TRANSKRIP 🔗
WEBVTT
00:00:01.439 --> 00:00:07.599
This is a reality-approved possibility, an exploration of human ingenuity.
00:00:23.199 --> 00:00:29.920
This is reality proofs possibility, and I have the honor to be here today with Chris Marquis and Otto Sharma.
00:00:30.000 --> 00:00:33.359
And we're continuing the conversation on transforming business education.
00:00:33.439 --> 00:00:38.320
And Chris, you had a a powerful op-ed in the New York Times.
00:00:38.479 --> 00:00:48.240
And while some of us would sort of submit that some of these old media don't have much of an influence, it did really cause a ripple in the space.
00:00:48.479 --> 00:00:54.560
Many people responding to it on LinkedIn or in other formats, even on traditional TV.
00:00:54.719 --> 00:01:04.079
And so in that sense, I think it's it's it's powerful to see how that that kind of environment and ecosystem can still cause conversations of some depth.
00:01:04.239 --> 00:01:10.640
And Otto, you just published again another piece on the big conversation of transforming education and higher education.
00:01:10.799 --> 00:01:14.480
So thanks both to being in the conversation.
00:01:14.799 --> 00:01:15.040
Thank you.
00:01:16.079 --> 00:01:20.959
So so Chris, just maybe check, tell us a little bit, how was it received from your perspective?
00:01:21.120 --> 00:01:27.040
What was your main takeaway from both the reception from colleagues, but also in a broader context?
00:01:27.120 --> 00:01:30.079
And how would you characterize yes, the the all that?
00:01:30.239 --> 00:01:38.079
Yeah, so uh so so so sort of your your intro suggested a bit of surprise, how much impact it has.
00:01:38.239 --> 00:01:42.799
And that is exactly, you know, if you had to ask me one word, it would be it would be just surprise.
00:01:43.040 --> 00:01:50.799
I never would have expected that it would generate the conversation and discussion it has.
00:01:51.040 --> 00:02:02.879
Obviously, I assumed that some of my friends at business schools, you know, would would read it and have and to start a dialogue, but but never would have expected it to travel as far and as wide as it has.
00:02:02.959 --> 00:02:06.560
I mean, outside of the B-school, you know, sort of academic ecosystem.
00:02:06.799 --> 00:02:12.240
As you mentioned, a number of sort of TV and other appearances on a variety of NPR shows.
00:02:12.400 --> 00:02:16.319
I mean, even still, um, you know, this is my third podcast about it today.
00:02:16.479 --> 00:02:23.199
I was on a podcast, a NPR program this morning, did another smaller podcast a couple hours ago.
00:02:23.360 --> 00:02:25.439
So it's so it's been just really crazy.
00:02:25.599 --> 00:02:41.759
And and in that case, you know, it's really been super gratifying how the reaction, you know, I think as both of you am passionate about delivering, you know, sort of high impact influential experiences to shape next generation leaders.
00:02:41.919 --> 00:02:44.800
And and having conversations about that is really important.
00:02:45.039 --> 00:03:01.039
And I think the business school ecosystem, I think there's just some systemic issues which which I describe and in the piece, you know, as far as you know, just reaction, the number of people that have emailed me with appreciation and gratitude.
00:03:01.280 --> 00:03:10.319
And in many cases, some of these were like emotional because they just it really touched them in a way for from their experience in business school.
00:03:10.560 --> 00:03:11.840
That was a total shock.
00:03:12.080 --> 00:03:20.560
I've written some things before that have had a little bit of impact from the general public, maybe get like, I don't know, 20 or 30 emails or something like that.
00:03:20.719 --> 00:03:24.560
Usually those are like cranks, to be honest, and like ranting ranting at me.
00:03:24.800 --> 00:03:36.000
But pretty limited, pretty pretty limited number of rants actually from this, surprisingly so, given I'd say the LinkedIn uh has had it's more than more than a fair share of rants, in my opinion.
00:03:36.080 --> 00:03:56.400
But but the the emails and reaction, and this is from yeah, from people that have been through an MBA, people that are glad they didn't go through MBA, people who are current MBA students, lots of them at all kinds of institutions that are struggling and they really appreciated what I wrote faculty at, I mean, like every major school.
00:03:56.560 --> 00:03:59.199
I mean, it's really been super gratifying.
00:03:59.439 --> 00:04:03.599
The the public LinkedIn, I've been a little disappointed with, to be honest.
00:04:03.759 --> 00:04:09.439
I I found a lot of the responses are really pretty lame, in my opinion.
00:04:09.599 --> 00:04:26.720
I I've I have a friend who's in publicist, and you know, she just because I was involved in it, tracked, tracked a little bit and said, you know, she's never seen anything like this where people have taken some viral thing and then used it to to basically promote themselves in their own work.
00:04:26.800 --> 00:04:35.920
And I think, you know, so many of the of the responses are, you know, this can't be true because here are all the great things I'm doing or my school is doing.
00:04:36.079 --> 00:04:43.360
And I think it really, anyways, I I think that there's so many people that that that want to actually have an impact in this space.
00:04:43.519 --> 00:04:46.160
And and I think these kind of reactions detract from that.
00:04:46.480 --> 00:04:47.920
Otto, maybe just over to you.
00:04:48.160 --> 00:04:51.120
Well, it it's really amazing, uh Chris.
00:04:51.360 --> 00:04:58.560
And uh so I got just kind of in the moment it was out, I got the first uh messages from friends.
00:04:58.639 --> 00:05:01.680
Uh and uh I think it came out on a Sunday, right?
00:05:01.839 --> 00:05:13.759
And I think it really it it articulates a feeling that many people have, but it's something that has not been fully articulated in public, right?
Load full transcript
00:05:13.920 --> 00:05:16.399
In private, yes, but not in public.
00:05:16.560 --> 00:05:24.879
And it's also it's coming at a moment where the I think we are at a plastic hour in higher education, right?
00:05:25.040 --> 00:05:33.600
Where through AI, through uh a bunch of other factors that that you mentioned, the whole system that was in doubt already before, right?
00:05:33.680 --> 00:05:35.839
But now it's unbearable in a way.
00:05:36.000 --> 00:05:45.120
And many people feel that but don't really have quite the sometimes the frames or words, but also sometimes the authority.
00:05:45.279 --> 00:05:55.600
Kind of you could speak from someone who actually is not just criticizing the case study method, but who has written some of the more successful cases and so on.
00:05:55.759 --> 00:06:02.480
So it's kind of really this perspective from within that makes makes you a legitimate voice.
00:06:02.720 --> 00:06:09.439
I thought that really contributed to also to an opening that we all share right now.
00:06:09.600 --> 00:06:17.040
Kind of basically what you what your piece did is it opened a conversation that needed to happen and that didn't have the space.
00:06:17.199 --> 00:06:24.720
So in a way, your piece is, you know, a container for a conversation that's really critical to have uh for all of us.
00:06:25.040 --> 00:06:41.920
Well, well, the thing uh yeah, I I hope that it actually continue, you know, ends up serving that that function because that's you know, that's why I I wrote it, to try to help, you know, us all think about ways uh of potential reform and discuss white what might actually be more be more effective.
00:06:42.240 --> 00:06:48.720
So I wonder from the reactions that you got, was was there well what were the surprises?
00:06:48.879 --> 00:06:53.600
So uh, you know, you probably expected some reactions from colleagues and so on.
00:06:53.759 --> 00:06:54.959
So what what was it?
00:06:55.040 --> 00:07:01.839
But then, you know, the current student generation, for example, or former students kind of who are now work in companies or so.
00:07:01.920 --> 00:07:04.720
So what what did you have any surprises around that?
00:07:04.879 --> 00:07:09.040
Where was the most responsive reaction to the piece?
00:07:09.279 --> 00:07:28.000
Yeah, I think similar to what you're saying, that actually maybe people, you know, particularly the students, you know, the the people that actually had had either been current or former students, there was a, yeah, I could not put my finger on, there was just something that was not, I felt was wrong, and I I felt it was me that was the problem.
00:07:28.160 --> 00:07:28.480
Yeah.
00:07:28.720 --> 00:07:33.360
And then they said, oh, maybe it actually wasn't me that was the problem.
00:07:33.439 --> 00:07:40.720
So this is why I think many of them, many of the former, you know, sort of current former students, this this was the tenor of their messages.
00:07:40.879 --> 00:07:45.279
I got a lot of really thoughtful discussions, which I have had not sure what to do about.
00:07:45.360 --> 00:07:46.399
And I'd love, you know, I don't know.
00:07:46.480 --> 00:07:48.480
This is something that you work on, about that.
00:07:48.560 --> 00:08:04.000
Really, I need to be thinking much more deeply about higher ed more generally, not just business schools, that, you know, this, you know, I identify based on my experience, I identified some issues with business schools, but really it's it's part of a bigger set of issues at university.
00:08:04.160 --> 00:08:07.600
That was another sort of set of thoughtful comments I got.
00:08:07.839 --> 00:08:19.279
Also, I think that it there's some really important discussion to be had and thinking to be done around, you know, different types of MBA experiences around the world.
00:08:19.439 --> 00:08:26.000
And, you know, a number of people, and I think it's a valid, thoughtful critique, you know, I have experience at these three elite business schools.
00:08:26.160 --> 00:08:28.560
And, you know, maybe in Europe it's different.
00:08:28.720 --> 00:08:43.519
Although I would say, you know, I have been at Cambridge, and my sense is that, or my experience has been that at Cambridge, actually, because Cambridge cares more about the rankings than the other places have been, actually, some of these issues are actually even more pronounced there.
00:08:43.679 --> 00:08:52.240
I think that because there's a lot of global ranking, with the FT being the most, you know, well, well known, I think that actually creates a homogenization.
00:08:52.399 --> 00:08:56.720
That so you can't just say, oh, it's different in Europe, although maybe some European schools.
00:08:56.879 --> 00:09:02.080
I think also maybe, you know, some less elite schools things might be a a little different.
00:09:02.159 --> 00:09:06.159
But but here too, I do think I think the rankings are really an issue with this.
00:09:06.320 --> 00:09:08.480
I think also at the university level, too.
00:09:08.639 --> 00:09:11.919
So, anyways, it's so those are some reactions I've had.
00:09:12.240 --> 00:09:16.879
So, in many ways, I mean, this conversation is not novel, right?
00:09:17.120 --> 00:09:26.080
You've been able to sort of put it into a space where people respond at a almost like, well, a knee-jerk defensive reaction.
00:09:26.240 --> 00:09:26.480
Yes.
00:09:26.720 --> 00:09:31.679
And I think that's what you're describing oftentimes in the LinkedIn post, what people see is like, oh, okay, it's not that bad.
00:09:31.759 --> 00:09:32.720
We just need to reform it.
00:09:32.799 --> 00:09:37.919
And you see that from lots of formal authorities in business education, right?
00:09:38.000 --> 00:09:42.639
It's like, oh yeah, we've heard this before, and yes, we just need to sort of tweak a little bit here or there.
00:09:43.039 --> 00:09:43.919
What do you say to them?
00:09:44.080 --> 00:09:50.000
Because I think that's sort of where you and Martin
Parker and others have basically been in the space.
00:09:50.080 --> 00:09:51.519
This is just not salvageable.
00:09:51.679 --> 00:09:55.919
This is like medical education from from the from the 15th century.
00:09:56.000 --> 00:09:58.399
We we can't just keep on quacking, right?
00:09:58.720 --> 00:10:00.799
So it it there's a couple things I'll say to that.
00:10:00.879 --> 00:10:05.519
So I so I actually, and it's it's why it's so important to be talking about these these things.
00:10:05.679 --> 00:10:09.120
So I so I actually had a discussion over over the weekend.
00:10:09.279 --> 00:10:21.679
I was at a small conference with one of the people who had written it an online LinkedIn critique, one of the more thoughtful ones, but but still, you know, had issues with what I said and was was certainly had some some thoughtful comments.
00:10:21.840 --> 00:10:34.720
And what he said to me is actually he found that his dean had had a bunch of donors and other sort of interested parties in the university and elsewhere contacting him about this article.
00:10:34.879 --> 00:10:45.360
And so I do think, in part, some of the, you know, formal people with formal positions, I mean, they they are getting sort of pressure on this from important constituencies.
00:10:45.440 --> 00:10:50.720
And I think in some ways have to make this performance to, you know, for for for that, for that reason.
00:10:51.039 --> 00:11:02.080
On the, you know, sort of, you know, putting me in with Martin Parker, who really is a much, you know, earlier voice on this, and actually used the term business school shutdown, which I did not use actually.
00:11:02.159 --> 00:11:10.000
The New York Times headline writers ended up using that, that, that, that word, that word I would have recognized him for using that ahead of time if I had had done that.
00:11:10.159 --> 00:11:15.919
But to me, I think, and I've been involved in this particularly at HBS and Cambridge.
00:11:16.159 --> 00:11:37.279
HBS has this social enterprise initiative, and I was very involved in an effort to try to get more sustainability, social enterprise at the time it was called corporate social responsibility, into the required curriculum at HBS with very little success, doing audits of what cases are in there and trying to get more diversity and the protagonists, all kinds of things that people just don't want to change, basically.
00:11:37.440 --> 00:11:44.559
I mean, they have their class that works well and and they, you know, get good ratings and students like it, and and they're not experts in the topic, also.
00:11:45.759 --> 00:11:51.200
And at Cambridge, more recently, I was involved in an effort which similarly I feel that was not very successful.
00:11:51.440 --> 00:11:59.679
Enron, there was big, big discussion after Enron, after the financial crisis, you know, last 10 years, all this stuff around ESG and sustainability.
00:11:59.840 --> 00:12:07.840
So my feeling is that there has been so much, like little changes here and there, and in let's do this reform, that reform.
00:12:08.080 --> 00:12:18.480
The reason why I use the term abolish, I didn't use the term shut down, I used the term abolish in a way that I mean the the idea of a business school needs to be fundamentally reconceived and rebuilt from the ground up.
00:12:18.639 --> 00:12:20.960
And this means the mission and vision of the school.
00:12:21.120 --> 00:12:23.360
It means how it approaches the core curriculum.
00:12:23.600 --> 00:12:28.480
An important element of this, which connects the dots to the rankings, is the recruiting.
00:12:28.639 --> 00:12:48.159
I find, again, at all of my schools I've been at of I've engaged with the recruiting staff, and some are better than others, but I I feel that there is less of an interest to look outside the box for different types of jobs beyond sort of what traditionally that school, the the you know, the particular school recruits to.
00:12:48.320 --> 00:12:49.679
So so I think, yeah.
00:12:49.759 --> 00:12:52.639
So I that that that's my com my comment on that.
00:12:52.879 --> 00:12:54.480
Yeah, I I don't any follow up.
00:12:54.879 --> 00:13:07.360
So just to your point, Chris, um, so ten days ago we we we had a senior faculty meeting here at MIT Sloan, and of course the dean sent out your piece as pre-reading, right?
00:13:07.600 --> 00:13:08.000
For that.
00:13:08.320 --> 00:13:13.360
So so it's like uh and of course there is um all these issues, right?
00:13:13.440 --> 00:13:15.519
Kind of that what the there is a reason.
00:13:15.600 --> 00:13:19.039
I think it's kind of a general experience of all of us, right?
00:13:19.200 --> 00:13:29.519
That and you you you write that in your piece, all the sustainability and ethics and uh so forth stuff, it's ending up in electives, right?
00:13:29.679 --> 00:13:36.559
And that was you mentioned, and so I I wonder what what about uh and and we know some of the dynamics, right?
00:13:36.639 --> 00:13:37.840
You you just mentioned that.
00:13:38.080 --> 00:13:40.559
But what about other attempts?
00:13:40.799 --> 00:13:42.639
You mentioned too hard, right?
00:13:42.720 --> 00:13:44.240
You quote Sure.
00:13:44.480 --> 00:13:47.919
And so that's that's one attempt, right?
00:13:48.080 --> 00:13:52.159
Kind of to to really say, okay, it can't be just elective.
00:13:52.320 --> 00:13:54.320
We need to really reimagine the core.
00:13:54.480 --> 00:13:57.039
How would you look at that experience?
00:13:57.200 --> 00:13:59.279
Or and where do you see other ones?
00:13:59.440 --> 00:14:11.519
Because in a way, in our community, kind of the people who have tried, that experience has been around for a while, but we haven't really so we have created change at best, right?
00:14:11.600 --> 00:14:12.720
But marginal, right?
00:14:12.799 --> 00:14:15.200
It has not been transformative.
00:14:15.440 --> 00:14:17.120
And why I mean, why is that?
00:14:17.279 --> 00:14:23.759
In part you answer that in
your piece, but where do you see really alternatives that have generated some interesting results?
00:14:24.000 --> 00:14:25.120
Yeah, I think you're you're right.
00:14:25.200 --> 00:14:35.279
I've not the I I mean, I wish I had some great answer to this, because but I mean, I I do think, I mean, I have a lot of respect for the work that's that Stu and others did at Verbont.
00:14:35.519 --> 00:14:38.960
But it's a small program, has run into problems here and there.
00:14:39.120 --> 00:14:48.799
I think the idea of it though, so to me, I think a core, well, not to use the word core twice in the same, a key issue is affecting the core curriculum.
00:14:48.960 --> 00:15:00.320
I think this is something that, and not just affecting it, so you know, what I did at Cambridge was as part of the the things I'd worked on, we got more sustainability type of content in the core curriculum.
00:15:00.480 --> 00:15:08.320
This ended up being yanked out in because the new MBA director wanted place wanted cont wanted more AI content in the curriculum.
00:15:08.399 --> 00:15:11.279
And this was sort of an you know easy thing to to rip out.
00:15:11.440 --> 00:15:31.840
I mean, in the finance accounting, et cetera classes, I I I think that those uh and I think those are the classes where, at least based on my students, where they're actually really learning about, you know, I mean, to put simply, shareholder primacy and that that really businesses are are accountable to shareholders, full stop.
00:15:32.000 --> 00:15:40.000
And I think that, you know, I I think way if if there are ways to change the core, I think that is a key level.
00:15:40.159 --> 00:15:41.200
The core in recruiting.
00:15:41.360 --> 00:15:49.840
So I think those are the two levers that I think are most important to try to, you know, open things up in in a way that I feel would be more effective.
00:15:50.159 --> 00:15:56.399
So and I'm just gonna sort of pull on that thread and and want to discuss sort of what is the next level of school, right?
00:15:56.480 --> 00:16:13.519
We oftentimes I think sort of reference the professional school, law, medicine, a clear objective with a professional sort of setup of standards, shifts that they've gone through uh in in in different types of iterations of their development, right?
00:16:13.679 --> 00:16:24.799
And there were reports written about how unscientific medicine was, how it didn't really understand some of the basics, how how it had to become more scientific and research-based.
00:16:24.960 --> 00:16:28.159
And so you've had those efforts and business as well.
00:16:28.399 --> 00:16:35.679
In in a school that basically was really created, let's say, for this well, the past century, with with earlier iterations before.
00:16:35.840 --> 00:16:46.320
Um, but legal and medical and and other professional schools have a certain trajectory uh where competition sort of could potentially play a role.
00:16:46.480 --> 00:16:50.320
Right now, I think we
see some new schools develop.
00:16:50.399 --> 00:16:52.399
And Otto and I were talking about this also.
00:16:52.480 --> 00:16:55.279
Where are the new schools in the university coming from, right?
00:16:55.360 --> 00:16:59.600
And at Oxford, you have the Smith School for Sustainable Enterprise, right?
00:16:59.679 --> 00:17:04.480
And it's sort of part of, I think, in another school, it's sort of a program, not in the business school.
00:17:04.640 --> 00:17:08.720
Then you have at Stanford the Door School for Sustainability, right?
00:17:08.799 --> 00:17:10.640
You have Columbia has climate, the climate school.
00:17:12.720 --> 00:17:19.279
You have many universities sort of coming up with new schools, as you and others sort of that are more innovative.
00:17:19.519 --> 00:17:33.680
What kind of new school do you see emerging right now that maybe has the potential to capture the interest of this generation of students that you're talking about that actually gets potentially funneled into the wrong program?
00:17:34.319 --> 00:17:37.759
So I think those are all great examples of this.
00:17:38.000 --> 00:17:44.160
I think also, you know, the business school, it doesn't need to be just about an MBA, actually.
00:17:44.319 --> 00:17:58.480
You know, the business school can create other, you know, other degrees that maybe they will be called MBA, but but actually where the focus is actually on a broader set of grand challenges or systemic issues or sustainability or or whatever.
00:17:58.640 --> 00:18:12.319
And so it is, I'm not sure about your your schools, but I know the number of the schools that I've been at, there's been an interest in actually for the healthcare sector, having a different, in some ways, MBA pat there's basically a di a different MBA.
00:18:12.480 --> 00:18:24.480
And so I think I I so I think that all those examples that you mentioned, you know, at Stanford, Columbia, uh, Oxford, um, and probably some other why other places as well, are good examples from a school perspective.
00:18:24.559 --> 00:18:29.759
And I think the business school though, I mentioned changes in the core, changes in, you know, changes in recruiting.
00:18:29.839 --> 00:18:41.440
But I also think that that new, new and different degrees are another possibility that is not as far as getting a billion dollars from John Doe to set up, you know, a school at Stanford.
00:18:41.519 --> 00:18:43.200
And I think that some schools are actually doing this.
00:18:43.279 --> 00:18:50.079
I've I'm, you know, after all these podcasts, I'm a little my brain is a little adult, a little brain dead, but but I do think, I mean, there are schools.
00:18:50.240 --> 00:18:57.920
I think Duke pr perhaps might have just actually started a like a a stream of their MBA focused on sustainability.
00:18:58.000 --> 00:19:00.160
So that means that the core is different, et cetera.
00:19:00.400 --> 00:19:01.359
I might be mistaken.
00:19:01.680 --> 00:19:03.759
So a pretty pretty elite school.
00:19:04.000 --> 00:19:05.920
Recently, I saw something about this.
00:19:06.000 --> 00:19:10.640
So so I think that's another set of potential solutions that at least helps with the issue.
00:19:11.119 --> 00:19:13.599
So another question related to that.
00:19:13.839 --> 00:19:19.680
I was recently talking to a couple of deans at schools of government, right?
00:19:19.839 --> 00:19:20.880
Policy and government.
00:19:21.119 --> 00:19:32.880
And so the interesting thing there is when you really, and they're like equally frustrated, right, about the focus and the lack of leadership and transformation and so forth.
00:19:33.119 --> 00:19:33.359
Yes.
00:19:33.599 --> 00:19:37.680
And when you look at the evolution of governance, right, what do you what do you see?
00:19:37.920 --> 00:19:40.880
You see a shift from government-centric, right?
00:19:40.960 --> 00:19:43.680
And that's even reflected in the name of these schools, right?
00:19:44.000 --> 00:19:49.119
Yes, Harvard Kennedy School of Policy and Government, not governance, right?
00:19:49.279 --> 00:20:09.440
And so the reality of governance, right, in our uh current moment where one part of the world is moving back to unilateral dominance, like our current White House, and then other, particularly on a local level, you see really interesting new forms of governance emerging that are more polycentric and plurilateral.
00:20:09.519 --> 00:20:11.920
So, in other words, it's the coalition of the willing.
00:20:12.079 --> 00:20:13.920
And it's more than government, right?
00:20:14.079 --> 00:20:15.359
And local authorities.
00:20:15.440 --> 00:20:22.079
It it includes business, it includes civil society, it includes like academic and other institutions.
00:20:22.240 --> 00:20:32.319
So, in other words, this multi-sector, so the future of governance has a lot to do with moving beyond government-centric thinking.
00:20:32.480 --> 00:20:40.640
And I wonder when we just take that as a template, so where we need more relation, more connection, let's say, to a business school, right?
00:20:40.799 --> 00:20:43.839
More connection to other relevant schools there.
00:20:44.079 --> 00:20:58.880
So I wonder whether we see uh in business something similar and whether then, you know, a lot of future potential, because many of the new programs, Michael, you were just mentioning, are like blended things, right?
00:20:58.960 --> 00:21:00.720
Kind of it's this ant, right?
00:21:00.799 --> 00:21:02.799
It's kind of the ant rather than the or.
00:21:03.119 --> 00:21:05.200
So what what what do you see in that regard?
00:21:05.440 --> 00:21:21.200
I I I really that that very much resonates with me because you know, I think that the way these schools were set up, like you mentioned, you know, Kennedy School of Government and Harvard Business School, and you know, they they were set up as like silos, sectoral silos.
00:21:21.359 --> 00:21:32.720
But so many of the problems that we need to deal with in
the world actually require both not just interdisciplinary, you know, crossover, but also, you know, or actually need to be addressed by all sectors.
00:21:32.799 --> 00:21:35.599
Uh, I sp I spent a year and a half at the Harvard Kennedy School.
00:21:39.119 --> 00:21:48.720
Was there, I took a leave when I was at Cornell, and because the dean, a new dean, uh uh named Doug Emeldorf, uh, who had a vision which I really appreciated.
00:21:48.880 --> 00:21:56.880
He said, you know, you know, the I forget what the Kennedy School of Govern Harvard Kennedy School's mission is, but basically it's like solving the world's most pressing problems.
00:21:57.039 --> 00:21:57.200
Yeah.
00:21:57.440 --> 00:21:59.759
And he said he said when it was founded.
00:22:00.079 --> 00:22:02.880
And whenever 50, 60 years ago, it was government that did that.
00:22:02.960 --> 00:22:07.839
Then we had a lot of students also interested in nonprofits and sort of third sector doing that.
00:22:07.920 --> 00:22:08.799
And they expanded that.
00:22:08.880 --> 00:22:11.759
And he said, now we actually need business.
00:22:11.839 --> 00:22:14.960
And there are students who are tremendously interested in social entrepreneurship.
00:22:15.039 --> 00:22:18.480
And actually, there's a lot of business solutions to these problems too.
00:22:18.559 --> 00:22:26.319
So he had he started, which Julie Batalana was the founder of, and I helped set set up the social innovation and change initiative.
00:22:26.480 --> 00:22:36.799
And it was because of this idea that the dean saw that, you know, the with a mission of addressing the world's pressing problems, you it's not you need all these all these sectors.
00:22:36.960 --> 00:22:42.319
I think if if that could be reformulated at a business school, it would be really compelling.
00:22:42.480 --> 00:22:52.319
And part part of part of why I wrote the essay is that I think that for legitimacy reasons, business schools put forward this vision that they are doing that.
00:22:52.480 --> 00:22:58.720
You know, like Harvard Business Schools, you know, may sort of if you look at go on the website, it's like educating leaders who make a difference in the world.
00:22:58.960 --> 00:23:04.720
Well, no, actually, really, you're just, you know, creating a bunch of shareholder primacy automatons.
00:23:04.799 --> 00:23:07.440
That's a strong way to put it, not to offend people at HBS.
00:23:07.519 --> 00:23:09.119
Sorry if anyone anyone's listening.
00:23:09.359 --> 00:23:31.519
But but I do think though, if and I think that what stands in the way from these lofty visions and actually what is delivered to the students and where the students actually move is is issues around the fact that finance and economics and accounting and even operations have such a foothold foothold and strong grip over what is actually taught in the required curriculum.
00:23:31.759 --> 00:23:34.559
And I think that is that's that that makes it a challenge.
00:23:34.720 --> 00:23:43.039
Whereas at the business at the Kendi school, there was not such there was political science and economics do have deep, uh, deep, sort of deep, deep influence.
00:23:43.200 --> 00:23:50.160
However, it's not as if like people are people are taking or forced to take government 101 and government 102.
00:23:50.240 --> 00:23:54.400
And I mean, the there's a lot of flexibility actually in the curriculum people take in different pathways.
00:23:54.480 --> 00:24:11.759
And I think, you know, maybe it's because of our accrediting bodies, the A, C S B or whatever, you know, there has to be all of these different classes, which then get staffed by I think the the these subfields that are not as open to the types of change that we're talking about as maybe the departments that we're all in.
00:24:12.000 --> 00:24:20.640
So that that that brings me to to another piece here, because the government schools, the governance schools, there are there are they are emerging as the leadership caters.
00:24:20.720 --> 00:24:28.079
And if you look at France with the École Nationale Administration and all of that, you know, you have in some way these setups.
00:24:28.240 --> 00:24:33.279
They are typically a product of post-World War II, where the elite failed.
00:24:33.440 --> 00:24:39.279
And I don't know, does it take World War III to actually get another sort of setup of these schools going?
00:24:39.599 --> 00:24:40.240
Hopefully not.
00:24:40.400 --> 00:24:43.680
But at the same time, that is oftentimes a breakdown that's happening.
00:24:43.839 --> 00:24:45.839
We might be witnessing a similar breakdown.
00:24:46.000 --> 00:24:52.880
So looking at the next level schools, I'm I'm just looking at the power of the imprint, and you were doing that kind of research, right?
00:24:52.960 --> 00:25:02.000
That imprinting, especially at the Kennedy School, and I was there for three, four years teaching and and even being exposed and doing things.
00:25:02.079 --> 00:25:13.680
But it seemed, and I was teaching at Ena for one one, it seemed like the imprint of the homoeconomic thinking, the ontology was way stronger there than in the business school, right?
00:25:13.839 --> 00:25:24.960
And I think recently Michel Michelena uh that we work with uh Otto that was at the Kennedy School, she was saying people refer to the Kennedy School as sort of the second best business school at Harvard.
00:25:25.200 --> 00:25:31.119
Because the you're saying that there is maybe a broader set of uh disciplines that people can draw from.
00:25:31.200 --> 00:25:31.440
Sure.
00:25:31.680 --> 00:25:43.279
But somehow the the coagulation of of the basic insights of human behavior and who we are is still dominated by non-scientific assumptions that economics brings, right?
00:25:43.440 --> 00:25:45.279
And so that's where I'm always puzzled.
00:25:45.440 --> 00:26:02.319
That power of the imprint in an institution that claims to be scientific, which is basically a assumption base
that has been just proven over and over and over, that we still need to sort of figure out how we can get the science into the university, right?
00:26:02.400 --> 00:26:14.400
And so I don't know how you respond to this, but I I find it puzzling that in school service you you have even a stronger pull towards the psychopathic ontology than in even in business schools.
00:26:14.480 --> 00:26:21.440
And I think there needs to be, as Otto is writing, a fundamental reshift of higher education at multiple levels.
00:26:21.599 --> 00:26:23.599
So anyway, what what what's what's your take on that?
00:26:23.839 --> 00:26:24.640
I to I totally agree.
00:26:24.720 --> 00:26:27.519
And this has actually been something that has been fairly surprising.
00:26:27.599 --> 00:26:51.039
You asked me surprises about the responses to the essay again, is yeah, I mean, how unscientific basically it ends up be people have, you know, I think the you know, the the sort of assumptions of economics, I think because those are dominant, somehow people think that that they are they they don't actually realize that it's just the same it the same even deeper ideology than they are accusing you of.
00:26:51.200 --> 00:27:02.880
And so I do think this taken for grantedness of economics and economic decision m the the way decisions are made is a huge underlying issue in in all in all of this and in and the change.
00:27:02.960 --> 00:27:13.680
And again again, yeah, I was really I was really shocked at a lot of a lot of the responses actually didn't even they weren't even like self-reflexive enough to realize that that they were actually doing the exact same thing they were accusing me of.
00:27:13.839 --> 00:27:15.680
But any any response.
00:27:16.079 --> 00:27:25.119
Well, it's just when you just look at the so if we just zoom out a little more, but we started with business schools and now we talk about higher ed and universities.
00:27:25.279 --> 00:27:32.319
And of course, when you look at the bigger picture, the the there is the the the misalignment is clear, right?
00:27:32.480 --> 00:27:43.359
We have all the the disciplines, the disciplinary uh departments, and then you have and then the mission statement, as you said, it's it's basically making the world a better place, right?
00:27:43.599 --> 00:27:45.279
Regardless of what the department is.
00:27:45.440 --> 00:27:48.960
So, but they all do that in their own channel, right?
00:27:49.119 --> 00:27:49.920
That's the misfit.
00:27:50.000 --> 00:27:56.799
So there's the structural, so that's kind of where innovation is going to happen when you just look at the misfit of the structure.
00:27:57.039 --> 00:28:10.000
And what I find, Chris, you you had like uh you really w what one of the uh interesting things you did in your piece is is really undermine the the scientific legitimacy, right?
00:28:10.160 --> 00:28:12.319
Kind of uh the whole enterprise, right?
00:28:12.559 --> 00:28:15.920
A business school, and the hollowness of some of that.
00:28:16.079 --> 00:28:21.680
And so then the question, of course, is where is the source of legitimacy coming from, right?
00:28:21.839 --> 00:28:27.599
And it could be because what is the when you go across campus, what's really interesting about a business school?
00:28:27.680 --> 00:28:34.559
And I would say, well, obviously, one aspect is the business schools are connected to the business community, right?
00:28:34.720 --> 00:28:37.200
Kind of and in all but to the larger communities.
00:28:37.279 --> 00:28:47.359
And there is also, I don't know whether the two of you would agree, but perhaps like a little bit like an eclectic mindset, kind of so it's what works, right?
00:28:47.440 --> 00:28:57.839
Which actually is in, you know, when you look at the misfit of the old paradigms with the 21st century realities, that's actually a good thing to have.
00:28:58.079 --> 00:29:16.079
So I wonder whether the if the business, so whether one way business schools and schools of management could get legitimacy is kind of to play really a pioneer role in, you know, because we need a new connection between universities and their communities.
00:29:16.240 --> 00:29:16.480
Yes.
00:29:16.640 --> 00:29:21.279
And a a key piece of that community is the business community.
00:29:21.440 --> 00:29:39.440
And Michael and I are just coming from back from Latin America, where we facilitate, you know, we we we held sessions around that, and it was really interesting to see that the connection of business schools with their local community is so much stronger, so much more felt.
00:29:39.599 --> 00:29:44.880
Yeah, and so then we experienced that here in the north.
00:29:45.119 --> 00:30:10.079
And so I wonder whether there isn't like a space for uh a structural innovation or something where business schools could, you know, because there's something missing between universities and community and and business community in particular, and that's kind of where we could be maybe could come up with innovations that could help not only the business schools, but the entire university.
00:30:10.400 --> 00:30:19.759
Yeah, and on this say on this, so that you mentioned two points about one how to have legitimacy and related to that, but I'm gonna go off in a direction where it doesn't connect that much about the community.
00:30:19.920 --> 00:30:29.039
I so so deeply agree with you on this point about the connectivity with, you know, community practice, the real world, so to speak.
00:30:29.200 --> 00:30:33.279
And I think it's I agree 100% that it is the business school, it is such a strength.
00:30:33.519 --> 00:30:36.799
When I was, and I'm still at Cambridge, although I'm gonna be moving as of January 1st.
00:30:36.880 --> 00:30:41.599
So I've sort of my I've mentally sort of moved on to the Cornell uh where I'll be starting January 1st.
00:30:41.920 --> 00:30:56.000
But at Cambridge, I was the head of an executive education program uh for BCG,
where they were interested in having a program that upskilled their consultants on climate and sustainability issues.
00:30:56.160 --> 00:30:59.039
These were, you know, huge investment of this firm.
00:30:59.200 --> 00:31:02.640
People came for a week, these were high potential people, some of them very senior.
00:31:02.720 --> 00:31:07.680
And so I pulled, I mean, fortunately, I got this assignment to do this when I was relatively new at Cambridge.
00:31:07.759 --> 00:31:13.359
So I was forced to get to know people all around the university instead of just relying on sort of friends I had already at the business school.
00:31:13.519 --> 00:31:17.680
And I got people from climate science and architecture building 200-meter timber buildings.
00:31:17.759 --> 00:31:24.799
I got people from engineering creating, you know, ships that that with ammonia drivetrains and various things.
00:31:24.960 --> 00:31:31.599
And I was asked to go to present to the board of trustees about this and took some of the people like climate science, et cetera.
00:31:31.680 --> 00:31:33.839
And Cambridge, you know, is an 800-year-old institution.
00:31:33.920 --> 00:31:35.599
The business school is not very legitimate.
00:31:35.680 --> 00:31:37.440
It's only been there since 1991.
00:31:37.680 --> 00:31:56.559
And the people from other disciplines that came and were sort of testifying about this program, this they they just they were like, you could just tell the surprise in their voice about how key the business school is in its role of this connection with the real world on these important issues.
00:31:56.799 --> 00:32:05.119
But also, as you mentioned, this eclectic function where actually something like climate sustainability, all those disciplines I mentioned are totally essential to that.
00:32:05.200 --> 00:32:17.680
So it really can be a focal point for the most important and challenging issues of the world, and also really embedding that in a in a way that actually has a huge impact on these problems.
00:32:17.839 --> 00:32:20.400
And so I, you know, that really resonates with me.
00:32:20.559 --> 00:32:32.319
It's hard to think about the the legitimacy aspect of that is interesting because so much of the legitimacy within academia is not about actually working with practice.
00:32:32.400 --> 00:32:38.160
It's it this was like I think it's part of the surprise that a lot of the the people that were testifying about this had.
00:32:38.319 --> 00:32:51.359
So that is an issue that I don't, it's a tension that I think we have at the business school because we obviously want to have, you know, sort of, you know, rigorous, evidence-based, you know, solutions and frameworks and practices, et cetera, that we're sharing.
00:32:51.519 --> 00:32:55.839
But those need to be, you know, sort of worked through in a way that you can see the impact.
00:32:55.920 --> 00:32:58.319
It's a it's a professional school, you know, after all.
00:32:58.400 --> 00:32:59.839
So it's about
application.
00:33:00.160 --> 00:33:06.480
So so then what I'm hearing also in this conversation emerging, of course, there is the case of reforming it, right?
00:33:06.559 --> 00:33:08.240
That's been the standard pathway.
00:33:08.319 --> 00:33:17.359
That's where the knee-jerk reaction comes in terms of defending against your argument so that we can do the kind of social enterprise sustainability initiative on the margin.
00:33:17.519 --> 00:33:34.000
At the same time, that may be a pathway, and and Otto, you call it the inversion, where the margin moves to the center in the context of the existing structure, possibly, in this plastic moment, as you describe, Otto, where it's like, hey, this may be a moment similar to World War II, you know, where okay, now we need to rebuild.
00:33:34.079 --> 00:33:36.480
We need to do something in this breakdown moment.
00:33:36.559 --> 00:33:38.720
And here are certain options how we can do it.
00:33:38.799 --> 00:33:40.319
We can reform the existing structure.
00:33:40.400 --> 00:33:42.000
The business school has these assets.
00:33:42.160 --> 00:33:43.359
First of all, is existence.
00:33:43.599 --> 00:33:46.480
Second of all, the potential to connect with practice.
00:33:46.720 --> 00:33:52.960
The third I see is that there is the potential for an actual engagement with the universitas, with the science.
00:33:53.119 --> 00:33:54.640
It doesn't do either, right?
00:33:54.720 --> 00:33:55.599
It doesn't do either.
00:33:55.680 --> 00:34:02.000
The bridge to the science isn't there, and the bridge to the to the uh the professional community isn't really there.
00:34:02.240 --> 00:34:11.440
If it were to do both, it may actually be a real uh catalyst for for useful knowledge generation and dissemination.
00:34:11.599 --> 00:34:14.000
And so I think there may be this opening up.
00:34:14.320 --> 00:34:26.320
How would you, if you had the possibility at either schools, let's say you pick it, but even just the general, you get a$1 billion gift from somehow some billionaire that wants to wants to invest here.
00:34:26.400 --> 00:34:29.440
And it seems to be more and more uh availabilities such as this.
00:34:29.519 --> 00:34:33.760
But what would you suggest, like at a high level, that be done?
00:34:33.920 --> 00:34:39.519
Like either a new school, a new program, transforming an existing one at a Cornell potentially or other places.
00:34:39.679 --> 00:34:42.159
But what are sort of the core Yeah, good, good question.
00:34:42.320 --> 00:34:42.480
Yeah.
00:34:42.559 --> 00:34:44.960
If you have a billion dollars, what what do you what do you do with it?
00:34:45.280 --> 00:34:53.360
I mean, so I'll say something, but I I I don't want it to have I don't know, sort of exper x expiration date in in some in some ways.
00:34:53.679 --> 00:34:56.639
I mean, I think that we need to be focused on problems in the world.
00:34:56.800 --> 00:35:04.159
And those require a ultimately cross-disciplinary connecting the exact, like you mentioned, science with practice.
00:35:04.320 --> 00:35:11.360
And so I do find the c school of climate change or or you know, sustainability because they're oriented to problems.
00:35:11.519 --> 00:35:18.320
I don't know what, you know, I I think that it seems that environment and sustainability issues are very front and center.
00:35:18.559 --> 00:35:26.400
I think that, you know, issues of inequality, particularly, you know, both within countries, across countries, north-south.
00:35:26.480 --> 00:35:33.519
You think about supply chains, you know, how how so many problems are just so out of sight i in our world.
00:35:33.679 --> 00:35:40.480
And so the fact that a lot of our living here in in the US is subsidized by pretty horrible treatment of people.
00:35:40.639 --> 00:35:46.159
And so so I I don't know what you know, it would it would be focused on some sort of set of problems and issues.
00:35:46.400 --> 00:35:57.599
And perhaps around inequality might be where I would anchor things because that touches on climate a bit, but also I think gets at these deeper root issues that are not considered as often.
00:35:58.000 --> 00:36:04.400
So that's that's the focus on problems and maybe your suggestion on inequality because it's been less in focus.
00:36:04.800 --> 00:36:08.480
Any anything else that methodology, you criticize the case method, right?
00:36:08.719 --> 00:36:13.360
But you you you also criticize indirectly the paradigm that's underlying all of this.
00:36:13.599 --> 00:36:13.760
Right.
00:36:14.639 --> 00:36:15.920
What what else would you suggest?
00:36:16.000 --> 00:36:27.440
Sort of even even for our conversation here, where we have the possibility to shape a couple of schools and and and see how and how potentially guide some of the transition or maybe the foundation of new schools.
00:36:27.679 --> 00:36:31.599
Yeah, I I I'm not sure how the actual writing of the curriculum would take place.
00:36:32.000 --> 00:36:36.480
But like for instance, I'm thinking about this program I did on climate sustainability.
00:36:36.639 --> 00:36:40.320
You know, it's you know, it was I I was the person that was leading it.
00:36:40.400 --> 00:36:54.320
So I had my I sort of governance, accountability interest, but but worked very closely with, you know, people in climate science, people that were working on conservation, people that so that were working on, you know, in in engineering.
00:36:54.480 --> 00:36:56.559
And so I do think that that, yeah.
00:36:56.639 --> 00:37:12.800
So I think I think getting out of the you know traditional silos within business and also the underlying economics, economic assumptions that underlie a lot of the a lot of the thinking in business schools is important and bringing in these different disciplines.
00:37:12.880 --> 00:37:25.599
So I yeah, that's I think it needs to be a collaborative team-based effort from multiple different different disciplines beyond the the ones that we are not
thinking about traditionally because we've been in this in these silos.
00:37:25.679 --> 00:37:32.559
And I think, yeah, so certainly sort of engineering in a variety of sciences and social sciences are you know really essential.
00:37:32.800 --> 00:37:37.840
What do you think about architecture as a as a sort of professional school that actually lends itself?
00:37:37.920 --> 00:37:42.320
And I think Otto, you just draw on Bauhaus as a as a sort of reinvention.
00:37:42.480 --> 00:38:00.719
And I think that the kind of studio approach, I wrote a piece on Gaudi and inventing like business as a as a craft and art, and actually something that embraces the spirit and the soul in a much more deeper, deeper way, but it is actually grounded often in in the practice, right?
00:38:00.800 --> 00:38:01.599
So just tall.
00:38:02.000 --> 00:38:03.760
I think maybe Otto, you want to add on to that.
00:38:04.000 --> 00:38:04.800
Yeah, go ahead, Otto.
00:38:04.960 --> 00:38:06.159
No, no, you go first, Chris.
00:38:06.400 --> 00:38:06.880
I I agree.
00:38:06.960 --> 00:38:11.119
Some sort of studio and application-based curriculum, I think to 100% makes sense.
00:38:11.280 --> 00:38:22.400
You know, it's not exactly studio, but the the teaching that I've done that I felt has had the biggest impact on students is when we do something experiential and have them actually doing things hands-on.
00:38:22.559 --> 00:38:25.440
And so So, yes, thank you for for me.
00:38:25.679 --> 00:38:30.880
I mean, I do think that needs to be a really crucial part of any sort of reform.
00:38:31.039 --> 00:38:42.400
If you want to actually connect to practice in an effective way, you need to actually not just be sort of thinking and learning frame backs, you need to actually be uh be doing, or at least very closely engaged with some sort of doing as well.
00:38:43.199 --> 00:38:46.800
So just uh adding to that, I mean, that completely resonates.
00:38:46.880 --> 00:39:01.199
And that's also Chris what uh Michael and I and many of the other conversations we have been holding, even though it is a really marginal topic, right, as you know in business school, but you know, experiential learning and embodied learning, right?
00:39:01.280 --> 00:39:06.800
Those are kind of two dimensions that come up time and again for exactly the reasons you just mentioned.
00:39:06.960 --> 00:39:17.679
And that is certainly one of the things that has been around, but that has been really at the margin, and that going forward, we believe will be a lot more in the center.
00:39:17.920 --> 00:39:22.880
And so then there is on the so on problem solving, right?
00:39:22.960 --> 00:39:26.800
So that certainly is a key dimension.
00:39:26.960 --> 00:39:28.880
It's also very MIT, right?
00:39:29.039 --> 00:39:32.000
Some people even define leadership as problem solving.
00:39:32.159 --> 00:39:36.800
I actually do not really see it that way because I think it's just one piece.
00:39:37.039 --> 00:39:40.400
And
because it privileges current reality.
00:39:40.639 --> 00:39:56.880
But when we look at the mental health issues and the collective sense of depression, right, that is so dominant, especially among younger people, then I think we realize that something else is necessary, and that is imagination, right?
00:39:57.119 --> 00:40:04.320
We need to develop the capacity to really reimagine something very different from what we are experiencing now.
00:40:04.480 --> 00:40:15.599
And and and you know, and that's something that's going beyond just solving the problem in front of you or fixing the because you're already reacting to something that's out there.
00:40:15.920 --> 00:40:25.199
But imagination is connecting you to a different level of your own life experience, kind of, and and of your own aspiration, perhaps.
00:40:25.440 --> 00:40:31.039
So creating these kinds of environments, I think, is also really a key piece.
00:40:31.119 --> 00:40:40.639
And and I would say that like the the the way we think about reimagining higher ed should not it should go beyond just the curriculum, right?
00:40:40.880 --> 00:40:41.599
New content.
00:40:41.760 --> 00:40:45.039
But it's it's really about how we relate to the world.
00:40:45.199 --> 00:40:52.559
There's action learning, but then there's also connecting, I would say it's what I I would call the social field, right?
00:40:52.719 --> 00:40:57.119
The quality of relationships, how we connect with each other, but also with ourselves.
00:40:57.280 --> 00:41:25.440
And I think that is where experiential and embodied learning comes in, where we need to move into learning that is not just horizontal learning and horizontal development, new tools like loading a new app, but it's really vertical development, kind of reflecting, deep reflection, and noticing kind of the structure of our attention, the structure of our awareness, and being able to shift how we relate to ourselves and to others.
00:41:25.599 --> 00:41:31.360
I think those are, it's like kind of as if in a in a smartphone we upgrade the operating system.
00:41:31.519 --> 00:41:39.679
And that's by and large missing, not, I mean, of course, it's missing in business schools, but it's also missing in in in in pretty much all of the other departments.
00:41:39.760 --> 00:41:52.960
It's kind of a blind spot of universities today, but maybe is one of the key things we need to equip ourselves and each other with as we move into the AI-dominated environments.
00:41:53.280 --> 00:41:53.599
Exactly.
00:41:53.760 --> 00:42:12.400
Yeah, that's obviously a background to hold this whole discussion, which I think, yeah, you know, as you sort of articulate that, I think that's to to me, that's, you know, as we think about because higher ed clearly is going to need to be reinvented in some way in the age of of AI, you know, many of the what you just put forward makes a lot of sense to me to be part of the solution.
00:42:12.719 --> 00:42:21.840
So then what I'm hearing is that the curriculum, the interdisciplinary approach, the the field, the the conversation, the connection, the embodiment, the action, the imagination.
00:42:22.079 --> 00:42:26.000
There are a number of other pieces, and I think you can definitely learn through cases, right?
00:42:26.079 --> 00:42:29.199
And I don't think you're like critical about cases.
00:42:29.280 --> 00:42:30.559
It's just the way that they manifest.
00:42:31.280 --> 00:42:31.519
Totally.
00:42:31.679 --> 00:42:33.840
And I think that they they they serve a good purpose.
00:42:33.920 --> 00:42:38.239
And I think that we as like researchers need to be be thoughtful on how we use them.
00:42:38.400 --> 00:42:39.760
But but that without a doubt.
00:42:39.920 --> 00:42:43.199
I mean, I think they're they're, you know, I wasn't saying never have cases.
00:42:44.320 --> 00:42:49.679
So and then I think the to me, the operating system is one part, the application is another part.
00:42:49.760 --> 00:42:57.119
For me, the kernel, the underlying ontology that we're working with is something that that remains to be explored in many different ways.
00:42:57.360 --> 00:43:15.599
I'm curious what advice would you give PhD students that are going through these programs that are potentially set up for a school that may not exist, you know, or they may actually perpetuate a school that that just basically reinforces all the issues you're criticizing.
00:43:15.679 --> 00:43:25.840
And I think there is a real opportunity for a long-term transition and shift, but we're currently not in an intentional effort to really shift those programs.
00:43:25.920 --> 00:43:27.360
So we are creating people.
00:43:27.599 --> 00:43:27.840
Sure.
00:43:28.000 --> 00:43:33.679
And then I wonder how you see that, because we're not just creating these MBAs in this short-term fashion.
00:43:33.760 --> 00:43:40.800
We're creating their teachers in a way that there is a certain legitimacy conversation that you can have, and everything else is private.
00:43:40.960 --> 00:43:44.960
And this is how you can go into the classroom, but everything else is not allowed.
00:43:45.119 --> 00:43:49.840
So I'm wondering just what thoughts do you have about PhDs and in that uh pipeline?
00:43:50.159 --> 00:43:57.280
Yeah, I I I do think that, you know, in line with what we were just discussing, I mean, the need to get out into the field is essential.
00:43:57.440 --> 00:44:08.400
I think in a lot of PhD programs, the Traditional thing has been, yeah, you you s you stay in your office or your home and and write your papers and and run your analyses.
00:44:08.559 --> 00:44:14.719
And it's it's not very engaged with the broader world, so so to speak.
00:44:14.960 --> 00:44:33.920
So, you know, this missing connection between practice and science, I think that is something that the the that will need to be bridged and part of it will be the sort of embodied and experiential and and the extent to which the PhDs can
actually engage in that in their program, I think will be uh, you know, influential to their six text later.
00:44:34.079 --> 00:44:38.000
You know, uh two two aspects of the PhD education.
00:44:38.159 --> 00:44:43.519
So one will be how they're able to actually contribute to whatever school they end up going to work at.
00:44:43.760 --> 00:44:49.920
And that is something where be being engaged in the in this way we've discussed will will be very helpful to them.
00:44:50.159 --> 00:44:55.840
The aspect of that that is hopefully connected, but sometimes is not, is the research that they do.
00:44:56.000 --> 00:45:06.960
And this is something where, you know, PhD programs are set up in in very cookie-cutter type of ways, and they're not really and the people that run them are not necessarily don't have much incentive to change them.
00:45:07.119 --> 00:45:15.920
And so, yeah, so I I I don't have a good solution for the research side, or nor am I optimistic that that places will change.
00:45:16.239 --> 00:45:18.880
But I do, yeah, I mean, I clearly think it's important.
00:45:19.199 --> 00:45:33.519
So just to put out an idea, Chris, because you are like uh you you spark this uh global conversation and response, and you may be in a good place to also, you know, help help it uh to shape the evolution of that.
00:45:33.679 --> 00:45:43.119
One of the things that Michael and I came about is uh what Peter Dufano did in terms of PhD and climate finance.
00:45:43.360 --> 00:45:52.480
He basically, it is a program, I think kind of eight, I don't know, 150 or I don't know, or even more schools participate.
00:45:52.639 --> 00:45:55.679
Sure with I think 800 participants or so.
00:45:55.920 --> 00:46:04.480
It's teams, it's it's uh no in in in part it's Federal Reserve from the Federal Reserve System, and in part it's from from research.
00:46:04.880 --> 00:46:12.000
And then it's uh and it's it includes both faculty and PhD students, and they basically co-teach.
00:46:12.079 --> 00:46:17.039
So they create a field that wasn't there before, climate finance, and uh and they co-teach.
00:46:17.199 --> 00:46:26.159
They basically have so when you teach there, kind of you have not, you know, 20 PhD students or five, but 800, right?
00:46:26.239 --> 00:46:31.519
And then and they have like a lineup of really interesting faculty, it's like best off, right?
00:46:31.679 --> 00:46:34.320
Because you can source from all these different places.
00:46:34.480 --> 00:46:50.159
So it's basically, you could say, a collaborative that works with institutional intelligence because it allows the right people in their departments kind of to get credits for working on these contents and then advance the field.
00:46:50.320 --> 00:47:03.920
So, and I wonder whether, so that's climate finance and whether the bigger conversation that we have been exploring over the past hour, whether that or not also requires something similar, right?
00:47:04.079 --> 00:47:10.000
Kind of where
a collaborative effort that, because we all know where the things start going wrong, right?
00:47:10.079 --> 00:47:12.480
It's kind of your career track, right?
00:47:12.559 --> 00:47:17.039
When when you uh create your PhD and you know, all these wrong incentives.
00:47:17.119 --> 00:47:33.840
And could is there the possibility to, because that's the core of the machine, and is there something we could innovate together, right, across all these institutions in a similar way that Peter and his colleagues pioneered that in a so interesting way?
00:47:34.159 --> 00:47:39.679
I I do think these cross-university types of collaborations are are hugely important.
00:47:39.760 --> 00:48:08.719
And I and and if it's and I and I do think the PhD or including PhDs is an important sort of lever in some ways, because you know, really at a lot of schools, you know, at least you know, my experience is that actually the PhDs somewhat are leading the faculty because the faculty are clearly playing a helpful role in getting things published, perhaps and learning how to frame, but actually the questions and passions and sort of finger on the pulse of the literature, the PhDs probably have a deeper, sort of clearer, clearer sense of that.
00:48:08.880 --> 00:48:12.639
So so I yeah, I mean, I I do see potential in that.
00:48:12.800 --> 00:48:17.599
I would the the like problem area in some ways would need to be scoped well.
00:48:17.760 --> 00:48:25.280
I think, you know, Peter's focus on climate and finance, I think is, you know, maybe in retrospect it looks like a natural fit.
00:48:25.519 --> 00:48:36.400
But yeah, think thinking about what the right intervention that could help that could get PhD, it could get faculty, because you need the faculty involved first and then their PhDs are involved.
00:48:36.480 --> 00:48:43.440
And I think it sort of has the flywheel type of thing if you can get the the the faculty initially involved in at least one sort of cohort of PhD.
00:48:43.599 --> 00:48:43.840
Yeah.
00:48:43.920 --> 00:48:46.960
But I I I so as a model, I think that has a lot of potential.
00:48:47.039 --> 00:48:51.280
But I sort of scoping the right problem area, I think is also really important.
00:48:51.599 --> 00:48:51.920
Wonderful.
00:48:52.000 --> 00:48:56.079
So there are a number of things that I think we can probably want to follow up on, right?
00:48:56.400 --> 00:48:57.280
Yeah, definitely.
00:48:57.679 --> 00:49:03.519
New schools, the impact with the business community, the connection with the university in in general.
00:49:03.679 --> 00:49:13.039
I'm uh wondering before we close, um, what are some of the key conversations that you'd like to continue or have people explore after this piece?
00:49:13.199 --> 00:49:15.199
Uh before your next one, so to speak.
00:49:16.639 --> 00:49:20.320
What are the some of the the key things that you think are resonating with you right now?
00:49:20.400 --> 00:49:24.480
And maybe Otto, you have another final uh question to Chris uh before we close.
00:49:24.639 --> 00:49:40.480
But that I think I want to just express your my gratitude for you being able to put this out in such a way that it does crystallize many of the conversations and advance them and would love to continue this conversation offline, online, and different other forms as we're sort of exploring what what can be done.
00:49:40.719 --> 00:49:42.960
But Otto, what what what what last question do you have?
00:49:43.519 --> 00:49:45.280
I I think that's a perfect closing question.
00:49:45.519 --> 00:49:45.920
So Chris.
00:49:46.159 --> 00:49:46.320
Yeah.
00:49:46.400 --> 00:49:48.000
So uh yeah, th thank thank you.
00:49:48.400 --> 00:49:52.559
Uh Michael, thank you, Otto, both of you for you know actually having this discussion.
00:49:52.719 --> 00:50:14.079
I think, yeah, this has been one of the, if not the most, it definitely one of the most thoughtful discussions I've had following the piece because, you know, I do think we have identified some areas that I had not really, you know, that I think are new ways of thinking about the problem around the PhDs, you know, the experiential piece, sort of putting some some flesh onto that.
00:50:14.159 --> 00:50:28.800
Uh, as far as what I would like to see future discussions go, I think I think that venues like the Humanistic Management Association, there, you know, RBM research, you know, uh irresponsible business, there's Prime, Principles, you know, response.
00:50:29.119 --> 00:50:33.199
So I do think that there's a lot of different venues and and organizations.
00:50:33.280 --> 00:50:49.280
And I so I'm not sure, like sometimes there might be too too many of those, but I do think it needs to be a conversation that draws in people from very diverse types of schools in order to really be thinking about what some key, you know, at least initial leverage points would be.
00:50:49.440 --> 00:50:54.400
And I think, yeah, some of the things that we've identified here are some of those, you know, key leverage points.
00:50:55.039 --> 00:51:11.039
Maybe now uh comes to my mind actually a closing question also from my end, which is uh business schools, as we all know, kind of are often catered to the Goldman, Sachs, and the McKinseys and so on, the big guys, not to the small SMEs, right?
00:51:11.119 --> 00:51:12.719
The small and medium-sized companies.
00:51:13.119 --> 00:51:19.760
And that are often often kind of more place-based, more regional, more long-term and family-owned.
00:51:20.159 --> 00:51:28.960
What role do you see that that part of the business community play in reimagining and evolving business goals?
00:51:29.360 --> 00:51:34.960
Yeah, I think that these are some of the really essential economic actors in our communities and in the world.
00:51:35.119 --> 00:51:52.320
I mean, it's it's I think a lot of times, you know, we sort of look at these large public companies or, you know, large consulting companies, but they're like very, very small number of the businesses in the world and the the you know, sort of power and leverage of the small, medium-sized enterprises.
00:51:52.400 --> 00:51:54.480
And so many times, you know, they're family-owned.
00:51:54.719 --> 00:51:56.239
They have deep connections in the community.
00:51:56.480 --> 00:52:08.079
They actually are much more oriented to sustainable practices and thoughtful business practices that you know are ethical and connect to inequality.
00:52:08.159 --> 00:52:16.800
I'm I'm meeting uh so a grad undergraduate degree at Notre Dame, and I'm going there this weekend for uh for a football game and doing actually something at the business school.
00:52:16.880 --> 00:52:22.400
And one of the alumni who runs this amazing organization, the Gund Group.
00:52:24.159 --> 00:52:25.519
Yes, shout out, shout out to him.
00:52:25.920 --> 00:52:29.920
We were working with I thought that he was working with you.
00:52:30.079 --> 00:52:36.880
So so he had emailed me, and there was this amazing article in the Wall Street Journal about the they're not laying people off.
00:52:37.039 --> 00:52:54.480
And so this is the kind of company, and I've done so much work, not enough that I with a lot of the B corporations that I've studied, where they are these organizations that are deeply embedded in their communities, and they, for a variety of reasons, embody a really powerful, you know, social and environmental ethos.
00:52:54.719 --> 00:52:59.360
And yeah, I I really think the more that they can be engaged in this process, the better.
00:52:59.519 --> 00:53:04.480
We can get away from the large McKinseys and large tech firms and and large businesses.
00:53:04.559 --> 00:53:08.079
And because that's really what, in some ways, commerce should be about.
00:53:08.480 --> 00:53:12.159
Well, thank you so much, Chris, for your time, for your work, for your willingness to engage.
00:53:12.320 --> 00:53:14.639
Uh, thank you, Otto, for for being here.
00:53:14.800 --> 00:53:19.039
And yeah, my my hope is that we can continue more of this conversation.
00:53:19.360 --> 00:53:35.039
Definitely connect and and and also intentionally see how we can develop and and build social fields around these leverage points and and see how how this plastic moment, as Otto describes it, can be actually a a real stepping up from where we are.
00:53:35.119 --> 00:53:39.519
I think uh that that is my sincere hope, and I thank you both for being here.
00:53:39.679 --> 00:53:41.599
So yeah, thank you, thank you both.
00:53:41.679 --> 00:53:43.039
I was really enjoyed the conversation.
00:53:43.280 --> 00:53:43.840
Thank you, Chris.
00:53:44.000 --> 00:53:44.480
Thank you, Michael.
00:53:44.719 --> 00:53:45.119
Thank you both.
00:53:45.760 --> 00:53:46.400
Take care, bye bye.
00:53:46.719 --> 00:53:47.440
Great, okay, bye bye.
00:53:47.599 --> 00:53:48.480
To be continued.
00:53:48.639 --> 00:53:49.760
Yes, definitely.