文字起こし 🔗
00:00:01
Speaker 1: I'm Daniel James, and you're listening to 7am. For generations, Australians could reasonably expect that their lives would be more prosperous than their parents. But over recent years, that bargain has started to break down. Productivity growth has barely moved for a decade. We're working more hours without producing much more for each hour we do work. And that stagnation is showing up in incomes and living standards. Now, with economic growth under pressure, the government is betting that new technology, particularly artificial intelligence, can help turn things around. Today, Productivity Commission Chair Danielle Wood on why Australia has stopped becoming more productive, whether AI can change that, and what happens if it can't. It's Thursday, October 15. Danielle, it's good to have you on the show. When the RBA raised interest rates at the end of last month, one of the big problems Michelle Bullock identified was productivity.
00:01:13
Speaker 2: The bottom line is that productivity is doing nothing.
00:01:17
Speaker 1: It was also something Treasurer Jim Chalmers stated as a top priority for the government's second term.
00:01:22
Speaker 3: We've got the biggest and broadest productivity package in the budget that we've seen for some decades.
00:01:27
Speaker 1: Can you start by explaining what productivity is? Because it doesn't mean working harder and longer, correct?
00:01:34
Speaker 2: That's right. And I'm very glad you say that.
00:01:36
Speaker 4: I remember early on in this role, a union leader said to me, when people hear productivity, they hear, you know, work till you bleed. And that's absolutely not what we are talking about. Productivity in sort of economic terms is the amount of value add we create per hour worked. And generally, productivity improves over time because... We get more machines and capital. We get better technology. You know, think about how different our healthcare system looks now compared to 50 years ago. That's an improvement in productivity. We train people. We match them to jobs. All of those things can help broader productivity. And that's what then drives improvements in our living standards over time.
00:02:20
Speaker 1: Productivity growth in Australia has been stagnating for like over the last decade almost. How bad is it and how does that affect people's lives?
00:02:29
Speaker 4: Look, you're absolutely right to say the last decade has been a very challenging time. The national accounts outcome last week was a sharp reminder that we cannot afford to take growth for granted. Despite these developments, the gains in productivity from technical change appear to be diminishing.
00:02:47
Speaker 3: That productivity has started to slow for a number of reasons. We're still growing, but not growing as fast as we would hope.
00:02:54
Speaker 4: Look, if we took a 60-year average, productivity has grown about 1.6% a year. If we just look at the last decade, it's been about 0.3% a year.
00:03:05
Speaker 2: And it bounces up and down and COVID did some weird things.
00:03:08
Speaker 4: But, you know, so it's essentially, it's pretty close to zero, less than a quarter of its 60-year average. What that means, I think we all would have seen it. Real wages grow less strongly. We're not seeing the same kind of improvements. And then over a longer term horizon, when you start hitting a decade mark, it actually starts to impact generation on generation progress in living standards. For example, millennials or late millennials born in the 1990s hit the job market as productivity started to flatline. They're the first generation not to earn more than people born 10 years before them at the same age.
00:03:47
Speaker 2: So we start to.
00:03:48
Speaker 4: See that kind of expectation of generation on generation progress confounded.
00:03:55
Speaker 1: Yeah, and it leads to a great deal of discontent. One of the things Michelle Bullock pointed out at a conference last month was the role of business. She said over the last decade, Australian businesses have become less dynamic, they're not investing enough, they're not looking at ways to increase productivity. Have we lost our innovation over the past decade? What's happened there?
00:04:16
Speaker 4: I mean, it does sort of, when you look at the data, it does look like the animal spirits have somewhat left the building. And certainly investment well down as a share of the economy since the global financial crisis, so even a bit longer than the period that we're talking about. It's a little unclear what's going on. It may be that there have been sort of less broad opportunities, but I think we see it, for example, in lower adoption of new technologies compared to other countries we like to compare ourselves with. We're slower up the AI adoption curve, for example. Some of that could be about management capability. Some of it might be about risk appetite. But certainly, I think Michelle Bullock is right to point to a role for business in turning around this productivity challenge.
00:05:04
Speaker 1: How big a factor is competition? We've got a lot of big duopolies in this country, especially if we think of things like the supermarkets.
00:05:10
Speaker 5: There are more than 26 million of us, but just two supermarkets control how much we spend. Coles and Woolworths among the most profitable in the world.
00:05:21
Speaker 1: Does that create a certain lethargy, a certain laziness? Because you don't need to innovate if you rake in monster profits.
00:05:31
Speaker 4: Look, it's certainly true that competition is really an important.
00:05:35
Speaker 2: Driver of the.
00:05:37
Speaker 4: Need to invest and innovate, and it keeps people on their toes and dynamic.
00:05:43
Speaker 2: And so the way I think about it.
00:05:44
Speaker 4: Is we want to make sure that policy is creating the conditions for competition.
00:05:49
Speaker 2: The government did a year or so ago.
00:05:51
Speaker 4: Some
Load full transcript
reforms to mergers laws, which were really important because it's about making sure that it's harder to get anti-competitive policies market position and market power, but also it's really important that we kind of look market by market and make sure that there's not impediments.
00:06:06
Speaker 2: And things like regulation can actually be an impediment.
00:06:09
Speaker 4: If we have big, complex regulatory systems, it can make it hard for new entrants to come in and challenge.
00:06:14
Speaker 2: So I think competition is part of the story.
00:06:17
Speaker 1: What's the government role in all of this? Is the problem that Australian businesses over the past decade have become more risk adverse or does government need to rejig its policy settings to create an environment that encourages business to invest in their own productivity?
00:06:32
Speaker 4: Look, I think governments do have an important role, but sometimes the public conversation sounds like, if governments just pulled the big lever, mark.
00:06:41
Speaker 2: Tax reform, then everything's going to be fine.
00:06:43
Speaker 4: It's not that simple, but governments create the ecosystem in which productivity can occur. So you can think of it, they create some of the really important enablers, so skills and training, population health, innovation policy. They have an important lever around incentives, so tax, regulatory settings make a difference. And then just governments, just big players in the economy themselves. So through their own provided services, they can have an impact on productivity there. So governments do have an important role. It's not a single policy issue. I say it's a game of inches because you've actually got to be shifting the dial across a whole range of areas and then business can invest and take risks within that kind of broad ecosystem.
00:07:35
Speaker 1: Coming up, can artificial intelligence bring productivity back to life? So, Danielle, how do we turn this around? Because as you said, we've had long stints of productivity, but we are now stagnating. The government is optimistic, predicting productivity growth of 1.2% a year in its recent intergenerational report. AI seems to be the thing that they're pinning so much of their hopes on when it comes to that growth. Is AI the answer?
00:08:11
Speaker 4: Look, I am optimistic about AI being an important part of.
00:08:18
Speaker 2: The story going forward.
00:08:19
Speaker 4: And if we look back through history, it has been shifts in general purpose technologies, you know, going back to the steam engine and electricity and the kind of first wave of ICT. Those things have fundamentally changed the way we've structured our economies and businesses and unleashed decades, sometimes centuries of growth. And so I think people are looking at AI, it is general purpose, you know, it has use cases across almost every part of the economy and society.
00:08:52
Speaker 3: The AI revolution is the most consequential new emphasis since the 2023 report and the biggest economic transformation.
00:09:01
Speaker 1: Of our lifetime.
00:09:02
Speaker 4: And so, you know, when I think about where's the kind of structural change going to come from in that story, I do agree with the government that I think AI is probably the most likely candidate.
00:09:14
Speaker 2: As to the magnitude, I mean, it's super hard.
00:09:18
Speaker 6: To know.
00:09:18
Speaker 2: I think we're all going to be very modest in this space.
00:09:21
Speaker 4: We did an exercise about a year or so ago where we just looked at sort of task-specific efficiencies. And based on that, we thought could add about 0.4% a year to labour productivity growth over the decade. You know, there are more optimistic scenarios that say, you know, if AI changes the pace of innovation itself, it could be more than that.
00:09:42
Speaker 2: But, you know, hand on heart, I don't think anyone could tell you for sure.
00:09:46
Speaker 1: Thank you for your brutal honesty there. Let's say AI does raise productivity. People are concerned that it'll leave humanity behind and leave people behind. How do you ensure it lifts wages and living standards and the just profits?
00:10:01
Speaker 2: Look, I am reasonably optimistic about that point as well.
00:10:05
Speaker 4: And I think most of the early evidence and then some of the kind of forward-looking projections don't suggest that this will be about replacing jobs. There'll certainly be some jobs where a lot of the tasks could be replaced and those are the kind of people that we will.
00:10:22
Speaker 2: Have to think about transitioning.
00:10:25
Speaker 4: So one question then is skills and training, particularly for small and medium businesses where they don't put a lot of money and resources into training workers, partly because they're constrained financially and in terms of capacities. We think government support is warranted there to help make sure that people have the skills that they're going to need in that new world. And then I think the kind of broader piece on competition matters.
00:10:48
Speaker 2: Here as well that you raised before. We want to have competitive markets for products and services.
00:10:54
Speaker 4: Then that human element, which will be in demand, I believe, people will continue to compete for talent in the way they do now. So I think those things together, making sure that people have the right skills and then making sure that markets have a good level of competition should make sure that some of those productivity benefits are flowing through to people.
00:11:16
Speaker 1: So despite this stagnation, Danielle, Australia's economy has largely managed to keep growing because we've added more people to it, which has allowed us to mostly avoid confronting the productivity problem. Now, all the major parties are promising cuts to immigration. What does that mean if we don't improve productivity while cutting immigration so drastically at the
same time?
00:11:39
Speaker 4: I think it will make the productivity challenge more stark, as you're pointing to. So it's certainly rightly that our economy has kept growing partly because of population growth. If that rate of growth slows, businesses will feel it in sales not rising as quickly. The government will feel it in terms of their budget position. And so turning around the equation on productivity growth will be even more front and centre than it is now. I think nobody wants to be in an economy that is going backwards. We know recessions are terrible because of the impacts, particularly on labour markets and employment, but also the broader impacts on standard of living. And so, you know, I think this productivity challenge is already to some degree front of centre, but it may become even more so in a world where we're somewhat turning the taps off on the migration program.
00:12:35
Speaker 1: And the consequences are high, aren't they? If we don't boost innovation and turn its productivity trend around, it has significant ramifications for current and future generations.
00:12:46
Speaker 2: Exactly right.
00:12:47
Speaker 4: I think we all want to be in a world where we think we're leaving our kids a better place and, you know, where they've got a shot if they work hard to earn more than what we did. So I think that's important. And there's a whole lot of other things that sit beside that, you know, our capacity to deliver the housing that we need, our capacity to build out the electricity and energy system that we're going to need for cheaper, cleaner power. all of those things have kind of productivity challenges at their heart. But, you know, I do think about it both in terms of making it easier for life for Australians now. We want our wages to be moving, but really importantly for leaving the world a better place for the next generation.
00:13:26
Speaker 1: Danielle, thank you so much for speaking with us.
00:13:32
Speaker 2: Thank you so much for having me.
00:13:51
Speaker 6: Also in the news, the Federal Court has overturned an Aboriginal protection order that halted a billion dollar coal mine in New South Wales. Former Environment Minister Tanya Plibersek approved the order after being asked by the traditional owners to protect the site, which is central to their creation stories.
00:14:08
Speaker 7: But a judge found the order invalid.
00:14:10
Speaker 6: The proposal will now be sent back to the current Environment Minister, Murray Watt, for redetermination. And Labor Prime Minister Anne Ali has revealed she's received 19 death.
00:14:21
Speaker 7: Threats in the past week alone.
00:14:23
Speaker 6: It's after Opposition MP Angie Bell told Parliament Ali should be shamed and stoned in the square over a decision made by the Tax Office to ban credit card payments. Ali says the comments, which were later withdrawn, were racist and misogynistic.
00:14:38
Speaker 7: I'm Ruby Jones. This is 7am. Thanks for listening.
00:14:45
Speaker 6: You