전사 🔗
[0:01] Welcome to the e-commerce IP report.
[0:06] Hello, everyone.
[0:07] Welcome back to the e-commerce IP report.
[0:10] Adam Urbanczyk is the principal attorney at AULLC, a Chicago law firm focused on intellectual
[0:16] property litigation, e-commerce disputes, and helping businesses protect their brands in
[0:21] a rapidly evolving marketplace.
[0:23] I'm Sean O'Connor, and today Adam and I are discussing how Schedule A intellectual property
[0:29] lawsuits work in federal court.
[0:33] Hi, Adam.
[0:34] How are you?
[0:35] Hi, Sean.
[0:36] How are you doing?
[0:37] I'm doing pretty well.
[0:38] This is something that admittedly I know nothing about, so I'm looking forward to hearing
[0:43] about it.
[0:45] Let's start with just like defining what is a Schedule A lawsuit, and how does it differ from
[0:50] a typical IP lawsuit?
[0:53] So the Schedule A, the term Schedule A, is eponymous and refers to an exhibit or an attachment
[1:02] to a complaint, you know, a lawsuit will typically begin whether you're in state or federal
[1:07] court with filing a complaint or petition or some other case initiating document.
[1:14] In this context, it's a list of the defendants in the case.
[1:19] The main difference between Schedule A intellectual property lawsuits, and other lawsuits that
[1:25] either don't include a Schedule A, or they don't include an exhibit that has a list of
[1:32] defendants, is that, well, in Schedule A cases, we'll just call them all Schedule A cases
[1:36] where one rights holder, or maybe two rights holders, like an owner and a licensee, are pursuing
[1:45] a group of defendants.
[1:46] It's the fact that there's a, one, a group of defendants, a larger group of defendants
[1:52] usually beyond five.
[1:55] Sometimes they can get up to 100 or cases where there's maybe 250.
[2:00] I think cases like that are that is frequently filed now, but usually there's a number of them.
[2:08] So it's kept the size of the defendant pool, and then the procedural posture, they adopt
[2:14] as a result of those defendants primarily being located overseas and a bit less reachable
[2:24] via a U.S. court judgment.
[2:27] Because of that, the rights holder or council have to take certain additional steps that are
[2:34] not particular to Schedule A cases, but are more involving temporary restraining orders,
[2:42] preliminary injunctions, at the outset of the cases, so that the rights holders can secure
[2:48] some of the equitable relief against the defendants who may likely don't have any assets in
[2:56] the country, they don't have any commercial presence, they're just shipping stuff into
[3:00] the country.
[3:01] So they have to take some different steps to do something about that.
[3:05] Is that why the Schedule A cases are filed in federal court instead of state court because
[3:11] of that international status, or are there other reasons?
[3:16] Well, they're going to be filed in federal courts because the rights that issue are mostly
Load full transcript
going
[3:21] to be coming under federal law.
[3:23] So okay, intellectual property, there are trades secret and trademarks can be protected at
[3:29] state level under different state statutory or common law schemes.
[3:34] But we're talking about IP, we're talking about patents, which are creatures of federal
[3:39] legislation, the US attack, copyrights are federal preachers under the US copyright act.
[3:46] And then trademarks, your trademark law exists at common law state-to-state, every state
[3:52] will have its own common law with respect to trademark and trademark rights and rights
[3:57] about them for competition and deceptive trade practices and things like that.
[4:00] There can be state statutes or there are probably usually a state statutes.
[4:04] In each state that proscribed unlawful behavior about wrongfully identifying products as being
[4:15] genuine when they're not genuine and there are things like that.
[4:18] For the Schedule A cases, the trademark claims are generally going to be brought under the
[4:22] Lanem act specifically, which is US federal legislation.
[4:26] It isn't, you know, there is federal trademark infringement, that is infringement of a federally
[4:32] registered trademark.
[4:34] So the filed in federal court because the claims are primarily federal claims.
[4:40] There can be some additional state law claims at a plaintiff can invoke, you know, if you're
[4:46] pursuing defendants for violating your US federal trademark registration, you're probably
[4:50] also bringing a claim under the state deceptive trade practices act claim in the state in which
[4:59] the court sets and there might be a common law trademark infringement, there might be a common
[5:03] law and for a competition type claim to, so yeah, that's why they're in federal court
[5:08] for the most part.
[5:09] I see.
[5:10] Okay.
[5:11] Can you walk us through the timeline?
[5:12] You know, is there a typical Schedule A timeline from, you know, from the day it's filed
[5:17] to, you know, resolution?
[5:19] I, perhaps ideally there is and it might be a bit more prescribed, proscribed or prescribed.
[5:26] You know, the case will be filed, a complaint will be filed that'll initiate the lawsuit
[5:32] and usually either the same day, depending on the court you're filing into, whether it's
[5:38] being sealed or not or how it's being sealed, a motion for entry of a temporary restraining
[5:42] order will probably be filed contemporaneous with the complaint.
[5:47] That'll be supported by a declaration from like an investigator or some representative from
[5:53] the plaintiff who can attest to the veracity of the evidence that's being submitted and what
[5:58] relevance it has and what it's showing.
[6:01] At this, usually at about the same time motion for, for leave to serve the defendants with
[6:07] process and other documents in the case electronically, that is via email or some form of email, the
[6:13] email might have attachments or might just include a URL to a public facing web page that
[6:20] will have the case materials on the page.
[6:23] That will be filed at the outset too, and a declaration from the attorney who, or the attorney
[6:31] or an investigator who may have done some research into trying to locate where the defendants
[6:37] are based on publicly available information, usually taking from the defendant's storefronts
[6:43] on Amazon or Team World War, World, or whatever, that'll be filed as well.
[6:48] So the case is a bit front loaded, there's a complaint obviously, some supporting documentation,
[6:54] if there's a, you know, whatever the patent debt issue is, that'll be submitted.
[6:59] The identity of the rights at issue are filed under seal.
[7:04] The defendant list is the filed under seal too.
[7:07] The rights holders don't want that information being public when you file something and federal
[7:13] courts is, you know, by default, going to be publicly accessible, you can petition the
[7:18] court for leave to file certain things under seal that are sensitive.
[7:21] In this case, there is a significant seller community in China and elsewhere that monitor
[7:27] paste or dockets and other filings to see which way the one's blowing.
[7:33] And if they're tipped off, that some rights are about to be enforced where they might be restrained
[7:38] by something, they may take some actions that can visionate the rights holders' attempts
[7:43] to secure it's, you know, the equitable relief it's entitled to under rule 65 or otherwise.
[7:49] So that sensitive stuff is filed under seal, usually.
[7:56] And then it's plopped in for the court.
[7:58] And then the court will take some time to review everything.
[8:01] And then if things work out for the rights holder, the court will enter a temporary restraining
[8:05] order that will look at the evidence that's submitted by the plaintiff, determine if there's
[8:13] a likelihood of success in the merits.
[8:15] If that's the case, and it doesn't look like the evidence is too old for the most part,
[8:20] the court will grade the TRO.
[8:23] That's good for 14 days to start with the order that, the order that, well, the temporary
[8:31] restraining order, the order that enjoins the offending uses by the defendants that will
[8:35] usually also allow for some expedited discovery to take place.
[8:40] So the plaintiff gets the order, will send that to Amazon or Walmart, will get the sales
[8:46] and other identifying information from the platform, who the defendants are.
[8:50] And then they'll use that to serve them with process.
[8:53] That process can take a few weeks, perhaps, depending on how responsive the platform is.
[8:59] Often, if it looks like that information is not all coming back in the 14 day period that
[9:05] the TRO is initially good for, the rights holder can extend that for another 14 days, at which
[9:10] point it sort of de facto turns into a preliminary junction.
[9:14] But before too
long, the plaintiff will move the court to convert that TRO into a full
[9:20] pledge preliminary injunction for the same basic reasons.
[9:24] It's eventually will serve the defendants with process.
[9:27] That starts 21-day clock from ticking by, after that's over with, if the defendants don't
[9:33] show up, the plaintiff will move to fault them, more or less.
[9:38] And then meanwhile, once the TRO is affected, the defendants will show up, they'll raise their
[9:43] territories disputes.
[9:45] If they have some most of the time, if they're showing up at all, it's usually to negotiate
[9:48] some kind of a settlement.
[9:52] And then, I would say, a smooth sailing schedule A case wherein the plaintiff has strong rights.
[10:02] The defendants set isn't overbroad.
[10:05] There isn't some fair use argument that the plaintiff vanishes it if they use to raise.
[10:12] There's nothing to do.
[10:14] The plaintiff has test bias into the jurisdiction.
[10:17] There's not going to be a slew of 12 B2 motions, things like that.
[10:23] By the time you file the case, TROs entered, maybe in a week, that's good for 14 days.
[10:30] Pulmonary injunctions is entered, say, three, four weeks after that.
[10:38] The defendants served that about that time, 21 days go by.
[10:43] And for entry of default and default judgment is teed up right after that on the 22nd day.
[10:48] And then that that's entered, maybe in a month.
[10:52] So it could be as quick as a few months, if it's very, very cleat.
[10:57] That's probably my minority of cases in which that is because often defendants will show up
[11:01] and file motions for an extension of time while they can negotiate without, you know, they want
[11:07] to, they want some additional time to negotiate settlement without having to file any answer
[11:10] or some other motion practice under rule.
[11:12] Right. So minimum three months and more typically.
[11:16] Yeah. I think if you're in, as a writer, if you're in and out in three months, that's, that's a pretty good.
[11:21] What about, you know, you mentioned earlier in the, when we were talking about the schedule, you know,
[11:26] several names, two hundreds of, of defendants named.
[11:31] Why? Why is that the nature of these cases?
[11:35] Is it because there's just vast networks of sellers or what comes into play there?
[11:41] There can be vast networks of sellers.
[11:44] Absolutely.
[11:46] In any particular case, if you have a, a scheduling case and there are 100 defendants is every single
[11:55] one of those defendants interrelated with every single other defendant, that might be difficult
[12:02] or impossible to establish.
[12:04] Mm-hmm.
[12:05] Are those 30, that 12, those six guys, are they together?
[12:16] Maybe that's it.
[12:18] You know, the peculiarity of schedule, like cases or what is related to the nature of the defendants
[12:26] in the case, we're talking about parties who are ostensibly located in China, usually, sometimes
[12:34]
out of Israel or Vietnam or Thailand or something.
[12:37] Sure.
[12:38] But it can be very difficult to get confirmation of who the defendants actually are.
[12:48] And it's, it may not be practicable to go send people overseas to knock on doors and conduct these investigations to figure out exactly what's going on.
[12:57] Usually, the defendants, if it's not an individual, it's going to be a limited company, sort of like a sole proprietorship, that, you know, can't be registered with Chinese, Chinese government entities, but, you know, just because there's something on a database over there saying something doesn't mean that, in fact, is the case sometimes.
[13:23] And the inability to really confirm things, there's sort of an accountability on the other side of the Pacific Ocean.
[13:30] They know few of any people are going to be crossing it to do something about what they were doing over here in the U.S. Interstate Commerce.
[13:38] So they can just kind of sell things in that sit.
[13:41] So as, as a right-solder, even if you're a, you know, if you're a Chinese or, or the foreign right-solder who was pursuing claims here in the United States,
[13:50] you're running up against the same, the same issue. It was confirming, but, basically, who the defendants are, could be a real challenge.
[13:57] Yeah.
[13:58] That's due in large part to the fact that the defendants are not here in the U.S. but not me to be as readily subject to any sort of judgment coming out of a court here, and you just physically go over there and check things out.
[14:13] Yeah.
[14:14] I like the defendants in somewhere in New Jersey, and I know what the address is.
[14:18] I'm going to go over there and not kind of like, so where have you been?
[14:21] Never really do that.
[14:22] At least that, not that easily.
[14:23] Yeah, yeah, yeah.
[14:24] Geography is a major factor.
[14:26] You know, I mean, you've got so much experience with this, and we've just got a couple of minutes left at them.
[14:31] But where do you see schedule a litigation?
[14:34] Like, where have you seen a change?
[14:35] We're more and more importantly, like, where do you think it's at it?
[14:38] What's the trend?
[14:40] Two recent appallia cases.
[14:42] Cangle.
[14:44] Head to do with service of process.
[14:48] And Yenvy Lou, which is, which is a case that we brought on appeal.
[14:54] Which had to do with the, it was a jurisdictional argument.
[14:57] What were, it seems like things are going is that, you know, the courts are still allowing the cases to proceed.
[15:03] But the plaintiffs have a little bit more.
[15:07] T crossing and eye dotting with respect to ensuring that the defendants, even at the outset of the case.
[15:15] Yeah.
[15:16] Are, are properly before the courts personal jurisdiction.
[15:20] And that might involve, you know, that might wind up pushing the situation where, or rights holders are going to have to get test spies for everything.
[15:27] At the outset, if they're looking for.
[15:30] At least you'll pull them in and jump to relief or relief.
[15:34] If they're trying to get a temporary restraining order, we run into situations on the plaintiff's side where.
[15:39] Despite the allegations in the complaint, which are supposed to be taken as true, the court.
[15:44] Suicide in the, the title to do this.
[15:47] Have questions about whether the defendants are subject to the courts personal jurisdiction, because they don't want to let this up.
[15:53] You don't want to enter the, the orders and then have the defendants show up and say, oh, well, we don't have any sales here.
[15:59] So get a side to care, which to be sure we've been on that side.
[16:03] Yeah.
[16:04] Up and down for the last seven years, so we're extremely familiar with, with that happening.
[16:08] So we see that the judge being sort of activist and progressive in the way that they're just asking upfront, well, what evidence do you have right now?
[16:15] Yeah, it was perhaps always the case that if, you know, the plaintiff wanted to be sure they could, at least in the seventh circuit.
[16:24] At least in the seventh circuit going back to NBA properties and other seventh circuit appeals case, they could have just had test buyers of everything.
[16:33] Now, for some cases, it may not be practicable.
[16:36] If you're going after people in fringe, you know, selling knockoff electric bikes, and there's a hundred defendants, are you about order a hundred electric bikes to your office and then assemble them?
[16:47] No, that might be honoris.
[16:50] T-shirts, I guess you could do t-shirts, but this stuff piles up.
[16:54] And if you're a plaintiff's practice, and you have dozens and dozens of cases, you have a lot, some lots of material to sort of.
[17:02] That's kind of the, it's the plaintiff's problem or by extension, it's the plaintiff's attorney's problem, what to do with all that, that's the way around.
[17:11] Of course, our tightening that up, I think they're generally not enjoying attempts to join, attempts to join under rule 20, 50 or 100 defendants as much.
[17:27] So the defendant's sets are a bit more modest, but they're more test purchases.
[17:32] And then did they're requiring the plaintiffs to show a bit more due diligence with respect to ensuring that they're not located anywhere that's reasonably identifiable.
[17:44] So there's not running into a, hey, a hate convention problem.
[17:47] God, that seems to be what's going on in 2026.
[17:50] Got it, got it. Well, hey, we're out of time, but that's a super informative. Thank you.
[17:55] Adam for forgetting into that and I look forward to future conversations.
[18:00] That's it for this episode of the e-commerce IP report. If you want to learn more about Adam Urbanczyk and his practice, visit the website AU-LLC.com.
[18:12] Thanks for listening and don't forget to like, subscribe, and maybe leave a review if you found this episode helpful.
[18:18] I'm Sean O'Connor. Have a great day.
[18:20] Thanks for watching. Be sure to hit that like and subscribe button and leave us a review in the comments.