전사 🔗
WEBVTT
00:00:13.279 --> 00:00:41.636
Remembers the Pulse nightclub attack 10 years ago in Orlando with tributes to gay victims when they should be warning you about your own safety on America's 250th anniversary today on The Tenth Man This morning, ABC News Good Morning America First Look, that's a half-hour show that comes on at, like, 5:00 AM.
00:00:41.805 --> 00:00:45.426
It's a good, uh, short, concise, uh, picture of the news.
00:00:45.926 --> 00:00:59.886
But they did a First Look today on the 10th anniversary of the Pulse nightclub shooting in Orlando, and they called it an attack on a gay nightclub, and that pretty much was their whole story.
00:01:00.356 --> 00:01:02.536
As far as they're concerned, that is the whole story.
00:01:03.945 --> 00:01:05.915
CNN ran, ran a piece as well.
00:01:05.915 --> 00:01:12.225
I didn't watch it, I actually read it, and it's the same thing, an attack on a gay nightclub.
00:01:13.786 --> 00:01:20.665
Now, the CNN piece is actually worth pausing on for a moment because they did something interesting.
00:01:21.965 --> 00:01:39.346
They wrote that Pulse was the most violent terrorist attack on American soil since September 11th, and they used the word terrorist one time in a subordinate clause.
00:01:39.365 --> 00:01:41.605
That's what the English teachers would call it.
00:01:42.566 --> 00:01:53.566
And then they spent the rest of the piece talking about LGBTQ+ grief, survivor recovery, and memorial being built in Orlando.
00:01:55.365 --> 00:01:57.305
And the memorial, that's not a bad thing.
00:01:57.305 --> 00:02:00.396
The Senate had a resolution, I believe, as well,'cause it was terrorism.
00:02:00.396 --> 00:02:04.885
But in their reporting, the word Islam does not appear.
00:02:06.275 --> 00:02:08.015
ISIS does not appear.
00:02:09.455 --> 00:02:30.336
The 911 call that Omar Mateen, yeah, it wasn't Sean Douglas, it was Omar Mateen, that he made during the attack while people were dying around him, in which he pledged allegiance to the Islamic State, to ISIS, that also does not appear.
00:02:32.026 --> 00:02:33.765
So they know it was terrorism.
00:02:33.855 --> 00:02:34.776
They said so.
00:02:35.596 --> 00:02:46.885
They just decided that that was the one detail that didn't need developing, and 10 years later, that editorial decision is still intact.
00:02:48.425 --> 00:02:50.026
So that's what we're gonna talk about today.
00:02:51.445 --> 00:02:55.376
And I guess, uh, this is what I was gonna call a bonus ep- episode.
00:02:55.376 --> 00:03:03.246
We do an episode, we try to do an episode every Monday, and this is a Friday episode, and, uh, uh, my apologies if I don't get it out on time.
00:03:03.246 --> 00:03:06.015
We usually try to launch these at 3:00 PM.
00:03:06.015 --> 00:03:09.195
But that's what we're doing on the anniversary.
00:03:09.336 --> 00:03:15.686
And, uh, oh yeah, tell a friend about The Tenth Man podcast, blah, blah, blah, uh, so we'll keep it going if you do.
00:03:16.825 -->
Load full transcript
00:03:26.735
Now, let me tell you what Pulse actually was, because it's a very different story from what you saw on GMA First Look this morning.
00:03:29.080 --> 00:03:33.080
Omar Mateen walked into a nightclub and killed forty-nine Americans.
00:03:33.919 --> 00:03:35.900
He used a SIG MCX.
00:03:35.900 --> 00:03:37.969
Well, that's a SIG Sauer is the company.
00:03:38.169 --> 00:03:39.409
We call it SIG for short.
00:03:39.919 --> 00:03:47.569
Not an AR-15, which was reported, though you would have a hard time finding that correction if you go looking for it now.
00:03:48.550 --> 00:03:55.699
The specific model didn't survive the news cycle because what the press needed was the category.
00:03:55.719 --> 00:03:57.439
They needed to say it was an AR-15.
00:03:57.979 --> 00:04:06.349
So when it was not, they just stopped talking about it, because it's the category that drives the frenzy about gun legislation.
00:04:07.819 --> 00:04:14.219
But never mind the gun for a moment, because the gun is genuinely the least interesting part of this story.
00:04:15.960 --> 00:04:25.360
While people were bleeding out on the floor around him, Mateen stopped and called nine one one, and he pledged allegiance to ISIS.
00:04:26.720 --> 00:04:28.259
That's a recorded statement.
00:04:28.339 --> 00:04:30.639
The FBI documented it.
00:04:31.879 --> 00:04:43.949
So right from the start, you have an ISIS attack on American soil, the worst since nine one one, and the press-- nine one one, nine eleven.
00:04:44.129 --> 00:04:49.490
And the press spent the following week explaining why it wasn't really about ISIS.
00:04:49.689 --> 00:04:51.750
It was about his self-loathing.
00:04:51.759 --> 00:05:11.221
It was about, oh, the gun, of course, and it was about American culture, and about toxic masculinity, about anything but the phone call he made while he was conducting this murderous act The framing that replaced those facts went like this.
00:05:12.432 --> 00:05:15.151
Gay Americans were attacked because they were gay.
00:05:16.822 --> 00:05:23.012
And look, uh, that's half true, which makes it completely a lie.
00:05:23.951 --> 00:05:40.122
These were Americans in a public space targeted by a soldier of an organization that murders homosexuals as a matter of settled theology, but also murders Christians and Jews and Yazidis and anyone else who gets in the way.
00:05:41.581 --> 00:05:50.312
The motive was Islamic supremacy, and the vix- victims, victims s-sexuality was incidental to the attacker.
00:05:52.012 --> 00:05:57.942
In fact, here's a fact that didn't make the anniversary coverage since they were focused on the site.
00:05:58.622 --> 00:06:03.192
Before settling on Pulse, Mateen actually scouted Disney Springs.
00:06:04.012 --> 00:06:07.651
Not a gay venue at all, just a crowd.
00:06:07.791 --> 00:06:09.841
The target was Americans.
00:06:10.901 --> 00:06:18.781
The gay nightclub was a target of opportunity, but the press turned it into the point.
00:06:20.651
--> 00:06:37.351
The victim's sexuality was not incidental to the press because hate crime against gay Americans routes the story to domestic culture war, and ISIS attack on American soil, on the other hand, routes it to a place that they didn't wanna go.
00:06:39.947 --> 00:06:46.288
Now, you'll hear the term lone wolf applied to Mateen, and it's applied as a form of lessening.
00:06:46.288 --> 00:06:47.668
It's applied as an excuse.
00:06:47.668 --> 00:06:50.387
It sounds like it means something.
00:06:51.148 --> 00:06:58.807
But what it actually means in practice is that the press can sever the chain of accountability.
00:06:59.658 --> 00:07:01.877
Without a chain, there's no pattern.
00:07:02.447 --> 00:07:11.208
And without a pattern, there's no uncomfortable questions about what we're importing to the United States and where we're importing it from.
00:07:12.838 --> 00:07:16.288
But here's what the press never explains about lone wolf attacks.
00:07:16.947 --> 00:07:21.108
The lone wolf methodology is ISIS' exact doctrine.
00:07:21.817 --> 00:07:22.658
They designed it.
00:07:22.947 --> 00:07:23.767
They promoted it.
00:07:24.348 --> 00:07:36.307
They instructed sympathizers in the West to use whatever weapons they could, anything of any weapon of opportunity, whether it be a car, a knife, or indeed a firearm, just to attack any crowd.
00:07:36.918 --> 00:07:50.538
So no coordination required, no operational contact needed, and then when an attack does happen, ISIS rightfully claims the attacker as their soldier, as they did in this case.
00:07:51.728 --> 00:07:53.877
That's not just opportunism.
00:07:54.187 --> 00:07:57.148
That's the mechanism working exactly as intended.
00:07:57.747 --> 00:08:01.228
Mateen wasn't a lone wolf who happened to like ISIS.
00:08:01.538 --> 00:08:06.747
He was ISIS' distribution model operating inside the United States.
00:08:07.677 --> 00:08:13.838
The franchise doesn't need a direct line to headquarters, and that's the whole point of the franchise.
00:08:15.658 --> 00:08:20.718
Because talking about that chain, here's the chain they never drew for you.
00:08:22.228 --> 00:08:23.997
Pulse was on June 12th.
00:08:25.437 --> 00:08:40.878
32 days later, July 14th, Bastille Day, Mohamed Lahouaiej-Bouhlel drove a 19-ton truck through a crowd celebrating on the waterfront in Nice, France, and killed 86 people.
00:08:41.788 --> 00:08:52.447
It's the same franchise, the same playbook, and the same post-attack claim admission acknowledging him as one of their own from ISIS.
00:08:53.648 --> 00:08:59.168
Now, it's a different continent, a different weapon, but the same organization.
00:09:00.967 --> 00:09:17.577
And then in November, Abdulrazak Ali Artan, a Somali refugee resettled in Minnesota from what would become Ilhan Omar's congressional district, drove his car into a crowd at Ohio State University and attacked people with a butcher knife.
00:09:18.457 --> 00:09:19.618
13 were injured.
00:09:20.988 --> 00:09:25.758
The same chain again, the same inspiration, and the same ISIS claim.
00:09:26.798 --> 00:09:41.187
Ah, but with these two, there was no gun involved, which is probably why you probably remember them less clearly than you do Orlando, because the press will never remind you of those two 10-year anniversaries.
00:09:42.857 --> 00:09:46.548
Three attacks in six months on two continents.
00:09:46.908 --> 00:09:47.238
Hmm.
00:09:47.988 --> 00:09:49.437
And one franchise.
00:09:50.528 --> 00:09:53.368
Now notice how the press handled the geography.
00:09:54.227 --> 00:10:02.717
Nice was covered as a French tragedy, a foreign story, sad, distant, no American implications.
00:10:03.738 --> 00:10:09.538
Pulse was covered as an American gun problem requiring American gun legislation.
00:10:11.048 --> 00:10:19.278
That is a remarkable editorial conclusion given that the same organization directed both attacks within thirty-two days of each other.
00:10:20.827 --> 00:10:25.238
The gun didn't cross the Atlantic, the ideology did.
00:10:26.528 --> 00:10:34.518
But in the press narrative, Europe's tragedy is Europe's business, and America's tragedy is evidence of America's sickness.
00:10:35.548 --> 00:10:36.937
That framing has a name.
00:10:36.937 --> 00:10:51.035
It's called blaming America Now, here's what an honest newsroom would be doing right now on the tenth anniversary of Pulse with July fourth twenty-two days out.
00:10:52.466 --> 00:10:59.035
They would be noting that this franchise has demonstrated a specific appetite for symbolic dates.
00:10:59.846 --> 00:11:04.946
Bastille Day, the French national holiday, was not a coincidence.
00:11:05.905 --> 00:11:07.655
These are not random Tuesdays.
00:11:08.916 --> 00:11:21.346
The press would be asking what the threat posture looks like heading into the most symbolically loaded date on the American calendar this year, in the year we celebrate two hundred and fifty years of independence.
00:11:22.525 --> 00:11:30.846
They would be drawing the line from Orlando to Nice and asking whether that line points anywhere in particular this summer.
00:11:32.605 --> 00:11:37.375
And I don't know whether you've noticed that the Muslim world is not that happy with the US at the moment.
00:11:38.586 --> 00:11:42.676
That's what journalism looks like when it is not managing a narrative.
00:11:43.936 --> 00:11:46.495
But you won't see it on GMA First Look.
00:11:47.355 --> 00:11:48.765
You won't see it on CNN.
00:11:49.875 --> 00:12:08.707
What you'll see is the memorial construction schedule and another conversation about gun laws that wouldn't have stopped a truck in Nice or a knife at Ohio State And that brings us to the anniversary this week of another event that you didn't see on GMA, and won't.
00:12:09.988 --> 00:12:20.327
Because if the press is going to use Pulse to talk about who gets targeted in America and why, there's a parallel case five days earlier that belongs in that conversation.
00:12:21.927 --> 00:12:36.077
On June 7th, 2016, five days before Pulse, a drugged driver plowed his pickup truck into a cycling group called the Chain Gang on a rural highway outside Kalamazoo, Michigan.
00:12:37.577 --> 00:12:40.628
Five people died and two others were injur- injured.
00:12:42.107 --> 00:12:45.347
Four of the dead were active Christians, three of them Catholic.
00:12:46.788 --> 00:12:52.447
This week, ten years later, just a handful of survivors held a quiet memorial ride.
00:12:53.327 --> 00:13:01.988
Local Michigan television covered it, but there's no national story, no presidential statements, and no think pieces.
00:13:03.587 --> 00:13:09.727
Now ask yourself what would have to be different about those five people for Kalamazoo to be wall-to-wall national coverage today.
00:13:11.548 --> 00:13:17.197
If the chain gang had just happened to be a gay cycling club, you know the answer.
00:13:18.557 --> 00:13:26.778
The grief would be identical, the dead would be equally dead, but what changes is whether the victim identity is editorially useful.
00:13:28.337 --> 00:13:37.677
The press has a variable it runs every story through before deciding how much coverage it gets, and Kalamazoo didn't pass the test.
00:13:38.687 --> 00:14:07.094
Pulse did, and the difference between those two outcomes is not the tragedy, it's the narrative What Pulse was, stated plainly, an ISIS franchise attack on American civilians by a domestic actor executing ISIS-designed tactics within an ideological network that was simultaneously running operations in France and would run another one at Ohio State five months later.
00:14:08.604 --> 00:14:13.724
Ten years of anniversary coverage and the burial of the real story is still intact.
00:14:15.004 --> 00:14:17.193
The Nice chain goes unmentioned.
00:14:18.144 --> 00:14:19.823
Ohio State goes unmentioned.
00:14:20.663 --> 00:14:22.134
Kalamazoo goes unmentioned.
00:14:23.394 --> 00:14:42.673
The lone wolf framing, improperly framed, stays in place because that way you don't have a pattern, and a pattern would require an answer to a question the press has decided just not to ask And here's the full chain of accountability the press will not draw.
00:14:43.923 --> 00:14:58.793
Europe spent a century drawing borders across the Middle East, carving up peoples and tribes into nations that were never nations, creating the failed states and grievance cultures that incubate the ideology that produced ISIS.
00:15:00.104 --> 00:15:12.283
Then Europe imported that population instability directly into its own cities, allowed radical enclaves to form and fester, and watched the ideology metastasize inside its own borders.
00:15:13.644 --> 00:15:22.043
And then that ideology, born in Europe, crossed the Atlantic and killed Americans in Orlando.
00:15:23.153 --> 00:15:24.443
That's the chain.
00:15:26.114 --> 00:15:27.964
Europe made the mess.
00:15:28.803 --> 00:15:31.193
Europe exported the mess.
00:15:32.134 --> 00:15:34.724
But America got the body count.
00:15:36.624 --> 00:16:09.274
And the American press responded by demanding that Americans give up their guns, not by asking what European immigration policy had to do with a nightclub in Orlando, not by asking why a Somali refugee resettled in Ilhan Omar's Minnesota was consuming ISIS propaganda and driving into crowds at Ohio State, not by drawing the line from European colonialism to European multiculturalism to European-exported terrorism to American casualties.
00:16:09.653 --> 00:16:10.323
None of that.
00:16:11.374 --> 00:16:12.354
Just the gun.
00:16:13.303 --> 00:16:14.634
Always the gun.
00:16:15.673 --> 00:16:31.166
Because the gun is the one variable in this story that points at America, and pointing at America is what this press does CNN told you this morning that Pulse was the most violent terrorist attack on American soil since 9/11.
00:16:32.046 --> 00:16:32.916
They were right.
00:16:34.076 --> 00:16:39.785
And then they told you it was an attack on a gay nightclub and moved on to the memorial construction schedule.
00:16:41.755 --> 00:16:43.635
That is not journalism.
00:16:44.635 --> 00:17:08.943
That is narrative maintenance, and it is still running this morning, ten years later, without a single correction July 4th is 22 days away The same franchise that chose Bastille Day chose it deliberately Nobody in the mainstream press is going to tell you that, but now you've heard it from The Tenth Man.
00:17:10.493 --> 00:17:11.564
Thank you for listening