文字起こし 🔗
Ann Marie McHenry: Dr. Bluma Sapir is a clinical psychologist with over 20 years of experience in individual and pair therapy, working with couples, adult siblings, parent-adult child relationships, close friends, and workplace pairs, and most recently training as a life coach. Her work addresses both common and complex relational challenges, including chronic conflict, betrayal, trauma, sexual concerns, fertility journeys, and life stage transitions. A central focus of her work is adult-sibling relationships, co-authoring I'm Right, You're Stupid. To examine how unresolved sibling dynamics shape attachment and conflict across the lifespan. Her approach as a life coach through her pair coaching model, helping individuals and pairs translate insight into durable relational change. She's the mother of five, bringing lived insight to her clinical and coaching work. Welcome, Dr. Bluma Sapir. Thank you so much for joining me on Conversations with Women Who Lead. I would love to hear about what you do and your experience to start.
Dr Bluma Sapir: Thank you, thank you, Emory, for having me. It's real pleasure to be here. So, you know, when I think about what led me or drew me to my work, I think about that phrase that people say, me search research, if ever heard that before, right?
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: You know, it's not like it was a professional decision at first. I think that it was something that I lived with a long time before I ever really had language for it. So I grew up in a pretty chaotic, complicated, confusing environment. And I found myself assigned to a role that I think many people would be familiar with, but wouldn't necessarily name or know how to name. I look at it as being the emotional bridge in my family. So I served that role between my parents when they fought and eventually divorced. And I served that role for my mother in dealing with my other siblings. So I think that I was doing a lot of paying attention, a lot of mediating, a lot of interpreting feelings, a lot of... you know, trying to help people find repairs. And I think that what I, you know, noticed or sensed were that these dynamics were bigger or felt bigger than just one person. So at the time, I didn't really feel like this was work. It just felt very necessary for me, you know? And I think that over time, I've learned to be very deeply attuned to what happens between people, not only within one person. And so I think that that was the thread that followed me into
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: my professional life and led me to become a psychologist.
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm. And so tell me more about your work as a psychologist.
Dr Bluma Sapir: Sure, so I have spent most of my career working with individuals and couples. And what I've continued to notice is that so much of our suffering and our healing happens in the space between two people. That can happen between an individual adult. and a mental health professional in their own individual healing and when it comes to relationships between couples. So I think that I found that the more that I worked with couples, the more that I saw that the healing didn't happen in isolation. It didn't happen within only one person's nervous system, but rather the interaction between those two nervous systems. whether it was the misattunements or the longings or the attempts to repair. So over time, I started to think about this more broadly. And so, yes, couples, but also parent adult child pairs and siblings and best friends and professional partnerships. And I started to kind of look at this as pair work, right? That
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: these duo relationships that shape us, that challenge us, that often stay with us across a lifetime. now my work really is trying to help people who want to look at themselves individually and also look at their relationships to try to find where they can use this history to build strengths and build cooperation and really build a broader sense of what it means to be a pair in a relationship in the world. Yeah.
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm, yeah. I love that you're calling those relationships pairs because you know started to specialize in working with couples and then realized that there's more to relationships than just people who are partnered in a couple. There's parent-child, there's siblings, there's friendships, there's all kinds of pairs that we are just in relationship with another person and that's two people are involved. So I love that you're calling it pairs.
Dr Bluma Sapir: Thanks.
Ann Marie McHenry: It sounds like your interest in getting into working with relationships started with your younger years, your childhood, growing up in a large family, watching the dynamics between your parents and probably a lot of other people because you had siblings and more people involved in your life, I'm sure. Can you tell me about how you became Dr. Blumas up here and the research that you did as you got your doctorate?
Dr Bluma Sapir: Sure. So, right. So I remember actually the day that I decided I wanted to be a psychologist. I was in eighth grade and I had gone
Ann Marie McHenry: Okay.
Dr Bluma Sapir: to my own psychologist and I had one meeting and I told, poured my heart out and then she invited my mother to come in for a private conversation and when they came out they started talking about all the things that I had just shared. And
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: it was so jarring and I remember thinking, I'm gonna grow up and become a psychologist and keep everybody's secrets.
Ann Marie McHenry: Yeah.
Dr Bluma Sapir: And that was the impetus to starting. In graduate school, I felt like I finally found a home for the way that my brain thinks.
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: When I heard learning about different disorders, I found so much compassion. for people and a clarity. I felt like a lot of my life I was so confused by behaviors because I didn't
Load full transcript
really understand how to think about them. And then this
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: gave me this framework to really start to. growing up on the border of El Paso, know, El Paso, Texas and
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: Mexico, I was always in what I would consider a multicultural community. In fact, for very long, I felt like I was Mexican even though I'm not from Mexico, like I just, the culture, I mean, when I make food, my comfort food is always enchiladas, beans and rice. like, know, it's a very,
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: know, culture is a big part of my understanding about how human beings operate. I, in fact, looking at, you know, when I started doing couples work and studying it in school and, you know, it was at the very beginning and I focused on it for most of my... most of, until I, mean, forever. That's really been my focus as couples and culture. And those two things go hand in hand.
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: I think that, so, and then ultimately when I was, you know, I also, think that spirituality and religion, you
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: know, sometimes gets a bit of a bad rap in the psychology kind of mental health field.
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm. Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: You know, it's, might even consider it as the softest science of them all. But I think that it is a huge part of how we relate to the world. And so I also felt like there's a lot of healing that can be found in those kind of wisdom traditions. so I ended up writing my dissertation with a know, comprehensive literature review, looking at the spiritual practice within the Jewish culture and
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: really rounded out my understanding of how I think human beings find themselves in conflict and despair and the way in which we can find ourselves toward healing and recovery, if you will.
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm. That's so fascinating to do that research on spirituality and culture because spirituality and culture involves people and what they're creating together, right, in their belief systems.
Dr Bluma Sapir: Exactly.
Ann Marie McHenry: Can I ask what you found? Is there an easy way to describe that?
Dr Bluma Sapir: Exactly. Yeah. Yes, absolutely. So firstly, the research is very, very rich within Buddhism or Eastern religions, other Eastern religions. And Christian, there's actually a whole field of Christian counseling. If
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: you go on Psychology Today, you can click that as an option.
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: So there's a lot of appreciation for that. And at the time I was working, I was in an internship in my third year of grad school, working with the Native American population.
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: And I also found that they had so many spiritual traditions that aided in the healing and growth. of a person's mind, body, and spirit.
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: so I also was like, okay, well, what is my, you know, as a Jewish woman, what does my culture have to say about this? And one of the practices that exists is called the counting of the Omer. And
Ann Marie McHenry: Hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: it is a 49 day, seven week practice. that goes through seven different human emotional attributes
Ann Marie McHenry: Hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: and looks at how they show up in our lives in a healthy or unhealthy balance, always trying to find the balance. And
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: you go through each of those seven and how they themselves interact with each other. And the goal is that you go through a stock of how you're holding up right now in those different emotional ways and for yourself in relation to others. And the goal is to try to come to the other side of that feeling both a sense of peace in where you've been and also with a plan and an understanding of where you need to go. And
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: that's what I focused on in my dissertation.
Ann Marie McHenry: Amazing. That's so cool. Yeah.
Dr Bluma Sapir: Yeah, was really, thanks. Thank you, yeah, it was fun.
Ann Marie McHenry: Yeah. Tell me about how your experience in education now informs your current business and the work that you do.
Dr Bluma Sapir: So the part of what I feel like has Taken root in me and actually has changed me in some ways is holding a space to allow another person's perspective to wash over you and
Ann Marie McHenry: you
Dr Bluma Sapir: all the while still holding your own perspective with dignity.
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: that is a strategic thing to have to learn how to do. It does not necessarily come naturally. I think that one of those things can come naturally to a person, right? We can be very clear about how we feel and have no problem saying it, or we can be very good at listening to other people and not knowing how to express ourselves. I think that those two things, those polarized places can feel very natural to some people depending on
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: their personality type or their sensory profile. But the being able to do both
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: was a skill that took time to really develop.
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: The purpose in my professional life with using that ability is to be able to allow a person enough space to find the answers themselves before, you know, we see things. It's much easier for us to see what's going on. the
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: growth often, not always, but often the growth is helping a person believe in themselves that they have the answers inside.
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: and helping them draw those answers to the surface, vis-a-vis reflecting back their own stories or asking, clarifying or questions to further refine their understanding of what they are saying and feeling. And
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: I think that that's been something that helps me professionally and as well as personally. It's
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm hmm. Mm hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: definitely a tool.
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm hmm. And as you think about, yeah,
Dr Bluma Sapir: Does that answer it?
Ann Marie McHenry: let me go a little bit deeper. As you think about working with pairs, and let's say maybe one person, comes very naturally to listen to the other person's perspective, let their perspective wash over them. And the other person in the pair, it's very natural for them to share their perspective and be very rooted in their perspective. How do you help the pair? kind of like come to the same understanding or take each other's perspectives in a more balanced way. Because it seems like it would be easy if you have two people who pair up, one person's really good at listening to the other and the other person's really good at talking, then we're in a relationship where one person's needs tend to be met probably more often than the other. And so what I hear you describing is that's a skill to develop is sharing your needs but also being able to take on another perspective. Is that right?
Dr Bluma Sapir: Yeah, that's exactly right. I just, you know, I have a perfect example, kind of a, you know, a anecdotal story to describe this.
Ann Marie McHenry: Thanks.
Dr Bluma Sapir: I was working with a couple where one of the, you know, one of the, one partner worked in mental health. Okay. So
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: he was, he was very good at expressing and holding space. on a level.
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: They had conflict in their relationship, that's why they were in therapy, but on his own was able to do that. And the wife came from a culture that did not value complaining, okay? Did not value
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: celebrating. Anything that was too emotional or too, you there was a very, very limited range
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: where you could express yourself. And yet, She wasn't living in that culture and she was married to somebody who had a very common, know, a very easy way of doing it. And so as they were going through a conflict and, know, and I, you know, and he, she shares what her problem is, what she's, you know, where she's struggling and he wants to explain to her what really happened. And
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: so I, I, I helped him to learn to pause and first reflect back to her what
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: she's seen. And I did the same for her. And it was very difficult for her to do that. It was really difficult for both of them, but much more difficult
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: for somebody who does not have the skills just to
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: express themselves. And what I explain is, and it's so helpful to understand that there's science behind this. It's not just emotion. And emotion
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Yep.
Dr Bluma Sapir: you could say is science too, but the science is like physical heart rate, fight
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: or flight.
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: that when we create the pattern that we, as the Gottman Institute beautifully defines, understanding must proceed advice. And I use
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: that in this way as well, that if we put ourselves in a position to first share and reflect back what we're hearing, their perspective is, it slows us down. It forces us to slow down. That means our heart rate stays hopefully under 100 beats per minute. Our fight or flight is not kicked off. We're still in
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: a place where we can be creative and constructive. And so in doing this, very often I'll say, this is, okay, so you understand why this is important. All right, go ahead, it a go. And then they launch into a, I heard what you said, but. And so my role really is very active. I really just, I try to always remind them that I come from love. I say that. My heart is fully present here for you. And
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: to help you, I need you to try something that's different than what you're used to. And it's uncomfortable and it's clunky and it feels like, it doesn't feel natural or even. real because I'm the one saying to do it in that field, but your brain will not
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: interpret it that way. Your brain will take in this information as if it is natural and it is you. So that if you do it one full time, then the next time you come to a situation like this, your brain will suddenly say, I have two choices here. And it bifurcates. I can either go this way, which is a very heavy corded off area that I've done very often and I already know the outcome doesn't work for me or I can try this very nascent approach, but it's there. The second you feel like you have choice, all of a sudden it's a brand new game. And that's kind of how I try to approach it in working with pairs.
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Do you find that the skill of being able to listen, hold space, reflect back the other person's experience very important and often difficult for most of us, and that not being able to do that will often create conflict in our relationships, right? Do you find that that type
Dr Bluma Sapir: Yeah.
Ann Marie McHenry: of conflict and that skill that needs to be developed Does that translate to other pairs? Because I know a lot of this research comes from couples and how we support couples in this work of understanding each other and really aligning with each other. How do you see that and does it translate to the parent-child dynamic or to the sibling relationships or to friends?
Dr Bluma Sapir: Gosh, the truth is, I said, these pairs are really duo relationships. It's with
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: two people. We see this
most often in couples therapy because that is what the market has supported for the last 40 years in terms of
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: who goes to therapy. The second pair that is less common, But I see in my practice, less common in the market, but very much a part of my practice is parent adult child pairs. And
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: it is not the same process because you're dealing with a different kind of history between two people where the parent
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: was the adult and the child was the child and now it's an adult child and so they're trying to navigate. how to adjust expectations given unresolved history that still feels very present and gets activated pretty easily.
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: And so being able to hold a perspective, typically the challenge becomes teaching the adult child to learn how to honor that their parent is a person also.
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: not just the parent that is now, you have to listen to me, there's a demand from the child to be heard, which is very common in parent adult
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: child pairs. And the parent doesn't wanna hear, doesn't really wanna take in that they,
Ann Marie McHenry: Thank
Dr Bluma Sapir: how many things are they gonna listen to that they were wrong? They did the best you
Ann Marie McHenry: you
Dr Bluma Sapir: can't possibly understand.
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: And the key feature that I try to teach it with these pairs is that when you go back into the memory work, which is,
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: big part of typically the conflict is because a child will remember something a certain way and
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: the parent very, very often has a different recollection of the same event. And the parent
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: feels like they know better because they were an adult when all of this was happening and the child can't possibly understand all the other things and no, no, that's not what happened. But actually
Ann Marie McHenry: Thank
Dr Bluma Sapir: the research Ronald Roaner, Dr. Ronald Roaner, he's done some amazing work in this field.
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: And his research, over like, think 63 countries, he studied parent adult child relationships. It's amazing. And he showed that he found rather that very, very often, if not almost always, the parent does not corroborate the child's
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: version of events. And it doesn't make it any less valid. So if
Ann Marie McHenry: Hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: you get stuck trying to process what was true, you will forever be in conflict because the child lived with that truth that has defined
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: their development. So is it really about the events itself or is it about what that how that landed for them? And so that
Ann Marie McHenry: You do?
Dr Bluma Sapir: teaching that understanding and really kind of normalizing for the parent that, yeah,
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: makes sense. You're not going to remember this. at all that way. Nope, it's gonna be different and that's okay. It doesn't
Ann Marie McHenry: Yeah.
Dr Bluma Sapir: make you wrong. It doesn't make you wrong. In fact, it makes both of you right, but you have to hear each other's perspectives in order to understand where are we going from here?
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: So in that population, that's what I would say about parent adult child pairs. I would just also cross over into sibling relationships and say very similar pattern goes on there. where you have two different people who had two different experiences. I heard an interview, think it was definitely Gabor Matej, who was saying that someone said, my sibling and I grew up in the same household. And he interrupted and said, no, no one grows up in the same household. And it's so true that each of us has a different, we are born with a different. way that we sense the world and interact with our environment and different birth orders and then where the parent is and how that is landing for them and how they're able to regulate their emotions around each child. Sometimes it's easier, sometimes it's harder.
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: And so, you know, that affects how the sibling relationship develops as well. learning how to kind of see the different perspectives on some of the same. experiences that they shared,
Ann Marie McHenry: Thank you.
Dr Bluma Sapir: you know, firsthand is also one of those things.
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: And, you know, I would then finish off by saying that best friends as well as are like siblings, I would say in a way,
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: and those professional relationships, those workplace pairs, it's so important to be able to learn how to what I like to call an technology, not an apology, okay?
Ann Marie McHenry: Yeah.
Dr Bluma Sapir: You don't have to take ownership for someone else's feelings, but
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: much like what Esther Perel says that intention does not erase impact. So
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: very often in therapy, I hear people say, look, I didn't intend for that to happen. And
Ann Marie McHenry: you
Dr Bluma Sapir: so somehow that feels, it helps resolve in them this feeling that they're not a bad person. Great,
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: we agree, you're not a bad person. And that happened and that impacted that person in a certain way. And so if you can acknowledge like, yes,
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: that happened to you. I hear that that was hard for you. I'm sorry that my actions led to you having pain. Just an acknowledgement
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: of that, think. goes a long way and it has to
be that you're able to hold a little bit of space for somebody else's different perspective long enough for that relationship to calibrate to.
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: That was a long answer.
Ann Marie McHenry: So much awesome information in that answer. I love the acknowledge. I've never heard that before. that feels so profound and impactful to me because the acknowledgement is just so important. But it does require being able to hold the space yourself and not react or need to prove or make sure that somebody else knows your perspective. But just acknowledging without apologizing for how they feel. it's not your responsibility. Like how somebody feels is not your responsibility. but you can have an impact on somebody that is very worthy of acknowledging. So I love that
Dr Bluma Sapir: Yes.
Ann Marie McHenry: technology. That's so good. Yeah.
Dr Bluma Sapir: Yeah, yeah, use it. I'd love to hear it. I'd love for some time in my life to come around and hear someone else use it and be like, yes. Yeah.
Ann Marie McHenry: We'll make sure that happens, But the part about the parent-child dynamic and parent and child remembering things differently feels so important. And yes, the adult is gonna have more perspective because they've lived more life than their child, but I love that you mentioned what the child remembers is what has shaped part of their development. so understanding that perspective and acknowledging that is also very profound and very impactful for the parent to hear. And then also the siblings. who grew up in quote unquote the same household did not have the same experience. were however many months or years apart. When they were born, their parents were in a different emotional situation, economical, professional, just the way that their parents received them, they were inevitably in a different in their lives when each sibling was born. And so even if the siblings experienced the same dinner table conversation together, with their parents, their relationship with their parents is different because when they were born, their parents were in a different place and they're also perceiving things differently based on all those different factors of when they were born and beginning to be raised. There's just so much complexity but also it's so simple at the same time, the way that you broke it down. Like to how differently we receive and experience different situations just based on who we are.
Dr Bluma Sapir: Totally. I really feel like there is such an opportunity right now, especially with so much of this current soup du jour, this thing that's out there right now that's of no contact and very toxic relationships. I have so much appreciation for the experience of being in a relationship that's toxic. I personally can relate to that and professionally have seen it so many times. It is real. I don't want to minimize that. But I also want to encourage people to... understand that no matter where you go, there you
are, right? And so if you think that you can walk away from a toxic relationship, that means that on some level, that person that you're trying to escape from got so deeply embedded in you that the only choice you have is to walk away. But what are you going to do with all that energy, all that tension,
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: all that, all that the impact? that hat on
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: you, what do do with that? And human beings tend to, you can just look at children who watch how many frozen movies parents have complained
Ann Marie McHenry: Yeah.
Dr Bluma Sapir: about, know, or, you know, Toy Story or whatever, know, kids like to repeat, repeat, repeat, repeat. That's how they learn. And so we oftentimes
Ann Marie McHenry: Mmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: as humans want to get, you know, have, you know, a sense of control over, you know, mastery over things that were confusing or uncomfortable or scary. And so we seek familiar, whether it's good for us or not. And so
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: I think at minimum, if the choice is no contact, my choice in that moment for that person would be, and then you should go right into therapy or coaching even to try to find a way of understanding what is true for you,
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: what you want to do with that information.
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: It's difficult if you have never gone to therapy before to jump
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: into the next step of taking action
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: on that. you know, just taking, going into a deep dive, whether it's therapy or, you know, a pray love kind of vibe, something that gives you, you know, a time to really like take in what is true for you and get it, you know, trying to find a
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: way of integrating who you are and separating the parts that don't feel authentic.
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: Because if you don't, then you play that role somehow in other relationships.
Ann Marie McHenry: So true, yes. And back to your point of the relationship that might be toxic that we decided to step away from, even if that person is no longer in our life or we don't have contact with them, that experience of being with them, that pain and those patterns are still living in us. And we like to revisit and be reminded and kind of keep talking about what we know, like that repeat, that repetition that you were mentioning. That's so true. And so then we create the story completely based on our experience of what happened. And we tell
Dr Bluma Sapir: Right.
Ann Marie McHenry: ourselves that story on repeat. And I love your prompt to say, go to therapy. Let's talk about that. Because we need to find a different perspective. Otherwise, that really negative, detrimental story stays in our heart. And it's still painful. And in some ways, we're still in relationship with that
person, even though we've cut off contact.
Dr Bluma Sapir: That's exactly right. Exactly, Anne-Marie. That's exactly it. And
Ann Marie McHenry: Yeah.
Dr Bluma Sapir: so then, you you're really stuck in a loop. And
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: also, you're stuck seeing yourself in that role, whatever role that
Ann Marie McHenry: Yes.
Dr Bluma Sapir: is. And there's a... I don't know, I want to say it this way, but I don't want it to come across in any way that would be unkind, but it's very victim-y, you know?
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: you feel like you're the victim of that story. so then you feel empowered by walking away, but
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: you're, you really are only addressing the immediate issue, which is I can't take it anymore. But
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: then, but then you haven't, I mean, there are simple things like, I mean, simple in the sense of simple to understand, like the grief.
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: the grief that comes from walking away from that relationship and the grief of not having the kind of relationship that you would want
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: or not have, you know, feeling completely unseen or uncared for or neglected by somebody and how you are able to, you know, metabolize that.
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: some, know, if you're trying to get rid of toxicity and trying to find a way of healing. mean, I really, there are very few ways of doing that without addressing it. I
Ann Marie McHenry: Yeah.
Dr Bluma Sapir: often say the only way is through. You
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: can't find alternative, mean, alternative as in avoiding looking at it. I think the only
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: way is through.
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Yeah. Can you speak to, there is a lot of cutoff. I almost want to call it the cutoff culture. It's very prevalent right now. I think in large part because of people going to therapy and starting that process of, this a healthy relationship for me? If it's not, I'm gonna set the boundary of no longer choosing that relationship or staying involved. But it happens a lot nowadays. And I'm just curious your thoughts on that, especially as you talk about needing to process it. But there is a lot of cutoff happening, and especially between family members.
Dr Bluma Sapir: Yeah. So one of the ways I understand it, I think, is because there's a little bit of a cultural permissiveness to walking away from things you don't agree with.
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: And I think that you have that piece over here. That would be what I would consider the child. Okay. I would say that my, research is like, I think it's something like 23 % of the people who seek parent adult child, you know, pair,
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: relation, treatment are children, but the rest are parents. Okay. So the parents
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: are really struggling.
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm. Yes.
Dr Bluma Sapir: because the kids are walking away and they can't control that. can't, you know, they don't know what to do with that because, so part of that, and I think that part of the problem for parents is that they feel entitled to respect.
Ann Marie McHenry: Mmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: you know, unfortunately, respect is not given, it is earned. And that
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: is really hard for parents to, except, my caveat here is that it feels like, and I'll say my personal opinion, I should say,
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: my personal opinion is that parents, I think, have, I don't use the word deserve very often, okay? But in this case, I'll say that a parent
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: who raised you deserves the very basic level of respect for having done so. Now,
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: that puts a lot of parents who neglected their children, this, that, and the other into that separate category. People who do a disservice to their child, I'm not saying that for them.
Ann Marie McHenry: Yeah.
Dr Bluma Sapir: But a parent who raised you and gave a roof over your head and clothes and food and helped you through school and blah, blah, blah, the standards, I would say,
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: I think are entitled to a baseline respect. Okay. That's my opinion and not everybody would agree with it, but I think that that's
Ann Marie McHenry: you
Dr Bluma Sapir: what parents expect.
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: and so, when they're not getting that from their child, I think they double down. Most parents kind of double down. And
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: when, and it's a mistake, just like it is for a child who's having a tantrum, you have to understand that there are certain things that we can't control. so. I think that the culture, and again, no contact is not only between parent and child, but it is predominantly the case.
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: so, you know, the parent has to understand that their child is an adult and they have to grow up the way that they think about their child.
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: And their child, I think, has been in a pattern of really wanting their relationship to be more than it is. and wishing their parent could show up for them in a way that makes them feel seen or understood or supported at minimum, know, and their goals and expectations are very askew. And so there's only so long that a trajectory that's going like this can continue before it's gonna crash or go in opposite directions. And I think... that I would imagine that they were going like this, they crossed over and then they're no contact is going this way. And unless something happens that's drastically gonna reroute
that situation, it will continue, I think to go like this and then this because of family events and then this, know,
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: in a crisscross pattern because
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: people do end up going back to their families for some things. And then they have to see their... you know, toxic family member and then, you know, and then everything resurfaces and it starts again. And so, like I said, there's no growth to walk away. Well, let me say it with a caveat that if you endured and endured and endured and never walked away, there is an empowering nature to saying no more. But
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: saying no more is the beginning of a process, not the end.
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Yeah.
Dr Bluma Sapir: You
Ann Marie McHenry: It's all very stressful to go through that. Like, coming together out of conflict and then separating
Dr Bluma Sapir: Mm-hmm.
Ann Marie McHenry: out of conflict and then coming back together and revisiting the conflict and then having to separate again. Like, that pattern is just so stressful to me. and sounds so painful, but it's not uncommon. It happens in all kinds of relationships all the time. Yeah, think you're, mm-hmm,
Dr Bluma Sapir: That's That's true. You know, yeah, go ahead.
Ann Marie McHenry: no you go.
Dr Bluma Sapir: was just going to say that I, you know, there's also one other piece to this, which is important to mention, which is very often when the child, when that small percentage of adult children reach out for help, usually it's because they're either pregnant, they're
Ann Marie McHenry: Mmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: expecting a child, or they want to start trying to have children and all
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: of a sudden they're like looking at things from a very different perspective and
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: wanting, whether it's, I don't want to repeat the patterns that I had from my own parent, but I don't trust myself on how to do that or I want my child to have a relationship with my parent, but I currently don't, so I don't
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: know how to do that or I... or I don't trust my parents on how they're gonna have, because the grandparent piece is a humongous factor in this
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm. Yep.
Dr Bluma Sapir: no contact situation, because all of a sudden the parent feels an entitlement to have a relationship with their grandchild.
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: And this becomes a very common, very like, I would say similar to when parents get divorced, right? And
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: when a couple gets divorced and it's like, well, yeah, both parents actually do. have a right
Ann Marie McHenry: Thank you.
Dr Bluma Sapir: to be with their child, but how you express that right can really
Ann Marie McHenry: me.
Dr Bluma Sapir: shape the way that you have a relationship with your child. And the same
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: is true in these grandparent-grandchild things. the parent, if the grandparent is not, you know, an unhealthy, abusive person
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: in a way that would threaten the safety of the grandchild, okay?
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: But they're just really super annoying and frustrating, let's just say, okay, to the child, then on some level, the child might be very surprised at what kind of relationship the grandchild could have with their grandparent. actually might be a restorative emotional experience for everybody, but it's very
Ann Marie McHenry: Yeah.
Dr Bluma Sapir: hard when the parent and adult child don't have a way of relating to really trust that that's going to trickle down in a positive way. But that is another reason why people come to therapy about this is to deal with what am I gonna do to create some
Ann Marie McHenry: Yeah.
Dr Bluma Sapir: kind of symmetry here, you know? So.
Ann Marie McHenry: Yeah, yeah. And I would imagine there's also lot of grief that the adult child experiences of not having their parent involved
Dr Bluma Sapir: Definitely.
Ann Marie McHenry: in the grandchild or the parent child's life. Like not having your mom or dad around when you have a kid because you've chosen that cutoff is really sad.
Dr Bluma Sapir: Absolutely. And what's equally sad is when they don't cut it off and then you have regular explosive upheavals
Ann Marie McHenry: Yeah.
Dr Bluma Sapir: or silent treatment for like weeks and people are carrying
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: all this tension, both are equally troublesome and troubling. And I think there's also like the child feeling the need to punish their parent as well
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: and manipulating their situation, knowing that their parent wants to have contact with their children and
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: using it as a manipulation to get, to somehow get their need met. And so part of, part of what therapy does is help them talk about what,
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: where, where is that need coming from? Like what, what origin story? do you have
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: in your relationship that is unresolved still? Let's
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: help resolve that. Because typically, once you find the origin story of where something came from in a relation, especially in parent-adult child pairs or sibling pairs, you tend to be able to kind of prune that tree, right? We have an origin
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: story, and then we have little branches that come out from that. that act like antennae and they're like, you know, sensing whether something threatening similar to this is gonna come around, right? And so we don't ever wanna have this painful event again. So we cut things off at the, you know, at the top so that we don't have to have
that. As soon as
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: you deal with the origin story, in my experience, these things tend to prune. So they're
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: still kind of there, but they don't feel as sensitive or as like on high alert.
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: And that gives the relationship a bit of new ground to grow. It's a little
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: bit more fertile to kind of grow a healthier
Ann Marie McHenry: Yeah.
Dr Bluma Sapir: relationship.
Ann Marie McHenry: Yeah. And it seems really important to say that it's okay to have a reason to step away from a relationship. There are
Dr Bluma Sapir: Definitely.
Ann Marie McHenry: lots of reasons, especially when you mention abuse or neglect or just any sort of harm that has been caused in that relationship. And if it's directed towards a person, sure, step away. But... doing that internal work and getting into therapy and starting to understand and process what actually happened so that you're not, it's almost like coming back to an earlier topic, you're not the victim in it. And I guess the caveat is we can be victimized by people, but to live in a space
Dr Bluma Sapir: Mm-hmm.
Ann Marie McHenry: of always being the victim in that story isn't fair to you. Like we need to be able to say, I'm choosing to not be in this relationship and this is why, and I'm gonna move forward with my life. If I choose to reengage that relationship, I will do so in a different way. I also don't have to, but just to be in a place of, I hate this, I don't wanna do it anymore, it doesn't feel good, I'm cutting off. That usually doesn't evolve our growth. And it does feel a little bit tricky sometimes, you know, because we can be very hurt by people and we can in fact be abused by people and so we do not need that in our lives and we should leave. But there is still work to be done for ourselves to process that and to make whatever choices we want to moving
Dr Bluma Sapir: Absolutely.
Ann Marie McHenry: forward.
Dr Bluma Sapir: Absolutely. I often suggest an intervention to people who have been betrayed or abused
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: or neglected that at the end of their day, that they have a statement that they,
Ann Marie McHenry: Hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: you know, a self statement of forgiveness, forgiving yourself
Ann Marie McHenry: Hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: and forgiving others with the caveat that you can hate anyone again in the morning if you want to. Okay.
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: You can hate them all over again and live with that during the day. But to start a habit of offering forgiveness for whatever you feel about the situation. I mean, I've heard so many beautiful ways that people word this. And you say the
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: same statement because it opens up a part of you that's not wanting to be open because we're
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: in protective
mode. You know, when you're
Ann Marie McHenry: Right.
Dr Bluma Sapir: a victim, the whole point is that you're like, never again, you know, like I'm
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: closing off, no one can hurt me. I won't take that from anyone ever again. Very empowering first move. And
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: you can't, but we're not meant to live alone. not, we're not meant to live without support
Ann Marie McHenry: Yeah.
Dr Bluma Sapir: and without love and without companionship and without friendship. We need those things. And if we,
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: if we learn how in this, so this little act of, of, of, of letting go at night. gives you that little muscle that you start to practice that
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: allows you to start to imagine the possibility of being able to let other things go or ease back or being a little bit more flexible. It's good for everyone
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: to learn to do that a little bit.
Ann Marie McHenry: Yeah, I love that you are mentioning this because when someone has deeply hurt us, we want to protect, we don't want to do that again, but that protection can then create a barrier between us and all kinds of other people because we're so afraid that that will happen again. So practicing
Dr Bluma Sapir: Right.
Ann Marie McHenry: building that muscle bit by bit in tiny moments at night before you go to bed of allowing just some space for forgiveness and love feels very, very important. Because if we're walking around protecting ourselves all the time, we don't get to enjoy really our life because relationships are a part of our life.
Dr Bluma Sapir: Exactly, Anne-Marie. And the other thing just to say that you meant when you mentioned like, you know, walking around like that is, know, energy draws on, it's a little bit like it begets its own. Okay. So if you're
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: in protective mode, there's a bit of you looking around for things that you that are threatening, which of course
Ann Marie McHenry: Hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: is survival skill. And yes, but You know, it's a little bit like that saying of like, there's not a saber tooth tiger, you know, on the freeway. So responding
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: in such a way is, you know, disproportionate. And so the point is like, you know, yes, in the immediate aftermath of something like you, finally make it a person finally makes a decision to walk away from something toxic or abusive or negative. That
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: initial act is massive. And then the point that you want to try to get to is The reason you walked away
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: ostensibly is so that you have peace in your life. Well, you got to build that. It's got to be built. It doesn't just naturally emerge because you walked away. And so I think that
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm.
Dr
Bluma Sapir: the idea of trying to find the energy that you want to have in your world, that you want to survive with and thrive
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: on has to be something you invest in, I
Ann Marie McHenry: Yeah.
Dr Bluma Sapir: think.
Ann Marie McHenry: Yeah. This I think will be my last question with Dr. Bluma, a peer expert in relationships. What have you learned? What is the most important learning that you have gained since specializing and becoming an expert in relationships?
Dr Bluma Sapir: The most important thing that I think that I've learned is that although we seek a binary explanation for things in our lives, they are unfortunately not reality. A person can be good and bad at the same time. Someone
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: might say there are no bad people. I think there might be, but they probably have good in them too.
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: I think that we get stuck when we are hurt or, you know, we're saying a lot about being hurt, but like we could also say like, you know, when we get excited. You know, I've seen people get so excited and then everything seems possible, but you also have to like, you know, balance is everything is my point. You have to find a balance and
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: strike a balance in your life, which, you know, is essentially saying like there is one side and there is another side, there is living in a continuum is really the way that I
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: see the world. We are a continuum. Each and every one of us has a
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: bit of all of the above inside, you know, which is why
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: I think that we're so fascinated by watching reality shows and
Ann Marie McHenry: you
Dr Bluma Sapir: and watching animal, those natural history stuff. And I think that we're fascinated by things because we relate. And that's
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: because we are complex, because we are not binary, we are multifaceted. And that's
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: what I think I've learned the most by seeing so many different people share their stories.
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm that makes so much sense. I love that you just named that What do you want people to know about you where can they find you?
Dr Bluma Sapir: What would I like people to know about me? That I think that human beings are wonderful.
Ann Marie McHenry: Thank
Dr Bluma Sapir: I think that truly, as trite or cliche as that might sound, think that so often when someone meets me at a party or at an event and they find out that I'm a psychologist, I would say 90. percent of the time they'll say, I better not talk around you. I better not say anything, you know, and,
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: and, and I, I really, it's quite the opposite. I'm like the safest person that,
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: that anyone could, could, could talk to because
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: I have so much understanding and compassion for what it means to be a human.
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: and so that's, that's one of the main things that I would want people to, you know, think about me. from now on when they find out that I'm a psychologist and Where can they find me? So social media right now would be the best place you know, I You know, dr. Blumas appear on on Instagram and Facebook and I my website the pair Institute comm is in progress and
Ann Marie McHenry: Mm-hmm.
Dr Bluma Sapir: So that will that will be available. I'll let you know in that when that's you know live And I have other things in the works too, so I'll let you know.
Ann Marie McHenry: Amazing. Thank you so much for sharing your expertise and your wisdom on pairs, these duos of people, because we are all in relationship and just talking more about relationship and how non-binary the experience is of people is, I think, really healing to talk about and to hear from you about. So thank you so much.
Dr Bluma Sapir: Thank you, Anne-Marie, for having me. It was just a pleasure to talk to you. Really, thank you.