TRASCRIZIONE 🔗
Marcy: Welcome back to Table Stakes. I'm Marcy Tweet, your host and the founder of Veerless. This is a solo episode, which means it's just me talking today, but I'm coming to you with the thoughts, feelings, and opinions of all the people who attended our very first book club discussion on October 9th for Claire Stapleton's book, Don't Be Evil, her account of years inside Google, and a discussion that we had with a room full of Corporate responsibility leaders, HR leaders, there were just awesome people in this room who read this book with me and discussed it a couple of weeks ago. we hosted this session after really coming off of this summer's success of these read responsibly conversations I had with authors, recognizing that so many of us, number one, love reading and really want to talk about it with the folks that are around us in our working lives. And we wanted to bring together a group of of cool people, and we did with lunch, Zoom, and a good book in Claire Stapleton's Don't Be Evil, and really talk about people who spend their working lives thinking about how companies behave and in this case, how companies can avoid being evil. The plan was to record the full episode and to drop. that whole conversation right here on table stakes as a podcast episode. I even told people at the top of our call of this book club call that we were going to do that and everybody was okay with it. And then about 20 minutes in, people really started telling their stories about bad bosses, about bars after work events, about what they'd been told to swallow in the name of culture, very similarly to how Claire was at Google. And I realized halfway through that conversation that I really couldn't post it as a podcast episode. Even if we only did it as audio, even if we didn't name who was on the call, we really had it's a it's a success because we built a room where people could be honest. And that felt awesome. So we're changing course a little bit here. Going forward, we're gonna continue to do these book clubs, not on a necessarily super regular cadence, maybe every couple of months or so. And we're going to run these book club conversations. On the concept of Chatham House rules. So you can use what's said in that room, but don't attach it to anyone who said it. And that's why you're getting me solo today on table stakes with my own takeaways and a few ideas from the room, but with no names attached. And so interestingly, yes, I see the irony that a an episode about corporate accountability opens with me changing my mind in public. And you know, I'll take that. Owning that call is Is a part of where we're at. And I think this will be a fun way for us to keep this book club going, keep it connected to the podcast, and still be able to share insights for those who couldn't make it to the book club conversation. So let's talk about Claire's book as a primer for those of you who may not have read it. Claire Stapleton joined Google in 2006 and she left in 2019.
Load full transcript
For a long stretch, she was really the voice of the company. People called her the bard of Google. She wrote the all hands emails, the internal newsletters, the words that told Googlers who they were as a company. And by her own account, she was a true believer in Google. She had a lot of things throughout her time there that maybe were red flags, maybe beige flags, as we've talked about in the past. And then came 2018, after reporting revealed how Google had handled sexual misconduct claims against senior executives, very much in the line of a host of Me Too movement reporting. It included a $90 million exit package for one of their executives. After all of that, Claire was one of the leaders who helped organize a very famous and well reported on Google. Walkout. Around 20,000 employees around the world left their desks on the same day. And afterwards, Claire says she faced retaliation and within a year was gone. Now, that's not an isolated incident. When you read Claire's book, what you'll see throughout is there were a lot of red flags in Google's culture and in the way that they handled female employees. And, you know, I think it's really interesting that that Claire is both. coming at this from a sense of how the walkout affected her, but also reckoning with all the things that happened in the 10 plus years before that that maybe were a part of the problem, right? One thing before we dig in as well, I found it so interesting that Claire uses real names in this book. executives, colleagues, the works. And my first question reading it was which lawyer signed off on this? It takes real guts. And it makes the book land a lot harder than some other corporate memoirs. So if you haven't read Claire's book, highly recommend you do. But what we're gonna do today is five key takeaways that our group, as we came to our book club conversation, really found in this book. let's dive in. Takeaway number one is really about accountability. And at the end of the day, it's three words accountability flows upwards. Google consistently asked its people to think like owners. That was something they said over and over and over again. Claire describes a required training from Google called Conscious Business, which directly said to employees that they needed to be players and not victims. Here's how she describes the result, and I'm quoting from Claire here: You had to accept whatever happened to you, no matter the circumstances. Radical accountability in the corporate lexicon. Meant taking responsibility not just for your actions, but for the conditions around you, absorbing blame upward and outward until there was nothing left to question. She goes on to say that questioning authority was not treated as healthy, it was treated as whining. When I read that, and a lot of us said this in the Read Responsibly book club room, we thought, wow, we've been in that company. At some point, most people have been in that company. Someone in our session described an airline
that told employees over and over and over again, we're a family. And no, you're not. You're not a family. You're coworkers with the benefits package. This idea of family language is very lovely until it gets used to explain why you shouldn't complain. And here's my translation: in sort of accountability is a good thing, but it's supposed to flow upwards. The buck stops at the top. And it's interesting that a couple of airlines came up in our discussion as maybe some places where where things were not so great. And I actually brought up when Oscar Munoz was the CEO of United in 2017, and a passenger was dragged off of the United plane, Oscar's first statement to the press kind of famously made things worse. The statement that it turned that turned it around. Was one where a couple of days later Oscar came out and took full responsibility. That first statement nobody remembers fondly. The second, people really took an idea that Oscar could step up and say, Hey, I'm sorry, this is on me, right? And I think what we learned in Claire's book about Google specifically is that this idea of radical accountability for the people with the least power and a lot less of it for people with the most, right? So it was really an interesting kind of flip. In their direction. So I think that's that's the first key takeaway. Accountability flows upward and the buck has to stop at the top level of the company. Second takeaway is really about the walkout. And and the interesting thing, we talked a lot about famous walkouts, not just the Google one, but Netflix around the Dave Chappelle episode, Wayfair when Wayfair was. Selling furniture to ICE detention centers, the kind of list goes on. And the takeaway that we all kind of felt is a walkout of your employees means you've already failed. And this is where Claire's book gets really juicy, right? Because Google spent years telling its people they were owners. They should think like owners. They should hold the company to its values, don't be evil. And then a group of employees. A lot of them women said, okay, we will hold you accountable. We will say don't be evil. And they walked out. Claire described the walkout, and I found this so interesting. The language she used is she said that a number of their executives or or people around them were saying that this was an anti-Google moment. And Claire said the leaders of the walkout movement saw this as a pro-Google movement. They saw their actions as deeply loyal. And then she was surprised when the rally retaliation came afterwards. Promotion stalled, roles changed, relationships sour. And I'll be honest with you, and Claire, if you're listening, I say this with love. And it was the discussion on our book club. All of us went, Yeah, you know what, Claire, we could have seen that coming a mile away. If you stage a public walkout, Leaders are going to have feelings about it. Our read from the subtext of Google Leadership was kind of, we want you to be an advocate, just not so loudly, right? Which is part of the problem at play. I'll put on too my kind of self-described corporate drone hat in the ESG world. We bang the drum hard on whistleblower hotlines. And we talked about this in our in our discussion. Regulators require this, rankers require this, right? A really good whistleblower hotline, a really strong speakup process will set out the path to raise an issue with anonymity in some cases, with non-retaliation practices in all cases. And a walkout steps outside the protection of something like a whistleblower hotline. So one of the questions I would have for anyone at Google. At that time, or at Wayfair, or at Netflix, whatever that is, is what did they try first before the walkout? Did they ask for a meeting? Did they bring demands to the room before they brought their signs out to the sidewalk? Right? It's an interesting question. And I'm sure there were people who did. I just would have loved to hear more about that. The other side of this, which makes the book really clear. Is when people go straight to the signs on the sidewalk, it usually tells you they've stopped trusting the room they're in. That's on the company. That is absolutely not on Claire or any of those employees, which I think is really, really interesting. the other thing that got brought up in our book club, and again, I say this with love, Claire, if you're listening, a little bit of a spicy take. A lot of the people in this story, I hesitate to say all, but a lot, were very well paid. Google pays for loyalty and at times it does pay for silence. And that doesn't make the walkout wrong. It doesn't 100% support their rights and their choices. But it does mean that the folks who were doing this walkout were taking a risk with a pretty big cushion underneath them, right? And a lot of workers do not have. Right. A walkout at Google is very different than a walkout of frontline workers in minimum wage jobs or in union situations. Right. So I just think that's an interesting thing that I would have loved to hear more on. and I think it's it's an interesting thing that we could dive deeper on. I'm thinking about it in my own writing as well, of like, how do we look at these this sense of this trend of walkouts that has happened in some corporate in the last 10 years and Does it work? Does it not? it'd be interesting even to go back to the 70s and some of those Norma Ray walkouts that happened. so, you know, an interesting thing to riff on as well. Okay, let's move on to takeaway number three, which is the problem of quote, nothing major. Now, let me dive into this, and I want to be really intentional here because I and the group that we had this discussion with a couple of weeks ago consistently used a term that Claire didn't use in the book. And I think she did this intentionally, not using the term sexual harassment. But Claire describes throughout the book. A pervasive culture of bad behavior in men, whether as bosses or as leaders. And she
specifically describes a night at a bar after a Google event with a senior executive named Nikesh. She writes, and I quote, Nikesh grabbed me around the waist with one hand. I could feel all five fingers clasping me, not so much pressure. And yet it was like I was locked and frozen in place. Someone walks up in that instance and Claire takes the opportunity to leave. And I believe Nikesh says something to her, like, you'll you'll have drink with me another time. Right. And later she tells another colleague, he was, and again, I quote, A little inappropriate with me in New York, nothing major. And she later says it quote barely raised an alarm bell. And this just for everybody who was on our conversation a couple of weeks ago about this book resonated so strongly. And the two words, nothing major. Almost every woman on that call, and every woman I know who has worked in any business setting has some kind of story where they would say something like, He was a little inappropriate with me, nothing major. I have them, other people have them. One of the companies I work for had a really pervasive drinking culture. And early on, another female executive taught me a trick is get to the bar before everyone else, hand the bartender a 20 and say, hey, whatever I order tonight, give me a seltzer with lime. Because when you know the men around you are going drink for drink, you don't want to be the one in the bad situation at the end of the night. And the fact that we need tricks like that is the problem. Right. And here's what I think all of us wrestled with. Right. The a number of us had sat on that side of the table, and a number of us also had sat on the HR side of the table. And it frustrates both the women and the HR leaders, whether women or not, of why didn't she report this? Right. Why wasn't Any of this reported? Why wasn't the bad behavior of these men reported? But then again, we go back to Google's radical accountability expectation. If a company teaches you that everything that happens to you is your responsibility, then a hand on your waist at a bar becomes your problem, your problem to manage. And someone put it perfectly in our session in the chat. They said this kind of culture normalizes misconduct and makes the recipient part of the problem. And that is so, so, I just want to say effing true, right? So true. Claire also quotes the idea that misconduct is just a part of any company culture this large. And she said that had come from a a very high up HR leader. Like in a company this big, of course there's going to be misc misconduct. And we talked a lot about that on our call. We hear it and we think, God, you are giving up if you are just saying, yeah, there's always going to be misconduct. There's always going to be sexual harassment. And and that's incredibly frustrating. We talked a lot and and it came up about the Cornell case that has been all over headlines this fall. And a man actually asked me at a networking event recently whether I thought this wave of reckoning with Cornell will be any different than me too. And my answer, although might have been another kind of give up statement, which is that I'm not sure it's different. It's just another generation getting to reckon with the same thing. but I do think, I do think that. as we go forward, you know, let's say 10 plus years after this experience Claire had with this executive at a bar. I think we are less willing to call these things nothing major. And I think that counts for something. And I think we should continue to push that, right? These moments of it's no big deal, it's locker room talk, it's boys will be boys, it's nothing major. I think we're willing to call them out more than we used to be. So that's takeaway number three. Takeaway number four is support doesn't end with flowers. And this is specifically in ref ref reference to when something terrible happens in an employee's life. Claire very openly talked about the death of her brother and the generosity Google experienced during that time or how she experienced their generosity, time off, condolence notes, flowers sent to her parents' house. I actually have a friend whose husband lost his father while he was at Google. And very similarly, they flew him home overnight from a business trip, covered everything. That's real and it really matters. But we had an interesting discussion about supporting workers through difficult times in their lives. Claire talks about specifically in relationship to her brother's death. She said, after the nicely witten written condolence notes from coworkers, And the big bouquet of flowers they sent to my parents' house, it was pretty much never mentioned again. She also says a very similar thing about coming back from maternity leave. You're supported on the way out, but business as usual, the second you're back. This, I think, is again a translation of this all in kind of culture, right? We've got your back, take the leave, but when you return, you're back right into that workaholic culture. Nobody gets rewarded for taking a break. Right. And I think that's that's really important. I think this is another place where again culture starts with tone at the top. And I I once heard a Female CEO and her head of HR talk about her own experience with the CEO going on maternity leave, where her head of HR said, You're taking maternity leave. You are not taking your laptop. You're not bringing the baby to the office. This was right around the time that Yahoo's CEO Marissa Mayer famously only took a couple weeks off and built a nursery next to her office, right? And this HR leaders point to this CEO, who actually I I I hesitate to attribute this because I can't. I I don't know if the story was ever was ever printed, but it was actually a former Googler CEO said, if you don't take real leave for maternity, no one else will feel like they can. And I think that's the missing piece at Google, the gestures. were great, but the norms
after the gestures were the problem. And so that's something that I think we all thought about in the context of our current jobs, right? When someone goes on parental leave, when someone has the death of a family member, or even the death of a pet or friend, or they go through something difficult or someone in their family has an illness, whatever that might be, it's very easy to say, do what you need to do. take the time you need. It's very hard weeks later to come back and say, hey, how you doing? And did that work? Do you need anything else? Right. And I think it's again, what things culturally, and maybe this goes in general in our fringe benefits packages, right? What things culturally in our companies are gestures and what are norms? And norms will beat gestures every day of the week. And I think that's really, really interesting. Finally, takeaway number five. Values only count if someone can hold you to them. Values only count if someone can hold you to them. And there were really a couple of moments in the book. That make this point from two really opposite ends, right? So the first one, anyone who's ever written for an executive will understand this. Claire writes an email for then CEO of Google, Larry Page, and it comes back with no edits, right? Can you all of us have probably been there? If you are in sustainability at any level, you've written stuff for leaders. And when they don't edit something, there is a moment of excitement. And Claire says, Quote, I've nailed it. Larry hadn't edited it at all. The email was so empty, so artless, a regurgitation of meaninglessness, but it was a quick momentary satisfaction. And this literally made me laugh out loud, Claire. Fantastic. The standard process for writing for an executive, right, is to read their CEO speeches, study how they talk, understand how they prefer to write. It's a great way to get a letter signed and a terrible way to get a leader to push anything new forward. And Today, AI can do this even faster, right? We can build synthetic versions of a CEO that can regurgitate exactly what they would say to any given audience. And that makes our job incredibly hard. And this is where I personally want to challenge anyone who writes for executives. If your sustainability report is coming back to you with no edits, you should not be celebrating. It might mean you nailed it. It might also mean you didn't ask for anything substantive. Now, the other end of this, right? So I said there were two things on values only count if you can hold if someone can hold you to them. The other end of this was going back to 2004, when the Google CEOs first coined the frame, the phrase, don't be evil. And Claire notes that when that happened, Google sent hard copies of that letter, that manifesto, if you will, to people's homes, including their investors. And that detail really stopped me because number one, in 2026, paper is not happening, right? Companies are not mailing anything to you. That's how much they wanted, especially for an internet company. Think about this. In 2004, an internet company wanted their employees to hold that. message in their hands, right? I have a my husband used to work for Walgreens, right? That used to hand every employee a magnet with its values on it and recite them at every meeting. That is something you can hold in your hands, right? The problem is the day that that stops happening, right? The day that like there's no more magnet or the day when there's no more don't be evil manifesto, right? So when you put your values on paper and you mail them to someone and they read them at their kitchen table, that is telling them you can hold us to this. Google did that. And in 2018 with this walkout, their employees held them to it. So, you know, the takeaway is this an empty letter, nobody edits, can't be held to anything. It can't. A letter mailed to your kitchen table can. And if you are the one writing values for a living, you need to write something that someone could hold on to. I mean, I get it. We can't always mail something to someone's house. And in today's world, that might not be the answer. But how do we find those places that state values in a way that someone can hold on to them? So really interesting. Let's wrap up here because I think this has just been a great recap of of a conversation that we had. At the end of the book, Claire says she's become something of an agony aunt for tech workers. People write to her about burnout and ethical stress and about working in a cushy job that they suspect may not matter and might be making things worse. And her response is this line that I will I will leave you with before we do a little end matter here. There is no finish line. There's only a constant process of trying to figure it out, of tuning in to your own voice and sense of what matters. It is healthy and important to be able to separate what you think from the manager and the company line and to build the courage and capacity to speak up and push back when your moral sensors are blaring. So, congratulations to Claire Stapleton for speaking up and pushing back when her moral sensors were blaring and for taking that step in this book. So, to recap, five key takeaways: accountability flows upward. A walkout means the room has already failed. Nothing major is a major problem. Support doesn't end with flowers and condolences, and values only count if someone can hold you to them. I think at the end of the day, Google told everyone, don't be evil. And when their people saw something that looked like evil, they pushed back. Maybe it worked, maybe it didn't. And in a strange way, that's the company slogan doing its job. It really makes me sad that they've walked back that kind of slogan. And I'll add an honest caveat as we as we wrap up here. We're lucky this is a story about Google, right? Where most people, again, walked away with a lot of money. If we were talking about frontline workers earning a fraction of that, this would be a very different conversation and a much higher stakes one. So I I commend Claire Stapleton for being the person who is willing to talk about this. And I say for everybody, keep not being evil. It's a process, not a finish line. Find your moral compass, keep pushing on those things. And also use those things like whistleblower hotlines and non-retaliatory ways to come at this in your own companies if you need to. If you want in on this discussion going forward, we are going to do another Read Responsibly book club that will be totally Chatham House rules. And I will do another one of these podcasts where I recap that book club. We are picking our next book now. It will be on my LinkedIn page to vote on that book, and then we will schedule the conversation from there. So come for the book. But I told people leading up to this, even if you didn't read Claire's book, this was an awesome discussion. So You know, come for the book, stay for the honest discussion, bring your your ideas and know that what's said in that room will stay in that room unattributed. So thanks for listening. I'm Marcy. Read responsively.