TRASCRIZIONE 🔗
Sidedoor (S12E18) – Lonnie Bunch final web transcript
Lizzie Peabody: I feel a little bit more formal than I usually do on the show, because I have so much respect for you and for your position.
Lonnie Bunch: Oh, please. You don't have to be that formal.
Lizzie: That's what I'm feeling right now.
Lonnie Bunch: I'm just some guy from Jersey trying to make it in the big city.
Lizzie: You say that, but you know it's not true.
Lonnie Bunch: Oh, it is. You always keep yourself—remember who you are, not who they think you are.
Lizzie: Okay.
Lizzie: This is Sidedoor, a podcast from the Smithsonian with support from PRX. I'm Lizzie Peabody. Okay, Sidedoorables, today we have an extra special treat for you: a chance to sit down with the big boss, the Secretary of the Smithsonian, the one in charge of it all, to talk about America's 250th birthday. And more particularly, about an exhibition he himself has curated in its honor, on display for just a couple months in the Smithsonian Castle, "American Aspirations." And it looks back at the founding of our nation, and the values and aspirations that have and continue to shape this great nation. So I am sitting down with the secretary to talk about how the heck you choose which objects tell the story of American aspiration. Welcome to the show, Secretary Bunch.
Lonnie Bunch: Thank you. It's my great pleasure.
Lizzie: Is it okay if I call you Lonnie?
Lonnie Bunch: Please.
Lizzie: Okay. You can call me Lizzie.
Lonnie Bunch: Well, you know, no, I wasn't going to. You're too formal.
Lizzie: [laughs] So I want to talk about the exhibition.
Lonnie Bunch: Mm-hmm.
Lizzie: But first, I want to ask, you know, when you think about the nation turning 250, what emotion comes first?
Lonnie Bunch: Well, I think that what's important is to recognize that the challenge for America is to find common ground. And for me, it's the 250th, and celebrating Jefferson allows us to understand what America was, what it is, but maybe what it can be. And I've always been shaped by words that were said to me by a sharecropper that I was working with 30 years ago in South Carolina, who said, "I'm not sure what a historian does, but maybe your job is to help people remember, but help them remember not just what they want, but what they need to remember." And I think that's part of what we want to do at the Smithsonian, is give people what they want, but also what they need to be able to understand and find clarity and find hope.
Lizzie: I think the Rolling Stones would be proud.
Lonnie Bunch: Absolutely. [laughs]
Lizzie: So, you are the secretary of the Smithsonian, which, just to make sure everybody's on the same page, does not mean that you get coffee for other people and book hotels. You are, to put it plainly, the boss.
Lonnie Bunch: But I do get coffee and book hotels, too, so ...
Lizzie: [laughs] Well, that is good to know. But you also steward the entire institution, which I think is a role that carries a lot of responsibility, but especially at a time when our national narratives are so publicly in contention. Before you were the boss, you were a curator. How long has it been since you've curated an exhibition yourself?
Lonnie Bunch: Well, I curated a lot of the exhibitions in the National Museum of African American History and Culture, and that opened 10 years ago. So it's been a while since I've done things at the Smithsonian, but I've always helped other museums around the country doing exhibitions. So, you know, the key to being the secretary is never lose who you are as a historian. And so that's why it was especially important for me to do this as well.
Lizzie: Yeah, I was gonna ask, what made you put your curatorial hat back on after so many years?
Lonnie Bunch: I mean, I think it's this notion of, first of all, it's who you are, right? I mean, I'm a historian. When all else fails, I'm reading history or thinking about the past. But also, I realized that at this stage, I had a long vision of what I think a good exhibition is, what I think America could use. So it was really the chance to do that, and also to remember that what this exhibition is, it really is a centerpiece. And so I really wanted it to be this sort of crown jewel-like exhibit that would give people an opportunity to be intimate with these objects.
Lizzie: I love that you use the word "intimate," because the exhibition really does have that feel. You go into this dark space. It's small, it's kind of cozy feeling. Tall ceilings, though.
Lonnie Bunch: Right. Right.
Lizzie: So it's grand, but it's cozy. And the objects are lit almost like jewels. You said the crown jewel. Was that part of your vision? Absolutely.
Lonnie Bunch: Absolutely. I mean, the goal was that—you know, I've curated so many exhibitions, from when I was in American History to others, and often in an exhibition, you're distant from the object. People sort of graze by. What I wanted was that to think about the 250th, I wanted you to be intimate with the ideas, with the hopes, with the challenges and with the objects that would do that. So rather than try to find 200 objects that would tell a story, I thought, let's just take a small number, even though that means you can't tell every aspect of it, but use it like jewel-like, almost like a relic. So it really was an opportunity to sort of not overwhelm, but to challenge people to recognize the great strength of a nation is to recognize that it's a work in progress, that America, people have debated, voted, died, protested, marched to help make concrete the ideals of Jefferson. And there's nothing wrong with celebrating that, because we are a very different nation than we were 250 years ago, partly because we had the founding ideals. We had people who grabbed them and said, "Let's make them real."
Lizzie: This may seem like a basic question, but I did want to touch on this before we delve into the objects themselves.
Lonnie
Load full transcript
Bunch: Sure.
Lizzie: In the digital age, why objects?
Lonnie Bunch: Well, I've thought a lot about that. I mean, when I was building the African American Museum, there were initial discussions about just do it digitally. But there's something unbelievably powerful about watching people engage with an object. It is both the sort of sense of reducing it to human scale. So you're not talking about immigration, you're looking at a particular object. And also, I think what's so powerful about it is the interactions that occur. I don't know how many times in my career I've watched people engage with an object with people they don't know. Somebody will sort of ask a question and somebody will overhear and say, "Well, you know what I think about this?" And so there's a sense of learning that comes from that kind of informal engagement. And I think the other issue for me is that the objects are pretty cool. [laughs]
Lizzie: They are. They are. But that's such a great point you make—something conceptual, concrete.
Lonnie Bunch: Yes. I mean, I think that's really the key. And that it's also about how do you humanize? I think the challenge from history is that we talk about slavery, immigration, work, voting rights, but sometimes we forget that people sort of were doing it as individuals. And I want you to reduce it to human scale. I think that the great strength is to never forget it's about people. It's not about the broad themes, it's about people.
Lizzie: These objects together are telling the story of the nation, or the story of a nation in pursuit of its founding ideals.
Lonnie Bunch: Yes. Yes.
Lizzie: Here at Sidedoor, we're in the business of telling stories. Stories are made of details, and the details that you select to include in the story amount to the story you tell.
Lonnie Bunch: Right.
Lizzie: So in this case, the details are the objects. How did you think about selecting which details to include in this particular telling?
Lonnie Bunch: You always try to find the right tension between scholarship and presentation. And for me, I used to be a lousy filmmaker, so for me exhibitions are always about the visual. How do you make them like a film? And so what I realized is that in films you've got a couple of scenes that may carry.
Lizzie: Mm-hmm.
Lonnie Bunch: And so I thought, let's just do that. Let's find a couple of objects, let them carry the weight. Let them not answer every question,
Lizzie: Mm-hmm.
Lonnie Bunch: But let them be the way that we can guide people into thinking. And so it was really thinking about what are the aspirations we wanted to explore, you know, the pursuit of democracy, the pursuit of hope, the pursuit of freedom, the defending democracy. And for me, my favorite pursuit is always the pursuit of fairness. And so I wanted to sort of look at those themes, and as we grappled with that, then I said, "Okay, what do we really want to say? What object can really carry that or open the door to further questioning?"
Lizzie: Right.
Lonnie Bunch: And for us, it was always starting with the Jefferson desk. You know, as somebody who was a curator in political history early in my career, I remember very passionately discovering two things. I had come back to the Smithsonian in the late '80s, and I was opening drawers, trying to find stuff. And I opened one drawer, and there was Abraham Lincoln's top hat that he wore the night he was assassinated. I was like, "Okay, Smithsonian's pretty cool."
Lizzie: [laughs]
Lonnie Bunch: And then I opened a drawer, and there was the compass that Lewis and Clark carried when they went across the country, which taught me as a curator the key is not to be smart, just don't drop anything. That was really my understanding. And then I stumbled upon the Jefferson desk, and the fact that this tiny little desk was really something that Jefferson wrote some of the most powerful words ever, that the Declaration of Independence was drafted piece by piece on that desk. And that, to me, was both a way to humanize Jefferson, but also a way to sort of try to help people understand what those ideals were. And what I loved about the desk more than anything else is that Jefferson realized this was important so he put a little note in it, making sure people knew that that was the desk he wrote the Declaration of Independence on.
Lizzie: Really?
Lonnie Bunch: Yep.
Lizzie: Oh, so he was thinking down the line.
Lonnie Bunch: Oh, absolutely. And then a year before he died in 1825, he gave it to his granddaughter's husband, a guy named Joseph Coolidge. And Coolidge kept it, and then, you know, sort of almost 50 years later, they decided to give it to the United States government, and it was accepted by acclamation by both houses of Congress. And so it sat in the State Department, and then came to the Smithsonian in the 1920s. So for me, it is both the amazing object that it is, but also the fact that it survived.
Lizzie: Mm-hmm.
Lonnie Bunch: And that the Smithsonian really is the place that people trust to keep those objects, because those objects are really their memories.
Lizzie: Yeah, I want to dive back into the desk. I think, you know, this exhibition is up for a very short time, two months, which is a blink of an eye in museum time.
Lonnie Bunch: Right.
Lizzie: So most of our listeners will never get the chance to see it in person. So I'm hoping you can lead us on a little bit of a backstage tour of some of these objects. And the Jefferson desk that you mentioned, that is the first thing that you see when you walk into this room. It's right in front of you. And when I think "desk," this is not what I picture.
Lonnie Bunch: Right.
Lizzie: So, describe the desk for us, its scale. You know, what are we looking at?
Lonnie Bunch: So Jefferson called it a "writing box," right? It's probably 13 inches by 12 inches. It's not a big box, but what it is, is it's very creative. You open it, and you can
see where pens and inks and paper are kept, but you could also see how in an age of mobility, when you're in coaches or horseback, you can carry that with you. And the fact that you would be in meetings all day debating the future of the nation, and then you could go back to your room and pull that out and begin to draft the Declaration, it's so powerful to me.
Lizzie: Yeah. Yeah, you can see these pen scratches and the hinges. And it's got a little drawer that—does it ...
Lonnie Bunch: Right. It's got a little drawer.
Lizzie: The drawer pulls out with almost like a little pencil organizer.
Lonnie Bunch: I mean, I think about—to me, that's about reducing it to human scale.
Lizzie: Yeah.
Lonnie Bunch: You know? It's the scratches, it's the pen marks. It's the fact that Jefferson carried that with him and kept it his whole life.
Lizzie: Yeah, I think it takes something like the Declaration of Independence, which I think we can sort of think of as something that descended from heaven.
Lonnie Bunch: Right. Right.
Lizzie: And places it in the lap of a man with a pen, sitting in a coach, in his office, writing. And it does situate it in a time and a place, and also, I think, in the hands of a man who was writing about equality at a time of great contradiction.
Lonnie Bunch: But writing about equality for some, not all, right?
Lizzie: Right.
Lonnie Bunch: And so that's why I think, to me, the Declaration's foundational, because you could argue that whether it's Lincoln and the Civil War, whether it's women and the right to vote or whether it's the African American desire to fight for civil rights, they look back to that language and say, "Wait a minute, you promised. You expected this to happen."
Lizzie: Mm-hmm.
Lonnie Bunch: And so what our job is is not to do something that is revolutionary. All we're trying to do is make real the revolution of Jefferson. And so I think to me, that's what's so powerful about it, is that America has always been aspiring to the promised land. It may never get there, but those aspirations are part of the strength of a nation. That's what excites me.
Lizzie: So those words in the Declaration of Independence are written in a replicated copy of the Declaration, which in the exhibition is right above the desk. Why does that particular engraving exist, and what made you select it?
Lonnie Bunch: First of all, what's important is I wanted to juxtapose the desk with the words, right? I didn't want it just to be a desk, because I could get excited about how this was made, but it's really the words that came off that were written on that desk. And then what I love is we have what is known as a "Stone copy" of the Declaration. In the 1820s, John Quincy Adams looked at the original Declaration and realized that it was fading. You can now see it in the National Archives, and it's still hard to see it. And they've preserved it for, you know, years now. But he realized that he needed somehow to preserve
it, so he went to Mr. Stone to say, "I want you to make an engraving so we can do this." And then he did. He gave a copy of the engraving to all the living signers of the Declaration who were still around in the 1820s. But he basically made 200 copies of those, and there are only a few in existence, and we have one. And so for me, it was both about here's a way to see the words, but it's also about a country recognizing how important it is to preserve its history. And that these documents—I always like to say that the Stone copy says to me documents may fade, but the words are engraved and they stay with us forever. And so I really like that as a way to juxtapose Jefferson's ideals, but the sort of living notion of how do you preserve those words.
Lizzie: When I heard there was a Stone engraving in the exhibition, I thought it was literally chiseled into a tablet, you know?
Lonnie Bunch: [laughs]
Lizzie: And I got really excited, because I thought that must have been incredibly labor-intensive.
Lonnie Bunch: That would have been hard.
Lizzie: That would have been hard. So not literally set in stone, but set in just Stone engraving.
Lonnie Bunch: No, that's right. Set in a copper engraving.
Lizzie: Yes.
***
Lizzie: Hey there, Sidedoorables. Welcome back to Sidedoor's very own 250th birthday party to the United States of America. I'm partying it up with Secretary Lonnie Bunch, and he is leading me proverbially, through the "American Aspirations" exhibit, which tells the story of who we are as Americans through our founding values. So walking through this exhibition, you'll see the Declaration of Independence, you will see the Star-Spangled Banner, and then you'll see Amelia Earhart's flight suit, which, at first glance, feels kind of like a swerve. But evidently, to you, it belongs in the same conversation. So why?
Lonnie Bunch: Part of what is so powerful to me is the aspiration to go beyond what is expected. And as somebody who started at the Air and Space Museum as this 25-year-old kid, I've always had this fascination with aviation. But for me, Amelia Earhart's flight suit is really about saying the strength of a nation is to allow people to soar beyond where they think they are.
Lizzie: Okay.
Lonnie Bunch: And for Amelia Earhart to basically, you know, solo across the Atlantic in 1932, as the first woman to do that—she soloed across the Pacific from Hawaii to the United States, and then she was lost in 1937, as she was on a round-world flight. What is so powerful to me, though, is several things. First of all, it's that Amelia Earhart opens doors for people like Sally Ride, who was the first woman astronaut in space. And I just think that trying to imagine what it was like to, in a male-dominated world, to become the pilot she was, because remember, pilots were really, in the 1920s, almost considered godlike. They were special. Only a few people can do that. And so the notion was that, you know, men could master the air. But for Amelia Earhart and other women to challenge that, to basically say, we can fly as high and as fast, and the hope is that if we can do that, then maybe equality will follow on the ground. And that's why I love doing Amelia Earhart.
Lizzie: On top of that, it is an exceptionally stylish garment, I think.
Lonnie Bunch: Très chic. [laughs]
Lizzie: Très chic. Head-to-toe leather. It's got these cool big buttons. It's got leather cargo pockets.
Lonnie Bunch: It is—remember, this is to keep you warm. But it's also stylish, right? And I think that what I love about it is that you could really look at it and just really deconstruct it. Think about okay, why does she have these boots on? Why do you need that?
Lizzie: Mm-hmm.
Lonnie Bunch: What's it like in an airplane with limited heat that you're flying so high? And it really gives you a sense of how hard it was to just do something that we now take for granted: getting in an airplane. And so I wanted to basically make it much more complex and help people understand the challenge of just getting in an airplane in 1928.
Lizzie: And I think there's something just visceral about being in the presence of fabric that touched a living person's skin, especially somebody so notable and who disappeared. You know, there's something very tactile about that idea. You know, this leather, she wore it.
Lonnie Bunch: Well, in some ways, because she was lost, the flight suit becomes even more powerful.
Lizzie: Yeah.
Lonnie Bunch: It's a symbol of who she once was, who she could have been. And I think that, for me, it's really a way to say, how do you yes, raise the question of breaking ceilings, but how do you remember her? This tells you about her size, her confidence, her courage.
Lizzie: I had this question as I was thinking about the Amelia Earhart flight suit. You know, do you think that we're especially drawn to figures who disappear mid-story?
Lonnie Bunch: Well, I mean, I think that there's a sense of unfinished business, right? That part of what they're also doing is by unfinished business, they're challenging others to step up. And so when I look at Amelia Earhart, imagine what it did to so many people, because in early aviation, there are women that are trying to sort of play a role, African Americans playing a role. So what you see is that Amelia Earhart really opened doors for so many people that she could never imagine.
Lizzie: So no exhibition about the great American democratic experiment would be complete without some campaign materials. And you have campaign materials, not from a recent campaign, but a hand-painted banner from 1860. And it says, "Lincoln and Hamlin, Sure, in November, for Justice Shall Triumph."
Lonnie Bunch: Absolutely.
Lizzie: Tell me about this banner. First of all, where would it have hung? It's huge! It's like a giant coat of arms or something.
Lonnie Bunch: I love it. First of all, again, this is part of my heritage as a curator of
political history, right? I'm a 19th-century historian. And very few people know that Hannibal Hamlin, from Maine, was Lincoln's first vice president.
Lizzie: I had never heard his name before going to this exhibition.
Lonnie Bunch: I love it. And the notion of—it's really part of the evolution of campaigning, right? That it really isn't until the 1830s that people began to realize it's okay to have politicians. It's okay to campaign. You know, Washington, even Jefferson, worried about the factious nature of politics.
Lizzie: Wait. Sorry. They were worried that campaigning would point out that politics—wait.
Lonnie Bunch: Yeah, here's what it is.
Lizzie: Okay. [laughs]
Lonnie Bunch: Remember, the United States is a republic, not a democracy. And there was always a notion that the better sort should rule, because you need to make sure that yes, you want to be accountable to the people, but you don't want people to be swayed by politicians. So it really wasn't something until really the 1820s and 1830s that you begin to realize that politics have a role to play.
Lizzie: Hmm.
Lonnie Bunch: And then part of it is also, as you see the vote expanding. It was initially only the elite, then it was sort of white males, and then what you began to do is figure out how do you get people to care about your candidate? So they started campaigning. They started making things like buttons and banners. And this is a banner that was hung in Belfast, Maine, to convince people to come out and vote for Lincoln. Because the 1860 election is crucial, right? It's the election that's got Stephen A. Douglas running as a Democrat, and it really is an election about the future of America. And Lincoln, as the sort of first person from the Republican Party to be elected as president, really recognizes that he needs to demonstrate that he's got support in New England. And the fact that Lincoln won with only 39 percent of the vote is really very powerful. But ultimately for me, it was just like, don't forget Hannibal Hamlin.
Lizzie: [laughs] Wow! Yeah, I won't now. What a name! From afar, it looks like a very professional banner.
Lonnie Bunch: Right.
Lizzie: But from up close, you see it was hand-painted with paintbrushes, and it's just—you can see the marks of the humans behind it.
Lonnie Bunch: Well, what you forget is that all of these are about craftsmanship. Now some of them have much better skills than others. You know, some of them you carve—when Lincoln ran, you know, they would carve log cabins, and they would carry them on a stick, because they called him the "log cabin candidate." So I love the fact that part of what we're doing is yeah, we're celebrating Lincoln—crucially important. We're remembering Hannibal Hamlin—not crucially important, but has been to me
Lizzie: Sounds like the reason, actually. He sounds like he's the headliner.
Lonnie Bunch: I'm a 19th-century guy. That's him, you know? But also, I think that I want people to understand that the strength of a nation, in part, is engaging in these campaigns is having sort of reasonable debate. And so I love the fact that Lincoln won and Hamlin helped.
Lizzie: I did not realize that campaign materials were so relatively recent.
Lonnie Bunch: Oh, absolutely. I mean, you really have—it's really like the 1840s that really you begin to see slogans, like "Tippecanoe and Tyler, Too," right? These are all ways to get people engaged with voting.
Lizzie: Right.
Lonnie Bunch: And what is so interesting is in the exhibit, we do have campaign buttons from the 1890s, really, to the present. And what's so powerful is with technology changing, with people using television, people still want those buttons. They want those buttons to be able to say, "I'm supporting X," whoever X is. Because in a way what it does—banners allow the community to rally. Buttons allow individuals to say, "This is my person." That's powerful.
Lizzie: You're really making me wish I wore my "I Love Lonnie" button today.
Lonnie Bunch: [laughs]
Lizzie: Because you know we have them. [laughs] Okay, so this next object is a shining example—pun intended—of ingenuity. This is a light bulb that you know well.
Lonnie Bunch: Yes.
Lizzie: Tell me about this light bulb.
Lonnie Bunch: Well, first of all, it doesn't look like the light bulbs we have, right? I mean, it's really on a kind of wooden stand, and it's sort of this oblong glass shape. And you could almost say to yourself, "Well, what is it?" Well, it's the light bulb that Thomas Edison invented that really brought light and electrification to the country. What I love about it, though, is Edison—first of all, he's in New Jersey, so that's always good.
Lizzie: [laughs]
Lonnie Bunch: But Edison really is a great inventor, right? Thinking about ways you can use technology to enrich people, and for me, it's the notion of the electric light bulb that is so powerful. Remember, people are using whale oil, other things for lighting, flammable things. And Edison was trying to find a way to light the country that was, quote, "safe." And what I think is so wonderfully interesting about this is that Edison, after years of experimentation, comes up with this that he thinks works. But then he figures out, how do you convince people that this is the way to go? So what he does is, in Menlo Park in New Jersey, New Year's Eve, 1879, he invites people to come because he is going to light up his entire campus. And he electrifies his whole thing, and people are just blown away that they can see at night. And what I love about it is one, I love the inventive genius, but also I love the marketing notion.
Lizzie: Yeah.
Lonnie Bunch: That, you know, come see this lighting. I mean, you could just see people come from Philadelphia and New York. And my God, the thing is lit up. And what I think that's so powerful about it is that that light bulb really leads to a transformation. It really helps America begin to
think about electrification, right? So for me, this is really about American ingenuity. It's about the promise of America, it's about giving you the opportunity to transcend. And I think that that's why this light bulb is so powerful. Plus, it's pretty cool looking.
Lizzie: It's awesome! People would pay a lot of money at an antique shop for something like that. It looks very retro chic.
Lonnie Bunch: [laughs] Retro chic. I hadn't thought about it that way, but okay, I like it. I like it.
Lizzie: Did I hear a rumor that you had this light bulb in your office for a while?
Lonnie Bunch: Yes. When my office was in the Castle, before we had to close for the construction, we did have the Edison light bulb. We had a few things, because what you want is when people are coming to see the secretary, yes, they're in the Castle, that's right, but you also want to say, "Look at the cool stuff we have." So I would periodically walk somebody by and go, "Oh, that's the light bulb that Thomas Edison invented." "Really?" And that would disarm just about anybody. So, you know, for me, these were objects that should be venerated, but they were also objects that helped me sort of break down barriers and make people feel comfortable.
Lizzie: That makes so much sense. I love that image.
Lonnie Bunch: Well, you know, you're gonna have a bad meeting? Oh my God, look what you're seeing.
Lizzie: The art of distraction. And bridging divides.
Lonnie Bunch: That's a good way to put it. But it's also the art of distraction, too. It's like, you know, I want to win, so I disarm people. [laughs]
Lizzie: Very smart. That's politics. Okay, so I would love to talk about the Statue of Liberty.
Lonnie Bunch: Yes.
Lizzie: Not the Statue of Liberty, but—because she's in New York Harbor—but there is a model in the exhibition. Tell me about this mini version of Lady Liberty.
Lonnie Bunch: You know, I was in New York yesterday, and I actually was stopping to look at the Statue of Liberty. And think about how it is now so embedded in America's identity, right? But the maquette that we have was by Frédéric Bartholdi, who creates the Statue of Liberty. Now when most people see it, they immediately think of immigration. They think of Emma Lazarus. They think of that amazing poem, you know, about I lift my light for the golden door. And it's become a symbol of welcome to America, a symbol of leaving behind the worst of Europe or Asia and coming to the United States for what would be the hope of America. So I love that. It's a great story. But it's also important to recognize that what this was really created for had nothing to do with immigration.
Lizzie: Mm-hmm.
Lonnie Bunch: It was really about freedom. And that's why it's called the Statue of Liberty, because when it was created, it was created to demonstrate America had a long relationship with France. I mean, France was crucial to the success of the American Revolution. But it was also a way to celebrate America's abolition of slavery. And what I love about the maquette, and even the Statue of Liberty, is that if you look at the feet, they're standing on broken chains.
Lonnie Bunch: And for me, part of the job of a historian is to give you layers of complexity, to give you ambiguity. And so for me, being able to think about how this was first about liberty, how it then becomes a symbol of immigration, and then through that, it becomes this, in some ways, contested notion of what America is today, right?
Lizzie: Mm-hmm.
Lonnie Bunch: It is a land of promise, a land of hope, but, you know, some people have argued there's too much promise, too much hope, in a way. So for me, being able to look at this amazing image that has stood in New York Harbor since the 1880s is really unbelievably powerful. And I just want people to know that—look at it through different lenses. Think about what it meant in the 1880s for a nation like France, who had its own complicated history, to celebrate something that America did that was so profound, which was to end an institution that people thought would be in America forever.
Lizzie: And what you see in the maquette—is that how—am I saying it correctly?
Lonnie Bunch: Maquette. Maquette.
Lizzie: Maquette. I think it's worth pointing out that this isn't a replica that was built after the Statue of Liberty. This was sent over beforehand as a proof of concept.
Lonnie Bunch: Absolutely.
Lizzie: To say, "Do you want it? Do you like it? Here's what's coming."
Lonnie Bunch: Or, "Here's what's coming, whether you like it or not."
Lizzie: Fair. [laughs] Fair point. Get on board.
Lonnie Bunch: That's right.
Lizzie: It's like the little notification in the US mail which is like, "This bill is coming your way."
Lonnie Bunch: That's right. Absolutely. But I think that's so powerful. I mean, I think that, first of all, you should look at it. I mean, first of all, it's a woman, right? And at a male-dominated time, to have this woman, Lady Liberty, is really very, very powerful. And I love this light that she's holding, right? Because it is the country as a city on a hill, a beacon of light, right?
Lizzie: Mm-hmm.
Lonnie Bunch: And to be honest, the actual Statue of Liberty being so large, it really had become the landmark of so many people coming to the New World. Which is why I love the maquette, to be able to, in a way, you get much closer to it than you could the Statue of Liberty. You can see the folds in her gown, you can see the strength in her arm. And so for me, it really was what I wanted for the whole show. Here's a way to get intimate with something like this that you will never see in the same way when you're at the Statue of Liberty in New York.
Lizzie: And you can see the broken chains at her ankles, which it's impossible to see from your vantage point on Ellis Island.
Lonnie Bunch: Exactly. It's my favorite part of it, that I really love the fact that she's standing on those chains.
***
Lizzie: Lonnie, is there anything that you wish that you had included in this exhibition that didn't make the cut?
Lonnie Bunch: Well, I mean, I think that the Apollo space capsule would have been pretty cool, right?
Lizzie: Would have been a little bit harder to get in there.
Lonnie Bunch: Yeah, a little hard to get in there, right?
Lizzie: What kind of conversation do you hope that this exhibition might spark among people who are leaving it, who've come and seen it and are leaving it or are on their way home?
Lonnie Bunch: Well, you hope that several things happen. First of all, you want them to be amazed at the Smithsonian, right? That the Smithsonian ...
Lizzie: We want them to love us.
Lonnie Bunch: Absolutely. I mean, this is the repository of all of our memories, right? We're not an attic. We're repositories of who we once were and who we aspire to be, right? So I want them to do that, but I also want them to think about America as a work in progress, to think about the enduring and really everlasting journey of America trying to be the America of our dreams. And I think that what you see is people had different hopes and different dreams, but the notion was that America was going to be the place to allow us to fulfill those dreams. And so I want people to understand that while that may be the goal, it really wasn't fairly available to everybody, and that people really did amazing things to make America be America.
Lizzie: Mm-hmm.
Lonnie Bunch: I keep thinking of Langston Hughes' poem where he says, "I, too, am America. I, too, am America." And he basically says, let us be the America that we hope it can be. And I think that what you see is, from the time of Jefferson, people are aspiring to something very different, and that ultimately, we as a nation have grappled with that—not always successfully, and not without loss, not without real challenge, but ultimately, the notion of the United States as a work in progress, rather than saying, "We're here, we've made it."
Lizzie: Right.
Lonnie Bunch: Rather that we'll always be grappling with these questions. And what's so powerful about it, if you look at nations around the world, most don't have those founding ideals. They don't have that thing to say, we could be better. We could live up to this. And I think that the challenge has always been the debates between those who think we're here and those who think we have much more to aspire to and let's work towards.
Lizzie: That's so well put. And this idea that the struggle itself is laudatory, that if we have this sense that we've arrived and we are perfect now, then any admission, anything that reflects poorly on our country means that we've failed.
Lonnie Bunch: Exactly.
Lizzie: Or we are a failure. But we're not. I think there's just—it's almost like in a math problem, you know, when you're in school and they say, show your work.
Lonnie Bunch: Right.
Lizzie: You need to show all of the calculations and
all the ways that you got to where you are here, because it's part of the learning process. It's part of the evolution.
Lonnie Bunch: As long as you don't ask me to do math, I'm with you. But, I mean ...
Lizzie: [laughs] Okay, fair.
Lonnie Bunch: But I do think you're absolutely right. I think that part of this is really having the confidence in the America of our dreams, having the confidence that people like Jefferson had, which were—they were revolutionaries.
Lizzie: Mm-hmm.
Lonnie Bunch: They knew that the country would evolve and change, you know? And they hoped that it would change for the better, these ideals would guide them. And I think that's what's so powerful. So I'm not one of these people that say, "Run away from the founders," right? I think they're unbelievably brilliant. They're unbelievably human, with the challenges of being unbelievably human. But I think that it's the words that allow us to sort of transcend who they were, but point us towards what America can be. I mean, I love the notion of how to dream a world anew, right? How to dream a world based on Jefferson's ideals. And I think everybody has debates of what that world is, but my goodness, what it means is that America is a nation in pursuit. America is not a nation that settles. It's a nation in pursuit. And that's what I think is so powerful.
Lizzie: You know, when people walk into a Smithsonian exhibition, and I think especially one like American Aspirations, they often expect authority. You know, the official version of history. Do you think museums work that way? Is there an official version of history?
Lonnie Bunch: There's not a single version. What there is is the kind of interpretation based on scholarship first and foremost, based on how do you work in exhibitions. You know, exhibitions aren't books, so there are different ways you make arguments in exhibitions than you do in books. But I do believe that as a scholar, we move away from master narratives, right? But I think in museums, people come for the narrative.
Lizzie: Mm-hmm.
Lonnie Bunch: People want to understand, and so what I believe very strongly is it's not my job to tell you how to think about everything, but it is our job to illuminate corners that one might want to grapple with, one might want to think about. And that's why I keep going back to where I started, which is, as that man in South Carolina, Princey Jenkins, said to me, "How do you help people remember not just what they want to remember, but what they need to remember?" And that's why places like the Smithsonian are driven by scholarship, but also education, right? If I had all the choices of what I wanted in education, I wouldn't be able to add two plus two. I hated math, right? But you get to learn that, and it makes you better. And so I think that our job is not to pontificate, our job is to educate. Our job is not to have points of view that aren't driven by scholarship and reflection, but our job is to contribute to the greater good. And to me, that has always been my mantra. What can we do that contributes to the greater good? One of my dearest old friends was Studs Terkel, the great oral historian.
Lizzie: Hmm.
Lonnie Bunch: And when Studs was near the end of his life, he used to say to me, "Lonnie, I'm 90 years old. I can't hear a thing. I can't see much, I can't stand for long, but I want you to do me a favor." I said, "What do you want, Studs?" He'd say, "Always turn me in a direction where I can do good." That's what I think museums are about: always helping people go in a direction where they can do good based on their understanding of science, art, history, culture. Or at least that's what I believe.
Lizzie: Thank you so much, Secretary Bunch.
Lonnie Bunch: My great pleasure.
Lizzie: It's such a pleasure talking with you. I've been speaking with the Secretary of the Smithsonian, Lonnie Bunch. If you want to check out the exhibition "American Aspirations—" which you do—it is going on through July 26 at the Smithsonian Castle, which is open especially for this purpose. Any—I don't know, any final words?
Lonnie Bunch: Well, I mean, I think that as I think about all the time I've spent at the Smithsonian from being a 25-year-old kid to today, I realize what an amazing gift the Smithsonian is, right? It is an opportunity to come for free to understand art, history, science and culture. And I am so privileged to work with over 7,000 gifted people who are public servants, and all they want to do is do good.
***
Lizzie: You've been listening to Sidedoor, a podcast from the Smithsonian with support from PRX. To learn more about the "American Aspirations" exhibition, find us on social media. Our handle is @Sidedoorpod. For help with this episode, we want to thank the one and only Lonnie G. Bunch III for taking the time to talk with us.
Lizzie: Our podcast is produced by James Morrison and me, Lizzie Peabody. Executive producer is Ann Conanan. Our editorial team is Jess Sadeq and Sharon Bryant. Fact-checking by Nathalie Boyd. Episode artwork is by Dave Leonard. Transcripts are done by Russell Gragg. Extra support comes from PRX. Our show is mixed by Tarek Fouda. Our theme song and episode music are by Breakmaster Cylinder. If you have a pitch for us, send us an email at sidedoor [at] si [dot] edu. And if you want to sponsor our show, please email sponsorship [at] prx [dot]org. I'm your host, Lizzie Peabody. Thanks for listening.
Lonnie Bunch: You know, like I tell people all the time, growing up in Jersey taught me how to fight, when to run and how to talk my way out of trouble. And this time has made me use all of that. [laughs]
-30-