文字起こし 🔗
0:00
When you look across the literature as a whole, there are still a lot of questions that remain around these different dietary interventions. There were certainly some people who didn't appreciate us talking about the skeletons in the closet, but that's the way it goes. Hello and welcome to Existential Threat. So today we'll talk about some of those very trendy diet and lifestyle changes that we hear a lot about, like intermittent fasting and keto and calorie restriction. And we'll see what the science actually says if they're really worth the trouble. Also, some huge downsides that very few people talk about. The perfect person for this conversation is Matt Caroline, who is a renowned expert in the biology of aging, and he actually took the time to dedicate to delving into this literature about nutrition, which was very interesting to me. So let's get into it. And at the end I will also share the principles that I've adopted when it comes to my diet as a result of reading this paper a few years ago and also this recent discussion with Matt, which was very eye opening for me, I hope for you too. First, I was just curious about why a busy guy like Matt took the time to work on nutrition and clarifying what we know about nutrition currently. There were some misunderstandings about, you know, these different dietary regimens that had been sort of popularized not only within the general public, but even within the scientific community, you know, who studied the biology of aging. And so so we really, you know, dove into the question of really trying to to address a couple of issues. You know, one is if you really look at the literature as a whole, how much evidence is there that that that variations of caloric restriction, like protein restriction or ketogenic diet or intermittent fasting on their own extend lifespan or healthspan once you actually control for caloric assumption. Right. And it turns out there really isn't at least for ketogenic diet and intermittent fasting and time restricted feeding, very little evidence. Once you once you take out the caloric restriction piece that they really do much at all in mice. And then also this question of how much can we extrapolate from the animal studies to human biology. And and so we just tried to, you know, tried to take an unbiased approach to really addressing those issues by looking at the literature as a whole and also by recognizing that there is somewhat of a publication bias within the literature where, you know, people tend to favor publishing positive results. And there are actually if you go look for them, you can find plenty of studies where caloric restriction or other dietary interventions didn't have any effect on lifespan. Those tend to get buried and ignored in favor of the the positive studies. And again, just trying to make the point that, you know, when you look across the literature as a whole, there are still a lot of questions that that remain around these different dietary
Load full transcript
interventions. And, you know, I think it was I think it was a good it was certainly beneficial for me in terms of learning a lot of the literature that I sort of knew about but had never done a deep dive into. And I think it had a beneficial impact on the field. More broadly speaking, although there were certainly some people who didn't appreciate, you know, talking about the skeletons in the closet, but that's the way it goes. I got to say that this made me a bit upset because, as you know, I have some chronic conditions, nothing less threatening. But I know that a lot of my friends are dealing with our own issues and it makes us all much more vulnerable to this kind of information because we're kind of desperate to solve a problem. And, you know, in our society, food is seen as something that will either kill you or save you, which is probably both are incorrect in most cases. And and you have these experts and I'm not talking about influencers, I'm talking about actual scientists from reputable institutions who just say things so confidently giving advice to the masses when now you can see that there is no actually solid data behind us. In the best case, it can work for some, but not for others. And it's not only that it's lost that may just waste your time and make you frustrated, but it can also actually cause physical and mental harm. This also makes me wonder if we should start looking at dietary interventions more like we look at drugs. But when you're considering taking a new medication, you seriously weigh the benefits against the side effects. You consult your doctor, you try to understand what the consequences may be. And I think we should implement the same kind of thinking when it comes to making changes in the way we eat. So what we mean when we talk about a dirty drug or a clean drug or a dirty intervention, a clean intervention really just means how specific is the target, right? So from a biochemical perspective, a clean drug would be a drug that only impacts one protein, doesn't impact any other proteins Very, very specific. So rapamycin is a good example of a clean drug based on this definition, because as far as we know, it only impacts mTOR, which is the mechanistic target of rapamycin. That's a protein and in fact it only impacts one complex that interacts. And so it's very, very specific. Contrast that to something like metformin, which has many, many targets and really nobody actually knows for sure what that what the protein target is. That leads to the antidiabetic effect. It's probably not one thing. Probably dozens of things. So so that's that's what we mean by dirty and clean. Now, I think it is important to be clear that those are not like when we say a dirty at least when I say a dirty drug, it's not meant to be, you know, a negative thing. It's just describing the specificity. You can have a very, very potent drug that is very, very beneficial and it can be also very dirty, can have multiple targets. You may not know exactly how it's working. It's really just a biochemical definition. But I do think in the context of lifestyle interventions, those are all as far as I can think of very, very dirty meaning they have many, many biological effects. So if you think about a dietary intervention, you know, there are probably hundreds, if not thousands of chemical reactions in our bodies that are modified by relatively simple dietary interventions. Just think about, you know, increasing your fiber by 100%, doubling the amount of fiber you eat. That's going to have a whole ton of different impacts. Biologically, it's not going to affect just one thing. So really, any lifestyle intervention, exercise, sleep quality, you know, all of these things are going to be very, very dirty. And so, again, that doesn't mean they aren't very potent and can have beneficial effects, but it also increases the risk of side effects because when you're you know, when you're modifying dozens or hundreds of different chemical reactions, the off target effects potentially are going to be negative. And so that's important to recognize. And it also means that it is difficult to really do very mechanistic, scientific studies of something like caloric restriction. I mean, we would all love to say that caloric restriction is increasing lifespan because it does X and it only does one thing, but that's probably not the case because it does dozens of things that are that are probably all interacting to have the net effect that we see on longevity or reproduction or, you know, a whole bunch of other traits or phenotypes that are modified by caloric restriction. So we've established that lifestyle interventions can have more significant and dangerous side effects than medication. That also applies to natural supplements or any any treatment and therapy that we look at as something kind of benign because it doesn't require a prescription. What's interesting is that even the gold standard in longevity circle is calorie restriction that is known to be the the one thing that we know extends lifespan in health span. Even that, as Matt tells us, is not true. There are cases where it causes just the opposite effect in animal models. And then, you know, even if those animal studies weren't so contradicting, we need to really be careful when we extrapolate from animal studies to humans, because this is a very different environmental and also biological situation. So let's see what Matt has to say about that. I personally think we have to be very careful extrapolating from the animal studies to humans when we're talking about something like caloric restriction. So again, you know, this mostly comes from from rodent studies, mice and rats, mice. Recently, rats have sort of, you know, in the last few decades become less commonly used. And in the mouse studies, these are almost always genetically inbred lines. So they're they're not like people where they're, you know, we're genetically diverse. They're
usually a single genotype. And all of the animals are genetically roughly identical to each other. And they live in this very controlled, very sterile environment. And that's completely different than the human situation. And you mentioned bone density and muscle mass mice at least don't really tend to get a lot of sarcopenia as they get older, which is loss of muscle mass and bone density doesn't also doesn't really seem to be a limiting factor, at least for longevity in mice, but in people we know in the elderly, loss of bone density and loss of muscle mass are the primary drivers of frailty, which leads to a whole host of other problems and mortality. And so because caloric restriction certainly can have an impact on bone density and muscle mass as we're getting older, I would be much more concerned about about decreased bone density and decreased muscle mass in people and potentially offsetting any longevity benefits there as opposed to in mice where that probably isn't offsetting the longevity benefits. So this may be a case where caloric restriction actually is very potent from a of anti-aging perspective. And people it very, very well might decrease the rate of biological aging, but that doesn't really matter if you're aging more slowly, but you fall down and fracture your head and die, you're still not living longer. So I think that's a that's a nice case example where an unanticipated consequence that really isn't a problem in the laboratory animals becomes a potentially a huge problem in people. I think infections are another place where this is this is a good, good case. You know, again, because mice in the lab are in this sterile environment. They're called specific pathogen free facilities. They aren't exposed to the same kinds of constant, you know, pathogens that humans are. We know caloric restriction can have a negative impact, at least at least acutely on immune function. It may increase the risk of infection. It may increase the risk of dying due to something like influenza or COVID 19. Again, that would offset any benefit you might get, even if you're aging more slowly. So those are the kinds of things that I that it's worth just thinking about as we try to extrapolate from the animal studies to humans. It is really hard to accept this truth about, I think, life in general, that an intervention or an event can be both good and bad. It can help us in many ways and at the same time be detrimental in other ways. Additionally, what we can really see when it comes to animal studies is the mental impact of certain interventions. And when I say mental impact, not only suffering itself, but how it impacts our lives and our physical health as a result as well. Particularly a very restrictive, you know, dietary or lifestyle regimen, certainly for some people could create, you know, social anxiety, loss of relationships, you know, a stress, higher stress. You would anticipate that those things, you know, could have a certainly a detrimental effect on quality of life and potentially quantity of life as well. And again, in mice, that's not really an issue. They don't they don't have a choice. That's the other thing that's different, right, for people doing caloric restriction, it's a choice, right? You're constantly bombarded with all of these food cues, right? You can't walk down the street without smelling a fast food restaurant. So so it is a different situation where you're making a choice. You are you know, to some extent, I think almost everybody is going to feel like they are, you know, restricting themselves voluntarily, which is hard to do for a lot of people. And so that also may create stress. Again, being fair, that's also possibly could have some beneficial effects. I think we just really don't know because it's so complicated and in humans and there are the mental health components where certainly some people are susceptible to eating disorders and things like that when they try to go on these very restrictive lifestyle regimens. And again, we don't really have that's not something that we can model well in the laboratory animals. So just a side note, with all this talk about the mental impact of nutrition, I couldn't help but wonder about, you know, the similarities between eating disorder language like pro-ana style and the biohacking tech approach kind of advice for longevity. And it's so similar sometimes that it's just striking. I know the context is different. And of course the intention and the goals are different. And I think I think women we have we are slightly more sophisticated about these things, just because we've been exposed to diet messaging since we can remember ourselves, most of us. And so we kind of recognize the red flags. But for men, maybe it's kind of it's processed in a different way. And it's interesting to see that difference while noticing that it can sound and look very similar. Anyway, with all this debunking, I was wondering if Matt had anything that he did feel confident about when it comes to nutrition. So eating a quality diet and this is where I think very rapidly you get into the gray areas, but there are some things that probably everybody would agree falls under the category of quality diet, right? So reducing highly processed foods for sure, reducing foods that have a lot of added sugars, I think almost universally is going to be a net when, you know, cutting out fast food, reducing alcohol, I think is a big one for a lot of people. I know that, you know, it's kind of interesting because there's now it feels like at least among some of the influencers, there's this push to like all alcohol is bad. And, you know, I think you can make an argument certainly based on the epidemiology that that may not be exactly correct. But but the challenge is for a lot of people, you know, one drink a day suddenly becomes two or three or four. So I think in general, for most people, reducing alcohol and probably cutting it out
completely, you know, is for most people probably a win those things. I think it's hard to argue too much with once you get past that, I think then it really becomes individual. Whatever you're eating right, eat a high quality diet, especially if you're calorically restricting intermittent fasting. I think this is one of my concerns with the new GLP one agonist drugs, which work really well. They are very potent at helping people lose weight largely because they suppress appetite. The problems we run into there is if is if people are eating less but they're still eating crap, you know, you're getting less of the nutrients you need and that's a problem. So I think focusing on the quality of the diet is super important. And the other challenge with with the GLP one agonist is most of the people who lose weight, at least from the literature that I've seen, don't take steps to maintain bone density and muscle mass. And so there's a corresponding loss certainly of muscle mass. About half the weight that's lost seems to be muscle mass that's potentially problematic if you regain the weight because you're probably not going to regain the muscle mass. So coupling weight loss with resistance training I think is important. And I would argue also with a higher protein composition in the diet. So those are the kinds of things that I think about. But I try really hard not to get too far into the everybody should eat X amount of protein or everybody should, you know, be ketogenic. I don't think that I don't think that's realistic. That doesn't work there. There's too much variability in what works for people. This was really eye opening. Here's what I decided to do. First of all, I remind myself that, you know, the history of nutrition science and recommendations for the masses has changed so much. There are things that we look at from, I don't know, even ten, 20 years ago that again, we say what? How could they think that that is helpful or healthy? And I'm sure there are things we do today that would seem completely crazy in 20 years from now. So when I hear nutrition advice these days, here are a few things that I ask myself before I decide to do anything. First, I just try to find out what is a trial based on what is the nature and science of the trial to Have there been human trials, or is it only based on animal trials, which as we know, is really limited in how much we can extrapolate for humans? Three. Has it been placebo controlled is really important and we talk about it at length in the video that we'll link here below for This is not foolproof, but you know, using my common sense, does it make sense to eat all my food of the day when 2 hours or does it feel like my my, my stomach hurts just thinking about it? Fine. How does it make how would this change make my body feel, my gut, my sleep, etc.? Six How would it make my mind feel? Would it make me go crazy and think about food all the time and obsess all the time? And most importantly, And maybe that's the first question that I need to ask myself before I make a change in the way I eat is what's my real motivation now to really be honest and ask myself, okay, why am I doing this? Could it be peer pressure? Could it be virtue signaling? Could it be the need to control my body or my body size? And could it be in my case, often helps anxiety? So after I've explored all these questions, I at least have some idea of whether it's worth further exploring what is being offered. But otherwise I really don't rush to make changes because, as we said, nutrition is like a drug in a way, and making changes can have serious side effects. So I take it quite seriously before I make that decision. Lastly, we all crave certainty and food feels like something we can control, but nutrition science is very far from being in a place where we can really know for sure what's the right way to eat. And it seems that the right way to eat is different for different people in different circumstances, environment and stages of life. So what I try to do is just to enjoy the food I love and that feels good with the people I love and to relax about it. I know relaxing is a bit hard for some of us, but we try. But I invite you to join us in part two, where Matt goes way more into detail about what we can do as individuals to maintain and improve our health. He also talks about his very exciting project. So I hope to see you there and thanks so much for sticking around.