total mess.
00:09:42.833 --> 00:09:50.053
And I already got to some of why it was a mess because of like, you know, Hunter Biden laptop issues and anti vaxxers and all this kind of stuff.
00:09:50.364 --> 00:10:06.999
But part of the big problem is that, you know, the Supreme Court It, they just sort of throw a whole bunch of stuff into the pot and say, you know, the government was mad about like covid misinformation which they were, and then, and different aspects of the government spoke out about it.
00:10:07.389 --> 00:10:13.119
Then also we know that different administration officials met with.
00:10:13.793 --> 00:10:30.673
Social media companies in particular, like the FBI had some regular meetings, which as has come out, we're generally about like foreign influence campaigns, like, you know, Russian attempts to, to influence the election or whatever, where the FBI would have some information and they would share it with social media.
00:10:30.864 --> 00:10:38.443
And very clearly shared in the form of you know, we have identified these accounts as Pushing Russian misinformation.
00:10:39.283 --> 00:10:40.333
Do what you want with it.
00:10:40.413 --> 00:10:45.874
Like very, very clearly not threatening them or, or saying anything, but saying, you know, do what you want with it.
00:10:45.884 --> 00:10:47.774
See if it violates your policies, basically.
00:10:48.293 --> 00:10:55.158
And then there were the fact that there were like the anti vaxxers who became plaintiffs in the case who had Content moderated in some form or another.
00:10:55.499 --> 00:11:11.328
And so they, the, the, the case sort of throws all that into a pot and says, because of a, B and C because of administration mad because of meetings and because of people getting suspended, therefore we can say that those suspensions were because the government told these companies to suspend it.
00:11:12.428 --> 00:11:24.433
Nowhere in any of, and there's thousands and thousands of pages of evidence that was thrown into this case, nowhere could they find anything that was effectively like This account, you must take down.
00:11:24.933 --> 00:11:38.634
There were a couple of things where they took comments completely out of context, or in some cases deleted words from sentences and some other cases added words to sentences, which seems really problematic to try and make that case.
00:11:38.653 --> 00:11:43.043
You know, the, the, one of the most egregious ones that I saw was two government officials.
00:11:43.364 --> 00:11:55.344
Francis Collins and Anthony Fauci, who are both semi famous, were upset about a public declaration about COVID treatments and stuff that was, was, you know, questionable.
00:11:55.344 --> 00:12:01.614
And Collins emailed Fauci and said, we need a published takedown of this.
00:12:01.793 --> 00:12:09.693
As soon as possible and was clearly saying it read in context, like somebody needs to respond to this and we need to publish it and, and promote it.
00:12:09.994 --> 00:12:14.453
And in fact, like Fauci responded with a link to a wired articles like this kind of does it.
00:12:14.833 --> 00:12:18.864
But in the, in the hands of the plaintiffs in the court, they removed the.
00:12:18.864 --> 00:12:29.244
Published part of published take down and just said, we need to take this down, take, we need a take down of this, implying that they wanted it to be removed from social media, which was, which was clearly not the case.
00:12:29.514 --> 00:12:31.224
There were a number of these kinds of examples.
00:12:31.224 --> 00:12:37.394
And so my fear going into the, into the, the oral arguments that the Supreme Court was, that they would not see this.
00:12:37.394 --> 00:12:40.514
And, and certainly, you know, the Supreme Court has become somewhat politicized.
00:12:40.514 --> 00:12:41.624
You may have heard, uh,
00:12:42.964 --> 00:12:43.663
just recently.
00:12:44.563 --> 00:12:45.553
yeah, yeah.
00:12:45.614 --> 00:12:45.823
yeah.
00:12:45.823 --> 00:12:46.933
It's just a bit of an issue.
00:12:47.173 --> 00:12:47.533
Uh.
00:12:47.714 --> 00:12:57.793
So the, so the oral arguments then, so the case is, is not, not very good in the first place, but what, take us through kind of what happened in the oral arguments of Mundo then.
00:12:59.058 --> 00:12:59.448
Yeah.
00:12:59.499 --> 00:13:05.418
And so, you know, my fear was that it was, it was going to be, everyone was going to assume that these things had actually happened.
00:13:05.609 --> 00:13:07.369
In which case the case is pretty clear.
00:13:07.369 --> 00:13:14.078
Like if the things that, that they claimed happened, happened, it feels like it probably should be a violation of the first amendment.
00:13:14.379 --> 00:13:31.078
And thankfully, like it felt like most of the justices actually did recognize that, that, and, and in fact, the deputy solicitor general who argued the case for the U S He effectively said very early on, like, if we were suppressing speech, that would be a first amendment violation.
00:13:31.389 --> 00:13:33.099
The problem is we weren't.
00:13:33.349 --> 00:13:43.859
And so then there were, there were a bunch of interesting discussions and a lot of it gets really into the legal weeds, which we don't necessarily need to do in, in, in the time that we have here, but there was a lot of skepticism.
00:13:44.173 --> 00:13:47.303
From the variety of justices across the political spectrum.
00:13:47.303 --> 00:13:50.533
So it wasn't, it didn't fit neatly along political lines.
00:13:50.793 --> 00:13:58.673
And in fact, you had like Brett Kavanaugh and Elena Kagan, who it very interestingly that both of them had been White House lawyers in the past.
00:13:58.673 --> 00:14:07.464
So had experienced being a part of the executive branch saying like, wait, like we would call
up reporters all the time.
00:14:07.678 --> 00:14:15.359
And like urge them not to run a story or tell them, like, you wrote this story and you got this, this and this wrong.
00:14:15.369 --> 00:14:16.589
Like, don't do that again.
00:14:17.178 --> 00:14:20.538
Like, like saying that kind of thing should be allowed.
00:14:20.538 --> 00:14:21.839
Like we weren't threatening them.
00:14:21.839 --> 00:14:24.139
We were just telling them we thought they got the story wrong.
00:14:24.509 --> 00:14:26.499
And how is this any different than that?
00:14:26.918 --> 00:14:35.573
And the, you know, The person who was defending the case from the state side, who is Louisiana's solicitor general, who was only recently appointed to the job.
00:14:35.573 --> 00:14:42.124
And I think this sort of fell into his lap and maybe he wasn't all that prepared for it really kind of struggled with, with those examples.
00:14:42.124 --> 00:14:55.553
And, and also really struggled with the test question because you know, as I said at the beginning, like it would be really nice if the Supreme Court gave us a really clear test so we could tell where's that difference between persuasion and coercion.
00:14:55.778 --> 00:15:00.759
And and multiple justices asked him, you know, what test, what test are you giving us to, to use?
00:15:01.129 --> 00:15:08.668
And all he would say is like, well, my test flows from the first amendment, which is not an answer because that's not a test.
00:15:08.668 --> 00:15:25.234
And so like a bunch of hypotheticals were thrown around and a bunch of different different things and he was really I think ill prepared for, for the argument and then was really ill prepared for the fact that multiple justices called them out on, on factual errors.
00:15:25.234 --> 00:15:32.793
I mean, Sonia Sotomayor was the most vocal who said, you know, directly, like, I have problems with your brief counsel.
00:15:32.923 --> 00:15:36.394
Like, you know, you, you have things here that are wrong.
00:15:36.403 --> 00:15:43.323
You have people saying things that they didn't say you have, you know, you don't show any, any You know, real connection.
00:15:43.333 --> 00:15:51.903
At one point you complained that like, you know, people were upset about this, but the, the actual moderation happened to that person's brother, not them, like it
00:15:51.948 --> 00:15:57.589
They, they do, they do say that misinformation often comes from the top and this is a really good example of that again, isn't it?
00:15:59.043 --> 00:16:00.193
yeah, yeah.
00:16:00.193 --> 00:16:03.173
I mean, there's a lot of misinformation happening around this case.
00:16:03.173 --> 00:16:10.543
And so it was interesting to, to see the, the justices call that out and sort of be skeptical of, of the state's arguments.
00:16:10.578 --> 00:16:10.938
Okay.
00:16:11.119 --> 00:16:11.448
Okay.
00:16:11.519 --> 00:16:17.719
So that's kind of your feeling as to where it all goes at the this this will be thrown out
this one.
00:16:17.808 --> 00:16:18.178
Yeah
00:16:18.524 --> 00:16:26.203
I, so I think the worst possible solution of them buying that all this really was happening is unlikely to happen.
00:16:26.553 --> 00:16:29.754
That still doesn't mean like there's a whole bunch of nuance in here.
00:16:29.764 --> 00:16:34.604
And obviously when you get around the first amendment, there's a, there's a lot of details and nuance that are really important.
00:16:34.894 --> 00:16:41.649
And there's all sorts of like stray random things that could be said in an opinion that cause all sorts of Damage down the road.
00:16:41.958 --> 00:16:45.609
And so I'm not convinced that the Supreme Court won't screw stuff up in that way.
00:16:46.038 --> 00:16:51.339
There won't be, there won't be some like offhand line that they don't realize how much damage they're causing.
00:16:51.548 --> 00:17:03.234
But I, I came out of it comfortable that at least a large group of the justices sort of recognized the problems of the case and hopefully won't, make the world worse in their final opinion.
00:17:03.278 --> 00:17:16.798
okay And and just before we kind of move on you talked you wrote piece on Techdirt about The case itself and you had a line in there about how you generally think that government officials Are they often get away with jawboning?
00:17:17.078 --> 00:17:26.028
And they kind of pass across the line a little bit on this But you didn't even explain why you thought that can you give a little bit as to why you think that that is the case
00:17:27.243 --> 00:17:27.644
Yeah.
00:17:27.653 --> 00:17:38.683
You know, I, I, as a general believer in, in the first amendment, and I realized like, you know, we have a global audience, but, but in the U S context, I actually do think the first amendment works very, very well.
00:17:39.003 --> 00:17:46.403
And that the government's job is not to be not to be compelling or suppressing speech in any way.
00:17:46.433 --> 00:17:52.743
And, you know, it is that question of that line between persuasion, which they are free to do.
00:17:52.753 --> 00:18:02.963
But as soon as it crosses that line and gets to, gets to a point where it is threatening or it is threatening retaliation for speech, I think that creates real problems.
00:18:02.963 --> 00:18:08.564
And some of those are just in, you know, silencing important speech that that should be heard or.
00:18:08.814 --> 00:18:22.963
You know cracking down on dissent and, and you can see how that kind of thing, you know, just pick the, whichever politician you trust the least and, and think of what happens when that power is in their hands and you can see where it becomes really problematic.
00:18:22.963 --> 00:18:40.608
So, you know, even if I agree that the, you know, certain websites didn't handle COVID misinformation or vaccine misinformation very well, you know, I don't think that the government has any place in threatening to punish the companies for that, because I think that leads to really dangerous and problematic results.
00:18:40.608 --> 00:19:00.269
And just as one really quick example, and I know we have to move on, that, you know, early on in the pandemic, there was a Chinese doctor who raised the issue of COVID before, you know, before it was even named COVID before all of this, who was really, you know, ringing the alarm bells and saying, we have this disease that is spreading like crazy and it's very contagious and very dangerous.
00:19:00.558 --> 00:19:04.078
And Chinese officials were just like, no, you know, this is bad.
00:19:04.088 --> 00:19:06.939
And like went to his house and forced him to make an apology.
00:19:07.338 --> 00:19:11.179
And he then a few weeks later caught COVID himself and died.
00:19:11.634 --> 00:19:18.003
If he had been allowed to speak out, you know, we might have recognized the risk and dangers of COVID earlier.
00:19:18.284 --> 00:19:18.973
It's a counterfactual.
00:19:18.973 --> 00:19:27.763
We don't know exactly what would have happened, but it was basically, you know, about three weeks, he started speaking about three weeks before the rest of the world realized that COVID was this real threat.
00:19:28.243 --> 00:19:32.443
And, you know, that is an example of you crack down too hard on certain speech.
00:19:32.689 --> 00:19:35.689
You know, it can lead to really, really dangerous results.
00:19:35.729 --> 00:19:37.939
The ability to speak is, is, super important.
00:19:38.429 --> 00:19:43.028
and and in a one word answer Do you have a good test?
00:19:44.378 --> 00:19:47.058
Lined up do you have you cracked the test question?
00:19:48.878 --> 00:19:53.808
You know, I really do think it has to come down to this, this question of, is there any threat?
00:19:55.368 --> 00:19:59.638
that could be an implied threat or an explicit threat, but there has to be a clear threat.
00:19:59.919 --> 00:20:07.209
And, you know, when it's clear that you are just providing information and saying like, Hey, we found these, these things, do what, do with it what you want.
00:20:07.358 --> 00:20:09.548
That doesn't seem to imply any, any threat.
00:20:09.959 --> 00:20:17.898
But you know, there's, there, there are many, many law review articles to be written on exactly how to, how to tune that.
00:20:17.949 --> 00:20:21.229
And so I'm not going to do that in the five seconds we
00:20:21.398 --> 00:20:21.689
Yeah.
00:20:21.719 --> 00:20:22.239
Okay fair.
00:20:22.489 --> 00:21:02.588
Great, so that that's really helpful overview and we will probably touch on issues of jaw burning in the future let's switch gears now and talk about I guess the other kind of major story in terms of Technology at least and to an extent platforms this week, which was reddit's ipo so really really big story in the context of silica valley and the first ipo Since 29 other social media companies since 2019 You Kind of signals a whole bunch of things in terms of the way that, the, the appetite of investors for
technology companies in 2023, a time where, you know, things aren't really going well economically.
00:21:02.878 --> 00:21:18.469
But I really want to zoom in on a story that was published by the New York times and a journalist there called Kevin Roos, which was entitled Reddit's IPO is a content moderation success story, which if you've been covering content moderation and online speech for as long as we have Mike.
00:21:18.903 --> 00:21:24.854
That's something that's going to get you reeled in right that I was instantly I instantly pricked up my ears.
00:21:24.894 --> 00:21:30.223
I was like, there's very few Sentences that combine the words content moderation and success story,
00:21:31.209 --> 00:21:31.378
Yes.
00:21:32.054 --> 00:21:32.884
uh, at least in my
00:21:32.959 --> 00:21:34.249
Exactly my reaction.
00:21:34.653 --> 00:21:47.013
um, so it's a really good piece to read we'll include it in the show notes, obviously, but basically kevin kind of Unpacks how the success of reddit's ipo this week where it was valued at 6.
00:21:47.013 --> 00:21:53.703
4 billion 34 dollars a share And ended the day 48 percent up.
00:21:54.144 --> 00:22:11.064
So making a whole bunch of initial investors, you know, really, really happy and really successful that he has tied back to this long standing battle on the platform for a kind of healthy and less toxic environment.
00:22:11.074 --> 00:22:35.618
He's, he makes the case, interestingly, that Reddit's turnaround is down to A whole bunch of decisions made by the platform to clean itself up and he kind of charts this this kind of era of you know from the the days where there was a whole bunch of non consensual speech on the platform from A time where there was, you know creep shots being posted.
00:22:35.618 --> 00:22:37.098
There was jail bait.
00:22:37.108 --> 00:22:51.743
There was all kinds of Harm and issues on the platform where it was really renowned as a place for kind of weirdos and geeks not even you know, not even probably 10 years ago To being a cleaned up slightly more sanitized version of that.
00:22:52.153 --> 00:23:01.023
I wouldn't say he was completely completely addressed But he you know, it has got better in many regards I I use reddit from time to time.
00:23:01.023 --> 00:23:10.273
I'm not a massive user, but I can see that even myself and he makes the point that advertising revenue has soared In particularly the last few years as well.
00:23:10.884 --> 00:23:11.463
It's gone up.
00:23:11.923 --> 00:23:39.888
It's trebled in in the last three years and Increased 20 last year alone according to the information so The fact that it's been cleaned up that the fact that there's some of the harms that we've seen in the kind of early You know, 2010s have been addressed has been, has mean that advertisers have really returned to the platform and it's looking like it's, that's really helped his IPO and Kevin puts it down to three reasons, which I'll just briefly go onto.
00:23:40.388 --> 00:23:46.868
He said that the decision to kind of get rid of subreddits back in the day has really proven successful.
00:23:46.888 --> 00:23:47.558
So the
00:23:47.903 --> 00:23:50.344
They were harmful, harmful, subreddits
00:23:50.548 --> 00:23:50.858
subreddits.
00:23:50.909 --> 00:23:51.068
Yeah.
00:23:51.088 --> 00:23:52.338
Ones that were causing an issue.
00:23:52.749 --> 00:23:57.923
And Of which there are kind of countless examples, including ones connected to former U.
00:23:57.923 --> 00:23:58.074
S.
00:23:58.104 --> 00:23:58.804
Presidents.
00:23:58.903 --> 00:24:01.644
But there was, you know, anti Muslim hate at various points.
00:24:01.644 --> 00:24:55.199
There was Russian misinformation at various points, and they took the decision to kind of get rid of those to kind of cut cut the cut the monster off at the at the neck, basically, and it also did a whole bunch of work around empowering moderators via tooling and allowing additional people Guidelines to be applied to subreddits which I think made the moderators feel More like it was their space not just the platforms And then kevin makes the point that it it didn't try to be a kind of politically neutral Online arena, so he didn't try to kind of appease republicans and also appease democrats when it got rid of subreddits He didn't try to kind of address that on the other side either so He makes the point that these kind of three areas were basically the reason why it has You Has kind of been able to IPO in the first place and I think it's you know, I have I have a few Kind of views on this.
00:24:55.509 --> 00:25:23.949
I don't know if the picture is as as rosy as Kevin makes out I think if you've been tracking reddit's Tracking reddit's time Particularly the last five years and some of the stories have been coming out It has not looked like this at all and I was somewhat surprised and and it seems like media and and the finance media in particular was really surprised about how Transcribed Well, it performed on the first day, What did you think about the kind of kevin's piece mike because I know you read it as well
00:25:24.894 --> 00:25:25.354
Yeah.
00:25:26.034 --> 00:25:34.213
You know, it was interesting and it sort of drew me in for the same reason because it's so rare to see anything, you know, that says success and content moderation, as you said.
00:25:34.894 --> 00:26:03.479
But, you know, it's surprising because, you know, yes, like Reddit had, you know, it went public, it was, you know, 6 billion and it had the first day pop that, that you always expect to see, even though, you know, technically first day pop is, is all money that is left on the table because it's, it's investors trading it, not, not, you know you know, not the equity holders of the, of the earlier things, but also like the history of Reddit is so bizarre and it's, it's unlike many other companies in that it's been around for almost 20 years.
00:26:03.828 --> 00:26:06.358
It's, it's not your standard
IPO story.
00:26:06.759 --> 00:26:20.098
And there were all these other problems with it that, you know, that the company had, including that, like, yes, it went public at over 6 billion, but like the last time it was it had a valuation was 10 billion.
00:26:20.459 --> 00:26:24.118
So this is technically a down round, which is not good.
00:26:24.118 --> 00:26:26.239
And it doesn't usually speak of a.
00:26:26.638 --> 00:26:28.088
Success story.
00:26:28.459 --> 00:26:41.298
Also the company has never been profitable in the, you know, all of the years that it has been around, it has lost money every year and their predictions on how much revenue they were going to make were not met.
00:26:41.648 --> 00:26:44.709
And it's growth story has really flattened.
00:26:44.709 --> 00:26:45.929
Like it's not growing.
00:26:46.278 --> 00:26:50.064
There are all of these things that say like, you know, it's not a.
00:26:50.203 --> 00:26:53.584
Great company for, for a variety of reasons.
00:26:53.983 --> 00:26:57.834
And so I really didn't, didn't see the success story part of it.
00:26:58.084 --> 00:27:02.064
That's not to say that it's not an interesting content moderation story.
00:27:02.064 --> 00:27:12.763
And there are a whole bunch of really interesting things about how it is a, a, you know, it's a different content moderation story than the one that is most commonly heard of, which is.
00:27:13.239 --> 00:27:14.719
Totally centralized systems.
00:27:14.719 --> 00:27:30.179
And we're sort of used to the Facebook, Instagram, Twitter model of like a centralized trust and safety team has to handle this stuff and read it really did present a different way that it can be done where you have some element that is centralized, which is just sort of like the most egregious cases.
00:27:30.179 --> 00:27:32.558
We're going to block these certain things.
00:27:32.699 --> 00:27:33.608
And then you have.
00:27:33.874 --> 00:27:38.163
The, the other ones that are like, we're going to hand power off.
00:27:38.183 --> 00:27:42.203
We're going to push it to the edges to these volunteer subreddit moderators.
00:27:42.433 --> 00:27:43.433
Though it's interesting, right?
00:27:43.433 --> 00:28:07.618
There's also like the whole fight last year in which they sort of, you know, cut back API access and one of the big complaints from many of the moderators was that that broke a bunch of the tools that they use to moderate these, these subreddits and made, made it, Possible to really moderate, you know, as volunteer moderators to moderate some of the larger, more rowdy sub subreddits that were out there.
00:28:09.219 --> 00:28:16.989
So, you know, I, I I'm confused as to where the, where the successes, other than the fact that they went public
00:28:17.469 --> 00:28:17.798
I think
00:28:17.989 --> 00:28:21.278
and, and, if it also, it just feels.
00:28:21.979 --> 00:28:29.388
You know, the content moderation aspect of it feels kind of disconnected from the you know, from the IPO.
00:28:29.398 --> 00:28:32.259
Like, I don't, I don't see how those stories are actually connected.
00:28:32.314 --> 00:28:51.473
Yeah, I mean, there's some interesting posts on X slash Twitter by a reporter called Scott Nova about how the, the kind of storyline around the moderation of Reddit was really going to depend on how well the IPO fared.
00:28:51.933 --> 00:29:05.884
And he made the point that You know, if, if it went well, then, then the kind of community would be buoyed and particularly the 75, 000 moderators and core users that it.
00:29:06.314 --> 00:29:12.183
Opened up the ability to kind of buy shares for in the course of the ipo would be really happy, right?
00:29:12.413 --> 00:29:40.088
and that was a really clever really clever thing that it did because it it Averted this idea of the volunteer moderators feeling like they were just a kind of cog in in the big reddit wheel in the big in the big machine and so it's kind of empowered the moderators to earn this success From the ipo to kind of buy into what happened and and he made the point that Actually, if it went badly, who knows what could have happened?
00:29:40.439 --> 00:29:54.459
You know, we've had blackouts on Reddit before 2020, you might remember there was like 800 subreddits, which signed a letter in support of better policies around white supremacy and hate speech.
00:29:54.578 --> 00:30:04.318
And a whole bunch of them, you know, basically stopped moderating and closed so that no one could see the content or join or, or leave, you know, leave comments.
00:30:05.023 --> 00:30:06.634
And that's the power that they hold.
00:30:07.074 --> 00:30:19.963
It's only because the IPO went well and, you know, that pop was a pretty significant one, that you didn't have moderators losing money or, becoming disenchanted with the fact that the IPO happened.
00:30:20.804 --> 00:30:28.223
And so, again, I agree with you to an degree that there's, it's not quite the success story that I think Kevin's painting.
00:30:28.604 --> 00:30:31.634
Basically, Reddit did enough to IPO.
00:30:32.574 --> 00:30:41.584
Basically it was it made itself a better version of itself, but it I don't think it's something that we We should be aiming for as the
00:30:41.759 --> 00:30:41.999
Yeah.
00:30:42.473 --> 00:30:48.443
as the kind of pinnacle of online speech And platforms like I think that's something that we probably want to call out, right?
00:30:49.398 --> 00:30:49.788
Yeah.
00:30:49.798 --> 00:30:53.028
I mean, I think there are lessons that can be taken from, from what Reddit has done.
00:30:53.028 --> 00:30:59.528
And I actually think there's some stuff in the way Reddit is set up that is really interesting for the decentralized space, even though Reddit is a very centralized platform.
00:30:59.898 --> 00:31:01.699
I think, you know, the approaches that.
00:31:01.759 --> 00:31:07.038
That Mastodon and, and Blue Sky are taking, there are actually some really interesting lessons from Reddit.
00:31:07.278 --> 00:31:10.489
But I, but yeah, success story, I'm not sure I would go that far.
00:31:10.614 --> 00:31:30.038
Yeah, I agree and I think you know steve huffman the ceo one of the co founders will get a lot of credit for this You know, he's in charge at this point in time, but you know previous ceos have had a really You Rough time and you know being chased out of the platform for by its users and
00:31:30.318 --> 00:31:30.919
yes.
00:31:30.979 --> 00:31:34.880
For some of, for some of these varied decisions, you know, and, and.
00:31:35.483 --> 00:31:40.304
You know, and and also just the idea that like advertisers came because of these decisions.
00:31:40.554 --> 00:31:41.844
I'm not convinced that's true.
00:31:41.844 --> 00:31:49.703
I mean, I think the company has always struggled to have like a really useful and and and valuable advertising platform.
00:31:49.703 --> 00:31:50.943
And in fact, that's true today.
00:31:50.943 --> 00:31:53.913
That's why it doesn't have that much revenue, why it's not profitable.
00:31:54.273 --> 00:31:59.854
And so, you know, I think I think that story is not really connected to the content moderation story, though.
00:32:00.203 --> 00:32:03.923
Obviously, like there are issues around like if you don't do it.
00:32:04.098 --> 00:32:04.868
Content moderation.
00:32:04.868 --> 00:32:14.868
Well, like advertisers will stay away from your platform, but I'm not sure it's clear that that the advertisers that Reddit does have is because of the decisions they made on, on the content moderation side.
00:32:14.939 --> 00:32:15.239
Yeah.
00:32:15.719 --> 00:32:21.368
And let's see if the if the pop crackles and and dissipates over the over the coming weeks.
00:32:21.368 --> 00:32:28.759
I think that will this story won't necessarily be concluded, you know, we might we might see a bit of a backlash if if things do take a turn
00:32:29.739 --> 00:32:29.999
Yeah.
00:32:29.999 --> 00:32:30.348
We'll see
00:32:31.148 --> 00:32:37.378
great so As Listeners all know from last week, Mike, we've done our two major stories of the week.
00:32:37.378 --> 00:32:42.358
We're now do, gonna do a bit of a quickfire roundup of other stories you've been reading and a little bit
00:32:42.368 --> 00:32:43.138
quick as we can.
00:32:43.138 --> 00:32:45.058
a little bit about why they're interesting too.
00:32:45.509 --> 00:32:46.798
You had a interesting one.
00:32:46.798 --> 00:32:55.019
We were talking about it before we started on Twitter and, uh, the shocking news that Twitter might be providing a, a cover for Nazis.
00:32:56.078 --> 00:32:57.578
Well, it's not Twitter anymore, Ben.
00:32:58.919 --> 00:33:00.209
I can't, I can't stop it.
00:33:02.429 --> 00:33:23.128
Yeah, so there was this crazy story this week where, you know, some people had, had worked out who there was a, a legitimately neo Nazi cartoonist who goes by the name Stonetoss who was publishing, you know, just absolutely awful, terrible you know, racist, horrible cartoons and people were trying to figure out who they were, who he was.
00:33:23.128 --> 00:33:28.179
And somebody finally figured out who he was and where he worked and published about it.
00:33:28.679 --> 00:33:40.269
And suddenly X decided to, you know, suspend or take down any posts that mentioned this person's real name, which is.
00:33:40.759 --> 00:33:41.689
Just weird.
00:33:41.749 --> 00:34:26.659
I mean, for a wide variety of reasons some people will recall that, you know, when Elon took over Twitter and after promising that he would not ban the ElonJet account, eventually did, and then for a while was suspending anyone who even mentioned the existence of ElonJet And then when, when, you know, attacked on that, especially given his one promise not to suspend the account and his continual talk of like, you know, we believe in free speech, we're only going to take down stuff if it violates laws he, you know, he claimed that like, well, you know, doxing is, is illegal, which in certain places it is, but not, not, You know, showing where the public information, where your jet is, that does not violate any doxing law anywhere.
00:34:27.009 --> 00:34:34.528
And certainly like giving someone's real name is not that either, but it seemed like an extension of that.
00:34:34.559 --> 00:34:36.668
And, and so they suspended a bunch of people.
00:34:36.768 --> 00:34:58.153
It's funny that this also happened the same week that the the now infamous Don Lemon interview, which is a whole other story, came out with Elon Musk where Lemon sort of Okay Quizzes Musk on this whole like commitment to free speech and taking stuff down and, and Musk goes on this rant about how he believes in just following the laws.
00:34:58.543 --> 00:35:07.653
And then like literally at the same time, he is setting it up so that X is removing anyone who mentions this guy's name.
00:35:07.923 --> 00:36:01.239
And there's, there's this funny bit in all of it, which is that, you know, that sort of, you know, to, To justify this, they changed the, the privacy policy on X to include a thing that says they just added this line says what, for what is in violation of this policy, it says the identity of an anonymous user, such as their name it now violates the, their privacy policy, but if you scroll down on that same privacy policy, where it says, what is not a violation of this privacy, which existed longer than this past week it says non posting private information that is not a violation of this policy includes sharing information that we don't consider to be private, including names, which, you know, it's, it's Schrodinger's, uh, privacy policy here, where it's both a violation and not a violation to share someone's names.
00:36:01.259 --> 00:36:08.849
And it really, you know, as always seems to come down to what is it that Elon likes and what is it that he doesn't and the things that he doesn't like.
00:36:08.849 --> 00:36:08.889
Okay.
00:36:09.043 --> 00:36:10.503
are
violations of his policy.
00:36:10.523 --> 00:36:19.213
And in this case, what he doesn't like is people exposing a neo Nazi, which says something about Elon Musk's view of the world at this time.
00:36:19.963 --> 00:36:23.574
But also, you know, gets to some of these issues.
00:36:23.574 --> 00:36:38.713
And I had Tried to highlight these right when he took over Twitter with my, you know, the speed running the, the content moderation learning curve where, you know, you say these, these grand things like we're only going to follow the laws and we're, we're going to be, believe in free speech.
00:36:38.744 --> 00:36:41.603
We're not going to take anything down unless we absolutely have to.
00:36:41.864 --> 00:36:46.103
And then you, you discover that they're like really terrible people and they'll do terrible things.
00:36:46.103 --> 00:36:46.864
And you usually.
00:36:46.878 --> 00:36:52.228
Usually the way that works out is people figure out like, Oh, well, we have to do some trust and safety.
00:36:52.228 --> 00:36:58.909
We have to do some moderation to, to make the platform, you know, safe And, effective and to, to deal with these things.
00:36:59.139 --> 00:37:00.469
And, and here, like,
00:37:00.739 --> 00:37:02.548
he's got he's going the opposite way to Reddit.
00:37:02.643 --> 00:37:07.844
He's going the opposite way where he'll, he'll do those things, but only to protect the Nazis.
00:37:07.864 --> 00:37:18.994
It's just like this bizarro world that we're living in, where he's, he's sort of learning that you can't do the fully hands off thing, but he's learning it in the worst possible, stupidest possible way.
00:37:19.289 --> 00:37:21.068
And God knows who his advisors are.
00:37:21.278 --> 00:37:27.028
Because it's, he's not taking he's not taking counsel from anybody that would listen to this podcast, certainly.
00:37:27.389 --> 00:37:32.378
And it's but it's almost the perfect kind of Twitter Elon Musk, trust and safety story.
00:37:32.378 --> 00:37:34.159
So yeah, thanks for bringing that to us, Mike.
00:37:35.009 --> 00:37:35.699
it's incredible.
00:37:35.728 --> 00:37:43.179
So, and then I know you wanted to talk about, there's a story that both of us saw this week that we really liked, From, from, from David Kaye and foreign affairs.
00:37:43.179 --> 00:37:44.068
So you want to take that
00:37:44.153 --> 00:37:54.614
Yeah, I mean, this is just a really, really kind of well put together long read by David Kaye, who, if you don't know him, is a University of California law professor.
00:37:55.099 --> 00:37:59.259
And a rapporteur for the EU.
00:37:59.259 --> 00:38:07.759
I believe in various roles previously has done a lot of really good work to understand speech laws and the effects of speech.
00:38:07.759 --> 00:38:14.259
And he, he writes this great piece about basically the risks of internet regulation.
00:38:14.833 --> 00:38:24.324
And goes through the efforts made by the EU, the UK and the US to craft effective speech legislation.
00:38:24.873 --> 00:38:31.123
And basically kind of concludes that, you know, there's no one doing a great job right now.
00:38:31.443 --> 00:38:35.313
The EU is, is the best of, of kind of a bad bunch and in some senses.
00:38:35.724 --> 00:38:43.469
And, you know, just really flags the, the challenges that are going to be ahead in terms of, you know, Making speech regulation work.
00:38:43.588 --> 00:39:25.489
He, he does kind of cast ire and throws a bit of shade at the EU, which I wondered if, if that was the kind of You know them looking, you know him looking across the pond and Being slightly jealous of the way that the eu have managed to implement the digital services act in such a short space of time i'm just saying but you know he talks about thierry breton kind of being very forthright and and creating a scene around the dsa which Again, I think many people have said is has not been The best approach and how civil society organizations have pushed back against that and maybe that's creating a The right conditions to regulate platforms, but it's just a great piece.
00:39:25.489 --> 00:39:33.168
And I think really kind of takes the, a nice long view as to where we've got to really in terms of speech regulation,
00:39:34.248 --> 00:39:41.318
So, so I'm going to defend David Kaye's honor because I mean, the fact is, right.
00:39:41.349 --> 00:39:46.914
I mean, Unlike certainly some people in the U S who will take a very, very U S centric view to everything.
00:39:46.914 --> 00:39:49.684
Like David has always had a very global view.
00:39:49.684 --> 00:39:55.313
And as you mentioned, like he's done a lot of work with the UN and he was the UN repertoire on, on freedom of expression.
00:39:55.673 --> 00:40:03.983
And so this is not just like, Oh, like, you know, an American viewpoint on, on global internet speech, but the, the piece.
00:40:04.204 --> 00:40:15.313
Is is really really thoughtful and really highlights the, the challenging trade offs to regulating the internet and how it can come at the expense of speech.
00:40:15.673 --> 00:40:17.284
And I think it does a really good job.
00:40:17.284 --> 00:40:18.873
It talks about the EU approach.
00:40:18.873 --> 00:40:25.213
It talks about the, the UK approach and the us approach and the different challenges, you know, between all of them.
00:40:25.503 --> 00:40:33.244
And I think it's, it's just a really worthwhile piece overall, but it was interesting to me that, you know, right after.
00:40:33.579 --> 00:41:10.784
Reading that piece, I saw this other piece in the financial times about the EU promulgating these new guidelines around election disinformation and under the DSA and basically making it very, very clear that they are going to enforce these rules under the DSA if different platforms and, and Twitter being a big one that they are targeting, if they do not do something to stop election misinformation from appearing on the platforms, which to me highlights the real risk
of this stuff, which is, you know.
00:41:12.318 --> 00:41:18.179
People in the EU swore to me that the DSA would not be used to suppress any speech.
00:41:18.509 --> 00:41:19.818
It was process driven, right?
00:41:20.498 --> 00:41:25.018
Yes, it's, it's pro it's process and it's all about best practices and blah, blah, blah.
00:41:25.289 --> 00:41:37.498
But like, every time I would have that conversation, I had that conversation with the, the EU official who opened up a nice little office here in Silicon Valley to, you know, to, to watch over all of, all of the companies here.
00:41:37.699 --> 00:41:46.478
And I would have this, this discussion where they would say like, well, it's, we're not, we're not regulating speech, but if there's, if there's, Really problematic speech.
00:41:46.509 --> 00:41:47.789
Like, we're going to think that's a problem.
00:41:47.789 --> 00:41:49.289
I was like, so you are regulating speech.
00:41:49.289 --> 00:41:50.369
And they're like, no, no.
00:41:50.929 --> 00:41:53.268
And so, you know, this is, this is another example of it.
00:41:53.268 --> 00:42:02.048
And it is raised in David's piece also about like how this, this tries to straddle the line, but, but is potentially really risky as a tool for suppressing speech.
00:42:02.329 --> 00:42:12.528
And then to see this stuff about, you know, well, we're going to crack down if you don't get rid of election misinformation, you know, and some people will say, obviously like, well, election misinformation is bad and problematic.
00:42:12.708 --> 00:42:13.793
In some cases, it can.
00:42:14.034 --> 00:42:28.664
It certainly can be, but where you draw that line and how you decide what is election misinformation and as you know, comes up in, in, in David's beast too, is like, you know, do you allow like Victor Orban to determine what is election misinformation?
00:42:28.664 --> 00:42:35.344
Because, you know, that presents a very different picture than, than other people determining what is election misinformation.
00:42:35.344 --> 00:42:38.344
As soon as you open that door, there are real risks involved.
00:42:38.344 --> 00:42:38.853
And so,
00:42:39.009 --> 00:42:39.329
I mean,
00:42:39.454 --> 00:42:40.574
you know, it, it worries
00:42:40.759 --> 00:42:56.923
yeah, I would agree that the, this, this piece is a touch worrying to the fact that You know, EU elections happen, I think on the 6th of June and these guidelines could come in as soon as next week and be enforced by that point.
00:42:57.373 --> 00:43:08.014
And if you're a platform, you know, there's a, that's a lot of work to do in a very short space of time to understand what it is that they mean for your operations and then making sure that you comply.
00:43:08.353 --> 00:43:10.244
So this does feel very hasty.
00:43:10.474 --> 00:43:13.853
It does feel very kind of reactionary and it's clearly.
00:43:14.594 --> 00:43:25.554
in response to the fact that, you know, Bretton and the, the, the commission at large think that something's, think that something's bad is going to happen in the, in the June elections.
00:43:25.954 --> 00:43:29.403
Which is not a surprise, you know, that's been in the diary for a long time.
00:43:29.833 --> 00:43:34.753
So even whether you agree that they should be doing it the way that they've done it is not ideal.
00:43:35.713 --> 00:44:09.844
And, and again, David's piece in this story linked to another story, which we probably don't have time to go really into I think we should maybe spend another episode talking about about canada, but the their online harms act has received a whole bunch of Criticism over the last couple of weeks and there's a really good story in the globe and mail about about it and how it's kind of what it calls stagger staggeringly reckless, which is not a great look for a piece of speech regulation and You yeah, we'll probably come back to that, because that's, that's
00:44:09.954 --> 00:44:10.324
Yeah.
00:44:10.384 --> 00:44:17.023
It's, it's a big, big story and there's, there is a lot of nuance involved in the, in the Canadian approach and I think they are taking lessons from everybody else.
00:44:17.034 --> 00:44:19.853
But I do think that there are, there are certainly some dangers.
00:44:20.014 --> 00:44:31.204
So to, to, to wrap it up, do you want to give us a quick defense of the, of the the EU and in a different context where we're, what they're doing with the DSA and some companies.
00:44:31.409 --> 00:45:03.333
I think we probably aren't there just yet, but the, the way, the way that it's bringing cases against some of the VLOPs and, you know, the investigations that are being conducted against, You know x slash twitter and and tick tock and latterly Ali express which was the story that came out this week, you know I think they're going to be really telling as to whether this is working and and the reaction obviously of those platforms to the judgments, that have passed so I don't think we're yet there yet.
00:45:03.353 --> 00:45:14.188
But You know, at least there's been some There's been cases brought against them, there's been these investigations set up, which in a relatively short space of time I think is something.
00:45:15.804 --> 00:45:16.103
Yeah.
00:45:16.103 --> 00:45:16.594
And we'll see.
00:45:16.594 --> 00:45:24.409
And obviously like the, the investigation into Aliexpress sort of follows on what we talked about last week about Sheehan and, and how that, that, that.
00:45:24.579 --> 00:45:26.179
Plays into the whole DSA thing.
00:45:26.179 --> 00:45:31.768
So certainly going to be a story that we'll have plenty of opportunities to follow up on, on future podcasts.
00:45:33.548 --> 00:45:55.228
And so with that, I think we are concluding this part of our second episode, but we will move on to something you do not want to miss, which is our bonus chat, where we invite on expert guests with experience in the trust and safety and online speech worlds in an effort to go
deeper and explore Some particular topic.
00:45:55.259 --> 00:46:04.088
And so this week's bonus chat is brought to you by Block Party whose new privacy party tool helps you better protect your own privacy across a wide range of sites.
00:46:04.588 --> 00:46:20.489
And so I got a chance to speak to Block Party founder and CEO, Tracy Chou about how feeling unsafe online can actually lead to less speech through self censorship as people don't feel comfortable talking in different spaces and how important that is.
00:46:20.489 --> 00:46:26.929
If we're talking about online speech, let me talk a little bit about how different companies might be able to deal with that.
00:46:27.248 --> 00:46:35.918
So it's a really interesting discussion and certainly it has much wider implications for the entire internet and other services as well.
00:46:35.918 --> 00:46:37.438
So please take a listen.
00:46:47.699 --> 00:47:06.878
All right, so we talk a lot about online speech and how the internet enables lots of speech, but one, I think, critically underexplored area regarding online speech is how there are certain scenarios that actually lead to less speech in the form of self censorship.
00:47:07.219 --> 00:47:11.719
So can you talk a little bit about what you think leads to that in some cases?
00:47:13.103 --> 00:47:24.632
Yeah, there's a lot of these online attacks, whether it's harassment, doxing or other things that occur under the guise of free speech that are actually intended to silence people.
00:47:26.802 --> 00:47:34.422
And we've seen pretty high profile cases of folks who've withdrawn from social media or the public sphere saying, I can't handle the harassment.
00:47:34.422 --> 00:47:36.452
This, this is untenable.
00:47:36.472 --> 00:47:37.463
It's not okay.
00:47:37.893 --> 00:47:40.362
And there's a lot of other folks who just quietly.
00:47:40.632 --> 00:47:41.463
Back away.
00:47:42.313 --> 00:47:57.253
And in the course of user interviews and research for building privacy parties, trying to build tools for everyday people around privacy, we have talked to a lot of people about how they think about these issues around safety and privacy.
00:47:57.672 --> 00:48:05.083
And even when people don't talk in these terms, these are very industry terms, like safety, privacy,
00:48:05.938 --> 00:48:06.298
right.
00:48:06.552 --> 00:48:10.193
often what they describe as their reactions to what's happening online is.
00:48:10.572 --> 00:48:11.643
Self censorship.
00:48:12.072 --> 00:48:20.123
So a lot of folks have said things like, I just don't talk about particular topics anymore because it's not worth it to me.
00:48:20.882 --> 00:48:24.983
There are particular categories of information that people don't share anymore.
00:48:25.572 --> 00:48:32.992
It could be things that you would have imagined to be fairly innocuous, like, oh, I'm in this city and I'm going to be giving this talk.
00:48:33.233 --> 00:48:34.862
And I want to meet people at those things.
00:48:35.358 --> 00:48:43.407
Some folks we've talked to have very deliberately pulled back from sharing and it comes at a very clear trade off to them.
00:48:43.407 --> 00:48:46.818
They know that I'm missing out on potential audience.
00:48:46.818 --> 00:48:48.788
There are some messages I want to get out there.
00:48:49.018 --> 00:49:00.288
There's some discussions I would be really interested in having their connections I might want to make or potential collaborations, but I don't feel comfortable posting these things anymore because of the threats to my safety and privacy.
00:49:01.432 --> 00:49:03.702
Folks have all sorts of different rules that they use.
00:49:03.742 --> 00:49:10.722
A lot of the women I've talked to have said things like, do not post photos in front of the house.
00:49:10.822 --> 00:49:13.853
Do not post photos from inside the house of exterior.
00:49:13.853 --> 00:49:17.612
So no views outside the windows where you could then identify where I live.
00:49:18.222 --> 00:49:25.213
Don't post anything, photos or videos within five minutes of where I live or places that I frequent, like coffee shops or gyms.
00:49:26.248 --> 00:49:27.777
never mentioned these things.
00:49:28.018 --> 00:49:29.958
There are landmarks close to where I live.
00:49:30.617 --> 00:49:35.807
And you understand why they're doing all these things, but it also, it does come at that trade off.
00:49:35.818 --> 00:49:37.807
And I personally have experienced it as well.
00:49:37.807 --> 00:49:52.137
When I used to be much freer about sharing all of these things online, it led to some really fun, serendipitous connections and really interesting insights from folks that I wouldn't necessarily have expected to hear from or known their perspectives.
00:49:52.188 --> 00:50:11.967
But when it doesn't feel safe anymore whether it's from harassment attacks, so it could be dog piling or just a bunch of trolls from the internet descending upon your comments or making your life difficult in online ways or people who start threatening things in the offline world, like stalking you and physical safety becomes an issue.
00:50:13.038 --> 00:50:17.947
It becomes a little scary and it feels like the best solution is just to stop talking.
00:50:19.648 --> 00:50:23.469
Yeah, yeah, no, I think it's, it's, it's really scary.
00:50:23.469 --> 00:50:32.829
And I mean, I've experienced some of that, but I think, you know, I know that it is significantly worse for, for women, certainly.
00:50:33.179 --> 00:50:39.849
And, but it is interesting to me to think about, to think about these different trade offs, right?
00:50:39.849 --> 00:50:56.994
And so, you know, there are all these discussions about online speech and like, you know, enabling free speech and And, and there's this belief that, that seems very common that, you know, free enabling free speech online means enabling all speech.
00:50:57.603 --> 00:51:08.244
But, you know, as, as you're seeing and as the interviews that you've done and the research that you've, you've been involved with shows that that, that actually can lead to, to less.
00:51:09.014 --> 00:51:11.853
Actual freedom of speech for lots of people.
00:51:12.204 --> 00:51:27.474
And so are there things that you think different sites and services online can do to make people feel more comfortable to, to be able to, to speak when they want to and to, to bring up these things the way that they want to.
00:51:27.474 --> 00:51:29.603
Yes.
00:51:29.782 --> 00:51:32.222
thing is building that safe environment.
00:51:32.623 --> 00:51:35.012
How to do so is a little bit harder.
00:51:35.922 --> 00:51:44.733
Um, one idea I want to call out is in understanding how technology functions and the impacts of technology.
00:51:45.282 --> 00:51:53.362
The question is often not just what is possible, but what is easy and therefore what are people likely to do.
00:51:53.813 --> 00:52:02.882
And so when we're talking about things like harassment attacks or abuse, this is true of the mechanisms of attack and also the mechanisms of defense.
00:52:03.313 --> 00:52:18.182
So when you think about consumer web scale social platforms where anyone can at anyone else or engage with anybody from their basement contact anybody around the world, that does lead to the potential for widespread attacks.
00:52:18.572 --> 00:52:24.077
So in that case, Perhaps more friction would be better in the user experience.
00:52:24.447 --> 00:52:32.237
But on the defense side, so people securing their own privacy and safety settings, oftentimes it's really difficult.
00:52:33.688 --> 00:52:44.467
So when we talk about what are the best practices, industry experts or people who are just familiar and tech savvy often have a long list of these quote unquote, simple and easy things to do.
00:52:44.967 --> 00:52:52.208
Like rotate your passwords or have strong passwords, turn off location sharing set up 2FA, but this information is kind of spread out.
00:52:52.248 --> 00:52:53.487
The settings are hard to find.
00:52:53.487 --> 00:52:55.867
It's just kind of a pain to do these things.
00:52:55.878 --> 00:53:01.637
So it makes it so that normal users are not going to do them to protect themselves.
00:53:01.748 --> 00:53:08.657
And so what's easy is for attackers to attack and what's not easy is for people who don't want to be attacked to defend themselves.
00:53:09.643 --> 00:53:26.873
Yeah, I mean, I it's funny because I remember having a conversation with one of the creators of PGP, the email encryption service, who admitted that he doesn't use PGP because it was too, too complicated to actually use.
00:53:27.063 --> 00:53:32.693
So that brings us around to to Privacy Party, which is the service that you guys are creating, obviously.
00:53:32.954 --> 00:53:42.688
And, and, you know, I think part of Part of the goal of that is to help deal with that and make it easier for people to actually protect their privacy and feel safer on these services.
00:53:42.688 --> 00:53:44.489
So do you want to talk a little bit about how that works?
00:53:45.498 --> 00:53:55.568
What Privacy Party does is make it easy for users to protect themselves on social media, so the solution for safety and privacy doesn't just have to be self censorship.
00:53:57.507 --> 00:54:11.668
It's a browser extension that provides expert recommendations on social media privacy settings with automations to fix them, so you don't have to go do that yourself, and it runs across platforms like Facebook, LinkedIn, Strava, Venmo.
00:54:11.668 --> 00:54:22.307
Some of these are obvious ones, others are obvious when you think about the fact that you don't want to share where you run every day or all the financial transactions you have, potentially like paying your landlord.
00:54:24.057 --> 00:54:36.588
It's sort of like your tech savvy, very security conscious and patient best friend who's leaning over your shoulder while you're at your computer to help you click through and fix all your settings.
00:54:38.858 --> 00:54:41.483
That's the The short of it, we try to make it easy.
00:54:41.583 --> 00:54:45.463
We're also working on things to clean up old content.
00:54:45.802 --> 00:54:50.813
This might be photos that you have shared previously, whether it's flipping all the privacy settings.
00:54:51.123 --> 00:55:01.943
Right now, if you want to manually change the privacy settings on a photo album on Facebook, it takes six clicks, multiply that by how many albums you have, we can do that in one click for you.
00:55:01.943 --> 00:55:03.672
We just go through and flip all of them.
00:55:04.478 --> 00:55:11.838
Just trying to make it easy for you to keep being online without necessarily the overexposure of your digital footprint.
00:55:12.943 --> 00:55:13.534
Yeah.
00:55:13.943 --> 00:55:32.623
And are there ways that the different platforms, I mean, obviously you're doing this on, on a variety of different platforms that you mentioned, are there ways that those services and platforms can, can actually make it easier for you to provide this service and, and to, you know better help people feel safe on, on those services?
00:55:33.268 --> 00:55:42.628
The best way would be for them to provide standardized interfaces for us to build programmatic tools, which would be APIs, application programming interfaces.
00:55:44.367 --> 00:55:51.148
It might take a little while to get to, but also just not making the settings pages horrible is already an improvement.
00:55:53.103 --> 00:56:01.632
Some platforms won't name names, maybe I will, meta, um, sometimes have three different versions of the same privacy settings pages.
00:56:01.643 --> 00:56:04.393
So it's not even that one set of them is confusing.
00:56:04.393 --> 00:56:06.483
It's that there's three different sets of them and you don't know where to go.
00:56:07.092 --> 00:56:10.893
And so for us to build solutions on top of that is also cumbersome.
00:56:12.233 --> 00:56:22.143
Do you know, do you know, is that just because they're like A B testing stuff or is it just like they just put stuff in weird places or is it just like because they've been around so long that that's how it's ended up
00:56:22.262 --> 00:56:23.902
like it's all of those things.
00:56:23.983 --> 00:56:26.853
Um, sometimes I suspect it's that.
00:56:27.373 --> 00:56:28.262
Someone has the idea?
00:56:28.262 --> 00:56:40.952
to improve things and so they propose a new settings management system and as they're trying to roll that out and trying to pour people over they end up just with all of the different ones the same time.
00:56:44.132 --> 00:56:44.382
Yeah,
00:56:44.382 --> 00:56:44.764
Okay.
00:56:45.313 --> 00:56:47.753
Well I think that's, that's great.
00:56:47.753 --> 00:56:48.384
Thank you.
00:56:48.753 --> 00:57:07.903
So much for, for joining us and, and and talking about this and hopefully some of the folks at services who are listening to this, hopefully decide that they'll make it easier for you to, to make the lives of their users easier and feel more comfortable speaking on, on the various platforms.
00:57:08.103 --> 00:57:15.914
So if people want to want to try out Privacy Party or follow you or understand this more, where should they go?
00:57:16.603 --> 00:57:18.682
You can check us out at BlockPartyApp.
00:57:18.682 --> 00:57:19.253
com.
00:57:19.952 --> 00:57:38.472
Just to give a quick plug, if you are a trust and safety professional or a semi public figure of any form talking about topics that might get people mad, you may be at risk for people coming after you, so I do recommend trying Privacy Party to lock down your own social accounts and limit your own attack surface area.
00:57:39.233 --> 00:57:44.913
If you're the type of person who's looking out for other people's safety and privacy, try it yourself and you can recommend it.
00:57:45.498 --> 00:57:50.237
It will make your life easier than walking people through all the settings manually yourself.
00:57:51.023 --> 00:57:53.054
So thanks for joining us, Tracy.
00:57:53.143 --> 00:57:53.722
thank you.
00:57:57.012 --> 00:57:59.152
Thanks for listening to Ctrl-Alt-Speech.
00:57:59.342 --> 00:58:02.532
Subscribe now to get our weekly episodes as soon as they're released.
00:58:03.333 --> 00:58:10.103
If your company or organization is interested in sponsoring the podcast, contact us by visiting ctrlaltspeech.Com.
00:58:10.293 --> 00:58:12.492
That's C T R L Alt Speech.
00:58:12.853 --> 00:58:13.182
com.
00:58:14.083 --> 00:58:27.152
This podcast is produced with financial support from the Future of Online Trust and Safety Fund, a fiscally sponsored multi donor fund at Global Impact that supports charitable activities to build a more robust, capable, and inclusive trust and safety ecosystem.