전사 🔗
Catherine Roebuck: So couples that have been together a long time are co creating something. And so we're looking at what these two are co creating and they're co creating a dynamic where It looks like she is the fuel, she's the fire, she's she provides all the energy to this dynamic. But then as we saw more of them, then we're seeing he actually has his ways of continuing to stoke that fire and add to it that are are they're not great. So if they're gonna address this, which they're starting to. She needs to settle herself down. I think he also needs to deal with how he this doesn't, it's not just that this works for him and he's okay with it continuing, but he actually actively feeds it.
Jackie Aston: But her resentment is so palpable and she does own it. It's having a significant impact on her and the relationship. She it's easier to stay resentful than to do something and deal directly with your partner. And so she is Doesn't do that well. And I think that would be something she'd have to deal with is how can I let him take me seriously? Because he's not taking me seriously when I'm beating up on him. He's writing me off and he's egging me on. And so if she could deal with him, she doesn't have to be resentful.
Catherine Roebuck: Hi, welcome to Differentiated Love and Sex. Today we're going to comment on some clips of Michael and Michal from Couples Therapy.
Jackie Aston: Okay, this should be fun. Ready. that's an easy answer. If Michael were just different.
Catherine Roebuck: I I appreciate how transparent she is with her position. you can see the resentment, the entitlement, the anger coming through here. And there's such a difference between how she shows up and how he does that she's very forceful and he hasn't even said anything yet.
Jackie Aston: Yeah, their body language is so interesting too. He's just like, here it goes. I think the that's a common idea is like if my partner were just different, I'd be happy. she has a lot of resentment and it is clear,
Catherine Roebuck: yeah.
Jackie Aston: and that's absolutely impacting the relationship too.
Catherine Roebuck: so a couple things that stand out so far is one, they enjoy interacting this way. they both are getting something out of this back and forth. even though they're frustrated. Okay, so when she has a problem with him, then she feels really entitled to be very mean about it. So she's, calling him names, making personal attacks. and then they both go to the extreme. So she says he's lazy and that she's doing contributing more in every area than him, and then he counters with the other extreme, which is like, you're saying I'm not doing anything. Well, they're both exaggerating.
Jackie Aston: Yes, yeah. I think the way she handles herself makes it really difficult to talk with her. She doesn't give any space for anyone to really engage with her. And I actually think that's a move in the session. She does it with Dr. Orna when, Dr. Orna's trying to settle her, have her settle herself down. And she does it with her husband. So I think, it it it looks good that they're both in the therapy session. But to me she's not really taking it seriously. I think it's almost like there's no way she's open to anybody really being direct with her.
Catherine Roebuck: Yeah, not so far. And it's always interesting when people they come into a session and they want to do all of the talking. And and I sometimes wonder what's the mechanism that you think is gonna change this if it's not some type of outside input.
Jackie Aston: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. But I think you're right. There is something they're both getting from this dynamic. And they're smiling, both of them. which is different than other couples who we see where they're really pissed off. And they don't look that pissed
Catherine Roebuck: Mm-hmm.
Jackie Aston: off. They look like they're enjoying it.
Catherine Roebuck: Yeah, there's there's one layer where they're mad, but another layer where they actually do seem to like each other and enjoy interacting this way.
Jackie Aston: Yes, okay. that this I feel like I'm watching two kids. these are two children who are being competitive with each other and they're going back and forth and seeing whose argument is gonna win. They're both not budging, of course.
Catherine Roebuck: Yeah, and it it does it has almost a playful feel to it, even while it's combative, that neither of them is serious about the stuff they're saying and they keep going to extremes.
Jackie Aston: Mm-hmm. And I guess what do you think about this idea where she says, there's just one thing I want you to do?
Catherine Roebuck: It's support me, it is a big umbrella. And and she she does say like support me so I don't have to work. So but even there, couples that decide that one person is going to earn all of the money often are making a trade-off of they're going to live at a lower standard of living or the partner that's earning all of the money is going to be minimally involved in household tasks and parenting. and I think she does want more than him just to earn to earn the money. I think she wants multiple things here, even though she's framing it that way right now.
Jackie Aston: Yeah, I think that's what I thought too, is she puts out an idea, it's mostly financial, but I don't think she's okay with just the financial piece. She's wanting more. And that's part of why she's saying support, because there's there's more she's looking for.
Catherine Roebuck: Well, and then we're just seeing how she relates, how they each relate, and the way she relates is so critical and so combative that she's very likely to continue to relate that way even as he earns more money. And
Jackie Aston: Mm-hmm.
Catherine Roebuck: so, when he's saying is there just some number? there probably isn't, there really isn't that she would continue if she doesn't address the way she's handling not getting what she wants or the way she relates, then his income could go up and up and she would still
Load full transcript
keep relating to him this way and talking to him that way.
Jackie Aston: It's interesting that Dr. Orna is telling the wife that she's doing all the work because she doesn't it doesn't look like she's working that hard to me. It looks like she's ranting, which is just a release of her anxiety. In fact, it probably feels really good to her because she just can discharge it onto Dr. Orna and discharge it onto her husband.
Catherine Roebuck: Well, I think she is she's making a point about how Michal is running the session and is insisting on running the session that she's not allowing Dr. Orna to steer. And so there is a way she's doing too much. It's like she's talking about it as you're working so hard and and I think it's a a gentler way to say you're doing too much.
Jackie Aston: Mm-hmm, mm-hmm.
Catherine Roebuck: so we're seeing over functioning in real time here. And then when she said that she's let him relax and enjoy his life for ten years, I was thinking about how how easy is it to relax around this kind of energy. Actually he does seem able to do it. you look at him there on the couch and he's he's like pretty laid back about it. so he's used to this and it does work for him. But it's hard to imagine her actually getting off his back for more than a day or two at a time, right?
Jackie Aston: Yeah. I I think, here he might be compensating for what she's doing and look at her like, well, she's the crazy one. I'm certainly not gonna do that. So he goes to the other extreme.
Catherine Roebuck: Yeah. And partners do this all the time where they you pick somebody that embodies something that you don't know how to have for yourself. she has all of this this drive and fire to her, and he has all of this ease and an ability to settle down. And so I think they both can sense that they're imbalance and they go pick somebody that is on the other side, but it doesn't really give either person balance to do it that way, and you end up mad at each other. so it's ultimately you have to develop those qualities in yourself.
Jackie Aston: that the husband is tracking something in his wife and saying something at this point. he's not handling himself well in the session throughout, but here I think he is saying something. He's saying that his wife isn't really considering who's with her, and it doesn't really matter a whole lot who that person is. In fact, he uses their child to describe this. It's like, well, they can get to the finish line. But did you care about him along the way? and and I think that that's something to address because each person is tracking the other.
Catherine Roebuck: Yeah, I'm seeing both of them have good points that they're not making in a way that makes it easy to take them seriously. And so I think what he's bringing up is a really good point, but it isn't funny actually. It it's absurd, but it's not actually funny. And he'd get further if he'd make his point in a serious way. And same on her side. She's getting more and more worked up and she actually has a serious concern here as well that she feels like she provides all of the forward momentum for the couple. And that might be the case. And it's a miserable position to be in. And Dr. Orna is trying to talk to her about how she's keeping that going herself. But she's she's also providing all of this forward momentum for the session and not n not being willing to s settle down, sit back, and let Dr. Orna lead. Although she's showing here that she actually is workable. Dr. Orna's getting through to her and she's starting to settle herself. But it makes me think about what does it take to be taken seriously? And getting more and more worked up doesn't help.
Jackie Aston: Mm-hmm. Yeah, it's so much easier for the husband to dismiss her. In fact, he's making jokes about what she's gonna say, am I dead weight? And she knows
Catherine Roebuck: Yeah.
Jackie Aston: he that he knows she can be mean. And so he throws that back at her and it's a way to not really deal with what she is saying.
Catherine Roebuck: Right, and as long as she's being super mean, then it does put him in a position where it's easy for him to not deal with the things that she's saying.
Jackie Aston: Yes. I think that's hard for couples to let go of that kind of dynamic. if I make you feel like a piece of shit, if I make you feel badly, you'll change. But really it's a way the other partner could just move away that much easier and dismiss them.
Catherine Roebuck: Yeah, I do think that a lot of people as kids, that was how their parents tried to modify their behavior was by making them feel bad. and so if you have a a model in your brain that punishment is what works. and you don't come a fr from a family where things get talked through to a point where they make sense, then it can be easy to just reach for that. I just have to make my partner feel bad and that's what will get them to do something different. But It doesn't tend to go very well. It doesn't tend to be very effective.
Jackie Aston: Yeah, they tend to be more rebellious in fact and he's getting
Catherine Roebuck: Yeah.
Jackie Aston: he's getting back at her in the session.
Catherine Roebuck: Yeah.
Jackie Aston: my thought is he puts out the idea that she provokes me so I get more done? I'm actually wondering if that's true. I don't have the data
Catherine Roebuck: Mm.
Jackie Aston: on it to know how d that's possible, but is that really true or does he just like to see her revved up?
Catherine Roebuck: That's an interesting question and and Dr. Orna is seeing it more like he gets something out of it emotionally. and so he's trying to frame it more in the direction of, well, it's just it's functional. It's beneficial to me in some functional way. But watching him thinking about what plays out in the room, we're not really seeing the him work harder as she gets more revved up in the room.
Jackie Aston: Mm-hmm.
Catherine Roebuck: So I think we can lean more the direction of what we're actually
seeing play out, which is the more revved up she gets, the more amused he seems and the more relaxed. And so it's like she ends up looking unserious and reactionary and it makes it really easy for him to do less. the more worked up she is, the less he has to look at and talk about what's actually going on on his side.
Jackie Aston: Yeah, it actually looks like it's a way to blow her off more because
Catherine Roebuck: Yeah.
Jackie Aston: she's gotten herself all worked up about it and he can
Catherine Roebuck: Yeah.
Jackie Aston: make more excuses for not doing anything and just look at her as the crazy one.
Catherine Roebuck: And it's in an interesting move that he just made because he says, well, this works. if you want me to do more stuff, this is a good way to to do that. put this kind of pressure on me and and it motivates me. he says that being provoked works on him. I think I think that's a false picture. I think it doesn't actually work. But he just put forward that he he's fine with this continuing. and he's using his understanding of what his partner wants to implant a false picture that if this continues it'll get her more of what she wants, when there's so far no evidence of that.
Jackie Aston: Yeah, I think if they were to say, yes, he starts to do the dishes as soon as I am upset, like the wife's upset, or he starts picking up the house or he takes the kids out, then that would indicate that he his what he put out there is true. But that actually they're not backing any of this up and it looks very different the way he's presenting in the sessions.
Catherine Roebuck: Right. Yeah, there are couples where that would be true that as soon as she yells, he does jump up and start doing more, and that's the dynamic. It's not what we're seeing.
Jackie Aston: I just wanted to say, the wife says, when my husband tells me he's gonna be home with me and working from home, I get so excited, as if she buys that he's going to show up and be really involved. do you really think she thinks that he's gonna do all this stuff to help out?
Catherine Roebuck: I was no, that stood out to me too, and and I'm just thinking this is two people that can implant false pictures because she's doing the same
Jackie Aston: Yes.
Catherine Roebuck: kind of move here, where she says she was really happy to have him home, but everything she had said up to that point was like, I can't stand being around him, I just wanna punch him in the face. Like she said all of these very aggressive things about how she actually feels when she's around him, and then we see how she treats him when she's around him, and it doesn't look like somebody that enjoys being near him. Well, she does enjoy the fight a little bit, but
Jackie Aston: Yes.
Catherine Roebuck: so what is it that she's happy about when she thinks about him being home all the time? Is it like we'll fight so much or it's not coming through that this is a couple that can enjoy time together in a peaceful way? Doesn't mean that it isn't possible, we have to work off of what we see here, but yeah, I thought that might be a false picture.
Jackie Aston: Yes, I'm like she now he's gonna be home working and helping when he wasn't helping when he wasn't working. So it just it d I I don't think she actually believed that.
Catherine Roebuck: Yeah, or or she's thinking she'll have she'll be able to keep an eye on him all the time and and tell him to work harder. I I don't know.
Jackie Aston: Yeah, that's actually one I don't have enough information. If I was working with a client, I'd be gathering more before jumping to this. But,
Catherine Roebuck: Mm-hmm.
Jackie Aston: I'm wondering if she wants to corner him. Now she sees him and is monitoring him and she can get on his case about a whole lot more.
Catherine Roebuck: Yeah.
Jackie Aston: I think that was a good move from Doctor Orna. She realized she could not she can't work with them at this level of functioning. She laid that out there. And I think it had an impact on the wife 'cause she's starting to settle herself down.
Catherine Roebuck: Yeah, I thought that was a really beautiful intervention there. and it's it was done so respectfully, even though like what Michal is doing here is super dysfunctional and mean and personal attacks and aggression and it'd be easy for Dr. Orna to get reactive to that. She's not a very reactive person, so she she didn't. but It's really interesting to see you brought up earlier that they're kinda like two kids fighting and it was looking that way again, where it's like it's the level of functioning is so low, they look very, very immature and they're just sniping at each other and it's getting nowhere and Dr. Orna just says, well we can't work this way. we've gotta do this differently. And she actually got got some traction on that. That it does look like Michal's gonna settle herself down.
Jackie Aston: Yeah, that was great. I think Michal I'm wondering how blind she is to herself because she says, Well, what if you could just be a little bit more like me, to her husband? I I think she's aware that what she's doing is mean. But I
Catherine Roebuck: Sure.
Jackie Aston: also so it's like when she puts out that picture, be like me, I think she'd hate being on the other end of this. But she puts out it that it's nice.
Catherine Roebuck: Yeah, and it it would be so disastrous, for the whole family. If they both were at each other like this, it'd be disastrous. I think she's talking in terms of do as much as I do because she sees herself as doing so much. I don't know whether she does that much. it's also possible that she doesn't actually do that much more in terms of task and contributing to the family, but she is very loud and very critical and just put puts this picture out that she's doing way more.
Jackie Aston: Yes, I I think that's a good point. How much what is she really doing? but also if she's going to put the idea be more if she's going to put the idea out be more like me,
she's very selective about what she wants,
Catherine Roebuck: Sure. Right. So if say say she really is doing a lot of tasks, that's possible, but that how she fuels herself to do that is through this constant fire of critique and anger. yeah, you don't want two people operating that way. It's not gonna be good.
Jackie Aston: When the husband says I actually do more, again, that's where I'm thinking there's the pleasure in revving her up because he's not putting
Catherine Roebuck: Yeah.
Jackie Aston: out any data to say, actually here's what I see going on and how I'm involved and here's what I see with you. He's just saying it and bam, she's worked up about it and now she's yelling at him.
Catherine Roebuck: appreciate you bringing that up because he's very smooth and he knows how to rev his partner up and get under her skin while looking very calm and reasonable. And this tends to make people feel crazy and reactive and angry when you've got a partner who does that, who's really, really good at the sneak attack. And so you can have partners where one person looks just terrible on the surface, which we've kind we're seeing that right now, where it's like, hang on, pull yourself together, settle down, manage your the volume of your voice, manage the things you're saying. you keep talking about wanting to punch him. That's not okay. So there's it's so easy to criticize what she's doing because she's so overt and out front with it. But yeah, he's got his ways. what's the point of that comment other than to rev her up again?
Jackie Aston: Yes, yeah. It's interesting. I briefly saw some comments online before recording this with you. And a lot of people take the side of the husband because he looks calm. We
Catherine Roebuck: Mm-hmm. He looks good. Yeah.
Jackie Aston: like that. And I think it's easy to go blind to what he's doing. And she
Catherine Roebuck: Mm-hmm.
Jackie Aston: is tracking that in him. She's tracking something in him where he's not being fair to her. and she's just getting so reactive that no one can really pay attention and deal with what she's seeing and dealing with.
Catherine Roebuck: Right. Anytime I'm working with a couple where one is very, very reactive and the other looks smooth and calm, I'm looking for what is this smooth, calm person doing that continually fuels this fire? Because, they've been together, it sounds like 10 ish years. There's something that he's doing that's contributing to stabilizing a dynamic where she's always worked up, angry, critical, mean. he's at a at minimum fine with it, but we're also seeing that there's ways that he actually contributes to it and sets her off deliberately.
Jackie Aston: Yeah, so I'm not sure what's in it for him is, 'cause does he want to look like the good guy? some of it is he's taking pleasure in her being revved up. but I would be moving in on him and exploring what he is doing in the session.
Catherine Roebuck: Yeah. my My guess is that it is close to what Dr. Orna brought up about he gets some kind of pleasure or enjoyment from this. And I think that can come from I'd want to hear about his relationship with his mom growing up because my my hunch would be he had a mom who was critical and controlling and that the way he had a sense of self in the face of that as a kid was to set her off and feel like superior and and she was unreasonable because she was acting unreasonable, while doing stuff that's that's deniable but is gonna work her up more. So it's one way to handle a controlling parent is you set them off until they're out of control and then you have the satisfaction of watching well, they're spiraling, so even though they can continue to put consequences on you and such, that it gives you a feeling of they don't control everything. They're
Jackie Aston: Mm-hmm.
Catherine Roebuck: not as strong as they want to be seen as.
Jackie Aston: Mm-hmm. So the wife brings up that the husband is wasting time. And I'm guessing, so she must be monitoring him. She must be looking at his computer screen, or I guess she's saying he's on the phone with his friends or talking to his friends. I'm wondering about that. is he in the shared space doing all of this and provoking her in that way? Or is she going into his private office and looking at his screen or overhearing him on the phone. So I would actually like a better picture of what's happening because that also could be how he is playing into this as well.
Catherine Roebuck: Mm. Okay. So you're you're saying maybe she's being intrusive?
Jackie Aston: So I don't know. But if he, is watching YouTube videos in the family room when everyone's around while he's supposed to be doing his work, of course that's gonna upset his wife who supposedly is doing all this stuff for the kids in the family.
Catherine Roebuck: Mm-hmm. Yeah, so he's got his ways of provoking her and and that would be possibly one way he'd do it. obviously the clips that we were shown of them at home were were curated clips, but he looked real relaxed in that armchair with his
Jackie Aston: Yeah. Yeah.
Catherine Roebuck: laptop. didn't didn't necessarily look like someone who was that dialed in on work. But another thing I'm thinking is about the time that she wastes, because she wastes a ton of time having the same interaction with him over and over, where she's just gonna pound on him and it will yield nothing. And so that's also like she's wasting time and I don't maybe she's enjoying it. It does seem like she enjoys it to some degree. But it's not better for her to waste time that way than for her to go watch TV. It'd be better for her to watch TV.
Jackie Aston: Yes, yes. It's interesting because in this interaction, instead of seeing two kids fighting, which I I see that, but I see a parent-child dynamic, in which I think you're saying, I want to explore what what the husband's relationship with his mom was like. Because it's like
Catherine Roebuck: Yeah.
Jackie Aston: he can get a slap on the
hand. it's more forceful than that what she's doing. But and then Okay, then we move on and I see you're upset and maybe I like that, but I I'm not doing I'm not gonna do anything differently. And so it's like it's a way kids blow off their parents all the time too when they do that. It's like I'll take I'll take the punishment. You're clearly punishing
Catherine Roebuck: Sure.
Jackie Aston: me and then we can move on. And and maybe I'll
Catherine Roebuck: Yeah.
Jackie Aston: get back to what I was doing that I wasn't supposed to be doing.
Catherine Roebuck: Right, so this is how people at lower levels of differentiation and all children are at lower levels of differentiation because it's a developmental stage thing. it's how you have a sense of self. under pressure when you're less differentiated. And what we're seeing with these two is they're still doing it that way to a great degree. That and and lots of people are in adulthood, so that's not that unusual. But the strategies that they're using, they make more sense for a kid. They're still super difficult and annoying for a parent to have a kid doing that. that's that's hard. But but it's much more understandable for a a kid, even a teen to handle themselves that way. And then when you get into adulthood and you're dealing with your partner and instead of him taking a solid position, he's just going to be in this passive aggressive rebellion of her control all the time of you're not in charge of me but I won't really take you on in a good way about hey this is destructive, like I'm I'm gonna take responsibility for myself and I'm not interested in this amount of input from you on what I'm doing.
Jackie Aston: Yes. So he he's staying underdeveloped. So is she.
Catherine Roebuck: Yeah. And it gives you this false sense of being your own person, but i you wanna get to where you can you can stand on your own feet under pressure without doing underhanded stuff.
Jackie Aston: Mm mm. So the question is, does he really want this to change?
Catherine Roebuck: Not so far.
Jackie Aston: So we're seeing the wife settle down. So it seems like Doctor Orna is having an impact on her now. what do you think about that, Catherine?
Catherine Roebuck: like that intervention. It's it's a balancing move and it also is gonna push both of them up against their patterns. That she has a hard time settling down. even though she's saying she wants this, my guess is that it it'll be quite hard for her to do it and to just stay out of managing him for two hours and It'll also probably be hard for him to stay engaged with something for two hours without her coming and poking at him. What do you think?
Jackie Aston: Yeah, I still have the question of how much is she doing really? Cause that's a nice image that she's doing a lot. It's very possible, and you can see in the session, she's like dominating, she wants things to she's pushing forward, she's has more energy. But I'm still wondering about that. So I would actually want to get clearer about that. But let's just say she's doing all of this. I think that would be hard for her to let her husband step up. And Dr. Orna is good about saying, and your husband will do it in his own way. Because it's easy for the person
Catherine Roebuck: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm.
Jackie Aston: who's being controlling and doing all the work to be like, Now you will do all the work, but you will do it my way and my way is the
Catherine Roebuck: Sure.
Jackie Aston: best way. And then the par other partner feels controlled and then they're more rebellious. And then the dynamic just keeps going and it's problematic.
Catherine Roebuck: Yeah. There's a way I'm not sure it matters whether she does that much or not for this particular assignment. Because even if the main thing she does is bother him and criticize him, if she takes two hours a day to not do that and to to do
Jackie Aston: Yes.
Catherine Roebuck: something else, that's still improvement. I I think she's she's doing too much all the time, whether it's helpful and contributing or it's just critical. And so this would be it'd be good for her to slow herself down.
Jackie Aston: Yes, and she's hyper focused on him. So she could
Catherine Roebuck: Yeah.
Jackie Aston: redirect that energy into doing something for herself and and let
Catherine Roebuck: Yeah.
Jackie Aston: him be. so I think that's good. I think it is hard to find two hours if she's, doing what she's saying. So I would be thinking they'd have to take they they it would require some collaboration between the two of them about when this is gonna happen and who's gonna watch the kids. And I think that's sometimes hard for couples to do, especially when there is this power control dynamic and rebellion.
Catherine Roebuck: Mm-hmm. Yeah.
Jackie Aston: so what is your take on if you just sum up the issues you see each person struggling with?
Catherine Roebuck: So couples that have been together a long time are co creating something. And so we're looking at what these two are co creating and they're co creating a dynamic where It looks like she is the fuel, she's the fire, she's she provides all the energy to this dynamic. But then as we saw more of them, then we're seeing he actually has his ways of continuing to stoke that fire and add to it that are are they're not great. So if they're gonna address this, which they're starting to. She needs to settle herself down. I think he also needs to deal with how he this doesn't, it's not just that this works for him and he's okay with it continuing, but he actually actively feeds it. And
Jackie Aston: Yes.
Catherine Roebuck: it's he doesn't only feed it by sitting around looking like he's not doing anything. He might do that, but it's not the only thing he does. But also when he says things to her in a completely unserious way with no data, well, I think I do more. Yeah, that's gonna that's gonna stoke that fire. So I also think they both would need to get more clear about what is it that
you want here, what really matters to you. Because he's in this position of just pushing back against her, and he's not taking a clear position on what he wants on much of anything, but he's still not doing what she wants. and so he actually is. like he's he's acting in a way that he's choosing, but it's not linked to values or goals he's identified, other than, I I'm not gonna do it your way. So which is pretty immature. and on her side, and we'll see more of this as we continue next time, but It does start to look like she mostly wanted a baby and she's picking a lot of fights to try to get one thing. And it might be too many fights. sometimes you have to put some of your battles back and just settle for fewer battles. but also, I'd I'd also want to look at that more too. if you want a baby, if that's the most important thing, what's important to you about it? And what kind of home are you bringing that baby into? Because it's not a good thing for kids to grow up around this kind of fighting.
Jackie Aston: Yeah, my take if I were to start with the wife she might really be doing a lot in the home. But her resentment is so palpable and she does own it. It's having a significant impact on her and the relationship. it's easier to stay resentful than to do something and deal directly with your partner. And so she Doesn't do that well. And I think that would be something she'd have to deal with is how can I let him take me seriously? Because he's not taking me seriously when I'm beating up on him. He's writing me off and he's egging me on. And so if she could deal with him, she doesn't have to be resentful. the resentment and the way she handles him is very punishing. And so I'm also thinking that's not encouraging for him to change any behavior. And I'm wondering what that's like for them in their sexual relationship, right? Because that would be hard to get into bed with someone who's punishing you. but he's getting at her as well. So I think the two of them, there's some sadism there. And there's normal marital sadism that, that can exist. But I think the fact that they both get at each other so much, it just takes the issue off of whatever they really want to change. And it's more about punishing and egging on and making the other person feel badly. So they both have to
Catherine Roebuck: Mm-hmm.
Jackie Aston: deal with that.
Catherine Roebuck: Yeah, you brought up their sexual relationship and she at the very start said that she's not satisfied with it. and then, Dr. Orna picked up this piece about maybe he gets some type of pleasure from humiliation. I I wouldn't rule out that that plays out in sex as well, that he enjoys her being unhappy with their sex.
Jackie Aston: That's very possible. And so I'm wondering, is she having sex with him? we know that she has a baby, the future one, but where is she going along with why why is she doing that? Why is she engaging with him in that way? the other pieces with the husband is he is very good at looking more clean and like he is doing things well. but he's clearly not. And so I'm trying to I would want to be understanding if there's motivation for him to change, why change this when he he doesn't look like the crazy one? and is he willing to step up, What would he do? What would he need to do? What would he need to face in himself in order to step up and share the responsibilities?
Catherine Roebuck: That's another reason I think it makes sense to focus on her first is that she's the one who's suffering more here. And so she's gonna have more motivation, most likely, than he is. and so it's not like when you're choosing there's so many pieces you can pick up with a couple, and so when you're choosing where to start, for me there's a lot of considering who has more motivation in this. And it's very often the person who's hurting more that is more motivated to do something. And so this is working for him. he doesn't seem he says it hurts, but we aren't really seeing h distress so far in him. We're definitely seeing that in her, even though she's also d not very serious about how she handles that or communicates it. And so when she's Dr. Orna is telling her to change something, and she's like, How about he changes something? It's not about he doesn't need to change anything. It's about what would his reason be? And she's got a reason. She's she's got reasons in both directions. She's got things she wants that she doesn't have. She's got distress she's experiencing that she wants to have less of. so she has more pushing her on this, and and it's often the person that has more pushing them that has to go first.
Jackie Aston: That would be hard for her to go first because she already feels like she's doing everything. And oftentimes
Catherine Roebuck: Mm-hmm.
Jackie Aston: that person in the relationship is like, Well, this is just one more thing I'm taking on and I'm doing. But it wouldn't be doing it for him. It would be doing it for her because she is suffering.
Catherine Roebuck: Yeah. And when you're over functioning, go for going first can mean you do less, which
Jackie Aston: Yeah.
Catherine Roebuck: can be hard to make yourself do, but that can be the move. And so if she can if she can qualitatively change how she's showing up here, that is the thing that stands a chance at putting some effective pressure on him to need to do something about this. But right now, I I think it's easy for someone in her position to try to get the therapist on board with, Will you just be as hard on my partner as I'm being? And
Jackie Aston: Yes.
Catherine Roebuck: it's like, no, but we know what your partner does with that. they can brush that off so
Jackie Aston: Yes.
Catherine Roebuck: easy. aside from I I would never treat a client that way, but also it's like, I
Jackie Aston: Yeah. Yes.
Catherine Roebuck: know what your partner will do with that kind of dynamic. so it doesn't work. I I've had people frustrated that I won't be. harsh with their partner. And I'm like, there's no way that's gonna get you anywhere. you you've tried that a thousand times. We have to do something different. so yeah, I don't I don't think she likes being in a position of needing to go first, but that's my map of this couple is if something's gonna shift, it'll be her that shifts first.
Jackie Aston: Yes, I agree. And I'm glad, of course, Dr. Orna doesn't take the bait just to be cruel back. In fact, I think if she can she can show the wife how to handle the husband, and I think she does it a little bit when she says she calls him out on getting pleasure out of making his wife upset, she's not cruel about the way she says it. She's actually saying and being straight with her,
Catherine Roebuck: Mm-hmm. Yeah.
Jackie Aston: this is what I see.
Catherine Roebuck: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Yeah. I think it's really helpful that she doesn't sensationalize the stuff going on because they sensationalize stuff. And
Jackie Aston: Mm mm.
Catherine Roebuck: so, she's very matter-of-fact and calm about this. this is just some of the ways people do it.
Jackie Aston: Yes, yes. Okay. Well shall we wrap it up?
Catherine Roebuck: Yeah, thanks, Jackie. That was fun.
Jackie Aston: Okay, I'm glad we could do this.