전사 🔗
Josh Arnold: If your inspection process consists of walking around the truck once and slapping a safety sticker on the glass, if you're not an inspector, you're a liability.
Marshall: The pressure to cheat the annual safety is everywhere. Today we're talking about the real cost of compromising your integrity. And today we've got with us special guest Brent Osman from the K the Canadias over there. And ⁓ 51st state representant, and he's actually from the Berta, the great province of the Berta. So we wanna welcome him. We're gonna now
Josh Arnold: Fifty first state representing Yeah.
Marshall: The inspections in the in the great state of Canadia are significantly more in depth in the commercial side than they are in the United States, just to be clear. ⁓ also does not mean which we're gonna get, we're gonna give Brent a chance to get into some details on that. They definitely are not getting done at the level that they probably should be. and so take it away, Brent. Let us know what's going on over there in the great state of Canada.
Josh Arnold: Doesn't mean they're getting done right though.
Brent Osmond: So in the great state of Canadian. I would never say it and now I said it. ⁓ yeah. You got you got one. Yeah. So Calgary just ran a commercial safety blitz. ⁓ hundred hundred and ninety seven trucks on the road. They they pulled over hundred and ninety seven trucks, a hundred of those trucks failed a roadside inspection. Hundred trucks.
Josh Arnold: Ha ha ha ⁓ We got it.
Marshall: We got ⁓
Brent Osmond: That just puts it slightly over 50% of those trucks on the road failed a roadside inspection, right? Which to me, quite frankly, that's embarrassing for the commercial truck industry, right? Because it's like, what are we doing here? Right. Where did those stickers come from? Right. Because I can guarantee you there's some of those trucks that were just had a roadside inspection that probably had a sticker, brand new sticker that was dated that month. Right. And like you said in the in the opening, so it's it's compromising your own integrity. So when a when a truck rolls into the shop, do I just, you know, lick and stick like you know Josh brought up, right, and let it go? No. I mean, you know, ⁓ in Canada we had, you know, twenty eighteen we killed ⁓ sixteen kids on a ⁓ hockey players on a bus, right? Because of what was a truck that was probably deemed unworthy to be on the road, right?
Marshall: Yeah.
Josh Arnold: Is So how so how does this happen up there, Brandon? I I doubt it's just like a mechanic, you know, just like yeah, whatever, s you know, slapping a sticker. I'd hope not, right? But how d how does this happen?
Marshall: Does it break down like international or any of those things? Were they all Canadian trucks? Does it break does it give you any breakdown of ⁓ what they were put out of service for?
Brent Osmond: It d the it the news report doesn't give you a breakdown on what they were put out of service for. ⁓ but I mean like trucks can be put out of service for a a multi ⁓ like some of the smallest things, like you know, just just airlines rubbing near the brake pots themselves, right? Just those kind of things. They can take that out of service for that, which is fine. Like I agree with that, right? But it doesn't it doesn't give you a scale of, you know, what these trucks were put out of service for. ⁓ I would I would like I would like to see it.
Marshall: Yeah. Yeah. Like to put it
Brent Osmond: Just to see, right? To see if there's a a commonality behind it, right? So
Marshall: Yeah, so to like put in perspective ⁓ the last DOT blitz in the United States we did last May or this May, ⁓ fifty-four thousand five hundred seventy five trucks were inspected. over eighty one percent of the vehicles ⁓ passed without any out of service violations. ⁓ see here. However, a total of ten thousand three hundred and fifty commercial motor vehicles ⁓ and three thousand one hundred and eighty-four drivers were pulled off the road due to serious safety infractions. So the drivers would be put out of service for being over their hours, the regulated hours that they're allowed to drive. ⁓ because drivers are only allowed to drive ⁓ like fourteen hours a day or whatever. Or there was some kind of ⁓ issues with their logs for their driving or something like that. They they could be put out of service for those items. So the Or they were intoxicated or sleepy or like the the the or they couldn't unfortunately speak the correct language in that area so they couldn't read the s the signs that are in that that particular area. it says when looking specifically at vehicle inspections that include mechanical checks levels one, two, and three, the vehicle out of service rate reached twenty three point five percent. ⁓ totaling thirteen thousand nine hundred and twenty four total vehicle violations. And then it gives you a breakdown for that. three thousand three hundred and seventy nine of those out of service violations were for the brake systems. ⁓ 2,914 were for tires. ⁓ 20% were for defective brakes. or 20% defective brakes. So Josh will
Josh Arnold: It is.
Marshall: there is a a rule that they put it out of service if twenty percent of the brakes are defective. So, you know, you know
Josh Arnold: Okay. Crazy crazy that you had allowed twenty percent.
Marshall: Agreed, but you gotta remember that it's a eighteen wheeler and it has that many brakes on it. So ⁓ you know, twenty percent of the d of the brakes were defective on two thousand seventy two trucks that they inspected.
Josh Arnold: Fair enough. But to look at that though, like think about it like this car has four brakes. You're twenty-five percent, one quarter of the car doesn't stop. Are are and you're sliding that thing through?
Marshall: Yeah. Yeah. Hey ⁓ cargo securement ⁓ was one of the twenty twenty six ⁓ focus areas, one thousand seven hundred and twenty four. ⁓ what was the show with the the logs that come off and kill all
Load full transcript
the kill the g the
Brent Osmond: Just brought this up the other day in the shop. It was ⁓ what is that now? How come I can't remember?
Josh Arnold: Okay, we we can edit it all out. Take us take as long as you need.
Marshall: Yeah. Yeah, we could edit it all out. But it but anyway, long story short, this is like is the stuff that the truck hauling properly secured on the trailers, you know what I'm saying? Logs not being scrapped and you know, stuff being loose, things like that. And then one thousand six hundred and fifty nine were for lights.
Josh Arnold: Nah, sure Those are important too, I think. Like I mean all all every tank that you're reading here, I'm just like, Yeah, this is what we need on a vehicle and not alone not let alone a massive vehicle that's carrying thousands and thousands of pounds. I mean, Marshall
Marshall: ⁓ Yeah. I don't think the the United States DOT regulations are tight enough, to be honest with you. I think they're a little bit on the lack side, my my personal opinion, but it also says ⁓ combined the two brake categories accounted for thirty nine point one percent of all the vehicle out of services.
Brent Osmond: Yeah.
Marshall: So pretty interesting stuff. And then it does go into ⁓ the out of driver or the driver out of services. So no medical card, hours of service, no commercial driver's license. They got six hundred and fourteen drivers that did not have a commercial driver's license is wild. Three hundred and sixty one of them were for English proficiency. ⁓ false records of duty status, two hundred and fourteen. So that's why I was talking about like they didn't put themselves in the, you know, with the
Brent Osmond: Yeah.
Marshall: their records were not good. ⁓ and ⁓ yeah, so then they go in a little bit on some ⁓ hazardous materials. But yeah, some pretty good stats from the DOT. I think they do a pretty good job doing their blitzes and recording all those and and making them ad ⁓ available to the public. So good on them for that.
Josh Arnold: So why do why do we think this is happening in shops? Do you think it's laziness? Do we think it's lack of proper time? Like what is it?
Brent Osmond: No, I don't I don't think it's laziness. I I think it's you know it's it's your your buddies with a shop, right? And you take your truck there, maybe just for oil changes all the time, and then it comes to uptime, your annual inspection is due, right? And then you just go in and say, Hey, can I get a inspection sticker for five hundred dollars? Right? And then
Josh Arnold: Yeah.
Marshall: I'm not gonna lie to you, ⁓ pretty much every ⁓ every place that I've worked at, ⁓ most of the technicians weren't qualified to do d ⁓ the inspection, the annual inspections. And and they still did them anyway. And the reason being is because the management teams don't understand what DOT is and they don't understand what the requirements of a of an inspector are. And so ⁓ to be a legitimate DOT inspector, there's some requirements. And one of those things is you have to have a year experience.
Josh Arnold: So she's God dang.
Marshall: You have to go through a a break class. you know, I'm a DOT certified brake inspector as well. So like I have ⁓ quite a bit of DOT ⁓ credentials, to be honest with you. But the ⁓ first thing is do you have an understanding of the regulation? So a simple question that could be asked if you're a manager listening to this and you run a diesel shop of any kind, dealer or independent or whatever, you could go right out to the shop. Go to one of your guys that you know is doing DOT inspections and ask him, where do you find the DOT regulation for an inspection? And if you can't rattle that off his head, that's a fail. He cannot do DOT inspections until he understands where the dang regulation is. Because if they do a DOT inspection and it leaves and that vehicle is part of a ⁓ a death. ⁓ and and someone dies, a fatality is what I was looking for. If it's part of a fatality, they're going to tear you apart and look at every record from that truck being there. They're going to look at multiple years of repair and and maintenance records. And if your shop is in there and the guy that you did it, they're going to come there and question that particular technician, but you have to keep those records for X amount of years. So they're going to come back and tear you apart. And you're gonna provide those records to the DOT and ⁓ they're gonna go right to that technician. Hopefully he still works for you, and they're gonna ask him the first thing, where do you find the records to to do that inspection? Or where do you find the the the the rules ⁓ to do a DOT inspection? Where do you find the rules for the deficiencies in an inspection ⁓ or the pro Particular part on brakes. Maybe they suspect it was a brake failure and they want to know if this technician knows a good the the the way to actually inspect some brakes. And they ask him some particular questions. He's got to know all of those things off the top of his head. ⁓ or he needs to be able to reference it quickly from where those inspections are. ⁓ so I if they ask me, I I know exactly where they are, what chapter they are, and I can tell you exactly where we need to go. And I would say, Well, yeah, this is the chapter. Let's go right to it. And ⁓ I would pull it open and then I would thumb through the the chapter until I find the break portion and I would say, There it is. ⁓ and and you've got to know that.
Brent Osmond: Cool. Yeah.
Marshall: So that's how that's how ours work. ⁓ but it's I was telling Brent before the show that with our inspections, since the qualifications are so lenient and ⁓ they're not regularly checked ⁓ by any regulatory agencies, ⁓ you know, they're they're the DOT's not going to any dealerships and asking who's doing DOT inspections and ensuring that they're qualified. ⁓ whereas like it's a little different in Canada because those technicians go through a regulatory body to be
certified so ⁓ from the government. ⁓ so it's a little bit ⁓ different. I I actually prefer their their setup a little better.
Brent Osmond: Yeah, we have to pass it. We have to pass a criminal record check and that kind of stuff. I don't know what they look for in the criminal record check, to be honest with you. and then I believe in some of the other provinces, it has to be renewed every two years, right? ⁓ some of the other provinces too, you have to take a course every two years, like to recertify to safety, right? ⁓ I know here in Alberta. So say if there is so say if one of these trucks that just went through this blitz in Calgary, ⁓ and it just had a recent sticker and they've they trace it back to the technician. Well that technician's gonna have to go through a retraining class, right? Where ⁓ some of the instructors I used to work with at the college here, they would teach that retraining class. And some of these ⁓ technicians coming through ⁓ couldn't use a dial indicator to measure, you know, anything. Right. So how are you doing an inspection? Right. All that kind of stuff, right? Yeah. Right.
Marshall: Yeah. How you checking for hub play? How are you checking for S Cam play? How are you checking for camp play? Yep.
Brent Osmond: So there's there's there's things like that happening, right? So ⁓ yeah.
Marshall: And oddly enough, there's a lot of guys that don't even know how to check wheel and play the w like w the right way. How you're like they don't know how to set up a hub and then measure with a dial indicator the way you're supposed to do it. They've just always been taught, well, you you you put your bearings in, you slide your hub on, you have your outer bearing out, you pre fill the the hub valley, you put your bearing in lubed.
Brent Osmond: Mm-hmm.
Marshall: And then you put your out your inner nut on, you crank that joker down as hard as you can, you back it off two flats, you torque it down to fifty foot pounds, you put your outer nut on, you put it that you put the beans to that joker should be like three fifty to four hundred foot pounds, and Bob's your uncle, they put their safety whatever safety clip it has in it, they put the cap on, you know, and they're done. Whereas like they're not measuring the play. Like you like that may be the procedure to to install that, but you still have to check that because if we're re if you're reusing everything, it it may need to be a different you may need to adjust it a little bit.
Brent Osmond: You still be taking hearing until after yeah. Mm-hmm. Yeah.
Josh Arnold: And it and it's not like those guys are flat rate, right? So I mean what's what's going on there?
Marshall: I mean very rare occasion. Yeah, there's there there's very few ⁓ dealerships and ⁓ I g I only know of one dealership that does flat rate and they only do it with a certain level of technicians. And ⁓ you know, I know there's a handful of ⁓ of ⁓ independent shops out there that that in the heavy duty world that
are flat rate, but like to your point, there's really not a lot of excuse for it. Not with something that's you know, gonna be carrying eighty thousand pounds. I don't I don't feel like it's worth the risk. You know what I mean? I go ahead.
Brent Osmond: Yeah, and I think Most of the time we we quote enough time to do that, right? So you usually we get two and a half hours to three hours to do one so what one wheel end on a drive axle, right? So that's more than enough time, plenty of time to mount the hub, get it all set up, get a dial indicator, check for end play, that kind of stuff, right? You know? And then and then the other thing that really yeah, is reusing oil soaked brake shoes that yeah.
Marshall: Yeah. Plenty of time. Dude, that drives me w wicked crazy because let me j let me just give it the can I give the spiel, Brent. So the thing about Josh in in heavy duty we we use a lot of ⁓ drum brakes still. Okay. So but our drum brakes are are are humongous, obviously. ⁓ so your your your hub seal, your wheel seal, it goes bad. And it's oil bath bearing, so you get you get some oil down. There is some grease ones out there, but on truck side it's kind of rare.
Brent Osmond: ⁓ yeah. ⁓ yeah, give her.
Marshall: So you get some oil down in there and it gets on your brake shoes. So you change everything. And a lot of guys, and I've seen it and I've worked at places where I've seen guys rinsing them off. Now, once oil gets in the brake material, it's it would yeah, you cannot get it out. It it's it's penetrated in there and it cannot come out. So as that brake shoe heats up, that will bake out.
Josh Arnold: Yeah, they're done.
Marshall: And then it can catch on fire. And it's important that these guys know that the flash point of oil is lower so the than the working temperature of the brakes. So the brakes, when they're working and they're being heavily used, they're hotter than what it takes to catch oil on fire. So that's the flash point, right? So it's a it's a it's gonna bake that out and it's gonna catch on fire. And a lot of guys will say, well.
Josh Arnold: Right.
Marshall: I've done it a million years and it's never done it yet, you know what I mean? Well, yeah, it's that one time and it's gonna be on a truck that's hauling a load of freaking gasoline and it explodes. You know what I mean? ⁓ it's almost Yeah, and it and you did that over a thirty dollar set of brake shoes. The the brake shoes are thirty bucks. Thirty five dollars. So why would you do that? Like why would you risk the biscuit for a thirty five dollar thing of brake shoes? Like you know, and
Josh Arnold: Ha ha. That's gonna end up on TikTok and be all over the world. Crazy.
Brent Osmond: Mm. Mm.
Marshall: I'm always like, dude, if I take brake shoes off, I'm putting new ones on it. Like we're already here. Like why am I putting the the old ones back on? That's the most idiotic thing. Like, I'm already there. Let me take everything off, inspect the foundation breaks, make sure everything everything's tight. And ⁓ let's throw some new ones on here. We're already here. You know what I mean?
Josh Arnold: Ha ha ha.
Brent Osmond: Right? Yeah.
Josh Arnold: And and so ⁓ it's funny enough, on Toyota they did drum brakes up until twenty twenty. So I'm actually very familiar with that failure because wheel bearings would knock out and then they would have the similar thing happen where the drum brakes would get saturated. Absolutely would never reuse reuse them though. That's wild to even consider it.
Marshall: No, yeah, dude, they'll d they'll have a case of break clean out there just hosing them jokers down, dude. I
Josh Arnold: You you'd think they were paid off of w how much money they save you doing something like that. ⁓ So
Marshall: Dude, it's yeah, it it it's wild. It's
Brent Osmond: Yeah, you use three cans of brake clean, that's like a full set of brake shoes.
Marshall: The the other thing too is is like we're we a lot of technicians don't like get into the the nitty gritty of braking coefficients and things like that. Or even like so when you go through foundation brakes training and you you get and you work yourself into that DOT brake inspection side of things, ⁓ like you learn a lot about braking coefficients and you learn a lot about the proper ⁓ brake shoes to use based on the application.
Brent Osmond: Yeah.
Marshall: of the truck. So like what kind of what the job is. Like you might have two trucks, they're the same model of truck, but one truck does this job and the other truck does this job. And this one, they will need different brakes based on what they do for a living. So like they may have the wrong brake pad material. You may take off the wrong ones because when they come from the factory they put a basic setup on there. You know what I'm saying? Well this might be its first brake job and it's two or three years old now. And you were like you need to be interviewing your client and figuring out, Hey, what does this truck do for a living? Does it need a heavy duty or brake? ⁓ Yeah, and a lot
Josh Arnold: Yeah, yeah, yeah.
Brent Osmond: Well and the the coefficient of the braking is based on the axle weight too, right? So actually we just ran into this in the shop ⁓ a couple months ago where brake drums were becoming glazed like shiny, right? Because there was the wrong coefficient of friction shoe being used, right? So and and that's stamped right on the on the edge of the shoe, you can see, right? And it wasn't until ⁓ one of the other techs had had done some research is like, well, this is the second time this has happened, so why is this happening?
Marshall: Yeah. Correct. Yeah.
Brent Osmond: Now it wasn't shoes that we had put on, it was the the fleet company was just buying shoes in bulk, right? So right. But they they may not know any better either, right? So they don't know. Yeah.
Marshall: Yeah. Yeah, yeah. So if you put if you if you put too heavy of a shoe on on a truck, right, and it and it works really light, the job that it does is it it it's a light braking application. It will glaze the brake.
Josh Arnold: So I I was gonna I was gonna before we get lost in the weeds on your guys' break and break ⁓ break shoe class here. I think it brings up a good point though. You you have technicians that probably aren't trained properly. So I have a way to bring this into the automotive here. Here here we go. Here we go. So I go to my Texas ⁓ to get my Texas emissions license when I move down here, right?
Marshall: Right. Dude, we're freaking fired up about break. ⁓ God, here we go.
Josh Arnold: I'm studying up. I'm like, okay, I gotta make sure I know what I'm talking about, even though I've done the ASCs and all that crap, right? I'm I'm just that type of person. I walk into this testing center, room full of 30 guys. They're like, okay, we're gonna review some of what's gonna be on the test. And no joke to you guys, they read every single question on the test and provided an answer before you took it. That right there is not doing anything.
Marshall: Ehk yeah.
Josh Arnold: Those people did not learn anything. And I I will b I will tell you this. There was one guy that failed in the class. And it's ⁓ but here's the thing. I think what I think what we're talking here is it's not flat rate. We can't say that, right? You guys are less fireboard. We can't say it's that. It's it's coming down to training. What we're experiencing and the problem that we're having here is unqualified technicians.
Brent Osmond: Yeah.
Marshall: Yeah. And they gave him a second shot and he g and he passed it the second goer.
Brent Osmond: Yeah.
Josh Arnold: And that being said, we are at that twenty minute mark. So what do we always say?
Marshall: Hold on, before we before we say it, I just gotta give a shout out to my boy Jay Ganenin, and I wanna see some DOT related items in in the T series. Your boy will be there to take ⁓
Josh Arnold: Fair enough, fair enough. You I'll make sure Jay sees that.
Marshall: Yeah. And so what we always say at the end is I'll catch you on the next one.
Josh Arnold: Yeah, right.