전사 🔗
WEBVTT
1
00:00:03.962 --> 00:00:08.743
People would say the cliche of Peter Greenway, if you don't mind, people would say, Peter Greenway, sex and death.
2
00:00:09.084 --> 00:00:09.984
Those are his obsessions.
3
00:00:10.004 --> 00:00:12.725
And I always think, well, aren't they everyone's?
4
00:00:12.765 --> 00:00:19.927
If you're a nun or a sex maniac, I rather suspect those two phenomenon are...
5
00:00:20.887 --> 00:00:23.528
pretty much alive in us.
6
00:00:23.868 --> 00:00:32.050
I cannot believe that there is any continuity after that final closing of the eyes and saying goodbye to life.
7
00:00:32.650 --> 00:00:43.112
I was interested in making a manifestation of evil, with a capital E. You are always reminded in this film that you're only watching a film.
8
00:00:43.552 --> 00:00:46.433
You should be aware of watching a Greenaway film.
9
00:00:46.953 --> 00:00:50.414
If I could live to maybe 300 years, heaven forbid,
10
00:00:51.235 --> 00:00:53.359
there was a way it would have been fun to have made them.
11
00:00:53.579 --> 00:00:56.945
Wouldn't that be a fascinating project, the unmade films of Peter Green?
12
00:00:57.005 --> 00:00:58.949
I think a lot of people would love to, yeah.
13
00:00:59.089 --> 00:01:02.135
If you have the power to organize it, please go ahead, my husband.
14
00:01:07.217 --> 00:01:14.281
Welcome to this special edition of Martin Deason Unloaded from SMAF, which is the Samaritz Festival of Arts and Film.
15
00:01:15.462 --> 00:01:28.569
Can you imagine what a great pleasure this is for me here, that I've been brought out to Samaritz to sit in front of these beautiful alpine mountains to spend half an hour chatting to Peter Greenaway about his career.
16
00:01:29.930 --> 00:01:32.632
I have to do the obligatory introduction because that's kind of the...
17
00:01:33.332 --> 00:01:35.054
the grammar of these things.
18
00:01:35.434 --> 00:01:41.099
Peter trained as a painter, then became an avant-garde filmmaker, if that's the correct description.
19
00:01:41.759 --> 00:01:48.845
Then I suppose his big breakthrough moving into mainstream success would have been The Draftman's Contract in 82.
20
00:01:48.965 --> 00:02:00.295
Other notable films in that era were The Zed and Two Noughts, Belly of an Architect, Architect Drowning by Numbers, The Cook, The Thief, His Wife and Her Lover, which I want to talk about in a minute, Prospero's Books, Night Watching,
21
00:02:00.935 --> 00:02:13.708
And then other areas of work in art and multimedia culminate, or not culminating, but in 2014, receiving the BAFTA Outstanding British Contribution to Cinema Award.
22
00:02:14.549 --> 00:02:17.512
And here at the Samaritz Film Festival...
23
00:02:18.273 --> 00:02:23.794
showing the film The Greenaway Alphabet, which is actually made by your wife, Saskia Boudicca, if I'm saying that correctly.
24
00:02:23.854 --> 00:02:24.334
Boudicca.
25
00:02:24.494 --> 00:02:24.934
Boudicca.
26
00:02:26.455 --> 00:02:29.135
Which is a remarkable film that I watched yesterday.
27
00:02:29.195 --> 00:02:30.896
It brought me absolutely great joy.
28
00:02:31.476 --> 00:02:33.616
It's, how do I sum it up?
29
00:02:33.636 --> 00:02:43.478
It does have an alphabet theme, but in it, Peter is interviewed largely by his daughter, Pip, who at the time was 15 and 16.
30
00:02:43.598 --> 00:02:46.199
And there's something remarkably remarkable,
31
00:02:46.359 --> 00:02:53.101
Obviously personal, but it's almost like a review of your life, of legacy, of art.
32
00:02:53.921 --> 00:02:56.321
It is an encyclopedia of the inside of your head.
33
00:02:56.681 --> 00:03:02.723
While also I found fascinating the relationship between the father and the daughter, I found it a deeply personal film, obviously.
34
00:03:02.763 --> 00:03:03.583
It really touched me.
35
00:03:04.723 --> 00:03:07.284
But it was made a few years ago, I think I'm right in saying, Peter.
36
00:03:07.304 --> 00:03:08.724
Is that eight or nine years ago?
37
00:03:08.744 --> 00:03:10.045
I think that's correct.
38
00:03:10.445 --> 00:03:11.125
And have you seen it?
39
00:03:11.525 --> 00:03:13.185
I mean, I wonder, do you see it today in the festival?
40
00:03:13.225 --> 00:03:13.765
How is it seen?
41
00:03:13.785 --> 00:03:15.306
No, I haven't seen it for some time.
42
00:03:15.526 --> 00:03:15.766
Right.
43
00:03:16.286 --> 00:03:30.818
Because I was wondering how that would be because it's very self-consciously looking back over your life and at one point you even say that you don't really want to live much beyond 80 and here we are in 84.
44
00:03:30.998 --> 00:03:33.000
How has it changed since then?
45
00:03:34.501 --> 00:03:38.664
Well I don't think in any way really, maybe or two,
46
00:03:39.607 --> 00:03:44.849
on your suggestion to see it again in order to refresh my memory.
47
00:03:45.189 --> 00:03:47.630
But I think my memory is pretty good about the film.
48
00:03:48.531 --> 00:03:51.752
I certainly acknowledge it.
49
00:03:53.533 --> 00:04:01.436
It's full for, I suppose, semi-confessions, some of which are indeed, as you suggest, very personal.
50
00:04:04.727 --> 00:04:11.071
Maybe if I were to do the whole thing again, then perhaps I would change some of the answers.
51
00:04:11.871 --> 00:04:15.893
But I rather suspect those changes would not be particularly great.
52
00:04:17.714 --> 00:04:18.775
I mean, I don't know how you...
53
00:04:18.855 --> 00:04:20.156
I'm a bit younger.
54
00:04:20.196 --> 00:04:20.616
I find...
55
00:04:21.636 --> 00:04:26.359
I'm surprised at the ageing process, how much I change in that process.
56
00:04:26.419 --> 00:04:27.580
I don't know how much I changed
57
00:04:28.480 --> 00:04:31.762
in my 30s and 40s, but I find now perhaps I do.
58
00:04:31.982 --> 00:04:33.343
And I don't know how you feel about it.
59
00:04:33.363 --> 00:04:38.167
I mean, people always say that the cliche about Peter Greenway, if you don't mind, is Peter Greenway, sex and death.
60
00:04:38.527
Load full transcript
--> 00:04:39.448
Those are his obsessions.
61
00:04:39.468 --> 00:04:41.329
And I always think, well, aren't they everyone's?
62
00:04:42.049 --> 00:04:45.992
But I tend to feel that my first 50 years, I probably thought about sex all the time.
63
00:04:46.032 --> 00:04:47.453
And now I'm in my 60s.
64
00:04:47.493 --> 00:04:49.674
I tend to find I think about sex and death all the time.
65
00:04:50.215 --> 00:04:52.817
Do you find you change in that way?
66
00:04:53.657 --> 00:04:58.982
Well, those two themes are omnipresent, aren't they, with us all, I think.
67
00:04:59.623 --> 00:05:11.133
You know, if you're a nun or a sex maniac, I rather suspect those two phenomenon are pretty much alive in us.
68
00:05:14.947 --> 00:05:23.075
The notion of death as an oppressing subject hasn't, I don't think, particularly increased.
69
00:05:24.076 --> 00:05:26.237
I would like to believe I'm not
70
00:05:27.013 --> 00:05:53.598
afraid of dying, but I obviously would want to find that death to be as peaceable and as, I won't say pleasurable, that's asking an awful too much, but also to be singularly without pain and without discomfort and without enormous sense of sadness with all those people I love and I rather suspect those people who love me.
71
00:05:53.618 --> 00:05:55.098
I suspect they do.
72
00:05:55.758 --> 00:06:00.402
And I'm about to ask a question one wouldn't normally ask in an interview, but do you believe in an afterlife?
73
00:06:00.422 --> 00:06:01.243
Do you have an opinion?
74
00:06:01.263 --> 00:06:02.123
I do not.
75
00:06:02.904 --> 00:06:03.865
You do not?
76
00:06:03.985 --> 00:06:08.549
I find that very interesting because I was, I mean, it's very different, but I was brought up very devout Catholic.
77
00:06:08.569 --> 00:06:16.755
I'm not in any way a Catholic now, but I have been left with a lingering conviction that if I look deep inside, there is something else out there and going on.
78
00:06:16.795 --> 00:06:21.599
And yet, with no belief in the afterlife, you seem very sanguine about the affair.
79
00:06:22.020 --> 00:06:24.081
Well, yes, it's, I suppose,
80
00:06:25.287 --> 00:06:37.837
The conversion or the realization that there's nothing indeed after the moment of death occurred to me when I was about 13, I think, 13 or 14.
81
00:06:37.857 --> 00:06:53.909
I find it extremely difficult to imagine that there is indeed anything that happens ever afterwards, that we are deeply human, we are deeply physical, we are the product of a long, long, long system of evolution.
82
00:06:55.030 --> 00:07:02.533
which relates us intimately to all the other animal life, all the sentient animal life on the planet.
83
00:07:03.253 --> 00:07:11.877
And I cannot believe that there is any continuity after that final closing of the eyes and saying goodbye to life.
84
00:07:12.678 --> 00:07:19.043
And I don't think you say it in the film, but that doesn't surprise me that it comes across without you being stated explicitly.
85
00:07:19.444
--> 00:07:27.651
And there's some very interesting bits in the film where your daughter, Pippa, who is the main person interviewing you, and who is now here at the festival and is nearly 10 years older now,
86
00:07:29.292 --> 00:07:36.757
is questioning in quite a funny way that a 15 or 16-year-old might whether you would actually have any legacy in your creative endeavour.
87
00:07:36.797 --> 00:07:47.543
And you were already quite confident saying, I think I absolutely do, that I've touched people's lives and there's no reason why I wouldn't continue to touch them with my art.
88
00:07:48.203 --> 00:07:51.445
That must be... Is that the afterlife to you?
89
00:07:52.126 --> 00:07:53.146
Well, I suppose so.
90
00:07:53.166 --> 00:07:54.687
There is...
91
00:07:56.962 --> 00:07:59.483
an opportunity to leave some things behind.
92
00:07:59.503 --> 00:08:02.644
I rather suspect they won't last for very long.
93
00:08:04.065 --> 00:08:09.587
The activities of filmmaking are, I think we all have to agree, basically very ephemeral.
94
00:08:10.546 --> 00:08:13.650
The actual media itself is rapidly changing.
95
00:08:14.471 --> 00:08:18.116
Perhaps it has its own revolution maybe every ten years.
96
00:08:18.617 --> 00:08:26.707
A different system of cinematic representation tends to in some ways negativise what has gone before.
97
00:08:28.291 --> 00:08:47.675
I would like to think that maybe if the possibilities of some sort of cinematic presentation could continue, whatever that might be, it'd be rather different, I think, from if we take The Cook, The Thief, His Wife and Her Lover, for example, which is a cinema, cinema product.
98
00:08:48.256 --> 00:08:49.776
It was shot as a film.
99
00:08:49.796 --> 00:08:51.756
It wasn't shot as a video.
100
00:08:51.796 --> 00:08:53.857
It wasn't shot as a television phenomenon.
101
00:08:54.777 --> 00:09:04.160
It was 24 frames a second performance, which is still, I believe, highly understandable, negotiable.
102
00:09:06.021 --> 00:09:13.543
So it is a presentation of what I would be thinking about in all the different areas of my life at that particular time.
103
00:09:14.423 --> 00:09:21.706
And it involves all sorts of credences and beliefs and notions of existence.
104
00:09:22.386 --> 00:09:26.168
which I think are valid then and continues certainly.
105
00:09:26.528 --> 00:09:28.249
How many years is it after now?
106
00:09:28.749 --> 00:09:37.773
It must be, what is it, about 30 or 40 years after having made it because the film was made, for me, thinking, looking back, quite some time ago.
107
00:09:38.133 --> 00:09:47.858
But that's funny you should say that because that's the exact, watching the documentary, that's the exact example I thought of because I thought, I wonder what the legacy of your films, and I thought, my God,
108
00:09:48.478 --> 00:09:56.022
I've only seen that film, I'm pretty sure, once at the cinema when it came out, 1989, I believe, so I would have been 23.
109
00:09:56.042 --> 00:09:57.702
I remember where it was.
110
00:09:57.742 --> 00:10:02.465
It was the Renoir Cinema in the Brunswick Centre in Bloomsbury in London because I was living in King's Cross.
111
00:10:03.305 --> 00:10:07.187
And it's absolutely imprinted on my mind, the visual...
112
00:10:07.587 --> 00:10:23.751
the flavour of it, the language, the fecundity, the tables overflowing, but also the horror of the Gambon character and Helen Mirren's character in this kind of trapped with the hideous gangster and the satire of Thatcherism at the time and everything.
113
00:10:23.931 --> 00:10:25.011
It's unusual.
114
00:10:25.051 --> 00:10:28.972
I can't think of another film that I've only seen once that stayed with me in that way.
115
00:10:29.593 --> 00:10:32.173
And it was interesting to hear you say that in the documentaries.
116
00:10:32.213 --> 00:10:34.494
I thought, well, if someone saw that now for the first time,
117
00:10:35.174 --> 00:10:37.619
Why would it not affect them in the same way?
118
00:10:38.160 --> 00:10:41.407
Perhaps not, you're saying, if they watched it on their phone, though, probably, unfortunately not.
119
00:10:42.617 --> 00:10:46.559
Well, I think it's certainly, shall we say, a big screen phenomenon.
120
00:10:47.299 --> 00:10:53.502
It was designed with all the notions of aesthetic appreciation in mind.
121
00:10:53.522 --> 00:10:56.844
It's a deeply, deeply artificial film.
122
00:10:57.524 --> 00:11:07.989
It's full of devices which can be taken from theatre, from cinema, from painting to a certain extent, and through all the forms, I suppose, of classic art.
123
00:11:08.750 --> 00:11:13.215
melodrama which have existed in the last, what, 5,000 years.
124
00:11:13.976 --> 00:11:19.402
It owes a lot, I think, very much to notions of 19th century melodrama.
125
00:11:20.684 --> 00:11:25.589
It has this character that supposedly represent notions of the devil.
126
00:11:26.470 --> 00:11:33.631
of a very negative creature who exploits every person and phenomenon around him.
127
00:11:35.272 --> 00:11:37.012
It's a very moral tale too.
128
00:11:37.932 --> 00:11:52.775
The perpetrator of so much unhappiness, of so much violence, ultimately ends up violently with a sudden shot from a revolver with the death of the anti-hero.
129
00:11:54.285 --> 00:12:02.590
There is a way of looking at the film, of course, that there should be a curious, I suppose, continuation.
130
00:12:03.783 --> 00:12:05.004
we're left with a problem.
131
00:12:05.344 --> 00:12:07.685
A woman in fact has committed a murder.
132
00:12:08.445 --> 00:12:23.473
Whatever the circumstances we feel at that murder in some curious way is understandable and part of the logic of good and evil and all the things that we associate with those two phenomenon.
133
00:12:24.233 --> 00:12:25.534
But there's a price to pay.
134
00:12:26.394 --> 00:12:35.446
What will happen to indeed the murderess who, in fact, despite all our sympathies for her, has
actually murdered her husband?
135
00:12:36.007 --> 00:12:37.589
So there is this sort of sequel here.
136
00:12:37.929 --> 00:12:40.873
I'm pretty certain I shall not make that sequence.
137
00:12:41.963 --> 00:12:58.847
So the conventional reading, if you like, of The Cook and the Thief at that time was that it was a satirization of The Greed is Good, the years of Thatcherism, that the kind of the rise of the people in finance in the city and so on was becoming, Britain was changing and becoming more materialistic.
138
00:12:58.887 --> 00:13:02.168
And if anything, since then, that process has continued apace.
139
00:13:02.968 --> 00:13:06.809
And we're sitting here in San Moritz, the playground of the super rich, Monaco of the Alps.
140
00:13:07.329 --> 00:13:12.570
Do you think that kind of worldview that you were satirizing has won out since then, become more entrenched?
141
00:13:12.610 --> 00:13:15.750
Well, I still think it's in essence is with us.
142
00:13:16.451 --> 00:13:27.413
There is an awful lot of, should we say, financial evil in the world where people are grossly, I suppose,
143
00:13:32.308 --> 00:13:37.712
savouring products which are certainly unacceptable morally.
144
00:13:38.573 --> 00:13:42.156
I don't think our moral position in a curious way has changed.
145
00:13:42.756 --> 00:13:44.378
Maybe it's been exacerbated.
146
00:13:44.998 --> 00:13:51.543
There's a way there are many more millionaires in the world now than there was back at the time of Mrs. Thatcher.
147
00:13:52.044 --> 00:13:58.569
And I think indeed Mrs. Thatcher's reputation has suffered very, very negatively.
148
00:13:59.009 --> 00:14:01.091
We don't feel very favourable at all
149
00:14:01.631 --> 00:14:08.562
to her policies, to her excesses, to her intransigence in a curious way.
150
00:14:09.323 --> 00:14:11.086
I don't think that position has changed.
151
00:14:11.526 --> 00:14:13.790
If in anything, it's probably got worse.
152
00:14:14.892 --> 00:14:15.132
Yeah.
153
00:14:15.863 --> 00:14:19.566
I think it's a mix in the two films, going back to the out, the green away alphabet as well.
154
00:14:19.586 --> 00:14:28.534
There's a very striking piece in there where you talk about if we're on earth to have a mission, if we're here to do anything, you say that we are here to contribute.
155
00:14:28.554 --> 00:14:33.838
We're not just here to have pleasure, I think is your exact words, to place grains of sand on the beach of civilization.
156
00:14:34.399 --> 00:14:39.202
And that really struck me because as a young man at 23 seeing The Cook's a Thief, of course, I wasn't part of...
157
00:14:39.963 --> 00:14:43.546
the Porsche owning city of London stuff, quite the opposite.
158
00:14:43.566 --> 00:14:56.617
I'd been a penniless student, then I was living in a squat and most of my friends were on the dole for five or six years in depressed Thatcherite Britain before they became painters, writers, artists, whatever it was they were becoming in life.
159
00:14:57.098 --> 00:15:01.902
So then the 90s came along and my generation kind of did very much live for pleasure in the 90s.
160
00:15:02.682 --> 00:15:31.019
um it just struck me that i wonder how you felt during that decade which became like a 60s hedonistic decade did you feel that things were going off the rails or were you watching everyone having a cool britannia time thinking good on them well there's sufficient changes i suppose in western civilization um the position of the female maybe as one of the most important changes i think that's happened there has been a shift and a sympathy
161
00:15:31.539 --> 00:15:35.540
towards the female position, which is highly agreeable.
162
00:15:36.281 --> 00:15:38.121
From my position, it's highly agreeable.
163
00:15:38.682 --> 00:15:44.844
And that the world, in a sense, from the feminine point of view, has had some advantages.
164
00:15:45.424 --> 00:15:49.906
Many, many, many necessities still to be perfected and developed.
165
00:15:50.246 --> 00:15:51.746
And I'm sure they certainly will.
166
00:15:53.727 --> 00:15:58.489
So the position of the female, the notion of
167
00:15:59.489 --> 00:16:07.092
Ideas of greed, I suppose, are still basically the same and still are unacceptable.
168
00:16:09.033 --> 00:16:11.053
The world has got faster.
169
00:16:11.834 --> 00:16:14.575
The world has got more communicable.
170
00:16:15.315 --> 00:16:22.298
I'm not so sure that's necessarily the communication possibilities, whether they, in fact, have become more positive.
171
00:16:22.838 --> 00:16:25.219
In some ways, we could, both of us,
172
00:16:26.139 --> 00:16:33.743
list a whole series of phenomenon which in fact would be, in fact, the communication has become more problematic.
173
00:16:34.604 --> 00:16:35.384
Are we more...
174
00:16:37.612 --> 00:16:41.533
appreciative of the evil that's existed in the world.
175
00:16:43.074 --> 00:17:02.960
We have a political situation centered very largely on American politics, which gives us lots of examples of a certain sort of much greater acceptance of all the unnecessary unhappinesses of the world, which of course is deplorable.
176
00:17:04.026 --> 00:17:08.667
But there again, the Western world, supposedly, is democratic.
177
00:17:09.248 --> 00:17:22.311
So we could, I hope, I believe, but the fact that since there is democracy and we are empowered to a certain extent to change things, that things will indeed change for the better.
178
00:17:22.351 --> 00:17:25.712
And I would certainly hope that that would happen.
179
00:17:26.093 --> 00:17:30.174
If I were to make the film again, I think the same moral climate
180
00:17:31.274 --> 00:17:43.425
would not be so different, but I'd obviously have to update it in terms of new sophistications of communication, for example.
181
00:17:44.816 --> 00:17:49.359
Which I was going to say that because you mentioned before about changes in technology and filmmaking.
182
00:17:49.379 --> 00:17:51.860
So
I wondered where, how does that sit with you?
183
00:17:53.421 --> 00:17:56.683
Not being a filmmaker, it's different for writers with the background I come from.
184
00:17:56.703 --> 00:18:04.348
But I'd imagine for a filmmaker, the whole AI could be quite liberating in the sense that you can literally talk and make an image.
185
00:18:04.368 --> 00:18:07.350
Do you find the possibility of AI filmmaking exciting or is it...
186
00:18:08.387 --> 00:18:11.429
Well, I feel very equivocal about it.
187
00:18:11.769 --> 00:18:19.373
We don't really fully understand how much evil has been perpetrated by the notions of our new technologies.
188
00:18:19.793 --> 00:18:24.856
And it will obviously take generations to finally understand what sort of effect this has.
189
00:18:25.236 --> 00:18:26.217
But this is a film.
190
00:18:26.297 --> 00:18:27.158
It's a film film.
191
00:18:27.218 --> 00:18:28.418
It's made on celluloid.
192
00:18:28.859 --> 00:18:29.679
It's made on 35mm film.
193
00:18:31.740 --> 00:18:33.862
And it has all those characteristics.
194
00:18:34.583 --> 00:18:37.405
And therefore, it is very much a product of its time.
195
00:18:38.066 --> 00:18:40.347
But it's also a product of theater.
196
00:18:40.948 --> 00:18:42.469
It's a very theatrical thing.
197
00:18:42.549 --> 00:18:47.353
It owes a lot, I think, to notions, shall we say, of Baroque drama.
198
00:18:47.994 --> 00:18:57.342
You could point the finger at various products that might be associated with Baroque English drama, for example.
199
00:18:59.636 --> 00:19:01.877
Do I think that maybe it's overplayed?
200
00:19:02.398 --> 00:19:03.218
I don't think so.
201
00:19:03.698 --> 00:19:19.847
But it does, shall we say, suffer, if that's the correct way to use, from a very self-conscious notion of, shall we say, the idea of a presentation of a
202
00:19:21.548 --> 00:19:27.134
evil, which I suppose could be described as beautiful.
203
00:19:27.415 --> 00:19:28.496
Can I use that way?
204
00:19:28.997 --> 00:19:35.024
There is a way that the costumes are very considered, are very related.
205
00:19:35.064 --> 00:19:37.667
There is, for example, references to...
206
00:19:38.748 --> 00:19:44.190
Baroque painting, there is notions of colour coding, which are very self-conscious.
207
00:19:45.351 --> 00:20:02.297
And there are some curious devices which are, I suppose, very modern insofar as I make you, the audience, very self-conscious that this is a piece of artifice, just like Baroque notions of manufacture of theatre are very aware of
208
00:20:04.518 --> 00:20:06.000
notions of convention.
209
00:20:06.220 --> 00:20:22.499
Like, for example, the prime, a peculiar item, if you talk about it like this, is that often when characters move from one scene to another, that they drag along, for example, with a change of costume, which is, again, a deliberate indication.
210
00:20:23.180 --> 00:20:39.250
to an audience that film is an artifice and it's a process of a deliberate, shall
we, transmogrification, if I can use a very sort of, well, artificial sort of notion.
211
00:20:40.191 --> 00:20:44.893
You are always reminded in this film that you're only watching a film.
212
00:20:45.434 --> 00:20:46.835
And if I can be as
213
00:20:48.548 --> 00:20:59.921
How shall I say I must choose my adjectives carefully if I can make sure you're not only aware of watching a film, but you should be aware of watching a Greenaway film?
214
00:21:01.002 --> 00:21:02.784
Oh, I think it's essence of Greenaway.
215
00:21:02.824 --> 00:21:04.486
If you could distill it, that is Greenaway.
216
00:21:04.867 --> 00:21:05.828
I remember what you're saying.
217
00:21:05.848 --> 00:21:07.309
I remember that as being one of the biggest...
218
00:21:08.210 --> 00:21:31.685
deepest impressions watching it was that disturbing impression of knowing that you're watching something where you're meant to be disgusted by the evil and the la la but in fact the seduction of of the painterly overflowing tables that abiding imagery i remember about 10 years later in the late 90s i was in palma in mallorca interviewing the international drug smuggler howard marx very
219
00:21:32.165 --> 00:21:34.485
charismatic fellow Welshman.
220
00:21:34.565 --> 00:21:38.886
And he said, Martin, you must come now to this restaurant with me in Parma.
221
00:21:39.166 --> 00:21:41.627
It looks just like the cook, the thief, his wife and her lover.
222
00:21:41.987 --> 00:21:45.848
And we go in there and there were tables overflowing with fruit.
223
00:21:45.908 --> 00:21:50.028
And it turned the film into something seductive.
224
00:21:50.128 --> 00:21:54.129
And that's kind of what I was hinting at a bit earlier on, that it's a satire of the rich people.
225
00:21:54.169 --> 00:21:58.610
But by the 90s, excess became something almost as a
226
00:21:59.771 --> 00:22:01.052
resist token of resistance.
227
00:22:01.072 --> 00:22:02.613
You know, why can't we all have someone out?
228
00:22:02.633 --> 00:22:04.074
Why shouldn't we just live for pleasure?
229
00:22:05.616 --> 00:22:06.877
So I suppose that's being an artist, though.
230
00:22:06.897 --> 00:22:08.598
You don't know which way your things are going to be taken.
231
00:22:08.618 --> 00:22:09.239
They become interior.
232
00:22:09.259 --> 00:22:16.325
But there was a way when I decided to make this film that I was curious about what is evil?
233
00:22:18.066 --> 00:22:19.827
What is going on here?
234
00:22:20.547 --> 00:22:23.588
What is the examination of greed, etc., etc.?
235
00:22:24.289 --> 00:22:30.772
And as my major protagonist of the film is obviously Albert Spieker, there is a way that...
236
00:22:31.553 --> 00:22:37.115
Self-consciously, I was interested in making a manifestation of evil with a capital E.
237
00:22:40.497 --> 00:22:46.139
Whether that's a good thing or a bad thing, was I making a moral judgment part of human nature?
238
00:22:46.599 --> 00:22:48.319
I suspect I sincerely was.
239
00:22:50.120
--> 00:22:56.122
And to move on a bit, to bring it up to where we are now, I'm not a film critic, so you have to tell me.
240
00:22:56.522 --> 00:23:00.383
You're making a film or have made a film which was Luca Mortis.
241
00:23:02.497 --> 00:23:03.218
Please tell me more.
242
00:23:03.238 --> 00:23:11.245
But as far as I understand it, it's about an Italian-American, goes back to the beautiful city of Lucca in Italy to survey his life at the end of his life.
243
00:23:11.265 --> 00:23:13.487
But it's now called Tower Stories, Dustin Hoffman.
244
00:23:14.188 --> 00:23:15.128
Is that project going ahead?
245
00:23:15.168 --> 00:23:16.269
Is that coming out this year?
246
00:23:17.070 --> 00:23:17.350
Um...
247
00:23:18.191 --> 00:23:22.153
There is a way that we have all gone quiet about this film.
248
00:23:22.793 --> 00:23:25.874
It's in a certain sort of abeyance at the moment.
249
00:23:26.414 --> 00:23:36.898
And I think until certain critiques have been justified, it's quite sensible of me not to add anything to this argument at this present moment.
250
00:23:37.378 --> 00:23:39.199
Should we say the jury is still out?
251
00:23:39.779 --> 00:23:47.723
and we are awaiting all sorts of decisions, which I don't think are very profitably discussed by me at this moment.
252
00:23:47.783 --> 00:23:49.024
This is not the place to do it.
253
00:23:49.064 --> 00:23:54.467
That explains why, by my usual journalistic digging on the Internet, I was like, this smells strange.
254
00:23:54.507 --> 00:23:57.508
I can't find out what's going on here, but we won't pursue it.
255
00:23:58.009 --> 00:23:59.529
Well, then let's look back again.
256
00:23:59.609 --> 00:24:07.354
So if you had to pick where do you pick as your your favorite films, the greatest ones you've made, the ones that you think for me?
257
00:24:07.374 --> 00:24:07.694
Yeah.
258
00:24:08.454 --> 00:24:12.616
Well, certainly I would not deny this film.
259
00:24:12.736 --> 00:24:13.877
I'm certainly not going to.
260
00:24:14.377 --> 00:24:26.504
But even here at St. Moritz, there's been a showing of a much earlier film called The Drassam's Contract, which again has the same excitement about notions of beauty.
261
00:24:27.344 --> 00:24:29.085
of artificiality.
262
00:24:29.786 --> 00:24:39.731
So these two characteristics, I think, are a Greenaway element, which probably are expected by audiences.
263
00:24:41.332 --> 00:24:46.095
Often the evil is couched in terms of, indeed,
264
00:24:47.155 --> 00:24:52.521
the potentiality, if you like, about one of the ways in which we can regard ourselves.
265
00:24:53.302 --> 00:25:04.534
So the costumes, for example, of both the cook, the thief's wife and her lover are very self-consciously organised, as they are indeed in the film The Dwarasim's Contract.
266
00:25:05.454 --> 00:25:12.637
One of them is certainly meant to be a period movie actually created.
267
00:25:12.797 --> 00:25:14.298
I give you the date in the film.
268
00:25:14.338 -->
00:25:18.459
I think it's, what is it, 1694.
269
00:25:19.080 --> 00:25:22.581
It's the regime change in terms of the English royal family.
270
00:25:24.482 --> 00:25:31.645
The Stuarts are out, and the potentiality of a new
271
00:25:32.545 --> 00:25:39.647
parliamentary based sort of civilization is beginning to develop.
272
00:25:39.687 --> 00:25:44.429
For example, I think the date is the Married Woman's Property Act.
273
00:25:44.849 --> 00:25:52.532
There was a change in the ability of women to be able to handle their own money, their own finances, and there's lots of
274
00:25:53.272 --> 00:25:57.735
references in the dialogue in the film of these sorts of changes that were being happened.
275
00:25:58.215 --> 00:26:06.260
So it is a period of change, and I would like it's not historically inaccurate in that particular respect.
276
00:26:07.021 --> 00:26:16.466
So all the same concerns that occur in, indeed, the cook, the thief, his wife and her lover are foretaste, are...
277
00:26:17.568 --> 00:26:27.270
prophesied in a peculiar way, in fact with the moral position of all the characters in indeed the Darsan's Contract.
278
00:26:28.552 --> 00:26:30.793
I like the way you talk about yourself in the third person.
279
00:26:30.833 --> 00:26:34.375
I find that interesting and I just genuinely use the word like literally.
280
00:26:34.455 --> 00:26:34.855
I like it.
281
00:26:35.955 --> 00:26:54.824
What other, if those are the Greenway-isms, people talk about them and what came across in the Greenaway alphabet was, what do I say, a love of categorization, a sort of reminds me of some Victorian gentleman who's, I mean, there are collections of moths and so on in that film that you're doing and,
282
00:26:55.684 --> 00:26:56.985
other biological specimens.
283
00:26:57.005 --> 00:26:58.766
What other Greenwayisms are there?
284
00:26:58.946 --> 00:26:59.626
Is that part of it?
285
00:26:59.647 --> 00:27:00.527
The categorisation?
286
00:27:00.547 --> 00:27:00.787
Listing.
287
00:27:00.927 --> 00:27:04.229
I mean, we take the titles of some of the films.
288
00:27:04.690 --> 00:27:07.771
I mean, Drowning by Numbers, I don't know whether you've seen that movie.
289
00:27:08.252 --> 00:27:12.974
Even that title suggests the idea of species.
290
00:27:13.455 --> 00:27:20.459
I don't know whether these words are actually of very value anymore, but the notion of creating structures.
291
00:27:22.500 --> 00:27:50.620
These are obviously fictions which are related to notions of literature, and I can give you all sorts of examples of theatrical titles which may be associated with it, but they are self-consciously about stripping down, of creating structures, which are more, perhaps, as I would find, agreeably satisfying than just simply relying upon notions of literary fiction.
292
00:27:51.708 --> 00:27:53.429
So there was a categorization.
293
00:27:54.629 --> 00:27:58.772
There's a very, I find it very funny, as we have a connection in that.
294
00:27:59.112 --> 00:28:05.235
I was trying to do the maths, but I think Pip in the film is 15, so you must have had her at about 59, 60, I think.
295
00:28:05.255 --> 00:28:10.857
And I had my daughter, my most recent daughter, at 53, which is an interesting experience, I think.
296
00:28:12.198 --> 00:28:16.201
She says to you things that I can imagine my daughter already, who is eight, saying to me.
297
00:28:16.561 --> 00:28:25.088
She's saying in the film that she thinks you're autistic, for instance, which is something that we associate with categorisation, I think, and interesting numbers.
298
00:28:25.848 --> 00:28:27.309
Is that still an opinion she has?
299
00:28:27.369 --> 00:28:28.991
Was she just baiting you?
300
00:28:29.051 --> 00:28:31.953
Did you find that annoying or perceptive?
301
00:28:31.993 --> 00:28:32.974
No, I would listen.
302
00:28:32.994 --> 00:28:37.557
I would listen and I can see why those solutions have been created.
303
00:28:38.017 --> 00:28:41.540
I don't necessarily believe them in any great particular depth.
304
00:28:42.080 --> 00:28:50.746
I don't find them offensive, but I find that maybe they'd rather miss the point of what these films are representing.
305
00:28:51.567 --> 00:28:56.170
Would it be enlightening to you if someone went, oh, right, Peter, actually, I am a psychiatrist.
306
00:28:56.190 --> 00:28:56.791
Yes, you are.
307
00:28:56.811 --> 00:28:57.591
You do have autism.
308
00:28:57.791 --> 00:28:59.272
Would that mean anything to you at all?
309
00:29:00.793 --> 00:29:02.855
a name, isn't it, the title?
310
00:29:02.895 --> 00:29:11.600
If you were diagnosed, if I sat here and said... No, I think it's a categorisation which is personal to the person who bespoke it originally.
311
00:29:11.660 --> 00:29:13.401
Right.
312
00:29:14.161 --> 00:29:26.128
One must be aware, though, that people who make those decisions do have prior knowledge of me, which maybe the general public do not, and therefore there's a position of some sort of privilege.
313
00:29:26.268 --> 00:29:28.830
But then that's in the nature of the exercise.
314
00:29:28.850 --> 00:29:28.930
Yes.
315
00:29:29.670 --> 00:29:34.533
No, it's just interesting to see a man who loves categorization being categorized by his own daughter on film.
316
00:29:34.573 --> 00:29:35.053
It's amusing.
317
00:29:35.874 --> 00:29:40.496
And so, other Greenaway-isms, I mean, like I say, people always talk about the human body.
318
00:29:41.197 --> 00:29:43.358
I think you talk very interestingly about that.
319
00:29:43.398 --> 00:29:44.759
Yes, it's very much...
320
00:29:47.200 --> 00:29:48.361
a characterization.
321
00:29:48.761 --> 00:29:50.482
There are many unmade films.
322
00:29:50.522 --> 00:29:55.885
There are films about anatomists, which I should love to have made, which we never did.
323
00:29:56.405 --> 00:30:09.371
There was a film about a man who is very, very critical of those powers of evolution which have created the notion of a
soul or the notion of a heart.
324
00:30:09.831 --> 00:30:12.693
Maybe soul and heart are interchangeable as ideas,
325
00:30:13.353 --> 00:30:14.834
But those films were never made.
326
00:30:15.295 --> 00:30:20.038
And I think it's far too late to even consider the possibility that they should now be made.
327
00:30:21.479 --> 00:30:31.906
So there are many, many, many unfinished Greenaway films, which are indeed, I don't know, the amount of human activity has inevitably limited.
328
00:30:32.446 --> 00:30:33.567
So you take your pick.
329
00:30:34.387 --> 00:30:40.652
I mean, over the years there have been many, many films which have been prognosticated by me, but have never ever been made.
330
00:30:41.392 --> 00:30:48.527
If I would live to maybe 300 years, heaven forbid, there is a way it would have been fun to have made them.
331
00:30:48.647 --> 00:30:52.115
Would you like that if I literally could say here now, Peter?
332
00:30:52.915 --> 00:31:07.662
Well, if I were to make, heaven forbid, you know, because I would need to be a filmmaker who was probably much more vigorous, certainly, much more cogent, much more informed, to have made these sorts of movies.
333
00:31:07.762 --> 00:31:10.304
And it would be an interesting fascination to do that.
334
00:31:10.804 --> 00:31:14.626
But I'm talking about dreams because these dreams are never going to come to pass.
335
00:31:15.666 --> 00:31:19.167
Wouldn't that be a fascinating project, the unmade films of Peter Greenaway?
336
00:31:19.187 --> 00:31:21.008
I think a lot of people would love to.
337
00:31:21.168 --> 00:31:24.229
If you have the power to organise it, please go ahead.
338
00:31:24.369 --> 00:31:26.230
If only I had that power, who knows.
339
00:31:27.290 --> 00:31:29.831
Pete, that's probably a good moment to stop.
340
00:31:29.871 --> 00:31:34.513
I've taken up enough of your time, but I think the world would love to hear more about that.
341
00:31:35.173 --> 00:31:37.674
Perhaps it should be a film made by your daughter.
342
00:31:38.454 --> 00:31:40.855
The unmade films of Peter Greenaway, you could rattle through them.
343
00:31:41.650 --> 00:31:47.636
Oh, unfortunately it's not going to happen, but it's a wishful thought.
344
00:31:48.737 --> 00:31:49.757
That's a good way to end.
345
00:31:49.878 --> 00:31:50.999
Peter, it's been an absolute pleasure.
346
00:31:51.039 --> 00:31:52.100
Thank you so much for doing this.
347
00:31:52.200 --> 00:31:52.660
Thank you.
348
00:31:52.760 --> 00:31:55.463
You have been a very considerate questioner.
349
00:31:55.723 --> 00:31:56.123
Thank you.
350
00:31:56.163 --> 00:31:59.566
Well, that's all I could ever hope for, and it's been an absolute pleasure and a privilege to meet you.
351
00:31:59.807 --> 00:32:00.187
Thank you.
352
00:32:00.928 --> 00:32:02.829
Goodbye from us here at the podcast.
353
00:32:02.849 --> 00:32:07.133
I hope you enjoyed that as much as I did, and goodbye from the beautiful Swiss Alps.
354
00:32:07.153 --> 00:32:07.594
See you soon.