文字起こし 🔗
WEBVTT
00:00:10.432 --> 00:00:14.432
Hello again, everybody. Welcome back to the Bible Difficulties and Answers podcast.
00:00:14.925 --> 00:00:18.699
I'm your host, Lance Smith, and this is episode 317.
00:00:19.402 --> 00:00:23.495
Have you ever wondered why Jesus turned water into wine at a wedding?
00:00:23.942 --> 00:00:30.753
If drinking alcohol is always wrong? Or why the Bible says wine can gladden
00:00:30.753 --> 00:00:36.306
the heart in one passage, but warns that it can turn people into fools in another.
00:00:36.957 --> 00:00:41.635
And what are we supposed to make of Jesus drinking wine with his disciples at the Last Supper?
00:00:42.343 --> 00:00:48.293
Today, we're looking at a question raised by the Skeptic's Annotated Bible under Matthew 26:29.
00:00:48.902 --> 00:00:51.294
Is it okay to drink alcohol?
00:00:52.363 --> 00:00:56.669
My answer is yes. The Bible permits the moderate use of alcohol,
00:00:57.208 --> 00:01:02.339
but it also delivers some very serious warnings about drunkenness and excess.
00:01:02.873 --> 00:01:07.873
So, let's examine what Scripture actually says, because we want to avoid making
00:01:07.873 --> 00:01:10.853
the Bible say either more or less than it does.
00:01:11.481 --> 00:01:17.463
Matthew 26:29 records Jesus telling His disciples at the Last Supper (from the
00:01:17.463 --> 00:01:22.843
New Living Translation), "Mark my words--I will not drink wine again until the
00:01:22.843 --> 00:01:25.895
day I drink it new with you in my Father's Kingdom."
00:01:27.082 --> 00:01:31.946
Okay, Jesus has shared the cup with his disciples as part of the meal associated
00:01:31.946 --> 00:01:33.717
with the new covenant in his blood.
00:01:34.285 --> 00:01:38.551
He then looks forward to drinking wine with them again in His Father's Kingdom.
00:01:39.229 --> 00:01:44.773
This passage doesn't establish that every possible use of alcohol is acceptable,
00:01:45.307 --> 00:01:50.281
but it certainly doesn't portray wine itself as inherently sinful.
00:01:50.919 --> 00:01:56.798
And that brings us to the larger question. Does the rest of scripture support that conclusion?
00:01:57.655 --> 00:02:04.482
Wine, it's a gift that can be abused. Several passages speak positively about wine.
00:02:05.161 --> 00:02:11.066
Psalm 104:15 describes God's provision of "wine to make them glad,
00:02:11.366 --> 00:02:15.372
olive oil to soothe their skin, and bread to give them strength."
00:02:15.939 --> 00:02:21.866
Deuteronomy 14:26 even permits the Israelites to use their tithe money to purchase,
00:02:22.365 --> 00:02:28.501
"wine, or other alcoholic drink" and celebrate in the presence of the Lord with their households.
00:02:29.539 --> 00:02:37.021
And Ecclesiastes 9:7 encourages its readers to eat with joy and drink their wine with a happy heart.
00:02:38.339 --> 00:02:41.497
These aren't descriptions of people getting drunk in the corner.
00:02:41.904 --> 00:02:45.630
They're examples of enjoying God's provision with
Load full transcript
gratitude.
00:02:46.324 --> 00:02:51.856
Then we have John 2, where Jesus turns water into wine at the wedding in Cana.
00:02:52.460 --> 00:02:57.636
The master of ceremonies praises the quality of the wine, observing that people
00:02:57.636 --> 00:03:03.837
ordinarily serve the best wine first and the cheaper wine after guests have had plenty to drink.
00:03:04.986 --> 00:03:09.694
Jesus, however, provides excellent wine later in the celebration.
00:03:10.262 --> 00:03:17.617
And in 1 Timothy 5:23, Paul advises Timothy, "Don't drink only water.
00:03:17.879 --> 00:03:22.494
You ought to drink a little wine for the sake of your stomach because you are sick so often."
00:03:24.021 --> 00:03:29.402
Taken together, these passages make a universal prohibition against consuming
00:03:29.402 --> 00:03:31.103
alcohol difficult to defend.
00:03:31.945 --> 00:03:41.453
But now let's look at the other side of the evidence. Proverbs 20 verse 1 warns, "Wine produces mockers;
00:03:41.784 --> 00:03:43.793
alcohol leads to brawls.
00:03:44.298 --> 00:03:47.467
Those led astray by drink cannot be wise."
00:03:48.289 --> 00:03:54.750
Proverbs 23:29-35 describes the misery associated with excessive drinking:
00:03:55.214 --> 00:03:59.619
sorrow, conflict, injuries, distorted perceptions, and,
00:04:00.153 --> 00:04:03.618
the craving for another drink despite the consequences.
00:04:04.361 --> 00:04:09.411
Ephesians 5:18 commands believers not to become drunk with wine,
00:04:09.875 --> 00:04:11.907
but to be filled with the Holy Spirit.
00:04:12.708 --> 00:04:17.915
Galatians 5:21 includes drunkenness among the works of the flesh,
00:04:18.391 --> 00:04:23.152
warning that those who practice such things will not inherit the kingdom of God.
00:04:24.179 --> 00:04:30.623
And 1 Timothy 3:3 says that an overseer must not be a heavy drinker.
00:04:31.374 --> 00:04:35.263
The Bible takes drunkenness seriously, and for good reason.
00:04:35.739 --> 00:04:41.372
Alcohol can impair judgment, damage relationships, and lead people to do things
00:04:41.372 --> 00:04:45.176
they would never consider doing sober. Here's the distinction:
00:04:45.878 --> 00:04:52.055
The fact that something can be abused doesn't automatically make every use of it wrong.
00:04:53.012 --> 00:04:55.542
Food can be abused. Money can
00:04:55.542 --> 00:05:00.476
be abused. Even a good thing can become destructive when it controls us.
00:05:01.216 --> 00:05:04.774
The question isn't simply whether something can cause harm.
00:05:05.320 --> 00:05:11.694
It's what scripture permits, what it prohibits, and how we exercise the freedom we have.
00:05:12.812 --> 00:05:17.252
So, what about the passages that require abstinence?
00:05:17.903 --> 00:05:23.679
Someone might reasonably ask, "What about the people in the Bible who are told not to drink wine?"
00:05:24.452 --> 00:05:29.122
That's a good question. So, let's look at the context. Numbers 6:
00:05:29.122 --> 00:05:32.520
1-4 describes the Nazirite vow,
00:05:32.984 --> 00:05:37.572
a special commitment to the Lord that included abstaining from wine,
00:05:37.572 --> 00:05:40.745
other alcoholic beverages, and products of the grapevine.
00:05:41.530 --> 00:05:46.813
GotQuestions.org, in its article, "What is the Nazirite/Nazarite Vow?,"
00:05:47.393 --> 00:05:52.482
explains that this was a voluntary commitment that could be undertaken by men
00:05:52.482 --> 00:05:55.020
or women for a specified period.
00:05:55.833 --> 00:06:01.847
David Guzik makes a similar point in his Enduring Word commentary on Numbers 6.
00:06:02.422 --> 00:06:06.636
Since wine and grape products were generally regarded as blessings,
00:06:07.217 --> 00:06:13.707
abstaining from them was a distinctive act of self-denial associated with special consecration.
00:06:14.362 --> 00:06:19.582
In other words, abstaining from something ordinarily permitted can be part of
00:06:19.582 --> 00:06:25.188
a special commitment to God without making that thing sinful for everyone else.
00:06:25.957 --> 00:06:31.772
We see another example in Leviticus 10:9. Priests were forbidden to drink wine
00:06:31.772 --> 00:06:36.239
or other alcoholic beverages when entering the tabernacle to perform their duties.
00:06:36.815 --> 00:06:41.062
The following verses explain the concern. They needed to distinguish between
00:06:41.062 --> 00:06:44.907
the holy and the common, and between the clean and the unclean.
00:06:45.561 --> 00:06:51.412
This restriction concerned their sacred responsibilities. It wasn't a lifetime
00:06:51.412 --> 00:06:53.838
prohibition imposed on every Israelite.
00:06:54.584 --> 00:07:00.052
Daniel's choices in a pagan court and John the Baptist's distinctive prophetic
00:07:00.052 --> 00:07:05.045
role provide other examples of abstinence in particular circumstances.
00:07:05.724 --> 00:07:08.622
But the choices of specific individuals
00:07:08.622 --> 00:07:12.771
don't automatically establish a universal rule for all believers.
00:07:13.603 --> 00:07:19.161
Isaiah 28:7 likewise condemns priests and prophets whose drinking causes them
00:07:19.161 --> 00:07:21.045
to stumble in their responsibilities.
00:07:22.194 --> 00:07:27.651
Notice the recurring theme. Scripture is particularly concerned about intoxication
00:07:27.651 --> 00:07:33.735
and impaired judgment when people have responsibilities that demand clear thinking.
00:07:34.848 --> 00:07:40.810
Context matters. A special vow is not the same thing as a universal command.
00:07:41.402 --> 00:07:46.106
And a restriction on someone performing sacred duties isn't automatically a
00:07:46.106 --> 00:07:47.774
prohibition for everyone.
00:07:48.375 --> 00:07:52.578
So, what do history and the biblical languages tell us?
00:07:53.284 --> 00:07:57.486
Several of the resources I've consulted approach this question from historical
00:07:57.486 --> 00:07:59.298
and linguistic perspectives.
00:08:00.021 --> 00:08:05.275
Edward Eddie Moyo and Christopher Kabwe
Mukuka, in their 2026 study,
00:08:05.675 --> 00:08:11.939
"Wine and Alcoholic Beverages in Ancient Israel: A Comparative Study with Ancient Near Eastern Nations,”
00:08:12.572 --> 00:08:17.483
examined Israel's wine practices alongside those of neighboring cultures.
00:08:18.059 --> 00:08:22.786
Their study highlights the place of wine in the ancient world and the distinctive
00:08:22.786 --> 00:08:28.036
emphasis Israel's covenant faith placed on sobriety, discernment,
00:08:28.036 --> 00:08:32.978
and responsible conduct, particularly in sacred service and leadership.
00:08:33.647 --> 00:08:39.456
Kenneth L. Gentry, in his Chalcedon article, "Does Scripture Permit Us to Drink
00:08:39.456 --> 00:08:45.096
Alcoholic Beverages?," examines the Hebrew and Greek terminology used for wine
00:08:45.096 --> 00:08:46.298
and alcoholic beverages.
00:08:46.963 --> 00:08:52.276
His argument challenges the claim that biblical references to wine must always
00:08:52.276 --> 00:08:54.574
mean unfermented grape juice.
00:08:55.206 --> 00:08:59.845
The relevant words can refer to fermented beverages capable of intoxication.
00:09:00.326 --> 00:09:06.116
Scripture doesn't consistently make the modern distinction between grape juice
00:09:06.116 --> 00:09:10.688
and alcoholic wine that some abstinence arguments require.
00:09:11.378 --> 00:09:16.358
Gentry also addresses the subject in “The Bible and the Question of Alcoholic Beverages.”
00:09:17.003 --> 00:09:22.686
The point isn't that every ancient beverage had the same alcohol content as
00:09:22.686 --> 00:09:27.526
a modern drink is that we shouldn't impose a distinction on the biblical text
00:09:27.526 --> 00:09:30.204
that the text itself doesn't establish.
00:09:30.982 --> 00:09:36.386
Other resources reach broadly similar conclusions. Bible.org's article,
00:09:36.386 --> 00:09:40.866
"The Bible and Alcohol," recognizes that wine can be a blessing,
00:09:41.069 --> 00:09:44.431
but can also be abused through addiction and drunkenness.
00:09:45.175 --> 00:09:52.123
Chad Bird, writing for the 1517.org in "The Old Testament in Alcohol: a Short Q&A,"
00:09:52.965 --> 00:09:56.953
discusses the ordinary place of wine and beer in the lives of God's people,
00:09:57.458 --> 00:10:02.716
while noting the special restrictions on priests serving in their duties and
00:10:02.716 --> 00:10:04.502
those under a Nazirite vow.
00:10:05.128 --> 00:10:08.890
Christianity.com's article, "Christians, Alcohol, and the Bible,"
00:10:09.256 --> 00:10:12.687
likewise distinguishes between alcohol's use and its abuse.
00:10:13.335 --> 00:10:17.584
John Piper addresses the question in Desiring God's Interview,
00:10:17.787 --> 00:10:19.372
“Is Drinking Alcohol a Sin?”
00:10:20.010 --> 00:10:25.194
He argues that Scripture doesn't require every Christian to abstain completely,
00:10:25.699 --> 00:10:29.460
although abstinence may be wise in particular circumstances.
00:10:30.197 --> 00:10:35.606
Unforsaken.org's Bible study on Christians drinking alcohol similarly emphasizes
00:10:35.606 --> 00:10:41.096
that Scripture permits some uses of alcohol while condemning drunkenness,
00:10:41.096 --> 00:10:43.373
addiction, and causing others to stumble.
00:10:44.089 --> 00:10:49.093
Now, not everyone agrees with that conclusion. The Assemblies of God,
00:10:49.633 --> 00:10:55.519
in its position paper, "Abstinence from Alcohol," argues for total abstinence
00:10:55.682 --> 00:11:01.237
based on the dangers associated with alcohol and the Christian responsibility to love others.
00:11:02.328 --> 00:11:07.114
We should represent that position fairly. Some Christians abstain because of
00:11:07.114 --> 00:11:11.654
personal conviction, concerns about addiction, family history,
00:11:11.654 --> 00:11:13.701
or the example they want to set.
00:11:14.234 --> 00:11:19.494
Those can be legitimate reasons to abstain. But we need to distinguish between
00:11:19.494 --> 00:11:25.684
a personal conviction or wise precaution and a universal command that Scripture
00:11:25.684 --> 00:11:27.416
imposes on every believer.
00:11:27.956 --> 00:11:34.906
Those aren't necessarily the same thing. Christian freedom comes with responsibility.
00:11:35.853 --> 00:11:41.516
So, where does this all leave us? First, the Bible does not prohibit every use of alcohol.
00:11:42.190 --> 00:11:47.494
The positive references to wine, the allowance in Deuteronomy 14:26,
00:11:47.494 --> 00:11:52.871
and Jesus' actions at Cana all weigh against that conclusion.
00:11:53.610 --> 00:11:57.105
Second, the warnings against drunkenness are serious.
00:11:57.658 --> 00:12:01.674
Christian freedom isn't permission to surrender self-control,
00:12:02.278 --> 00:12:08.158
neglect responsibilities, damage relationships, or become enslaved to a substance.
00:12:08.789 --> 00:12:16.160
Third, something can be permissible without being wise for every person in every circumstance.
00:12:16.921 --> 00:12:22.694
Romans 14:21 reminds believers that it can be better to give up something otherwise
00:12:22.694 --> 00:12:26.273
permissible than to cause a brother or sister to stumble.
00:12:27.009 --> 00:12:33.184
That principle matters here. Someone with a history of addiction may need to abstain completely.
00:12:33.916 --> 00:12:39.064
Someone whose drinking could endanger others or damage a marriage has compelling
00:12:39.064 --> 00:12:44.254
reasons not to drink. And someone who chooses abstinence out of conviction shouldn't
00:12:44.254 --> 00:12:48.295
be pressured to prove that he understands Christian liberty.
00:12:49.502 --> 00:12:54.196
On the other hand, we shouldn't assume that a Christian who abstains is automatically
00:12:54.196 --> 00:12:58.198
more biblical than one who drinks moderately and responsibly.
00:12:58.953 --> 00:13:03.786
We need to evaluate our decisions by Scripture, wisdom, self-control,
00:13:03.786 --> 00:13:10.023
and love for others, not simply by whether we personally approve of someone else's choice.
00:13:10.689 --> 00:13:16.361
Christian freedom isn't a competition to see who can get closest to the line without crossing it.
00:13:17.214 --> 00:13:23.124
The goal is to honor God, not to find the maximum amount of liberty we can squeeze out of a passage.
00:13:23.834 --> 00:13:30.234
So, is it okay to drink alcohol? Let's return to Matthew 26: 29.
00:13:30.906 --> 00:13:35.393
Jesus tells his disciples that He will drink wine with them again in his Father's Kingdom.
00:13:36.113 --> 00:13:40.751
In context, this fits naturally with the broader biblical picture.
00:13:41.279 --> 00:13:45.494
Wine can be enjoyed as a gift, but its abuse is condemned.
00:13:46.209 --> 00:13:52.990
The apparent contradiction disappears when we distinguish between the gift and the abuse of the gift.
00:13:53.756 --> 00:13:58.645
We don't have to pretend that wine is always sinful simply because drunkenness
00:13:58.645 --> 00:14:03.865
is sinful, and we don't get to ignore the Bible's warning simply because some
00:14:03.865 --> 00:14:05.441
uses of alcohol are permitted.
00:14:06.242 --> 00:14:12.081
Some Christians will choose to abstain entirely. Others will drink moderately and responsibly.
00:14:12.610 --> 00:14:17.171
Either way, our decisions should be guided by Scripture, sound judgment,
00:14:17.380 --> 00:14:19.464
and genuine concern for others.
00:14:20.269 --> 00:14:23.655
When we encounter passages that seem to contradict one another,
00:14:23.655 --> 00:14:28.535
we need to examine their context, identify whom they're addressing,
00:14:28.535 --> 00:14:31.152
and understand what they actually teach.
00:14:31.806 --> 00:14:37.233
Sometimes the contradiction isn't in the Bible. It's in the assumptions we bring to it.
00:14:37.728 --> 00:14:40.898
That's why careful study matters.
00:14:41.838 --> 00:14:44.535
If you'd like to support the Bible Difficulties and Answers podcast,
00:14:44.535 --> 00:14:47.522
you can do so at buymeacoffee.com/LanceSmith.
00:14:48.071 --> 00:14:50.933
As always, it's appreciated, but never expected.
00:14:51.512 --> 00:14:55.455
You can find every episode at bibledifficultiesandanswers.podbean.com.
00:14:55.455 --> 00:15:00.005
You can also find us on Facebook or email me anytime at bibledifficultiesandanswers
00:15:00.005 --> 00:15:04.655
@gmail.com. I read every message that I generally enjoy hearing from you.
00:15:05.339 --> 00:15:09.734
This is Lance Smith wishing you good health, good study, and God's richest blessings.
00:15:10.146 --> 00:15:12.410
We'll see you next time. So long, everybody.