TRASCRIZIONE 🔗
00:00:07
Speaker 1: Electricity is not something new, but all of a sudden, electricity-powered devices seem to be winning over the masses. In Europe, battery installations have grown 75% in the first six months of this year, while in the Philippines, electric car sales have risen 150%. Even in the U.S., where the government is clearly against the transition, electric car sales are rising again. Oh, And Ferrari came out with an electric car. Two mixed reviews.
00:00:36
Speaker 2: You should Google it.
00:00:38
Speaker 1: Yet, despite the good news, there are still plenty of obstacles to electrification, which I'm hoping to unpick on today's show. My guest today is Jan Rosenau, professor of energy and climate policy at Oxford University, where he spends a lot of his time thinking about how energy systems work and how to make them better. His answer is championing electrification. And not because he wants to, but because he has the numbers and the analyses to back it.
00:01:05
Speaker 2: This is Zero.
00:01:06
Speaker 1: I am Akshat Rati. Today, the case to electrify faster. For those of you listening to the audio version of this podcast, this episode is part of a new video series we are making on electrification. If you'd like to watch this episode instead, head over to YouTube. We've put a link in the episode notes. Jan, welcome to Xero.
00:01:29
Speaker 2: Thanks for having me. So you're a big.
00:01:31
Speaker 1: Proponent of electrification. That's what we're going to talk about. But let's start at home. What have you electrified and what's still left? We have electrified pretty much everything in our house. So we have no fossil fuels that are consumed on site, but also our car is electric.
00:01:49
Speaker 2: So we have a heat pump. We have an electric car. We have induction hub and the gas pipe has been cut off. So it's a fully electrified home and actually uses a lot less energy as a result of it. And it's very comfortable. A lot of people don't believe that, but it's actually more comfortable than it was before.
00:02:07
Speaker 1: So we've come to sort of the advantages that electrification brings. But let's start with the context that we are sort of living through this year, which is the U.S. 's attack on Iran and the war that has essentially created panic in the energy markets. crazy swings in prices. You've been following what countries are doing pretty closely as a result of this war. A lot of the fossil fuel importing countries are looking to electric options. You say that this kind of move towards electrification is now a fundamental reorganization of the energy system. What does that reorganization look like?
00:02:45
Speaker 2: So right now, countries that sit on vast fossil fuel resources get a lot of revenues from exporting them. And then a lot of countries that don't have that, which is the majority, more than 70%, of countries in the world are net importers of energy. They pay for those imports. And in the future, as we think about an electrified system, those trade flows will fundamentally change. That's one of the parts where the energy system will be looking very, very different. And you think of sort of petrol states, you know, they have been exporting vast quantities of oil like Saudi Arabia. You know, that may shift and, you know, shift into a direction of maybe other geographies. I mean, think of China, of course, that's usually mentioned. as an example, but also countries that provide critical minerals, like lithium from Chile, for example. So we're already seeing those changes happening. And if we accelerate, much more of that is going to come. It's very hard to predict when and how fast, but it's very clear that the current system as we know it will look very different from that perspective. But then also within, I think, the energy system, you know, we have a very centralized, largely one directional system where consumers pay for energy and producers provide it. And then there's transportation in between. But in the future, it's going to be much more decentralized and interconnected, bi-directional, more intricately woven and digitalized. So a very different system than what we know.
00:04:12
Speaker 1: Well, it's different. But from the perspective of a consumer, you know, yes, an electric car feels different because it's not quite shaking as much, not making that much noise. But the rest of the system, whether you're staying at home with a heat pump or with a gas boiler, or whether you're using your computer, using green electricity or fossil fuel electricity, that part doesn't feel that different. Is there a consumer side of this equation that you feel would be a fundamental change?
00:04:40
Speaker 2: I think you're right. You still get the same energy service. You're still driving a car and getting from A to B. You still have a comfortable home. But the interaction with the technology is different, I think, because technological change always involves a change in your thinking. And you suddenly have to think about how many people think about that gas boiler or that petrol car and the engine that's in it. Unless it breaks down. Right, unless it breaks down. But once you switch, you have to engage people. with the question, do you want to make that switch? And then you actually quite, I think, you're considerate of what you're doing with your heating or with your travel, with the energy that you use. So I think it is different from that perspective that you suddenly have to really think through what your options are. And it does, I think, change perception of energy. And for the first time for many people, maybe they actually have to think about energy. Although having said that, I think with the high prices we've seen, that is one of the reasons why we see so much interest now in electric technologies as a way to shield ourselves against those high prices.
00:05:46
Speaker 1: Perhaps engaging within the energy system in this way is not a bad thing
Load full transcript
because a lot of people have forgotten where things come from and maybe having that engagement is useful. Now, there's a mantra that has been there among climate people for quite some time, which is electrify everything. But it's not like... the modern grid or continuous electricity supply is new. It was invented in the late 1800s. It's been spread around the world over the last century. Why is it that we are talking about electrifying everything now?
00:06:19
Speaker 2: I think the case for electrification is at least twofold. I think we have figured out how to decarbonize electricity to a large extent. We haven't fully decarbonized it in most countries, but we know how to do that now. And yes, the last 10% will be harder, but let's take that for granted. We know how to decarbonize electricity. So electrification allows us to use clean energy that doesn't require the combustion of fossil fuels. That's one reason why electrification is important. We still have a climate problem to solve. Then on the other hand, you have these huge efficiency advantages of electrification. Heat pumps, electric vehicles use maybe a third, a quarter of the energy that combustion technologies use. And you have those energy security benefits. You can produce energy within the country and don't require imports. So I think in combination, that is quite a compelling case. And I'm writing a book right now about this very question. What is the case for electrification? What I would say is that electrify everything is something that we might want to look at a bit harder because you can't electrify everything. You can electrify a lot, but there are limits to electrification as well.
00:07:29
Speaker 1: So let's look at the emission side first and then come to the efficiency side. Clearly, electricity has one big benefit, that it can come from many fuel sources. Of course, renewable ones like sun, wind, water, geothermal are preferred. Even nuclear, if you can build it cheaply and safely. But a lot of the electrification that has happened so far has happened on the back of fossil fuels. Coal, gas, and in many places, even oil. There is a risk in pushing for electrification that you end up using more fossil fuels and perhaps increase emissions. Are you worried that that might happen?
00:08:08
Speaker 2: I'm not worried about that. And that's for two reasons. The first reason is that even with the existing grid that we have and the mix of resources that generate electricity, in a lot of countries, electrification already makes sense from an emissions perspective. Why? That's because of the efficiency that I briefly mentioned before. So you could run the entire grid on gas, for example, have 100% of your electricity from gas. And we know that heat pumps are still cleaner than a gas boiler. They still use less fossil fuels, result in less emissions. And that is not something new. I mean, David Mackay, Professor David Mackay, said this in, I think, 2008 in his book, Sustainable Energy Without the Hot Air. So this is not news. Of course, there are countries like take Poland or China, where you still have a lot of coal on the system, where those gains might be non-existent yet because electricity is still largely based on fossil fuels. And when we look at new capacity that's being built, and Bloomberg New Energy Finance, for example, puts out these charts every year, we see that most of the new capacity is now renewable electricity. There's still some fossil in there, but it's tiny. I I would be surprised if the additional electricity demand that we're layering on top would be provided with fossil fuels. I think most of it will be served with renewables.
00:09:30
Speaker 1: And that's true globally. But in places like the United States, where we are seeing a boom because of artificial intelligence and all the data centers that need to be powered, there is clear indication that gas burn is going to increase in the short term. But do you think even in the U.S., in the long term, this is not going to be the case?
00:09:49
Speaker 2: Yes, and that's specifically because the fundamental economics have changed in a way where I just don't see how in 10 years time, or even now, there's a strong business case. for building new fossil generation. And research shows this very clearly, that the expectation is that in most parts of the world, the cheapest way of generating electricity will be a combination of renewables, mainly solar and wind plus storage. Even factoring in storage at the same time, it will be cheaper than building new gas-fired power stations.
00:10:19
Speaker 1: So let's take this goal that many countries are going to talk about at COP 31, which is to increase the final energy of global consumption to 35% for electricity by 2035. from about 20-ish percentage. We'll come to the sort of final energy question later, but there is clearly an increase in electricity share of whatever energy is being consumed. Do you think that target should include that the electrification needs to come from clean sources?
00:10:51
Speaker 2: I mean, one of the problems with such targets is always that you could achieve them in a way that actually isn't particularly helpful. So let's, you mentioned data centers before, right? You could just build loads of data centers, which drives up the electrification rate. Is that a good thing? Some people would say yes, because we want lots of data centers. But it's not a good thing from an emissions perspective. It's not a good thing from replacing, displacing fossil fuel consumption in industry buildings, transport, because it's just adding electricity demand that wasn't energy demand that wasn't there before.
00:11:21
Speaker 1: So, yeah.
00:11:24
Speaker 2: The target as it stands is not particularly helpful when it comes to understanding how you deliver on that target and what the benefits will be. I would still say having this huge symbolic value of having an electrification target because it
does focus people's minds and it leads to a conversation about electrification. And that's a good thing. But I've always been rather skeptical of target metrics. They usually get adopted by politicians who are no longer in power when these targets kick in and then they're quietly abandoned. So I think targets are useful to focus minds and drive the discussion in a certain direction. But I wouldn't be too obsessed with them either.
00:12:02
Speaker 1: I suppose you could say the same thing about the Paris Agreement, where there are clear targets about keeping global warming below 2 degrees Celsius and preferably below 1.5 degrees Celsius. It focuses the mind to actually act on it, even though there is a very real risk that we may even blow past 2 degrees Celsius. 1.5 degrees Celsius already looks like we are going to blow past it. But let's come to the final energy question. There was a recent report from the International Energy Agency that had the sentence in it, and I'm going to read it, which is, electricity is 23% of global final energy. yet it delivers 37% of the useful energy that people actually make use of. Now, there's a third jargon term here, which is primary energy. And to me, these three jargon terms are sort of energy wonkery, but they're sort of crucial to understanding why electrification is fundamental to the changes that we need to make. in our energy system. So let's just start with definitions. What do you mean by primary, final and useful energy? And if you can give them with examples.
00:13:13
Speaker 2: Yeah, I think a good way of maybe visualizing this in your mind is to think about the energy flow that we see in the world. And a lot of people have drawn Sankey diagrams. That's a sort of technical term. Captain Sankey, he was, I think, an Irish pilot. engineer who wanted to understand how efficient steam engines were. And he's drawn a diagram where you sort of see the losses in the system and you can find how much of the energy you put in is actually useful and drives the engine. And when we look at the energy system, the primary energy is all of the energy resources we put into the system. So coal, oil, gas, solar, wind, hydro, In this case, it comes out as electricity. And then we have so-called final energy, which is what you consume. So that may be electricity, which might be from gas, might be from wind or solar, or it may be refined products from hydrocarbons, maybe petrol, maybe diesel. And the useful energy is the very final stage. So if you walk through the flow diagram from the left-hand side with primary energy inputs, transformation in the middle, and then you have the final end use stage on the very right, that goes into useful energy. That's energy services, essentially your home being warm or your car driving at the factory running a process. That's essentially what useful energy is trying to measure.
00:14:44
Speaker 1: And so one way to think about it is from the perspective of oil, like drilling, just crude oil is primary energy. Then having refined products in petrol, diesel or jet fuel is final energy. And then if the fuel is used for motion most of the time, that motion itself, the outcome of that motion, how much energy it consumed is the useful part. And every time, because the process of refining does take energy, you lose a little bit. And then the internal combustion itself is highly inefficient. It converts only about 20-30% of all the fuel energy into motion. You get these losses that add up. How does electrification help in this situation?
00:15:32
Speaker 2: So let me restart with the end use first and work backwards. So let's stick to the car example and the internal combustion engine. If you have an electric car, you put in, let's say, one unit of electricity... about 90% of the energy in that one unit of electricity will be actually driving the car forward, will be propelling you forward. There are some losses, of course, friction, some waste heat. That's unavoidable. There's also when you brake, you can recover some of those losses. So about 90% efficiency. And you mentioned before that an internal combustion engine is maybe only 20% or 30% efficient now. So you have a vast improvement in efficiency because of that. When you work further upwards in the value chain, of course, you have to generate that electricity from something. And if that was generated by a coal-fired power station, you also have losses. The coal-fired power station throws away about 70%, perhaps. of all the primary energy inputs to make the electricity. But if that came from solar or wind, you would only have maybe 10% losses in the grid. There would be some storage, but that's not that much. We're talking maybe 10, 12% of losses. So it's vastly more efficient.
00:16:47
Speaker 1: If we end up doing electrification of almost everything, not everything, everything, what does the end result situation look like from a primary energy perspective for the world?
00:17:00
Speaker 2: It's roughly half. So we have new research coming out that we've done together with the Lawrence Livermore National Lab. They draw these global Sankey diagrams that I mentioned before for almost every country and also for the world. And we've redrawn that for 2022, where we have the latest comprehensive data set and then created an alternative Sankey diagram for a highly electrified economy based on renewables and we get to about half of the primary energy input by using existing technologies in industry transport and buildings and and that's what the end result is of of that calculation.
00:17:34
Speaker 1: While we are getting the same amount of useful activity or less or more.
00:17:40
Speaker 2: The same so if you also then assume maybe things like energy efficiency weatherization of homes um or maybe some behavior change, modal shift to public transport, you could cut primary energy by even more. We haven't looked at that, and we haven't looked at technologies that might be
emerging and maybe be commercialized in 10, 15 years. This is existing technologies we have available today that we could deploy over the next five to 10 years.
00:18:11
Speaker 1: After the break, more of my conversation with Jan Rosenau, Professor of Energy and Climate Policy at Oxford University. If you've enjoyed this episode, please take a moment to rate and review Xero on whichever platform you're listening on. Thank you. I want to come to sort of exciting technologies. But before that, there is, at least here in the West, a real debate around electrification that has to do not with climate, but all with cost and affordability. The UK has some of the highest electricity prices. Europe in general has very high electricity prices. One reason is that those electricity prices are set by gas today. Maybe in the future, 10, 15 years from now, it may not be. But getting to that future requires you to have political buy-in from people to electrify, which at the cost that prices are today doesn't seem viable. What can governments really do right now to make electricity cheap and show the savings that may come from electrification today?
00:19:27
Speaker 2: There's a number of things. Let me start perhaps with taxation because that's kind of an obvious area where governments can quite quickly decide to lower the cost of electricity. We know that in many countries we overtax electricity compared to fossil fuels. We essentially have higher tax rates and levies policy costs on electricity bill. That's also the case in the U.K. but elsewhere as well. And fossil fuels get a bit of a free ride. So that rebalancing of taxation and levies. can in some cases make a really, really significant difference to what the price of electricity is. Then you have things like network costs, and that's a bit more tricky because we are paying for infrastructure that we may need for the next 10, 20, 30 years, but we need to build it now in anticipation of a rising electricity demand So how are you allocating that cost? And the risk there is that if we pay for all of that cost right now, that drives up bills. And partly that's what we're seeing in a number of countries, that there's a rising element of network costs. There are different ways of dealing with that and different views as to what is appropriate. You can pay for it with electricity bills, but some people would also argue we should consider paying for it through other means, maybe general taxation, because this is an investment in public infrastructure, that is critical and is really important. We're going through a massive transition here and it doesn't necessarily have to be on the electricity bill. And then finally, I would say, The way wholesale markets work in Europe, you mentioned this, is still that often the gas price determines the electricity price. That is changing the number of jurisdictions with batteries, with renewables. But we still have places like Italy, for example, or the UK, where gas is a very dominant factor in the wholesale market. So reducing that by speeding up the deployment of storage, speeding up the deployment of renewables will also help bring down prices.
00:21:23
Speaker 1: One aspect of this, which is sort of playing out with the Iran war and where fossil fuel prices are, sure, many consumers have looked to electric options, but a lot of government's initial reaction has been to find other sources of fossil fuels or to subsidize energy right now because the prices are shooting up so quickly and people should not feel the suffering of those prices. So those subsidies are being levied. But There is a risk here, which is that either buying new fossil fuel burning devices today is likely going to lock that system into burning more fossil fuels for 10, 15, if it's a new industrial build, maybe for decades to come. You've worked with governments, advised them, you've showed why an electrification system is a better one. And yet this urgency that we must electrify hasn't quite sunk in with most governments. Why is that?
00:22:24
Speaker 2: I think there's always a short-term scramble to solve the crisis, and that's understandable. I mean, if you're in government and you see prices shoot up by maybe three, four, five, or 10 times even in 2022, that's what we've seen in the gas markets in Europe, you have to react. And you can't just say, oh, over the next 10 years, we're going to change the energy system. You have to do something in that very moment. And in this case, it was making sure we have enough gas for the winter. um that was coming um you know we already saw um there was a cut in gas supply from russia in in i think it started in september august 2021 and you have to react to that and make sure there's enough energy available right um at the same time when prices rise you've got to protect people from those price rises so i totally understand why governments have acted in that way What is a missed opportunity, though, is when governments then stop there and only do the short-term fix, because that's sticking plaster. It's dealing with the symptoms, but it's not curing the illness. And the illness is the over-reliance on fossil fuel imports and an exposure to these very volatile markets. So some countries have reacted in a more holistic fashion. I mean, France was the first country that has put forward an electrification strategy in April, just a couple of months after Hormuz closed. And then Canada followed, I think, the same month. And in July, the European Commission put forward the electrification action plan for Europe. There's a few other initiatives, but those are the three, I would say, standout examples where countries have really gone all in with a strategy that is for the long term and not just a short-term fix.
00:24:04
Speaker 1: In terms of Europe, the biggest share of emissions tends to be heating homes and buildings with natural gas. I know you have looked at electrification of heating very closely. The
obvious solution is heat pumps. But there are success stories and then there are failures across Europe when you look at the deployment of heat pumps. Many countries have had periods when the deployment had been very good, then it sort of plateaued. Some countries like here in the UK, there's really never been a success story and governments continue to struggle with it. Is there a formula that you have understood that would work in electrifying heating of homes and buildings?
00:24:48
Speaker 2: Yeah, I think we know what the ingredients are. And it's really quite simple. One of which we already talked about is electricity price. So we know where the electricity to gas price ratio is low. So by low, I mean at least below three, ideally lower than that. people will start buying heat pumps. We see that in countries like Norway, Sweden, for example, where you have a very low price ratio, we have a lot more heat pumps. In Norway, about two thirds of homes have a heat pump.
00:25:17
Speaker 1: So one unit of electricity should be a third of the price of gas?
00:25:21
Speaker 2: No, should not be more than three times as expensive. Therefore, a very simple reason, if you have an efficiency advantage of maybe three to five over a fossil fuel system, If the price of electricity is maybe three or less than that times more the gas price, you start saving money. And that then justifies the investment in the technology.
00:25:44
Speaker 1: And why does that three to five times efficiency advantage come through in a heat pump?
00:25:48
Speaker 2: Well, essentially, it's moving pre-existing heat that's already there in gas. the air, the ground or the water, depending on where the heat source is. It's moving that from one place to another and upgrades it, lifts the temperature up. And it needs a lot less energy to do that than burning gas in a boiler as a result. So you have this big efficiency advantage.
00:26:08
Speaker 1: And so is there a situation where perhaps a heat pump is not practical, is not the right solution?
00:26:14
Speaker 2: And if that's the case, what should the heating solution be? There are certainly places where it's harder, but I would say there's almost a solution for every single building now. People often mention, what about a tower block with flats in London? Well, there are now projects in tower blocks with flats in London, also very old. I've seen them myself, very old Victorian or Edwardian flats where heat pumps have been fitted. There are communal heat pumps that are ground source that you can build that service flats individually, don't require lots of space. Or old buildings. My own house is 146 years old. That was built at a time when there was no gas grid. There was not really an electricity grid yet. And there's now a heat pump in it and it works just fine. So I would say in most cases there is a solution. Yes, there are harder buildings where it's more difficult. But let's start with the easy ones first. People often jump
to the hardest examples and say, oh, what about this? And therefore we can't do it. And I always think, well, why don't we start with the bulk where it's easy or practicable and possible and economic. And then we worry about the really hard ones a little later when technology has improved, we've seen more innovation. Let's do the easy things first.
00:27:29
Speaker 1: Coming to your point about technology development and what could be changes in the next 10 to 15 years on technologies that could help the electrification of everything.
00:27:41
Speaker 2: Let's stick with heating.
00:27:42
Speaker 1: What are sort of heating electrification technologies that you are excited about?
00:27:46
Speaker 2: Maybe I switch to industry as a sector that uses a lot of heat as well. Electrothermal storage is one of those technologies where you essentially use electricity when it's at low cost, ideally from renewable sources, and you store it in the form of heat. It's basically like a heat battery at an industrial site. And that heat battery can provide 24-7 steam to the facility. So you decouple the energy consumption, the heat that you need for processes, from the way that heat battery is being charged. And you have that flexibility opportunity that's good for the grid, but it also lowers the cost of the heat that is being delivered.
00:28:25
Speaker 1: But the heating that homes and buildings require, you know, is sort of boiling water, which is possible to do with heat pumps. But industrial heat can go from boiling water to really high temperatures where you're melting something, you know, 1000 degrees Celsius. What portion of this can really be electrified?
00:28:48
Speaker 2: Almost all of it is the answer. And it's useful to segment it into the different temperature bands. So the low temperatures maybe go up to 200 degrees C. That can be done with industrial heat pumps with existing technology. Some of the manufacturers now claim up to 280 degrees C can be done with industrial heat pumps. Then you have maybe the mid temperature band, maybe 200 to 500 or 600 degrees C You have electric boilers there. You can use electrothermal storage, which I mentioned before. There's a combination of technologies. And above that, resistance heating, plasma torches. There's lots of things that can be... And electric arc furnaces, not a new technology. It's been around for a long time to recycle steel. That goes up to very high temperatures, you know maybe 2.8 thousand degrees centigrade and beyond that there's still technologies available the problem is the further up you go in the temperature ranges the more difficult it gets because the technologies are less advanced less mature so start with the easy part first you can do about half of industrial heat with existing technologies pretty easily technically the question is Can you do it fast enough? And are the economics pointing in the right direction?
00:30:01
Speaker 1: There's an aspect of this which we can talk about in sort of specific policies that could allow for economics to work. But I had Arthur Downing, who's an author of a new book called Power and the People on the show. And his main argument is that, you know, technologies are not the real challenge here. It is the business model of electricity. that is the challenge for deploying electricity more widely and at lower cost. And its solution is that some portions of the energy system, which will be mainly electric, have to be owned publicly because take the grid. It is a natural monopoly. You cannot have two competing grids in a capitalist system trying to find which is the cheaper one. You can only really afford to have one. And his answer is, if there is only one, it is really on governments that they should use that monopolistic asset well, effectively. And then, of course, you can have competition in other parts of the energy system. You can have many generators of electricity from solar to gas or whatever. competing to provide electricity. And you can have electricity prices that are reflected by markets. Do you think that is a formula that will actually work?
00:31:23
Speaker 2: I guess I'm not persuaded that public ownership is always the right answer. I think there'll be examples where publicly owned utilities do a pretty good job and they deliver on societal outcomes in the public interest. But there'll also be examples where that's not the case. And you will find that privately owned companies that are regulated well may deliver well on public interest as well, or they may not. That has to do with regulation. So I don't think it's that simple to say public ownership will be the pathway to have a better managed grid or vice versa, to say it has to be privatized, otherwise it will never work. I think we need to figure out how to set the incentive structure for those natural monopolies in a way that they deliver on the public interest. And defining what that is, is the first step, right? What do we actually want from these companies? Is it to just put more copper in the ground, expand the network, connect people, or is it perhaps to connect new devices to make sure we can go through this transition? And then the question becomes, how do we do that in the most cost-effective way that lowers costs for consumers and that gets us to where we need to get in the fastest possible way?
00:32:41
Speaker 1: Well, I think the easiest way to say what we really want from the energy system in general is something that is clean, affordable, and secure. One strain of argument is that electrification can provide that security because a fully electrified country that's dependent on renewables is not importing energy from outside, is less vulnerable to the types of shocks that we are seeing this year and have seen in recent past. But there is another side of the argument, which is that an electric system is much more vulnerable because it is a centralized system to a large degree. It is accessible to the
digital network, so really open to cyber attacks. And of course, electricity is hard to store, even if we have batteries, electric ones or heat batteries. It's just not possible to store energy as we can in, say, an oil reserve or a gas reserve. How do you make an electrified system a secure one?
00:33:48
Speaker 2: This is a great question. Let me perhaps comment briefly on the competing goals of the transition, which have often been framed as the energy trilemma, where you have affordability, you have reliability of supply. and you have sustainability. And I think increasingly those three goals are not in conflict necessarily. And there are definitely sweet spots where you can deploy a technology, find a solution that delivers simultaneously on all three. Having said that, of course, if we electrify, we have to think about resilience. And we have seen in Berlin, for example, I think it was last winter, that after a deliberate attack on, I think it was a substation in the south of Berlin, there's been a blackout for extended periods of time. And similar things may happen, maybe cyber attacks. What I would say, though, is that without electricity, we would not have a functioning energy system that includes a fossil fuel energy system. So when you think about your gas boiler, that needs electricity to run. When you think about getting your car fueled at the pump, there's an electric pump that pumps up the petrol or the diesel into your car. The water system would fail. The whole society depends on electricity. So I think we've got to be careful to frame it as in, The current system is resilient and could deal with a shock to the electricity system just fine. And then electrified economy would be much more exposed. I'm not persuaded that that's necessarily the case. But I think we should really have a much more honest discussion about what are the risks for the existing system and the future system and how do we mitigate against those risks.
00:35:25
Speaker 1: It's already true that the electric system is... is core to global economics, to any country's economics, more than any other type of fuel has been. You know, the oil shocks of the 1970s had a devastating effect on global economies, while the oil shock of 2022 or 2026 hasn't quite had the same economic impact because the electricity system has been able to provide a backup. And of course, a lot of that electricity system is becoming cleaner But even before it becomes cleaner, that electricity system is providing a backup. And you're right. In a way, that electricity system is so embedded. If you're not thinking about securing it today, well, we're already making a mistake. So thinking about future security starts today in a way.
00:36:16
Speaker 2: Yeah. And there are also examples of cyber attacks or data breaches when it comes to fossil fuel infrastructure. You know, the examples of pipelines suddenly not working anymore. And it's not just limited to the electricity sector. But I wouldn't
want to just brush that away and say, oh, it's not a problem. I think this is a serious problem that we have to deal with. You know, the companies in charge of the electricity network are dealing with it every day and are thinking very carefully about those things.
00:36:44
Speaker 1: Let's take the framing that you talked about earlier, which is more and more countries will use electricity. Some of these countries are already on that cusp. Many call them electrostates. There is an advantage that comes from it, which is if you are generating that electricity at home through renewable sources, you are more independent as a country. We've seen a lot of wars happen. over the past century have been started as resource wars, have been fossil fuel driven wars. Do you see an electrified world being a more peaceful world?
00:37:16
Speaker 2: There's still be trade, right? That's important, I think, to acknowledge. And I think at the beginning of our conversation, we talked about that already to a degree. but the trade flows will be very different. And of course, the argument that's being made often is that we're just going to depend on other countries instead of maybe oil or gas exporters, which is true, but it's a very different type of dependency. You know, we're importing technology. We're not importing fuel that we need continuously. So once the device is installed, you need that continuous stream of fossil fuels to operate it. Whereas if you have renewables and you have electric technologies operating, You don't need that. You need to replace what breaks down. Or if you want to expand the network, the infrastructure, then you have to import. But is it a more peaceful world? That's a really good question and perhaps one that I don't dare to answer because this is sort of geopolitics and international relations, which is outside of my area of expertise. But my intuition is that I would hope so because it enables countries– to be less threatened by these disruptions. And we've seen what happened with energy price shocks in the past and sort of wars that were clearly arranged around where fossil fuels were being located. And hopefully we have less of that in the future.
00:38:34
Speaker 1: Yeah, because there is a darker scenario here. In a way, the US would likely have not started a war with Iran had it not felt energy independent as it does with the amount of oil and gas it is producing. It's not fully independent. It still needs to depend on partners, but it's more independent than it has been in the recent decades. So the darker scenario could be as more countries become energy independent with renewables, they feel less constrained to be able to pursue whatever goals that they might have otherwise. and could perhaps create more wars?
00:39:08
Speaker 2: As I said, I don't have the answer. I still believe that one of the reasons for why we have seen sort of wars around energy in the past have to do with where fossil fuels are and strategic choke points that controlling those is important geopolitically. So I think that's going to change fundamentally. But yes, indeed, there may be new dynamics. And of course, we haven't talked about critical minerals yet. You know, those are located in particular places and they're not abundant everywhere. So there will be new dynamics. And I wouldn't argue that there will be a complete absence of conflict around energy. It will be a different type of conflict and hopefully there will be less of it.
00:39:46
Speaker 1: In the five to 10 year period, are you optimistic that the energy transition will continue? not just continue, but speed up as the world must to try and tackle climate change?
00:39:56
Speaker 2: I think Hormuz has been an accelerator. We know that from looking at the data. You see there's been an uptick in sales of electric cars, heat pumps, but also solar storage. That's definitely been an accelerator for the transition. And I think that's going to continue because we've seen two price shocks in four years, two severe crises. And people are now well aware that there is a risk of continuing the way we have. So, Yes, I think we will see an acceleration. Will it be fast enough? Probably not. But we will see, I think, an acceleration of the transition over the next four to five years.
00:40:34
Speaker 1: Thank you, Jan.
00:40:35
Speaker 2: Thanks for having me.
00:40:39
Speaker 1: And thank you for listening to Xero. Me and my colleagues from Bloomberg Green are currently at COP31. You can check out our coverage on Bloomberg.com forward slash green. Now for the sound of the week. Is this the first four-door Ferrari? First five-seater.
00:40:57
Speaker 2: First five-seater.
00:41:04
Speaker 1: That is Pope Leo XIV inspecting Ferrari's first electric car, a car so divisive it needed the Pope's blessing. If you liked this episode, please take a moment to rate and review the show on Apple Podcasts, YouTube and Spotify. This episode was produced by Oscar Boyd. Special thanks to Somersadi, Megan Olson and Alyssa MacDonald. I'm Akshat Rati, back soon.