TRANSKRIP 🔗
Greg: So today we are talking about or going to be talking about what does private equity in construction mean?
Adam: We did the episode about this to start off the conversation.
Greg: A short, it was like— It got a lot of comments. It did. We started off about a 15-minute conversation trying to explain what private equity was.
Adam: There's a lot of people hating on PE right now.
Greg: And so what happened was we broke it into a shorter clip where I was actually just explaining what private equity was, kind of in my point of view as someone who spent part of my career in that private equity space. And it blew up on TikTok. I think now it's over 25,000 views. And so, right, it's great. And there was a lot of comments and a lot of engagement. So it wasn't just a lot of views. It was a lot of people commenting, a lot of people liking, a lot of people forwarding, et cetera, and a lot of people leaving comments. And the comments were, I would say, overwhelmingly negative. And so, yeah.
Adam: Were there any positive comments?
Greg: I didn't see any.
Jeff: Did they just not like your shirt or was it about people?
Greg: It was all about me. No, it was all about, you know, exactly what we're talking about. This sort of rise of private equity in the construction space over the last couple years. So, what we're going to do today, and I'm going to just kind of lead you guys through some of the comments as I read them, and I'd love to get your feedback since we know so much about it. We have a lot of clients in the private equity space. And let's just have a conversation about what it means. And I don't think we need to be pro or—
Adam: I will take the position to try and defend private equity.
Greg: Well, that's what I was going to say. I was going to say, I don't necessarily think we have to be for and against, but it would be good to get feedback or maybe at least talk about both sides. Because I think we can see both sides of it without...
Jeff: I completely understand why people would have a negative impression.
Greg: Sure. Because what I want to talk about is, why is that a negative impression? Yeah. It's negative when it's from the point of view of the person who was bought by private equity.
Adam: Not if they got paid out.
Greg: Well, even so, I think sometimes that is. That's the point. You know, how long do they stick around? What's their experience like? And then what's the point of view of the private equity? Are they also feeling like, what did we buy and what did we get into? Are they always happy? You know, and the seller is always unhappy. So there's kind of, I think there's levels to this. Yeah, there's no absolute.
Adam: Let's get in. Let's hear some of these people.
Greg: So I just want to give a little bit of context first that we all know that private equity has gone into the construction space over the last couple of years, especially, and they're buying it and they're doing what private equity does, which is they buy one, they buy three, they buy five, they package them, and they come in and they put their private equity format and their private equity expectations on sometimes companies that have never been owned by anyone other than, let's say, one owner.
Jeff: The founder, probably.
Greg: The founder and the family. So, when we talk about what we mean by private equity, that's what we mean, right? A private equity firm comes into some market, buys the company, and then either the owner sticks around for a few years or the owner leaves in a few months or some kind of hybrid of that.
Jeff: There's different structures of how they get paid out.
Greg: Yeah. Right. So I just wanted to maybe ask your opinion first since we have some time to talk about it. What's your experience with private equity in the construction space as you know it here? And then we'll take Adam's point of view.
Jeff: So we've got a couple of clients. I'm working with a client right now. Private equity has bought multiple companies, but the concept is the same. And I guess in all three, yeah, in all three, four, five occasions, there's a founder that had been in the business 25, maybe 30 years in that market. And they made a decision to exit. Doesn't matter why they want to exit. Could be age, could be lots of reasons, but they decided it was time for them to exit. And so they, I don't actually know the details of this. They either went to a broker and said, I'm looking to sell. And PE found them or maybe it was, maybe they went out and found them on their own. I'm not really sure, actually. There's a few ways it can happen. But it starts because somebody was willing to sell their business. I think that's actually an important piece of this. It's actually an important piece of this when there's a negative idea about private equity, like they're some sort of swarm of locusts who come in and take over a town. Well, somebody sold it to them. They're not an invading army. There's somebody who's looking to invest, grow a business, probably sell it again later to earn back. But the point is that somebody had to want to sell it in the first place.
Greg: No, it's a good point. They're not stealing these companies from people. They're not stealing them out from other people. Someone is saying, yes, I want to sell to you because I want to cash out. That's the point, right? Okay, so what about you? Any overarching views of PE in construction with what you've seen for the last couple years?
Adam: I would say the majority of the private equity clients that we've had see the opportunity in construction, but they don't have a lot of construction savvy folks on the team. They're finance and investment people. They have ideas about what they can do with these businesses long-term to grow them, scale them, make them more profitable. They typically install some type of management layer. And that management layer is the one that has the
Load full transcript
construction experience. So the actual buyers...
Jeff: Or just general business growth experience.
Adam: Right. But a lot of times they install somebody who has construction experience. You know, we're working with several right now that have brought in construction-specific expertise. And then they brought us in as well to provide more depth to that bench. Right. But a lot of times they are investors and they, and they don't have a lot of construction experience. That's been an overriding theme I've seen throughout the last five or six years of working with private equity-backed companies. I think you made a great point. Somebody agreed to sell their business, and they agreed that this private equity investor group or person was the right group to sell it to. They went through a lengthy process to get there. This doesn't happen overnight. This is a long, drawn-out, drawn out 60 to 90 day due diligence period. They had to position the company to sell in the first place. So it shouldn't be a surprise when the company actually gets purchased by a private equity investor.
Greg: We're going to talk in a minute about some of the negative backlash. And it'll be curious if we, and we might not know this, it'd be curious if some of these comments that we're going to read are from people who've been through this and understand the process, or these people who just think like, oh, they're ruining everything. And they're kind of, they're looking at it from the outside, you know, because,
Adam: you know, there's been roll-ups going on in the industry forever, decades, for a long time.
Jeff: You know, I'm taking this from, if you think about this from the, from the employee point of view, because I, you know, we'd taking this from, if you think about this from the employee point of view, because, you know, we talk to the employees, you know, and our clients. And I think there's this consensus, this general sense, rather, that private equity is, it's like this, well, we've been in construction a long time. And there's kind of this anti-corporate thing like we you know corporate's a bad word because that means lots of bureaucracy or it means lots of lots of rules and we don't like rules and all that kind of thing so i think there's a sense there that it's we're becoming like
Adam: i don't know we've awarded big corporate construction companies
Jeff: oh i don't think that way but i think there's interesting i don't think there's a sense don't think that way. Interesting. I don't think there's a sense in the industry that way. Don't you think so?
Greg: If we use Star Wars as an example, because I love Star Wars, I think a lot of our clients see themselves as, they're like the Luke Skywalkers of the world. They're out in the middle, doing their own thing. They're the resistance. They're the little guy. These guys come in as Darth Vader. They're going to put rules down. They have an iron fist. They're going to change everything about
what I do. They want to be Luke Skywalker, but now all of a sudden they have Darth Vader in their face and they don't like it.
Adam: Well, the Empire was just trying to make it a better galaxy. See?
Greg: So, point counterpoint. That's all I'm talking about. Here's what I'm going to say.
Jeff: This is my favorite part about you, is that, hold on, we have to stop here for a second. You enjoy debating so much that you will defend Darth Vader. You will defend the Empire.
Adam: They came in and blew up his f***ing spaceship twice.
Jeff: You will defend the Empire.
Adam: They blew up his entire Death Star. How many construction workers were working on the Death Star when they destroyed it?
Greg: How many innocent people died in that explosion?
Jeff: He was just a job builder.
Adam: I mean, he was creating jobs. He was.
Greg: But I think what's interesting about that is there are two points of view.
Adam: Haven't you seen Clerks 2 where he defends, like, think about how many innocent construction workers are just there, probably union guys on a big federal job, putting together the Death Star, and here comes the rebels and blow it up, and they weren't warned. They didn't get a chance to evacuate. How many construction workers died when Luke Skywalker blew up the Death Star?
Greg: See, it's always a good idea to bring up Star Wars. Always. Yes. I stand by my decision.
Adam: I'm sure that our listeners are dying to hear some of these comments. I think we jump in and see where it takes us.
Greg: All right. Well, let's start with that because, like we said before, there was a lot of views and there were a lot of comments. And so we're going to go through a few of these here. I'm just going to read them. So the first one that we got was, and we don't have names here, so we're just quoting TikTok users. TikTok commenters. PE ruins everything. They load up the debt on companies and they make them have debt for generations.
Adam: Well, I would say that in my experience with most of the companies we've worked with, the private equity company was actually doing the investing to bring in people like us to buy new software. And they were not passing those costs through down to the entity, to the business that they had bought. Occasionally, they've had that company pay for the diligence or pay for the assessment phase. But a lot of times, it's the investors that are actually paying for stuff, depending on how it's being run. If it's a single investor versus a multi-investor, or if they've bought one entity versus multiple entities. I think there's a lot of variety.
Jeff: Well, there's nothing – I guess what I'm taking away from that is that I don't – there's not a universal model where private equity buys a business, construction business or otherwise, and loads it with debt. I mean, this person may have a single experience, but I don't think that's typical.
Adam: Right.
Greg: Well, and it also depends whether the private, like you're saying, if the private equity firm buys you out and you're just an employee of your former company that you owned, yeah, it's their debt. It's their money. But if you stay in and you still have money in the business and they come out, for example, and say, hey, all right, we want to buy all new software. We want to hire a bunch of new people.
Adam: Fleet of trucks.
Greg: Fleet of trucks. We want to buy – we want a new office. We want to buy a building. That could be what that person is talking about.
Jeff: It could be that. It also could be that the investors have put money, so now they have cash. Yeah. I mean, go invest in that. Go invest in that. I have a client right now. They're concerned about their position in the market because several of their competitors are owned by private equity.
Greg: Yeah.
Jeff: They perceive that as a threat to their business because they're like, those guys have unlimited funds and we don't.
Adam: They can bury us in ad spend.
Jeff: Yes.
Adam: Something like that.
Adam: So I would say I have seen, we've read case studies, business case studies where, yeah, investors came in, bought the company, ran up the debt because they were trying to scale it and grow it, and they didn't have the free cash. They used leverage. They used the company's credit to make those investments. And if it didn't pay off, it didn't have the right strategy, then yeah, you're saddled with a company with debt, but that's no different than an owner trying to do the same thing.
Jeff: No, right.
Greg: Yeah. And it's also, we're not talking about something really important here, which is what is the due diligence going into the transaction? Like you can't just say after the fact, well, I didn't know they were going to do something. Well, that's part of the due diligence process of to whom you sell and who buys you. So, this is a little bit of a –
Adam: And how much control you have.
Adam: And how much control you have and whether you stick around for three years as an owner, whether you're an employee, whether –
Adam: It's an earn out.
Greg: It's an earn out. Whether you keep your employees that work for you and they have a piece of the deal, whether you're an ESOP or not. I mean there's a lot of context here. I mean, there's a lot of context here. But I think the point of that comment is someone feels very negatively about an outside buyer, right? That's kind of the context. So here's one that needs a little bit of context. And I actually know this context. There was a comment. I might have said something about it in the post or I don't remember. But the context is, look, if you're willing to sell, once you sell, your legacy is ruined. If you were an owner, your legacy is ruined, you know, if you sell. So you deserve what you get. So this comment says, if you're ready to sell, you don't care about your legacy. I think the legacy is an important point, but is that
important to people?
Adam: Well, I would say if your legacy is that important to you, then you might not want to be selling to private equity.
Greg: That's exactly what I would say.
Jeff: There are other options.
Adam: That owner made a choice. Yeah, there are other options. It's no different than selling your business to your competitor because you have nowhere else to sell it. They're not going to keep your name out through the door. They're going to put their name on the door. They're going to put their name on the door. They're going to make your employees become their employees. It's no different than a buyout. I mean, from an outsider looking in, yes, you gave up your legacy, but that was the owner's choice to do that.
Greg: I feel the same way. My point of view would be, okay, if that's how you feel, what did you get for that legacy?
Adam: He traded the legacy for lots of cash.
Greg: For hopefully a big payout or at least a moderate payout. I mean, otherwise, what are you doing? These sellers are not giving these businesses away for free. Let's be honest, right? Someone is paying them.
Adam: Oftentimes millions of dollars.
Greg: Millions of dollars. And whether they stick around for five minutes or they stick around for five years, they are getting something in return. And so this is not about legacy always. I mean, it could be.
Adam: It's their choice. They traded their legacy for cash. The legacy was less important to them than the buyout.
Jeff: If you want legacy, if you want a perpetual business, you could go the ESOP route, which by the way, there's debt attached to that.
Adam: Sure.
Greg: Sure. Yeah.
Adam: Sell to an heir?
Jeff: Yeah, to your children, to some family member, your brother, your uncle, your cousin, your nephew. There's other ways to keep the name on the door.
Adam: I mean, we have a client that sold his business to one of his employees years ago, and he didn't change the name simply because they had brand recognition in the market a lot of service companies have good there's no reason to change the name it's not owned by anybody in that original founding family anymore it's owned by a former employee who's now the owner but he kept the name exactly the way it was because it had brand recognition and i will and he gets he gets a lot of benefit out of that brand recognition.
Jeff: I want to add something here.
Jeff: I won't get too far off script on this, but I would propose that a lot of business owners that are looking to exit the business because they've reached a certain age, they're ready to retire, they probably waited too long to put a succession and continuity plan together. Yeah. And therefore, their options got thin. Yeah. And private equity's got money and they're willing to buy. Passing it off to your company or to an employee or a family member, that option gets a little light because they're like, well, I don't have the cash, dad. How am I supposed to do that?
Adam: Yeah. Or they just don't have everybody in the company who's groomed or ready.
Jeff: Yeah, because you waited
Greg: because you didn't prep. I literally just took a sales call about a week ago from an older gentleman who was what I would call past retirement age. He had no prep. He had no planning. And he told me, neither of my kids want this business. I'm not sure what I can do now. And I actually said to him, well, there's a couple things you can do, what we're talking about. This is an option. He was a little small for private equity. But the point is, you're right. There's planning. There's prep. So if legacy is what matters to you most, what I would say is plan for it. That's right. You said plan for that or plan for not that. Find another route, right? Okay, so this is one I like. This is really straightforward. PE will chew up all the goodwill you've built with your clients in about two years.
Jeff: That sounds very specific.
Greg: Yeah, maybe someone got burned. So what this means to me, for you guys to expound on this, you've built your business for years and years, and you sell it to someone, and there's a new owner in town, and now all of a sudden, they're going to treat your clients differently than you treated them, and people don't like that. Is that true or not?
Adam: Well, if you only change the owner, and you don't change any of the employees, the employees are typically the client-facing folks. Maybe the owner had a relationship, but he's going to leave behind project managers, superintendents, tradespeople who have a relationship with the clients already. They're the ones who are maintaining that relationship. Unless you start jacking up prices and trying to gouge them all, and then they're just not going to give you any more work. I don't understand how you chew up all the goodwill.
Jeff: I was going to say, I've got two ways to think about that. Number one is, if I'm the buyer, and I'm moving into your market, wherever you are, and I buy your company, I need all of that goodwill. I'm counting on your backlog and your runway for the business to maintain. It's illogical that I would intentionally burn relationships. Right. But you're right. It could be that there's a perception. Maybe you're on, maybe you're literally underpricing your work and somebody who comes in and has an understanding of pricing and the market shows up and says, we need, we could be selling our services for more, this particular person seems to think that pissed off a client that she was getting the deal of the century for the last 10 years.
Greg: That's what I think it is. You guys are taking goodwill from a certain point of view. Goodwill could mean I'm your client and you've been working without signed change orders for 25 years. And now there's this new guy on the road who's like, wait, wait, you can't do that anymore. And your client gets pissed off and says, well, you could before.
Jeff: Yeah, we've been working
on our change orders over breakfast for 20 years. Why can't we?
Greg: We've been doing handshake business for 20 years and now, wait, now you can't shake my hand anymore? That's crap.
Jeff: We have contracts? What's that? That's bullshit.
Greg: So I think that's probably what, and I think that's the whole point here, right? Is that people think that they're Darth Vader coming in with the Dark fist and the Overlord and there's a new man in town and everything's about to change. It doesn't mean that's a bad thing. And I think we could take both sides of that. Is that bad or is that good? Is it better to run a company a little more, maybe professionally, a little more best practice than if you're a one-man shop? You know, that's another point.
Jeff: We kind of have an entire business around helping people do that, so I'm for that.
Greg: So, here's another one that's sort of, I think, Adam, you mentioned this. So, the quote is, they put people with no construction experience in charge.
Adam: Right.
Greg: They being private equity.
Adam: They being the investors, so the managing partners or whoever is the immediate contact with the...
Jeff: I suppose that's possible.
Adam: Yeah, I mean, that's not unusual. We've seen it. They usually wind up calling a company like us. Hopefully.
Greg: Yeah, they're finance people or they've been in other sectors maybe, or they've been in...
Adam: They have roofing experience, but they bought an HVAC company. Right. And they don't really understand HVAC, but they typically want to learn. They want to rope their sleeves because they want to try and improve the business. They don't buy these businesses to keep them stagnant. They buy these businesses because they see an opportunity to grow them and grow the top line and grow the bottom line and grow all the lines and therefore build a better business.
Greg: And I think, too, there's no reason to think that they're buying, they being private equity, they're not buying your business to fail, is the point.
Adam: No. This is not Gordon Geko. They're not looking to liquidate and go to an M&A.
Greg: Hold that thought because that's the next comment.
Adam: Oh, got it.
Greg: But I think what's interesting is they're in the business to make money as well. And that's maybe something that we should talk about.
Adam: Nobody invests in the stock market hoping that it'll go down unless you're buying options.
Greg: Unless you're shorting. And there's no shorting in construction business because that's not it. There's not shorting in private equity. And so what I would like to, you know, I think it's important to point out is they're trying to make the business better. Their means, their methods, and the former owner's point of view can be completely different from that. Yeah, correct. But that doesn't mean that the private equity firm is not out there to get a better multiple when they then sell.
Jeff: Well, this goes back to kind of a point of view thing. Because during the due diligence process, if I'm selling the business and I'm being courted, I've put my business on the market. Hopefully, I'm getting multiple offers. Private equity happens to be one of them. Maybe there's – I've seen circumstances where there's multiple private equity firms bidding against one another to go buy a business. There's an alignment period. They meet. They go to dinner. They talk. They go out of their way, in my experience, to make sure – do we align philosophically here about the business that you've been running for years? And, again, I need your backlog and your runway to remain. So there's going to be a transition period here where we're going to work as partners for a while to keep that going. So they want that to work. They're not showing up to do that, to do the opposite of that, I guess is what I'm saying.
Greg: I just think that a lot of these comments have something in common, which is people are hearing a lot about PE. They're feeling it. Maybe they think it's an option for them. And by people, I mean, you know, owners of companies.
Adam: I don't think this is owners. I think this is employees.
Jeff: I think so, too.
Greg: Well, that's literally what I was about to say. I was going to say the point of view here is different.
Adam: Or somebody who didn't cut a very good deal and regrets it now.
Jeff: That happens.
Adam: They went into it uneducated or misrepresented or underepresented. They didn't have a good broker to negotiate on their behalf. They cut what they thought was a good deal and everything went sideways on them after they handed over the keys. They were tied to the business for six months or two years or three years and they have a bad taste in their mouth.
Jeff: It's a very good point. It is all a matter of perspective. But I've seen, I've got experience seeing a business owner sell to private equity and then just basically, this is bullshit. I hate every bit of this. Tens of millions of, this person got paid. Sure. And still didn't feel good about it, was still in the business for an earn out, because it's not uncommon, and kind of fought it the whole way, tooth and nail, even after getting paid multiples of tens of millions of dollars. Because they just suddenly decided, man, I don't know. I can't get into their head and understand why they would think that way, but they changed their mind. They decided this isn't any fun for me.
Adam: We're all human beings. We're emotional creatures.
Greg: We've had a client who did that, sold their business to a conglomerate of other businesses. They happen to be an electrical firm, you know, an electric company, electrical. And they said this isn't working and they bought themselves back.
Adam: I've heard of that too. yeah so they un-exited.
Greg: yeah there's a they exited themselves they were their own exit
Adam: they re-entered
Greg: they re-entered yeah that's what happened
Jeff: there's a GC here in town that did that um five ten years ago.
Adam: Mm-hmm.
Greg: So I'm gonna
Adam: what's the next comment there's a gordon gecko one yeah what's that one
Greg: so one of my favorites from wall street so this is what i so this is what it says bought up by pe then changed then closed down and then sold for parts
Jeff: that's the gordon gecko model
Greg: i don't i personally I don't know if you guys have ever seen that.
Adam: Yes. I would say that private equity either had that plan all along going in or their strategy didn't work and that was not the outcome they were looking for.
Jeff: Sure. That was their bailout.
Adam: That was the last resort. They had screwed it up so bad by not having the right people, the right team, or having bought the wrong business. And that was their only exit strategy was to liquidate it for parts.
Greg: Well, and staying on the private equity side here for a minute, what I would say to that is, a lot of people who are being bought by private equity, like you said, Jeff, they might be a one-time owner, they might be a family business, they might be a second or third generation business, and they don't have any experience with the wider Wall Street, if you will. So they think, well, why would you sell me for parts? Why not give me another chance? Why not – is this really what you're going to do? I think what's important to remember is private equity is a business. At some point, they cut their losses. It's a whole model. If you're losing money, you cut your losses.
Adam: They don't throw good money after bad.
Greg: No. If you have to fire half the team because that's a business decision, it's not, well, that's my grandmother that you fired. I don't care who it is. She's not working for me anymore. It's a business. And it feels like a lot of these comments are taking things personal.
Adam: I do know that private equity has fired people because they weren't a good fit anymore with the new ownership, personality-wise.
Greg: Which is partly what we're talking about, right? Were you a good fit at the time of the deal? Was someone lying to you? Yes. Were you lying to yourself?
Adam: I mean, a lot of times what I've seen is private equity has plans for the business, and the owner's on board with that, and he sells it, but part of his team is not on board with that. Well, they're the ones who become resistors.
Jeff: People are emotional. People hate change as a rule. Adam:
They resist it at least.
Jeff: Well, yeah, they'll resist. Yeah. I mean, tolerance for change is different person, but nobody really loves it. But what's more is that the owner in most cases, knows about this, has been preparing emotionally for it when he decided or she decided, I think I'm going to sell the private equity. That took some time. Then there's the due diligence period where they get okay with it, and then they sign. The employees don't find out until way over here on the end of that spectrum. So it's a bomb dropped on them. And they have to keep it that way.
Adam: But that's not the investor's fault. That's the owner's fault. The owner is the one who's shielding the employees because he doesn't want the deal to go south. He doesn't want people to leave. He doesn't want to upset the...
Jeff: It messes up the deal for everybody.
Adam: Yeah, it can.
Jeff: Yeah.
Greg: All right, and here's the last comment, and then I want to pivot to another point of view. So this comment says, there's no exit in construction like in other scalable industries. As you guys know, and we've talked about this on previous podcasts, and we spend a lot of time talking about this because we know a lot about private equity and construction, the exits have been really difficult for the last three years across the board. They're getting better, but exits have been a really difficult, touchy subject for people.
Adam: What do you mean by exit? Do you mean the owner exiting or are you talking about private equity exiting the original buyout?
Jeff: I think that is the owner exiting.
Greg: No, I'm taking this as the private.
Adam: I don't think there's any problem with owners exiting.
Greg: Right. It's the private equity cannot exit. So they buy your company and There's no problem with orders exiting. Right. It's the private equity cannot exit. So they buy your company. Okay. And there's no exit. You know, meaning there's only certain paths for a private equity firm to exit a business.
Adam: Well, let me set the stage for those of you who haven't seen our other episode. So when private equity buys your business, assuming it's just an investor-style purchase, right? They buy it with a, what, five to seven-year horizon. Five to seven-year horizon. Meaning that in the next five to seven years, they need to grow the business significantly so they can sell it to another buyer.
Jeff: Probably a private equity.
Adam: And have an exit. A bigger shot. Because they borrowed the money to buy the business, and that, that loan has a term on it. So I'm an investor. I'm going to borrow $5 million to buy your business. I borrow that from an investor. That investor is expecting a return on that $5 million and I'm expected to pay them, let's just say $7 million in five years. So I have to grow this business I bought sufficient to have enough value that I can sell it for $7 million to give this person back their money with interest, and ideally to sell it for more than $7 million so I get my money's worth out of it because I'm the one who ran the business and grew it. So I'm trying to get $10 million out of it, let's say, so I can give the investor back $7 million and I can keep $3 million for myself. In basic math, that's what we're talking about. Those people who bought the businesses five to seven years ago have had a very hard time finding new buyers to take the business off their hands and they're having to hold the
money longer, hold the business longer, and they're having to tell their investors that they can't pay them back right now. They don't have a buyer for the business. That's what we're talking about.
Greg: Yes.
Adam: And that is true. That has been going on for the last several years now that they've had a harder time exiting.
Greg: So just to go back to where were. So we've been talking about what does an exit mean in private equity? You described it. It's when a private equity firm who has purchased a business or multiple businesses, they then have an exit strategy. So if we talk about the former buyer or the former seller, they're long gone or not, right? But their exit was selling to someone, right? And in this case, they sold to a private equity firm. Then the private equity firm has to come in, and part of their business model is to then sell to someone, right? And in this case, they sold to a private equity firm. Scale it up and sell it. And one of the things that I commented on, I think, on this original post is, which is what you just said, they need to make a certain amount of money. But there are only so many ways to exit a deal in the private equity space. You either sell it back to an individual or a smaller firm, or you sell it to a different private equity firm who maybe, you know, is in that market, you know, or, you know, or smaller, you could break it apart. And, you know, there are different levels of private equity firms. Some are, you know, billion dollars, some are, you know, a few million dollars, Some are $300 million, whatever. They only want to buy one or two things maybe at a time. But there are not – there's not an incalculable number of ways to get out of these investments.
Jeff: Basically, two or three.
Greg: It's two or three tops. And so part of what the industry suffered with over the last couple of years was nobody wanted to buy the thing that I bought. No one wanted to buy it from me because either it didn't pay off, the margins didn't go up, it wasn't a great business.
Adam: Or I can't sell it for enough to pay off my investors and I'd be upside down in the deal.
Jeff: I bought a Chevy Vega and nobody wants to buy it used now.
Adam: Yeah. You still owe more than the note on it is worth. The note on it is higher than what its street value is.
Greg: Which is back to maybe our previous comment about what would happen in that case. Maybe that is when someone would just say, well, let's just sell this thing for parts. Let's sell the equipment. Let's sell the book of business. Let's sell a couple of projects.
Adam: You still owe those investors that money.
Greg: As much as you can.
Adam: But it's not guaranteed money. So the investors have to take the loss, too. So they have to back that deal as well.
Jeff: Which means you probably don't get, if I'm the key guy, I'm not getting a lot of other investments after this.
Adam: No.
Jeff: People are giving me their money to go buy more businesses.
Adam: If you're my stockbroker and you keep giving me advice and I keep losing money, you're not going to be my stockbroker much longer. I'm going to pull my account and go find somebody else to invest my money with.
Greg: So this is the pivot that I wanted to make. So those are some pretty negative comments if you think about it that way. And I think we don't know, like I said, but we don't know if those were employees. We don't know if those are private equity people, but we got enough comments across the board. Those were some of them to kind of show that people are not happy with private equity. So we kind of all three took the point that there's another way to look at it. There's the private equity point of view where they're just doing what they're meant to do. I think it'd be interesting for you, why don't we take the private equity is evil. They are awful. They're not right. They're ruining the industry. They're trying to consolidate. They're taking the family business out of the family business. Is, is there anything to that? And what, you know, what should people, I mean, we kind of touched on it. Maybe you're not the best person to sell the private equity. Maybe, maybe you need to think about who, you know, who you're selling to and why you're selling to them before you have to deal with Darth Vader.
Adam: You know, this is like, I'm going to use a really stupid analogy, but you go to the grocery store and you have the option to buy a bag of carrots or a bag of Oreos. They cost the same. It's $3 each.
Greg: Oh, come on. Everyone buys the carrots. Don't be crazy. Of course they do.
Adam: Yeah.
Greg: Yeah, right.
Adam: And then the people who buy the Oreos complain when they don't feel well or they eat too many Oreos or they got fat. When they get fat. And the people who eat the carrots don't complain about that. And then they want to say it's the Oreo manufacturer's fault that they bought the Oreos or the marketing company's fault that they bought the Oreos. You bought the fucking Oreos. Deal with your consequences. You sold to private equity. Deal with your consequences. They are an option. Sometimes they're the only option for people because they have to get out of their business. They can't work anymore. They need to retire. They don't have anybody who's available inside of the business. They have no heirs to take over the business. And there's this option where an investor, group, or person is saying, look, I'll give you some money for your business. Because otherwise, what's your option is you shut it down yourself and you liquidate it and you lay off all your employees. But if you don't have that, if you don't want that option, maybe they're the only game in town. And if you take that option, you deal with the consequences.
Jeff: I've got a client right now that is looking to exit. He personally is looking to exit the business. He had this idea that he wanted a legacy business. He just
wanted to get out and retire. He looked at a couple different options. He courted PE, talked to them, and was just about ready to go that way, and then pulled the plug at the end. He decided, I actually don't know all the reasons he decided, but it was more of a personal decision than it was a business decision. But part of the business decision was he was going to make more money going that PE route. He chose to go another route where he's going to save money on taxes. So he's going to get paid a little less. He's going to save a lot in taxes. He gets to keep the legacy concept that was important to him. He chose at a point in time where he still had time to figure that out.
Greg: Which is important. And you guys are both kind of doing the same thing. You're still saying it's the owner's responsibility, there's a decision, and private equity is a viable option. I guess what I'm wondering is...
Adam: Even if they're the evil empire, plenty of planets signed up to be part of the federation. There was a whole huge room full of senators from all different planets. They all decided to go to the federation. It seemed like a good idea at the time.
Greg: Okay, but let's stick with that. Would it be hard for us to say that the Empire was bad? No. It's easy to say that. Because we know what it is. We know the movie. We know the trilogy. We know that there's evil in the thing.
Adam: I think it was written by somebody who didn't like the Federation.
Greg: But isn't there some...
Adam: The Empire, you know.
Greg: Evil is too strong a word. But is – here, I'll ask it like this. Are there negative effects of private equity going into construction?
Jeff: Sure.
Greg: Okay. So let's just talk about some of those because I think it might help people understand what they are and acknowledge them and then make their own decision.
Adam: Okay.
Adam: So I'll talk about one aspect. I wouldn't say this is good or bad. It's just a strategy that they have. If they can buy all of the preminent HVAC contractors in a certain region, then they can eliminate competition, and they can price control the market. They can raise the prices at all these companies to be a standard price, and then every homeowner pays the same price. It doesn't matter if you call company A, B, C, or D, you're paying the same price from all of them. This happened with travel companies. I don't know if you know this, but Trivago and Expedia and Yahoo Travel, they're all owned by the same company. They level the pricing. It doesn't matter which site you go to, maybe it's $10 cheaper for the hotel room for that, but that's because the other ones were just worked up more, and they're just kind of channeling you to one or the other to move the revenue around. But they control the whole market. So that can happen with private equity.
Greg: It's about to happen, and it's about – actually, a law just got passed this week. I just read this. It's about to happen in media.
Jeff: Really?
Greg: So now news stations are going to be allowed to actually consolidate way more than they are. And there's going to be only a couple of people, groups who own news channels across the whole country. It's the same concept. So, yeah, is that a bad thing?
Adam: I don't know if that's good or bad, but that impacts the homeowners who need the services, the roofing companies.
Jeff: Well, that's the fear of the client I told you about. They're like, we have competition that is owned by private equity. They've got all the money in the world. They're going to drive prices down and be a loss leader to take the market from me. When I go out of business, they'll buy me cheap or I'll just close the doors or whatever. And then they own the market and they jack the prices. That's their concern.
Adam: So it's kind of the monopoly model that they can... I'm not saying they're doing this. I'm saying they have the potential to do that. It's a strategy where they want to buy—
Jeff: It's a geographic strategy.
Adam: I've heard about them trying to buy a string of them across a region of the United States, like across seven states. They want to have a band of them so they can get a percentage of the market share across that whole region so they can do a volume play. And again, if they can lower their prices a little bit to take more market share, not necessarily to put you out of business, but just to own more of the market because they can do the volume play. They can make two points less, but of a bigger pie.
Greg: And I just finished a project just last week with a client doing exactly that in Ohio. They own Ohio now in a certain sector. And they own probably eight or nine service companies doing this one or two things. Sure. And they own the whole state now. And they are happy to do it. And they have consolidated. They rebranded themselves.
Adam: The other thing is, does that eventually provide a benefit to homeowners? Because it's a standard warranty, a standard company across the region, and they all get the same treatment. Everybody pays the same price. I don't know. I'm just saying there's some benefits to standardization. There's also negatives.
Greg: We're taking the positive again. But yeah, there are negatives to that.
Jeff: People in general, it goes back to the change thing, but it's different but the same. They don't like things they don't understand.
Adam: Okay.
Jeff: So if I'm just Joe Q Public and I'm buying construction services, maybe I'm an employee of one of these companies, you look at other trends. You're like, well, the mall ruined Main Street USA. Well, actually, Main Street USA has been coming back for the last 10 or 15 years. It took a while. It takes a while, but there are cycles, I guess, is my point.
Adam: You know what I'm reminded of? States' rights versus the federal government.
Jeff: If you don't have control of something, you don't like it. Yeah.
Adam: Certain things we
want the federal government to be in charge of like the army right you don't want the states to have individual control of the army in their states that's a federally provided service or you know social security is a federally run program not a state-run program but unemployment insurance is at the state level right they figured it was easier and better if the states managed that for their residents rather than trying to go through the bureaucracy of the federal government. Kind of reminded similar.
Greg: I think that's a good analogy. I think that there is a lot to be said for standardization and there's a lot to be said on both sides. Right. For individuality. Right. Let me ask you guys if you think this is a negative. We've all been in this business for a long time and we know what the nature of construction has been for at least 100 years. It's been, there are some huge companies, but a lot of it is the mom and pops who, you know, started a business. So, is private equity killing the face of construction? And killing is a strong word, but is it fundamentally changing the majority of construction companies across this country that are not maybe the Turners and the Gilbains?
Adam: No, I don't think so.
Jeff: I don't think so.
Adam: There's so many young, newer construction companies that we talk to that for every one that private equity buys, I think there's at least one or two new ones that are sole proprietors.
Jeff: Well, I mean, yeah, the scenario could be private equity. I'm a project manager. I've been working for the old man for a while. He sold out to private equity. This isn't for me. I'm going to start my own company, and I'm going to compete against them or sort of compete against them maybe.
Adam: The nice thing is if you worked there for a little while, you know what their playbook is.
Greg: But in 20 years when that sole proprietor doesn't have a kid that wants the business, doesn't sell to a competitor, is it just this?
Adam: Well, that's the same thing that's going on right now.
Greg: Well, that's my point. Are we just in a cycle of now? This is what's going to happen.
Adam: The silver tsunami.
Greg: The silver tsunami.
Adam: But all the boomers that are aging out, it's the same exact thing that's happening right now. And they don't have the same thing. I don't have somebody to sell my business to in my family or in my employee. So I'll sell to an investment group because they will give me the money that I need to retire. I built this business. I need to get my equity out of it so I can go retire.
Greg: We know for a fact, because we talk about this a lot, that there are probably very few places that touch our modern world that private equity does not have a handle on. They own software companies. They own hotels. They own grocery stores. They own everything. Investment opportunities all over the place. Everywhere.
Adam: But I don't think they own a majority of the country in any one sector.
Greg: No, I don't think they own any one sector as a majority. What I'm saying is I don't think there's a sector where private equity does not own something.
Adam: They play.
Greg: They don't play in it, right? Right. So now they're playing in construction.
Adam: And there's people who invest in everything. There's people who collect all sorts of different memorabilia.
Jeff: Yep.
Greg: We know for a fact that private equity went into the ERP space, right? We know because we know some of those companies, they buy them, they do something to them, and then they sell, and then they sell, and they keep going. So that's, you know, has that fundamentally changed the software space? Probably.
Adam: Is it that much different than the stock market?
Jeff: No, well, look, private equity owns clothing brands. Yeah, right. Private equity owns restaurant brands. Hotel chains.
Adam: Hotel brands. But for all the publicly traded companies in the United States, there's 10 times as many privately held companies.
Greg: Yeah. No, I don't think that we think—
Adam: By the way, I don't know if that number is right. Somebody will have to double-check the number of privately owned companies to publicly traded companies, but I would think it's at least in order of magnitude.
Greg: So maybe there'll be a disclaimer at the bottom of the screen right here. We'll have our— We'll go over our backtracks.
Adam: Put it in the show notes. Check out the show notes.
Greg: But I guess for people listening to this, should we take a stand and say we don't think the private equity is fundamentally changing the construction sector? Or is it okay to say it is changing it? I would say influencing? Yeah.
Adam: I think they're starting to influence the sector.
Jeff: Fundamentally changing is really strong, and I would say no.
Adam: Yeah, it's not at some type of a threshold like that. I would say they're certainly influencing. Influencing the industry. They're making people think differently about their business. Either to be competitive with private equity backed, or to become appealing to private equity as an exit strategy. But they're certainly influencing.
Jeff: It's all a matter of scale. I would argue that I'm very happy to see lots of investor capital come into this industry for software development, construction technologies. There's been a lot of money there in the last 15, 20 years.
Greg: And it's booming. There's a ton of new, there's a lot of new.
Jeff: Construction companies, traditionally, the only way to get out was give it to your son, your daughter, sell it to another guy.
Greg: Or close it down.
Jeff: Close it down. ESOPs have become more popular in the last, say, 10, 15, 20 years maybe. But I, for one, at 100,000 feet, I think it's a very good thing. You get down to street level and maybe you're a specific employee who now you don't know your boss very well.
Greg: Yeah. And you've worked for the
same guy for 25 years and he's like a dad. He's like a grandfather to you.
Jeff: That probably feels like shit. Yeah, right. I get that. I totally get that. So it's all a matter of where you – your perspective on it.
Greg: I think an interesting take is that construction for all the years we've all been in it and for the years before we've been in it, it's kind of been very status quo for what it is. There's a change that's happened, I would say, in the last cycle where it's – is it growing up a little bit?
Adam: Is it a sea change or is it just –
Greg: is it a sea change or is it just, this is what's happening.
Adam: It's on the path towards a sea change. Maybe that's why I said influence, but not fundamentally change or shift yet. Maybe it's building that way.
Greg: So just to recap here, I think, I think we, I think we all kind of feel the same way, but it, I do think it's interesting for anyone watching this podcast to think maybe we're going to come off as pro-equity. Hooray, private equity is the best. I want to make sure that we're able to say there's two points of view here.
Adam: Yeah, I mean, I would say we tend to be unbiased. We work with plenty of privately owned companies as well as equity-backed, investor-backed companies. They present different types of challenges, different types of projects, different types of engagements. But they're all looking to do the same thing. They're looking to improve their businesses.
Jeff: Yeah, I'm pro-making money.
Adam: We live in a capitalist society. If you're not that concerned about that, then be a.org.
Greg: Well, and I think, yeah. And so the point that I was trying to get to is I don't think that we should leave anyone thinking that private equity is either good or bad. I don't think this is a binary.
Adam: That's the eye of the beholder.
Greg: It's the eye of the beholder, and it's not a binary. This is a, is private equity right? Let's go through it. Is private equity right for you? That's something that I think everyone thinking of selling should probably ask themselves at the very beginning. And then understand what that means.
Adam: Yeah, what is that? And get educated. Get educated on the question. And not all, and we've talked about this before, not all investors are the same.
Jeff: No.
Adam: Look for one that has already invested in construction, has bought other companies like yours, or has people on their team that understand how your business works or is willing to learn how your business works. And they're not just buying you as like a mutual fund that they're going to have.
Jeff: Right. If your concern is a legacy, and that means your employees.
Greg: Sure. That's a great point. It's not just your name, and that means your employees.
Jeff: I'm going to get paid out, and I'm going to go get on the boat, or I'm going to go whatever I'm going to do. But I care about the people that I have employed because I know that I'm responsible for their families, et cetera. That's important to you, and I think it should be. Then they're buying you, but you get to interview them. You get to decide, no, I don't think we're going to be a short-term business partner.
Greg: Yeah, this is not a foregone conclusion.
Adam: This is a mutually beneficial arrangement.
Jeff: Right, yeah.
Greg: It's not a foregone conclusion that you are going to have to sell to someone who you don't like, who you don't know, and who's not right for you.
Jeff: Right.
Adam: I'll put in a plug for another podcast if you if you haven't listened to it check out The Acquired Podcast and all and also built to sell those are two podcasts if you listen to built to sell you'll hear a lot about people who have exited their businesses and hear about their positive experiences as well as their negatives that's when I listen to a lot to learn about this industry.
Greg: I think that's a great segue because the next thing that I was going to say is once maybe you decide kind of if we can be educational for a minute. Right. Once you decide that private equity is the right thing for you. Well, if you decide it's not, then, you know, right.
Jeff: You've got other avenues.
Greg: You have a few other avenues. If it is for you, I would say the next thing to do is what you just said. Get educated, understand who you are and what you are and why you're that and what you want to get out of the deal, right? Is it legacy? Is it money? Is it, you know, protection for your employees? Is it whatever, right? And then I think after that, what you said, there's a lot of due diligence that would probably solve a lot of the negativity that we heard on this post by understanding this is not a foregone conclusion. If there's a red flag, I think it's okay to say that's a red flag. You're not right for me. I'll move on.
Jeff: We have a private equity client that attempted to make an acquisition, and the guy walked at basically the 10th hour, maybe the 11th hour. He didn't literally walk away from the table, but he killed the deal. He's like, yeah, no, I'm going to make a go of it on my own. He wasn't getting the return he thought he should get. He just, for whatever reason, didn't feel good to him. He went off and did it. He's like, I'm going to go on my own.
Adam: The other thing I would say is you need to get a broker to represent you as a seller. You need a seller side agent and a broker. That person should have experience with your type of business as well. That's the person who's going to guide you. You wouldn't go to court without a lawyer. You shouldn't go into a business deal without a broker. Or you wouldn't buy a house, typically, without an agent.
Greg: Right for error there. It can be done, but you don't...
Jeff: This isn't one of those selling your construction business to PE for dummies book type of thing.
Greg: This is people who've done this before.
Adam: You need to have a solid broker on your side, a listing agent, just like when you sell your house, who's going to make sure that the deals are put together properly, legally, that you're getting a good deal. They can help you vet it. They can help you spot the gotchas or the— Or the red flags.
Greg: The red flags or the yellow flags even.
Adam: The terms and conditions, helping you understand all the different terms and conditions, understanding what an earn out is versus a cash buy out.
Jeff: A good broker will prep you emotionally, too. The first question they're going to ask you is, do you think you could work for somebody? Yeah, exactly. Because you've been working for yourself for so long. Do you think you could report to somebody? Because you might during an earn out period for two, three, four, five years. So you should be prepared for that.
Greg: And to tell you what that looks like. Like, you know, not just say you're going to be working for someone three years. Great. What does that mean? What's your level of responsibility? Do you get a board seat? Is there a board?
Jeff: You're going to have to fill out a timesheet.
Greg: You're going to have to fill out a timesheet. Is that okay with you? Right. Details. And then finally, what I would say to all this, I think we're all probably saying the same point. Once you get to that point and you decide that it is right for you and you've done your due diligence and you've hired a broker, we all probably agree, then I think you have to do the work to get ready to sell. And I think if you do that work to get ready to sell, right, whether it's data, whether it's systems, you know, all the things we've talked about in lots of other podcasts. If you do that work, too, then you really know what you're getting into and you know what you're selling. So maybe that's also a way to bring down the negativity.
Jeff: Sure.
Greg: Right. 100 percent transparent of what's going to go on and what they're buying and what you're selling, as opposed to I'm not sure what happened here.
Adam: I think it's a great place to wrap this episode up. Thanks to everybody for watching and listening. Please like and subscribe and find us wherever you find all your podcasts. Thanks.
Greg: Thanks.