TRASCRIZIONE 🔗
1
00:00:00,435 --> 00:00:04,029
JOHN: Discussion boards and learning
management systems, particularly
2
00:00:04,029 --> 00:00:08,212
in the age of AI, rarely capture
the authentic voice of students.
3
00:00:08,592 --> 00:00:12,926
In this episode, we discuss how
using a chat application can motivate
4
00:00:12,927 --> 00:00:15,833
conversation and build community.
5
00:00:21,214 --> 00:00:25,431
Thanks for joining us for Tea for
Teaching, an informal discussion
6
00:00:25,432 --> 00:00:28,575
of innovative and effective
practices in teaching and learning.
7
00:00:29,164 --> 00:00:32,532
REBECCA: This podcast series is
hosted by John Kane, an economist
8
00:00:33,016 --> 00:00:35,133
JOHN: and Rebecca
Mushtare, a graphic designer
9
00:00:35,488 --> 00:00:38,453
REBECCA: and features guests doing
important research and advocacy
10
00:00:38,453 --> 00:00:42,693
work to make higher education more
inclusive and supportive of all learners
11
00:00:51,930 --> 00:00:53,436
Our guest today is Greg Campbell.
12
00:00:53,744 --> 00:00:56,546
Greg is the chair of the English
department at the Community College
13
00:00:56,547 --> 00:00:59,433
of Baltimore County, and the
deputy director of the Community
14
00:00:59,433 --> 00:01:01,197
College Humanities Association.
15
00:01:01,537 --> 00:01:04,282
He's been teaching online
courses since 2011.
16
00:01:04,513 --> 00:01:05,147
Welcome, Greg.
17
00:01:05,693 --> 00:01:06,005
GREG: Hello.
18
00:01:06,062 --> 00:01:07,071
Thanks for having me today.
19
00:01:07,654 --> 00:01:08,469
JOHN: Thanks for joining us.
20
00:01:09,003 --> 00:01:11,470
Today's teas are … Greg,
are you drinking tea with us?
21
00:01:12,051 --> 00:01:13,755
GREG: I am actually an avid tea drinker.
22
00:01:14,221 --> 00:01:19,237
I was raised in a tea household, so I am
enjoying a cup of Earl Grey at the moment.
23
00:01:19,764 --> 00:01:20,192
JOHN: Very nice.
24
00:01:20,417 --> 00:01:21,011
REBECCA: Nice.
25
00:01:21,433 --> 00:01:24,709
I have just an English
breakfast today, John.
26
00:01:25,235 --> 00:01:27,174
JOHN: And I have an
Irish breakfast today.
27
00:01:27,759 --> 00:01:30,102
REBECCA: Completely situated
in the black teas today.
28
00:01:31,764 --> 00:01:33,794
It's not common around here,
actually, for everyone to be
29
00:01:33,795 --> 00:01:35,198
drinking in the same ballpark.
30
00:01:35,567 --> 00:01:36,836
JOHN: It's that time of the semester.
31
00:01:37,053 --> 00:01:37,169
Yeah.
32
00:01:38,720 --> 00:01:39,363
GREG: Adding caffeine.
33
00:01:39,738 --> 00:01:40,097
REBECCA: Yeah.
34
00:01:40,562 --> 00:01:44,191
So Greg, we invited you here today
to discuss how you've used GroupMe to
35
00:01:44,191 --> 00:01:48,138
facilitate more effective discussions
in asynchronous online classes.
36
00:01:48,465 --> 00:01:50,606
Can you talk a little bit
about the problem you wanted
37
00:01:50,606 --> 00:01:52,009
to address by this choice?
38
00:01:52,835 --> 00:01:53,955
GREG: Yes, absolutely.
39
00:01:54,351 --> 00:01:55,675
Again, thanks for having me today.
40
00:01:55,744 --> 00:01:56,568
It's a pleasure to be here.
41
00:01:56,990 --> 00:02:01,625
So obviously, with my work in an English
department as well as with a humanities
42
00:02:01,625 --> 00:02:04,419
association, I'm deep into the humanities.
43
00:02:04,518 --> 00:02:07,669
And if you've ever taken a humanities
class, you know that one of the
44
00:02:07,764 --> 00:02:12,263
biggest things we do in class is spend
a lot of time discussing and having
45
00:02:12,265 --> 00:02:14,454
conversations with our students.
46
00:02:14,911 --> 00:02:19,676
And through this, we're able to build a
common understanding, common knowledge,
47
00:02:19,988 --> 00:02:23,492
and ensure that our students actually
understand topics that we're covering.
48
00:02:24,017 --> 00:02:27,981
So I realized that this is something
that we really need deeply in the
49
00:02:27,981 --> 00:02:31,892
humanities, not that it isn't necessary
in other fields and courses as well,
50
00:02:32,358 --> 00:02:35,096
but it's kind of the bedrock of a
humanities class, is that you know
51
00:02:35,096 --> 00:02:36,583
you're gonna have a lot of discussion.
52
00:02:37,026 --> 00:02:41,533
And I realized that having taught
online for a long time and looking as a
53
00:02:41,534 --> 00:02:47,698
department chair at the results of online
classes, anything from attrition to lower
54
00:02:47,700 --> 00:02:52,798
grades, started asking myself, "Okay,
we've got this outcome that's low, and
55
00:02:52,798 --> 00:02:57,390
we can't figure out why results are lower
with students who take an online class,
56
00:02:58,166 --> 00:02:59,803
so what's kind of the problem here?"
57
00:03:00,142 --> 00:03:05,236
And I was studying MBE, Mind, Brain,
and Education, with Dr. Kristen
58
00:03:05,241 --> 00:03:10,846
Betts at Drexel, and realized that
maybe the problem isn't the outcome.
59
00:03:11,426 --> 00:03:14,382
Maybe it's actually upstream,
and we're having problems with
60
00:03:14,384 --> 00:03:17,190
outcomes because we're having
problems with the original input.
61
00:03:17,777 --> 00:03:24,137
So I started looking at ways to identify
how to strengthen the input, and I kind
62
00:03:24,139 --> 00:03:29,973
of had just a moment of lovely clarity
late at night working when I realized
63
00:03:29,985 --> 00:03:33,954
that in English departments, we tend to do
everything in three stages in our classes.
64
00:03:34,381 --> 00:03:37,319
So we have the in-class discussion,
and then we have what we call an
65
00:03:37,353 --> 00:03:41,156
informal assignment, which is like
a short essay, maybe a response,
66
00:03:41,161 --> 00:03:46,495
or something that we're not really
grading intensively, more kind of just
67
00:03:46,595 --> 00:03:49,566
making sure the students understand
and are grappling with questions.
68
00:03:50,059 --> 00:03:53,510
And then, of course, we have formal
assessments, which are the research
69
00:03:53,511 --> 00:03:57,553
Load full transcript
paper and kind of thing And I realized
that the discussion boards that we were
70
00:03:57,553 --> 00:04:01,646
doing, and this is nobody's fault, I
think this has just kind of happened over
71
00:04:01,646 --> 00:04:04,643
time, and I know that this is a blanket
statement, so it's not everybody, but
72
00:04:04,919 --> 00:04:09,272
a lot of these assignments have started
turning into, rather than discussions,
73
00:04:09,310 --> 00:04:10,786
it's almost like a mini essay.
74
00:04:11,320 --> 00:04:16,425
So we're jumping straight into the
informal assignment, and we've never
75
00:04:16,426 --> 00:04:20,427
had that time to actually discuss and
ensure that we have clarity amongst the
76
00:04:20,429 --> 00:04:23,279
students of what is the subject at hand?
77
00:04:23,485 --> 00:04:25,405
Do I understand the terminology?
78
00:04:25,653 --> 00:04:27,906
Do I understand the broader scope of this?
79
00:04:28,340 --> 00:04:32,535
And so I realized that maybe the issue
is actually an input, and there's a very,
80
00:04:32,559 --> 00:04:36,523
and I'm really gonna stress here, very
basic way of looking at memory building,
81
00:04:36,551 --> 00:04:40,850
which is that we have sensory memory, then
working memory, and then long-term memory.
82
00:04:41,081 --> 00:04:45,406
And sensory is kind of the input,
working is what we hold onto for a few
83
00:04:45,407 --> 00:04:47,603
seconds, and then we have the long term.
84
00:04:48,269 --> 00:04:52,618
Well, the problem with the first step, the
sensory memory, is that students in online
85
00:04:52,618 --> 00:04:54,453
classes weren't necessarily getting that.
86
00:04:54,914 --> 00:04:58,607
They have to go and read things
that are listed in the course shelf.
87
00:04:58,647 --> 00:05:00,424
They have to go and do these things.
88
00:05:00,952 --> 00:05:04,607
We aren't necessarily interacting
with them to ensure that they
89
00:05:04,611 --> 00:05:08,148
understand the material before they're
doing these informal assessments.
90
00:05:08,566 --> 00:05:11,653
So yeah, I realized we just
need to figure out how to get
91
00:05:11,654 --> 00:05:12,907
students talking to each other.
92
00:05:13,218 --> 00:05:17,844
And I had a faculty member, great
guy, who introduced me to the GroupMe
93
00:05:17,848 --> 00:05:23,490
app, and I started using that in my
classes just as an attempt to increase
94
00:05:23,490 --> 00:05:27,376
student participation And I broke
the students up into groups so that
95
00:05:27,376 --> 00:05:31,370
they're actually in small groups,
and class participation skyrocketed.
96
00:05:31,712 --> 00:05:34,847
Basically, what I do now is we
don't do the discussion boards the
97
00:05:34,847 --> 00:05:37,494
way we traditionally do in the LMS.
98
00:05:37,870 --> 00:05:43,359
I post the discussion prompts once a
week into the GroupMe app, into each
99
00:05:43,359 --> 00:05:48,025
of the small groups, and then the
students respond to the discussion there.
100
00:05:48,528 --> 00:05:51,791
Sometimes they do get off topic,
but I relish that because I'm
101
00:05:51,793 --> 00:05:54,466
like, "Great, this is even more
like what would happen in class.
102
00:05:54,469 --> 00:05:57,459
You're having a natural conversation
with each other." So they're able
103
00:05:57,460 --> 00:06:02,178
to build social bonds as well
as interact with the material.
104
00:06:02,210 --> 00:06:05,698
And I'm in each of these groups
too, so I can see and offer
105
00:06:05,699 --> 00:06:07,443
guidance and insight as necessary.
106
00:06:07,526 --> 00:06:10,960
But the students are saying it's less
intimidating 'cause it's a smaller group.
107
00:06:10,961 --> 00:06:16,060
We get to know each other, and we're
building a sense of belonging, and it just
108
00:06:16,060 --> 00:06:17,643
really enhanced the student experience.
109
00:06:17,687 --> 00:06:20,703
And I'll level with you, it also
enhances the faculty experience
110
00:06:20,703 --> 00:06:23,029
because all of a sudden they
start asking each other questions.
111
00:06:23,497 --> 00:06:28,198
And so the load on my inbox or
my email goes down significantly
112
00:06:28,198 --> 00:06:29,349
as the semester goes along.
113
00:06:29,382 --> 00:06:32,298
But yeah, it was basically just
to say one of the bedrocks of a
114
00:06:32,299 --> 00:06:34,722
humanities class is discussion.
115
00:06:34,820 --> 00:06:37,264
So how do we recreate discussion?
116
00:06:37,646 --> 00:06:41,006
And instead of trying to reinvent the
wheel, I said, "Where are students
117
00:06:41,007 --> 00:06:44,709
talking to each other now?" So we
use this particular application.
118
00:06:44,735 --> 00:06:46,011
Now, you could use anything.
119
00:06:46,044 --> 00:06:48,390
I mean, WhatsApp has capabilities.
120
00:06:48,485 --> 00:06:52,130
You could even set up your own groups if
you wanna give out your own phone number.
121
00:06:52,508 --> 00:06:54,057
So there's a lot of other
ways you could do this.
122
00:06:54,060 --> 00:06:56,605
It was just the application I
chose because I had just been
123
00:06:56,605 --> 00:06:58,207
introduced to it and it fit the need.
124
00:06:58,519 --> 00:07:01,311
But I think there's a lot of other
ways you could mimic this just to get
125
00:07:01,311 --> 00:07:05,104
students in small groups talking to
each other and talking about a prompt.
126
00:07:05,525 --> 00:07:08,861
JOHN: Why did you select GroupMe
over one of the other apps or over
127
00:07:08,862 --> 00:07:12,792
using small group discussion boards in
Brightspace, which is what you use there?
128
00:07:13,230 --> 00:07:13,995
GREG: Great question.
129
00:07:14,361 --> 00:07:20,057
I settled on GroupMe in part because
they allow signups to use the app
130
00:07:20,226 --> 00:07:25,181
through email So students didn't need
to submit their personal information
131
00:07:25,194 --> 00:07:26,544
to sign up for the application.
132
00:07:26,925 --> 00:07:30,805
Everything's basically kept confidential
because they only need to use
their
133
00:07:30,806 --> 00:07:35,133
school email address, which everybody
would see is visible in the LMS anyway.
134
00:07:35,515 --> 00:07:38,031
So a student doesn't have to
surrender any personal information.
135
00:07:38,035 --> 00:07:39,919
So that was one of the
reasons that I landed on that.
136
00:07:40,277 --> 00:07:43,450
But the other thing is, and this
is where, again, any other similar
137
00:07:43,450 --> 00:07:46,977
application would work, is that
they don't have to log into the LMS.
138
00:07:47,633 --> 00:07:52,449
So the application I chose does also
have a web-based platform, so students
139
00:07:52,452 --> 00:07:55,398
could use their computer, but most
of them just want it in their pocket,
140
00:07:55,601 --> 00:07:57,230
and then they get notifications.
141
00:07:57,240 --> 00:07:59,005
So-and-so responded to your message.
142
00:07:59,419 --> 00:08:02,048
You have three new responses,
or something like that.
143
00:08:02,643 --> 00:08:05,340
So they're able to respond a
little more naturally, rather than
144
00:08:05,353 --> 00:08:08,639
having to sit down and say, "This
is when I'm gonna do my work.
145
00:08:08,704 --> 00:08:12,436
This is when I'm going to think about
these things." So you're actually almost
146
00:08:12,457 --> 00:08:16,581
getting that repetition of concepts into
students' brains throughout the course
147
00:08:16,582 --> 00:08:20,662
of the day because they get a ding on
their phone, check it, wanna see what
148
00:08:20,662 --> 00:08:23,033
their friends are saying, and reply.
149
00:08:23,052 --> 00:08:25,558
So it's like an ongoing conversation.
150
00:08:26,156 --> 00:08:29,510
The other nifty thing with this
is texting doesn't work the
151
00:08:29,510 --> 00:08:31,301
way normal interactions do.
152
00:08:31,861 --> 00:08:36,155
I think some people see texting as
synchronous and others as asynchronous.
153
00:08:36,566 --> 00:08:42,873
So it kind of falls into this gray area
where students are talking asynchronously,
154
00:08:42,875 --> 00:08:47,408
but it feels more synchronous than I
have to go log into my LMS and respond.
155
00:08:47,931 --> 00:08:52,193
So it just became a really powerful way
that the students can interact with each
156
00:08:52,193 --> 00:08:54,627
other and get that constant feedback.
157
00:08:55,050 --> 00:08:56,510
And there are two other
things I'm gonna add here.
158
00:08:56,739 --> 00:09:00,442
One is they all said they appreciated
that they got the notifications.
159
00:09:01,042 --> 00:09:03,526
Some faculty said, "I'm getting
a lot of notifications ," and I
160
00:09:03,548 --> 00:09:04,584
said, "You can turn them off."
161
00:09:05,421 --> 00:09:08,206
But for the students, they appreciate
that they just get the small group
162
00:09:08,206 --> 00:09:13,322
notifications, and that drove them to
get in to see, well, what did they say?
163
00:09:13,622 --> 00:09:16,069
Because we all have that inherent like,
"Ooh, there's a new message. What's
164
00:09:16,070 --> 00:09:19,268
going on? I wanna check it out." So
you're driving engagement that way.
165
00:09:19,326 --> 00:09:24,425
Also, it's separate from their regular
texting, so they know it's different,
166
00:09:24,512 --> 00:09:26,159
but at the same time, it's familiar.
167
00:09:26,552 --> 00:09:31,748
The second thing I would add is the
LMS my institution uses allows students
168
00:09:31,748 --> 00:09:36,397
to post in a discussion board, and I
don't love this function, but it says
169
00:09:36,435 --> 00:09:39,821
how many people have viewed the post
and then how many replies there are.
170
00:09:40,347 --> 00:09:44,771
Now, you might have 17 people view
your post and get zero replies,
171
00:09:45,195 --> 00:09:48,991
and that is, to me, rough, right?
172
00:09:49,668 --> 00:09:52,232
You're basically saying 17 people
looked at this and nobody wanted
173
00:09:52,232 --> 00:09:53,329
to say anything in response.
174
00:09:53,848 --> 00:09:54,339
Really, guys?
175
00:09:54,952 --> 00:10:00,261
So I think that fights against student
engagement, whereas with this application,
176
00:10:00,582 --> 00:10:03,392
if it was something that was hard to
respond to where somebody was just
177
00:10:03,392 --> 00:10:07,512
making a valid point, they don't need
to go in and just say like, "Great idea.
178
00:10:07,526 --> 00:10:11,853
Nice work." They could just send a
thumbs up that went directly onto the
179
00:10:11,853 --> 00:10:16,449
message the way you do on most texting
apps, or a heart or something like that.
180
00:10:16,848 --> 00:10:21,698
So even if they weren't getting responses
written, they knew somebody saw this
181
00:10:21,698 --> 00:10:26,030
and liked it, rather than somebody
saw this and didn't want to or need
182
00:10:26,046 --> 00:10:28,307
to take the time to type a response.
183
00:10:28,776 --> 00:10:32,300
So I think it also helps drive engagement
that way because it's a little drop of
184
00:10:32,300 --> 00:10:35,863
dopamine every time a student gets in
there and sees a thumbs up on their post.
185
00:10:36,309 --> 00:10:41,692
So it was also really helpful to drive
engagement that way, and the number of
186
00:10:41,703 --> 00:10:47,694
students who used those emoji reactions
to react to somebody's text was fantastic.
187
00:10:47,726 --> 00:10:50,872
I mean, we had so much feedback, and
they were so supportive of each other.
188
00:10:50,891 --> 00:10:54,266
And that's another thing, where you
get those smiles and nods in class.
189
00:10:54,640 --> 00:10:57,307
How do we replicate that
when we're looking online?
190
00:10:57,317 --> 00:11:00,435
We need to rethink the way that we
would do that, but not completely.
191
00:11:00,988 --> 00:11:06,294
And so let people text each other and send
emoticons and thumbs ups and things like
192
00:11:06,295 --> 00:11:08,213
that to say, "I really like this point.
193
00:11:08,214 --> 00:11:10,291
Your excellent idea," and
it worked really well.
194
00:11:10,749 -->
00:11:13,733
REBECCA: Can you talk a little bit about
some of the other privacy concerns in
195
00:11:13,734 --> 00:11:15,909
thinking about using an external tool?
196
00:11:15,932 --> 00:11:19,678
So you talked about the importance of
thinking about only disclosing an email
197
00:11:19,678 --> 00:11:23,630
address, but then we also need to think
about what these organizations are doing
198
00:11:23,630 --> 00:11:26,977
with your data that you're sharing or
the things that you're talking about.
199
00:11:27,597 --> 00:11:31,172
GREG: So that's where I will say
another reason that I stuck with the
200
00:11:31,172 --> 00:11:37,130
application I used is that it is owned
by a large, trustworthy tech company
201
00:11:37,459 --> 00:11:41,132
that, if I recall correctly, it used to
be Skype, and it's owned by Microsoft.
202
00:11:41,720 --> 00:11:44,256
So there wasn't a lot
of concern with that.
203
00:11:44,285 --> 00:11:47,762
I also checked with my IT department
to make sure that they approved
204
00:11:47,764 --> 00:11:49,007
and those kinds of things.
205
00:11:49,586 --> 00:11:54,209
But basically, what it all came down
to was it was more secure probably even
206
00:11:54,233 --> 00:11:57,747
than something like a WhatsApp because
with a WhatsApp, you're giving your phone
207
00:11:57,755 --> 00:12:02,262
number, whereas here all you had to do
was provide your school email address.
208
00:12:02,439 --> 00:12:04,347
And then I'm in each of the groups.
209
00:12:04,858 --> 00:12:07,640
So I'm there to ensure that,
you know, things can get off
210
00:12:07,641 --> 00:12:11,113
topic, but we're not gonna harass
anybody or cause any problems.
211
00:12:11,440 --> 00:12:16,194
And fortunately, we've never had this
instance, but if someone were to post
212
00:12:16,204 --> 00:12:20,051
something that were problematic, you
could immediately remove them from the
213
00:12:20,148 --> 00:12:21,963
chat, which is really quick and easy.
214
00:12:22,555 --> 00:12:27,286
And something that I'll add is I didn't
allow students to edit or delete posts.
215
00:12:27,742 --> 00:12:30,136
Part of the reason for that was I
was worried that a student would
216
00:12:30,194 --> 00:12:35,387
post something distasteful or
cruel, and I didn't want them to
217
00:12:35,387 --> 00:12:38,144
then be able to delete it and say,
"I never said that," or edit it.
218
00:12:38,444 --> 00:12:41,377
So that was another way, and I
told students that ahead of time-
219
00:12:42,134 --> 00:12:44,026
They see as well when they sign up.
220
00:12:44,567 --> 00:12:45,601
This is the way it's set up.
221
00:12:45,802 --> 00:12:49,765
But yeah, there are ways that we can
ensure that we have supervision over
222
00:12:49,766 --> 00:12:54,489
the class, but otherwise, it's really
no different than providing email
223
00:12:54,489 --> 00:12:57,609
addresses to each of the students
and saying, "Email each other."
224
00:12:57,960 --> 00:13:02,672
It's just much more in line with the way
students interact anyway, in that they're
225
00:13:02,672 --> 00:13:04,561
just texting, so it comes naturally.
226
00:13:05,547 --> 00:13:08,889
JOHN: Before we recorded this, you
had mentioned that this project grew
227
00:13:08,923 --> 00:13:12,463
out of something you had done in
your face-to-face classes earlier.
228
00:13:12,780 --> 00:13:17,094
Could you tell us about that initial
experiment and how this grew out of that?
229
00:13:17,709 --> 00:13:18,858
GREG: Yes, absolutely.
230
00:13:18,893 --> 00:13:26,376
So I can be introverted at times,
and I am the student who would
231
00:13:26,387 --> 00:13:29,891
traditionally walk in, find the
seat in the back corner, sit down.
232
00:13:30,101 --> 00:13:34,434
I raise my hand maybe once or twice
a class to ask questions, but I was
233
00:13:34,435 --> 00:13:38,047
definitely the annoying student who would
have time to think about what we discussed
234
00:13:38,048 --> 00:13:41,559
in class and then start the next class
with, "I just have a quick follow-up."
235
00:13:42,114 --> 00:13:47,048
And so I kind of felt like I
needed time to digest material
236
00:13:47,509 --> 00:13:48,743
rather than just dive in.
237
00:13:49,432 --> 00:13:54,023
I teach at a community college where
we're teaching a lot of first generation
238
00:13:54,031 --> 00:13:58,548
college students who it's their first
semester in college and they're nervous.
239
00:13:59,278 --> 00:14:01,247
So a lot to balance there.
240
00:14:01,724 --> 00:14:04,644
So in my face-to-face classes, I
realized that some students may
241
00:14:04,684 --> 00:14:06,484
be hesitant to raise their hand.
242
00:14:06,879 --> 00:14:10,033
They're also very concerned
if they're 18 to 25.
243
00:14:10,053 --> 00:14:12,810
They're concerned about image, and
I don't wanna ask this question.
244
00:14:12,810 --> 00:14:13,668
Is it stupid?
245
00:14:14,263 --> 00:14:18,364
So what I started doing is what I
call questions for the class, and
246
00:14:18,365 --> 00:14:22,692
this was probably 2012 I started
doing this, and I still do it.
247
00:14:23,250 --> 00:14:26,772
But I just tell my students that over the
course of the semester through the LMS,
248
00:14:26,811 --> 00:14:30,363
there's an area that's an assignment,
and they have to post 10 questions in
249
00:14:30,364 --> 00:14:31,858
there over the course of the semester.
250
00:14:32,402 --> 00:14:38,614
And if they don't like interacting
in class That's fine, just post extra
251
00:14:38,614 --> 00:14:41,823
questions and questions for the class,
and I'll give you your participation
252
00:14:41,823 --> 00:14:45,246
points that way by considering that
you're still asking questions in this way.
253
00:14:45,701 --> 00:14:49,566
So it allowed students to actually
have time to consider what they
254
00:14:49,566 --> 00:14:54,402
were going to say and still
participate, and those shy students
255
00:14:54,487 --> 00:14:56,599
are also still able to participate.
256
00:14:57,270 --> 00:15:02,897
Now, there's also an added trick to
this, which is that it is a dream for
257
00:15:02,897 --> 00:15:07,743
a faculty member because what I would
do is I don't lecture in my classes.
258
00:15:07,743 --> 00:15:11,793
I mean, it's an English 101, but I
find that when I ask questions of
259
00:15:11,814 --> 00:15:15,713
my students, whenever possible I
have some prepared questions and I
260
00:15:15,731 --> 00:15:19,067
post those into a PowerPoint just
so students can see the question
261
00:15:19,067 --> 00:15:20,841
on the wall as we're discussing it.
262
00:15:21,235 --> 00:15:24,270
But what I then do is also I take
questions for the class right before
263
00:15:24,270 --> 00:15:29,495
class starts, paste them into that
PowerPoint at the beginning, and the
264
00:15:29,496 --> 00:15:32,808
first thing I'll do is I walk into
class, talk for a couple of seconds.
265
00:15:33,202 --> 00:15:36,365
"How's everyone doing? Great. Let's
see what the first question from
266
00:15:36,365 --> 00:15:37,615
your fellow students was today."
267
00:15:38,078 --> 00:15:40,423
And I cluster them 'cause I
try to do paired readings.
268
00:15:40,675 --> 00:15:43,316
So I cluster them, but then I'm
just saying to the class, like,
269
00:15:43,560 --> 00:15:44,702
"These aren't even my questions.
270
00:15:44,752 --> 00:15:46,311
This isn't even what I'm asking of you.
271
00:15:46,314 --> 00:15:50,623
This is what you found as you were
reading." And what's interesting is
272
00:15:50,629 --> 00:15:54,078
the students get jazzed, and it's funny
because especially the introverted
273
00:15:54,079 --> 00:15:57,003
students who you think are never
gonna fess up to that's my question,
274
00:15:57,159 --> 00:15:58,017
they'll be like, "That one's mine."
275
00:15:58,477 --> 00:16:01,143
And all of a sudden you're
building some more cohesion here
276
00:16:01,161 --> 00:16:04,165
and the students are seeing, hey,
we all have similar questions.
277
00:16:04,184 --> 00:16:08,219
And I'll even say, "We had three questions
exactly like this, so you're not alone
278
00:16:08,220 --> 00:16:11,622
in thinking that. Here's the first one,
here's the second, here's the third. So
279
00:16:11,622 --> 00:16:13,320
broadly, how do we wanna deal with that?"
280
00:16:13,828 --> 00:16:18,193
So I've always been interested in
this idea of how can we leverage
281
00:16:18,194 --> 00:16:20,912
technology and not substitute it?
282
00:16:21,581 --> 00:16:26,704
And so what we're doing here is saying, "I
still want my students to ask questions in
283
00:16:26,705 --> 00:16:30,849
class, but let's leverage technology and
give them other options and opportunities
284
00:16:30,859 --> 00:16:36,179
for doing that." And the students are
happy because they see their question on
285
00:16:36,179 --> 00:16:37,901
the screen and they're excited by that.
286
00:16:38,452 --> 00:16:40,007
They all get to voice their opinion.
287
00:16:40,569 --> 00:16:44,111
The quieter students are able to
participate the way they choose
288
00:16:44,111 --> 00:16:48,388
to, and every student feels like
they're represented then in the class
289
00:16:48,390 --> 00:16:51,361
because everybody at some point has
a question that's up on the screen.
290
00:16:51,517 --> 00:16:56,587
And also as a faculty member, easily the
first half of class is done because I
291
00:16:56,614 --> 00:17:00,762
just copy and paste their questions and
then I pepper in the things that I need
292
00:17:00,776 --> 00:17:04,331
to based on the in-class discussion.
293
00:17:04,849 --> 00:17:09,396
So I'm still just running a class
discussion, but they're actually running
294
00:17:09,396 --> 00:17:14,141
the discussion and I'm more moderating
it, and that's how we cover getting
295
00:17:14,142 --> 00:17:18,979
students involved regardless of their
comfort level, but also supporting them
296
00:17:18,980 --> 00:17:24,092
in building a comfort level So I had
already done this, and when it came to the
297
00:17:24,092 --> 00:17:28,238
asynchronous class, I was just thinking
to myself: how do I recreate these
298
00:17:28,245 --> 00:17:30,693
questions for the class in this setting?
299
00:17:31,349 --> 00:17:35,664
And the best thing I could come up with
was have them submit questions, and
300
00:17:35,664 --> 00:17:39,782
then I make that the discussion board,
but then you have the same problem of
301
00:17:39,946 --> 00:17:43,811
we whisper about this in the hallways,
faculty and students, that everybody
302
00:17:43,811 --> 00:17:47,354
reads the first post and responds to
that, and then the higher up in the
303
00:17:47,354 --> 00:17:51,019
queue, the more replies, the lower in the
queue, the fewer, and they get kind of
304
00:17:51,019 --> 00:17:53,357
repetitive after a little while, right?
305
00:17:53,672 --> 00:17:54,148
We all know.
306
00:17:54,676 --> 00:17:59,244
So I was just thinking, I can't keep
up with constantly posting, "Well,
307
00:17:59,244 --> 00:18:02,588
this got sent in this morning, and I
know I had meetings all morning, so
308
00:18:02,588 --> 00:18:05,934
here it is this afternoon." So instead
I thought, let's figure out a way to
309
00:18:05,935 --> 00:18:09,716
put the burden on them to ask each
other the questions, because they're
310
00:18:09,743 --> 00:18:13,234
already doing it through the technology
and getting my support with that.
311
00:18:13,603 --> 00:18:17,501
And yeah, it was anything to do to drive
engagement that I could come up with.
312
00:18:17,935 --> 00:18:20,091
I mean, we have to remember,
they're college students.
313
00:18:20,793 --> 00:18:21,935
They want to socialize.
314
00:18:22,040 --> 00:18:22,998
They want to make friends.
315
00:18:23,076 --> 00:18:24,227
They want to connect.
316
00:18:24,537 --> 00:18:27,427
And I will add, they want to connect with
the faculty member, and they appreciate
317
00:18:27,441 --> 00:18:30,830
having the faculty member in the chat,
too, because then they can also just
318
00:18:30,981
--> 00:18:34,854
private message you if they need to
and get direct connection to you that
319
00:18:34,857 --> 00:18:37,205
doesn't feel as formal as an email.
320
00:18:37,557 --> 00:18:42,268
So this was all driven from the
premise of, okay, this is how I did
321
00:18:42,268 --> 00:18:43,945
it in the face-to-face classroom.
322
00:18:44,486 --> 00:18:48,361
I need to replicate that questions
for the class and the discussions.
323
00:18:49,086 --> 00:18:50,371
How do I bring that in?
324
00:18:50,423 --> 00:18:54,454
And then I was introduced to the
GroupMe application by Dr. Ibarrola.
325
00:18:54,784 --> 00:18:58,962
And he used it just to keep in touch
with us, because I was in a small
326
00:18:58,963 --> 00:19:01,582
class of just six students, and
he was like, "Let's just use this.
327
00:19:01,846 --> 00:19:04,394
It's an easy way for you to get ahold
of me." So we just used it to ask
328
00:19:04,394 --> 00:19:06,068
him questions in a statistics class.
329
00:19:06,453 --> 00:19:11,266
But all of a sudden, a light bulb went
off over my head that was, wait a minute
330
00:19:13,057 --> 00:19:16,448
The students can interact through this,
ask each other questions through this.
331
00:19:16,549 --> 00:19:19,055
I can still monitor and make
sure that they're safe and
332
00:19:19,296 --> 00:19:20,675
nothing crazy is happening.
333
00:19:21,079 --> 00:19:24,953
And yeah, it just developed from
there, and it was a great study.
334
00:19:24,981 --> 00:19:25,771
We had a lot of fun with it.
335
00:19:26,228 --> 00:19:29,295
REBECCA: As you've been talking about
the transition from what you were doing
336
00:19:29,295 --> 00:19:33,361
in your face-to-face classes to trying
to move towards a more synchronous type
337
00:19:33,361 --> 00:19:37,839
of conversation in an online class, I
was thinking about opportunities that
338
00:19:37,840 --> 00:19:42,434
I've had in classes where I moved towards
using something like Slack or Gchat in
339
00:19:42,434 --> 00:19:46,794
a project based class where you need the
opportunity to have real time exchanges,
340
00:19:46,798 --> 00:19:51,817
but also the more asynchronous dialogue
as opposed to a discussion board.
341
00:19:51,951 --> 00:19:54,804
It doesn't have a structure
similar to a conversation at all.
342
00:19:55,701 --> 00:19:57,143
It's like no one talks in threads.
343
00:19:58,166 --> 00:19:58,431
GREG: No.
344
00:19:58,748 --> 00:20:02,112
And I love the idea of Slack too
because that can also prepare
345
00:20:02,112 --> 00:20:03,292
students for the workplace.
346
00:20:03,858 --> 00:20:07,065
And particularly if you're having
them do group projects, the idea
347
00:20:07,090 --> 00:20:10,357
of this is the way your projects
are gonna work in the future.
348
00:20:10,742 --> 00:20:12,031
I think that's fantastic.
349
00:20:12,096 --> 00:20:15,508
But the idea here was it
was low level implementation
350
00:20:15,515 --> 00:20:16,953
for first semester students.
351
00:20:17,504 --> 00:20:23,526
And like you said, when I read through
discussion board prompts in other classes
352
00:20:23,577 --> 00:20:28,607
or past classes I've taught where there's
seven paragraphs with citations and
353
00:20:28,651 --> 00:20:32,875
references at the end, and I say, "You
would never talk this way in class.
354
00:20:33,070 --> 00:20:37,107
This is not a conversation." So I used
to even get mad at my students and
355
00:20:37,111 --> 00:20:39,098
be like, "Stop writing paragraphs.
356
00:20:39,170 --> 00:20:43,135
Keep it brief." But I think there's
almost this sense of, well, that's
357
00:20:43,146 --> 00:20:45,195
not the format of a discussion board.
358
00:20:45,908 --> 00:20:50,091
They've been inherently taught that
discussion boards are multi-paragraph,
359
00:20:50,517 --> 00:20:52,080
what I would call an informal assignment.
360
00:20:52,685 --> 00:20:55,137
Whereas texting, they know how to text.
361
00:20:55,250 --> 00:20:56,914
They know that paragraphs
are unacceptable.
362
00:20:56,964 --> 00:21:02,636
Like, if you're sending a six paragraph
text, nobody's reading it So the format
363
00:21:02,636 --> 00:21:06,805
matches more closely with conversation,
and that's what I liked about it.
364
00:21:07,460 --> 00:21:10,979
Just as you said, and I just can't agree
more with that, like, nobody talks the way
365
00:21:10,979 --> 00:21:12,734
a discussion board is actually fashioned.
366
00:21:13,309 --> 00:21:17,818
So we need those discussions, but how
do we rethink the way we're doing those
367
00:21:17,818 --> 00:21:22,593
discussions and format it in such a
way that it fits both the modality
368
00:21:22,676 --> 00:21:26,082
as well as will get student buy-in?
369
00:21:26,415 --> 00:21:29,074
JOHN: So when you started to
use GroupMe, you also decided to
370
00:21:29,074 --> 00:21:32,574
use this as a research project
for your dissertation research.
371
00:21:32,962 --> 00:21:36,172
Can you tell us a little bit about
how you designed the experiment
372
00:21:36,227 --> 00:21:37,909
that you used in your study?
373
00:21:38,561 --> 00:21:39,043
GREG: Oh, yeah.
374
00:21:39,144 --> 00:21:40,985
So things are about to get complicated.
375
00:21:42,207 --> 00:21:46,201
I gathered a lot more data than I probably
needed, but it worked out in the long run.
376
00:21:46,339 --> 00:21:51,310
So the way it was designed, and I
can tell you also we had some issues
377
00:21:51,313 --> 00:21:56,009
along the way, so it was originally
going to run in a 14 or 15-week
378
00:21:56,011 --> 00:21:59,002
semester at an external institution.
379
00:21:59,553 --> 00:22:04,160
Then we ran into some barriers with
that, and we were gonna run it at my own
380
00:22:04,160 --> 00:22:07,682
institution in a 15-week semester, and
then it was too tight, so I said, "What
381
00:22:07,683 --> 00:22:13,183
about a 10-week semester?" And I already
had research being done for others at the
382
00:22:13,183 --> 00:22:17,112
institution and other individuals
with all
of the classes that were 10-week classes,
383
00:22:17,114 --> 00:22:21,234
so I ended up doing seven-week classes
and worked with the faculty members to
384
00:22:21,299 --> 00:22:25,522
explain if you have problems, you need
to go to a coordinator or the dean.
385
00:22:25,955 --> 00:22:29,863
So we made sure it was ethically handled
so that I wasn't supervising these folks,
386
00:22:30,349 --> 00:22:34,863
and they were fully online classes taught
by adjuncts, which I tend to oversee
387
00:22:34,875 --> 00:22:38,477
the full-time faculty more, and I have
coordinators who oversee the adjuncts.
388
00:22:38,494 --> 00:22:41,386
So I made sure there were layers
of protection, that there was
389
00:22:41,386 --> 00:22:42,374
nothing getting in the way.
390
00:22:42,635 --> 00:22:44,518
So there was a little bit of
a time crunch, that we were
391
00:22:44,519 --> 00:22:45,619
now in a seven-week class.
392
00:22:45,723 --> 00:22:49,031
Also, I will say it was a
spring second seven-week class.
393
00:22:49,059 --> 00:22:51,105
So we had a little bit
of attrition as well
394
00:22:52,116 --> 00:22:53,031
REBECCA: which is understandable.
395
00:22:53,300 --> 00:22:56,585
GREG: Yeah, so the study was
designed in a manner in which
396
00:22:56,619 --> 00:22:59,136
I did a pre and post-survey.
397
00:22:59,141 --> 00:23:04,112
So the pre-survey was a series of 10
questions, and then the post-survey
398
00:23:04,146 --> 00:23:08,301
was most but not quite all of the
community of inquiry framework questions.
399
00:23:08,628 --> 00:23:13,080
And then the 10 pre-questions were also
taken from the community of inquiry
400
00:23:13,083 --> 00:23:17,976
theory, and we also had some open-ended
questions for students So the first
401
00:23:17,976 --> 00:23:21,749
step was the quantitative data, which
was gathered through Likert scale
402
00:23:21,750 --> 00:23:23,632
questions in the pre and post surveys.
403
00:23:24,275 --> 00:23:29,108
Also, during the course of the seven
weeks, I collected and coded all of the
404
00:23:29,109 --> 00:23:36,297
data from the GroupMe chats and coded all
of the GroupMe chats using NVivo coding.
405
00:23:36,933 --> 00:23:43,248
Then, still not quite enough, the plan
was to have one or two focus groups, but
406
00:23:43,248 --> 00:23:48,480
it was hard to get students into a focus
group over the course of seven weeks.
407
00:23:48,958 --> 00:23:51,951
They already had a lot going on,
so we made the decision to change
408
00:23:51,955 --> 00:23:56,122
from focus groups to individual
interviews, and I interviewed four
409
00:23:56,122 --> 00:23:58,315
students and three faculty members.
410
00:23:58,315 --> 00:24:01,986
So it was the two faculty members who
taught the classes, two intervention
411
00:24:01,987 --> 00:24:04,244
courses, and then one that was a control.
412
00:24:04,571 --> 00:24:08,657
And then those transcripts were
coded through NVivo, and then
413
00:24:08,708 --> 00:24:11,310
everything was brought
together,
triangulated for results.
414
00:24:11,898 --> 00:24:14,005
So it was quite a complicated summer.
415
00:24:14,774 --> 00:24:15,978
A lot of coding happened.
416
00:24:16,495 --> 00:24:21,769
But the results were fantastic and
supported by faculty and students alike.
417
00:24:22,359 --> 00:24:24,894
I will never forget the
first interview I did.
418
00:24:24,932 --> 00:24:28,872
I was like, "Okay, I want to make sure
students have a sense of support and
419
00:24:28,872 --> 00:24:32,630
belonging and that they like the GroupMe
application because that's what they're
420
00:24:32,630 --> 00:24:35,811
stuck with." And the first student I
interviewed, I said, "So tell me how
421
00:24:35,812 --> 00:24:39,148
it's going." And I kid you not, the
student just said, "It's just given me
422
00:24:39,149 --> 00:24:41,432
a real sense of support and belonging."
423
00:24:42,155 --> 00:24:43,766
I was like, "All right, we're good.
424
00:24:44,598 --> 00:24:48,459
Wrap it up." But no, the only negative
comment I actually received from a student
425
00:24:48,485 --> 00:24:51,350
was it was a question about discussion
boards and the student said, "I really
426
00:24:51,355 --> 00:24:52,728
don't like the discussion boards.
427
00:24:52,791 --> 00:24:54,888
However, I enjoyed the GroupMe.
428
00:24:54,903 --> 00:24:57,577
We could've done more of that."
And I just giggled to myself and
429
00:24:57,577 --> 00:24:59,923
thought, "You didn't even realize
you were doing discussion boards.
430
00:25:00,461 --> 00:25:04,629
You were doing them the whole time."
So yeah, all in all, the results were
431
00:25:04,629 --> 00:25:09,692
really positive, and I should know this
number off the top of my head, but I can
432
00:25:09,693 --> 00:25:14,233
get close, which was, I believe there
was one question that was in the post
433
00:25:14,233 --> 00:25:20,164
survey, I feel more connected to my
classmates in regards to non-academic
434
00:25:20,322 --> 00:25:22,970
subjects or non-academic interactions.
435
00:25:23,503 --> 00:25:30,524
And the control group fell from about
50% to zero, and the intervention
436
00:25:30,525 --> 00:25:34,068
groups went from 30% to 80%.
437
00:25:34,581 --> 00:25:38,202
So one dropped by about 50%, the
other increased by about 50%.
438
00:25:38,700 --> 00:25:42,176
And so just building that
sense of connectedness.
439
00:25:42,758 --> 00:25:46,352
And what I will say I think may be the
most interesting outcome of the study
440
00:25:46,425 --> 00:25:52,665
is what I call the social-emotional
belonging fabric And basically I think
441
00:25:52,666 --> 00:25:57,890
of it in this term of if you know of
like physics and astronomy, there's this
442
00:25:57,890 --> 00:26:04,021
idea of the space-time fabric and that
everything sits in this space-time fabric.
443
00:26:04,647 --> 00:26:08,224
And to me, that's what this
social-emotional belonging is, is
444
00:26:08,224 --> 00:26:12,159
that you need to build that social and
emotional
belonging, and then the students
445
00:26:12,161 --> 00:26:16,546
will be more willing to interact over
the course of the academic materials.
446
00:26:16,982 --> 00:26:20,924
But the academics can also then
reinforce the social and emotional
447
00:26:20,924 --> 00:26:24,185
belonging if they're connecting
when they're doing the academic work
448
00:26:24,216 --> 00:26:25,493
as they do in those small groups.
449
00:26:26,170 --> 00:26:30,881
So to me it was that for a synchronous
online class to really be effective,
450
00:26:31,055 --> 00:26:32,965
we need that baseline fabric.
451
00:26:33,653 --> 00:26:37,038
We need the students to be interacting
with each other, to be building bonds
452
00:26:37,039 --> 00:26:40,884
and to be comfortable with each other,
and then we have the fabric upon which
453
00:26:40,888 --> 00:26:42,478
we can build the other structures.
454
00:26:43,008 --> 00:26:47,463
But to me that was the most interesting
thing, that every student and every
455
00:26:47,464 --> 00:26:51,707
faculty member just talked about how
the students were more connected with
456
00:26:51,708 --> 00:26:56,039
each other and that led to stronger
connections with the material.
457
00:26:56,267 --> 00:27:00,965
So I think that we maybe need to
think about how do we reconceptualize
458
00:27:01,155 --> 00:27:04,873
asynchronous online classes so
that the goal is to establish that
459
00:27:04,873 --> 00:27:08,867
fabric and then put the structure
of the course on that fabric.
460
00:27:09,197 --> 00:27:14,231
And that to me is where we need to go
maybe in the future as we reconsider
461
00:27:14,385 --> 00:27:17,768
the possible ways of structuring
asynchronous online classes.
462
00:27:18,764 --> 00:27:20,319
JOHN: A couple of
clarification questions.
463
00:27:20,335 --> 00:27:22,239
One is, you mentioned a control group.
464
00:27:22,543 --> 00:27:25,060
Am I correct in assuming that
the control group was the class
465
00:27:25,085 --> 00:27:28,855
that used traditional discussion
boards instead of using GroupMe?
466
00:27:29,586 --> 00:27:29,995
GREG: Correct.
467
00:27:30,134 --> 00:27:30,538
Yes.
468
00:27:30,925 --> 00:27:34,561
JOHN: And another is, not all of
our listeners will be familiar with
469
00:27:34,577 --> 00:27:36,976
qualitative research or with NVivo.
470
00:27:37,365 --> 00:27:40,649
Could you describe what NVivo
is, just to fill people in?
471
00:27:41,322 --> 00:27:41,728
GREG: Yes.
472
00:27:41,802 --> 00:27:46,467
So NVivo is a process by
which you can do coding.
473
00:27:46,948 --> 00:27:50,949
I'm using it in this sense
to describe a coding system.
474
00:27:51,389 --> 00:27:56,312
So basically, what you can do is you can
code material in many different ways.
475
00:27:56,733 --> 00:27:58,605
There are whole handbooks on how to code.
476
00:27:58,639 --> 00:28:02,839
There are different styles, systems of
establishing what you're looking for.
477
00:28:03,279 --> 00:28:05,058
And coding's often done in two cycles.
478
00:28:05,074 --> 00:28:08,419
So you go through it one way, and then
when you're all done, you say, "Oh, good
479
00:28:08,443 --> 00:28:11,387
heavens, I have to do all that again."
And then you do it all again a second
480
00:28:11,408 --> 00:28:13,230
time with a different coding system.
481
00:28:13,803 --> 00:28:17,491
So I can tell you what I did was
for the GroupMe transcripts, as
482
00:28:17,493 --> 00:28:20,476
well as the open-ended responses
in the pre- and post-surveys, I
483
00:28:20,477 --> 00:28:22,331
did what's called a priori coding.
484
00:28:23,052 --> 00:28:27,125
So that's where I took existing
terminology and vocabulary, and I
485
00:28:27,127 --> 00:28:31,143
used a lot of terms that came from
social and emotional belonging and
486
00:28:31,143 --> 00:28:32,609
the community of inquiry framework.
487
00:28:33,128 --> 00:28:36,976
And I looked for keywords or
themes that related to those,
488
00:28:36,977 --> 00:28:40,088
and any time you come across one
of them, you kinda highlight it.
489
00:28:40,425 --> 00:28:46,010
So with my first round of coding in
the pre open-ended responses, the
490
00:28:46,010 --> 00:28:49,780
post open-ended responses, and the
transcripts, I did that a priori coding.
491
00:28:50,053 --> 00:28:54,005
Then I followed up with what is called
descriptive coding for the second cycle.
492
00:28:54,594 --> 00:28:57,675
This is where you're describing
what the students are doing.
493
00:28:57,705 --> 00:29:01,574
So I might have keywords that are
things like supporting each other,
494
00:29:01,911 --> 00:29:05,057
student-focused support, or peer-to-peer
support, something like that.
495
00:29:05,404 --> 00:29:08,725
And then anywhere you're seeing that
the students are doing that peer-to-peer
496
00:29:08,733 --> 00:29:12,620
support, you highlight it, and then you
can compare how often am I seeing this
497
00:29:12,639 --> 00:29:17,326
peer-to-peer support populate in the
transcript for the intervention groups
498
00:29:17,340 --> 00:29:21,304
versus how often do I see it populate
in the transcripts for the control group
499
00:29:22,001 --> 00:29:25,270
And now I did one other thing which
I thought was kind of a little nifty.
500
00:29:25,665 --> 00:29:30,609
I finished with descriptive coding as the
second cycle for all of that material.
501
00:29:30,642 --> 00:29:35,638
But then for the interviews, I used
those same descriptive codes as the first
502
00:29:35,638 --> 00:29:40,360
cycle of the interview transcripts, so
there was kind of an alignment there.
503
00:29:40,676 --> 00:29:43,850
And then for the second cycle, I did
what's called values coding, where
504
00:29:43,850 --> 00:29:47,657
you look at what are the things that
they're saying they find valuable as a
505
00:29:47,657 --> 00:29:53,784
value or an emotion or a belief, and you
try to focus on those kinds of things.
506
00:29:53,828 --> 00:29:57,045
And that to me was good for the
interviews because it got to the heart
507
00:29:57,107 --> 00:30:00,434
of these are the things that you're
talking about, so they're important,
508
00:30:00,464 --> 00:30:01,822
whether they're positive or negative.
509
00:30:02,213 --> 00:30:03,849
If these are the things you're
talking about, these are your
510
00:30:03,851 --> 00:30:06,851
core values, and these are the
things you valued in the course.
511
00:30:07,175 --> 00:30:10,471
So that's why I used that as the second
round of coding after I made sure that
512
00:30:10,472 --> 00:30:15,227
I had some alignment, because I had so
much different qualitative material that
513
00:30:15,304 --> 00:30:18,899
I just needed a way to make sure that it
was all aligned or I was gonna go crazy.
514
00:30:19,149 --> 00:30:22,346
So it's a process, and then
basically what you can do is look at
515
00:30:22,608 --> 00:30:25,794
And then this is what we call
triangulation, is you look at the
516
00:30:25,819 --> 00:30:30,533
quantitative results And so I can
say, okay, quantitatively, according
517
00:30:30,534 --> 00:30:34,425
to the Likert scale questions,
students believed that working
518
00:30:34,426 --> 00:30:35,916
in small groups was a positive.
519
00:30:36,129 --> 00:30:40,290
And then you go over to your
qualitative and the codes, and you try
520
00:30:40,290 --> 00:30:42,186
to break it down into bigger themes.
521
00:30:42,645 --> 00:30:47,546
And of those bigger themes you say,
well, this theme relates to this
522
00:30:47,577 --> 00:30:52,445
qualitative code or this qualitative
outcome, and so here the qualitative
523
00:30:52,475 --> 00:30:54,216
and the quantitative match.
524
00:30:54,590 --> 00:30:56,642
So I'm getting qualitative
results that say that the
525
00:30:56,644 --> 00:30:58,213
students like the small groups.
526
00:30:58,563 --> 00:31:02,571
In the interviews and in the chat
transcripts, we also got that.
527
00:31:02,947 --> 00:31:06,963
So if those results align qualitatively
and quantitatively, that's what
528
00:31:06,964 --> 00:31:09,239
we call triangulation, because
they're supporting each other.
529
00:31:09,607 --> 00:31:14,385
So it's basically a way of gathering
qualitative information, kind of
530
00:31:14,558 --> 00:31:18,174
making it quantitative because you're
then able to count the number of each
531
00:31:18,176 --> 00:31:22,019
code or each theme, but then you look
at the two and compare them and say,
532
00:31:22,019 --> 00:31:25,687
yes, this actually supports what we
were saying in the quantitative data.
533
00:31:25,735 --> 00:31:29,476
And so for that reason, we believe
there's a strong level of support to this.
534
00:31:29,998 --> 00:31:33,964
So it's a mixed method study, but
the heart of this study was really
535
00:31:34,058 --> 00:31:38,277
conversation, student interaction,
do you feel supported by each other?
536
00:31:38,829 --> 00:31:43,743
And as much as we can gather information
on that quantitatively, I felt quite
537
00:31:43,744 --> 00:31:47,261
strongly that we also
needed the
qualitative aspects and the individual
538
00:31:47,263 --> 00:31:52,086
student and faculty feedback to see that
that was actually supported, and it was.
539
00:31:52,412 --> 00:31:54,844
REBECCA: At the top, you talked a
little bit about what your goals were
540
00:31:54,851 --> 00:31:56,478
and what you were trying to achieve.
541
00:31:56,862 --> 00:31:59,139
You talk about belongingness and
connection, but, like, what kinds
542
00:31:59,139 --> 00:32:03,069
of words are they using to describe
why they like the platform or why
543
00:32:03,082 --> 00:32:04,772
they like this kind of interaction?
544
00:32:05,149 --> 00:32:09,451
GREG: So there were a lot of different
responses, and this is why I landed
545
00:32:09,451 --> 00:32:14,331
on that theory of a social-emotional
background fabric, is because the levels
546
00:32:14,418 --> 00:32:18,105
were so broad, but also broadly supported.
547
00:32:18,402 --> 00:32:22,156
So I can tell you one response that
I got from students was, "Well, it
548
00:32:22,157 --> 00:32:25,547
was nice to know that if I needed
to privately message my professor, I
549
00:32:25,547 --> 00:32:28,976
could just pull out my phone and do
it." And I said, "Well, did you?" "No.
550
00:32:29,312 --> 00:32:32,257
But it was nice to know that I
could." Well, to me, that's an
551
00:32:32,257 --> 00:32:33,674
interesting form of support.
552
00:32:33,899 --> 00:32:35,810
And I said to them, "Well,
did you email at any point?"
553
00:32:35,810 --> 00:32:39,897
And they said, "Nah, email's too formal."
But I said, "You didn't even use it, but
554
00:32:39,897 --> 00:32:42,245
it felt supportive." And they said, "Yeah.
555
00:32:42,641 --> 00:32:43,211
They're right there.
556
00:32:43,213 --> 00:32:47,791
They're on my phone." So it's even
interesting that you didn't necessarily
557
00:32:47,791 --> 00:32:52,668
need to utilize every opportunity, but
just them knowing that they could went
558
00:32:52,668 --> 00:32:57,084
a long way Then there was also students
who said, "I get anxiety when there's 17
559
00:32:57,084 --> 00:33:00,687
or 20 posts and threads, and I have to
read them and decide who to respond to."
560
00:33:00,687 --> 00:33:01,544
And they're honest.
561
00:33:01,558 --> 00:33:05,012
They're like, "I don't read them all. I
just find one with only one response or
562
00:33:05,012 --> 00:33:09,538
none and try and make them feel good."
So students felt supported because there
563
00:33:09,538 --> 00:33:13,563
was reduced anxiety, and they got to know
the people in their group, so it wasn't
564
00:33:13,600 --> 00:33:16,406
a who are these people after seven weeks.
565
00:33:16,738 --> 00:33:17,909
They knew who the people were.
566
00:33:18,215 --> 00:33:19,607
So there was that support.
567
00:33:19,671 --> 00:33:23,541
There was also, as I mentioned earlier,
the support of student to student, where
568
00:33:23,581 --> 00:33:28,220
I even had responses where it's 2:00 AM,
and a student sends a text
out through
569
00:33:28,220 --> 00:33:32,240
the application saying, "I can't find
such and such assignment." And another
570
00:33:32,240 --> 00:33:34,275
student who was up at that hour responded
571
00:33:34,600 --> 00:33:36,059
And they can use the @ sign, too.
572
00:33:36,509 --> 00:33:39,661
So they said, "@ so
and so, it's over here.
573
00:33:39,954 --> 00:33:44,089
It's titled this." And then
the student responded, "@ so
574
00:33:44,089 --> 00:33:45,551
and so, thank you so much.
575
00:33:45,553 --> 00:33:46,175
I just found it.
576
00:33:46,177 --> 00:33:49,677
I really appreciate that." And then
the other student responded, "I gotcha.
577
00:33:49,866 --> 00:33:52,099
I'm up at this hour, too, if you
need anything," stuff like that.
578
00:33:52,111 --> 00:33:55,838
So it was really interesting that
they also then support each other.
579
00:33:56,149 --> 00:34:00,569
And they know that we all have the
same questions and the same things.
580
00:34:00,571 --> 00:34:03,788
So that's why it kind of landed on
this idea of a fabric because I'm
581
00:34:03,788 --> 00:34:05,371
not sure there's any one thing.
582
00:34:05,681 --> 00:34:09,754
I think it's just a broad can I access
the faculty member if I need to?
583
00:34:09,941 --> 00:34:11,905
Can I talk to other students if I need to?
584
00:34:12,024 --> 00:34:15,168
Am I alone out here in a
class where we never meet, and
585
00:34:15,168 --> 00:34:16,549
I'll never see anyone's face?
586
00:34:17,092 --> 00:34:18,362
Is anyone on my side?
587
00:34:18,570 --> 00:34:20,771
And it's like, yeah, the
people over here in your little
588
00:34:20,773 --> 00:34:21,636
group, they're on your side.
589
00:34:22,159 --> 00:34:26,992
So as to like a specific
what is it, I don't know.
590
00:34:28,234 --> 00:34:31,092
I think that area is ripe
for further research.
591
00:34:31,532 --> 00:34:36,110
But what I have kind of likened it
to is if you get good honey, is it
592
00:34:36,148 --> 00:34:38,678
the bees, the flowers, the hive?
593
00:34:39,226 --> 00:34:41,351
Who knows I got good honey.
594
00:34:41,460 --> 00:34:46,362
I don't know if it was coming from
just the small groups or just the
595
00:34:46,362 --> 00:34:50,458
use of the application or just
the fact that they could DM each
596
00:34:50,458 --> 00:34:51,953
other and me if they needed to.
597
00:34:52,405 --> 00:34:57,452
And it's incredibly hard to parse that
out because how do you know, unless
598
00:34:57,453 --> 00:35:00,328
you ask each student individually,
what was the one thing that you found
599
00:35:00,330 --> 00:35:04,305
most supportive, which we did in
interviews, but even when we did that,
600
00:35:04,639 --> 00:35:05,969
students can't put their finger on it.
601
00:35:05,985 --> 00:35:08,863
There's this, "Well, you know, I like
this, but I also really like this, and
602
00:35:08,864 --> 00:35:13,485
I can do this." It was everything from
I like that it dings because then I know
603
00:35:13,578 --> 00:35:18,091
to jump in, to I can do this while I'm
in line at the grocery store with my kids
604
00:35:18,136 --> 00:35:22,895
and still get my discussion board points,
to I didn't have to go log in through the
605
00:35:22,895 --> 00:35:27,755
log in to the institution, then the log in
to the LMS, then the click on the thread.
606
00:35:28,145 --> 00:35:30,922
It cuts the time, so they like that.
607
00:35:30,942 --> 00:35:32,804
So further research is definitely needed.
608
00:35:34,971 --> 00:35:35,794
But they like it.
609
00:35:35,794 --> 00:35:36,975
But there's something … Yes.
610
00:35:37,404 --> 00:35:38,023
They like it.
611
00:35:38,038 --> 00:35:41,689
There's something to it, and
that to me was the big success
612
00:35:41,721 --> 00:35:43,330
here, was that it worked.
613
00:35:43,504 --> 00:35:45,611
It's at least a proof of concept for now.
614
00:35:46,014 --> 00:35:50,347
I think a lot could be done with it, and
I also think you could drill down into
615
00:35:50,347 --> 00:35:52,197
different things in different places.
616
00:35:52,694 --> 00:35:55,395
So one of the things I wanted to
try and figure out was how well
617
00:35:55,395 --> 00:35:59,791
are students understanding actual
concepts and material, but it's
618
00:35:59,800 --> 00:36:05,337
really hard to do that because how
do you know what they knew coming in?
619
00:36:05,776 --> 00:36:10,455
So I said to an A&P, anatomy and
physiology professor, "Maybe we could use
620
00:36:10,455 --> 00:36:15,358
an A&P class and see how well students
learn the vocabulary in control versus
621
00:36:15,518 --> 00:36:18,906
intervention group because that way
you'd be able to say are they actually
622
00:36:18,906 --> 00:36:23,460
learning specific terms and understanding
specific individual content."
623
00:36:23,845 --> 00:36:28,324
That's really tough to do in a writing
class because we don't have a ton of
624
00:36:28,325 --> 00:36:32,579
terminology and it's very conceptual,
so it's hard to be like, "Did you
625
00:36:32,580 --> 00:36:35,853
understand formatting and thesis
statements better because we were
626
00:36:35,867 --> 00:36:40,431
chatting?" It's just very, very difficult
to gauge something that specific in an
627
00:36:40,431 --> 00:36:42,654
English class, especially English 101.
628
00:36:42,964 --> 00:36:47,617
But I think there's other opportunity
in the future to do studies in different
629
00:36:47,667 --> 00:36:51,119
departments or classes where you
could drill down into some of those
630
00:36:51,124 --> 00:36:53,043
questions a little bit more in depth.
631
00:36:53,108 --> 00:36:57,536
But again, this was proof of concept
to get the dissertation done.
632
00:36:57,686 --> 00:36:59,286
But it was a really fun project
633
00:36:59,840 --> 00:37:03,567
JOHN: Rebecca and I keep hoping to
have a podcast where the concept of AI
634
00:37:03,591 --> 00:37:08,743
doesn't come up, but it already did sneak
in a little bit because Envivo does use
635
00:37:08,775
--> 00:37:13,741
AI in analyzing the transcripts, which
can save a tremendous amount of time.
636
00:37:14,143 --> 00:37:18,613
But one of the things I was thinking
about also is when I last taught an
637
00:37:18,621 --> 00:37:22,101
online class, it was about a year and a
half ago, I think now, one of the things
638
00:37:22,105 --> 00:37:25,549
that was happening is I was getting
discussion posts very much like you
639
00:37:25,549 --> 00:37:29,613
described that looked very much like
most of them were AI generated, even
640
00:37:29,613 --> 00:37:31,447
including sources and other things.
641
00:37:31,788 --> 00:37:35,625
And a lot of faculty are reporting
that discussion boards seem to be
642
00:37:35,627 --> 00:37:40,587
mostly done by AI in many classes,
and I'm wondering if perhaps the
643
00:37:40,587 --> 00:37:44,166
more informal nature of this might
reduce the incentive to do that.
644
00:37:44,502 --> 00:37:48,817
Students are not very likely to use
AI when texting each other, but when
645
00:37:48,817 --> 00:37:52,607
they're sitting at a computer responding
to something that feels higher stakes,
646
00:37:52,962 --> 00:37:56,913
it seems to be creeping into more and
more of the work that we're seeing.
647
00:37:57,313 --> 00:38:01,095
Maybe this might be one way of
getting more productive discussion
648
00:38:01,095 --> 00:38:03,391
boards by avoiding AI intervention.
649
00:38:03,908 --> 00:38:04,262
GREG: Oh, yeah.
650
00:38:04,509 --> 00:38:08,762
And I think to add to that, the kind
of response that you do in a text, it's
651
00:38:08,762 --> 00:38:13,887
almost faster just to reply than it is
to go, "ChatGPT, give me a one-sentence
652
00:38:13,900 --> 00:38:15,777
response to this," and fire it off.
653
00:38:16,115 --> 00:38:20,447
So I think that it drives engagement
that way, but this is also why I said
654
00:38:20,448 --> 00:38:24,320
I think it could even be implemented in
face-to-face classes, is that if you know
655
00:38:24,321 --> 00:38:27,892
the students are having the discussion
in class and then are following up
656
00:38:27,893 --> 00:38:33,399
with each other through small groups
and text messages this way, it's also
657
00:38:33,401 --> 00:38:39,767
incentivizing to have that natural,
regular communication and don't rely
658
00:38:39,767 --> 00:38:41,378
on technology to give you the answer.
659
00:38:41,441 --> 00:38:45,468
And so we have students in these classes,
we said, "You know, all you need to do is
660
00:38:45,471 --> 00:38:50,518
give us an idea for what your next essay's
gonna be about." So then we're throwing
661
00:38:50,520 --> 00:38:53,083
out, "Well, I'm kind of between this and
this, and I'm not really sure, but you
662
00:38:53,083 --> 00:38:55,054
can…" Like, that's not coming from AI.
663
00:38:55,609 --> 00:38:58,823
And then you see a thesis statement,
and they're all responding to each
664
00:38:58,823 --> 00:39:02,593
other's thesis statements, "Yeah, I
think you could say this or say
that."
665
00:39:02,749 --> 00:39:07,617
And I hate to be so potentially dreary,
but it means even if they are using AI
666
00:39:07,657 --> 00:39:11,087
to get that thesis statement, they're
still interacting with students and
667
00:39:11,087 --> 00:39:15,242
getting feedback and making adjustments,
so they're still thinking about it,
668
00:39:15,546 --> 00:39:19,571
which is better than I'm just going to
generate it through AI and post it to
669
00:39:19,571 --> 00:39:21,020
the discussion board and leave it there.
670
00:39:21,681 --> 00:39:24,790
So forced interaction
of some sort, I guess.
671
00:39:25,124 --> 00:39:29,401
But yeah, definitely, it is a very
strong potential to be … I was
672
00:39:29,401 --> 00:39:32,679
never quite sure how to phrase this,
and I think the best way to say
673
00:39:32,712 --> 00:39:36,598
is it helps avoid reliance on AI.
674
00:39:37,016 --> 00:39:42,198
I don't think we're gonna be able to
completely get it out of the classroom
675
00:39:42,265 --> 00:39:47,699
ever, but this is something where there's
less reliance, and they are building
676
00:39:47,701 --> 00:39:50,673
confidence as they're talking to each
other about the course material in the
677
00:39:50,676 --> 00:39:54,231
chat anyway, so they're interacting
with the material no matter what
678
00:39:54,921 --> 00:39:59,629
REBECCA: It does seem like the format
because it's informal, it's low stakes.
679
00:39:59,843 --> 00:40:03,586
It probably feels, for students, like
it doesn't have to be performative.
680
00:40:03,734 --> 00:40:06,564
We're often in settings where we
feel like we need to be performing,
681
00:40:06,564 --> 00:40:09,278
and so we're concerned about how
we're constructing a sentence.
682
00:40:09,515 --> 00:40:13,250
But the nature of texting is so
informal that there isn't, like, a
683
00:40:13,250 --> 00:40:17,033
performance attached to it, and that
might just take away a lot of the stress.
684
00:40:17,423 --> 00:40:20,977
It, it feels more intimate
and private and what have you.
685
00:40:21,473 --> 00:40:26,234
GREG: And I'm going to get myself
in trouble here, but I will also say
686
00:40:26,245 --> 00:40:30,234
there's only one thing that was maybe
a little performative on my end when
687
00:40:30,234 --> 00:40:33,658
I do this, because I've done this
in my own classes a few times in
688
00:40:33,790 --> 00:40:36,921
preparation for the study, and I'm doing
it now in a class that I'm teaching.
689
00:40:37,696 --> 00:40:40,006
There's one thing that's maybe a
little performative on my part, and
690
00:40:40,008 --> 00:40:43,720
it's because it's very difficult
to not correct my text messages.
691
00:40:44,202 --> 00:40:49,995
But when I make a typo, I don't fix
it, and I have to say, "Greg, stop it.
692
00:40:50,330 --> 00:40:51,037
Help yourself.
693
00:40:51,397 --> 00:40:52,058
It's fine.
694
00:40:52,312 --> 00:40:55,814
Just go ahead and send." But it then
encourages the students to be like, "Oh,
695
00:40:55,814
--> 00:40:57,319
well, Professor Campbell had a typo.
696
00:40:57,319 --> 00:41:00,441
It's fine if I have a typo." And I
just say to them, like, "This is not
697
00:41:00,442 --> 00:41:05,384
being graded for grammar or usage
or anything like that, nor would
698
00:41:05,384 --> 00:41:08,303
an in-class discussion be." I'm
not sitting up there saying, "You
699
00:41:08,303 --> 00:41:09,924
know, you said who instead of whom.
700
00:41:10,163 --> 00:41:14,430
Dock five points." We would never do
that in an in-class discussion, so don't
701
00:41:14,444 --> 00:41:16,683
carry that into the virtual discussion.
702
00:41:17,198 --> 00:41:20,618
So that's the only thing that can maybe
be a little performative is I pull
703
00:41:20,620 --> 00:41:22,754
myself back and say, "Keep it natural.
704
00:41:22,754 --> 00:41:24,845
If you made an error, just
leave the error in there.
705
00:41:24,845 --> 00:41:27,225
Let them see that it
really doesn't matter.
706
00:41:27,368 --> 00:41:31,457
You make mistakes, too, and none of
this is graded for that." It's another
707
00:41:31,457 --> 00:41:34,613
way of just trying to be a little
more supportive and natural with it.
708
00:41:34,651 --> 00:41:38,696
But yeah, sometimes I'm like, "Oh, I
really want to go back and change that."
709
00:41:40,612 --> 00:41:42,069
REBECCA: But the rules are no editing
710
00:41:42,298 --> 00:41:43,120
GREG: No editing, yeah.
711
00:41:43,682 --> 00:41:44,393
That is the rule.
712
00:41:45,096 --> 00:41:45,645
Yeah.
713
00:41:46,053 --> 00:41:46,959
It is perfectly fair.
714
00:41:47,087 --> 00:41:50,164
I'll hold myself to the same standard
as them, and I had no problem with that.
715
00:41:50,507 --> 00:41:54,573
JOHN: As long as they don't incorrectly
use the subjunctive mood, but- We
716
00:41:54,588 --> 00:41:57,489
always end with a question, what's next?
717
00:41:58,114 --> 00:41:58,964
GREG: Excellent question.
718
00:41:59,301 --> 00:42:05,378
So I think what's next for me is I
gathered so much … I mean, as you
719
00:42:05,379 --> 00:42:08,196
heard, like, I had mountains and
mountains of data to sift through.
720
00:42:08,495 --> 00:42:13,096
So I think I wanna continue looking at
some other potential outcomes, and then
721
00:42:13,327 --> 00:42:18,399
as I've mentioned, future attempts at
how to incorporate this into classes.
722
00:42:18,826 --> 00:42:21,762
So I can tell you a few things
that are kind of in the works.
723
00:42:21,762 --> 00:42:24,302
So I've got this going with a
class of mine right now, but it's
724
00:42:24,512 --> 00:42:26,458
English 205, World Literature One.
725
00:42:27,021 --> 00:42:32,793
So the students are already at least a
semester into college, and it's easier
726
00:42:32,793 --> 00:42:36,494
to get them into it, and they kinda
control the chat much more themselves.
727
00:42:36,534 --> 00:42:40,627
So I wanna continue doing what I'm doing
with my own work, but I really wanna
728
00:42:40,628 --> 00:42:42,948
try this with three different things.
729
00:42:43,345 --> 00:42:47,590
One is another department, even math,
and I'm saying that because I've
730
00:42:47,590 --> 00:42:51,076
laid in here on the humanities, but
this would be useful in STEM classes.
731
00:42:51,120 --> 00:42:54,496
And if a student can just reach out
to a math instructor, and I say math
732
00:42:54,499 --> 00:42:57,945
because that's the other gateway
class, obviously, at the institution.
733
00:42:57,948 --> 00:43:01,313
So I'd like to pair with someone over
there and maybe see what we can do there.
734
00:43:01,760 --> 00:43:05,673
Secondly, I think it's really
important to see how this functions
735
00:43:05,746 --> 00:43:07,493
with a face-to-face class.
736
00:43:07,902 --> 00:43:09,512
Does this support the students or not?
737
00:43:09,842 --> 00:43:15,186
And at my institution, we actually
created the national standard model for
738
00:43:15,252 --> 00:43:19,093
accelerated English, the Accelerated
Learning Program, where we have a class
739
00:43:19,102 --> 00:43:23,417
of 10 students who are developmental
education students, 10 who are
740
00:43:23,418 --> 00:43:27,282
regular college students, all together
as a class of 20 in English 101.
741
00:43:27,823 --> 00:43:31,119
And after that class ends, the 10
college-ready students leave, the
742
00:43:31,120 --> 00:43:34,210
other 10 students go and get some
individual coaching with the faculty
743
00:43:34,210 --> 00:43:37,673
member, and maybe do some further
assistance in helping the students.
744
00:43:38,046 --> 00:43:42,340
And I talked to a faculty member, she's
actually the coordinator of the program,
745
00:43:42,711 --> 00:43:44,666
and she said she wanted to give it a shot.
746
00:43:45,180 --> 00:43:48,138
So we're gonna try this, and she said,
"Well, I just think I'll give it to the
747
00:43:48,138 --> 00:43:52,093
10 developmental education students."
And I said, "I think as soon as word gets
748
00:43:52,094 --> 00:43:56,263
out that these students can text you, and
are in a group texting each other, you're
749
00:43:56,272 --> 00:44:01,221
gonna have trouble with the other 10."
So she agreed, and so we actually have
750
00:44:01,671 --> 00:44:05,395
It's a hybrid class, so the students will
meet for the first three weeks in person.
751
00:44:05,889 --> 00:44:07,991
They'll get to know each other
a little bit there, then we'll
752
00:44:07,994 --> 00:44:09,360
have four groups of five.
753
00:44:09,477 --> 00:44:12,151
So two groups of five for the dev ed
students, two groups of five for the
754
00:44:12,151 --> 00:44:17,131
regular students, and we're gonna see if
this also helps support students who are
755
00:44:17,150 --> 00:44:19,305
considered more of our at-risk population.
756
00:44:19,734 --> 00:44:24,755
So will they feel a stronger sense of
belonging and connectedness to each other,
757
00:44:24,764 --> 00:44:28,631
the faculty member, and the institution
if we implement this into that course?
758
00:44:28,655 --> 00:44:31,976
And so that class starts
in a week, I think.
759
00:44:32,601 --> 00:44:35,057
So I'll have results
on that at some point.
760
00:44:35,093 --> 00:44:37,599
But I think there's a lot of
further research that can be
761
00:44:37,600 --> 00:44:38,557
done on this kind of stuff.
762
00:44:38,599 --> 00:44:43,852
And then my other thing is just to
continue looking at how do we improve
763
00:44:43,921 --> 00:44:47,248
engagement, particularly student
engagement, in asynchronous online
764
00:44:47,251 --> 00:44:50,940
classes, because I think we're gonna
continue to see a lot of growth in those.
765
00:44:51,159 --> 00:44:55,938
I- that modality is the fastest
growing modality we have, and we wanna
766
00:44:55,939 --> 00:44:59,028
make sure that students are actually
learning in my English department.
767
00:44:59,061 --> 00:45:00,077
That's pretty important to me.
768
00:45:00,546 --> 00:45:04,398
So continuing to look at how we can
support students and student engagement
769
00:45:04,577 --> 00:45:08,944
through new and different means that are
maybe a little creative, but also not
770
00:45:08,944 --> 00:45:11,343
necessarily an earth-shattering idea.
771
00:45:11,779 --> 00:45:15,179
What are other little things like this
that we can continue to do to support
772
00:45:15,179 --> 00:45:16,862
students and support student engagement?
773
00:45:17,161 --> 00:45:17,758
JOHN: Well, thank you.
774
00:45:17,763 --> 00:45:21,116
This is a great project, and we
really appreciate you sharing
775
00:45:21,117 --> 00:45:22,398
this with us and our listeners.
776
00:45:22,712 --> 00:45:23,654
GREG: Thank you so much for having me.
777
00:45:23,655 --> 00:45:24,279
This was a pleasure.
778
00:45:24,812 --> 00:45:27,669
REBECCA: And we definitely look forward
to hearing what happens next in some of
779
00:45:27,669 --> 00:45:29,036
these other studies that you're doing.
780
00:45:29,569 --> 00:45:32,819
GREG: I will follow up with you
guys as soon as I have any feedback.
781
00:45:33,133 --> 00:45:36,505
Maybe at some point in January or
February, I'll have results from the
782
00:45:36,505 --> 00:45:37,664
study we're gonna do for the dev eds.
783
00:45:37,922 --> 00:45:38,117
Great
784
00:45:44,989 --> 00:45:47,649
JOHN: If you've enjoyed this
podcast, please subscribe and
785
00:45:47,649 --> 00:45:51,651
leave a review on Apple Podcasts
or your favorite podcast service.
786
00:45:52,237 --> 00:45:56,806
To continue the conversation, join us
on our Tea for Teaching Facebook page.
787
00:45:57,739 --> 00:46:00,352
REBECCA: You can find show
notes, transcripts, and other
788
00:46:00,352 --> 00:46:02,706
materials on teaforteaching.com.
789
00:46:03,706 --> 00:46:05,720
Music by Michael Gary Brewer.
790
00:46:06,941 --> 00:46:10,387
JOHN: Editing assistance
provided by Madison Lee.