文字起こし 🔗
1
00:00:00,320 --> 00:00:02,080
This podcast was created on the lands of
2
00:00:02,080 --> 00:00:03,560
the Wurundjeri people of the Kulin
3
00:00:03,560 --> 00:00:05,600
Nation. We pay our respects to elders
4
00:00:05,600 --> 00:00:07,760
past and present. We acknowledge the rich
5
00:00:07,760 --> 00:00:09,480
history of knowledge, sharing and
6
00:00:09,480 --> 00:00:11,680
storytelling by First Nations people.
7
00:00:12,240 --> 00:00:14,920
Always was, always will be Aboriginal
8
00:00:14,920 --> 00:00:17,800
land. This podcast contains discussions
9
00:00:17,800 --> 00:00:20,160
about adult topics. Use your judgment if
10
00:00:20,160 --> 00:00:21,680
there are little ears around.
11
00:00:22,880 --> 00:00:25,280
Welcome to Doing It. This is a podcast
12
00:00:25,280 --> 00:00:27,680
made by Sexual Health Victoria. We run a
13
00:00:27,680 --> 00:00:29,240
whole lot of education programs for
14
00:00:29,240 --> 00:00:30,960
communities and medical professionals
15
00:00:30,960 --> 00:00:33,400
across Victoria. We also run sexual
16
00:00:33,400 --> 00:00:35,280
health clinics in the city and Box Hill
17
00:00:35,360 --> 00:00:37,600
in Melbourne. My name is Leon, my
18
00:00:37,600 --> 00:00:39,680
pronouns are he/him, and I'm part of the
19
00:00:39,680 --> 00:00:41,920
SHV Schools, Community and Disability
20
00:00:41,920 --> 00:00:44,640
team. We run classes for all year levels
21
00:00:44,640 --> 00:00:47,040
on bodies, growing up, puberty, sex,
22
00:00:47,040 --> 00:00:49,520
reproduction and relationships. This
23
00:00:49,520 --> 00:00:51,281
podcast is for parents and carers of
24
00:00:51,281 --> 00:00:53,441
school-aged children and people working
25
00:00:53,441 --> 00:00:55,761
with young people. This is so we can
26
00:00:55,761 --> 00:00:57,561
share what goes on in a relationships and
27
00:00:57,561 --> 00:00:59,681
sexuality education class and help
28
00:00:59,681 --> 00:01:01,441
support the conversations you might be
29
00:01:01,441 --> 00:01:03,841
trying to have with young people, whether
30
00:01:03,841 --> 00:01:05,761
it's at home or through your work.
31
00:01:06,481 --> 00:01:09,201
Today, I'll be talking to Bec Martin from
32
00:01:09,201 --> 00:01:12,041
Evolve Education. They provide education
33
00:01:12,041 --> 00:01:14,241
on online safety and digital wellbeing to
34
00:01:14,241 --> 00:01:16,201
young people and adults across Australia.
35
00:01:16,881 --> 00:01:18,641
We've had Beck on the podcast a few times
36
00:01:18,641 --> 00:01:20,361
before, and we've brought her back so
37
00:01:20,361 --> 00:01:22,001
that we can talk about something that we
38
00:01:22,001 --> 00:01:24,241
are hearing more about in schools and on
39
00:01:24,241 --> 00:01:26,481
the news, AI deepfakes.
40
00:01:28,881 --> 00:01:30,961
This podcast was done in front of SHV
41
00:01:30,961 --> 00:01:32,801
educators, so you might hear Beck refer
42
00:01:32,801 --> 00:01:35,281
to people in the room. Before we chat
43
00:01:35,281 --> 00:01:37,521
with Beck, let's quickly define AI.
44
00:01:38,241 --> 00:01:40,881
AI, or artificial intelligence, refers to
45
00:01:40,881 --> 00:01:43,201
technology that performs tasks typically
46
00:01:43,201 --> 00:01:45,841
requiring human intelligence. It's used
47
00:01:45,841 --> 00:01:47,681
in many areas such as understanding
48
00:01:47,681 --> 00:01:49,921
written and spoken language, analyzing
49
00:01:49,921 --> 00:01:52,561
data, recognizing images, and making
50
00:01:52,561 --> 00:01:55,321
recommendations. AI is commonly
51
00:01:55,321 --> 00:01:57,441
experienced through voice assistants like
52
00:01:57,441 --> 00:02:00,081
Siri and Alexa. Generative
53
00:02:00,161 --> 00:02:02,961
AI, or Gen. AI, on the other hand,
54
00:02:03,281 --> 00:02:05,441
goes a step further by creating entirely
55
00:02:05,441 --> 00:02:07,521
new content, such as creating images and
56
00:02:07,521 --> 00:02:10,041
videos based on prompts, or services like
57
00:02:10,041 --> 00:02:12,241
ChatGPT for answering questions and
58
00:02:12,241 --> 00:02:14,321
performing tasks. This conversation
59
00:02:14,321 --> 00:02:16,561
speaks about image-based abuse and child
60
00:02:16,561 --> 00:02:19,481
sexual abuse material, or CSAM. So take
61
00:02:19,481 --> 00:02:22,241
care when listening. Now, let's dive into
62
00:02:22,241 --> 00:02:24,641
how young people are using Gen. AI.
63
00:02:27,201 --> 00:02:29,121
So, people may have heard of some terms
64
00:02:29,121 --> 00:02:31,641
around AI, ones that are sometimes linked
65
00:02:31,641 --> 00:02:33,522
to sex or sexuality, but they may not
66
00:02:33,522 --> 00:02:35,482
know what these terms mean. Can you
67
00:02:35,482 --> 00:02:37,722
explain what AI deepfakes are?
68
00:02:38,642 --> 00:02:41,042
So I think a really good place to start
69
00:02:41,042 --> 00:02:42,802
is just talking about deepfakes in
70
00:02:42,802 --> 00:02:45,082
general. So if you've seen the latest
71
00:02:45,082 --> 00:02:47,282
Indiana Jones movie, you would notice
72
00:02:47,282 --> 00:02:49,922
that Harrison Ford appeared with his face
73
00:02:50,242 --> 00:02:52,722
looking 30 years younger. And that's
74
00:02:52,802 --> 00:02:55,082
AI deepfake at play, what we call face
75
00:02:55,082 --> 00:02:57,842
swapping. So taking pictures of Harrison
76
00:02:57,842 --> 00:03:00,002
Ford when he's younger and superimposing
77
00:03:00,002 --> 00:03:02,522
them onto his older self's
78
00:03:02,962 --> 00:03:05,762
face. You'll also see
79
00:03:05,842 --> 00:03:08,162
popular examples on platforms like
80
00:03:08,162 --> 00:03:11,042
TikTok. So there's a deep fake Tom Cruise
81
00:03:11,042 --> 00:03:13,922
who has 5 million followers. It's not
82
00:03:13,922 --> 00:03:16,802
really Tom Cruise. Tom Cruise's official
83
00:03:16,802 --> 00:03:19,602
TikTok page has only 1 million followers.
84
00:03:19,762 --> 00:03:22,122
Right. But very convincing and
85
00:03:22,162 --> 00:03:25,122
uses
Load full transcript
large sets of
86
00:03:25,122 --> 00:03:27,562
data, large sets of Tom Cruise's face to
87
00:03:27,562 --> 00:03:30,002
create, you know, a very realistic deep
88
00:03:30,042 --> 00:03:31,762
fake image using what we call generative
89
00:03:31,762 --> 00:03:34,002
AI. So you've given the examples of
90
00:03:34,322 --> 00:03:35,682
Harrison Ford, Tom Cruise are using
91
00:03:35,682 --> 00:03:37,202
celebrities, but what other kinds of
92
00:03:37,202 --> 00:03:39,762
images are they creating?I think firstly,
93
00:03:39,762 --> 00:03:42,082
just a description of deep fakes. Deep
94
00:03:42,082 --> 00:03:43,882
fake is an image or video where someone
95
00:03:43,882 --> 00:03:46,562
appears to be doingor saying things
96
00:03:46,802 --> 00:03:49,282
that they haven't actually done. Some
97
00:03:49,282 --> 00:03:51,642
other examples are where deep fakes are
98
00:03:51,642 --> 00:03:53,762
being used to scam people. So you might
99
00:03:53,762 --> 00:03:55,682
hear students or your own children
100
00:03:55,682 --> 00:03:58,562
talking about Hamish Blake selling
101
00:03:58,562 --> 00:04:00,722
weight loss gummies on platforms like
102
00:04:00,722 --> 00:04:03,522
Instagram, or Mr. Beast doing
103
00:04:03,642 --> 00:04:06,442
an iPhone giveaway for $2. Things that
104
00:04:06,642 --> 00:04:08,722
are sort of screaming at us as adults
105
00:04:08,722 --> 00:04:11,442
that are too good to be true. And
106
00:04:11,442 --> 00:04:13,522
for our children and young people, it's
107
00:04:13,522 --> 00:04:16,083
not a case anymore of seeing is
108
00:04:16,083 --> 00:04:18,003
believing. We need to be really critical
109
00:04:18,003 --> 00:04:19,603
that what we're seeing isn't, in fact,
110
00:04:19,603 --> 00:04:22,363
real. Are young people
111
00:04:23,123 --> 00:04:25,843
able to easily access the technology to
112
00:04:25,843 --> 00:04:28,723
generate images?Yeah, they are. So
113
00:04:29,603 --> 00:04:32,523
there's a range of ways that-- and what
114
00:04:32,523 --> 00:04:34,563
we're going into now is sort of deep fake
115
00:04:34,923 --> 00:04:36,883
and deep fake nudes is where the problem
116
00:04:36,883 --> 00:04:39,683
really is for schools. deep fake
117
00:04:39,923 --> 00:04:42,643
nudes are very easy to generate. So
118
00:04:42,883 --> 00:04:45,483
another popular case is Taylor Swift. You
119
00:04:45,483 --> 00:04:48,323
might remember last year had a deep fake
120
00:04:48,323 --> 00:04:51,283
nude that went viral on X. It was 19
121
00:04:51,283 --> 00:04:54,003
hours before X took that image
122
00:04:54,003 --> 00:04:56,563
down and it was only after it was mass
123
00:04:56,563 --> 00:04:59,203
reported by her fans. It had
124
00:04:59,203 --> 00:05:01,523
7 million views in
125
00:05:02,563 --> 00:05:05,203
19 hours and 260,000
126
00:05:05,203 --> 00:05:07,563
likes. And what's important to note with
127
00:05:07,563 --> 00:05:09,443
that particular case is that it came
128
00:05:09,523 --> 00:05:11,923
after months of misogynistic online
129
00:05:11,923 --> 00:05:14,643
trolling because she dared to attend
130
00:05:14,883 --> 00:05:17,763
her boyfriend's games. So it was sort
131
00:05:17,763 --> 00:05:19,923
of in an attempt to put her back in her
132
00:05:19,923 --> 00:05:22,643
box. Right. With platforms
133
00:05:22,883 --> 00:05:24,483
like X or any other social media
134
00:05:24,483 --> 00:05:26,963
platform, do they have like
135
00:05:27,043 --> 00:05:29,283
rules around those kind of generated
136
00:05:29,283 --> 00:05:31,043
images aboutmaking sure that they're not
137
00:05:31,043 --> 00:05:32,723
there or is it just a free-for-all on the
138
00:05:32,723 --> 00:05:35,603
platforms?Pretty much unregulated,
139
00:05:35,603 --> 00:05:37,203
free-for-all. If you jump onto
140
00:05:37,203 --> 00:05:39,363
Instagram's explore page, type in any
141
00:05:39,363 --> 00:05:41,203
celebrity and write in AI, you'll get a
142
00:05:41,203 --> 00:05:43,043
really good understanding of just how
143
00:05:43,043 --> 00:05:45,003
prolific these types of images are.
144
00:05:46,403 --> 00:05:48,643
I think too, it's important to note that
145
00:05:48,643 --> 00:05:51,603
these images can be really easily created
146
00:05:51,603 --> 00:05:53,763
simply by taking existing photos of
147
00:05:53,763 --> 00:05:56,324
people. So your LinkedIn headshot,
148
00:05:56,644 --> 00:05:59,204
photos of your holidays on Facebook,
149
00:05:59,364 --> 00:06:02,004
those innocent fully clothed images
150
00:06:02,324 --> 00:06:04,644
can be taken and put through an Undress
151
00:06:04,644 --> 00:06:07,164
or Nudify app, have the clothes removed
152
00:06:07,164 --> 00:06:09,124
and that then creates a very realistic
153
00:06:09,124 --> 00:06:11,684
nude image of somebody without obviously
154
00:06:11,684 --> 00:06:14,284
their consent. So if I think about the
155
00:06:14,284 --> 00:06:15,964
people who probably listen to our podcast
156
00:06:16,124 --> 00:06:17,484
either parents or carers or professionals
157
00:06:17,484 --> 00:06:20,244
working in the field, the risk for
158
00:06:20,244 --> 00:06:23,164
them is if they're posting or
159
00:06:23,484 --> 00:06:25,524
even like storing images of young people
160
00:06:26,204 --> 00:06:27,444
on their social media or on their phones
161
00:06:27,444 --> 00:06:28,564
or that, there's a potential that they
162
00:06:28,564 --> 00:06:31,244
can then be used?Yeah and so that's
163
00:06:31,244 --> 00:06:32,644
something that we've sort of really
164
00:06:32,644 --> 00:06:35,204
advocated for over the past few years is
165
00:06:35,364 --> 00:06:37,044
you know the risks of sharenting or
166
00:06:37,044 --> 00:06:39,844
parents oversharing images of their kids
167
00:06:40,244 --> 00:06:42,884
because you know the technology has
168
00:06:42,964 --> 00:06:45,724
rapidly changed so in the pastWhen
169
00:06:45,724 --> 00:06:47,604
people were creating deep fake
170
00:06:48,084 --> 00:06:50,884
morphology or deep fake images,
171
00:06:51,284 --> 00:06:53,284
it was a slow process. It was done using
172
00:06:53,284 --> 00:06:55,604
programs like Photoshop, cutting out the
173
00:06:55,604 --> 00:06:57,924
face, superimposing it on a body. And
174
00:06:57,924 --> 00:06:59,764
child exploitation material was created
175
00:06:59,764 --> 00:07:02,404
in the same way. We know now
176
00:07:02,404 --> 00:07:05,164
because of how easy these apps are to
177
00:07:05,164 --> 00:07:08,084
use and how quickly people can get
178
00:07:08,084 --> 00:07:11,044
access to images of children, those
179
00:07:11,044 --> 00:07:13,604
images can also be used through these
180
00:07:13,604 --> 00:07:15,604
apps to create what's known as synthetic
181
00:07:16,004 --> 00:07:18,644
child sexual abuse material. Now when we
182
00:07:18,644 --> 00:07:21,324
talk to the AFP and the
183
00:07:21,324 --> 00:07:22,684
Australian Centre to Counter Child
184
00:07:22,684 --> 00:07:24,244
Exploitation, the problem that they're
185
00:07:24,244 --> 00:07:27,044
facing is with the proliferation of
186
00:07:27,044 --> 00:07:29,604
so much synthetic child exploitation
187
00:07:29,604 --> 00:07:32,244
material, they are finding it really hard
188
00:07:32,244 --> 00:07:35,204
to identify children that are in actual
189
00:07:35,204 --> 00:07:37,925
cases of abuse because trying to
190
00:07:37,925 --> 00:07:39,685
determine what is a photo of a child
191
00:07:39,685 --> 00:07:41,605
who's in a current situation where
192
00:07:41,605 --> 00:07:42,965
they're being abused and what is a
193
00:07:42,965 --> 00:07:45,925
synthetic AI image is really challenging.
194
00:07:46,205 --> 00:07:48,045
And so that's why we really heavily
195
00:07:48,165 --> 00:07:51,005
caution parents from over-sharing
196
00:07:51,005 --> 00:07:53,165
images of their kids online and making
197
00:07:53,165 --> 00:07:55,165
sure that if you do share pictures of
198
00:07:55,165 --> 00:07:56,805
your kids online, and we are, we're proud
199
00:07:56,805 --> 00:07:58,485
parents, we want to share and celebrate
200
00:07:58,485 --> 00:08:00,405
those moments with friends and family,
201
00:08:00,805 --> 00:08:02,725
making sure that we do things like having
202
00:08:02,725 --> 00:08:05,445
our privacy settings really tightened up,
203
00:08:05,685 --> 00:08:08,325
being aware of who follows our content
204
00:08:08,605 --> 00:08:10,005
and the type of content we might be
205
00:08:10,005 --> 00:08:12,365
posting on social media platforms. If
206
00:08:12,365 --> 00:08:14,725
people are generating these images using
207
00:08:14,885 --> 00:08:16,765
AI, using existing photos of people,
208
00:08:17,685 --> 00:08:19,925
Is this classed as image-based abuse?
209
00:08:20,645 --> 00:08:23,485
Absolutely, and look, the government, and
210
00:08:23,485 --> 00:08:25,645
particularly eSafety, are doing a lot to
211
00:08:25,645 --> 00:08:27,605
strengthen the laws and legislation
212
00:08:27,605 -->
00:08:30,485
around making these criminal
213
00:08:30,965 --> 00:08:33,685
harms. So creating and distributing these
214
00:08:33,685 --> 00:08:35,525
types of pictures, especially when it's
215
00:08:35,525 --> 00:08:37,845
of people who are under the age of 18, is
216
00:08:37,885 --> 00:08:40,405
absolutely image-based abuse. And there's
217
00:08:40,405 --> 00:08:42,005
lots of different laws that can be
218
00:08:42,005 --> 00:08:44,645
applied in situations, particularly in
219
00:08:44,645 --> 00:08:46,525
schools, where this type of harm has
220
00:08:46,525 --> 00:08:48,685
occurred. We've got laws relating to
221
00:08:48,685 --> 00:08:51,445
using a carriage service to intimidate,
222
00:08:52,085 --> 00:08:54,005
threaten, or harass. So sometimes it can
223
00:08:54,005 --> 00:08:55,925
be followed through with cyberbullying
224
00:08:55,925 --> 00:08:58,325
laws. We've got laws around producing and
225
00:08:58,325 --> 00:09:00,965
distributing child sexual abuse material
226
00:09:01,205 --> 00:09:02,685
as well. And then we've also got new
227
00:09:02,685 --> 00:09:04,525
amendments that came through last year
228
00:09:05,125 --> 00:09:07,445
around classifying deep fake
229
00:09:07,925 --> 00:09:09,885
nudes as a type of IBA.
230
00:09:10,885 --> 00:09:13,845
Because AI-generated images fit in
231
00:09:13,845 --> 00:09:16,085
with altered images, which is already
232
00:09:16,085 --> 00:09:18,085
existing in that image-based abuse law,
233
00:09:18,325 --> 00:09:20,046
but I don't think people might be aware
234
00:09:20,046 --> 00:09:22,046
that things that are created by AI and
235
00:09:22,086 --> 00:09:23,446
even drawings and things like that all
236
00:09:23,446 --> 00:09:25,206
fit in under that same law, so there are
237
00:09:25,206 --> 00:09:27,366
protections there. Yeah, and I think for
238
00:09:27,366 --> 00:09:29,926
parents and carers, image-based abuse
239
00:09:30,166 --> 00:09:32,886
is a tricky term because it's an
240
00:09:32,886 --> 00:09:35,366
umbrella term that covers a lot of
241
00:09:35,366 --> 00:09:38,326
different types of images, how
242
00:09:38,326 --> 00:09:40,726
those images are taken, how those images
243
00:09:40,806 --> 00:09:42,646
might be shared, but the really clear
244
00:09:42,646 --> 00:09:45,366
underlying, I suppose, message with
245
00:09:45,366 --> 00:09:48,286
IBA is it's non-consensual. So that
246
00:09:48,286 --> 00:09:50,766
might be non-consensually taking a photo
247
00:09:50,766 --> 00:09:52,406
of somebody, like what we see in
248
00:09:52,446 --> 00:09:54,966
upskirting or downblazing. It might be
249
00:09:54,966 --> 00:09:57,126
non-consensually sharingimage that was
250
00:09:57,126 --> 00:09:59,206
originally shared with you consensually.
251
00:09:59,526 --> 00:10:01,686
It can contain things like sexual
252
00:10:01,686 --> 00:10:03,486
extortion, people that might be getting
253
00:10:03,486 --> 00:10:05,246
catfished and sharing a nude and then
254
00:10:05,246 --> 00:10:06,966
being extorted for money. That's also a
255
00:10:06,966 --> 00:10:09,526
type of IBA. And now we've got sort of
256
00:10:09,846 --> 00:10:11,606
the 4th quadrant. If you look, Karen
257
00:10:11,606 --> 00:10:13,526
Bredfield has a beautiful graph that
258
00:10:13,526 --> 00:10:15,366
explains in detail different types of
259
00:10:15,366 --> 00:10:18,246
IBA. Digitally altered
260
00:10:18,286 --> 00:10:20,326
images as well. Yeah. So
261
00:10:21,126 --> 00:10:22,486
There's a little bit there in terms of
262
00:10:22,486 --> 00:10:24,846
the legal ramifications that might appear
263
00:10:24,846 --> 00:10:26,286
for a young person. But you've also
264
00:10:26,286 --> 00:10:27,086
touched on something that's really
265
00:10:27,086 --> 00:10:29,286
important, which is potential ethical
266
00:10:29,446 --> 00:10:31,446
issues. So what are some of the ethical
267
00:10:31,446 --> 00:10:34,166
issues around generative AI and deepfakes?
268
00:10:34,486 --> 00:10:36,806
I think the thing we need to be really
269
00:10:36,886 --> 00:10:39,686
mindful of with young people is
270
00:10:40,366 --> 00:10:42,486
when we look at motivations of adults who
271
00:10:42,486 --> 00:10:45,446
perpetrate image-based abuse, they're not
272
00:10:45,446 --> 00:10:47,286
the same as teenagers who might be
273
00:10:47,286 --> 00:10:49,766
engaging in that sort of behavior. Our
274
00:10:49,766 --> 00:10:52,006
teams have an underdeveloped prefrontal
275
00:10:52,006 --> 00:10:54,246
cortex, which might cause them to make
276
00:10:54,246 --> 00:10:56,886
some impulsive decisions, and when you
277
00:10:56,886 --> 00:10:59,366
pair that with how fast you can use these
278
00:10:59,366 --> 00:11:01,047
apps, you can... see that there becomes a
279
00:11:01,047 --> 00:11:03,127
problem, because we're not necessarily
280
00:11:03,127 --> 00:11:05,367
taking the time to think about those
281
00:11:05,367 --> 00:11:07,727
long-term consequences. We've also got a
282
00:11:07,727 --> 00:11:09,847
reward system that's really wanting us to
283
00:11:09,847 --> 00:11:12,007
fit in with our peers, and so sending it
284
00:11:12,007 --> 00:11:14,007
off to the boys, for example, for a bit
285
00:11:14,007 --> 00:11:16,567
of a laugh can lead to some pretty
286
00:11:17,367 --> 00:11:19,487
catastrophic decisions in short amounts
287
00:11:19,487 --> 00:11:22,087
of time. And so I think
288
00:11:23,087 --> 00:11:25,687
When you consider as well that 50% of
289
00:11:25,687 --> 00:11:27,607
year nine to year 12 students don't know
290
00:11:27,607 --> 00:11:29,767
that image-based abuse is even illegal,
291
00:11:30,327 --> 00:11:32,727
you know, we're so quick to sort of whack
292
00:11:32,727 --> 00:11:34,807
them when they're not necessarily aware
293
00:11:34,807 --> 00:11:36,727
that what they're doing is wrong. We need
294
00:11:36,727 --> 00:11:38,447
to provide education to make sure that
295
00:11:38,447 --> 00:11:41,047
they
understand the impacts of the types
296
00:11:41,087 --> 00:11:42,967
of things that they do online. The other
297
00:11:42,967 --> 00:11:45,327
statistic that's worth noting is that 48%
298
00:11:45,327 --> 00:11:47,767
of year nine to 12 students report that
299
00:11:47,767 --> 00:11:49,607
they've been sent a nude, that they
300
00:11:49,607 --> 00:11:52,407
didn't ask for, 35% of 16 to
301
00:11:52,407 --> 00:11:54,607
19 yearhave experienced image-based
302
00:11:54,607 --> 00:11:57,527
abuse. So I think it's important about
303
00:11:57,927 --> 00:12:00,727
this technology is a symptom of a larger
304
00:12:00,727 --> 00:12:03,447
problem, which is that we have
305
00:12:03,767 --> 00:12:06,647
misogyny at play here, and also things
306
00:12:06,647 --> 00:12:09,287
like when there's gender inequality and
307
00:12:09,287 --> 00:12:11,407
rigid gender stereotypes, and then you
308
00:12:11,407 --> 00:12:14,167
have the availability of these types of
309
00:12:14,167 --> 00:12:16,727
programs. it can cause a lot of
310
00:12:16,727 --> 00:12:19,527
harm. Yeah and then obviously
311
00:12:19,607 --> 00:12:20,767
the important thing that you've touched
312
00:12:20,767 --> 00:12:22,287
on a few times is about the education and
313
00:12:22,287 --> 00:12:24,647
so preventative programs ones that you
314
00:12:24,647 --> 00:12:26,327
might offer or we might offer when we get
315
00:12:26,327 --> 00:12:28,007
into schools are really important because
316
00:12:28,007 --> 00:12:30,487
it helps young people to understand what
317
00:12:30,647 --> 00:12:32,247
might actually be problematic like things
318
00:12:32,247 --> 00:12:33,487
like image-based abuse or might be
319
00:12:33,487 --> 00:12:35,527
illegal rather than just them having no
320
00:12:35,527 --> 00:12:37,887
idea at all and then making some poor
321
00:12:37,887 --> 00:12:39,967
decisions later on. Yeah and I think it's
322
00:12:40,007 --> 00:12:42,007
also worth noting that this is a gendered
323
00:12:42,007 --> 00:12:44,848
issue soImage-based
324
00:12:44,848 --> 00:12:46,728
abuse using deep fake nudes
325
00:12:46,728 --> 00:12:49,368
disproportionately affects girls and
326
00:12:49,368 --> 00:12:51,888
women. Julian Grant from the
327
00:12:52,008 --> 00:12:53,608
Safety Commission reported that
328
00:12:53,608 --> 00:12:56,568
ninety-nine percent of deep fake
329
00:12:56,808 --> 00:12:59,368
nudes feature young girls and women.
330
00:12:59,808 --> 00:13:02,568
What?kind of factors
331
00:13:02,968 --> 00:13:05,688
lead to a young person taking part
332
00:13:05,848 --> 00:13:08,808
in these generated images or creating
333
00:13:08,808 --> 00:13:11,448
these images of other young people?So I
334
00:13:11,448 --> 00:13:12,968
think we touched on some of that before
335
00:13:12,968 --> 00:13:14,888
when we talked about that prefrontal
336
00:13:14,888 --> 00:13:17,048
cortex. And when faced with a choice,
337
00:13:17,048 --> 00:13:19,248
teens might be driven sort of by the
338
00:13:19,248 --> 00:13:21,608
immediate emotional or social rewards,
339
00:13:22,168 --> 00:13:24,648
like peer approval or the excitement.
340
00:13:25,528 --> 00:13:27,448
rather than potentially weighing on the
341
00:13:27,448 --> 00:13:29,288
long-term consequences of their actions.
342
00:13:29,608 --> 00:13:31,288
Sometimes we hear from kids or
343
00:13:31,368 --> 00:13:34,208
instigators that justify their
344
00:13:34,208 --> 00:13:37,048
actions as just a joke. We know that
345
00:13:37,048 --> 00:13:39,528
harmful behaviour can sometimes blur with
346
00:13:39,528 --> 00:13:41,928
teens not grasping the emotional or legal
347
00:13:41,928 --> 00:13:44,648
risks of creating and sharing this
348
00:13:44,648 --> 00:13:47,608
type of content. And then we know as
349
00:13:47,608 --> 00:13:49,448
well, again, to circle back to sort of
350
00:13:49,448 --> 00:13:51,448
misogyny is that rhetoric from
351
00:13:51,448 --> 00:13:53,608
influencers like Tate, for example, that
352
00:13:53,608 --> 00:13:56,128
promote harmful attitudes. like the
353
00:13:56,128 --> 00:13:58,888
beliefs that men should have ownership
354
00:13:58,888 --> 00:14:01,048
over women or that women's bodies are
355
00:14:01,048 --> 00:14:04,008
objects to be exploited or
356
00:14:04,008 --> 00:14:06,528
even things like the objectification of
357
00:14:06,528 --> 00:14:08,648
women online can lead to some pretty
358
00:14:08,648 --> 00:14:10,648
confusing messaging for our young people
359
00:14:10,648 --> 00:14:13,528
about what is and isn't okay. And
360
00:14:13,528 --> 00:14:16,248
so I think when you take all of those
361
00:14:16,248 --> 00:14:18,488
things, you know, impulsivity
362
00:14:19,288 --> 00:14:21,488
being shaped by misogynistic or sexist
363
00:14:21,488 --> 00:14:23,248
views again and the
364
00:14:23,888 --> 00:14:26,849
Rapidly available software and
365
00:14:27,049 --> 00:14:29,769
programs that allow us to not only create
366
00:14:29,769 --> 00:14:32,649
but share very quickly can be a tricky
367
00:14:32,649 --> 00:14:35,289
one. The other thing I'll say regarding
368
00:14:36,409 --> 00:14:39,369
kids, and I'm sure people in the room
369
00:14:39,449 --> 00:14:41,089
who work with students and talk to
370
00:14:41,089 --> 00:14:43,369
teachers will hear this all the time. is
371
00:14:43,369 --> 00:14:45,609
when we have online harms
372
00:14:46,289 --> 00:14:48,209
and disclosures of online harms in group
373
00:14:48,209 --> 00:14:49,849
situations, whether it's been things
374
00:14:49,849 --> 00:14:52,249
shared through group chats. Often,
375
00:14:52,729 --> 00:14:54,409
there'll be people that are involved who
376
00:14:54,409 --> 00:14:56,769
might not surprise you, but more often
377
00:14:56,769 --> 00:14:58,809
than not, you'll hear from the kids who
378
00:14:58,809 --> 00:15:00,049
wouldn't normally say boo in the
379
00:15:00,049 --> 00:15:01,609
classroom being involved and
380
00:15:01,609 --> 00:15:03,569
participating in some of these harms
381
00:15:03,569 --> 00:15:06,089
online. And so, yes, there is a
382
00:15:06,089 --> 00:15:08,009
connection between, you know, in cases
383
00:15:08,009 --> 00:15:10,489
like cyberbullying, where people that are
384
00:15:10,489 --> 00:15:13,209
targeted,you know offline will
385
00:15:13,209 --> 00:15:15,849
also be targeted online and instigators
386
00:15:15,849 --> 00:15:18,409
who target offline will also target
387
00:15:18,409 --> 00:15:21,209
online. You sometimes get kids that would
388
00:15:21,209 --> 00:15:23,849
never behave like that in an offline
389
00:15:23,849 --> 00:15:26,369
space engaging in really damaging online
390
00:15:26,369 --> 00:15:29,049
behaviors and what that shows us is there
391
00:15:29,049 --> 00:15:31,569
is still a massive disconnect between
392
00:15:31,569 --> 00:15:33,209
what we do in the real world and what we
393
00:15:33,209 --> 00:15:35,209
do online and that can be tricky for
394
00:15:35,209 --> 00:15:36,889
teenagers because they don't view those
395
00:15:36,889 --> 00:15:38,889
two spaces as different. They view them
396
00:15:38,889 --> 00:15:41,609
as the same. But we know that we
397
00:15:41,929 --> 00:15:44,049
that real disconnect where they haven't
398
00:15:44,049 --> 00:15:46,889
realized the true impact of what they're
399
00:15:46,889 --> 00:15:48,569
doing and how that might hurt somebody
400
00:15:48,569 --> 00:15:50,969
else. Do you think that with those young
401
00:15:50,969 --> 00:15:52,729
people that might surprise us that are
402
00:15:52,729 --> 00:15:55,529
engaging in it, is the reason for
403
00:15:55,529 --> 00:15:58,009
engaging in it still based on that peer
404
00:15:58,009 --> 00:16:00,849
pressure and trying to fit in?I think
405
00:16:00,849 --> 00:16:03,449
peer pressure and trying to fit in is a
406
00:16:03,449 --> 00:16:06,009
huge problem in this space. And something
407
00:16:06,009 --> 00:16:07,690
else that comes up a lot when we talk
408
00:16:07,690 --> 00:16:09,930
about encouraging upstander behaviour,
409
00:16:09,930 --> 00:16:12,090
how do we position our boys and young men
410
00:16:12,170 --> 00:16:14,530
to be advocates and allies to gender
411
00:16:14,530 --> 00:16:17,290
equality and to these types of issues, is
412
00:16:17,290 --> 00:16:19,530
one of the major roadblocks when we talk
413
00:16:19,530 --> 00:16:22,330
to, particularly boys, is they are
414
00:16:22,330 --> 00:16:24,290
terrified of being labelled a snitch or a
415
00:16:24,290 --> 00:16:27,050
dobber. And so we need
416
00:16:27,050 --> 00:16:29,130
to work through those problems with young
417
00:16:29,130 --> 00:16:31,370
people so thatwe remove those roadblocks
418
00:16:31,370 --> 00:16:33,130
to them speaking up. And we also need to
419
00:16:33,130 --> 00:16:35,850
be careful as parents that when our kids
420
00:16:35,850 --> 00:16:38,450
do come to us for help, that in seeking a
421
00:16:38,450 --> 00:16:40,810
solution or standing up for someone else,
422
00:16:40,810 --> 00:16:42,730
that we don't inadvertently throw our own
423
00:16:42,730 --> 00:16:45,170
child under the bus with their peers. So
424
00:16:45,170 --> 00:16:46,650
in a lot of cases where we have group
425
00:16:46,650 --> 00:16:48,890
chats happening on WhatsApp, maybe your
426
00:16:48,890 --> 00:16:50,490
child's come forward and said, hey, I've
427
00:16:50,490 --> 00:16:53,010
seen this photo being flicked around in a
428
00:16:53,010 --> 00:16:55,370
group chat, or the chat's really toxic,
429
00:16:55,770 --> 00:16:57,610
and they've gone straight to the school.
430
00:16:58,490 --> 00:17:01,370
that can have a really damaging outcome
431
00:17:01,370 --> 00:17:03,370
on their child. So we need to make sure
432
00:17:03,370 --> 00:17:04,970
that we work in consultation with our
433
00:17:04,970 --> 00:17:07,850
kids and we do the right thing, but we
434
00:17:07,850 --> 00:17:09,410
also do it in a way that's not going to
435
00:17:09,410 --> 00:17:11,010
harm our child. Or
436
00:17:11,290 --> 00:17:13,650
professionals working in the space,
437
00:17:13,650 --> 00:17:14,930
whether it's like preventative, as I was
438
00:17:14,930 --> 00:17:17,370
talking about, or even reactionary, is
439
00:17:17,370 --> 00:17:20,330
there a risk?of targeting
440
00:17:20,410 --> 00:17:22,610
the group of young boys and talking to
441
00:17:22,610 --> 00:17:24,930
the group of young boys only that that
442
00:17:24,930 --> 00:17:27,170
can either exacerbate the issue or just
443
00:17:27,170 --> 00:17:29,450
make them feel victimized in this space.
444
00:17:29,930 --> 00:17:32,370
Yep, totally agree with what you're
445
00:17:32,370 --> 00:17:35,050
saying. So when we do discuss these
446
00:17:35,050 --> 00:17:36,730
types of harms, we need to do it in a
447
00:17:36,730 --> 00:17:39,090
collective way. It's about how can we, as
448
00:17:39,090 --> 00:17:41,130
a community, collectively respect each
449
00:17:41,130 --> 00:17:43,450
other online. And even things like when
450
00:17:43,450 --> 00:17:45,930
we're doing examples, creating scenarios
451
00:17:45,930 --> 00:17:47,330
for students who want to use gender
452
00:17:47,330 --> 00:17:49,611
neutral language, we don't want to create
453
00:17:49,611 --> 00:17:52,131
an atmosphere of defensiveness before
454
00:17:52,131 --> 00:17:54,731
we've even started. And so part of
455
00:17:54,731 --> 00:17:57,131
positioning, you know, young boys
456
00:17:58,171 --> 00:18:01,051
as being a solution to the problem is
457
00:18:01,051 --> 00:18:02,891
not making them feel like they're likely
458
00:18:02,891 --> 00:18:04,971
to become a perpetrator. So it's like
459
00:18:04,971 --> 00:18:06,171
highlighting the fact that it is a
460
00:18:06,171 --> 00:18:08,011
gendered issue without that being the
461
00:18:08,011 --> 00:18:09,611
only thing that you talk about for your
462
00:18:09,611 --> 00:18:11,371
hour and a half session with them. And I
463
00:18:11,371 --> 00:18:13,651
think that's the real difficulty in this
464
00:18:13,651 --> 00:18:16,411
space is because... And look, the flip
465
00:18:16,411 --> 00:18:17,771
side of this too, we're doing a lot of
466
00:18:17,771 --> 00:18:19,531
work on sextortion at the moment, which
467
00:18:19,531 --> 00:18:21,371
is also a gendered issue where boys are
468
00:18:21,371 --> 00:18:23,531
disproportionately targeted by that harm,
469
00:18:24,011 --> 00:18:25,411
is you're dealing with gendered issues,
470
00:18:25,411 --> 00:18:27,131
but the way that we educate in a
471
00:18:27,131 --> 00:18:29,051
preventative way actually needs to not be
472
00:18:29,531 --> 00:18:31,331
gendered. It needs to be very gender
473
00:18:31,331 --> 00:18:33,571
neutral. And I think part of the problem,
474
00:18:33,571 --> 00:18:35,011
if we talk about misogyny and the
475
00:18:35,011 --> 00:18:37,771
manosphere, boys don't become
476
00:18:37,771 --> 00:18:40,011
radicalized and end up in those spaces.
477
00:18:40,251 --> 00:18:41,851
They're seeking to understand
478
00:18:41,851 --> 00:18:43,771
explanations to how they're feeling. They
479
00:18:43,771 --> 00:18:45,611
go into those spaces and that's wherethey
480
00:18:45,611 --> 00:18:48,171
become radicalised. And so to come in
481
00:18:48,171 --> 00:18:49,931
with this sort of finger wagging,
482
00:18:50,331 --> 00:18:52,931
you're all doing this and this is your
483
00:18:52,931 --> 00:18:54,531
fault and these are harms that your
484
00:18:54,891 --> 00:18:56,811
gender are perpetrating is really
485
00:18:56,811 --> 00:18:58,211
damaging and does nothing to help the
486
00:18:58,211 --> 00:19:00,771
problem. And it's really difficult to not
487
00:19:00,771 --> 00:19:03,291
do that. It's so easy to go into that
488
00:19:03,291 --> 00:19:04,851
space and do the finger wag and do the
489
00:19:04,851 --> 00:19:06,891
finger point, but as we say, we know it's
490
00:19:06,891 --> 00:19:08,451
damaging and so it's difficult to
491
00:19:08,451 --> 00:19:10,091
sometimes, I think, take that step back
492
00:19:10,411 --> 00:19:11,851
and say, right, well, I've just got to go
493
00:19:11,851 --> 00:19:13,851
into this space and just educate and try
494
00:19:13,851 --> 00:19:15,211
to get everyone to come on board with the
495
00:19:15,211 --> 00:19:17,771
messagewithout having someone switch off
496
00:19:17,771 --> 00:19:19,531
because I've said all of you are the same
497
00:19:19,531 --> 00:19:20,611
and you're all going to do this thing
498
00:19:20,611 --> 00:19:22,571
that's problematic. And I think too,
499
00:19:22,571 --> 00:19:24,411
putting my teacher hat on, that's where
500
00:19:24,411 --> 00:19:27,051
facilitating really great conversations
501
00:19:27,051 --> 00:19:29,532
rather than coming in top down with this
502
00:19:29,532 --> 00:19:31,292
is what, you know, what to think.
503
00:19:31,612 --> 00:19:33,932
Actually getting kids to explore
504
00:19:34,172 --> 00:19:36,852
examples in the everyday media
505
00:19:37,412 --> 00:19:40,052
of gender inequality, getting them to
506
00:19:40,092 --> 00:19:43,052
discuss things in a critical way together
507
00:19:43,652 --> 00:19:44,932
and letting them come to their own
508
00:19:44,932 --> 00:19:46,172
conclusions. about
509
00:19:47,532 --> 00:19:50,212
how our views are shaped towards
510
00:19:50,212 --> 00:19:52,532
women can be a great way of doing that
511
00:19:52,532 --> 00:19:55,172
too. So we've talked a lot about the
512
00:19:55,292 --> 00:19:56,972
creation of the images, why people might
513
00:19:56,972 --> 00:19:59,052
be creating these images. What kind of
514
00:19:59,132 --> 00:20:01,812
impact can the creation of these images
515
00:20:01,812 --> 00:20:04,332
have on the person who the image is of,
516
00:20:04,332 --> 00:20:06,412
or I guess the people that are creating
517
00:20:06,412 --> 00:20:09,212
the images?Yes, so put
518
00:20:09,212 --> 00:20:11,532
yourselves in the shoes of a young girl
519
00:20:11,532 --> 00:20:14,092
that's had this shared around. Imagine
520
00:20:14,092 --> 00:20:15,612
it's happened over the weekend and you've
521
00:20:15,612 --> 00:20:18,332
got to come to school on Monday morning.
522
00:20:18,812 --> 00:20:21,692
So even if friends and family know
523
00:20:21,692 --> 00:20:24,652
that the images are fake, the emotional
524
00:20:24,652 --> 00:20:27,412
impact on that victim is profound.
525
00:20:28,492 --> 00:20:30,812
The fact that you can do nothing wrong
526
00:20:31,612 --> 00:20:33,372
and have this done to you, the total loss
527
00:20:33,412 --> 00:20:35,692
of autonomy, and also as well for
528
00:20:36,172 --> 00:20:38,812
victim survivors targets,It's knowing
529
00:20:38,812 --> 00:20:41,772
that the onus for taking
530
00:20:41,772 --> 00:20:44,332
care of that now is on you. So you've had
531
00:20:44,332 --> 00:20:46,972
no hand in this image being created, but
532
00:20:46,972 --> 00:20:49,732
now it's on you to manage monitoring
533
00:20:49,732 --> 00:20:51,692
where it might appear, making sure that
534
00:20:51,692 --> 00:20:54,252
it gets taken down, reporting it, going
535
00:20:54,252 --> 00:20:56,052
through a legal process to make sure that
536
00:20:56,052 --> 00:20:58,252
you get an outcome. And so
537
00:20:58,892 --> 00:21:01,452
the feeling of violation, I think, for
538
00:21:01,852 --> 00:21:04,692
targets is really high. The
539
00:21:04,732 --> 00:21:07,132
other thing that we hear from kids
540
00:21:07,292 --> 00:21:10,092
is sometimes a slight silver lining,
541
00:21:10,252 --> 00:21:11,933
that when deep fake nudes were being
542
00:21:11,933 --> 00:21:14,013
shared around, some students reported,
543
00:21:14,013 --> 00:21:15,853
Well, I'm glad that that happens, because
544
00:21:15,853 --> 00:21:17,973
at least now if my real nude image gets
545
00:21:17,973 --> 00:21:20,173
shared around, I can use that as an
546
00:21:20,173 --> 00:21:23,053
excuse,
you know, that it's not real, it
547
00:21:23,053 --> 00:21:24,573
wasn't me, it's a deep fake.
548
00:21:26,333 --> 00:21:29,213
And so what can also cause these images
549
00:21:29,213 --> 00:21:31,613
to spread really rapidly is kids love to
550
00:21:31,613 --> 00:21:33,933
speculate. Is it real, or isn't it real?
551
00:21:34,013 --> 00:21:35,693
And so that can actually cause these
552
00:21:35,693 --> 00:21:37,573
images to go viral and to be flicked
553
00:21:37,573 --> 00:21:39,693
around, because kids will look at them,
554
00:21:39,693 --> 00:21:41,773
and they're trying to pick whether it's a
555
00:21:41,773 --> 00:21:44,493
deep fake or real. And the excitement of
556
00:21:44,493 --> 00:21:46,733
the potential that it is real, depending
557
00:21:46,733 --> 00:21:48,813
on who the image is of, would keep that
558
00:21:49,213 --> 00:21:50,453
conversation going and keep the
559
00:21:50,453 --> 00:21:53,213
generation going as well. Yeah, and so
560
00:21:53,213 --> 00:21:55,773
some of the impactsAnd I'll talk
561
00:21:55,773 --> 00:21:58,693
about individual impacts,
562
00:21:58,693 --> 00:22:00,893
and then maybe some bright... the broader
563
00:22:00,893 --> 00:22:03,453
societal problems is obviously emotional
564
00:22:03,853 --> 00:22:06,253
and psychological distress, social
565
00:22:06,253 --> 00:22:09,053
isolation and stigma, so kids not wanting
566
00:22:09,053 --> 00:22:11,013
to come to school, not wanting to engage
567
00:22:11,013 --> 00:22:13,453
in extracurricular activities or social
568
00:22:13,453 --> 00:22:14,973
events which can further lead to their
569
00:22:14,973 --> 00:22:16,733
feelings of isolation. Future
570
00:22:16,733 --> 00:22:19,213
relationships, that feeling of who's done
571
00:22:19,213 --> 00:22:21,693
this?Why would someone do this?That
572
00:22:21,693 --> 00:22:23,773
distrust that they might have in future
573
00:22:24,573 --> 00:22:26,253
relationships that can impact things like
574
00:22:26,253 --> 00:22:28,613
intimacy and mistrust or fear of future
575
00:22:28,613 --> 00:22:30,733
exploitation. AndAnd as well, sort of
576
00:22:30,733 --> 00:22:32,813
legal and school-based challenges. So
577
00:22:32,973 --> 00:22:35,573
sometimes when we talk to the
578
00:22:35,573 --> 00:22:37,693
victims or targets of image-based abuse,
579
00:22:37,693 --> 00:22:40,053
because we're navigating quite
580
00:22:40,053 --> 00:22:42,893
complex legal structures,
581
00:22:42,893 --> 00:22:45,173
depending on what types of laws the
582
00:22:46,013 --> 00:22:47,813
local police use, whether it's federal
583
00:22:47,813 --> 00:22:49,853
law or local law, the outcomes can
584
00:22:49,853 --> 00:22:52,173
change. And depending on how equipped a
585
00:22:52,173 --> 00:22:53,934
school is to deal with disclosures of
586
00:22:53,934 --> 00:22:56,854
this type of online harm,It can sort
587
00:22:56,854 --> 00:22:59,534
of amplify feelings of injustice if that
588
00:23:00,014 --> 00:23:02,014
target doesn't feel like there's been
589
00:23:02,574 --> 00:23:04,894
appropriate justice. And it's interesting
590
00:23:04,894 --> 00:23:06,894
too because when we talk to teachers who
591
00:23:06,894 --> 00:23:09,214
have been targeted by this type of online
592
00:23:09,214 --> 00:23:11,694
harm, they share really similar feelings.
593
00:23:11,974 --> 00:23:14,014
They feel like the law didn't support
594
00:23:14,014 --> 00:23:16,134
them because it was teacher and student
595
00:23:16,134 --> 00:23:18,054
based and that the school was trying to
596
00:23:18,054 --> 00:23:20,014
protect the student but then the teacher
597
00:23:20,014 --> 00:23:21,294
feels that they weren't sort of
598
00:23:21,294 --> 00:23:23,854
necessarily protected or covered or that
599
00:23:23,854 --> 00:23:25,214
might not have been a consequence or
600
00:23:25,214 --> 00:23:28,094
outcomethey felt was just or appropriate.
601
00:23:28,774 --> 00:23:31,294
When we talk about these sorts of harms,
602
00:23:31,694 --> 00:23:33,614
we do sort of report them as discrete
603
00:23:33,614 --> 00:23:35,934
forms of psychological injury, but I
604
00:23:35,934 --> 00:23:37,734
think we do need to
605
00:23:38,734 --> 00:23:40,414
make sure that we look at a broader
606
00:23:40,414 --> 00:23:42,974
cultural context that's at play
607
00:23:43,294 --> 00:23:45,334
and sort of consider these harms from a
608
00:23:45,334 --> 00:23:47,694
more nuanced perspective because they are
609
00:23:47,694 --> 00:23:50,134
symptomatic of a larger problem that's
610
00:23:50,134 --> 00:23:52,334
happening in society at the moment. Yeah.
611
00:23:53,374 --> 00:23:56,014
I guess the big questionis what can
612
00:23:56,014 --> 00:23:58,494
people do to support someone who's had
613
00:23:58,494 --> 00:24:00,774
this happen to them?And maybe if we start
614
00:24:00,774 --> 00:24:02,334
by talking about what can schools do?
615
00:24:02,654 --> 00:24:04,454
There's sort of two arms to this. And
616
00:24:04,774 --> 00:24:07,454
when we work with teachers, we
617
00:24:08,094 --> 00:24:09,974
sort of look at it through two lenses.
618
00:24:09,974 --> 00:24:11,774
There's always prevention, and then
619
00:24:11,774 --> 00:24:13,294
there's responding. And usually schools
620
00:24:13,294 --> 00:24:14,974
come to us because they're responding,
621
00:24:14,974 --> 00:24:16,334
they're reacting, something's happened.
622
00:24:18,494 --> 00:24:20,694
And so we know as well an important point
623
00:24:20,694 --> 00:24:22,974
is when we do our programs we often start
624
00:24:22,974 --> 00:24:24,614
with responding because teachers don't
625
00:24:24,614 --> 00:24:26,174
want to have a conversation about these
626
00:24:26,174 --> 00:24:28,014
issues because they're often scared of
627
00:24:28,014 --> 00:24:30,174
what might come up in the classroom. And
628
00:24:30,174 --> 00:24:32,174
so building teacher capacity to feel
629
00:24:32,174 --> 00:24:33,734
really capable in responding to
630
00:24:33,734 --> 00:24:35,255
disclosures of online harm actually needs
631
00:24:35,255 --> 00:24:37,695
to come first before we put in place
632
00:24:37,935 --> 00:24:39,535
preventative programs like digital
633
00:24:39,535 --> 00:24:42,015
citizenship. or digital safety
634
00:24:42,015 --> 00:24:43,695
workshops so that everyone feels
635
00:24:43,695 --> 00:24:45,695
comfortable about what things can come up
636
00:24:45,735 --> 00:24:47,775
and you would know all sorts of things
637
00:24:48,255 --> 00:24:50,335
can come up with a special. So what can
638
00:24:50,335 --> 00:24:52,415
schools do?Well, teachers, especially in
639
00:24:52,415 --> 00:24:54,415
times of panic and especially as a
640
00:24:54,415 --> 00:24:56,455
parent, you might be on fire on the
641
00:24:56,455 --> 00:24:59,375
inside, but we need to be cool, calm
642
00:24:59,375 --> 00:25:01,615
and collected and what can help do that
643
00:25:01,615 --> 00:25:04,175
is a script. for that time of panic. And
644
00:25:04,175 --> 00:25:07,135
so clear messaging around thanking that
645
00:25:07,135 --> 00:25:08,855
young person for coming to you. I'm so
646
00:25:08,855 --> 00:25:11,695
glad you told me. I believe you and
647
00:25:11,695 --> 00:25:13,935
really importantly, this is not your
648
00:25:13,935 --> 00:25:16,095
fault because we know that
649
00:25:16,455 --> 00:25:18,655
particularly again from girls and women,
650
00:25:19,135 --> 00:25:20,775
even in cases where they've done nothing
651
00:25:20,775 --> 00:25:22,175
wrong, they will still exhibit victim
652
00:25:22,175 --> 00:25:24,655
blaming attitudes towards themselves. And
653
00:25:24,655 --> 00:25:26,735
I think, you know, helping young people
654
00:25:26,735 --> 00:25:28,575
collect evidence is important but of
655
00:25:28,575 --> 00:25:30,495
course with any type of online harm that
656
00:25:30,495 --> 00:25:32,175
features nude images of children, we need
657
00:25:32,175 --> 00:25:33,775
to be reallythankful that as teachers and
658
00:25:33,775 --> 00:25:36,095
parents we never collect those images
659
00:25:36,095 --> 00:25:38,255
ourselves. For schools,
660
00:25:38,735 --> 00:25:41,535
eSafety has a fantastic toolkit for
661
00:25:41,535 --> 00:25:44,495
schools. We help teachers implement that
662
00:25:44,495 --> 00:25:46,575
and embed it across their whole school
663
00:25:46,575 --> 00:25:49,135
setting where you can triage
664
00:25:49,135 --> 00:25:51,895
and respond to different types of
665
00:25:51,895 --> 00:25:53,695
disclosures of online harm because what
666
00:25:53,695 --> 00:25:55,895
you think is really serious, somebody
667
00:25:55,895 --> 00:25:58,735
else might think is mild. And so
668
00:25:58,815 --> 00:26:01,695
learning how to triage those disclosures
669
00:26:01,695 --> 00:26:04,655
from mild to severe and then having clear
670
00:26:04,655 --> 00:26:06,895
steps of how you're going to respond
671
00:26:06,895 --> 00:26:08,495
because for a
lot of teachers they don't
672
00:26:08,495 --> 00:26:10,415
know how to respond. These harms might be
673
00:26:10,415 --> 00:26:11,935
totally new to them, they might not even
674
00:26:11,935 --> 00:26:14,415
be on social media. And so having a clear
675
00:26:14,415 --> 00:26:15,775
pathway to work through is really
676
00:26:15,775 --> 00:26:18,376
valuable. You might
677
00:26:18,376 --> 00:26:20,256
be in Victoria where you'd be making a
678
00:26:20,256 --> 00:26:22,496
report for this type of harm to Socket
679
00:26:23,336 --> 00:26:26,176
and Victoria Police. The other
680
00:26:26,176 --> 00:26:29,056
thing that can be forgottenparticularly
681
00:26:29,136 --> 00:26:31,416
by adults, is we are so protectionist in
682
00:26:31,416 --> 00:26:32,816
nature. We are really quick to sort out
683
00:26:32,816 --> 00:26:34,816
the problem online. We try and sort out
684
00:26:34,816 --> 00:26:37,056
the problem for them at school and manage
685
00:26:37,056 --> 00:26:39,376
that and then we go job done. But we
686
00:26:39,376 --> 00:26:42,016
really need to monitor and continually
687
00:26:42,016 --> 00:26:43,936
check in over the weeks following to make
688
00:26:43,936 --> 00:26:45,536
sure that that young person is coping
689
00:26:45,536 --> 00:26:48,176
okay because we know re-traumatisation
690
00:26:48,176 --> 00:26:50,016
with resurfacing of these images, for
691
00:26:50,016 --> 00:26:52,496
example, can be an ongoing problem. What
692
00:26:52,496 --> 00:26:55,256
can the adults at home do to
693
00:26:55,256 --> 00:26:58,136
support these young people?So when
694
00:26:58,136 --> 00:27:00,256
we work with parents and carers, one of
695
00:27:00,256 --> 00:27:02,536
the key messages we deliver through our
696
00:27:02,536 --> 00:27:04,816
communicate chapter
697
00:27:05,056 --> 00:27:07,376
is that speed and support are key.
698
00:27:08,016 --> 00:27:09,856
In order to deal with these harms, you
699
00:27:09,856 --> 00:27:11,736
need to know that they've happened, and
700
00:27:11,736 --> 00:27:13,616
if there are barriers to kids speaking
701
00:27:13,616 --> 00:27:14,976
up, they're not going to come to you for
702
00:27:14,976 --> 00:27:17,696
help. So first and foremost, it's looking
703
00:27:17,696 --> 00:27:19,816
at the barriers that stop teenagers in
704
00:27:19,816 --> 00:27:21,776
particular from coming forward to us as
705
00:27:21,776 --> 00:27:24,096
parents and carers. Those things are fear
706
00:27:24,096 --> 00:27:27,056
of removal of their device,Fear
707
00:27:27,056 --> 00:27:28,816
of being labelled a dobber or a snitch,
708
00:27:29,136 --> 00:27:31,216
and this one. fear of being judged and
709
00:27:31,216 --> 00:27:33,776
shamed, how could you be so silly?So as
710
00:27:33,776 --> 00:27:35,616
parents, if we can remove some of those
711
00:27:35,616 --> 00:27:37,376
barriers and let our young people know
712
00:27:37,376 --> 00:27:38,736
that there's nothing that they could ever
713
00:27:38,736 -->
00:27:41,096
do that would make us love them less, and
714
00:27:41,096 --> 00:27:43,456
to come to them quickly, that's the first
715
00:27:45,936 --> 00:27:47,376
way that we can be aware that these
716
00:27:47,376 --> 00:27:50,256
images have happened. And I
717
00:27:50,256 --> 00:27:52,896
think as well, there's a few
718
00:27:52,896 --> 00:27:54,896
pathways and a few organisations out
719
00:27:54,896 --> 00:27:56,616
there that can certainly help parents and
720
00:27:56,616 --> 00:27:58,577
carers. Sometimes it can be really
721
00:27:58,577 --> 00:28:00,417
confusing with online harms to know
722
00:28:00,417 --> 00:28:02,777
whether you're reporting to eSafety or to
723
00:28:02,977 --> 00:28:05,217
ACE. Julian McGrant
724
00:28:05,937 --> 00:28:08,817
recently was talking about the reporting
725
00:28:08,817 --> 00:28:11,377
pathways and said in a lot of cases young
726
00:28:11,377 --> 00:28:13,857
people don't necessarily want to push for
727
00:28:13,857 --> 00:28:16,497
criminal action or criminal
728
00:28:16,497 --> 00:28:19,217
charges. They just want the content to be
729
00:28:19,217 --> 00:28:22,017
taken down. So in a lot of cases where
730
00:28:22,017 --> 00:28:23,857
nude images of under-18s have been
731
00:28:23,857 --> 00:28:25,857
shared, you'd go to ACE. Sometimes for
732
00:28:25,857 --> 00:28:28,097
IBA we go to eSafety. That can feel
733
00:28:28,097 --> 00:28:30,657
confusing for teachers and parents. Go to
734
00:28:30,737 --> 00:28:32,857
either. They work hand in hand. And if
735
00:28:32,857 --> 00:28:34,737
you go to the wrong organisation, it
736
00:28:34,777 --> 00:28:36,017
doesn't matter, there is no wrong
737
00:28:36,177 --> 00:28:38,337
organisation. They will give you a warm
738
00:28:38,337 --> 00:28:41,217
referral to where you need to go. And
739
00:28:41,217 --> 00:28:43,937
also deep fake nudes can be lodged
740
00:28:44,097 --> 00:28:46,337
with NECMEC, which is an
741
00:28:46,497 --> 00:28:48,857
organization who can create basically a
742
00:28:49,057 --> 00:28:51,057
hash, like a thumbprint of that picture,
743
00:28:51,697 --> 00:28:54,657
and scan social media platforms
744
00:28:54,657 --> 00:28:57,457
like Instagram. So if that image surfaces
745
00:28:57,497 --> 00:28:59,057
on those social media platforms, it's
746
00:28:59,057 --> 00:29:01,937
recognized and taken down. It's a bit of
747
00:29:01,937 --> 00:29:04,417
a whack-a-mole approach, but it's just
748
00:29:04,417 --> 00:29:07,377
anotheroption that you can
749
00:29:07,377 --> 00:29:09,697
offer to young people to help reassure
750
00:29:09,697 --> 00:29:11,537
them that there's support out there for
751
00:29:11,537 --> 00:29:14,097
them. I think hopefully what's comforting
752
00:29:14,097 --> 00:29:16,177
for schools or adults at home is that...
753
00:29:17,057 --> 00:29:18,417
Everything that you said just then is
754
00:29:18,577 --> 00:29:19,857
really the messages that we give them
755
00:29:19,857 --> 00:29:21,617
about any kind of disclosure, any kind of
756
00:29:21,617 --> 00:29:23,257
harms that might appear for young people,
757
00:29:23,257 --> 00:29:25,217
and it's just applying it to a new
758
00:29:25,217 --> 00:29:27,457
context with a few extra specialist
759
00:29:27,457 --> 00:29:28,977
organisations to follow up with. So
760
00:29:29,457 --> 00:29:30,737
hopefully that makes it a little bit
761
00:29:30,977 --> 00:29:32,897
easier to process what we're kind of
762
00:29:32,897 --> 00:29:34,977
talking about today. Yeah, and I think
763
00:29:35,137 --> 00:29:37,697
something else that's interesting, and I
764
00:29:37,697 --> 00:29:40,018
think what we'll see in this space is a
765
00:29:40,018 --> 00:29:42,458
real change, is a bit of a shift from the
766
00:29:42,458 --> 00:29:44,418
digital footprint discussion.
767
00:29:45,178 --> 00:29:46,738
particularly in cases of
768
00:29:47,458 --> 00:29:50,018
non-consensual nudes being shared or
769
00:29:50,018 --> 00:29:52,738
sexual extortion. Kids getting really
770
00:29:52,738 --> 00:29:54,738
strong messaging that if your nude is
771
00:29:54,738 --> 00:29:57,378
shared, your life is over, is so, so
772
00:29:57,378 --> 00:29:59,498
damaging. Because you can have the best
773
00:29:59,498 --> 00:30:01,658
family support, wrap around, friends that
774
00:30:01,658 --> 00:30:03,658
are really there for you. But if you feel
775
00:30:03,658 --> 00:30:05,418
like society's going to judge you for the
776
00:30:05,418 --> 00:30:06,978
rest of your life because your nude was
777
00:30:06,978 --> 00:30:09,538
shared in year 10, that's a really hard
778
00:30:09,538 --> 00:30:11,938
pill to swallow for a young person. So I
779
00:30:11,938 --> 00:30:13,378
think we need to look at some of the ways
780
00:30:13,378 --> 00:30:15,778
we discuss online safetytopics as well in
781
00:30:15,778 --> 00:30:18,098
the classroom. Yeah. I am conscious that
782
00:30:18,098 --> 00:30:20,138
we have talked about a lot of the
783
00:30:20,178 --> 00:30:23,138
negatives today. Are there any positives
784
00:30:23,138 --> 00:30:25,618
to generative AI?I think there's lots of
785
00:30:25,618 --> 00:30:28,018
positives out there with generative AI.
786
00:30:28,178 --> 00:30:29,698
And I think what's interesting is
787
00:30:29,698 --> 00:30:31,578
generative AI has even actually been used
788
00:30:31,578 --> 00:30:34,298
to combat a lot of online harm. So I know
789
00:30:34,338 --> 00:30:35,778
that eSafety are doing some pretty
790
00:30:35,778 --> 00:30:38,418
interesting work in using bots to
791
00:30:38,418 --> 00:30:40,738
perhaps flag to users if they're viewing
792
00:30:40,738 --> 00:30:43,618
CSAM, that perhaps they're engaging
793
00:30:43,618 --> 00:30:46,258
or looking at materialsthat's potentially
794
00:30:46,258 --> 00:30:48,738
damaging or problematic. So I know
795
00:30:48,738 --> 00:30:51,538
there's cases where AI is also
796
00:30:51,538 --> 00:30:53,458
being utilised across
some social media
797
00:30:53,458 --> 00:30:55,618
platforms to try and identify
798
00:30:56,178 --> 00:30:58,738
synthetic child sexual abuse material and
799
00:30:58,738 --> 00:31:00,218
make sure that it's removed and doesn't
800
00:31:00,218 --> 00:31:01,818
spread. So there's definitely positive
801
00:31:01,818 --> 00:31:04,738
applications where they're, not to go
802
00:31:04,738 --> 00:31:06,258
back to the negative, but where there's a
803
00:31:06,258 --> 00:31:08,818
problem isThe spaces like these
804
00:31:08,818 --> 00:31:10,818
Undress and Nudify apps, for example, get
805
00:31:10,818 --> 00:31:13,138
massive investor funding, and so they
806
00:31:13,138 --> 00:31:15,538
proliferate at a much faster rate than
807
00:31:16,098 --> 00:31:18,738
the organizations who are trying to use
808
00:31:18,738 --> 00:31:21,218
AI to combat those harms. You've got
809
00:31:21,539 --> 00:31:24,499
really big, big piles of money, and
810
00:31:24,499 --> 00:31:26,979
tech giants competing against people like
811
00:31:27,019 --> 00:31:29,899
eSafety who are trying to utilize
812
00:31:29,899 --> 00:31:32,539
and encouragetech giants to do things
813
00:31:32,539 --> 00:31:34,499
like safety by design to make sure that
814
00:31:34,899 --> 00:31:37,579
they're creating programs that are safe
815
00:31:37,579 --> 00:31:39,939
and ethical. Bek, are there any
816
00:31:40,099 --> 00:31:42,339
last messages or anything-- is there
817
00:31:42,579 --> 00:31:45,139
anything you want to say about generative
818
00:31:45,139 --> 00:31:47,819
AI or this landscape for young people or
819
00:31:47,819 --> 00:31:50,139
their trusted adults?If you
820
00:31:50,739 --> 00:31:53,379
have a look yourself at App Store and
821
00:31:53,379 --> 00:31:55,939
Google Play and type in words like nudify
822
00:31:55,939 --> 00:31:58,139
and undress,you'll get a really good
823
00:31:58,139 --> 00:32:00,739
understanding of what's out there. A lot
824
00:32:00,739 --> 00:32:03,459
of these apps are rated for 4
825
00:32:03,459 --> 00:32:06,139
plus. You'll see very quickly they might
826
00:32:06,139 --> 00:32:09,099
be marketed as trying on different
827
00:32:09,099 --> 00:32:11,939
outfits and toning up bodies, but you can
828
00:32:11,939 --> 00:32:13,499
see very quickly that there is a
829
00:32:13,499 --> 00:32:15,059
nefarious application that's being
830
00:32:15,059 --> 00:32:17,779
promoted there. Particularly
831
00:32:18,019 --> 00:32:20,819
if you look at the definition or like the
832
00:32:20,819 --> 00:32:23,259
promotional quote that goes alongside
833
00:32:23,259 --> 00:32:25,499
those apps. I can read you a couple just
834
00:32:25,499 --> 00:32:27,939
so. Sure. So these are just a few that
835
00:32:27,939 --> 00:32:29,699
are readily available in the App Store.
836
00:32:29,939 --> 00:32:31,859
Nudify any girl with the power of AI.
837
00:32:31,859 --> 00:32:33,659
Just choose a body type and get a result
838
00:32:33,659 --> 00:32:35,859
in
a few seconds. Undress anyone
839
00:32:35,859 --> 00:32:38,219
instantly. Just upload a photo and the
840
00:32:38,339 --> 00:32:40,419
Undress AI will remove the clothes within
841
00:32:40,419 --> 00:32:43,299
seconds. Imagine wasting time
842
00:32:43,299 --> 00:32:45,579
taking her out on dates when you can just
843
00:32:45,579 --> 00:32:48,099
use redacted site to get her
844
00:32:48,099 --> 00:32:50,819
nudes, so sending some pretty
845
00:32:50,819 --> 00:32:52,899
confusing messages to our young people
846
00:32:52,899 --> 00:32:54,819
about what's acceptable behavior, yeah,
847
00:32:54,899 --> 00:32:57,099
and that's just in the like bio for the
848
00:32:57,139 --> 00:32:58,779
app, like it doesn't actually get in
849
00:32:58,779 --> 00:33:00,179
there, and it's a whole... whole
850
00:33:00,179 --> 00:33:01,619
different field. And a lot of these apps
851
00:33:01,619 --> 00:33:04,180
are free. And also, they're
852
00:33:04,180 --> 00:33:06,260
promoted heavily. So interestingly, in
853
00:33:06,260 --> 00:33:09,140
the last 12 months,
854
00:33:09,140 --> 00:33:11,940
there's been a massive increase
855
00:33:11,940 --> 00:33:14,260
in the places that these apps are
856
00:33:14,260 --> 00:33:16,940
promoted in. So I think it's 2,400%
857
00:33:17,100 --> 00:33:19,700
increase
858
00:33:19,780 --> 00:33:22,740
in the advertising of these apps to young
859
00:33:22,740 --> 00:33:25,060
people on the platforms that they use, ex
860
00:33:25,060 --> 00:33:27,780
Instagram, Reddit, for example. Yeah,
861
00:33:28,020 --> 00:33:29,860
so increase in advertising means increase
862
00:33:29,860 --> 00:33:32,220
in usage, which means increase in cases
863
00:33:32,220 --> 00:33:33,300
of what we've talked about today.
864
00:33:33,540 --> 00:33:35,700
Absolutely. They've been marketed towards
865
00:33:35,740 --> 00:33:37,620
our young people aggressively, and there
866
00:33:37,620 --> 00:33:40,500
is little to no explanation as to the
867
00:33:40,500 --> 00:33:43,300
legal ramifications of their misuse. So
868
00:33:43,380 --> 00:33:45,620
something else that parents and carers
869
00:33:45,620 --> 00:33:48,140
can do is to really empower
870
00:33:48,580 --> 00:33:50,340
their children and young people to be
871
00:33:50,340 --> 00:33:53,060
upstanders. and to position our young
872
00:33:53,060 --> 00:33:55,020
boys as allies and advocates for gender
873
00:33:55,020 --> 00:33:57,780
equality and to speak up. If they see
874
00:33:57,780 --> 00:33:59,700
this happening, often these images are
875
00:33:59,700 --> 00:34:02,340
shared through group chats and oftentimes
876
00:34:02,820 --> 00:34:05,140
lots of children are aware, and so
877
00:34:05,140 --> 00:34:07,620
getting them to speak up. And also really
878
00:34:07,620 --> 00:34:09,940
talking to our kids from an early age
879
00:34:09,940 --> 00:34:12,660
about the need to be really critical of
880
00:34:12,660 --> 00:34:15,220
the media that they're consuming, to be
881
00:34:15,220 --> 00:34:17,540
mindful of rigid gender
882
00:34:17,540 --> 00:34:20,180
stereotypes and gender inequality when
883
00:34:20,180 --> 00:34:22,740
they see that. can be a great way of
884
00:34:22,820 --> 00:34:24,620
combating some of the ways that we might
885
00:34:24,620 --> 00:34:26,500
be viewing women. It's that proactive
886
00:34:26,500 --> 00:34:28,580
conversation of both technology and all
887
00:34:28,580 --> 00:34:29,500
the stuff that we've talked about that
888
00:34:29,500 --> 00:34:31,780
relates just to technology, but also the
889
00:34:31,780 --> 00:34:33,700
larger conversation around sex or
890
00:34:33,700 --> 00:34:36,140
sexuality or gender discussions that will
891
00:34:36,140 --> 00:34:38,100
help that too. And so having those, as
892
00:34:38,580 --> 00:34:40,580
you say, age-appropriate ways, which is
893
00:34:40,780 --> 00:34:42,220
going to look different for who you're
894
00:34:42,220 --> 00:34:43,940
talking to, but can be really beneficial
895
00:34:44,340 --> 00:34:46,581
in this conversation as well. And really
896
00:34:46,581 --> 00:34:48,901
open conversations around consent. Bec,
897
00:34:48,901 --> 00:34:51,741
this has been extremely informative and
898
00:34:51,741 --> 00:34:53,621
interesting and engaging. And I know that
899
00:34:53,781 --> 00:34:54,981
the listeners are going to feel the same
900
00:34:54,981 --> 00:34:56,501
way. So I really appreciate your time.
901
00:34:56,501 --> 00:34:58,421
Thanks for coming on the podcast. Thank
902
00:34:58,421 --> 00:35:01,301
you so much for having me. Thanks to
903
00:35:01,301 --> 00:35:03,861
Bec for that chat. Here are some key
904
00:35:03,861 --> 00:35:05,461
things that stood out for me in this
905
00:35:05,461 --> 00:35:08,341
discussion. Young
906
00:35:08,341 --> 00:35:10,741
people don't know that creating deepfakes
907
00:35:10,821 --> 00:35:12,181
is image-based abuse.
908
00:35:14,021 --> 00:35:16,141
We need to rethink how we think about
909
00:35:16,141 --> 00:35:17,221
digital footprints.
910
00:35:18,661 --> 00:35:20,821
Reporting these incidents works in the
911
00:35:20,821 --> 00:35:22,981
same way as other disclosures.
912
00:35:24,541 --> 00:35:26,941
While this is a gendered issue, talk to
913
00:35:26,941 --> 00:35:29,421
all young people in non-gendered ways and
914
00:35:29,421 --> 00:35:31,221
encourage them to be upstanders.
915
00:35:32,341 --> 00:35:34,341
Bec mentioned some resources, and we have
916
00:35:34,341 --> 00:35:36,661
them and some others in the show notes.
917
00:35:37,541 --> 00:35:39,101
You can find out more about Bec and
918
00:35:39,101 --> 00:35:40,501
Evolve Education at
919
00:35:40,501 --> 00:35:42,701
evolve-edu.com.au.
920
00:35:44,021 --> 00:35:46,221
For more information about SHV, you can
921
00:35:46,221 --> 00:35:48,061
visit shvic.org.au
922
00:35:49,301 --> 00:35:52,181
or follow us on LinkedIn, YouTube,
923
00:35:52,421 --> 00:35:54,941
Instagram, and TikTok. You can
924
00:35:54,941 --> 00:35:56,661
contact us directly at
925
00:35:56,661 --> 00:35:59,141
doingit@shvic.org.au.
926
00:36:00,581 --> 00:36:02,661
Subscribe or follow the podcast wherever
927
00:36:02,661 --> 00:36:05,621
you listen so you don't miss out. Thanks
928
00:36:05,621 --> 00:36:06,101
for listening.