TRASCRIZIONE 🔗
WEBVTT
00:00:48.900 --> 00:01:01.732
The problem lies in the fact that, because everybody, all humans, are going to react in the same way, well then, it makes us predictable and then it makes us manipulable.
00:01:01.732 --> 00:01:05.528
So, that's how dark patterns were created.
00:01:05.528 --> 00:01:09.039
In a way, you know, it's a manipulation of our cognitive biases.
00:01:09.039 --> 00:01:17.963
It's playing on these human weaknesses to make us do things without realizing, or even against our interests.
00:01:18.545 --> 00:01:20.872
Hello, I am Debra J Farber.
00:01:20.872 --> 00:01:32.950
Welcome to The Shifting Privacy Left Podcast, where we talk about embedding privacy by design and default into the engineering function to prevent privacy harms to humans and to prevent dystopia.
00:01:32.950 --> 00:01:44.949
Each week, we'll bring you unique discussions with global privacy technologists and innovators working at the bleeding- edge of privacy research and emerging technologies, standards, business models and ecosystems.
00:01:44.949 --> 00:01:49.730
Welcome everyone to The Shifting Privacy Left Podcast.
00:01:49.730 --> 00:01:53.913
I'm your host and resident privacy guru, Debra J Farber.
00:01:54.735 --> 00:02:02.394
Today, I'm delighted to welcome my next guest, Marie Potel-Saville, an esteemed lawyer and impact entrepreneur.
00:02:02.394 --> 00:02:13.490
After a decade of working in top-rated law firms, she moved in-house to become General Counsel of the EMA region for several global companies, like Chanel.
00:02:13.490 --> 00:02:21.736
Marie is the Founder of Fair Patterns, a solution for detecting and remedying large-scale dark patterns.
00:02:21.736 --> 00:02:41.919
She's also Founder and CEO of Amarabi, an award-winning innovation studio specializing in ethical, privacy-friendly, and age-appropriate design; and, she's Host of The Fighting Dark Patterns Podcast.
00:02:41.919 --> 00:02:50.853
Marie lectures internationally on human-centered law and legal innovation through design and is a member of the European Data Protection Committee's Expert Support Pool on Dark Patterns.
00:02:50.853 --> 00:03:03.768
So, as you may surmise, today we're going to talk about dark patterns how to make sure that you're only creating fair patterns and not dark patterns when you are building a new product or feature.
00:03:06.119 --> 00:03:07.283
Thank you so much, Debra.
00:03:07.283 --> 00:03:08.929
It's a pleasure to be here with you.
00:03:09.540 --> 00:03:10.423
Oh, I'm so excited.
00:03:10.423 --> 00:03:24.888
I think this is a really great topic that people might know about at a really high level, but haven't had the time to really uncover all of the interesting literature and research around dark patterns and fair patterns.
00:03:24.888 --> 00:03:27.704
So, I'm really excited to have this conversation with you today.
00:03:27.704 --> 00:03:36.205
Maybe just tell us a little bit about how you ended up transitioning from practicing law to focusing your career on legal design and fair patterns.
00:03:36.727 --> 00:03:41.444
Yeah, it's been an amazing journey - I have to say - and I enjoyed every single moment.
00:03:41.444 --> 00:03:48.608
I guess, I'm at the time of my career where, you know, everything I've done previously fully makes sense now.
00:03:49.129 --> 00:04:01.713
It's like all of the various bits and pieces now fully click all together and I'm able to bring my whole self to work, namely because I sort of invented my own job, which helps.
00:04:01.713 --> 00:04:09.233
But basically, to answer your question, I guess the beginning of my career was extremely traditional.
00:04:09.233 --> 00:04:16.802
You know, I was in big law, the usual suspects like Creshfields, Allen and Overy in London, Paris, Brussels, etc.
00:04:16.802 --> 00:04:38.240
Then, I moved in-house, as you mentioned, and I guess this was the beginning of the journey, to the extent that it made me realize the huge gap between the legal advice that you provide as an external counsel and what it becomes on the field in real life.
00:04:38.240 --> 00:04:42.232
The answer is not very reassuring.
00:04:42.232 --> 00:04:47.427
Basically, the law, within the company, is absolutely not understood.
00:04:47.427 --> 00:04:54.603
It's even rejected as a pure business constraint - something that's going to slow everybody down.
00:04:55.446 --> 00:04:57.471
I really wanted to change that.
00:04:57.471 --> 00:05:08.042
It's really because I'm in love with the law that I wanted to give the law back it's place that it deserves in society, but in companies as well.
00:05:08.222 --> 00:05:18.036
I wanted really to change those business constraints into empowering tools to provide efficient solutions, really.
00:05:18.036 --> 00:05:27.164
And so, in practice, what I did was that in my own legal division - I was VP Legal EMEA at Estée Lauder
00:05:27.224 --> 00:05:44.812
at the time; -I I was covering 70 countries, 30 different brands, with a team of four lawyers, which was an interesting concept; and so, I started experimenting, leveraging Stanford's Legal Design Lab.
00:05:44.812 --> 00:05:47.903
At first, I think it was very clumsy on my side.
00:05:47.903 --> 00:05:51.128
I was just trying and testing and learning.
00:05:51.128 --> 00:06:22.431
But, what was really interesting is that, as clumsy as it was, it produced amazing results so that my fellow VPs, like the brand VPs and the marketing VPs, et cetera, would knock on my door saying, o"Oh look, I didn't know that law could be so engaging, and they were referring, for example, to competition law training, which is not naturally fascinating to marketing people, to say the least.
00:06:22.431 --> 00:06:25.845
And they were like, o"h, this is really interesting, can you train my team " team?
00:06:25.845 --> 00:06:31.132
" And so that encouraged me to actually properly train in innovation by design.
00:06:31.132 --> 00:06:50.484
I did a master's degree for 18 months and
Load full transcript
then I set up the company because I really wanted to share as widely as possible this new methodology, basically applying design to the legal arena to solve users' issues and basically bridge the gap between the law and their users.
00:06:51.326 --> 00:06:57.628
So tell us about your legal design firm, Amurabi, which focuses on innovation by design.
00:06:57.628 --> 00:06:59.092
What do you really mean by that?
00:07:01.141 --> 00:07:08.134
Well, I mean that the law is not doomed to be impossible to understand, totally inaccessible.
00:07:08.134 --> 00:07:18.309
You know all the walls of jargons that you hit online each time you click on terms of use or terms and conditions or privacy notices, etc.
00:07:18.309 --> 00:07:20.508
It's not doomed to be this way.
00:07:20.508 --> 00:07:49.251
There is actually a rock solid methodology that enables us to transform all of these walls of jargon into content and information that everybody loves to read, that everybody truly understands and that empower users to really better understand their rights but also make their own free and informed decisions.
00:07:49.251 --> 00:07:51.507
Amurabi is an agency.
00:07:51.507 --> 00:07:53.126
We're not advisors.
00:07:53.126 --> 00:08:08.456
We don't produce fancy slides to tell you what to do; but, what we do produce, deliverables, tangible projects - for example, privacy notices that everybody would love to read, compliance programs, litigation design.
00:08:08.456 --> 00:08:08.456
.
00:08:08.456 --> 00:08:08.456
.
00:08:08.456 --> 00:08:08.456
.
00:08:08.456 --> 00:08:20.567
That's basically what we've been doing for the past six years and that's actually what led us to create our R&D Lab several years ago to specifically tackle dark patterns.
00:08:21.342 --> 00:08:22.286
That's really exciting.
00:08:22.286 --> 00:08:24.240
What exactly are dark patterns?
00:08:24.240 --> 00:08:27.530
I think it makes sense to define that before we go any further.
00:08:27.530 --> 00:08:33.225
I'm sure there's several different definitions, but how would you sum it up for the audience today in our discussion?
00:08:40.019 --> 00:08:40.240
Of course.
00:08:40.240 --> 00:08:49.303
So basically, a dark pattern is an interface that deceives you or that manipulates you to make you do something you didn't mean to do and that could even be against your interests.
00:08:49.303 --> 00:08:50.648
Does that make sense?
00:08:52.052 --> 00:08:52.192
It does.
00:08:52.131 --> 00:08:55.982
So, how are dark patterns different from deceptive patterns?
00:08:55.982 --> 00:08:56.825
I mean, we hear this.
00:08:56.825 --> 00:08:56.825
.
00:08:56.825 --> 00:08:56.825
.
00:08:57.326 --> 00:08:57.606
both .
00:08:57.606 --> 00:08:57.606
.
00:08:57.606 --> 00:08:57.606
.
00:08:58.107 --> 00:09:04.681
language when it comes to negative things about design when it comes to privacy and data protection and other things.
00:09:04.681 --> 00:09:08.831
So, let's distinguish that: dark patterns versus deceptive patterns.
00:09:09.519 --> 00:09:21.536
So, basically, Harry Brignull coined the term dark patterns nearly 14 years ago to describe what I just explained: tricks that make you do things you didn't intend to do.
00:09:21.536 --> 00:09:31.172
That was 14 years ago, and, along the way, Harry has really led the charge against deception and manipulation online in an absolutely brilliant way.
00:09:31.172 --> 00:09:37.826
He's now authored a book, which I can't recommend enough, called Deceptive Design Patterns.
00:09:37.826 --> 00:09:42.606
To answer your question, it's actually the same - dark patterns and deceptive patterns.
00:09:42.606 --> 00:09:44.331
It's the same concept.
00:09:44.932 --> 00:10:43.319
Simply, Harry, with whom we have the pleasure to collaborate by the way, Harry was conscious of the fact that the term dark pattern could potentially be misinterpreted as associating dark, you know, with something negative.
00:10:43.319 --> 00:10:50.753
So, to avoid any possible misunderstanding, he had this term evolve into deceptive patterns.
00:10:50.753 --> 00:10:58.160
That's merely a precaution, and I fully subscribe to that precaution because, obviously, the intention is not to offend anyone.
00:10:58.160 --> 00:11:02.106
On the contrary, it's really a human- centric approach.
00:11:02.106 --> 00:11:06.154
That's all about protecting humans, that's for sure.
00:11:06.801 --> 00:11:13.091
So, he's had this term evolve; but, quite frankly, it really doesn't matter how it's called.
00:11:13.091 --> 00:11:21.488
What matters is to be aware of the reality of the manipulation and the deception online and to change the situation.
00:11:22.149 --> 00:11:22.430
Great.
00:11:22.430 --> 00:11:23.653
I mean, that's really helpful.
00:11:23.653 --> 00:11:31.843
I think now would be a great time to talk about your project, Fair Patterns (which anyone listening here, you could access it by going to fairpatterns.
00:11:31.843 --> 00:11:33.566
com).
00:11:33.566 --> 00:11:44.089
You not only created Fair Patterns with your team, but validated your work by deploying these patterns on a project with King Games.
00:11:44.089 --> 00:11:46.760
So, that's the maker of Candy Crush Saga.
00:11:46.760 --> 00:11:54.981
I think everybody pretty much knows that game; and that won you the IAPP award for Most Innovative Project, which is so exciting.
00:11:54.981 --> 00:11:56.163
Congratulations!
00:11:56.943 --> 00:11:57.865
Thank you so much.
00:11:57.865 --> 00:12:01.989
Yeah, it was a real surprise for us, to be honest, That was back in 2022.
00:12:01.989 --> 00:12:07.814
To be named Most Innovative Privacy Project for basically the rest of the world, apart from the U.
00:12:07.814 --> 00:12:08.075
S.
00:12:08.075 --> 00:12:12.141
was a huge surprise for us.
00:12:12.501 --> 00:12:12.501
But so exciting.
00:12:12.501 --> 00:12:18.361
Tell us, what is Fair Patterns and what motivated you to found that project along with King Games?
00:12:19.403 -->
00:12:19.703
Sure.
00:12:19.703 --> 00:12:44.554
Fair Patterns is a solution that fights against dark patterns by automatically detecting them and by also transforming dark patterns into the countermeasure, which is Fair Pattern, which are basically interfaces that empower users to make their own free and informed choices.
00:12:44.554 --> 00:12:49.151
So, that's the concept that we've created after several years of R&D.
00:12:49.151 --> 00:12:53.027
What motivated us to create this project?
00:12:53.027 --> 00:13:00.086
It's basically all of the dark patterns that we're seeing on a daily basis in our projects at Amurabi.
00:13:00.086 --> 00:13:08.451
Each time we would transform a privacy notice or terms and conditions or any online journey, really we would see them.
00:13:08.451 --> 00:13:14.006
We would spot them and we would get really irritated, even angry at times.
00:13:14.346 --> 00:13:25.583
It's completely crazy, but you get some dark patterns that could, for example, say things like t"There are two buttons, one to accept the offer and the other to reject it.
00:13:25.583 --> 00:13:35.684
And the button to reject the offer sometimes says things like "Oh no, I would rather bleed to death to make you feel really, really bad and ashamed of clicking on it.
00:13:35.684 --> 00:13:37.406
That's how crazy it gets.
00:13:37.406 --> 00:13:47.764
And so, because we got so, so shocked by the scale of dark patterns and by the depth of this phenomenon.
00:13:47.764 --> 00:13:48.325
.
00:13:48.325 --> 00:13:48.645
.
00:13:48.645 --> 00:13:49.827
it's all around the world.
00:13:49.827 --> 00:13:54.704
It's quite deep, not just on the interfaces, it's also in the code.
00:13:54.704 --> 00:14:00.339
It's also, sadly, in algorithms; and, that's not improving.
00:14:00.941 --> 00:14:08.335
So, back in 2021, we decided to create our R&D Lab specifically to focus on dark patterns.
00:14:08.920 --> 00:14:14.992
Two years after that, we managed to create the concept of fair pattern as a countermeasure.
00:14:15.901 --> 00:14:19.501
Maybe it's worth explaining this concept a little bit more.
00:14:19.501 --> 00:14:25.774
There has been a great amount of work done by academia over the past 14 years.
00:14:25.774 --> 00:14:32.200
So, you've got an amazing amount and quality of research on what's the name of dark patterns.
00:14:32.200 --> 00:14:33.687
What's the right name for it?
00:14:33.687 --> 00:14:35.354
What's the right taxonomy?
00:14:35.354 --> 00:14:37.883
You've got like 16 different taxonomies.
00:14:37.883 --> 00:14:40.588
What are the harms caused by this problem?
00:14:40.588 --> 00:14:41.069
Et cetera.
00:14:41.069 --> 00:14:54.766
So, basically, you've got over 10 years of problem- focused research, which is great, which is amazing; but then, very, very little research and proposals on the solution.
00:14:54.766 --> 00:15:01.736
So, there were some proposals around bright patterns or light patterns.
00:15:02.380 --> 00:15:12.327
Basically, these initiatives were proposing to nudge users towards privacy-friendly or consumer-friendly interfaces.
00:15:12.327 --> 00:15:18.529
To be honest, we're not sure that nudge is the solution here.
00:15:19.771 --> 00:15:27.471
The reason for that is that is people don't learn anything when they are being nudged.
00:15:27.471 --> 00:15:31.483
Obviously, they just continue to blindly click.
00:15:31.483 --> 00:15:48.893
They're just directed to a supposedly ethical solution instead of the bad one; but, that doesn't really solve the core issue, which is that people have given up properly reading online and thinking online to make their own free choices.
00:15:48.893 --> 00:16:08.287
So, that's really what we wanted to change, and the whole concept of Fair Patterns is to empower users to even maybe take the two or three seconds that they need to think about it and to really make the choice that's meaningful and beneficial for them.
00:16:08.287 --> 00:16:09.365
Does that make sense at all?
00:16:09.799 --> 00:16:10.925
It definitely makes sense.
00:16:10.925 --> 00:16:17.966
It just highlights something I've been feeling for pretty much a lot of my career: why am I so excited about privacy and data protection?
00:16:18.106 --> 00:16:20.471
Why is that my jam, you know?
00:16:20.471 --> 00:16:22.482
Why am I so obsessed with the space.
00:16:22.482 --> 00:16:22.804
Right?
00:16:22.804 --> 00:16:29.125
A lot of it, for me, and I think generally, comes down to it's a subset of agency.
00:16:29.125 --> 00:16:33.113
You know, how much more freedom- focused could this issue be?
00:16:33.113 --> 00:16:33.413
Right?
00:16:33.413 --> 00:16:40.046
Agency: your ability to make choices about your life and what you're doing and what's collected about you.
00:16:40.246 --> 00:16:45.447
So, I think sometimes we forget that that's what privacy is, a subset of agency.
00:16:45.447 --> 00:16:55.354
And, if we're taking away people's ability to make meaningful choices, we're really taking away their agency and that should be seen as a real negative, harmful thing at scale.
00:16:55.354 --> 00:16:55.437
Right?
00:16:59.443 --> 00:17:03.613
This is so important and thanks for putting this context back.
00:17:03.613 --> 00:17:10.701
This is so central and I know that you were at the IAPP Global Privacy Summit because we saw each other.
00:17:11.062 --> 00:17:12.005
Yeah, that's where we met.
00:17:12.005 --> 00:17:13.107
That's where we met at the last .
00:17:13.269 --> 00:17:26.670
I'm sure you remember one of the speakers for the closing session explaining that the new frontier is not so much data governance or AI governance, it's decision- making governance.
00:17:26.670 --> 00:17:34.675
How do we make sure that humans are still able to make their own decisions in a meaningful and ethical way?
00:17:34.675 --> 00:17:36.738
I think that's really the new frontier.
00:17:37.720 --> 00:17:48.072
Yeah, and I think that if that's not done in a good way, I mean it's pretty
easy to see that that will put constraints on society's decision-making as a whole.
00:17:48.072 --> 00:17:56.146
Of course still individual decision-making, but then we're steered by big tech or other forces rather than our own individual choices.
00:17:56.146 --> 00:18:05.121
So, yes, I think that is kind of a great way to end the conference on those notes and taking that home to stew on, marinate on.
00:18:05.121 --> 00:18:06.564
Exactly.
00:18:06.564 --> 00:18:17.902
You know we're talking some meta concepts here, but why should business executives generally care about preventing dark patterns from being coded into their websites and apps and interfaces?
00:18:18.703 --> 00:18:26.125
Yeah, you're right to bring the question back to reality, back to the field, back to what really matters.
00:18:26.125 --> 00:18:31.621
There are many, many reasons for executives to be concerned.
00:18:32.121 --> 00:18:37.947
I will focus just on the business reasons, to be honest, because obviously there are plenty of ethical ones.
00:18:37.947 --> 00:18:54.477
But, just on the business side, what's really interesting is that we've seen that deception and manipulation online - all these dark patterns - are starting to stop being profitable.
00:18:54.477 --> 00:19:11.687
I think that they used to be profitable a couple of years ago, but as customers become more savvy, but also more demanding, they're really willing to have that super profound trust relationship with the brands they buy from.
00:19:11.687 --> 00:19:21.585
We're seeing that dark patterns simply do not work anymore, or not as well as before, sheerly in terms of profitability.
00:19:21.585 --> 00:19:41.439
And, that's really interesting because, of course, with a dark pattern - let's say for a renewal of subscription - you will likely get a very short-term boost in your turnover, but as soon as users will realize that they have been tricked, they will be furious, and rightly so.
00:19:41.620 --> 00:19:45.889
Then, they won't want to hear about you ever again or your brand.
00:19:45.889 --> 00:19:50.490
I guess that's the key point for businesses to care about it.
00:19:50.951 --> 00:19:55.342
The second business reason is simply the bad user experience.
00:19:55.342 --> 00:19:56.243
It's terrible.
00:19:56.243 --> 00:19:58.106
We've all experienced it.
00:19:58.106 --> 00:19:58.708
Right?
00:19:58.708 --> 00:20:00.176
I mean, you get annoyed.
00:20:00.176 --> 00:20:06.302
You see them, the 45 people looking at the same room as you.
00:20:06.302 --> 00:20:18.521
We've all been through these interfaces where we are tricked into paying for a seat on the plane when we all know it should be free.
00:20:18.521 --> 00:20:21.086
I mean, it gets really on our nerves.
00:20:22.008 --> 00:20:37.906
The European Commission actually produced a very interesting study back in 2022, where they showed scientific evidence that dark patterns actually increase your heart rate and increase anxiety.
00:20:37.906 --> 00:20:43.459
I mean, as if this world didn't generate enough anxiety by itself.
00:20:43.459 --> 00:20:48.929
[Debra: wow!] The second business reason is really this bad user experience.
00:20:48.929 --> 00:20:50.881
People, they're fed up with it.
00:20:50.881 --> 00:20:54.701
And then, of course, we could talk for hours about all the other reasons.
00:20:54.701 --> 00:20:59.289
You know, the individual harms and the structural harms caused by dark patterns.
00:21:05.442 --> 00:21:07.987
Yeah, and I think we might even get to some of those questions.
00:21:07.987 --> 00:21:16.605
For now, I want to understand - I hear from you and your work on your website that dark patterns harm individuals and exploit our cognitive biases.
00:21:16.605 --> 00:21:22.700
So, you've kind of already went through some of the harms; but, can you describe how it's exploiting our cognitive biases?
00:21:22.700 --> 00:21:23.943
What does that mean?
00:21:23.943 --> 00:21:25.459
Give us some examples there.
00:21:26.382 --> 00:21:27.446
Sure, absolutely.
00:21:27.446 --> 00:21:33.538
Perhaps it's useful for your audience, Debra, to briefly explain what cognitive biases are.
00:21:33.538 --> 00:21:44.746
This all stems from, basically from Ken Mann's research, who sadly passed away recently, but he's been really an amazing thought leader in neurosciences.
00:21:44.746 --> 00:21:48.840
He was also a Nobel Prize winner in economy.
00:21:48.840 --> 00:21:56.980
B asically, he's the author of Thinking Fast and Slow, which still is the authority book to date.
00:21:57.916 --> 00:22:07.301
He very clearly explained - identified first and then explained - that our brain is working by two main systems.
00:22:07.301 --> 00:22:21.018
System one, which is very fast, very efficient, but which relies on a number of cognitive biases precisely to help us make those decisions or make those choices very, very quickly.
00:22:21.018 --> 00:22:32.187
And then, system two, which is slower, which is also more energy consuming - so, the brain doesn't like that by default, it likes to save the energy.
00:22:32.187 --> 00:22:38.928
But, system two is basically what enables us to solve complex problems like a math problem.
00:22:39.556 --> 00:22:41.074
So, back to cognitive biases.
00:22:41.074 --> 00:22:56.244
In system one, the reason why we can act very quickly and be that efficient is that in order to make a choice, we will fall back, we will resort to these cognitive biases and that's completely unconscious, obviously.
00:22:56.244 --> 00:22:57.868
We won't realize that.
00:22:57.868 --> 00:23:10.411
It means that all humans are going to react in the same way when they're faced with a given situation, a given type of information.
00:23:10.411 --> 00:23:14.447
Overall, there are 180 cognitive biases.
00:23:14.447 --> 00:23:23.970
For example, when we are faced with information overload, then the typical response is we don't read.
00:23:23.970 --> 00:23:33.918
When we are faced with a risk of
loss, there's the loss aversion bias, which makes us absolutely try to avoid this loss.
00:23:33.918 --> 00:23:49.465
When we are faced with an information that is framed in a specific way, well, the cognitive bias associated with that means that we stick to that frame and we are less likely to challenge the first information that we got.
00:23:49.745 --> 00:23:57.336
I could go like that, you know, for a long time, but that's basically what cognitive biases are and the problem with that.
00:23:57.336 --> 00:24:01.666
Well, first of all, you know, we can't avoid having these cognitive biases.
00:24:01.666 --> 00:24:04.177
That's part of being human, really.
00:24:04.177 --> 00:24:17.908
The problem lies in the fact that, because everybody, all humans, are going to react in the same way, well, then it makes us predictable and then it makes us manipulable.
00:24:17.908 --> 00:24:22.166
That's how dark patterns were created, in a way.
00:24:22.166 --> 00:24:25.385
It's a manipulation of our cognitive biases.
00:24:25.385 --> 00:24:34.190
It's playing on these human weaknesses to make us do things without realizing or even against our interests.
00:24:34.190 --> 00:24:35.400
Does that make sense?
00:24:36.215 --> 00:24:38.158
It does and it makes me wonder.
00:24:38.158 --> 00:24:46.050
We use law to address harms to people, especially in the United States.
00:24:46.050 --> 00:24:53.363
We have a very much - our privacy laws have been around where has there been a actual harm as opposed to rights- based.
00:24:53.363 --> 00:24:53.504
Right?
00:24:53.363 --> 00:24:54.888
Like it is in the EU.
00:24:54.888 --> 00:24:58.942
What does the law generally say about dark patterns?
00:24:58.942 --> 00:25:03.154
Do we have good, established laws around the world that address dark patterns?
00:25:03.154 --> 00:25:04.997
What is the state of the law today?
00:25:05.836 --> 00:25:06.758
Great question.
00:25:06.998 --> 00:25:14.863
The first thing to say is that it's always been prohibited to manipulate or deceive people.
00:25:14.863 --> 00:25:17.185
It never was licit in the first place.
00:25:17.185 --> 00:25:31.094
So, even if the term dark pattern was not specifically mentioned in a number of acts and regulations, for sure manipulating someone, deceiving someone, is totally prohibited.
00:25:31.094 --> 00:25:33.938
So, that's the first thing that's really, really important.
00:25:33.938 --> 00:25:35.221
For example, in the U.
00:25:35.221 --> 00:25:35.522
S.
00:25:35.522 --> 00:26:01.897
you've got Section 5 of the FTC Act on deceptive practices, which is totally and fully applicable to dark patterns and that's basically the legal basis that the FTC is using to go after Epic Games for all the dark patterns and trying in Fortnite, leading to a huge settlement for half a billion dollars, etc.
00:26:01.977 --> 00:26:03.821
So, that's really important.
00:26:03.821 --> 00:26:22.752
You don't need to have the term dark pattern in any piece of legislation for a dark pattern to be caught in that legislation, which means that you've got prohibitions and general prohibitions of manipulation and deception in consumer law, obviously in privacy law as well.
00:26:22.752 --> 00:26:34.257
Let's just remind everyone here that, obviously, in GDPR, there's the Article 5 of GDPR with the fairness principle (which is at the core of GDPR).
00:26:34.257 --> 00:26:41.289
Fairness means that, obviously, you can't trick anyone to obtain their personal data.
00:26:41.289 --> 00:26:44.321
That's completely illicit.
00:26:44.321 --> 00:26:44.842
Right?
00:26:45.143 --> 00:26:49.616
Especially as it really discusses consent like fairness around the consent.
00:26:49.797 --> 00:27:01.431
Exactly, and what's interesting is that for the past two or three years, we've been seeing new and specific legislation that would specifically target dark patterns.
00:27:01.431 --> 00:27:07.043
So, it comes in addition to all the existing legal framework, which I just described.
00:27:07.043 --> 00:27:08.786
For example, in the U.
00:27:08.786 --> 00:27:09.105
S.
00:27:09.105 --> 00:27:13.418
, the California Privacy Rights Act defines dark patterns specifically.
00:27:13.418 --> 00:27:21.298
The FTC staff report that they published in 2022 distinguishes four types of dark patterns.
00:27:21.298 --> 00:27:35.180
In the EU, we've got the Digital Markets Act, the Digital Services Act and the brand new AI Act, which also provide specific definitions of dark patterns and specific prohibitions.
00:27:35.180 --> 00:27:41.598
Basically, what it means is that the legal net is getting tighter and tighter.
00:27:41.598 --> 00:27:50.384
So, there are now multiple legal bases around the world that make dark patterns totally and utterly illicit.
00:27:51.015 --> 00:27:51.778
That's fascinating.
00:27:51.778 --> 00:28:02.879
It'll be interesting to see how quickly companies are ready to adapt to this growing net of laws around dark patterns as enforcement begins and what that'll look like.
00:28:03.140 --> 00:28:06.176
I know we could probably talk about that for like half a day as well.
00:28:06.176 --> 00:28:21.343
So, first I want to take the conversation really broad to talk about structural risks and our economies and such, and then I want the audience to know well, we are going to get very specific as to what do we mean about dark patterns and then how do we create countermeasures.
00:28:21.343 --> 00:28:23.894
What are the countermeasures to create fair patterns?
00:28:23.894 --> 00:28:28.625
But first, I want to really bring it to the societal impact.
00:28:28.625 --> 00:28:36.589
How do dark patterns create structural risks for our economies and then, ultimately, our democratic models?
00:28:36.589 --> 00:28:41.942
How do they impact competition and trust in brands and the overall market and such?
00:28:42.584 --> 00:28:44.348
That's such an important question.
00:28:44.348 --> 00:28:47.843
This has been studied by many regulators.
00:28:47.843
--> 00:28:56.791
So, we've got studies by the OECD, for example, and many other regulators, like the Competition and Markets Authority in the UK, the European Commission.
00:28:57.393 --> 00:29:39.576
Basically, they all say the same: ultimately, dark patterns do affect competition, mostly because, well, if consumers are prevented from changing suppliers because they are either caught in subscriptions that they can never cancel or because they are prevented from objectively comparing prices - which is another type of dark pattern - if consumers do not have transparent, objective information online which is another dark pattern then they're not able to make the best decisions for them, and so definitely it affects competition.
00:29:39.576 --> 00:30:08.725
Also, because dark patterns can and are used to collect ever more personal data, ever more personal data, which can give large groups a decisive competitive advantage or which could even strengthen a dominant position - I'm sure you're seeing which type of players I'm referring to - that creates a true structural risk for the economy.
00:30:08.725 --> 00:30:33.397
Let's just remind everyone that the reason why today we still consider market economy as the best model to date is that it's because it's supposed to bring the best benefits to consumers, and by best benefits it is understood lower prices, better quality of services and products, and innovation.
00:30:34.419 --> 00:30:51.683
But, what the OECD very clearly explained in its report in 2022 is that if companies end up competing by the quality, so to speak, of their dark patterns instead of focusing on innovation, low prices, etc.
00:30:51.683 --> 00:30:54.140
, then it's a losing game for consumers.
00:30:54.140 --> 00:30:55.204
They are being tricked.
00:30:55.204 --> 00:30:56.882
They don't get the lower prices.
00:30:56.882 --> 00:30:58.374
They don't get the better products.
00:30:58.676 --> 00:30:59.882
It's just a losing game.
00:30:59.882 --> 00:31:03.124
And then, of course, there's the trust issue.
00:31:03.124 --> 00:31:18.297
If consumers lose trust in brands because they've been tricked, because they've been manipulated, ultimately they also lose trust in the economy at large.
00:31:18.297 --> 00:31:19.199
So, that could also endanger the whole system.
00:31:19.199 --> 00:31:31.590
And, back to your point about the democratic model, ultimately it could also affect their trust in the overall democratic system and it's even beyond that.
00:31:31.975 --> 00:31:54.839
Our main concern, I guess, at Fair Patterns, is that once we're all trained to accept; once we're all used to click "I agree, even though we haven't read one single line, then what's the next thing that we accept blindly, without having read?
00:31:54.839 --> 00:32:05.027
From a democratic standpoint, it's an interesting question, particularly in 2024, which is a huge electoral year around the world.
00:32:05.027 --> 00:32:20.843
I think it was the Financial Times that published an article on the fact that no less than two billion citizens are going to vote this year and, of course, yeah, you've got a big election coming up in the U.
00:32:20.843 --> 00:32:21.144
S.
00:32:21.144 --> 00:32:21.946
, needless to say.
00:32:23.575 --> 00:32:23.575
Definitely.
00:32:23.575 --> 00:32:27.246
I think that all rings true to probably all of our experiences.
00:32:27.246 --> 00:32:27.555
So.
00:32:27.555 --> 00:32:33.664
thank you for framing the societal importance, or impact, I should say, of these dark patterns.
00:32:33.664 --> 00:32:35.408
Let's get to solutions.
00:32:35.408 --> 00:32:40.302
What are the benefits of using fair patterns and what are fair patterns?
00:32:40.602 --> 00:32:40.903
Yeah.
00:32:40.903 --> 00:32:48.923
Fair patterns are interfaces that empower users to make their own free and informed choices.
00:32:48.923 --> 00:33:14.798
It means that, instead of being tricked, instead of being left in the dark with a wall of jargon, et cetera, you are given the right information at the right time of your journey to understand the consequences of your choices and you are able to make the choice that's beneficial for you, that also matches your preferences.
00:33:14.798 --> 00:33:17.503
That's basically what a fair pattern is.
00:33:18.325 --> 00:33:24.303
Maybe it's interesting to get a bit more into concrete examples, if that's helpful.
00:33:24.303 --> 00:33:30.644
So, for example, you can have a number of default settings which are are harmful.
00:33:30.644 --> 00:33:33.499
It's the pre-ticked boxes, it's all of that.
00:33:33.499 --> 00:33:42.985
Well, the countermeasure, the fair pattern to that, is simply neutral default, where actually you don't have the pre-ticked box.
00:33:42.985 --> 00:33:44.368
You're not framed.
00:33:45.897 --> 00:33:51.528
Back to the question of cognitive biases, it could be empty boxes.
00:33:51.528 --> 00:33:58.783
It could be individualized settings that allow the user to choose for each single case.
00:33:58.783 --> 00:34:12.072
Perhaps, as a practical example, we could describe some default setting where you have one single box for several purposes of data processing.
00:34:12.072 --> 00:34:21.038
Well, first, that's illicit, but second, obviously you know you can't decide to what you agree simply because there's one single box.
00:34:21.038 --> 00:34:33.876
So the fair pattern is simply to have several boxes that are not pre-ticked, so that you're not framed and you can have a granular consent and a distinct decision.
00:34:33.876 --> 00:34:41.639
So, for example, you could agree to receive the newsletter but not the promotional offers from the company's partners.
00:34:41.639 --> 00:34:43.083
Does that make sense at all?
00:34:43.644 --> 00:34:44.708
Yeah, absolutely.
00:34:44.708 --> 00:34:48.960
You're not combining all the consent into one thing so that it's binary.
00:34:48.960 --> 00:34:54.628
You're giving kind of choices to the individual as to what they
want to opt in or out of.
00:34:55.710 --> 00:34:56.311
Exactly.
00:34:56.311 --> 00:35:10.581
To stick to the privacy dark and fair patterns, very often, as regards to the privacy settings, you've got what we call a maze - something that is super difficult to navigate.
00:35:10.581 --> 00:35:21.943
You have to click, like, at least five times to make the first choice, and then you have to go back to a different page to continue adjusting your privacy settings.
00:35:21.943 --> 00:35:24.695
None of that is by chance, obviously.
00:35:25.396 --> 00:35:32.028
So, the fair pattern that solves this type of situation is simply a seamless path.
00:35:33.659 --> 00:35:56.648
It could take many different forms, but it could be a privacy dashboard where you have all your rights and all your options at a glance on one single screen with buttons, and you can decide okay, I'm happy to share my name and my email address for that purpose to this company, but not to the third party partners.
00:35:56.648 --> 00:36:07.577
I'm not happy to share my phone number, except for deliveries, perhaps you know I want to decide on the information on how I use the services.
00:36:07.577 --> 00:36:15.461
Well, I'm okay for your company, the one I'm buying from, to use it, but not third-party partners, etc.
00:36:15.461 --> 00:36:19.748
Basically, it's really good UX.
00:36:19.748 --> 00:36:23.157
That's what I want to say.
00:36:23.157 --> 00:36:27.820
If you think about it, UX wasn't meant to trick anyone.
00:36:27.820 --> 00:36:36.606
It was meant to help users do what they intended to do in a quick and easy way.
00:36:43.673 --> 00:36:51.320
That makes a lot of sense, especially when you frame it that way.
00:36:51.320 --> 00:37:07.288
One of the reasons we're talking about this topic on The Shifting Privacy Left Podcast is that we want to shift addressing privacy way earlier on, before you ever collect data in the design phase, the development phase, the products, the getting the requirements for the product phase.
00:37:07.288 --> 00:37:07.615
Right?
00:37:07.615 --> 00:37:17.517
Well before you even have to think about the life cycle of data, shift into earlier in the decision-making and make sure you've got good privacy.
00:37:17.517 --> 00:37:23.932
So, privacy design and privacy UX is a huge component of that.
00:37:23.932 --> 00:37:28.702
It's the perfect conversation for today and for this show and for this audience.
00:37:29.224 --> 00:37:45.124
So, what I'd like to do now is your Fair Patterns project has identified - they came up with seven categories of dark patterns with, I believe it was, 16 different dark patterns that fit in those seven categories; and you could go to fairpatterns.
00:37:45.124 --> 00:37:55.945
com and see that for each category there is a definition, what are the main cognitive biases that are manipulated through that dark pattern, and then the main risks to individuals.
00:37:55.945 --> 00:38:08.313
But, I'd rather focus on today in our
conversation, I'd like to go through each of those seven categories and talk about what are the fair pattern countermeasures as I walk through those.
00:38:08.313 --> 00:38:09.275
Does that make sense to you?
00:38:09.275 --> 00:38:21.200
[Marie: Sure, sure, sure].
00:38:21.200 --> 00:38:26.880
So, I think that you already talked about the first one, this sense of a maze, where you're tricking the user and they have to go through seems like an endless number of clicks until they're able to actually effectuate what it is they want to do maybe opt out, cancel something, whatever.
00:38:27.541 --> 00:38:33.481
You mentioned that the seamless path is the countermeasure, the fair pattern, to use instead.
00:38:33.481 --> 00:38:37.450
So let's go to the second one, which is called harmful default.
00:38:37.450 --> 00:38:40.423
What is that and what are the countermeasures there?
00:38:47.659 --> 00:38:47.740
Yeah.
00:38:47.740 --> 00:39:01.059
So the harmful default, you know, is this pre-ticked box that could also combine several purposes, and so you couldn't decide whether you agree to one purpose but not to the other, and so the countermeasure is this neutral default with the granularity of choice, basically.
00:39:01.059 --> 00:39:07.793
So, you can decide for each different purpose, what you agree with and what you disagree to.
00:39:07.793 --> 00:39:12.912
The third category is misleading or obstructing language.
00:39:12.912 --> 00:39:18.532
By the way, the way we call dark patterns really doesn't matter, at least not to us.
00:39:18.532 --> 00:39:20.867
What really matters is the solution.
00:39:20.867 --> 00:39:27.393
So, the solution to misleading or obstructing language is simply plain and empowering language.
00:39:27.393 --> 00:39:28.981
And you know what, Debra?
00:39:28.981 --> 00:39:36.822
Spoiler alert to your audience, it is totally possible to explain privacy with plain language.
00:39:36.822 --> 00:39:42.913
It doesn't have to be, you know, obscure, full of legalese, absolutely not.
00:39:42.913 --> 00:39:44.682
We do that for a living.
00:39:44.682 --> 00:40:07.871
And plain and empowering language means that anyone without a legal background, you know, without being a specialist in privacy, very easily finds the information they need; that they understand it upon first reading - that's very important; and, that they also understand the consequences of their choices.
00:40:07.871 --> 00:40:12.249
So, that could be very short and clear sentences, obviously.
00:40:12.249 --> 00:40:17.483
A neutral tone of voice, also, to avoid any emotion manipulation.
00:40:17.483 --> 00:40:29.209
But, that's also sometimes about adding some information, precisely to empower users to understand the consequences of their choices.
00:40:29.650 --> 00:40:37.567
Then, we've got the category that we call distorted UX, and the fair pattern to that is fair UX.
00:40:37.567 --> 00:40:42.273
So, this one is really common sense, I would like to say.
00:40:42.273 --> 00:40:49.869
A distorted UX would be basically trapping users through the visual interface.
00:40:49.869 --> 00:41:17.010
So, for example, you would have something, an interface with your birth date, and then a big fat button share it with everyone, and obviously you are prompted, if not manipulated, to share this personal information, when a fair UX will be a visual interface that really respects your intention.
00:41:17.010 --> 00:41:28.476
So, you would have three equivalent buttons, for example, to decide with which companies or people you want to share your birth date.
00:41:29.017 --> 00:41:45.867
It could be the company services, it could be your friends, it could be everyone, but you really have a choice and you've got three equivalent buttons with the same salience, the same color, and there's no visual interference that directs your choices.
00:41:45.867 --> 00:41:47.550
Does that make sense at all?
00:41:47.550 --> 00:41:49.376
[Debra: It does, thank you].
00:41:49.376 --> 00:42:11.452
I think what's important to mention is that we've developed, not just the concept, but also a library of patterns that we're continuously improving and expanding, and so that's what's great about a pattern is that it's a system that will consistently solve the problem.
00:42:11.452 --> 00:42:26.932
And just so you know, we've been testing the fair patterns with users, also with a range of experts, independent experts to continuously improve them, and so we hope in the future to develop even further our library of fair patterns.
00:42:28.000 --> 00:42:31.055
Yeah, in fact it's not just like legal experts, right?
00:42:31.055 --> 00:42:33.884
You have really interesting people, like you have neuroscientists.
00:42:33.884 --> 00:42:37.132
Say the types of experts you're working with on this site.
00:42:37.400 --> 00:42:38.704
That's a great question.
00:42:38.704 --> 00:42:49.713
So obviously, you know, this is a multidisciplinary collaboration where we've got, obviously, UX strategists, so UX designers, but also neuroscientists.
00:42:49.713 --> 00:42:54.811
This is absolutely critical, given the cognitive biases at stake.
00:42:54.811 --> 00:43:31.204
We've got plain language experts working with us within the team, obviously legal experts, privacy experts, and last year we decided to have our concept and the library of fair patterns audited or examined by 10 independent experts in the various fields that I mentioned, including psychology, so that they would give their honest, objective opinion about what works, what should be improved, and that was an amazing experience and that pushed us even further.
00:43:31.726 --> 00:43:32.489
That's awesome.
00:43:32.489 --> 00:43:45.266
And just to close the loop, the last three dark patterns and countermeasures are "more than intended is the dark pattern and the countermeasure is free action, and you can learn about all these on the website.
00:43:45.266 --> 00:43:51.568
The sixth one is push and
pressure, and then the countermeasure would be non-intrusive information.
00:43:51.568 --> 00:43:58.211
And then the last is the dark pattern would be missing information and the countermeasure would be adequate information.
00:43:58.211 --> 00:44:00.864
Again, you could find more information on fairpatterns.
00:44:00.864 --> 00:44:02.226
com.
00:44:02.226 --> 00:44:21.351
I'm also going to ask in a little bit where else people can learn about this, but for now, given that we've got privacy engineers as an audience base for this show, what advice do you have specifically for designers and developers to ensure that they are designing fair patterns as they're building products and features?
00:44:22.581 --> 00:44:29.365
Sure, this is a very, very important point, because everything you know goes to practice and practical solutions.
00:44:29.365 --> 00:44:37.625
So our advice for designers is basically to go through a series of short and simple questions.
00:44:37.625 --> 00:44:42.253
This is a framework that we've developed with Harry Brignull.
00:44:42.253 --> 00:44:45.284
He joined us in January, which is amazing.
00:44:45.865 --> 00:44:55.409
Together, Harry and I, we've developed this fairly simple framework that we called: Does My Design Contain Harmful Choice Architecture?
00:44:55.409 --> 00:45:04.688
" And this was based on The Seven Stages of Action Model by Don Norman, obviously, who needs no introduction to designers.
00:45:04.688 --> 00:45:21.548
So, we took those seven stages and applied them to harmful choice architecture; and, basically, for when you start the product design phase, you have the perception, then the comprehension, then a number of steps.
00:45:21.849 --> 00:45:33.208
What we advise designers to do is, at each of these steps, ask themselves five simple questions at each of the stages of the user experience.
00:45:33.389 --> 00:45:35.755
The first question is Autonomy.
00:45:35.755 --> 00:45:42.552
Does my design allow users to make decisions based on their preferences?
00:45:42.552 --> 00:45:45.369
The second question is Agency.
00:45:45.369 --> 00:45:55.153
Back to your point, Debra, does my design allow users to take the actions they want easily, without coercion?
00:45:55.153 --> 00:45:58.389
The third question is Transparency.
00:46:00.615 --> 00:46:09.574
Does my design provide sufficient objective, accessible information in plain language for users to make informed decisions.
00:46:09.574 --> 00:46:12.159
The fourth question is Honesty.
00:46:12.159 --> 00:46:20.635
Does my design contain misleading information or omissions that could induce false beliefs?
00:46:20.635 --> 00:46:25.872
And the fifth question, which is probably my favorite, is Fairness.
00:46:25.872 --> 00:46:34.597
Is my design likely to cause an outcome that's favorable to the business but detrimental to the users?
00:46:34.597 --> 00:46:44.555
And so, with these five fairly simple questions, we actually catch most of the legislative and regulatory framework.
00:46:44.555 --> 00:46:56.465
It seems quite simple when I say it like that, but this is actually the result of tons of legal research to make sure that we catch GDPR, old privacy laws currently tackling dark patterns, et cetera.
00:46:56.465 --> 00:46:58.608
So, we hope that's helpful to designers.
00:46:59.579 --> 00:47:04.706
That is really helpful and I think you framed it really well for why designers and developers should care.
00:47:04.706 --> 00:47:16.630
Those personas, the designers and the developers, they, a lot of the times, are going to be driven by executive and marketing's desire to boost sales through these interfaces.
00:47:16.630 --> 00:47:16.932
Right?
00:47:16.932 --> 00:47:18.940
But, we want to do that without dark patterns.
00:47:18.940 --> 00:47:22.563
So how can companies boost sales with fair patterns?
00:47:23.925 --> 00:47:39.371
Well, the great news is that we've been working hard with economists and we've been studying plenty of econometrics studies, and the good news is that fair patterns produce better results than dark patterns after six months.
00:47:39.873 --> 00:47:47.353
It's true that, for a very short amount of time, dark patterns might be more profitable; but, that's really only two or three months.
00:47:47.800 --> 00:47:59.628
The curve really changes as soon as six months afterwards, when fair patterns are actually as efficient economically as dark patterns.
00:48:00.068 --> 00:48:03.014
Then, after six months, they become more profitable.
00:48:03.014 --> 00:48:24.842
We've been seeing that in the media sector, for example, where subscription-based models clearly show that a fair pattern is going to be more efficient, simply because people actually don't want to subscribe, or subscribe less when they suspect a dark pattern.
00:48:24.842 --> 00:48:28.229
So, they will just refrain from subscribing.
00:48:28.229 --> 00:48:54.110
When there's a fair pattern, they are more inclined to subscribe because they know they won't be tricked, and so that makes trust and the customer lifetime value that derives from trust, that makes fair patterns way more profitable - not just in the middle term, but obviously in the longer term, because it's also boosting the value of your brand instead of damaging it.
00:48:55.375 --> 00:48:56.920
That's really compelling data.
00:48:56.920 --> 00:49:01.512
I would love for you, after this call, if you could send me the [inaudible].
00:49:02.360 --> 00:49:03.326
Yeah, of course.
00:49:03.599 --> 00:49:17.151
Let's get this in the hands of those who are designing the UX and UI and developing new products and features so that they could push back against marketing teams and executives that are trying to push them into creating dark patterns.
00:49:17.291 --> 00:49:21.706
Then, if you could have these compelling metrics that, "Hey, we could boost sales better with fair patterns.
00:49:21.706 --> 00:49:27.240
I think that that could really do a lot of good for
well society as a whole.
00:49:27.240 --> 00:49:32.501
But first, to push back on management with what is ethical, right and going to make them more money.
00:49:32.501 --> 00:49:34.769
It's pretty compelling.
00:49:35.771 --> 00:49:40.485
Then, also make sure to share with me the document you were saying that you helped create.
00:49:40.686 --> 00:49:42.751
The framework.
00:49:45.485 --> 00:49:45.485
Yes, I would love to put that in our Show Notes.
00:49:45.485 --> 00:49:52.090
So, where can our listeners learn more about dark patterns besides, you have a wonderful podcast called Fighting Dark Patterns.
00:49:52.090 --> 00:49:53.545
People should check that out.
00:49:53.545 --> 00:49:55.648
And then, of course, the Fair Patterns website.
00:49:55.648 --> 00:50:05.311
But, in terms of categorizing them and showing how they work and spread and which risks they create and which laws they breach, where would you direct people to learn more?
00:50:06.059 --> 00:50:12.874
So, without hesitation, the go-to source is Harry Brignull's website Deceptive Design Patterns.
00:50:12.874 --> 00:50:15.289
It's a goldmine of information.
00:50:15.289 --> 00:50:18.690
Again, you know he was the one inventing the term.
00:50:18.690 --> 00:50:26.130
He's been really leading the research since then and his website is a goldmine of information, as well as his book.
00:50:26.130 --> 00:50:29.731
Let's remind that he authored a book last summer.
00:50:29.731 --> 00:50:31.887
It's super easy to read.
00:50:31.887 --> 00:50:40.244
It's really not just for designers, it's for everyone, and I cannot recommend it enough In terms of online information.
00:50:40.704 --> 00:50:45.434
There's also the dark patterns tip line if you want to report a dark pattern.
00:50:45.434 --> 00:50:47.967
So there's a hall of shame on Harry's website.
00:50:47.967 --> 00:50:53.713
There's also a tip line in the, specifically in the US, where you can report dark patterns.
00:50:53.713 --> 00:50:59.753
And then, of course, you know you can and you should just tag the companies.
00:50:59.753 --> 00:51:08.289
If you see an interface that very much looks like a dark pattern, just tag them on social networks with the hashtag "dark patterns.
00:51:08.289 --> 00:51:12.331
Ask the company, make them accountable for what they produce.
00:51:13.240 --> 00:51:15.289
This really has an effect, by the way.
00:51:15.289 --> 00:51:23.501
We know for a fact that regulators are really tracking those comments on social media with the hashtag "dark patterns.
00:51:23.501 --> 00:51:33.005
It could also prompt regulators to you know, engage, to launch a legal action or to ask questions, to launch an investigation.
00:51:33.005 --> 00:51:38.664
So, it's really worth spending those few minutes to post on socials if you see one.
00:51:38.784 --> 00:51:39.385
Oh, that's great.
00:51:39.385 --> 00:51:43.010
It feels empowering in a world where you feel like you can't control everything.
00:51:43.010 --> 00:51:48.067
You can actually take some action that might affect some change in that way, so that's awesome.
00:51:48.067 --> 00:51:54.750
What is the best way for people to reach out to you to learn more about Amurabi's legal design services or fairpatterns.
00:51:54.750 --> 00:51:55.532
com?
00:51:56.280 --> 00:51:58.204
There's our Amurabi.
00:51:58.204 --> 00:51:58.905
eu website.
00:51:58.905 --> 00:51:59.686
There's fairpatterns.
00:51:59.686 --> 00:52:00.949
com.
00:52:00.949 --> 00:52:04.295
And, I'm always happy to share thoughts on LinkedIn.
00:52:04.295 --> 00:52:05.927
I'm very easy to find on LinkedIn.
00:52:05.927 --> 00:52:11.706
Just tag me or reach out to me, and I'm always happy to have a chat.
00:52:11.907 --> 00:52:12.369
Excellent.
00:52:12.369 --> 00:52:18.485
And lastly, I usually ask this for most of my guests, do you have any words of wisdom to leave our audience of privacy engineers with today?
00:52:18.485 --> 00:52:19.932
Or, last words of wisdom; you've given us plenty of words of wisdom.
00:52:26.320 --> 00:52:34.494
I guess, what I really want your audience to take away is this decision-making governance.
00:52:34.494 --> 00:52:47.952
You know we've been talking a lot about dark patterns and interfaces, but there are also dark patterns in AI, thanks to AI, but also within AI itself, within the algorithms themselves.
00:52:48.875 --> 00:52:52.162
This is so critical for privacy.
00:52:52.162 --> 00:53:01.007
If we're no longer able to make our own decisions, to make meaningful choices for ourselves, it's the end of privacy, simply.
00:53:01.007 --> 00:53:09.500
So, decision-making governance that's really what every privacy engineer should be working on.
00:53:09.539 --> 00:53:10.686
Thank you so much.
00:53:10.686 --> 00:53:12.728
It's been a really fascinating conversation.
00:53:12.728 --> 00:53:16.668
Thank you for joining us on The Shifting Privacy Left Podcast.
00:53:16.668 --> 00:53:22.260
Until next Tuesday, everyone, when we'll be back with engaging content and another great guest.
00:53:22.260 --> 00:53:27.490
Thanks for joining us this week on Shifting Privacy Left.
00:53:27.490 --> 00:53:29.880
Make sure to visit our website, shiftingprivacyleft.
00:53:29.880 --> 00:53:34.992
com, where you can subscribe to updates so you'll never miss a show.
00:53:34.992 --> 00:53:36.503
While you're at it.
00:53:36.503 --> 00:53:38.691
if you found this episode valuable, go ahead and share it with a friend.
00:53:38.691 --> 00:53:48.605
And, if you're an engineer who cares passionately about privacy, check out Privado: the developer-friendly privacy platform and sponsor of this show.
00:53:48.605 --> 00:53:50.289
To learn more, go to privado.
00:53:50.289 --> 00:53:51.733
ai.
00:53:51.733 --> 00:53:54.925
Be sure to tune in next Tuesday for a new episode.
00:53:54.925 --> 00:53:55.688
Bye for now.