TRANSKRIP 🔗
00:00:04
Speaker 1: Welcome back to Rosters to Rings alongside Chet West. I am Thad Levine. In our continued effort to take listeners behind the scenes of how championship rosters are constructed, I couldn't think of a better person to join our conversation than Bill Barnwell, ESPN senior writer, esteemed NFL insider, host of the Bill Barnwell Show, and dear friend of our program, Rosters to Rings. From dissecting salary cap gymnastics and trade deadline blockbusters to explaining why certain contenders fall short in January, Bill has spent nearly two decades expertly breaking down how championship rosters are actually constructed. Bill, welcome back to Rosters to Rings.
00:00:41
Speaker 2: Nearly two decades really hit me hard. I was thinking, like, that can't be right. And then I did the math and I said, oh, no, it is right. And that got me very perturbed to start the show. But thank you anyway for that. I really appreciate the kind intro. Outside of reminding me how old I am.
00:00:56
Speaker 1: Bill, I was just talking to my wife earlier today and saying, How crazy and outrageous it is that their assistant GMs in baseball now in their late 20s and early 30s. And she reminded me you were actually one of those about X number of years ago that she said. So I commiserate with your pain.
00:01:11
Speaker 3: Bill, this is your second visit to the show. I don't know if you know the mug and pencil set. How's that coming to that? It is.
00:01:18
Speaker 1: It requires five visits, five visits, and then you will be bestowed a roster string mug and pencil set. So you're two fifths of the way there.
00:01:25
Speaker 3: Those are still being manufactured right now, though, I believe.
00:01:28
Speaker 2: Do we have any members of the five guest club yet?
00:01:31
Speaker 1: I think John Daniels may be the first person to achieve that as somebody who has co-hosted a number of times. No actual guest has reached that. So as we're looking at your vaunted bookshelf behind you, perhaps someday nestled amongst your books will be a mug.
00:01:50
Speaker 3: Right next to the Around the Horn? Yeah, we could throw it up there.
00:01:54
Speaker 2: It could possibly replace the football phone if needed.
00:01:56
Speaker 3: Oh, I don't know about that. That's a beautiful piece. I've been looking at that since we jumped on here.
00:02:01
Speaker 1: Compliment the football phone. Don't do that.
00:02:03
Speaker 3: Yes.
00:02:03
Speaker 1: Certainly not replace.
00:02:05
Speaker 3: That's fair. Bill, we just went through the NFL trade deadline. I'm going to hit you right between the eyes with this right off the bat. A little context. I'm a Lions fan. We have a, we'll call it a text thread between myself and some of the guys from back home in Detroit. We get a little worked up around trade deadline ever since Brad Holmes took the gig because he seems to be allergic to making the big deal to one degree or another. You wrote extensively about all the holes that the Lions had
Load full transcript
this year that they probably really needed to patch up. Every year seems the same story. Fans see obvious holes in their team's roster. They see other teams making the moves all over the NFC North. We saw moves being made. Lions stood pat. And the fans are left wondering why their own front office stood pat. From a fan's perspective, it can feel like management isn't doing enough to win. But from the front office perspective, there are obviously factors fans don't see. How should we evaluate a team that doesn't make a move when it seems very clear that they should have? It takes two to tango. But at what point does being disciplined and protecting future assets become a missed opportunity to win right now? because I'm speechless over this whole thing.
00:03:25
Speaker 2: Yes, and we should leave what happened after the trade deadline with Aiden Hutchinson's knee injury perhaps aside, because it's a little unfair to say, hey, we can see a week into the future and know that your best player is no longer available for the rest of the season. So let's leave that aside just as part of this conversation. I actually would like to hear Thad's answer to this first, because I know from your perspective, Thad, thinking about the Twins and sort of the last few years, There were years where you were active at the deadline. It did not lead to the success you were hoping for. And there were years where you were more passive at the deadline and years that led to success independent of the fact that you did not do too much relative to your maybe expectations or your fans' expectations at the trade deadline.
00:04:06
Speaker 1: I think this is one of the biggest evolutions I've seen in the game and candidly, maybe not for the better. So I think there was, when I started my career, there was a lot of energy around the trade deadline. Everyone was either named a buyer or a seller, and most sellers sold and most buyers bought. And the general consensus was the teams that were trying to win now were going to sell future assets to acquire an enhanced position to win today. And the teams that were building for the future were happy to sell those now valued assets for future prospects. And then what happened in our game is we started getting an incredible amount of intelligence and data that actually educated us to the fact that two months of a player really didn't meaningfully sway your chances to win. And so I think we then shifted from a mindset of trying to get great players to help us win to trying to do great deals. And the reality is doing a great deal at the deadline is very tough to execute. Because you're trading potentially in a prospect's case, six years of their services, sometimes for two months of a very solid veteran. And you're talking about impacting what is usually at most one third of the season and ideally the postseason. It is really tough to justify an actual bona fide return on investment in that. So then I hearken up one of my mentors, John Hart,
and he always said, He felt that if the team had done their part, which is to say that they were in playoff contention, it was up to the front office to do their part, to do something to try to help them win. And so I think where I reconciled in my mind why you would do something when the team has put themselves in a chance to win is because you have to value winning. And valuing winning doesn't always perfectly fit in a formula that has surplus value in baseball or return on investment or some metric like that. So I think when I've been involved in the best moves of the deadline, typically it's when the team I'm working for is a prohibitive favorite to be in the playoffs. And the move we're making is to enhance our chances to win once we get in the playoffs. I think the mistakes are made when you're really sitting well outside of the playoff discussion and you're hoping that this move by hook or crook can get you in the playoffs. I think that's when you can make a move that you regret making. But I think when you're a prohibitive favorite to be in the playoffs... it is your job to do something to try to enhance your chances to win when you get there and kind of shed this notion of like, well, anything can happen when you get there. While true, typically the team with more talent actually wins.
00:06:44
Speaker 3: Is it the same for football though? What do you think? It's different.
00:06:47
Speaker 2: I mean, it's certainly different, right? Like I think this idea of you have a much bigger roster, usually you're trading draft picks as opposed to prospects. And it's easier for fans to get excited about prospects prospects i think because there's something tangible there like they're like you know you can watch the highlights of a prospect you can sit here and say okay i know what this guy is doing in a ball or in double a like maybe it's easier to envision okay this is how this specific player might impact our team in the years to come draft picks are sort of just value there's a wild card right and and so you sort of like you're just like well we have We traded this thing in the future that is nothing yet for something now. That feels so satisfying and exciting. And so every time a team trades, like the Bears trade with Jeffrey Simmons, for example, two first round picks in the future, it's like, well, those picks could be anything. Jeffrey Simmons is a superstar right now. And that's such an exciting and tantalizing thing. And yet you look at history and the vast majority of the time, these trades have not worked out for the team that made that big trade. And I think to that point, the idea of we're a competitive team, we should do something to supplement our roster is legit and fair and realistic. And I look at a team like the Seahawks last year that traded for Rasheed Shaheed, gave up a couple of mid-round picks. And Rasheed Shaheed was not a superstar in Seattle, but he had an important, I think, a kick return or a punt return for a touchdown that led them back against the Rams in the regular season for their comeback that led them to the one seed. They went and hit a big catch in the postseason that helped them. win a game. So it wasn't like he was an essential piece, but he was a player where supplemented a weakness, filled in, you know, kind of a part of that team where he could have outsized value and then did for a team that won the Super Bowl. But I feel like I've been talking for so long already, but this is the really, I think the interesting thing that's happening in the NFL is this idea of all in. Like this idea of like, we have to take advantage. We are good right now. We have to sacrifice a significant portion of our draft capital to get a guy to fill our team and give us a chance of winning a Super Bowl this year.
00:09:04
Speaker 3: But sometimes it doesn't seem like they're giving up that much draft capital. I mean, to go out and get a cornerback, you trade a fifth round pick, right? I mean, at the end of the day, that doesn't seem like that much yet. A lot of these guys, Brad Holmes being one of them, doesn't seem to want to give up that fifth round pick for that corner. Or at least that's my irrational, mouth-breathing fan speak here, right?
00:09:27
Speaker 2: No, I mean, that's the kind of trade I would have expected the Lions to make. And I think that's the trade where I'd say, you know, could you really have been a little more aggressive trying to find a guy like Arik Wollin, for example, where it's a pending free agent, you get a deal like that done? But you look at the Bears. They traded two first-round picks for Jeffrey Simmons. You look at the Packers. They traded two first-round picks last year for Micah Parsons. And there's this thing around the NFL of, well, we need to go all in because other teams are doing it. And you look at the last 20, 25 years of the NFL, there has been one team that went all in in a certain year and won the Super Bowl. And that was the Rams. The Patriots, yeah, they occasionally traded for, you know, players who are there, but they gave a fourth round pick for Randy Moss, a second round pick for Wes Welker, a second round pick for Corey Dillon. They did not say, hey, we're going to trade two future first round picks to go get a guy. If anything, they traded picks They traded players away to get picks and kind of keep their roster supplemented with young talent. The Chiefs, with Patrick Holmes, they've traded Terry Kill, Trent McDuffie, Jalen Watson for significant– not Jalen Watson– Trent McDuffie and Marcus Peters for significant draft capital over the last few years. The Philadelphia Eagles, who have been to two Super Bowls, one with Howie Roseman, another team– sorry, went to three. Same thing. They've traded away more players for draft capital recently. then traded four players to supplement their roster. And so I think there's this distinction where like, yes, the idea of we want to add a player on the margins, we want
to add a player to prove to our team, to our building that we're committed to this, that we think this guy can actually be a player who does make kind of a difference in the margins over the course of the rest of the season or into the years to come. I think there's nothing wrong with that and it's a reasonable and logical thing to do. But we saw teams get really aggressive And the prices for those players as a result became really aggressive because teams were saying, hey, if you're getting a first round pick and a second round pick for Jordan Davis, a good nose tackle who plays half the defensive snaps in the game, doesn't make an impact on third downs, we're going to ask for a lot for a player who might have been worth a fourth or fifth round pick a couple of years ago. Maybe that guy was going for a second round pick because the price of those players had gotten so high. So I do think there's a middle ground that makes sense between doing nothing and just stacking all the surplus value and going all in and just trading all your future draft picks away. But that's hard to kind of realize because you don't really know what offers are out there and how much players are going for potentially in the days before the trade deadline.
00:11:58
Speaker 3: Did you see a move that made you shake your head the most? Kind of made you sit there and say, oh, no way. Why did they do that?
00:12:03
Speaker 2: The Jordan Davis trade was the big one because we've seen, it's not that Jordan Davis is a bad player. We're talking about a useful nose tackle in a league that wants to play with more lightboxes. which means six players in the box. You get more defensive backs in the field. You're asking a little more out of your defensive tackles. But in years past, first round, second round pick, that was for a player who was going to be playing at an all-pro level, a player who was going to be in the prime of their careers, a premium player who was going to be affecting the field on all three downs. And the Jaguars traded the first and second round pick for a player who's never even been to the Pro Bowl, never really been competitive for a Pro Bowl, a talented player, a young player still, really in the prime of his career, a great athlete. But a guy who the Eagles, I'm sure they were thrilled at the amount they got for a player who was not a core part of their team, who was not going to be a player who they saw as irreplaceable or essential to their roster. And so I think for a Jags team that has a quarterback who's young, still really in the prime of his career, and Trevor Lawrence, Did they really need to go all in this year? Was this going to be their best chance? They have a good coach. They have a good quarterback. They have a good roster. They have some really talented players, none of whom are about to go anywhere. Bears, same thing. When they traded two first-round picks for Jeffrey Simmons, good player, but they have a great quarterback, a great head coach.
They're both relatively young. Ben Johnson's under 40. Caleb Williams, I think, is 24 or 25. They're not about to disappear. They're going to have a lot of chances to win over the next decade. So the idea of we're going to make it harder to win a Super Bowl is in the four or five years to come to increase our chances right now, I just don't see the sort of like desperation necessary that justifies that trade, even if it does make the team better right now.
00:13:47
Speaker 3: Fed, I don't know if this is football or baseball, and maybe you feel the same way, and you're a football fan, and you've worked across baseball and front offices. I feel like I get a little more irrational over football when the teams don't make the deal I want to see them make. Whereas baseball, it could be the length of the season. It could be it's 162 games. It could be, you know, football is like one shot 17 times in a season. And it feels like the world is ending when that one week falls apart. You know, that one week you get blown out or something. And you want to see the team make a deal to get better right now because you can't have another Sunday like that. Whereas baseball, it's like we're going to play another 25, 30 games. Who knows what's going to happen? I mean, you know, the Patriots, they get throttled in Munich. if they had a three-game set against the Lions, they'd come back the next day and throttle them right back. No, we'd remember that game. But of course, we're going to sit here and stew over it for seven days. So maybe that's a little bit of it playing into it. It's the patience aspect for a fan in football.
00:14:46
Speaker 1: Well, I think one of the biggest differences, Chet, is the fact that in baseball, we have done better of educating the fans of who the prospects are. So, you know, whereas in the NFL, you're just talking about draft picks. So they're a little bit more unknown players. Now, not to say that everyone in the baseball does well in the draft, but like Bill could probably tell us very clearly which general managers, which front offices do do well in the draft. But in our market here, Bill, in Minnesota, one of the criticisms of Quesi was that he ultimately did not excel in the draft. And so as a result, he was kind of losing on both ends where he wasn't necessarily trading the draft picks to get now capital. And when he was doing it, the trades weren't awesome. But when you retain the picks, the assumption is you're going to do extremely well with those picks. And that is a little bit of a misconception. And I wonder how much that factors into some of these teams pushing a few more chips in today is because it's the humility and understanding that maybe we don't do as well in the draft as we always think we shall. And yes, well, we assign a value to these draft picks. And to echo what you said earlier, Bill, I looked it up earlier. There were 11 trades since the draft involving first, second or third round picks, which seemed like a
very high number. Quite frankly, it seemed as if NFL GMs were operating a little bit more like baseball GMs because usually the NFL trade deadline is not exceptionally noteworthy. It was this year. And I think the last thing I just would say about this topic is one constituency that I think sometimes that front office executives do miss on is your team. And I think there is something you're saying to your team when you do invest in them at the deadline. You can't do this capriciously. You can't keep doing this year in and year out. and mortgaging your future, but you don't necessarily want your locker room to be motivated by this notion that the front office doesn't believe in us. Now let's try to go prove them wrong, which once again, you can't make short-term decisions all the time, but I do think it is a worthwhile constituency for executives to take into consideration. They're important to what you're doing and should not be ignored.
00:16:49
Speaker 2: This is the major league conundrum where, you know, when we major league, if there had been a major league six, The same tactics would not have worked on Cleveland by the time we got to Major League Five or Six.
00:16:59
Speaker 3: That's an incredible pull. That's great.
00:17:04
Speaker 2: I think there's something that makes sense with both of your guys' points, which is this idea of the small sample, right? The idea of the anxiety. If we have to get this one right because we don't get very many of them, that applies to the 17-game season where you only get so many games and you're waiting a week. to get your next game. And on top of that, I think with draft picks, right? Where, you know, for a guy like Kweisi Adolfo Mensah, who, you know, had plenty of hits in free agency, I think did some things really well. But obviously, some of the draft picks are not all that great. I will say, to be fair, that last, that big draft, they trade up for J.J. McCarthy, they trade up for Dallas Turner.
00:17:42
Speaker 1: J.J.
00:17:42
Speaker 2: McCarthy's having a good season, unfortunately, for the Giants. Dallas Turner is having a Pro Bowl year this year for the Vikings on edge. So one of those things where, number one, you might get fired before you can actually see your guys develop into useful players. But with the Major League Baseball draft, even the reduced, the shortened Major League Baseball draft, you're still getting so many more players into the building. There's just such a bigger farm system, so many more opportunities. You know, you can assign players internationally. There's, you know, there's just such a wider range and it takes so much longer for those players to get to the majors so that there is that sort of like, you know, multi-year developmental cycle where you can sort of convince yourself hey like as a fan even if my team's not that great right now well i i i can still wait and see okay i know there are good players coming down the pike there are good players in our our triple a
team our double a team um i can get excited about them in the nfl from a fan perspective you're seeing those guys immediately so you're judging them if you think they stink immediately if you're you know if they play well suddenly your gm's a genius and you feel like he doesn't know what he's doing but you might only get judged as a GM based on two first-round picks or maybe one first-round pick and a couple second-round picks. You might only get three or four shots.
00:19:01
Speaker 3: If it's a big enough success or a big enough failure, right? Right, exactly.
00:19:05
Speaker 2: And so I've seen plenty of GMs over the course of my time covering the league, Bill Belichick, Howie Roseman, John Schneider, where if you ask the fans... three years into their tenure, hey, are they good at their jobs? Are they good at picking players in the draft? They would say, oh my God, these guys are incredible. We are so lucky to have them. And if you ask them five years later, they would be saying about the same people, they're idiots. They don't know what they're doing. Howie Roseman's never scouted. He doesn't know what he's talking about. Bill Belichick, the game has passed him by. He's a coach. He's too busy to be general manager. Howie Roseman drafted Jalen Raker over Justin Jefferson in the draft one year Eagles fans got so upset they went to a Phillies game. in April the following year and chanted, fire Howie. This guy had won them a Super Bowl four years earlier, and he was about to win them another one in the years to come. And I don't think it's because Howie Roseman was suddenly a bad GM, or they didn't know what he was doing, but it's just in the NFL... because the draft is so high profile and because it's such a small sample and fans are very much, what have you done for me lately, both in a good way and a bad way, there's just such pressure to get these things done so quickly and succeed so quickly. And so I do think there's more pressure. And so I wonder if, like you said, that is a reaction to that. It's just, hey, if I don't feel confident I have any ability to draft players better than the next guy, Maybe it is better for me to take the guy who I feel more confident about because I can evaluate him at the pro level and I'll find the players around him, the cheap solutions, those cost control players around him. I'll try to find those guys on day two or day three of the draft with later picks because I think it's a crapshoot. I'd rather have the sure thing and then take my crapshoot later on as opposed to having the crapshoot there early in the draft when you're taking those big decisions.
00:21:00
Speaker 3: Bill, you mentioned something about sample sizes there and it makes me think a little bit about analytics and We're going to take a quick break here for a word from our sponsors. When we come back with Bill, I'm going to pose some questions to he and Thad in regards to analytics and kind of get their take on how football and baseball differ when we return on Rosters to Rings. Welcome back to Rosters to Rings. We've got Bill Barnwell. Bill, I want to cover some stuff around analytics. You've written about this quite a bit over the years. I know when I started reading you in Grantland, it was kind of a new concept and I loved it. It's, you know, Thad and I talk about it all the time where it kind of is involved in baseball, but football seemed to have catch on to that stuff kind of slowly. Baseball went through its analytics revolution before football really started to embrace it. Today, virtually every NFL organization has an analytics department. Have we reached a point where teams are all looking at the same information and reaching the same conclusions, or are there some differences there in how these teams are using analytics? For sure.
00:22:17
Speaker 2: There are definitely differences. I would say, based on talking to people in both leagues, my own evaluations, I seeing decisions that are being made, and certainly more so with football than with baseball, just because I cover the NFL for a living and I just am paying more attention to the NFL than I am to Major League Baseball. I would say the disparity between teams in terms of how they use data, how interested they are in data, and how much that actively influences their important decision-making I would say, is still quite significant. Whereas with Major League Baseball, obviously there are teams that have bigger analytics departments, teams with more data, less data. But football is sort of where baseball might have been, I would say, in 2006 in terms of the range of interest in data and how that influences things on a week-to-week basis or a season-to-season basis. And If you look at every NFL's front office on their website, every team has analytics people. We're not at the point where teams don't have analytics people. And there has been growth. I think if you looked at the NFL maybe 15 years ago, there were buildings where there might be an intern who was technically the team's analytics person who the NFL team would not even trust with access to their data. They would not have access to the team's scouting reports. They would not have access to you know, official NFL data. They just kind of had to piece things together because, you know, someone in the front office said, hey, we need to have an analytics person and the other people who were in charge not buy into that. That's no longer the case. Analytics has a seat at the table, but it's very different from organization to organization in terms of whether that person has a voice at the table. They have a seat for sure, but are they in the draft room helping make decisions? Are they actively working you know, speaking with the coach, with the front office, with ownership. And then the biggest thing is just like every team has a person who can help them with this stuff. Are the people in charge going to listen? You know, we, we talk about coaches and their
decision-making on Sundays. And like, there are coaches who are super interested and insightful and want to learn this stuff and, and find it to be helpful. There are coaches who are more hands-off and then most coaches are in the middle where it's, Hey, I want to hear about this stuff. But when it comes to the actual decision on Sunday, when I have 20 seconds to make this call in the middle of real time, I don't necessarily want to hear from my analytics person. I'm going to let my gut make this decision. And sometimes that's right. And sometimes that's wrong. And so I do think there's a pretty wide range where you have organizations where data and analytics and evidence and information is really part of every part of their critical decision-making process. Um, and there are more, I would say probably that are in the opposite direction of, yeah, we have an analytics person, but we don't really listen to them at any point. And, uh, you know, they're only going to make only going to matter, you know, in very rare cases. And then most teams are kind of somewhere in the middle.
00:25:36
Speaker 3: At this point. And Thad, am I reading that right? Like is, or is baseball, is baseball have like, is every team now kind of caught up on analytics or is there some teams that do it a little, a little better than others still?
00:25:49
Speaker 1: So on rosters to rings, one of our traditions, Bill, is if you say no offense at the beginning or at the end of your point, you're allowed to say things that are a little bit offensive. So let's just say I'll say things that are informative. Chet, I think there is closer to becoming a homogenization of everyone having a lot of data and a lot of information and a lot of resources, but it is a catch up, right? So There are some teams who were famously behind, who have recently changed their leadership, I'll just say, who the assumption will be that they'll get caught up to speed. But to echo a few of Bill's points, there was a kind of a race to getting the most information. And I think what most baseball teams realize, the goal is not to have the most information, it's have the right information and form your decisions to help acquire talent, develop talent, and ultimately win games at the major league professional level. So I think there's been, and I think one of the things that has been an advent in baseball recently is just the buy-in from your manager. Bill referenced it. We can do the best we can do. We can provide the best resources, but if the person on the front line really isn't utilizing the information, it doesn't go any further than that. So I think it used to be in baseball that there was a division between church and state where the front office acquired all the talent, put together the 25 and now 26-man roster, and But then it was up to the manager to deploy the talent to try to win. I think both parties are now really integrated in each other's business so that we're making the best and most informed
decisions. So my theory, and I'd be curious to Bill's thoughts on this, two things. I have one direct question for Bill and then one idea to bounce off you. The question is, in baseball, there is a pretty high correlation now between teams that are utilizing data and analytics and information and winning. you know, there are not many teams who are not using it who are not winning anymore. I'm curious, in the NFL, is there such a high correlation or are you still seeing that some teams are doing a quote-unquote old-school ways in winning versus now the new-school way? And you don't have to name names unless you want to, but if you do, just say no offense before or after whatever you say.
00:27:55
Speaker 2: No offense to the teams that are not using data. I do think it leans more towards the teams that are more open to information. And again, I do think it's, you know, It's tempting to treat it as a binary thing. And I think in the NFL, it's really not. I'll think about the Eagles, for example. They have Howie Roseman, who is a very nontraditional general manager, came up as a cap guy, running their front office, running their building, and has been very successful. That's ownership down. Jeffrey Lurie is someone who's been very interested in data in the past, mentioned it in press conferences when he's talked about the team. that's an organization where they are very invested in data. And now, admittedly, they stink this year. So this is the wrong time to be talking about it from a perspective of other smart news data. But that has been one of the league's better franchises. I think about the Chiefs, for example, where you go back to the Super Bowl, they played with the 49ers in overtime, where Andy Reid shouted out that I went to, you know, our analytics guy, who unfortunately, whose name I can't think of off the top of my head, I apologize. but that they went to their analytics guy before the season and said, hey, if we get to the postseason, and admittedly we're the Chiefs, we'll probably get into the postseason, and we get to overtime, should we take the ball first or should we take the ball second? Because the league's rules had changed about things, and the analytics person went over what the options are, and he said, basically, you're much better off getting the ball second. They got the ball second, and they won the Super Bowl because they knew, hey, we could play, we were going to be in four-down territory this entire drive after what the other team does first. We know the situation that's more valuable than getting that third possession and seeing whether we have to, you know, potentially losing without having to get the ball back. But, you know, I don't know that the Chiefs are necessarily as inclined to, you know, I don't think Andy Reid's looking at, you know, our prints outs to prepare his game plan starting the week because Andy Reid is a more old school coach. So I do think you have a wider range of sort of like potential influences when it comes to how much is this being influenced? I do think in general, the teams that are using data that are more analytically inclined have been on the more successful side, but also the Cleveland Browns. I'm not telling tales out of school here. They hired Paul DePodesta, who now is running the Rockies. They hired Andrew Berry, who's a super smart guy who comes from a combination of a football background, but also a data background. they were a very analytically inclined team, still are a very analytically inclined team, and they have mostly stunk for the entire time. But I will be fair, the Browns have stunk without data, and they've stunk, they've been a little better, but they have also been bad with data. And so it's a proof that maybe using analytics cannot solve everything and fix everything. But I do think overall, there has been kind of more of a lean towards, it's been a positive for the teams that have leaned heavily into.
00:30:56
Speaker 3: Using So this question, I'm getting this both of you guys, because I'm curious to hear Thad's answer, and we've touched on this a little bit, Thad, but I'm also curious because my team, the Lions, have been on the forefront of some of these things, but every team's got a sophisticated model, scouting info, access to the similar data. What's that next competitive advantage that could be out there? Is it better information? Is it interpretation or Is it having the courage to act on something others won't, like going forward on fourth down on your own 28-yard line? Is that the Dan Campbell thing? Is that kind of his move? Because I can't imagine what data backed that up because not a lot of teams did it. So where was your sample coming from? A very small sample size there, right? Yeah.
00:31:44
Speaker 2: I mean, you have to extrapolate, certainly, and say, hey, if people are going forward on fourth and one on their own 40-yard line, We know basically what the different values are, what the risk would be giving it up on our own 28-yard line. You can adjust for that. It's not necessarily going to be exactly the same situation, but it's going to be close, and you just have to kind of inform what you might do. I will say, I don't know that Dan Campbell... I think Dan Campbell is open to data. I don't think Dan Campbell is doing that because of a data thing. I think he's saying sort of.
00:32:12
Speaker 3: More of a nature.
00:32:15
Speaker 2: Number one, I've had six coffees today, and I'm ready to explode, and so I want this game to be over.
00:32:22
Speaker 3: My head is about to explode.
00:32:23
Speaker 1: Yes.
00:32:25
Speaker 2: I'm powered by something stronger than the Panera Lemonade. But number two, what would I be scared of? What would I be scared of if I were the coach on the other sideline? And I think about the Lions. Lions' defense is not that good. The Lions' offense is terrifying. Jameer Gibbs is a fantastic football player. Amon Ross St. Brown is awesome. They have a
very good offensive line. They have a great play caller, great quarterback in Jared Goff. That's the thing we should be leaning into. And I think that's the thing that if Dan Campbell had the Minnesota Vikings, we had a dominant defense and a messy quarterback situation, a bad running game, would he coach his team the same way? I don't know that I can say with any confidence that he would be willing to do that.
00:33:11
Speaker 3: He's been aggressive. The Lions' best defense is their offense, just keeping the other team off the field. Might as well let them out there for four downs.
00:33:17
Speaker 2: Right, and probably move the ball and get better field position for the defense to protect them for a while. And so I do think that's sort of at the heart of what's happening there. But I do think you can get this question of how do we take advantage of things other teams aren't doing.
00:33:39
Speaker 3: Yeah, what's the next thing? What's the next thing? I don't know.
00:33:44
Speaker 2: I'd be intrigued to hear that thought.
00:33:45
Speaker 3: Yeah.
00:33:46
Speaker 1: Yeah, so this is not earth shattering or particularly nuanced, but I just will share my thoughts on this is, I think one thing that a lot of baseball teams are spending a lot of time right now is trying to figure out if they can prognosticate injuries and help avoid them. So it's happening on two fronts. One is our performance groups are just growing exponentially. We have chiropractors, massage therapists, acupuncturists, sleep specialists, nutritionists, We're trying to do everything we can. We have physical therapists. We have people who are committed to what is now called prehab. So it's not rehab, but it's before you get hurt, how you can avoid it. We're trying to do the best we can do to keep the best players on the field. I think similarly, if we can get data and analytics about biomechanical elements of your physiology to understand where the risks lie and where some of the strengths of humans are, and we feel like we can on the margins improve those decisions, then I think that is something that will be cutting edge. And, you know, Bill, I look at, at football, which is, you know, probably one of the most significant injuries ever to take place in the game was the one in which Drake May breaks his ankle and Aiden Hutchinson celebrates and maybe tears his knee in the same, same move. That may change the trajectory of both those teams. So I know you were skeptical of the, the Patriots being a playoff team, but nonetheless, their hopes are now probably snuffed out. Similarly, the team I follow, the Ravens, they are a prohibitive Super Bowl contender with Lamar Jackson. They're probably not playoff relevant without him. And the one reason maybe the Cincinnati Bengals are doing as well as they are this year is the offensive line has been able to protect Joe Burrow. Joe Burrow has always been an excellent player. He just happens to be healthier this year. And so the ability,
the fortunes of your franchise is, when it comes to playoff opportunities, odds, and winning a championship are so dramatically impacted by your ability to have your star shine, I think the team that gets their heads wrapped around of how can we prevent some of these injuries and ideally sign players that are less inclined to get injured will be well ahead of their competitors.
00:36:00
Speaker 2: Yeah, it's a really good point. And there's definitely a lot of openness in the NFL that teams are not necessarily, who might not necessarily be inclined to rely on an analytics person for fourth-down decision-making might be far more open to a sports scientist or a psychologist or someone who might make an impact there where that's not traditional, but it's also not something that's data... Not data-driven is the wrong word, but not data-driven in the way that we think about football analytics in terms of in-game decision-making, which I think is kind of the most common lens that we threw stuff to. I also think about Bruce Arians. the head coach most recently of the Tampa Bay Buccaneers. He won a Super Bowl before that, the Arizona Cardinals. And this may be apocryphal, so no offense to Bruce Arians if this is false. But there's a story about how Bruce Arians would not have stretching during practice. And you'd be like, well, you know, everyone stretches. Olympic athletes stretch. And Bruce Arians' response was, you know, if a lion was chasing you, would you get up and stretch or would you start running? And his attitude was, you should start running. And so that was why he said, I wouldn't stretch. And so I'm not saying that's right or wrong. I think if you asked a sports scientist, they would probably tell you, or, you.
00:37:21
Speaker 3: Know, hey, probably good to stretch.
00:37:24
Speaker 2: Yeah, might be good. But number one, Bruce Arians won a lot of football games. And number two, Bruce Arians had a lot more power in the building than whoever the Cardinals or the Bucs hired to be their sports science person. And so I do think it's really fascinating to think about, you know, you have these multi-billion dollar teams, these multi-billion dollar organizations where decision-making really goes through an owner, a coach, a GM, maybe a couple other people, a team president. But like you're talking about six or seven people where their attitudes towards being open-minded, towards changing things, doing things in a different way, could be the difference between being open to spending millions of dollars to improve a department or improve your players' availability or just sort of sticking with what you have and hoping it works out. And that does vary dramatically from building to building and organization to organization. And the teams that don't succeed over long periods of time, no matter who they hire as a coach or a general manager or who they have on the roster, I think that speaks to some of the issues within the building between the people who do stick around after those coaches and GMs move on.
00:38:39
Speaker 3: So something just kind of dawned on me here is when we talk about analytics in football, we talk about analytics in baseball. Baseball uses it a lot to identify players. They're combing through all sorts of analysis to identify players they want to target, players that fit what they want to do. Football, the analytics, and correct me if I'm wrong here, Bill, but I think they get used a little more in the game planning area the play calling strategy, maybe, but to evaluate players, like when an evaluator comes in and you've got, let's just suppose you've got the analytics department and you've got your traditional football evaluator and they disagree on a player who should win that argument in.
00:39:22
Speaker 2: The NFL.
00:39:22
Speaker 3: You got an analytics guy over here. It's like, there's no way that guy's going to fit what we do. Look at X, Y, and Z data and the evaluator. your scout is sitting there saying, no, no, no, no. He's the guy that we need. I know this is this type of player. What, who wins that argument or who should win that argument?
00:39:37
Speaker 2: It's a great question. And I do think it's sort of contextual, right? Like it's not anything of, okay. Analytics says this player stinks. A scout says this guy is great. In that scenario, I think the scout is usually going to win the argument in terms of the pick. I don't know who wins the argument in the long view in terms of which is more likely to be correct. I think what I would say is it's important to understand why each of those people like the decision that they're making. I'll go to the Raiders taking Ashton Genting in the first round of the draft a couple years ago, where I think a scout might have said, hey, Ashton Gentry was a great player at Boise State, wildly successful, very productive, great skill set. An analytics person might say, well, this is a draft that has a ton of running backs. The surplus value of a running back in the first round is just not super high. There's real opportunity costs. It's much easier to find a really good running back like a Saquon Barkley, like a Derrick Henry in free agency. You can't really find players of that caliber. You can't find the second best edge rusher in the league or the fifth best edge rusher in the league in free agency because those guys kind of stick around. Both those guys can be right. Both those people can be right. There's not necessarily anything wrong, but I think it's a question of how much you value the big picture versus how much you say, well, this is the exception. I think there are teams who would say, yeah, you shouldn't trade a third-round pick for a kicker. just as an extreme example. And yes, in practice, you should not do that. But if you've had a team that your kickers have stunk for the last few years and there's a really good kicker available, you might say, you know what? We need a kicker more than your typical team.
And that sometimes is true and sometimes leads you to mistakes that you should not necessarily make organizationally. And so I do think in an ideal world, and I think Dad can speak to this better than I do, but I think in an ideal world, It's not like we're pitting one person against another and have to find the right answer. I think it's more about just what can your area of expertise contribute to this conversation? So for an analytics person, I don't think it's sitting here and saying, well, a scout thinks this guy is fast and this guy is slow. I think it's more, hey, what does the GPS data say about this player? How can we contextualize that to be more meaningful? What kind of routes does he excel on? How can we compare that to players who are running the same kind of routes? How can we use data to get sort of a clearer picture of the tangible things we know about this player? And then I think we take the scouting elements and say, okay, what's the intangible information that we can't necessarily track down? What contextual information is important? Was this guy playing in a new scheme for the first time? Was he used correctly? Did he have a great relationship with his teammates? Was he playing too often? Was he tired because he was on the field too much? I think there's all these different things that some of which we can quantify, some things we can't, but I think you're just hoping to get the best possible scouting perspective, the best possible analytical perspective.
00:42:50
Speaker 3: So there's a balance in the problem.
00:42:51
Speaker 2: Of course, there's a balance. And I think if I'm judging a punter, I really don't care much beyond can you punt it far and can you punt it at a high enough height where there's going to be time for our coverage guys to go underneath it. For a punter, I would typically just take data and say we're at 95% of the way there. And with a guard, I think you're typically taking like 10% of the data.
00:43:16
Speaker 3: Oh, really?
00:43:19
Speaker 2: You're using a lot of more football side, scouting side, coaching side. I think it's not like a binary thing. It's more of like a spectrum.
00:43:29
Speaker 3: Not as much data to put into a guard as there may be a punter.
00:43:32
Speaker 2: There is some data for sure. There's agility data and there's block data, but I think I would probably lean more on the coaching side when it comes to a guard.
00:43:42
Speaker 3: Thad, you've been in the room on the baseball side of things where you've probably had an evaluator and an analytics guy disagree. They're a scout and an analytics guy have a disagreement. Never. How does that get sorted out? I can't imagine that that's a clean transaction.
00:43:59
Speaker 1: Usually it's thumb wrestling.
00:44:02
Speaker 3: Not leg wrestling. Okay, good. So they stay on their feet.
00:44:05
Speaker 1: Chet, you know, the reality of what you just shed light on is like this has been a a major point of confrontation in baseball for the recent past. The teams that are creating more synergies between their data and analytics group and their scouting group are just beating other teams because the other ones are still at odds with each other. Way back when we had A.J. Hinch on the show, and I thought he did a great job of framing the data and analytics, he simply called it information. And he said, who amongst us wouldn't want to have more information to make our decisions? The reality of a lot of what's going on in baseball draft rooms, per se, is that we do create these models. One of the biggest drivers of the models are the scouting reports from the scouts. So they are still playing a big role. And then in addition, the point that Bill just made is right on point, which is we're also tasking the talent evaluators, the conventional scouts, to find all this other information that our models can't capture. You know, it's work ethic. How good of a teammate is this guy? What is his threshold of pain? What is his resiliency? And some of these things that you really can't understand just simply by looking at the numbers and crunching them. So I think there's a place for it. The way I've always reconciled it in my mind is as a senior decision maker or somebody who's contributed to senior decision making, I want to ground all of my decisions in the information, but I want to make them humanly. So where that shows up in a draft space and where it still gives agency for the scouts is If we have two players in a similar band and one is above the other, but the one who's lower is deemed to have the better work ethic and is deemed to be the guy who loves the game more and has been a better teammate throughout his career, by all means, let's take that guy. And I will never dispute that. So I want to make sure that the model gets the bands right so that we're not compromising on talent acquisition too much. But once we're in the same band, Give the scouts the freedom to make the right decision. And then once again, we discussed this, but where that shows up in the dugout is every pitching coach, every bench coach, every manager has a matchup grid, which shows exactly which of our relievers matches up best against each hitter on the opposing team. Sometimes, however, the guy who is the best suited to get their three, four or five hitters out Their two-year-old daughter had croup last night and the guy didn't sleep at all. Only my pitching coach knows that information. He has to be equipped with the latitude on the front line to be able to make that decision such that I will never crack down and say, but the matchup grid said this. Yes, will it lead to a conversation later?
00:46:42
Speaker 2: Perhaps.
00:46:43
Speaker 1: But that is something that you want to empower the people on the front line to ultimately make the decisions humanly, but provided that they're grounded in all of the information we have.
00:46:53
Speaker 2: I just want to point out, you know, there's some things you
can't count for. And Thad mentioning that A.J. Hinch framed an argument a certain way, I think is a next level combination of former catcher and verb there. So I just want to say I appreciated that.
00:47:07
Speaker 3: Folks, we're going to take a quick break. When we return here with Bill, we're going to ask him a few final questions when we return on Rosters to Rings.
00:47:26
Speaker 1: Welcome back to Rosters to Rings. We are very honored to be joined today by NFL expert insider Bill Barnwell. Bill, I feel like there's some correlation here between what we're seeing in the NFC and what we saw in the American League, which is to say you've got two divisions, the NFC East and the NFC South, eight teams. Only one of those teams is above 500. Yet, as we know, based upon the way the playoff schedule works, Two of those teams will be hosting playoff games, undoubtedly probably against teams that have better records and quite frankly may just simply be quite a bit better than them. What is your take on what is happening in the NFC globally here? And it feels as if the NFC South has been doing this for a couple of years. The East is joining them this year in their wallowing in mediocrity. But are there any changes you'd propose to the NFL playoff format or do you think we've got this just right?
00:48:17
Speaker 2: I do lean towards sort of letting the world play out the way that we might. And I think we've had more cases of this in the recent past for some reason. I don't know if it's really a meaningful sample in terms of just bad divisions leading to unexpectedly frustrating and disappointing teams hosting playoff games. But I'll give you a couple of examples why I think we shouldn't touch it. 2020 NFC East, the Washington football team, I believe they were at the time, won the... division with seven wins. The Eagles were, I don't want to be, again, no offense, outwardly tanking in the final week of the year to get a better pick, which they did. And they traded that pick down, got an extra first round pick for it, turned it into Devontae Smith, really good set of trades there. So tanking did work for them, at least for that week. Two years later, they had one of the best records in NFL history, collectively as division through nine games. So it turned around really quickly. for that division. And then I would also think about one of maybe the most important and I think memorable NFL playoff games of the last 20 years, which was, I want to say 2010 or 2011. Please correct me if I'm wrong with the year, but the Seattle Seahawks won the NFC Championship. West, the final week of the year in primetime, I want to say with Charlie Whitehurst as their starting quarterback against the St. Louis, at that time, Rams with Sam Bradford, they hosted the New Orleans Saints, who were a much better team in Seattle. And that game ended, or at least kind of climaxed, I guess, with Marshawn Lynch running through the entire Saints team for a victory. with a crowd that
was so loud that it was registered on the Richter scale. It didn't directly lead to Seattle winning a Super Bowl, but it was a Pete Carroll coach team. It was a Marshawn Lynch-led offense where he became a focal point of the offense in the years to come. There were some players on that team who weren't part of the Super Bowl team, but it was a really significant moment for that organization, for that city.
00:50:28
Speaker 3: I feel like that's when beast mode became a thing, right? Wasn't that when beast mode got invented around Lynch?
00:50:34
Speaker 2: It did. Yes. And so even though that, you know, would that have meant a 10th as much if it had happened in New Orleans as opposed to Seattle? No, it would not be anywhere near as memorable. It was memorable because it was great play, but it was also the fact that the crowd was going absolutely insane because it was a home game for Seattle. And so I would be a little reticent to say, okay, you have to skip the postseason if you don't win nine games, if you don't win a record, you don't get a home game if you do. I do think I want to reward teams who win a bunch of games, but I do think if you are really that good of a team, you should be able to beat a mediocre team on the road in the postseason. And so the Rams pulled it off last year. They beat the Panthers. It was a close game, closer than I think a lot of people expected. I would lean more towards keeping things the way they are.
00:51:25
Speaker 1: Wayne, the fact that they recede after the first round helps resolve some of this, right? Because what we saw in the American League this year, which was The Cleveland Guardians, who had the 11th best record in Major League Baseball, got a bye, which was significant because their road to the ALCS was meaningfully more paved and easier than the three AL East teams that beat themselves up. It's something we've talked about in baseball circles, about the notion of receding. The NFL does do that. So if you do have that one kind of misaligned game to begin with, it does correct itself and incorrect itself pretty quickly in the playoffs for the NFL.
00:51:58
Speaker 2: Yep.
00:52:00
Speaker 3: I want to float something here. You don't want to change the playoffs, which is fine. That's, that's fine. We're not going to change the playoffs. I floated this with Thad before. How do you feel about changing the draft order a little bit? How so? Well, here's what I'd like to do. And you can use this in one of your columns or something. You can throw it out there and run with this. Um, I'm never going to get relegation, which I think is a wonderful process for getting rid of the teams that aren't succeeding and promotion is awesome.
00:52:29
Speaker 2: Can you imagine pitching Jerry Jones on relegation?
00:52:32
Speaker 3: We could do a whole series on this. There's no, I would love nothing more than to see. Yeah, that would be incredible. I, and I don't think we have quite the infrastructure for it yet in any
of our sports. That said, I would like to see something done about the draft where the worst team gets the number one overall pick. And there's a few reasons for a, I don't think they deserve to be rewarded for anything. They did terribly. Um, B I don't think the player that's getting picked in that slot deserves to have to go to an organization that terrible. Uh, what if we did something along the lines of like the number one pick went to the best performing team of the non post-season teams. So like the nine and 17, that's almost there. Didn't quite get it. Maybe had some injuries, bad luck, whatever. Let's give them the first pick in the draft next year. Is that something you could see being a reality at any point in time?
00:53:27
Speaker 2: Well, we're seeing in a couple places. The NBA, I think, they've changed some of their rules where they're now incentivizing teams to not finish with the worst record. I like, and it might be tough in football because the number of games is just not, it doesn't lend itself to having significant differences between teams, but there's a, it's called the gold plan. which I want to say I've read about in my former colleague Sean McIndoe's columns about the NHL at The Athletic. But it's this idea of we determine draft order by how many games a team wins after they're eliminated from the postseason.
00:54:07
Speaker 3: Oh, that's a nice wrinkle.
00:54:09
Speaker 2: There's this idea of, yes, you're going to stink. You're going to get eliminated. That's not ideal. But you want to be competitive. You have to keep trying. You're not going to sit there and say, okay, We're going to play our AAA All-Stars in September to try and get the best possible draft pick and lose as many games as possible. Now, I don't think you're going to call up all your prospects and start eating up their service time and try and get a better pick necessarily, but there's a balance, right? There's a thing of, okay, we know there's a tangible benefit to being competitive, and that's going to matter because you're going to have teams who are competing for the postseason having to play tougher games in September instead of just having kind of luck in the schedule and playing some bad teams. It's tough in football just because you're only talking about probably three or four games for a lot of teams or even less. But I do think in baseball, in basketball, in hockey, where you have significantly larger schedules, that does seem like an appealing way to make the draft sort of more equitable and keep competitive balance on a higher level.
00:55:10
Speaker 3: I like the idea.
00:55:12
Speaker 1: What's your idea? Well, no, but he added the wrinkle.
00:55:15
Speaker 3: He added the wrinkle there that I like. It's not his wrinkle. The gold plan's wrinkle.
00:55:19
Speaker 2: No, it's the gold plan. It's by a PhD student whose last name is gold. But it does sound nice. No matter what the gold plan is, it seems like something you should do. I like the concept.
00:55:30
Speaker 1: It's the balancing act, Bill, of how much do we want to reduce tanking, which I don't think we'll ever be able to perfectly eradicate. But how much do we want to reduce it? versus we started this whole conversation talking about the trade deadlines, it will mute the trading deadline. If you, because there's no such thing as then selling, you will hold on to your expiring asset because you are coveting that future draft pick, or you're going to be asking for such a dramatic return to account for the fact that you're not going to get the draft pick. So there are trade-offs to this, but it's something that I think could certainly eat into this notion of teams tanking. And whether it's, you know, in baseball starting on, right after the trade deadline, it's a sprint to the finish line. Whoever finishes first of the 10 teams with the worst records at that point, I think the challenge in addition in football, as I see it, is it's not a uniform schedule. So the strength of schedule for each of these teams is so dramatically different. And as we just quipped, some of these divisions are not very good. And if you're playing two games in division, you may find that you're not equitably actually handling this. I'm sure there's some statistic out there. I was reading about strength of victory earlier as a new statistic that people are tracking that may be a little nuanced for the fans out there, but there's something where you could capture the best of Chet's ideas and the best of your ideas, curb tanking, and hopefully not also totally diminish the impact of the trade deadline.
00:56:53
Speaker 3: Yeah.
00:56:54
Speaker 2: As we've said so many times during this conversation, there's a balance, right? There is a middle ground that I think gets us closer to the right direction without necessarily having to commit to an extreme example. And so I do think, you know, it really depends on how much motivation there is to get stuff done. I think in the NBA, you know, there were such a significant sort of influence from tanking from teams who were actively trying to lose. You had, you know, five or six teams that were pretty much running out, you know, non-competitive lineups for two or three months. Players were getting traded and then immediately sitting for the rest of the season. Like, you know, and I think it's also just the reality of like, people are smart. Coaches, GMs, executives, people at time on their hand, they're going to do whatever they can based on the incentives you've afforded them and act accordingly in these games that we're playing. And so I do think you have to incentivize people to act in an ethical or thoughtful way for the sake of fans, to get the best possible product out there for fans. Because at the end of the day, this is about winning, and of course it's about winning rings, but it's also about putting the most entertaining product out there for the people who are paying their money to go to games
every week.
00:58:10
Speaker 1: Yeah, Bill, it's funny how many times I've been asked in my career how outraged I am by a new rule. I've never been outraged by a new rule. I just want to know what the new rule is so that we can figure out how to get a competitive advantage from the new rule. But I think we all like the evolution in the sport. We don't want to be doing the same thing. As we mentioned earlier, you've done it for two decades. I've been doing it for two and a half decades. We don't want to do the same thing for two and a half decades. Bill, we remiss in letting you leave without giving us a Super Bowl prognostication. Who do you have playing in the game, and who is your winner?
00:58:43
Speaker 2: Okay, so quick backstory. I have picked the Chiefs to win each of the last seven years. So it was a tough pick for me this year because they were coming off of a Patrick Mahomes injury, their worst season of the last decade. I did pick the Chiefs to win again, so I feel pretty good about that one. I'm sticking with the Chiefs. Unfortunately, I picked the Eagles to be the team they were playing in the Super Bowl, and that is... uh i'll be impressed it'll be a heck of a story if you put this on video now as the eagles make it to the super bowl as we sit here with them having two wins in the middle of november um i'm gonna abandon the eagle side i will say chiefs and i will i'll go with the same vein i was thinking you'd have a rubber match between the Chiefs and the Eagles, who have played each other twice in the Super Bowl on 1-on-1 each. Closest thing to that would be the 49ers, a team that has lost to the Chiefs twice, although in very narrow fashion both times.
00:59:36
Speaker 3: They look pretty good. They look pretty good this weekend.
00:59:38
Speaker 2: The team I was skeptical of this year, and I have been very wrong about that so far this season. They just scored approximately 8,000 points on the Cowboys yesterday as we record this. So I will say Chiefs and Niners in the Super Bowl, and I will go with a Chiefs victory, as I have predicted now every year for the last seven seasons.
00:59:55
Speaker 3: McCaffrey drinking from the fountain of youth right now, it appears.
01:00:00
Speaker 2: No offense.
01:00:01
Speaker 1: Bill, I think when you earn your third trip here on route to your mug, we'll have to talk about some of these coaches. I mean, Kyle Shanahan seems to be somewhat unsung. Everyone does talk about him. Every one of their receivers has been hurt multiple times this year. And somehow they continue to just dominate. And it's incredible how they do it. really on both sides of the ball. They've been decimated with injuries over the last few years, but it seems to be kind of an Energizer bunny thing in San Francisco where they're just relevant every season. And if they can stay healthy through the postseason, they are going to have a significant chance of being a team that no one's going to want to face, I imagine.
01:00:39
Speaker 2: Yes. And certainly it feels like we've let the electrical substation theory subside after all of that last season. So I feel like we're now at least focus on what's happening on the field for the 49ers as opposed to what's happening next to their practice facility.
01:00:54
Speaker 1: It's well said. Bill, thank you so much for joining us and sharing all your wisdom about the NFL and analytics and sharing this conversation with us. And for the listeners out there, thanks for joining us this Thursday and every Thursday on Rosters to Rings.