전사 🔗
Damien: I'm not going to be living a life based upon what you do and don't like from one
Josh: Right.
Damien: day to the next.
Josh: This magical ability to infer somebody else's intent is crazy and it's also ridiculous.
Damien: people don't understand that you are always operating on a belief system, right?
Josh: Thank you. You already have one. You already are living one, regardless.
Damien: Right.
Josh: I don't want people to outsource the reason. I don't want them to completely become second handers who just let experts tell them what to do. I just want people to acknowledge the fact that they are limited. We don't have the ability to know every single thing directly, and that's okay.
Damien: sometimes I encounter people who are com almost completely irrational, but I still would consider them intelligent.
Josh: I'm big on direct communication. I love that. That's how I operate. And it's very frustrating when I have to go to work and do things that are indirect. Like I don't like political games. I don't like the corporate world. I don't love sitting with middle managers and trying to play he said, she said, blame games. this is really not helping anyone. Nothing actually
Damien: Ha ha ha.
Josh: got done today. Now I get it. There is a way to present this to advance your career, but I actually don't need to be here for this part. I don't care. I can't make your career better. So this isn't helpful to me. And don't also have to be here. So please let's speed this up to the point where you should go or I should go. One of us should not be here.
Damien: Ha ha ha.
Josh: man.
Damien: I mean, yeah. I'm trying to think of a situation where I'm playing politics. I mean, we all kinda play it at some level.
Josh: Yeah. There's some level of politics that that are appropriate for everything. when there are actual issues, like real problems with how the work is getting done, or if the work is getting done, that is not the time I want to sit blaming how people are interested in some other priority over here. I'm like, no, I'm not saying we can't do your priority, but like that project's gotta take a back seat to us getting the first things done. We need a foundation laid. We need to have an actual way to make sure that this job is here tomorrow. Then after we've done these higher priority issues, then we can get to this other thing that you want to use to make yourself look good, 'cause I mean, I'm not opposed to the work getting done. I just need the work to exist first.
Damien: Okay.
Josh: Keep the building here, and then we can talk about the next thing you want to do to make sure that the building's operating more efficiently sometimes in a way that makes you look, more favorable.
Damien: See, that's the thing, right? So I find myself in that a lot. It's an art to understand how to interact with someone who with whom the work isn't necessarily the important thing. It's
Josh: Right.
Damien: the way that they look about the work. And it's almost like I
Load full transcript
gotta find a way to leverage this. It's like
Josh: Ha ha ha.
Damien: how can I sell this in a way that you would look good in front of the people you wanna look good in front of? That gets you to do what I need you to do. That's
Josh: Right.
Damien: it's like I don't like playing that game, but I wish you were just as interested in the thing as I was interested in the thing and getting it done, but you're not. So
Josh: Thank you.
Damien: I'm not gonna keep beating my head up against a brick wall and pretending like this is not normal, because it is normal for people to just be thinking, I just want the boss to recognize me for
Josh: Yeah.
Damien: whatever. that's not necessarily my goal, but there are people who are like their goal is recognition. recognition is their objective fact. That's not not doing the job, but being known as doing the job.
Josh: Right.
Damien: Right. I was watching Birdman for whatever reason with my wife yesterday. But he had this sign in the in the dressing room. It was an okay movie when I saw it, but I didn't think it was all that. But the sign says, the note in the mirror says, the thing is the thing, not what is said about the thing, or not what people say about the thing.
Josh: Nice.
Damien: But some people, what people say about the thing is the thing to them.
Josh: Right. That's the only part that matters. That's the only part that's relevant. That's the only part that they're gonna prioritize, right?
Damien: Dad, yeah. It reminds me of this conversation. it's like my second OCON. And I think this lady was from Australia. And we were talking about Atlas. And she was saying something about Rearden Metal. And and And somehow it was something simple and she was like, Yeah, and they were saying that it was bad, but it turned out to be good. And I was like, Red and Metal didn't turn out to be good. Red and Metal was good. And it's just it just so happened that other people
Josh: Yeah.
Damien: just started to agree. But that's like that's to me the whole thing about Red and Metal and Rand and and Dagny, in that she just was like, I don't care. James Taggart would be like, no one's bought it. No one's used it before. Right.
Josh: Right? No one likes this. Everybody thinks this is trash. This is new. We can't trust it.
Damien: And she's just like, no, it's great. This is great.
Josh: Hmm. No, no. I've evaluated this based off of objective criteria. I've seen it work.
Damien: The
Josh: I know it works. We're we're going to do the thing. It works. That's true.
Damien: She didn't even say that she saw it work, right? She just she she saw the science and the work behind it, right? Cause nobody had used it on the rail before, right? They just understood the characteristics of it as a as a metal, right?
Josh: Mm. They have the actual specs and they're like, All right, engineering it holds up. Therefore.
Damien: Yeah. But that's that's a different kind of person, Well, there are some people who are like that and there's some people who aren't who aren't. And yeah, that's what leads to the politics.
Josh: It's different approach to life. It's different it's it's a different viewpoint. And having that conversation is a much different conversation than trying to find someone who actually is interested in a solution or interested in dealing with data. They're like, mm-mm. Some people are interested in the the verifiable data and there's people who are interested in just what other people think about the data and especially the other people in their immediate vicinity who are gonna make their life a little bit better. Like who do the people I care about think about this? Like I didn't take a poll. I don't know what the people who you're care who you ca who you care about. I don't know what they think about this yet. And I don't think that's where I don't I think that's where we should start this conversation. We can get there one day, I guess, but like that's not going to immediately fix the problem today.
Damien: No, but at the same time you don't really have to worry about those people because they
Josh: Mm-hmm.
Damien: ultimately need the people who can do the stuff at the end of the day. They can think
Josh: Right.
Damien: however they want to think. You'll still need someone who can do the stuff. So I'll just do the stuff.
Josh: Right. Just do the stuff, be excellent at the job. And then have people, who can respect that be the ones you stick with. If they can't respect that, then it's always a good time to consider alternatives.
Damien: yeah. Yeah, it definitely sharp your skills.
Josh: Mm-hmm.
Damien: Cause people like the thing that I struggle with with people like that is they really legitimately can't respect your work. Like they can respect the accolades from your work. back to Atlas again. This is kind of like a
Josh: That's right. Yeah.
Damien: what is the place that they all went? All of the people Gordon Gulch. Gulch
Josh: Cult cult cults. Yeah.
Damien: Gulch. Because all essentially they like, The people here can understand what's good about my work. You know,
Josh: Mm-hmm.
Damien: whereas though other people just don't really respect it. They just use it and throw it away or whatever. And I guess not everybody deals with that feeling or whatever, well, some people, like myself, want to be respected for the thing that they want to be respected for, right? Yeah.
Josh: They value the things that you care about the most. You're like, hey, I'm good at this thing over here. I like this thing over here. I spent time, energy, effort to get good at this thing. I'm super pro proud of that. And then there are other people who don't have that same approach.
Damien: That's true. And but that's one thing, right? So one thing is I want recognition for the thing that I like, that I think that I'm good at or whatever. But the other one is it may not even be a like a love of yours, but it's just like, I am saying that this thing that I've done is good. I can tell
objectively that the thing is good. And when someone who's not looking at the properties and on doing an evaluation, objective evaluation of the thing, and they're doing an evaluation of how what how other people view. The thing is it's kinda empty, Because their whole engagement with you is based on other people's engagement with you or engagement with the things you should done. And it's like Yeah. Kinda empty.
Josh: Right. Their proof so they want is social proof. And so it's a whole separate conversation. Mm-hmm.
Damien: Yeah. That that is a tricky thing. I would bet that there are a lot of relationships like that.
Josh: Right.
Damien: Just like trophy women or whatever they call a dude that that I don't even know what the opposite of it. I know that it whatever it is, it does exist, but I don't know what it's called. It's not okay, high value man, something like that. Okay.
Josh: Value man? I don't know, that's up.
Damien: Wiz though. I mean, because I've heard women have told me this. Like they just like they they like the man who stops the room or something like that. Or they can tell
Josh: There you go.
Damien: who's the guy in the room or something like that.
Josh: Mm-hmm.
Damien: And and some people have that energy and some people don't. And so Yeah, it is what it is. But just like that with men and then trophy wives too. So it's you want the the girl that some people want the girl that all the guys are looking at and makes
Josh: There you go.
Damien: you I think some people well, in the sense that I think they call it a beard if the god is if the guy is gay and he
Josh: Right.
Damien: has the girl, they call it a beard, I guess. In a straight man situation it still is a trophy wife, like
Josh: Yeah. It's still some sort of cover for your confidence. It's still some sort of external display of self esteem that you're using just to prop things up.
Damien: Yeah. Yeah, man. So I gotta bring it up, man. Have you seen this Converse thing? Have you
Josh: This which one?
Damien: the Converse story? Have you seen any parts of this thing? wow.
Josh: No, I don't think so.
Damien: Maybe I'm on the internet too much or something.
Josh: there was a thing a few days ago where there was like a Converse ad and they're like, it's racist. It's racist cause is that we're talking about? man, that was hilarious and ridiculous. Where
Damien: Yeah. Yeah
Josh: did you hear about it and where did you land? 'Cause I gotta know how this was introduced to you.
Damien: if you ever stop and listen to something on social media, they'll keep trying to feed you the same people stuff. So it's this guy,
Josh: Right.
Damien: I think his name is Elliot Connie or something like that. He's supposed to be a psychotherapist. Yeah, Elliot Connie.
Elliott Connie: It's a secondary consequence of removing DEI because now people of color, black people specifically, are removed from the rooms where these decisions get made because they were accused of only being in those rooms because of DEI and their positions are cut and crazy numbers of layoffs happened of black people in executive positions in major companies. So now you have decisions being made in these rooms, and those are the people that would have said, Hey. We can't release this. Like, this is bad. This harkens to a very dark history in America. And it would stop those things from actually coming out. But that didn't happen here. Nobody stopped it, and now it got released.
Damien: So he starts going in and he's talking about, because people want to react to it quickly, I guess is part of the how they can get their social media jumping. And he
Josh: Hmm.
Damien: starts talking about how this picture is a reflection of why you need DEI. Right? Because if a black person is in the room, this mistake doesn't get made. As if this is some big thing to do. wow. We this we really had to have that happen. But and he starts talking about how like Converse is owned by Nike and this is ridiculous that Converse is doing this thing. I'm really just checking out like I don't know how long his first his post was, but it was I'm looking at him maybe about two or three minutes, maybe four minutes. And I just, go to the comment, I'm like, look, this is really rich for somebody sitting there wearing a Nike shirt. Like you're sitting
Josh: Right?
Damien: there wearing a Nike shirt.
Josh: No.
Damien: But I guess the point at some point in the video he starts talking about well, I only have Nike clothes, I'm out on a trip or whatever. the point was he thought it was racist that they they would have this this picture.
Josh: And it's just
Damien: My thing is my thing is Yo. it wasn't that. It it may have looked y'all gotta start y'all gotta start h reining in your instincts and intuition, like your associative minds. You know what I'm saying? Like
Josh: Right? I'm like, of all things, this deserved a little bit more thought. Come on, y'all. Come on. I understand that racism does exist. I'm not debating that point. But like in this ad,
Damien: Yeah.
Josh: I'm like, this was not the one we should have focused on. No. No. There was a person in blackface earlier. It's a Halloween costume. That was the one. That was the one like, hey, this is not okay.
Damien: Mm.
Josh: I'm like, I alright, fair. Not okay.
Damien: Yeah. I I don't really have much to say about it, but I will say I saw like a post today and it was I guess it was a black girl and she started criticizing the the picture. And then I don't know w who it was who responded. her post was like somehow white people think that black people need their permission to be offended by something. And then whoever wrote back and was like, it's not that we think that you need our permission to be offended. It's just that we're constantly dealing with people who can't manage their emotions. And, you know, it it to that to something to that point. And I'm like, yes, I mean. My thing is like, if you get offended by it, fine, but let's not pretend
like there's something else. You should be able to manage your emotions about this one. There's some part of maturity.
Josh: Right, right. Yeah.
Damien: Okay, somebody made a picture. it didn't land right. Things sometimes don't land right. Got
Josh: Yeah.
Damien: it. But come on, man. Like, But some of this to me is fake outrage too. It's not really real outrage.
Josh: Yeah, I mean this is a great form of controversy this is a great form of outrage marketing. I don't wanna ever pretend that the people who make this ad are angry at themselves or anybody else. They are like, We are the best people at marketing in the world. They are super excited about all this that's coming along. I mean that I think the out some outrage, a lot of the outrage, is real. I just think that like when people respond in this way that is completely outside of reason and just so ridiculous, there is a lot of responsibility people have to regulate and manage their own emotions and their own responses when they see something they don't like. If they don't like it, they they're free to say they don't like it. But the way they say it, the way we describe every single action as a moral action which This magical ability to infer somebody else's intent is crazy and it's also ridiculous. And so I can see why you'd have a black person saying, Hey, why do people why do I white people think they need our permission? I'm like, Because forever people have freaked out when a white person said something, like, why do you think you're entitled to do whatever you want and say whatever you want and be outraged on our behalf? I'm like, we've had problems in the past. There there have been people Who have overreacted in ways that have been unhelpful and then there are people who've been trying to support in ways that have been unhelpful. I mean, both things have existed and we can allow for the nuance to say there are some other real ways to do this. But all I want to say is that if they looked at the ad, it's an agent person. Number one, please stop calling her white. Number two, she's holding holding Converse in her hand, and there's no one being hung in the picture, but I get it. It looked kind of like that from that angle, which was a very creative way for these people to market the shoes. And three, I'm like, they
Damien: Ha ha.
Josh: have marketed peop outrage marketing exists. They have done this before. This is a clear way to get the word out about a shoe that most people don't really care that much about and have a huge connection to. But now everyone knows. Everyone knows it for a different thing. And I I I just wanted everyone to say, if you're gonna Market it, get paid. But don't do it unwittingly. Don't be part of the sheep
Damien: Ha ha
Josh: who are just like, I'm mad, and now everyone needs to pay attention to Converse. Converse is like, everybody needs to pay attention to Converse. I mean, listen to them. They clearly know what they're talking about. And also, since you're
here, do you want to buy this shoe? Well, not this shoe. Maybe like this other shoe that's like in blue? Maybe you want it in red. Maybe you like it in a different color. Anyway, I this is this is this
Damien: I mean I don't think I mean like for me
Josh: is a lot.
Damien: you say what?
Josh: That's it. I'm just like this is this is a lot. When I saw people get angry at this and call it a racist issue and then it ended up being an Asian person, I'm like, I mean someone's being racist but it's it's not who you think.
Damien: If you feel like it's a racist thing, I feel like, okay, that's fine. I just think I don't know if I wanna be friends with someone who thinks that this is a racist thing like that, you know.
Josh: Thank you. Right.
Damien: Like, I just associated all of this with like immature activity. This is underdeveloped activity. And when I say that, I it's just that it's more and more acceptable to not evaluate anything objectively. It's just like, hey, I saw this, it reminded me of that, and that's the thing that matters. What?
Josh: think that's good thinking at all. I think we've missed out a few steps here in this logical connection. I think you just jump into random conclusions. You're just saying things you don't
Damien: Yeah.
Josh: like.
Damien: Yeah, i it reminded me of that book, Nathaniel Brandon, but not Nathaniel Brandon's part. So I listened to it. I think you read it. But he had a chapter it's not even a book, it was a set of lectures. I think it's the book is called Excuse me. The The Philosophy of Ayn Rand or something like that, but the one I read or listened to was called something else. I can't remember. But B Barbara Brand Brandon did a a lecture and she was just talking about how some people think that they're thinking, but they're not really thinking. They're
Josh: Great.
Damien: just stewing. Like they're just thought just things are just flying around their head like ghosts in the night or whatever. And then she read, huh? Yeah.
Josh: They're not can taking things and connecting these ideas based off of other evidence. They're just saying, there's a thought about somebody else's has a thought about this. And, you know, what if that means this? What if that means that? What if that means that? And I'm like, now you're just you're drifting into conjecture. You are no longer going to the logical part of connecting rational thoughts anymore.
Damien: No, no, and he brought up examples. He he was saying about he brought up an example of a schizophrenic and how like he thought he saw Jesus in a piece of toast or something. And you
Josh: You know?
Damien: know, and and then but she also, she brought up another example. I think she brought up an example of a schizophrenic where he wrote a letter to his mother, and she was like, listen to these words. And it's just a random stringing together of things. And they didn't have any rhyme or reason. And the thing that's dangerous, like I I'm always trying to look at the bigger
idea. It's not I'm not trying to make more of it. I'm just saying that without reasons, there's no depth to the human brain when you take reason out the picture, man. You can
Josh: Right.
Damien: make anything be anything. Like, have you ever seen that movie Memento?
Josh: Yes.
Damien: And at the end of the day, right, he act like he trying to find this this the clues to the solve this thing. And
Josh: Uh-huh.
Damien: he gets down to the end and he's like, This was it. No, I don't I don't wanna remember this. This I wanna
Josh: Right.
Damien: re I want something else.
Josh: I spent all this time searching and all I found out was this wasn't that important new in the first place. I just have a I just have a bad memory. Like you do have a bad
Damien: or or it was all it was me or something. You know.
Josh: memory. You are bad at this.
Damien: But that's what I mean. Like, so for me, I'm just thinking Yo, we cannot just go back and normalize monkey brain, right? It
Josh: Right. Monkey Mind is not the goal. Mm-mm.
Damien: No, and and I don't hope somebody don't take monkey mind is is racist. It's anybody can have the monkey mind. The whole idea that you are not supposed to evaluate your thoughts. you just can't take them and run with them. You just well, you you can in an emergency situation. I get it, but if you are evaluating something, you just don't take everything for surface value. range of the moment thinking all the time. So it's just
Josh: Good movement.
Damien: There's no depth to anything, but at the same time I'm like, all right, cool. Well, history tells me that this is the natural order of the majority of people. But then at the same time, I also feel like the the there are ebbs and flows in the normal in society. Maybe it's just my perception and where I'm standing. It just seems like it's getting worse. Like people are apologizing for or just that's the expectation, like, yeah, if the person felt that, that's what it was.
Josh: Right. It's their truth. It's their experience. You can't invalidate their experience with your judgement.
Damien: right.
Josh: But you can? You seem like you just did that with my judge. Is that is that what's happening now? Interesting how this hypocrisy works. Hm All
Damien: Right. Touche.
Josh: right.
Damien: But that's I just think that that's a once again, coming from like black culture, I hate that part about it because it's just I don't know I don't know what the end game is here in black culture, bro. I guess that's kinda for me like a little segue into the video. I sent you a video today, right? I don't know
Josh: Yeah. He did, yeah.
Damien: if you got any check if you had any time to check it out at all.
Josh: I did. Yeah.
Damien: Yeah.
Josh: what did you get out of though?
Damien: People say people don't understand that you need a belief system. people don't understand that you are always operating on a belief system, right?
Josh: Thank you. You already have one. You already are living one, regardless.
Damien: Right. And so when people say so the whole assault on Christianity and let me let me pull this up 'cause this is this was wild to me. It's but
Josh: You're wild.
Damien: it speaks to something else though, man. It's something else going on here that That is off, in my opinion. The the specific goal of tearing down Christianity. Tearing down a structure with nothing to put in place of it is wild to me, right? I mean I grew up Christian. I'm not going to say that that's the goal for me to, be rooted in Christianity. I'm not advocating for it, but it is a belief system that's a moral it's a belief system,
Josh: Code and a moral foundation. Yeah.
Damien: moral foundation that provides meaning, and you're going to need that. And if you're going to tell me that you're going to leave a moral foundation like Christianity for these things like politics and economics and all these things that are derivatives of moral premises. I'm like, man, get the hell out of here. What are you talking about, yo? You know what I'm
Josh: Yes.
Damien: saying? people try to purport it like, this is the higher level of thinking. It could be not what you're doing. Y you
Josh: I mean, he could get there. I'm not not opposed to seeing a higher level of thought demonstrated one day. but it hasn't happened yet. Not in this video, at least.
Damien: No. No. This is one of these things that I'm thinking like, man, people learned this word colonization and just went crazy with it. it's so almost infuriating to me that people are saying these words as if they are spitting knowledge. And you and it's like You need something to ground your meaning in, okay?
Josh: Uh-huh.
Damien: And you're saying, all right, we're just going to reject this because it comes from the colony, but you don't have anything else. And so you'll always be a dependent. You'll always be on somebody else's ticket because if you think that economics and politics are a ground level that you can enter on, you are foolish. You're a foolish person.
Josh: Right. You are mistaken. That has not been how it
Damien: You know what I'm saying?
Josh: worked out in any part in history, and multiple different economic policies and political systems oppose each other. You are asking
Damien: Yes.
Josh: for more divide.
Damien: Right. what grounds your politics? What grounds your your economics? And I it's like when I hear stuff like that, I'm like, here's another sleepwalker. Here's another sleepwalker. They have no idea You can't criticize Christian th Christianity to me as if they're the sleepwalkers when you a sleepwalker too. You you're just
Josh: Yes.
Damien: a drone too. You know what I'm saying? You just like
Josh: Yes. I mean the things he says are meant to be offensive, but also they present him as a expert on the subject. And I'm like, you don't want to come from this frame. You you need to come from a frame of hey, I don't like this. I don't know anything about it and I don't like it. I associate it
with negative things and therefore I don't like those negative things. I'm like, okay, I'll listen to that. Because at least I can understand where you're coming from. But he presents
Damien: Mm-hmm.
Josh: it as like, no, I've looked through the research and I've done it all and there's no redemptive piece of Christianity at all. It's all just evil and people using religion to control people and it's all just terrible. I'm like, so I hear you, bad things are bad, and now you overgeneralized and conflated everything to saying I all the bad things are in the Christianity bucket. And clearly we we have to s defeat them and specifically the black ones. I'm like, what? What is happening? What where is this coming from? But also what do you think is happening w like what group is specifically opposed to what you are angry at? Like I I I'm trying to pretend that he is speaking to a specific audience that that that is gonna be able to hear what he's coming from and then like band together to do anything. I'm like, I don't think you guys are organized and I don't think you really have. plan. And I don't think you have a framework to replace it with at all.
Damien: No. But I don't think a lot of people understand that. This is why I'm equating this to some of these left-leaning, black Marxist arguments that I hear, in the sense that they think that they can defer to an economic argument in a vacuum or a political
Josh: Right.
Damien: argument in a vacuum. And they're not speaking to any base moral belief system that would validate or it's a program. Like economics are. The facts of economics are rooted in a program. It's rooted in the moral outlook.
Josh: Right.
Damien: All things are rooted in a moral outlook. And I literally wrote about this in a book. and people don't really understand it. They think that they can just delve in this thing and delve in that thing. And they don't understand why they think one is wrong. The what the weird thing about it is like, like you, I think you said it before, is like people. Use language that isn't moral to talk about things that is moral and this is this is a wild, weird confusion. Like obviously you think one thing is right and one thing is wrong, but then you don't
Josh: Exactly.
Damien: wanna get into the moral beliefs that differentiate right from wrong, and then you wanna start talking about economics as if I don't know what the hell to make of it, man. I don't it's a comf it's a utter confusion. Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. Alright, cool.
Josh: You should you should you should you should play some some the video. We should play a little bit just so we get a little something out of it. It's it's interesting.
The Saint: Yeah. There must be war against the black Christians. And it's really a war to essentially silence them and stop them from proselytizing and spreading the slave religion that they got from their parents, who got it from their parents, who got it from their parents and their parents and their parents,
and then the enslaver. The truth is that in eighteen seven. A slave Bible was published, which is to say that the white Christians modified that which God originally authored and then gave it to the blacks to control them, to go from enslaving the body to enslaving the mind. And the reason that we must deal with the black Christians is because they today are the chief proselytizer and mental enslaver of the black peoples. You get your religion from your parents and your family. And the Christian culture that they voluntarily continue to practice. The truth of the matter is that no matter what black people may say, the lies that they tell, most black human beings on the planet Earth, we're talking about in excess of 95%, have received Christianity directly from colonization or enslavement, which is nearly the same thing. And some would claim that the Ethiopians have their own Christianity. Once you trace it back, you will find that that too was foreign. I encourage you to look back on another video that I made called Christianity Did Not Come from Africa. The Ethiopians did not have the original Bible. And I
Damien: Josh, I'm I'm sorry. Cannot. Cannot listen to it, but it's it
Josh: It's it's it's infuriating for all the wrong reasons. And it's just like you know none of that can be true, and you know none of that has to be true. When he got to this part, I'm just like, how did you get to this part in life? Like if he had grown up with the like those black Hebrews, what whatever they're called, those guys Israelite, the black Israelite. I'm
Damien: Israelites. Israelites.
Josh: like, okay. I could understand if he was having a conversation with them, then I'd be like, Okay, okay, maybe he's trying to address some actual concerns. But to say that Christianity didn't come from Africa as if it is a a news flash, I'm just like, that's that's a bare minimum not understanding. You know Christianity is Jewish, right? You know you know Jesus Christ is the Jew. You know the whole part about Christianity comes from Christ the anointed person who was a Jew and the Jewish person decided to let people know about Judaism. And then then clearly that was foreign to Africa because if we're not Jews, right? That's not a secret, is it? Do we have to go back and defend that part? That seems like a part we shouldn't have to anyway, the more and more I listened, the more angry I became to the point where I'm like, I'm going to write about this so I could have some clarity when I have to talk to someone Who has this level of confusion because it's just if we don't even understand that Christianity is Jewish, we're not even starting with a bare minimum understanding of the religion. Because now they're like, how can you possibly take what these white people did? I'm like, I mean, do you if you consider all Jews white, then I can I can hear where you're coming from. But I don't think that's where we're coming from. I think you think that people believe that Jews and Christ Christians and the Christianity itself is all black and came from Ethiopia itself. And I don't think anyone believes that. I don't think there's any actual evidence to suppose that Christ was Ethiopian. I I think we can all agree he was Jewish. I I think we shouldn't have to debate that.
Damien: mean, I would not see I'm not even gonna go to the to to the historical, empirical No, and it's not that it's not
Josh: See I'm use I'm using logic and reason. Okay. We don't we don't have to give a whole lesson on on on the fact that these things exist.
Damien: it's not about logic and reason. Thing First of all, he starts off talking about Christians are the biggest enslavers of black people. What is this enslavement? Like, I don't really understand what this enslavement is, right? Like
Josh: Right.
Damien: how is that working? I'm I'm assuming that if they're an ex enslaving people and you're against it, so somehow you've been liberated. What is the definition of being liberated? Not being enslaved? I don't know. I would like to ask him that. So that's one thing. And then he gets into the thing that I cannot stand. That they all that all these people do is like, it's like, such and such came from white people, so you know it's bad. Like anything,
Josh: There you go.
Damien: anything, anything in the world. Like I'm not gonna evaluate
Josh: Yeah.
Damien: An inability to evaluate anything on its own merit by a person. Like the the lack of objectivity to look at, hey, are these principles good or are they bad? No, I'm not gonna make that judgment. I'm gonna say they came from him or they came from her. It's always some
Josh: Right.
Damien: some fascination with a person, And so it's already a second-handed approach. So
Josh: Yes.
Damien: you're a second-handed person. What liberation can you find as a second hander? There's no liberation to be had by somebody like that. So
Josh: Right. No. Yeah. Race cannot be a moral standard. That's irrational.
Damien: It's crazy the more interesting thing to me about this, these are the same arguments. These are the same arguments as blaff black leftist, black Marxists, all of the colonization, all of the
Josh: Right.
Damien: such and such came from this person. If we go back like I hate when people say, well, such and such invented blah blah blah, and that person was a racist, so this thing is bad. That's a dumbass argument, right? And so, but nobody
Josh: Right.
Damien: ever says that. Nobody ever says that's a dumbass argument. As if, like, I care who invented the telephone. I use the telephone. Like, whoever invented it, I don't give a damn what they was meaning to do when they did it. It doesn't matter to me. It helps me talk to someone who isn't here. That's the job it does for me. But you don't know that such
Josh: Right. That does the actual thing I need.
Damien: and such and such invented it. I give a fuck. I don't care. I don't care who vented
Josh: Mm.
Damien: it. You know but
Josh: Right, that is
irrelevant. That's an that's a literal red herring. You have you have failed the basic logical fallacy. You you already did not make an argument. You had a claim, your goal was to support your claim with evidence, reasons, actual arguments. You failed. You failed from from the outset because you started with a falsehood. And now that I see that you have this clear logical fallacy, I'm rejecting the whole thing altogether. Either either find a new way to support your claim.
Damien: Right. There's nothing there's nothing to listen to.
Josh: But yeah, you can say it's a stupid argument and you can just say it's false.
Damien: I guess I'll give this dude just a little bit more, I don't think I gave him a fair shot. Well, I did give him a fair shot
Josh: Yeah.
Damien: but might as well just give him more time just in case I mean, just because.
The Saint: Go through the scholarship that explains the truth of the matter. What we're dealing with is deception. Not only did the enslaver deceive you when he forced Christianity upon you, but today blacks deceive other blacks, trying to force them into a religion that is foreign to us and detrimental. The effects of Christianity have been maleficial, which is to say that not only have you observed Extraordinary levels of bloodshed, whether it was the Native American being eradicated, or it was the colonization of the African continent and the colonization of Asia, or the transatlantic slave trade, or the apartheid system. In each case, all of these things were justified, legitimized, supported by the church and Christianity from a theological perspective, from a process perspective. And all of the people are guilty, but not just the people, also the religion. You are hearing
Damien: I'm not gonna say that there's a element of truth here. there's something that has to be dealt with in what he's saying. Right.
Josh: Yes.
Damien: That for people who don't deal in right and wrong, when people who do deal in right and wrong, when they come through, they're like, they're gonna tell you that you can and can't do certain stuff. There's going to be some kind of conflict, right? it's going to be a conflict, and some people are like, well, people bring violence. This I'm trying to stay away from the Christianity piece because I'm not really speaking about Christianity right now. I'm speaking about being ethical or moral, bringing up a moral orientation into a community or a a place. And what I'm saying is that your actions can be classified with judgment, right?
Josh: Yes, right?
Damien: And when you think that, nothing is right or wrong, things just are. And a people who come through with the idea of there's absolutely right and wrong, and we're going to punish wrong and we're going to praise right. That's a conflict. And that's some that's a conflict that some people can't understand. Somebody somebody might think that I'm giving Christianity to me like a a a false raising it up. But I'm like I said, I'm not really trying to talk about Christianity. I'm talking about morality as such. It's for people. And yeah, there's just going to be issues when you just think that, wow, man, these people come around and they tell us that doing whatever we've been doing is right or is wrong and they're trying to punish us for it. That's just the kind of conflict that's gonna come up when you get moral morality in the picture,
Josh: Ha ha.
Damien: right? That and that's just the fact. The fact of the matter is it's like we used to beat our women. We used to do this, that and the other. Well, we don't that's not what we're doing anymore.
Josh: Right. Well also
Damien: No, but
Josh: those actions when we did them were wrong. We can we can judge that appropriately according to this universal standard. We have some moral or ethical basis.
Damien: But see, that's what I'm saying. Like, but not everybody's carrying this universal standard though. See, that's what I'm saying.
Josh: They're not.
Damien: The people with the standard come through with to people without a standard, and it's like, it's this is oppression. See, we used to live
Josh: Yes.
Damien: totally free, and now y'all come with all of these rules, and that's just wrong. But I'm trying to present the idea of a person who lives with a rule mind. I'm a rule minded person. Right. And they
Josh: Right.
Damien: are things that are right and they're things that are wrong. And damn sure, yes, I feel justified in punishing wrong. And the person who doesn't live with that right and wrong mindset is like, yo, how could you just come through and just do those things? And that to me is the I'm trying to present that whole ideology of hey, structure and order. When you put structure and order on no structure, no order, that's that feels like oppression because it's like, We didn't have laws, and now you're punishing me for things that I didn't accept as right and wrong. And it's it becomes too bad. That's it that's what it becomes at the end of the day. So you can say it's right or wrong. that's why I I I always try to tell people and and explain my program. The program is rationality, the program is morality. The program is not disorder. Disarray. The program is not hedonism. The program is not whatever irrational thing that you can come up with. There will be order. This is the thing, this is the the conflict to me that you see. People who are not dealing in right and wrong that are like, yo, you're coming with the framework. You're coming with order. That order is oppressive. I don't want to be subordinate to the punishment that that's, that's. that comes down from you presenting this order, I want to be able to do whatever I want to do whenever I want to do it.
Josh: There you go. Mm-hmm.
Damien: And so that's a problem. That's a conflict. So I mean, I I don't know if I'm explaining it well, but there's always going to be that conflict when you're dealing with people with order. And it
Josh: Right, because you have two
different standards coming into play. There's a whole different standard on one side where you're having these rules, you're having this kind of singular approach, and then there's another approach that says, Hey, we're not going to follow any one real standard. We're just gonna come up with our own and make it up as we go. And so when you come into interaction with somebody else who has a real standard that they hold, they have real bound boundaries, there are things they're not going to do. Then I'm like, all right, we we're going to have conflict. You're gonna demand
Damien: Yes.
Josh: that I call you by pronoun or that I follow you on social and jump through some random hoops and say the right things and apologize all the time. And I'm gonna say no, I'm not going to do that. That's that's stupid. I
Damien: Yeah.
Josh: judge that as wrong. I judge that as incongruent with who I am. It violates my integrity, it violates my principles. I'm not going to do the things. It's like, well, if you don't adopt my standard over here, you are a bad person to you. Yes, but see, in my standard, you didn't adopt my standard either. So you're a bad person to me. See, it's subjective now, and we're not having a conversation anymore.
Damien: Yeah. So it's a battle of the frames. But the thing is, like, for me, I know what side I sit on. Like, I sit on the side of objectivity. I sit on the side of, rationality. So it can't just be an unwritten rule. It can't be like baseball and and and throwing at the somebody just hit a home run. It i I'm not into unwritten rules. I'm not going to submit myself to unwritten rules. If it's a problem. Write it down so I know it beforehand so I can make a decision and a judgment before I incur the situation. But if you're gonna be like,
Josh: Right, you gotta communicate.
Damien: I didn't like what you did, we're gonna punish you because I didn't like. I'm not going to be living a life based upon what you do and don't like from one
Josh: Right.
Damien: day to the next.
Josh: Right.
Damien: Okay? If it's a problem, write it down, put it in the code, let's, codify it. Let's put it in
Josh: Right.
Damien: the in the policy.
Josh: But the bare minimum you
Damien: And in that way
Josh: is communication. If this is a relationship, then you are required to communicate what it is that you're thinking and feeling in a way that I can understand. If you want this relationship to work. If you don't want it
Damien: Yes.
Josh: to work, then we can just go and evolve back into savagery. that is what is left if you refuse to communicate what it is you want, what it is you need and what it is that you expect. Then you can't be surprised when I don't meet your expectations. It wasn't
Damien: Do.
Josh: even on the table for us to discuss. So who knew what you wanted? Who knew if I was gonna do it? I didn't agree to it. You just got surprised.
Damien: Yeah. That's so it's two failures that we have in society. Like for one, we like to put in bad laws. And see when you put in bad laws, you can't practice them. So the law sucks already. It's like what are we gonna do with that? Right. But then you you also get this thing where it's like if you don't put anything in law or anything firm. Then you can always move the goalpost depending on how you feel at that time. Right? So but I just had to stop and at that point because I I just that's what I'm detecting when I'm hearing what he's saying.
Josh: you can t turn it off if you want. If you w wanna listen you more we can, but I get it. There's I think we've covered the significant part that he wanted to say. He he does get a bit repetitive.
Damien: okay. 'cause I didn't watch the whole thing all the way through. let me give him a minute or two more. Let me see.
The Saint: Fools when they tell you that, those are not real Christians. They're not real Christians because you must lie to yourself to maintain your religion. You're dealing with those who are truly deluded, in fact, mentally sick. And what's worse is that it's a sickness that is widespread and commonplace. And so human beings being social creatures, we tend to accept it. But let me tell you something. I accept Christian persons' religion or God. No more than I accept an individual who says that they're transgender, telling me that they are something that they are apparently not. And I would forward that the transgender person has a more legitimate argument than the one who says that they believe in God. For the transgender person at least has something to show, though it may not be persuasive. The one who claims to believe in the white sky daddy has nothing to show. Christianity is both white supremacist. And false and detrimental. If it's white supremacists, it's necessarily detrimental. Some things can be false and not detrimental, right? I can tell you that you are the best, and that can be something that helps you while it is false. But Christianity is both false and detrimental. And as we have blacks with low EQ who were brainwashed into this so early in life that it was before they could reason. It was when they were hearing this from their parents, their grandparents and their immediate society in the church when they were just two years old, three years old, and this brain
Damien: Yeah, I think I'm done. It's a couple of things, like three things. The last thing is like, look, everybody everybody's getting something when they're one, two, three years old. That it doesn't matter if it's Christianity or what. Like, whatever
Josh: Thank you.
Damien: they're learning is their world at that time. What what are we even talking about? What the f what are they talking about?
Josh: What are we even talking about? Like people are shaped by their experiences. They are. People are influenced by people other than themselves. Yeah yeah, that's how human experience works. Can you believe this? Yeah, that's that's fair. That's fair. I can believe this. Sometimes people tell them things that
they themselves believe. Yeah, yeah, I'm sure that's how that's the only way people speak. Mostly the things that they believe. Especially if they're like coming from an adult to a kid, they typically most
Damien: Exactly
Josh: parents do tend to raise their children. Uhhuh. Yes. Okay. But no, that's not that's not that's not that's not not a secret. I'm like my god
Damien: Good talk.
Josh: you are not teaching me anything. I didn't learn something new from that exchange.
Damien: No, the thing, man, is that and one of the more bigger reasons I like to share or wanted to share is something like this. Is this what I mean when I'm saying, like, for me, the fabric of society was religion, right? That was the fabric of the society that I grew up in. It it tied a lot of people together. Now. Once again, I say I'm not I'm not into religion anymore, but it's not that I really will need to disrespect it. I don't get any big benefit by disrespecting it, like that. but I'm trying to show that this is the fraying. This is the fraying. This is what I mean by There's a lot, like if you check the comments with some of this stuff, people are identifying with this and they are
Josh: Yes, they eat it up.
Damien: eating it up, and they're also using their bad experience in Christianity to to
Josh: Thank you.
Damien: as a proof to, to see, this was I knew it was right all the time, or whatever. You know what I'm saying?
Josh: Of new house.
Damien: And and my thing is, okay, as a belief system, when you are talking against. Christianity. You've got to be talking about some philosophy. You've gonna have to talk about some philosophy, some
Josh: Yes.
Damien: sort of worldview. And especially in the black things that I've seen that who speak out against Christianity, they're not presenting any alternative worldview. Like they don't it's almost like they don't even know that worldviews, full worldviews exist. Like,
Josh: Right? It's not even on the radar.
Damien: no. They think that they can swap out a a worldview or belief system for a system of politics or an economic system. It doesn't work like that. And that's
Josh: Right.
Damien: that's the poverty of what I'm seeing is that This is for one a con job for some people. This is a way to make some money for some people. And you're not presenting any value. There's really no value. because to me, if it's like, yo, hit here's how you get better decisions in life. To what end? To to cause the program tells me the end, right?
Josh: Right?
Damien: So what's what is better? Better is about an end. What's the end? you make more money. Money is not an end. It's it's not an end in itself. Money is a tool.
Josh: No, it does tool. There you go.
Damien: what do you want to be famous? That's not an end for me, could be an end for you. I'm not, you know, it's not not deep enough.
Josh: Ha ha.
Damien: You know what I'm saying? You gotta you
Josh: Yes.
Damien: have to get some more. So what are we doing here? Is it about women? Cause
to me it's only gonna be about certain adoration or I don't know, it's not you want adoration, you want to be famous, you want Women, you want money, you want power. These are some of the base things, and some of them kinda don't even sit at the same level either. But these are the ends. So all of this advice has to be given with some end goal here. And the program is missing, so there's no end goal. I don't see it in goal.
Josh: Mm. I don't see an end goal. I don't see a real program. There's no moral framework that he's presenting, a lot of his premises are just wrong. And so when when you start there, it's real hard to continue. Like, well, you gotta give everybody the benefit of a doubt. I'm like, I don't think you do. I think once they say wrong things, you can re you can judge the wrong thing as being incorrect and say, The premise is wrong, therefore the ending is clearly going to be off.
Damien: So the video I brought up last week was the Kant video, right? and the thing is, like once again, I think that this this guy, he he's missing the mark on it completely. And so I just wanna talk about what it actually is that that I think that that matters. And it's the program. It's this the the the core belief system. And And when people start talking about economics and politics and and the history of things, they start getting into the empirical elements of things, right? I think it's a tricky thing, right? It's because Kant's thing is reason is or morality is a priori or a priori or whatever. And that actually is, in my opinion, correct. Right. You're you're operating on principles, but principles that are derived from reality. But the principle itself is not a reality. You know what I'm saying? a principle is not a reality, but the principle is derived from reality. And and so the whole point is that you're not operating on what actually happened. You're operating on the right thing to do. you can only use your judgment, and I can't really say the future, but I can tell you, you know, I can have an intent and have a goal. in my mind and make that decision and that's the best I can do. And so that's what I think gets lost sometimes. But yeah, that that whole thing about that's why to me, like when people start talking about what the history of this is and the history of that and this person said this and this person said that, That's not what that's not what morality is about though. It's about your choice, it's about your judgment.
Josh: There you go. these are things that are gonna support your life, these are actual standards that you use to find things that are going to point yourself in the right direction, help yourself live in line with that.
Damien: Yeah. This is related to what I'm saying. It's like when we start getting to this thing about, does this thing have evidence? And does that thing have evidence when we're talking about morality? I think that that's partly a a wrong conversation. Right? And and the reason why I'm saying that
is that when he presents, let me let him present it.
Lee Braver: Mill wanted a universal law. He wanted a morality that would apply to every situation. And therefore, Mill said, I need to base my morality on something that is universally shared by all humans, something in human nature. And he picked the feeling, the ability to feel pleasure and pain. This is something that is in human nature, all humans feel it, and therefore, if I base my morality on it, the greatest happiness principle derived theory of life. then I can have universal application. Kant says that might be good enough for Mill, it's not good enough for Kant was a a very, very good astronomer. In fact, there was a Kant-Laplace law that was in effect for for many, many, many years. And Kant believed in the existence of alien life forms. And Kant asks, okay, Mill, what happens when an alien comes down and we meet the alien? Where is your your theory then? Your theory is based on human nature, which means it can say nothing to the alien. It has to be silent about the alien, which means if the alien eats us, utilitarian just shrugs its shoulders and says, Well, I don't know, I guess that's not good for us. We don't like that. And that violates local culinary rules, but hey, it's not a human, so it doesn't apply to them. That's not good enough for Kant. Kant is thinking about one of the questions that we always have to ask as well with Mill is to whom does morality apply? Who is a morally relevant being? For Mill, anything that feels pleasure pain. Kant doesn't think that's right for a number of reasons. But one of them is this reason. For Kant, what it means to be a moral agent, a being who can be held responsible for their action, means that you can choose your own actions. And what it means to choose your own actions is to entertain various possibilities. I could do this, I could do this, I could this, and reflect on them. Is this the right thing to do? Is that the right thing to do? What it means to be a responsible moral agent to be an agent, moral agent who is responsible for your actions means you've chosen your actions. What it means to choose your actions is you have the capacity to entertain various possible actions, examine each, and decide which of them you're going to take. That is the exercise of reason. It's not the exercise of feeling pleasure and pain. It's the exercise of reason. So it's rational agents, beings who can think that are moral agents. We don't blame.
Damien: So this is my point with this is if you do encounter aliens, like morality has to survive that that type of interaction, right? So to me, if I'm saying that this is this is moral and this is immoral, and then another being comes from another place or whatever, and they don't have the same vulnerabilities as a human. I don't know if he's making a case. I think he's just presenting what Kant said and what these people said. But my thing is Morality and the the the the ability to reason, to reflect, or make moral choices, be a rational agent, that's about human life. And it's only about human life because that's the only life we really understand in that lane. And so
Josh: Right.
Damien: when we engage with aliens, i it doesn't really change anything about the morality because
Josh: Should it? We're still the same moral agent involved. Mm-hmm.
Damien: Exactly, exactly. But that's what unites us though, our our similar vulnerabilities, our similar similar weaknesses, our similar lifespan, the way our s we bleed, we need oxygen, we need all of these things. Even like, you know, animal is similar, but it's not the same in the sense that, you know, it's it's not like a human, a human being, you
Josh: No,
Damien: know.
Josh: no, it cannot do human things, it doesn't have human choices, so it cannot have the same moral agency, it doesn't fit in the same category.
Damien: Yeah. this is what I'm submitting to kind of like support my support of the a prior a priori perspective of it just sits at the front. It's a it's a worldview, it's a program. but the the the human experience undergirds the principles, but the principles sit at the forefront of y of the action now. Like maybe I'll get some more evidence that changes my mind later, but what matters now is What sits in my principles right now. and that's maybe in the future we live to be a hundred and such and such. Maybe, but I'm operating on what what our common experience is now and the choices that I can make about that now. I think what happens is just that people just like, well, the the situation has changed. That does not mean anything. That that that does not
Josh: Mm-hmm.
Damien: I mean, over time maybe you can incorporate it, but it may just be a bad day. you you might have just been hungry today or just had a bad day and you couldn't find food or whatever. It does not mean that the situation has changed. That's that's what I'm saying.
Josh: Principle it remains the same regardless of how people's different random experiences is like if we collect collect all the experiences together, we'll find more experiences that support morality as a principle than those that contradict it. I think that is the part that matters the most is the part of saying there are principles that work for life. There are some things that promote life. If life is the standard then we can say we can make certain actions that promote the life and certain actions that take away this life. And therefore we can have a clearer approach of how we do these things.
Damien: Yeah, and we have to be specific about human life too.
Josh: Yes, that's true. Yes. Human
Damien: Because that's
Josh: life is the standard, then we have some real clear objectives or way to judge something whether it is a moral action or not.
Damien: Rus. Yes. Absolutely. Because let's say aliens did come to Earth and they don't had the same vulnerabilities that we have. But they do have the capacity to reason. I mean, what does that mean to us? I'm just
making up a fictitious argument, but I can shoot the alien. He doesn't he just swipes it off or he takes the bullet and comes back or whatever. He doesn't have a similar experience that that grounds his morality is grounded in something else. And it's not similar to mine. Right? And and well, if he has the capacity to reason in in this argument. This this is the argument he's given. If he has the capacity to reason, well he's reasoning about his experience or her experience or
Josh: There you go.
Damien: whatever his his experience is. But it's not a human experience. So I can't interact with and engage with this being the way that I can a human who has a similar experience to me.
Josh: Right. We don't have the same expectations, we don't have the same standards for them. They're different. Gotta
Damien: Yeah.
Josh: treat them as they are, not as I am.
Damien: Hmm. but that kind of says that sets up a place like I'm thinking of an animal at this point. Cause I'm thinking like,
Josh: It does. All right.
Damien: okay, sure, I'm gonna treat the the lion as he is, not like I am, but that means I'm gonna have to protect myself from this lion, cause that's like
Josh: There you go. There you go. Like when you threaten me, I'm going to need to protect my human life. And not even maybe at the expense of yours. Random line. You're gonna there will be
Damien: Yeah.
Josh: consequences for actions regardless.
Damien: Yeah. Yeah. I think people get into too many Empiricist arguments I don't know about things. Empirical.
Josh: Right? They get they get into empiricist arguments without recognizing the limits of empiricism. And I think that is the concern I have is that people are just like, I only believe evidence. I'm like, excellent. Become a researcher. And then you'll have something you have evidence for. And once you have evidence in that area, you can be considered more knowledgeable than you were before. But you can't say that you won't believe anything without evidence because you're not a researcher of everything. You don't have that much time or those kind of tools. You're you literally don't know those things, so you can't say, Well, seeing is believing. I'm like, You have not seen most of the world. I'm going to need you to expand your mind and be able to say, I have limits, and I'm gonna have to take some things on the trust that other people have got data that I don't have and trust those experts to make those decisions in those areas. I don't want people to outsource the reason. I don't want them to completely become second handers who just let experts tell them what to do. I just want people to acknowledge the fact that they are limited. We don't have the ability to know every single thing directly, and that's okay.
Damien: No, but it's a flawed perspective from the beginning, man, because
Josh: Yes it is. That's why Imperius fell out of favor.
Damien: What would you be knowing?
Josh: What would you even know?
Damien: People don't understand, like, yeah, I'm gonna go find the evidence. You don't need evidence of what? If you don't have anything
Josh: Ha ha ha.
Damien: s firm, you don't even know what the evidence is evidence of. What
Josh: Right.
Damien: what are we talking about here? I'm gonna go measure it. you believe in a a system of measurement? so there's something that you believe, there's something that had to h stay firm for you to even evaluate the evidence. What?
Josh: Right.
Damien: What is it? or are you gonna go with your senses? Are we gonna go back to true cave people? Hey, I touched it and it burned, and I I looked at it and it was bright. Or okay. Do you have tools? you believe in tools. You believe in a f a jewel or a vault? these are people. People name you believe in someone, in something, somebody gave you something as as a tool.
Josh: Right? Trust happens. Trust happens. I think this is always the thing when we get into epistemology. I'm like There is a way we know things and there are some things that we just accept. And you're going to need to just come to that realization that you being a human being means that you trust things. You trust certain people and you trust what they say and you trust the evidence of your senses and you trust the evidence of The th the the stuff in the history books, hey, is everything you know perfect? No. Do you usually have enough data to go about your day to day life? Probably. There are probably things you can do when it comes to getting up today, washing, getting to work, getting back home, eating and sleeping. You can probably do that on the data you have. And okay.
Damien: Yeah. But that's the that's why I for me when I hear people who are deep into philosophy or deep into science and they try to pretend like the average person's just some dummy, it's like they may be living a better life than you. You know, they're
Josh: Right?
Damien: like you don't underst you man, I might want to bring this thing up too. You find these people who it's like they're stuck in a science class. They they cannot think outside of, well, here's the logic of this and here's the logic of the how does that relate to life? It's almost like they don't know. It's like, hey, I can tell you what the science says, but I don't know. I didn't know that it related to life. I just thought it was just the science. They can just do the science piece. They can just do the logic piece, but they don't
Josh: Right.
Damien: They can't get it. They can't get it back to the place that it originated from. The science is here because it had a purpose. And then
Josh: Right.
Damien: people just started doing science. And now people are like detached from the purpose. And it's like you do know that this this is a science would not be a thing. If it didn't have a human purpose, like we wouldn't have developed it. You do know that,
Josh: There you go.
Damien: right? But they think that this, like, no, I know how to do the logic, I know how to do the science. You're just an
employee. You
Josh: Mm-hmm.
Damien: you just know how to do the thing. We call you when we need to. Just put the report on the desk and get out of here, man. that's how I feel
Josh: Right.
Damien: about it. But all right, my bad. Getting late. But have you ever heard have you heard of this Jason O R Day thing? The the the guy that I guess offed himself, cause he was plagiarizing stuff at Cambridge University or something like that. Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.
Josh: Ooooo that guy. That's crazy. Yeah.
Damien: Yeah. And so there's this there was somebody who outed him. It's this some white guy, right? I've been checking out some of these videos. He was on Coleman Hughes. But then he was on the Glenn Lowry show, recently. And he does he's got this thing it's called race realism or something like that.
Josh: Yeah.
Damien: And it's interesting, This is one of these types of people I'm talking about. He he's doing science, but it's like he doesn't really understand how it connects to reality or some something like that. And It's it's it's a wild thing, man. That's why I can't even really explain it. I almost just have to to share it. Yeah. It's
Josh: You have to see the belief like, this is where we're at.
John McWhorter — The Glenn Show: What's your end game? And I don't mean that you have a sinister one, but what's the point of this? Given that people really don't want to hear it, given that we're not gonna have a society where Harvard doesn't have any black professors. What are you doing? What are you what are you getting out of this? I don't understand.
Nathan Cofnas — The Glenn Show: Well, I a society where Harvard doesn't well in a meritocracy there would w there would be black professors at Harvard. It would just be a smaller number than than it is now. now I've said that I think that some affirmative action would be potentially desirable in a multiracial society, so that Everybody, not in all positions, and not that everybody should be equally represented based on their proportion of the population, but so everybody feels that that they have a voice and in our collective faith. That was the expression that I I used in the original essay. There are huge disparities among races and and other demographic you can divide people in different ways, but just among race. there are enormous disparities. People notice it and now if nobody noticed it and nobody cared then maybe I wouldn't talk about this. But people do notice and they demand an explanation. We've ruled out a priori any role for natural differences between people in either ability or temperament or interests or anything like that. Therefore disparities must be due to the environment and The most obvious environmental explanation is, especially when you're talking about groups who were historically persecuted. Like that is a thing that actually happened, right? So if you were if you're an environmentalist and you're trying to explain the cause of the disparities, that's the most obvious explanation, is either past or present racism. And wokeism simply is the war on racism which is causing the disparities which won't end until we achieve a quality of outcome. If natural differences play an important role
Glenn Loury — The Glenn Show: Excuse me for interrupting Nathan, but I I I I'm not entirely following the logic here. Yes, there are differences. Without any questions, differences in crime rates, differences in test scores, and so on. and yes, racism is one of the environmental factors that could be caught looked upon to give an account. it's one that has a moral res resonance with it. I accuse someone of racism, I'm making a serious charge. But it's not the only environmental factor that could give an account. And the fact of differences is hardly proof of the nature of the differences, that is to say, the root cause thereof. So help me understand why embracing what you guys call racial realism is the only alternative to wokeism. it looks like there are a lot of other possibilities that are not being considered.
Nathan Cofnas — The Glenn Show: Well the main possibility is the cultural explanation.
John McWhorter — The Glenn Show: May if I may interject though, you're being a little you're being a little euphemistic here, and I and all of us do it. You keep on talking about race differences. But what you really mean is black people are the least smart. Let's face it, that's what you're saying. I'm not accusing you, I'm stating that that is what you're saying. Why the euphemistic language? And well, Nino, that's not a question. Of course you'd have to talk in euphemism, but when you say differences, theoretically there could be many. But what we're really talking about is black people are the dumbest people. I mean, if we're really going to use very basic English. Why do we need to talk about that in particular? What is the point in terms of how we're organizing society? That someone of your intelligence and with your zitzfleisch is going to show us that black people have the lowest IQs. Why does that need to be skyridden?
Glenn Loury — The Glenn Show: Not everybody knows what zit spice means, John.
John McWhorter — The Glenn Show: Zitz fleiß means that sitting neat and so that you can sit down and work for a very long time. Why do we need to talk about the fact that black people are the dumb ones, which is what you're saying?
Nathan Cofnas — The Glenn Show: You you I'm sure have much deeper insights than I do into the concept of euphemisms and why people speak it or speak speak in different ways about different topics. I I didn't think that I was speaking that euphemistically. Okay, so we're talking about a one-standard deviation in IQ. So the average African American IQ is between eighty-two and eighty-five compared to the the white IQ, American IQ of a hundred, East Asian IQ is a little higher. so And there there it is. I wouldn't use words like so I I I am comfortable referring to the right stupidity problem and saying that
on average conservatives are are stupider than and liberals for genetic reasons. It's a it's a matter of kind of sensitivity, right? I'm I'm part of that group. And there are things that a black person can say about the about b black people or or or black culture that I wouldn't say and I I think it's the I know it's you
John McWhorter — The Glenn Show: You you worry me a little bit, and I'm not given to that kind of melodrama, but you know, the last conversation I had with Amy Wax, she said long before she went public with it, that there are never any black students at the top of her classes. And she said, and we need to be able to talk about it. And I said, Well, why? Why do we need to be able to talk about it? And she said, Well, we need to be able to talk about it. And I said, No, no, I don't think you understand. I mean, to what end do we need to talk about that? And she never really answered and I know
Glenn Loury — The Glenn Show: Answer John.
John McWhorter — The Glenn Show: what's in Amy's mind, but what's in yours? To what end?
Glenn Loury — The Glenn Show: But what you've not yet argued for is that there are no alternatives other than to acceptance and complacency in the face of the disparity.
Nathan Cofnas — The Glenn Show: Well, I mean i compla complacency
Glenn Loury — The Glenn Show: Why wouldn't investment in the development Why wouldn't investment in the development of productive capacities amongst the population that has been historically held back and that is underperforming be on the table, even if we acknowledge the existence of the differences. You're using the word natural. You use the word natural. What what do you mean? Do you mean the genetic structures are such that and who's demonstrated this, such investments are a waste of money?
Nathan Cofnas — The Glenn Show: How much more money do we do we throw at the problem? And if you look at how much money we spend per student, you know, in the United States, it's it's enormous. It's just enormous. now I'm not saying that that education is perfect. Obviously the we we can make improvements and the but we are putting it's not clear how much more resources we should be directing to this problem or what are what we should kind of results we should expect.
Glenn Loury — The Glenn Show: What is your evidence that resources cannot make a difference in reducing the racial disparity in intellectual performance?
John McWhorter — The Glenn Show: 'Cause we only have IQs of eighty five. So it's only gonna go
Glenn Loury — The Glenn Show: That's exactly the argument that I'm trying to expose, but Nathan seems not to be willing to own up to it.
Nathan Cofnas — The Glenn Show: Wait. So I I'm saying there are the the the differences in IQ that we see now basically due to genetic variation between groups. So
Glenn Loury — The Glenn Show: Well, do is is the evidence the genetic variation between groups or is the evidence within groups the heritability of IQ across family lines? And those are two very different things.
Nathan Cofnas — The Glenn Show: But so you wouldn't infer between group heritability from w within group heritability.
Damien: It's almost like they accosted him at some point. And I didn't think it was
Josh: Yes.
Damien: I didn't think it was unfair so much that like I guess the only reason I thought it like it's two of them, it's only one of him, right? But
Josh: But they're actively interrupting him the whole time. Like it's it
Damien: Yeah.
Josh: they have done other shows where they've let the guests speak and they've had a a reasonable back and forth. This was not that time.
Damien: No. No but I mean I think that they were trying to get to something like
Josh: They were, but it wasn't a helpful something. But it was it it was they were trying to
Damien: Ha ha
Josh: get there. But it's it's unfortunate because they are able to have done more research into this topic to be able to bring up counterarguments and have a little dialectic response to say like, all right, you said this thing, let's push back a bit about this. You presented this evidence, what about this counter evidence? You presented this claim, what about this counterclaim? And I would there could have been more of that.
Damien: But John wasn't going for. John was not going for that at all. Because
Josh: No.
Damien: it's not, he didn't need to. If anybody would have did it, it would have been Glenn. Because he was interested in the argument.
Josh: Right. That's what I expected. Mm.
Damien: John is like, he like me, like, yo, what's the end goal here? You know, like, what's the point?
Josh: Right? You sound like you trying to do a little something. What do you what do you what do you what do you think is happening? What are you doing? And why do you why do you think that's okay?
Damien: it's like yo, you just you keep tap dancing, you keep You keep saying these these words and it's like, what do you really wanna say? And maybe you think that that's not that's not really because that's what that's to me where John was coming from. And he's like
Josh: Yes, that's exactly where Yes. Mr. Mc Mr. McWhorter was talking about. I'm like, that's exactly right. Exactly what what he what he's getting at. And I'm just like, why have this guest on your show and ask him this question? Like I it's funny, but it's not like useful. Do you think he's gonna like, yeah, let me just tell you out right now.
Damien: But that's what my thing is, like, if that's if you're going to try to present this argument, like this is what I mean about excuse me, when people I get into conversations with people about maybe philosophy and or even psychology, and they're like, they come up with this point that's sounds good in the classroom, then I'm like, okay, where does that point meet reality? And they're like, well. That's not really my concern. And so that's where I feel like that's where John was coming at it. Like, okay, and all of this does what to the price of tea in China? You know.
Josh: Right. How did we apply this principle?
Damien: Right. So what am I supposed to do that black people are the whatever, the lowest on the IQ scale or whatever you call it? and I just I do feel like he was probably I don't know, I can't say that he was offended really. I I just think that he's like, What am I gonna do with this information?
Josh: Right.
Damien: W What do I do with it? I enjoyed the conversation just in the sense that the dude started the he was on his heels at at some point in time and he was like, Well,
Josh: Yeah. Yeah, I mean but like the premise was wrong. Nathan Cofnas brings up a good point that frequently there are people who blame white people for all racial disparities. He's like, okay, if we're gonna play the race game, then the research shows that there are people who are not my race, but the other one, or an alternative at least, have
Damien: Mm-hmm.
Josh: a negative part said about them. And why aren't we talking about that? There are people who are worse than others. There are people in the category I'm not in who are worse at things. Data shows. I'm like, all right. Fair. That is a real point that can be brought up when in in what they're talking about. But I just go
Damien: Right.
Josh: back to the to the to the to the premise. I'm just like, racism isn't real. Like they have racism is a social construct. That we know is that way, and we have actual evidence from the genome project that clearly showed there were more differences within the race than there were between races. We know genetics isn't the issue. We know this isn't a natural phenomenon, we know this isn't real, and therefore, since it's not evidence-based, it is clearly society-based and do and like there are real influences in the world. The cultural differences, the testing, nutritional, Well there are environmental factors that can cause people in certain categories to behave differently. I'm like, all right, that's something to talk about. Nothing there's nothing wrong with having a clearer conversation about that. But anyway, since I reject racism as as a since I reject race as a premise, it this isn't an interesting conversation because it's false. But again, we can talk about the downstream effects of the environmental factors.
Damien: I mean, but that okay, we got three things. So we got environmental factors factors, we got race, and we got intelligence, which is
Josh: Mm-hmm.
Damien: the very different things because
Josh: Very different.
Damien: See, because this is to me why I just think that we've gotta be more clear about the concept of intelligence. Cause sometimes
Josh: Right.
Damien: I don't think we all agree on what intelligence is. I don't think so.
Josh: No, we don't. And I don't think IQ has been codified effectively where it's being properly standardized or measured across all people in all situations, which makes me uncomforta uncomfortable.
Damien: Yeah I don't know, sometimes I encounter people who are com almost completely irrational, but I still would consider them intelligent.
Josh: Right.
Damien: But maybe is that because I'm misunderstanding intelligent, or is it because we're not clearly differentiating between intelligence and rationality or reasoning? That's that's kinda like what I'm thinking.
Josh: Yeah, I think we we we have grouped the idea of intelligence into multiple different cognitive functions. And I think that is an overgeneralization that is not doing us any any benefits. it's doing us a significant disservice for sure. And so I think it's very helpful when I can say when I say this person is intelligent, I mean their brain works like this. They have certain amount of ability to remember certain things. They've a certain amount of ab ability to process something. They have a certain amount of ability to conceptualize this issue or conceptualize this particular space. I don't believe in all the extra this person has relational intelligence and emotional intelligence and magical intelligence. I'm like may maybe less of that. But I do believe in people like, this person is better at spatial solving spatial problems than others. conceptual problems and others or physical problems and others. I'm like, okay, that's a actual thing I can get my hands around. We can test for that. That's a different form of intelligence that I support, understand, and can at least say, All right, there are some things about this we can categorize that way. But I think it's helpful just to go back to a cognitive function and say like, what specifically is the brain doing here? How well can this person do it in a certain time period? How much can they memorize? How much can they think through? How much can they solve in this period of time? Under ideal conditions. Not magically ideal under just the general normal conditions. No one actively stopping them from doing.
Damien: Yeah man, but what do you do with the geniuses? Like like what do you do with the criminal masterminds?
Josh: But d the geniuses Right, and those people actively perform well in all those areas. A lot of those people that we call geniuses have print pretty much of photographic memory or high level memory at that point. A lot of these geniuses actively have high level of product processing where they can actively take in data so quickly that they not only learn it, but they understand it. And so a lot of these geniuses actively are able to think ten or thirty steps ahead. And like when when asked about it, they can talk about these things and communicate it in a way that lets you know, they're they're outperforming people. It's not just like, who knows how the seniors did it. It's like, no, he he literally just told you that he was more aware of it than you and remembered more than you and did it faster than you. So those were like signs that he's smarter. He wasn't just guessing.
Damien: But see the thing for me is man, like that that intelligence is never going to be presented as
intelligence on a grand scheme. I mean on a scale.
Josh: I agree. I hear you. Yeah, I mean, all that intelligence doesn't have to turn into performance. I have to stop evaluating people based off of their performance alone. Performance meaning their achievements in life are great things, but that can't be the only thing because I don't know. If I just look at people based off of their achievements, I'll miss all the people who didn't have the perfect ideal conditions to get those achievements. And so I want to be clearer when there are times when I'm discussing intelligence. I want to focus on a specific cognitive function that the brain is doing and say, look, this is what occurred. This person did this function in this way, in this time period, and that was measured against somebody else who tried to do the same thing. And now have a better Measurement when it says, do I want this person to do a certain thing or should I trust this person in this area? I will have a better way to evaluate it. Personally, I think that's just we aren't being specific enough when we talk about intelligence. we just say the word and we group all the things that we want to be true there. And I'm like, this is not a useful des definition.
Damien: I mean, yeah, for for intelligence, I guess to me, t at least there there's a consistent way that people who have accepted testing intelligence. I'm not really worried about The things that people can do so much because I'm more worried about how they can I don't know, work together. Like interact with others in a civilized manner. That's my main concern, to be honest with you. It's different ways to get there. But that's the more important part. You know, I'm always talking about the morality and and the and the ethics of everything. Because like smart people can come and go. Like,
Josh: Yes.
Damien: I don't ain't that much damn smart to me, Josh. Cause like, I'm not one of these people like, my goodness, if this person didn't do this thing, it would have never have happened. I don't. truly believe that? You know, it's just like I don't believe in soulmates. I I just believe that things happen and I would like for them to happen and In a society that is just. And could there be greater things that happen in the unjust society? Maybe, but I'm not interested in that. and actually, I probably I probably would say that I wouldn't even look at those things as greater things if they had to exist in the unjust society. That's just the way my brain works.
Josh: I hear ya. I hear ya. Yeah, there are requirements that have to have to be met so that society functions well. And those are things that you can prioritize. I think there are helpful ways to look at that and there are helpful ways to clearly know what we're talking about. And so sometimes you can use your brain to do the right things or things that promote your life and then also society. And then there are unhelpful ways to navigate that as well.
Damien: I just think that that's the more important thing about it. 'Cause it becomes this thing where I'm not doing it for the other. I'm just, you know how, what's that saying when people be like, well, first they came for the for the this and I didn't say
Josh: Yes.
Damien: anything, and then they came for the that and I didn't say anything, but then they came for me. Right? And I can what is Iron Brands thing? Because I it in my book. She was like, I'm, I'm not. I'm not brave enough to something like I'm not brave enough not to pay attention to the to what's going on, you know, to to to ignore the consequences or something like that. because it's like I'm not I'm not stupid. I understand, yeah, it it could be me. Like if we're gonna have an unjust society, that was just them that time. it was just them that time. Wait a minute. What what what if it's me? What if it's me one time?
Josh: Right.
Damien: I'm not gonna like that. So if I don't like it, why would I want somebody else to like that? You
Josh: True.
Damien: know? And so it always comes down to that for me. I'm I'm stuck in that in that world. And everybody's not doing that level of reasoning. that's a foresight. That you are at actively imagining something that hasn't happened yet. But that's not to say that there hasn't been evidence of that thing probably or logic it's a logical conclusion. Right? And if I say, yo, we shouldn't we shouldn't do these things because these are not good things and these are not Things that you would want someone to do to you. And so just because it's you're not the one who's having it done to them now doesn't mean that you're
Josh: Yeah.
Damien: not going to be the one that it's done to tomorrow. So even if you didn't accept the argument of just being nice to people, you would probably not want to do this thing because it could actually end up bad for you, maybe not today, but you if you had the foresight, you could understand something beyond today, you know.
Josh: Right. This increased risk. This clearly can make it harder for you to live.
Damien: Good. this is why I say to you though, Josh. This is why I just move. This is why I just do things. This is not
Josh: Nice.
Damien: I'm not interested in explaining things to people and getting into arguments of explaining why they're wrong and why I'm right. I just do things and
Josh: Let's do it like all right. My my f
Damien: That's
Josh: my work will speak for itself.
Damien: Right, exactly. And people will be like, That's wrong, this is wrong, blah blah blah blah blah. If I'm doing the thing and you're talking about it, I'm winning. That's how I look at it, you know. So
Josh: Right. There you go. That's enough. All right, man. Do it
Damien: Catch you next time. Peace.
Josh: again.