전사 🔗
00:00:01
Speaker 1: You're with John Pullman on 702. Let's walk the talk. 702 Drive. Let's focus our attention now on the Metro of Johannesburg and the uncertainty that still prevails as to how the city will be governed following the local government elections. The magic number, if you want to determine the future of Johannesburg, is 136. But you probably want a few more seats than that in a 270-seat council than just that margin of one. Because if you're putting together a coalition that has lots of small parties in it, well, that is going to be pretty tricky because you can't always control what any one of them might do. So there was a story today on News 24 saying that the ANC was on the verge of a deal with Action SA. Let's look at the possibilities of this and crucially, what kind of coalition this might produce. And welcome to 7.02 Drive, Professor Alex van den Heerfer, who is from the Wits School of Governance. Prof, welcome and thanks very much for your time. If you put together ANC and Action SA, You get 106 seats, which is a good deal short, 30 seats to be precise, of that magic number I mentioned. Bring in the EFF and the MK party, which are the next biggest parties, and you're over the line by two seats. If you don't want to go with both of those or either of those, the road is more complicated and a lot longer. At the very least, I would have thought the ANC Action SA leads in that coalition would need to bring in another sizable player, possibly the IFP with seven, the PA with five, Rai Zamzansi has five, and on and on it goes through a number of parties with a smaller number of seats. Is this a inherently a difficult way of governing a city if you are dependent on five, six, seven parties to keep things together.
00:02:04
Speaker 2: Yes, it is. The real question is, what is the glue that keeps the particular coalition together? What are the quid pro quos? And how does it affect how they actually govern at the end of the day? And if a big risk with the way in which some coalitions can be structured, if they are purely transactional, is that effectively you hand portions of the city over to party political control rather than an overall governing approach. And it potentially fragments delivery and potentially results in lots and lots of corruption.
00:02:42
Speaker 1: So, I mean, if I'm looking at what holds parties together, you could argue that a coalition, and I'll pull out Action SA for a moment, but the ANC, the EFF, and the MK party, if you look at that part of the ANC that is not as enamored with the national governing arrangements that part of the party aligned with President Sul Ramaphosa is, you could argue that with the ANC, the EFF, and the MK Party, they actually have quite a lot in common. They probably see many political issues in a similar way. And if Action SA is willing to work within that broad political context, add in the Patriotic Alliance, you've got something with a fairly high level of consensus, don't you?
00:03:30
Speaker 2: Well, it's a question as to what they've got consensus on. Is it allocating the... tenders to front companies and people with relationships to the political players. If that's the purpose, if that's the point of the governing, and that's what the glue that holds them together, then obviously it will result in more of what we've seen in Johannesburg. where essentially there is no real focus on proper governance. And it's quite clear that substantial amounts of money are stripped away. So on the one hand, at a superficial level, you could say perhaps there's some kind of ideological agreement among them, but basically condoning corrupt conduct is not actually an ideological position of any worth. It is essentially a a privatization of a public authority. So what you want is that at the end of the day, the coalitions are competing on delivery and they can have different approaches to how they do it, different emphases, different parameters in terms of distribution. But at the end of the day, I mean, you know, a metro is about fundamental service delivery, roads, lights, city development, housing regulation, property regulation, et cetera. Those are the basic functions. They're not grand ideologies. And if you can't do that, you shouldn't be in government. So the question is, are the coalitions that are going to be formed about a corrupt purpose or are they about delivery? It's concerning in that it's quite likely that a coalition can be formed based on inappropriate incentives.
00:05:13
Speaker 1: All those parties would argue that your characterisation of them is simplistic, that there has been and that's been demonstrated amply, for example, in the ranks of the ANC at every single level of government. But, for example, the EFF might argue, well, you know, they haven't really had a chance to govern in any significant way in a great many municipalities in that they have policies that, like everybody else's, says they are vigorously opposed to corruption and will act against it.
00:05:51
Speaker 2: Well, there are books that say differently. The issue is that they have been in governing positions and being able to influence government in the city of Johannesburg and Ekereleni. And we've seen where delivery has gone in these metros. So the question is, do they really have that as their focus? In the case of NK, they're essentially a splinter of the ANC that was essentially fingered by the Zondo Commission, and large portions of their ranks come out of what was argued to be systematic state capture. So the question is, do we have parties that are actually seeking to govern, or are they seeking to capture the resources of the state? So I think that that's the question as to whether that is the division we're seeing in terms of the distribution of political parties. And within the ANC, it can also be argued that there are factions who do want to see renewal and a focus on governing within the ANC. And there are factions that could be
Load full transcript
argued to be entirely transactional as well. And it's a question as to which faction will win out. At the end of the day. So it's a difficult scenario. But the problem with our electoral process is that essentially once the bargaining kicks in after an election, you're pretty much stuck with that for five years. And if the governance processes are weak, in other words, structurally weak, that you can't actually hold people to account for corruption. which we have been struggling to do, then essentially you're stuck with corrupt parties all the way for five years. And that's a very long time for a city to be run in that particular way.
00:07:37
Speaker 1: You mentioned, Prof, that within the ANC there are people committed to renewal and flowing out of that would operate in a way that would demonstrate a commitment to put Joburg back on its feet. Is it not... plausible that Action SA, whose record I think of governance has generally been pretty good, certainly they would say they've done well in Tswane. Would that not constitute a sufficient, what's the word, critical mass within a coalition like that, that could offer Joburg something a little bit more optimistic than you set out at first?
00:08:17
Speaker 2: Well, the question is really are they a significant player? I mean, the question is are they subject to the conditions that are laid out by essentially the other parties? And if they are so desperate to create an agreement that avoids the DA, then the question is how far does that desperation extend? How much are they prepared to concede? And it's been argued that essentially they're prepared to concede quite a lot. And the governing of Chani is actually in question. The collapse of water systems has raised the more immediate issues about governance in Chani and the sort of the water tanker contracts and various others that have been noted. also in relation to the Bundelunger Commission. So it's not clear that there is a coherent governance focus in the case of Action USA. They've got a lot to demonstrate before one can be convinced. But the question is really why they're so averse to a very straightforward deal with the DA. And if the concern is that the DA would actually be strong in governance, then we all have to be concerned about that. But I think we're going to find out what these parties are worth after the coalitions are created. But unfortunately, we might find out in a very nasty way.
00:09:40
Speaker 1: Prof Alex van den Heerfer joining us from the Wits School of Governance. So, yeah, have a look at that News 24 story. Very interesting. The headline reads, ANC on verge of counting deal with Action SA, suggesting that this may extend beyond that. And what they say, by the way, is that the ANC has sent letters to several parties suggesting they work together as part of a deal between Action SA and the ANC. Yeah, the story authored by a number of their journalists suggesting a number of them are out there ferreting for info. Carol Payton, Amanda, Cosa Tlamini and MC Ferreira. the three names on that particular byline. 27 minutes past four.