TRASCRIZIONE 🔗
00:00:00
Speaker 1: Donald Trump's approval ratings not heading in the right direction, but Republicans still not looking terrible in this November. Is there right chance they hold Congress come January twenty twenty seven. Harry Enton joins for that conversation and much more. I'm Josh amber and this is Josh Hambershaw. Harry Enton, I've seen and joins us a little lay in the program for a wide ranging conversation about all things midterm related President Trump, Senate's House DSA. We will get into all of that and morbar for now, just some headlines that we want to impath for you before a conversation with Harry Enton. So, as of this morning, Friday morning, Bill Cassidy of Louisiana, the Lame Duck Center, Donald Trump personally campaigned against, and indeed Bill Cassidy lost quite bigly, you might say, in his Louisiana primary, finishing third actually in that state wide contest. He has come out and he has said that he will indeed be the final vote for Todd Blanche as trained I know. So to back up a little bit, Susan Collins and Lisa mccowski the to Rhino East of the Rhinos in the Caucuss has said that they will not be voting for Tod Blanche, who ultimately came down to Bill Cassie or else. This could have been a real defeat for President Trump. But Bill Cassidy is going out with some pizzazz and with some style. He could have chosen the deeply, deeply petty route. He could have done that, and he could have just tried to stick it to Donald Trump. But he deserves credit. Frankly, Cassie deserves credits for saying he will vote for Todd Blanche, Dido John Corn, by the way, Corn and Tillis of North Carolina, who we were very critical of here on the show, including just a Monday with our guests Will Chamberlain. We're very critical of them for their very unclear ask from Todd Blanche when it came to the so called anti Weaponization Fund, but they ultimately did come down on the right side, and the ultimately did come down voting for Todd Blanche. And at this point, top Blanche is going to be confirmed, presumably this weekend, and that's a real win for Donald Trump. Top Blanche is going to be a turnal. He's already been the acting Attorney general for some months now. He's essentially been running the show already. We talk a lot about a torney general here on the show because it is my long standing belief that it is the single most important cabinet position in the entire executive branch.
00:02:14
Speaker 2: In all of Article two.
00:02:16
Speaker 1: There are a lot of other big ones or Secretary of State, Secretary of War, Secretary of Treasury, and beyond, but the most foundational core duty of the President United States is to quote take care that the laws be faithfully executed.
00:02:29
Speaker 2: That's a take care clause of Article to the Constitution.
00:02:32
Speaker 1: That means you need a rock solid and dare I say, also, very loyal Attorney general tub Blanche will be exactly that the man has led for the President in a personal capacity when he defended Trump during the height of the Democrat Law Fair Complex persecution, the Merrick Garland Jack Smith targeting of Donald Trump. Blanche is going to be a great attorney general and that is now totally confirmed. Well, speaking of President Trump, by another thing that just leapt off the page to me was Trump signed two executive orders on Thursday yesterday on the topic of birthright citizenship. Now you might say, how could he possibly do anything here. The Supreme Court just ruled on this and the Trump versus Barbara case. But did they did they actually rule squirrely completely on literally every aspect of the birthright citizenship debates. And the answer is no, they did not. What the Barbara case did was it essentially upheld the eighteen ninety eight wan kim Ark case, which infamously said that if you are here, then you and you and you give birth to a child, then that person, that child will be a US citizen. The wan kim Mar case purported to limit its to legal aliens, those who were domicilet here. In the language of the opinion, the move from Wankimark to Barbara is then to take that and to expand it to illegal aliens, which is an incorrect, erroneous move. But that was moving Barbara. What Barbara did not do. What the Barbara case did not do is it did not overturn, It did not overturn the exceptions that were already part of the wan kim Arc regime. So if you go back and read the Barbara opinion, it deliberately intentionally leaves in place the exceptions to blanket birth resizenship from the wankim mar case over a century prior. Those exceptions are things like the children of ambassadors, the children of foreign consuls, and foreign dinitaries. Those folks are very very very clearly under any interpretation, they are quote not subject to the jurisdiction of the United States in the relevant forty million language, and therefore they do not get automaticizenship when they have children on this soil. There are other examples as well, as we discussed on this show. A major example is invasion. If you have a foreign hostile adversary, an army, a military, or even a Maltia or some functional military that is in the midst of an invasion on this soil, those children they don't get birthright citizenship. So when the British were well, this is before the forty amendment, but in theory, when the British were burning down the US capital in the war making twelve, they have a child not birthwright sitizenship. And today I would argue if you are the child of one of the cartel leaders. For instance, if you're part of the Sinela cartel and you're human trafficking in the Rio Grande Valley in Texas and you get over the border and you have a child. No, that's an invasion. And in fact, there is this new bill from Senator Jim Banks of Indiana that is trying to convey this into law and to declare that birth taurus and those who are who are born here to legal alien parents shall be interpreted as invaders for purposes of Wanki, Mark
Load full transcript
and Barbara, therefore falling outside of the Trump versus Barbara decision. It's a very very good idea and one that I've been pushing in my own capacity for some time. Hopefully that build get some tractors. So what did don Trump actually do in these executive orders? Well, he signed two of them. The first executive order is targeted on birth tourism itself, and it basically says that if you are here and you fraudulently get a visa solely for purposes, solely for purposes of trying to give birth here, then that's not actually going to cut it. Then you're not actually automatically going to get citizenship for just getting a visa and then coming here. Now, birth tourism was not directly directly addressed by the Barbara majority, something that was pointed out by the dissenters by Sam Alito by Clara Thomas really a Lada more than anyone else, because birth tourism was not really a thing in the wan kim Ark regime. In other words, in eight ninety eight, there was no world. We could hop on a plane and then flighting and I says, pop out a baby, get a citizen. So when Barbara upheld the wan k Mark exceptions, bird tourism was not really discussed, if that makes sense. So Trump is trying to create this birth tourism exception as well. That's one of the executive ors. The other executive order is just affirming that these one k Mark Barbera exceptions still apply. So the executive order, this is the second one, applies to future birth tied to four categories. Children born of foreign diplomatic staff working on behalf of another government, while in the US, children of people who are classified as alien enemies, including those who belong to FTOS, foreign terrorist organization especially designated terrorist groups, et cetera, those who were born in US territories. That's actually more interesting and long standing legal disputes. And then children born to mothers who expressly and deceptively enter for the sole purpose of birth tourism. So that's the first secutive order. Those are the base parts of these executive orders. They will immediately be subject to legal challenge, I presume, if the ACLU and various other liberal groups have not sued already. I think Trump is on firm ground here with these, especially especially with that second one, just trying to recodify the one Mark Barbara exceptions. The birth tourism one is a more novel question, again one not squarely addressed by the Barbara case. We will see how it winds its ways through the courts. Frankly, entirely possible that actually that actually that exact question, how birth tourism specifically, how that comports with the Ford mental comports exactly with the Barbara case and the one kid Mark regime. It's entirely possible that that ends up getting back to the Supreme Courts, and that will definitely be a blockbuster case. Finally, one other headline that I want to get to. So if you're a long time listener view of the show, you know that big tech is a topic that I care a lot about for a lot of reasons. One is because big tech controls the modern day public Square X Facebook, look meta. These are TikTok. This is how you communicate in the twenty first century. Back in seventy seventy six, you had Thomas Paine running around in Philadelphia Ton Commons passing out as pamphlet common sense. But that's not a thing anymore now you do it online. But there are all sorts of other reasons to care about big tech as well. One of them is that these algorithms are all the time is pushing vulnerable people to really malicious content. And there's been all sorts of lawsuits in recent years that Meta, more than any other company, has faced Mark Zuckerberg's company, which controls Facebook, Instagram, and WhatsApp. Because you have parents of teenagers who have sued for mental health for mental health but been saying that Meta either was willfully ignorant of negligently did not care about the mental health of their users, or in a worst case scenario, it actually exacerbated and made it worse. So a court in New Mexico on Thursday, as a result of this lawsuit, order Meta to pay more than half a billion dollars five hundred and sixty seven million dollars. That's on top of a previous jury judgment back in March that order three hundred and seventy five million. So this brings Meta's liability in this one case alone to almost a billion dollars nine hundred and forty two million dollars. Why is this Well, the judge Brian Bidesheide found that Meta had created a public nuisance, which means that it's a it's a hazard basically for the whole state, and as part of this judgment, he ordered the company to implement a series of youth safety measures that include things like monthly limits on teens use of Facebook and Instagram, restrictions on notifications, tighter controls on adults contacting miners, safeguards for AI, chatbots and the like. We've touched this a little bit recently, especially in the context of AI, which is the big conversation du jour, But this is our basic thesis on the topic of big tech technologies are here to stay.
00:11:03
Speaker 2: We are not luttites.
00:11:04
Speaker 1: We're not trying to put the technological genie back into the bottle. There's no point in trying to go to the local data center and protesting that it be shut down because it's probably very profitable. It's probably actually paying a lot of property taxes, it's not going there. Rather, the better solution, whether it's in social media, big tech, AI, whatever, is to have prudential regulations and rules such as what this judge is doing here and is ruling in place that channel this technology and harness it so that it elevates human flourishing and openly conduces.
00:11:36
Speaker 2: To the common good.
00:11:38
Speaker 1: Technology has in the long run of things, has benefit of mankind, whether it's the printing press or electricity, the automobile, you name it. But you need regulations for new technologies because otherwise it could get lost. This ruling
out in New Mexico is a very very sound step in the right direction. Hopefully much more to come. I definitely don't pity Mark Zuckerberg and Facebook. They deserve to pay this. Hopefully, Frankly, there will be much more to come on that front.
00:12:04
Speaker 2: Folks. About to go to a quick commercial break.
00:12:07
Speaker 1: On the other side, we'll be joined by Harry Anthon of CN for a long ranging conversation on the midterms and much more.
00:12:12
Speaker 2: We'll be right back with Harry Entton. Welcome back. So we have a special treat for you today, folks.
00:12:21
Speaker 1: Making his return appearance to the Josh Shammer Show is a longtime guest and a longtime friend. You've probably seen him on your television recently. He is none other than Harry Enton. So Harry Enton is the chief data analyst for CNN and the host of the nine Scale on CNN All Access. He has also become ubiquitous in political media, frankly, and media in general. Harry, I've known you a long time, my friend, and I've really enjoyed watching you explode into being the polling guru of all gurus. And we look forward to getting your insights here on the show today. So thank you very much for joining. I want to start at a higher level that then we'll start to get and little nitty gritty. We're now in the home stretch. So this this is August, this is the recess month, and then it's really the home stretch of Tenber October into the midterms. There is so much fretting that I see, well, really across the spectromy especially on the right, Democrats roughly five percent advantage on the generic ballot. But give me just your high level observations as to right now where things stand when we're getting into the midterm conversation.
00:13:27
Speaker 3: Yeah, Sholom. Good shots to you, my dear friend. Look, here's the deal, right, I think you hit it right. You look at the different generic ballots, you might find you know, three, you might find five, you might find seven, you might find nine. It's somewhere, you know, five, six, seven, somewhere that Democrats are ahead.
00:13:45
Speaker 2: What does that mean?
00:13:45
Speaker 3: Well, first off, if that translated perfectly to what the House result would be, Democrats would take back the US House of Representatives. I think most handicappers believe that they will do so the exact majority be determined. It probably won't be a seed or two, but a won't be you know, Democrats running away and getting two hundred and thirty five, two hundred and forty House seats.
00:14:05
Speaker 2: That being said, five is pretty close to three.
00:14:08
Speaker 3: If you take you know, an average apolisy, you probably ge pretty close to five. And I think three to four is kind of a dividing line. I think that's where most experts do it, between Republicans holding out of the House and Democrats gaining the House because of three district thing that happened across the map. So if you know Democrats win by a point or two, that's not good enough. So it's still within the margin of era, but Democrats are favored there. The Senate, to me, is the far more interesting picture, right. The Senate's interesting because if you take an initial look at the map, you'd say, hey, there's no way. But given that Donald Trump's approval rating is at best in the low forties at this point, again depending on which poll you look at, and more likely than not in the upper thirties, that puts states at play that might not otherwise do so. And we can dig into that more. But I think the high level thought here is President Trump's some popular Democrats are favoring in the House. Republicans are favorite to hold onto the Senate, but not by as much as they probably should be.
00:15:06
Speaker 2: So let's droll on the House. Then we'll get to the Senate.
00:15:07
Speaker 1: So the House, Harry, what I've been saying on the show for months now is is Republicans have essentially picked up ten to fifteen seats just in redistioning alone. So it kind of becomes a calculation as to what is the greater advantage. Is it the redistioning pickup or is it the generic advantage in the polling for Democrats?
00:15:25
Speaker 2: And there's also there's so few districts at.
00:15:27
Speaker 1: This point that a true swing, was it fifteen twenty dishriest in the whole country that are essentially toss up. So if you're handicapping the House at this point, what would what would you say?
00:15:37
Speaker 3: Yeah, okay, so you know, you're digging a little bit deeper and we can kind of discuss that. I kind of did a little bit, but yeah, I mean, look, I think the simplest way to do it, which was, you know, if you had just looked at the twenty twenty four House lines, right, you would say that Democrats really only needed to barely win the national popular vote in order to take back the House. What are we talking We're talking a ship of you know, uh, maybe they have to win it by half a point and that would be good enough. But now what we're really doing, and again modeling this is not the easiest thing in the world, but we're really talking about, is that Democrats need to win nationally by three to four points, which is a big difference. Right, That's a three to four point shift that we're talking about at this point. It does seem that the anger towards the incoming party, which is what you normally see in a midterm will be great enough and be able to climb that wall in order to get over the top. But you know, when you're all of a sudden looking at the math and you're looking at the map, what you do see is that Republicans start off at a higher baseline than they did in prior cycles. You know, it's something instead of you know, seats that are leaning Republican or say for likely republican, probably was between two hundred and two ten, say in twenty eighteen at this point. Now we're north of ten right now, right, we're talking to twelve two thirteen, again, depending on how you do the math. But given how unpopular the
president is, it just you look at that generic bot, it's just tough. But I will say this, which is it's close enough whereby you have you know, what's going on in Ohio seventh District with Max Miller, where you say that that seat now favors Democrats in my mind if Miller stays in a race, and that could really matter at the end of the day. So we're not far enough away to say one seat doesn't matter, yeah, but we are Democrats are up enough where we can say they're up.
00:17:34
Speaker 2: Yeah.
00:17:35
Speaker 1: No, the polling out of a House seven is not great. And I am among those who woud encourage Max Miller to drop out of this race or whatever it's worth.
00:17:41
Speaker 2: But I mean another hand Harry into in Tennessee.
00:17:43
Speaker 1: Just last night Andy Ogles lost his election to a comparative moderate. So maybe maybe, but that's probably a safety anyway. It's hard to say, but that's that's a student analysis has always my friends. So I want to turn to the Senates, which, as you said, is is the more interesting of the two chambers. The situation Michigan, I think definitely is another wrinkle broad into the broader Senate map. I think a lot of folks frankly didn't have Mike Rogers on the radar as a likely Michigan pickup opportunity in the Senate. So it talk about Michigan a little bit, but also how Michigan fits into to the broader play for a control of the Senate.
00:18:19
Speaker 2: Come January twent twenty seven, all right, let's talk about Michigan. Let's talk about a little history of Michigan.
00:18:23
Speaker 3: The state hasn't elected or Republican senator since Spencer Abraham back in nineteen hundred and ninety four. I don't think a Republican has won an a mid term there since what like nineteen hundred and sixty six something like that, and that was with a Democratic president. I can't even remember the last time they did so with a Republican president. So you look at that as you know, no way. But then all of a sudden you look over the last few years and you see that those margins that Democrats have been winning the Senate races, why I have shrunk and shrunk and trunk, and Alyssa sluck and won by less than a point. Then you look at who the candidate is, and obviously Abdulla Sied ran and a very good campaign in that primary. Obviously the Democratic Party has moved to the left of where it once was. The Democratic Party is significantly more skeptical of Israel than it once was. And Abdula said, is certainly no friend of Israel, at least is I think the way most people would define it, certainly not the people in Israel. And you watch his primary performance and you go, wow, this guy barely won.
00:19:27
Speaker 2: He won by what a point and.
00:19:29
Speaker 3: Did so on the backs of college towns and the Arab Muslim population in and around Detroit. He lost all fifteen counties with the lowest share of college educated voters. He very clearly lost in the swing areas. And you look at Mike Rogers, who lost by less than a point, and you go, wow, there's a real potential pickup opportunity here. Now, I will not the prediction markets still have I'll say it favored, but barely.
00:19:58
Speaker 2: Well.
00:19:58
Speaker 3: Now, now look at that right, and you go, okay, if Republicans can possibly win there, it makes the map so much more difficult. And combine that with what you have going on in Maine. Right, I think Troy Jackson is favored, but given how I'm popular Trump is in Maine, and yes, Susan Collins has had a history of winning, and you know in Maine she won in twenty twenty, even though Trump Wilson say, but she's not as popular as she once was. All that that's going on basically you go, okay, we can get into sort of those democratic pickup opportunities. But now there are two potential either one as a potential Republican hole that you might not otherwise have thought, and one is a potential Republican pickup and that is part of the reason why the Senate is still leaning GOP.
00:20:41
Speaker 1: And it's fascinating right because the Republicans are very much playing defense when it comes to some of these other Senate sees. North Carolina comes to mind, certainly with the retirement Kelly Loylis probably lost. So what is the likeliest Democrat pick up if Michigan is now the likeliest Republican pickup?
00:20:55
Speaker 3: Yeah, okay, so I think North Carolina is probably you know number one, right Cooper, a two term governor.
00:21:02
Speaker 2: They are in North Carolina popular guy.
00:21:05
Speaker 3: I would say this, which is you know, I know, for a lot of years, a lot of people have been very skeptical of democratic chances in Texas, and James Tallerico is not, by his own record, the most moderate guy in the world. However, he's trying to run against a gentleman in Ken Paxon, who was literally impeached by the Texas House of Representatives, who is very much underwater in terms of his net favorability in that state. In Tallarico is above. We have now had a number of polls in the last week and change that have had Tallarico ahead. Bener O'Rourke was never ahead of Ted Cruz. There has not been a Democratic Senate Canada ahead of a Republican in Texas since Lloyd Benson in nineteen hundred and eighty eight. This is very much new territory. Trump is underwater in Texas. This could happen. So I might argue that after Carolina and I think you know, Maine probably is number two, Texas may very well be number three, which is shocking for me to say.
00:22:07
Speaker 2: But the numbers are the numbers.
00:22:10
Speaker 1: The numbers are what they are, my friend, and as a former textan myself, it's it's hard to sometimes to hear those words and to take it seriously. I lived during the twenty eighteens, o'verurik, But but I hear you a lot and cleer of the numbers this time are quite different.
00:22:21
Speaker 2: Times.
00:22:21
Speaker 1: We have to go to a quick commercial break, but say what this, folks would be joined by Harry for much more on this
side. We'll be right back with much more from Harry end. Welcome back, and we are rejoined by our friend Harry Anton. He's the chief data analyst for CNN. You can also check out a show the indin Scale and CNN All Access Fall Harry on X at Forecaster Enton, where he runs a lively social media feed, Harry before the break, We're talking a little bit about about Texas, and we had a guest earlier this week, Luke Macius, who was a long time consertive activist in Texas. I've known Luke for a long time. He used to live in Texas, and I thought Luke would actually be more reassuring. Ah, Paxson's got this, and actually no, he was hedging quite a bit. So I can tell you that even the conservative grassroots in Texas are really starting to get to get nervous about this. What is the current dynamic on the ground in Texas, Because it seemed to me going back to twenty twenty, remember the Rold, these headlines that Trump was dominating in the Rio Grand Valley, these ninety percent star counties of PoTA County, these massive Aspanic counties, seemed like Trump was just totally dominating. I actually took Texas personally off the map. I thought Texas was safe read for a long time. And now tell Rico who is Let's call him a heterodox cant that I think would be a polite way of saying it. He actually really could take this thing. You're not wrong about that. So what is actually happening in Texas?
00:23:42
Speaker 3: So I think there are two trends that have happened over the past ten or fifteen years in Texas which kind of helped the GOP hold on to Texas when a lot of people thought, you know, it's always been the promise that Democrats, you know, oh, as the state becomes more diverse will be you know, we'll gain and we'll be able to overtake it and make it a blue Texas. Well, what actually ended up happening was the college educated areas you know, around Houston, around Dallas became significantly more blue. But at the same time, as you were pointing out the Latino the Hispanic vote started to shift to the right, and it sort of canceled each other out and allowed Texas to be won by Trump rather easily. I think it was thirteen points was the margin in twenty twenty four, after sort of you know, being in single digits in twenty twenty. Well, what's happened in Texas is what's happening nationally, which is Latinos has started to shift and sort of rebounded more towards the Democratic party now, perhaps not to the levels that they were in twenty sixteen under Hillary Clinton, but at least you know, when we're looking at the polling, if you're James Tallerico, he's ahead with Latinos. That was not the case well with Kamala Harris, right, And so all of a sudden you have that combined with the white college graduates continuing their shift to the left. But two of those together are a dynamic that makes Texas very very interesting. It's nearly what Betto was able to do better. Rock was nearly able to do in twenty eighteen, but he just wasn't able to pull it up. But remember that wasn't race that was decided by under three points. Now, all of a sudden you had those college educated white voters even more left than they were. You have all of a sudden the recovering with Hispanics, aided by Donald Trump's unpopularity with them, and that very much puts the seat in play.
00:25:27
Speaker 2: Combined of course, with just the fact again.
00:25:29
Speaker 3: I just point out Ken Paxton was literally impeached by the Texas House.
00:25:32
Speaker 2: Abrupt presentatives scandals do matter, and that works.
00:25:39
Speaker 1: Yeah, Listen, I think it's easy to say that we live in a post scandal era.
00:25:43
Speaker 2: But it's actually not true. I mean Eric Swalla just resigned from Congress.
00:25:46
Speaker 1: I mean Max Miller might drop out as as we already allude to it, It's actually not true. These sore a scandals sometimes really do percolate in the back of voters' minds. And Harry, I want to shift heres a little bit and talk to you know about a specific scandal, clad handed it, but perhaps a scandalous movement. And I'm referring here to the DSA of the Democratic socials in America. We touched on Abdul Sayat in Michigan already in a conversation, but this is of course a much a much broader trend. The recent New York City primaries, people like Dario Lisa Villa Chevalier's or Mamdani endorsed. The rise of the DSA is really all the talk, from what I can tell, in politics today. And I can't think about this Bill Maher monologue from Real tim and HBO last Friday, where Bill Maher just went off, just went off from the DSA. He seems like he's ready to vote for a reasonable Republican alternative. So I guess I'm curious if your breakdown of the demographics here, is there a Bill Maher demographic?
00:26:42
Speaker 3: Is that?
00:26:43
Speaker 1: Is that a real demographic of people who have generally liberal sympathies but just don't want anything to do with DSA and socialism? Is is that a real slice or is this kind of isolated to a few higher profile individuals.
00:26:55
Speaker 2: We'll find out. We'll find out.
00:26:57
Speaker 3: I mean, look, you're going to have an election in Michigan and a few months and let's see what happens, because if Abdulasia does not win there. Now not abdu Alas say it as a capitalist, but I'm talking about the progressive left, you know, more broadly here, and the same sort of you know, underlingings that helped catapult him are catapulting the DSA at large.
00:27:16
Speaker 2: But I would say we'll find out.
00:27:18
Speaker 3: But that being said, here are a few things that we should just kind of talk about within the polling right, which is number one, who are the biggest supporters of the DSA Within the Democratic Party? You might think, oh, it's these Democratic leaning independents who are kind of trying to come in and you know, almost invade the party and turn it to their way.
00:27:37
Speaker 2: That's not the case at all.
00:27:39
Speaker 3: The people within the
Democratic Party who are more likely to self identify as Democratic socialists are democrats themselves. They are not the democratic in the democratic aligned independence. That is not the case. These are Democratic voters who turned out in twenty twenty four for Kamalaris. So I want to put that sort of aside. That being said, you take a look within the Democratic Party. The DSA is popular. It is you just say, as you know, faarable, unfairbele, it's the net favorabilities on the plus style ledger, significantly so, even more so than Democratic leaders in Congress. That being said, you look at the general electorate and the DSA is very much under water. And I think there's this real question. I don't know if it's Bill Maher with liberal sympathies. I don't know whether it's swing voters, but I do think there's a chunk of voters out there who are skeptical, very much so of the DSSA. And I think the question ultimately, as we'll have to find out, and maybe the midterm isn't the best test event, is, you know, is the DSA's unpopularity such that it can somehow mute the effect that Donald Trump's own unpopularity will have. And it may just be the case that Donald Trump's unpopularity is simply put too strong. But then I think the question would be, if you're getting back to Bill Maher, what happens in twenty twenty eight if the Democrats do nominate someone who is very much on the progressive side of things, very liberal, and Republicans don't do that, and depending on who they nominate, will there be this block of voters? There may very well be, but at that point, but at this point, we're just not dealing with that dynamic.
00:29:14
Speaker 2: Now.
00:29:14
Speaker 1: I know that you're a national guy and you cover national politics, and you obviously do it quite well. But you're also, among other things, how you're a New Yorker, and in fact, in my mind you're you're an iconic New Yorker. Actually you're enough, you're born and bred. You really are of buy and for the big Apple. So I kind of want just your more parochial assessment of the Zora Mamdani era, because he really is the kingpin of the DSA. I would actually argue he's the king maker of Democratic Party as a whole. Frankly, at this point, I think's actually a Clipsberty standard. That's that's a whole different conversation. But sticking to New York City just for a minute here, he hasn't been empowered quite for a year, but we've had a sufficient sample size at this point. Has his performance do you think been a boon to the DSA or has it raised a lot of red flags for the DSA branks? It seems to me like his case and Dorsees are still winning. But don on only know what that means for the broader public.
00:30:10
Speaker 3: I would say that at this point he has been a tremendous boon well to the DSA brand. I think you see it in those primaries in New York. I mean, let's just talk about the you know, look, Dan Goldman was always in trouble and Brad Ladner again much like abdu A LA's a very very progressive but does it it does not call himself a democratic socialist. But you go into northern Manhattan and you mentioned Chevalier, right, you mentioned that race was she was going up against Esplot, who is quite liberal, was at one point an undocumented immigrant or you know here illegally at one point did from everything that I can tell nothing wrong for that district right. He was not a poor fit for the district right, and he lost, and he lost in a large part in my opinion, because around Donnie endorsed the challenger. What in the world that is still very much of a boon? And look will Wade and see. You know, the mayoralship of New York has a way of humbling even the strongest and greatest of politicians. But the latest day that I have seen very much suggests he's on the plus side of the ledger here and when all of a sudden you can do what he is doing. I think a lot of Democratic socialists say hey, hey, hey, and a lot of Democratic voters say hey, he's able to be the left and it's still popular. Yeah, I'd still say he's a boon for sure, And it.
00:31:41
Speaker 1: Seems to me that way from Afar, I just can't help but think, Harry, that that at some point that DSA is going to overplay their hands. This whole mainstream to do so, this whole mainstreaming of a san piker is crazy. I mean, this guy has literally said America deserved nine eleven. I mean, even Bernie Sanders, I believe was actually on your network on CNN, and even Bernie Sanders said, I can't defend that.
00:32:02
Speaker 2: That's a that's an indefensible comment.
00:32:04
Speaker 1: So as more of this stuff gets out there, I just can help cannot help but think that at some point is going to be a Sears backlash, as we've already allude to that that backlash very well could happen in the Wolverine state, in the state in Michigan. It could be some history for Republican Center winning in midterms. As you said there with Mike Rogers. We will have to see if it happens.
00:32:22
Speaker 2: Folks.
00:32:22
Speaker 1: We're gonna have to go to another quick break. We have been joined by Harry Enton. He's the chief data analyst at CNN fall him on X at Forecaster Engin. I'm going to go to a quick break and we'd be right back on the side with some more with Harry end say this week right back with Harry. Welcome back, and we are rejoined by Harry Enton. He's the chief data analyst at CNN. You can check out the Entin Scale at CNN All Access Fall Harry on X at Forecaster Enton, where I like to note that I believe the forecast was actually initially a reference not to political forecasting, but actually to meet Rodgull forecasting. In fact, I've known Harry for so long, but I actually used to get his his daily weather forecasting emails. In fact, I actually very much look forward to those emails, and I regretted the fact when they went away because you had.
00:33:06
Speaker 2: Perhaps bigger pursuits. I guess, I guess we'll put it down. There were a lot of factors that went into that, fair
enough.
00:33:11
Speaker 1: But perhaps the whether email will one day return. But for now, I want to talk about the elephant in the political room, which is the President United States, Donald Trump. So it seems to me, Harry that again, listen, I'm a trum voter, im conservative cars the table, But it seemed to me like the first year of this second term was generally going quite well for President Trump, at least from my perspective. He seemed to be winning a lot of political and legal battles, cultural battles, and approval rating was generally pretty good. I mean, Meli, the tarrorifts were a little of a wrinkled even in that first year, but the second year has been a different story.
00:33:45
Speaker 2: So can you just talk a.
00:33:46
Speaker 1: Little bit about the effect in particular of the Iran conflict. Is it really as big of an anchor? Is it as big of an albatross around the neck as some people fear it is.
00:33:56
Speaker 3: I would say there have been two things you hit on it, Taris earlier and then the Iram War. Donald Trump was re elected to the White House for a simple reason, and that was to fix the economy that American and American minds believe was broken. Inflation as well. And when all of a sudden you enter into a conflict that at the start was not all that popular, and then all of a sudden the gas prices go up, and that of course goes right to inflation, right to the economy, etc. That's a killer, man, that's a killer if you're a Republican down ballot. The war is very much unpopular. And it's interesting to sort of think about these things, right because the gas prices, when you take into account inflation, really aren't that high historically. But there have been a significant rise on top of what Americans are already thinking is inflation that's just simply put too high. Obviously, that started back during the Biden erawhere, it really hit its peak in terms of the inflation rate, and you just go, this is an anchor, and you can, honestly, you can see the numbers when there was the idea there was going to be a ceasefire, right, you kind of saw those numbers stabilize and maybe a climb up point or two, not significantly, but you know you saw going in the right direction if you're him, and then all of a sudden, the war starts back up again and down go the numbers again. It's not the only thing. But as someone who's just looking at from an electoral standpoint, I mean, if your approval rating on gas prices are lucky to hit twenty five percent and sometimes are below twenty which is the worst ever by far, yeah, I would say it's a big problem.
00:35:35
Speaker 2: So does the situation resolve itself?
00:35:38
Speaker 1: Prior to November, it's been this, I mean, no one knows, right, it's been this tit for tats, they strike, we strike it. It's very odd, Harry, because I feel like I can feel, I can almost feel the palpable frustration from the White House, from their ENTERTEWM advisors. They clearly want this thing to be over. They
want to focus on the economy. They want to get back to James Carpol it's me stupid and all the bove there.
00:36:01
Speaker 2: But I don't know.
00:36:02
Speaker 1: I mean, do you do you see this wrapping up somehow prior to November? Or is this going to be the same situation on election.
00:36:08
Speaker 2: With I mean, the question is how far how close?
00:36:13
Speaker 3: You know, if it wraps itself up tomorrow, okay, that's one thing, but if it's by October, you know, if it's in the middle of October and it's October, so I'm not sure it matters, right, so's you're almost the timeline is actually a little bit more crunched voter sentiment starts to bake in, et cetera.
00:36:29
Speaker 2: I don't know.
00:36:30
Speaker 3: I can merely say this, which is, if this war is still going on come November, and Donald Trump's numbers are what they are come November, it would be the greatest political trick I've perhaps ever seen for Republicans to hold on to the US House of Representatives. And I would think that Democrats might actually at that point be favored and maybe not by an insignificant margin in the United States Senate because it'd be awfully difficult give and how we now vote in terms of you know, we really do kind of vote more straight ball than we used to, in terms of the fact that how you feel about the president has an increasing hold and predictability of how you vote for the United States Senate. And given that President Trump's numbers are underwater in all these different states, and then the number one issue is inflation, and the gas prices are still decently high, and he's still in a war that Americans don't like.
00:37:24
Speaker 2: That would be politically very very bad.
00:37:28
Speaker 1: So, speaking of iron, and you mentioned the related topic of Israel earlier a little bit in the conversation about Abdulasiet, I guess I would be miss Harry if I didn't ask you all the one question about our community, the American Jewish community and voting patterns. I was listening to a conversation on radio earlier this week from my friend Buck Sexton and his co host Clay Travis, and they were debating whether or not Abdul sayeed Man Donnie, whether the rise of the DSA and what's almost referred to as his Red Green alliance, but whether this will actually meaningfully affect Jewish voting patterns, and what Buck Sexman said as he thought, no, because it's already been priced in. The folks who are going to move have moved already. Klay Travis said, no, this another wake up call, you know, Carson the table. I evenclined towards the viewpoint that I actually don't think this is going to be a massive, massive shift. Having said that, I was reading an article just just this morning about how some prominent Jewish Democrats in Michigan, wealthy donors are not going to be headlining fundraisers for Mike Rogers maybe a row may. Maybe they're actually is going to be a big shift this November and beyond.
00:38:30
Speaker 2: How do you.
00:38:31
Speaker 1: See the Jewish vote going this November and beyond with the rise of the DSA.
00:38:38
Speaker 3: So I think the real question is is what we saw in the Michigan primary is what we saw in the New Jersey I believe it's the eleventh District special election at all. Yeah, is that sort of you tear you sort of string that out right, you open it up and you go those districts where there are a lot of Jewish voters very much swung in that special election to the right. We know that I'll do all I say, I did very poorly in you know, large Jewish communities during that primary.
00:39:14
Speaker 2: Can that actually move the needle?
00:39:16
Speaker 3: I will say that there is a lot of skepticism of bb nefi Yahoo and of Israel, even within the Jewish Democratic community. But but to your point, if I'm recalling this correctly, I do believe that the majority of Jewish Democrats called what has happened in Gaza a genocide, which is not the way that most Israelis would see it. I Josh, I haven't asked you this question. I don't believe it's the way that you would see it. And I do I understand the strong skepticism from Buck on that one.
00:39:51
Speaker 2: I do.
00:39:51
Speaker 3: I look, I do think that there is going to be some movement, but I don't think it's going to be the movement to the extent that you you might expect that. You know, maybe that's a cop out, but I would play it down in the middle that way. I do.
00:40:04
Speaker 2: Yeah, go ahead, No, I think it's totally fair.
00:40:06
Speaker 1: I mean, in twenty twenty four, of the Jewish percentage of voever, Donald Trump was still four hundred fifty percent.
00:40:12
Speaker 2: Who was actually debated what is outly was?
00:40:14
Speaker 1: I saw some folks say thirty five percent, some folks said as high as forty percent, but whatever it was, it was. Yeah, it was a marginal increase for sure. Over twenty twenty, it's getting higher, but it's not a majority vote, So maybe a marginal me a marginal move here or there, Harry, in our main few minutes, I guess I wanted to just ask a couple of rapid ish fire questions for you, which which was turning your attention to two thousand and twenty eight. I kind of would just want your prediction as to who the nominee in each shot is going to be at this point, so let's start with the Democrats.
00:40:47
Speaker 2: That's probably more interesting conversation.
00:40:48
Speaker 1: Honestly, who will be the Democrat president pregnancial nominee in twenty twenty eight?
00:40:53
Speaker 3: I don't have a freaking clue, But what I will say is that there is no favorite. I think if you had asked me six months ago, I think you Gavin Newsom was a favorite. I don't know I'd like. Honestly, we have a darth of polling data. If Kamala Harris runs, I do think she is the most likely person. Maybe, but you look at those new Hampshire polls and well, I don't know if that's going to actually be the first the nation primary, but you see that, you know, you see a number of things that are going on up there. Alexander Costio Ortees is quite strong. You've seen John Asso kind of take off. I'm going to be very interested to see. But there all, this is the most unsettled field since at least nineteen hundred and ninety two when Bill Clinton was able to win that nomination.
00:41:38
Speaker 1: Well, fair enough, listen, my piction probably would be Gaven Newsom, for whatever it's worth.
00:41:43
Speaker 2: I mean, it could be, it could very well be. It could be, but we really have no clue.
00:41:48
Speaker 1: As you just said, the Republicans on the isle, I think we have a greater clue, but I guess I will friend the question this way, is jd Vance a walk or is there any question in your mind?
00:41:56
Speaker 2: Yeah?
00:41:56
Speaker 3: Okay, I you know, last time we spoke, I was very very strong in JD. He is still the favorite to be that nominee. Okay, he's still that favorite. But you go to New Hampshire, right, I just mentioned it, which will be the first in the nation primary on the Republican side, and that lead, which was forty plus points at the beginning of the year, where Marco Rubio excuse me, where Marco Rubio was lucky to be hitting double digits and jd aanswers north to fifty percent? What did the latest Paul have him within fifteen? There's a legitimate conversation that I think is going to be had there. So I would say he's not a lock JD Vance, but he is the favorite at this point. But Marco Rubio pretty popular with in Republican circles. And I think the ultimate question is does Donald Trump decide to get involved, And if he does, I think.
00:42:41
Speaker 2: He could choose who he wants it to be. So that's one question. The other question I think is will Rubyll even do this? Is he interesting?
00:42:47
Speaker 1: I mean, of what I've heard, it's just kind of scuttle blocks. But what I've heard through the grapevine is that he has no infrastructure. That's just what I've heard. He's apparently not planning at all and running at the time. These things, though, as we both know how a habit of changing. Unfortunately, though we're up to leave it there, we are out of time. Harry Anton is the chief data analyst for CNN. Check out the Endine scale at CNN All Access. Harry, you're a mention. We appreciate your time as Zovie's spots. Shulman, we'll talk to you soon.
00:43:13
Speaker 2: Good show us my friend. All right, folks, that's.
00:43:15
Speaker 1: Going to be all for today's show. Have a great evening, the great weekend. We'll be right back on Monday.