전사 🔗
WEBVTT
00:00.501 --> 00:05.096
What do you say that they may be missing?
00:05.613 --> 00:08.429
And I don't even want to use missing as if there's something we have to
00:08.929 --> 00:11.282
receive from it, but might be, you know,
00:11.894 --> 00:16.097
overlooking, if you will, if they rejected the
00:16.597 --> 00:19.323
new perspective just, you know, off the top. They say, you know, no,
00:19.485 --> 00:22.853
I'm good on mine. What would be areas that you
00:22.950 --> 00:25.477
would say you may want to consider this?
00:29.996 --> 00:34.004
I'll go back to something I said earlier. For preachers,
00:34.441 --> 00:37.647
I think that the number one— I mean, one of the number one things
00:37.696 --> 00:41.295
we wrestle with is our context. And there's a congregational
00:41.795 --> 00:44.454
context. That's what we preach to. We preach to people in a context.
00:45.762 --> 00:49.272
And the new perspective is helpful because
00:49.450 --> 00:53.460
it really asks hard, serious questions about what contextually
00:53.476 --> 00:57.195
Paul is doing in his letters. And so you don't read 1
00:57.211 --> 01:01.159
Corinthians and Romans in the same way because Paul's context is fundamentally
01:01.659 --> 01:05.059
different, and he's not doing systematic theology
01:05.252 --> 01:09.056
and then imposing his systematic theology on these different congregations.
01:09.104 --> 01:11.560
Instead, he's asking really sensitive questions,
01:12.795 --> 01:34.412
and I would say Hello
01:34.444 --> 01:38.038
everyone and welcome back to Scripture in Black and
01:38.070 --> 01:41.633
White. We are thrilled, we are so excited that you
01:41.681 --> 01:45.371
have joined us, and I'm just going to let you know we've got
01:45.871 --> 01:48.500
a great episode for you. As you know,
01:49.046 --> 01:52.877
It's me, Anthony Walker, the minister of the Highway 231 South
01:52.909 --> 01:56.371
Church of Christ here in Murfreesboro, Tennessee,
01:56.499 --> 02:00.378
and I'm joined by my good friend, my good brother,
02:00.763 --> 02:04.273
Daniel McCoy. Hey, Daniel. Hey, Anthony, how are you?
02:04.770 --> 02:08.200
I'm great, my man. So I'm Daniel and I
02:08.700 --> 02:11.021
work with Renew.org and Ozark Christian College.
02:11.726 --> 02:14.772
And Anthony, I just wanted to say by way
02:15.272 --> 02:18.701
of introduction of our topic, Um, that we have a couple things in common.
02:19.760 --> 02:23.177
One, both of our NFL teams are tied,
02:23.947 --> 02:27.590
0 and 1. Both Titans at this recording,
02:27.686 --> 02:31.585
Titans and Packers are both 0 and 1. Another thing we've got in common are,
02:31.874 --> 02:35.901
uh, we like— most people would think, oh, they like theology.
02:36.126 --> 02:40.121
That's not true. We like good theology. We don't
02:40.201 --> 02:43.314
like bad theology. And hopefully in these conversations,
02:43.346 --> 02:46.672
we're helping people get good theology But the question kind of before us
02:46.865 --> 02:50.246
is this thing we're going to be talking about called the New Perspective
02:50.327 --> 02:53.723
on Paul. Which category does it belong in? Does it belong in— is it
02:54.223 --> 02:58.091
good theology? Is it bad theology? So I'm
02:58.124 --> 03:01.753
just going to set up this conversation in a way that for me,
03:02.011 --> 03:05.044
I think this expresses why this matters.
03:06.573 --> 03:10.645
The story was simple. Okay. It used to be simple
03:10.919 --> 03:15.388
in the 1st century AD. Paul was arguing
03:15.485 --> 03:19.226
against Jews who were trying to work their way to
03:19.258 --> 03:21.955
heaven, work their way to salvation through the works of the law.
03:22.871 --> 03:26.435
Fast forward. Protestants in the 16th century,
03:27.302 --> 03:30.578
they're seeing the Roman Catholic system of you got to do this,
03:30.594 --> 03:34.447
you got to do that to go to heaven kind of built up
03:34.947 --> 03:38.622
around the Gospel, and the Protestants say, no, it's by grace through through
03:39.122 --> 03:42.362
faith, not by works righteousness. You can't do anything to save yourself. Look at what
03:42.475 --> 03:45.685
Paul told those Jewish people. It's not about works righteousness,
03:46.167 --> 03:50.099
and that was the story. It's very simple, except that the story
03:50.599 --> 03:54.321
gets a lot more complicated because fast forward to the 20th century, last century,
03:55.076 --> 03:59.201
you had some New Testament scholars who were saying that, well, the Protestants
03:59.650 --> 04:04.065
got Paul wrong. The Jews were not actually ever
04:04.565 --> 04:08.029
really trying to work their way to heaven. They knew about God's grace,
04:09.184 --> 04:12.312
and so when Paul was talking about works righteousness, he was talking
04:12.812 --> 04:16.788
about something different from trying to work your way to heaven, and so
04:17.060 --> 04:20.814
that became known as the new perspective on Paul. I've greatly oversimplified it,
04:21.135 --> 04:23.044
and that's why we got a couple guys are going to help us with this,
04:23.221 --> 04:26.894
but it's become a huge debate between one
04:26.942 --> 04:30.103
side which says you guys have totally
04:30.440 --> 04:34.549
oversimplified the Gospel, be the New Perspective people
04:35.049 --> 04:38.308
are going to say, you know, the traditional Protestants have really oversimplified the Gospel,
04:38.629 --> 04:41.906
but then the other side is going to say, actually, you New
04:42.002 --> 04:46.098
Perspective guys have seriously undermined the Gospel.
04:46.692 --> 04:49.857
Some Protestant thinkers, especially from within the Reformed camp, are going to
04:49.873 --> 04:53.230
have major issues with the New Perspective on Paul,
04:54.146 --> 04:57.326
so that's just to kind of set it up, but you know,
04:57.679 --> 05:01.341
I'm looking forward to our guests who are going to really be able to tell
05:01.841 --> 05:05.461
us why this matters, what this is, and
Load full transcript
hopefully give us a good way forward.
05:06.728 --> 05:08.892
Wow. Wow. You know,
05:09.710 --> 05:12.804
I'm looking forward to it. I'm looking forward to learning.
05:13.782 --> 05:17.950
In my early days in college and
05:17.982 --> 05:21.862
studying Paul, you know, the heated conversation
05:22.039 --> 05:25.069
at the time was, you know, Paul v. James.
05:25.181 --> 05:28.756
Right. And so, so now this one is taking
05:28.788 --> 05:32.684
it even to another uh, level. And so I'm looking to
05:32.796 --> 05:35.746
learn and to hear as well. Um, Daniel,
05:35.762 --> 05:38.535
tell us who we have today. Yeah, well,
05:38.712 --> 05:42.046
John Whitaker, who is back with us. Uh, we love John.
05:42.094 --> 05:45.509
John's, uh, the founder of the Listener's Bible Commentary
05:45.541 --> 05:48.811
of both the New Testament and the Old Testament. And that app,
05:48.907 --> 05:51.408
Listener's Bible Commentary, is one of my top 5 apps.
05:52.017 --> 05:55.480
Love, love that. And, uh, John is kind of everybody's favorite
05:55.980 --> 05:57.888
Bible teacher. So hey, John, thanks for joining us.
05:59.317 --> 06:02.545
Thanks, Daniel. Good to be with you guys again on Scripture in Black and White
06:03.045 --> 06:06.897
podcast. And Bob Turner is the lead minister
06:07.266 --> 06:11.137
of the Church of Christ at White Station in Memphis, and if you've ever
06:11.637 --> 06:15.456
read Bob's stuff, for example on renew.org, you'll agree with me that
06:15.956 --> 06:18.717
he kind of reminds me of the great Malcolm Gladwell.
06:19.214 --> 06:22.474
He's a great writer. So Bob is with us. Really grateful that you're
06:22.523 --> 06:25.895
here with us, and I'd love to have you guys kind of define what
06:26.395 --> 06:28.938
are we talking about. New Perspective on Paul,
06:30.015 --> 06:33.199
the idea that Protestants have gotten Paul wrong.
06:33.247 --> 06:36.205
Kind of help us with a definition here. What are we talking about?
06:38.427 --> 06:43.001
Who do you want to go first? Either one.
06:44.402 --> 06:47.706
Go for it, Bob. Well, I appreciate that.
06:48.355 --> 06:52.039
It's great to be with you guys. Thanks to Daniel and Anthony and John.
06:52.087 --> 06:55.734
I look forward to this conversation. I'm a Cleveland
06:56.234 --> 06:59.862
Browns fan, so I'm 0-1 too, but I'm going to have
07:00.362 --> 07:02.906
a zero in the win column much longer than you guys will.
07:04.839 --> 07:08.358
So if you're a Browns fan, you've been
07:08.454 --> 07:11.716
used to losing. So, you know, I'm the pro here.
07:12.005 --> 07:16.273
Let's kind of talk about this. I think that basically
07:16.337 --> 07:20.610
what we're thinking about today is that
07:21.110 --> 07:24.444
the way that we've read Paul has been greatly influenced by the work of
07:24.541 --> 07:28.265
the Reformation by Martin Luther, and the question we want to ask is,
07:29.438 --> 07:34.158
have we read Romans and Galatians with questions
07:34.351 --> 07:38.541
that came out of the 16th century rather
07:39.041 --> 07:42.828
than the 1st century? And so certainly we've got answers
07:43.245 --> 07:46.825
that come to us from Paul's letters, but Have
07:47.325 --> 07:50.239
we asked the right questions? And so as I think about this,
07:51.020 --> 07:52.451
I'm just asking the question,
07:54.898 --> 07:58.499
is it the case that what we did was we said,
07:58.611 --> 08:02.035
okay, Paul is
08:02.292 --> 08:06.516
reacting to the challenges in his ministry context—
08:06.887 --> 08:10.579
Romans, Galatians— who were his opponents?
08:12.308 --> 08:16.371
It's unquestioned at this point that when Martin Luther 1,500
08:16.403 --> 08:20.161
years later is writing, he is seeing himself in
08:20.193 --> 08:24.144
the character Paul, and in the way that Paul would have reacted against
08:24.449 --> 08:27.999
people who some people have called Judaizers or people who
08:28.063 --> 08:31.163
were requiring that Gentiles perform
08:31.917 --> 08:35.563
Jewish works of the law to be part of the covenant people,
08:36.254 --> 08:40.558
that that was exactly what Paul said or that Luther thought he was experiencing
08:41.554 --> 08:45.169
through the Roman Catholic Church, and I would just say
08:45.669 --> 08:49.170
that I think that that's appropriate contextual
08:49.670 --> 08:53.332
theology for his time, but it is not helpful
08:53.749 --> 08:57.188
for us, and so we need to ask different questions
08:57.204 --> 09:01.205
for our time, and I don't think that simply
09:01.237 --> 09:04.161
lining up that category or that comparison is fair.
09:05.174 --> 09:08.915
And so while I think justification by faith
09:09.172 --> 09:13.090
is the perfect solution to what's
09:13.122 --> 09:15.257
going on in Roman congregations,
09:16.558 --> 09:20.010
it's just worth saying that's not exactly what Paul does in all of his
09:20.026 --> 09:23.446
letters. That's not the path
09:23.462 --> 09:26.256
that he takes in every conversation about salvation.
09:27.717 --> 09:31.314
Even in the book of Ephesians, He can in one
09:31.362 --> 09:34.927
verse say we're saved by grace through faith,
09:35.681 --> 09:39.053
and then 2 verses later say that we're created
09:39.553 --> 09:42.393
for good works. Ephesians 2:8, Ephesians 10.
09:43.067 --> 09:46.375
So Paul can work this out. Luther struggled with it
09:46.423 --> 09:49.924
a little bit more. I think a lot of the New Perspective wants to return
09:49.956 --> 09:53.633
to Paul without having to go through Luther
09:53.809 --> 09:54.419
every single time.
09:59.447 --> 10:02.872
Well, all right, go ahead, John. Kind of set this up for
10:02.905 --> 10:06.324
us from your perspective. No, I think Bob
10:06.824 --> 10:10.208
has done a fair summary, and if I were just to give a real simple
10:10.708 --> 10:14.042
kind of succinct description of what the New Perspective on Paul is,
10:14.942 --> 10:20.631
it's really an attempt to read
10:20.663 --> 10:24.233
Paul on Paul's terms
rather than read Paul,
10:24.249 --> 10:27.861
as Bob said, through Luther, through Calvin, through the Protestant information.
10:28.053 --> 10:31.600
And so a lot of the thinkers who would be kind
10:32.100 --> 10:36.206
of lumped into this large category of New Perspective on Paul— people
10:36.398 --> 10:39.961
like James Dunn or N.T. Wright, or even some more
10:40.089 --> 10:43.844
recent ones, you know, such as Scott McKnight and others— that
10:44.344 --> 10:47.776
would be lumped into that category, what they're really after
10:47.856 --> 10:51.660
is, are we hearing Paul rightly, or have
10:51.708 --> 10:55.563
we read Paul and heard Paul through the filter of the
10:56.063 --> 10:59.927
concerns of the Protestant Reformation. So if we're going to wrestle
11:00.427 --> 11:03.550
with what the New Perspective on Paul is, in a nutshell, I think that's really
11:04.050 --> 11:07.183
what it is: an attempt to read scripture on Paul's terms rather than read it
11:07.933 --> 11:09.628
in the terms of the Protestant Reformation.
11:11.636 --> 11:14.677
And why does this matter? Like, why is this conversation important?
11:17.575 --> 11:20.723
Bare minimum, because we want to understand scripture rightly, right? Like,
11:21.127 --> 11:24.290
if scripture's if Paul is trying to communicate some thoughts,
11:24.306 --> 11:27.881
we don't get to make up what those thoughts are. Bible study is
11:28.554 --> 11:31.920
an effort in discovery, not creation, right? And so we're
11:32.420 --> 11:35.784
trying to discover what the author meant. We're not trying to create
11:35.992 --> 11:39.599
our own preferred understanding of what he's saying. So we
11:40.099 --> 11:42.500
want to hear Paul on his terms, bare minimum. That's why it matters for that.
11:42.965 --> 11:47.454
More specifically, it matters, I think, because of
11:47.954 --> 11:51.770
how you read Romans particularly and how you read Galatians.
11:52.749 --> 11:57.147
If the classic reading of Paul post-Protestant Reformation
11:57.404 --> 12:01.882
is right, then those 2 books are primarily about individual salvation
12:02.620 --> 12:06.215
and about not earning
12:06.248 --> 12:08.350
your salvation in any sort of way.
12:09.682 --> 12:13.310
If the new perspective on Paul is right, those books aren't
12:13.810 --> 12:18.377
so much about individual salvation— how does an individual get saved— as
12:18.409 --> 12:20.559
they are about who are the people of God.
12:22.225 --> 12:25.668
So if we're going to hear Paul, particularly Romans and
12:26.168 --> 12:28.124
Galatians accurately, this conversation I think matters.
12:30.390 --> 12:34.176
Yeah, Jon, I think that's right. I believe, you know,
12:34.872 --> 12:38.529
I preached through Romans all 52 weeks
12:38.982 --> 12:42.539
of the year 2025, and we're a
12:43.039 --> 12:47.542
city church located in Memphis, We're a majority African-American
12:47.656 --> 12:50.821
city. Our church really wants to kind of be the
12:51.321 --> 12:55.963
church for the city. I believe Romans,
12:56.238 --> 12:59.702
if it's not the best book in the New Testament for thinking about
12:59.783 --> 13:01.855
ethnic divisions, it's right up there,
13:03.763 --> 13:07.207
and I think when you read it, there's chapters in 14
13:07.304 --> 13:11.351
and in 15 that are just incredibly
13:11.851 --> 13:15.156
rich chapters for thinking about conversations around
13:15.221 --> 13:18.931
ethnic identity. Most of
13:19.431 --> 13:22.836
the ways that it's been interpreted though in the Reformation has been
13:22.868 --> 13:26.515
systematic theology, just asking this question
13:27.015 --> 13:30.778
of like, I'm a sinner, how does God save me, which attends to the vertical
13:31.278 --> 13:34.896
relationship of the human and God, but I think
13:35.396 --> 13:39.145
if you read it on its ethnic terms that what Paul
13:39.291 --> 13:44.657
is doing is he's using justification by faith as
13:44.754 --> 13:47.392
a solution to what you see in chapter 1,
13:47.890 --> 13:51.686
which is that Gentiles worship idols. They've lost their way. But also that
13:52.186 --> 13:56.028
in chapter 2, the Jewish leadership,
13:56.901 --> 14:00.700
it can just come off incredibly smug and also has
14:01.200 --> 14:04.805
its own sin problem. And so he uses justification by faith
14:05.242 --> 14:09.051
to address this ethnic situation of
14:09.551 --> 14:13.190
asking the question, well, then who can't be saved? I think it's
14:13.690 --> 14:17.316
an incredible place to go when you think about removing barriers that
14:17.816 --> 14:20.298
exist between people in a church. But if we're only going to do it for—
14:20.798 --> 14:24.704
use it for systematic theology of asking, you know, is there
14:24.769 --> 14:26.901
a righteous God who can save me?
14:27.903 --> 14:31.880
It totally, I think, ignores the horizontal implications.
14:31.928 --> 14:35.065
You know, a lot of people have used Romans even in— you
14:35.081 --> 14:38.184
think about things in our tradition like gospel meetings or evangelistic preaching.
14:39.677 --> 14:42.873
People like Billy Graham, for Churches of Christ it would be Jimmy Allen,
14:43.531 --> 14:47.610
they taught this book as if like chapters
14:47.706 --> 14:51.256
14 and 15 were there, but they were the practical section.
14:52.059 --> 14:55.126
People like Scott McKnight have called us back and said, no, that's where you
14:55.174 --> 14:58.402
actually find the occasion of the letter. That is why
14:58.902 --> 15:02.593
this exists, is asking the question, how do the weak and the strong live together?
15:02.642 --> 15:06.239
How do people negotiate differences around matters of ethnicity?
15:07.139 --> 15:10.643
So this matters because I think if we get it wrong,
15:12.210 --> 15:14.406
we don't have as much hope for a multicultural church.
15:16.870 --> 15:20.607
So to summarize, it's kind of a question
15:20.640 --> 15:24.021
of whether the Jews of Paul's time
15:24.685 -->
15:28.130
were primarily thinking vertically, like how do we
15:28.276 --> 15:32.586
do enough to get in heaven versus we
15:33.086 --> 15:36.137
know that God has shown us his grace. He's chosen us,
15:37.182 --> 15:40.347
but we don't think they should belong. The Gentiles shouldn't belong with
15:40.459 --> 15:43.994
us. They've got to do the works of the law. So it's kind
15:44.494 --> 15:48.397
of a debate about whether the works of the law are more of a vertical
15:48.590 --> 15:52.419
orientation or more of a horizontal. Is that a fair way to kind of
15:52.919 --> 15:53.631
summarize the stakes?
15:56.330 --> 16:00.674
Yeah, and I think that's why we would see I'll
16:01.174 --> 16:05.435
let Jon step in here, but I think that's why we see that Paul goes
16:05.549 --> 16:08.999
through such— I mean, and this is— he goes through such pain
16:09.659 --> 16:13.218
to affirm the goodness of Torah that we know that
16:13.718 --> 16:17.631
the law is good. We base our entire case based on the characters
16:18.131 --> 16:20.497
of the Old Testament like chapter 4 with Abraham.
16:22.164 --> 16:24.723
He's not dismantling Judaism.
16:25.683 --> 16:29.408
He is saying that if you read it— so let's
16:29.456 --> 16:32.732
reread it through a covenant promise. Let's reread
16:33.232 --> 16:37.227
it as God's blessing to all nations. Let's think about justification
16:37.727 --> 16:41.418
by faith in Habakkuk in order to do the whole program God
16:41.918 --> 16:45.448
was trying to do from the beginning. So yeah, it doesn't seem to
16:45.948 --> 16:49.350
me like in Romans Paul is trying to look at a person who's
16:49.366 --> 16:53.484
Jewish and say, that your faith is fundamentally flawed.
16:53.564 --> 16:57.171
Instead, he's saying there's something within your faith that
16:57.671 --> 17:00.359
you haven't explored, and it's God's love for the nations.
17:03.193 --> 17:06.825
Yeah, and the one thing I would add, Daniel, or to emphasize
17:06.873 --> 17:10.618
what you're saying, is I think that's one
17:10.666 --> 17:14.422
of the chief concerns of the new perspective. It's not the only chief concern,
17:15.165 --> 17:18.426
but what does Paul mean by works and works of the law?
17:18.994 --> 17:23.055
That's one of the chief concerns. When I was in college and grad
17:23.071 --> 17:27.230
school, I had class on Romans. I had
17:27.940 --> 17:31.860
Jack Cottrell's Doctrine of Grace course at Cincinnati Bible Seminary,
17:32.053 --> 17:35.456
and in both cases— my Romans class in undergrad,
17:35.473 --> 17:39.844
my class with Cottrell in graduate school— both cases Romans
17:39.860 --> 17:43.209
was all about how an individual gets saved, and the word works
17:43.402 --> 17:47.009
was code for works by which you're trying to earn your salvation.
17:48.090 --> 17:51.846
So that's how I was taught to read Romans and understand Romans
17:53.930 --> 17:57.996
as well as Galatians because there's a lot of similarities to it. In fact,
17:58.221 -->
18:01.626
in my Romans class we got done
18:02.126 --> 18:05.815
with chapter 8, and what was said was you could literally go from
18:05.880 --> 18:09.746
chapter 8 to chapter 12 and miss nothing of significance in
18:09.843 --> 18:12.958
Romans. It's like chapters 9 through 11 is sort of this appendix that's
18:13.007 --> 18:15.510
stuck in there, and we're not sure what to do with it, and that's only
18:15.623 --> 18:20.152
the case if we think
18:20.200 --> 18:23.783
Romans is all about how an individual gets saved, and so to me that
18:23.831 --> 18:27.270
should have been a clue that maybe we were hearing Paul wrong. If we think
18:27.286 --> 18:30.549
we can bracket off chapters 9 through 11,
18:30.661 --> 18:34.021
maybe we're hearing Paul wrong, right? So this concern
18:34.521 --> 18:38.584
over earning your salvation, what works means, it's one of the core concerns
18:39.084 --> 18:40.881
of the new perspective. Not the only one, but it is one of the core
18:41.381 --> 18:44.748
concerns. Well, what I'd like to do now is take
18:45.248 --> 18:48.604
maybe 5 minutes or so and talk about what is helpful
18:49.102 --> 18:51.930
about the new perspective on Paul. You know,
18:52.059 --> 18:55.546
what are some pros to it? And then about 5 minutes
18:56.046 --> 18:59.675
or so on what it maybe lacks, maybe what it gets wrong.
18:59.724 --> 19:02.680
Now back to my original framing. You know,
19:03.403 --> 19:07.003
none of us want to oversimplify the
19:07.503 --> 19:10.621
Gospel. But at the same time none of us want to undermine
19:10.653 --> 19:13.790
the Gospel in any way, and so yeah,
19:13.806 --> 19:16.781
keep those concerns in front of us. We want to be accurate. We want to
19:17.267 --> 19:20.047
be biblical, so yeah, what are 5 minutes or so of,
19:20.762 --> 19:23.834
yeah, this is actually some pretty helpful stuff from the New Perspective,
19:25.530 --> 19:28.235
and either one can go. Yeah,
19:28.802 --> 19:32.042
my understanding, and I think the New Perspective can
19:32.542 --> 19:35.363
be used as like an umbrella. The way that I thought about it is like
19:36.287 --> 19:39.269
a word that we use in our normal language, like environmentalism,
19:40.054 --> 19:43.789
where all of us appreciate a little bit of it, and then all
19:43.837 --> 19:46.947
of us have certain texts and practices that we abide by where it's like,
19:46.963 --> 19:50.795
okay, I recycle, does that count? Okay, I visit national parks, does that count?
19:51.612 --> 19:54.305
And then there's also places you're going to say like, oh, well, I mean,
19:54.482 --> 19:57.848
I'm this, but I'm not that. That's what
19:58.348 --> 20:01.824
I would say. One thing that I think they added to the conversation
20:01.856 --> 20:04.773
that was healthy, and I think it was the work from E.P.
20:04.821 --> 20:08.511
Sanders, 1977, so It's 49
20:09.011 --> 20:12.238
years old. I don't know if 49 years counts as a new perspective anymore,
20:12.848 --> 20:16.446
but it's, it's this idea that I think is just so
20:16.543 --> 20:20.205
healthy that there's grace in the Old Testament, um, that one
20:20.237 --> 20:24.397
of God's key attributes in the book of Exodus is that he is compassionate
20:24.975 --> 20:29.039
and that he's, he's slow to anger, and that God does put grace—
20:29.424 --> 20:33.743
uh, God's— they always believed in grace. And so the
20:33.807 --> 20:37.879
grace-law dichotomy is
20:38.328 --> 20:41.005
like, well, the Old Testament's law and the New Testament's grace.
20:41.983 --> 20:45.157
I don't think Paul teaches that. I don't think the Old Testament teaches that.
20:45.606 --> 20:48.572
There is grace in the Old Testament. So that's the first thing I would say,
20:49.838 --> 20:53.830
uh, definitely I think would be really, um, an important contribution
20:54.728 --> 20:58.335
from the new perspective that's really healthy. The second one that John mentioned
20:58.835 --> 21:02.304
is understanding this idea of works, that it
21:02.804 --> 21:06.265
doesn't have to be all of the works, which is how we can reconcile in
21:06.765 --> 21:09.887
a place like Ephesians 2:8 and then 2:10, that it— that
21:10.387 --> 21:13.961
the use of works can have a very specific context. I think this is really
21:14.557 --> 21:18.007
healthy in Churches of Christ and in Christian churches and Stone Campbell
21:18.023 --> 21:20.253
churches because, you know,
21:21.885 --> 21:25.101
one of the, one of the aspects of asking like, what does it mean to
21:25.117 --> 21:27.450
be saved by grace through faith,
21:28.515 --> 21:32.420
or faith only in these things, or are
21:32.920 --> 21:35.980
we saved simply by faith in Christ, which has been one of the debates within
21:36.073 --> 21:39.965
this, is our tradition
21:40.465 --> 21:43.894
has never said you are simply saved by faith in
21:44.394 --> 21:47.390
Christ. That we've said, well, you're saved by faith in Christ, and then what do
21:47.890 --> 21:51.155
we say? We say like, and you put on Christ in baptism.
21:52.338 --> 21:56.241
And this has been sort of, I think, or where you would even
21:56.289 --> 21:59.470
say you, you're saved. There's nothing you can do to earn your salvation,
21:59.502 --> 22:03.084
but you, you, you live out your salvation through
22:03.212 --> 22:05.686
sanctification or these kinds of things.
22:06.955 --> 22:11.195
I think that's just really healthy to say that Paul is never going for some
22:11.244 --> 22:15.773
sort of absolute bare minimum of definition
22:15.870 --> 22:19.114
of faith where it's like there's a fuzzy idea in your
22:19.242 --> 22:22.422
head that you don't act on, that you don't live in.
22:22.856 --> 22:26.132
And somehow that's what Paul is getting people to. I don't see that.
22:26.790 --> 22:29.857
And I think that's where the new perspective has been embraced by a lot of
22:30.357 --> 22:33.374
people in our traditions, because we have believed
22:33.874 --> 22:37.742
that a person
surrenders their life in baptism or that they submit themselves to
22:38.242 --> 22:41.853
the lordship of Jesus or things like this. We're not working our way,
22:42.544 --> 22:44.455
but we do— there is a response.
22:47.442 --> 22:50.707
Yeah, no, that's good. Yeah, the emphasis on
22:51.689 --> 22:54.874
that the Old Testament did not teach salvation by
22:54.986 --> 22:57.912
works and using that to run down,
22:57.977 --> 23:01.511
disparage the law. I think that's been a helpful component of
23:02.011 --> 23:06.155
the new perspective to help us realize and to re-emphasize that salvation
23:06.655 --> 23:08.886
was by grace under the Old Covenant as well as the New. So I do
23:09.386 --> 23:13.277
think that's a strength. Sadly, still I hear way too many
23:13.309 --> 23:16.198
preachers at a popular level just talk about, well, you know,
23:16.824 --> 23:19.616
under the Old Testament it was just all salvation by works,
23:19.648 --> 23:22.601
613 laws they had to keep in order to be saved. And it's like,
23:22.618 --> 23:26.052
well, hold on there. Read the Old Testament on its terms and
23:26.552 --> 23:29.454
then hear what Paul says about it on his terms. And so the new perspective
23:29.954 --> 23:33.820
has given us the opportunity and the freedom to go back and question
23:33.932 --> 23:37.351
some of those popular common ways of packaging
23:37.447 --> 23:41.138
what the Jews believed and what the Old Testament taught. So I think that's
23:41.638 --> 23:45.163
a strength. The other thing I would add to that is the
23:45.663 --> 23:49.429
people of God component that the
23:49.929 --> 23:53.246
new perspective has emphasized. This idea that we're talking about a
23:53.746 --> 23:57.752
people, not just a person. And I think that's important too, that it's not
23:58.252 --> 24:02.227
just a matter of how does an individual get saved, how do
24:02.307 --> 24:05.803
you get into a right relationship with God, but when you get into a
24:06.303 --> 24:09.283
right relationship with God, you also join a people who are in a right relationship
24:09.783 --> 24:13.674
with God. So there's this people of God element, which is
24:13.739 --> 24:17.911
why Romans 9 through 11 is there, right? It's all about that question,
24:17.943 --> 24:21.404
like, what's the place of the Jews? Who are the people of God? You end
24:21.904 --> 24:24.834
Romans 9 through 11 with a family tree. God has one family tree.
24:24.963 --> 24:28.830
It's composed of Jews and Gentiles. So the people of God element
24:29.008 --> 24:32.483
that is emphasized in the new perspective, I think, is a strength of
24:32.516 --> 24:35.779
the new perspective. And then one other thing I would add in as a
24:35.892 --> 24:39.733
I think a strength of the New Perspective is the big story of the
24:39.749 --> 24:44.089
Bible. The New
24:44.589 --> 24:48.492
Perspective has emphasized that Jesus
24:48.912 --> 24:52.365
and the New Covenant is the culmination of a long story,
24:52.543 --> 24:56.510
a whole story that began in Eden, was caught
24:57.010 --> 25:01.074
up again with Abraham in Genesis 12, and includes
25:01.090 --> 25:05.048
the nation of Israel. And you can't You can't just subtract
25:05.112 --> 25:08.502
Israel out or just pick up at Matthew and understand the Bible,
25:08.598 --> 25:12.440
understand Jesus, and understand what's going on. That there is a whole big story
25:12.472 --> 25:16.193
that is culminating in Christ. So I think that's an
25:16.693 --> 25:20.418
important re-emphasis that the new perspective has
25:21.015 --> 25:23.902
brought us back to and forced us to think clearly about.
25:27.919 --> 25:31.522
What are some things, maybe 5 minutes or so, that have not
25:32.022 --> 25:36.731
been helpful, maybe have strayed into the inaccurate
25:37.621 --> 25:39.271
from the new perspective on Paul?
25:42.340 --> 25:45.538
I'll respond to a few criticisms I've heard that I think are fair.
25:45.747 --> 25:49.122
One of them is— one of the criticisms
25:49.622 --> 25:53.542
is, well, if you take Paul within Judaism,
25:54.649 --> 25:58.920
if he's not criticizing it, if we're
25:59.420 --> 26:02.689
saying that his Damascus Road experience was a calling and not
26:03.189 --> 26:07.185
a conversion, if we're saying that Paul has no strong word
26:07.848 --> 26:10.339
for ethnic Jews who have not received Jesus,
26:11.504 --> 26:15.289
if we're saying Romans 9 through 11 is all Israel will be saved and
26:15.789 --> 26:18.576
there's no expected conversion, many people have said,
26:20.540 --> 26:24.248
are we really saying that that Paul wasn't
26:24.748 --> 26:27.277
calling Jewish people to receive Jesus.
26:28.655 --> 26:32.901
And does that make him, you know, sort of maybe go towards a universalist
26:33.401 --> 26:35.850
on this? Um, I think that's a fair criticism.
26:36.747 --> 26:40.288
I, I think that his work in synagogues and his work— what you see
26:40.788 --> 26:44.903
in Acts— entering synagogues and telling Jewish populations
26:45.000 --> 26:49.246
like, you should receive Jesus as the Messiah, I think that that is part
26:49.746 --> 26:53.948
of his missionary work. I do think he sees himself as spreading good
26:53.980 --> 26:57.766
news that is first for Jews but also
26:57.830 --> 27:02.018
for Greeks. I don't think it's the case where he's just saying if
27:02.518 --> 27:05.837
you're ethnically Jewish, sit where you are. This is nothing for you. You just have
27:05.853 --> 27:08.565
to receive Gentiles. I don't think it's that.
27:09.960 --> 27:13.121
The second thing that's related to that is many people who
27:13.169 --> 27:16.378
oppose the new perspective think that the new perspective has a very low
27:16.878 --> 27:20.659
view of the atonement, the atoning death of Jesus, um, that they've also
27:21.210 --> 27:24.578
rejected things, um, that Jesus's death was a substitution
27:24.627 --> 27:28.024
for our sins. And I, I would say,
27:28.234 --> 27:31.752
I
think in, in the New Testament there is substitution
27:31.865 --> 27:34.995
language used in text, even text outside of Paul.
27:35.399 --> 27:38.192
You think about some of the, the teachings of Jesus. Um,
27:38.983 --> 27:42.034
so I, I would not want to go so far
27:42.534 --> 27:45.824
as to say that just because you accept some tenets of the New Perspective or
27:46.324 --> 27:49.901
some of the ideas that, that you would reject. Things like that Jesus died
27:49.917 --> 27:52.870
for our sins and that no matter what your ethnic background is,
27:53.624 --> 27:57.364
that you should receive the atoning blood of his,
27:57.781 --> 28:00.863
um, death and that you would then submit to his lordship.
28:00.943 --> 28:04.747
So those are, those are at least 2 places where probably
28:04.779 --> 28:08.197
on the, on the edges of the New Perspective there's been other ideas that have
28:08.229 --> 28:11.552
come in that I don't know that you need to receive all of
28:11.600 --> 28:14.779
those to kind of align with the core message of what some
28:14.811 --> 28:16.898
of the scholars are doing. Yeah,
28:18.343 --> 28:21.794
that's good. One of the things to realize when we
28:22.294 --> 28:26.385
say new perspective on Paul is it's
28:26.514 --> 28:30.222
a perspective. There's a lot of different
28:30.722 --> 28:34.637
perspectives under the umbrella that fit into that category, and so
28:35.102 --> 28:38.505
you'll find people like who's probably N.T.
28:38.569 --> 28:41.635
Wright's probably the most well-known guy at this present time who
28:41.683 --> 28:45.117
fits into the camp of new perspective. And you'll find him criticizing,
28:45.294 --> 28:48.407
arguing against other people who are in the camp of the new perspective.
28:48.504 --> 28:52.051
So it's not like it's a monolithic kind
28:52.551 --> 28:56.159
of uniform sort of group of people that all think the same way. I think
28:56.659 --> 28:59.883
it's important to recognize that, that there are some differences. So what are weaknesses?
29:01.038 --> 29:05.147
Well, sort of depends on which new perspective writer you're reading and criticizing.
29:06.013 --> 29:09.269
I mean, it's just the reality, right? But having said
29:09.366 --> 29:13.071
that, I would say here's something
29:13.536 --> 29:17.177
that I think is a problem. Bob referenced
29:17.225 --> 29:21.059
E.P. Sanders' book Paul and Palestinian Judaism that came out in 1977
29:21.091 --> 29:24.748
that was sort of like the kind of the fountainhead
29:24.844 --> 29:28.806
for the whole New Perspective movement that said Jews didn't believe
29:28.934 --> 29:32.928
in salvation by works, that wasn't the issue that Paul was addressing.
29:33.668 --> 29:37.399
And we've said the New Testament certainly teaches salvation by grace. The Jew, you know,
29:37.480 --> 29:40.741
Israel was redeemed before they received the law. You read the Old
29:41.241 --> 29:44.770
Testament, right? So that's— in that sense that the Old
29:45.270
--> 29:48.805
Testament teaches salvation by grace doesn't necessarily mean there
29:49.305 --> 29:51.839
wasn't a single Jew who struggled with salvation by grace.
29:53.645 --> 29:57.064
And so to make it monolithic on the other side, no Jews struggle with
29:57.564 --> 29:59.887
it, Paul never had to address that, I think that's an overstatement.
30:01.107 --> 30:05.001
And I think we have to be honest with that. Like Protestantism today,
30:05.289 --> 30:09.279
by and large, teaches salvation by grace, and yet
30:09.779 --> 30:13.606
I know plenty of individual Christians who struggle with salvation by grace and think
30:14.106 --> 30:16.827
they have to do more, right? Were there Jews that thought that way?
30:18.109 --> 30:20.689
Well, one, just human experience would tell us probably so,
30:21.298 --> 30:25.321
but some of the 1st century material, 2nd Temple Judaism
30:25.821 --> 30:29.169
material, indicates sure enough they did struggle with some of
30:29.669 --> 30:33.178
that. So E.P. Sanders overstated his case and swung the pendulum
30:33.678 --> 30:37.043
too far the other way. I think that's a problem. So some
30:37.543 --> 30:40.908
of the things Paul says in his letters do probably address this
30:41.101 --> 30:44.998
issue of our tendency as human beings to think I have to do more
30:45.126 --> 30:47.130
to make God welcome me,
30:48.093 --> 30:51.669
so I think we can be a little more nuanced about that than going
30:51.910 --> 30:55.139
completely the other way. Another problem,
30:55.205 --> 30:58.947
I think, criticism with the people of God is that— I mean,
31:00.310 --> 31:03.638
with the New Perspective is like when
31:03.670 --> 31:06.950
you read N.T. Wright as an example
31:07.450 --> 31:11.350
of the New Perspective, he so emphasizes the people of God perspective
31:11.850 --> 31:15.316
that the individual is almost completely lost. And when
31:15.381 --> 31:18.660
pressed on it, he would say, no, no, no, I know that that's all there
31:18.708 --> 31:22.510
and that's important. That's all well and good, but because he thinks he's
31:22.558 --> 31:26.633
correcting a problem, he overstates the solution
31:27.227 --> 31:30.307
and creates another problem, and so I'm concerned about that.
31:30.419 --> 31:33.643
That yes, your salvation is not individual,
31:34.205 --> 31:37.429
but it's personal, right? We all have
31:37.929 --> 31:40.573
a personal relationship with Jesus. We just don't have an individual one,
31:41.809 --> 31:45.454
and so again we need to be a little bit more both/and than either/or.
31:45.664 --> 31:50.077
And I think sometimes in the new perspective they've turned the whole— in
31:50.109 --> 31:53.266
trying to correct some of the perceived problems with
31:53.766 --> 31:57.141
the post-Protestant Reformation reading of Paul, they've created new problems
31:57.222 --> 31:59.882
by making it a little too either/or rather than both/and.
32:01.800 --> 32:03.160
Let me ask this.
32:04.975 --> 32:09.123
There may be preachers, there may be scholars
32:09.623 --> 32:12.241
or whatnot who have read Paul, preached Paul.
32:12.691 --> 32:15.501
I'm listening to Bob talk about how he, uh,
32:15.966 --> 32:19.194
courageously preached all of Romans last
32:19.694 --> 32:23.208
year. Um, but, but there may be the preacher or, or those who
32:23.708 --> 32:26.772
are out there, you know, I feel good about how I interpret Paul. I feel
32:26.885 --> 32:30.915
good about what I've been, what I've learned, what I've— what
32:31.415 --> 32:34.335
do you say that they may be, um,
32:34.769 --> 32:38.149
missing and I don't even want to use missing as if there's something we
32:38.213 --> 32:42.757
have to receive from it, but might be overlooking,
32:42.821 --> 32:46.293
if you will, if they rejected the
32:46.793 --> 32:50.644
new perspective just off the top, they say, no, I'm good on
32:50.660 --> 32:54.251
mine. What would be areas that you would say you
32:54.751 --> 32:56.196
may want to consider this?
33:00.210 --> 33:01.785
I'll go back to something I said earlier.
33:03.359 --> 33:06.474
For preachers, I think that the number one—
33:06.650 --> 33:09.444
I mean, one of the number one things we wrestle with is our context.
33:10.103 --> 33:13.121
And, and there's a congregational context. That's what we preach to.
33:13.169 --> 33:17.440
We preach to people in a context. And it—
33:17.585 --> 33:21.631
the New Perspective is helpful because it really asks hard,
33:21.679 --> 33:25.260
serious questions about what contextually Paul is doing in his letters.
33:26.095 --> 33:29.852
And so you don't read 1 Corinthians and Romans in the same way because Paul's
33:30.029 --> 33:33.613
context is fundamentally different, and he's not
33:33.661 --> 33:37.220
doing systematic theology and then imposing his systematic
33:37.720 --> 33:41.787
theology on these different congregations. Instead, he's asking really sensitive questions,
33:43.009 --> 33:46.417
and I would say that's
33:46.917 --> 33:50.358
a strength of the New Perspective is it said that
33:50.858 --> 33:54.013
it is just very clear that when Paul was talking to a largely Gentile
33:54.110 --> 33:57.121
audience, he does not do theology the way that when he speaks
33:57.621 --> 34:00.235
to a largely Jewish audience or a multiethnic audience.
34:01.666 --> 34:04.878
And I would say by getting in those granular
34:04.959 --> 34:09.215
details of a book like Romans and asking what was the dispute
34:09.715 --> 34:12.877
that he's mediating and what are his ways of working it out, what are the
34:12.909 --> 34:16.924
ways he works it out differently in Romans with meat idols or meat
34:17.406 --> 34:20.474
than he does when he talks about meat idols in 1 Corinthians.
34:21.245 --> 34:24.329
What is this list of names in Romans 16?
34:25.357 --> 34:30.204
This is congregational for us. Paul is not doing just trying He's
34:30.704 --> 34:32.127
not doing philosophical theology.
34:33.760 -->
34:38.072
He's tried— there are names and faces. When Paul talks in Colossians,
34:38.928 --> 34:42.736
there's a specific context. When he talks in Philippians, there's debates
34:43.236 --> 34:46.658
within that church. There's conflicts within that church. 1 Timothy has a context.
34:48.372 --> 34:52.582
That's what I would say is I do think the new perspective will
34:52.695 --> 34:56.712
help understand the particular context that shaped
34:57.212 --> 35:00.920
the theology Paul arrives at. Which will help preachers
35:01.501 --> 35:04.747
bring— or help preachers kind of do
35:05.247 --> 35:07.217
contextual theology in our own situations.
35:08.860 --> 35:11.920
Gotcha. John, you got anything on that? I mean,
35:15.143 --> 35:18.493
I just go back to the way I've typically heard Romans or Galatians
35:18.590 --> 35:21.875
taught and preached as arguing
35:21.972 --> 35:25.578
against earning your salvation, arguing against salvation
35:26.078 --> 35:31.014
by works. And so if you ignore
35:31.305 --> 35:34.769
some of the insights of the new perspective on Paul and you preach
35:34.866 --> 35:37.996
Romans the classic post-Protestant Reformation way of
35:38.367 --> 35:41.755
it's all about telling you you
35:42.255 --> 35:45.880
need to avoid salvation by works, I think you're going to misrepresent what
35:46.380 --> 35:50.571
Paul is talking about. I think you're going to misunderstand
35:52.657 --> 35:55.724
some of the specific things in either Romans or Galatians.
35:57.193 --> 36:00.986
Why in the world does Paul make such a big deal out of circumcision
36:01.486 --> 36:05.683
in Galatians chapter 5? Well, because they
36:05.764 --> 36:08.648
thought by circumcising their baby boys they were earning their salvation.
36:10.116 --> 36:13.235
Not at all. Circumcision never had that, right?
36:13.283 --> 36:17.126
So why does he want to spend so much time— not
36:17.626 --> 36:20.293
only that, why is Paul so angry in Galatians?
36:20.454 --> 36:23.970
It's the only letter of Paul where there's no thanksgiving for the church.
36:24.853 --> 36:28.193
The only one. He opens it instead of a thanksgiving,
36:28.225 --> 36:31.372
says, if anyone rejects what I'm about to say, let them be damned. Let them
36:31.436 --> 36:34.486
be accursed. And then it culminates with circumcision. Why?
36:34.952 --> 36:38.404
Why? Why in the middle in Galatians chapter 3 is there an
36:38.904 --> 36:42.932
entire recounting of the Old Testament story from Abraham
36:42.980 --> 36:47.410
to Israel to Jesus? Well, if you
36:47.910 --> 36:51.792
think it's all about a charter of liberty
36:52.146 --> 36:55.404
by which we're, you know, freed from having to earn our salvation,
36:55.918 --> 36:58.117
what do you do with Abraham? What do you do with circumcision? What do you
36:58.617 --> 37:02.467
do with Israel? What do you do with any of that? You're most likely going
37:02.483 --> 37:06.078
to either mishear Paul and maybe misrepresent Paul in your preaching
and teaching
37:06.110 --> 37:09.465
unless you all of a sudden have the freedom to realize, oh,
37:09.963 --> 37:13.590
maybe Paul's concerns are different concerns. Let me understand his concerns.
37:13.655 --> 37:17.133
What's the theology undergirding his concerns? Now let me preach that
37:17.633 --> 37:19.640
theology into my context as Bob has just said.
37:21.310 --> 37:24.791
Does that make sense? Oh yeah. Yeah, yeah. No, I think it also— like,
37:24.872 --> 37:28.079
here's one specific line in Galatians that I think is important.
37:28.470 --> 37:31.412
The fruit of the Spirit is— we all know how great the fruit of the
37:31.912 --> 37:34.852
Spirit is: love, joy, peace, patience, kindness, goodness, gentleness, faithfulness,
37:35.013 --> 37:39.064
self-control. And then the very next line we leave off: against such things
37:39.097 --> 37:42.233
there is no law. No law, right? Why does he have to say
37:42.733 --> 37:45.326
that when he's given the fruit of the Spirit? Why does he have to bring
37:45.358 --> 37:48.451
up the law? He brought it up just before he listed it off too.
37:48.867 --> 37:51.383
Like, you know, if you walk by the Spirit, you're not under the law.
37:51.832 --> 37:54.893
Why this whole law stuff in the context of the fruit of the Spirit?
37:55.389 --> 37:58.514
Again, if you don't allow Paul to
37:59.014 --> 38:02.184
speak on his terms, you don't know what to do with some of these specific
38:02.248 --> 38:04.844
phrases and how to teach them and what Paul's really talking about.
38:08.355 --> 38:11.886
Is there a verse in Paul that
38:12.386 --> 38:16.475
shows that he is definitely concerned with
38:16.684 --> 38:21.161
people who are thinking that they can work their way to
38:22.140 --> 38:23.889
heaven based on their merit?
38:25.270 --> 38:28.543
And I ask that because, you know, would it— it'd probably be possible
38:28.559 --> 38:32.314
to have the opposite lens shift
38:32.427 --> 38:37.868
to where now everything becomes just that one horizontal
38:38.847 --> 38:42.795
concern, and so is there a verse there that we can look at?
38:42.924 --> 38:46.824
Okay, it's clear that he at least has this in view here.
38:47.674 --> 38:51.735
Yeah, and I think it's a good question because again I feel like it's easy
38:52.490 --> 38:56.149
again to turn it into an all or nothing, right? An either or rather
38:56.181 --> 38:59.327
than a both and, and I do think
38:59.375 --> 39:02.810
Paul is somewhat concerned with that. I do think justification by faith
39:02.986 --> 39:07.720
in Romans chapter 3:21-26 addresses
39:07.833 --> 39:10.983
this concern of ours that we
39:11.128 --> 39:14.666
don't have to work our way into a right relationship with God.
39:14.796 --> 39:18.490
So I think the question's important because I think
39:18.554 --> 39:22.004
Paul is sometimes doing both
39:22.037 --> 39:25.315
parts of the equation rather than just one. So Romans
39:25.412 --> 39:29.088
3:21-26, Paul in a very dense paragraph
39:29.136 --> 39:32.375
lays out his understanding of justification by faith.
39:32.963 --> 39:36.189
Apart from works of the law, right? And he's thinking
39:36.689 --> 39:39.543
of works of the Torah. And he tells us, you know,
39:40.185 --> 39:43.765
that we are justified by faith apart from those
39:43.797 --> 39:47.247
works as a gift. Those kinds of phrases to me
39:47.747 --> 39:51.340
indicate that Paul is wanting to make sure he emphasizes it is a sheer— it's
39:51.840 --> 39:55.818
a present, not a paycheck, right? Like he's
39:56.318 --> 40:01.225
wanting to emphasize these things with these phrases. So Those little phrases indicate it's
40:01.289 --> 40:05.460
not that there's no concern for that. There's just more
40:05.960 --> 40:09.936
than that also being addressed in Romans chapter 3. Or when
40:10.436 --> 40:13.786
you get to the culmination of his discussion of justification,
40:14.363 --> 40:18.582
right? So you get chapter 4 of Romans, and you get the long example
40:18.614 --> 40:22.063
from Abraham about justification by faith. It goes clear back to Genesis
40:22.563 --> 40:26.281
15:6, and then it culminates in Romans 5:1. I think you get another
40:26.313 --> 40:30.255
verse that deals with this concern of our
40:30.383 --> 40:34.069
own tendency to feel like I got to do more to make God
40:34.569 --> 40:38.059
like me. So Romans 5:1, therefore, having been
40:38.155 --> 40:41.825
justified by faith, we— not should
40:41.841 --> 40:45.734
have, will have— we have peace with God as
40:45.799 --> 40:49.164
a statement of fact dealing with our own personal relationship with God.
40:49.244 --> 40:53.201
It's now marked by shalom and harmony and peace. Not by hostility
40:53.698 --> 40:56.951
and fear of wrath. And so there is the personal side.
40:57.800 --> 41:01.341
There is the I don't have to strive to
41:01.841 --> 41:05.346
make God like me component in this long section of Romans.
41:05.410 --> 41:08.807
It's just even though there is that, there's also more than that,
41:09.335 --> 41:13.357
right? Because each person, whether Jew or Gentile
41:13.421 --> 41:16.770
in their case, whether Black or white or whatever else in our case,
41:16.786 --> 41:20.166
whatever our divisions are, because each person comes to God
41:20.666 --> 41:23.570
the same way, The ground is level at the foot of the cross. Guess what?
41:24.148 --> 41:27.088
It also brings us all together as one people of God as well.
41:27.603 --> 41:31.153
So there's the individual side, personal side, but there's also the
41:31.653 --> 41:35.411
corporate collective side in what Paul is doing. I think Ephesians 2
41:35.911 --> 41:39.107
is another classic example that answers your question, Daniel, where,
41:39.589 --> 41:43.220
you know, by grace you have been saved through faith, not as a result
41:43.720 --> 41:46.787
of work, so that no one should boast. For we are his workmanship, created in
41:46.819 --> 41:50.145
Christ Jesus for good
works. And so yeah, you know,
41:50.226 --> 41:51.224
it's interesting too.
41:53.746 --> 41:57.040
I would suspect culturally, to speak to the importance
41:57.540 --> 42:01.104
of this, I would suspect culturally this was a larger deal
42:01.699 --> 42:06.877
when a lot of church people defined their earlier
42:06.942 --> 42:08.995
life in church as legalism.
42:12.697 --> 42:16.346
And so there was this idea like there's no question that Martin Luther felt
42:16.846 --> 42:20.433
like he was totally in the bondage of
42:20.658 --> 42:23.527
like Roman Catholic rules,
42:24.526 --> 42:27.718
abuses. I mean, most of the 95 Theses,
42:27.750 --> 42:31.479
I think the number one egregious sin he addresses repeatedly is the selling of
42:31.979 --> 42:35.343
indulgences. And so if that's
42:35.843 --> 42:39.920
your framework, then I can see the attraction
42:40.292 --> 42:43.921
to that. I don't know that we have a lot of people
42:44.421 --> 42:47.803
whose number one theological question right now is like, is there a
42:48.303 --> 42:51.732
loving, gracious God who will free me from the bondage of legalism?
42:53.079 --> 42:56.511
Um, we're just not dealing— that's just not a ministry
42:56.527 --> 42:59.429
context that I feel— I think, I think for a certain age of people,
42:59.445 --> 43:03.102
that's absolutely what they feel like they got. I think,
43:03.182 --> 43:06.919
I think there might be a different set of questions right now. Um, you know,
43:07.207 --> 43:10.527
one of the leading Paul scholars on this was Krister Stendahl
43:10.719 --> 43:13.141
in, in the, um, '60s and '70s.
43:14.265 --> 43:17.462
He responded by— his kind of response
43:17.962 --> 43:22.329
to this whole thing was like he thought modern society had
43:22.522 --> 43:25.076
read Paul through the lens of psychology.
43:25.975 --> 43:29.815
And so rather, you know, Martin Luther would say, where do I find a gracious
43:29.911 --> 43:32.658
God? Is there a God who will accept me? And he believed that we just
43:33.158 --> 43:36.947
took that for hundreds of years and said, like, is there
43:37.076 --> 43:40.529
a God in the world who will provide peace for my troubled
43:41.029 --> 43:44.684
soul? He presented his lecture on Paul and introspective
43:45.184 --> 43:48.356
conscience of the West to like a psychological association.
43:48.452 --> 43:52.220
He was like a keynote speaker at a meeting for psychologists and
43:52.236 --> 43:55.075
just believed that he had made this really psychological,
43:56.229 --> 43:59.581
um, which I can appreciate. I mean, I think there is
43:59.613 --> 44:03.221
some angle to what Luther was going through. I think
44:03.721 --> 44:07.743
there might be just different questions on the table in 2026 as people
44:08.578 --> 44:13.252
read the New Testament texts. And it could be that
44:13.752 --> 44:17.556
people are actually asking some of the collective questions
44:17.829 --> 44:20.977
that Paul was— that Paul is answering, like,
44:22.471 --> 44:26.101
does God have a seat at the table for different groups of people?
44:27.546 --> 44:30.694
And do— does my group have to feel
44:31.194 --> 44:35.464
a sense of shame even though we've been the excluded group? Or Or does
44:35.480 --> 44:39.800
my group have to feel a sense of shame because we've been the excluding
44:39.976 --> 44:43.701
group? All of these really relevant social questions I
44:44.201 --> 44:48.149
think might have more cultural currency
44:48.181 --> 44:51.328
than maybe they did for a generation who was raised on legalism.
44:51.730 --> 44:55.134
So maybe that's a fresh thing to think about and how this
44:55.230 --> 44:59.068
can relate to our ministries. I think that's good, Bob. I would add
45:00.447 --> 45:03.587
I think it depends, like you've said, on your context. I literally was just
45:04.087 --> 45:06.920
at a small church in Western Oregon preaching last weekend,
45:07.674 --> 45:10.366
and then we did a Q&A. They combined all the adult Sunday school classes,
45:10.382 --> 45:14.083
did a Q&A with me, and we spent 20,
45:14.163 --> 45:16.535
30 minutes of that Q&A, um,
45:17.833 --> 45:21.118
and it was all about legalism and salvation and
45:21.618 --> 45:25.156
grace and works. So, but it was a group
45:25.656 --> 45:29.091
of people that were 50-plus.
45:29.139 --> 45:32.291
So they're still asking the question, and they're still wrestling with the question.
45:34.126 --> 45:36.798
And so I just think we have to be sensitive to that, and I do
45:37.298 --> 45:41.241
think Paul— what Paul says speaks to that question. Romans 5:1-2.
45:41.305 --> 45:44.026
I mean, that was the verse I gave him to memorize and meditate on and
45:44.526 --> 45:48.048
think through, and we explored that together and what that means because I think it
45:48.548 --> 45:52.914
speaks to that question. So I think what Paul says contrary
45:53.414 --> 45:56.361
to what you sometimes would read or hear or get the sense of from New
45:56.861 --> 46:00.705
Perspective people, I think Paul does have some things to say to
46:00.769 --> 46:04.104
that topic. On the flip side, when I'm sitting
46:04.120 --> 46:07.438
with 22, 23-year-olds, they're wrestling more with the kind
46:07.938 --> 46:11.430
of questions you just addressed, and I think Paul has something to
46:11.930 --> 46:16.352
say to that group of people too, so if we limit Paul one
46:16.400 --> 46:20.044
way or the other, and turn it into an either/or rather than both/and, I think
46:20.109 --> 46:24.358
we, one, misunderstand Paul and limit what Paul has to say to both—
46:24.730 --> 46:28.422
to all different groups of people in our world. Great point,
46:28.471 --> 46:32.127
John. One thing I was reflecting on, I preached Romans last year.
46:32.191 --> 46:35.944
Right now I'm working in the Sermon on the Mount, and I
46:36.074 --> 46:39.582
would say to bring Jesus into this, you know, sometimes we
46:40.082 --> 46:43.743
can like let Paul be Paul and do what he's doing, but like I just—
46:43.999 --> 46:47.339
Jesus's teachings on the disposition of
46:47.387 --> 46:51.128
the heart and how every— it's like every paragraph of
46:51.160 --> 46:54.837
the Sermon on the Mount basically says no matter what
46:55.337 --> 46:58.064
your externals are, if your heart is not right with God, then you're not where
46:58.564 --> 47:03.089
God wants you. And Jesus there is speaking against
47:03.265 --> 47:06.509
the sort of external religious
47:07.054 --> 47:10.469
performative holiness that I
47:10.646 --> 47:14.197
do think people need to hear a rejection
47:14.697 --> 47:17.908
of that, whether they want to call it legalism or whatever they want to call
47:18.036 --> 47:21.173
it, sectarianism or whatever, and Jesus
47:21.673 --> 47:24.619
gets people back to the heart. So that's kind of another biblical resource that I
47:25.119 --> 47:28.869
think addresses some of the things that we need to be speaking
47:28.870 --> 47:32.177
against, but I think there Jesus is clearly doing it. I don't think there's
47:32.677 --> 47:35.845
a big debate about that. Yeah. As I, as I listen
47:35.957 --> 47:39.332
to you guys, I, I've been learning. I just
47:39.396 --> 47:43.076
learned a new phrase as well— performative holiness.
47:44.297 --> 47:47.495
We could almost do a whole, uh, podcast on that one. Guys,
47:48.089 --> 47:52.219
I want to say thank you to, uh, to John and to Bob for
47:52.653 --> 47:56.718
how you have just unpacked, uh, the new perspective on
47:56.830 --> 48:00.253
Paul. Again, as a student here, I'm learning
48:00.526 --> 48:04.249
And, um, and, and I've been given some things to, to chew
48:04.298 --> 48:08.005
on, some things to rethink, uh, and, and hopefully to our
48:08.505 --> 48:11.680
viewers and listeners, hopefully you've gotten something as well. Uh,
48:11.760 --> 48:15.371
I do like the point that you guys both made that, um,
48:15.452 --> 48:18.999
it is not kind of a take every part of
48:19.499 --> 48:22.995
it because it is a perspective, as you put, uh, John. And there, there may
48:23.011 --> 48:26.221
be parts of this where you say, okay, now I see that, I, I hear
48:26.721 --> 48:29.945
that. Um, and I also liked, uh, Bob, how you both as well,
48:30.154 --> 48:33.605
but Bob in particular, how you pointed out the context,
48:33.910 --> 48:36.704
um, and, and how that matters. You know, in our circles,
48:37.217 --> 48:40.572
uh, context is king, especially how we look at the text. So,
48:40.669 --> 48:44.168
uh, thank you both, uh, and thank those of you who've been listening.
48:44.746 --> 48:48.631
Um, you know, John has been speaking a lot about NT Wright,
48:49.081 --> 48:53.014
uh, and, and he has a nice, nice piece, uh, on NT
48:53.094 --> 48:56.723
Wright on renew.org. It's called N.T.
48:56.884 --> 49:00.159
Wright: A Theological Appraisal. We would
49:00.659 --> 49:04.093
encourage you all to look at that as well, and even as you're
49:04.593 --> 49:07.770
chewing on this subject. So thank you
49:07.802 --> 49:11.158
all for listening, for joining us. Be sure to like
49:11.658 --> 49:13.839
this, share this, follow us on Renew.
49:14.931 --> 49:18.945
And for all of us here, thank you for listening to Scripture.
49:19.010 --> 49:20.264
Scripture in black and white.