전사 🔗
WEBVTT
Kind: captions
Language: en-US
00:00:00.400 --> 00:00:02.829
Hi there, thanks for joining us on a Q&A
00:00:02.839 --> 00:00:05.629
edition of Space Nuts and this is where
00:00:05.639 --> 00:00:07.950
we answer audience questions and we've
00:00:07.960 --> 00:00:09.950
got a whole bunch today. We're going to
00:00:09.960 --> 00:00:12.790
talk about the light of a distance star
00:00:12.800 --> 00:00:15.750
a star or the lack of and what happens
00:00:15.760 --> 00:00:17.789
when the star goes out and the light you
00:00:17.799 --> 00:00:19.949
know, where does it go? Do we see it? Do
00:00:19.959 --> 00:00:21.190
we not?
00:00:21.200 --> 00:00:23.149
We'll tell you all about that.
00:00:23.159 --> 00:00:26.229
Black holes versus white holes. That's
00:00:26.239 --> 00:00:27.910
an old chestnut that comes up from time
00:00:27.920 --> 00:00:28.990
to time.
00:00:29.000 --> 00:00:32.510
The massive the earth is
00:00:32.520 --> 00:00:34.030
something that somebody wants to know
00:00:34.040 --> 00:00:36.269
about and we talked about black holes
00:00:36.279 --> 00:00:38.269
and white holes. What about neutrinos
00:00:38.279 --> 00:00:40.390
versus black holes? We'll answer all of
00:00:40.400 --> 00:00:43.670
that or not on this episode of Space
00:00:43.680 --> 00:00:44.309
Nuts.
00:00:44.319 --> 00:00:49.149
15 seconds. Guidance is internal. 10 9
00:00:49.159 --> 00:00:50.949
ignition sequence start.
00:00:50.959 --> 00:00:51.870
Space Nuts.
00:00:51.880 --> 00:00:54.589
5 4 3 2
00:00:54.599 --> 00:00:56.830
1 2 3 4 5 5 4 3 2 1
00:00:56.840 --> 00:00:58.030
Space Nuts.
00:00:58.040 --> 00:01:00.990
It feels so nice to be able to do this.
00:01:01.000 --> 00:01:02.870
Here again to try and solve all of that
00:01:02.880 --> 00:01:04.868
is Professor Fred Watson astronomer at
00:01:04.878 --> 00:01:06.629
large. Hi Fred.
00:01:06.639 --> 00:01:09.350
Nice to see you again Andrew.
00:01:09.360 --> 00:01:09.909
Fred.
00:01:09.919 --> 00:01:11.269
Still at large as well.
00:01:11.279 --> 00:01:14.110
Yes. I'm less large. I just I've been
00:01:14.120 --> 00:01:16.229
losing weight lately which
00:01:16.239 --> 00:01:18.269
isn't a bad thing. Isn't a bad thing.
00:01:18.279 --> 00:01:19.229
Okay.
00:01:19.239 --> 00:01:21.509
I'm back to manageable levels.
00:01:21.519 --> 00:01:23.110
Well, that's good. Well, congratulations
00:01:23.120 --> 00:01:23.350
on that.
00:01:23.360 --> 00:01:25.070
Thank you. Yeah, I think it's the first
00:01:25.080 --> 00:01:27.269
time in a decade I've been under 80
00:01:27.279 --> 00:01:29.150
kilos.
00:01:29.160 --> 00:01:31.189
Oh, that's
00:01:31.199 --> 00:01:32.189
that's quite light.
00:01:32.199 --> 00:01:32.750
Yeah.
00:01:32.760 --> 00:01:34.790
For somebody of your height.
00:01:34.800 --> 00:01:37.189
It's about right for my height.
00:01:37.199 --> 00:01:38.229
Okay.
00:01:38.239 --> 00:01:39.150
But
00:01:39.160 --> 00:01:43.430
yeah, it's taken a while but by design
00:01:43.440 --> 00:01:45.070
slow and steady is the way to do it.
00:01:45.080 --> 00:01:46.150
That's a great thing.
00:01:46.160 --> 00:01:47.790
I took my sweet time about it. That's
00:01:47.800 --> 00:01:50.229
for sure.
00:01:50.239 --> 00:01:52.869
All right. We've got some questions to
00:01:52.879 --> 00:01:54.229
deal with. Do you want to hear the first
00:01:54.239 --> 00:01:55.390
one?
00:01:55.400 --> 00:01:58.990
I could I could say let me guess but um
00:01:59.000 --> 00:02:00.682
might hear it instead.
00:02:00.692 --> 00:02:02.442
This comes from Billy.
00:02:02.452 --> 00:02:05.482
Professor Watson, Andrew, Billy Gerard
00:02:05.492 --> 00:02:08.522
here in New Jersey on the great old big
00:02:08.532 --> 00:02:11.722
old USA. I I got a quick question. Let's
00:02:11.732 --> 00:02:13.762
just say hypothetically we are looking
00:02:13.772 --> 00:02:16.122
at a star that's a billion light-years
00:02:16.132 --> 00:02:18.522
away. And we're So so theoretically
00:02:18.532 --> 00:02:20.082
we're looking back in time a billion
00:02:20.092 --> 00:02:21.962
years. Now, hypothetically let's just
00:02:21.972 --> 00:02:25.122
say that one day that star just goes
00:02:25.132 --> 00:02:28.442
out. It stops shining.
00:02:28.452 --> 00:02:31.242
Like would we still see that star for
00:02:31.252 --> 00:02:32.802
like would like does that light that's
00:02:32.812 --> 00:02:35.122
on its way to us keep coming? Like would
00:02:35.132 --> 00:02:37.322
it take a billion years before we saw it
00:02:37.332 --> 00:02:39.722
go out? How does that work? Help me
00:02:39.732 --> 00:02:41.722
understand that. Finally love you guys
00:02:41.732 --> 00:02:43.602
love you both love the podcast love
00:02:43.612 --> 00:02:45.122
hearing you and uh
00:02:45.132 --> 00:02:46.962
like boy I go all the way I've been
00:02:46.972 --> 00:02:48.042
listening to you guys for a really long
00:02:48.052 --> 00:02:50.002
time. So I really appreciate the podcast
00:02:50.012 --> 00:02:51.642
and everything you do. And thanks so
00:02:51.652 --> 00:02:54.882
much for taking the call. Billy Gerard
00:02:54.892 --> 00:02:59.042
here in uh New Jersey US of A.
00:02:59.052 --> 00:03:01.242
Thank you, Billy. Uh so lovely to hear
00:03:01.252 --> 00:03:02.522
from you and I'm glad you've been a
00:03:02.532 --> 00:03:04.362
long-term listener and uh
00:03:04.372 --> 00:03:06.162
glad you finally got through to us with
00:03:06.172 --> 00:03:07.482
a question.
00:03:07.492 --> 00:03:09.122
Uh this this sort of
00:03:09.132 --> 00:03:10.962
uh is the same or similar to the
00:03:10.972 --> 00:03:13.562
question that we had recently the
00:03:13.572 --> 00:03:15.482
hypothetical about the sun suddenly
00:03:15.492 --> 00:03:17.762
switching off and how much light we
00:03:17.772 --> 00:03:20.242
would see. Like if if it switched off
00:03:20.252 --> 00:03:22.002
right now
00:03:22.012 --> 00:03:24.322
we wouldn't see that happen for another
00:03:24.332 --> 00:03:26.442
8 and a bit minutes 8 minutes
Load full transcript
20 seconds
00:03:26.452 --> 00:03:27.722
or something to that effect.
00:03:27.732 --> 00:03:28.402
Exactly.
00:03:28.412 --> 00:03:30.642
It's the same for stars all over the
00:03:30.652 --> 00:03:32.802
universe, is it not?
00:03:32.812 --> 00:03:33.322
Yes, it is.
00:03:33.332 --> 00:03:34.642
Except that it'll be longer than 8
00:03:34.652 --> 00:03:35.602
minutes and 20 seconds.
00:03:35.612 --> 00:03:37.402
That's That's right. So it's the same
00:03:37.412 --> 00:03:40.002
principle that light
00:03:40.012 --> 00:03:43.442
travels at that rapid speed of 300,000
00:03:43.452 --> 00:03:44.922
km
00:03:44.932 --> 00:03:49.002
per second or in units that um anybody
00:03:49.012 --> 00:03:51.602
in the USA will understand, 1 ft in a
00:03:51.612 --> 00:03:53.002
billionth of a second.
00:03:53.012 --> 00:03:53.442
Ooh.
00:03:53.452 --> 00:03:55.242
Uh
00:03:55.252 --> 00:03:57.002
So yeah, that's quite convenient
00:03:57.012 --> 00:03:59.042
actually that it's a foot in a billionth
00:03:59.052 --> 00:04:00.442
of a second.
00:04:00.452 --> 00:04:04.204
Um So yes, so that's the exactly how it
00:04:04.214 --> 00:04:06.004
works. I mean, there's a there's always
00:04:06.014 --> 00:04:11.604
the analog of um, you know, sound. We We
00:04:11.614 --> 00:04:15.044
when we listen to something a a noise
00:04:15.054 --> 00:04:16.444
made by something at a distance, for
00:04:16.454 --> 00:04:18.524
example, uh, lightning. And there was
00:04:18.534 --> 00:04:19.964
plenty of lightning around here last
00:04:19.974 --> 00:04:20.564
night. We had a
00:04:20.574 --> 00:04:22.324
Huge storm last night. I've seen some of
00:04:22.334 --> 00:04:23.444
the footage. Woo.
00:04:23.454 --> 00:04:24.324
Yeah.
00:04:24.334 --> 00:04:26.884
Uh, you get a flash, um, and then it
00:04:26.894 --> 00:04:28.204
takes
00:04:28.214 --> 00:04:30.404
well, it takes sometimes minutes several
00:04:30.414 --> 00:04:32.804
minutes for the uh, sorry, several
00:04:32.814 --> 00:04:35.284
seconds for the sound to reach you. Um,
00:04:35.294 --> 00:04:37.804
and so, if you you know, if the only way
00:04:37.814 --> 00:04:39.204
you knew about this thing was by the
00:04:39.214 --> 00:04:41.644
sound uh, you'd you'd be listening in
00:04:41.654 --> 00:04:43.804
the past, as it were, because of that
00:04:43.814 --> 00:04:46.604
several seconds that it took. Uh, and
00:04:46.614 --> 00:04:48.644
it's true with uh, stars, whether they
00:04:48.654 --> 00:04:49.804
are
00:04:49.814 --> 00:04:51.484
as near as the sun is, and you're
00:04:51.494 --> 00:04:53.644
exactly right, 8 minutes and 20 seconds
00:04:53.654 --> 00:04:55.684
is the light time from the sun to the
00:04:55.694 --> 00:04:57.604
Earth. We wouldn't know anything about
00:04:57.614 --> 00:05:00.204
it until 8 minutes and 20 seconds had
00:05:00.214 --> 00:05:02.684
gone by after the sun had managed to
00:05:02.694 --> 00:05:04.404
disappear or become
00:05:04.414 --> 00:05:07.164
extinct or what whatever. Um, and
as
00:05:07.174 --> 00:05:09.004
we've spoken about before, gravity
00:05:09.014 --> 00:05:10.444
actually would work the same way,
00:05:10.454 --> 00:05:11.844
because gravity
00:05:11.854 --> 00:05:14.164
uh, also our gravitational waves also
00:05:14.174 --> 00:05:15.484
travel at the speed of light.
00:05:15.494 --> 00:05:15.844
Mhm.
00:05:15.854 --> 00:05:16.644
Or
00:05:16.654 --> 00:05:18.764
the impulse of gravity. So, yeah, it's
00:05:18.774 --> 00:05:20.284
uh, it's absolutely right, Billy. You're
00:05:20.294 --> 00:05:22.484
looking back in time, and you're looking
00:05:22.494 --> 00:05:24.644
back in time sometimes a long, long way.
00:05:24.654 --> 00:05:25.484
Um,
00:05:25.494 --> 00:05:26.604
certainly
00:05:26.614 --> 00:05:28.644
the uh, um, you know, the most distant
00:05:28.654 --> 00:05:31.244
things that we can see we're seeing as
00:05:31.254 --> 00:05:32.804
them as they were when the universe was
00:05:32.814 --> 00:05:34.644
only about 300 million years old. So,
00:05:34.654 --> 00:05:36.524
you're looking back almost the whole
00:05:36.534 --> 00:05:38.444
13.8 billion year history of the
00:05:38.454 --> 00:05:41.644
universe, which is staggering, really.
00:05:41.654 --> 00:05:44.644
It is. Uh, and just for the record, uh,
00:05:44.654 --> 00:05:47.604
the furthest star ever detected at this
00:05:47.614 --> 00:05:52.004
point in time is 12.9 billion
00:05:52.014 --> 00:05:53.524
light years from Earth.
00:05:53.534 --> 00:05:55.684
That's right. So, um,
00:05:55.694 --> 00:05:57.844
um, that means, you know, it emitted its
00:05:57.854 --> 00:06:00.124
light when the universe was 900 million
00:06:00.134 --> 00:06:03.244
years old. Um, and I do remember reading
00:06:03.254 --> 00:06:06.125
about that uh, some time ago. We We
00:06:06.135 --> 00:06:07.925
probably covered it on Space Nuts. But
00:06:07.935 --> 00:06:09.165
and the only reason we could see a
00:06:09.175 --> 00:06:11.245
single star is because it's
00:06:11.255 --> 00:06:13.565
gravitationally lensed. It's being
00:06:13.575 --> 00:06:16.005
magnified by the gravitational
00:06:16.015 --> 00:06:18.325
distortion of of a cluster of galaxies
00:06:18.335 --> 00:06:19.925
in front of it. So, we can't see an
00:06:19.935 --> 00:06:21.725
individual star at that distance.
00:06:21.735 --> 00:06:23.645
Yes, we can. But
00:06:23.655 --> 00:06:25.365
I don't I can't remember what the number
00:06:25.375 --> 00:06:27.765
Billy said was 10 billion or
00:06:27.775 --> 00:06:28.525
1 billion.
00:06:28.535 --> 00:06:30.125
Uh yeah, I think he said 10 billion.
00:06:30.135 --> 00:06:32.325
Yeah, so sorry. No, he said a billion.
00:06:32.335 --> 00:06:32.725
So,
00:06:32.735 --> 00:06:35.165
if a star a billion light years away,
00:06:35.175 --> 00:06:38.365
Billy, just suddenly went out right now,
00:06:38.375 --> 00:06:41.845
you'd have to set your watch
00:06:41.855 --> 00:06:44.605
to go off in a billion years,
00:06:44.615 --> 00:06:46.525
basically. Give or
take because of
00:06:46.535 --> 00:06:48.485
gravitational lensing and other other
00:06:48.495 --> 00:06:49.965
effects.
00:06:49.975 --> 00:06:51.965
Um but it would take that long for you
00:06:51.975 --> 00:06:53.845
to see it go out.
00:06:53.855 --> 00:06:55.365
It's It's just hard to get your head
00:06:55.375 --> 00:06:58.005
around that sometimes, isn't it? Um that
00:06:58.015 --> 00:07:00.445
that everything's finite, even light. I
00:07:00.455 --> 00:07:01.805
mean, it's Yeah.
00:07:01.815 --> 00:07:03.045
There's a limit.
00:07:03.055 --> 00:07:04.405
I think what's
00:07:04.415 --> 00:07:06.725
what's more almost more profound is that
00:07:06.735 --> 00:07:09.365
um our view of the universe
00:07:09.375 --> 00:07:10.365
doesn't matter whether you're talking
00:07:10.375 --> 00:07:12.245
about individual stars
00:07:12.255 --> 00:07:15.565
or galaxies or nebulae or whatever, we
00:07:15.575 --> 00:07:18.405
are always looking into the past. So,
00:07:18.415 --> 00:07:20.365
hm, you know, when we look outwards,
00:07:20.375 --> 00:07:22.125
we're just looking further and further
00:07:22.135 --> 00:07:23.805
and further back in time. It's why we
00:07:23.815 --> 00:07:26.645
talk about space-time because space and
00:07:26.655 --> 00:07:30.765
time are so intimately related. Um and
00:07:30.775 --> 00:07:32.165
that means
00:07:32.175 --> 00:07:34.605
because gravity also works on that speed
00:07:34.615 --> 00:07:37.085
limit, um
00:07:37.095 --> 00:07:38.685
there's no point in really thinking
00:07:38.695 --> 00:07:40.205
about things
00:07:40.215 --> 00:07:42.405
in what we might think of as an absolute
00:07:42.415 --> 00:07:44.045
sense where you're looking at the
00:07:44.055 --> 00:07:45.405
universe from outside and seeing
00:07:45.415 --> 00:07:47.725
everything in it happening, uh
00:07:47.735 --> 00:07:50.525
you know, simultaneously, almost. Um
00:07:50.535 --> 00:07:52.045
it's always
00:07:52.055 --> 00:07:54.565
um modified by our view, the fact that
00:07:54.575 --> 00:07:57.165
we are at the center of a an observing
00:07:57.175 --> 00:08:00.205
sphere. It's a we're only a an imaginary
00:08:00.215 --> 00:08:01.725
point, and you know, there's nothing
00:08:01.735 --> 00:08:04.005
significant about where we are. But it
00:08:04.015 --> 00:08:07.647
means that our whole a of observation
00:08:07.657 --> 00:08:10.407
it this time gradient across it, going
00:08:10.417 --> 00:08:12.087
back right to the Big Bang itself, cuz
00:08:12.097 --> 00:08:13.367
we can still see the flash of the Big
00:08:13.377 --> 00:08:15.487
Bang in the cosmic radiation.
00:08:15.497 --> 00:08:16.847
Cosmic background radiation.
00:08:16.857 --> 00:08:18.647
It's incredible. Uh
00:08:18.657 --> 00:08:21.607
I was reading an article
00:08:21.617 --> 00:08:24.367
uh on the weekend uh about a scientist
00:08:24.377 --> 00:08:25.887
who was
00:08:25.897 --> 00:08:27.527
um quite prominent in the past. I can't
00:08:27.537 --> 00:08:29.127
think of his name right now, but, uh, he
00:08:29.137 --> 00:08:31.007
kind of got debunked
00:08:31.017 --> 00:08:32.886
or criticized or laughed at, whatever
00:08:32.896 --> 00:08:34.847
you like, for coming up with the theory
00:08:34.857 --> 00:08:38.287
that our existence is based purely on
00:08:38.297 --> 00:08:40.567
consciousness; that the universe and
00:08:40.577 --> 00:08:42.766
everything that's happening in it exists
00:08:42.776 --> 00:08:45.767
because we are
00:08:45.777 --> 00:08:47.567
sentient beings; that we are, we are
00:08:47.577 --> 00:08:49.447
creating all of this.
00:08:49.457 --> 00:08:52.527
Um it is so hard to
00:08:52.537 --> 00:08:53.807
I think that's going on in your head.
00:08:53.817 --> 00:08:56.527
I think that's the strong anthropic
00:08:56.537 --> 00:08:57.287
principle, I think.
00:08:57.297 --> 00:08:59.207
That's that's exactly what it was, yes.
00:08:59.217 --> 00:08:59.687
Yeah.
00:08:59.697 --> 00:09:01.847
Um I can't remember why it came up. It
00:09:01.857 --> 00:09:04.167
was probably just one of those newsfeeds
00:09:04.177 --> 00:09:06.247
that pops up from time to time, but uh
00:09:06.257 --> 00:09:06.807
yeah.
00:09:06.817 --> 00:09:08.567
Yeah, it's a fascinating theory.
00:09:08.577 --> 00:09:09.847
Um
00:09:09.857 --> 00:09:11.527
but there are those who believe you can
00:09:11.537 --> 00:09:13.927
manipulate that to your advantage, but I
00:09:13.937 --> 00:09:16.047
don't know if that's true or not. Um
00:09:16.057 --> 00:09:18.407
there was a famous case of a woman who
00:09:18.417 --> 00:09:19.007
um
00:09:19.017 --> 00:09:21.767
claimed that she could, and she won
00:09:21.777 --> 00:09:24.447
more prizes than anyone in history or
00:09:24.457 --> 00:09:26.127
something like that.
00:09:26.137 --> 00:09:27.487
There's some strange stories out there.
00:09:27.497 --> 00:09:28.847
Could just be coincidence, that's
00:09:28.857 --> 00:09:30.527
another theory as well.
00:09:30.537 --> 00:09:32.847
Thank you, Billy. Uh awesome to hear
00:09:32.857 --> 00:09:35.247
from you in the lovely state of New
00:09:35.257 --> 00:09:36.407
Jersey.
00:09:36.417 --> 00:09:38.487
Uh our next question on SpaceNuts Fred
00:09:38.497 --> 00:09:40.447
comes from
00:09:40.457 --> 00:09:42.887
uh Tristan and Simon. Simon's the dad,
00:09:42.897 --> 00:09:44.807
Tristan's his son. My 9-year-old son
00:09:44.817 --> 00:09:46.607
Tristan, see, I was right.
00:09:46.617 --> 00:09:49.687
Uh and I
00:09:49.697 --> 00:09:51.767
My 9-year-old son Tristan and I listen
00:09:51.777 --> 00:09:54.247
to your podcast on our daily drive to
00:09:54.257 --> 00:09:56.767
school, and he has a question among
00:09:56.777 --> 00:09:58.967
many. Tristan is interested in black
00:09:58.977 --> 00:10:01.247
holes and has heard about the
00:10:01.257 --> 00:10:04.047
theoretical idea of a white hole. His
00:10:04.057 --> 00:10:06.087
question is, if black holes have
00:10:06.097 --> 00:10:08.927
extremely high gravity, are
white holes
00:10:08.937 --> 00:10:11.328
the opposite? Thank you for keeping us
00:10:11.338 --> 00:10:14.088
entertained and curious during our long
00:10:14.098 --> 00:10:17.248
commute, Tristan and Simon.
00:10:17.258 --> 00:10:19.408
Thanks uh to both of you and uh hello
00:10:19.418 --> 00:10:22.128
Tristan. Hope uh all is well at school.
00:10:22.138 --> 00:10:23.648
I don't know if you like school or
00:10:23.658 --> 00:10:27.568
loathe it. Uh I was not
00:10:27.578 --> 00:10:30.568
a very motivated student when I went to
00:10:30.578 --> 00:10:31.848
school. I think I did most of my
00:10:31.858 --> 00:10:34.088
learning when I got out.
00:10:34.098 --> 00:10:36.408
Um after they unlocked the doors. But
00:10:36.418 --> 00:10:38.448
anyway, um
00:10:38.458 --> 00:10:40.168
Tristan's got a good question. We've had
00:10:40.178 --> 00:10:41.848
black hole, white hole questions a few
00:10:41.858 --> 00:10:44.768
times in the past uh and
00:10:44.778 --> 00:10:48.568
it is probably logical to say that the
00:10:48.578 --> 00:10:50.408
theory is it would be quite the
00:10:50.418 --> 00:10:52.608
opposite. That that's the reason it's
00:10:52.618 --> 00:10:55.568
called a white hole, I think. Or it they
00:10:55.578 --> 00:10:58.048
think it's white. I don't know, Fred.
00:10:58.058 --> 00:10:59.688
We haven't found one yet.
00:10:59.698 --> 00:11:02.248
No, we haven't. Uh so they are
00:11:02.258 --> 00:11:04.848
theoretical entity.
00:11:04.858 --> 00:11:05.408
Uh
00:11:05.418 --> 00:11:08.248
and they are mathematically the opposite
00:11:08.258 --> 00:11:10.088
of a black hole
00:11:10.098 --> 00:11:16.408
uh in terms of some of the aspects.
00:11:16.418 --> 00:11:17.968
Particularly in terms of something
00:11:17.978 --> 00:11:20.328
called time reversal. Uh
00:11:20.338 --> 00:11:22.448
a comment that I've seen is if you
00:11:22.458 --> 00:11:23.848
played a video of a black hole
00:11:23.858 --> 00:11:25.408
backwards, it would look like a white
00:11:25.418 --> 00:11:26.568
hole.
00:11:26.578 --> 00:11:28.128
Um
00:11:28.138 --> 00:11:29.328
that
00:11:29.338 --> 00:11:30.528
we
00:11:30.538 --> 00:11:33.208
Yeah, we we don't To be honest, most
00:11:33.218 --> 00:11:34.968
physicists don't believe that they
00:11:34.978 --> 00:11:36.288
exist.
00:11:36.298 --> 00:11:36.888
Uh
00:11:36.898 --> 00:11:39.608
that um they're not real. But
00:11:39.618 --> 00:11:41.528
just going to the question that Tristan
00:11:41.538 --> 00:11:43.928
has posed, um black holes have extremely
00:11:43.938 --> 00:11:46.208
high gravity. Uh white hole's the
00:11:46.218 --> 00:11:49.928
opposite. Uh and the answer is it No,
00:11:49.938 --> 00:11:52.808
they're not. They still have a gra-
00:11:52.818 --> 00:11:55.328
They still have a gravitational field
00:11:55.338 --> 00:11:57.368
because they've got mass.
00:11:57.378 --> 00:11:58.248
Uh
00:11:58.258 --> 00:12:00.448
it's You know, that doesn't go in The
00:12:00.458 --> 00:12:02.648
time reversal
doesn't affect that.
00:12:02.658 --> 00:12:04.928
But so what the the main thing is it
00:12:04.938 --> 00:12:06.808
doesn't have negative gravity, which is
00:12:06.818 --> 00:12:08.208
what you might think cuz it's the
00:12:08.218 --> 00:12:09.808
opposite of a black hole in every other
00:12:09.818 --> 00:12:12.848
way. But it's not the
00:12:12.858 --> 00:12:15.449
not the fact that its mass becomes
00:12:15.459 --> 00:12:16.809
negative,
00:12:16.819 --> 00:12:20.409
it's the way space-time behaves behaves
00:12:20.419 --> 00:12:21.929
around it.
00:12:21.939 --> 00:12:24.769
Um that's the crucial thing that makes
00:12:24.779 --> 00:12:25.689
it
00:12:25.699 --> 00:12:27.529
uh a white hole where it's trying to
00:12:27.539 --> 00:12:29.649
push everything outwards rather than
00:12:29.659 --> 00:12:31.409
pull everything inwards, which is what a
00:12:31.419 --> 00:12:33.169
black hole is doing. So, it's all is a
00:12:33.179 --> 00:12:35.769
geometrical point. And I And I should
00:12:35.779 --> 00:12:37.649
just highlight here that the whole of
00:12:37.659 --> 00:12:40.609
relativity is built on geometry. Uh it's
00:12:40.619 --> 00:12:43.369
a geo geometrical theory. Um
00:12:43.379 --> 00:12:45.329
I'd um I did a talk on it a couple of
00:12:45.339 --> 00:12:46.609
weeks ago, and I actually took the
00:12:46.619 --> 00:12:48.409
equations out of it just because I
00:12:48.419 --> 00:12:50.129
didn't want to bore everybody to death.
00:12:50.139 --> 00:12:51.609
But, the equations of relativity are
00:12:51.619 --> 00:12:54.009
basically geometry. Uh in fact, in a
00:12:54.019 --> 00:12:56.009
sense, it's all Pythagoras'theorem, but
00:12:56.019 --> 00:12:58.369
it's very highly modified.
00:12:58.379 --> 00:13:00.009
Um and so, the geometry of the
00:13:00.019 --> 00:13:01.849
space-time around the white hole is what
00:13:01.859 --> 00:13:04.369
makes everything want to get pushed out
00:13:04.379 --> 00:13:08.449
rather than it having negative mass.
00:13:08.459 --> 00:13:11.649
Okay. Yes, I understand. Um
00:13:11.659 --> 00:13:14.409
I'm just I was just doing an AI search
00:13:14.419 --> 00:13:16.009
on that very thing, and it says white
00:13:16.019 --> 00:13:17.849
holes are mathematically possible under
00:13:17.859 --> 00:13:19.969
Einstein's general theory of relativity,
00:13:19.979 --> 00:13:21.489
but physically
00:13:21.499 --> 00:13:23.649
unproven and unlikely to exist in our
00:13:23.659 --> 00:13:25.409
universe.
00:13:25.419 --> 00:13:26.969
I think I said something very similar to
00:13:26.979 --> 00:13:27.729
that.
00:13:27.739 --> 00:13:29.009
Yeah.
00:13:29.019 --> 00:13:30.449
You know, I just wanted to compete with
00:13:30.459 --> 00:13:31.209
Einstein.
00:13:31.219 --> 00:13:33.369
Me and AI were like that.
00:13:33.379 --> 00:13:34.969
Yeah.
00:13:34.979 --> 00:13:36.489
Yeah, it's got its positives, but it's
00:13:36.499 --> 00:13:38.329
certainly getting some bad press, too.
00:13:38.339 --> 00:13:40.049
Yeah, it is. Yes, it is indeed.
00:13:40.059 --> 00:13:42.889
Uh I I learned a new um online word.
00:13:42.899 --> 00:13:45.329
It's not a new word, but it's a new
00:13:45.339 --> 00:13:48.569
use for the word. It's It's called slop.
00:13:48.579 --> 00:13:50.529
Do you know what slop means?
00:13:50.539 --> 00:13:54.049
Um it's Yes, it is the the sort of
00:13:54.059 --> 00:13:56.449
it's AI that's not got things quite
00:13:56.459 --> 00:13:57.769
right. Is that right?
00:13:57.779 --> 00:14:00.809
It's sort of It's It's where an entire
00:14:00.819 --> 00:14:04.329
paper, book, article, whatever, has been
00:14:04.339 --> 00:14:07.249
AI generated. Absolutely no human
00:14:07.259 --> 00:14:09.329
creation in it at all.
00:14:09.339 --> 00:14:11.129
And unfortunately, it's starting to
00:14:11.139 --> 00:14:13.169
happen more and more and more.
00:14:13.179 --> 00:14:13.969
Yeah.
00:14:13.979 --> 00:14:16.931
It's nasty stuff. Uh and white holes are
00:14:16.941 --> 00:14:19.251
slop as well. Now, we don't know that.
00:14:19.261 --> 00:14:19.971
Um
00:14:19.981 --> 00:14:21.091
but
00:14:21.101 --> 00:14:24.491
we do know if black holes exist. We
00:14:24.501 --> 00:14:26.771
don't know if black white holes exist.
00:14:26.781 --> 00:14:28.971
They probably don't, but uh they would
00:14:28.981 --> 00:14:31.091
not be the exact opposite of a black
00:14:31.101 --> 00:14:32.371
hole is what we're saying.
00:14:32.381 --> 00:14:33.851
Yeah, that's right. In the in that
00:14:33.861 --> 00:14:35.571
regard, it's um it's what they do to
00:14:35.581 --> 00:14:38.171
space-time that changes the basically
00:14:38.181 --> 00:14:39.731
changes the um
00:14:39.741 --> 00:14:41.931
the the nature of the thing into
00:14:41.941 --> 00:14:43.331
something that's the opposite of a white
00:14:43.341 --> 00:14:44.171
of a black hole.
00:14:44.181 --> 00:14:44.731
Mhm.
00:14:44.741 --> 00:14:47.531
A great question, Tristan, and one I'm
00:14:47.541 --> 00:14:50.211
absolutely delighted you um you asked
00:14:50.221 --> 00:14:52.331
because it gave me a chance to think all
00:14:52.341 --> 00:14:54.371
that stuff through and bring back some
00:14:54.381 --> 00:14:55.891
memories of what I learned a few years
00:14:55.901 --> 00:14:56.891
ago.
00:14:56.901 --> 00:14:59.131
Very good. Uh thanks, Tristan. Thanks,
00:14:59.141 --> 00:15:01.971
Simon. And uh keep the curiosity coming.
00:15:01.981 --> 00:15:04.451
We love hearing from uh the younger
00:15:04.461 --> 00:15:06.971
audience members here on Space Nuts.
00:15:06.981 --> 00:15:08.811
You're with Andrew Dunkley and Professor
00:15:08.821 --> 00:15:11.331
Fred Watson.
00:15:11.341 --> 00:15:13.131
Let's take a quick break from the show
00:15:13.141 --> 00:15:16.371
to tell you about our sponsor, NordVPN.
00:15:16.381 --> 00:15:18.691
Now, if you travel, work remotely, or
00:15:18.701 --> 00:15:21.451
regularly use public Wi-Fi, having a VPN
00:15:21.461 --> 00:15:24.611
service can be a
very useful layer of
00:15:24.621 --> 00:15:26.291
online security.
00:15:26.301 --> 00:15:28.211
NordVPN encrypts your internet
00:15:28.221 --> 00:15:30.371
connection and helps keep your online
00:15:30.381 --> 00:15:32.651
activity private by hiding your IP
00:15:32.661 --> 00:15:34.771
address and your location. And that
00:15:34.781 --> 00:15:37.051
means when you're connecting from an
00:15:37.061 --> 00:15:39.531
airport, a hotel, a cafe,
00:15:39.541 --> 00:15:41.771
uh or any public network for that
00:15:41.781 --> 00:15:44.251
matter, you can have a greater level of
00:15:44.261 --> 00:15:47.171
protection for your internet traffic.
00:15:47.181 --> 00:15:50.331
NordVPN also lets you secure up to 10
00:15:50.341 --> 00:15:52.451
devices with a single account, so you
00:15:52.461 --> 00:15:54.491
can protect your phone, your computer,
00:15:54.501 --> 00:15:57.091
your tablet, your TV, or any other
00:15:57.101 --> 00:15:58.811
compatible device.
00:15:58.821 --> 00:16:01.011
And it's not just about privacy.
00:16:01.021 --> 00:16:02.811
Depending on the plan you choose,
00:16:02.821 --> 00:16:05.971
NordVPN also offers security features,
00:16:05.981 --> 00:16:08.131
scam and phishing protection, uh ad and
00:16:08.141 --> 00:16:10.731
tracker blocker, uh malware protection,
00:16:10.741 --> 00:16:12.531
password management. That's the tool I
00:16:12.541 --> 00:16:14.211
love the most actually, the password
00:16:14.221 --> 00:16:16.731
management system. I I would die without
00:16:16.741 --> 00:16:18.892
it. It is so very handy. You don't have
00:16:18.902 --> 00:16:21.292
to remember anything except your um one
00:16:21.302 --> 00:16:24.052
password to get in to the Nord tool that
00:16:24.062 --> 00:16:26.052
looks after everything else. There's a
00:16:26.062 --> 00:16:28.652
30-day money-back guarantee as well,
00:16:28.662 --> 00:16:30.812
giving you the opportunity to try before
00:16:30.822 --> 00:16:32.492
you buy and see if it's right for you.
00:16:32.502 --> 00:16:34.772
And I really do think it will be.
00:16:34.782 --> 00:16:36.052
They're the best in the business and
00:16:36.062 --> 00:16:37.972
they're our sponsor. So, go to
00:16:37.982 --> 00:16:42.572
nordvpn.com/spacenuts, a special URL for
00:16:42.582 --> 00:16:44.692
Space Nuts listener listeners to find
00:16:44.702 --> 00:16:49.092
out more. That's nordvpn.com/spacenuts.
00:16:49.102 --> 00:16:50.772
And don't forget the code word Space
00:16:50.782 --> 00:16:51.492
Nuts.
00:16:51.502 --> 00:16:53.452
I believe that this nation should commit
00:16:53.462 --> 00:16:54.612
itself
00:16:54.622 --> 00:16:56.452
to achieving the goal
00:16:56.462 --> 00:16:59.172
before this decade is out of landing a
00:16:59.182 --> 00:17:01.572
man on the moon and returning him safely
00:17:01.582 --> 00:17:02.292
to the earth.
00:17:02.302 --> 00:17:04.172
Space Nuts.
00:17:04.182 --> 00:17:08.532
Our next question, Fred, is massive.
00:17:08.542 --> 00:17:10.852
Hey, Space
Nuts. This is Mike in
00:17:10.862 --> 00:17:12.452
Hayward, California.
00:17:12.462 --> 00:17:14.251
Got a question for you about dark
00:17:14.261 --> 00:17:16.212
matter, big surprise.
00:17:16.222 --> 00:17:18.611
So, I've been thinking about dark
00:17:18.621 --> 00:17:20.731
matter, and the way that you've
00:17:20.741 --> 00:17:23.212
described it on the podcast
00:17:23.222 --> 00:17:26.452
is, it seems to be the solution to the
00:17:26.462 --> 00:17:28.892
problem that astronomers observe when
00:17:28.902 --> 00:17:30.812
they look at galaxies
00:17:30.822 --> 00:17:32.692
and they see the rate at which they're
00:17:32.702 --> 00:17:33.972
spinning
00:17:33.982 --> 00:17:37.252
doesn't quite line up with the mass that
00:17:37.262 --> 00:17:39.772
they can calculate of the galaxy. That
00:17:39.782 --> 00:17:42.412
it seems like the stars should be flying
00:17:42.422 --> 00:17:44.532
off into space
00:17:44.542 --> 00:17:46.492
except that they're not. So, there must
00:17:46.502 --> 00:17:49.892
be more matter there that is causing a
00:17:49.902 --> 00:17:53.572
gravitational force to keep them in
00:17:53.582 --> 00:17:54.932
place.
00:17:54.942 --> 00:17:57.092
So, I've been thinking about
00:17:57.102 --> 00:17:59.492
are there other ways to measure this
00:17:59.502 --> 00:18:01.252
more locally?
00:18:01.262 --> 00:18:03.332
And I was thinking about the earth
00:18:03.342 --> 00:18:06.012
and we can make a direct accurate
00:18:06.022 --> 00:18:08.412
measurement of the earth's gravity
00:18:08.422 --> 00:18:09.972
but we can't really make a direct
00:18:09.982 --> 00:18:13.292
measurement of the earth's mass. So, my
00:18:13.302 --> 00:18:17.252
question is is the earth's mass over
00:18:17.262 --> 00:18:19.932
overestimated because there's a
00:18:19.942 --> 00:18:22.413
component of the gravity that we feel
00:18:22.423 --> 00:18:25.573
that is attributable to dark matter and
00:18:25.583 --> 00:18:28.853
not all of it is baryonic matter.
00:18:28.863 --> 00:18:30.773
Anyway, hope that makes sense. Love your
00:18:30.783 --> 00:18:32.813
podcast. Can't wait to hear the answer.
00:18:32.823 --> 00:18:34.093
Thanks, guys.
00:18:34.103 --> 00:18:35.493
Thank you, Mike. Oh, you put a lot of
00:18:35.503 --> 00:18:38.533
thought into that. That's That's um
00:18:38.543 --> 00:18:39.493
That's
00:18:39.503 --> 00:18:40.653
uh um
00:18:40.663 --> 00:18:42.173
It's a difficult question to get your
00:18:42.183 --> 00:18:43.453
head around.
00:18:43.463 --> 00:18:44.413
Um
00:18:44.423 --> 00:18:47.013
So, over to you, Fred.
00:18:47.023 --> 00:18:48.613
I was going to get on to I was going to
00:18:48.623 --> 00:18:50.253
paraphrase what he was asking, but it's
00:18:50.263 --> 00:18:51.853
just gone straight in one ear out the
00:18:51.863 --> 00:18:53.693
other.
00:18:53.703 --> 00:18:54.933
So, yes.
00:18:54.943 --> 00:18:56.253
I'm so
00:18:56.263 --> 00:18:56.853
uh
00:18:56.863 --> 00:19:00.893
Well, um Mike's point was that
we can
00:19:00.903 --> 00:19:02.333
measure
00:19:02.343 --> 00:19:05.013
gravity on Earth more accurately
00:19:05.023 --> 00:19:06.853
accurately that we can than we can
00:19:06.863 --> 00:19:08.373
measure its mass.
00:19:08.383 --> 00:19:10.413
Um I don't think that's true. The mass
00:19:10.423 --> 00:19:13.013
of the Earth is very well determined and
00:19:13.023 --> 00:19:14.453
it comes actually from space
00:19:14.463 --> 00:19:16.133
observations. You can
00:19:16.143 --> 00:19:18.293
just looking at the dynamics of the
00:19:18.303 --> 00:19:20.333
solar system, the way the planet moves
00:19:20.343 --> 00:19:22.013
in its orbit around the Sun, and the way
00:19:22.023 --> 00:19:24.173
it interacts with the other planets, we
00:19:24.183 --> 00:19:27.173
know its mass to a very high accuracy.
00:19:27.183 --> 00:19:29.333
Um and so
00:19:29.343 --> 00:19:31.653
that's
00:19:31.663 --> 00:19:34.453
not something we can compare
00:19:34.463 --> 00:19:36.333
and so so
00:19:36.343 --> 00:19:37.813
we know its mass
00:19:37.823 --> 00:19:39.653
the gravitational pull
00:19:39.663 --> 00:19:41.773
as a result of that, which we can also
00:19:41.783 --> 00:19:42.973
measure
00:19:42.983 --> 00:19:45.053
uh is completely consistent with its
00:19:45.063 --> 00:19:46.373
mass. So,
00:19:46.383 --> 00:19:48.533
um I think what Mike is asking is if you
00:19:48.543 --> 00:19:50.333
measure the mass of the Earth and you
00:19:50.343 --> 00:19:52.493
measure its gravitational pull
00:19:52.503 --> 00:19:55.373
uh is there a a component of that
00:19:55.383 --> 00:19:57.133
gravitational pull that's not due to the
00:19:57.143 --> 00:19:59.733
Earth, it's due to dark matter?
00:19:59.743 --> 00:20:03.733
And the answer is no because
00:20:03.743 --> 00:20:07.373
we on Earth are immersed in a blob of
00:20:07.383 --> 00:20:08.853
dark matter, which certainly has
00:20:08.863 --> 00:20:11.653
gravitational pull, but it's it's going
00:20:11.663 --> 00:20:14.773
in all directions, and so we don't feel
00:20:14.783 --> 00:20:17.173
its effects. It We don't
00:20:17.183 --> 00:20:19.573
It just cancels out. It's It's pulling
00:20:19.583 --> 00:20:21.335
in all directions because blobs of dark
00:20:21.345 --> 00:20:22.535
matter.
00:20:22.545 --> 00:20:26.495
Uh
00:20:26.505 --> 00:20:27.575
Um
00:20:27.585 --> 00:20:29.255
Did Did you hear that?
00:20:29.265 --> 00:20:31.095
That sounds like a dark matter.
00:20:31.105 --> 00:20:33.175
It was It was um
00:20:33.185 --> 00:20:35.775
It was me uh tripping over a cable
00:20:35.785 --> 00:20:38.775
underneath my desk, which pulled all
00:20:38.785 --> 00:20:41.175
this stuff attached to it down onto the
00:20:41.185 --> 00:20:41.695
Oh.
00:20:41.705 --> 00:20:43.295
onto the floor.
00:20:43.305 --> 00:20:44.855
I can still see you. That's the good
00:20:44.865 --> 00:20:46.815
news and I can still hear you.
00:20:46.825 --> 00:20:48.215
Yeah, no, it's all right. It's not done
00:20:48.225 --> 00:20:51.015
any harm. My table lamp is lying
00:20:51.025 --> 00:20:53.895
pointing awkwardly upwards rather than
00:20:53.905 --> 00:20:55.615
downwards like it's supposed to be, but
00:20:55.625 --> 00:20:57.175
everything will be fine.
00:20:57.185 --> 00:20:59.735
I'm not really worried about that.
00:20:59.745 --> 00:21:03.775
Um So, um yeah, so so dark matter
00:21:03.785 --> 00:21:06.015
basically what you can you can you know,
00:21:06.025 --> 00:21:07.775
if you imagine the Earth, there it is
00:21:07.785 --> 00:21:10.455
trundling around in its orbit, but it's
00:21:10.465 --> 00:21:13.215
it's immersed in a blob of dark matter,
00:21:13.225 --> 00:21:15.375
which is probably much bigger than the
00:21:15.385 --> 00:21:19.095
whole galaxy. And so, the that the
00:21:19.105 --> 00:21:20.895
density of that dark matter is
00:21:20.905 --> 00:21:23.175
effectively the same everywhere as far
00:21:23.185 --> 00:21:24.335
as the Earth's concerned.
00:21:24.345 --> 00:21:24.775
Right.
00:21:24.785 --> 00:21:26.335
And so, it's pulling in all directions.
00:21:26.345 --> 00:21:28.655
You You can just take it completely out
00:21:28.665 --> 00:21:30.735
of the the equations of motions of a
00:21:30.745 --> 00:21:32.055
planet.
00:21:32.065 --> 00:21:34.775
Okay, so would would the dark matter be
00:21:34.785 --> 00:21:37.135
moving with the Earth and with the
00:21:37.145 --> 00:21:40.255
galaxy or are we passing through it?
00:21:40.265 --> 00:21:42.855
Uh it's it's probably um there probably
00:21:42.865 --> 00:21:45.255
isn't a relative velocity between us and
00:21:45.265 --> 00:21:47.375
dark matter. Although, there is an
00:21:47.385 --> 00:21:50.455
experiment that's being done in Gran
00:21:50.465 --> 00:21:53.655
Sasso, in Italy, that suggests that we
00:21:53.665 --> 00:21:55.335
are moving through dark matter because
00:21:55.345 --> 00:21:57.415
they think they see a different
00:21:57.425 --> 00:22:00.015
signature of certain I think it's gamma
00:22:00.025 --> 00:22:02.615
radiation that they're picking up, uh,
00:22:02.625 --> 00:22:04.055
when the Earth is on one side of its
00:22:04.065 --> 00:22:06.615
orbit from when it's on the other side.
00:22:06.625 --> 00:22:09.655
Uh but more or less, you can imagine
00:22:09.665 --> 00:22:11.695
that the blob of dark matter is rotating
00:22:11.705 --> 00:22:14.735
with the galaxy. That's very roughly.
00:22:14.745 --> 00:22:17.335
Okay. So, what was the answer to Mike's
00:22:17.345 --> 00:22:18.575
question?
00:22:18.585 --> 00:22:19.095
No.
00:22:19.105 --> 00:22:21.575
No?
00:22:21.585 --> 00:22:23.175
I love it when it's that simple.
00:22:23.185 --> 00:22:25.375
Yeah, I can't remember what the question
00:22:25.385 --> 00:22:27.376
was. Let me just have a quick look to
00:22:27.386 --> 00:22:29.696
remind me.
00:22:29.706 --> 00:22:31.216
Actually, no. It's It's an audio
00:22:31.226 --> 00:22:34.296
question, so I can't see it.
00:22:34.306 --> 00:22:37.296
But yes, the the
00:22:37.306 --> 00:22:40.896
I like the idea of, you know, taking
00:22:40.906 --> 00:22:42.856
measuring the Earth's gravity, measuring
00:22:42.866 --> 00:22:44.896
its mass, and
00:22:44.906 --> 00:22:46.256
from its mass you work out how much
00:22:46.266 --> 00:22:47.856
gravity it should have, and then you
00:22:47.866 --> 00:22:50.136
compare the two, the measurement of the
00:22:50.146 --> 00:22:52.496
gravity with the theoretical prediction.
00:22:52.506 --> 00:22:54.416
But they're exactly the same, and that's
00:22:54.426 --> 00:22:56.096
because the dark matter's gravity
00:22:56.106 --> 00:22:57.576
cancels out, basically.
00:22:57.586 --> 00:22:59.576
Oh, here's a test for you, Fred.
00:22:59.586 --> 00:23:02.216
What is the mass of the Earth?
00:23:02.226 --> 00:23:04.336
Um it's about
00:23:04.346 --> 00:23:06.376
a few tons, isn't it? It's um
00:23:06.386 --> 00:23:07.976
It's a couple of kilograms.
00:23:07.986 --> 00:23:11.016
Yeah, the number I think the Sun's mass
00:23:11.026 --> 00:23:12.696
is
00:23:12.706 --> 00:23:15.016
10 to 27
00:23:15.026 --> 00:23:17.176
kilograms. Is that right, or is that
00:23:17.186 --> 00:23:19.096
tons? I can't remember. But it's a
00:23:19.106 --> 00:23:22.616
number with a lot of zeros after it.
00:23:22.626 --> 00:23:23.736
What is the mass of the
00:23:23.746 --> 00:23:24.096
tons.
00:23:24.106 --> 00:23:29.176
5.9722*10 to the 24th kilograms, or
00:23:29.186 --> 00:23:33.056
5.976 trillion kilograms.
00:23:33.066 --> 00:23:33.536
Yep.
00:23:33.546 --> 00:23:34.816
I don't know what that is in pounds.
00:23:34.826 --> 00:23:36.856
Sorry, America.
00:23:36.866 --> 00:23:38.576
I apologize.
00:23:38.586 --> 00:23:40.056
Yeah, what is it in dollars? That's the
00:23:40.066 --> 00:23:40.456
thing.
00:23:40.466 --> 00:23:42.536
That's a good question.
00:23:42.546 --> 00:23:46.136
I wonder if AI can answer that.
00:23:46.146 --> 00:23:47.216
What is the mass of the Earth in
00:23:47.226 --> 00:23:49.256
dollars? I bet it can.
00:23:49.266 --> 00:23:51.496
I'll I'll do it in US dollars cuz, you
00:23:51.506 --> 00:23:53.776
know, Australian dollars it'll just say
00:23:53.786 --> 00:23:58.136
10 bucks.
00:23:58.146 --> 00:23:59.416
Oh, dear.
00:23:59.426 --> 00:24:01.776
Yeah.
00:24:01.786 --> 00:24:02.776
I wonder if AI will come up with a
00:24:02.786 --> 00:24:04.176
number.
00:24:04.186 --> 00:24:06.056
It might. I think AI's going to be
00:24:06.066 --> 00:24:06.296
smart.
00:24:06.306 --> 00:24:09.536
did. 5 quadrillion US dollars.
00:24:09.546 --> 00:24:11.696
That's what the Earth is worth.
00:24:11.706 --> 00:24:15.496
I thought Elon Musk had that much money.
00:24:15.506 --> 00:24:17.096
Anyway.
00:24:17.106 --> 00:24:18.536
There you go.
00:24:18.546 --> 00:24:20.296
Nobody can say we're not adequate with
00:24:20.306 --> 00:24:20.696
answers now.
00:24:20.706 --> 00:24:22.456
being very thorough when it comes to
00:24:22.466 --> 00:24:24.616
money.
00:24:24.626 --> 00:24:25.856
Well, some people are. I haven't got
00:24:25.866 --> 00:24:26.656
any.
00:24:26.666 --> 00:24:28.377
All right. Thanks, Mike. Thanks for the
00:24:28.387 --> 00:24:30.857
question. Hope we adequately covered it
00:24:30.867 --> 00:24:31.977
for you.
00:24:31.987 --> 00:24:34.337
Suspect not. But anyway, we'll um
00:24:34.347 --> 00:24:39.137
we might do a sequel one day.
00:24:39.147 --> 00:24:40.057
3
00:24:40.067 --> 00:24:40.977
2
00:24:40.987 --> 00:24:41.897
1
00:24:41.907 --> 00:24:43.377
Space Nuts
00:24:43.387 --> 00:24:45.737
Our final question on Space Nuts today
00:24:45.747 --> 00:24:49.297
Fred comes from Eduardo who is from Gran
00:24:49.307 --> 00:24:52.057
Canaria in the Canary Islands. Lovely.
00:24:52.067 --> 00:24:52.697
Um
00:24:52.707 --> 00:24:55.097
we drove past there last year in in a
00:24:55.107 --> 00:24:56.177
ship.
00:24:56.187 --> 00:24:57.537
We we got to wave. We were supposed to
00:24:57.547 --> 00:24:59.337
stop there but um
00:24:59.347 --> 00:25:01.617
the schedule changed so we we ended up
00:25:01.627 --> 00:25:02.617
um
00:25:02.627 --> 00:25:03.857
at um
00:25:03.867 --> 00:25:05.977
uh Tenerife instead.
00:25:05.987 --> 00:25:08.297
Uh so Eduardo asked, "Do neutrinos
00:25:08.307 --> 00:25:10.097
interact with gravity at all? Do they
00:25:10.107 --> 00:25:12.257
get swallowed by black holes or do they
00:25:12.267 --> 00:25:14.857
just shoot through them like ordinary
00:25:14.867 --> 00:25:15.897
matter?
00:25:15.907 --> 00:25:18.177
Uh light is massless, moves at the speed
00:25:18.187 --> 00:25:20.377
of light and yet can't shoot through the
00:25:20.387 --> 00:25:22.497
Earth like neutrinos do, hardly
00:25:22.507 --> 00:25:24.657
interacting with matter at all. Although
00:25:24.667 --> 00:25:26.617
I imagine it would be hard even for
00:25:26.627 --> 00:25:28.697
neutrinos to shoot through a point of
00:25:28.707 --> 00:25:32.097
infinite uh density. I suppose that
00:25:32.107 --> 00:25:34.977
point, the so-called singularity, is all
00:25:34.987 --> 00:25:37.897
the way uh down the gravity well of a
00:25:37.907 --> 00:25:40.417
black hole. Not all of the black hole
00:25:40.427 --> 00:25:42.297
volume from the event horizon to
00:25:42.307 --> 00:25:45.297
significantly uh to the singularity has
00:25:45.307 --> 00:25:46.497
infinite
00:25:46.507 --> 00:25:49.417
uh density, I guess. Or does it? What
00:25:49.427 --> 00:25:51.457
about space-time itself? Bodies with
00:25:51.467 --> 00:25:53.817
huge mass and gravitational influence
00:25:53.827 --> 00:25:56.177
bend space-time. They can also make it
00:25:56.187 --> 00:25:58.657
vibrate, generating gravitational waves
00:25:58.667 --> 00:26:00.417
if the interaction is strong enough,
00:26:00.427 --> 00:26:02.937
making space-time somewhat of a material
00:26:02.947 --> 00:26:04.217
in nature.
00:26:04.227 --> 00:26:06.777
Could huge supermassive black holes feed
00:26:06.787 --> 00:26:09.097
on space-time itself? Thanks for your
00:26:09.107
--> 00:26:11.217
answers, Eduardo."
00:26:11.227 --> 00:26:13.137
Thought-provoking.
00:26:13.147 --> 00:26:16.857
Mhm. It is, yeah. Um I uh also have
00:26:16.867 --> 00:26:18.857
visited Gran Canaria
00:26:18.867 --> 00:26:20.097
um
00:26:20.107 --> 00:26:23.457
many times um on my usually on my way to
00:26:23.467 --> 00:26:25.537
La Palma where I used to observe a lot
00:26:25.547 --> 00:26:26.937
on the um
00:26:26.947 --> 00:26:28.737
William Herschel Telescope on the island
00:26:28.747 --> 00:26:29.417
of La Palma.
00:26:29.427 --> 00:26:30.217
Yeah.
00:26:30.227 --> 00:26:33.179
Uh it's a lovely part of the world. Uh
00:26:33.189 --> 00:26:35.499
my last trip there was
00:26:35.509 --> 00:26:38.459
kind of disappointing because um Nandy
00:26:38.469 --> 00:26:40.019
was supposed to come with me, but for
00:26:40.029 --> 00:26:41.579
reasons beyond our control, she
00:26:41.589 --> 00:26:43.259
couldn't. So, I ended up there on my own
00:26:43.269 --> 00:26:45.619
doing a conference. Anyway, that's a
00:26:45.629 --> 00:26:47.379
long story.
00:26:47.389 --> 00:26:50.539
Um Um okay. Uh
00:26:50.549 --> 00:26:53.019
so, the basic question
00:26:53.029 --> 00:26:55.819
uh is, let me just read the question. Do
00:26:55.829 --> 00:26:58.259
in Do you neutrinos interact with
00:26:58.269 --> 00:26:59.579
gravity at all?
00:26:59.589 --> 00:27:00.219
Mhm.
00:27:00.229 --> 00:27:02.219
And the answer is yes,
00:27:02.229 --> 00:27:02.779
um
00:27:02.789 --> 00:27:06.019
because they've got um a nonzero rest
00:27:06.029 --> 00:27:07.259
mass.
00:27:07.269 --> 00:27:09.619
Unlike a photon, which has a zero rest
00:27:09.629 --> 00:27:10.579
mass,
00:27:10.589 --> 00:27:14.339
um a neutrino has a nonzero rest mass,
00:27:14.349 --> 00:27:16.659
but is very, very small.
00:27:16.669 --> 00:27:18.979
But nevertheless, uh that is enough to
00:27:18.989 --> 00:27:21.179
mean that it follows the curvature of
00:27:21.189 --> 00:27:24.459
space-time exactly as defined by general
00:27:24.469 --> 00:27:27.019
relativity. So, they do interact with
00:27:27.029 --> 00:27:28.299
gravity.
00:27:28.309 --> 00:27:30.779
Um and the
00:27:30.789 --> 00:27:32.179
you know, that's the that's the the
00:27:32.189 --> 00:27:34.259
basically the crucial point about all
00:27:34.269 --> 00:27:35.219
this.
00:27:35.229 --> 00:27:40.899
Uh if a neutrino crosses the event
00:27:40.909 --> 00:27:43.139
horizon of a black hole,
00:27:43.149 --> 00:27:43.779
uh
00:27:43.789 --> 00:27:47.979
they uh they do get swallowed um
00:27:47.989 --> 00:27:50.859
by a black hole. Uh
00:27:50.869 --> 00:27:52.859
so,
00:27:52.869 --> 00:27:56.539
it's the ones that are probably moving
00:27:56.549 --> 00:27:58.059
quickly enough that avoid being
00:27:58.069 --> 00:27:59.819
swallowed. But because they've they've
00:27:59.829 --> 00:28:01.139
got mass,
00:28:01.149 --> 00:28:03.459
and black holes love eating mass, that
00:28:03.469 --> 00:28:05.539
means they just basically get swallowed.
00:28:05.549 --> 00:28:06.379
Generally speaking.
00:28:06.389 --> 00:28:08.699
get much out of a neutrino.
00:28:08.709 --> 00:28:10.379
No, that's not right. They're certainly
00:28:10.389 --> 00:28:13.339
not sustained by a neutrino um in terms
00:28:13.349 --> 00:28:14.899
of sustenance.
00:28:14.909 --> 00:28:17.779
Um so, yes, that's basically the
00:28:17.789 --> 00:28:19.859
question that um they they do get
00:28:19.869 --> 00:28:23.179
swallowed. They don't just shoot through
00:28:23.189 --> 00:28:23.899
uh
00:28:23.909 --> 00:28:26.899
them, you know, like
00:28:26.909 --> 00:28:28.539
well, like nothing does really.
00:28:28.549 --> 00:28:30.259
And yet, they say they can pass through
00:28:30.269 --> 00:28:31.899
Earth.
00:28:31.909 --> 00:28:34.820
Yeah, but that's because their mass and
00:28:34.830 --> 00:28:37.340
their you know, their interact if I can
00:28:37.350 --> 00:28:39.260
put it this way, their interactability
00:28:39.270 --> 00:28:40.460
with other
00:28:40.470 --> 00:28:42.620
uh subatomic particles is so low,
00:28:42.630 --> 00:28:44.700
they're weakly interacting, very, very
00:28:44.710 --> 00:28:46.700
weakly interacting. So, they just zoom
00:28:46.710 --> 00:28:47.580
through the Earth.
00:28:47.590 --> 00:28:47.980
Yeah.
00:28:47.990 --> 00:28:48.780
Uh
00:28:48.790 --> 00:28:51.380
but they still have mass.
00:28:51.390 --> 00:28:54.420
Uh but only a tiny amount, and so they
00:28:54.430 --> 00:28:56.260
will be sucked into a black hole.
00:28:56.270 --> 00:28:57.220
Mhm.
00:28:57.230 --> 00:28:58.620
Uh and that was the second part of his
00:28:58.630 --> 00:29:01.220
question. Uh and then the crux of that
00:29:01.230 --> 00:29:03.580
was could a super massive black hole
00:29:03.590 --> 00:29:06.580
feed on space-time itself?
00:29:06.590 --> 00:29:07.420
Um
00:29:07.430 --> 00:29:10.020
I I I don't think so, because uh
00:29:10.030 --> 00:29:11.460
space-time
00:29:11.470 --> 00:29:13.700
it is
00:29:13.710 --> 00:29:15.900
you know, it I mean
00:29:15.910 --> 00:29:18.260
essentially Eduardo's suggesting that
00:29:18.270 --> 00:29:21.220
space-time is material in nature.
00:29:21.230 --> 00:29:21.660
Mhm.
00:29:21.670 --> 00:29:23.820
But it's not, it's the medium, if I can
00:29:23.830 --> 00:29:25.340
put it that way. It's not a medium, it's
00:29:25.350 --> 00:29:27.100
just a framework within which everything
00:29:27.110 --> 00:29:28.500
else sits.
00:29:28.510 --> 00:29:30.580
Uh so, um
00:29:30.590 --> 00:29:32.380
a black hole feeding on space-time I
00:29:32.390 --> 00:29:34.460
think would be out of the question.
00:29:34.470 --> 00:29:35.980
There's plenty of other stuff within
00:29:35.990 --> 00:29:37.900
that space-time for it to feed on, which
00:29:37.910 --> 00:29:39.860
is material in nature.
00:29:39.870 --> 00:29:41.940
Uh but not space-time itself.
00:29:41.950 --> 00:29:44.260
Yeah. Okay.
00:29:44.270 --> 00:29:47.380
Very good. Did I think we covered it.
00:29:47.390
--> 00:29:48.860
Um I I hope so.
00:29:48.870 --> 00:29:49.620
Yeah.
00:29:51.590 --> 00:29:54.140
All right. Uh thank you, Eduardo. Um
00:29:54.150 --> 00:29:56.020
thanks for sending the question in, and
00:29:56.030 --> 00:29:57.300
a reminder if you'd like to send us
00:29:57.310 --> 00:29:59.340
questions, please do. Just go to our
00:29:59.350 --> 00:30:02.300
website, spacenuts.podcast .com or
00:30:02.310 --> 00:30:05.100
spacenuts.io. There's a little link at
00:30:05.110 --> 00:30:07.180
the top called AMA.
00:30:07.190 --> 00:30:08.940
Ask me anything. You click on that, and
00:30:08.950 --> 00:30:11.580
you can send us text or audio questions.
00:30:11.590 --> 00:30:13.340
Uh just fill in the blanks. Uh if you've
00:30:13.350 --> 00:30:15.100
got a device, a smart device with a
00:30:15.110 --> 00:30:16.740
microphone, you're all set. Just don't
00:30:16.750 --> 00:30:18.660
forget to tell us who you are and where
00:30:18.670 --> 00:30:20.460
you're from. We just like to know so we
00:30:20.470 --> 00:30:23.700
can spam you.
00:30:23.710 --> 00:30:25.380
I wish that was not true, but I have
00:30:25.390 --> 00:30:27.580
actually spammed a couple of people
00:30:27.590 --> 00:30:28.900
lately with
00:30:28.910 --> 00:30:31.140
you know, some book that I was trying to
00:30:31.150 --> 00:30:32.500
flog.
00:30:32.510 --> 00:30:34.100
Yeah. Um
00:30:34.110 --> 00:30:35.780
and thanks for those who have
00:30:35.790 --> 00:30:38.021
bought it, and even bigger thanks to
00:30:38.031 --> 00:30:40.702
those who read it. I appreciate that.
00:30:40.712 --> 00:30:43.101
Um cuz I I've gone um I've gone Kindle
00:30:43.111 --> 00:30:45.381
Plus on it, Fred, and
00:30:45.391 --> 00:30:47.221
uh it gives me a report every day of how
00:30:47.231 --> 00:30:49.621
many pages have been read. Which is
00:30:49.631 --> 00:30:53.021
fascinating cuz I get paid per page.
00:30:53.031 --> 00:30:55.341
Okay. Oh, that's interesting. Per page
00:30:55.351 --> 00:30:55.822
read.
00:30:55.832 --> 00:30:58.661
Yeah. So, you you you get you get um
00:30:58.671 --> 00:31:00.781
so many cents per page. I earned 5 cents
00:31:00.791 --> 00:31:02.981
yesterday.
00:31:02.991 --> 00:31:03.901
After tax, that'd
00:31:03.911 --> 00:31:06.661
be 1 and 1/2 cents.
00:31:06.671 --> 00:31:08.901
It's um not really comparable with the
00:31:08.911 --> 00:31:10.422
mass of the Earth in dollars, is it?
00:31:10.432 --> 00:31:11.582
No, not really.
00:31:11.592 --> 00:31:13.542
No.
00:31:13.552 --> 00:31:15.062
Yeah, I never thought of it that way.
00:31:15.072 --> 00:31:17.582
But anyway, it's it's just fun to do it.
00:31:17.592 --> 00:31:19.861
Now, I enjoy the writing and I enjoy the
00:31:19.871 --> 00:31:21.422
I don't really enjoy the marketing side
00:31:21.432 --> 00:31:25.221
of things. That's That's not my jam.
00:31:25.231 --> 00:31:27.422
Mhm, that's right.
00:31:27.432 --> 00:31:28.582
Anyway.
00:31:28.592 --> 00:31:30.621
Uh so, yes, keep those cards and letters
00:31:30.631 --> 00:31:33.861
coming in. Love to hear from you and uh
00:31:33.871 --> 00:31:35.462
thank you, Fred, as always for answering
00:31:35.472 --> 00:31:38.261
those questions so thoroughly.
00:31:38.271 --> 00:31:40.501
Well, thank you, Andrew. I yeah
00:31:40.511 --> 00:31:41.861
I I'm glad you think they were
00:31:41.871 --> 00:31:43.942
thoroughly answered. That's all right.
00:31:43.952 --> 00:31:45.461
Or adequately.
00:31:45.471 --> 00:31:46.781
I'll
00:31:46.791 --> 00:31:48.861
I'll I'll take that one. Thank you.
00:31:48.871 --> 00:31:50.542
Fair enough. I'll see I'll see you soon,
00:31:50.552 --> 00:31:51.302
Fred. Thank you.
00:31:51.312 --> 00:31:52.702
Yeah. Cheers for now. Bye-bye.
00:31:52.712 --> 00:31:53.621
Professor Fred Watson,
00:31:53.631 --> 00:31:55.381
astronomer-at-large, and thanks to Hugh
00:31:55.391 --> 00:31:57.582
in the studio. Uh couldn't be with us
00:31:57.592 --> 00:32:00.182
today because he underestimated his mass
00:32:00.192 --> 00:32:02.501
and he's had to go to the gym. And from
00:32:02.511 --> 00:32:04.781
me, Andrew Dunkley, uh we'll see you on
00:32:04.791 --> 00:32:06.302
the next episode of Space Nuts. Until
00:32:06.312 --> 00:32:07.621
then, bye-bye.
00:32:07.631 --> 00:32:10.021
Space Nuts. You've been listening to the
00:32:10.031 --> 00:32:12.981
Space Nuts podcast.
00:32:12.991 --> 00:32:16.141
Available at Apple podcasts, Spotify,
00:32:16.151 --> 00:32:18.741
iHeart radio, or your favorite podcast
00:32:18.751 --> 00:32:21.141
player. You can also stream on demand at
00:32:21.151 --> 00:32:23.981
bytes.com. This has been another quality
00:32:23.991 --> 00:32:28.871
podcast production from bytes.com.