TRANSKRIP 🔗
The Playful Lens: Amanda, you're so welcome back to the Playful Lens. in this episode we are delighted to be joined again by Dr. Amanda Gummer. And Amanda, would you just like to reintroduce yourself
Amanda: Thank
The Playful Lens: for our listeners?
Amanda: Sure, thank you for having me back. I'm Amanda Gammott. I'm a research psychologist specializing in child development play. I run Fundamentally Children, which is a research consultancy and home of the Good Play Guide. And recently I have become the founder of the Thrive Digital Alliance, which I'm delighted to be here talking to you about today.
The Playful Lens: Yeah. So tell us a little bit about that. What does that involve?
Amanda: So last year we got some money from Innovate UK to develop a children's digital wellbeing framework. Now we've developed frameworks for different things before children's activities, assessing toys and finding toys that build resilience, those kind of frameworks that we judge things against. And so we've done this sort of thing for a while, but we've never done it in the digital space. So we wanted to find a way of helping parents and educators and ideally platforms as well, identify good quality kids content and games. if you look at, I mean, there's a lot of concern around the sort of the digital world at the minute. But if you get rid of all the nasty stuff, like the really sinister stuff, there is still a massive amount of difference between a child spending an hour scrolling through a cat video. or, you know, doom scrolling on TikTok or something, and, I know, playing Minecraft with their friends or playing an online game with their grandparents. So what we're trying to do is identify a way of understanding what good looks like. And this is all within the context of a balanced play diet, because we know it doesn't matter how good the digital world is, we know that children still need to play in real life and build real friendships with real people and, you know, exercise and all of that kind of stuff. It's building on the work that we've been doing with Good Play Guide with the balanced play pyramid and the balanced play guide that we talked about last time. But it takes it into a digital world. So trying to look at how to help children thrive in a digital world.
The Playful Lens: That's so important and I like what you said that it is about a balanced plate. we know children are using screens, but it's about using them effectively and in a really good way. So how has the framework been built and how is it going?
Amanda: So it's been built. So we built it last year and launched it in Sheffield at the Children's Media Conference in July. It was a truly collaborative effort. We had over 60 people from across different industries, education, academia, policy, children's rights, all of those kind of things, all kind of having an input. So it's become a really comprehensive framework. And the idea, there's three things that make me really proud of it. One is it's that point about going beyond doing no harm. So we're trying to get that, you know, what does good quality look like? The second thing is that, and I've not seen this in other frameworks, but it's segmented by age because developing skills such as confidence or communication, the features of a digital experience for a three-year-old are going to be different from an eight-year-old or a 14-year-old. So... We need to make sure that the guidelines and the framework recognizes the age and stage of the children and provides that kind of guidance accordingly. And the third one, and this is an important one for me because it's about helping parents. We need one stamp or one way of recognizing whether something is good across all kids' digital experiences. So... There's some great work being done in games. There's some great work being done on kids and TV, know, screen time, especially for the young kids. There's stuff being done on AR and VR and AI and EdTech and publishing and screen free stuff as well, but still digital, but it's screen free. And so the idea of the Alliance is that it brings all of that together. But one of the things about the framework is it's relevant across all of those different types of digital activity. it doesn't matter from an industry point of view, it doesn't matter what you're making for children, you can use the framework to just check that you're kind of doing the right thing by kids and your product or your content is going to be beneficial to children in some way. So yeah, so it's going really well. We've had such amazing feedback from it. Lots of people are downloading it. And the other thing, again, because it was government funded and so collaborative, We've made it free, so anybody can download the framework from Thrive Digital Alliance. And that's, again, another reason why we've created Thrive is because it felt wrong to have it, to keep the framework and the accreditation programme as a revenue stream just for one research agency. We want it to be a kind of, continue that collaborative approach and give it access to as many people and work with as many people as we can. to really help parents, teachers, educators, childminders understand how to help children thrive.
The Playful Lens: Yeah, and it's it's so important because the last time we spoke to you, Amanda, what we what you said was there is common sense seems to go out the window when we think digital. We're either no screens are bad, not happening, or you know, it's the digital childminder and they have completely free access to screens all day long. So it sounds like you're bringing the common sense with that approach. Can you help us understand so? What does A pa a balanced digital play dice look like.
Amanda: So I think it's about understanding what the digital activity does for the children. So if it's helping develop social skills or creativity or it's helping them learn to read or it's helping them keep in touch with friends, if it's doing
Load full transcript
that, then it's got some value. So it's less about whether there's a screen involved or whether it's a digital activity and more about the play pattern that it's... It's provoking. if you think about, I know, Pokemon Go or something, you're outside, you're running around, you're building your fitness, you're engaging with your community, you're maybe playing with friends. There's lots of good stuff there. The idea that there's a tech involved in there for, you know, it's bad, just doesn't ring true with me. And I think it's, you know, the world is evolving and technology and digital activities and experiences. are part of kids' everyday lives and we just want to make sure that they're as positive and beneficial for children as possible.
The Playful Lens: So, one of the things that always comes up when we talk about screens is boundaries and time and and all of that. So if we were to talk to you on a really practical level, what's your take on all of that?
Amanda: So I would say time is a lazy metric to use when it comes to screen time or digital time. It's much less about how long they are engaging with digital activities and much more about what they're doing. So if they're running outside and doing geocaching or Pokemon Go, if they're using it to help with their homework or reinforce a, know, develop a hobby or, you know, interact with friends, that's... much more positive than just sitting there on your own, not moving, scrolling through TikTok or whatever. I think, you know, having some kind of limits makes time limits makes absolute sense so that you are making sure you're getting the exercise and the social interactions and it's not impacting on, you know, meal times or sleep or homework or any of the other things that you your children should be doing. But I think Yeah, I think putting just time limits on things is less helpful. And what's really good is where you can have a conversation with your children about what they're doing online and talk about it in a diet kind of analogy, because this is the good, healthy stuff. If you've done any homework, if you've had some exercise, if you've done this and then you want to spend 20 minutes surfing the internet and doom scrolling on TikTok, then that's not going to... do any significant harm. But I think it's that having those open conversations with the kids and setting reasonable limits and using, making sure you've got all the parental controls on and all that stuff so that they're, you've got some idea of what they're doing. But I think that's a much stronger and more collaborative way of doing it than just sort of setting strict time limits.
The Playful Lens: And I think children, I know my eight-year-old son, if I sat down and had that conversation with him around the balanced play diet, he actually really would understand that. So instead of as a parent saying, get off it now, you're finished, the time is up, as you say, having those conversations is so important because then children understand and they can start to build their their own play diet and realize I've had enough now, it's actually not good for me. Or as you say, you know, a few minutes on a rainy Saturday evening or whatever it is. is, having those conversations is is gonna build their tolerance and their confidence as well, isn't it?
Amanda: Yeah, absolutely. And maybe you agree different time limits for different types of activities. So, if you're playing on Minecraft with a friend, maybe, it's still really important that they have regular breaks and get up and move and everything regularly. But maybe there's an allowance for that. And then there's a there's a smaller amount of time that's just free. You can do, you you you go and do whatever it is you want. That's fine, because you've you've done all the other stuff. But I think, you know, thinking. engaging with the kids and understanding what they're doing and having conversations with them about where they're spending time online or in the digital world and what it is that they're doing is very different.
The Playful Lens: Yeah, and it's a that's such a pragmatic approach. And it's so important, Amanda, because I'm gonna own it here. I am somebody whose I screens I struggle with. Same. And it's I feel like I need to cop on almost and realise this is part of my children's world. And I'm actually doing them a disservice the stricter I am around absolutely not out go and play outside, get out in the fresh air. I need to be more, more balanced and move away from that rigid. Okay, you've a half an hour on this now, and then I'm taking it and turning it off. Children don't need that. They need the collaborative approach where we're sitting down having a contract almost before this even starts and just being flexible, but also being aware that I need to make sure there's balance in this and realizing sometimes that's going to be hard for them because a lot of these games are designed to be so addictive that I want more and more and more. Yeah.
Amanda: Yeah, and that's again, that's one of the things that we address with the framework is, is the design addictive? And if it is, it won't pass the accreditation. So, you know, are the natural breaks, are there links for offline play? Does it encourage, you know, playing the real world away from the screen? Those kind of things are all design considerations that we've built into the framework. So people making people who really care about kids and are wanting to make good digital experiences for kids can. haven't have not got the excuse that they don't know anymore because the framework is there. We've done the research. It's you know, it's freely available. So I think that's one of the things that I I want to make sure that ignorance is no excuse when it comes to making these things for kids. So we can then go after the bad guys and go you do know better. There's no there's no excuse for the I know the matters of this world to be doing what they're doing in terms of
you know, addictive by design. It's it's Yeah, it's really important to me that this is as open access and we've got a well, not massive yet, but it's a fast growing resource bank for research in this area so that we can keep on top of latest developments. Because I'm a big fan of Maya Angelou, know, do the best you can with what you've got when you know better, do better. And I think we are learning a lot about this as, you know, it's a new technology, it's emerging and it takes a while for the research to catch up. But when we have the research, we need to apply it. know, I think being able to take an evidence-based approach, but also a common sense approach, because the evidence isn't, you know, by its very nature, isn't able to lead the way. It's working on things that are already happening. So there is still stuff that we can do to say, okay, there's no evidence around this yet, but... common sense and what we know about child development and everything means that we're going to recommend X, Y, Z. So I think being able to have that access to that information and whether you're a parent or a developer or whatever just gives you the confidence.
The Playful Lens: Yeah, and I love what you say there, Amanda, that ignorance isn't an excuse. So you've got this framework which is evidence-based, but also it's free. you can't say, well, actually I couldn't afford it, or, it's behind a paywall, or I love that it's free. So there actually is no excuse. it's really, it's evidence-based, it's free, it's there, it's available. Use it.
Amanda: Absolutely, absolutely. And the idea behind Thrive, so the Thrive is a social enterprise, it was only set up last month, so it's all still very new, but we're developing Thrive as a hub for anybody who wants to know more and do better for kids in the digital world. And the idea there is that as it evolves, we'll be developing resources for parents, for teachers, for people doing design courses in schools and colleges. all of those things so that there is, again, an evidence-based hub for people to go to for advice and information that, like you say, doesn't do, doesn't fear monger or scare monger, doesn't, but also doesn't just wave everything through and assume that all digital is equal because it's not.
The Playful Lens: Yeah, yeah, it's a really good point. And I think I told this story before, but like Helena said, like I'm very no screens, we don't do them, but I definitely need to get better at that. And I think I may have told you this story before, Amanda. My son, who's eight last year when he was doing a project, he came home with the finished project after a couple of weeks and we were reading it, and a sentence literally stopped and the and we said, And the what? And he said, I don't know, that's where the iPad stopped. So we had gone so strict on screens that he didn't know you scroll up on an iPad. And we actually talked about it afterwards. We said, that was research, that was good digital time. He was
actually learning, but he didn't know to go further up. So, there is that you have to allow it because we went, Yeah, we don't know. And he didn't learn anything more because he didn't scroll up. So I have to get better at allowing the good screen time too.
Amanda: Yeah, and I think, but I think take the children's lead on that as well. think if they are interested, it's managing the battles, isn't it? Because if they are interested and they do want screen time, then that's the time to have the conversation with them around, what's good screen time, how you can use it positively and how much is too much and all of that kind of stuff. But I love the fact that, you know, kids, there are kids who are still wanting to go outside and play and the more of that, the better. as far as I'm concerned. So it's not about trying to dissuade any of all the good, real life outdoor, exciting adventurous play, because that really is for me, that is the superfood of the play diet.
The Playful Lens: Yeah, and I think that's why we haven't had to have this conversation really is because all he wants to do is be outside. So, the friends call or he wants to go and kick ball, he that's all he wants to do. So we haven't actually had these conversations yet. So when it came up in the context of the research for the project, it was kind of new to us all because it just isn't thankfully isn't an issue in the house at the moment. He just wants to be outside kicking balls. So long may that continue.
Amanda: Absolutely, absolutely.
The Playful Lens: And and you know it's interesting because Dr. Peter Gray's research would align with with what you said, Gillian. It's like if children will actually choose to go outside once they have freedom, freedom to play, they'll choose to go outside and play with friends, but that's in an ideal world. The reality is not every child has somebody knocking on their doors to say, Come on, do you want to go out and play? So then the screen becomes the the default. And I know like I have three daughters. And my eldest has a tablet because I'm probably like a screen Nazi going, I can keep them out of the house for as long as I can. So we don't have a lot of screens, but my eldest has a tablet and I struggle with trying to manage that. So initially it was like before she got it, we kinda agreed that, well, look at weekends. You know, you can use it at the weekend because she wanted to keep in touch with her her classmates. And I was like, okay. And Now she's in sixth class, so all her classmates have moved on to a phone and why they had a group chat on the iPad, now it's a group chat on the phone. And it's I find it so hard to navigate my ten year olds like, but can I get can I get a tablet for Christmas? And I'm like, god, is this going to be more battles now? And me fighting with her about using it and not using it, because I don't like the control element. I don't like that I'm the one who's Yeah, as you say, we need the contract, so it's not me coming in saying, put that away now and causing all these fights. It's like having an agreement and holding boundaries. But it's it's so hard to navigate, Amanda, isn't it?
Amanda: It's really hard, yeah really hard and we've got the social media ban coming in in the spring and so you've got all of that going on as well.
The Playful Lens: That's brilliant. We don't have that. We don't have that here. It's much needed. Yeah, it's much
Amanda: okay.
The Playful Lens: needed here.
Amanda: Well, I think it's a bit of a blunt instrument in some ways because it doesn't catch everything. as far as I'm aware, it's not catching things like Roblox and some of the gaming consoles that you can have chats on there. So I think it gives parents a little bit more leverage to say, you're not having a smartphone until you're old or whatever. And certainly if you're having a smartphone, you're not getting access to the social media platforms. which I think is, generally is a good thing, but I think kids are able to get around it in lots of ways. And I think the bad actors are able to get around it as well. So yeah, it's a tricky one, but yeah, phones for children in that kind of young teen age is a real minefield. And I think you've got to trust parents to know their children and be able to do it in a way that makes sense for them. maybe one of things one of the techniques I like is giving having a a family phone so that it's not theirs and they can't there's nothing private on there because everybody can access it but it's a way of keeping in touch with friends or whatever so starting off as it being a family phone rather than a personal phone can be a way and then again as your second daughter gets a bit older if they need to make sense of a message or whatever there is a number there that they can use but they know that it's not private.
The Playful Lens: That's good idea. that's a really good idea. 'Cause my ten year old is in fourth class and all of her pals have phones and then she's like, Can I use your phone to text? And I'm like, that's so hopefully opening a whole other kind of worms. So I really like that idea of family phones. Yeah, it's good idea. Yeah.
Amanda: And then they can show that they're responsible and use that well and not, take it step by step. And then, if they can show that they can use it well, then when they get to a certain age, they can have their own phone. But, you know, making sure that you're still very much able to access it and that they know that that's part of the deal to start with.
The Playful Lens: Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. it's just so hard. It's just such a layer of complexity on parents that, you know, my mother and father never had to deal with.
Amanda: No, my parents just worried I watched too much TV as a kid and that was when, there was only four channels and it went
The Playful Lens: Yeah.
Amanda: off at seven o'clock anyway.
The Playful Lens: Yeah, yeah, yeah, that's it. And I think this constant access to to screens is
is like that's why I feel like you know, in an ideal world the research would be like we can step back out of this and trust children, but they're going to get enough of it. They're going to get fed up with it and like, I'm going out to play with my pals now. But I feel like the design of the technology is too much for that. It's too they get sucked in and time passes. So I feel like I have no choice but put time limits and I know every house is different and some house children telly could be there and they'll just breeze past it and they won't care whereas I know my children are like me and it's like magic box be stare at you all day and all night. Well my my
Amanda: Yeah.
The Playful Lens: son is outside kicking ball all day he comes in with filthy knees that take ages to wash
Amanda: Yeah, and then it is, I think it really is a point that, and again, that's the whole idea behind the balanced play pyramid approach is that it's a tool and you adapt it to the needs of your family. And, if you've got kids of different ages or you've got other responsibilities, or maybe you've got, you know, a blended family where people have come from having two different approaches to technology, there's all sorts of, you know, nuances. So it's definitely not a one size fits all. But I do think that the more informed we can be about it, the easier it is to make sensible decisions that work for your family. So I think that's the, for me, it's all about getting the information out there and helping people understand what's good, what violence looks like, and how to help kids thrive in an increasingly digital world.
The Playful Lens: Okay, so let's I want to break this down because I know this episode is going to go out before Christmas and other parents might be like me wondering, ooh, what do I do if they're looking for loads of devices? So if I was to break this down to a really practical level, if my children are age, so age doesn't really come into it for you, Amanda, or is there a certain boundary that you'd hold?
Amanda: No, it does. I think, I think under the age of sort of six or seven, it's really is a parent led thing. you know, small bursts, no more than sort of 20 minutes, half an hour at a time. And ideally co viewing as well or co participation. You know, once they get six, seven, eight, you know, then they're going to start to want to do things on their own. there's things, maybe stuff they're looking at for school and education stuff. and they're able to navigate the games a bit better on their own. And I think that's where the conversation around what is it you're doing, what games are you playing, how long are you playing them for, who are you playing them with, all of those kinds of things. Those conversations are really important there. And then how does this fit into, you your balance play diet generally, and how do we maximize the benefits and make sure you're not just... set on your bottom doom scrolling.
The Playful Lens: Yeah, yeah. So get
ahead of it. Basically, Steven before the
Amanda: Yeah.
The Playful Lens: technology comes into the house. Yeah. Nearly agree on what it's going to look like, how it's going to work and putting responsibility on them. Once they know themselves, yeah, the balance played out. Don't be afraid of it. Yeah. and n don't be afraid to trust my own judgment as a parent in knowing my children and and figuring it out so that if it is time to bring in whatever I don't even know. Are they Nintendo's too do they still play Nintendo? Are they all we now or what do they play?
Amanda: No, Nintendo is really popular.
The Playful Lens: So if they want a Nintendo, instead of being like, no way, that's not coming into the house, it's like, okay, right, let's figure this out how to keep you safe in it and what what will balance look like? And then we agree on it. And then it will be my job to hold those boundaries because I'm the parent in a fair in a fair way. and that I'm not harming my child, I'm not impacting their brain development, I am not letting them open to the predators of the world if I do bring a bit more technology into my house because it's the way of the world. Is that fair, Amanda?
Amanda: Yeah, I think that's a great summary. think it's, it isn't, there are some very good things about technology and especially for kids who don't learn well in social situations and classrooms and stuff. you know, it can, for kids with additional needs, it can be a real lifesaver, but it does need managing and it does need that whole balanced approach is definitely the right way, you know, the way I would
The Playful Lens: Yeah.
Amanda: approach it.
The Playful Lens: Yeah. No, that makes sense. It's just the fear, isn't it? And the reality is they see me with a phone in my hand, you know, a lot of the day, even though I'm conscious of it and I try and have it in a different room when I can. They see me with my phone in my hand and I see them play when they make their Lego phones. Yeah. They'll be sitting on the couch, the Lego phone is beside them. And it's you know, we are I just need to get with it. Move with the time. Embrace it. Embrace sus area
Amanda: But do it gently, do it gradually as well. It's not an all or nothing. In the same way that you teach them to ride a bike and then go down the park on their own, you don't just suddenly let them out in the street. You walk them
The Playful Lens: Yeah.
Amanda: there and you hold their hand and then you let them go for a short amount of time. It's exactly the same with technology. They have to earn the trust and the more they show that they make good decisions and are responsible in using it, the more comfortable you'll feel about letting them.
The Playful Lens: Yeah. I feel so much better after talking to you, Amanda, because this holding
Amanda: that's good.
The Playful Lens: yeah, holding the this strict boundary around it doesn't feel right. I'm like, I know I'm depriving them in some way, but also I'm hearing all
the the scaremongering stuff. Do you feel all of the terrifying things that you hear and you're like, well then we just won't have it because then it can't happen. And I agree, it's that holding this absolutely not, it's not in the house because the minute we bring it in, something bad is going to happen. We'd have to let go of that. Yeah. Yeah.
Amanda: I think it's really important to see the bigger picture because if
The Playful Lens: Yeah.
Amanda: it's a part of their world and it's a part of their world that they think you just don't approve of, don't like, don't understand, they won't talk to you about it. And that's
The Playful Lens: Yeah.
Amanda: more dangerous because you're not going to stop them accessing it. They're just going to access it via secretive means or other means.
The Playful Lens: Yeah. Yeah.
Amanda: and it sends it underground and that means you have absolutely no control over it. And I think that's much more dangerous in the long run. So I think keeping the conversation open, explaining your concerns and your worries and the dangers to kids. If they're old enough to have a phone or go online, then they're old enough to understand that there are dangers and they've got to be careful and this is how it works. But I think parents with the best intentions, around, and this is around technology, can be around, it can be around, you know, all sorts of things going out on their own, parties, whatever it is as they get older. If you're too strict about it and the children don't feel that you understand or you're being reasonable, the chances are they'll do it anyway and just not tell you about it.
The Playful Lens: Do it anyway, and they're not educated on it, and they're not telling us, which is as you say, that's the dangerous combination. And it's like everything. If you make something taboo, then as you say, Amanda, it goes underground and you lose control completely. Yeah.
Amanda: And it also becomes more appealing because it's like, it's grown
The Playful Lens: Yes, yeah.
Amanda: up. What am I missing?
The Playful Lens: Yes, yeah. Yeah. Yeah. If it just becomes part of everyday life and it's normal and it's talked about, it's as you say, it's it's not exciting then. It's not as exciting. Yeah.
Amanda: No. And in the same way, know, they know where the sweets or treats are kept in the house, but they don't have free reign or unable to just go and gorge themselves. It's a similar they can have it there and learn how to manage it themselves and with your support. I think that's the most positive way of doing it.
The Playful Lens: Love it. Yeah. That is that is just a brilliant message. I feel I feel really reassured from that conversation and really informed and really I need to, you know, I just need to stop being so scared and need to realize this the way to keep them safe is actually to be be with them as we navigate this and not be the one saying, No. Yeah.
Amanda: together as well because if you can do it with them as they're learning how to use it and you're learning how to use it then that's a really good way of keeping those conversations open so that
The Playful Lens: Yeah.
Amanda: they know that they can talk to you about it because they recognize that you understand and you've you've gone on the journey together.
The Playful Lens: Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. So Amanda, the digital framework that you have created, who is it aimed for? Like who would you recommend to read it, to look at it, to have it?
Amanda: So it's aimed primarily at people making things for kids. the
The Playful Lens: Okay.
Amanda: game developers, the TV producers, anybody making apps and games and digital activities for children. That's the primary audience, but Thrive Digital Alliance is for everybody. And that's going to be a hub of, again, a lot of industry people, but it's also going to have resources for parents, for educators. Still all very new. There's nothing on there yet for those audiences, but hopefully within the next few months, we'll start to be putting more and more resources in there so that people can actually use it as a place to go. But anybody who's interested in the topic, like you said, the framework's free to download. There's no harm in downloading it if you're interested to look at what things you should be looking for when you're choosing games for your kids. And also the research bank, have a look at things that are going on there and the resources and the organisations that are affiliated with it to find more advice and information.
The Playful Lens: Sounds great and it's great to have a central place for all of this information. Yeah.
Amanda: That's the plan.
The Playful Lens: Amanda, you are doing phenomenal work and as a parent I am so grateful to you for this. Thank
Amanda: No, thank you.
The Playful Lens: you. Yeah. Thank you.
Amanda: Well, thank you for having me on to talk about it because it's something I'm really passionate about. So I appreciate the airtime.
The Playful Lens: yeah, brilliant. And I know you said that all the ri the resources are not there yet, but we'll certainly share the link so that people can keep dipping in and out and can can see when the resources then become available. Yeah.
Amanda: Yeah, and in the meantime, goodplayguide.com is still a good place to get ideas on the balanced play diet and some of the digital stuff as well.
The Playful Lens: Thank you so much, Amanda. Amanda, we won't put you through the rapid fire questions again. And
Amanda: Ha!
The Playful Lens: thank you for giving your time. It's wonderful to have you on Platon Lands again. Thank you so much.
Amanda: No, thank you for having me. I've really enjoyed it.