ကူးယူချက် 🔗
[0:01] Welcome to courtroom quarterback the experiences and thoughts of a court-martial defense attorney
[0:07] Hey, everyone. Welcome back to an all-new episode of courtroom quarterback the experiences and thoughts of a court-martial defense attorney
[0:16] With attorney Joseph L. Jordan the founder of the Jordan UCMJ law group. I am your host Spike Leon
[0:22] You know Joseph here is a former Army Jag and worldwide court-martial defense attorney
[0:27] And he's tried more than 240 court-martials two verdict and handled more than
[0:32] 350 military cases all across not only here in the US but Europe the Pacific and in the Middle East and in today's episode
[0:39] We're going to be stepping into what Joseph considers probably the most important part of a defense lawyers craft
[0:46] And that's the cross examination part of this right?
[0:49] So Joseph you're gonna explain all this in just a second why it's so crucial, but this is part one of a two-part series that we're gonna
[0:55] Do we're gonna focus on the purpose the discipline and judgment before even a single question is even asked
[1:02] Joseph, it's good to see you as always so I just mentioned it of that you think cross-examination is the most important thing that a defense council does
[1:11] Why is that why does it sit at the center of your practice?
[1:14] Well, first of all good afternoon
[1:17] When I think about cross-examination I think of it as the tip of the spear it is the arrowhead
[1:23] It is what you use to pop the balloon of the government's case
[1:28] You are at the tip of the spear when you are a cross-examining witnesses
[1:33] particularly
[1:34] Accusers and in my business
[1:36] I
[1:37] Would say almost 90% of the time I'm cross-examining an accuser an alleged victim someone that has has a
[1:47] Agreements where they say they've been harmed in some way shape or fashion whether it's sexual assault assault domestic violence
[1:57] larceny theft burglary those sorts of things so
[2:02] being able to
[2:04] Take apart the witness and their story is
[2:08] Where you win cases as defense council. It is the most important job of a defense council is to have effective
[2:16] cross-examination of each and every witness that the government counsel the prosecution puts forward
[2:22] Just if you know if you think of the law shows, right you think about cross-examination and
[2:28] Two things happen, right you either trying to credit a witness or discredit them, right with respect to
[2:35] Direct and cross-examination. How do you kind of determine which of those serves the case that you're working on?
[2:41] Sure, so your overall strategy is what dictates that right? So there may be circumstances where you've done your homework
[2:49] You've interviewed the witnesses. You have a good idea what the expert may say
[2:56] Or the witness may say and you want to use that information to
[3:02] Help your case move forward. So maybe you do credit them
[3:06] With experts especially that's one thing that you want to do
[3:10] And show the nuances and differences of your case vice what they're presenting
[3:17] Most of the time though you are discrediting a witness in some way shape or form, especially if it's an accuser
[3:24] And the way you do that depends on the individual
[3:29] Their experience in life the nature of the circumstances of the case
[3:34] You know those sorts of things. So it just depends on the strategy of the overall case and what you want to accomplish with each particular witness that you cross-examining
[3:44] Well, let me piggyback on that like so what in your mind for the people that are listening watching to this like what what's the ultimate goal of cross-examination in your mind?
[3:53] Like what should it accomplish if you do your job really well on cross-exam? What is it accomplished?
[3:58] Teach the jury what you want them to know
[4:02] Often times
[4:04] People think it's the answer that matters when you're questioning a witness on direct examination. That's true
[4:10] But on cross-examination the question is what matters not necessarily the answer
[4:16] You want the jury that focused on your questions, okay?
[4:20] You want the military panel focused on the defense counsel's questions and what they're asking because
[4:28] That triggers in their mind critical analysis critical analysis of the problem, right?
[4:35] So you want them
[4:38] Walking the path that you're walking you want to bring them on the trail with you as you question the witness
[4:46] And many times you're in the military especially you're dealing with
[4:50] Very intelligent people people that are a lot more experience in life in many cases
[4:54] They're they have a degree even you're enlisted
[4:58] Members if they're a non-commissioned officer, they'll have a degree. They'll have a bachelor's degree
[5:04] They'll have an associate's degree so they know what it means to critically analyze problems and they lived life
[5:09] So you want to bring them along on the trail and highlight things that they may take for granted and think about daily
[5:17] But you sit there and you you highlight certain things and you bring the visceral
[5:22] Reality of the situation when I cross examine
[5:25] witnesses and domestic violence cases in assault cases and sexual assault cases
[5:31] My style is to bring the visceral reality of this situation to the table, okay?
[5:37] So that means we get right down into the nitty gritty of
[5:40] What happened in the bedroom and whether or not there was
[5:44] Penis to vagina penetration and how did that work, right?
[5:48] The dynamics of putting on a condom before you actually enter into the act of sex
[5:54] That's how visceral and how you have to get and that educates the panel
[5:59] It makes them think about these things not on a cloud level or an abstract level, but on a very real level
[6:08] And that's
[6:09] That's where I find that we're able to connect with juries and
Load full transcript
win cases especially in close calls Joseph
[6:16] What about the times that maybe it didn't get up, you know, no questions you're on or you don't cross examine it all well like
[6:23] Can you take us through the times that you've done that and has it been smarter to sit down instead of standing up if there's nothing to accomplish with the witness
[6:32] Why question it sends a signal to the jury to
[6:38] That witness isn't that important
[6:40] Well, they didn't even think the question of why what was the point, right?
[6:45] So that the jury will dismiss them oftentimes when you do that
[6:49] But it is a careful analysis. You don't do that with every witness obviously
[6:53] But if there's nothing that you can accomplish with them
[6:56] There are the immovable object
[7:00] Then there's no point in questioning them whatsoever
[7:03] So yeah, let's talk a little bit about your preparation
[7:07] That that you've talked about in previous episodes for this stuff like what is the
[7:12] Real preparation get into weeds for us like what does it look like for you before you even step foot into that court court room as you're preparing to
[7:20] Potentially cross examine all these witnesses
[7:22] This is one of my favorite parts of the case um is the preparation for cross examination and
[7:31] First of all the first thing I do is I read the whole case file
[7:34] I get a very big picture 30,000 foot view of the case file. What does this thing look like
[7:40] Big picture then I start to develop my strategy and then I start to funnel down
[7:45] On the key witnesses
[7:47] That are going to turn the tables on this case where where's the case going to turn right
[7:52] And eventually you drill down to the alleged victim and you look at all of her statements and usually with a with the military case file
[7:59] You're going to get a summary of statements
[8:01] Um initially and then as just the discovery process develops you will eventually get their actual statements
[8:08] In most cases it's an audiovisual statement. So a recorded statement of the interview that the investigators have with the alleged victim and other witnesses
[8:17] Um, and so I make a judgment call on do I want to transcribe that or not right?
[8:22] So depending on the importance of the witness what what critical analysis or the critical analysis that we do
[8:29] Um, and how critical they are to the case determines if I want to transcribe it we transcribe it
[8:34] Um, and we break it down
[8:36] um
[8:37] and
[8:39] Continue to break it down. I then I will start to look at other things. I will look at the behavior of the witness and that's based off of observations of other witnesses that maybe friends or peers or acquaintances of the alleged victim right or of of our client as well
[8:55] Um, depending on behaviors and those sorts of things um, so
[9:00] As I've probably stated before when I look at sexual assault, I look at it as a wagon wheel and the accuser is the hub of the wheel all the stories that she tells are
[9:12] The spokes of the wheel so every person that she's talked to about the case which people commonly call as outcry witnesses
[9:20] Those are spokes of the wheel and so I look at those spokes and determine what's consistent and what isn't and you can start to develop across examination strategy based off the various stories
[9:29] But then you also look at the actual statement that the individual is made right so the what is the accuser said
[9:38] Um, and is there any inconsistencies within what they have said
[9:42] Uh, what were they led to have said based off the interrogation or the interview rather so during the interview you're looking at did the
[9:50] Agent lead them one direction or another right so and each witness that you
[9:57] Prepare for is different you prepare for an expert differently than you prepare for an accuser you prepare for a child victim
[10:04] You prepare for a peripheral witness that has something to add to the table
[10:08] Um, so everybody's a little different and what you're looking to do is to build um
[10:15] You're building a project um, you're building a puzzle as it were uh legos is one of my hobbies so um
[10:22] You're you you're putting together the Lego project to present to the panel and so you have to sit there and
[10:31] manage and strategize and then figure out what tactics you're going to use to get there depending on what witnesses
[10:38] You are examining big Lego guy myself so I get the references when my daughter is handed to me and I have to put it together
[10:44] So but speaking of stories because you mentioned the word stories
[10:47] I'm sure you have some stories from cross-examination
[10:51] Especially where this preparation that you've done so extensively paid off can you can you share a case
[10:57] We're being fully prepared for that case kind of created a decisive shift once you started questioning
[11:03] Sure, I've got multiple stories
[11:05] Uh for this particular case that I have in mind and it's uh
[11:09] It's a case that I did years ago in Italy um
[11:13] I remember it vividly because of the kind of the entertain it entertainment value that this thing brings
[11:19] So
[11:21] The situation is this my client was really really drunk
[11:25] His buddy was about six foot five two hundred forty pounds. He could have been a tight-end for uh for an NFL team
[11:34] Um
[11:35] They're they're drunk off off their rarers, right um
[11:38] So for some reason they got a hold of a shopping cart
[11:41] And my buddy gets dumped into the shopping cart and they wheel it into the lobby of the of the barracks on
[11:46] A del Dan which is this really lovely facility in Italy
[11:51] um and in the in the facility and the way it's set up matters uh as it relates to this this story
[11:58] so um and there's a lot of a lot of things to pull into this
[12:03] so
[12:04] Uh one value of going and walking the scene and seeing how everything is
right
[12:09] So you go to del Dan barracks and you see that you've got these
[12:12] 20-foot-class windows and at night so I went during the day and then I went again at night
[12:18] um it lights up the whole four-year area and it's a nice big four-year area
[12:22] There's a seating area with a TV. There's another on the other side. There's a
[12:26] A pool table which becomes important to the story
[12:29] um
[12:30] So my guy gets wheeled into the four-year um and he gets up out of the the shopping basket and he walks up to
[12:38] uh
[12:39] The nco the nanchik commission officer was a female um who's in charge of watching the barracks at night
[12:46] They call it you know cq charge of quarters um or fire or watch whatever you want to call it right
[12:51] But she's in charge making sure anything's safe that night. Well my guy's drunk
[12:56] And unfortunately for this particular individual she was
[13:00] known to have a certain type of reputation and
[13:03] uh
[13:04] My client was a young pfc walks up to her and he's like well, where am I gonna get my turn
[13:09] And he starts flirting with her and
[13:12] His buddy sees what's happening and he says look
[13:16] Let's just get you to your barracks room. So it gets my client to the barracks room client comes back down
[13:22] sometime later and
[13:24] continues to flirt with
[13:26] the nco
[13:28] and
[13:29] From this flirtation comes allegations of attempted sexual assault
[13:34] And what she describes is very interesting and I was able to prepare
[13:41] um one of the more entertaining parts of this cross examination based off of her interview
[13:46] That she gave to cid army criminal investigative division
[13:51] And
[13:52] First of all, I looked at the fact that she's an nco and I questioned like hey you're a non-commissioned officer
[13:58] you
[13:59] Have
[14:00] Command authority and you should use it and you didn't in this case right
[14:05] That's kind of how I started the cross-examination. So knowledge of the army culture
[14:10] Knowledge of the individual and their capabilities and what they didn't do right
[14:15] next
[14:17] You know, there's a lot of things to work with in this case. She had several motives. She didn't want to be in the
[14:24] She didn't want to be in italy
[14:25] She wanted to be back in the states. We were able to assess that out by
[14:29] Interviews of peer in CEOs, supervisory in CEOs
[14:34] Those things of that nature
[14:36] But she said something that was very very curious to me
[14:41] um, she described the situation where
[14:45] My client was allegedly coming after her
[14:49] And she decided that she didn't have anywhere to go
[14:52] So she went and she sat on the pool table
[14:56] Now here's an interesting thing everybody knows what a pool table looks like
[15:00] You know how high they sit off the floor
[15:02] She was about five one
[15:05] So if she's sitting on the pool table. She's not in a position of power or a place to protect herself
[15:12] What do we know that's on pool tables
[15:15] pool sticks and pool balls
[15:18] And she described picking up the balls and and playing with them while she's trying to figure out what she
[15:24] Is going to do next
[15:26] picking up the pool stick as she's thinking through her next steps
[15:30] And she literally said not only in the interview but on the stand
[15:35] That is she's sitting on the pool table trying to get away from my client
[15:39] That she didn't have any tools in her toolkit left she didn't know what to do
[15:46] So in my cross examination of her I had prepared this
[15:51] And practiced it
[15:53] And I've walked the dog on this so
[15:56] Yes sat on the pool table not a position of power is it no
[16:02] You said that you picked up the pool balls and played with those right yes
[16:06] You had the pool stick in your hand at one point is that true yes
[16:10] So as you're playing with the balls
[16:13] And playing with the pool stick
[16:16] You didn't have any tools in your toolkit at all
[16:21] It's one of the only times in my whole trial experience
[16:26] That I got the judge to laugh multiple members in the panel to laugh and the gallery
[16:32] was um
[16:34] They were quite entertained
[16:36] Needless to say that was a very short liberation um in that case but it's just
[16:42] I had the interview to work with and I was able to practice and just
[16:47] That's what I mean by taking the visceral nature of a of of a case in the situation
[16:53] And bringing it to the jury and saying look at the stoop
[16:57] Look at how stupid this is look at the ridiculous nature of
[17:00] this situation you
[17:02] Lot of phallic symbols in there. I would have gotten it as I was on that jury
[17:06] Joseph we leave it there for part one. Thanks as always my friend continue success
[17:11] Yeah, and thank you to everyone out there for listening to this installment of courtroom quarterback with attorney Joseph Jordan
[17:17] If you want to learn more about Joseph's worldwide court martial defense practice like that story you just heard
[17:22] Visit Jordan ucmjlaw.com right now and do me one more favor before you go hit like hit subscribe leave a review comment
[17:30] Share the episode with someone who needs to hear it. I'm Mike Leon. We'll see everybody next time
[17:38] Thanks for watching be sure to hit that like and subscribe button and leave us a review in the comments