전사 🔗
00:00:07
Speaker 1: You're listening to a Mamma Mia podcast. Welcome to Burning Questions. I'm Kath Mahoney.
00:00:23
Speaker 2: And I'm Dr Ginny Mansberg. We have spent a lot of time talking about women's health on the Mamma Mia podcast well, but now Kath and I are entering a new era with a podcast dedicated entirely to to your burning health questions.
00:00:39
Speaker 1: Indeed, because if you grew up with Dolly Doctor, chances are you've spent much of your adult life searching for health advice you can actually trust. Whether it's for yourself, your partner, your kids or your ageing parents, there's always something you want to know. And that is where my dear friend, Dr. Ginny, comes in. Because I'm not a doctor, apparently. But I'll be asking all the questions you've sent us while Ginny is here to help make sense of it all. Aren't you, Ginny?
00:01:06
Speaker 2: I am a doctor.
00:01:07
Speaker 1: Because you are a doctor, aren't you? I am.
00:01:08
Speaker 2: I'm actually a real one. I went through uni.
00:01:10
Speaker 1: You literally did go through uni.
00:01:11
Speaker 2: Unlike Bruna Papandrea, who someone lost her medical degree.
00:01:15
Speaker 1: And her lawyer's degree. Exactly.
00:01:17
Speaker 2: It doesn't seem right to me. But anyway, I am a doctor. But a reminder that I am not your doctor. So please make sure to reach out to your own GP on burning questions every week. I'm going to answer your real life questions. No question is too embarrassing, too niche or too weird. We love niche and weird.
00:01:35
Speaker 1: Love niche and weird. That's how I roll in the bedroom as well. So, Kath, what have we got on today's show? Right. We're kicking off by fact checking some of the wildest wellness claims doing the rounds.
00:01:47
Speaker 2: What's real?
00:01:48
Speaker 1: And what's just internet nonsense designed to sell you something? I feel like I've bought a lot of these things, Ginny. Then we're getting into genuinely useful advice about sleep. Before finishing with how to ask your doctor for what you need and feel more confident in the consultation room. So let's get into it. Okay, here is our first segment. Is this true? Turmeric can help with inflammation and or peri-symptoms. This is on TikTok and a lot of the wellness gurus are talking about it.
00:02:21
Speaker 2: It's not entirely bunkum, but it's not entirely true either. I think that's what is so much online. Like they'll take a kernel of truth. So if you take studies of turmeric, especially the active property in it, which is curcumin, so you can kind of buy one or the other.
00:02:37
Speaker 1: So turmeric is the orange thing and a spice thing that I would have bought and never used. Is that right?
00:02:43
Speaker 2: And I bought and used it a lot. Great with a lentil. But if you actually take the turmeric, the active part of it is called curcumin. And it has been studied in petri dishes and a couple of animal studies. And it does look like taking curcumin, if you take somebody's blood before and after, there are certain inflammatory chemicals that we can identify in your blood that do seem to drop. But so what? Because what we don't have is the next bit. Do you therefore have less inflammation or less depression or fewer peri symptoms have never been studied for that. So we don't actually have the evidence that just because you're dropping the biomarkers, you actually reduce inflammation in your body. Does that mean that there is absolutely no point in taking turmeric or curcumin? No, it means we've got absolutely no idea whether it's going to help you or not. I have got patients who swear.
00:03:36
Speaker 1: By this stuff.
00:03:37
Speaker 2: And if they're happy to pay for it and they understand that it may or may not be working according to the studies, I reckon all power to you. But If you're the sort of person who goes, listen, until I know that for sure it's going to work, I'm not going to use it, then this is not one for you because we are not there yet.
00:03:51
Speaker 1: Because people have it in drinks and all sorts, don't they? There was a real fad a few years back where I worked with a guy on Radio Whipper and he just put turmeric on everything.
00:04:00
Speaker 2: Have you ever had a turmeric latte?
00:04:02
Speaker 1: No. Is that like a pumpkin latte? Is that like a Halloween situation?
00:04:06
Speaker 2: I think it's basically a sugary coffee-flavoured drink. But it's also turmeric-flavoured. But all the sugar makes it very, very palatable. I quite like it. And I do like the taste of turmeric, seriously, with lentils, particularly if you add black pepper, which, by the way, it looks like that combination further reduces your inflammatory markers in your body. But I would not take a turmeric tablet myself. I'm not that interested because I like something with, like, gold evidence. You want some fats, lady. I want someone to have done the study in humans and taken people and given half of them turmeric and half of them not and see whether their osteoarthritis improves and they've got better walking speeds on a test that is completely objective. The thing is, it's pretty hard to do a test on turmeric. Number one, Because how would you get a placebo? Because the turmeric has got such a distinctive smell. And number two, who's going to pay for it? Because this stuff is not proprietary. So you can be a company who sells turmeric and spend $ 100, 000, $ 150, 000 on a trial. It's not even going to be a big one for that amount of money.
00:05:09
Speaker 1: All right, next question, Ginny. This one is part myth and part question. I've heard a glass of red wine each night can aid sleep or even be good for you because of antioxidants.
00:05:22
Speaker 2: There's a little bit of truth in that in as much as a lot of people, I certainly am a sleepy, if I drink alcohol, I feel very, very tired, but I'm unlikely to get through the night without waking up. So it puts you to sleep, but it doesn't keep you
Load full transcript
there. Most people have a worse night's sleep after alcohol, particularly if you have a lot and you've got like some reflux or you feel uncomfortable or that kind of thing. And it's definitely not good to keep you asleep all night. There are some compounds involved. inside, particularly the skins of especially red grapes that do have some anti-inflammatory properties. So they are our old friend Flavanol.
00:06:00
Speaker 1: Oh, Flav.
00:06:01
Speaker 2: Flav is back. For anyone who can't remember, Kath's waiter in Athens was called Flavanol. Yes, I'm sure he was.
00:06:07
Speaker 1: I'm sure he was. He definitely wasn't a red grape.
00:06:11
Speaker 2: Definitely didn't look like that. He was quite hot from memory.
00:06:12
Speaker 1: He was hot, yeah.
00:06:14
Speaker 2: So Flav is back and this time it's one called Resveratrol, which is one of those things that you're going to see in supplements, in skincare. Can't cross the skin barrier, by the way. It's too big a molecule. But it does actually, particularly in a petri dish, have some anti-inflammatory properties. And certainly some studies of that, you know the Mediterranean diet? Yes.
00:06:35
Speaker 1: Yeah.
00:06:36
Speaker 2: So that's the diet that's had by different communities that live around the Mediterranean Sea. A lot of them do have a glass of red wine every night. So it was sort of included in some Mediterranean diets. The thing is, it's kind of fallen out of favor a little bit because when you look at the data and you tease apart the food and the customs of the Mediterranean diet from the wine itself, it doesn't look like the wine is adding anything. In Australia, the guidelines are 10 standard drinks for both men and women. I'm pretty sure- Not a night? Well, a week.
00:07:10
Speaker 1: Okay. Sorry.
00:07:11
Speaker 3: Sorry.
00:07:11
Speaker 2: So you can't have one night then. Well, you could get up to one a night. You're meant to have two alcohol-free days a week within that 10.
00:07:20
Speaker 1: Okay.
00:07:20
Speaker 2: And just a reminder of two things. When it comes to red wine, a standard drink is 100 mils. That is not what you get at a pub or a restaurant. They generally give you 150 to 180 mils. So 100 mils is when you go to the waiter. That's a bit of a stingy pour. That is actually– The standard drink.
00:07:37
Speaker 1: But you might not be technically pouring if you're at home alone.
00:07:40
Speaker 2: Well, if you have a bottle of wine, just to do some quick maths on this, a bottle is 750 mils. So work out how long it takes you to finish a bottle of wine. Because if you and your husband are polishing off a bottle of wine in a night, you're basically having three and three quarters standard drinks in a night. Like that's a lot. And the National Health and Medical Research Council says that four standard drinks in a single day is a binge. And associated with all sorts of bad health outcomes. So you don't want to be doing that. Even if you went through a bottle
of wine on your own in, let's say, three nights, you're still, don't forget, it's 750 mils divided by three is 250 mils. That's two and a half standard drinks a day. It's again more than what we would recommend. So that's just the first thing. The second thing to remember is that I think drinking can really sneak up on you. And what can start as one cheeky pour can end up at a really big problem very, very quickly. So I would say if you are the sort of person who can have 100 mils of wine a night, five nights a week. So if you're just having one standard drink, five nights a week, I think you're probably okay. But if you're having more than that, it might be worth now keeping a diary and actually working out. Do you have a problem?
00:09:00
Speaker 1: Maybe not worth the antioxidants. After this break, we're going to get some real helpful advice on sleep, my favorite thing in the world. And why are we not getting as much as we need? We'll be right back.
00:09:21
Speaker 3: My sleep's so bad, I can't function at work. I need solutions that work fast. I'm not depressed. I'm just not sleeping at all. Between the night sweats, the 3 a.m. wake-ups, and the racing heart that comes out of nowhere, I may be getting three or four broken hours a night. I've been running on fumes for months. I've tried melatonin. I've tried meditation apps. I've tried going to bed earlier. Nothing touches it. My doctor just said, it's perimenopause, like that explains everything and sent me on my way. But here's what's keeping me up now. I have a performance review in three weeks and I can't think straight. I'm snippy with my team. I lose exhausted because I am exhausted. For those of you who've been through this, what actually worked?
00:10:15
Speaker 1: I am desperate. And honestly, I'm a little scared. That's horrible, isn't it, to listen to? I really feel for our listener. That is horrendous.
00:10:25
Speaker 2: I just think there's a bit to unpack here because I always think that there are things that you can control and things you can't control. So having a performance review in three weeks is going to happen and we can't control that. But oh my goodness, perimenopause, you totally can control. Number two... You need to get checked out. I don't get where the doctor's coming from saying that your racing heart does not need any further investigation. I would be going back and just going, hang on, do I need to go to a cardiologist? Is there something actually happening with my heart that we might need to fix? Where I think we have a major issue is that three and a half to four hours of sleep in total per night very quickly becomes very, catastrophic for your brain, increased risk of workplace accidents, particularly if you work like with machinery, falling off a ladder, like that kind of thing can really happen. You're going to make major mistakes at work. You're already finding that is happening. Driving is really, really dangerous for you. Like it's having a blood alcohol of some enormous level when you're getting to this lower sleep. So it is fairly urgent. If you were sitting in my surgery, and just a reminder, I'm not your doctor. You've got to go talk about this with your doctor who knows you really well. But I would be unpacking things. I'd be making sure that I'm ruling out, let's say, a thyroid condition that's giving you palpitations or heart disease or even sleep apnea or something like that that's actually physically wrecking your sleep. I think there's probably an element of perimenopause there just because of the hot flushes coming on with the palpitations. We know 42% of women in PERI do get palpitations. And then if it is PERI, which, by the way, there's no blood test for that. We've just got to listen to you and take a really, really detailed history of before we can call it, if it is that, we have treatment. We have hormonal treatments that we can give you that are going to pretty much do a lot to help you super, super, super quickly. I think short-term, when I'm looking at a patient like this where it's catastrophic and we need to put some sleep back into the sleep bank that has now been run so far into overdraft that we have some issues, I would even consider a short-term sleeping medication even just on the weekends, just to catch up while we're trying to implement the new strategies. Because by the time you get into the doctor, they've ruled everything else out. They've done the thyroid test. Your performance review is now in the rear view mirror and you might now have lost your role. So this is now catastrophic and we need to sort you out. I would probably give you a short-term sleeping pill just for the weekends, just for Friday, Saturday night, just in case you feel a bit hung over the next morning, just to make sure you are okay and can function again. And I would take everything off your plate that does not need to be there while we're trying to get through this medical emergency kind of situation. And then I'd also be treating your, if we do work out that it's peri, I'd be treating that really, really quickly because you're going to feel less anxious. By the time you get to that performance review, we're going to have taken this down from a nine out of 10 catastrophe to at least a five out of 10. It's not going to cure everything, but we can certainly bring it down a notch. Kath, have you ever got this bad?
00:13:28
Speaker 1: Yeah, I have a few times. I mean, and I'm awful without my sleep. All the wheels fall off. I don't want to exercise in the morning. I'm snappy with my son. You're brain foggy. You're anxious. You're drinking the coffee in the morning to try and wake up. Then you're drinking too much coffee, which is impacting your night time. It's horrendous. So I really feel for our listener because you just can't achieve anything.
00:13:52
Speaker 2: I am so grateful that she wrote in. Mm-hmm. if this feels any better, I probably see one of you every day in my surgery,
like at least one person like this. And often my patients have got elderly sick parents, a child who might be neurodivergent, who's still in their bed three, four times a night, and we can't do anything. It can be really difficult. And I wanted to thank you for sharing and bringing this to Unleashed, to Burning Questions, because there's so many people who can relate to this and it's a Great, great, great question to ask. Thank you.
00:14:24
Speaker 1: Ginny, so if everything else has been ruled out, what could the sleep situation be down to?
00:14:29
Speaker 2: Assuming that there was no hormonal cause, because I think there's clearly something hormonal going on for our listener. If you are a lifelong, terrible sleeper, then the best thing that we know by far is something called cognitive behavioral therapy for insomnia. We've spoken about it before on Well... I refer a lot of people to.
00:14:49
Speaker 1: So tell me about it again for the listeners, because I'm perimenopausal.
00:14:52
Speaker 2: I've forgotten. So cognitive behavioral therapy is one of the core tools that psychologists use to reframe your thinking about things. And it says that a lot of the ways you feel are led by the way you think about things. And some of your negative thoughts are actually leading your brain astray and giving you feelings that you feel like you can't control. So it puts you back in the driver's seat a little bit. And there's an adapted form of cognitive behavioral therapy specifically for insomnia. And it gives you all the sleep hygiene, addresses all of your negative beliefs about sleep and how it affects you and what kind of sleeper you are. But this is not for somebody who's in a catastrophic situation that's been going on for a all their life. I see these people all the time and it's not a sprint, it's a marathon. You are a turtle in that situation rather than a hare. And so you are actually going to be doing courses. I prescribe a lot of online CBTI, which is free. I can send you a program for free, but that might take months to actually implement that. And I don't think it's appropriate for our listener. I think she's in a catastrophic situation where she needs some urgent medical help.
00:16:03
Speaker 1: ASAP.
00:16:04
Speaker 2: Now, Do I pull out sleeping pills for most people? Very, very, very rare. But I look at this poor woman whose life is literally falling apart around her because of her sleep. And you would not be human if you did not think, I've got a tool in my tool belt that can help you. I think she just needs some help. And for that kind of person, I am going to help her if I can. And we will deal with the rest of it in time. But I'm certainly never... going to, for this patient, go, right, let's put you into a CBT-I course and let's hope in three months. Just take things slow.
00:16:38
Speaker 3: Yeah.
00:16:38
Speaker 2: So let's see what happens in three months time. She might've had a car accident by then and have broken a bone. So like, no, we need to help her. So when we look at temporary fixes, whether there are over the counter remedies like doxylamine, which is a kind of an antihistamine that has sedation as a side effect, or a prescribed sleeping pill that works on certain parts of your brain and helps you sleep. They put a little bit of petrol into a tank that's run completely dry. Why doctors don't love them permanently is for a couple of reasons. Number one, it's not addressing the long-term issue. If you have a long-term sleeping issue, you would be better off with cognitive behavioral therapy for insomnia. So it's not addressing the underlying issue. The second thing is in the case of the prescribed sleeping pills that are called benzodiazepines, they are addictive. And what I mean by addictive then is not I'm addicted to my phone. but it actually needs to have two parts to it. Tolerance. So what worked yesterday no longer works today. I need two pills. I used to be fine on one pill. Now I need two. And then dependence. You have a night off from it and you don't sleep a wink. You just stare at the ceiling all night. So we just do not want to get you into an addictive situation. They are short-term. And the third thing is they actually don't allow you a proper sleep cycle with REM sleep, non-REM sleep, deep sleep, light sleep. And that circadian rhythm where you have a normal sleep cycle is very essential to good brain functioning. So long-term, to avoid brain-related issues, we don't want any pills that are going to disrupt your natural circadian rhythms. We would much rather you get into a situation where you can help yourself to sleep. That's where CBTI is brilliant, but it's just not what we need right now. What about melatonin? I have a lot of friends who use it.
00:18:25
Speaker 1: When you're overseas, it's very easy to get over the counter. Where does that fit into this and could it possibly help the listener?
00:18:32
Speaker 2: It may, and some people find it super, super, super helpful and some people find it useless. So we know that brain levels of melatonin, which are produced by your brain at night when the lights go out and are turned off by any bright lights, mainly sunlight, it does help you to sleep. And we know that levels naturally drop around perimenopause. And that's why so many women do turn to melatonin supplements to supplement their own natural melatonin levels. The problem is that we don't have really good evidence in perimenopause.
00:19:04
Speaker 1: All right, coming up after the break, we're going to arm you with what you need to say in the consultation room. All right, before we get to how to ask for what you need in the consultation room, we have some quick burning questions to pick your brain on, Ginny. Here is what the listeners want to know from you rather than a search engine. Number one, can you improve your metabolism in your 50s?
00:19:36
Speaker 2: Yes. Oh my goodness. So many of my patients are so worried about their
weight and they ask about increasing their metabolism all the time. You kind of do need a better diet. A lot of my patients who think they've got a great diet don't, and they're very, very carby. So don't forget, you need plenty of fiber, you need plenty of protein. And if you really want to boost your metabolism, you need plenty of skeletal muscle. So that's the stuff on your arms and legs. So resistance exercise, I know it feels like so much judgment, but it is going to boost your metabolism.
00:20:05
Speaker 1: I literally went back to the gym this week for the first time in 12 months. So I am taking your advice, Ginny. Is it too late to do something about my pelvic floor LBL? And where do I start? What's an LBL?
00:20:18
Speaker 2: Light bladder leakage. Oh, jeez. That's common. Is it too late? No, is the simple question. Just make sure you get to your doctor immediately. to make sure that the kind of bladder leakage you have is the sort that will respond to pelvic floor exercises. So if you have a little bit of wee come out when you are jumping, running for the bus, sneezing, coughing, that is going to respond really, really well. But if you're the sort of person who sits in my surgery every day and instead it's like I just stood up and wee came out, what the hell is going on? Or I thought about needing to go to the toilet and then all of a sudden it started to come out. Or I'm weeing like three times a night, what's going on there? That is a different type of light bladder leakage. It's actually nothing to do with your pelvic floor, all to do with an overactive bladder. And actually, if you make your pelvic floor too tight, you can make that type worse. I know this is just so mind-blowing for women, but what we want to make sure is that if you have that second type, which we call urge incontinence, as opposed to stress incontinence, the coughing and sneezing one, that you talk to your doctor, make sure you address constipation and Do a medication check because a lot of them have that as a side effect. Make sure you don't have too much caffeine or too many fizzy drinks. And then we do some bladder retraining. But actually, I've had patients whose physio has made that one worse.
00:21:40
Speaker 1: I think we might need to do a deep dive into that one.
00:21:42
Speaker 2: Yeah, let's do a deep dive.
00:21:42
Speaker 1: Let's do another one. Because I think I have a lot of questions. And while I was doing my pelvic floor then when you were saying that, then I stopped because I was like, maybe I have the second one. Final question. Your penultimate tip for vaginal dryness, please. I love saying vaginal dryness.
00:21:59
Speaker 2: I know. I know. I love a dry vagina. Ladies, can we just get it checked by the doctor? Don't assume anything. Because we know that women won't bring this problem to their doctors, even in the middle of a menopause consultation.
00:22:09
Speaker 1: Took me a long time to talk about it with my doctor.
00:22:11
Speaker 2: Even to a woman, we just don't talk about it. Only 7% of women ever mention it who have this issue, which is close to like 65% at the start of menopause. It gets worse from there. There are treatment options available, but it's important to have the symptoms assessed first, as other conditions can cause similar problems. Something like lichen sclerosis, which we'll talk about again in another episode, but it's more common than you think. It's white patches on the vulva and untreated. That has a 5% chance of becoming cancerous. Plus, it's very, very, very unpleasant. And the treatment approach may be different. So just please, I know it's really awkward, but we do need to get it checked first.
00:22:49
Speaker 1: All right, well, we have covered a lot today, haven't we, Ginny?
00:22:51
Speaker 2: So much. It's been crazy.
00:22:53
Speaker 1: So we want to end each episode with some practical advice on how you can ask your doctor for a test, advice, or to explain your symptoms. So, Ginny, let's start with sleep. If our listeners want to investigate their sleep, what should they be saying? What are the doctor's orders this week?
00:23:10
Speaker 2: I think if you don't know how to talk about it, just do a sleep diary and come in and show your doctor and go, I want to talk about my sleep. Here's what's been happening. And I think this is an easy one because it's not that awkward.
00:23:20
Speaker 1: Okay, good job.
00:23:21
Speaker 3: All right.
00:23:21
Speaker 1: So Ginny, we talked about alcohol and units earlier on. If somebody is concerned they might be drinking too much, would you also suggest that they might want to take a sort of an alcohol diary to see their doctor?
00:23:33
Speaker 2: Yeah, or you can just come out and say it. I think there are so many people who either feel like they want to be friends with their doctor or that what they have is so darkly shameful that no one else has ever in the history of ever come to their doctor and explain the same thing. I wish you could sit in my surgery all day. Alcohol problems? Every day. Like literally every day. There's nothing that I see that I go, oh, that's weird. You're a strange person. Don't really want you in here anymore. It's just really, really common. And I promise you, your doctor has heard it all before. I think any doctor who makes anybody feel awkward with anything, whether it's a rash or an STI or drinking too much, I think you might need to change doctors. I don't think it really matters what the issue is. If you can't be honest with your doctor and say what's going on, And if you feel judged, out of there in a hurry, because I think this is not helpful.
00:24:23
Speaker 1: Vaginal dryness. I mean, I'm an oversharer, as you know, but it definitely took me a long time to bring it up with my doctor. I was embarrassed. I'm like, why?
00:24:32
Speaker 2: If it's hard for you, that means that 99.9% of our listeners are going to find it even harder.
00:24:39
Speaker 1: Again.
00:24:40
Speaker 2: I have seen more vaginas than the average football player. Sorry to tell that to the ex-wife of a football player, but he's seen a few. To me, when I'm looking at a vagina, I'm looking at a throat or I'm looking at a rash. I don't really think about it in that way. Your doctor has seen a lot of vaginas. I know a lot of women think the absolute last thing that I ever want to talk about or pull out and show anybody is that vagina. Do you know nine out of 10 of my patients apologize before I have to do like a pap test or a, a vaginal examination. I'm like, oh my goodness, I've never seen ever a vagina that has made me think, I really need a break from this job. Like, it's so fine. I really don't care. Your doctor is like that. I absolutely promise you. And you've got to think about getting your needs met. Unfortunately, your doctor is the gatekeeper to you getting your needs met. So it might just be really hard, but just close your eyes and say it because there's no other way you're going to actually get this problem solved.
00:25:39
Speaker 1: Thank you for joining us for our first Burning Questions. What do you think? How did it feel? Well, good. I mean, as always, I'm learning on the job, which I love. I'm 51, still learning.
00:25:52
Speaker 2: How good are the Unleashes? Just sending in such great questions. They were awesome. Like every one I thought was literally what I see on a daily basis.
00:26:00
Speaker 1: And if you're listening, anything, anything you want to know in the health space, send it in because I will not know the answers, but Dr. Ginny will.
00:26:09
Speaker 2: And Kath will probably say, I hard relate to.
00:26:12
Speaker 1: Everything that you send in. And then when we finish recording, I'll go, Ginny, do you think I've got this? What's Kath got this week?
00:26:20
Speaker 2: Okay, guys, this podcast is general information only, and it's not a substitute for advice from your own doctor. I'm a doctor. And I'm not your doctor.
00:26:28
Speaker 1: This episode came about because we did a shout-out on our Unleashed Instagram. We sure did, yeah. This episode will not exist unless you guys send in your questions. And they can be totally anonymous.
00:26:39
Speaker 2: Oh, yeah. You don't have to send us your name.
00:26:41
Speaker 1: No. I mean, if you want a voice note, we can re-voice them. We can do everything.
00:26:45
Speaker 2: I do love a voice note. But you can just... Either slide into our DMs and just send us a question that way as well.
00:26:51
Speaker 1: Our Instagram, unleashed.show. You can also look at our show notes and reach out any way that you want. We will be back in your ears for the silly, laughy version of Unleashed on Tuesday.
00:27:02
Speaker 2: So what do we say?
00:27:04
Speaker 1: See you next Tuesday.
00:27:05
Speaker 3: Bye.
00:27:05
Speaker 1: Mamma Mia acknowledges the traditional owners of land and waters that this podcast is recorded on.