전사 🔗
WEBVTT
00:07.228 --> 00:28.230
[SPEAKER_01]: Axis Mooney I'm at South Philly Community Acupuncture lying down on one of the four reclining chairs or beds in a small open area where others are getting treatment.
00:29.501 --> 00:33.445
[SPEAKER_01]: Their soft instrumental music playing, and the smell of incense.
00:34.547 --> 00:37.470
[SPEAKER_01]: The room is dark, quiet, and calm.
00:38.892 --> 00:47.902
[SPEAKER_01]: Loreno Bryan, the founder of this practice, has been treating me for seasonal allergies, back stiffness, and ankle soreness since 2013.
00:50.311 --> 00:55.093
[SPEAKER_01]: Aggie puncture is highly effective, but every spring, the pollen gets worse.
00:56.373 --> 01:00.114
[SPEAKER_01]: If I sit in front of the computer for too long, my back issues return.
01:01.114 --> 01:10.077
[SPEAKER_01]: Each time I come back from a meditation retreat where I spend a week sitting, putting pressure on my ankles and knees, I need healing.
01:11.278 --> 01:17.960
[SPEAKER_01]: This is to say, I'm a regular, and I've experienced Aggie puncture from a handful of licensed practitioners.
01:20.140 --> 01:23.382
[SPEAKER_01]: but there's one episode that really stands out in my memory.
01:24.982 --> 01:32.706
[SPEAKER_01]: If you've never gotten acupuncture before, like many of the students I teach, you may understandably be nervous around needles.
01:33.927 --> 01:39.049
[SPEAKER_01]: We've been conditioned as kids to associate needles and shots with pain.
01:40.170 --> 01:45.693
[SPEAKER_01]: When I get acupuncture, I can feel the needle entering my skin, but it doesn't hurt.
01:46.772 --> 01:52.454
[SPEAKER_01]: To overwhelming majority of the time, it feels like someone is pushing a pen on my skin.
01:53.334 --> 01:54.314
[SPEAKER_01]: They're slight pressure.
01:55.454 --> 01:57.595
[SPEAKER_01]: Sometimes I can barely feel anything.
01:58.695 --> 02:04.337
[SPEAKER_01]: Rarely does its thing, but even then it's mild, nothing like getting the flu shot.
02:06.257 --> 02:08.318
[SPEAKER_01]: So there I was in South Philly.
02:09.358 --> 02:14.619
[SPEAKER_01]: After chatting in a quiet whisper with Lauren about what was bothering me that day,
02:17.754 --> 02:21.817
[SPEAKER_01]: The needles are going into my legs and I barely feel them.
02:22.938 --> 02:26.801
[SPEAKER_01]: Lauren is one of the most gentle acupuncturists I've encountered.
02:28.403 --> 02:40.733
[SPEAKER_01]: As she inserted them one by one, she paused and said, sorry, a split second before I even registered the pinch I felt on my chin and let out a soft ouch.
02:42.294 --> 02:44.256
[SPEAKER_01]: She smiled and I smiled back.
02:45.216 --> 02:45.877
[SPEAKER_01]: I was puzzled.
02:47.238 --> 02:49.720
[SPEAKER_01]: I asked, Lauren, what happened there?
02:50.761 --> 02:54.484
[SPEAKER_01]: My question was not voicing any displeasure from the mild sting.
02:55.445 --> 03:10.977
[SPEAKER_01]: I simply couldn't make sense of how she knew to apologize before I even registered the
Load full transcript
slight pain, before any minor movement of my leg in response to the needle or my verbal indication of my sensation.
03:12.658 --> 03:14.480
[SPEAKER_01]: She said, I missed.
03:16.918 --> 03:18.540
[SPEAKER_01]: But how did you know I asked?
03:19.741 --> 03:22.764
[SPEAKER_01]: Lauren said, I can feel it on my fingertips.
03:24.786 --> 03:30.272
[SPEAKER_01]: I thought only I was feeling chief, flow in my legs and body when I was getting treatment.
03:31.093 --> 03:38.020
[SPEAKER_01]: Similar to the way my dad, my uncle and I, can feel the ball of tea between our palms when we do teagull.
03:40.900 --> 03:49.643
[SPEAKER_01]: a few years later, when I asked another acupuncturist James Bay, who runs a clinic in Brooklyn about the sensation of tea.
03:50.603 --> 03:59.786
[SPEAKER_01]: He explained that acupuncturists also feel tea when they give treatment and sometimes they twist the needles slightly to adjust it.
04:01.319 --> 04:08.081
[SPEAKER_01]: In 17th century Japan, Tsugayama Wahichi developed his own school of acupuncture.
04:08.962 --> 04:11.122
[SPEAKER_01]: The catch, he was blind.
04:11.963 --> 04:17.725
[SPEAKER_01]: He invented a guiding tube for other seeing impaired people to administer acupuncture.
04:19.225 --> 04:27.308
[SPEAKER_01]: Of the approximately 90,000 acupuncturists currently in Japan, roughly 30% are seeing impaired.
04:28.505 --> 04:31.706
[SPEAKER_01]: They use their palms and fingertips to diagnose.
04:32.887 --> 04:37.469
[SPEAKER_01]: How else can they perform acupuncture if they do that feel the tea?
04:39.090 --> 04:40.590
[SPEAKER_01]: How do syllables work?
04:41.731 --> 04:47.434
[SPEAKER_01]: Why are some practices labeled placebo while others accepted as medicine?
04:48.614 --> 04:51.575
[SPEAKER_01]: Maybe the question we should be asking is,
04:57.758 --> 05:09.601
[SPEAKER_01]: Even though evidence of healing from the kinds of techniques that my dad uses, acupuncture, teagull, and so-called traditional medicine present to us as clear as day.
05:23.003 --> 05:31.907
[SPEAKER_01]: I'm Dr. Kim Chung, a scholar of religion, and this is between T and science, my experience of what can't be measured.
05:32.807 --> 05:37.850
[SPEAKER_01]: When I was 17, my dad taught me Hacom, what you may know as Ticom.
05:38.870 --> 05:50.355
[SPEAKER_01]: We were standing in our living room in Coney Island Brooklyn, and as I followed his movements something strange happened, I felt a pressure between my hands, a warmth, something I could
05:53.076 --> 05:55.797
[SPEAKER_01]: That moment has stayed with me for nearly three decades.
05:57.157 --> 06:06.499
[SPEAKER_01]: My father became a healer, drawing on teagull, acupuncture, Buddhist rituals, rakey, and other Chinese medical and religious practices.
06:07.840 --> 06:09.240
[SPEAKER_01]: I took a very different path.
06:10.500 --> 06:20.143
[SPEAKER_01]: I became a scholar of religion, trained to ask questions about evidence, knowledge, belief, and what we meet when we
say something is real.
06:21.247 --> 06:28.051
[SPEAKER_01]: And eventually, I realized that my father was at the center of many of the questions I had spent in my life's study.
06:29.652 --> 06:45.662
[SPEAKER_01]: This series is an exploration of that complicated territory between science and religious practice, between what can be measured and what can be experienced, between a father and son, and the worlds we build for ourselves.
06:46.812 --> 07:00.482
[SPEAKER_01]: I'll tell my father's story, but I'll also ask larger questions about healing, migration, suffering, knowledge, and the ways our bodies and experiences shape what we believe is possible.
07:02.103 --> 07:03.544
[SPEAKER_01]: I don't have a simple answer.
07:04.445 --> 07:10.630
[SPEAKER_01]: In fact, the more I studied these questions, the more comfortable I've become with uncertainty.
07:11.790 --> 07:13.950
[SPEAKER_01]: So come with me into that uncertainty.
07:14.711 --> 07:22.412
[SPEAKER_01]: This is between tea and science, my experience of what can't be measured.
07:23.392 --> 07:24.733
[SPEAKER_01]: It's morning on a weekday.
07:25.973 --> 07:31.234
[SPEAKER_01]: The middle-age Filipino American truck driver comes into my dad's Kony Island home.
07:32.654 --> 07:39.456
[SPEAKER_01]: He's one of the few patients treated by my dad who doesn't speak Chinese, but body language is universal.
07:40.758 --> 07:45.322
[SPEAKER_01]: His friend told him my dad could treat his back pain from long hours on the road.
07:45.923 --> 07:49.767
[SPEAKER_01]: That friend already spoke with my dad so they both knew what to expect.
07:51.128 --> 07:58.595
[SPEAKER_01]: After greeting my dad in English, the truck driver takes off his shoes and leaves them near the door before walking into the living room.
07:59.847 --> 08:12.361
[SPEAKER_01]: The bareball massage table my dad brought from Amazon is laid out in the living room that barely has space for it between the sofa, the TV, and an altar filled with fungser charms and Buddhist images.
08:14.204 --> 08:15.345
[SPEAKER_01]: The driver hops on.
08:16.666 --> 08:20.451
[SPEAKER_01]: My dad treats him with an acupressure massage and some haycome.
08:21.822 --> 08:27.166
[SPEAKER_01]: After an hour, he hops off, does some quick stretches while thanking my dad.
08:28.127 --> 08:32.430
[SPEAKER_01]: Then he offers a red envelope with $20 cash before leaving.
08:33.791 --> 08:43.098
[SPEAKER_01]: Although my dad does not charge anyone fees for his services, he will gladly accept the Chinese custom of gifts of red envelopes with cash inside.
08:44.307 --> 08:53.212
[SPEAKER_01]: Though he neither requires or expects this, typically, his patients give $20 per visit for an hour or two of healing.
08:54.112 --> 08:57.994
[SPEAKER_01]: But a monetary amount and duration of healing varies widely.
08:59.595 --> 09:05.498
[SPEAKER_01]: Compared this to the typical massage therapists who charges $1 to $200 for an hour.
09:06.599 --> 09:09.880
[SPEAKER_01]: My dad earned a few dollars an hour at the sweatshops.
09:14.688 --> 09:17.069
[SPEAKER_01]: He heals because he feels it's his duty.
09:17.989 --> 09:23.592
[SPEAKER_01]: His current neighbors in New Jersey once asked him how much they owe him for Hagueon treatment.
09:24.252 --> 09:25.473
[SPEAKER_01]: And he told him, nothing.
09:26.113 --> 09:29.794
[SPEAKER_01]: Just share some of the veggies growing in your yard when you harvest them.
09:30.555 --> 09:39.939
[SPEAKER_01]: His students, once who don't simply receive healing, but also learn Hagueon and Buddhist spells from him, also regularly give red envelopes.
09:41.148 --> 09:49.618
[SPEAKER_01]: Sometimes they provide gifts like food, tea, toys and clothes for his grandchildren, or pay for the bill at restaurants.
09:54.484 --> 09:57.627
[SPEAKER_01]: My dad considers his closest students his friends.
09:58.796 --> 10:03.217
[SPEAKER_01]: The money given to him changes meaning, depending on the change in relationship.
10:04.038 --> 10:18.723
[SPEAKER_01]: As the same $20 in a red envelope, can mean a tuition fee to a teacher from a student, a service fee for his capacity as a healer from a patient, or a gift from one friend to another.
10:20.063 --> 10:25.625
[SPEAKER_01]: He gives red envelopes in return to his friends on special occasions such as holidays.
10:27.543 --> 10:30.164
[SPEAKER_01]: Why would anyone give him red envelopes?
10:31.224 --> 10:32.525
[SPEAKER_01]: Why do the students return?
10:33.705 --> 10:34.765
[SPEAKER_01]: Are they really healed?
10:36.166 --> 10:41.127
[SPEAKER_01]: For something like back pain, all we know is people's self-reported feelings.
10:41.947 --> 10:43.288
[SPEAKER_01]: It's difficult to measure.
10:44.828 --> 10:45.709
[SPEAKER_01]: I know what you're thinking.
10:46.429 --> 10:47.209
[SPEAKER_01]: I've thought it too.
10:48.249 --> 10:49.530
[SPEAKER_01]: Is it just a placebo?
10:50.960 --> 10:59.423
[SPEAKER_01]: Perhaps my dad's techniques seem traditional, authentic, and mystical, and thus trick people into thinking they work.
11:00.343 --> 11:04.345
[SPEAKER_01]: Just a placebo is a very common way to dismiss TIGON.
11:05.153 --> 11:11.335
[SPEAKER_01]: acupuncture, Chinese healing practices, and basically anything outside the medical establishment.
11:11.875 --> 11:13.915
[SPEAKER_01]: You can find this dismissal everywhere.
11:14.656 --> 11:21.757
[SPEAKER_01]: In popular journalism that quotes medical professionals or YouTube videos that feature historians of medicine.
11:23.198 --> 11:31.380
[SPEAKER_01]: A 2013 academic article titled Acupuncture is theatrical placebo has been cited hundreds of times.
11:33.276 --> 11:34.597
[SPEAKER_01]: But I'm trained in philosophy.
11:35.397 --> 11:38.459
[SPEAKER_01]: My job is to investigate things like this intellectually.
11:39.359 --> 11:40.300
[SPEAKER_01]: So I looked into it.
11:41.340 --> 11:44.422
[SPEAKER_01]: And placebo's don't actually explain anything.
11:45.643 -->
11:49.725
[SPEAKER_01]: Over the last decade, the more I read, the more fascinated I became.
11:50.953 --> 12:00.982
[SPEAKER_01]: I realized that this is a big problem for mainstream medicine because the label placebo is a way for it to hide and quarantine what it doesn't know.
12:02.103 --> 12:04.865
[SPEAKER_01]: And dismiss people like my dad.
12:12.692 --> 12:14.233
[SPEAKER_01]: What are placebo effects?
12:19.010 --> 12:25.415
[SPEAKER_01]: By definition, it's healing that is not supposed to heal, isn't that weird?
12:26.696 --> 12:36.304
[SPEAKER_01]: Not if you realize it is just mainstream medicine's way of admitting they don't know how healing works without saying it explicitly.
12:37.826 --> 12:42.990
[SPEAKER_01]: They use the convenient label of placebo to contain their ignorance and move on.
12:44.168 --> 12:52.754
[SPEAKER_01]: By moving on, they get to dismiss healing that doesn't fit with the mainstream framework by saying it's mere placebo.
12:54.155 --> 13:04.082
[SPEAKER_01]: In other words, placebo is a category for all the things mainstream medicine doesn't know what to do with and doesn't want to legitimate.
13:05.042 --> 13:08.485
[SPEAKER_01]: Like basically, everything my dad does with his patience.
13:10.769 --> 13:18.991
[SPEAKER_01]: mainstream medicine proposes several mechanisms to explain placebo effects, plural, because they are not just one thing.
13:20.511 --> 13:31.394
[SPEAKER_01]: One explanation is that healing comes from expectation, reward and conditioning responses that release chemicals such as dopamine in the brain and body.
13:32.785 --> 13:46.254
[SPEAKER_01]: This is used to explain how plesibles that are sugar in the form of little white pills shaped like Tylenol that were familiar with and have taken in the past to relieve pain can help reduce pain.
13:47.615 --> 13:54.500
[SPEAKER_01]: Many of us have taken pills enough that we expect them to have an effect to despair.
13:55.321 --> 13:56.581
[SPEAKER_01]: Conditioning is real.
13:57.631 --> 14:06.034
[SPEAKER_01]: It's like how the strong smell of coffee and the first sip of it in the morning will make us feel like we're already waking up.
14:06.834 --> 14:16.358
[SPEAKER_01]: Even if scientists studying caffeine say it takes at least 30 minutes after we drink for the chemical to have an effect on our body.
14:17.178 --> 14:29.907
[SPEAKER_01]: That is, it takes 30 minutes for the caffeine in our coffee to impact us, but the smell and taste of the coffee changes us immediately due to our conditioning.
14:30.907 --> 14:32.989
[SPEAKER_01]: But conditioning only goes so far.
14:33.769 --> 14:39.173
[SPEAKER_01]: It does not explain the far more interesting results we get when we study placebo's seriously.
14:40.642 --> 14:47.226
[SPEAKER_01]: We know that taking a Tylenol-sized sugar pill reduces pain more than taking nothing at all.
14:48.246 --> 14:57.292
[SPEAKER_01]: You may be surprised that taking a giant white pill that you can barely swallow reduces even more pain for more people.
14:58.833 --> 15:05.817
[SPEAKER_01]: And taking a tiny white sugar pill also increases the pain reduction compared to a
15:08.517 --> 15:14.161
[SPEAKER_01]: The reasoning is that people unconsciously assume the medicine is so potent.
15:14.641 --> 15:17.763
[SPEAKER_01]: They only need a small amount for it to work.
15:18.344 --> 15:21.786
[SPEAKER_01]: And indeed, it works, but this is just a start.
15:24.108 --> 15:34.635
[SPEAKER_01]: Natasha Campbell and Amiraz conducted experiments on medical students and found that red placebo stimulate, but blue ones calm.
15:36.187 --> 15:45.374
[SPEAKER_01]: Students were told that they would be getting either a stimulant or sedative, but the placibos were never assigned a color.
15:46.594 --> 15:57.562
[SPEAKER_01]: They used first-person reports on alertness, tension, drowsiness, and sluggishness before and 20 minutes after the ingestion of the pills.
15:58.783 --> 16:03.847
[SPEAKER_01]: The results held with diverse student populations from educational backgrounds.
16:05.192 --> 16:20.177
[SPEAKER_01]: In their words, quote, interestingly, upon seeing the results, the student population most suspicious of and resistant to the validity of the experiment are reliably fourth-year medical students.
16:21.322 --> 16:27.164
[SPEAKER_01]: First, your medical students in contrast, accept the results and implications far more readily.
16:27.865 --> 16:35.848
[SPEAKER_01]: Suggesting that skepticism towards placebo effects may develop over the course of medical training and quote.
16:37.117 --> 16:43.662
[SPEAKER_01]: Injections of placebo shots produce more healing than any color or size the pill.
16:44.763 --> 16:52.909
[SPEAKER_01]: And fake surgery produces the highest reported healing even more than injections.
16:52.929 --> 16:59.894
[SPEAKER_01]: In 2002, Bruce Mosley and his team published their article, a controlled trial of
17:05.649 --> 17:09.272
[SPEAKER_01]: which detailed their experiment on 180 patients.
17:10.373 --> 17:17.460
[SPEAKER_01]: The patients in the placebo group received skin incisions and underwent simulated surgery.
17:18.481 --> 17:24.867
[SPEAKER_01]: The doctors went through all the motions, asking their assistance for the scapula, et cetera.
17:25.547 --> 17:31.633
[SPEAKER_01]: Just in case any patient woke up from anesthesia in the middle of the placebo surgery.
17:33.485 --> 17:45.874
[SPEAKER_01]: over multiple points within two years after the surgery, both real and placebo surgery patients were asked about their pain and completed tests of walking and climbing stairs.
17:47.175 --> 17:55.621
[SPEAKER_01]: It turns out that the placebo group reported just as much pain reduction as those who receive orthoscopic surgery.
17:56.661 --> 17:59.423
[SPEAKER_01]: Both groups said their knees felt much better.
18:07.837 --> 18:17.184
[SPEAKER_01]: Ted Kapshok is an acupuncturist trained in China and author of the web that has no
weaver understanding Chinese medicine.
18:18.165 --> 18:23.749
[SPEAKER_01]: A book considered required reading now in acupuncture schools in the United States.
18:25.050 --> 18:28.733
[SPEAKER_01]: He is currently at Harvard and one of the leading researchers of
18:30.787 --> 18:37.231
[SPEAKER_01]: He felt studying placebo meant deceiving people in need of healing, and that was unethical.
18:38.372 --> 18:42.095
[SPEAKER_01]: So he designed an experiment in which there was no deception.
18:43.456 --> 18:57.365
[SPEAKER_01]: People were told explicitly that they were participating in an experiment on placebo, and they would report if taking sugar pills would help with their irritable bowel syndrome,
19:01.611 --> 19:14.058
[SPEAKER_01]: The pill bottles clearly and explicitly said placebo, the results, the group taking placebo reported more relief than those who took nothing.
19:15.899 --> 19:21.742
[SPEAKER_01]: People knowing that they were taking fake pills reported healing.
19:27.919 --> 19:32.341
[SPEAKER_00]: The placebo effect is not a mind body, new age, mind cure.
19:32.901 --> 19:39.583
[SPEAKER_00]: Those things happen, not because you think, but because you do, you perform, and you enact.
19:40.003 --> 19:44.085
[SPEAKER_00]: The placebo effect is embodied in what patients and doctors do.
19:44.565 --> 19:50.127
[SPEAKER_00]: It's way below and much stronger than thinking you're going to get better and you get better.
19:50.767 --> 19:57.050
[SPEAKER_01]: In other words, maybe the placebo effect isn't a mind trick, but bodily action.
19:58.027 --> 20:07.380
[SPEAKER_01]: The healing comes from doing something about pain, ritualizing the process, and attempting to improve the situation.
20:08.622 --> 20:12.428
[SPEAKER_01]: Perhaps the healing is in the ritual, not the belief.
20:18.007 --> 20:37.099
[SPEAKER_01]: Claude Levystrasse was an influential anthropologist, and he wrote about a curious case of an indigenous healer, Kesselid, that's Que S-A-L-I-D, who set out to debunk the shamanic healer of his tribe.
20:38.400 --> 20:44.544
[SPEAKER_01]: Kesselid became an apprentice and learned that the shaman's trick was to conceal
20:48.045 --> 21:09.728
[SPEAKER_01]: During the climax of the ritual, the healer bit his tongue to draw blood in order to mix that blood with the feather, which is then spit out and shown to his patient and the onlookers as the pathological foreign body extracted as a result of his sucking manipulations.
21:11.687 --> 21:32.804
[SPEAKER_01]: However, even knowing this trick, Kesselid was persuaded to perform a healing ritual on a young girl when the shaman was away, because that family dreamt that Kesselid would be the one who would save their daughter, so he did the feather ritual, and she was healed.
21:34.085 --> 21:37.007
[SPEAKER_01]: No longer did Kesselid try to debunk his teacher.
21:38.015 --> 21:45.368
[SPEAKER_01]: From then on, he practiced the ritual to cure members of his tribe and was known as a
great healer.
21:49.655 --> 22:02.019
[SPEAKER_01]: The lesson here is not that shamans are deceptive, but rather, this case study should compel a re-examination of the dominant medical paradigm.
22:02.699 --> 22:08.701
[SPEAKER_01]: Is placebo less a mind trick and more about the bodily action one applies to healing?
22:09.881 --> 22:13.082
[SPEAKER_01]: Is it ritual rather than deception that does the work?
22:14.428 --> 22:22.632
[SPEAKER_01]: What if we looked at the rituals of the dominant medical paradigm from the perspective of the community members healed by Kesselid?
22:23.693 --> 22:27.915
[SPEAKER_01]: Would the establishment's medical practices begin to look more like ritual?
22:29.005 --> 22:33.527
[SPEAKER_01]: When we go to the doctor, are we participating in a similar ritual?
22:34.727 --> 22:44.611
[SPEAKER_01]: Imagine if such populations came across the mainstream medical ritual of wearing white lab coats ritual attire.
22:45.692 --> 22:48.433
[SPEAKER_01]: Using stethoscopes, ritual implements.
22:49.531 --> 22:52.792
[SPEAKER_01]: and pronouncing a diagnosis with a Latin name.
22:53.272 --> 23:04.697
[SPEAKER_01]: Say, put the rice as rosacea for the medical condition, ritual labeling, and then prescribing various pills, the climax of ritual healing.
23:20.182 --> 23:22.423
[SPEAKER_01]: say you have pain of some kind.
23:23.084 --> 23:26.166
[SPEAKER_01]: To find healing, you begin a pilgrimage.
23:27.246 --> 23:40.855
[SPEAKER_01]: The patient is the pilgrim who makes the journey to a temple of healing or the hospital where their identity is transformed into a new name given a medical record number.
23:41.395 --> 23:44.277
[SPEAKER_01]: Maybe a bracelet if they are prepping for surgery.
23:45.550 --> 23:51.713
[SPEAKER_01]: They have to remove their outside attire and change into patient gowns before examination.
23:53.193 --> 24:14.102
[SPEAKER_01]: Temple acclites or nurses and assistants prepared a program or patient before they meet the simple priest or doctor who comes in wearing ritual attire their pristinely white lab coats and ask the pilgrim to confess or disclose their health problems.
24:15.087 --> 24:21.030
[SPEAKER_01]: and then use this sacred instruments, like the Stethoscope, and run tests.
24:22.171 --> 24:36.478
[SPEAKER_01]: The priests consult sacred texts, or the test results for a prescription that may include a sacrament in the form of pills or anointment in the form of oils or creams.
24:37.962 --> 24:48.750
[SPEAKER_01]: If the program undergoes surgery, they are being born again after waking up from anesthesia, healed, and ready to return to the ordinary world.
24:50.191 --> 25:00.759
[SPEAKER_01]: Ask any scientists, pharmacists, or medical experts, Hall Tylenol works, and if they're knowledgeable, they'll admit no one actually knows.
25:01.825 --> 25:07.827
[SPEAKER_01]: We have some guesses, but even Tylenol producers themselves are not certain.
25:09.447 --> 25:29.112
[SPEAKER_01]: Tylenol or acita menofin was discovered by accident, but because it's a chemical and fits into the biomedical paradigm easily, mainstream medicine accepts it even when they are unsure of the exact mechanism of how it works.
25:30.735 --> 25:35.440
[SPEAKER_01]: To be clear, I'm not saying we don't know how any paint killer works.
25:36.321 --> 25:39.524
[SPEAKER_01]: Scientists do have an explanation for aspirin.
25:41.266 --> 25:45.110
[SPEAKER_01]: I am also not claiming that Tylenol is unsafe.
25:46.171 --> 25:52.037
[SPEAKER_01]: Yet, when acupuncture reduces pain, it's dismissed as placebo.
25:53.617 --> 26:05.102
[SPEAKER_01]: This is not just a one-off, but represents something systematic with mainstream medicine in how it allows Tylenol but excludes acupuncture.
26:06.442 --> 26:12.645
[SPEAKER_01]: For that, we'll have to talk about how defenders of mainstream medicine often point to
26:28.817 --> 26:39.799
[SPEAKER_01]: I asked Josephine Briggs, former director of the National Center for Complimentary and Integrative Health, about how medical research is conducted in the United States.
26:40.699 --> 26:49.781
[SPEAKER_01]: When asked to provide a working definition of health, Briggs said NCCI H has none, and admits
26:54.769 --> 27:12.991
[SPEAKER_01]: this glaring lack of attention to the philosophy and intellectual history of medicine and health may not be surprising to those familiar with the day-to-day operations of medical research centers and the pressure to secure funding and deliver results.
27:13.925 --> 27:25.814
[SPEAKER_01]: When asked about research on agriculture and tea, she flatly told me she would not fund experiments that have no theoretical basis she can understand.
27:27.315 --> 27:31.598
[SPEAKER_01]: However, Briggs is not just any medical researcher.
27:32.799 --> 27:41.085
[SPEAKER_01]: She was the decade-long director for a leading research center on complementary, alternative, and integrative health.
27:42.245 --> 27:51.670
[SPEAKER_01]: In other words, she's not willing to look for nor consider evidence that challenges the mainstream.
27:53.651 --> 27:56.953
[SPEAKER_01]: Mainstream medicine is found all over the world.
27:57.893 --> 28:06.738
[SPEAKER_01]: It is mainstream not only because it is highly effective or science-based, but also because it is backed by governments around the globe.
28:07.810 --> 28:15.737
[SPEAKER_01]: Nation's established mainstream medicine above all other competing forms through state laws and ideology.
28:17.098 --> 28:23.404
[SPEAKER_01]: The historian of medicine, Helen Tilley, calls this ideology soft laws.
28:24.405 --> 28:32.672
[SPEAKER_01]: She writes, quote, this matrix of legislation and jurisprudence, rules and regulations,
28:33.525 --> 28:39.429
[SPEAKER_01]: did its own boundary work by setting standards and guidelines and quote.
28:40.750 --> 29:00.645
[SPEAKER_01]: She explains how mainstream medicine dictates four important processes, how to classify disease, think about
human bodies, interpret environments, and martial evidence, in a way that blocks other ways
29:03.521 --> 29:15.644
[SPEAKER_01]: Evidence that contradicts mainstream medical theory at the time, such as the term theory of the disease of today, is dismissed as inadmissible evidence.
29:17.364 --> 29:31.227
[SPEAKER_01]: Philosophers point out that even though medicine is supposedly based on evidence, medical authorities seem to dismiss a great deal of evidence that doesn't fit their paradigm.
29:33.117 --> 29:42.841
[SPEAKER_01]: In fact, the history of mainstream medicine has a compelling case in the 19th century before the widespread acceptance of the term theory of disease.
29:44.721 --> 29:56.966
[SPEAKER_01]: Ignat Semois, a doctor in Vienna, presented empirical evidence for his colleagues to wash their hands with strong antiseptics before contacting patients.
29:58.440 --> 30:11.026
[SPEAKER_01]: He conducted his own scientific experiment on the two hospitals he was running and collected data for years that showed washing hands, saves mother's lives.
30:12.587 --> 30:31.611
[SPEAKER_01]: Other doctors rejected his suggestion because to prevailing theories of disease, the myasma and contagion theories could not account for strong evidence he presented that supported what today would be an obvious practice for surgical hygiene.
30:32.152 --> 30:39.113
[SPEAKER_01]: Thus women kept dying from child bed fever needlessly because doctors refused to accept evidence
30:43.774 --> 30:51.937
[SPEAKER_01]: Mainstream medicine, police' competing medical paradigms, and excludes evidence that challenges its hegemony.
30:53.958 --> 31:07.283
[SPEAKER_01]: The lesson from Semowice, and how his evidence was ignored before the germ theory of disease, is not that science have overcome ignorance and is steadily working towards the so-truth
31:15.925 --> 31:35.080
[SPEAKER_01]: If to seabals are so powerful, why can't we trick ourselves, for instance, instead of visiting Lauren, how come I cannot simply look at the Skittles candies in my hand and say, this has the power to heal my seasonal allergies.
31:36.537 --> 31:48.259
[SPEAKER_01]: If I eat my candy and get no other treatment, my eyes will still itch and my nose will still run when I'm in contact with tree pollen.
31:48.399 --> 32:01.742
[SPEAKER_01]: In 1985, Richard Gracely and his team published a study into Lancet, the world's leading medical journal, titled, Clinicians Expectations, Influence, Placible, and Agesia.
32:03.112 --> 32:09.337
[SPEAKER_01]: The researchers deceived only the doctors prescribing the pain medication, not the patients directly.
32:10.458 --> 32:16.583
[SPEAKER_01]: Instead, the doctors unknowingly pass the incorrect information on to their patients.
32:19.465 --> 32:27.812
[SPEAKER_01]: In this experiment, dentists were told that researchers have just discovered a brand-new version of a pain killer.
32:28.653 --> 32:30.735
[SPEAKER_01]: Let's call it super-titanol.
32:31.780 --> 32:37.025
[SPEAKER_01]: They hyped this up and told the doctors this is a revolutionary new pain reliever.
32:38.306 --> 32:56.643
[SPEAKER_01]: In the first group of patients who had their wisdom teeth removed, the dentists were told that due to some administrative protocol, they were not allowed to prescribe supertalinol just yet, so the dentists were instructed to give their patients placebo pain killers.
32:58.418 --> 33:03.162
[SPEAKER_01]: a week later, the dentist's retode, good news, everything is approved.
33:03.762 --> 33:18.073
[SPEAKER_01]: Now they can give their patients super-talinol and the dentist happily did, but neither the dentist nor the patient's new, the second group was getting the exact same placebo sugar pills.
33:19.329 --> 33:24.975
[SPEAKER_01]: now with only the dentist's belief or knowledge changing.
33:25.795 --> 33:30.059
[SPEAKER_01]: Remember, the patients know nothing about the existence of this new miracle drug.
33:31.020 --> 33:39.188
[SPEAKER_01]: The patients taking the placebo in the second group reported significantly more pain reduction than the first group.
33:40.269 --> 33:42.331
[SPEAKER_01]: It was the same placebo.
33:43.724 --> 33:49.590
[SPEAKER_01]: Both groups of patients believed they were taking pain medicine prescribed by their dentist.
33:50.911 --> 33:57.197
[SPEAKER_01]: Dentists were deliberately instructed not to disclose their knowledge of super-tional.
33:58.178 --> 34:04.244
[SPEAKER_01]: Yet, the healer's knowledge has impacted the patient's healing.
34:05.946 --> 34:08.048
[SPEAKER_01]: Let that sink in for a moment.
34:09.624 --> 34:22.434
[SPEAKER_01]: Maybe you're wondering how much information is shared through the non-verbal communication of the dentist's excited that their second batch of patients are getting super-tidal.
34:23.775 --> 34:28.279
[SPEAKER_01]: I cannot stress this enough because of how weird this is.
34:29.725 --> 34:48.879
[SPEAKER_01]: The expectation in this instance was only from the dentist, so any explanation of expectation and conditioning does not fully explain why patients in both groups with the same beliefs report different results from taking placebo.
34:50.520 --> 34:56.565
[SPEAKER_01]: Mormon explains that healing cannot be fully explained by individual belief.
34:57.785 --> 35:06.691
[SPEAKER_01]: The beliefs of the community matter just as much as those beliefs are taught and acted and reinforced through ritual.
35:08.232 --> 35:14.356
[SPEAKER_01]: He writes, quote, The placebo effect is not an anomaly.
35:15.377 --> 35:25.424
[SPEAKER_01]: People are simultaneously biological and cultural creatures, biology and culture interact and are equal partners
35:28.076 --> 35:37.146
[SPEAKER_01]: Although this is evident in many different aspects of human life, it is particularly clear when we treat one another for illness or suffering.
35:38.388 --> 35:43.033
[SPEAKER_01]: It is indeed an inescapable aspect of that process.
35:44.174 -->
35:46.637
[SPEAKER_01]: It is a fundamental part of being human.
35:48.025 --> 36:10.006
[SPEAKER_01]: Recognizing that it is not something inherently based on deception, but on meaning, opens the possibility of many new and exciting ways of understanding human health and healing, as well as new and powerful clinical tools for healers of any kind and quote.
36:11.387 --> 36:35.324
[SPEAKER_01]: In other words, scientific experiments that focus only on measuring numbers, such as heartbeats per minute, cortisol levels, blood pressure, etc., miss out on a vital part of healing that human beings crave meaning, and we need to make sense of our ailments and path forward.
36:36.945 --> 36:53.436
[SPEAKER_01]: aspects of culture can be measured, but no number or quantification can replace the reality of a meaningful experience which often provides healing, such as having food with your family or laughing with your loved ones.
36:54.957 --> 37:00.141
[SPEAKER_01]: The social sciences and humanities are just as important as the natural and
37:12.147 --> 37:25.561
[SPEAKER_01]: Race comes to four when the medical practices by my dad and other Asian Americans such as verbal remedies taught by their grandparents who grew up in Asia are labeled as traditional.
37:26.835 --> 37:43.767
[SPEAKER_01]: Referring to the term traditional Chinese medicine, coined in the 1950s by the Chinese Communist Party, Tilly writes, quote, new or recently assembled medical cultures were labeled traditions.
37:44.647 --> 37:56.152
[SPEAKER_01]: and often placed in an explicit, ethno-national lineage eventually becoming something previously called traditional or indigenous medicine.
37:56.712 --> 38:00.854
[SPEAKER_01]: For example, traditional Chinese medicine or Maori medicine.
38:01.714 --> 38:18.297
[SPEAKER_01]: Consider why professional scientists and doctors often of European descent have insisted that other people's cognitive and perceptual experience is unreal, pseudoscience, superstitious, and dangerous.
38:19.218 --> 38:34.555
[SPEAKER_01]: While their own analyses of faith and health, mind and matter, language and effect, and even energy flows, produce judicious and dispassionate understandings of reality, and quote.
38:36.840 --> 38:44.364
[SPEAKER_01]: The historian and practitioner of Chinese medicine, Boger Shide, does S.C.H.E.I.D.
38:45.144 --> 39:01.713
[SPEAKER_01]: points out that traditional medicine gets reported in popular media as exotic and is often criticized for usage of bizarre or unfamiliar animal parts, such as rhino horn and tiger bones in Chinese medicine.
39:02.593 --> 39:09.283
[SPEAKER_01]: and Cal urine in Ayurveda, even if this is typically rare in contemporary practice.
39:10.184 --> 39:18.737
[SPEAKER_01]: Just like how mainstream medicine have recently abandoned the long history of using leeches for blood letting.
39:20.225 --> 39:42.701
[SPEAKER_01]: In contrast, the use of horseshoe crab blood is presented as an unfortunate but necessary sacrifice for the greater good, because it is used by mainstream medicine, and is justified in popular journalism with scientific nomenclature on the anti-bacterial properties of its blue blood.
39:43.501 --> 39:55.953
[SPEAKER_01]: Even when horseshoe crabs were overharvested to vulnerable, threatened species levels, during the height of the COVID-19 pandemic and the race for a vaccine.
40:04.721 --> 40:05.902
[SPEAKER_01]: It's December of 2025.
40:07.931 --> 40:15.993
[SPEAKER_01]: My dad just finished a video chat with his niece in southern China, who is suffering from paranoia and depression.
40:17.513 --> 40:19.714
[SPEAKER_01]: She thinks everyone is out to get her.
40:21.094 --> 40:26.556
[SPEAKER_01]: She calls the cops on her neighbors upstairs, complaining that they are making too much noise.
40:27.796 --> 40:31.257
[SPEAKER_01]: But after the cops came, they judged that the neighbors did not.
40:32.575 --> 40:40.859
[SPEAKER_01]: She thinks someone leaving the door open, is purposely trying to get a breeze in the room to give her a code.
40:42.419 --> 40:50.003
[SPEAKER_01]: My dad tells me it's hormonal and related to her being in her 50s and not being married.
40:51.384 --> 40:55.946
[SPEAKER_01]: I cringe at the sexism, but bite my tongue as he has more to say.
40:57.366 --> 41:01.028
[SPEAKER_01]: He said some people might explain this as a comic card.
41:02.319 --> 41:05.001
[SPEAKER_01]: He shared an example of how he helped his niece.
41:06.642 --> 41:09.424
[SPEAKER_01]: She was paranoid about the crows near her home.
41:10.605 --> 41:18.010
[SPEAKER_01]: He told her that Chinese people find crows nearby to be a bad omen, but he interprets it differently.
41:19.091 --> 41:26.917
[SPEAKER_01]: He says the crows making call-call sounds are actually singing the beginning of an A sound.
41:27.617 --> 41:32.738
[SPEAKER_01]: as in Amitua-Fua, or the Buddha of Infinite Light.
41:33.958 --> 41:38.019
[SPEAKER_01]: So, the crows are chanting on her behalf.
41:39.360 --> 41:40.860
[SPEAKER_01]: She liked that explanation.
41:42.760 --> 41:46.661
[SPEAKER_01]: He thinks he can cure her immediately if she comes here.
41:47.761 --> 41:51.422
[SPEAKER_01]: He always thinks he can cure anyone of anything.
41:52.662 --> 41:54.863
[SPEAKER_01]: I had to disassemble him of that notion.
41:57.054 --> 42:02.580
[SPEAKER_01]: I said, if she developed this over a long time, it's going to take a long time to heal.
42:03.901 --> 42:05.683
[SPEAKER_01]: He then admitted it's complicated.
42:08.307 --> 42:15.450
[SPEAKER_01]: He said he helped her tremendously, just by talking online for an hour, and that happened two or three times.
42:16.870 --> 42:28.214
[SPEAKER_01]: He asked about special medicine or treatment here, including extracts from marijuana, which he's obsessed with, and thinks, is a miracle drug and panesia.
42:29.515 --> 42:35.377
[SPEAKER_01]: He's getting videos on CBD on his Chinese social media feed again, I can tell.
42:36.302 -->
42:46.809
[SPEAKER_01]: He then mentioned that his older sister, the mother of his niece, gave her some fake medicine pretending it's from the US and that it's from him.
42:47.670 --> 42:57.136
[SPEAKER_01]: His sister had to concoct a very elaborate tale that it was left over by someone else who doesn't need it anymore.
42:57.577 --> 43:02.140
[SPEAKER_01]: Hence, there was no packaging and no name she can look up online.
43:03.795 --> 43:09.096
[SPEAKER_01]: He agreed to join the play and said that she felt better after taking it.
43:10.177 --> 43:11.137
[SPEAKER_01]: He said it's mental.
43:12.337 --> 43:16.458
[SPEAKER_01]: He asked for what fake names of medication they can use.
43:17.359 --> 43:21.960
[SPEAKER_01]: A fake name is better than a real one because she can look up the real ones.
43:23.735 --> 43:32.740
[SPEAKER_01]: I told him there's no miracle cure here and she needs to see multiple doctors for multiple opinions before taking medication.
43:33.900 --> 43:37.162
[SPEAKER_01]: They tried one medication and it wasn't effective.
43:38.342 --> 43:41.664
[SPEAKER_01]: He doesn't know their insurance or financial situation.
43:42.745 --> 43:43.245
[SPEAKER_01]: It's hard.
43:53.448 --> 43:55.369
[SPEAKER_01]: there are limits to healing intent.
43:56.370 --> 43:58.171
[SPEAKER_01]: Placivos don't work on everything.
43:59.291 --> 44:04.174
[SPEAKER_01]: Mainstream medical doctors will be the first to tell you, they can't heal everything.
44:05.075 --> 44:16.762
[SPEAKER_01]: In fact, you should be suspicious of anyone who, like my dad, has such a big eagle and confidence in their ability to heal anyone and any ailment.
44:17.402 --> 44:20.024
[SPEAKER_01]: If it sounds like snake oil, it probably is.
44:22.492 --> 44:28.074
[SPEAKER_01]: Some mindfulness meditation retreats in North America and Europe cost tens of thousands.
44:29.314 --> 44:34.995
[SPEAKER_01]: Almost always charged by white teachers who go by some Japanese or Tibetan name.
44:35.876 --> 44:44.858
[SPEAKER_01]: This is not to say, there aren't super expensive meditation retreats in Asia as well, notably in Thailand and Southeast Asia.
44:46.152 --> 44:52.193
[SPEAKER_01]: Yet, the majority of meditation retreats are inexpensive or donation-based.
44:53.374 --> 44:56.294
[SPEAKER_01]: My point is that race comes into play here.
44:58.835 --> 45:07.317
[SPEAKER_01]: Asian and Asian American Buddhist centers in North America typically charge much less and that has to do with a number of factors.
45:09.503 --> 45:21.646
[SPEAKER_01]: One of them, being that places like the Dahmer drum mountain centers in the New York area, where I used to go for regular retreats, are supported by donations from their main base in Taiwan.
45:23.865 --> 45:30.887
[SPEAKER_01]: Buddhism, economics, and capitalism is a whole other topic that I and other scholars have published on.
45:31.807 --> 45:40.289
[SPEAKER_01]: I'll just summarize that Buddhists, like other people living in society,
engage in business and the economy from the very beginning.
45:41.129 --> 45:48.471
[SPEAKER_01]: But there is a difference between charging a fee for a religious service or ritual and exploitation.
45:54.793 --> 46:00.397
[SPEAKER_01]: When I was 17, I experienced the energy of teagull in my family's living room.
46:01.177 --> 46:06.180
[SPEAKER_01]: Since then, I've become a scholar whose role is to analyze and investigate.
46:07.101 --> 46:10.923
[SPEAKER_01]: In essence, I've figured out how things work and why.
46:11.844 --> 46:20.609
[SPEAKER_01]: In the 25-year since that life-changing experience, my beliefs have changed and complexified, but never became simple.
46:24.095 --> 46:43.712
[SPEAKER_01]: It's not just a continuum, from absolutely believing something works to this belief or holding the position that something does not work, in which positions can range in between or being unsure or leaning in certain directions depending on X factors.
46:45.810 --> 47:00.693
[SPEAKER_01]: There's also the feeling of wanting to believe, like wearing a lucky jersey when cheering for your local or national sports team, or putting your hat on backwards when your team is down so they can rally from behind.
47:01.773 --> 47:09.795
[SPEAKER_01]: That desire to believe is a desire for control over the things we have little to know control over.
47:12.675 --> 47:17.380
[SPEAKER_01]: philosophers distinguish between weak and strong agnosticism.
47:18.741 --> 47:24.907
[SPEAKER_01]: The weak version is one more people are familiar with, which is to withhold judgment.
47:25.868 --> 47:28.190
[SPEAKER_01]: Basically, saying, I don't know.
47:29.472 --> 47:35.498
[SPEAKER_01]: I don't know if God exists, if karma exists, if we are reborn after death.
47:36.688 --> 47:44.091
[SPEAKER_01]: The strong version isn't taking a position on what exists or not, or withholding judgment.
47:45.111 --> 47:48.913
[SPEAKER_01]: Rather, it's a position on the limits of our knowledge.
47:50.354 --> 47:52.294
[SPEAKER_01]: I am a strong agnostic.
47:53.395 --> 47:58.437
[SPEAKER_01]: This means that I do not think we have the ability to know for sure.
47:59.573 --> 48:11.900
[SPEAKER_01]: I do not know, nor do I think any of us are capable of accessing the truth with a capital T or reality with a capital R. It cannot be singular.
48:13.060 --> 48:16.362
[SPEAKER_01]: If others claim they know, I don't believe them.
48:17.323 --> 48:19.984
[SPEAKER_01]: They just haven't experienced the other possibilities.
48:21.205 --> 48:21.805
[SPEAKER_01]: They've never
48:26.331 --> 48:30.095
[SPEAKER_01]: But I also know I am unable to convince them.
48:34.599 --> 48:43.547
[SPEAKER_01]: As a strong, agnostic of various medical worlds, I cult switch by using multiple medical treatments.
48:43.567 --> 48:48.192
[SPEAKER_01]: I use mainstream medicine and acupuncture for seasonal allergies.
48:49.735 --> 48:57.959
[SPEAKER_01]: As soon as the COVID-19 vaccine became available, I signed up to get it with my wife, my parents, and my young children.
48:59.359 --> 49:01.860
[SPEAKER_01]: My family gets to flu shots every year.
49:03.241 --> 49:08.963
[SPEAKER_01]: I still bring my children to the hospital and see that they get treated like machines.
49:10.644 --> 49:15.486
[SPEAKER_01]: Mormon calls out how mainstream medicine treats people like cars
49:19.874 --> 49:28.419
[SPEAKER_01]: Sure, engineering principles help, but that is nowhere near the full picture of the human bodies healing potential.
49:32.338 --> 49:41.440
[SPEAKER_01]: In the next episode, I will talk about how my dad is a healer whose work is based on intimacy, not mechanics.
49:42.800 --> 49:46.581
[SPEAKER_01]: He's not a detached observer fixing a gadget.
49:47.721 --> 49:51.262
[SPEAKER_01]: He's an intimate partner and multi-dimensional healing.
49:52.182 --> 49:56.743
[SPEAKER_01]: That makes him not only a challenge to much of mainstream Western medicine.
49:57.543 --> 50:03.549
[SPEAKER_01]: but also a challenge to traditional views of men and masculinity.
50:22.853 --> 50:30.058
[SPEAKER_01]: You've been listening to between T and science, my experience of what can't be measured by Dr. Kim Chung.
50:31.098 --> 50:41.445
[SPEAKER_01]: This series was made possible with funding from the Henry Luce Foundation, and in collaboration with Apari, the Asian Pacific American Religions Research Initiative.
50:43.930 --> 50:46.832
[SPEAKER_01]: The Executive Producer is Dr. Bradley Onishi.
50:47.772 --> 50:49.554
[SPEAKER_01]: The producer is Andrew Gil.
50:50.514 --> 50:53.176
[SPEAKER_01]: Editorial support comes from Dr. Leah Payne.
50:54.197 --> 51:00.761
[SPEAKER_01]: Original music and engineering are by Scott Volkomozo, with production assistance from Carrie Onishi.
51:02.307 --> 51:18.207
[SPEAKER_01]: Thank you for listening and for joining me and exploring the complicated relationship between healing and science, experience and evidence, family and scholarship, and what we think we know and what we may never fully understand.
51:19.188 --> 51:21.531
[SPEAKER_01]: I'm Dr. Kim Chomp, until next time.