TRASCRIZIONE 🔗
WEBVTT
1
00:00:00.320 --> 00:00:02.419
You have a VR headset that lets you play the
2
00:00:02.439 --> 00:00:07.360
game of life where the winning strategy is offspring, how
3
00:00:07.400 --> 00:00:10.300
many offspring you have. We got the cheap headset. We
4
00:00:10.359 --> 00:00:15.269
might understand alien intelligences as having different headsets that are
5
00:00:15.710 --> 00:00:18.269
different from ours in ways that we can actually write
6
00:00:18.309 --> 00:00:22.910
down mathematics. This may not be the only reality. My
7
00:00:22.969 --> 00:00:25.829
own view, though, about the spiritual, it comes down to
8
00:00:25.870 --> 00:00:28.870
a very fundamental thing about science itself, and that is reality.
9
00:00:29.109 --> 00:00:31.410
Every scientific theory starts with assumptions.
10
00:00:31.710 --> 00:00:33.369
All right, Don, why are we in a crappy dimension?
11
00:00:33.390 --> 00:00:45.579
It's all your fault. This is StarTalk Special Edition. Today...
12
00:00:45.780 --> 00:00:49.350
We're going to be exploring the nature of reality.
13
00:00:50.090 --> 00:00:50.210
Oh.
14
00:00:50.270 --> 00:00:56.229
Really? Really reality. We got Gary O'Reilly. Gary, right to
15
00:00:56.270 --> 00:00:59.310
my right. Former soccer pro. I know. Announcer. Yep. And
16
00:00:59.350 --> 00:01:04.709
my co-host. And we got actor comedian. Chuck Nice. Yes.
17
00:01:04.730 --> 00:01:06.560
How you doing, man? Oh, the Lord of Nice. The
18
00:01:06.719 --> 00:01:09.159
Lord of Nice. Wow. Well, okay.
19
00:01:09.200 --> 00:01:09.480
Yeah.
20
00:01:09.680 --> 00:01:12.299
I like that. Deal with it. So set the picture here.
21
00:01:12.319 --> 00:01:13.659
What do you put together?
22
00:01:13.959 --> 00:01:17.379
In theoretical physics, they often ask questions about the nature
23
00:01:17.480 --> 00:01:21.530
of reality. But what about looking at reality from the
24
00:01:21.590 --> 00:01:26.150
neuroscience lens? Today, we're going to talk about the limits
25
00:01:26.250 --> 00:01:29.469
to our perception, the role of consciousness, and the nature
26
00:01:29.569 --> 00:01:33.290
of reality itself. Yes, Neil, time to bring in our guest.
27
00:01:33.349 --> 00:01:35.310
This one's going to go deep, so I'm looking forward
28
00:01:35.329 --> 00:01:35.750
to it.
29
00:01:35.750 --> 00:01:37.930
All right, let's see where it takes us. We've got
30
00:01:38.129 --> 00:01:40.799
Professor Donald Hoffman. Donald, welcome to StarTalk.
31
00:01:41.250 --> 00:01:42.959
Thank you very much, Neil. Good to be with all
32
00:01:43.000 --> 00:01:43.219
of you.
33
00:01:43.620 --> 00:01:47.140
Yeah, you're Professor Emeritus. You're not that old. In the
34
00:01:47.219 --> 00:01:52.819
Department of Cognitive Sciences, UC Irvine, right there in Irvine, California.
35
00:01:53.340 --> 00:01:57.730
You're obviously a cognitive neuroscience scientist and an author, right?
36
00:01:58.180 --> 00:02:00.659
I have most recently here, and if you have another book,
37
00:02:00.700 --> 00:02:04.900
let me know, The Case Against Reality. Nice. Oh, shots fired.
38
00:02:04.920 --> 00:02:08.650
Let me tell you, I'm an expert in that. Shots fired.
39
00:02:09.349 --> 00:02:15.289
How evolution hid the truth from our eyes. Love it. Ooh.
40
00:02:15.789 --> 00:02:19.090
I love it. All right. So what are you saying?
41
00:02:19.210 --> 00:02:22.050
We don't really see the full picture? I mean, I
42
00:02:22.110 --> 00:02:25.610
agree with you. Who would disagree with that? But you're
43
00:02:25.629 --> 00:02:30.090
bringing in evolution here. blame for this. So can you
44
00:02:30.129 --> 00:02:31.530
catch us up on what you mean by that?
45
00:02:31.979 --> 00:02:36.719
That's right. So the standard view is that evolution shapes
46
00:02:36.800 --> 00:02:40.419
organisms to be fit. And surely to be fit, we
47
00:02:40.439 --> 00:02:44.199
should see the world pretty accurately, right? You want to
48
00:02:44.280 --> 00:02:46.780
see a cliff. If there's a cliff and not fall off,
49
00:02:46.819 --> 00:02:48.800
you want to see what is a mate and so forth.
50
00:02:48.879 --> 00:02:51.419
So just to be clear, when you say fit, you
51
00:02:51.439 --> 00:02:55.789
don't mean it like in a fitness center. Right. It's
52
00:02:55.810 --> 00:02:57.949
not a crunch gym thing. It's not a crunch.
53
00:02:58.169 --> 00:02:58.349
Right.
54
00:02:59.090 --> 00:03:02.849
Please remind us what evolutionarily what the word fit means.
55
00:03:03.310 --> 00:03:06.780
That's right. So in Darwin's theory, fitness really means the
56
00:03:06.810 --> 00:03:10.340
chance that you're going to have offspring successfully. So fitness
57
00:03:10.419 --> 00:03:14.099
is really one thing. What's the probability that you will
58
00:03:14.139 --> 00:03:18.180
survive long enough to raise your offspring successfully? That's what
59
00:03:18.199 --> 00:03:18.719
it is. Wow.
60
00:03:18.759 --> 00:03:19.300
Okay.
61
00:03:19.340 --> 00:03:24.110
Clearly Darwin had no children. Cause he went, no, they
62
00:03:24.150 --> 00:03:27.080
will kill you. And I don't mean like murder. I mean,
63
00:03:27.139 --> 00:03:28.800
just having them will kill you.
64
00:03:30.580 --> 00:03:30.800
Okay.
65
00:03:30.879 --> 00:03:34.080
So, so we were trained to not run off the
66
00:03:34.120 --> 00:03:38.069
cliff to run the opposite direction of lions. Right. What else,
67
00:03:38.349 --> 00:03:39.509
what else are we really good at?
68
00:03:40.229 --> 00:03:43.969
Well, avoiding poisons and things like that and finding right mates.
69
00:03:44.229 --> 00:03:46.310
So we're not, we don't try to mate with trees
70
00:03:46.409 --> 00:03:47.610
or rocks or things like that.
71
00:03:47.669 --> 00:03:53.509
So we speak for yourself there, Don. I'm sorry, guys.
72
00:03:54.240 --> 00:03:55.879
I'm sorry. I had to do that.
73
00:03:56.340 --> 00:03:59.400
And so many people have conjured up an image of
74
00:03:59.460 --> 00:04:01.699
a drunken Saturday night.
Load full transcript
75
00:04:01.800 --> 00:04:03.319
I'm sorry. Go ahead, Don. Continue.
76
00:04:04.159 --> 00:04:07.669
Right. So the standard view, not only among people who are,
77
00:04:07.689 --> 00:04:11.729
you know, sort of just partially acquainted with evolutionary theory,
78
00:04:11.770 --> 00:04:14.210
but for people who are deeply acquainted with the theory,
79
00:04:14.669 --> 00:04:19.180
is to assume that Darwin's theory entails that most of
80
00:04:19.220 --> 00:04:22.189
the time, we see reality as it is. Of course,
81
00:04:22.310 --> 00:04:25.170
not all of the time. There are illusions and so forth.
82
00:04:25.509 --> 00:04:28.329
But the idea would be, if you're going to be
83
00:04:28.490 --> 00:04:33.610
fit in Darwin's sense of being reproductively successful, then you
84
00:04:33.649 --> 00:04:36.740
need to see reality as it is. And what I
85
00:04:36.759 --> 00:04:41.300
have done with some colleagues, Chetan Prakash, Manish Singh, and others,
86
00:04:41.759 --> 00:04:44.319
is to look at the mathematics of evolution. It turns
87
00:04:44.379 --> 00:04:48.899
out Darwin wasn't a mathematician, but a century after he
88
00:04:49.000 --> 00:04:52.600
published his theory, mathematicians turned it into mathematics, and it's
89
00:04:52.620 --> 00:04:56.000
called evolutionary game theory. John Maynard Smith and others worked
90
00:04:56.060 --> 00:04:59.910
on this. So we can now ask specific mathematical questions
91
00:04:59.970 --> 00:05:03.730
of Darwin's theory. And the answer when we look at
92
00:05:03.769 --> 00:05:08.810
the mathematics is that the probability is zero, that any
93
00:05:08.889 --> 00:05:12.069
organism has ever been shaped at any time to see
94
00:05:12.189 --> 00:05:15.069
any aspect of objective reality as it is. It's just
95
00:05:15.329 --> 00:05:18.480
precisely zero. I didn't expect that when I went into it.
96
00:05:18.569 --> 00:05:22.910
I expected to have the answer be that we saw
97
00:05:22.949 --> 00:05:25.689
reality some of the time, but maybe not as often
98
00:05:25.730 --> 00:05:29.870
as we thought we would. Steven Pinker has published a
99
00:05:29.910 --> 00:05:32.870
paper on that idea. He has some good arguments for
100
00:05:32.910 --> 00:05:36.939
why there are pressures from evolution not to see reality
101
00:05:37.000 --> 00:05:40.420
as it is. So Pinker's already been there and I
102
00:05:40.439 --> 00:05:42.899
know he's talked with you before. And so what I
103
00:05:42.939 --> 00:05:45.139
was surprised though, that when we looked at the mathematics,
104
00:05:45.779 --> 00:05:48.339
the answer was the probability is zero.
105
00:05:48.750 --> 00:05:51.529
Yeah, so now we have to back up a bit.
106
00:05:51.709 --> 00:05:51.949
Yeah.
107
00:05:52.310 --> 00:05:54.870
What do you mean by reality? If you're going to
108
00:05:54.910 --> 00:05:57.089
assign a zero to it, I want to know what
109
00:05:57.129 --> 00:05:58.589
it is you just zeroed out. Wow.
110
00:05:58.629 --> 00:06:01.550
So, yeah, because, I mean, mathematically, reality would have to
111
00:06:01.569 --> 00:06:03.839
have a value if it equals zero.
112
00:06:03.899 --> 00:06:05.839
If at some point you're going to give it a zero. Right.
113
00:06:05.860 --> 00:06:07.579
And it seems to me the teeth on that line
114
00:06:07.699 --> 00:06:13.839
is pretty reality looking. Right. The cliff ledge feels pretty
115
00:06:13.899 --> 00:06:15.250
real to me. It does.
116
00:06:16.300 --> 00:06:18.759
The interesting thing about the mathematics is you don't have
117
00:06:18.810 --> 00:06:21.889
to specify what reality is for the mathematics to still
118
00:06:21.930 --> 00:06:25.069
give you the theorem. So I don't have to assume
119
00:06:25.110 --> 00:06:27.769
what reality is. I can just look at the structure
120
00:06:27.790 --> 00:06:30.709
of evolutionary theory and say, suppose there is some reality
121
00:06:30.769 --> 00:06:34.129
out there and there are these so-called fitness payoff functions.
122
00:06:34.230 --> 00:06:37.350
So Darwin talks about payoffs and the payoffs really are
123
00:06:37.649 --> 00:06:42.329
effectively if I have an organism like a lion in
124
00:06:42.350 --> 00:06:46.120
a particular state, like it's hungry, And it has some
125
00:06:46.220 --> 00:06:48.370
actions to take. And one of them might be eating
126
00:06:48.810 --> 00:06:52.509
a leopard or eating an antelope or eating you or
127
00:06:52.569 --> 00:06:55.209
eating you. Then that for that lion, that's a that's
128
00:06:55.250 --> 00:06:58.040
a very, you know, that's a very good payoff. Right.
129
00:06:58.079 --> 00:07:02.060
That's but if it's if it's looking to be, you know,
130
00:07:02.180 --> 00:07:04.079
to eat and it tries for a rock. it's going
131
00:07:04.100 --> 00:07:06.420
to have a very poor payoff. And so you can
132
00:07:06.439 --> 00:07:10.519
have these abstract payoff functions. And so we don't have
133
00:07:10.560 --> 00:07:12.899
to know what reality is. We can just look at
134
00:07:13.310 --> 00:07:16.310
the property of these payoff functions. And we can ask,
135
00:07:16.850 --> 00:07:20.850
whatever reality is, what's the probability that a payoff function
136
00:07:21.470 --> 00:07:23.189
would tell you about that reality?
137
00:07:23.670 --> 00:07:27.769
Okay. I still don't know what you're talking about. So
138
00:07:27.889 --> 00:07:33.660
I don't mind representing... These forces that operate on your fitness,
139
00:07:33.860 --> 00:07:37.399
on your survival. I have no problems abstracting those to
140
00:07:37.459 --> 00:07:43.750
mathematical elements. But I need you to tell me that
141
00:07:43.850 --> 00:07:48.480
the lion that is chasing me isn't real. And you're
142
00:07:48.500 --> 00:07:49.240
not saying that.
143
00:07:49.899 --> 00:07:50.720
Oh, I'm going to get there.
144
00:07:51.420 --> 00:07:56.000
Oh, damn. That's just the lion. That's the lion. Get
145
00:07:56.019 --> 00:07:57.220
to me before the lion
does.
146
00:07:57.240 --> 00:08:00.410
Well, then let me just dovetail that real quick. Is
147
00:08:00.449 --> 00:08:04.250
it possible then that the probabilities don't mean anything if
148
00:08:04.470 --> 00:08:07.350
the fact that they come out to zero, but yet
149
00:08:07.389 --> 00:08:10.410
the lion can still eat you? And I mean, that's
150
00:08:10.470 --> 00:08:13.800
pretty real to you. I mean, is it very possible
151
00:08:13.839 --> 00:08:17.720
that although the probability is you know, equates to zero,
152
00:08:18.060 --> 00:08:21.079
that maybe that's a particular probability that has no value
153
00:08:21.120 --> 00:08:21.540
to us.
154
00:08:22.430 --> 00:08:24.949
It's in the nature of scientific theories, just to see
155
00:08:25.009 --> 00:08:28.110
what they say. All I'm doing is saying, this is
156
00:08:28.129 --> 00:08:31.800
what Darwin's theory says when we mathematize it. And Darwin's
157
00:08:31.819 --> 00:08:35.179
theory says there are these things called payoffs, right? If
158
00:08:35.950 --> 00:08:39.529
you pick an organism, like the lion, its state, hungry
159
00:08:39.789 --> 00:08:43.029
or wanting to mate, and an action, like feeding, fighting, fleeing,
160
00:08:43.070 --> 00:08:45.490
or mating, and then I'll give you a number for
161
00:08:46.169 --> 00:08:48.870
how good that was, that's what the payoff functions are.
162
00:08:49.490 --> 00:08:51.570
And whether or not you like Darwin's theory, I'm just
163
00:08:51.590 --> 00:08:53.759
saying this is what the mathematics of Darwin's theory says.
164
00:08:54.299 --> 00:08:57.100
And when you look at that mathematics, then it says
165
00:08:58.039 --> 00:09:03.779
the payoff functions do not have information about reality. Almost,
166
00:09:04.200 --> 00:09:06.340
almost surely. When I say almost surely, that means a
167
00:09:07.080 --> 00:09:08.320
hundred percent of the time, basically.
168
00:09:08.340 --> 00:09:10.440
So maybe I'm going to reword what I think you're
169
00:09:10.519 --> 00:09:13.299
actually saying. And you tell me if I'm completely off
170
00:09:13.340 --> 00:09:17.570
the point, what you're saying is it doesn't matter whether
171
00:09:17.610 --> 00:09:21.629
it's real in any objective sense. All that matters is
172
00:09:21.669 --> 00:09:25.029
whether the organism responds in a way that is in
173
00:09:25.070 --> 00:09:26.809
the interest of its own survival.
174
00:09:28.070 --> 00:09:29.009
That's exactly right, Neil.
175
00:09:29.169 --> 00:09:29.580
Okay.
176
00:09:29.879 --> 00:09:34.500
Okay, so that's... I mean, I think that's pretty, you know,
177
00:09:35.139 --> 00:09:37.419
reasonable and feasible to accept.
178
00:09:38.080 --> 00:09:38.279
Right.
179
00:09:38.700 --> 00:09:41.779
So it doesn't matter to me that it's real is
180
00:09:41.820 --> 00:09:43.980
a different statement from saying it isn't real.
181
00:09:45.159 --> 00:09:47.899
Well, so what I would say is that what Darwin's
182
00:09:47.919 --> 00:09:50.789
theory tells us is that we were shaped not to
183
00:09:50.830 --> 00:09:53.789
have a window on the world. but to have a
184
00:09:53.789 --> 00:09:56.460
VR headset that lets us play the game of life.
185
00:09:56.840 --> 00:10:00.669
That's the simple bottom line. So most of us think
186
00:10:01.049 --> 00:10:05.120
we were shaped with senses that give us a mostly
187
00:10:05.169 --> 00:10:10.039
true depiction, a true window on reality. And what Darwin
188
00:10:10.080 --> 00:10:13.559
says is basically, no, you have a VR headset that
189
00:10:13.600 --> 00:10:16.559
lets you play the game of life where the winning
190
00:10:17.120 --> 00:10:21.340
strategy is offspring. how many offspring you have. And so
191
00:10:21.379 --> 00:10:23.779
that's that. So the idea then is in some sense,
192
00:10:23.840 --> 00:10:27.659
this is what we're perceiving is more a VR thing
193
00:10:27.840 --> 00:10:30.139
than a true picture of reality.
194
00:10:30.419 --> 00:10:33.409
I can believe that because I don't know exactly when
195
00:10:33.450 --> 00:10:35.409
it was, but we did an episode.
196
00:10:35.899 --> 00:10:37.100
We were talking about measurements.
197
00:10:37.799 --> 00:10:42.210
And basically, we got into this area of, in science,
198
00:10:42.289 --> 00:10:47.309
without these tools, our measurements would suck because we would
199
00:10:47.350 --> 00:10:50.809
have to rely on our senses. And our senses are
200
00:10:50.990 --> 00:10:55.120
never sufficient to measure things properly.
201
00:10:55.139 --> 00:10:57.059
All right, so pick up from there, Don. There are
202
00:10:57.080 --> 00:11:00.750
species here on planet Earth that the reality is, A,
203
00:11:01.100 --> 00:11:04.649
maybe a mantis shrimp. That can see so many different colors.
204
00:11:05.029 --> 00:11:09.169
A bat that exists with sonar. Birds that can register
205
00:11:09.210 --> 00:11:14.679
light on a UV spectrum. Their reality is different to ours, surely.
206
00:11:15.159 --> 00:11:19.019
But these are all sensory capabilities. We're just not able
207
00:11:19.100 --> 00:11:21.750
to process the data. Is that what we're trying to
208
00:11:21.779 --> 00:11:22.120
say here?
209
00:11:23.389 --> 00:11:26.029
Partly, there's so much data that we can't process, but
210
00:11:26.090 --> 00:11:29.110
it's even deeper than that. We don't see reality because
211
00:11:29.149 --> 00:11:31.049
what we've got are tricks and hacks. And I'll give
212
00:11:31.070 --> 00:11:32.549
you a concrete funny example.
213
00:11:32.570 --> 00:11:33.289
All right.
214
00:11:33.470 --> 00:11:37.129
There's a jewel beetle in the outback of Australia. So
215
00:11:37.149 --> 00:11:41.330
these beetles are dimpled, glossy, and brown. The males fly.
216
00:11:41.350 --> 00:11:45.730
The females are flightless. And males fly around looking for
217
00:11:45.850 --> 00:11:48.570
eligible females. And if a male finds one, he alights
218
00:11:48.649 --> 00:11:52.139
and mates.
And they've done that for who knows how long,
219
00:11:52.200 --> 00:11:54.259
tens of thousands of years. It's been a very successful
220
00:11:54.559 --> 00:11:56.980
life for the jewel beetles. But it turns out that
221
00:11:57.080 --> 00:12:00.750
there are some beer bottles that guys like to drink
222
00:12:00.850 --> 00:12:04.429
from in Australia. They're dimpled, glossy, and just the right
223
00:12:04.529 --> 00:12:08.409
shade of brown to tickle the fancy of these male
224
00:12:08.450 --> 00:12:10.750
jewel beetles. So these guys will throw them out into
225
00:12:10.769 --> 00:12:14.940
the desert, and jewel beetles flock all over these bottles.
226
00:12:15.419 --> 00:12:17.620
They get on them. They crawl all over them trying
227
00:12:17.679 --> 00:12:21.639
to mate. And the females aren't getting anything. It's just
228
00:12:21.879 --> 00:12:22.500
all bottle.
229
00:12:22.720 --> 00:12:25.299
Because the guys are idiots. What else is new?
230
00:12:25.379 --> 00:12:28.210
I'm going to say that that's more an admonition against beer.
231
00:12:30.450 --> 00:12:32.169
Those are the truest beer goggles ever.
232
00:12:34.269 --> 00:12:39.509
Okay, so that evolutionary element got hijacked by the beer bottle.
233
00:12:40.710 --> 00:12:44.549
That's right. So the beetles, the males have full body
234
00:12:44.629 --> 00:12:48.230
contact with the bottle. They're crawling all over it. And
235
00:12:48.289 --> 00:12:51.110
yet they cannot tell that this is not a female.
236
00:12:52.049 --> 00:12:55.450
So it's truly stunning. What did they learn? You would
237
00:12:55.490 --> 00:12:58.309
think that the males actually had been shaped by evolution
238
00:12:58.350 --> 00:13:01.309
to know what a female is. No, all they had
239
00:13:01.350 --> 00:13:05.039
was a simple hack. A female is anything dimpled, glossy,
240
00:13:05.080 --> 00:13:07.460
and brown. The bigger, the better. And that was what
241
00:13:07.500 --> 00:13:08.179
they were looking for.
242
00:13:08.559 --> 00:13:10.629
And they didn't need to know more than that. They
243
00:13:10.649 --> 00:13:12.250
didn't need to know basics. No, they had to know. Right.
244
00:13:12.529 --> 00:13:15.210
I'm going to go with Neil's assertion that they're idiots.
245
00:13:15.230 --> 00:13:16.889
Because I'm going to.
246
00:13:16.870 --> 00:13:17.330
Tell you something.
247
00:13:17.350 --> 00:13:21.289
We have in our species something called real dolls. And
248
00:13:21.350 --> 00:13:24.389
although they call them real, we know they're not real.
249
00:13:25.480 --> 00:13:26.340
Do you really, though?
250
00:13:26.360 --> 00:13:26.500
Okay.
251
00:13:26.519 --> 00:13:27.659
Nope. That's lame.
252
00:13:32.529 --> 00:13:33.429
Mm-hmm.
253
00:13:33.929 --> 00:13:39.149
Ready? Do you harbor questions about the universe? Some long-held
254
00:13:39.789 --> 00:13:45.019
bit of cosmic curiosity lingering within you? Or questions about
255
00:13:45.100 --> 00:13:50.899
anything at all? You can become a Patreon supporter of StarTalk.
256
00:13:51.720 --> 00:13:54.679
You have access to our exclusive question line on our website.
257
00:13:55.500 --> 00:13:58.649
Those are where we draw our questions for our cosmic survey.
258
00:13:58.970 --> 00:14:02.860
Some of the most extreme objects in the universe. StarTalk
259
00:14:02.919 --> 00:14:07.299
is a work in progress where we, every month, come
260
00:14:07.340 --> 00:14:10.139
up with some new way, some new idea, some new
261
00:14:10.240 --> 00:14:13.679
understanding of how to bring the universe down to Earth.
262
00:14:14.399 --> 00:14:17.789
We could not do that without your support. Thank you.
263
00:14:18.429 --> 00:14:20.269
And as always, keep looking up.
264
00:14:21.870 --> 00:14:25.629
If we're only able to process a minuscule part of reality,
265
00:14:26.149 --> 00:14:30.789
what happens to our minds when we introduce psychedelics? And
266
00:14:30.809 --> 00:14:32.509
maybe you could show us. Pick up on that.
267
00:14:32.789 --> 00:14:35.529
Oh man, I'll let the good doctor go first. Because
268
00:14:36.529 --> 00:14:40.190
I've never done psychedelics, nor do I have any intent
269
00:14:40.230 --> 00:14:40.690
to do so.
270
00:14:40.710 --> 00:14:41.070
I know.
271
00:14:41.110 --> 00:14:45.659
On the grounds that the human mind barely works at
272
00:14:45.840 --> 00:14:50.039
all as a data-taking device in our environment. And I
273
00:14:50.100 --> 00:14:53.539
highly value objective reality. So if I'm going to stir
274
00:14:53.610 --> 00:14:57.350
in chemicals into my brain, I don't know what the
275
00:14:57.389 --> 00:15:00.269
objective is, but if it takes me farther away from...
276
00:15:00.820 --> 00:15:04.019
from reality, I can't, it's not calling to me. In
277
00:15:04.039 --> 00:15:08.259
the words of Ray Manzarek, it's about mind expansion, man. Yeah,
278
00:15:08.279 --> 00:15:11.139
I don't want to expand in a place that is
279
00:15:11.200 --> 00:15:14.419
farther away from objective reality. Okay, well, all right. It's
280
00:15:14.500 --> 00:15:15.230
all you now, Don.
281
00:15:16.070 --> 00:15:19.990
Right, so I myself have not taken any psychedelics, but
282
00:15:20.049 --> 00:15:23.190
I'm collaborating with people who have and who are doing
283
00:15:23.210 --> 00:15:26.590
research into this. And most of the time I would say,
284
00:15:27.509 --> 00:15:31.480
The best hypothesis is they're just screwing things up, right?
285
00:15:31.500 --> 00:15:34.860
The psychedelics are just sort of addling your brain. But
286
00:15:35.179 --> 00:15:39.059
there are cases where I think it's worth scientific research
287
00:15:39.159 --> 00:15:43.179
to try to figure out if something deeper is going on,
288
00:15:43.250 --> 00:15:46.750
perhaps in the case of DMT, for example. But I
289
00:15:46.789 --> 00:15:49.950
should say that what I just said about evolution gives
290
00:15:49.990 --> 00:15:53.490
me a different view on neuroscience
than you would normally
291
00:15:53.529 --> 00:15:57.000
hear from a neuroscientist. So I'm a neuroscientist. I love
292
00:15:57.019 --> 00:15:59.759
to study the brain. And I think that neurons do
293
00:15:59.799 --> 00:16:01.529
not exist when they're not perceived.
294
00:16:02.570 --> 00:16:05.889
Oh, that's no quantum, isn't it? Look at that. Yeah,
295
00:16:05.950 --> 00:16:08.129
you went total string theory on us. No, he went
296
00:16:08.169 --> 00:16:11.029
total quantum. Neuro quantum string theory. He went off the
297
00:16:11.070 --> 00:16:12.639
quantum ledge on that. He did.
298
00:16:12.649 --> 00:16:14.129
That's right. So the idea is that if it's a
299
00:16:14.190 --> 00:16:17.450
VR headset kind of thing, what you see... is what
300
00:16:17.470 --> 00:16:19.909
you render on the fly. So if you're in like
301
00:16:19.950 --> 00:16:22.250
a game like Grand Theft Auto and you see a
302
00:16:22.289 --> 00:16:25.240
red Corvette off to your right, well, there is no
303
00:16:25.279 --> 00:16:28.179
red Corvette in reality because the supercomputer has no red
304
00:16:28.220 --> 00:16:30.879
Corvette in it. So the red Corvette that I'm seeing
305
00:16:31.620 --> 00:16:34.370
is there when I look and render it. And when
306
00:16:34.389 --> 00:16:37.649
I look the other direction, it's gone. So the Corvette
307
00:16:37.789 --> 00:16:40.389
only exists as I perceive it. Now, if I'm a
308
00:16:40.610 --> 00:16:43.269
multiplayer game and someone else is looking at a red Corvette,
309
00:16:44.070 --> 00:16:46.990
when I'm not, they're seeing their red Corvette. They're not
310
00:16:47.009 --> 00:16:47.570
seeing the one.
311
00:16:47.490 --> 00:16:47.759
That I saw.
312
00:16:47.769 --> 00:16:50.470
They're not seeing yours. You just described the game of
313
00:16:50.649 --> 00:16:55.289
adult peekaboo. That's funny.
314
00:16:55.529 --> 00:16:58.169
Explain to me, because I've never played Grand Theft Auto,
315
00:16:58.490 --> 00:17:01.769
does it render only the direction you're looking in to
316
00:17:01.830 --> 00:17:02.590
save CPU?
317
00:17:03.149 --> 00:17:04.789
That's right. That's the goal of games.
318
00:17:05.130 --> 00:17:06.210
So it knows which way you're looking.
319
00:17:06.329 --> 00:17:06.490
Right.
320
00:17:06.900 --> 00:17:07.819
Okay, so.
321
00:17:07.839 --> 00:17:09.700
Because it doesn't make sense if you're not looking at
322
00:17:09.740 --> 00:17:11.519
it for it to be rendering because you can't see
323
00:17:11.539 --> 00:17:11.720
it anyway.
324
00:17:11.740 --> 00:17:16.420
This has been the major argument in simulation theory where
325
00:17:17.500 --> 00:17:23.619
why would the programmer waste computer power simulating things that
326
00:17:23.740 --> 00:17:27.890
no one is conscious of? That makes sense. Just make
327
00:17:27.930 --> 00:17:30.190
it exist when you get there. So, for example, if
328
00:17:30.230 --> 00:17:32.549
you dig into the earth and. It only has to
329
00:17:32.630 --> 00:17:34.450
make the layers of the earth when you get there.
330
00:17:34.470 --> 00:17:38.450
That you're digging right to. Way cheaper. Way cheaper. Way
331
00:17:38.519 --> 00:17:43.839
more accessible to the programmer than creating everything there all
332
00:17:43.859 --> 00:17:44.220
at once.
333
00:17:45.140 --> 00:17:47.180
That's my theory on the speed of light, if there's
334
00:17:47.200 --> 00:17:47.859
a simulation.
335
00:17:48.680 --> 00:17:48.859
What?
336
00:17:49.000 --> 00:17:50.740
The reason why you can't go faster than the speed
337
00:17:50.779 --> 00:17:54.259
of light is because that is the speed at which
338
00:17:54.680 --> 00:17:58.740
they need to create the simulation so that, It can
339
00:17:58.779 --> 00:17:59.670
be there when you see it.
340
00:17:59.769 --> 00:18:02.849
Okay, so Einstein had a theory. That's your hypothesis. Oh, sorry.
341
00:18:03.890 --> 00:18:09.809
You're absolutely right. That's my idea. That's a thought. That's
342
00:18:09.910 --> 00:18:10.410
my thought.
343
00:18:10.430 --> 00:18:15.390
So you've both tapped into simulation theory. Don, is that
344
00:18:15.430 --> 00:18:19.000
what's in practice here? I mean, are the realities layered
345
00:18:20.019 --> 00:18:21.079
and one within another?
346
00:18:22.559 --> 00:18:25.859
Simulation theory, as it's typically put out, like Nick Bostrom
347
00:18:25.900 --> 00:18:28.039
and others who are, Elon Musk who are interested in it,
348
00:18:28.670 --> 00:18:30.869
So I'll say at top level, yes, this is very,
349
00:18:30.910 --> 00:18:34.349
very similar, but I'll make two important distinctions between Bostrom's
350
00:18:34.430 --> 00:18:37.690
point of view and what I'm saying. One point is
351
00:18:37.730 --> 00:18:41.480
that Bostrom says, you know, we're probably a simulation and
352
00:18:41.519 --> 00:18:44.119
there's some geek with a computer at a different level
353
00:18:44.160 --> 00:18:46.980
that's programming us and making us up. But that geek
354
00:18:47.039 --> 00:18:49.839
is actually simulated by someone at an even lower level
355
00:18:49.859 --> 00:18:51.869
and you can go down many, many levels until you
356
00:18:51.880 --> 00:18:54.950
get to the bottom level. And the bottom level, he assumes,
357
00:18:55.029 --> 00:18:57.109
is a physical space-time level.
358
00:18:57.539 --> 00:18:58.460
A real thing.
359
00:18:59.559 --> 00:19:01.220
And that's where I get off the train because I
360
00:19:01.259 --> 00:19:04.799
say there's no reason on evolutionary grounds to believe that
361
00:19:04.859 --> 00:19:08.559
space-time is fundamental. In fact, we have good reason to
362
00:19:08.579 --> 00:19:12.359
believe on high-energy theoretical physics grounds that space-time is doomed.
363
00:19:12.680 --> 00:19:16.880
As many high-energy theoretical physicists say, space-time is doomed, and
364
00:19:16.900 --> 00:19:20.819
they're looking for new structures beyond space-time. So I don't
365
00:19:20.859 --> 00:19:25.049
want to buy that the bottom level is a space-time level.
366
00:19:25.700 --> 00:19:28.660
And the second part of the standard simulation theory that
367
00:19:28.680 --> 00:19:31.680
I don't buy is that the idea is that you
368
00:19:31.720 --> 00:19:37.829
can simulate consciousness, conscious experiences through algorithms on computers. And
369
00:19:37.849 --> 00:19:41.269
I'm good friends and colleagues with most of the players
370
00:19:41.289 --> 00:19:43.759
who are trying to do this. And it's a remarkable thing.
371
00:19:43.779 --> 00:19:48.640
I mean, these are brilliant, brilliant scientists. But the hard
372
00:19:48.700 --> 00:19:52.200
fact is that to date... there's not a single specific
373
00:19:52.240 --> 00:19:55.880
conscious experience that any scientific theory has ever been able
374
00:19:55.940 --> 00:19:58.880
to show we could program up. For example, there's no
375
00:19:58.940 --> 00:20:01.359
theory about how we get the taste of chocolate, the
376
00:20:01.400 --> 00:20:06.690
smell of garlic, nothing. So we are batting exactly zero
377
00:20:06.769 --> 00:20:12.440
right now in terms of explain a specific conscious experience.
378
00:20:13.059 --> 00:20:16.509
So I think it's principled, a principled failure. These people
379
00:20:16.549 --> 00:20:19.089
are brilliant. Many of them are geniuses. They're good friends
380
00:20:19.130 --> 00:20:20.869
of mine. If we could do it, I think we
381
00:20:20.910 --> 00:20:22.750
would have done it and we haven't been able to
382
00:20:22.809 --> 00:20:23.059
do it.
383
00:20:23.190 --> 00:20:25.369
So, I mean, it's very possible that we don't have
384
00:20:25.390 --> 00:20:28.109
the computing power to do it because, go ahead.
385
00:20:28.170 --> 00:20:32.549
Wait, wait, wait. Okay. So all you just said, if
386
00:20:32.609 --> 00:20:35.869
I may summarize, is that we don't understand consciousness yet
387
00:20:36.589 --> 00:20:42.210
as we think It exists. So I don't believe you're
388
00:20:42.250 --> 00:20:45.250
saying anything deeper than that. It's just a frontier, a
389
00:20:45.349 --> 00:20:50.349
neuroscience physics frontier. So what point are you making other
390
00:20:50.369 --> 00:20:52.869
than saying we don't understand it yet? I can say
391
00:20:52.890 --> 00:20:55.339
we don't know what happened before the Big Bang. That's
392
00:20:55.390 --> 00:20:58.559
a frontier. I'm not trying to say anything deeper than that.
393
00:20:59.180 --> 00:21:01.000
If we don't understand it, we don't understand it. We
394
00:21:01.019 --> 00:21:03.660
have top people working on it. So where are you
395
00:21:03.680 --> 00:21:04.380
trying to take us there?
396
00:21:04.940 --> 00:21:07.349
So where I'm taking this is that for the last
397
00:21:07.349 --> 00:21:11.190
30 or 40 years, there's been concerted effort by many
398
00:21:11.250 --> 00:21:15.910
brilliant neuroscientists and computer scientists and a number of theories proposed.
399
00:21:16.509 --> 00:21:21.450
For example, integrated information theory, Penrose and Hameroff's quantum collapse
400
00:21:21.490 --> 00:21:26.349
of microtubules theories. There's lots of specific mathematically precise theories.
401
00:21:27.039 --> 00:21:29.779
And when you ask them, okay, you have a theory
402
00:21:29.819 --> 00:21:35.309
of observation, conscious experiences. What specific conscious experience can you explain?
403
00:21:36.170 --> 00:21:38.190
And the answer is zero.
404
00:21:38.410 --> 00:21:41.269
And this has been after decades. And what I tell
405
00:21:41.309 --> 00:21:44.339
people is, you know, by the way, of course, there's
406
00:21:44.359 --> 00:21:48.210
a book published on consciousness. three times a year, okay?
407
00:21:48.410 --> 00:21:51.710
Like a number, it'll be pretty close. And that is
408
00:21:51.849 --> 00:21:54.829
evidence we don't yet understand consciousness. Because if we did,
409
00:21:55.210 --> 00:21:57.569
all the publications would stop and we'd be onto some
410
00:21:57.589 --> 00:22:01.170
other subject. So the more that's published on something, it's
411
00:22:01.369 --> 00:22:04.289
evidence of how little we understand. That's the point I'm
412
00:22:04.309 --> 00:22:07.839
trying to make. So Don, as you know, in biological circles,
413
00:22:07.859 --> 00:22:12.539
there's a lot of talk lately about emergence, like the
414
00:22:12.619 --> 00:22:15.319
flocking of birds. You know, if you can analyze every,
415
00:22:15.970 --> 00:22:19.029
cell of a bird and every molecule within it. It
416
00:22:19.049 --> 00:22:23.250
doesn't say nothing indicates flocking flocking yet together. They all
417
00:22:23.390 --> 00:22:27.069
sort of know what they're doing. So might consciousness. Be
418
00:22:27.210 --> 00:22:32.180
something emergent within our evolutionary tree, or is it that
419
00:22:32.279 --> 00:22:35.660
is you need these other base ingredients and then consciousness
420
00:22:35.960 --> 00:22:39.339
manifests atop them all. What do you think is built
421
00:22:39.420 --> 00:22:40.220
into our code?
422
00:22:40.920 --> 00:22:43.809
So most of my colleagues who are scientists who are
423
00:22:43.849 --> 00:22:47.470
studying consciousness from a physiological or computational point of view
424
00:22:47.769 --> 00:22:53.430
would think that consciousness somehow emerges from either properties of
425
00:22:53.549 --> 00:22:56.990
algorithms or properties of neural activity or so forth.
426
00:22:57.450 --> 00:23:02.519
So a chat bot's conscious. Has consciousness emerged given they
427
00:23:02.539 --> 00:23:05.019
have access to every word we have ever posted on
428
00:23:05.039 --> 00:23:09.710
the internet? That's a big slice of anyone's brain. of
429
00:23:09.779 --> 00:23:13.859
the summation of many brains, but will you deny them consciousness?
430
00:23:14.539 --> 00:23:18.039
Because I don't think Turing would. Turing would.
431
00:23:18.099 --> 00:23:21.240
Most of
my colleagues would say that they're conscious. And
432
00:23:22.019 --> 00:23:25.319
I would say that the whole question is framed the
433
00:23:25.359 --> 00:23:29.119
wrong way. We're starting with something inside of our headset,
434
00:23:29.819 --> 00:23:33.960
and we're asking if the headset can generate consciousness. And
435
00:23:34.000 --> 00:23:37.519
I think it's the other way around. Consciousness looks at
436
00:23:37.559 --> 00:23:41.230
itself through infinitely many different headsets and space-time is just
437
00:23:41.339 --> 00:23:44.440
one of them. And the proof of this will be
438
00:23:44.700 --> 00:23:50.619
whether or not one can actually use neural activity or
439
00:23:51.160 --> 00:23:56.109
some kind of algorithms to actually give theories, not just claims,
440
00:23:56.190 --> 00:23:59.329
but a theory of specific conscious experiences. I like the
441
00:23:59.369 --> 00:24:03.319
taste of it. Give me an algorithm And a theory
442
00:24:03.359 --> 00:24:05.859
that says this must be the taste of mint, a
443
00:24:05.900 --> 00:24:08.940
scientific theory that says this must be the taste of mint,
444
00:24:09.000 --> 00:24:12.359
and here is why. Or, for example, in the case
445
00:24:12.500 --> 00:24:16.680
of integrated information theory, a theory of neural activity, and
446
00:24:16.720 --> 00:24:19.970
more general than neural activity, a theory about how the
447
00:24:20.009 --> 00:24:25.250
right kind of causal structures could be conscious experiences. I would, again,
448
00:24:25.309 --> 00:24:29.710
ask them, give me a specific integrated information causal structure
449
00:24:29.750 --> 00:24:32.690
that must be the taste of mint. Right now, there
450
00:24:32.750 --> 00:24:35.390
is zero on the table. There are no successes.
451
00:24:35.799 --> 00:24:40.259
Well, for humans as well as chatbots. So you can't
452
00:24:40.519 --> 00:24:41.619
blame chatbots for that.
453
00:24:42.359 --> 00:24:46.519
Absolutely. So I think my view is consciousness does not
454
00:24:46.579 --> 00:24:50.099
emerge from algorithms. It does not emerge from neurons. It
455
00:24:50.160 --> 00:24:53.109
does not emerge from anything inside space and time whatsoever.
456
00:24:53.750 --> 00:24:55.930
In fact, it's the other way around. Space and time
457
00:24:56.230 --> 00:25:00.769
and everything inside them emerges as a trivial headset. from consciousness.
458
00:25:00.990 --> 00:25:05.309
Okay, so are we looking at mathematics as the key
459
00:25:05.630 --> 00:25:09.470
to a solution? Are we looking here at consciousness being
460
00:25:09.490 --> 00:25:12.690
a quantum, I want to say thing, but that sounds
461
00:25:12.730 --> 00:25:14.490
really clumsy and heavy.
462
00:25:15.250 --> 00:25:17.619
I mean, why couldn't it be a quantum manifestation?
463
00:25:17.670 --> 00:25:20.920
So in which case, when does space-time cease to exist
464
00:25:20.980 --> 00:25:23.380
and at what scale, what level are you saying that
465
00:25:23.440 --> 00:25:24.299
that stops to happen?
466
00:25:26.180 --> 00:25:28.599
Well, on the very last question, I can say that
467
00:25:28.740 --> 00:25:31.460
it's not me saying it, but actually the high energy
468
00:25:31.480 --> 00:25:34.789
theoretical physicists tell us precisely where it stops. It stops
469
00:25:34.849 --> 00:25:37.529
at 10 to the minus 33 centimeters and 10 to
470
00:25:37.549 --> 00:25:38.730
the minus 43 seconds.
471
00:25:38.849 --> 00:25:46.130
Yeah, it's a Planck scale. That's a Planck scale. space-time,
472
00:25:46.390 --> 00:25:48.690
as we think of it as a continuum, as described
473
00:25:48.730 --> 00:25:53.490
by Einstein, is very successful in accounting for what we
474
00:25:53.529 --> 00:25:56.609
see in the universe. What we find is that on these,
475
00:25:56.630 --> 00:25:59.589
I can't even call it granular scale, because it's way
476
00:25:59.630 --> 00:26:04.710
smaller than that, there's a breakdown, and the general relativity
477
00:26:04.759 --> 00:26:08.039
does not play nice in the sandbox with the quantum.
478
00:26:08.579 --> 00:26:11.440
But most people are betting on the quantum. because of
479
00:26:11.640 --> 00:26:15.619
how successful it has been. If I were you, I'd
480
00:26:15.720 --> 00:26:19.859
stick with the quantum. But before you even go further
481
00:26:19.900 --> 00:26:25.670
on that, Gary, Don, I want to just assess layers
482
00:26:25.750 --> 00:26:31.450
of reality, not in a programmer's sense, but there's still
483
00:26:31.490 --> 00:26:33.809
the lion, the matter of the lion that has teeth.
484
00:26:34.450 --> 00:26:37.430
And I see teeth, and those teeth will eat me.
485
00:26:38.269 --> 00:26:38.470
And so.
486
00:26:40.019 --> 00:26:45.200
I cannot embrace your statement that that is some kind
487
00:26:45.299 --> 00:26:50.150
of virtual reality that does not correspond with an objective reality.
488
00:26:50.529 --> 00:26:54.450
Because I can, as a scientist, this is what we've
489
00:26:54.470 --> 00:26:58.829
been doing since Galileo, and especially since the 19th century,
490
00:26:59.130 --> 00:27:02.500
we can create a machine that can make a measurement
491
00:27:02.859 --> 00:27:06.799
that does not use your neurons. And I can say,
492
00:27:06.819 --> 00:27:11.069
I'm looking at a, furry thing with a mane and
493
00:27:11.130 --> 00:27:15.529
big teeth, and it weighs 800 pounds. And then it
494
00:27:15.869 --> 00:27:19.250
walks on a scale. The scale registers 800 pounds. A
495
00:27:19.390 --> 00:27:21.880
picture gets taken of it. It's got a mane. It's
496
00:27:21.890 --> 00:27:25.420
got big teeth. And 10 minutes later, I am mauled.
497
00:27:26.279 --> 00:27:30.759
So I have a hard time embracing your statement that
498
00:27:31.319 --> 00:27:34.869
evolution prevents me from seeing the objective reality of what
499
00:27:34.890 --> 00:27:35.329
just happened.
500
00:27:36.259 --> 00:27:39.710
Well, so I'll just say that the evolution says the
501
00:27:39.750 --> 00:27:42.730
probability is zero, that any measurement gives you a true
502
00:27:42.910 --> 00:27:46.450
picture of reality. But the issue that you raised about
503
00:27:46.549 --> 00:27:50.819
observation is really a critical one. I think it's, in fact,
504
00:27:51.119 --> 00:27:55.079
the central issue before science today. What's remarkable is that
505
00:27:55.180 --> 00:27:59.720
science does not have a theory of observation. And that's
506
00:27:59.799 --> 00:28:04.400
one of the biggest open problems in science that's widely recognized.
507
00:28:04.420 --> 00:28:08.279
I mean, John Wheeler, in his famous 1989 paper from Bit,
508
00:28:08.299 --> 00:28:13.509
was basically saying, we have to reboot our physics with some,
509
00:28:13.690 --> 00:28:16.990
what he called, observer participants. And Frank Wilczek has said
510
00:28:17.049 --> 00:28:19.029
the same thing. We need to have a theory of
511
00:28:19.089 --> 00:28:23.710
the observer. And what's remarkable is, now in the quantum
512
00:28:23.750 --> 00:28:27.230
measurement problem, so where we're trying to figure out how
513
00:28:28.130 --> 00:28:31.470
When we make measurements in quantum theory, we have one
514
00:28:32.109 --> 00:28:34.910
evolution that's called the unitary evolution when you're not looking.
515
00:28:35.170 --> 00:28:37.880
And then there's this collapse when you're supposed to be observing.
516
00:28:38.519 --> 00:28:42.660
And there is no theory yet about that collapse. So
517
00:28:42.819 --> 00:28:45.500
where science is right now is we don't have a
518
00:28:45.599 --> 00:28:49.019
theory of observation. And what's stunning about that is if
519
00:28:49.039 --> 00:28:52.160
you think about what science is, it's a bunch of
520
00:28:52.460 --> 00:28:56.769
people that are looking and talking to each other and saying,
521
00:28:56.809 --> 00:28:58.890
this is what I saw. What did you see? Let's
522
00:28:58.910 --> 00:29:03.910
compare notes. Let's try to understand how to understand what
523
00:29:04.009 --> 00:29:07.150
are different perspectives and views and observations.
524
00:29:07.210 --> 00:29:09.890
I have to correct that. They're not saying, this is
525
00:29:09.910 --> 00:29:12.150
what I saw, what did you see? They're saying, this
526
00:29:12.210 --> 00:29:15.670
is what I measured. What did you measure? And so
527
00:29:15.849 --> 00:29:17.769
let me add to your comment that we don't have
528
00:29:17.809 --> 00:29:22.250
a theory of observation that's definitely true. But as a
529
00:29:22.319 --> 00:29:26.630
correlate to that, we don't have a full theory of measurement. Right.
530
00:29:26.710 --> 00:29:28.519
And they're related. They're related because.
531
00:29:28.619 --> 00:29:34.059
Because the wave function collapse is consistent through all those
532
00:29:34.119 --> 00:29:34.660
who measure.
533
00:29:35.039 --> 00:29:39.349
Correct. But it's... Right. Except if you're not measuring it,
534
00:29:39.390 --> 00:29:41.460
it's not collapsing. Right. So they're related.
535
00:29:41.700 --> 00:29:41.900
Yes.
536
00:29:41.980 --> 00:29:44.660
Right. So I don't want to, so I'm still trying
537
00:29:44.680 --> 00:29:48.910
to take human perception out of this equation because I
538
00:29:48.950 --> 00:29:51.630
can build a machine to make the measurement. Now, you're
539
00:29:51.650 --> 00:29:54.829
a neuroscientist, so perception is everything, but coming to you
540
00:29:54.910 --> 00:30:00.069
as a physicist, I cannot embrace... the idea that we
541
00:30:00.109 --> 00:30:04.029
are perceiving anything, because we worked really hard to get
542
00:30:04.069 --> 00:30:06.210
our five senses out of the experiment.
543
00:30:07.029 --> 00:30:09.930
When you make a measurement with a physical device, it
544
00:30:09.970 --> 00:30:14.029
doesn't get into a scientific theory until some person actually
545
00:30:14.250 --> 00:30:16.329
perceives the measurement outcome. Correct.
546
00:30:16.410 --> 00:30:20.490
But we can all then look at that measurement and
547
00:30:20.559 --> 00:30:26.079
agree what it says without having to trust someone's testimony.
548
00:30:26.490 --> 00:30:27.369
for what they observed.
549
00:30:27.509 --> 00:30:29.930
Or are you saying that the agreement itself is a
550
00:30:30.029 --> 00:30:31.009
shared perception?
551
00:30:31.970 --> 00:30:35.009
Well, we know from Einstein that if we both are
552
00:30:35.029 --> 00:30:38.160
looking at, we're both measuring the velocity of an object
553
00:30:38.220 --> 00:30:39.900
or the speed or the shape of an object, we're
554
00:30:39.920 --> 00:30:42.819
going to get different answers depending on our frame of reference, right?
555
00:30:42.859 --> 00:30:46.039
But we actually know how to translate between, you know,
556
00:30:46.119 --> 00:30:49.369
Neil's frame of reference and Chuck's frame of reference to say,
557
00:30:49.609 --> 00:30:53.250
even though they got different answers, we can understand that
558
00:30:53.269 --> 00:30:54.430
they somehow agree.
559
00:30:55.069 --> 00:30:59.170
There is no There is no transference into Chuck's frame
560
00:30:59.210 --> 00:30:59.609
of reference.
561
00:30:59.950 --> 00:31:00.109
Right.
562
00:31:00.230 --> 00:31:03.859
He has his own... Absolutely. Let me tell you something
563
00:31:03.880 --> 00:31:06.759
right now. It's a mess up in.
564
00:31:08.480 --> 00:31:08.700
Here.
565
00:31:08.960 --> 00:31:11.650
Okay, so we've talked about how we as humans can
566
00:31:11.710 --> 00:31:15.470
perceive and our frameworks, et cetera. What if we now find...
567
00:31:15.630 --> 00:31:19.740
Alien beings who have the sensorial capacity to be able
568
00:31:19.799 --> 00:31:23.039
to absorb way more data than we possibly could of
569
00:31:23.079 --> 00:31:25.640
the reality. Are we then, and I can get carried
570
00:31:25.660 --> 00:31:30.170
away now, looking at a fourth, fifth, sixth dimension in
571
00:31:30.230 --> 00:31:33.849
which these problems that we've fumbled with are solved?
572
00:31:33.930 --> 00:31:36.809
Wait, before you get there. That's an important question that
573
00:31:36.869 --> 00:31:40.829
I address in my recently published book. Take me to
574
00:31:40.869 --> 00:31:44.319
your leader. There's a whole chapter on alien powers that
575
00:31:44.339 --> 00:31:47.339
they could have. I'm currently reading that, so I haven't
576
00:31:47.359 --> 00:31:50.380
got to that. There's a story by Voltaire, of all people,
577
00:31:51.079 --> 00:31:54.180
written in the mid-18th century, where he imagines, this is
578
00:31:54.220 --> 00:31:59.609
one of the earliest total alien fictional stories imagined, where
579
00:31:59.710 --> 00:32:05.099
there's an alien 26 miles tall, And stay with me.
580
00:32:05.680 --> 00:32:08.180
He's in the NBA.
581
00:32:08.240 --> 00:32:08.859
Very good.
582
00:32:09.740 --> 00:32:13.039
The Knicks. He's joining the Knicks next year. They're going
583
00:32:13.079 --> 00:32:17.380
to win another championship. I don't know where he got
584
00:32:17.420 --> 00:32:20.000
the number. He's just 26 miles away and he has 7,000 senses.
585
00:32:20.980 --> 00:32:25.240
And he comes upon other life forms and can't fathom
586
00:32:25.869 --> 00:32:28.250
how they can be so tiny and have so few senses.
587
00:32:28.619 --> 00:32:31.009
and still understand or perceive the world. As we would
588
00:32:31.029 --> 00:32:34.680
look at a nurse worm. Exactly, exactly. So people have
589
00:32:34.700 --> 00:32:38.400
gone there before, but I just wanna say that these
590
00:32:38.500 --> 00:32:43.130
machines are not only measuring to replace our senses, they're
591
00:32:43.170 --> 00:32:47.579
measuring things that our senses have no access to, like
592
00:32:47.619 --> 00:32:54.599
the ultraviolet and the infrared and gravitational perturbations and ionizing radiation.
593
00:32:54.619 --> 00:32:57.710
It has nothing to do with our senses, but we
594
00:32:57.750 --> 00:33:01.569
have machines that can measure them. And so I'm quite
595
00:33:01.650 --> 00:33:06.690
proud of the scientific community for building what are now
596
00:33:06.910 --> 00:33:10.450
dozens of senses of the world so that when someone
597
00:33:10.509 --> 00:33:12.559
comes to your dinner party and says, I have a
598
00:33:12.630 --> 00:33:15.660
sixth sense. You could say. Give it to them.
599
00:33:15.880 --> 00:33:16.039
Right.
600
00:33:16.079 --> 00:33:17.720
And then. What you have is a delusion.
601
00:33:17.980 --> 00:33:18.579
No, no.
602
00:33:19.359 --> 00:33:22.319
Let them have their sixth sense, but say, I have
603
00:33:22.339 --> 00:33:22.960
another dozen.
604
00:33:23.500 --> 00:33:24.079
Oh, nice.
605
00:33:24.140 --> 00:33:26.670
Yeah, why don't you be impressed with mine? So anyhow,
606
00:33:27.069 --> 00:33:30.170
I don't think of things that our senses can't detect
607
00:33:30.849 --> 00:33:35.390
as some magical other reality. They're just
things that our
608
00:33:35.490 --> 00:33:38.859
machines ultimately can't we're able to bring to our awareness.
609
00:33:39.220 --> 00:33:40.460
I don't want to speak for Don, but I think
610
00:33:40.480 --> 00:33:43.640
he's saying that somehow our perceptions and those machines are
611
00:33:43.700 --> 00:33:44.420
tied together.
612
00:33:44.619 --> 00:33:47.329
Yes, in the following sense that we have, I'm claiming
613
00:33:47.369 --> 00:33:50.390
that our perceptions of the world are just a particular headset.
614
00:33:50.869 --> 00:33:55.150
We have a three-dimensional space, one-dimensional time headset with certain properties.
615
00:33:55.670 --> 00:33:59.049
I could imagine other headsets that have four dimensions, five dimensions,
616
00:33:59.049 --> 00:34:02.960
20 dimensions. have senses built into them that we can't,
617
00:34:03.009 --> 00:34:06.930
you know, for example, you know, electric sensing in water,
618
00:34:07.089 --> 00:34:09.010
things like that. I think sharks can do that kind
619
00:34:09.050 --> 00:34:09.309
of thing.
620
00:34:09.369 --> 00:34:15.349
Yeah, yeah, yeah, right. So your headset... Metaphor. Metaphor, thank you.
621
00:34:15.389 --> 00:34:20.170
That's the word I was looking for. He sensed that.
622
00:34:20.510 --> 00:34:21.429
I sensed it.
623
00:34:21.769 --> 00:34:24.429
So that headset metaphor is quite potent with regard to
624
00:34:24.449 --> 00:34:26.010
your aliens who are coming to visit. Yes, yeah.
625
00:34:26.769 --> 00:34:31.039
It is, and in fact, I'm... collaborating with Andrew Gallimore,
626
00:34:31.119 --> 00:34:35.159
who is a world expert on DMT and the studies
627
00:34:35.480 --> 00:34:37.800
of that. And one thing that we're, I have a
628
00:34:37.840 --> 00:34:41.400
mathematical model of how this headset, our headset is built
629
00:34:41.780 --> 00:34:44.239
and a theory of observation. And we're using that to
630
00:34:44.320 --> 00:34:48.230
try to begin to model how we might understand alien
631
00:34:48.269 --> 00:34:53.110
intelligences as having different headsets that are different from ours
632
00:34:53.210 --> 00:34:56.829
in ways that we can actually write down mathematics. For example,
633
00:34:56.949 --> 00:35:00.409
our headset may be a subset of theirs. They may
634
00:35:00.449 --> 00:35:02.010
have higher dimensions than we have.
635
00:35:02.409 --> 00:35:05.409
Love me high dimensional aliens. That'd be the funnest thing ever.
636
00:35:05.630 --> 00:35:08.269
Well, believe it or not, I met higher dimensional aliens
637
00:35:08.309 --> 00:35:09.769
while I was doing ayahuasca.
638
00:35:10.849 --> 00:35:13.570
I'm not even lying, man. By the way, did you know,
639
00:35:14.170 --> 00:35:16.329
did you know this? I only knew it researching for
640
00:35:16.369 --> 00:35:18.969
my book. Go ahead. There's a subset of DMT users
641
00:35:19.170 --> 00:35:22.250
that all agree that they're interacting with aliens and they
642
00:35:22.289 --> 00:35:26.500
have formed a subgroup within DMT. user, the user group.
643
00:35:26.679 --> 00:35:28.820
I did not know that. It's an alien sub, and
644
00:35:28.840 --> 00:35:32.000
they want to get together, see if they're actually somehow
645
00:35:32.559 --> 00:35:36.010
cross-dimensional communicating with aliens, and then compare notes.
646
00:35:37.170 --> 00:35:40.510
I would say that makes perfect sense because in my experience,
647
00:35:40.969 --> 00:35:44.090
quite frankly, I had, and maybe I did, because here's
648
00:35:44.139 --> 00:35:47.119
the thing. I felt like the entire time, first of all,
649
00:35:47.139 --> 00:35:50.659
you're not high when you do Ayahuasca. That's a misnomer.
650
00:35:51.110 --> 00:35:54.730
You are not a misconception. You're not like, you know, oh,
651
00:35:54.750 --> 00:35:57.730
my God, I'm tripping my balls off. It's no, you're
652
00:35:58.409 --> 00:36:05.440
it's like your brain has been subsectioned and you're kind
653
00:36:05.480 --> 00:36:09.380
of in touch with all of the different. sections of
654
00:36:09.440 --> 00:36:12.000
your brain, but the whole time I was telling myself,
655
00:36:12.340 --> 00:36:16.280
this is my perception. This is all coming from my brain.
656
00:36:16.769 --> 00:36:19.829
And the ayahuasca was like, and what difference does that make?
657
00:36:20.449 --> 00:36:22.989
Because it doesn't make any of this any less real.
658
00:36:23.550 --> 00:36:26.849
And the more I accepted that, the more expansive the
659
00:36:26.969 --> 00:36:30.840
experience became. And I met beings that told me that
660
00:36:30.949 --> 00:36:33.360
quite frankly, the way it works is we're in a
661
00:36:33.400 --> 00:36:34.460
really dimension.
662
00:36:36.030 --> 00:36:42.889
So Don, in your new metaphor, if you can actually
663
00:36:42.929 --> 00:36:45.309
mathematically model that, then it becomes more than a metaphor.
664
00:36:45.670 --> 00:36:50.710
It becomes a tool to calculate. What confidence do you
665
00:36:50.769 --> 00:36:55.829
have that Chuck actually had access beyond his current dimension?
666
00:36:56.710 --> 00:36:59.960
As a scientist, I'm hard-nosed and I'm completely agnostic, but
667
00:37:00.019 --> 00:37:02.719
I want to do experiments. And so I'm actually designing
668
00:37:02.780 --> 00:37:06.489
experiments with Andrew Gallenbar where we would For example, Andrew
669
00:37:06.510 --> 00:37:09.090
has this technology where you can put people under DMT
670
00:37:09.130 --> 00:37:11.889
for extended periods of time. So for more than just
671
00:37:12.269 --> 00:37:13.860
three or five minutes, you can put them in there
672
00:37:13.880 --> 00:37:16.840
for an hour or something like that, or 20 minutes.
673
00:37:16.960 --> 00:37:18.780
So you can actually have extent. So what we would
674
00:37:18.800 --> 00:37:21.820
like to do is say, are these aliens real? In
675
00:37:21.840 --> 00:37:25.579
the sense that they're sort of, we could have one neonauts,
676
00:37:25.900 --> 00:37:31.599
one person who's taking DMT, go and give an alien
677
00:37:32.440 --> 00:37:36.000
creature in the DMT world some piece of information and
678
00:37:36.039 --> 00:37:39.000
then have that transmitted to somebody else, a different person.
679
00:37:39.139 --> 00:37:40.960
Good way to test that. Wow.
680
00:37:40.980 --> 00:37:43.400
So we're coming up with experiments like that where I'm
681
00:37:43.800 --> 00:37:47.340
completely hard nosed. If that can be done, I don't
682
00:37:47.360 --> 00:37:49.059
know if I will believe it even then. I would
683
00:37:49.099 --> 00:37:51.300
want to do a bunch of experiments.
684
00:37:51.460 --> 00:37:57.550
I feel the same way about out-of-body experiences where if
685
00:37:57.570 --> 00:38:01.750
you're in the bed, get someone to write something that's
686
00:38:01.769 --> 00:38:04.719
facing upwards. If you have an out-of-body experience looking down
687
00:38:04.760 --> 00:38:07.820
on your body, you should be able to read that statement.
688
00:38:08.260 --> 00:38:09.699
And then come back and say, well, what does it say?
689
00:38:10.070 --> 00:38:12.650
Roses are red or some simple phrase that would be
690
00:38:12.750 --> 00:38:15.469
easy to remember and to read. So, yeah, you're doing
691
00:38:15.510 --> 00:38:18.849
exactly the right science-minded testing.
692
00:38:19.449 --> 00:38:24.219
And so I'm actually hard-nosed about it and disbelieving until
693
00:38:24.260 --> 00:38:26.599
I have hard evidence for it. But at least this
694
00:38:26.639 --> 00:38:31.300
headset theory says it's possible. So since it's possible, we
695
00:38:31.320 --> 00:38:34.710
should really check it out. But the higher probability is
696
00:38:34.769 --> 00:38:38.170
just that your brain got screwed up somehow. Your headset
697
00:38:38.230 --> 00:38:41.889
got screwed up. But if DMT is actually changing a
698
00:38:41.929 --> 00:38:44.530
parameter in the headset that says you were stuck with
699
00:38:44.550 --> 00:38:47.389
the three dimensions of space, but DMT is now taking
700
00:38:47.429 --> 00:38:50.000
you to four or five, and it's just a parameter change,
701
00:38:50.519 --> 00:38:54.760
and we can actually see more dimensions than we had
702
00:38:54.840 --> 00:38:57.019
seen before, I certainly want to know that and find
703
00:38:57.059 --> 00:38:57.619
that out.
704
00:38:58.000 --> 00:39:01.440
What in evolution would have allowed that to even be
705
00:39:01.480 --> 00:39:02.309
accessible to us?
706
00:39:03.530 --> 00:39:07.489
Well, what's interesting is when you look at, there are
707
00:39:07.530 --> 00:39:11.699
high-energy theoretical physicists who are studying structures outside of space-time now,
708
00:39:12.179 --> 00:39:15.840
as you probably well know. They're called positive geometries, and
709
00:39:15.880 --> 00:39:19.440
the European Research Council has a 10 million euro initiative,
710
00:39:19.900 --> 00:39:24.050
and there are many, many high-energy theoretical physicists and mathematicians
711
00:39:24.550 --> 00:39:28.800
finding structures outside of spacetime. And when you look at
712
00:39:28.840 --> 00:39:32.929
these structures, they have a– some of the structures, something
713
00:39:32.949 --> 00:39:35.929
called the amplitude hedon has a parameter n, which when
714
00:39:35.969 --> 00:39:40.110
it's 4, corresponds to our spacetime, one dimension of time,
715
00:39:40.190 --> 00:39:43.849
three dimensions of space. But these geometries then say, but
716
00:39:44.690 --> 00:39:47.710
we're not stuck with four. You can have 10, a billion,
717
00:39:47.889 --> 00:39:52.429
a trillion. So your space time is just n equals four,
718
00:39:52.760 --> 00:39:56.300
but our geometries outside of space time aren't stuck at four.
719
00:39:56.619 --> 00:39:59.139
We can go anywhere you want. So already we're seeing
720
00:39:59.559 --> 00:40:03.360
in high energy theoretical physics, a point or two, this
721
00:40:03.440 --> 00:40:07.739
may not be the only reality, n equals four. The
722
00:40:07.780 --> 00:40:10.840
mathematics allows us to go to n equals whatever you wish.
723
00:40:11.630 --> 00:40:14.639
And four, we're sort of, we got the cheap headset. We,
724
00:40:14.679 --> 00:40:16.760
we got the cheap.
725
00:40:16.920 --> 00:40:18.079
That's what I was told.
726
00:40:18.239 --> 00:40:20.619
And I'm telling you right now, what you just described
727
00:40:21.380 --> 00:40:24.579
is something that the tribes who actually do the rituals
728
00:40:24.639 --> 00:40:28.739
where I was in Costa Rica, um, And they're called
729
00:40:28.940 --> 00:40:33.400
sacred geometries. That's what they're called, sacred geometries. And in
730
00:40:33.440 --> 00:40:39.210
these sacred geometries, there are representations of dimensions that seemingly
731
00:40:39.289 --> 00:40:42.750
are infinite, but like I've described before, are like a
732
00:40:42.869 --> 00:40:45.570
deck of cards. They're like a deck of cards that
733
00:40:45.610 --> 00:40:50.559
go in all directions, but they're dimensions. Some of them larger,
734
00:40:50.599 --> 00:40:54.260
some of them smaller, some of them where the communication
735
00:40:54.380 --> 00:40:58.920
happens downward, but we're in a crappy dimension where we
736
00:40:58.980 --> 00:41:02.710
can't go upwards or outwards, and so we have to
737
00:41:02.750 --> 00:41:06.849
be communicated with from above or beside.
738
00:41:06.869 --> 00:41:08.530
All right, John, why are we in a crappy dimension?
739
00:41:08.550 --> 00:41:12.309
It's all your fault. You know, and listen, I was
740
00:41:12.329 --> 00:41:15.659
just like this. I thought the whole time I kept
741
00:41:15.679 --> 00:41:18.659
saying to myself, you're high. That's all I kept saying.
742
00:41:18.940 --> 00:41:22.159
But the more I talk to people like you, Don,
743
00:41:22.880 --> 00:41:26.639
and Brian Green, and Jan Eleven.
744
00:41:27.199 --> 00:41:29.909
This stuff that I
really didn't have any knowledge of
745
00:41:30.860 --> 00:41:33.530
is kind of the basis of the experience.
746
00:41:33.969 --> 00:41:34.550
I'm just saying.
747
00:41:35.150 --> 00:41:38.130
Okay, so these positive geometrics, are they going to be
748
00:41:38.610 --> 00:41:42.170
the solution to what David Chalmers phrased as the hard
749
00:41:42.489 --> 00:41:43.449
problem of consciousness?
750
00:41:44.420 --> 00:41:49.320
I don't think so. And I think that the high
751
00:41:49.460 --> 00:41:53.639
energy theoretical physicists aren't trying to do that. They are
752
00:41:54.460 --> 00:41:57.969
trying to understand observation. So that's a big, big problem,
753
00:41:58.090 --> 00:42:01.630
open problem in quantum gravity right now, especially the attempts
754
00:42:01.650 --> 00:42:05.949
to get quantum gravity that have forced mathematicians and physicists
755
00:42:06.349 --> 00:42:09.250
to say, you know what, we've never understood the observer.
756
00:42:09.690 --> 00:42:12.150
And it looks like that is the obstacle. We need
757
00:42:12.170 --> 00:42:15.369
to go back and really understand what an observer is.
758
00:42:16.090 --> 00:42:18.019
And that may be the key.
759
00:42:18.139 --> 00:42:19.780
Yeah, but if you're going to take something we don't
760
00:42:19.800 --> 00:42:22.539
understand in the quantum realm, and then you're going to
761
00:42:22.559 --> 00:42:25.519
take consciousness, which you don't really understand in the neuroscience realm,
762
00:42:26.059 --> 00:42:29.130
staple them together, and turn that into an explanation of
763
00:42:29.190 --> 00:42:33.170
something that you're going to trust, feels like very unstable ground.
764
00:42:33.679 --> 00:42:36.159
to be standing on. Completely. I agree.
765
00:42:36.300 --> 00:42:39.039
I think that we can talk about observers without worrying
766
00:42:39.059 --> 00:42:41.280
about consciousness first. We can just ask, can we get
767
00:42:41.320 --> 00:42:45.630
a mathematical model of observation? I think we can. I've
768
00:42:45.670 --> 00:42:49.469
got my own model right now that I'm working on.
769
00:42:50.329 --> 00:42:54.250
It's a simple model of observation that doesn't assume consciousness
770
00:42:54.329 --> 00:42:57.829
or non-consciousness to be fundamental. It just is a mathematical
771
00:42:57.869 --> 00:43:02.340
model of observation. I personally think that consciousness is important
772
00:43:02.389 --> 00:43:05.730
and fundamental, but this mathematical model doesn't require that.
773
00:43:06.110 --> 00:43:08.309
We've said so many times when we've come together, the
774
00:43:08.369 --> 00:43:10.619
three of us, that the problems that we're not able
775
00:43:10.659 --> 00:43:13.480
to solve right now, and now I'm a scientist, right?
776
00:43:14.500 --> 00:43:15.860
Exactly. Thank you.
777
00:43:17.019 --> 00:43:21.840
Requires different thinking. Do you consider yourself now in that realm?
778
00:43:22.440 --> 00:43:25.320
And if you are, what different thinking are you looking
779
00:43:25.460 --> 00:43:28.159
at we now need to take, the measures that you
780
00:43:28.219 --> 00:43:30.840
need to bring forward that are different, that we haven't
781
00:43:30.920 --> 00:43:31.480
yet thought of?
782
00:43:32.389 --> 00:43:35.170
Yes. So I think that we have to just think very,
783
00:43:35.210 --> 00:43:38.429
very clearly about what does it mean to observe? We
784
00:43:38.469 --> 00:43:42.389
need to get it to its bare essence, no extra
785
00:43:42.429 --> 00:43:48.019
bells and whistles. What is the absolute minimum essential for observation? observation.
786
00:43:48.440 --> 00:43:51.420
We need to understand that mathematically. Then we have to ask,
787
00:43:51.659 --> 00:43:54.820
can we start with that and that alone to build
788
00:43:54.960 --> 00:43:58.800
up all of modern physics? So it's a new foundation.
789
00:43:58.820 --> 00:44:01.150
We don't start with space-time because we now know that
790
00:44:01.170 --> 00:44:06.150
space-time is doomed. That cannot be fundamental. It stops at
791
00:44:06.170 --> 00:44:08.909
the Planck scale. So what are the new foundations going
792
00:44:08.949 --> 00:44:12.510
to be? I think that Leibniz was right. Leibniz said
793
00:44:12.550 --> 00:44:14.989
we need to start with observation. He called them monads.
794
00:44:15.550 --> 00:44:17.769
And he said there had to be these monads that
795
00:44:17.949 --> 00:44:22.550
were somehow interacting and had some kind of mathematical pre-established harmony.
796
00:44:23.300 --> 00:44:30.360
Leibniz was a mathematical philosopher, all credited with co-inventing calculus.
797
00:44:31.099 --> 00:44:33.639
And there was some dispute between him and, of course,
798
00:44:33.699 --> 00:44:39.530
my boy, Isaac Newton. But their discoveries are completely independent
799
00:44:39.570 --> 00:44:42.670
in the sense that they represent the calculus very differently
800
00:44:43.170 --> 00:44:46.329
with their symbology. In physics, we use a lot of
801
00:44:46.409 --> 00:44:51.710
Newtonian representation, but in math, it's all Leibniz's notations. So
802
00:44:52.170 --> 00:44:53.630
the integral sign comes from him.
803
00:44:53.949 --> 00:44:57.360
You mentioned the OGs of physics there. Are we likely
804
00:44:57.429 --> 00:45:01.340
through your research to find that there are slightly different
805
00:45:01.409 --> 00:45:04.469
laws of physics in play that we weren't aware of?
806
00:45:04.480 --> 00:45:07.460
Oh, I think not just slightly. I think that we
807
00:45:07.480 --> 00:45:10.460
will find that our headset is one of the more
808
00:45:10.519 --> 00:45:13.539
trivial headsets and that other headsets have much more interesting physics.
809
00:45:14.159 --> 00:45:16.409
But I want to Let's set it straight here. The
810
00:45:16.469 --> 00:45:19.679
history of physics is not where the history of physics
811
00:45:19.780 --> 00:45:23.179
since Galileo is not where, oh,
we all believe this.
812
00:45:23.440 --> 00:45:25.460
And then later on, that's all wrong. And we believe
813
00:45:25.500 --> 00:45:28.179
something else. That's not how it happens. We only believe
814
00:45:28.219 --> 00:45:31.320
something is true if it's been experimentally verified. Then we
815
00:45:31.380 --> 00:45:34.820
find out there's a deeper truth. Get right in your
816
00:45:34.880 --> 00:45:38.119
belly wick here. There's a deeper truth in which that's embedded,
817
00:45:38.480 --> 00:45:40.099
and that's just a special case. Yeah, you don't throw
818
00:45:40.119 --> 00:45:41.579
the baby out with the bad one. Not at all.
819
00:45:41.739 --> 00:45:44.579
Then there's an even deeper truth. So I don't have
820
00:45:44.760 --> 00:45:50.079
any hesitation thinking that my lame ass 3D candy ass
821
00:45:50.139 --> 00:45:54.860
headset is legit in its world, but it's a subset
822
00:45:54.880 --> 00:45:57.550
of a much larger truth. Exactly.
823
00:45:57.599 --> 00:45:59.579
What you're saying is exactly where I'm headed. I want
824
00:45:59.619 --> 00:46:03.599
to show that I can start with a theory of observation, precise, mathematical,
825
00:46:04.420 --> 00:46:09.690
and get quantum gravity as a special case without hand waves. So,
826
00:46:10.070 --> 00:46:12.710
theorem and proof, theorem and proof. So, I decided to
827
00:46:12.750 --> 00:46:16.610
take Leibniz very, very seriously and let's get a mathematical
828
00:46:16.650 --> 00:46:19.250
model of observation that's as simple as possible and see
829
00:46:19.289 --> 00:46:24.449
where this pre-established harmony might arise. And the simplest idea
830
00:46:24.489 --> 00:46:27.730
that I can think of is forget consciousness. Just, I'm
831
00:46:27.769 --> 00:46:32.440
just talking observation, not consciousness. Okay. So observation, you have outcomes.
832
00:46:33.059 --> 00:46:37.099
So you have a list of possible outcomes and changes.
833
00:46:37.500 --> 00:46:39.719
I've seen this outcome and now I'm seeing that outcome
834
00:46:39.739 --> 00:46:42.449
and that's it. I just want to say observation involves
835
00:46:43.070 --> 00:46:47.510
outcomes and possible changes of outcomes. And what's the minimum
836
00:46:47.550 --> 00:46:50.269
mathematics that we can use to represent that kind of observer?
837
00:46:51.070 --> 00:46:53.650
It's a matrix that says, here's a list of all
838
00:46:53.690 --> 00:46:56.989
your outcomes. And here's a list of probabilities. If you
839
00:46:57.030 --> 00:46:59.769
see outcome one, what's the probability that you'll see outcome
840
00:46:59.789 --> 00:47:01.889
two next or outcome three, outcome four, and so forth.
841
00:47:02.150 --> 00:47:04.150
You just write down a matrix of all the outcomes
842
00:47:04.449 --> 00:47:07.199
and how they might change. And that's called a Markov chain,
843
00:47:07.760 --> 00:47:12.699
a Markov. And what I've discovered is a new logic.
844
00:47:13.380 --> 00:47:17.420
that unites all Markov chains. So I'm saying my notion
845
00:47:17.440 --> 00:47:20.909
of observer is a Markov matrix, which shows the observation
846
00:47:20.989 --> 00:47:23.789
outcomes and how they might change. The set of all
847
00:47:23.849 --> 00:47:26.869
possible Markov matrices is the set of all possible observers.
848
00:47:27.309 --> 00:47:27.630
That's it.
849
00:47:27.909 --> 00:47:31.610
It's an infinite class. And I discovered a logic two
850
00:47:31.639 --> 00:47:35.039
years ago that has never been seen before. It's based
851
00:47:35.099 --> 00:47:37.480
on something that is well known, that if I have
852
00:47:37.699 --> 00:47:40.800
one matrix and I can only see a subset of
853
00:47:40.860 --> 00:47:43.789
its states, So I got a big 10 by 10 matrix,
854
00:47:43.829 --> 00:47:47.949
for example, but I can only see three states. The
855
00:47:48.010 --> 00:47:52.000
big matrix will induce an apparent matrix on the three
856
00:47:52.019 --> 00:47:55.320
by three. So it's called the trace. So for example,
857
00:47:55.340 --> 00:47:58.730
if you're at a light and you see red, green,
858
00:47:58.750 --> 00:48:01.699
and yellow, and you're seeing them change, and someone else
859
00:48:01.739 --> 00:48:04.420
can only see red and green, well, the red and
860
00:48:04.440 --> 00:48:07.239
green transitions are determined by the red, green, and yellow transitions,
861
00:48:07.300 --> 00:48:09.980
but you can't see the yellow, so you're gonna get
862
00:48:10.019 --> 00:48:12.019
a different matrix for the red and green. And that's
863
00:48:12.059 --> 00:48:14.349
called the trace. It's a unique thing. If I give
864
00:48:14.369 --> 00:48:16.389
you a big matrix and say, you can only see
865
00:48:16.429 --> 00:48:19.550
this little window, then there's a unique matrix called the trace.
866
00:48:19.630 --> 00:48:21.869
And that's been known for a long time. It's a
867
00:48:21.969 --> 00:48:26.659
zero surprise matrix. And what I discovered is the property
868
00:48:26.679 --> 00:48:29.550
of being a trace gives you a logic on the
869
00:48:29.650 --> 00:48:33.030
set of all Markov chains. It's a non-Boolean logic that
870
00:48:33.090 --> 00:48:37.130
gives you the pre-established harmony that Leibniz was looking for.
871
00:48:37.289 --> 00:48:40.190
And so what we're doing now, I've got a team
872
00:48:40.210 --> 00:48:42.389
that's working on the mathematics of this. We want to
873
00:48:42.429 --> 00:48:47.429
show that with this trace logic, and it's a recursive.
874
00:48:48.090 --> 00:48:50.400
Now this gets technical. It's recursive trace logic. We can
875
00:48:50.699 --> 00:48:53.670
build agency out of it. But then we can show
876
00:48:54.230 --> 00:48:57.210
that the idea is we can then show how to
877
00:48:57.250 --> 00:49:03.019
build exactly space-time to get quantum theory, space-time and so
878
00:49:03.059 --> 00:49:03.780
forth from this.
879
00:49:04.119 --> 00:49:05.320
Well, that's quite ambitious.
880
00:49:05.619 --> 00:49:08.800
Man, I got to tell you, first of all, I
881
00:49:10.019 --> 00:49:13.139
need some weed right now. That's number one.
882
00:49:13.710 --> 00:49:16.530
You took Chuck to the ledge there.
883
00:49:16.590 --> 00:49:19.530
Yeah, you took me to the place where I'm just like, damn, how...
884
00:49:19.980 --> 00:49:23.000
but the only thing that really you know i'm not
885
00:49:23.019 --> 00:49:26.070
going to pretend like i really followed everything you said
886
00:49:27.010 --> 00:49:33.440
except that this larger representation It's not necessarily made up,
887
00:49:33.519 --> 00:49:37.829
but it's affected by the smaller representations that you're able
888
00:49:37.889 --> 00:49:40.250
to see the same way when you're looking at a
889
00:49:40.329 --> 00:49:42.989
light change. On the one side, you see the light
890
00:49:43.170 --> 00:49:46.090
change from green to yellow to red, but it's the
891
00:49:46.150 --> 00:49:49.780
exact same transaction that's happening to somebody who only sees
892
00:49:49.820 --> 00:49:52.480
the light change from red to green, but they are
893
00:49:52.920 --> 00:49:54.840
inexorably tied together.
894
00:49:55.320 --> 00:49:57.559
Am I following this? They're in the same matrix. They're
895
00:49:57.599 --> 00:49:58.480
in the same matrix.
896
00:49:58.500 --> 00:50:01.340
Okay, I got you. That's exactly right. And I'll just
897
00:50:01.440 --> 00:50:02.880
pick up on that, because that will give you just
898
00:50:02.920 --> 00:50:05.559
a little clue about how this can get us towards
899
00:50:05.659 --> 00:50:09.300
Einstein's theory of relativity. What we do is standard in
900
00:50:09.340 --> 00:50:13.280
Markov chain theory to have a counter. Every time your
901
00:50:13.420 --> 00:50:18.769
observation changes, you increment a counter, right? So I see red. Okay,
902
00:50:18.809 --> 00:50:19.170
that's one.
903
00:50:19.429 --> 00:50:20.309
Green. Okay, two.
904
00:50:20.809 --> 00:50:21.070
Yellow.
905
00:50:21.130 --> 00:50:21.550
Oh, three.
906
00:50:21.710 --> 00:50:23.849
So you just keep counting like that. Now, just think
907
00:50:23.889 --> 00:50:26.030
about the counter for the guy that can see red, green,
908
00:50:26.070 --> 00:50:28.570
and yellow versus the counter of the guy that only
909
00:50:28.610 --> 00:50:31.789
sees red and green. The red-green guy, his counter isn't
910
00:50:31.809 --> 00:50:33.369
going to go as fast because it doesn't see the.
911
00:50:33.329 --> 00:50:34.869
Yellows, right? Exactly.
912
00:50:34.969 --> 00:50:38.889
That, we claim, will lead directly to time dilation in
913
00:50:38.929 --> 00:50:39.969
Einstein's relativity.
914
00:50:40.039 --> 00:50:41.800
I'm going to tell you something else. You might need
915
00:50:41.820 --> 00:50:42.280
some weed.
916
00:50:42.500 --> 00:50:42.559
No.
917
00:50:46.360 --> 00:50:49.409
So Don, where else can you point this trace logic?
918
00:50:50.230 --> 00:50:52.090
Is it just? Wait,
wait. He just spent 10 minutes
919
00:50:52.110 --> 00:50:54.969
talking about The Matrix. We got to go to the movie. Yeah, man.
920
00:50:55.030 --> 00:50:58.269
Because honestly, go ahead. Go ahead. I love it. We
921
00:50:58.289 --> 00:51:03.769
can't just sidestep The Matrix movie. Especially since he's literally describing.
922
00:51:03.809 --> 00:51:06.929
Especially since it's my favorite movie. Okay. Well, that's another reason.
923
00:51:06.949 --> 00:51:09.329
You got one of those sweaters that's full of holes.
924
00:51:09.829 --> 00:51:14.130
So when that movie came out in 1999, there was no,
925
00:51:14.809 --> 00:51:18.789
it was new to many people, but no one questioned it.
926
00:51:19.710 --> 00:51:25.010
the capability of an intelligent enough system for making you
927
00:51:25.110 --> 00:51:29.570
think you're experiencing anything it wants to without regard to
928
00:51:29.659 --> 00:51:35.980
what is happening external to your physicality. And that's a
929
00:51:36.219 --> 00:51:39.320
headset of a sort that's, what's the metaphor again? A
930
00:51:39.340 --> 00:51:46.469
VR headset of a sort except we're going directly to
931
00:51:46.489 --> 00:51:50.630
the neurons. We're not even using your senses. And so
932
00:51:51.369 --> 00:51:57.800
could you just comment on the foundational theme of humans
933
00:51:57.980 --> 00:52:00.860
being alive and living out their lives in their own
934
00:52:00.900 --> 00:52:04.260
minds and not in their bodies? And also how dreamy
935
00:52:04.320 --> 00:52:05.219
Keanu Reeves is.
936
00:52:08.460 --> 00:52:11.320
So, you know, The Matrix was my favorite movie at
937
00:52:11.340 --> 00:52:14.800
the time as well. It's still my favorite movie. It is.
938
00:52:14.949 --> 00:52:18.630
It probably still is, actually. I wrote a book in 1998,
939
00:52:18.630 --> 00:52:21.869
just the year before The Matrix came out, called Visual Intelligence,
940
00:52:21.969 --> 00:52:24.269
How We Create What We See. Exactly this stuff. So
941
00:52:24.289 --> 00:52:26.349
that's why I was so taken with The Matrix, because
942
00:52:26.369 --> 00:52:29.769
it was exactly what I was talking about in visual intelligence.
943
00:52:30.449 --> 00:52:32.789
And it gets very, very weird.
944
00:52:33.389 --> 00:52:33.969
Neurons.
945
00:52:34.690 --> 00:52:37.630
So I'm a neuroscientist and I studied neuroscience and I'm
946
00:52:37.849 --> 00:52:41.949
all for neuroscience. We have 86 billion neurons, trillions of synapses.
947
00:52:42.530 --> 00:52:44.610
And yet I say that neurons do not exist when
948
00:52:44.630 --> 00:52:48.210
they're not perceived. So what are neurons? They are a
949
00:52:48.349 --> 00:52:53.710
headset representation of how our headset is engineered. So neurons
950
00:52:54.610 --> 00:52:58.829
are a headset representation of how our headset is being created.
951
00:52:59.130 --> 00:53:02.289
So neuroscience is much harder than we thought. We don't
952
00:53:02.670 --> 00:53:05.829
just have to understand the wiring and the physiology. That's
953
00:53:05.889 --> 00:53:09.269
just the baby beginning. Now we have to reverse engineer
954
00:53:09.329 --> 00:53:12.789
it and ask what is the software outside of space-time,
955
00:53:13.449 --> 00:53:17.110
which when you project it into space-time looks like neurons
956
00:53:17.590 --> 00:53:21.679
and synapses and physiology. So we have a really hard
957
00:53:21.760 --> 00:53:24.219
task ahead of us. As long as we're thinking we're
958
00:53:24.260 --> 00:53:26.800
stuck inside space-time and this is the reality, we're actually
959
00:53:26.980 --> 00:53:29.840
missing the real science that's ahead of us. The real
960
00:53:29.940 --> 00:53:33.619
science is space-time is a trivial headset. Let's get on
961
00:53:33.679 --> 00:53:36.780
with the job of reverse engineering it and understanding the
962
00:53:36.820 --> 00:53:39.300
first layer of software that's outside of it. I think
963
00:53:39.340 --> 00:53:42.679
the positive geometries that the high-energy theoretical physicists are finding
964
00:53:43.159 --> 00:53:46.389
are a first step. And I'm hoping to show that
965
00:53:46.449 --> 00:53:51.469
their positive geometries are actually so-called sub-geometries of the Markov
966
00:53:51.510 --> 00:53:52.690
polytope that I'm working with.
967
00:53:53.059 --> 00:53:55.760
All I was asking was, do you think, as portrayed
968
00:53:55.780 --> 00:53:58.760
in The Matrix, you could meddle in someone's head and
969
00:53:58.800 --> 00:54:00.659
make them think they're living out their entire lives?
970
00:54:00.920 --> 00:54:05.579
Absolutely. Once you understand the software, you can play and
971
00:54:05.619 --> 00:54:07.639
you can do miracles. If you think about it, if
972
00:54:07.679 --> 00:54:10.389
you wrote, suppose you're the wizard in Grand Theft Auto,
973
00:54:10.409 --> 00:54:12.349
so you can drive the car as fast as anybody.
974
00:54:12.650 --> 00:54:15.849
You can play all the rules inside the game. But
975
00:54:15.889 --> 00:54:18.670
suppose you're a geek who can't really drive, but you
976
00:54:18.710 --> 00:54:21.780
wrote the software. You wrote the software of the game. Well,
977
00:54:21.800 --> 00:54:26.769
you can turn the expert, the wizard's car into a donkey.
978
00:54:27.449 --> 00:54:29.489
You can do whatever you want. So once you know
979
00:54:29.530 --> 00:54:32.469
the software, you can do magic. And my guess is,
980
00:54:33.380 --> 00:54:36.519
not just a guess, if this approach is correct, when
981
00:54:36.539 --> 00:54:39.500
we start to understand the software outside of our space-time headset,
982
00:54:40.380 --> 00:54:43.079
the technologies will be mind-blowing. Everything that we have right
983
00:54:43.119 --> 00:54:46.239
now will be trivial compared to the technologies we will have.
984
00:54:46.260 --> 00:54:49.300
That'll be the next season of Black Mirror. where you
985
00:54:49.340 --> 00:54:52.340
get
inside the brain. And it's a whole set of
986
00:54:52.719 --> 00:54:54.860
plot lines right there. And you know what?
987
00:54:54.900 --> 00:54:58.559
I mean, can we for a second, because there's a
988
00:54:58.579 --> 00:55:04.090
lot of people, we live in a very polarized, divisive time. Sure.
989
00:55:04.670 --> 00:55:07.510
And so. Unlike the Second World War or the First
990
00:55:07.530 --> 00:55:10.269
World War. Or the Revolutionary War. Or the Civil War.
991
00:55:10.409 --> 00:55:12.730
Or the Civil War. Or the Vietnam War. Yeah, we're
992
00:55:12.789 --> 00:55:14.269
uniquely divisive, Chuck. Yes.
993
00:55:14.369 --> 00:55:18.610
I mean, however, I will say that, you know, The
994
00:55:18.710 --> 00:55:22.829
difference is, in all those times, we didn't have this
995
00:55:23.150 --> 00:55:32.889
constant influence of manipulation called visuals in phones and social
996
00:55:32.929 --> 00:55:37.650
media and algorithms. And so I'm interested to hear what
997
00:55:37.750 --> 00:55:43.840
you think about the power that these things possess, not
998
00:55:43.889 --> 00:55:45.820
only individually, but societally.
999
00:55:45.840 --> 00:55:48.380
I'm going to re-ask that with fewer words. In what
1000
00:55:48.460 --> 00:55:52.360
way has the algorithm hijacked our evolutionary proclivities?
1001
00:55:53.119 --> 00:55:53.320
Damn!
1002
00:55:54.280 --> 00:55:56.880
I gotta leave now!
1003
00:55:58.320 --> 00:56:01.179
I'm so ashamed of my question! Did I capture what
1004
00:56:01.219 --> 00:56:01.659
you were saying?
1005
00:56:01.679 --> 00:56:03.469
Now you captured it all in one phrase.
1006
00:56:03.489 --> 00:56:03.849
There you go.
1007
00:56:03.929 --> 00:56:06.269
I hope they still play the whole question I asked, though,
1008
00:56:06.289 --> 00:56:09.170
just so that people can see that you captured it
1009
00:56:09.530 --> 00:56:10.250
all in one phrase.
1010
00:56:10.630 --> 00:56:10.929
Yes.
1011
00:56:11.829 --> 00:56:15.329
Well, great question, and actually quite pertinent.
1012
00:56:15.630 --> 00:56:22.679
In other words, are we humping the beer bottle? Hey man,
1013
00:56:23.219 --> 00:56:30.159
stop doing my job. I'm allowed two jokes per episode. Okay.
1014
00:56:30.360 --> 00:56:31.360
All right, go ahead.
1015
00:56:31.820 --> 00:56:34.530
The background that I have in neuroscience and evolutionary biology
1016
00:56:34.610 --> 00:56:37.530
and evolutionary game theory has made me of interest to
1017
00:56:37.570 --> 00:56:40.250
various companies because they asked me to help them with
1018
00:56:40.289 --> 00:56:43.900
their marketing and advertising and product design because I know
1019
00:56:43.940 --> 00:56:46.760
the rules of the game. And so I'll give you
1020
00:56:46.780 --> 00:56:49.800
a concrete, there's lots of examples. I'll just say at
1021
00:56:49.840 --> 00:56:52.880
top level, we know how to manipulate your attention to
1022
00:56:52.900 --> 00:56:55.010
make you want things that you don't even know that
1023
00:56:55.050 --> 00:56:58.230
we're doing. So the answer is yes. Once you know
1024
00:56:58.309 --> 00:57:00.670
the rules of the game, you can play them and
1025
00:57:00.769 --> 00:57:04.670
companies pay me to do that. It's out there. I'll
1026
00:57:04.690 --> 00:57:08.789
just give you a fun one though, but there are many. Jeans,
1027
00:57:09.769 --> 00:57:10.389
denim jeans.
1028
00:57:11.170 --> 00:57:11.510
Mm-hmm.
1029
00:57:12.139 --> 00:57:15.570
Your visual system has rules for how you create 3D objects.
1030
00:57:15.809 --> 00:57:18.050
How do you create 3D shapes? So this is all
1031
00:57:18.070 --> 00:57:22.510
part of the headset software. And shading gradients and lines
1032
00:57:22.570 --> 00:57:24.530
and so forth are used by the visual system to
1033
00:57:24.550 --> 00:57:27.429
create 3D shapes. When you put on jeans and they
1034
00:57:27.449 --> 00:57:29.969
have distress, they're trying to make them look distressed and
1035
00:57:30.010 --> 00:57:33.230
so forth, and they have stitching, you are telling a
1036
00:57:33.590 --> 00:57:36.989
3D story about the body of the person who's wearing
1037
00:57:37.030 --> 00:57:40.869
those jeans. The only question is, Do you, as the
1038
00:57:41.190 --> 00:57:44.989
clothing manufacturer, understand what story you're telling? And is it
1039
00:57:45.030 --> 00:57:47.610
the story that you want to tell? Are you giving
1040
00:57:47.650 --> 00:57:50.349
the person pancake butt when you didn't want to do that?
1041
00:57:50.769 --> 00:57:52.929
Or are you making them look good? So I went
1042
00:57:52.949 --> 00:57:54.969
to these jeans companies. Well, they came to me, actually.
1043
00:57:55.469 --> 00:57:58.360
And so I showed them. I said, look, you're creating
1044
00:57:58.420 --> 00:58:01.280
pancake butt. But here's how you can change the distress
1045
00:58:01.480 --> 00:58:03.199
so that all of a sudden you can make any
1046
00:58:03.280 --> 00:58:06.039
shape rear end that you want. And I remember the
1047
00:58:06.079 --> 00:58:09.000
CEO of one company saying, When I was giving the presentation,
1048
00:58:09.019 --> 00:58:11.420
I won't mention the company. He jumped out of his chair,
1049
00:58:11.840 --> 00:58:14.639
ran up to the slide screen that I was showing
1050
00:58:14.929 --> 00:58:17.590
how I did this. And he said, our jeans make
1051
00:58:17.630 --> 00:58:21.750
my butt look terrible. And so they bought it. And
1052
00:58:21.769 --> 00:58:23.289
I showed them how to do it. And they then
1053
00:58:23.389 --> 00:58:27.099
went and made the stitching on their jeans different and
1054
00:58:27.159 --> 00:58:30.199
the distress different. And you can make any shape that
1055
00:58:30.239 --> 00:58:31.739
you want once you know how to do it. So
1056
00:58:31.780 --> 00:58:34.900
this stuff is being used. Once you know the rules
1057
00:58:34.940 --> 00:58:37.440
of the headset, you can play the game and no
1058
00:58:37.500 -->
00:58:38.510
one knows that you're doing it.
1059
00:58:38.679 --> 00:58:42.300
It's funny because the same thing happens similarly in nature.
1060
00:58:42.340 --> 00:58:45.949
The reason why zebras have stripes is because they herd
1061
00:58:46.409 --> 00:58:49.590
and when they are being hunted and they run, all
1062
00:58:49.630 --> 00:58:53.110
the stripes visually confuse the lion.
1063
00:58:53.130 --> 00:58:57.349
Yeah, absolutely. Most of the time. Most of the time.
1064
00:58:57.409 --> 00:58:59.940
I've seen a whole lot of zebra legs up. Yeah,
1065
00:59:00.039 --> 00:59:04.280
I know. I know, it's terrible. Humans think they're quite small.
1066
00:59:04.320 --> 00:59:08.449
I should have had more stripes. I knew I needed
1067
00:59:08.469 --> 00:59:09.130
more stripes.
1068
00:59:11.570 --> 00:59:14.539
Humans think they're really smart. Some of them do anyway.
1069
00:59:14.900 --> 00:59:17.860
And we can manipulate each other as we've just discussed.
1070
00:59:18.400 --> 00:59:19.219
Yes. Okay.
1071
00:59:19.519 --> 00:59:22.260
And we can write code like in Grand Theft Auto.
1072
00:59:22.659 --> 00:59:29.059
But ultimately, who is writing and in charge of this holistic,
1073
00:59:29.380 --> 00:59:33.670
this consciousness, this place you're trying to get to through
1074
00:59:33.690 --> 00:59:34.630
your trace logic?
1075
00:59:35.409 --> 00:59:37.289
There is no top to the trace logic, which is
1076
00:59:37.329 --> 00:59:41.230
really quite interesting. These Markov matrices go off to infinity
1077
00:59:41.250 --> 00:59:43.840
in any direction that you want, and there's no top
1078
00:59:43.880 --> 00:59:48.219
to it. So there is a pre-established harmony like Leibniz envisioned.
1079
00:59:48.579 --> 00:59:51.159
They're all tied together with this trace logic, but there
1080
00:59:51.239 --> 00:59:55.030
is no top, which is quite stunning.
1081
00:59:55.340 --> 00:59:59.039
In what ways have theologians approached you as someone who's
1082
00:59:59.179 --> 01:00:01.090
opening up a box where they can put their God?
1083
01:00:01.989 --> 01:00:04.510
Representatives from almost every kind of religion have approached me
1084
01:00:05.210 --> 01:00:10.469
because I'm saying that in some sense, observation is fundamental.
1085
01:00:11.170 --> 01:00:13.539
And it's very, very close in spirit to those who
1086
01:00:13.559 --> 01:00:16.480
want to say consciousness is fundamental. I myself think consciousness
1087
01:00:16.519 --> 01:00:19.900
is fundamental, but I don't have to say that for
1088
01:00:19.920 --> 01:00:22.480
this mathematics. The mathematics can just be observation.
1089
01:00:23.380 --> 01:00:26.360
You've made that point. It's an important point. Otherwise, you're
1090
01:00:26.440 --> 01:00:30.280
intertwined with something else that needs an explanation. Why complicate
1091
01:00:30.300 --> 01:00:31.239
your account?
1092
01:00:32.039 --> 01:00:32.400
Exactly.
1093
01:00:32.500 --> 01:00:36.000
As far as
science is concerned, I'll just call it observation, period.
1094
01:00:36.260 --> 01:00:39.960
And any scientist would say, absolutely, we need a theory
1095
01:00:40.000 --> 01:00:44.159
of observation. Bring it on. Whereas consciousness is more controversial.
1096
01:00:44.920 --> 01:00:50.730
My own view, though, about the spiritual aspects is it
1097
01:00:50.789 --> 01:00:53.210
comes down to a very fundamental thing about science itself.
1098
01:00:53.849 --> 01:00:57.539
And that is It's very, very simple point. Every scientific
1099
01:00:57.579 --> 01:01:02.119
theory starts with assumptions, period. It says, if you grant
1100
01:01:02.159 --> 01:01:04.840
me these assumptions, then I can explain all this other
1101
01:01:04.900 --> 01:01:09.530
wonderful stuff. But no theory explains its own assumptions. Now
1102
01:01:09.570 --> 01:01:11.449
you can say, well, I'll give you a deeper theory
1103
01:01:11.550 --> 01:01:14.710
that explains the assumptions of that previous theory. Yes, you can.
1104
01:01:15.510 --> 01:01:17.530
And your deeper theory will have its own assumptions.
1105
01:01:17.550 --> 01:01:19.030
Turtles all the way down. Right.
1106
01:01:19.090 --> 01:01:22.250
Turtles all the way down. And so there will never
1107
01:01:22.309 --> 01:01:25.510
be a theory of everything in principle. because we'll never
1108
01:01:25.860 --> 01:01:28.869
have a theory that explains us on assumptions. So there
1109
01:01:28.909 --> 01:01:29.769
is no theory of everything.
1110
01:01:30.409 --> 01:01:33.170
That's a girdle's incompleteness theorem right there.
1111
01:01:33.190 --> 01:01:36.170
It really is. It's a girdle's incompleteness theorem. So it's
1112
01:01:36.210 --> 01:01:41.630
a scientific incompleteness theorem as well. So when we sometimes
1113
01:01:41.670 --> 01:01:45.130
talk about the God of the gaps, well, I'm a scientist.
1114
01:01:45.230 --> 01:01:48.909
I love science. I love the rigor of science. We
1115
01:01:48.969 --> 01:01:53.349
do not assume that our assumptions are true. in science,
1116
01:01:53.409 --> 01:01:56.989
we assume that our assumptions are consistent. We know that
1117
01:01:57.010 --> 01:01:59.789
they're never the final truth. We're always gonna have some
1118
01:01:59.869 --> 01:02:02.369
deeper layer to go to. What we have to assume
1119
01:02:02.650 --> 01:02:04.710
is not that we have the truth, but that we
1120
01:02:04.750 --> 01:02:08.969
have a consistent set of starting assumptions If they were
1121
01:02:09.070 --> 01:02:10.730
not consistent, then we could prove anything.
1122
01:02:11.150 --> 01:02:14.690
And that's why scientists don't murder one another for their findings.
1123
01:02:15.929 --> 01:02:20.000
Generally, that's correct. Yeah, there are no marauding scientists on
1124
01:02:20.039 --> 01:02:24.519
the front line. E equals MC cubed, not squared.
1125
01:02:25.519 --> 01:02:28.739
And so we're infinitely far from the theory of everything.
1126
01:02:29.780 --> 01:02:31.679
So I'm not worried about a God of the gaps.
1127
01:02:32.960 --> 01:02:35.679
Science is infinitely far from a theory of everything. And
1128
01:02:35.940 --> 01:02:38.599
so I don't have a theory of God. And I'm
1129
01:02:38.820 --> 01:02:40.679
not a God of the gaps kind of guy.
1130
01:02:40.920 --> 01:02:43.019
Well, God of the gaps has been replaced by aliens.
1131
01:02:43.159 --> 01:02:45.940
You don't understand something as aliens. And so aliens of
1132
01:02:45.960 --> 01:02:48.449
the gaps doesn't have the same ring to it. So
1133
01:02:49.389 --> 01:02:55.769
in my book, I coined the phrase aliens of our ignorance. Nice. Yeah.
1134
01:02:56.469 --> 01:03:00.159
Don, what's the timeline on this research? which is ironic
1135
01:03:00.179 --> 01:03:01.260
seeing as space-time is doomed.
1136
01:03:02.860 --> 01:03:04.099
Do you have a timeline?
1137
01:03:04.159 --> 01:03:07.550
You've got a new kind of watch. That's how many dimensions.
1138
01:03:07.570 --> 01:03:11.789
So do you have a timeline for the work that
1139
01:03:11.829 --> 01:03:12.949
you're undertaking now?
1140
01:03:14.150 --> 01:03:17.130
Yes, I have a group. We're starting something called the
1141
01:03:17.190 --> 01:03:19.889
Trace Research Institute, and it's going to be coming out
1142
01:03:19.929 --> 01:03:22.570
in June, actually. We're being announced in June. And I
1143
01:03:22.849 --> 01:03:26.969
have some mathematicians and physicists working with me We have
1144
01:03:26.989 --> 01:03:30.900
eight specific mathematical conjectures that I'm hoping to prove in
1145
01:03:30.940 --> 01:03:33.360
the next three years. So that's sort of the goal,
1146
01:03:33.420 --> 01:03:36.440
to have these proven in the next three years. And
1147
01:03:37.340 --> 01:03:40.000
the idea would be we start with this trace logic
1148
01:03:40.079 --> 01:03:44.989
on observers and show exactly how we get first special relativity,
1149
01:03:45.530 --> 01:03:50.309
then general relativity, quantum field theory, non-locality, and so forth.
1150
01:03:50.510 --> 01:03:53.469
And then, so that's the idea, is to start to
1151
01:03:54.119 --> 01:03:59.250
reverse engineer our space-time headset by starting with observers that
1152
01:03:59.530 --> 01:04:02.750
could build a space-time headset, but they could build almost
1153
01:04:02.849 --> 01:04:06.329
anything else. And that's the key point. Observers can build
1154
01:04:06.489 --> 01:04:09.250
any headset that they want. Space-time is one of the
1155
01:04:09.289 --> 01:04:11.329
more trivial ones. It's only four dimensions.
1156
01:04:12.050 --> 01:04:15.869
Wow. You just dissed humans right there. Well, you know,
1157
01:04:15.889 --> 01:04:18.989
we are very dissable. Dissable. I've got to say. Have
1158
01:04:19.010 --> 01:04:22.179
you looked around lately? We really are dissable.
1159
01:04:22.760 --> 01:04:26.079
Well, actually, I'll turn that around now. I'll say something
1160
01:04:26.119 -->
01:04:31.000
about you and me. We are not our avatars. These
1161
01:04:31.199 --> 01:04:36.190
bodies in three-dimensional space, one dimension of time, there's a
1162
01:04:36.250 --> 01:04:40.449
Neil avatar, there's a Chuck and then Don. All these
1163
01:04:40.510 --> 01:04:44.690
avatars are just avatars. You're not your avatar. This is
1164
01:04:44.730 --> 01:04:47.530
just an avatar and a headset. So this is where
1165
01:04:47.550 --> 01:04:50.960
it does sound spiritual. Now, whoever you are, whatever you are,
1166
01:04:51.659 --> 01:04:55.530
it's not something inside space and time space and time
1167
01:04:55.789 --> 01:05:00.170
is inside you that's your creation on the fly you're
1168
01:05:00.269 --> 01:05:03.860
rendering your body so my hand is something i render
1169
01:05:04.019 --> 01:05:06.519
on the fly when i look at my hand and
1170
01:05:07.019 --> 01:05:09.159
with that otherwise there is no hand the hand is
1171
01:05:09.280 --> 01:05:13.159
just a headset avatar representation is there a way.
1172
01:05:13.099 --> 01:05:19.570
I can render a few choice bigger parts Well, DMT.
1173
01:05:21.820 --> 01:05:24.980
So I got to land this plane here. Let me
1174
01:05:25.059 --> 01:05:29.880
ask you the ultimate skeptical question. Sure. Let's say you
1175
01:05:29.920 --> 01:05:34.349
come out with this account of all that your ambitions
1176
01:05:34.590 --> 01:05:41.730
hold for you. What prediction can you make from that
1177
01:05:41.889 --> 01:05:47.699
new formulation that will give confidence that the new formulation
1178
01:05:48.329 --> 01:05:54.699
is real. Because what you described, it sounds like you
1179
01:05:54.719 --> 01:05:59.920
are in a position, you've constructed this literal matrix to
1180
01:05:59.980 --> 01:06:03.849
account for everything. And is that any different from the,
1181
01:06:04.920 --> 01:06:08.420
you know, how the leopard got its spots? The Richard
1182
01:06:08.460 --> 01:06:11.510
Kipling just so stories. I'm gonna make an explanation of
1183
01:06:11.530 --> 01:06:13.389
that's how it got its spots and here we are.
1184
01:06:13.840 --> 01:06:15.559
I'm going to make an explanation, which is why you
1185
01:06:15.579 --> 01:06:17.800
don't see this and you'd like that. And we got
1186
01:06:17.820 --> 01:06:21.039
a FaceTime here and it collapses there and we got relativity, boom.
1187
01:06:21.900 --> 01:06:22.659
Give me a prediction.
1188
01:06:23.030 --> 01:06:25.989
So the first thing we'll have to do is to
1189
01:06:26.110 --> 01:06:27.869
first show that we can get, for example, all of
1190
01:06:27.909 --> 01:06:30.510
special and general relativity and quantum field theory. We have
1191
01:06:30.550 --> 01:06:33.269
to do that first, right? But then we can take
1192
01:06:33.329 --> 01:06:35.429
the next step, which is to say, you know, Einstein
1193
01:06:35.469 --> 01:06:38.659
had to assume that the speed of light is the
1194
01:06:38.699 --> 01:06:40.500
same in all
inertial frames and that nothing could go
1195
01:06:40.519 --> 01:06:43.139
faster than the speed of light. That's an assumption. What
1196
01:06:43.159 --> 01:06:44.940
if we can prove that? What if we can show
1197
01:06:44.980 --> 01:06:47.219
from this deeper theory that it must be the case
1198
01:06:47.420 --> 01:06:49.719
in your headset that the speed of light is the
1199
01:06:49.739 --> 01:06:52.699
maximum speed? Now, all of a sudden, something that Einstein
1200
01:06:52.739 --> 01:06:56.030
had to assume, we show follows from the theory of
1201
01:06:56.070 --> 01:06:56.619
the observers.
1202
01:06:57.090 --> 01:06:58.909
That'd be a good one, by the way.
1203
01:06:58.929 --> 01:07:00.849
That would be one of my first ones that I
1204
01:07:00.889 --> 01:07:02.789
want to go to. And I can give you a
1205
01:07:02.869 --> 01:07:04.650
little hint as to where I think it's going to
1206
01:07:04.690 --> 01:07:07.889
come from. It turns out in a Markov chain, there
1207
01:07:08.050 --> 01:07:10.610
is something called a commute time, how quickly you can
1208
01:07:10.630 --> 01:07:14.670
go from one observation to another, and there is a
1209
01:07:14.750 --> 01:07:17.710
maximum commute time, a minimum commute time, and therefore a
1210
01:07:17.829 --> 01:07:21.840
fastest transition, and it's something called cyclic Markov chains. And
1211
01:07:21.880 --> 01:07:24.639
so the direction I'm gonna be going is, That because
1212
01:07:24.760 --> 01:07:27.989
there is a maximum speed of transition in Markov chains,
1213
01:07:28.429 --> 01:07:30.230
that's where the speed of light maximum is going to
1214
01:07:30.269 --> 01:07:34.070
come from. So that will be a completely new out
1215
01:07:34.130 --> 01:07:37.849
of the construct, a new construct for it. But that
1216
01:07:37.889 --> 01:07:39.829
will just be the beginning because then I want to
1217
01:07:39.889 --> 01:07:43.329
actually show once we go into these higher dimensions, I
1218
01:07:43.369 --> 01:07:46.989
can then start building technologies. Remember, my clock, if I
1219
01:07:47.010 --> 01:07:50.159
have a bigger space time than you, my clock is
1220
01:07:50.219 --> 01:07:52.219
ticking a lot more than you. That means I can
1221
01:07:52.260 --> 01:07:58.070
do miracles. Right. Because for two ticks of your clock,
1222
01:07:58.170 --> 01:08:00.329
I might have a million ticks of my clock. So
1223
01:08:00.369 --> 01:08:02.429
I can be doing all sorts of stuff. So this
1224
01:08:02.489 --> 01:08:05.190
may be how I'll explain UAP kind of phenomena that
1225
01:08:05.389 --> 01:08:09.469
seem to violate the laws of physics. They do violate
1226
01:08:09.590 --> 01:08:12.489
our laws if you're stuck in our headset, but they
1227
01:08:12.530 --> 01:08:14.969
may have a headset in which their clock is ticking
1228
01:08:15.010 --> 01:08:17.250
a million times to one tick of ours. And so
1229
01:08:17.270 --> 01:08:20.430
what looks like instantaneous acceleration to us is for them
1230
01:08:20.869 --> 01:08:21.949
a walk in the park.
1231
01:08:22.399 --> 01:08:26.420
Or just a fuzzy video artifact of a monochromatic data-taking device.
1232
01:08:26.779 --> 01:08:33.630
But okay. That's right. One or the other. So I
1233
01:08:33.670 --> 01:08:36.350
got you. So it's the experience of something that would
1234
01:08:36.369 --> 01:08:39.529
be normal in their reference frame that to us looks
1235
01:08:39.590 --> 01:08:41.109
extraordinary or even miraculous.
1236
01:08:41.229 --> 01:08:41.390
Right.
1237
01:08:41.670 --> 01:08:41.989
That's right.
1238
01:08:42.649 --> 01:08:45.729
And there's another aspect of this that's really quite interesting.
1239
01:08:46.590 --> 01:08:48.439
If you think about it, I look around and I
1240
01:08:48.449 --> 01:08:51.300
see an ant. And I ask myself, how much does
1241
01:08:51.340 --> 01:08:55.699
the ant... see about me? My feeling is probably nothing,
1242
01:08:55.779 --> 01:08:58.710
almost nothing. It doesn't know anything about me. But then,
1243
01:08:58.810 --> 01:09:01.520
and if you ask, okay, so how would it represent me?
1244
01:09:01.649 --> 01:09:03.189
It might not even represent me at all, but if
1245
01:09:03.260 --> 01:09:06.220
it does represent me, it's something trivial. Well, now turn
1246
01:09:06.239 --> 01:09:11.640
it around. I see the ant as fairly trivial, but remember,
1247
01:09:12.760 --> 01:09:15.779
this is just a headset. The headset dumbs things down.
1248
01:09:16.600 --> 01:09:18.479
It's quite possible that what I see as an ant
1249
01:09:19.270 --> 01:09:23.880
I'm actually, the reality that I'm interacting with is so transcendent,
1250
01:09:23.979 --> 01:09:26.159
so much bigger than me that if I can actually
1251
01:09:26.220 --> 01:09:29.899
understand it, I would fall down speechless before. But my
1252
01:09:29.939 --> 01:09:33.239
headset turns it down into a tiny little ant. So
1253
01:09:33.439 --> 01:09:35.500
this gives us a sort of a different way of
1254
01:09:35.720 --> 01:09:39.420
looking at everything around us. What I'm seeing is my
1255
01:09:39.520 --> 01:09:44.460
headset dumbed down representation of something that's not inside the headset.
1256
01:09:44.760 --> 01:09:46.640
So it changes the whole game of how I look
1257
01:09:46.659 --> 01:09:49.479
at the world. I see an ant. And I have
1258
01:09:49.699 --> 01:09:52.300
no idea what I'm really dealing with. All I know
1259
01:09:52.420 --> 01:09:56.460
is my headset is so stupid that it's just showing
1260
01:09:56.500 --> 01:09:57.760
me an ant. That's what I know.
1261
01:09:58.180 --> 01:10:02.859
So just touching on Darwin's theory, origins of species, et cetera,
1262
01:10:03.810 --> 01:10:08.270
obviously pre-internet, pre-computers, are you kind of telling us that
1263
01:10:08.350 --> 01:10:11.529
it is the most amazing theory and all it needed
1264
01:10:11.590 --> 01:10:15.449
was mathematics to show how amazing it was?
1265
01:10:16.310
--> 01:10:20.420
Well, I think that Darwin's theory is... brilliant and evolutionary
1266
01:10:20.479 --> 01:10:24.239
game theory. The mathematics really brought out all the wonderful
1267
01:10:24.310 --> 01:10:28.409
power of Darwin's theory. But now I step back. It's
1268
01:10:28.449 --> 01:10:31.130
a theory that's sort of tied to our headset, right?
1269
01:10:31.449 --> 01:10:35.930
Every scientific theory has its scope and also its limits.
1270
01:10:36.310 --> 01:10:39.409
So I think inside the headset, Darwin is the best
1271
01:10:39.470 --> 01:10:42.630
theory that we have for understanding biology inside of our headset.
1272
01:10:43.189 --> 01:10:45.350
Once we get outside the headset, I will want to
1273
01:10:45.409 --> 01:10:48.100
find a deeper theory and show how Darwin's theory is
1274
01:10:48.159 --> 01:10:51.819
a special case of something far deeper. But that's going
1275
01:10:51.840 --> 01:10:52.279
to be the thing.
1276
01:10:52.300 --> 01:10:56.720
Now you're getting greedy. Einstein wasn't good enough. You're going
1277
01:10:56.739 --> 01:10:58.340
to throw Darwin into the pot.
1278
01:10:58.939 --> 01:11:02.699
Science must always get to deeper theories. We always expect
1279
01:11:02.729 --> 01:11:04.470
that our theories are just stepping stones.
1280
01:11:06.029 --> 01:11:10.250
I love that. Professor Hoffman, this has been a delightful conversation.
1281
01:11:10.329 --> 01:11:16.399
Thanks for giving us a peek into your madness. You
1282
01:11:16.420 --> 01:11:19.340
want to say that again? Thanks for giving us a
1283
01:11:19.420 --> 01:11:22.939
peek into your genius. How about that? And they are
1284
01:11:23.060 --> 01:11:27.890
the same thing. Or rather, a peek into your headset.
1285
01:11:28.470 --> 01:11:30.529
It's been a great pleasure and a lot of fun.
1286
01:11:31.090 --> 01:11:32.310
I enjoy laughing with you guys.
1287
01:11:32.689 --> 01:11:35.170
Excellent, excellent. So good luck with that. Do you have
1288
01:11:35.189 --> 01:11:36.979
a good website for people to track or is it
1289
01:11:36.989 --> 01:11:37.409
all secret?
1290
01:11:38.060 --> 01:11:41.520
I have, for those who are scientists, if you do
1291
01:11:41.560 --> 01:11:44.310
Google Scholar on Donald Hoffman, you'll find a hundred papers
1292
01:11:44.399 --> 01:11:45.390
that I've got on Google Scholar.
1293
01:11:45.409 --> 01:11:48.510
Yeah, Google Scholar, people don't know, gains access to research
1294
01:11:48.569 --> 01:11:52.189
journals and provided there aren't other Donald Hoffmans out there,
1295
01:11:52.229 --> 01:11:54.649
you'll know, get all of his papers. But it's pretty
1296
01:11:54.689 --> 01:11:55.329
easy to filter.
1297
01:11:55.510 --> 01:11:55.710
Yes.
1298
01:11:55.989 --> 01:11:56.149
Yeah.
1299
01:11:56.189 --> 01:11:59.319
So we're announcing a Trace Research Institute, which is going
1300
01:11:59.359 --> 01:12:04.500
to be pursuing this research in the summer of 2026.
1301
01:12:04.500 --> 01:12:07.760
And the greatest value there, which we've, we've seen since
1302
01:12:07.840 --> 01:12:10.960
the early 90s when I think NASA was early out
1303
01:12:10.979 --> 01:12:15.579
of the box to recognize the value of multidisciplinary thinking.
1304
01:12:17.039 --> 01:12:19.920
They didn't ask how would a physicist do this? They said,
1305
01:12:20.399 --> 01:12:23.000
let us take on the topic of origins. Well, there's
1306
01:12:23.020 --> 01:12:26.039
the origins of the planet, of life, of the solar system,
1307
01:12:26.060 --> 01:12:30.079
and everybody got together in the coffee room and got
1308
01:12:30.100 --> 01:12:33.430
to share notes in ways that were previously siloed. So
1309
01:12:33.510 --> 01:12:41.369
in this new institute, You're going to have mathematicians, presumably biologists. Absolutely. Neuroscientists. Absolutely.
1310
01:12:41.449 --> 01:12:42.869
Any room for astrophysicists?
1311
01:12:43.130 --> 01:12:45.630
Yeah, absolutely. We want to get our own theory of
1312
01:12:45.649 --> 01:12:46.289
the Big Bang.
1313
01:12:46.310 --> 01:12:50.329
Do you need a job? No, I'm gainfully employed here.
1314
01:12:50.350 --> 01:12:51.010
I'm just checking.
1315
01:12:51.029 --> 01:12:54.770
No, absolutely. Actually, one of our conjectures is a new
1316
01:12:54.810 --> 01:12:57.600
way of modeling the Big Bang from the Markov chain.
1317
01:12:57.640 --> 01:13:00.020
So we have to do it all, or go big
1318
01:13:00.060 --> 01:13:00.460
or go.
1319
01:13:00.359 --> 01:13:01.819
Home, basically. All right.
1320
01:13:01.960 --> 01:13:02.239
All right.
1321
01:13:02.279 --> 01:13:03.220
There he is. Okay.
1322
01:13:03.529 --> 01:13:05.229
I don't think we need to say anything else after that.
1323
01:13:05.510 --> 01:13:06.970
Okay, sir. Thanks for joining us.
1324
01:13:07.229 --> 01:13:08.449
Thank you so much. It was a pleasure.
1325
01:13:08.649 --> 01:13:12.939
All right. This has been StarTalk Special Edition. What do
1326
01:13:12.949 --> 01:13:16.439
we call this one? The nature of reality. The nature
1327
01:13:16.479 --> 01:13:23.199
of reality. And in the end, it's just a matrix. Chuck,
1328
01:13:23.279 --> 01:13:25.659
always good to have you. Always a pleasure. Yeah, Ray. Pleasure, Neil.
1329
01:13:25.720 --> 01:13:30.479
All in. Neil deGrasse Tyson here, your personal astrophysicist. Keep
1330
01:13:30.500 --> 01:13:30.899
looking up.