전사 🔗
WEBVTT
00:00:09.150 --> 00:00:09.150
[Podcast jingle][ringtone] Hello?
00:00:09.150 --> 00:00:09.779
Oh, it is recording.
00:00:09.781 --> 00:00:10.679
I see the little figure.
00:00:10.740 --> 00:00:11.160
Okay, great.
00:00:11.369 --> 00:00:14.160
I will do my little spiel and then I'll introduce you.
00:00:14.310 --> 00:00:14.699
Nice.
00:00:14.910 --> 00:00:15.240
Okay.
00:00:15.630 --> 00:00:16.079
Here I go.
00:00:17.629 --> 00:00:24.260
So! Hi, I'm Sue and I'm from the Salvesen Mindroom Research Centre at the University of Edinburgh.
00:00:24.710 --> 00:00:33.859
We wanted to do something for all the practitioners, and parents, and students, who are stuck at home, but who still want to be developing their knowledge, even during the lockdown.
00:00:34.429 --> 00:00:43.789
With lots of folks homeschooling and our usual family routines disrupted, it feels like Developmental Psychology is a good topic right now, and I'm a developmental psychologist.
00:00:44.299 --> 00:00:50.960
So what we're doing is short phone calls with psychologists who study learning and development in children and young people.
00:00:51.259 --> 00:00:53.090
And this is the first one.
00:00:54.049 --> 00:01:08.689
So today's PsychologiCALL is with Vic Simms from Ulster University, and she's going to talk to me about a paper with the title"Understanding number line estimation in Williams syndrome and Down syndrome".
00:01:09.319 --> 00:01:09.709
Hello Vic! How are you?
00:01:12.500 --> 00:01:17.569
Hello! Uh, I'm great, yes, thank you! Yes, um, greetings from a very strangely sunny, uh, Ulster!
00:01:18.379 --> 00:01:19.280
Oh, lovely.
00:01:19.370 --> 00:01:21.290
Yeah, we've got sunny weather in Edinburgh too.
00:01:21.290 --> 00:01:21.980
So that's good.
00:01:23.390 --> 00:01:28.819
Um, so tell me, what was it that you discovered when you were doing this bit of research that we're talking about today?
00:01:29.959 --> 00:01:35.599
So I suppose I have been obsessed with, um, mathematical development for quite a long time.
00:01:36.230 --> 00:01:41.840
And my first post-doctoral position in 2008, looked at a task called the number line estimation task.
00:01:42.650 --> 00:01:44.569
Um, it's a really simple task to think about.
00:01:44.570 --> 00:01:58.849
So just imagine right now Sue, I'm asking you to think about the numbers from zero to a hundred, and you're probably thinking that they go from left to right, and, and with the big numbers on the right hand side and the little numbers on the left-hand side.
00:01:59.390 --> 00:02:13.490
And what's been really interesting about loads of research that we've done as a group, and also other people across the world is that kids' performance on being able to position numbers on that number line, so estimate where numbers go on that number line seems to be related to their mathematical ability.
00:02:14.419 --> 00:02:22.550
And one of the things that people thought about was this is like a k-, kind of like a direct lens into
Load full transcript
how people represented number in their mind.
00:02:22.550 --> 00:02:28.460
So using this task was like an instant snapshot of how people stored number in their brain.
00:02:29.180 --> 00:02:43.580
And we kind of thought that it couldn't be that simple because when we're asking people to estimate the position on a number line, they're having to make a physical mark on a, on a number line, they're having to do proportion-, proportional thinking, all of these types of things.
00:02:44.240 --> 00:03:01.000
So we were really fascinated by some of the research that was coming out suggesting that, um, the relationship between number line estimation and mathematical ability might be mediated, or it might be confounded by some other skills, such as visuospatial processing.
00:03:01.780 --> 00:03:10.599
And that's where, um a little grant opportunity came my way with, um, Jo Van Herwegen, and the late great Annette Karmiloff-Smith.
00:03:11.740 --> 00:03:15.400
Um, because we knew that individuals with Williams syndrome are...
00:03:15.460 --> 00:03:18.460
typically have quite poor visual spatial processing skills.
00:03:18.819 --> 00:03:25.240
And we thought we could ask quite a theoretically grounded question about, um, their performance on a number line estimation task.
00:03:25.780 --> 00:03:56.229
So that was kind of the motivation for doing this study, to understand"are there very kind of general cognitive skills that might impact people's performance to do number line estimation, and is that related to mathematical abilities?" Um, and then at the same time, we were able to look at a group of individuals with Down syndrome, and we know that individuals with down syndrome have um, uh, good-, relatively good visuospatial skills, but might have a little bit more problems with kind of fluency, verbal fluency.
00:03:56.740 --> 00:04:04.360
So it was a really interesting comparison study to do for a theoretical psychologist, a developmental psychologist who's really interested in theory, but also in a practical sense as well.
00:04:04.650 --> 00:04:06.599
Okay so...
00:04:06.870 --> 00:04:08.789
So if I've understood correctly then...
00:04:08.790 --> 00:04:08.939
Yeah.
00:04:08.790 --> 00:04:14.729
...You're trying to kind of separate out with this task what part of it is about how good you are at maths...
00:04:15.240 --> 00:04:15.449
Yeah.
00:04:15.960 --> 00:04:16.379
...
00:04:15.960 --> 00:04:27.000
and what part of it is about how good you are at more general visiospatial things like picturing things in your head, um, estimating kind of sizes and lengths of things.
00:04:27.029 --> 00:04:27.360
Is that, is that right?
00:04:27.410 --> 00:04:27.569
Yeah.
00:04:27.410 --> 00:04:29.129
Absolutely, yes.
00:04:29.130 --> 00:05:14.279
So we have, um, we can have a really interesting, very clearly, um, hypothesis-driven study that says, well actually, if individuals who have poor visualspatial skills, so being able to, you know, a typical task of visual spatial processing might be, uh, um, design copying, so asking children, young people, adults to copy some pictures that kind of helps us understand their visual spatial processing, we might be able to parse that out of their performance.
00:05:14.281 --> 00:05:19.470
So can we work out in number line estimation, how much, how much is important...
00:05:19.471 --> 00:05:21.000
How important is visual spatial processing?
00:05:21.240 --> 00:05:23.389
How important is it with your familiarity with just numbers?
00:05:23.399 --> 00:05:28.019
You know, your ability to count forwards and backwards.
00:05:28.110 --> 00:05:37.500
So we can start to really understand what that task is measuring, but we also might understand how we could help people improve their performance, um, in some mathematical tasks.
00:05:37.500 --> 00:05:56.639
And I think the really exciting thing about the paper that we published, um, this was at the end of last year, is that, um, actually the comparative or the relative strengths of individuals with Williams syndrome, so their fluency with numbers, is the thing that predicts their, their performance in the number line estimation task, and individuals with Down syndrome, their relative strength with
00:05:57.139 --> 00:05:58.339
Oh, that's so nice! So...
00:05:57.920 --> 00:06:04.759
So different groups of children are drawing on different kinds of strengths to achieve the same task.
00:06:05.410 --> 00:06:05.980
Yeah! Absolutely.
00:06:06.250 --> 00:06:21.879
And I think that that's a really important and a positive message to be able to take some-, from some of the research that maybe parents and practitioners hear kind of, you know, the kind of"these are difficulties, these are difficulties", but we're saying actually relative strengths are the things that we could maybe tap into to, to aid performance.
00:06:22.810 --> 00:06:26.189
Um, on that's, that kind of is also something that we like to think about as well.
00:06:26.190 --> 00:06:27.459
Um we, um...
00:06:27.550 --> 00:06:33.430
In some of our research with, um, people like Camilla Gilmore and Sam Johnson we've been looking a lot at children who are born very pre-term.
00:06:33.819 --> 00:06:38.350
And again, we kind of try and think about, well, what are the relative strengths that these children might have?
00:06:38.560 --> 00:06:45.459
Or how can we change the environment around them to help support their, their achievements or their performance in certain types of tasks.
00:06:45.850 --> 00:06:53.709
So taking a slightly different spin on things, um, and trying to think about the more positive aspects to support learning rather than always thinking about the difficulties.
00:06:55.180 --> 00:06:55.930
That's lovely.
00:06:56.170 --> 00:07:02.920
So, so before we get onto thinking a little bit more about what we can learn from it, can you just tell me a bit about how you did the study?
00:07:02.949 --> 00:07:07.839
Did you sit down face to face with these, uh,
children and young people?
00:07:08.500 --> 00:07:11.980
Um, did they have a number line in front of them or was it a computer task?
00:07:11.531 --> 00:07:11.980
Tell me some...
00:07:12.370 --> 00:07:12.759
Yeah.
00:07:13.180 --> 00:07:16.149
So this is part of a study funded by the British Academy.
00:07:16.151 --> 00:07:21.459
These are quite small grants, but they get a lot of bang for their buck I think by funding these projects.
00:07:21.850 --> 00:07:26.980
And so we had a really lovely, uh, researcher, Erica Ranzato, who worked on the project.
00:07:27.310 --> 00:07:39.850
And she did one-to-one assessments with, um, individuals who have Williams syndrome, Down syndrome, and then a very broad range of age groups of children and adults, so that we could have comparison groups.
00:07:40.420 --> 00:07:40.750
Um...
00:07:40.779 --> 00:07:48.129
The assessments were one-to- one, and one of the tasks that they did was the number line estimation task, and that was done just on paper and pencil.
00:07:48.220 --> 00:07:48.589
Um...
00:07:48.610 --> 00:07:51.250
We have this task now on an iPad.
00:07:51.730 --> 00:08:03.430
Um, that's that's okay, but sometimes, um, the measurements, their can be measurement issues because you can't get the precision of a lovely, finely drawn pencil mark on a page, while, um, when we're using the iPad, it can be a bit, a bit messier.
00:08:03.430 --> 00:08:08.290
So we've had to use the paper and pencil to mea-, uh, paper and pencil task for this study.
00:08:08.889 --> 00:08:18.310
Uh, but the young people, uh, children on adults did a number of other tasks that I think someone else might speak too about, uh, at another time during, uh, your, your little chats?
00:08:19.029 --> 00:08:20.500
I think they might, that's right, yeah.
00:08:20.319 --> 00:08:31.629
[Laughs] Um, and so, so you're asking them to mark on the line, according to a number that you've given them, and then you're literally just measuring how accurately they managed to do that?
00:08:32.019 --> 00:08:32.320
Yes.
00:08:32.379 --> 00:08:49.450
So what we do is this, this is, uh, bringing developmental psychology, right down to the first principles[laughs] where we, um, use a lot of paper, um, and give individuals blank number lines, and we ask them to position the number that we ask them on the number line on each number has a separate number line.
00:08:49.451 --> 00:08:54.879
So you can't use your last, um, estimation to help predict your next estimation.
00:08:55.470 --> 00:09:00.659
And, um, that's really important because we want people to think about each number as a novel entity.
00:09:01.620 --> 00:09:23.039
Um, then what you have to do, as a research assistant I had to do this on a longitudinal study, uh, with maybe about five, it must've been 500 participants effectively, and you measure the distance from the zero point to where that estimation is, and then we can work out how accurate, um the person's estimation is in comparison to where the actual position of the numbers.
00:09:23.399 --> 00:09:39.059
There's quite a lot of calculations involved, but it means that we can do some nice, quite simple statistical analysis to work out the amount of error in estimation and also how, um, how spread out the numbers are across the number line.
00:09:39.090 --> 00:09:52.230
And what we typically see is children show a profile where they spread the small numbers out, very, very, very large spaces between them, um, and then they squash all the big numbers together at the very end.
00:09:51.900 --> 00:09:55.289
So we would describe that as a logarithmic distribution.
00:09:55.830 --> 00:09:56.129
Um...
00:09:56.190 --> 00:09:59.850
And what you see with development is that they become a nice linear distribution.
00:09:59.850 --> 00:10:07.080
So individuals become better at being able to space those numbers across the line evenly and with age and development.
00:10:08.299 --> 00:10:14.240
Um, and you obviously wanted to capture visual spatial skills as well, given your hypothesis...
00:10:14.269 --> 00:10:14.570
Yeah.
00:10:14.269 --> 00:10:14.570
So...
00:10:15.110 --> 00:10:19.100
Did you use, can you maybe just give me an example of one thing you use to measure that?
00:10:19.490 --> 00:10:19.789
Yes.
00:10:19.820 --> 00:10:24.440
So in this study we just used a very well-known kind of block design tasks.
00:10:24.441 --> 00:10:31.970
So people are given some images and they have to try and recreate the images with the manipulatives or the little blocks that they're given.
00:10:32.299 --> 00:10:45.320
So we have used a variety of different visual, spatial tasks in a number of different studies when we've been looking at mathematics, and this seems to be a good task that seems to relate quite highly with mathematical skills.
00:10:45.321 --> 00:10:56.269
So being able to think about an image and recreate it nearly in your mental space, um, and then be able to produce something at the end is a good way to measure those visual spatial skills.
00:10:56.419 --> 00:11:01.669
But we totally recognize there are multiple ways to be able to assess visual spatial skills.
00:11:01.671 --> 00:11:03.440
It's a really complex area of research.
00:11:03.441 --> 00:11:07.159
And lots people, that is their sole focus, is looking at visual spatial processing.
00:11:07.519 --> 00:11:13.009
And I suppose, as someone who's interested in mathematical cognition, we look for the tasks that we see that perform well.
00:11:13.669 --> 00:11:19.070
Um, and, uh, we choose out of the battery of tests, um, in terms of what we would want to be able to assess.
00:11:21.470 --> 00:11:25.100
So, um, in terms of what we can learn from this, right?
00:11:25.159 --> 00:11:37.850
So, um, I love this idea that what you're drawing out is that these children are, I guess, relatively instinctively leaning on the things that they do well to help them in this task...
00:11:37.399 --> 00:11:37.850
Yeah.
00:11:37.399 -->
00:11:41.899
Are there ways that maybe as parents or teachers, we can encourage that?
00:11:41.929 --> 00:11:45.500
Is that something that you would say would be a recommendation from the work?
00:11:45.889 --> 00:11:55.480
Yeah, so I think one of the important things about mathematical development is it's highly impacted by our emotions and our assets.
00:11:56.110 --> 00:12:00.190
And we know this from multiple other studies where we know that anxiety, and we have...
00:12:00.340 --> 00:12:08.889
There's a specific types of anxiety called mathematical anxiety, can have a really serious impact on how we perform with, um, with numbers.
00:12:09.580 --> 00:12:18.159
And so I think that being able to reassure children or young people that they're, they're trying very hard and they're doing as well as they possibly can.
00:12:18.639 --> 00:12:26.529
It's one thing that it can come from you that we're encouraging people to use their strengths and the approach that they find is successful for them.
00:12:26.919 --> 00:12:32.860
We know that children who are, um, flexible, um, in the strategies that they use in mathematics.
00:12:32.860 --> 00:12:38.440
So, you know, your approach, even a simple addition problem, there's always multiple ways that you can do that.
00:12:38.649 --> 00:12:45.250
Children who show that flexible approach to being able to solve a problem are generally better at much more complex mathematics.
00:12:45.519 --> 00:12:54.909
And that, again, may tell us something about being able to rely on your strengths because you know how to solve the problem, and you're able to adapt the strategies that you use to solve that problem.
00:12:55.240 --> 00:13:08.649
So I think from the piece of research, this piece of research specifically around Williams syndrome and Down syndrome individuals, and they're doing this number line task, I think that the key message for us was that the reliance on these kinds of relative strengths is really important.
00:13:09.009 --> 00:13:33.909
But also I think really reassuringly from this paper, there's two things I think I really am quite delighted by, one is that we were able to replicate a paper that had been done by a group, an Italian group um, a number of years ago, that suggested when you use a developmentally appropriate measure, um individuals with Down syndrome were performing pretty much the same as their mental age group peers.
00:13:34.299 --> 00:13:43.779
I think that's important because you don't really see loads of replication papers in this area of research, and that, I think that's first thing that I'm really, really delighted that we were able to replicate a finding.
00:13:43.780 --> 00:13:46.990
I think that's very important, um so scientific rigor.
00:13:47.409 --> 00:14:04.000
Um, but the second thing I suppose as well is that, um, there had been, um, an, an idea that, um, individuals with Williams syndrome were actually performing significantly poorer than their mental age match peers
on this number line estimation task.
00:14:04.690 --> 00:14:15.490
And that had been using a number line that was really large, zero to a thousand, a number line, which is kind of outside of the familiarity brackets of individuals with Williams syndrome.
00:14:15.490 --> 00:14:20.059
But when we drop down and use a number line that's developmentally appropriate, we see that there...
00:14:20.529 --> 00:14:24.909
That this group of individuals is performing similarly to their mental age match peers.
00:14:24.910 --> 00:14:30.009
And I think that that is also really important that, um, we can see that maybe mathematics...
00:14:29.320 --> 00:14:30.009
um...
00:14:30.820 --> 00:14:36.250
this number line task is not something of a specific difficulty for individuals with Williams syndrome.
00:14:36.250 --> 00:14:39.039
So there are two, I think, important points that come from this paper.
00:14:39.850 --> 00:14:46.779
Um, and also then, more broadly for myself who I'm just interested in the number line estimation task, and does this have like a kind of...
00:14:47.679 --> 00:14:50.980
Are we able to look directly into the mind's eye through this task?
00:14:51.090 --> 00:14:57.970
And I think this re-, piece of research says"no absolutely not", because you're relying on so many other different skills to be able to do this task.
00:14:58.360 --> 00:15:09.129
And I think for me it was a paper that I feel really proud to have contributed to because it's askin-, answering practical questions, but also broader methodological and theoretical question.
00:15:10.389 --> 00:15:12.879
Yeah, I think that's such a strength of the study actually.
00:15:12.880 --> 00:15:13.929
And I really agree.
00:15:13.931 --> 00:15:22.960
It's so nice when you hit that sweet spot where you've got something interesting to say about the theory as well as about the kind of real life experience.
00:15:23.049 --> 00:15:23.559
Yeah.
00:15:23.561 --> 00:15:38.259
And I think, you know, as developmental psychologists, um, we are motivated by multiple things, aren't we, you know, um, and I think, you know, I'm a theoretical scientist at heart, but I really want my work to have practical applications because I think that's really, really important.
00:15:38.620 --> 00:15:45.610
And I don't think I've necessarily had a paper where I feel I've been able to pull those two things together so neatly, as in this paper.
00:15:45.610 --> 00:15:47.440
So it's been really fulfilling.
00:15:46.931 --> 00:15:55.570
And the other thing is, I think, um, Annette Karmiloff-Smith unfortunately passed away, you know, at the beginning actually of this, um, this project.
00:15:55.990 --> 00:16:04.600
And she had quite, um, huge questions to ask around, um, you know, cross syndrome comparisons, and mathematics skills...
00:16:04.750 --> 00:16:16.990
And, you know, she obviously talked about much more broad issues of mathematics, but I think it was really lovely to be able to test some of the questions that
she had been asking and, um, and be able to kind of carry on with that, that type of work.
00:16:16.990 --> 00:16:19.659
So I feel really privileged to be part of this research team.
00:16:20.590 --> 00:16:20.889
Yeah, absolutely.
00:16:20.590 --> 00:16:27.129
And to anyone listening, who's kind of interested in psychology, then the writings of Annette Karmiloff-Smith are just so highly-...
00:16:29.259 --> 00:16:31.360
Oh yeah, absolutely.
00:16:31.360 --> 00:16:48.159
You know, the, her beautiful, beautiful papers around neuro constructivism and, you know, her really broad, theoretical contributions, but then as well, her, her kind of real insight and passion, um, for families with children who may have developmental disorders, or more broadly.
00:16:48.460 --> 00:16:56.860
Um, and I just think what an amazing person and what an amazing contributions to developmental psychology in the UK and internationally.
00:16:57.190 --> 00:16:58.570
Yeah, absolutely.
00:16:59.710 --> 00:17:12.250
Um, so just one final question then thinking about, um, any early career researchers or students who might be listening, is there anything that you want to say to them, um, in this, uh, trying time?
00:17:11.711 --> 00:17:14.349
[Laughs] Any words of wisdom?
00:17:15.490 --> 00:17:17.380
[ Laughs] It's a big, that's a big ask, Sue!
00:17:17.170 --> 00:17:17.380
[Laughs]
00:17:18.339 --> 00:17:19.180
I think...
00:17:19.390 --> 00:17:19.930
Um....
00:17:20.529 --> 00:17:21.640
It, look...
00:17:21.549 --> 00:17:25.359
Early career researchers, so I, I was a post-doc for six years.
00:17:26.259 --> 00:17:34.630
Um, and it was a frustrating time because you were always on the lookout for the next post and it can be quite difficult.
00:17:34.631 --> 00:17:39.190
I, my husband and I commuted between Scotland and Northern Ireland and things like that.
00:17:39.609 --> 00:17:44.650
But the time that I had to read and think is something that I know I will never get back.
00:17:45.430 --> 00:17:53.430
Um, I know that times at this moment, time are hectic and crazy, but we have got a slightly enforced um, slowing down.
00:17:53.760 --> 00:18:07.440
The pace of research has to slow down, especially if we're developmental psychologists, you know, I, you know, I'm thinking we could be opportunistic and try and do lots of research, you know, doing, I don't know, assessing children through Zoom and things like that.
00:18:07.619 --> 00:18:18.089
But how real are these measures that we're taking during a time where we've got huge amounts of parental stress, kids are not seeing their friends, all of these things we have to put in context.
00:18:18.480 --> 00:18:22.049
So I think having that little bit of time to sit and think is really important.
00:18:22.380 --> 00:18:27.210
And I think that actually, you know, this paper, this paper for me, um is-, has taken...
00:18:27.809 --> 00:18:38.309
[Laughs]...has been 12 years in the making, because really this work started in 2008, when I first started my first postdoc, I'm still doing this type of work now.
00:18:39.240 --> 00:18:52.740
And I think that that shows us that sometimes our thoughts have to distill, and that trying to take some time to reflect on what we're doing resear-, why we're doing research, and what we are really, really interested in is really important.
00:18:52.769 --> 00:18:54.210
Especially at the start of your career.
00:18:54.390 --> 00:19:00.599
I did a post-doc, um, in the middle of my postdoc in an area of research that I don't continue.
00:19:00.630 --> 00:19:09.480
I haven't continued to publish in, but I learned unbelievable skills in terms of experimental psychology from, I worked with Teresa McCormack at Queen's University.
00:19:10.109 --> 00:19:10.529
Um...
00:19:10.920 --> 00:19:16.230
Those times, I think are times when we can really reflect on broader developmental issues.
00:19:16.500 --> 00:19:17.849
We can think about theory.
00:19:17.851 --> 00:19:22.140
We can think about how these things fit together in a system of development.
00:19:22.589 --> 00:19:26.339
And I think that this is really horrible for PhD students.
00:19:26.430 --> 00:19:59.779
And this is really horrible for early career researchers, because you feel like your projects have had a massive brake pedal slammed down, but actually trying to think and think bigger thoughts taking this opportunity, even if it's only like 20 minutes, because I, I recognize that there's, you know, stressful and there's not loads of time to think, but trying to use this time as a period of reflection to think about how your work might fit into a bigger picture is probably a kind of something that we may not have the opportunity to do again, once the brake pedals off again, and we fly back into our projects.
00:19:59.780 --> 00:20:04.680
So maybe seeing this as a time to, to think a little bit deeper might be a good opportunity.
00:20:04.111 --> 00:20:08.279
Ah, perfect words of wisdom! Thank you!
00:20:09.210 --> 00:20:11.700
[Laughs] No problem! I will try and do that myself, obviously![Laughs].
00:20:14.299 --> 00:20:16.559
It's easier giving advice than taking it, isn't it?
00:20:16.471 --> 00:20:16.559
[Laughs]
00:20:17.039 --> 00:20:18.220
[Laughs] Absolutely! Absolutely!
00:20:20.069 --> 00:20:38.279
So I'm going to thank you so much for giving me a bit of your time to do our first ever PsychologiCALL and, um, anyone who's listening, if you want to find out more about Vic's work and about what we talked about today, then there will be links on the podcast page at ed.ac.uk/salvesen-research.
00:20:41.940 --> 00:20:43.380
So thank you so much Vic! And bye!
00:20:44.940 --> 00:20:45.690
Thank you for having me.
00:20:45.691 --> 00:20:46.740
Thanks, bye![ringtone]
00:20:50.690 --> 00:20:53.569
Okay we did it! I thought that went quite smoothly![Podcast jingle]