TRASCRIZIONE 🔗
Why I made this unplanned video
This was an unplanned video.
It's not really about the occult, but it is philosophy, Western philosophy, which is my second love. Now the reason why I am producing this video is because I saw something in one of the occult groups. I'm part of so many I didn't even realize that I subscribed to them. I think people added me to them over the years and I was like, wait a minute. I don't remember you know subscribing to any of these. So anyway, I saw this comment and it was from more than one person, but there was clearly one person who sort of started the whole thing and then others sort of glommed on and it was this use of the term ubermensch, which is from the philosophy of Friedrich Nietzsche.
Now they used it in a way that was aggressive. It seemed it was misogynistic. It was almost racist like an elitist right as if they were using it as like look I'm an ubermensch, you know, and ubermensch just sort of means Superman or over man in in German and I'll get into all that a little bit in a moment. And then I was thinking my god, you know, god bless these people. But they don't even know what the fuck they're talking about. Okay, they don't know what they clearly don't understand the ubermensch concept or what Friedrich Nietzsche even meant by it.
And you know, there was this this one phrase someone who was actually against the comment was saying oh, you shouldn't use Friedrich Nietzsche because he was a Nazi blah blah blah. By the way, he was not a Nazi. If anything, he was against Nazism. And so in this podcast, in this video, I'm gonna sort of set this state, you know set the the record for this. I know it's not a cult but it was in an occult group. So I thought I have to have to do something right?
Philosophy, like I said is my second love. And so I am very familiar with Friedrich Nietzsche's work. And so in this video and it might be a little bit long, but I hope you do enjoy it. I'm going to get into what the ubermensch really means and whether Nietzsche had anything to do with Nazism. So I really hope you enjoy it.
What the Übermensch is in Thus Spoke Zarathustra
So when we hear the word ubermensch, okay, it's often translated as Superman or overman, you know, some people obviously, you know, they're they're looking oh look this is a caped comic hero, right? Some brutish type of villain, but Nietzsche's original idea is completely different and he introduced it in his 1883 book, Thus Spoke Zarathustra. And this ubermensch was neither a superhero nor some type of master race warlord, right? It was a philosophical vision of human potential. In Thus Spoke Zarathustra, Nietzsche has this prophet-like character, Zarathustra, proclaim, or rather was proclaiming to him, I teach you the ubermensch. Man is something that shall be overcome. What have you done to overcome him?
Now the ubermensch in is presented as a goal for humanity. This is an ideal type of human who rises above the current state of mankind sort of by overcoming his own his or hers or, you know, inner limitations and creating new values in a world where the traditional values sort of lost their power. Now to understand why he even felt the need for this concept of ubermensch, and again, I'm gonna get into all of this deeper before you say, oh, no, you shouldn't be this is this is nazism. It's not. Trust me.
God is dead and the problem of nihilism
We're gonna get deeper here. So to understand why Nietzsche felt we needed the concept of the ubermensch, we have to remember his famous declaration. Remember, God is dead, which by the way is also used incorrectly amongst even philosophical groups. They're like God is dead. Atheists use the term God is dead. No.
He doesn't mean it in that way. This was not in his mind a celebratory thing. But it was the reason why he said it was because it was a recognition that old religious morals were losing their hold on people's lives. And so Nietzsche worried that people without some type of guiding values, especially of the religious nature, without it, society would slip into nihilism, you know, or nihilism. I've seen it. I've heard it both ways.
Which is of course a kind of sort of existential despair or meaninglessness, right? So his answer was not to return to old beliefs but inspire a new kind of human who would create meaning here on earth. So as Zarathustra said in the book, the ubermensch shall be the meaning of the earth. Remain faithful to the earth and do not believe those who speak of otherworldly hopes. Now the ubermensch in this case embodies this world, right? The worldly ideals of this world.
So he's grounding values in life and human spirit rather than in some heavenly realm.
A goal for humanity and the bridge over the abyss
Now what's really crucial here is that Nietzsche never claimed that any ubermensch had yet existed. It was sort of this idealized vision, avatar of the future, right? And it was a challenge to future generations to become what you are and to push humanity forward. Now he hinted at figures he admired, you know, during all of his works that had this greatness of spirit. And he named some as Socrates and Jesus and Leonardo da Vinci, Shakespeare, you know, Napoleon and although Napoleon's a little rough, as examples of this excellence, right?
But he maintained these were inspirations, not actual ubermenschen, okay? They were not the ubermensch themselves. They were just sort of inspired. And don't worry again. I'm gonna get deeper into why this is not as bad as you might think it is.
So what makes the ubermensch special? It's not any aristocratic lineage or physical strength, but a kind of inner transformation and creativity, essentially what Jung called a person who is individualized to or rather achieved individualization, individuation, right? So Nietzsche describes humanity as a bridge between the animal and the ubermensch. And he says, a rope tied between beast and overman, a rope over an abyss. What is great in man is
Load full transcript
that he is a bridge and not an end.
So what he's saying in this sort of a little bit overly poetic way, humans are not final products. We're an experiment. We're always in a transition, right? And you can experience that in your own life, right? Or there's always a transition.
So the ubermensch is the beyond man, the next evolutionary step in our spiritual and cultural and in spiritual and cultural terms. And it's achieved when we overcome the petty aspects of the what we have in our own nature and realize our higher potential.
Will to power and self-mastery
So what qualities define Nietzsche's ubermensch? This is where we're gonna start starting to debunk some of the bullshit that's out there. Rather than cruelty or domination, the ubermensch is characterized by creativity, self-mastery, and an attitude that's sort of life-affirming. Nietzsche believed that underneath all of the bullshit human behavior that happens, that there's a force under us, right? And he called that the will to power. And it's not just the will to dominate others. Again, that's a complete misunderstanding, but fundamentally a drive to expand and to assert ourselves and grow. It doesn't say to be aggressive, but assertive, right?
But in a positive sense, this is the will to power over oneself. The ability for us to control, you know, the various impulses that we have, to overcome fears that we have, shape ourselves and our life in a creative way. So an ubermensch challenges this will to power inward, and that makes him overcome his perceived weaknesses, and it organizes, as he says, organizing the chaos within. So in Nietzsche's philosophy, such a person is what he called an artist of life, someone who creates new values as an artist creates beauty. So a person would be like breaking from the herd, like conformity, right? And saying yes to the various shit that happens to us in life.
So he represents, the ubermensch represents the full realization of human potential and freedom, not some bullshit Aryan, racist agenda. That is not what Nietzsche meant. In fact, if they really read any of these books, they would realize it doesn't.
Common misunderstandings of the Übermensch
So let's look at some common misunderstandings of the ubermensch. I mentioned some before, but I'm going to go a little bit deeper here. Now, given Nietzsche's sort of lofty and I guess you could say his abstract vision, it's no surprise that the ubermensch is misunderstood. Okay, the term itself suffered tremendously from all of these weird tricky translation histories, right? Early English translators rendered ubermensch as Superman, which unfortunately invites obviously that the whole comic book comparison, right? In fact, the creators of the Superman comic originally toyed with a villain character inspired by Nietzsche's idea, which is, which of course is sort of ridiculous.
Now, but unfortunately this pop culture association has led many people to equate Nietzsche's ubermensch with a kind of literal superhero, someone with these extraordinary powers, and essentially a caped crusader, but Nietzsche's Superman was never about leaping tall buildings or saving a metropolis, right? These were a misidentification, and this annoyed scholars, very much, especially scholars such as Walter Kaufman, who preferred the term for ubermensch overman, specifically to avoid confusion with, you know, Clark Kent, right? Another misconception is that ubermensch represents some type of callous, egoist, or a tyrant who tramples on the weak, essentially a main character in like Ayn Rand's books, right? Because Nietzsche had a very bombastic style in his talk of, and he used terms as master and slave, moralities, led some readers and critics to imagine that what he meant by ubermensch as a sort of this pitiless super villain, and this was of course reinforced in literature, right? For example, Jack London dedicated two novels, The Sea Wolf and Martin Eden, to critiquing what he took to be Nietzsche's ubermensch idea, viewing it as a recipe for self-selfishness and brutality.
But in reality, that is not what it is. I mean, far, far from encouraging senseless cruelty, Nietzsche speaks of the ubermensch as having a well-ordered soul. He even said the ubermensch is rather like the Roman Caesar with Christ's soul. See what I mean? So what he meant by that was that he had the boldness of a Caesar, but the empathy and creative love of a Christ.
So this is an unexpected combination, right? But that is how he saw the ubermensch. So let's dispel a few more things. It is not a master race ideology, and this is probably the most damaging misunderstanding is the idea that ubermensch refers to a biologically superior race or some racial supremist agenda. It doesn't. This notion took hold due to later political distortions.
But Nietzsche himself never talked about breeding a superior race. He did use language like higher types and lower types in humanity, but he was speaking about culture and spiritual quality, not a genetic stock. And thus spoke Zarathustra, the ubermensch ideal is offered to all of humanity as a goal, not a specific ethnicity.
And also, another misconception is that some have tried to adopt the ubermensch as a symbol of total freedom from all social constraints. But again, Nietzsche did not advocate for abolishing all laws or moral norms, so individuals can just, you know, do whatever the fuck they pleased. The ubermensch's freedom is self-discipline. It was essentially a freedom to create new values and ways of living. I mean, despite everything we know about Nietzsche, he did value order and form. He admired the capacity to rule oneself.
So the ubermensch might dance on the edge of chaos, right? But he or she isn't about that mindless mayhem or dismantling society just for the fuck of it.
Was Nietzsche a Nazi?
Now, we also have to address something that a lot of people misunderstand, is that people think, oh, Nietzsche was a Nazi, right? But he was not. In
fact, he was not only was he not a Nazi, he died before the Nazi party even existed, really. But more importantly, Nietzsche's personal views were utterly at odds with the Nazi hateful ideology that people had tried to claim on him. He couldn't stand the bigotry and the aggressive nationalism that swept 19th century Germany. He states, Deutschland, Deutschland uberales. That is the end of German philosophy. He scoffed and mocked the mindless patriotism of that time. And he once even said, I will have all antisemites shot. Hear that again. I will have all antisemites shot.
Now, that's a pretty powerful quote, right? And it leaves no doubt that Nietzsche loathed antisemitism and regarded the rising racial hatred in Europe as a sickness. And he proudly called himself the last anti-political German. He prized the cosmopolitan spirit over the nationalist fervor. For example, Nietzsche praised the contribution of Jewish people to European culture and imagined a future European race enriched by Jewish talent, saying that Jews were as useful and desirable an ingredient as any other in the mix of culture. So he basically advocated the destruction of nationalism in favor of a united and cultural Europe. But unfortunately, by the 1930s, the Nazi regime was loudly proclaiming Nietzsche as one of their intellectual heroes and tossing around the term ubermensch to glorify their notion of a master race. So the question is, and this is where people are probably don't know why, you know, or they're thinking that, oh, you know, he's a Nazi. This is why people think that he's a Nazi.
His sister Elisabeth and The Will to Power
And the answer to that is largely in the manipulation of his sister, Elizabeth Forster Nietzsche, and a bunch of later interpreters who twisted Nietzsche's words. Elizabeth, his sister, embraced the antisemitism and nationalism of her era. And she married an outspoken antisemitic agitator, his name was Bernhard Forster, and even helped him attempt to found an Aryan utopian colony in Paraguay in the 1880s, which eventually failed. Now, Nietzsche, who was alive when his sister was married, was so disgusted by her husband's anti-Jewish rants that he refused to attend her wedding. Unfortunately, though, and this is the sad part, is that in 1889, Nietzsche suffered a mental collapse, and people aren't sure what it was, maybe it was syphilis, who knows. And from that point until his death in 1900, he was incapacitated, and he wasn't able to manage his own affairs. So Elizabeth swooped in to take charge of her, her brother's estate and his writings and all that. So for nearly 40 years after Nietzsche's death, his sister became the curator, but I guess you could say, yeah, she was the curator, but she was also the censor and spin doctor of his literature. She was the gatekeeper who decided what would be published and what would not. And one early example of her sort of meddling with his ideas, but more specifically his autobiography, Elizabeth delayed
its publication and edited out parts she didn't like, including any unflattering mentions of herself, of course, but her most, I guess you could say, what she's most infamous for was what she did to the book, The Will to Power. And Nietzsche never actually published the book by that title. It was sort of an idea that was toyed in his own mind, but he later abandoned it. But after his death, Elizabeth scavenged through his unpublished notebooks and pulled out fragments and so many of them out of context and stitched them together into a new book she titled The Will to Power and presented it as if it were Nietzsche's magnum opus. Now this book, of course, was posthumous, right? But it was highly distorted because it amplified her what she liked, what she understood as sort of the idea of the Übermensch as being a heroic leadership, harsh judgments on weakness and all of that. And she omitted a lot of the nuance and contrary passages.
So she cultivated the Nietzsche archive in Weimar, Germany and turned it into essentially a Nietzsche-themed salon for German ultra-nationalists, which is crazy. So these people went so far as to claim that Nietzsche's real philosophy was to be found in his unpublished notes, which of course she doctored. Now I can't stress enough how sympathetic his sister was to Nazism. She was a very enthusiastic supporter of Hitler. Adolf Hitler himself visited the Nietzsche archive in 1933, and by then Elizabeth,
his sister, fawned over Hitler and ceremoniously presented Hitler with Nietzsche's own walking stick as a gift. So his philosophy, as we saw already, he was not anti-Semitic, but we could see that his philosophy was now in these compromised hands, and the Nazis found plenty of selectively edited quotes and concepts that they could cherry pick. I mean, Hitler and all of his propagandists seized on the term Übermensch, and they of course recasted as a racist term, proclaiming that the Aryan was the master race destined to rule, and all others whom they labeled, everyone else who was not Übermensch, were the Untermenschen, or the subhumans, who were of course in their eyes inferior. But to be clear, Nietzsche never used the term Untermensch, and would have been completely disgusted by how it was used, because his vision of the Übermensch, as I mentioned, was never about establishing a racial hierarchy. Nietzsche was proud of what he imagined as just being a person who's achieved individuation, right? Now, in all fairness, of course, we have to say that Nietzsche's writings were a little bit complex and a little bombastic, but it is pretty clear that Nietzsche did not shy away from praising certain warlike virtues or criticizing egalitarianism. This is something that, unfortunately, the Nazis would spin to their advantage, but the key context is that Nietzsche was talking about individuals and cultural health, not races or states, and so the Nazis read or misread the will to power in his other works to paint Nietzsche as this
kind of proto-fascist, which he was not. Now, it was only later in the 20th century that scholar Walter Kaufman, who worked really hard to rehabilitate Nietzsche's reputation, going back to all of these unedited texts and highlighting Nietzsche's actual stances, he really worked hard, and it became recognized in academia that Nietzsche was not a proto-Nazi. He was, in many ways, a victim of the Nazis when you really think about it, or at least they appropriated his work.
And essentially what they did was they took his work and they made it into fake news, so to speak, and I'm sure we are all familiar with that term. Now, I want to discuss something else. I know we're going pretty long here, but this is really important because people already misunderstand Nietzsche as it is. There is this other concept that Nietzsche believed in, and at first this might feel a little bit unrelated, but it is entirely related to the Übermensch. And we can't really explore the Übermensch without completely touching upon this concept that Nietzsche called eternal recurrence or eternal return.
Eternal recurrence and amor fati
Now, when we first look at it, this might seem like a completely wild notion. I mean, the idea that in his understanding is the idea that time and life repeat themselves over and over again, infinitely. Don't worry, I'm getting to a point here. In his book, the Thus Spoke Zarathustra, Nietzsche introduces eternal recurrence as a source of a challenge. He says, if you knew your life would recur eternally, exactly the same each time, how would you react?
Would that thought fill you with despair, or would you embrace it joyfully? So Nietzsche represents this thought, it's more like a thought experiment, as the ultimate test of an affirmation that, do you love your fate? Or are you completely against it? Is the thought of you coming back again and again and again forever in the same very life disturbing to you? Now, you're probably thinking, well, some of us might be like, oh, yeah, I love my life. I don't mind if I come back a thousand times. But most of us, I will say, probably not so much, right?
We're probably thinking, oh, I made so many mistakes and regrets and blah, blah, blah, and all that. So most of us would not like this idea of eternal recurrence. So now, to get to the point, it's like, how does this connect to the Übermensch? Think of it in this way. The Übermensch is the person who can pass this test, who would say, yes, to eternal recurrence, right? To Nietzsche, the ability to not accept the eternal recurrence of life is to be someone who is unhappy with their life. But the Übermensch is the person who says yes to all of life's experiences, the good and the bad, and wouldn't want a single moment of life to be different because they've achieved a state of complete affirmation.
So in Nietzsche's philosophy, this is intertwined with this concept amor fati, which is the love of one's fate, no matter what it is. An Übermensch is what he called a yes-sayer and loves life. The Übermensch is a person that is not resentful. Nothing in their life is regretted. Even suffering is seen as part of their grand eternal game of one's life, right? And this is the polar opposite of all the life-denying attitudes that we see in philosophy, like the Christian ascetic ideals, Schopenhauer's pessimism. So the Übermensch, he craves nothing to be different, and so he will accept the concept of eternal recurrence.
Now, to be clear, this is, again, a thought experiment, although some people say, oh no, he was actually trying to create a new idea of physics, but no, no, this was a thought experiment. And the Übermensch is the perfect individual to pass that test of the eternal recurrence. So just to conclude this, because we're already like, well, we're already over 30 minutes, my goodness, I'm sorry, but hopefully you found this interesting so far.
What the Übermensch really means
But in conclusion, I would like to say that what I saw about the Übermensch and all the bullshit racial stuff and the, oh, I'm superior to you, is bullshit. They've never read Nietzsche, clearly, or if they did, they didn't understand him, because the Übermensch is a far cry from the distorted images that followed in his wake. You know, and this is important. I think it's important to know, to keep this in mind, is because really what he's, why he created the concept of Übermensch was as an appeal to our own selves to live the best life that we can live. And I'm not, I don't mean this in like a, well, I sort of do, I guess, in a self-help type of way, but it's a person whose has no regrets, lives creatively, lives in a way that harms none, benefits him or herself and others. And when faced with death and the eternal recurrence has no regrets. And that's what he was trying to say. The Übermensch is a free spirit, right? Someone who's too big for the cramped understandings of the prejudices that we have in this life. Because he would scorn, he or she would scorn the very idea of racial purity, herd conformity, and whatever the Nazis tried to chain Nietzsche to. So I guess you could say in many ways, Nietzsche himself lived sort of like a precursor to his Übermensch. He was by no means an Übermensch himself, but he had this ideal. And it is not Nazism. It is not control over other people. It is the self-individualized person. That is what it means. And when you read Nietzsche closely, you see that that's exactly what he's talking about. And when you see all of his comments against anti-Semitism, no one could say that Nietzsche was an anti-Semite. His sister maybe, well, not maybe, for sure. And she moved his work around a little bit to make him seem like his ideas would condone it. But he himself, there are plenty of references, legitimate references of him saying that he abhorred anti-Semitism. He did not condone it at all.
And he did not condone tyrants. He did not condone nationalism. So all of these idiot nationalists that I'm seeing all over these groups that are like, oh, the superior man, no. That is not what he meant. And the best way to know this is to read his damn books and stop reading the quotes.
All these quotes taken out of context. It's all bullshit. It's just how certain Christian groups quote the Old Testament out of context. It doesn't even mean that what they're saying. And this is the same thing for Nietzsche. He's quoted in self-help. He's quoted in white Arianism. He's quoted in all of these ways, but completely out of context.
So I'm hoping that this video, as long as it is, helps you sort of understand that he was not about that. Nietzsche, Obermensch has nothing to do with any of that stuff.