TRANSKRIP 🔗
[0:01] Welcome to courtroom quarterback the experiences and thoughts of a court martial defense attorney
[0:07] Hey, everyone welcome back to an all-new episode of courtroom quarterback the experiences and thoughts of a court martial defense attorney
[0:15] With Joseph Jordan. I am your host Mike Leon Joseph here is the founder of the Jordan UCMJ law group and a former army Jag and Worldwide
[0:24] Court martial defense attorney who's tried more than
[0:27] 240 court marshals to verdict and he's handled thousands of military cases all across not only here in the U.S
[0:32] But the Middle East the Pacific Europe and beyond today's episode we're going to be talking about closing arguments, right?
[0:39] One of the most important things in a trial at Joseph's got to explain
[0:42] But the moment when everything that's happened in the courtroom either comes together or it falls apart
[0:49] Joseph, it's good to see you as always my friend. All right, so now we've reached closing arguments
[0:54] The panel has already kind of lived with this case for days. It's been in their ethos, right?
[0:59] What are you what are you kind of a paying attention to as you as you stand up to kind of give that closing argument and and what does that tell you before you even say a word?
[1:07] Well, you don't really pay attention to much because the cards are in so you're closing arguments prepared
[1:14] So you're listening to the government council's argument to hear you know, is there anything in particular?
[1:20] I want to exploit otherwise
[1:23] You already know what you're going to say and you want to keep it in line with what the panel is heard
[1:28] You don't come in there with smoking mirrors you come in there
[1:31] You argue the hard cold facts and explain them in a manner that makes sense to the panel and get your point across
[1:42] behalf of your client. Well speaking on that front because obviously the closing statement
[1:46] It's the finality of the trial most and so you don't really want to introduce anything new
[1:50] How are you choosing which parts of the trial you kind of want to harp on you want to bring back which ones you kind of want to leave out?
[1:57] When I look at closing arguments a first start with
[2:00] What the jury instructions are going to be but the panel is going to receive from the judge and then I start looking at
[2:08] What are the indisputable facts of the case as presented and
[2:14] Once I define what the indisputable facts are now we start to look at the points of contention and
[2:20] From there you're looking at motives you're looking at bias
[2:24] I want to say motives. I'm looking you know in a domestic violence case or a sex assault case
[2:31] Or murder case you're looking at motives to fabricate motives to lie
[2:37] And then you also want to focus on what everybody forgets in my business, which is common sense
[2:44] What is the common sense factor here?
[2:46] What I find in ports is that the
[2:51] reasonable person wins
[2:54] In the courtroom. So when you're in the closing arguments, let me just follow up on that like at that stage
[3:00] What are you really trying to confirm versus persuade the panel to to agree with you on? Sure
[3:07] what are the facts in dispute and
[3:12] Confirming those facts in dispute in such a way that they're tied to facts that are not in dispute
[3:20] So you really want to bring through the common sense factor for what people live
[3:29] each and every day. What do they know in their own minds to be true?
[3:33] You know, why do people lie? What are the different motives that people might lie?
[3:38] And just kind of like general things that everybody experiences each and every day
[3:45] And just tying that to the point that you're trying to make as you advocate for your client
[3:50] You know to that end you and I've talked about this in previous episodes about emotion and you've mentioned before how you know
[3:56] You get right to it. You get a little blunt sometimes in the courtroom
[3:59] Other lawyers maybe do it on an analytical basis with respect to the closing argument like how
[4:04] How do you think about the role like the emotion should play if any at this point in the trouser delivering that closing argument?
[4:11] So that's a bit of a complex question because it depends on who I'm talking to first of all
[4:17] So if I'm talking to a judge, I don't need to be emotional. I don't need to have a lot of extra gestures and showmanship
[4:24] It as it were. You know, here's the facts. Here's the law. Here's why you find my client not guilty. The government hasn't met their burden, right?
[4:32] If I'm talking to a jury though, almost always you're getting you're drawing some emotion, right?
[4:37] Because we're we're drawing on shared experiences to help tell a story this closing argument is storytelling and it's very basic
[4:46] Core closing argument should be telling a story your client's story and why he's not guilty now
[4:54] There may be certain cases where we're dealing with you know what color crime for instance
[4:59] Some sort of fraud right and in those cases. I mean that's there's not really a lot of emotional involved
[5:05] Emotions involved in something like that so you keep it clinical you keep it focused on the facts
[5:10] How about the other side of the prosecution like when they're delivering their closing argument
[5:18] What are you kind of listening in for are you finding maybe things that they say that
[5:23] Could potentially show that their case is vulnerable and then are you emphasizing that in your closing?
[5:28] You know, I've already prepared the closing argument
[5:33] But when I'm listening to government counsel, I will be looking at
[5:37] Easy areas to exploit
[5:41] For example if they use a slide deck and then miss fellow witnesses name look at how much they care about the case right
[5:48] If they use a slide deck and they get the facts wrong and I have and I
Load full transcript
can verify that with my own evidence
[5:56] great
[5:58] or if it's just a
[6:00] argument that they're making
[6:02] That doesn't make any sense
[6:04] Doesn't pass the smell test
[6:07] And cuts directly against known facts and a lot of times it's
[6:11] Bringing the jury back to hey, this is what this witness said remember that is a government wants you to get that
[6:18] So I'm sure then you have a temptation at times to kind of like
[6:24] Respond to some of the things that they said directly in closing like
[6:28] Take me through like how do you kind of decide?
[6:31] What what stays in response to what they said versus no?
[6:35] You know what I had already scripted this out. I'm going to read this
[6:38] Well, it's less about responding to them
[6:40] You never want to be put in a position where you're actually responding to the government's argument
[6:46] You pick one salient point
[6:48] That you're going to respond to
[6:50] You hit it you quit it you move on you stick to what you have prepared
[6:55] um, and sometimes what you can do
[6:58] You know the more experienced counsel
[7:00] uh will
[7:02] Pick a point and bury it within their overall argument, right? So like
[7:07] You've you've developed your outline. You know exactly how you want to
[7:11] Um, execute your closing argument. They say something that fits a nests with a section that you've already prepared
[7:18] Well, just bring a home. Hey, you know government said this and their closing argument. Let me tell you about that
[7:23] So again, it comes back to us. I've always said throughout this series
[7:27] Mastering your case only master your closing argument because when you're listening
[7:32] To what they have to say and you're looking through and reminding yourself on what it is that you want
[7:37] To deliver to the panel
[7:39] You are thinking about well do I need to respond to that? Should I respond to that? Here's how I need to respond to that
[7:46] You don't respond to everything. Well in that vein can you share obviously without giving the intricate details
[7:52] But can you share a case where maybe you gave a closing argument?
[7:56] You felt it was less about performance a little bit more about the alignment like what
[8:00] How did you get that sense from the panel that you knew the panels kind of already doing the work with you?
[8:05] What what what told you that so let's talk about the case in Okinawa
[8:09] Uh in that situation it there was a lot of things that really lined up well
[8:15] First of all the government decided to put my clients statement into evidence
[8:22] and
[8:23] The client the client statement there were some indications where he may have admitted to some conduct
[8:29] But he didn't really because of the way he was interrogated
[8:33] The client will try to explain something and then the agent would say well, let me stop you there because that's not what's important
[8:40] I need you to tell me why you did this. That's what's important
[8:43] You know think questions of that nature right
[8:46] And when you force the panel to actually watch that interplay
[8:51] They become
[8:53] More in line with the defense in the sense that they're irritated with the way this questioning went
[8:58] Doesn't seem real fair and then when you cross examine the agent and you sit there and you point out that the NCIS agent
[9:05] Is permitted to lie to the client to draw out answers
[9:10] Well, that ain't great for
[9:12] You know the government because the panel's not going to like that especially in the Marine Corps
[9:17] We had several really interesting facts come in
[9:21] There was some technical aspects of this case that were really important
[9:25] Um in the sense that there was a series of messages that were exchanged
[9:30] And we look at the digital forensics and we're trying to determine what certain
[9:35] Artifacts in the digital forensic report were and what they could be and why
[9:41] These artifacts were sent
[9:43] Along with messages and why they weren't sent and what we were able to determine was
[9:49] Uh, that the alleged victim while she was allegedly being sexually assaulted was sending out means to a friend of hers
[9:56] and I was able to draw that out
[9:58] from
[10:00] The agents and through the use of my under digital forensic expert as he consult as I consulted with him to understand this evidence
[10:08] And so we look at those pieces of evidence
[10:11] We look at um how my client was interrogated and at the end of his interrogation
[10:16] You know, you asked me earlier about when do you get emotional when you don't well sometimes the case
[10:21] Allows you to just be emotional
[10:23] Because my client the end of his statement to NCIS at the end of the interrogation he's emotionally
[10:30] Telling him. I said I don't know why I thought this I don't know why I thought that maybe it was because she allowed me in her room
[10:36] Maybe it was because
[10:38] She was talking sweet to me. Maybe it's because she said I could sleep in her bed
[10:43] Maybe she allowed me in the bed. I don't know why I thought it was okay
[10:46] But I thought she was awake. I thought she was awake because she was
[10:50] Into what was going on she was reciprocating to me. That's why I thought it
[10:54] You know, and he is pleading with the NCIS agent and you can see that it's not that he's pleading
[11:01] but he is
[11:03] Pouring out his emotion to the agent as he's describing what's happening to him
[11:08] And how easy is that for me as an advocate to make the panel feel that again
[11:13] Because that's your job right make them feel that emotion. So if they understand that's a true emotion
[11:20] That's a true emotion that you can take to the bank and you can feel good about saying
[11:24] That marine is not guilty. Well as we put a bow on this episode and it funnels into this perfectly because
[11:30] As you've now delivered the closing argument and we all are human beings right there is emotion to this
[11:37] Like what is it ultimately from that closing that lawyers should have that panel when they go back to delivery
[11:44] Like what should they have them stay with them at least all the way throughout from the closing argument
[11:50] What is the core tenet of your case? What is the biggest point that is important right?
[11:57] So what's the theme is what they like to say in a little school right you know
[12:01] You're sitting there and you're saying all right
[12:05] You can't believe the alleged victim and here's why
[12:07] Okay, so you want him to go back to the panel and say you can't believe the alleged victim and here's why
[12:13] one two and three
[12:15] So you want to give him some bite sizes number one number two. I like to leave questions out there
[12:22] Because who's responsible for answering the questions
[12:25] The government is they have to prove the case beyond a reasonable doubt
[12:31] So I want to put in the panel's mind
[12:34] Every reason of possible why they should question the government's case because anytime they're questioning the government's case
[12:41] It means the government hasn't answered the mail. They haven't answered the question. They can't
[12:47] Prove it beyond a reasonable doubt
[12:50] Joseph. It's great stuff as always appreciate the time and the insights
[12:54] Thank you, Mike and thank you to everyone out there for listening to this installment of courtroom quarterback
[12:58] attorney Joseph Jordan
[13:00] If you want to learn more about Joseph's worldwide court martial defense practice, do me favor right now
[13:04] Visit Jordan
[13:05] UCMjlaw.com to connect with Jordan his team and one more favor as always hit like hit subscribe leave a review comment
[13:13] Share the episode with someone who needs to hear it. I'm Mike Leon. We'll see everybody next time
[13:21] Thanks for watching
[13:22] Be sure to hit that like and subscribe button and leave us a review in the comments