TRANSKRIP 🔗
WEBVTT
00:00:00.516 --> 00:00:04.547
Good afternoon. This is John Richardson speaking with you from Toronto,
00:00:04.547 --> 00:00:09.497
Canada on this very, very important day, not only for American citizens,
00:00:09.497 --> 00:00:15.377
but arguably for the world because the U.S. elections have been going on all day.
00:00:16.018 --> 00:00:22.020
And it is therefore, I think, fitting that I talk to a great American lawyer,
00:00:22.542 --> 00:00:28.029
who is based in London, who I have known for many years, phenomenal lawyer,
00:00:28.685 --> 00:00:33.277
basically one of the people who's been doing expatriation, meaning renunciation
00:00:33.277 --> 00:00:39.237
since really before it was even a thing, I think, since possibly the 90s, etc.
00:00:39.897 --> 00:00:43.837
And for those of you who are long-time listeners to this podcast,
00:00:43.837 --> 00:00:48.897
this is Diane Gellin. And, you know, every time it's a difficult issue, I know where to look.
00:00:50.217 --> 00:00:55.209
So, Diane, how are you? I'm fine, John. Always lovely to have a chat with you.
00:00:55.772 --> 00:00:57.157
See what we can come up with.
00:00:57.856 --> 00:01:01.757
What games we can play. Bons of fun. Absolutely.
00:01:02.547 --> 00:01:05.497
Well, I mean, we have an awful lot to talk about.
00:01:06.057 --> 00:01:09.447
Well, why don't we start off with, what do you want to go with first,
00:01:09.447 --> 00:01:11.017
the election or renunciation?
00:01:12.937 --> 00:01:16.620
Let's do renunciation. God knows where the election's going, Denae.
00:01:17.204 --> 00:01:20.457
Well, that's true, but we've got all kinds of stuff on renunciation,
00:01:20.457 --> 00:01:25.547
too. So tell me, any uptick in the number of people who are calling you for assistance?
00:01:25.772 --> 00:01:27.437
Many more people, I think.
00:01:27.777 --> 00:01:32.457
Surprisingly, I've had a lot in the last six months. And I finally had somebody
00:01:32.457 --> 00:01:36.086
who actually said it was because of the current president of the United States.
00:01:36.527 --> 00:01:42.897
I've been doing this work since the late 1980s. Nobody has ever mentioned politics
00:01:42.897 --> 00:01:49.763
before, or who was president, or what wars the U.S. was involved in.
00:01:50.244 --> 00:01:54.397
And this was the first time. She actually has her appointment tomorrow,
00:01:54.877 --> 00:01:56.503
so we'll see how that goes.
00:01:57.319 --> 00:02:02.398
Is there any way the outcome of the election could influence her decision? Probably not.
00:02:03.639 --> 00:02:06.060
Just too much, huh? Yeah, too much.
00:02:07.538 --> 00:02:11.888
She's a naturalized American, so she's a little bit different.
00:02:12.289 --> 00:02:15.395
Well, she didn't grow up drinking all the Kool-Aid. No.
00:02:16.139 --> 00:02:17.857
No, she got it fed later.
00:02:18.694 --> 00:02:20.878
Got it fed later, a big dose of it later.
00:02:21.788 --> 00:02:24.978
Yeah. That's a Tory dose. Yeah.
00:02:25.858 -->
Load full transcript
00:02:29.979
You're up here, so you need to drink twice as much Kool-Aid. Exactly.
00:02:31.589 --> 00:02:35.838
Yeah, you know, I honestly, I mean, I kind of go on the assumption that people
00:02:35.838 --> 00:02:38.238
do not renounce for political reasons.
00:02:38.554 --> 00:02:42.078
I mean, I've heard a few people talk about they don't like the politics there.
00:02:42.078 --> 00:02:48.787
But honestly, I haven't had anybody, as far as I know, come to me recently and say, John, I've had it.
00:02:49.036 --> 00:02:52.450
I've had it with the United States. I want to renounce.
00:02:53.018 --> 00:02:57.778
No, I mean, I haven't either. I mean, we've got Afghanistan wars,
00:02:58.378 --> 00:03:00.218
Vietnam, whatever it was.
00:03:00.218 --> 00:03:05.298
Nobody's renouncing because of American policies overseas. Nobody's renouncing
00:03:05.298 --> 00:03:10.018
because of the wars that the U.S. have been involved in or the politics of the
00:03:10.018 --> 00:03:15.212
U.S. It's all, 99% of it is ease of life.
00:03:15.508 --> 00:03:19.606
They just want to be in one system and not be in two.
00:03:20.433 --> 00:03:23.996
Yeah, I think that's right. And certainly the being in, you know,
00:03:23.996 --> 00:03:28.776
I think, you know, in our lifetimes, I mean, would you agree that taxes,
00:03:28.776 --> 00:03:32.686
tax policy, really all over the world, has this become a bigger factor in how
00:03:32.686 --> 00:03:34.005
people are required to live?
00:03:34.801 --> 00:03:40.406
I think I hear, you know, mostly what I hear is how long it takes to comply
00:03:40.406 --> 00:03:45.858
with the sort of tax requirements that people have and are too afraid of making errors,
00:03:46.386 --> 00:03:51.564
and leaving something off, that it's complex, they can't do it themselves,
00:03:52.325 --> 00:03:57.908
and they have no way that they can even review properly their tax returns, for example.
00:03:59.076 --> 00:04:03.466
I think that's right I mean, you know, to put it another way Would you agree
00:04:03.466 --> 00:04:06.776
that what that means Is that the people who are incentivized to renounce Are
00:04:06.776 --> 00:04:10.437
the people who feel strongly about being in compliance And obeying the law?
00:04:11.082 --> 00:04:16.596
Yeah, no, they are Yeah, so many of them are So many of them are The greater
00:04:16.596 --> 00:04:20.608
the desire to comply with the law The more likely they are.
00:04:22.816 --> 00:04:27.076
Could be, could be People who don't comply Well, why should I renounce?
00:04:27.076 --> 00:04:27.856
It's not a problem for me.
00:04:28.936 --> 00:04:34.926
Exactly. They don't care. Amazing, amazing stuff. Well, maybe that was your
00:04:34.926 --> 00:04:37.396
person who ran out for political reasons.
00:04:38.588 --> 00:04:43.106
But as I said to her the other day, you're the first person who has given me
00:04:43.106 --> 00:04:46.163
that as an example as to why they want to.
00:04:47.417 --> 00:04:51.034
Well, I
mean, you know, Diane, as you know, it's a lot of work to renounce,
00:04:51.034 --> 00:04:52.634
isn't it, for most people? You
00:04:52.634 --> 00:04:57.394
know, it takes a lot of time to get appointments, paperwork, forms, tax.
00:04:58.374 --> 00:05:02.204
And also, I mean, today I had a client who, you know, where I've had many clients
00:05:02.204 --> 00:05:04.255
like this, can't do it till mom dies.
00:05:04.974 --> 00:05:11.254
Can't do it till dad dies. They still have that kind of tie to their parents
00:05:11.254 --> 00:05:13.805
in the United States and what a disappointment they'll be.
00:05:14.517 --> 00:05:18.664
So that was a conversation I had today with somebody. Their parents would be
00:05:18.664 --> 00:05:21.013
upset if they renounced. That's right.
00:05:22.114 --> 00:05:25.424
Well, you know, I mean, if the parents really understood what was going on,
00:05:25.424 --> 00:05:28.389
they'd be encouraging. Could be.
00:05:29.354 --> 00:05:32.504
But, you know, sometimes it's there, you know, the parents are,
00:05:33.034 --> 00:05:37.964
you know, where the person who's renouncing is a first generation American because
00:05:37.964 --> 00:05:40.194
their parents came over from somewhere else.
00:05:40.897 --> 00:05:45.185
And they just can't see that they can do that in their parents' lifetime.
00:05:46.139 --> 00:05:50.954
Well, that's right. There is a lot of that. And I think that part of the reason
00:05:50.954 --> 00:05:52.554
that people are renouncing, which,
00:05:53.214 --> 00:05:57.864
is overwhelmingly the inability to comply with these laws, or the inability
00:05:57.864 --> 00:06:01.374
to feel with enough certainty that they've complied with the laws,
00:06:01.374 --> 00:06:02.394
I think it's maybe better.
00:06:03.699 --> 00:06:08.174
I mean, that can be understood only by American citizens living outside the
00:06:08.174 --> 00:06:13.330
United States. Nobody in the United States can possibly understand that, right? No, no.
00:06:14.714 --> 00:06:18.597
Yeah. Well, and then you mentioned, you know, another reason,
00:06:18.597 --> 00:06:21.007
though, you know, speaking of the whole parent thing, right?
00:06:21.007 --> 00:06:23.737
I mean, I suppose there's the disappointment. There's also a lot of people who
00:06:23.737 --> 00:06:28.877
hold on to U.S. citizenship because, you know, they want to have a guaranteed
00:06:28.877 --> 00:06:33.259
right to return to take care of parents and things like that, right? Yeah, of course.
00:06:33.838 --> 00:06:38.037
Yeah, that's always a big issue. Still got my parents, still have,
00:06:38.037 --> 00:06:42.557
you know, an older brother or sister or somebody that they really care about
00:06:42.557 --> 00:06:47.979
and want to make sure that they can spend the appropriate time with them in the U.S.
00:06:49.647 --> 00:06:53.927
Absolutely and and you know it's funny because what brought us together today
00:06:53.927 --> 00:06:58.648
specifically was this conversation going on about uh,
00:06:59.378 --> 00:07:02.597
you know is it really true that if somebody renounces they're going to have
00:07:02.597 --> 00:07:06.078
trouble getting an esta to me well,
00:07:07.477 --> 00:07:12.747
i mean you and i have taken a look at this and and uh it certainly is appearing
00:07:12.747 --> 00:07:16.937
on a couple of people's websites that that is the information that they have
00:07:16.937 --> 00:07:20.862
figured out that through conversations with,
00:07:22.729 --> 00:07:27.088
immigration authorities that applying for an ESTA.
00:07:30.573 --> 00:07:35.187
When you are a former American citizen, somebody who has relinquished their
00:07:35.187 --> 00:07:40.767
citizenship, may not be able to easily get an ESTA,
00:07:42.218 --> 00:07:47.067
which, as you know, is the advanced document that you need to obtain in order
00:07:47.067 --> 00:07:51.035
to enter the United States as a visitor. So it's a visa waiver.
00:07:51.947 --> 00:07:55.087
Without actually going into trouble of getting a visa. Well,
00:07:55.523 --> 00:07:58.541
you know, I mean, so we look at these things that we read.
00:07:59.096 --> 00:08:01.939
You know, somebody was talking about this on LinkedIn today.
00:08:02.984 --> 00:08:08.493
I don't know how authoritative that was, but I mean, we found a couple of other articles.
00:08:08.493 --> 00:08:13.323
There was a Withers thing, for example, came down yesterday,
00:08:13.323 --> 00:08:18.103
and I didn't read that as categorically saying that, you know,
00:08:18.103 --> 00:08:22.564
the fact of renunciation means you can't get an ESTA. Did you read it that way?
00:08:23.166 --> 00:08:28.133
I didn't read it that way, and then subsequent to that went on the ESTA website
00:08:28.133 --> 00:08:34.063
to see if they were listing that as the types of people who couldn't apply for
00:08:34.063 --> 00:08:37.225
an ESTA, and that does not appear on their website.
00:08:37.678 --> 00:08:43.297
So I don't know, you know, when that has become, you know, implemented,
00:08:43.976 --> 00:08:50.143
And, you know, is it on a case-by-case basis Or is it a new blanket rule that
00:08:50.143 --> 00:08:54.645
somebody who has renounced their citizenship Is not eligible to apply for an ESTA?
00:08:55.659 --> 00:09:02.161
Yeah, so I think would the safest response to this at the moment be We really just don't know,
00:09:02.798 --> 00:09:11.343
you know, we see I think that's the safest response on the 3rd of November until
00:09:11.343 --> 00:09:13.846
I get more factual information on that.
00:09:14.711 --> 00:09:21.313
Yeah, I mean, what would be credible factual information? I would think that,
00:09:21.984 --> 00:09:25.573
there ought to be something appearing on the ESTA website, you know,
00:09:25.573 --> 00:09:27.313
warning of this, wouldn't you think?
00:09:27.913 --> 00:09:32.393
I would think that because otherwise, you know, you'd start making an application
00:09:32.393 --> 00:09:37.263
and maybe even paying the fee, and then suddenly it's refused.
00:09:38.082 --> 00:09:44.016
One of the websites that we looked at earlier today also indicated that they were,
00:09:45.256 --> 00:09:46.249
taking away.
00:09:48.275 --> 00:09:52.124
I don't know what the right words are for it, but people who had ESTAs,
00:09:52.791 --> 00:09:59.928
they're perhaps discovering who they are and taking away that ESTA right and
00:09:59.928 --> 00:10:03.507
forcing them to obtain a visa to enter the United States.
00:10:04.616 --> 00:10:11.648
Yeah, well, we don't know, but my take on this is a little more conservative
00:10:11.648 --> 00:10:17.818
in a sense I'm not sure how much of this, I'm not sure that the spin on this is actually correct.
00:10:17.818 --> 00:10:23.988
My impression of this is that the issue is it starts with if you're a U.S.
00:10:23.988 --> 00:10:25.788
Citizen, you can't have an ASTA.
00:10:26.648 --> 00:10:32.688
Correct. Seems to me that what's going on here is a more heightened inquiry
00:10:32.688 --> 00:10:36.151
of whether somebody actually is no longer a U.S. citizen.
00:10:36.703 --> 00:10:41.812
Mm-hmm. You know, I think that's also a credible interpretation of this.
00:10:42.708 --> 00:10:49.893
I think you need to add to it that when you do have an appointment to renounce your citizenship,
00:10:50.654 --> 00:10:54.738
which, as most people know, can only be done when you are outside the United
00:10:54.738 --> 00:10:58.867
States and personally appear before a U.S. consular officer.
00:11:02.355 --> 00:11:06.478
That consular officer does not make that determination, but that determination
00:11:06.478 --> 00:11:08.548
is made by folks back in Washington, D.C.
00:11:09.722 --> 00:11:16.468
Now, that determination can take three, four, five months before the person,
00:11:17.388 --> 00:11:22.398
who has had that appointment to renounce their citizenship then finally receives
00:11:22.398 --> 00:11:26.211
the approval in the form of a certificate of loss of nationality.
00:11:26.774 --> 00:11:31.958
So there is this sort of what I refer to as this no man's land of are you a U.S.
00:11:31.958 --> 00:11:35.017
Citizen, are you not a U.S. citizen? and you've had your appointment,
00:11:35.545 --> 00:11:42.842
you've signed the oath of renunciation, but it hasn't been formally approved by the U.S. government.
00:11:43.831 --> 00:11:49.175
Right, right. Well, you know, that leads to a very interesting question,
00:11:49.515 --> 00:11:52.525
you know, the interpretation of the actual statute, right?
00:11:52.525 --> 00:11:57.023
Because if you read the Immigration Nationality Act, there doesn't,
00:11:57.708 --> 00:12:02.375
for immigration purposes, there doesn't seem to me to be a requirement of a
00:12:02.375 --> 00:12:05.381
CLN having been issued to have lost citizenship.
00:12:05.753 --> 00:12:08.715
So it's not, I don't think it's a question of whether you've lost citizenship.
00:12:08.715 --> 00:12:11.742
I think
it's a question of proof. Right, okay.
00:12:12.364 --> 00:12:16.805
And, you know, if you're applying for an ESTA, well, you know,
00:12:16.805 --> 00:12:20.755
the fundamental prerequisite seems to me that you can't, or the necessary condition
00:12:20.755 --> 00:12:22.399
is that you can't be a U.S. citizen.
00:12:23.099 --> 00:12:27.155
Right. But if there's somebody born in the United States who has not yet been
00:12:27.155 --> 00:12:31.957
issued a CLN, it seems to me that from an immigration perspective,
00:12:32.514 --> 00:12:35.745
they could be in the situation of no longer being a U.S.
00:12:35.745 --> 00:12:41.071
Citizen, but lacking the ability to prove it because the CLN hasn't. Right.
00:12:42.038 --> 00:12:46.090
You know, I think that would tie some of these ideas together a little bit.
00:12:46.735 --> 00:12:51.955
Yeah, perhaps. But oftentimes at the appointment that a person will have at.
00:12:52.933 --> 00:12:55.695
A U.S. embassy, they will often
00:12:55.695 --> 00:12:59.454
ask, do you have plans to visit the United States in the next few months?
00:13:00.059 --> 00:13:03.675
And if you say, yes, you do have plans to visit the United States,
00:13:03.675 --> 00:13:09.213
they will either allow you to retain your U.S. passport for a period of time,
00:13:09.701 --> 00:13:11.761
or they will say you are required.
00:13:12.063 --> 00:13:14.031
We will hold your U.S. passport.
00:13:14.583 --> 00:13:18.298
And if you do wish to visit the United States.
00:13:19.347 --> 00:13:23.805
We will give it back to you for that purpose before the CLN is issued?
00:13:24.461 --> 00:13:28.259
Well, you know, that would be consistent with an interpretation that the CLN
00:13:28.259 --> 00:13:31.485
is a necessary condition to lose citizenship, right?
00:13:33.038 --> 00:13:36.254
I don't know. I mean, that certainly is not what the statute says.
00:13:36.423 --> 00:13:40.553
I guess the question would be, you know, is there a regulatory power?
00:13:42.589 --> 00:13:47.318
But I think that for practical purposes, you know, very practical purposes,
00:13:48.127 --> 00:13:54.359
it is clear that nobody's going to issue you an ASTA unless you're not a U.S.
00:13:54.359 --> 00:13:59.589
Citizen. So if you're born in the U.S. or whatever, without proof that you're
00:13:59.589 --> 00:14:02.547
not a citizen, I think you're going to have trouble with that. Would you agree?
00:14:03.709 --> 00:14:05.348
I do agree. Absolutely.
00:14:06.949 --> 00:14:12.899
Maybe that's part of the issue there. These reasons that are sort of coming
00:14:12.899 --> 00:14:17.162
out of the back and forth we're having here, I think this discussion sort of,
00:14:17.742 --> 00:14:23.729
demonstrates how somebody who's renounced could have a problem getting an ESTA,
00:14:23.729 --> 00:14:26.173
right? Mm-hmm. Well, same.
00:14:26.866 --> 00:14:30.729
You know, it's not like there's a blanket policy that says, you know,
00:14:30.729 --> 00:14:33.588
if you renounced, you know, you cannot get an ESTA, right?
00:14:34.450 --> 00:14:37.999
Well, not that I see on the ESTA. I mean, I would think if it was a policy,
00:14:37.999 --> 00:14:39.632
it would be on the ESTA website.
00:14:40.371 --> 00:14:44.039
Yeah, I would too. I mean, you know, that's a very, very significant,
00:14:44.039 --> 00:14:48.615
that would be a very, very significant. Yeah, huge change.
00:14:48.975 --> 00:14:50.839
In the war on American pride.
00:14:53.313 --> 00:14:55.873
I mean, that's not to say, you know, I wouldn't put it past them,
00:14:55.873 --> 00:15:00.633
but I'm just, I'm not seeing it because I can see how some people would have
00:15:00.633 --> 00:15:05.183
trouble, right, with a general policy.
00:15:05.183 --> 00:15:10.823
Do you think, Diane, that, let's say hypothetically that tomorrow they say,
00:15:10.823 --> 00:15:14.443
well, you know, we listen to John and Diane's podcast.
00:15:14.443 --> 00:15:18.343
And just for the record, John and Diane, by the way, anybody else who wants
00:15:18.343 --> 00:15:22.271
to open up this, we just want you to know the fact.
00:15:22.823 --> 00:15:27.362
We are absolutely not going to let anybody who renounced citizenship get a NASA.
00:15:28.440 --> 00:15:31.860
Do you think that... Don't blame me.
00:15:33.880 --> 00:15:42.140
I'll never blame you. But do you think that that would discourage people from renouncing? I don't.
00:15:42.790 --> 00:15:44.223
I don't think it would be a factor.
00:15:45.083 --> 00:15:49.233
I mean, I think maybe some people would think about it, but I don't think it
00:15:49.233 --> 00:15:50.682
would be the ultimate factor.
00:15:51.119 --> 00:15:55.807
Because, of course, you can always apply for a visa. Yeah.
00:15:56.490 --> 00:16:02.163
And it's just a longer process. It could be several weeks to several months
00:16:02.163 --> 00:16:03.943
before you could get a visitor visa.
00:16:04.666 --> 00:16:11.760
And it's just a longer, more intense, more expensive process. Yeah.
00:16:13.687 --> 00:16:17.703
I think you're probably right on that because by the time people get around
00:16:17.703 --> 00:16:22.303
to renouncing, And I think my impression of it is they really decided that they
00:16:22.303 --> 00:16:27.552
just cannot, they just cannot continue living with this as a problem in their life, right? Right.
00:16:28.220 --> 00:16:32.753
Mm-hmm. Well, we'll have to see how that, how this plays out.
00:16:32.753 --> 00:16:35.843
But, you know, for people who are listening to this, because I know that this
00:16:35.843 --> 00:16:40.963
is going to be of interest to people, do you want to take a stab at summarizing
00:16:40.963 --> 00:16:42.500
what I think we're trying to say here?
00:16:44.683 --> 00:16:47.497
I think we're trying to say that it could be a factor. Sure.
00:16:48.521 --> 00:16:54.709
Having relinquished your citizenship as to whether you can obtain a visa waiver,
00:16:55.040 --> 00:16:59.581
a simple visa waiver to
enter the United States if you wish to visit.
00:16:59.900 --> 00:17:02.903
We're only talking about visitors because, of course, if you're going there
00:17:02.903 --> 00:17:06.973
to work, even as a business visitor, you would need a visa.
00:17:07.760 --> 00:17:11.473
So we're only talking about true visitors to the United States,
00:17:11.473 --> 00:17:15.738
going to the Grand Canyon, maybe seeing a family member, whatever it is,
00:17:17.133 --> 00:17:22.480
or going to see the new Triumphal Arch in Washington, D.C., whatever it's going to be.
00:17:23.229 --> 00:17:27.663
We're going to the United States for a visit. So it might not be as easy as
00:17:27.663 --> 00:17:30.305
they think. It might not be as straightforward.
00:17:30.996 --> 00:17:38.241
But at the moment, it's not listed on the ESTA website as a possibility that
00:17:38.363 --> 00:17:42.160
it might be denied, your ESTA application.
00:17:42.752 --> 00:17:48.744
So I think we need to, you know, I can't answer whether it's,
00:17:50.590 --> 00:17:57.990
It's for real, and it's for everybody who's renounced. To read this information
00:17:57.990 --> 00:18:03.105
coming out today as well, for sure, that if you renounce, you cannot get an ASTO, right?
00:18:04.250 --> 00:18:05.965
Yeah, right. Okay.
00:18:07.910 --> 00:18:10.560
I'm sitting here in Toronto, Canada. You're in London, of course.
00:18:10.560 --> 00:18:13.830
Here we have one more advantage. If you're Canadian, if you're renounced,
00:18:13.830 --> 00:18:15.708
because you don't need a visa anyway, right?
00:18:16.970 --> 00:18:21.680
Right. Well, there you are. You're lucky. Unbelievable. Maybe people should
00:18:21.680 --> 00:18:24.735
get citizenship before they renounce.
00:18:25.269 --> 00:18:27.330
Good. We're all going to marry you, John. That's it.
00:18:27.950 --> 00:18:30.105
Oh, everybody. Okay.
00:18:30.732 --> 00:18:33.750
So, Diane, it's November 3rd.
00:18:34.663 --> 00:18:39.068
Excellent. What happens on November 3rd? Anything in particular?
00:18:39.440 --> 00:18:45.480
We've got this huge thing that they regard as part of the democratic process
00:18:45.480 --> 00:18:48.160
and the United States begins. What's that four-letter word, V?
00:18:48.270 --> 00:18:51.515
It starts with a V, ends with an E.
00:18:51.973 --> 00:18:56.350
That's right. So what's your thought on that? A lot of interest in this election?
00:18:56.350 --> 00:18:59.870
In London, are a lot of the Americans in London really heightened interest in
00:18:59.870 --> 00:19:03.520
this, or what's happening? Oh, I think there's definitely a heightened interest
00:19:03.520 --> 00:19:07.745
in it. I know that, you know, the people are having election parties tonight.
00:19:08.371 --> 00:19:11.950
It's been all over, you know, BBC News. You know, all of the,
00:19:12.270 --> 00:19:15.387
you know, it's being covered on the, you know, on the news here.
00:19:15.967 --> 00:19:19.009
As if it was, almost as if it was happening here.
00:19:20.438 --> 00:19:23.131
So it is a big deal.
00:19:24.635 --> 00:19:27.664
And it's being looked at as a big deal internationally.
00:19:28.707 --> 00:19:31.865
I don't know, you got the same thing going on in Canada? You guys don't have
00:19:31.865 --> 00:19:37.355
a great relationship these days with the United States? Oh, I understand.
00:19:39.285 --> 00:19:44.185
Yeah, I think that there's a lot of interest in this. What I'm not seeing,
00:19:44.185 --> 00:19:47.445
or maybe I just haven't been looking at, is usually Democrats abroad,
00:19:47.445 --> 00:19:52.190
you know, does this huge independent push. I haven't seen any flyers around Toronto.
00:19:52.416 --> 00:19:55.955
Maybe I just haven't seen them. Usually, Democrats abroad, you know,
00:19:55.955 --> 00:19:58.755
puts up flyers on telephone polls in Toronto.
00:19:58.755 --> 00:20:01.865
Oh, really? Oh, it's something like- I haven't seen- Well, they certainly don't
00:20:01.865 --> 00:20:07.055
put them up on telephone polls here, but I've certainly had a number of- consistently
00:20:07.455 --> 00:20:12.793
have had emails from them ensuring, you know, making sure they got out the vote.
00:20:13.855 --> 00:20:16.490
I assume the Republicans abroad are doing the same thing.
00:20:18.055 --> 00:20:23.195
I think both Republicans and Democrats abroad do a very good job of encouraging
00:20:23.195 --> 00:20:27.183
Americans who live abroad to vote. I think that's a good thing.
00:20:27.843 --> 00:20:32.539
You may or may not disagree, may not agree with me on that.
00:20:33.063 --> 00:20:36.195
Well, I think it's a good thing that they encourage people to vote,
00:20:36.195 --> 00:20:40.515
if that's your question. I mean, you know, my own, not that it matters particularly,
00:20:40.515 --> 00:20:46.450
is that I just don't think that citizens of any country living outside the country should be voting.
00:20:47.080 --> 00:20:52.025
You know, that's just how I see it personally Because most of these issues,
00:20:52.025 --> 00:20:55.475
right You know, affect people who live in the country And this,
00:20:55.475 --> 00:21:00.693
by the way, is why As far as I know, I think Wasn't there some issue with the state of Arizona?
00:21:01.575 --> 00:21:04.956
There was some U.S.A. recently Didn't want Americans abroad to vote So,
00:21:05.178 --> 00:21:08.455
I mean, I think Given that they can vote Yes,
00:21:09.321 --> 00:21:12.875
I think the political parties Ought to do anything to get people to vote That's
00:21:12.875 --> 00:21:17.325
a different question Right I don't know whether I think that citizens abroad
00:21:17.325 --> 00:21:19.928
of any country. I mean, let's look at it this way. Look at Ireland, right?
00:21:20.589 --> 00:21:24.105
I mean, Ireland's a country where I bet you there's more citizens living outside
00:21:24.105 --> 00:21:25.436
the country than in the country.
00:21:26.203 --> 00:21:28.593
So, you know, if they all vote, what are they going to do? Why
don't they all
00:21:28.593 --> 00:21:31.853
vote themselves pensions? You know, we'll get the people in Ireland to pay us
00:21:31.853 --> 00:21:33.517
pensions, you know, this sort of stuff.
00:21:34.086 --> 00:21:37.603
I know, but it's a big difference with the United States where we're still tied
00:21:37.603 --> 00:21:39.032
because of the tax rules.
00:21:39.798 --> 00:21:45.329
And we're treated as if we, you know, live in the 51st state,
00:21:45.561 --> 00:21:49.114
the 51st state of, you know, of citizens abroad.
00:21:49.497 --> 00:21:55.145
Or we're treated as if we lived in Iowa or New York or California or Illinois, wherever it is.
00:21:55.720 --> 00:22:01.524
We're still treated the same as every other American citizen in terms of taxation.
00:22:02.029 --> 00:22:03.515
And I think that's a big deal.
00:22:04.257 --> 00:22:07.398
Oh, I think it's a big deal. Do you think it's a good thing?
00:22:08.713 --> 00:22:12.703
That's a whole other issue. All right, Go ahead. Tell me the truth.
00:22:12.703 --> 00:22:15.228
Now, are you proud of citizenship taxation?
00:22:15.768 --> 00:22:18.856
I am not proud of citizenship taxation.
00:22:20.453 --> 00:22:24.209
I am an advocate of taxation based on residence.
00:22:24.615 --> 00:22:29.196
Yeah. Well, I think anybody, as Ronald Reagan used to say, what do you say?
00:22:29.523 --> 00:22:33.793
A communist is somebody who reads Marx and Lenin. A non-communist is somebody
00:22:33.793 --> 00:22:35.433
who understands Marx and Lenin.
00:22:36.936 --> 00:22:40.093
I think the same thing can be applied to citizenship taxation.
00:22:40.093 --> 00:22:44.253
An advocate of citizenship taxation is somebody who has a vague idea that it's,
00:22:44.833 --> 00:22:49.183
the same as filling out a U.S. tax return abroad. An opponent of it is somebody
00:22:49.183 --> 00:22:50.984
who understands what it actually is.
00:22:53.133 --> 00:22:56.803
Which is very, very different. And that, I think, has been a part of the struggle
00:22:56.803 --> 00:22:59.857
to get changed. But since you brought that up, Diane.
00:23:01.533 --> 00:23:04.646
Or since you brought it up, John. Did I bring it up?
00:23:05.234 --> 00:23:10.569
Yeah, I think you did. Go on. I'll never brought it up. I'll ask you anyway.
00:23:11.133 --> 00:23:15.463
I'll ask you anyway, Diane. What do you think the chances are of the U.S.
00:23:15.463 --> 00:23:17.657
Moving to residence-based taxation?
00:23:18.232 --> 00:23:19.358
Slim to none.
00:23:20.822 --> 00:23:27.512
Is my answer. Oh, my God. I mean, it's not in anybody, other than the few of
00:23:27.512 --> 00:23:31.462
us who live abroad, it's not in anybody else's self-interest.
00:23:32.036 --> 00:23:34.142
So it's not a priority.
00:23:34.942 --> 00:23:36.506
You know, we can't make it a priority.
00:23:37.632 --> 00:23:43.761
You know, can we get a senator or a few congresspeople to support this? Pretty difficult.
00:23:44.717 --> 00:23:49.833
Well, it clearly is difficult,
right? I mean, if you look at the various initiatives,
00:23:50.095 --> 00:23:55.482
legislative initiatives, the way I see the problem is that I don't even think
00:23:55.482 --> 00:23:58.672
Americans abroad advocate for residency-based taxation.
00:23:58.672 --> 00:24:02.815
What they advocate for is trying to make citizenship taxation more bearable.
00:24:03.577 --> 00:24:07.960
That's right. That's absolutely right. Entirely different thing, right?
00:24:08.262 --> 00:24:12.182
You know, who knows whether I'm right or wrong, but it seems to me that if they
00:24:12.182 --> 00:24:16.862
were to succeed to make citizenship taxation more bearable, might make it a
00:24:16.862 --> 00:24:18.842
lot harder to get rid of it down the road.
00:24:20.687 --> 00:24:26.166
Could be. I have no comment on that, really. But I haven't been impressed with,
00:24:26.875 --> 00:24:31.846
the draft legislation or draft ideas that people have come up with. That's interesting.
00:24:32.782 --> 00:24:38.786
Why? Care to comment why? Because I think for it to make proper sense,
00:24:38.786 --> 00:24:41.878
it has to be residence-based, and it's not.
00:24:42.470 --> 00:24:47.626
We need to be treated as probably non-resident aliens in some kind of way. Yeah, yeah.
00:24:48.705 --> 00:24:53.076
Yeah, well, I mean, that's my basic position, too, that it retains citizenship
00:24:53.076 --> 00:24:56.878
taxation and just sort of makes it easier, right? Mm-hmm.
00:24:57.579 --> 00:25:01.770
And, you know, I think that's a real problem.
00:25:02.187 --> 00:25:06.066
And it's also, I think, I mean, there's a lot of disagreement on this,
00:25:06.066 --> 00:25:10.536
but, you know, after many years of sort of thinking about this from time to
00:25:10.536 --> 00:25:14.566
time, I think that, you know, it tends to reinforce citizenship.
00:25:14.566 --> 00:25:17.495
Like, we think citizenship taxation is okay.
00:25:17.977 --> 00:25:20.281
We just want to make it a little more bearable.
00:25:21.593 --> 00:25:25.426
Let's get rid of some of the reporting requirements, you know, this sort of stuff.
00:25:25.986 --> 00:25:30.206
Yeah, and get rid of some of the penalties for non-reporting. Yeah.
00:25:31.263 --> 00:25:35.986
I mean, it's an extraordinary problem, but a huge part of the problem is that
00:25:35.986 --> 00:25:39.196
so few people actually understand how it works and what it is.
00:25:39.196 --> 00:25:42.736
I mean, you know, right now, I pleasure speaking with you as I'm talking to
00:25:42.736 --> 00:25:44.816
somebody who actually understands it. right?
00:25:45.476 --> 00:25:49.441
I hope I do. Yeah. I think you do, Diane. Yeah.
00:25:50.172 --> 00:25:53.893
I mean, is there anything in the world worse than citizenship taxation?
00:25:57.466 --> 00:26:02.566
A bad meal. How about that? Bad meal? Yeah.
00:26:03.166 --> 00:26:07.690
The person says, oh my gosh, sounds like you're a squirt of ship taxation. Okay.
00:26:08.380 --> 00:26:12.346
Well, okay. I don't know. Bad meal, bad taxation.
00:26:13.412 --> 00:26:18.896
Well, let me ask, would you agree that citizenship taxation, U.S.
00:26:18.896 --> 00:26:23.240
Form of it, well, no pun intended, U.S. form of citizenship tax,
00:26:24.325 --> 00:26:28.976
would you say that Effectively, U.S. citizens brought our tax more punitively
00:26:28.976 --> 00:26:31.564
than resident Americans for living an equivalent life.
00:26:34.392 --> 00:26:40.622
I think where the problem is, is that when you live abroad, you're subject to
00:26:40.622 --> 00:26:42.581
tax in two different jurisdictions.
00:26:43.417 --> 00:26:45.272
I can only talk best about the UK.
00:26:46.372 --> 00:26:50.226
So in the same way that we think we speak the same language,
00:26:50.818 --> 00:26:53.698
the Americans and the Brits, we don't speak the same language.
00:26:54.328 --> 00:26:59.831
And each country has its own way and its own rules of taxing people.
00:27:00.609 --> 00:27:02.989
And they've come up with what works best for them.
00:27:03.784 --> 00:27:05.232
So for example, in the UK.
00:27:07.932 --> 00:27:12.489
You can move through life and there are many things that they don't tax you on.
00:27:13.449 --> 00:27:17.733
You know, there's tax-free investments. There's the selling of your house where,
00:27:18.792 --> 00:27:20.512
you don't pay capital gains tax.
00:27:21.216 --> 00:27:29.846
But then when you die, only the first 320,000 pounds of assets are not taxable, okay?
00:27:30.456 --> 00:27:33.412
Now, that's just the way they've done it.
00:27:34.345 --> 00:27:39.441
So what happens is that you can pass on less to the next generation.
00:27:39.813 --> 00:27:44.526
Okay, that's an economic policy decision.
00:27:45.629 --> 00:27:50.192
So then you overlay that with an American who lives here, who is,
00:27:50.192 --> 00:27:57.251
for example, doesn't get the benefit of a UK tax-free investment because they pay US tax on it.
00:27:57.872 --> 00:28:04.362
They don't get the benefit of being able to sell their principal residence because
00:28:04.362 --> 00:28:06.222
in the U.S. they're going to pay tax on it.
00:28:07.460 --> 00:28:13.575
They then, so there are many benefits that the UK gives to its citizens,
00:28:14.051 --> 00:28:19.862
which the US citizens also benefit by on their UK tax returns,
00:28:20.181 --> 00:28:21.987
but not on their US tax return.
00:28:22.846 --> 00:28:28.600
And then you amass this great fortune, and lo and behold, you know,
00:28:28.600 --> 00:28:31.855
you can leave 13 million to the next generation, but whoops,
00:28:32.082 --> 00:28:36.337
we're also living in the UK, and that doesn't matter, hell of beans.
00:28:36.644 --> 00:28:40.777
So you've got these two systems which are fighting with each other,
00:28:41.161 --> 00:28:46.550
and the U.S. person who lives here doesn't get the benefit of either system,
00:28:46.550 --> 00:28:48.185
either taxation system.
00:28:48.957 --> 00:28:54.727
And that's where the problem
lies. It's as simple as that. And that's where the unfairness is.
00:28:56.540 --> 00:28:59.620
I think that that's a very, very good way to put it. Absolutely.
00:29:00.367 --> 00:29:04.820
You know, I mean, taxation is so prevalent now in how people do their financial
00:29:04.820 --> 00:29:06.422
planning, live their lives.
00:29:07.090 --> 00:29:11.860
I mean, it's almost as though, would you at least not disagree with the following
00:29:11.860 --> 00:29:16.270
statement, that taxation is the language of the 21st century?
00:29:18.101 --> 00:29:23.410
Certainly, I would say that a lot of my clients would say that, yes. Yeah, I'd agree.
00:29:24.177 --> 00:29:28.172
I think it's a big issue, yeah. It's a huge issue.
00:29:29.308 --> 00:29:33.385
And I mean, what would these advocacy groups do differently?
00:29:33.600 --> 00:29:37.088
I mean, do you think they would be better off if they were more unified?
00:29:37.088 --> 00:29:41.048
I mean, you know, they're all asking for different things and none of them wants
00:29:41.048 --> 00:29:46.028
to- We're not gonna unify the US tax system with 150 other countries around
00:29:46.028 --> 00:29:47.497
the world. So forget that.
00:29:47.979 --> 00:29:52.478
So the best that they can do, you know, that would help an American living abroad
00:29:52.478 --> 00:29:58.842
would say, okay, you're gonna be taxed as if you're a resident of another country, fine.
00:29:59.479 --> 00:30:04.098
You know, the UK overall has a higher rate, you know, and at the end of the
00:30:04.098 --> 00:30:06.840
day, you're going to wind up paying more tax over your lifetime.
00:30:07.090 --> 00:30:13.128
So, but do my clients who are Americans living here care about that? No, they don't.
00:30:13.488 --> 00:30:18.048
They just want to simplify their life and only be subject to tax,
00:30:18.048 --> 00:30:20.008
for example, in one jurisdiction.
00:30:20.338 --> 00:30:23.641
So, you know, hence they renounce. No, no, no.
00:30:24.834 --> 00:30:28.194
I mean, we agree that that's what's going on. We also agree that when they go
00:30:28.194 --> 00:30:31.584
and renounce, they don't say that. No.
00:30:32.854 --> 00:30:36.826
Okay. Do you, I'm just curious what your view would be. Do you think that,
00:30:37.469 --> 00:30:39.826
I mean, okay, let's break this down a little bit.
00:30:40.343 --> 00:30:43.715
Given that people pay higher taxes in the UK, right?
00:30:45.712 --> 00:30:50.024
Are there very many people living in the, Americans living in the UK who could
00:30:50.024 --> 00:30:53.503
possibly be renouncing to avoid paying US taxes?
00:30:55.114 --> 00:31:00.604
They're renouncing to avoid preparing U.S. taxes, not paying U.S.
00:31:00.604 --> 00:31:03.435
Taxes, preparing U.S. returns.
00:31:03.929 --> 00:31:05.214
Yeah, sure. I think that's right.
00:31:05.774 --> 00:31:11.250
And they're not the same thing. You know, I mean, the compliance is the issue
00:31:11.497 --> 00:31:16.286
and the complexity of the
compliance and the fear of getting something wrong.
00:31:17.146 --> 00:31:21.724
They're afraid of the penalties. That's right. No question about it.
00:31:21.724 --> 00:31:24.384
No, I mean, it's a terrible, terrible situation.
00:31:25.214 --> 00:31:29.933
Mm-hmm. So what do you think is going to happen in the election today, Diane?
00:31:31.000 --> 00:31:34.323
Not a bloody clue. Really not a clue.
00:31:35.407 --> 00:31:40.514
I don't know. You got a prediction? No. God, no. A blue wave?
00:31:43.134 --> 00:31:47.114
A red stop sign? I don't know. Well, I think that, you know,
00:31:47.514 --> 00:31:50.334
it depends on what you read, right? If you spend your time reading,
00:31:50.334 --> 00:31:54.754
as I do, I read the New York Times, including the New York Times.
00:31:55.294 --> 00:32:01.145
I read the New York Times and the Washington Post, and sometimes the LA Times.
00:32:03.247 --> 00:32:05.654
I'm from that part of the country, I think. I'm from that world,
00:32:05.654 --> 00:32:09.194
yeah. I read the Boston Globe for similar reasons.
00:32:11.925 --> 00:32:17.037
I mean, you would agree that the New York Times is fairly hostile to the Trump administration.
00:32:17.990 --> 00:32:25.654
They would appear that way, for the most part. They have a few op-ed pieces that are not so hostile.
00:32:26.725 --> 00:32:30.515
But by and large, you get the feeling they're not supportive of the administration.
00:32:32.123 --> 00:32:36.735
I would agree with that, yes. So, you know, you're exposed to that, right?
00:32:36.735 --> 00:32:40.365
You know, that particular echo chamber. burn it's easy to think oh my god you
00:32:40.365 --> 00:32:44.435
know you're going to get a huge anti anti uh are these republicans i don't like
00:32:44.435 --> 00:32:45.714
the republicans but you know,
00:32:46.785 --> 00:32:50.755
yes the administration what have you but if you read other stuff or you know
00:32:50.755 --> 00:32:52.546
i guess if you're a fox news junkie,
00:32:53.719 --> 00:32:56.273
you know you'd probably say it the other way so who knows,
00:32:57.562 --> 00:33:04.735
i have no idea yeah we'll find out in the morning when we wake up Maybe, maybe.
00:33:05.362 --> 00:33:09.832
When Trump was elected in 2016, I was actually in London.
00:33:10.465 --> 00:33:15.455
Were you? Yeah, and I fell asleep in my hotel room watching the television.
00:33:15.455 --> 00:33:20.165
I mean, I just fell asleep, right? And then I woke up, realized I'd fall asleep,
00:33:20.165 --> 00:33:21.494
and he'd won the election.
00:33:23.945 --> 00:33:30.484
It was completely surreal. Yeah. Okay, so no prediction on that. No prediction.
00:33:32.385 --> 00:33:36.464
I will come out and say I'm hoping for a blue wave, but no prediction.
00:33:38.849 --> 00:33:41.859
I think that what's going to be interesting is this, that even if there is a
00:33:41.859 --> 00:33:46.839
blue wave, I think that what they've been working on from the get-go is learning
00:33:46.839 --> 00:33:50.429
how to govern without Congress, right, you know, through these executive orders
00:33:50.429 --> 00:33:52.089
and this regulatory stuff.
00:33:52.409 --> 00:33:53.969
And he's going to continue to do that.
00:33:54.389 --> 00:33:58.139
Absolutely. In other words, I think this is warm, right, for,
00:33:58.139 --> 00:34:01.369
you know, how to— And whether they even take the oath of office,
00:34:01.369 --> 00:34:03.264
I'm not convinced come January.
00:34:04.778 --> 00:34:08.336
Yeah. So, I mean, we live in interesting times.
00:34:08.742 --> 00:34:13.406
Well, it's been a great discussion, as always. Thanks for joining me on this.
00:34:14.969 --> 00:34:18.966
Always lovely to hear your voice, to see your face. Okay.
00:34:19.758 --> 00:34:23.909
So, what's your final message to somebody listening to this?
00:34:24.549 --> 00:34:28.349
I mean, this is an important day. This is November 3rd, 2020.
00:34:28.349 --> 00:34:31.594
One of the most important days in probably in American history.
00:34:32.301 --> 00:34:37.569
You think so? Yeah, okay. Not as important as the day the income tax was enacted, but, you know.
00:34:40.049 --> 00:34:45.969
Or not the 4th of July in 1776. Well, the most important day for Americans abroad
00:34:45.969 --> 00:34:50.110
was October the 22nd, 2004.
00:34:51.055 --> 00:34:58.422
All right. You've got me stumped there, John. Oh, Diane, October 22nd, 2000.
00:34:58.654 --> 00:35:03.484
It was the day of the American Jobs Creation Act that included,
00:35:04.191 --> 00:35:08.017
one, the creation of the tax citizen.
00:35:08.644 --> 00:35:11.849
It was retroactive, by the way, back to June. Somebody sort of challenged it
00:35:11.849 --> 00:35:17.158
based on retroactivity. But also, the non-woolful F-bar penalty.
00:35:17.448 --> 00:35:21.719
That was when the opening of F-bar tickets began. So, you know,
00:35:21.719 --> 00:35:26.202
it's amazing. And I suspect very few people woke up that day and said,
00:35:26.850 --> 00:35:30.780
what is history for Americans abroad? Not a single one.
00:35:31.570 --> 00:35:38.641
No, I certainly didn't wake up that morning and say that. You didn't? Oh, I didn't. I didn't.
00:35:39.724 --> 00:35:46.054
Well, okay. Okay. So what's your message to all the Americans abroad struggling
00:35:46.054 --> 00:35:49.684
with their tax obligations? That's a big question to end with today,
00:35:49.684 --> 00:35:51.444
I think, isn't it? Stick with it.
00:35:51.924 --> 00:35:54.007
Stick with it and let's hope for a change.
00:35:54.658 --> 00:35:58.734
Okay. And actually, if you're sticking with it, not that this is the purpose
00:35:58.734 --> 00:36:02.034
of the podcast, but worth pointing out, you do this kind of work for people.
00:36:02.034 --> 00:36:03.165
You help them comply, right?
00:36:03.681 --> 00:36:08.830
I do. I help them comply and I help them relinquish their citizenship. We can do it all.
00:36:09.255 --> 00:36:12.644
Both sides for one stop all u.s.
00:36:13.384 --> 00:36:20.194
Problem solver exactly cool all right yeah i mean so who am i speaking with
00:36:20.194 --> 00:36:23.944
who's our one-stop citizenship solver would be diane gellan,
00:36:24.842 --> 00:36:32.098
diane gellan.com right diane at diane gellan.com is the email address no website,
00:36:32.683 --> 00:36:34.670
no website okay that's good.
00:36:36.524 --> 00:36:41.088
At d-i-a-n-e-g-e-l-o-n.com.
00:36:41.587 --> 00:36:47.228
Correct. All I have to do is put di in my email, and you immediately show up.
00:36:47.924 --> 00:36:54.780
Yeah, that's good. I put John in mine, and you immediately showed up, surprisingly.
00:36:55.192 --> 00:36:58.373
That's longevity. That's longevity. It is.
00:36:58.634 --> 00:37:03.562
It's been a long time. Well, it has been a long time. Yeah, absolutely.
00:37:04.015 --> 00:37:08.384
Well, okay, Diane, it'll be interesting to see what happens on all these fronts.
00:37:08.384 --> 00:37:12.804
And if you get some more information or insights, the most important question
00:37:12.804 --> 00:37:17.755
of the 21st century, meaning, namely, if an American renounces, can they get an ESTA?
00:37:19.084 --> 00:37:23.121
I am following up on that, and I will let you know as soon as I've got more info.
00:37:23.701 --> 00:37:28.269
So we can do the podcast, part two. We can do part two.
00:37:29.052 --> 00:37:35.333
All right. Sounds good. Okay, thanks very much. All right. Enjoy the rest of your day. Take care.