TRANSKRIP 🔗
Erin Rhoads: Alright everybody, are back at Murder Not Murdering with Erin and...
Autumn: Autumn.
Erin Rhoads: What's up y'all, let's talk about murders.
Autumn: We love murder.
Erin Rhoads: No, not murder, murdering, JK. That's our whole thing. We don't do the murdering. Although you should have heard the spicy conversation we were having right before this, so it might change your mind. Just FYI, customer service is a lot of testing patients. That's all I'm going to say about that.
Autumn: Emma G. It's true, true story, true story. That's an understatement.
Erin Rhoads: and anybody that works in customer service would absolutely understand that statement.
Autumn: Absolutely would.
Erin Rhoads: Yeah. Autumn, you sent me a TikTok the other day that has a interesting update. Do you want to share with our listeners?
Autumn: Yeah, yeah, I mean, I don't really know. Yeah, it's not really an update per se. I know. But at the same time, I mean, so it's the Kristen Smart case. They have subpoenaed the home of his mother, the man who has been convicted.
Erin Rhoads: I mean, it wasn't really in... There's movement.
Autumn: He's the convicted of her murder, but they've never found her body. And they have subpoenaed his mother's home for a search warrant. So to go inside and outside, and they've been digging for two days. I am curious what new evidence was presented for them to be able to go there and suspect that. So.
Erin Rhoads: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Well, here's the thing. They have to have enough evidence to warrant giving them a search warrant. So they have to have something new to suspect that she might be buried there or her body is somewhere in the vicinity of the home or inside the home, like in the basement or something. People have done that a million times, covered up with concrete or whatever. You know what I'm saying. So I mean, I've seen.
Autumn: Mm-hmm.
Erin Rhoads: when you sent that to me, had pictures of them like digging things up and searching the house and all of that. So, you know, it means that there's some movement, right? Whether we know if it's lateral movement or not, we don't know. But we will keep you posted.
Autumn: It's just so sad. And the guy just won't, he just keeps saying he's innocent and that's why he's not giving up her location. Bro, you've been convicted.
Erin Rhoads: That just drives me, yeah. It drives me crazy too when you know someone is the killer or maybe even they've confessed or they've been DNA tested or something and they still won't give that piece to the family. It just proves what monsters some people can be. You know what I mean?
Autumn: Absolutely. It's just heartbreaking. Let her family bring her home.
Erin Rhoads: Mm-hmm. For real. And if we do get more information on this, we will keep posting and letting you know and updating you on what we see as well. Because we know that if you listen to our podcast, most likely you've been following this story.
Autumn: And if our posts go missing on Instagram, that's
Load full transcript
because all of sudden they're taking down posts from our website.
Erin Rhoads: Yeah, so if any of our listeners work for Instagram, DM us. Because either somebody has been flagging us and flagging our posts. None of our posts are inappropriate. They always adhere to the guidelines. It did say we had one post that was talking about Ted Bundy. And they took that post down, I think, because it was a person who did harm.
Autumn: DM us. None.
Erin Rhoads: in their explanation. But that's ridiculous because we're not promoting a person that did harm. It's very odd.
Autumn: No, I mean, and they they took down a post about ⁓ just a bunch of things. They took down like four or five of our posts. I was like, OK, that's really interesting because.
Erin Rhoads: Yeah, so either somebody is out there reporting us, which can happen, or this is like a new thing in their algorithm, which I wouldn't be surprised because we all know Meta sucks. But it is also part of having a podcast. We've got to get the word out there to you all, and that seems to be the main platform that we can do that on. So if you're following us at Murder Not Murdering on Instagram,
Autumn: Yeah, which can happen. Yes. ⁓
Erin Rhoads: Like our posts because we don't know how long they'll be up for, I guess.
Autumn: Mm-hmm. Like, if they start disappearing, it's not us. It's not, I've been, I've appealed them and two of them have been brought back and I'm waiting on word on the other ones, so we'll see.
Erin Rhoads: It's not us. Yeah, we'll see. But anyway, that's our Instagram page. We post on there often about ⁓ any of our cases that we have ⁓ done lately. Another thing that I was going to tell you is a friend of mine who listens to this podcast I ran into at my Pilates class. And she had mentioned that she was just listening to our podcast. And one funny thing is she is the person that referred me to the Jake Bird Hex. ⁓ episode.
Autumn: ⁓ that was so long ago.
Erin Rhoads: It was so long ago, and it's super interesting. And ⁓ she actually sent me a picture of the actual house that still exists now where the murder took place. yeah. So if you want to go back in the archives, I recommend listening to that one because it is local, and it is interesting, and it's a horrific brutal ax murder. So if you feel into that, if that's your bag,
Autumn: ⁓ If that's your jam.
Erin Rhoads: then listen back to that case. It was just by chance that we ran into each other. So I thought I'd bring it up on the podcast. ⁓ yeah, check that one out. ⁓ I am doing a case this week that's pretty intense. And it's a little bit long because there's a lot of information. So I think I'm just going to jump right in if you're good with that.
Autumn: Yep, go for it.
Erin Rhoads: Okay, this is the Butcher Baker. Anchorage, Alaska in summer lingers so long it can start to feel unnatural. Midnight dim and blue instead black. The mountains stand silent against horizon. ⁓ and beyond the city limits stretches hundreds of miles
of wilderness, forests, rivers, bogs, frozen valleys, vast enough to swallow people whole. In the late 70s and early 80s, women began Some vanished from downtown Anchorage. Some were last seen getting into cars with strangers. Some were dancers. Some were sex workers. ⁓ Some were teenagers just trying to survive. One by one, they disappeared into the Alaskan dark. At first, the disappearances did not seem connected. then hunters started finding bodies, A shallow near Knick River. Human remains scattered in remote terrain. Women dumped so far into the wilderness, it took years to find them, if they were found at all. Police realized that They were hunting someone methodical, someone patient, someone who understood Alaska better than almost anyone else. This killer knew how to track his prey, how to move through the wilderness unnoticed, how to make people vanish. And all the while, this man lived quietly in Anchorage. He owned a bakery. He had a wife, children. Neighbors trusted him. Customers shook his hand every morning. His name ⁓ was Robert Hanson. And would eventually uncover one of the most horrifying murder cases in American history. But for years, no one knew exactly what was happening to the women who disappeared into the Alaskan wilderness. Tonight, we're going to talk about the victims, the investigation, and the failures that allowed the murders to continue, and the terrifying chain of events that finally exposed a killer hiding in plain sight. Robert Christian Hansen was born February 15th, 1939 in Esterville, Iowa. By nearly every account, he had a miserable childhood. He suffered from acne that scarred his face permanently. He had a pronounced stutter. He was painfully shy and other kids mocked him relentlessly. Teachers described him as isolated and awkward. And according to later reports, Hansen carried those humiliations with him for the rest of his life. His father, Danish immigrant, ran a bakery and reportedly ruled the household with strict discipline. Robert spent much of his youth working there. But there was one thing that made him feel powerful. Hunting. In the woods. He was no longer the awkward boy with a stutter. He was in control. He became obsessed with tracking animals, rifles, ⁓ wilderness survival, and stalking prey. These themes would later become horrifyingly important. In 1960, ⁓ his first major crime. He burned down a school bus garage in Iowa. Authorities believed it to be revenge against the people that he blamed for humiliating him in high school. He served about 20 months in prison. And during that incarceration, psychiatric evaluations reportedly described him as emotionally immature and consumed with resentment towards people who had wronged him. He also had schizophrenic tendencies and manic depression. After his release, Hanson married and eventually moved to Anchorage, Alaska in 1967. On the surface, He became exactly the kind of man no one suspects. The local baker. Neighbors liked him. He won hunting
competitions. He set records with a bow. He had children. Customers knew him as a hardworking, seemingly normal guy. But behind closed doors, the violence was escalating. 1971, Hanson was arrested twice. for abducting and attempting to rape a housewife. Now her name was not released. Then he was again for raping a sex worker. And this is where the story becomes deeply frustrating. The second charge was dropped during a plea deal, leading him to serve only six months of a five-year He was also arrested for larceny after trying to steal a chainsaw, and he was sentenced to five years in prison, but released for time served only two years later. Authorities after the fact realized that if Hanson had served the full time available to him, ⁓ For some of his earlier crimes, several women would still be alive. We know for a fact that at least three of his four convicted murders took place during the time that he would have been in prison had he served the full five years.
Autumn: That's frustrating.
Erin Rhoads: Yes. So back to where we are. Women are disappearing. One of the earliest suspect victims was 18-year-old Celia Van Zetten. She vanished in December 1971. Her body was later discovered in a remote area after she apparently escaped into the wilderness and froze to death. Hanson denied killing her, but investigators long suspected that he was responsible. And the disappearances continued. Young women, often vulnerable women, women who law enforcement at the time unfortunately categorized as disposable. Some were dancers at strip clubs. Some exchanged sex for money. Some were transients. Some were struggling with addiction. And because of that, their disappearances did not receive the urgency that they deserved. That failure is important to note. because predators notice who society ignores, and Robert Hanson had found his ideal prey. Over time, investigators started piecing together Hanson's methods, and it was the stuff of nightmares, everything we've been warned about now. He would approach women around Anchorage, often offering money in exchange for sex acts or to spend time with him. He was pretending to be harmless. Many women later said that Hansen did not seem intimidating at first glance. He was short, soft-spoken, awkward, and unimposing. But that appearance was camouflage. Once he isolated a victim, he would pull a gun on them. And Hansen himself chillingly said, and excuse the poor grammar, it was his, not mine, I says, If you do exactly what I tell you and don't give me any problem whatsoever, there's going to be no. No, you won't get hurt in any way, shape or form." Hanson told troopers, according to news accounts at the time, he was a monster trying to set them at ease. Then he often drove the women to his home where he would rape and torture them. And this is the part that became infamous. He would then transport victims to the Alaskan wilderness using his small plane. Some investigators believed that Hansen viewed these women as actual prey. He hunted moose, he hunted bears, and eventually he hunted women. Bodies later recovered in remote areas show gunshot wounds, shallow graves, and signs of terror. Many victims were found near the Kinnick River area. and surrounding wilderness. Some of these victims were never recovered at all. Authorities would later say that Hansen admitted to at least 17 murders, though investigators suspect the real number may have been much higher. And all the while, he kept baking bread every morning, playing husband and father, and being part of a community.
Autumn: Just so disturbing.
Erin Rhoads: It is. And here's where the story begins to turn. And this bastard is going to make a mistake. It's June 13th, 1983. 17-year-old Cindy Paulson was in Anchorage when Robert Hanson approached her. for oral sex. $200. She got into the car. And almost immediately, Hanson pulled a gun on her. Cindy later described trying to resist. She said, he had handcuffed one of my hands and I was trying to get loose, but he pulled out a gun and then he got my other hand cuffed. I don't know how he did it. It was frightening because I didn't really, I fought, but not a lot because I knew he would do something. She knew he wanted to hurt her and hurt her badly. He drove her to his house in Anchorage. Inside, he raped her. He sexually assaulted and tortured her for hours. He also put a chain around her neck and fastened it to a post in his basement. Having spent hours and hours trapped in the serial killer's home, Cindy was so smart because she took note of every detail that she could remember, including the bars that were on the windows. bullet holes she saw in the floor. And she said, then about five hours later, he woke up and came over. And I told him, all I want to do is go home because I live with my mom and I won't tell nobody. She said this to Sergeant Glenn Floth, the Alaska State Trooper leading the investigation. Cindy is a teenager in a stranger's house chained by her neck in a basement in handcuff, knowing no one knows where she is. At one point, Hansen reportedly asleep on a nearby couch. ⁓ Cindy understood something horrifying. He was not done with her yet. This was only the beginning. Later before dawn, Hanson loaded Cindy into his car again. He said that he had a plane over at Merrill that we go there. He would take me to his cabin and bring me back. And I knew I wasn't going to come back. After some hours in the home, Hanson did show Cindy his large collection of hunting trophies. He originally told her that his name was Don, but she could easily read his name listed on these awards. She said this was the moment she realized he was going to kill her because now she knew his true identity. And her only option would be to attempt an escape. They left around 5 a.m. Her wrists were handcuffed in front of her body. He drove towards the airport. There sat his small Piper Super Cub plane. Hanson parked, got out of the car, and told the still handcuffed Cindy
Paulson not to move or else he was going to kill her. After Hanson left the car to fuel and load his plane, Cindy threw her body into the driver's seat and managed to open the door. Wearing no shoes and still handcuffed, the teen street. ⁓ Hanson turned around just in time to see her escaping. He ran after her, yelling at her to return. But Cindy just kept running. She knew her life depended on it. And she successfully ran to Sixth Avenue. ⁓ a truck just happened to be coming by and saw her in distress. She asked the driver, named Robert Yont. to take her to a nearby motel where her boyfriend was staying. And thank God he stopped, because his decision not to just pass by or not to get involved changed the course of this entire case. Like I said, Cindy was smart, remembering all the details. And she later told police that she left her blue sneakers on the passenger floor door of the backseat. so that there would be evidence that she had been inside the car. I mean, that's some good thinking. Still at the airfield, Robert Hanson made his way back to the car and quickly sped off. However, an observant security guard took notice of his strange behavior and wrote down his license plate and car model. Back at the motel, Cindy, still in handcuffs,
Autumn: That's, yeah, that is.
Erin Rhoads: got a hold of her boyfriend over the phone at the front desk. Soon after, a motel employee called the Anchorage Police Department. Investigators later concluded that Hanson frequently flew victims to isolated areas before murdering them. And suddenly, for the first time in years, ⁓ had something concrete. A witness. A survivor. ⁓ name. When police interviewed Cindy, she provided a highly detailed account of her horrific ordeal, including information about Hanson's car, the interior of his home, the street that his property was on, and even details about the gun that the serial killer threatened her with. Less than an hour later after Cindy escaped him, the teenager was in a police car headed for the hospital, standard protocol for a victim of sexual assault. While en route to the hospital, they drove past the same airfield she had just run away from. She remembered area the airport she had been taken to and what Hanson's plane looked like. So Cindy Paulson then asked the officer to stop so she could lead him precisely to where Robert Hanson's blue and white plane was still parked. Noticing the scene taking place, that same security guard who wrote down Hanson's license plate flagged down the officers and shared his information. With the details about Hanson's car and the plane's registration, Anchorage police contacted the Federal Aviation Administration for final confirmation. As officers pulled into the hospital with Cindy, they received a call that the registration for both the car and plane matched. Anchorage local Robert C. Hansen. Even after Cindy had identified him, investigators initially struggled. Hanson, when questioned by investigators, denied Cindy's accusation, because of course he did, stating that she was just trying to cause trouble for him because he refused to pay her extortion demands. This excuse apparently had been something that he has used on several occasions.
Autumn: Mm-hmm.
Erin Rhoads: he had prior run-ins with the law. Hanson's meek demeanor and occupation as a baker along with an alibi from his friend John Henning persuaded police not to consider him a serious suspect. Because Robert Hanson did not fit their mental image of a serial killer, he was married, he owned a business, he had no outward appearance of being a monster. Some officers doubted Cindy because she was a teenage sex worker. And this part of the story is deeply important. Had police completely dismissed her to ⁓ marginalized women that he may have continued killing for years. ⁓ But one investigator began seeing the larger picture. Detective Glenn Floth worked with the FBI profiler, famous by way, John Douglas, who you might know recognize that name. He was one of the early criminal profilers later associated with the Science Unit. Douglas reportedly developed a profile describing him as a socially awkward hunter with low self-esteem who would target sex workers and flew victims into the wilderness. This matched Hanson perfectly. It had been four months or so after Cindy's assault and kidnapping when when Robert Hanson was finally arrested for his 12 year long serial killing spree. Police obtained search warrants and what they found inside Hanson's home was devastating. Jewelry belonging to victims. ⁓ weapons and perhaps most chilling of all an aeronautical chart. covered in little X marks. hidden behind Hanson's headboard. Many of these little marks matched sites where bodies had been found. When investigators told Hanson that they had seized his map marked with 17 locations and spots that they believed indicated the locations of bodies, Frank Rothschild, the ⁓ He was mild-mannered Bob the Baker. as I'm looking at him, all of a sudden, he transformed. The hair on the back of his neck stood up. His neck got red, and he was pissed. I can still see him when he got livid like that. Hanson then asked to speak to his attorneys went into another room. But Rothschild recalled. you could hear him screaming at his lawyers. He didn't see his victims as human. In his mind, there were good girls and there were bad girls. Initially, Hanson denied everything. But eventually confronted with the stacks of evidence and testimony, he began talking. As part of a plea deal, which makes me so mad, but I understand why they have to do it. As part of a plea deal, Hanson confessed to multiple murders and guided investigators to burial locations. attacks against women starting in 1971. He ultimately admitted to 17 killings. His earliest victims were girls or young women, usually between the ages of 16 and 19 years old. The full range, though, was 16 to 41 years old. Although based on evidence, law enforcement suspect that Robert Hanson
killed at least 21 female victims. The following is a list of confirmed victims and several other additional women who have been mentioned as possible victims. Of these 18 women, Hanson was only formally charged with the murders of four of them. Sherry Morrow, Joanna Messina.
Autumn: ⁓
Erin Rhoads: Eklutna Annie and Paula Goulding. He was also charged with the abduction and rape of Cindy Paulson. So it's those four women, the attempt on Cindy Paulson, Watson, Angela Federn, Tammy Peterson, ⁓ Luna, Malai Larson, Lisa Futrell, Robin Pelkey. And she was an important one because she was known as Horseshoe Harriet before she was found DNA. Delin Sugar Frey. Andrea Altieri, Roxanne Eastland, Mary Thill, Megan Emerick, Celia Van Zetten, and that is just the beginning of the list. Those are the ones that they were fairly certain they could prove. Some of the bodies were recovered and others were never found. Some families never even knew what happened to their daughters until years later. And perhaps the most heartbreaking reality of all of this, is that several victims were never reported missing. That is how isolated and vulnerable many of these women were. There's always a danger in serial killer stories that the murderer becomes the center of gravity. But Robert Hanson's victims were not props in his narrative. They were women trying to survive, and many of them failed repeatedly by systems that deemed them less worthy of protection. In that pattern, we see again and again in serial murder cases. Victims living on society's margins disappear, and people shrug, police delay, and predators continue. The Hansen case is one of the most clearest examples of that, because for years, bodies were literally being found in the wilderness while women from Anchorage streets just kept vanishing one after another. And still, the alarm bells didn't fully ring until Cindy escaped him. In 1984, Robert Hanson pleaded guilty to the four murders along with the kidnapping and rape of Cindy Paulson. He received 461 years in prison without the chance of parole. He spent the remainder of his life incarcerated in Alaska. Following his capture, Hanson's second wife and two children left Anchorage permanently and moved to Arkansas. The children's names have never been publicized and they live in anonymity. and good for them. Hanson served time briefly at Lemon Creek Correctional Center in Juneau until authorities found escape plans stashed among his belongings. Literally the makings of a bomb and like tons of escape routes. It was extensive. So they sent him to Seward. Officials said at the time that he had spent many of his final years of his life working as a jailhouse barber.
Autumn: Nice, nice.
Erin Rhoads: And in 2014, Hanson died in prison at the age of 75. One Alaska state trooper reportedly said afterward that the world was better without him. And I'd have to agree. But the final word in this story to Cindy Paulson because survivor stories matter, especially in true crime when we don't get them very often. Cindy was 17 years old, handcuffed, terrified, barefoot, and she still found the will to run. Her testimony shattered the illusion surrounding Robert Hanson, and without her, investigators may have never connected the disappearances. Without her, more women most certainly would have died. And because she survived, families got answers. Cindy's story was so powerful that it became the centerpiece for a star-studded movie in 2013 called The Frozen Ground. starring Vanessa Hudgens, John Cusack, and Nicolas Cage. Despite her troubled beginnings, Cindy's bravery turned her into a pivotal figure in one of Alaska's darkest criminal cases. Her story has since been told through documentaries, Today, ⁓ many search Cindy Paulson, Alaska and what happened to Cindy Paulson only find her resilience. ⁓ she remains an enduring reminder of strength the face of unimaginable danger. Frank Rothschild, the assistant district attorney who tried Hanson's case said, I would have wished every breath he took had an element of pain to it. But here's how I thought about it. Here's a guy whose passion in life was going out into the wilderness and hunting, the great Alaska wild. Instead of being able to do that, he was put in a cell with no view of anything. Forget the mountains, with rancid air and horrific people around him. That, to me, is the supreme punishment. He will not be missed. Good riddance to him. My sources were Wikipedia Robert Hanson, blurred bylines, how Cindy Paulson escaped serial killer Robert Hanson, People Magazine, how serial killer Robert Hanson was caught, Anchorage Daily News, serial killer Hanson dead, world better without him. Agreed. Digital Press.
Autumn: Ha.
Erin Rhoads: Cindy Paulson and Robert Hanson, Mindhunter by John Douglas, the famous FBI guy who started the behavioral unit, Alaska Bureau of Investigation cold case releases. ⁓ And that's it. That's my list.
Autumn: That's a terrifying story.
Erin Rhoads: It's an awful one, and it's a serial killer. I haven't done one of those in a minute. No, what they think is that he would take them up there after they were horribly mistreated, and then would set them free in the woods and hunt them down. And that one girl escaped him, but she froze to death because it was too cold out. I mean, just awful. And thank God for Cindy.
Autumn: I mean being hunted? That alone is... It's so crazy. It's so crazy.
Erin Rhoads: and that she went to the authorities and told them what happened. It sucks that they didn't fully believe her in the beginning, but eventually there was some level of justice.
Autumn: Some level, yes. ⁓ Fucking understatement.
Erin Rhoads: He was a monster. The fact that this man looked at people every day in the eye, baking his bread, playing with his children. I mean, it's disgusting. All the meanwhile, he raped and tortured at least 17 women, which he confessed to, but they know it's far more than that.
Autumn: 1000 % So gross.
Erin Rhoads: That
was a little departure from what I usually do. But I think it's an important case and I think it's important to make sure that we say the names of the victims ⁓ and hopefully that means that people understand that there's only so long that you can get away with shit. Especially now that we have DNA and all the rest of it. Because technology will fucking catch you.
Autumn: Yeah. I hope it catches all these old crotchety men who thought that they would be getting away with crimes for the rest of their lives.
Erin Rhoads: For real. And the thing that makes me frustrated, too, is that because of the remote locations of where the bodies were left or hunted or dropped, we will never find those bodies. Whether it's been decay or animals were out there and all of that, or just so remote that you couldn't find them, it's just really unfortunate there are still people out there that don't have a definitive answer. And that's really sad. But again, he should...
Autumn: Mm-hmm. I agree.
Erin Rhoads: Some of the people weren't even listed as missing because they lived lifestyles that, you know, the cops deemed as, not worthy ⁓ paying attention to.
Autumn: So, so fucked up.
Erin Rhoads: Yeah. Anyway, Autumn, what's your case this week?
Autumn: Wouldn't you like to know? So... No, not at all actually. Never is over here on this side, but this one is the girl who never made it to the store.
Erin Rhoads: A real pick me up. I didn't think so.
Autumn: gonna make you.
Erin Rhoads: Yeah.
Autumn: But hopefully something comes of it. So let's get into it here.
Erin Rhoads: I'm ready.
Autumn: It was supposed to be a normal Tuesday night, the kind of winter night that settles over a neighborhood. Porch lights glowing against damp pavement, televisions humming through thin walls, parents trying to keep children occupied while dinner dishes sit in sinks and people move through routines they've repeated a thousand times before. In the east side of Kennewick, Washington, four-year-old Sofia Juarez was excited for the next day because February 5th, 2003 was her birthday. She was about to turn five years old and somewhere inside that little house on East 15th Avenue, Sofia probably had all the kinds of thoughts children have the night before a birthday. Maybe she wondered what presents she might get. Maybe she was thinking about her cake or candles or seeing family members. Maybe she simply felt that restless excitement that makes it hard for children to sit still when something special is coming. But Sofia Juarez never made it to her fifth birthday. Instead, she vanished into the cold February darkness only blocks from home. And more than two decades later, nobody knows exactly what happened to her. This is one of the most haunting missing child cases in Washington state history. And even now, after thousands of tips, hundreds of searches, national media attention, and a case file more than 20,000 pages long, Sophia's story remains unfinished. Sofia Juarez was born on February 5th, 1998. She lived with a large extended family on the 100 block of East 15th Avenue in Kennewick. The home was crowded and busy, filled with relatives, children, conversations, movement, and constant activity. Sofia lived there with her mother, Maria Juarez, her grandmother, Ignacia Prado, Juarez, her grandmother's boyfriend, Jose Lopez Torres, and several aunts and uncles. The family had roots in Mexico, and Spanish was commonly spoken in the home. At the time Sophia disappeared, her mother Maria was only 20 years old herself. Sophia's biological father, Andre Gutierrez Abrahan, was not involved in her life. Reports say he denied paternity and had no relationship with Sophia or the family. Investigators would later look closely at him, like they did everyone connected to Sophia. But he was quickly ruled out after providing a verified alibi. people described they described a little girl who stood out immediately. She had dark hair and brown eyes. She had pierced ears and small gold hoop earrings she liked to wear. She had a mole beneath one eye and a birthmark on her lower back. She was missing her four upper front teeth, the kind of detail that instantly makes you picture a child smiling. At four years old, She stood about three feet tall and weighed only 33 pounds. She was tiny. So tiny that when you imagine her walking alone at night through a dark neighborhood in February, it immediately brings chills. And maybe that's part of why this case hit the community as hard as it did. Because almost immediately, investigators believed This was not a child who had simply wandered off. Something about the circumstances felt deeply alarming from the very beginning. February 4th, 2003, Tuesday night, just after 8 p.m. The weather outside hovered around 36 degrees. Cold enough that adults wore jackets. Cold enough that your breath would fog in the air. Inside the Juarez home, Sofia was playing with some of her younger uncles while adults moved in and out of rooms nearby. Jose Lopez Torres, the boyfriend of Sophia's grandmother, was preparing to walk to a nearby convenience store. Before leaving, he casually asked the children if they wanted to come with him. Nobody seemed interested, at least at first. Torres eventually left the house alone. But according to investigators, Sophia changed her mind at the last second. And this tiny detail, this one tiny miscommunication would become the center point of the entire case because Torres apparently never realized Sofia intended to follow him. Around the same time, Sofia reportedly asked her mother for a dollar to spend at the store. Maria Juarez later said she watched Sofia leave the room and heard the front door close. that moment, hearing the door shut, became the last confirmed moment anyone knows for certain that Sofia was alive.
Erin Rhoads: That just breaks my heart. Every detail of this is killing me. Just the thought of her and so young and it's awful.
Autumn: It's... It's... that it's her
frickin' birthday the next day. She stepped out into the February night wearing a red long sleeve shirt, blue overalls, violet socks, white Converse sneakers, and gold hoop earrings. No coat, no gloves, nothing heavy enough for the weather. She thought she was just heading to the store, and the store was only a few blocks away. But Sophia never arrived there. This is the part of the case that feels especially haunting because the distance was so short. If you look at Max of the neighborhood today, you realize how close everything was. Sophia should have reached the convenience store quickly. It wasn't some isolated highway stop or rural location miles away. It was a neighborhood route. A child trying to catch up to someone she knew. Meanwhile, Jose Lopez Torres reached the store and carried on normally. Surveillance footage later confirmed his timeline. He bought milk. He used a pay phone to call relatives in Mexico. Then he headed home. At approximately 9.45 p.m., he returned to the house. And that's when the horrifying misunderstanding became clear. Sofia had left to follow him. but he had never seen her. Maria and Jose immediately began searching for the child. Then at 9.53 p.m., police were called. And from the moment officers arrived, the atmosphere surrounding the case was different. Police reached the house within minutes and almost immediately investigators began noticing things that made this case feel more serious than a simple missing child report. It was nighttime. The temperature was near freezing. Sophia was only four years old. And despite rapid searches of the immediate area, there was no sign of her. No crying child hiding nearby. no footprints, no indication she had wandered into a neighbor's yard or gotten lost. The response escalated incredibly fast. Within an hour, the FBI had been contacted. Washington State issued its very first AMBER alert for Sofia Juarez. Mm-hmm. So it's the first AMBER alert ever issued in Washington State.
Erin Rhoads: way.
Autumn: That alone tells you how alarming authorities considered the situation from the very beginning. teams flooded the area. Police officers and volunteers searched parks, playgrounds, fields, vacant lots, ⁓ ⁓ garbage containers, drainage areas, ⁓ nearby businesses. ⁓ Night vision devices and thermal imaging equipment were used. Helicopters searched from above while boats searched waterways nearby. At one point, the search radius expanded to three miles around Sophia's neighborhood. Over the following days, more than 500 people became involved in the search effort. The Coast Guard searched rivers. Dive teams entered waterways. Cadaver dogs and scent dogs were deployed. City sewer systems were checked. Flyers with Sophia's photographs spread across Washington and beyond. And yet, nothing. No confirmed sightings, no physical evidence publicly identified. No trace of what happened to the little girl who simply walked out the front door trying to reach a convenience store. Cases involving children affect communities differently, especially when there are no answers. In Kennewick, people became consumed by Sophia's disappearance. A candlelight vigil was held one week later. Nearly 300 people marched from the Juarez home to St. Joseph's Catholic Church, carrying candles through the February cold. People prayed. People cried. people hoped. And one of the hardest parts of cases like this is the emotional whiplash families experience in those early days. At first, there's adrenaline. You believe someone will find the child any minute. You think maybe she wandered into a house. Maybe someone picked her up trying to help. Maybe she'll suddenly reappear. But as days pass, the silence becomes terrifying. and investigators began leaning heavily toward one conclusion. Sophia had likely been abducted. Over the years, investigators looked at countless possibilities. Family members were scrutinized. Friends were scrutinized. Known offenders were scrutinized. More than 150 sex offenders in and around Kennewick were investigated or researched for possible connections. Hundreds of tips poured in. In total, authorities would eventually examine more than 800 leads. Homes and vehicles were searched under warrants. Telephone records were analyzed. The FBI utilized major case management systems to organize information. And despite all of that effort, no arrests were ever made. At one point, police searched homes connected to a man named Jeremy Vargas Sagastuia. Their searches drew public attention, especially after relatives claimed police were pressuring them during questioning. But ultimately, no charges related to Sofia's disappearance came from those searches. Another man drew suspicion after making disturbing sexually explicit comments about Sofia during a phone call with a stranger. Disgusting. Police searched his residence as well.
Erin Rhoads: That's disgusting.
Autumn: Eventually, investigators determined he was unrelated to Sofia's disappearance, though he was charged separately with telephone harassment.
Erin Rhoads: Jesus.
Autumn: And then there were the rumors. Theories spread constantly through the years. One persistent rumor claims Sophia had been accidentally struck by people involved with drugs, then secretly removed from the scene and buried elsewhere. Investigators reportedly received more than 200 tips connected to variations of that theory. Different names, different vehicles, different alleged burial sites. but nothing ever conclusively tied any of those stories to Sofia. For many years, the public knew very little about possible suspects. Then, in 2021, investigators released one of the most unsettling developments in the entire case. A witness had apparently seen a Hispanic juvenile male, estimated to be between 11 and 14 years old at the time, interacting with Sofia shortly before she vanished. According to police, the witness described the boy leading Sofia toward a van while she cried. And somehow, the detail that
he was reportedly laughing while she cried makes the entire image feel even darker.
Erin Rhoads: That's awful and creepy. Yeah.
Autumn: and super disturbing. Police believe the boy and the van were connected to the abduction, but authorities have never publicly identified the individual. And that revelation opened another horrifying possibility. If the witness account is accurate, Sophia may not have been taken by an adult acting alone. Instead, another child or young teenager may have played a role in luring her away. One detail investigators repeatedly returned to was Sophia's personality. Her mother insisted Sophia was shy, not the kind of child who would willingly leave with a stranger. Maria believed Sophia would only have gone with someone she recognized or trusted, and that changes the emotional landscape of the case entirely. Because if that's true, then Sophia may have known the person who approached her. Or maybe she initially believed she was safe. Maybe she thought someone was helping her get to the store. Maybe someone used familiarity, friendliness, or another child to lower her guard. There are so many possibilities. And after 23 years, those unanswered possibilities become part of what makes the case so emotionally exhausting. because investigators still cannot definitively answer one question. Did Sophia die that night or did she survive? One of the most surprising aspects of this case is that some investigators publicly stated they believe Sophia might still be alive.
Erin Rhoads: I think a lot of people had that theory that she was still alive. know, just maybe a kidnapping and being that she was so young. You know what I mean? It's one of those things where she could have been told a story and then lived her whole life. You know what I mean?
Autumn: Mm-hmm. She's so young, four. She's only four. Mm-hmm and lived her whole life. I mean, she's so young even someone could have approached her Maybe they saw her crying like that and they were like your mom died You know, you have to come with us. You like your grandma's gone to like she doesn't know she's little Mm-hmm. And and I mean Maybe someone just really wanted a kid like as fucked up as that is and how to do it. I mean, there's some really
Erin Rhoads: Yeah, absolutely. And we've seen that tactic before. How many times have we seen people kidnap babies all the time, unfortunately?
Autumn: messed up situations like that. Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. There's one story that haunts me to this day that this woman gave birth to her child and she was with her sister-in-laws and they were leaving to get a taxi to go home. This was like back in the like early 80s and they got car jacked like
Erin Rhoads: I think I know this one.
Autumn: in the parking lot and they stole the baby and they never found the baby. Isn't that terrifying? Like, yes! It's horrible.
Erin Rhoads: Yep. Yeah. It's horrifying. There's also been lots of those ones of nurses kidnapping babies and things like that. It's just fucking awful. This is why I always struggle with children cases. It's just so awful. And they're so young.
Autumn: It's devastating. So young and innocent. Innocent. In 2011, Detective Randy Maynard said his instinct was that Sophia was alive, explaining that if she had died shortly after the abduction, he believed her remains likely would have been found. Other investigators were more cautious. One detective later admitted that he had no evidence proving she was alive, but also no evidence proving she was dead. And when there's no body, no confession, and no physical resolution, a case can exist in this terrible emotional limbo forever. Over the years, age-progress images of Sofia were released repeatedly by National Center for Missing and Exploited Children. People compared faces constantly. Tips came in from across the country. At one point, investigators even looked into a teenager in California named Sofia Juarez. after someone claimed she resembled the missing child. That lead went nowhere. Then in 2021, another viral moment reignited hope. A TikTok video featuring a young woman who resembled Sophia's age progression spread rapidly online. Police investigated that lead too. Again, it was not Sophia.
Erin Rhoads: They went as far as a DNA test. mean, that's how close this girl did look a lot like her. Exactly. I mean, you have to follow those up because you just never know.
Autumn: Mm-hmm. right the age progression and her they look so similar. You just never know, for sure.
Erin Rhoads: You never know. And in this digital age that we have where people have access to things like that, I mean, we see it all the time on TikTok, especially where people will go, do you think this person looks like so and so? And then it just starts going around and things like that. But it's well worth investigating.
Autumn: see that with like Madeleine McCann
Erin Rhoads: all the time. There's loads of people that I've seen that are like, this person could be, you know.
Autumn: Mm-hmm. And every false lead creates another emotional rise and collapse for the people who still carry this case with them. And this part's gonna make you very sad too.
Erin Rhoads: ⁓ her poor family.
Autumn: There's another heartbreaking layer to this story that often gets overshadowed by the investigation itself. Sophia's mother never got answers. After years of living under the weight of her daughter's disappearance, Maria Juarez eventually moved to California. In 2008, she had another child. But according to a family member, she never stopped hoping Sophia would come home. Then in January of 2009, Maria died from medical complications. She was only in her 20s. Nearly six years after Sophia disappeared, her mother died without knowing what happened to her little girl. And after Maria's death, her funeral procession,
Erin Rhoads: is just so sad.
Autumn: followed the exact same route as the candlelight vigil held for Sophia six years earlier. From East 15th Avenue to St. Joseph's
Church. That image is devastating. A mother searching emotionally for her child until the very end of her own life.
Erin Rhoads: It's just heartbreaking.
Autumn: I can't. I cannot. Poor little baby.
Erin Rhoads: I know. Well, I mean, we don't know, right? She could still be alive.
Autumn: This is true. As of 2026, the disappearance of Sofia Juarez remains unsolved. Investigators continue reviewing leads. The case file reportedly exceeds 20,000 pages. DNA profiles remain in national databases, and Kennewick police still publicly state they believe somebody knows what happened. In 2021, authorities launched renewed investigative efforts and created a dedicated website focused entirely on Sophia's case. Even after all these years, her photograph still appears at fairs, on awareness campaigns, on billboards, and even on semi trucks traveling across the Pacific Northwest. because people in Kennewick never will fully let her go. And maybe part of that is because of how quickly she disappeared. One moment, she was inside a crowded family home preparing for her birthday. Minutes later, she was gone. No screams, anyone remembering hearing anything, no confirmed abductor seen clearly, no explanation. Just a four-year-old little girl trying to follow someone to the store and then darkness. There's something especially painful about cases frozen in time. Sophia wasn't running away. She wasn't in danger in the way adults usually imagine danger. She was simply trying to catch up. That's it. A child following behind someone she trusted. on what should have been one of the happiest nights of her year. And somehow, in a span of only a few blocks, she vanished from the world. Today, Sofia Juarez would be an adult woman in her late 20s. She may look completely different now. She may not even know who she is. Or somewhere. somebody may still be carrying the secret of what happened on that cold February night in 2003. Either way, Sophia deserves an answer. And after more than two decades, the people who love her still deserve the truth. If you have any information, Regarding the disappearance of Sofia Juarez, authorities continue to encourage tips through the Kennewick Police Department or the National Center for Missing and Exploited Children. My sources were Wikipedia, Como 4, King 5, Seattle Times, Tri-City Herald, Seattle PI, CNN, Yakima Herald, and the Kennewick Police Department interviews.
Erin Rhoads: And we will post on our Instagram page the age-progressed photos as well, just so that you know. ⁓ That is a really, really sad case, and all I can do is hold out some hope that maybe someone did kidnap her and raise her, and that she's living somewhere just unaware of everything. hopefully, at some point, she's going to see a picture or something, or from a podcast, or...
Autumn: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Anything. And be like, hey, that kind of looks like me.
Erin Rhoads: an article or something. Exactly, and then look into it. You just never know. I mean, we've had a string of women lately, especially, that have been found later in life. There was a woman just the other day that was found 40 years later. So it's just kind of crazy that there are people that were kidnapped young, and they are found. So I'm hoping for her family. mean, felt so fucking sad about her mom.
Autumn: Mm-hmm. You never know. Mm-hmm. ⁓ Mm-hmm. Yeah. I mean, I have to say, like, I'm never going to shame, parent shame or whatever, but I mean, she was four fucking years old. How, I mean, I understand that they were gonna... I know, but I mean, I, I just, it's just like, I know, but I mean, she did know, she knew she was leaving. I would have, I just would have wanted to see my eyes connect with...
Erin Rhoads: Kids can get away really fast though. You know what I mean? Trust me, they can be really fast or sneaky. You just never know. Yeah.
Autumn: Her basically grandpa, you know? Like, I would just want for my sanity to see her connect with him. I mean, she was four years old. I'm crazy. A helicopter.
Erin Rhoads: Yeah. Sure. Yeah. But also you might trust the scenario, right? I mean, I don't think that any blame can be placed on her mom in that way.
Autumn: No, I'm not trying to blame or parent shame. I'm just... Please, like, a four-year-old? I mean... That is just so heartbreaking.
Erin Rhoads: It is heartbreaking. all we can do is hold out hope for her family that if anything that they get answers, whether it's good news or bad news, some resolution. Because these kind of cases sit with you. And they stick with you. And you want to know definitively one way or another, at least so that they can have a funeral or they can celebrate a return. You just never know.
Autumn: Mm-hmm. Forever.
Erin Rhoads: And like I said, we will be posting about this on our Instagram page. So do check that out in case you never know. She might be living your next door neighbor. Maybe you are. Who knows? If you don't know your full backstory or just look at the pictures, you just never know. You know what I'm saying?
Autumn: Maybe you're Sofia. Maybe you're Sofia. Yeah, look at the picture. You might, if you love gold hoop earrings and you have a mole under your eye, maybe you're Sophia.
Erin Rhoads: Perhaps. Who knows? Who knows? So do check that out. We will be back next week. out on Mondays. ⁓ And we will back again bringing you two brand new cases. ⁓ And ⁓ I want say thank you for listening. We appreciate you all so much. ⁓ And ⁓ yeah, be again next week. Bye.
Autumn: Bye.