文字起こし 🔗
00:00:00
Speaker 1: And a very good morning to you. Welcome to Mornings on 5AA, this Thursday, the 15th day of October. And we have to start with congratulations to South Australia's culinary trailblazers. The Michelin Guide has come to South Australia. A number of restaurants were recognised in a major event at the convention centre last night. I'd just like to say well done to our dedicated restaurateurs, our visionary chefs, the hard-working hospitality teams that make the SA dining experience so special. McGill Estate. Restaurant became the state's first two-star Michelin restaurant, an outstanding achievement. Ten other restaurants received a coveted one star. Then there were dozens recognised with bib gourmands and official recommendations. The night was a resounding success, a testament to South Australia's extraordinary produce, culinary mastery and our wonderful, wonderful and warm hospitality. A coup for South Australia, stealing a march on the rest of the nation. Last night, the Premier announced posted on social media this. Australia now has Michelin-starred restaurants. Every single one of them is right here in South Australia. We've always known our food, wine, and produce are among the best in the world, and that's thanks to the extraordinary people we have who make it possible. Now we have the stars to prove it. Well, I can understand your glowing and gloating, Premier, but it's a little disingenuous. The reason, and the only reason, all the restaurants to win Michelin stars are in South Australia... is because we paid for the privilege. Michelin has been trying to get into Australia for some time, but both New South Wales and Victorian governments refused to pay the asking price. And how much did it cost the South Australian taxpayer? Well, guess what? The SA government said the price it paid was confidential for commercial reasons and has not revealed any ongoing costs from the deal. Once again, the government hides behind commercial confidentiality. Hang on a moment. Across the ditch, the New Zealand government isn't so coy. They've admitted they paid for the Michelin stars there. They are up front after reportedly paying $ 6. 3 million over three years for the privilege. Now, to be fair, if it cost a few million to get Michelin here, I think it's money well spent. We've already received notoriety in Britain. Even the BBC ran a story on SA's Michelin star restaurants. But, Premier, the deal has been done. How much did we pay? Well, may you gloat, but it did come at a cost. So please tell us, what did you pay? Commercial confidentiality?
00:02:31
Speaker 2: Come on.
00:02:32
Speaker 1: Enough of that. 8223 0000 is the number to win her ring. Well, it was great news for over 65s overnight. The Senate has blocked the government's planned cuts to the private health insurance rebate for Australians aged 65 and over. All opposition parties and crossbenchers united against the bill. Joining us now to talk us through it, Senator Anne Ruston. Shadow Minister for Health. Senator, good morning to you.
00:02:55
Speaker 3: Good morning, Graeme.
00:02:56
Speaker 1: Were you surprised at the amount of support you got?
00:03:00
Speaker 4: Well, I was delighted at the amount of support I got because, you know, quite frankly, this piece of policy that the government's been trying to peddle has got no friends outside of Jim Chalmers who's trying to fix up his budget bottom line at the expense of Australia's pensioners.
00:03:14
Speaker 1: Why do you think the government's been so bloody minded about this? Because they seem to be spending money hand over fist but when they see they could save a bit, it's the pensioners that cop it.
00:03:24
Speaker 4: Yeah, it's a really, really good question. It seems like such an incredibly callous policy position that the government would think saving $ 3 billion, whilst I don't dismiss that, that's a large amount of money, but asking 1.5 million pensioners to pick up much of the tab and the rest of it is being shoved into our already overburdened public hospital.
00:03:48
Speaker 5: System because those people that drop their cover.
00:03:50
Speaker 4: Will end up, you know, on your ramps, on your waiting list, stuck in hospital beds, et cetera, et cetera. So it just seems like it's an incredibly ill-conceived policy that is going to be paid for by.
00:04:03
Speaker 5: The wrong places.
00:04:04
Speaker 1: I mean, the government says health costs are rising and that's a fact. If not this cut, how should the government handle the rising health costs?
00:04:12
Speaker 4: Well, I think the first thing the government needs to do is actually listen to the experts who are saying that the way that they're rolling out their systems, the way they're implementing and operating their systems are incredibly inefficient. We heard recently from the Inspector General of Aged Care that she believed that there was a lot of extra money being put into the aged care system, but it wasn't being spent very wisely. We heard examples where a $ 50 pair of crutches were costing $ 1, 800 because of all the red taping requirements the federal government keeps tying the sector up with. I mean, I think the first place that I'd say, let's get what we're spending, taxpayer money that we're spending, let's spend that efficiently before we go slugging pensioners to pay for the muck-up that the government's made of their aged care reform rollout.
00:04:57
Speaker 1: Health Minister Mark Butler's publicly used a figure of 44,000 seniors dropping cover because of a proposed change, but his department had a vastly inflated figure.
00:05:08
Speaker 4: Well, once again, the first thing I'd say here is the government never bothered to model this. They didn't model the impact on the public health system, which we know is under pressure. They didn't even bother to find out how many pensioners were going to be impacted by this. And then we find out through freedom of information that the
Load full transcript
government was actually only talking about the initial number of people who were going to drop immediately and that in the second year it was likely to be 78,000, and they've redacted the figures in the years gone on from that. So we don't really know the truth about what the impact of this policy is going to be because the government is not telling us.
00:05:43
Speaker 1: I mean, it seemed to be a crash or crash-through policy by the government. Only five out of 635 submissions supported the bill, and yet the government persisted.
00:05:53
Speaker 4: Look, absolutely, and I'd say to the government who are threatening to bring this piece of bad public policy back into the parliament... Listen to what older Australians are telling you. Listen to what your stakeholders are telling you. Actually respect the will of the Senate who think this is a really bad policy. Go away and come up with policies that actually are acceptable to the public and don't choose aged pensioners as a place that you want to pay for your budget muck-ups.
00:06:24
Speaker 1: Mark Butler said he's going to reintroduce the identical legislation today or tomorrow. What is the point there? Obviously, it'll pass the upper house. Is there any chance at all, or it'll pass the lower house, but is there any chance at all it'll pass through the Senate?
00:06:40
Speaker 4: Well, it's only got today to do it, but quite frankly, I just can't say why the Senate's going to change its mind. I mean, the Greens and the crossbench were all very clear that particularly when it related to aged pensioners footing the bill for this bad policy, that they were not going to accept that. So I think Mark Butler has been incredibly bloody-minded about this. And, you know, quite frankly, I'd say to your listeners, you know, do you think it's fair that Mark Butler is forcing pensioners to pay for his policy mess? And do you think it's right for Mark Butler, after it's been categorically rejected, that he's still coming for them?
00:07:20
Speaker 1: Yeah, I mean, that's a fair point. But we have had feedback from people sort of saying the reason, you know, pensioners are possibly copying it in the neck is because the government's already written them off. They're not going to vote for the government anyway. So, you know, they're not going to lose a vote.
00:07:35
Speaker 4: Well, I would say that there's probably some truth in the fact that this government has declared war. on older Australians. And I just say to anybody listening, and it's not just older Australians, because don't forget, older Australians have got families that care about them and care about their treatment, that we will stand with older Australians, not just on this, but on all the other things that this government seems to be doing to attack them. I mean, they pushed through a widow tax on their tax policy reform, even though they knew that it was going to impact people at a time, most traumatic time in their life. I mean, they are attacking older Australians by some of the actions they're taking when it comes to the rollout of their aged care reform. You know, this is a government that has, quite frankly, declared war on older Australians. And I just want to assure older Australians, the coalition will stand with you right the way to the next election because we think the government is doing the wrong thing and it's plainly cruel.
00:08:27
Speaker 1: We've had Mark Butler here in the studio and he's justified it by saying, look, you know, there's only so much money to go around. more money needs to be spent on aged care, housing, et cetera, et cetera. It just seems to be that the older Australians are the ones that are copying it when the government spends money in other areas without any regard or disregard.
00:08:49
Speaker 6: Look, absolutely.
00:08:50
Speaker 4: And so what sort of government have we got in terms of their ability to manage their budget when they're saying pensioners need to pay for their policy muckers and that we've got a situation where, you know, older Australians who have no capacity to change their incomes and they can't go and get a side hustle, they can't go and get extra hours or go and pick up a second job, they're on fixed incomes. I mean, like, how bad is it that the government thinks that taking health money away from older Australians is the way to fund their aged care system?
00:09:24
Speaker 7: I mean.
00:09:25
Speaker 4: Surely the government can find better places to make the necessary savings to provide the services that Australians rely on. This is called having a strong economy, not robbing older Australians for their policy muck-ups.
00:09:38
Speaker 1: Where would a coalition government find the savings to inject money into aged care?
00:09:43
Speaker 4: I think I'd go back to making sure that every taxpayer dollar is spent efficiently and effectively because we know that's not happening right now. I mean, the other thing too, this government just keeps on, building bureaucracies and climate change organisations and the like that I think we could certainly look at places there. But my absolute argument as the Shadow Minister for Health and Aged Care is that we shouldn't be robbing health to pay for aged care.
00:10:10
Speaker 1: We can do both. And you're confident if the bill is reintroduced in the lower house, which will automatically pass, that the Senate will reject it?
00:10:18
Speaker 4: Look, obviously, I can only speak on behalf of the Coalition. We absolutely will reject it, and I'm pretty sure that the crossbench will reject it too. The Australian Greens have made it very clear, particularly when it relates to pensioners, that they have got no appetite whatsoever to punish pensioners with this terrible bill. So I'd be reasonably confident that the government's got a problem, but I can only speak on behalf of the Coalition, and I can categorically say we will walk all the way to the next election defending older
Australians and opposing this bill.
00:10:49
Speaker 1: Senator Anne Ruston, thanks for your time today. Shadow Minister for Health on the fact that the bill for over 65s, you breathe a little easier. The Senate has rejected, blocked the private health insurance rebate bill put forward by the government that would see older Australians paying more for their private health. What are your thoughts? Love to hear them. 8223 0000. Vita says, Mark Butler will be retiring soon, so why does he care? I don't think that is the case. I think Mark Butler sees himself as an outside chance to be next leader of the Labour Party, next perhaps Prime Minister of Australia. I think he's a very effective and good politician. I think he's erring badly when it comes to this matter. But yeah, I don't think he has any plans of retiring. He's still a relatively young man. Paul says, I live in Port Adelaide and I'll never vote Labour again if Butler pushes this through. Well, he said he will reintroduce the bill unchanged, which surprises me somewhat because I would have thought that To get it through, maybe there need to be some changes. And the Greens, who generally side with Labor, maybe they can be appeased. Maybe there can be some modifications to the bill. But he said, no, it will go through the same. So I don't know. He's going to get the same outcome. It would seem. We will find out. Steve says, re-age care. This is typical Labor. Too lazy to do the due diligence of the effects of their policies, just like Jim Chalmers and the budget. They make policies on the run and try to mop up the mess afterwards. Thank you for that, Steve. 8223 0000 is the number. Also on the show today, would you support government intervention on Australia's rental crisis? I think it's fair to say most people don't want governments interfering as much as possible. Well, a new Gov poll of 1,100 voters shows strong backing for intervention. Almost 8 in 10 Australians, 78% in fact, supporting regulating rents. 55% favour capping increases at inflation or lower. And 23% want a temporary freeze. We'll take a closer look at that. Michael Packie will also join us. Plenty happening in Canberra, as we've just heard. Private health rebate has been blocked. What is Michael Packie's view of that? And Minister Annika Wells back in the spotlight over her spending. We have our legal segment this being Thursday. If you have any legal questions, call up 1030 8223 0000 and turn up the volume because this is large shirt day. Well, tomorrow is anyway. What is that about?
00:13:12
Speaker 3: 5AA Mornings with Graham Goodings.
00:13:16
Speaker 1: Do your calls in a moment on 8223 0000. Helen says, Graham, doesn't Mark Butler talk to you monthly on a Friday? He does come into the studio regularly, Helen. It's not always on a monthly basis. We have an invitation to him. It won't be for some time, but we will get him into the studio as soon as possible because I think there's a lot that I want to ask him and a lot
that you want to ask him too. Dave, good morning.
00:13:42
Speaker 8: On its own, I'd just like to say that they talk about removing the rebate for pensions, but then they talk about the rebate being removed at 65. You can't get a pension until you're 67. So, like, they sort of... It's the worst government I've ever seen in my life. Unfortunately, we don't have anyone decent to give them like a really good opposition, they can earn their money.
00:14:12
Speaker 3: At the moment, it's terrible.
00:14:14
Speaker 1: Yeah, look, I think it's fair what you say, Dave, and I think there's a lot of credence to the fact that the government has virtually written off older Australians, the baby boomers. They say, you know, there are no votes in the baby boomers. No matter what we do, they will not vote for us. So, you know, collateral damage. And unfortunately, we're paying the price. Lauren, good morning.
00:14:35
Speaker 9: Yes, hello. Look, I'd just like to thank everybody for finally standing up to Albanese and his shambles.
00:14:43
Speaker 10: Of the government.
00:14:45
Speaker 9: Just a little while ago, I rang up, spoke to a young man at Amanda Richworth's office, and I tried to make him understand. I volunteer at a hospital. I am now 71 years of age, so I volunteered now for six years, but two years at Odinga Community Centre and now four years at No Longer. And I deal with patients who are dementia patients, and I give them love and I give them little gifts that we can give through, you know, through our volunteer that we are all associated with, and repatch, all of those things, you know. But this young man had the gall to say to me that after I've raised three beautiful kids, all have beautiful, children all have worked hard for that, like their mum and dad. I only had a couple of years off for all my life and I've had very good, I've worked at Department of Youth, Sport and Recreation in Victoria when Brian was in the army. You know, Brian was in the army. But what can happen is things can change with pensioners. You know, like my sister died at 66 years of age, which broke my heart.
00:16:06
Speaker 11: So that's why I left my.
00:16:08
Speaker 9: Job of 32 years. I thought, how long have I got to live? So, you see, there are things that this government just did not take into account. Women didn't get super.
00:16:20
Speaker 11: You know, I worked.
00:16:21
Speaker 2: I got my first job of.
00:16:23
Speaker 9: The 32-year job that I had was $ 7, 000. And I work full-time with three kids. You know, do they have any idea of logic? And what about what they're going to put onto, you know, the hospitals because you're going to have more ramping if pensioners can't get this little bit of help to help them? And we're paying for it anyway. We pay a lot of money already.
00:16:50
Speaker 1: Yeah, and they want us to pay more. Lauren, thanks so much for your call and thank you for doing your work. voluntary work, it's most appreciated. Graeme, good morning.
00:16:59
Speaker 12: Morning, Graeme. Something Will said this morning on the radio to do with the rebate for the private health. He said that Mark Butler was the only one that was seen to be caring about the budget and wanting to push this through. Now, there's only one reason well, there's a few, arrogance, but there's another reason why he would want to push it through unchanged. And potentially the government wouldn't be, well, implementing some stupid policies, but they're not stupid enough to realise that things aren't going to get worse before the next election shoot. So I believe Mark Butler's positioning himself and Albanese could call a double dissolution election.
00:17:59
Speaker 1: Do you think it's a good time for the current government to think about a double dissolution and having an election?
00:18:07
Speaker 13: Yeah, because.
00:18:08
Speaker 1: Do you think they'd win?
00:18:10
Speaker 12: Interest rates are going to keep rising.
00:18:12
Speaker 1: At the moment, they're... So what you're saying, basically, this is as good as it gets for Labor?
00:18:19
Speaker 2: Yep.
00:18:20
Speaker 12: I can't see it improving anymore at the moment. The opposition hasn't really attacked them on anything or played any ground. And the polls are still showing Albanese is just scraping through. And it would surprise me if they call a double dissolution election.
00:18:39
Speaker 1: Well, interestingly, you're the first to call it, Graeme. I would think it would be a very unwise thing for them to do at this stage. People hate going and voting earlier than they need to, so that would count against the incumbent government, whether they're doing well or not. But this far out from an election, and with the polls showing it's marginal, and I would say the trend is away from Albanese, not towards him. He is holding on to some degree, but yeah, a bit shaky ground, I would have thought. Kayleen, good morning.
00:19:07
Speaker 14: Good morning.
00:19:08
Speaker 15: I'm just going to add to it. I've got a friend that lives on crossroads in a unit on her own. She's approximately 80 years old. She applied over 12 months ago, for safety equipment in the shower for a handrail and a shower chair. She got it about a month ago, and when the guy came to fit the handrail, she said, oh, about time. He said, what are you talking about? He said, every household I've been to this morning has been waiting over three years for this exact safety equipment.
00:19:44
Speaker 1: Three years?
00:19:46
Speaker 15: Three years.
00:19:46
Speaker 16: Yeah.
00:19:48
Speaker 15: I mean, that's just rubbish. And I was the one that rang up and complained about the facilities down at the repat. All right, they're addressing it. The pool, the rehab pool's fantastic. The equipment's fantastic. But there's no change rooms. There's three showers for 30 people. It's just crazy, and they won't open up. Flinders pulled it sentry in the afternoon, and I've just got a letter back
from the health department saying, too bad, just suck it up.
00:20:19
Speaker 1: Thank you, Kayleen. I feel for you. I don't know what the answer is, but lack of resources, lack of money, and lack of willpower, I think.
00:20:27
Speaker 3: 5AA Mornings with Graham Goodings.
00:20:31
Speaker 1: 27 to 10, 5AA. On the text line, BJ says, can guarantee you the Greens will cave... and pass the rebate bill minus pensioners. Trust me, BJ, I hope you're wrong. We should speak to the Greens, find out from them whether they'll stand firm and stick with the coalition and the crossbenchers and vote down the bill when it comes back again. Graeme, when we have companies that have not paid tax for 11 years, how many aged care facilities could have been built? Governments must do better. Fair point. Well, there's been overwhelming public support for government action on Australia's rental crisis. The Australia Institute has commissioned a poll and Deputy Research Director Jack Thrower joins us now. Jack, thanks for your time today.
00:21:13
Speaker 7: Thanks for having me.
00:21:15
Speaker 1: Were you surprised by the strength of support for rent caps?
00:21:19
Speaker 7: Partly, but mostly no. I think most Australians are seeing that renters are really doing it tough. I mean, you know, in the best of times it's Not fantastic to be a renter, but in recent years, we've seen across most of the countries, rents really surge. So, yeah, for those reasons, not particularly surprised that we did see such overwhelming support. So, as a reminder, we found that four in five voters support some sort of government policy. Regulation of rents, that includes about half who think that rents should only be allowed to rise by inflation or less, and about a quarter.
00:22:02
Speaker 10: Who think that there should be a temporary rent freeze.
00:22:07
Speaker 7: And we saw that sort of strong support across political lines, across generations, and across whether people were renters themselves or owned their home outright or have a mortgage.
00:22:23
Speaker 1: And what percentage didn't want to see any changes at all?
00:22:27
Speaker 7: It was less than one in five. It was 14% of voters thought there should be no limit on rises. And then there were some people that didn't have a view or weren't sure. But yeah, very low level of things that it should be completely unregulated in that way.
00:22:43
Speaker 1: Did these figures follow party lines?
00:22:47
Speaker 17: They.
00:22:49
Speaker 7: There was some influence, but it was pretty consistent across. So, you know, you might expect people like, you know, Greens.
00:22:58
Speaker 10: Voters to support these sorts of policies as they.
00:23:04
Speaker 10: The Greens have had sort of those policies in the past, but amongst One Nation and coalition voters, we found three and.
00:23:13
Speaker 7: Five coalition voters think that there should be.
00:23:18
Speaker 10: rents should be limited to rise with inflation or less. And one in six coalition voters think there should be a temporary rent freeze. And overall, yeah, similar numbers, one in five One Nation voters think that there should be a rent freeze as well, a temporary rent freeze as well. So, yeah, pretty consistent across. None of the parties saw anywhere near half of their voters supporting keeping it unregulated.
00:23:46
Speaker 1: Why do you think support for limiting rent increases is so high, even among people who aren't currently renting?
00:23:53
Speaker 10: I think it's just because it's become a particularly salient issue lately with the cost of living crisis. There's been reports that it's essentially impossible to.
00:24:08
Speaker 10: Not be in rent.
00:24:10
Speaker 7: To have an affordable rental if you're on welfare. And there's been, you know, reports from places like Anglicare on things like that. And yeah, I think people see and know people who are renting and having such a hard time and think that something needs to be done just to at least limit the rate of increase.
00:24:30
Speaker 10: Because even if we limited increases right now, that wouldn't bring the prices down. People would still have a hard time. We just wouldn't It wouldn't be getting as worse as quickly.
00:24:42
Speaker 1: What was the feeling on building more public housing?
00:24:47
Speaker 7: Even more overwhelming support. So we found that three and four voters agree the government should be spending more money. directly to build more public housing, and that included about one in three who strongly agree with that, and that was also consistent across all sorts of demographics, including parties. So seven in ten coalition and One Nation voters support government building housing and even higher proportions of Labour and Greens and independent voters. And I think that... pretty much reflects, I guess, voters seeing that we have a housing crisis and wondering why, when governments used to directly build a lot of public housing, why we can't do that anymore and why we leave it up to all these sorts of indirect subsidies and incentives to try to get private developers to do.
00:25:52
Speaker 10: Things when a strong, capable government public sector can actually build the public housing that we need.
00:26:01
Speaker 1: What scale of investment in public housing do you believe is actually necessary to make some sort of difference?
00:26:07
Speaker 10: I haven't run the specific numbers lately. I believe that it's in the billions, I think maybe tens of billions. I think the important thing to note, though, is that we've essentially the amount of public housing that the public sector builds has just declined, uh, over time. And the, um, while the stock has just steadily diminished. So yeah, back in the, um, the seventies and before, I think it was about, uh, one in six, something like that, uh, houses constructed was by the public sector, whereas now we're close to like 3%. Um, and we've seen public housing stocks sold off. Uh, so
yeah, the number of people living in public housing or it used, we used to see public housing as a, uh, a policy tool that was available for all sorts of reasons. We used to have nurses and teachers in public housing, whereas now it's steadily declined and we've, uh, put it out to see it as something for, you know, people on the very bottom rungs of society. And even when we're limited to those people, we still have these huge waiting lists. And, yeah, essentially another sign of governments across the country sort of stepping back from responsibility for managing housing. And I think the Australian public will ask, saying that they think that the government should take a more active role in helping provide what is an essential service.
00:27:56
Speaker 1: While there is a lot of support from the poll shows for rent control, there are critics that say that would reduce supply and discourage investment.
00:28:07
Speaker 10: Well, there have definitely been examples of poorly designed rent controls in the past. people will always point out specific case studies. But it's important to remember that we've come some way since the simplicity of dictating that rent can only be a certain dollar value or something like that. We actively have rent control in Australia currently in Canberra, in the Australian Capital Territory, which... is somewhat flexible, but essentially without additional permission, you're allowed to rent increases that are limited to slightly above the local rental inflation. And as a, you know, at least a sign that that's been helpful, then since mid-2022, rental prices across the country and in Adelaide have been about 23%, whereas in Canberra it's been about 6%. And we see that in Australia, we see that overseas, we see that in our history as well. And yeah, things can be poorly designed, but yeah, there's all sorts of other policies that you can have to offset any impact that it might have.
00:29:29
Speaker 7: It has a much more complicated impact than people generally acknowledge. So you know, one way of avoiding rent control is by building new housing because there's no comparative rent to control against. And you can also avoid it by upgrading the property and getting permissions that way. So, yeah, the effects can be complicated, but negative impacts on investment do seem to be manageable with proper policy design and other policies and things like that.
00:30:05
Speaker 1: Would you expect the government to take notice of this poll?
00:30:08
Speaker 10: Well, I'd hope so.
00:30:09
Speaker 7: I guess an important thing to note is that given that these sorts of regulations are generally at the state or territory level, It's very much open for the federal government to push this forward because they have all sorts of tools to encourage the states to do things, but also any state government that is bold enough to try to assist renters in these ways.
00:30:39
Speaker 10: Is able to.
00:30:39
Speaker 7: There's a lot of governments
that could listen to this poll and I'm not sure who will, but And hopefully we continue to see reforms in the interests of renters.
00:30:55
Speaker 1: Jack Thrower, good to chat. Left-wing think tank's Deputy Research Director, the Australia Institute. What are your thoughts? Steve at Kilkenny.
00:31:05
Speaker 11: How are you, Graeme? Graeme, this guy lives.
00:31:08
Speaker 18: You know, this guy's living in a perfect world. You know, when you've got interest rates going up, land tax going up, Insurance going up, council rates going up. Who do you think is going to pay for it in the end?
00:31:25
Speaker 19: It's unbelievable.
00:31:27
Speaker 18: You know, like, my land tax bill has gone up $ 7, 000.
00:31:31
Speaker 11: In one year, right? You know, can I get that back from the renter?
00:31:37
Speaker 12: No.
00:31:39
Speaker 11: You're already paying already. This guy is, you know.
00:31:43
Speaker 18: Rent control mate why don't you put a government control then the rents can come down because if it costs you a hundred dollars to rent a house out and you're making two.
00:31:53
Speaker 11: Dollars where's the investment there is none.
00:31:56
Speaker 1: Yeah exactly it's.
00:31:59
Speaker 11: Killing investment and that's why no one's doing it anymore you know it's just crazy absolutely.
00:32:06
Speaker 1: Crazy good on you steve yeah thanks for that um I'm not saying that there was the views of Jack Thrower from the Australia Institute, but that was the result of the poll. 1,100 voters commissioned by the Australia Institute showing strong backing for intervention. But, yeah, government intervention and causing freezes like this, as Steve said, can cause unthought-of problems. Well, unless you're a landlord, of course you'd be thinking of them.
00:32:31
Speaker 3: 5AA Mornings with Graham Goodings.
00:32:34
Speaker 1: 11 to 10, 5AA. Rick says, oh, yeah, let's kill the rental market altogether, get rid of negative gearing and capital gains tax and now freeze rental rises. Could we stuff up this country anymore? We don't live in utopia, folks. This is the real world. Thank you for that, Rick. Well, it's been a rather eventful week in Canberra, to put it mildly. Joining us now is 5AA Canberra correspondent Michael Packie. Michael, good morning to you.
00:33:01
Speaker 20: Good morning, Graeme.
00:33:02
Speaker 1: The private health rebate blocked in the Senate last night. Did that come as a surprise?
00:33:07
Speaker 20: Look, not so much because the opposition and the Greens have been saying that they don't support this move to essentially reduce the private health care rebate for over 65. And this is a policy that Labor was trying to get through, essentially to try and save the budget about $ 3 billion. The government was saying that by saving this $ 3 billion, it would then spend that money on aged care services. But the opposition's saying, well, you know, you're punishing people that utilise private healthcare, that have been paying
for private healthcare for decades. A lot of the people that have been paying for this private healthcare are not necessarily rich, but they have private healthcare in the event of a rainy day if they do get sick in later life and that they need to utilise it. So to wind back the rebate that they're getting on that private health cover... is cruel. That's what the opposition was saying. The Greens agreed, and they blocked the legislation from being debated in the Senate late yesterday. The weird thing is here, Graham, is that the government has said that they're reintroducing the legislation into Parliament today. And so the question is, well, why are you doing that? If you're going to reintroduce the same legislation, which has literally been blocked 24 hours earlier, you're not going to get a different outcome. So it'll be interesting to see what the negotiations start to look like here. There is talk with the Greens that if the government carves out pensioners from this policy, that they may back it in. So if you're a pensioner and that you still pay for private health cover, maybe you won't be affected by the reduction in your government rebate for having private health cover. But if you're not a pensioner, if you're a self-funded retiree and you do have private health, you would still have to cop a reduction to the government rebate. So it'll be interesting to see if they do carve out pensioners and if that's enough for the Greens to back it in.
00:35:14
Speaker 1: It sounded like Mark Butler was going to reintroduce the bill as is. And as you say, often bills are rejected in the Senate. They go back to the lower house. There are modifications to appease the minor parties or the Greens or whoever, and then it proceeds through. But would he really reintroduce it without any changes at all?
00:35:33
Speaker 20: Well, that's what it seems like. And I just find that quite bizarre why you would do that, why you would introduce the same bill into Parliament that's already been rejected. There is talk that negotiations are happening behind the scenes to carve out pensioners from the legislation. But you would think that once you negotiate get those carve-outs happening, maybe sort out the legislation in a different way, and then introduce the modified legislation into Parliament to hopefully get it passed. So it'll be interesting to see what happens here over the coming weeks and months, but clearly the government wanted this to pass before the end of the year. so it could start banking these savings. So if it does pass in any way, shape or form, the government is not going to be saving $ 3 billion. They might save a fraction of that. And you'd assume, as they say, they'll use that money to try and pay for aged care services. But as some independents this morning, as they were arriving in Parliament, people like Jackie Lambie were saying, you know, the The mess in the aged care sector is, you know, both parties are to blame, Labor and the Coalition. They're both to blame for the mess that the sector finds itself in. And to basically try and utilise pensioners and the most vulnerable in the community to try and sort out the mess is unacceptable.
00:37:04
Speaker 1: So if this bill just goes through the lower house unhindered, goes to the upper house unhindered, same thing happens, it's rejected. Does that set off any triggers? Does that sort of allow the government to do anything, you know, like a double dissolution or anything like that?
00:37:18
Speaker 10: Yes, it does.
00:37:20
Speaker 20: But the thing is, I don't think that the government will, you know, go to a double dissolution election on this issue. But yes, technically, you know, if the bill's been rejected twice... then the government has got that bill in its knapsack saying that, you know, we want to make this change. We think that this change is necessary. The Senate is stifling our ability to make this change. So we want to use this as a double disillusion election trigger. But the chance of that happening is pretty low.
00:37:53
Speaker 1: Well, as always, we'll just wait and see what happens next. I see ministers are back in the spotlight over their spending.
00:38:01
Speaker 20: Yeah, look, this is an interesting one. This is about Anna Lee. She's the small business minister and she's coming under a bit of scrutiny lately over the way she's handling her own portfolio of small business. There's a lot of small businesses that believe that she's not doing a very good job. Some of her colleagues don't believe that she's doing a very good job in this area and that she is coming under fire from the opposition during question time. But now another story has emerged in the News Corp papers suggesting that she spent more than $ 150, 000 in taxpayer funds to fly across the world and visit over 17 months. And she's visited various different countries over that 17 months. But she's done that in her capacity as the International Development Minister. So I think we've got to keep that in mind. She spent this $ 150, 000 over 17 months to visit nine countries, but she has done that in her capacity as International Development Minister and says that given that she does have that role, travel is part of her remit. So I would argue, Graham, that... $ 150, 000 to visit nine countries over more than a year is probably within reason for a minister when you're meeting your counterparts in other parts of the world and holding meetings with your counterparts in.
00:39:29
Speaker 16: Other parts of the world.
00:39:30
Speaker 1: The world.
00:39:30
Speaker 20: So I don't know how much this one will fly compared to the job that she's doing as small business minister, which is not very good because there's a lot of problems that are being brought up in that portfolio. And you wonder if she's going to come under more pressure in her portfolio as small business minister rather than international development minister.
00:39:51
Speaker 1: Have
we heard the end of Annika Wells and her spending on the Adelaide birthday party, or is that going to continue?
00:39:58
Speaker 20: Look, at the moment, we haven't heard any more about it. I think the hard thing about it with that is that she will always claim that what she did was within the guidelines. And the guidelines have now since changed. there were a few trips that Annika Wells did which didn't meet the pub test and she paid back $ 10, 000. I think the problem here with the $ 4, 000 birthday party that she attended in South Australia was that she said that she needed to travel from Brisbane, which is her hometown, to South Australia, to Adelaide, to have meetings with various people, including the health minister at the time, Chris Pickton. Now, Apparently, there's been a Freedom of Information request that's been conducted into Chris Pickton's diary, and it doesn't show any meeting with Annika Wells. However, within that diary entry, it does suggest that he did have a private meeting with someone, but we don't know who that someone is. So, look, the issue here is Annika Wells says that she didn't do anything wrong. Anything that she did was within the guidelines. It's not a good look for Annika Wells or the government.
00:41:08
Speaker 2: I think.
00:41:09
Speaker 20: But is anything more going to come of it? I don't think so. It's the same thing here with Anne Arleigh. I can't see that anything more is going to come out of this Anne Arleigh story of her spending $ 150, 000 in taxpayer money because she'll say that she spent that money in her capacity as the international development minister. So she was doing her job.
00:41:31
Speaker 1: Michael Packie, thanks for putting the spotlight on the issues and making it so understandable for us. Always appreciate your time and thoughts. 5AA Canberra correspondent, Michael Packie. Two minutes to 10 from the text line. Graham, why is the government so anti-aged? Health rebate cuts, work bonus not increased to encourage pensioners to work, etc., etc. And Bill says, how many votes will this health fund rebate cost? Well, Bill, I think the government has taken that into account. I don't think they believe that there are a lot of votes for the Labour Party among the pensioners. So they think, well, you know, cut them adrift. 8223 0000 is the number to ring. We better take a look at the stock market. The All Ords is down by 0.73%. ASX 200 down by 0.64%. The Dow Jones was down by 0.09 overnight. The Nasdaq was down by 1.8%. Oil, Brent Crude, $ 106 a barrel. West Texas crude 95 US dollars and gold 4,106 US dollars an ounce. The Aussie dollar currently buying 69.7 US cents. Back after the news.
00:42:41
Speaker 3: 5AA mornings with Graham Goodings.
00:42:44
Speaker 1: Good morning to you. Thanks for tuning in. Hope you can stick around till midday. 8223 0000 is the number to ring. Steve says to my baby boomer buddies who voted Labor, you better get used to losing more benefits because Labor know we no
longer have any voting power. They'll continue to come after our money, super, and any privileges we currently enjoy. You get the government you deserve. Thank you for that, Steve. And the government need to remember that pensioners have families, many who help manage their elderly parents' finances and affairs. Thanks for that. Well, I don't know if you've noticed it. You probably have. Bank branches continue to close around the nation. Joining us from Canstar is Sally Tindall. Sally, good morning to you.
00:43:24
Speaker 13: Hello, Graeme.
00:43:25
Speaker 17: How are you?
00:43:25
Speaker 1: Good, thanks. What's the grim news? What's happening?
00:43:29
Speaker 21: Oh, look, it's all still going down, down, down. And that's coming as no surprise to anyone that, you know, withdraws cash from an ATM or goes to a bank branch or tries to go to a bank branch to have a conversation with someone. So what the APRA data shows, it was released yesterday, is that bank branches continue their backpedal, 97 fewer bank branches in the country compared to the financial year before.
00:43:55
Speaker 10: It's a drop of 3%.
00:43:57
Speaker 21: But if you look across five years, Which isn't actually that long ago. We're talking about June 2021 that we're comparing it to. Five years ago, there was 1,215 more bank branches open around the country than.
00:44:13
Speaker 22: There are today. It's a significant drop of 28%.
00:44:16
Speaker 21: And it's happening across the country, mainly in the capital cities, because there is a moratorium from the big four banks not to close regional branches at this point in time. But, you know, for anyone that used to rely on a branch and now has to drive even further to get to one or queue up for a significant amount of time just to see someone face-to-face, they know all too well that this is a problem that needs to be solved.
00:44:44
Speaker 1: When they started closing branches, they introduced ATMs and said, you know, this is the way of the future. But ATM numbers are also in decline.
00:44:53
Speaker 23: Yeah.
00:44:54
Speaker 10: Oh, they absolutely are.
00:44:55
Speaker 21: Yeah, those free ATMs. Remember when the big four banks used to charge to get you access to your money and then they very publicly announced that they were going to drop that charge in order to withdraw your cash? I think it was in the lead up to the Banking Royal Commission and they were looking to earn some goodwill or.
00:45:12
Speaker 5: Something like that.
00:45:13
Speaker 21: Well, you know, what happened was that they made them free, but they also made them nearly impossible to find. Bank branches have dropped. I mean, there's 4,500, sorry, 4,959 bank ATMs across the country. But it's a drop in the last year of 184 bank-branded ATMs. That's a drop of 4%. Over the last five years... 2,798 have disappeared across the country, bank ATMs. There's lots of other ATMs around, but they'll sting you with a peg.
00:45:46
Speaker 1: And that's it. I mean, I used to go to a regular ATM. It was attached to a bank and it didn't cost me anything. The branch moved and, oh, there's an ATM inside. And I went and, no, it'll cost you $ 2 or $ 4. I said, no, thanks. I'm not paying you to get my money out.
00:46:03
Speaker 6: Yeah, exactly. It's quite difficult.
00:46:05
Speaker 21: I mean, there are ways around the ATM. That's important to remember. So you can get cash out at places like Coles and Woolies, although they keep lowering the amount that you can get out. But that is an option for some people to avoid having to pay those pesky fees. You can also get some, or there's not many these days, but, you know, some banks will refund you the ATM charge. I believe Macro Bank still does. But again, few and far between, very difficult to find. And that's just to access your own cash.
00:46:37
Speaker 1: So what's the motive? It's not about service, obviously, you know, fewer branches, fewer ATMs. What do they want you to do?
00:46:44
Speaker 21: So really it's a move to, well, the banks will tell you that it's moved to cashless society, as in like we're not going directly to a cashless society, but more people are are opting to bank electronically. They're using cash less. But what we know from the RBA surveys is that cash has actually risen ever so slightly, cash use that is. It's gone up to 15% of transactions, according to the last RBA survey, which was a small increase from 13% in the previous survey. Cash is not dead and buried. It's still a very popular way to pay for things across the country.
00:47:20
Speaker 20: The banks.
00:47:22
Speaker 21: know this but it's an expensive for for them because you know housing a bricks and mortar branch is quite expensive getting the staff to man it even having the atms and carrying that you know distributing that cash around the country is expensive for the banks so really ultimately what they're looking to do with the closure of these branches the disappearance of atms is to save a bit of money and.
00:47:45
Speaker 1: If you're only dealing online um using credit cards and so forth they can follow every single transaction, every move you make, every step you take.
00:47:54
Speaker 10: They really can.
00:47:55
Speaker 21: And look, some people love it. Don't get me wrong. I like using it for my kids.
00:48:00
Speaker 4: Because then I can.
00:48:01
Speaker 21: Tell where all their money's gone and point it out. That list of transactions is very handy. But, you know, it's not for everyone. But some people just want the anonymity that comes with cash. And at this point in time, you know, cash is very much a legal tender in this country and the government says it's here to stay. So we need to be able to access it.
00:48:22
Speaker 1: I mean, I've got nothing to hide, Sally, but... I've come home from work and on the way I bought some petrol and I get home and my wife says, oh, so you bought some petrol today. Oops, hang on. I mean, I'm not doing anything I
shouldn't, but it gives you a little bit of an uneasy feeling.
00:48:37
Speaker 21: Oh, look, I did used to take delight in ringing my husband up after lunchtime to tell him what he had for lunch.
00:48:43
Speaker 24: Because he threw it on his car.
00:48:46
Speaker 21: Especially when it was something like KFC. But anyway, but I learned very quickly that he did not enjoy the joke as much as I did and I had to stop doing it.
00:48:54
Speaker 6: Otherwise, I was forcing him to pay cash.
00:48:56
Speaker 24: But yeah, look, that's it.
00:48:59
Speaker 21: It's, you know, if you've got a system in place to spend your money, and it works for your finances. It helps you keep on track with your budget, things like that. You know, it's important to stick to that. A lot of people are turning back to the age-old traditions of cash stuffing, for example, where you take out your pay in cash or some of your pay in cash, you put it into envelopes according to each category. And then once that envelope is finished, that's it. There's no more to spend until next payday. And for some people, particularly young people, they're coming back to that kind of trend. and using cash for budgeting purposes. That's a very legitimate reason to be having cash.
00:49:40
Speaker 1: Yeah, well, I mean, there's no doubt about it. It doesn't feel painful when you go and pay for something with a card. You say, there's the card, you know. But if all of a sudden you reach into your pocket and you come out with a wad of $ 50 notes and you pay something, you really feel that. You really feel like the money has gone from you, you know, where plastic is sort of it's removed from you.
00:50:02
Speaker 20: Yeah, absolutely.
00:50:03
Speaker 21: They call it friction spending. So there's this where you hand over the 50, but you don't really let go of that note because you don't really want to, and it hurts. Look, for some people, that actually doesn't work for them because they split a 50 and then have no idea where the rest goes, and sometimes it goes into the bottom of the washing machine. Sometimes it falls out of their pockets on the.
00:50:25
Speaker 24: Bus or wherever.
00:50:26
Speaker 21: But for other people, they're really good about keeping track of notes and coins. and less good with their budgeting when it comes to tap, tap, tapping and never stopping to actually look at how much the overall damage is, particularly in periods where we're coming up to it at the moment, sale time, in the lead up to Christmas, where you go to the shopping mall or whatever because Black Friday's on, you tap, tap, tap away, and quite quickly you can find that you've actually blown your budget for the month.
00:50:54
Speaker 1: Ah, yeah, a very familiar story. So, Sally, realistically, how long do you think we have cash remaining? You know, is a cashless society on the horizon?
00:51:04
Speaker 21: I don't actually think it is, to be honest, Graeme. I do think that the government and, you know, the
regulators and the big banks have some tough decisions to make to make sure that cash is readily available and bank branches are still open for people to talk to a bank, you know, representative. in the foreseeable future.
00:51:25
Speaker 24: That's the big challenge.
00:51:27
Speaker 21: The government has said cash is here to stay for the foreseeable future. They've mandated the fact that, you know, businesses with the turnover of, I've forgotten off the top of my head, but $ 5 million or something like that, have to accept cash between the hours of 7am and 9pm for essential food and things like that. So cash is here to stay. I cannot see a future, you know, at least in the next... 20 years, maybe even more, where cash actually goes. But we really need a solution, a long-term viable solution to make sure that these bank branches and ATMs stay around the country.
00:52:07
Speaker 10: One option that is.
00:52:10
Speaker 21: somewhat working, but has its limitations, is BankerPost, where a lot of the big banks and other smaller banks have got a partnership with Australia Post, where you can do really basic banking in your Australia Post, which is great because it's building out that centre so that it doesn't just do you know posting of letters anymore you can get passports there and all the rest of it you can pay bills but you can also do some basic banking perhaps we need to develop that idea further but we want to make sure and the Australian Banking Association has put together a proposal and has sent it to the ACCC I believe about you know perhaps banks merging together to keep branches alive in regional centres where there are no branches available at this point in time But we also need to keep an eye on competition. We want to make sure that if you walk into a branch, well, sorry, one of these hubs, that you still have a range of choice of banking products, that you still, you know, that competition really stays alive because that's what also helps keep a lid on prices.
00:53:13
Speaker 3: Brilliant.
00:53:14
Speaker 1: Good on you, Sally. Always great to chat. Sally Tindall from Canstar. Have you had a branch near you shut down and lost an ATM? Mike has some good news. The National has opened a branch at Colonnades.
00:53:26
Speaker 3: Brand new.
00:53:27
Speaker 1: Good on you, Mike. How many other new branches have opened around the state? If you know of any, let us know. 8223 0000. Back with your call shortly.
00:53:36
Speaker 3: 5AA Mornings with Graeme Goodings.
00:53:39
Speaker 1: So much to talk about, so little time. 23 past 10, 5AA calls in a moment. Hi, Graeme. Do you know about nursing homes charging extra for a slice of bread for residents? Also little extras, e.g. ice cream, they are charged. It's disgusting. Prisoners are treated better. And Andrew says, how is it there is even a cost to tap electronically? It's computerised and doesn't involve any human processing. It's a straight out cash grab. Yeah, look, I must pose the
same question. I've transferred money and done dealings and they say, oh, it might take one or two days or three or four days for the transaction to get through. It's all electronic because I've done transactions and it's been instant. Like within a minute, the transaction's gone through and then they can say, oh, it'll take one or two days. So that gives them a little bit longer with your money. Keith, good morning.
00:54:29
Speaker 11: Morning, Graeme.
00:54:29
Speaker 1: Hope you're well. Very well, thanks.
00:54:32
Speaker 13: That's good. Hey, that socialist you had on where he's saying the vast majority of Australian people want rental, how would I say, traps down on landlords and stuff. Now, I'm not a landlord.
00:54:45
Speaker 10: We own our own home.
00:54:47
Speaker 13: But the best way to destroy the stability of the housing market is this. Government sells off housing plus homes, evicts or, through a local attrition, gets rid of the properties, then puts stress on private households and private owners who are landlords to drop their prices, thus regulating them rather than keeping the housing trust markets. Now, the best way to destroy any country is put it to a vote. How many Australians would like to see millionaires and billionaires taxed to 95%? I'll bet you any money, it'll be vast majority of morons out there, excuse my French, will say, yeah, let's tax all the billionaires and millionaires and leave them 5%. Best way to destroy a country. You know, the Victorian housing market has dropped below Adelaide for the first time in God knows how long. Because the Andrews government destroyed landlords. You want to pull the rug out of the housing market? I have no problem with houses dropping in price, but the way it will drop will be astronomical because all the landlords will offload their houses and there will be a glut on the market.
00:56:01
Speaker 1: Yeah, no, you make sense there, Keith. And I think this idea of because someone is wealthy, tax them to oblivion is crazy. There was someone, I think it was in England, they suggested... huge taxation, said, because you're earning so much, you've got a business and your profits are huge, you should be paying 75% tax, just pick a figure. And he said, well, you know what I'll do? I'll run my business for four or five months of the year and then shut it down because there's no point running it any longer. It's the same with somebody who is quite wealthy and you say, oh, look, they should be paying more tax. But that person that is very wealthy, they might have a cleaner that comes into their house once or twice a week. They might pay to have their clothes ironed, dry cleaned and the like. They might pay for a garden on a regular basis. You tax them indiscriminately, all of a sudden they'll lay off the cleaner, they'll lay off the gardener. They won't go out to dinner as often. I mean, these people are spending money. People should pay a fair amount of tax. But to say, you know, millionaires and billionaires should pay outrageous amounts, think it through. Dawn, good morning.
00:57:08
Speaker 25: Good morning, Glenn. Love your show. I just wanted to, we've been going down to Royal Adelaide Hospital to oncology, which I can't fault them at all. They're absolutely beautiful down there, especially Donna. What I'm ringing up about is I've been going down there for a couple of months now and the hospital is fine, but outside the hospital where the people sit, it's filthy dirty. I don't know whether anybody else has noticed it, but it really shocked my husband. And, you know, we went down there and we thought, well, you'd think that somebody on the doll or something could pressure clean it or something or other.
00:57:55
Speaker 1: So this is outside the Royal Adelaide?
00:57:57
Speaker 25: Yeah, outside the Royal Adelaide Hospital where people sit, you know, when they come out.
00:58:02
Speaker 1: What, there's lots of rubbish around, untidy, unchecked?
00:58:04
Speaker 25: No, there's not rubbish around, but it's... Dirty and grey and, you know, like stuff's been spilled, it looks like. And, you know, it just needs a good pressure clean.
00:58:16
Speaker 1: So it's just not being maintained?
00:58:17
Speaker 25: No, it's not being maintained. And it just takes the niceness off, you know, the Royal Abbott, I feel, or.
00:58:25
Speaker 13: We feel, yeah.
00:58:27
Speaker 1: And it's not all that old, is it? No, Dawn, look, thanks for bringing that to our attention. Look, there'll be a reason that the hospital won't maintain it, cutting costs, they can't get the staff to do it. But, yeah, you would think the outside and surrounds of a hospital should be maintained. Edwin, good morning.
00:58:44
Speaker 19: Good morning, Graeme.
00:58:46
Speaker 26: Look, I'd like to mention about a time when I, only recently, I went to, I rang up the Commonwealth Bank and I said I'd like to have a small loan so I could do a bit of renovation. And they said to me, oh, you can't have a small loan to do a renovation unless you go online. So this is the first time this has happened to me. So it seems to me that that's the way it's all going. It's all going to eventually, everyone will see that there'll be online banking everywhere, and you won't be able to access your money unless you go online.
00:59:24
Speaker 1: Yeah, I think that is the way of the world, Edwin, and this is a changeover period.
00:59:27
Speaker 2: Probably.
00:59:28
Speaker 1: 20 years down the track, everyone will be comfortable with it. You won't know any other kind of banking. But we're going through that transitionary period where there are a lot of people who aren't comfortable going online, who don't want to go online. They don't have a computer. They don't have a smartphone. They only want to deal in cash. So in the interim, we're going to have... It's teething problems, but I think the major banks should look after people in the interim. Thanks so much for your call.
8223 0000. Coming up after the news headlines... Our legal segment for Johnston Withers Lawyers. Get your questions ready. Any legal matters, 8223 0000 is the number. Back shortly.
01:00:03
Speaker 3: 5AA Mornings with Graeme Goodings.
01:00:14
Speaker 1: For Johnston Withers Lawyers, Tim Darney and Robin Nader join us in the studio. Good morning to you both.
01:00:19
Speaker 24: Good morning, Graeme.
01:00:20
Speaker 3: Good morning, Graeme.
01:00:21
Speaker 22: Thank you for having us.
01:00:23
Speaker 1: What a magnificent day it is, too.
01:00:24
Speaker 24: It's just beautiful.
01:00:26
Speaker 16: Beautiful out there. It's not too hot, and it's just beautiful. I was saying to Robyn, it's probably going to have a long, dry summer, they say, so we should enjoy the cool, while it's still a bit cool.
01:00:40
Speaker 1: I don't believe the Bureau anymore. Oops, I hope they're not listening.
01:00:42
Speaker 22: Wow.
01:00:44
Speaker 27: You better get a lawyer somewhere. I once said, You can't defame the Bob. I once said if I made as many mistakes in my job as the Bureau, I'd be out of work. But no, who can predict the weather? They do their best.
01:01:00
Speaker 16: Yeah, they do. Look, I'm sure it's not an easy job, so I won't comment.
01:01:07
Speaker 1: You're going to hang me out to dry, aren't you?
01:01:08
Speaker 22: I don't want to defame them.
01:01:10
Speaker 1: Thanks for your support.
01:01:11
Speaker 22: I'll represent you, though.
01:01:14
Speaker 1: Right. Before our calls, and now is the time to ring if you want to have a chat with Robin or Tim on a legal issue, 8223 0000. The area of divorce is an area that impacts so many people. There appear to be few winners and it can be a very, very expensive exercise.
01:01:34
Speaker 24: Yeah, look, it sure can, Graeme.
01:01:36
Speaker 28: And it came to the fore this week with a headline that I saw that really piqued my interest. It was a story about a lady in Victoria who came into her divorce or family law property proceedings with a pool of assets that she owned with her ex-partner of $ 1.
01:01:58
Speaker 24: 5 million.
01:02:00
Speaker 28: She ended up walking away with nothing because she spent about $ 500, 000 on legal fees.
01:02:07
Speaker 24: And the reason it got me thinking is because.
01:02:10
Speaker 28: I thought, well, look, why does this cost so much or why can it cost so much and how can people keep the cost down? And when I was breaking it down, there's a number of reasons, I think, and categories of what we do. And often the client doesn't see some of the work that goes into these matters. So, you know, back when I started my career, often the asset pool for a separating partnership included the family home, some super.
01:02:46
Speaker 24: bank.
01:02:46
Speaker 28: Accounts and maybe they had a car each. So that was the more simple times back in the day. But these days, there are a lot more complex asset pools with businesses, investment properties, cryptocurrency, all of that sort of thing. And the first step in any property separation is to work out what's in our pool. And that comprises anything that you own, anything that your ex-partner owns, whether it's together, whether it's a portion of an interest in another asset, everything has to be disclosed and worked out. So the first step in any property law separation is to look at disclosure. And both parties have an obligation to disclose fully and frankly their financial position. So that involves producing a whole lot of documents. The big time-consuming one that's costly is bank statements. So parties are required to disclose their bank statements from 12 months prior to separation up to the current date. So not just up to separation date. It goes to when you are actually doing your settlement, not from the date of separation. Now, if there are other issues or money spent or disputes, that could go back further. So it also includes disclosure of super tax returns, you know, any trusts, any investment properties, all of that sort of information, pay slips. It's a big wad of documentation to go through. But bank statements being the ones that end up being the most complex because banks not only do you have to produce it, the lawyers have to go through it, not only yours but the other sides as well, looking for bank accounts that might have transfers to or from them that haven't been disclosed, looking for big amounts, big deposits or withdrawals that are unexplained. We're looking for things like wastage, which could mean lots of sports bet transactions or things spending in pubs and clubs or you know liquor outlets things like that so we've actually got to go through all of those bank statements and look at whether there's any flags in there so that's a really time-consuming thing that can take hours to collate all of that information so it's in a sensible format and then for someone to go through it and the next step in in working all of that out is what's everything worth and there's usually a big dispute about this And going back to that simple asset pool where, say, you've got a family home with, you know, one person who wants to keep the family home, the other person is happy to get paid out for that asset. But, you know, what's that payout figure? And it comes down to what everyone thinks that house is worth. the person who's keeping the house wants it as low as possible and the person who's getting paid out wants it as high as possible. And what the law says is where you've got a dispute, you get a valuation. So you then times that by businesses, by expensive jewellery, by trusts that might be difficult to value. So anywhere where you do not agree, you have to get a valuation. So, a property valuation might cost you $ 1, 000. A business could cost $ 10, 000.
01:06:09
Speaker 24: You might have unusual assets.
01:06:13
Speaker 28: You know, I'm thinking about, say, Freemasons, regalia or jewels or things like that that need a
really specialty value or artwork, all of those things. So, you either agree or you pay for a valuation.
01:06:26
Speaker 24: You compromise or you pay. So, yeah.
01:06:30
Speaker 28: There's disputes about picking up belongings if one person's left the home but all their stuff is there. I've seen matters drag on for over a year just with people arguing about when someone can go back into the property and.
01:06:42
Speaker 24: Get their stuff. There's disputes about gifts from family. Are they gifts? Are they loans?
01:06:49
Speaker 28: How are they going to be dealt with in the pool? post-separation spending, people racking up huge credit card debts after separation and someone saying, well, that's not going in our pool. So there's all these intricacies that create disputes. Where there's a dispute, it's got to be resolved. Where you've got lawyers involved, that's by writing a lot of letters, maybe having a mediation. So the other big factor that's come into property settlements is is last year the Family Law Act was changed so that family violence now is relevant in property settlements from the point of view where the family violence against a survivor impacted that person's ability to make contributions to the relationship. And that might be whether it impacted them being able to go out to work.
01:07:40
Speaker 24: It might have impacted.
01:07:41
Speaker 28: Their ability to look after the kids and, you know, get them to school and things like that. So that can have an impact on how your property is divided. And the perpetrator of family violence may get a drop in the percentage they're entitled to.
01:07:56
Speaker 8: Yeah.
01:07:57
Speaker 28: These are all the things that increase the costs and client behaviour as well is a.
01:08:05
Speaker 24: Lot of it.
01:08:06
Speaker 16: I mean, on that score, what are ways that people like, that are listening, that are thinking about unfortunately having to separate and, you know, they're conscious of obviously how much it's going to cost.
01:08:23
Speaker 22: To do that. What are some... you know, tips, I suppose, that.
01:08:28
Speaker 16: They could use to try and at least approach it with not burning up their whole asset pool on lawyers.
01:08:36
Speaker 28: Yeah, look, that's a great question, Tim, because the good news is you can do it amicably.
01:08:41
Speaker 24: You can work this out at low cost.
01:08:44
Speaker 28: And my advice to get to that point is I would reach out to a lawyer early or reach out to the Legal Services Commission.
01:08:52
Speaker 24: They have a free legal advice line.
01:08:54
Speaker 28: Lots of lawyers will give you maybe half an hour. They might give you a phone call where you can get some initial generalization. advice about how it all works. So you go in with your eyes opened a bit. The second thing I'd be doing is having a chat to your bank or mortgage broker if you're looking at keeping a house. You might really want to keep that house, but it might not be
affordable for you with the interest rates going up.
01:09:16
Speaker 24: So that can... That can avoid a whole fight.
01:09:21
Speaker 28: If you go and see someone, look at your affordability and go, actually, I can't do this. The other party can't either. We're going to have to sell. Well, there's a whole dispute resolved.
01:09:30
Speaker 29: Yeah.
01:09:31
Speaker 28: You know, then I would suggest contacting places like Relationships Australia, Anglicare. If you're in the regional areas, Uniting Country or Centacare. they offer really cost-effective family dispute resolution or mediation. A private mediation with lawyers might cost you $ 5, 000 for a half a day. But if you go through one of those bodies, it's going to cost you in the hundreds of dollars rather than the thousands. They will actually help you get your pool together. So there's another step that saves time on lawyers.
01:10:05
Speaker 1: Yeah.
01:10:07
Speaker 28: Best case scenario, you might resolve the whole thing at mediation. It might be done and dusted and you walk away with a resolution. But worst case scenario, from my point of view, is that you narrow down the issues. Like, what are we really fighting about here and what's really important? So you might get all the values and all of that stuff out of the way, avoid the need for, you know, getting costly valuations and say, well, look, what's really important to me is that I can be able to get a house that I'm safe and secure with, that both of us have a house. So that can be really, really helpful. And make commercial decisions. There's no point arguing about.
01:10:49
Speaker 24: A cabinet that grandmother left you.
01:10:51
Speaker 28: In your will that's worth $ 1, 500 that might cost you five grand to fight about it.
01:10:55
Speaker 24: You know, think about.
01:10:56
Speaker 22: Yeah, proportionality is the biggest thing, isn't it?
01:10:59
Speaker 18: It is.
01:10:59
Speaker 9: It is.
01:11:00
Speaker 28: And also thinking about the big picture because unfortunately in family law disputes, no one walks away the winner. Everyone's going to be upset because no one's going to get exactly what they want. So rather than focusing on what you want, think about what you can live with that's going to help you make a new start and move on. because compromise can save you a.
01:11:21
Speaker 1: Lot of expense.
01:11:22
Speaker 22: Yeah, pay your compromise.
01:11:25
Speaker 28: Yeah, yeah, one of our directors said that. You either come to a compromise or you pay.
01:11:30
Speaker 22: Yeah.
01:11:30
Speaker 24: So, yeah, yeah, so that's my recommendations.
01:11:34
Speaker 1: Nobody has any problems today, folks.
01:11:35
Speaker 22: 8223 0000.
01:11:37
Speaker 1: No, everyone is just, everything is great. No one's going to get a divorce. No one's got a tree overhanging their property. No one's had an accident that's causing them grief.
01:11:47
Speaker 16: Well, we'll end up in serious financial problems then because we
won't have anyone to help and therefore to pay our fees because everyone's so content and happy.
01:11:57
Speaker 1: Mind you, David says on the text line, if a couple are divorcing after purchasing a house one year ago and the father or the daughter has contributed $ 200, 000 towards the house, will that money be looked at positively towards the daughter when carving up the assets?
01:12:11
Speaker 23: Yes.
01:12:11
Speaker 24: Yes, it will. Short answer.
01:12:13
Speaker 28: So it'll either be treated, depending on how it was made, it'll either be treated as a liability that's got to be paid back in your asset pool, which will reduce your asset pool.
01:12:23
Speaker 24: So whatever percentage.
01:12:24
Speaker 28: You get of that is going to be less, or it will be seen as a contribution made on her behalf, which will mean that her percentage share of the pool might go up.
01:12:36
Speaker 1: Excellent.
01:12:36
Speaker 24: So yes, it will.
01:12:37
Speaker 16: Just a quick one as well before we go to the break. It Family law, like my area of law, is another really good example where small business owners are hammered yet again because in any dispute, whether it be a personal injury dispute or a family law dispute, when it comes to small business, you're just in such a worse off position and people go into these businesses thinking, because they've got an exciting idea. But, you know, there's no rule book and they're not really explained to them just how much harder their life is when it comes to these sorts of things because proving the value of a business is just sensationally difficult as opposed to a PAYE earner.
01:13:23
Speaker 22: Where it's very simple.
01:13:24
Speaker 16: Yes, exactly.
01:13:26
Speaker 22: And that's the same.
01:13:26
Speaker 16: I mean, even in personal injury, it's all about evaluating someone's worth And for poor people that are self-employed, they don't, you know, they minimize their tax and then they're really, the insurers then have it all over them because they can say, oh, look, you don't earn any money because you don't declare much. So it's another lesson for, not another lesson, but it's just another thing for poor business owners just to be conscious about if they're going to If they're going into a divorce-type situation, they've got to be very, very conscious because they're going to pay three times as much as someone that's a PAYE earner.
01:14:06
Speaker 26: Yes.
01:14:07
Speaker 1: We'll take a break. 8223 0000. Ring now with your legal questions. 5AA Mornings with Graeme Goodings. And we're on air for Johnston with his lawyers. Your legal questions, 8223 0000. We'll take a call in a moment. Harry says, G'day, Graeme. How much will the legal fee be for your defence for the pending lawsuit from the bomb? Tim, over to you.
01:14:33
Speaker 16: The defence we will run with, thank you for that person texting him, will be the truth defence. And I think Graeme's got an excellent case, but, you know, I say
that without prejudice, of course. And I'm going to offer Graeme a 10% discount on all of his fees.
01:14:52
Speaker 1: Well, you've advised me. I don't need your advice any longer.
01:14:55
Speaker 10: No.
01:14:55
Speaker 1: I've got all the information I need.
01:14:56
Speaker 28: Correct.
01:14:57
Speaker 22: I've done myself out of that job.
01:14:59
Speaker 1: What do they say about defending yourself? Maybe I won't. Dave, good morning. Good morning.
01:15:04
Speaker 2: I think it should be the insanity defence, not the truth defence.
01:15:09
Speaker 8: Yes.
01:15:09
Speaker 16: Qualified insanity defence, Dave.
01:15:13
Speaker 22: It's a good one.
01:15:15
Speaker 2: You're looking at it across the table from you. What I was wondering is with regards to divorce, a friend of mine's daughter and her husband bought a house about a bit over a year ago. He contributed around $ 200, 000 plus. towards a deposit so they could actually get the house, they are now going through the process of getting a divorce. And I'm actually wondering whether the total value of the asset, the house, is now seen as either a core pool or whether because he can prove how much he's actually put into the house so they can afford to get it, whether the mum and dad bank will actually get their money back.
01:16:01
Speaker 24: Yes, yeah.
01:16:02
Speaker 28: It's a really good question, Dave, and one we see a lot of, you know, especially the whole bank of mum and dad thing with trying to get a property these days. So, yeah, so because that contribution was made so close to separation, it will be seen as a major factor. So I think I answered a text question before the break about how that affects. So it depends on how that was made. So if it was done as a loan that was expected to be paid back, No, it's not.
01:16:34
Speaker 2: So it's potentially seen as a gift, I would assume.
01:16:37
Speaker 16: Yes.
01:16:37
Speaker 28: So what that would go to is the percentage division. So the asset pool is all taken as at today's date, the day they're doing their property settlement. So the value of the property would be what the value is today. Where that contribution will come into effect, though, is how that property pool is divided, the percentage share. So that person would likely get a higher percentage because of that contribution and because it was so close to separation. If that was made 20 years ago, not so much of a percentage adjustment, but because it was just in the last few years, it will be very relevant.
01:17:17
Speaker 2: Thank you very much.
01:17:18
Speaker 24: You're welcome.
01:17:18
Speaker 1: And thanks for your call, Dave. 8223 0000 is the number. Alan says... If a next-door neighbour's kid kicks a ball over the fence and it breaks a screen or windows, are the parents liable?
01:17:34
Speaker 16: I think you could say they're liable because the ball came from their house, if that makes sense. But I suspect, yes, I don't know. It's not going to cause great neighbourly relations, is it? But I think you'd probably have a case to say, you know, you're liable.
01:17:55
Speaker 22: But let's face it, wouldn't you?
01:17:57
Speaker 16: You could claim on insurance, I suppose, and let the insurer could then argue it.
01:18:01
Speaker 1: I mean, I'm thinking my kids kick balls and hit balls over fences all the time. If I broke a neighbour's window or something, I'd feel duty-bound to, you know, pay up.
01:18:10
Speaker 22: Well, that would be the right thing to do.
01:18:12
Speaker 1: Yeah.
01:18:13
Speaker 16: And loco parenti or whatever it is, you've got this sort of overarching responsibility in relation to the child, so.
01:18:22
Speaker 1: And you've got to live with the neighbours, don't you?
01:18:24
Speaker 22: And that would be my thing, yeah.
01:18:27
Speaker 23: Yep.
01:18:27
Speaker 1: Let's take another call. Mark, good morning.
01:18:30
Speaker 5: Good morning, Graeme and team. I just had a quick question regarding the efficacy of a real estate agent. My friend's buying a house in a small country town, two and a half hours away, and they want the same agent they're buying from to sell their existing home here in Adelaide. And I just wondered, is there an efficacy issue with that?
01:18:53
Speaker 22: I don't think. Look, I'll start off by saying, Mark, I've no idea. I really don't know.
01:18:58
Speaker 16: I mean, real estate agents are paid by, obviously, on a percent, the value of the home. Generally, they will use an agent themselves, so they'll use an Adelaide agent, but it shouldn't change the fee arrangement.
01:19:17
Speaker 5: And I did ask, Tim, thanks for your thought on it, but I did ask because the house that they're buying is subject to sale of this one, and in the listing it already says by the agent that we're selling it slightly below market value. And you go, hang on, you're admitting that you're underselling it.
01:19:31
Speaker 12: Yeah.
01:19:32
Speaker 5: Because that's going to secure him the sale in the country town, you see.
01:19:36
Speaker 22: Yeah, I see.
01:19:37
Speaker 3: Yeah.
01:19:38
Speaker 5: I didn't know if it was a legal issue.
01:19:39
Speaker 28: Yeah, I mean, the agents have got an obligation to the person selling, the vendor. That's who they represent and that's who pays their fees at the end of the day. So, you know, they need to be acting in the best interest of their vendor. So if your friends are the vendor here for their property in Adelaide, then, you.
01:19:57
Speaker 24: Know, it might be.
01:20:00
Speaker 16: And the laws, you know, there's some. pretty tight regulations around real estate agents, around pricing, of course, bait advertising. You know, they're well regulated, and I would have thought the real estate agent would have to be very, very careful about how we represented the price there. given there's a perception of a conflict there in that sense. But without, you know, at the end of the day, if he gets a reasonable market
price for it, which could be established, then, you know, I suppose you'd be saying, where are the damages?
01:20:42
Speaker 22: Yeah.
01:20:44
Speaker 1: Finally, we need a quick reply to this. Hi, Robert and Tim. I'm executor for my mum's will with my oldest brother's. We've been granted probate approximately two months ago. Another brother wants to go into a vacant property that is still in the process of being passed over to the person who inherited it and do some repairs. Is this legal?
01:21:05
Speaker 24: Not if they're not an executor. So it's up to the executors.
01:21:09
Speaker 28: Executors normally would have power under a will to do things like that if it needs repairing or insurance or things like that.
01:21:17
Speaker 24: But if he's not an executor.
01:21:20
Speaker 28: Then no, he wouldn't have any legal right to do that.
01:21:24
Speaker 16: Yeah, they'd be wanting to get some legal advice, I would have thought, on that particular question that, yeah, he would not have the power to manage the land in any way like that.
01:21:36
Speaker 23: Mm-hmm.
01:21:37
Speaker 1: Just about time to go. Do we have a lawyer joke of the day?
01:21:41
Speaker 22: I've got an announcement on that.
01:21:43
Speaker 16: You once asked me whether I'd ever run out of lawyer jokes, and I said I wouldn't, but I have.
01:21:49
Speaker 1: I thought it would be bottomless pit.
01:21:51
Speaker 22: But it was... There's a joke in the bottom.
01:21:55
Speaker 16: There's a bottomless pit joke, I think. That's where you find all the best lawyers or something.
01:22:00
Speaker 22: Anyway, but what we.
01:22:02
Speaker 16: Are doing next week is a quick announcement before we have to go, but for... For the texter that texts in the best lawyer joke, it's got to be clean and short because we're going to read it out. they will get a free simple will from Johnston Withers.
01:22:17
Speaker 24: Oh, right.
01:22:18
Speaker 22: Yeah, it's a good competition.
01:22:20
Speaker 1: Can I enter?
01:22:20
Speaker 22: No, you can't.
01:22:23
Speaker 24: There's a conflict of interest.
01:22:25
Speaker 1: There's a classic conflict.
01:22:28
Speaker 22: You're as bad as the real estate agent.
01:22:30
Speaker 1: No.
01:22:31
Speaker 16: No, it's open to the public and it's a free simple will.
01:22:36
Speaker 22: We say simple will.
01:22:38
Speaker 16: We don't really want to have to do, you know, someone's, you know, someone with 18 different family trusts or anything.
01:22:44
Speaker 1: So there it is, folks. If you have a good lawyer joke, maybe direct it to Tim or Robin. I don't know.
01:22:50
Speaker 22: Well, they're not going to win it.
01:22:53
Speaker 16: Anything derogatory to us or Johnston Withers will not be entered.
01:22:56
Speaker 30: No.
01:22:57
Speaker 1: Tim, Robin, thanks for dropping by.
01:22:59
Speaker 24: Thanks, Graeme.
01:23:00
Speaker 1: Thanks, Graeme. When experience matters, trust Johnston Withers lawyers with over 75 years legal experience, johnstonwithers.com.au.
01:23:08
Speaker 3: 5AA Mornings with Graeme Goodings.
01:23:10
Speaker 1: 7 past 11, 5AA, this Thursday morning. News just out. Unemployment figures arise from 4.6% to 4.7%. That is more than was expected by economists. What impact will that have on the RBA? Stay tuned for further developments. Well, on a lighter and a happier note, Christmas is coming. It won't be far away. Can you believe it? We're going to take a look at the hottest toys for Christmas. And joining us from the Australian Toy Association, Executive Manager, Alice Sanderson. Alice, good morning to you.
01:23:42
Speaker 12: Good morning, Graeme.
01:23:42
Speaker 5: How are you?
01:23:43
Speaker 1: Very well, thanks. And I think every parent and grandparent will be listening eagerly because it gets to the time that, you know, what am I going to buy for the kids and grandkids? So how does the Toy Association going about grading the toys?
01:23:57
Speaker 6: Yeah, well, look, it is tough for people, so we're hoping that we can help. So we've got a list that's been published on our website, so austoy.com.au. We've got products that are ranging all different age groups, all different prices, all different categories. So I think there's definitely a few things up there that parents, grandparents, families will be able to find for their kids. Obviously, the squishies are doing quite well. I'm sure you've heard about them, positive and negative. So, yeah, so there's definitely.
01:24:31
Speaker 2: Heaps of squishies up there as well.
01:24:33
Speaker 1: So, I mean, there's a flavour of the month or flavour of the year. Every year something, you know, takes the mantle of the most favourite toy. So it's squishies this year, is it?
01:24:42
Speaker 10: It is, yeah, yeah.
01:24:43
Speaker 6: And, you know, they're becoming a collectible thing. So I think the squishies were designed for as a sensory product. So they're really good for, you know, helping you to concentrate and calm. And they're good for adults as well as children. But now you can get them in all different sizes, colors, shapes, et cetera. So, yeah, there's quite a few of them out there. And they're sort of a lower price point, some of them as well, which is probably– a good thing, and we need to just watch out that we're purchasing them from reputable retailers.
01:25:18
Speaker 1: I was going to say, you know, the quality control. I mean, you don't want to be putting something in the hands of a toddler or a young child that could be harmful.
01:25:27
Speaker 20: Correct, yeah.
01:25:28
Speaker 6: You definitely need to look at the age labelling, and if the product doesn't have age labelling, then it's not to standard.
01:25:35
Speaker 17: So they're all for three plus.
01:25:36
Speaker 6: We don't want babies and toddlers chewing them or eating them or sucking them, that's not what they're there for. So they're really for in your hand, squishing them and, you know, just calming and being
able to concentrate. I've got a couple on my desk, I have to say.
01:25:52
Speaker 1: I was going to say, I was going to say, Alice, it's not just for kids, it's squishies. I think as an adult, there's something very therapeutic about having a squishy or something similar in your hand.
01:26:03
Speaker 6: Yeah, yeah, definitely. I've got one in my hand right now while we're talking, but yeah, it's good when you're, You're trying to concentrate and, as I said, calm the nerves a little bit. So they're definitely good for parents or adults as well, especially with the current climate and the stress that we're all under and the pressure with work and life.
01:26:26
Speaker 1: So what other toys are going off the shelf for Christmas this year?
01:26:31
Speaker 6: So we've got everything from arts and crafts to a lot of buildables. So buildables are a category that does really well every year. So whether it's your bricks or your magnetic tiles or your ball runs as well. So, you know, connecting all the pipes and being able to, you know, push the ball through and it sort of comes out the other end or.
01:26:56
Speaker 6: We do have on the list something that seems to be quite popular is the new version of Tickle Me Elmo. So this is a Tickle Me Max.
01:27:06
Speaker 23: Oh, really?
01:27:07
Speaker 2: Yeah, he's more giggly.
01:27:09
Speaker 6: He's got more points where you can press him and he'll have a little giggle. So he's quite fun.
01:27:16
Speaker 1: So when you're looking at toys, obviously the age group, as a grandparent, you've got to take into account the parents because they– often have a theme or a theory or the sort of things that they want their children to have. And grandparents might see it a little bit differently.
01:27:31
Speaker 6: I think grandparents are not so worried about whether they're noisy products.
01:27:36
Speaker 19: That's for sure.
01:27:36
Speaker 6: I think parents probably don't want them so noisy. But, yeah, I think, you know, grandparents want to spoil their children as we all do. But I think it's also good to get a guide from parents as they know– Their children best, they know what they watch on TV and they know whether they love to draw or create things or use their imagination.
01:27:59
Speaker 1: You mentioned squishies as sort of the flavour of the year. Do trends and patterns change much over 12 months or is it a slower process than that?
01:28:10
Speaker 6: It's probably, well, they do change a bit. But I mean, the nostalgia, which I think we're always talking about, that seems to be a common theme every year. The buildables have been a quite common theme every year.
01:28:23
Speaker 2: But the trends, yeah, they do.
01:28:25
Speaker 6: Come and go. But the squishies, I think they've been going for quite a while now. And it'll be interesting to see what the new trend is. But I'm sure there'll be something around the corner.
01:28:37
Speaker 1: Yeah, I mean, you're only limited by your budget. I at your website at the moment, Pokemon Pikachu Tony Box 2 Starter Set, $ 229. 95. I mean, not cheap.
01:28:48
Speaker 6: No, there's definitely high-priced items, but, you know, if you go through, there's also, you know, $ 6 items and $ 15 items and.
01:28:56
Speaker 17: $ 20 items.
01:28:57
Speaker 6: So, yeah, there's definitely... higher priced items and I think there's always toys that are going to cost a little bit more but there's also toys that are sort of for those middle budgets and the smaller budgets as well. So there's something for everyone I think on the website.
01:29:11
Speaker 1: So what advice would you have for parents or grandparents when buying for Christmas?
01:29:17
Speaker 6: You don't need to purchase too much. I think, you know, children are really just happy to play. And so it's always good to get something that's long lasting. So it's a constant play. It's nice to have something that maybe the parents can play with their children because they do, you know, that builds that social aspect. But also just purchase from reputable retailers. I think that's probably the strongest message. I know it's, you know, the cost of living is an issue at the moment. You know, I see interest rates are going up and which means everything's going up. So I think just make sure you do purchase from reputable because we want to keep children safe as well. Look at those age labels. Make sure you're purchasing for the age of your child to just keep them safe. That's most important.
01:30:01
Speaker 1: Yeah, and buy for the child. I'm thinking back to when my kids were smaller and younger and I'd love to go to toy stores and look around and that. I think a lot of the time I was buying for myself, not for the kids.
01:30:15
Speaker 6: Well, you know, adults can have toys as well, right?
01:30:19
Speaker 2: We have a right to play.
01:30:20
Speaker 6: But if you're purchasing it for the.
01:30:22
Speaker 17: Children, yes, definitely purchase it for the kids.
01:30:26
Speaker 6: But, you know, if you have some fun, then maybe you can pass that fun on to the child and be able to teach them, you know, what you like about the.
01:30:34
Speaker 17: Product as well.
01:30:35
Speaker 6: So it's that engagement piece.
01:30:37
Speaker 1: No, certainly. So if people want to see the hottest toys for Christmas, what's your website?
01:30:43
Speaker 6: Austoy, A-U-S-T-O-Y dot com dot au.
01:30:46
Speaker 1: Excellent. Good on you, Alice. Nice to speak with you. Alice Sanderson, the Australian Toy Association Executive Manager. Yeah, I used to get caught up at times. One thing I used to find where you would get certain toys that need constructing or putting together, I always remember spending Christmas Eve out in the garage into the wee small hours putting together a tent or some construct or bike or chair or whatever it was and i vowed and declared that uh in future just buy things that are already completed didn't always work out that way what do you think's a
good toy for christmas done your christmas shopping have you started really admire people who sort of say you get to this time and say i've done all my christmas shopping how do you manage that 5AA.
01:31:31
Speaker 3: Mornings with graham goodings 20 past 11 5AA you're called shortly on.
01:31:34
Speaker 1: 8223 0000 On the text line, those squishies are a menace. They're actually being banned from many local markets due to toxicity and the dangers of them bursting. They smell like poison that can't be good. Yeah, I must be, I'd say I'd be a little wary of them. And in fact, the ACCC has put out a report. Squishy toys may contain small parts, beads, gel or chemicals that could be harmful to children. Check the safety instructions and supervise young children during play. If a person swallows or inhales the product's contents or develops symptoms after use, seek medical advice promptly. If the toy is damaged, stop using it and keep out of reach of young children. So be warned. Squishies. They might be fun, but if they burst, it could be trouble. Kay, good morning.
01:32:28
Speaker 14: Good morning, Graeme. Can you remember months ago that they dug up Jetty Road, they closed Jetty Road off, the tram had to stop at Brighton Road, a lot of the traders were affected and everything. Anyway, I went down to Jelly Road yesterday, and it's been blocked off again from Partridge Street up to Brighton Road. The tram has to stop at Brighton Road again, and they're digging it all up. And I said to one of the workers, what's happening here? Because no cars can park there. There's only certain areas where you can cross that part of Jelly Road. And I said, what's happening here? And she said, oh, they put down the wrong bitumen, so they've got to dig it.
01:33:06
Speaker 13: All up and relay it.
01:33:08
Speaker 1: Is that right?
01:33:10
Speaker 14: That's fair dinkum. And she said, but she said it will be finished by Friday night, so Saturday morning, no bet. But then she said, I don't know whether the other part from Partridge Street down to Moseley Square has to be done. Well, I presume it would be.
01:33:24
Speaker 1: We think so. You think it would all be done the same way. Yeah.
01:33:27
Speaker 11: Yeah.
01:33:28
Speaker 14: But I just thought, oh, those poor devils. put up with that for months and months and now it's all happening again.
01:33:34
Speaker 1: They're really copying it, aren't they? I really feel for the Jetty Road traders. Look, Kay, thanks for bringing that to our attention. If you're a trader in Jetty Road, give us a call, let us know what the situation is and we'll see if we can find out. So evidently part of the street between Partridge Street and Brighton Road has been closed off and it would appear they've dug up the asphalt because what they put down the first time around Wasn't right. How could they make such a mistake? We'll see what we can find out. Dave, good morning.
01:34:05
Speaker 19: G'day, Graeme. Just a bit of useless information. I was going through my dad's paperwork the other day and I found his old bank book.
01:34:15
Speaker 3: Yeah.
01:34:15
Speaker 19: The Savings Bank of South Australia. Now, dad was born in 33 and the first page of his bank book starts in 1934.
01:34:24
Speaker 7: Yeah.
01:34:27
Speaker 19: And it goes through to 1959. So there's 25 years that the old savings bank was around there. And the back three pages has got a list of all the branches, like the city branches, suburban branches, and the country branches. And I did a quick add-up. There was two in town, 15 suburban, and 26 country. Now, they were actual branches. And then it goes on the list, all the agencies, all the towns with agencies, and there were 325 of them. Is that right? Now, taking into the fact that the Savings Bank is no longer with us, who would we be.
01:35:17
Speaker 1: Better off with?
01:35:20
Speaker 19: Back then or now, taking into account you've got your cards and all that, which I will not use unless absolutely after I believe in cash, would we have been any better off?
01:35:34
Speaker 1: Well, a lot of people would say yes, Dave. There's no question about that. But I don't know. Hindsight's a wonderful thing. You look back and say, ah, you remember it fondly. But were we better off? I don't know. I remember having my own little bank book. I used to take it to school and put, you know, 20 cents or whatever it happened to be into the bank account. And they had those little money boxes. Remember the little money boxes?
01:35:57
Speaker 2: Certainly do.
01:35:57
Speaker 28: Yeah.
01:35:58
Speaker 19: You know, there's like towns here like Port Germain, Port Vincent, Murrayville. and then all over the West Coast that were listed as agents.
01:36:09
Speaker 12: Yeah.
01:36:10
Speaker 19: You'd be buggered to go and find even an ATM in some of those towns.
01:36:13
Speaker 1: Well, that's true, Dave. I mean, yes, service meant something totally different way back then, and I think we all used to respect and love and appreciate our banks and revere them. And I don't know that people feel that same way today about banks. Does anyone love their bank? I'm not so sure. Thanks for your call, Dave. Michelle, good morning.
01:36:33
Speaker 3: Oh, yes.
01:36:33
Speaker 6: Hello, Graham.
01:36:34
Speaker 31: I'm a massive fan of yours and your son's.
01:36:37
Speaker 4: Thank you.
01:36:38
Speaker 31: So I've never spoken on the radio before, but it.
01:36:41
Speaker 32: Was just in regards to the Women's and Children's Hospital, the current one, and I was just thinking, like, why couldn't the government have turned that into an elderly-specific hospital? Like, I know we have a hospital for the women's and children's, which will be a new one, and I know that, like, there are the general five major hospitals.
01:37:03
Speaker 31: But I was thinking, why couldn't they actually make that a hospital for all elderly? So then that would sort of free up, you know, the wards and
people wouldn't be dying with the ramping. But I believe they've sold it, like, and it's going to be an elderly, like, a retirement village. I'm not too sure, but I just know that, like, we need hospitals sort of for all generations. And I thought, like, that would be a really good idea, but.
01:37:32
Speaker 1: Yeah, well, the thing is, and this is where the difference is, Michelle, that aged care is the realm of the federal government. They're the ones that have the money to spend on that. It's not the realm of the state government. So the state government looks after public health and the like and building hospitals, but it's not really within the realm of the state government to build. I take your idea. I take your point. But really, we should be looking at the federal government to be doing that. But in that area, they're not looking after the elderly, are they? Harry, good morning.
01:38:05
Speaker 23: G'day, Graeme. Yeah, it's so true. Yeah, the only conclusion I could come to with Jetty Road was it was an archaeological dig, Graeme. I mean, how many more excuses could they come up with?
01:38:19
Speaker 1: I mean, if this story is true, they've relayed, you know, the whole street, and now they're finding that, oops, we made a mistake. We've got to dig it up and start again. I mean, seriously? I mean, we don't know that that's a fact, but we'll do our best to find out what's going on.
01:38:35
Speaker 23: God, that's frightening. And, Graeme, and just on your behalf, I want to complain on air to the 5AA management for blatant favouritism to other announcers. I mean, one day we've got Leith Forrest living like a king on a cruise ship, and the next day we've got Matthew Pantella hosting some new beauty event.
01:38:54
Speaker 2: Graeme, that's blatant favouritism.
01:38:57
Speaker 23: How come you never get any of these cushy jobs?
01:38:59
Speaker 10: Graeme, what's going on?
01:39:00
Speaker 1: No one's asking me, Harry. Is there a message there, do you think?
01:39:03
Speaker 32: Yeah, I think there is.
01:39:05
Speaker 23: I think, yes, we should get a petition together.
01:39:07
Speaker 10: Good on you, Harry.
01:39:13
Speaker 19: Oh, great.
01:39:13
Speaker 23: I just wanted to say very quickly, headline today, wife of top AFL executive, voices concerned over Nick Blakey trade deal.
01:39:22
Speaker 28: Yeah.
01:39:22
Speaker 23: Saying about the scandal involving Nick Blakey. Well, that's funny because I seem to remember just only a couple of years ago, there was a scandal involving the female cricketers for the Australian cricket team for sexual harassment.
01:39:39
Speaker 3: Yeah.
01:39:40
Speaker 23: One of the younger players had complained about sexual harassment. I thought, oh, it must be, you know, one of the male coaches or trainers or whatever. It was one of her teammates, Graeme. It was against one of her teammates.
01:39:54
Speaker 19: Yeah.
01:39:54
Speaker 23: So it's a bit of the kettle calling the teapot black, don't you think?
01:39:58
Speaker 1: Unfortunately, when you're in the public eye, Harry, it all becomes real. And I think our women's sports are finding that out now that when they were far lower profile... they never seem to get into any trouble, any mischief. We never heard about it. And we've looked at men's sports and thought, what are they doing? They're getting up to a lot of mischief. And now all of a sudden our women's teams are a higher profile and the spotlight comes on you and you can't get away with anything. Craig, good morning.
01:40:25
Speaker 2: Good morning, Graeme.
01:40:26
Speaker 19: Beautiful day out here today, mate.
01:40:28
Speaker 1: Superb, isn't it?
01:40:29
Speaker 23: Superb.
01:40:30
Speaker 10: Yeah, unbelievable.
01:40:31
Speaker 33: Hey, just very quickly, mate, that gentleman a couple of calls ago, just talking about banks and where we're better off and everything, I thought, oh, what an opportune time to call. I just called Pasadena to get some morning tea, and I walk in, and the guy's sort of, his face is always down. He looked a bit sort of upset, and he's always chirping. And the first thing he said to me is, oh, Airpods is out, so, yeah, if you've got to use your card, can't serve you. And customers were walking out left, right, and centre.
01:40:59
Speaker 2: Yeah.
01:40:59
Speaker 10: Poor bugger. I always carry cash, so I was fine.
01:41:02
Speaker 26: I was absolutely fine.
01:41:03
Speaker 33: We had a bit of a five-minute conversation about the whole scenario.
01:41:06
Speaker 10: He hates cards and he hates banks, mate.
01:41:09
Speaker 30: You know, this, like today, will cost him hundreds.
01:41:11
Speaker 1: Yeah, I mean, it is crippling, Craig, for small business when FPOS goes down because that's your life. That's your source of income. And how many, I mean, I don't know about you, but every young person I know doesn't carry cash. They just don't think they need it. I always still carry some cash.
01:41:28
Speaker 20: Yep.
01:41:30
Speaker 1: You never know when you're going to need it.
01:41:31
Speaker 11: Definitely.
01:41:32
Speaker 33: That's right.
01:41:33
Speaker 10: But I really felt for the poor bugger.
01:41:36
Speaker 33: But like I said, it never affects me because I'm always prepared for it.
01:41:39
Speaker 10: So, yeah, all good.
01:41:40
Speaker 11: I just wanted to mention that.
01:41:42
Speaker 1: Good on you, Craig. Yeah, thanks for sharing that with us. Yeah, I think it's good advice. It doesn't have to be much, $ 5, $ 10, $ 20, $ 50 if you can, but carry some cash with you. I've always sort of thought the story, you know, you're in the car driving up to Port Wakefield or somewhere in the, Your fuel gauge is pretty much on empty. You pull into a service station, fill her up, and they say, oh, sorry, the F-POS is down, and you've got no cash. What do you do? Get into strife. My number is 8223 0000. We'll be back after news headlines.
01:42:10
Speaker 3: 5AA Mornings with Graeme
Goodings.
01:42:14
Speaker 1: Final half hour of the show, but still time for you to call in if you'd like to have a chat, 8223 0000. David says, are squishies the modern-day stress ball? Yeah, I guess they are. I guess they are. Stress balls are good. What is it about them? What is the mechanics of it or the technology of a squishy or a stress ball? You squeeze it and you feel a little bit better. Maybe it's a way of getting rid of that pent-up energy. Not so sure. Well, something that's happening tomorrow is Loud Shirt Day. And let's find out more about it now from Lester Wynn-Jones from Can Do For Kids. Lester, good morning to you.
01:42:49
Speaker 17: Good morning, Graeme.
01:42:50
Speaker 2: How are you?
01:42:51
Speaker 1: Very well, thanks. Loud Shirt Day. Any excuse to wear a loud shirt's a good one for me. So what's it all about tomorrow?
01:42:58
Speaker 17: So Loud Shirt Day is something that happens every year, and it's happening on Friday the 16th of October. And it's a really important event in the calendar for Can Do For Kids. And it's really about raising awareness for children with hearing issues and their families. It's a great opportunity for us to talk more broadly about the services that we offer through Candid for Kids and the real difference that early intervention makes for any children that have hearing loss. Sorry, go on.
01:43:35
Speaker 1: No, keep going. You're fine.
01:43:38
Speaker 17: So the activities actually happen across the whole of October and we are very lucky in Can Do For Kids that we have many brilliant supporters across South Australia who join us in wearing loud.
01:43:50
Speaker 30: Shirts to raise the awareness for children with hearing loss.
01:43:54
Speaker 1: So what's the history of Can Do For Kids?
01:43:57
Speaker 17: Yeah, very interesting history. We started in 1874 by William Townsend, who at that time brought the first school for what was then called the deaf and blind. Not terminology that we use today, but he started a very special school to provide education. And we've continued that tradition for over 150 years. And I think we're very lucky that we have a long and rich history in helping children with hearing loss through the Cora Bartley Centre that merged with Townsend House and Can.
01:44:36
Speaker 30: Do For Kids, as we call ourselves today.
01:44:39
Speaker 17: And it gives us a real proud history, but also a real depth of experience of being able to work with very young children with hearing loss and supporting their families.
01:44:49
Speaker 1: When we think about hearing loss, we usually associate it with older people and, you know, It's something that happens later in life. But how prevalent is it among children?
01:45:00
Speaker 30: Well, fortunately, it's not too prevalent.
01:45:03
Speaker 17: And Australia has very good checking systems in place. So from birth, children do have regular hearing tests. So if there's any degradation in hearing, It's spotted very quickly. And
that's something that's absolutely.
01:45:20
Speaker 30: Key for the services that we can provide.
01:45:26
Speaker 17: Early intervention, and I can't stress this importantly enough, is that If something is identified that there's something wrong with hearing, finding it early makes a difference to the long-term prospects. And I think what we have learned is that we work together with Hearing Australia, the Women's and Children's Hospital, for example, and this early intervention means any children can get checked out and really then look at their options for the future.
01:45:55
Speaker 1: I mean, it's very much about raising awareness, and that's a good thing, but you're also raising funds too.
01:46:01
Speaker 17: Yes, that's absolutely right. So the two things go very much hand in hand and people wanting, making sure that people understand what the impact of hearing loss can be, but also what the prospects are for children.
01:46:14
Speaker 30: We work with cochlear.
01:46:18
Speaker 17: Implants, Mundell as well, where children can have a small implant made behind their ear. and they participate in what we call our Listen Unspoken Language Program. It's a very specialized program. Our brilliant team at CanDo for Kids really take this role very seriously, working not only with the children, but also with the parents. And this gives... children sadly with hearing loss real opportunities to have age-appropriate language and do all the things they want to do, all the things that normal kids do in school, in sports, going on to university and going on to careers. And we've got a really good track record in showing that children who are born with hearing loss have lots and lots of potential.
01:47:06
Speaker 1: How much are you hoping to raise?
01:47:08
Speaker 17: Yeah, so this year we're hoping to raise $ 75, 000, and this will go towards our Tiny Tots program. work that we do and this will provide free early intervention support for children with hearing loss and their families and this includes the family groups that we run so that people understand what is going on, what the benefits of the therapy services that people receive and the things they can do at home and outside to support their children's development.
01:47:41
Speaker 1: I guess a parent would pretty quickly know that their child has a hearing impairment, you know, when it doesn't respond and the like. What is the normal progress? You know, they just go and see a GP and take it from there?
01:47:53
Speaker 5: Yeah.
01:47:54
Speaker 17: So many parents don't notice, I think is the simple thing, because obviously in very young babies, the only way.
01:48:03
Speaker 30: Really to check is to have the testing done.
01:48:06
Speaker 17: And we're very lucky in Australia, the standard of testing that's completed is extremely good. So that's why regular testing and or through to school age where, I don't know, I remember myself when I was told to sit nearer the front of the class because maybe I wasn't listening properly sometimes that can be a sign that hearing loss is occurring at a little bit older age and therefore yeah going to a GP getting a specialist to check and coming to an audiologist and you can come to can do hearing we have specialist audiologists for for children and and then checking where you should be against the standards. And then if there's any sign of any problems, you can go for further checks. And that really gives you the knowledge of knowing what your situation is.
01:48:50
Speaker 1: So we all wear a loud shirt day tomorrow?
01:48:54
Speaker 17: It would be great if you would, Graeme, as loud as you possibly can.
01:48:59
Speaker 1: We've got.
01:49:00
Speaker 17: We've got some things going on at work both today and tomorrow. And we've got a number of organizations who've been supporting.
01:49:11
Speaker 1: Is that okay?
01:49:13
Speaker 5: Watch out for Torrance Transport.
01:49:16
Speaker 17: The drivers are wearing green baseball caps with Can Do For Kids on. We've already had events taking place at SA Water, SA Power Networks, CMV, Mercedes, Drake's are a supporter. And this weekend, Friday and Saturday, Nutrition Republic and all the organizations down at Plant 4 in Bowdoin are also raising money. ongoing supporters for can do for kids.
01:49:46
Speaker 1: Great fantastic and uh if anyone wants to support what's the best thing for them to do other than wearing a shirt of course they they.
01:49:54
Speaker 17: Can obviously any of those organizations they see um they can uh they can turn out there they can jump onto our website and there's a um a simple code there to be able to scan with your phone and it'll take you straight to where you.
01:50:07
Speaker 1: Can donate lester great to chat thanks for your time.
01:50:09
Speaker 17: Today Graham, thank you very much.
01:50:12
Speaker 30: And please, please, will you send me a picture of.
01:50:15
Speaker 12: You in your loud shirt?
01:50:16
Speaker 1: All right, okay. You've got me over a barrel. Yeah, I was going to wear one anyway, but all right, we'll do that for you.
01:50:23
Speaker 30: We'd love to.
01:50:24
Speaker 17: We'll post it on our website.
01:50:26
Speaker 30: Graham, thank you to everybody at 5AA.
01:50:28
Speaker 17: We really appreciate all your support.
01:50:31
Speaker 1: Lester Wynne-Jones, can do for kids. What a great idea. Loud shirt day tomorrow. Sam, remind me that. I've got to wear a loud shirt tomorrow. Not one of my normal typical typical conservative shirts and on we have to take a photo and send it on to lester to prove that we've taken part so yeah if you can support not only wear a loud shirt but uh make a donation for a great cause 8223 0000 is the number to ring back shortly 5AA.
01:50:56
Speaker 3: Mornings with graham goodings.
01:50:58
Speaker 1: It's a quarter to 12 5AA free switchboard at the moment so if you've got anything want to get off your chest give me a call 8223 0000 on the text line g'day
graham from harry my entrant joke for a free will. What's the difference between a janitor and a criminal defense lawyer? And that's where we'll leave it. Harry, I can't give your answer. And I don't know that you're going to win the free will kit. Phil says, I always found it ironic that the longer you are married, the worse your hearing gets. Andrew says, I do not want the government intervening in rent charges or anything to do with investors or business. They're currently doing enough damage. If the government could just focus on their job, reduce immigration numbers and build more housing and rent prices would reduce naturally. Jay says, I went to my local OTR server to get my car washed. I needed coins to put in their hand car wash machine. They charged me 25 cents for opening a cash register. OTR are not good corporate business.
01:52:00
Speaker 7: Really?
01:52:00
Speaker 1: Charging you to open their cash register?
01:52:03
Speaker 3: Seriously?
01:52:03
Speaker 1: And they want you to use their business? Most unusual. Here's something the government's been very quiet about. South Australian taxpayers have spent $ 1. 8 million storing and maintaining four hydrogen-capable gas turbines over the past financial year. That's despite the state government's flagship hydrogen energy project collapsing. According to the Auditor-General's latest report, the turbines, purchased for approximately $ 250 million, remain unsold, despite a sales process that began about 12 months ago. The government intended to recover its investment by selling the equipment, provided it was installed in South Australia to improve electricity generation and reliability. The turbines were originally intended for a hydrogen-powered plant at Wyala under the $ 593 million hydrogen jobs plan. Well, the plan was derailed following the Wyala Steelworks entering administration. The report also revealed that some turbine components have yet to arrive with delivery expected by early 27. Opposition leader, or opposition treasurer, Ben Hood, criticised the government, arguing taxpayers had been left with a costly liability rather than the promised financial return. The government has declined to further comment. Now, Tom Koutsantonis, the treasurer, I know his office always listens to this program. Maybe you'd like to ring up and give us a call, because we talked a whole lot about these turbines at one stage there, being part of the salvation of Wyala. And here we are. They're sitting there at the moment. We've spent $ 1. 8 million storing and maintaining them. And that is according to the Auditor General's latest report. What are your thoughts? Love to hear them, 8223 0000. Well, as you've heard, the unemployment rate has unexpectedly jumped to a post-COVID high. It's the second time in a month that they've gone up after nearly 40,000 Australians have fallen out of work. This is what Ross Greenwood had to say shortly afterwards. a short time ago on News 24. It has tipped up a little bit, 4.7%.
01:54:03
Speaker 29: The unemployment rate was tipped to be 4.6%. It is 4.7%. So a little higher than the market expected. We might see some market reaction there. So we'll get some of the reasons for this very, very shortly. But the reality is that, as I say, the unemployment rate in Australia is going higher. It is now a situation whereby unemployment rates at 4.7%. It shows that there were 39,000 fewer people employed during this month and 9,000 more unemployed people. So there's a higher proportion of people remain unemployed in comparison with recent years.
01:54:41
Speaker 1: Now, they've also indicated, Sean Crick.
01:54:43
Speaker 29: Who's the head of ABS Labor Statistics today, is indicating last month there was a higher proportion of people who were previously not in the Labor force employed moving to becoming unemployed. So that's another interesting trend here. So the unemployment rate has risen as well across the whole of our economy. The second part about this is that you've really now seen just a situation where you can see now that this is starting to tip higher. And as it gets closer towards 5%, that's where the government, clearly the amount of tax it takes from PAYG workers is The second factor also is just the stress in the housing markets. As more people become unemployed, it does create more stress in housing markets as well.
01:55:29
Speaker 1: And rental markets on top of this. So this is a response. That's Ross Greenwood on the fact that unemployment rate has hit 4.7%, higher than economists forecast. It was 4.6% before that. Just last week, this is what the RBA chief, Michelle Bullock, had to say about the unemployment rate.
01:55:48
Speaker 34: A rise in the unemployment rate does not necessarily mean job losses. People sort of say, well, that means you're kicking so many people.
01:55:54
Speaker 25: Out of work.
01:55:56
Speaker 34: In fact, the unemployment rate has risen from 3.5% over the past couple of years to 4.6%. And in that time, there's been over a million jobs created. So it doesn't mean job losses. What it often means is that people might be taking longer to find a job. In fact, the most recent increase, just the monthly one.
01:56:17
Speaker 34: There was an increase in the participation rate, so more people came in, but actually there was jobs created as well. So I just want to caution that if we can gradually, if we can lower the inflation rate by lowering demand and we can have a gradual increase in the unemployment rate to a level that isn't putting pressure on inflation, then that doesn't necessarily mean lots of job losses. In fact, it probably doesn't mean that at all What it means is that the number of jobs is growing more slowly than participation in the labour force.
01:56:52
Speaker 1: RBA Chief Michelle Bullock speaking last week on the unemployment rate, saying the rate going up doesn't necessarily mean people have lost their jobs, but the rate has hit 4.7%, and it would
suggest that the RBA, that will confirm the fact that they'll more than likely raise interest rates next time around, which is... what, the first Tuesday in November, Melbourne Cup Day. Geoff wants to know, why is unemployment rising when we're screaming out for immigrant workers to come here? Because, unfortunately, Geoff, it would appear that the people that are unemployed at the moment don't want to do the jobs that are available. They're saying, no, that's not for me. I don't want to pick fruit. I don't want to work behind a bar. I don't want to, you know, sweep floors. I don't want to, I don't want to, I don't want to. And they're obviously happy with Social Security being on the dole. And it works for them. So that's probably why that we are needing to bring people in from overseas. Another lawyer joke that I can't read out.
01:57:51
Speaker 18: Oh, dear.
01:57:52
Speaker 1: 8223 0000, the number to ring. Leith Forrest. G'day, Leith. How are you doing?
01:57:56
Speaker 35: Good morning, Graeme. I saw a great commercial that Jackie Lambie shared on social media about that. I think it was from the Hotels Association of what happens if we have no migrants.
01:58:06
Speaker 28: Yes.
01:58:06
Speaker 35: Yeah have you seen the commercial i have seen button yeah that's right you've got to do it all yourself that's right the mother's telling the uh the son that she needs to wipe his bottom and then the guy goes to the pub to try and get a counter meal and he's all of a sudden cooking and himself because they're all out yeah food for thought interesting debate isn't it how much is too much to send someone to space.
01:58:27
Speaker 1: How much is too much?
01:58:28
Speaker 35: Is $ 100 million to send Catherine Benalpeg too much?
01:58:32
Speaker 1: If it's coming out of the taxpayer's pocket, yeah.
01:58:34
Speaker 35: Three quarters are. So they've raised the $ 250. They need another $ 750. So it's the big debate. What does Albo do? History on one side. Never been an Australian before. Previous astronauts have had to change their nationality. what would it do for the industry? What would it do for women? What would it do for the homeless? What would it do for domestic violence? Love it. Good debate, isn't it? Good debate. And then I saw one of the stats. It's something like one three thousandth of what we're spending on AUKUS. So where do you rank space in terms of defence and all of your very valid points? So we'll look at that today.
01:59:11
Speaker 1: So how much have we raised?
01:59:13
Speaker 35: $ 100 million we need to raise and we've raised.
01:59:15
Speaker 1: $ 25 million.
01:59:18
Speaker 10: Yeah.
01:59:18
Speaker 1: And where's that come from?
01:59:19
Speaker 35: That has come from sponsors.
01:59:20
Speaker 1: Yeah. And that's good. That's good.
01:59:22
Speaker 3: Yep.
01:59:22
Speaker 1: Happy with that.
01:59:23
Speaker 35: They've got to get the other 75.
01:59:24
Speaker 1: I suggested yesterday, and it's probably short-term
notice to do it now, but when they built the Sydney Opera House, you know how they raised the money for that?
01:59:33
Speaker 35: Was it a fundraiser?
01:59:34
Speaker 1: Opera House Lottery.
01:59:35
Speaker 16: Really?
01:59:35
Speaker 1: And for years, even after the Opera House was built, they kept the lottery going and raised millions and millions of dollars and virtually built the Opera House for nothing.
01:59:45
Speaker 35: So the argument would be, too, we need everything in space from GPS to Wi-Fi to this and that. we would not have a seat on the table if we don't give Catherine this opportunity.
01:59:56
Speaker 1: I understand.
01:59:57
Speaker 35: It's great for her. She's not the one who's pushing, hey, send me to space. Everyone else has come out now, Kevin Rudd, Dick Smith and others. So we'll discuss that on the show today, how much is too much. So people might have a thought on that. One of the great South Australian success stories is the Hindley Street Country Club. A group of Adelaide musicians growing through COVID started recording songs and filming little clips in their basement.
02:00:20
Speaker 7: Yeah.
02:00:21
Speaker 35: Became international superstars. They've gone from people watching on YouTube to now selling out the arena at the entertainment centre. These are Adelaide Musos who are coming back. 6,000 seats they've sold for Saturday night's concert. So we're going to speak to them. And also I mentioned to you the other day about one of the great films, part of the Adelaide Film Festival called Coomerank, which is the Aboriginal name for Highmarsh Island. We're going to talk to the director about her film today, which opens this weekend, The Story of the Bridge at Highmarsh Island and the Secret Women's Business. So she will join us this afternoon.
02:00:57
Speaker 1: Massive story in the 90s, wasn't it?
02:00:59
Speaker 35: Well, I think it's, yeah, I think it's going to be revisited too once you re-see it. And it's interesting. So my folks live on Highmarsh Island and they've been having this conversation around, Locally, I'm not sure there was a lot of sympathy at the time, perhaps, for some of the Aboriginal people in the area. I think that's changed over time. So we'll discuss that on the show this afternoon. But you lived through it.
02:01:21
Speaker 3: I hadn't.
02:01:21
Speaker 35: It was like watching a time capsule of Adelaide News from 30 years ago.
02:01:25
Speaker 1: I'd be fascinated to see it. It's amazing how the memory dims, you know, what you recall about it.
02:01:30
Speaker 13: Yeah.
02:01:31
Speaker 1: So I'll look forward to seeing that. It's interesting.
02:01:33
Speaker 35: I would have thought, again, these are 2026 eyes. I would have thought if there's an envelope that says, Only women can read what's inside. Maybe only women should read it. That's me, perhaps.
02:01:44
Speaker 1: Good on you, mate.
02:01:45
Speaker 35: That's not what happened. See you, Graeme. See you from one.
02:01:47
Speaker 1: Lee Forrest coming up this afternoon. From the text line, Andrew says, it's ridiculous funding $ 100 million to put an Australian astronaut into space when we have so many issues that are more of a priority. How about putting it to fixing our deteriorating roads, health, aged care, housing, et cetera? It's elbows wanting state governments to fund this. States should push back and keep that money for more important priorities. And I believe our state government is happy. The Premier is happy to put money towards it. I know the New South Wales government is not interested. The Northern Territory government says no way. Don't know how the other governments have reacted, but I know and I would believe that our Premier is proactive in wanting to put money towards it. The IMF are forecasting the unemployment to rise to the highest in the developed world due to rising inflation and almost flatline productivity. It backs up the RBA's warning. We are headed for a recession. Well done, stupid, selfish government. And David says, whatever happened to the trial of using mirrors and ammonia to generate power for a community near Whaler was supposed to be an alternative to achieving net zero for the future with a stable 24-hour baseload power generation. And regarding Loud Shirt Day tomorrow, a really insightful interview with Leicester Re-Childhood Hearing What a shame that great organisations like VAT and Hutt Street Centre need to spend time and effort raising money when Labor spend hundreds of millions on hydrogen pipe dreams, etc.
02:03:17
Speaker 16: Ah, yes.
02:03:19
Speaker 1: Two in pros. Arguments on both sides. GG, why aren't the government going back to weatherboard or transportable homes for quick build in factory homes as we have a shortage of trades? Wouldn't need brick layers for a start. Remember the weatherboard and transportable homes. Should we go back to that? That's it for today. Thank you so much for your company. We'll be back tomorrow and we'll do it again.