TRANSKRIP 🔗
00:00:01
Speaker 1: I'm Daniel James, and you're listening to 7am. For generations, Australian elections have largely turned on which of the two major parties voters trusted to govern. In 2026, Victoria is revealing how much that arrangement has changed. Labor's troubles aren't delivering the coalition support they may have once expected. And in a state long regarded as Australia's progressive stronghold, One Nation is competing for voters who have lost faith in both. But with polls suggesting One Nation's surge may be levelling off, it's another thing to win those voters back. Today, political pollster at Redbridge Group, Cos Samaras, on what Victoria reveals about Australia's change in politics and whether One Nation's rise is running out of steam. It's Saturday, November 14. Cos, we're just two weeks away from the Victorian election, which is shaping up to be one of the most interesting and most important state elections in recent history. What's the current state of play according to your polling?
00:01:12
Speaker 2: Yeah, well, it definitely looks like the coalition could actually win in excess of 45 seats. And for your listeners, the magic number in Victoria is 45. That is to give you the one seat majority. And they will do that with a historically low primary vote, which is the story of our new political paradigm.
00:01:29
Speaker 1: In times of old, a number north of 40 in terms of primary votes was seen as essential to get elected as governor. What sort of numbers are we looking at right now?
00:01:38
Speaker 2: Yeah, that's right. So in the past, the coalition would need a primary vote of at least 43 to 44 to get a majority of seats. Coalition's sitting on about 31 at the moment. Labor's down in the low 20s now. They've gone backwards during the campaign. One Nation has lost support from the beginning of the year, could be a sign of things to come nationally. So, yeah, we've seen a lot of One Nation voters move over to the coalition during the last three to four months, and that's obviously positioned Jess Wilson and her team in an advantageous position now.
00:02:12
Speaker 1: So a Liberal majority in and of itself is possible. What about the chances of a One Nation partnership of some sort? Is that still a possibility? Can we see a situation where one nation actually holds the balance of power still?
00:02:26
Speaker 2: Yeah, we can't rule it out. But what we have now, because we now have three major parties that poll roughly somewhere in the 20s and 30s, is there's now a lot of three-way contests. We're going to see them in New South Wales in March next year. We're going to see them at a federal level. And in Victoria, there's around 35 state electorates that are genuinely a three-way contest. That is... that one of the coalition, Labor or One Nation can win that seat. However, your chances of winning that seat boil down to what is your primary vote looking like at a statewide level and how that then boils down to the particular geography we're looking at. So to give you a quick snapshot, Pakenham, the state seat of Pakenham, this is the seat that the One Nation leader Warren Pickering is contesting. At the beginning of the year, the One Nation was polling in the high 30s in that seat. They're now in the low 30s and parity with the coalition. What happens there is the Labor preferences elect the Liberal MP.
00:03:22
Speaker 1: What a time to be alive.
00:03:23
Speaker 2: That's right. So it's basically... That's why One Nation needs a very high primary vote now versus the coalition to actually win. Some seats in Melbourne's West could fall to One Nation because they don't need a super high primary because they will also get Liberal preferences.
00:03:41
Speaker 1: So on that front, Liberal leader Jess Wilson... is seemingly open to working with One Nation, they announced a preference deal.
00:03:48
Speaker 2: We have made the decision that we will be putting Labor, the Greens, the Socialists at the bottom of the ticket and all other parties above that.
00:03:55
Speaker 1: Aside from the politics of that and the morality of that for some people, is the preference deal as big a deal as many people believe it is? And at the very least, how will it shape the result?
00:04:09
Speaker 2: Yeah, look, what we know through extensive polling throughout the entire year is that Liberal Party voters or National Party voters will preference One Nation to the tune of about 75% if One Nation's contesting a seat against the Labor Party. That changes depending where we are. So in more middle, inner urban parts of Melbourne, and we'll see this in Sydney marks next year as well, that preference flow is as low as 40%. So lots of small C conservatives choose to preference the Labor Party, not One Nation. So it does vary. Now that particular nuance is important here because it could cost the Liberal Party some political skin in some of those inner urban, middle urban electorates where small C conservatives cannot stomach this arrangement. So my point here is these preference deals really are not needed because voters will do what they do. And we know from extensive research that they will do what they do. How to vote cards do sometimes make a difference because people will just follow the how to vote card of their preferred party. But by and large, we are seeing increasing numbers of Australians, and in this case, Victorians, who will preference based on what they want.
00:05:21
Speaker 1: Are we beginning to see the major parties now being able to sort of fathom what's happening here a little bit more dexterously now, or are we still in unknown land for them? They've had a few shots at it now, I guess.
00:05:35
Speaker 2: That's right. I would say right now in Victoria, the Liberal Party or the Coalition has a better understanding of what One Nation means to them and their vote, how they can strategically exploit that. And I would say that the Labor Party is the one in Victoria that is
Load full transcript
struggling with this new paradigm. They seem to be running a campaign that probably belongs back in 2010. These are the sort of strategies they used to use against the Greens. It does not work. And I'm referencing the sort of scare campaign, which is, you know, if you vote for the Liberal Party, you get One Nation. but I just don't really care about that. Enough to make a difference, that is.
00:06:18
Speaker 1: Still to come, the surprising trend that could see a different minor party rise. Because earlier this week we spoke with Nick McKenzie about his investigation into One Nation, which... painted a pretty chaotic picture of what happens inside the party. There are claims of undue influence from Gina Reinhart, of dodgy vetting processes, and links to the Comongeros' bikey gang for the party secretary. Do voters care about that stuff? And is this leading to the sort of diminishing in numbers you were alluding to earlier?
00:07:00
Speaker 2: Yeah, we are talking about now a different political atmosphere to the one that we had at the beginning of the year. So the economy has worsened. A lot of Australians report to us that they feel that things have just got a lot more serious, right, in terms of the interest rate rises and the pressure on them via the inflationary crisis. And the problem for One Nation is they are viewed by a lot of voters, including those that plan to vote for them, as not really a serious setup. And so they lose support. And in Victoria, they've lost support to the coalitions. at a national level, a most recent poll after the last interest rate rise benefited the coalition, not One Nation. So again, we're starting to see these little snippets of, I would say, evidence that as the world gets more and more difficult for voters, One Nation's, I would say, frivolous approach to internal management and the way they advocate for policy is probably going to hurt them.
00:07:57
Speaker 1: If we turn to federal politics, because the Labor Party is really filling the heap right now over the cost of living. with a lot of the voters blaming the PM for inflation and his treasurer, Jim Chalmers, and the five interest rate rises we've seen this year. Will that issue come into play this election?
00:08:15
Speaker 2: Well, I mean, we are definitely seeing some impact on the Labor brand in Victoria at this state election as a consequence of that last interest rate rise. It will be mostly felt by the Labor Party in the sort of mortgage belts that basically dot parts of Melbourne and some parts of regional Victoria. And we have seen at a national level, from a polling perspective, a drop in Labor support. Now, interestingly, it has not gone to One Nation this time. It's gone to what we will determine, minor parties or the Greens.
00:08:45
Speaker 1: Why?
00:08:45
Speaker 2: Yes, because what we're now left with is a fairly balkanised electorate. So One Nation support at a federal level is about 30%, thereabouts. Labor lost a couple of percentage points in our latest round of polling and it went to its flanks. It didn't go to One Nation. It didn't go to the coalition. A bit of it did, but not much. We're seeing now in Victoria, since the beginning of the campaign, very similar trends. So Labor has lost support from, they were polling about 25, 26, which again was historically low. They're now in the low 20s. Most of that's gone to, I would say, minor parties in the Greens because we're dealing with whatever's left on Labor's pile is fairly progressive.
00:09:25
Speaker 1: So, Cos, what does that mean for the Greens' political fortunes moving forward?
00:09:29
Speaker 2: Yeah, they had a rough trot in 2025 at the federal election where they lost seats, and there were some commentators who suggested that they were in a permanent decline, but I would counter that and say that in the next few electoral cycles, we will see the Greens' support grow exponentially, and they will start winning seats based on the fact that Generation Z, that is Australians between 18 and 28 years of age, 35% of them support the Greens irrespective of where they live in the country. And more importantly, the 18-year-old is no different to the 28-year-old. In other words, they're not changing as they're getting older. And there's still five years of more GNZs to enrol to vote. At the close of this decade, we're going to have 5.2 million of them on the electoral roll.
00:10:12
Speaker 1: If this election goes the way that the polls are predicting, what will be the message here for the federal government?
00:10:20
Speaker 2: That the federal government can find itself in the Victorian pincer, as I like to describe, which is you end up being buffeted by two other conservative parties from both flanks. So you are trying to defend seats versus the coalition and you're trying to defend seats versus One Nation. And those two have a better preference arrangement than you do. And the Greens are not polling high enough to save you. That is not a problem as long as you are polling in the 30s. As soon as you start to drop in the 20s, like the Victorian Labor Party did, and now we are seeing federally this is the same case with the Albanese government, you can get very quickly into very dangerous territory where you start to basically find yourself losing seats to One Nation, losing seats to the coalition in a very, very difficult position.
00:11:10
Speaker 1: Well, Cos, Merry Polling Christmas. Thanks for coming on 7am again.
00:11:14
Speaker 2: Thank you.
00:11:36
Speaker 1: 7am is a daily show from Solstice Media. It's made by Atticus Basto, Chris Dengate, Crystal Keller, Renee Auckland, Ruby Jones, Travis Evans, Zoltan Fetjo Jr. and me, Daniel James. Our theme music is by Ned Beckley and Josh Hogan of Envelope Audio. And if you'd like to support 7am in bringing you news independently, without fear or favour, please follow the show on your chosen podcast platform and on our social media accounts on Instagram, Facebook, YouTube and LinkedIn. Thanks for listening to 7am this week. Take care and have yourself a great weekend.