전사 🔗
00:00:00
Speaker 1: We saw all these headlines. The AI bubble has burst. I thought, really?
00:00:03
Speaker 2: There are days when you wake up, you look at your portfolio and you think, my word, things have changed overnight.
00:00:10
Speaker 1: Anything can happen to any company, you know, no matter how big.
00:00:13
Speaker 2: What does an experienced analyst make of events like this? We thought we'd check in with Greg Smith.
00:00:19
Speaker 1: Generate. And without fail, without word of a lie, I would get a tip from a taxi driver on what dot-com stock to buy. I'm Garth Bray. This is Shared Lunch.
00:00:28
Speaker 3: Investing involves risk. You might lose the money you start with. We recommend talking to a licensed financial advisor. We also recommend reading product disclosure documents before deciding to invest. Everything you're about to see and hear is current at the time of recording.
00:00:42
Speaker 2: Greg, you're an experienced man who's seen a lot of the markets. For a lot of people though, retail investors, this period that we've been through the last little while might be the first time they've seen real volatility in equity markets up and down. What do you make of, I suppose, the last three or four days just bouncing around on Wall Street?
00:01:03
Speaker 1: Yeah, thanks for making the point about being experienced. We've got the grey years to show for it. But yeah, look, if you're new to markets, you might think, gosh, there's been a lot going on. This year, we've got the conflict in Iran. We've had the midterms. We've had interest rates. We've had bond yields going up to multi-decade highs. That's not sort of good particularly for equity markets. We've got all sorts of stuff going on. But when you sort of step back, there's always stuff going on in markets. We talk about the wall of worry. You go back 100 years, go back to the depression. There's always stuff going on. So look, it depends on your perspective. I think if you've got a short-term horizon, that possibly matters more than it does if you've got a longer-term horizon. And I think that's certainly what we look at.
00:01:45
Speaker 2: If anything's different, it's, I suppose, that AI trade that we've seen unfolding for the last four years, which has just really pushed things forward. to new highs and really seem to kind of stick and unwind and then stick and then unwind again over the last four days. That kind of volatility must be sort of putting some question marks around investors.
00:02:04
Speaker 1: Yeah, I suppose it certainly has and we've taken for granted. We've basically been in a bull market for four years, particularly in technology. So ChatGPT sort of came along sort of four years ago and it's been off to the races ever since. And I think, look, there's not a question over whether AI works. It clearly does. And it's not a question of whether companies involved in AI make strong revenues and strong earnings. They clearly do. But it's what the investors are
Load full transcript
prepared to stomach in terms of what they pay for. And they're building these huge data centres. They're investing heavily in AI. And they're investing, I suppose, for the future. So I think that's sort of what some of the question marks have been about. A bit more of a focus on that. Also, bond yields going up has thrown a bit more of a focus around valuations. But I think when you look at those valuations, they're actually pretty modest. And we'll get probably to a bit more detail on NVIDIA perhaps shortly. But you look at that company, it's on around about 13 times earnings. It's set to grow revenues and earnings 70% plus next year. So that sounds like a pretty good story. And suddenly this happens, and then there's a spotlight. Still a great company, but now question marks. You've got what happens... if the CEO and the main man is to go? What happens at the board? There is governance here.
00:03:24
Speaker 2: Key man risk.
00:03:25
Speaker 1: Key man risk, that's right.
00:03:26
Speaker 2: So this is one person, Jensen Huang, who obviously has pushed this company to greater highs, somehow manages 60 direct reports and somehow still finding time for extracurricular activities. But if you are that much of a linchpin, market's not looking at that, or investor's not looking at that, analyst's not looking at that, going, hang on, you've got an awful lot riding on one person, a bit like Musk.
00:03:48
Speaker 1: In his control. Yeah, well, they were seeing this before, you know, and of course, Apple, you know, you think Steve Jobs, who thought, oh my God, how's the company going to go? Obviously, you know, terrible. It's passing, but, you know, the company went on and flourished. But there are question marks. I suppose then you can take the other point, you know, is there a bit of politics involved in this? You know, potentially we're going to have negotiations between Washington and Beijing. Yeah, there's obviously talk of chips being smuggled out and what happened. It seems like Donald Trump's in his corner. So This could well blow over, but certainly does focus that key man risk, as you say. Now, and if you step back from NVIDIA to, obviously, that's a specific set of circumstances, yeah, there has been a spotlight thrown on the AI trade, and there won't all be sort of winners, yeah, there'll be winners and losers. It won't be all winning companies. Again, I think that comes back to sort of getting away from concentration and rolling all the AI chips, as it were, on NVIDIA or whatever it might be, and there's certainly companies, I think, will look back and go, Yeah, and you look at the dot-com boom. So there were some leaders there back then that are not around today. And so, again, important to diversify. And just going back to that point, I think another difference versus perhaps dot-com, because it was amazing last week. We had the NASDAQ fell just over 5% in one session. We saw all these headlines. The AI bubble has burst. I thought, really? OK, 5% move is a lot, and we've since seen a couple of up days. But I thought that was quite premature. And you look at the definition of a bubble is when you have, and there's been lots of bubbles throughout history, tulip mania, the railroads.com, and expectations getting wildly ahead and impacting sort of valuations. I just don't think we're seeing that. We're seeing some companies, like look at some of your memory names, like Micron, SK Hynix. They're on PEs. SK Hynix is on a P of about three. I wouldn't call that a stratospheric valuation. And I also don't think we've seen the sense of euphoria that we did back in the dot-com boom as well. Actually, at the time, I was living in London, but I was working in Ireland. So I was commuting to Dublin every week. And without fail, without word of a lie, I would get a tip from a taxi driver on what dot-com stock to buy. and that's when you know things that's the warning you know i caught a cab here i didn't get a tip from a um from a taxi driver on ai stock so that's a good sign but i think you know genuinely we are um yeah we're not in that phase but yes like volatility is something that could actually continue and then we get to the midterms which is also very relevant.
00:06:28
Speaker 2: I was just going to ask you about the politics of it all because that seemed to really push markets around last week i kind of felt like straight out of the midterms things took off when almost they should have dropped, and then the next day they caught up to that sentiment and dropped, and then they lifted again.
00:06:43
Speaker 1: There's a lot of whipsaw going on in there. Oh, for sure.
00:06:45
Speaker 2: Is that just down to sort of geography and the map?
00:06:49
Speaker 1: I think there's a bit of second guessing. So we've seen the blue wave. And, of course, a lot of this has been about the AI, the data centre builder, should I say. So prior to the midterms, around about sort of, The states that are having massive data centre build-outs, around about 30% had Democratic governors. That's closer to 80%. And they've got much more of a view that, hey, we need more regulation. We need to slow down. Some are even saying we stop. We need a moratorium. And interestingly, in states like Texas, which accounts for nearly 30% of the data centre build-out in the US, they've got a governor there saying this should stop. Now, the way I sort of think about it, and I think what we're seeing with this volatility, and bear in mind, We're not going to see a change in the House and the Senate in these positions until January. Investors are trying to second guess what's going to happen. Interestingly, in recent days, the Texas governor has already moderated her position. I think that makes sense. I mean, if you say, let's put a stop, OK, well, what about all the jobs this is creating? And then are these companies just going, that's fine, we'll go to a Republican state where they don't have those restrictions. And then
it only becomes relevant if we get some sort of cap at the federal level. I just can't see that happening because if America suddenly says no more data centres, where do you think they're going to go? Are they going to go to China?
00:08:11
Speaker 2: We're up into space if they can speak it.
00:08:12
Speaker 1: Well, they might go out into space. But, yeah, seriously, look, obviously there was, you know, in the midterms, you know, Americans voted, you know, obviously cost of living was a big issue, but also it was about data centres. I think 70% in the recent Gallup poll said they wouldn't want to live near a data centre. 58% wouldn't want to live near a nuclear power station. So they're more worried about data centres than nuclear power stations.
00:08:34
Speaker 2: But is that about an opposition to data centres, or is that, again, a cost of living thing because they're worried about how it's going to change the price of power? So if you fix the cost of living, and arguably fuel is probably the biggest issue there, Do some of those data centre worries maybe just, you know, they're not as pressing for some of you?
00:08:51
Speaker 1: Oh, I think you're absolutely spot on. So, look, there's no mistake. They suck up a lot of electricity. The water thing, I think there's a bit of misinformation around that because they now circulate water within them, so they're not, like, continuously. There probably is the eyesore aspect as well. You know, we were talking earlier about the one they're building in the South Island. You know, it's going to be equivalent to, like, 40 Eden Parks. So, you know, you probably don't want to live next door to that. It's a bit of an eyesore. You can't put them at sea. You can't put them in the desert, it's too hot. So I think there is that aspect, but certainly the electricity issue, if that's solved. And then I think that also brings to the flip side. So I think the Democrats were more likely to be slowing down speed limits rather than stop.
00:09:31
Speaker 2: And clipping the ticket.
00:09:33
Speaker 1: A little bit? Maybe that, maybe that as well.
00:09:34
Speaker 2: How about you give it a little bit of redistribution, basically rent-taking and re-diverting some of that back into state coffers?
00:09:40
Speaker 1: That's right. But I think the other really important point as well, in relation to what might happen next year with the Democrats, is are we going to see a resolution to the conflict? Are we going to see a speedier resolution? And you've seen the oil price fall 20% in around about the last couple of weeks.
00:09:59
Speaker 2: Yeah, I mean, it's the cheapest it's been in three months, and that's largely because it feels like, at the moment anyway, the White House seems to have taken a read from that election result and said, hey, we need to slow our roll a little bit on the military actions, but the diplomatic.
00:10:11
Speaker 1: Absolutely. I've been tuning to a lot of macro strategy calls in the last few
days, actually, and this theme seems to be Donald Trump could go, okay, I've now got this window of, you know, six weeks to like go hard. And then, and then, you know, I'll be, you know, I'll sort of lose, lose power in January or, you know, goes with sort of the, the scapegoat option with his gift, which also might be developing a little bit. So, The possibility of an escalation in the next six weeks probably has crept up a little bit, but then de-escalation in the new year, which would be positive for oil prices coming down, could certainly play out. Then also, of course, do we get a reduction in defence spending? So there's a possibility that there'll be some alleviation there, if you like. I'm just thinking, if.
00:11:01
Speaker 2: You're starting to see maybe a bit of that golf risk stepping back, if the AI trade maybe... has a bit more friction in it. Does that start to make markets that maybe have taken a bit of a pacing? Europe's been reasonably good until energy prices got out of control. Does European markets and equities start to look a little bit more attractive at that point?
00:11:21
Speaker 1: Yeah, because it has been all about the AI trade. And I think it's always important to diversify. So we're certainly not all in on technology in general. I mean, we like the sector and we've got plenty of strong names in the portfolio. But yeah, in terms of being all in, certainly not the case. So I think, you know, we've seen when there's been a bit of risk off that older economy stocks have come to the fore. You know, certainly some older economy names have been battered, even if you look at the American markets. You know, Europe's been doing it tough. But, you know, Europe's big problem again. The economy hasn't been doing as well as America. And the US has been doing well. You look at those jobs numbers last week, 165,000, you know, double, Double forecast was really broad as well. It wasn't just sort of technology. Whereas Europe's been really more hamstrung by those higher energy prices. So, yeah, you could certainly see more capital go towards Europe if we do get an end to that conflict next year and, you know, a bit of money sort of finding it that way. I still think there'll be a reasonable, strong concentration in the AI sector in that trade. But, yeah, we could certainly see a bit more money find its way to other quarters, if you like.
00:12:30
Speaker 2: If you look at companies that Kiwis hold, particularly on this platform, but just broadly as well, I mean, Rocket Lab is a big name people talk about. They carry a lot of revenue and revenue risk probably from U.S. government sources and from U.S. sort of defense sources. I think they were careful on the call to sort of say they feel that that's continuing revenue at the moment. But is there any kind of a cloud hanging over that, mate?
00:12:54
Speaker 1: Well, the share price is already– taken quite a fall from those record highs a few months ago. So they've had the Neutron program sort of pushed out a bit, which probably hasn't helped sentiment. SpaceX, remember, literally got off to a flyer until it didn't. I think it's below its IPO price. So there's a bit of an effect going on there. But yeah, last quarter for Rocket Lab, pretty stellar. Interstellar. Revenue's up sort of 70%. Pipeline, really, really super strong. Yes, I suppose if we see defence expenditure moderate, that might have an impact. But I think that, again, they're not heavily concentrated in one particular customer. They have been broadening that. So that's a good thing. Look, the share price may be volatile, but it feels like they're travelling in the right direction sort of long term. They're making great progress over there. okay, so the timeline for one of their rocket programs has been pushed out a bit.
00:13:56
Speaker 2: They still seem to somehow have added a billion dollars extra worth of orders for that program since last quarter.
00:14:02
Speaker 1: So that's a good problem to have. A little bit.
00:14:05
Speaker 2: Like some of these chip makers who are selling stuff well in advance of production and really just the battle is can they actually supply that demand?
00:14:12
Speaker 1: Yeah, that's right. It's the inverse to a business which is struggling for orders and therefore having to react accordingly. So Yeah.
00:14:20
Speaker 2: New Zealand, by comparison, and the NZX, it feels a bit like potatoes, you know? It doesn't bring the meal down, doesn't really lift it up. It's just a good, reliable source of carbs floating through the middle, right? So we've seen the NZX50 drop and rise, not by the same kind of margins that we've seen the NASDAQ and S & P flick around by. What's the story there?
00:14:41
Speaker 1: Well, obviously, we've got a much different makeup of our market. So we don't have those AI names. We have Infertile. That's our data centre name. or invested in a data centre business. So we're full of gen tailors, electricity companies, healthcare, some construction. Fair bit of property in there, yeah. Property. Yeah, there is property, but on the whole, a pretty defensive market. And some would say a bit of a boring market, but boring can be quite good as a counter to when things are volatile. We've got one of the highest dividend yielding markets in the world, and there can be times where that... Yeah, that's in demand. So yeah, look, it hasn't done much this year. You've got to remember as well, we invest in stocks, which obviously are related to the economy. We are quite a defensive market. But our economy has probably done it relatively tough this year as well. We were just talking about green shoots in January. Then the conflict came along. Our currency has fallen. That's made it tougher. Cost of living, price of petrol has gone up. We're an importer of that. Our exporters have done well, you know, Pitcher & Biker, Wealthcare and other exporters, which is tourism's done well, but a lot of parts of the economy, you
know, have struggled. But what I think, again, gives optimism for next year, looking forward for our market and the companies in it, is that, you know, what I've talked about in terms of those inflationary pressures sort of easing globally. Also, it feels like our central bank, perhaps in contrast to previous tenures, is taking a more pragmatic approach i think it was completely the right call for them to go on hold last time everyone said they were going to.
00:16:18
Speaker 2: Raise rates well it's they've certainly been proven right so far yes i mean if you look at how um unemployment turned out much higher than expected uh and then when you've seen this easing in oil prices that's sort of two ticks for for the ball at uh at uh won the terrace.
00:16:33
Speaker 1: Absolutely so i think um you know as to whether they raise rates in december you know remains to be seen but yeah they could could well be done as well um and Labour, by the way, will probably get to the election, but Labour talked about restoring the dual mandate, but it sort of feels like they've been paying a bit of a nod to that anyway since Anna Brayman came in. So it feels like New Zealand Inc wants to get on with it. We saw during the annual meeting season, a lot of companies say, you know, we just want to sort of roll up and get on with it. Things are, Balkan Steel talked about things sort of improving and they're at the epicentre of the economy. Fletcher Building was a bit more guarded, but Companies are saying, yeah, there's reasons to be optimistic. A lot of the business surveys, tough in the here and now, tough for consumers, still quite tough for businesses, but the intentions are there to hire, to invest. That's the last bit of the jigsaw, actually, for our economy. Jobs.
00:17:23
Speaker 2: Election results still being counted. I think the specials probably just need to be checked now. But does that cast a wee bit of a pull, or is that a very temporary kind.
00:17:32
Speaker 1: Of a pull, do you think? I think, you know, so obviously with the election, we're used to waiting under MMP, the averaged time to form a government is 27 days. So it's not like it's a new thing. We could be the week of Christmas by the time we get a result. It might be sooner, fingers crossed. But you think always sort of dangerous to make decisions in advance of an election result, based on election result. You've got to get that right. You've got to get how the market reacts right. But it is clear, depending on whether we go left or right, one is looking a little bit more likely than the other. that there are some different outcomes. Obviously, Labour has the capital gains tax proposals. I think some of those minority tax proposals, you know, won't fly. They've been made for interesting headlines. But, you know, I just don't think we see a wealth tax unless we want more people to leave. I suppose one sector certainly in the spotlight, which is, you know, a well-held one by many investors is the retirement sector, and particularly, you know, the rules around, you.
00:18:27
Speaker 2: The rebate period where they've got to make capital returns.
00:18:30
Speaker 1: Yeah, that's right. So if you move on or you move out into care or whatever it might be, at the moment there's no maximum of when you need to be repaid, your estate repaid. National proposing that as nine months, Labour proposing three months. And given those retirement care homes would have to fund that, you're talking about thousands of units, you'd have to, basically until they get a new buyer, a purchaser.
00:18:53
Speaker 2: So The difference between those two timetables is very big.
00:18:57
Speaker 1: Oh, quite significant, you know, for companies that already got quite a bit of debt on their balance sheet.
00:19:02
Speaker 2: And have struggled really to make sales, I suppose.
00:19:05
Speaker 1: Yeah, companies have sort of been, had a lot thrown at them in New Zealand over the last sort of few years. But look, exporters have flourished, you know, we've got a little bit of a balanced market in that regard. You know, we've got some strongly yielding companies as well. So I think we can have a, and just, I think, having exposure to New Zealand and indeed Australia, it's just a little bit of an offset to the US and Europe, which can work at times. Big picture then.
00:19:31
Speaker 2: People have had a bit of a shocker in terms of news this week. What's the best bit of information you could lay before them to think about it?
00:19:41
Speaker 1: Things are always happening in markets. I think that's the key message. It's happened throughout time. And I think just don't let a week or two of headlines dictate a tendency to 20-year investment plan. Greg Smith from Generate.
00:19:53
Speaker 2: Thanks very much for your insights and your intelligence. Koi Matu, that's us for Shared Lunch this week.