TRASCRIZIONE 🔗
WEBVTT
1
00:00:00.591 --> 00:00:08.296
What's important in that, it was just a tax structure that just fundamentally you didn't get the credit on lower taxes.
2
00:00:08.336 --> 00:00:11.718
So your NOI, you know, goes down.
3
00:00:11.778 --> 00:00:13.159
Your cash flows wrong.
4
00:00:13.519 --> 00:00:14.359
Could I have closed it?
5
00:00:14.419 --> 00:00:15.540
Yeah, 100%.
6
00:00:15.860 --> 00:00:18.482
You could have looked the other way and did we lose our deposit?
7
00:00:18.802 --> 00:00:19.442
100%.
8
00:00:19.502 --> 00:00:25.126
Did we lose four months of marketing and the team launching that?
9
00:00:25.266 --> 00:00:25.566
100%.
10
00:00:26.006 --> 00:00:27.327
We'd already bought cool furniture.
11
00:00:27.387 --> 00:00:28.488
We've already bought everything.
12
00:00:29.068 --> 00:00:30.789
But it's not right.
13
00:00:30.990 --> 00:00:32.871
And making those phone calls, it took time.
14
00:00:33.532 --> 00:00:43.199
But the relationship on the other side, the prudency to say no, is far more important than anything else.
15
00:00:43.720 --> 00:00:44.000
J.M.
16
00:00:44.020 --> 00:00:57.211
LePage built Western Wealth Capital, buying and repositioning over 29,000 apartment units across 120 communities over the past 12 years, becoming one of the largest female-founded and led multifamily investment firms in the country.
17
00:00:57.871 --> 00:00:59.312
This doesn't happen by accident.
18
00:00:59.452 --> 00:01:06.995
But what's interesting is that some of the properties that she's pursuing today are the very types of deals that she would have passed on just a few short years ago.
19
00:01:07.255 --> 00:01:08.296
And there's a reason for that.
20
00:01:08.876 --> 00:01:11.037
Welcome to the Real Estate Investing for Cashflow podcast.
21
00:01:11.137 --> 00:01:11.857
I'm Kevin Bopp.
22
00:01:12.138 --> 00:01:22.142
Today, I want to unpack how Janet thinks about repeatable systems at scale and also what she learned from bringing property management in-house in a remarkably short time window.
23
00:01:22.482 --> 00:01:25.864
And just a quick note here, here's a fun little challenge I want to throw your way.
24
00:01:26.264 --> 00:01:29.987
Leave a comment on how many days you think it took her to bring property management house.
25
00:01:30.027 --> 00:01:32.569
And please don't cheat and skip ahead to find out.
26
00:01:32.949 --> 00:01:34.671
And let me know what your thoughts are.
27
00:01:34.691 --> 00:01:36.212
Let me know how long you really think it took.
28
00:01:36.452 --> 00:01:44.799
But all jokes aside here, I'm also excited to discuss how the current market conditions have led her toward an investment strategy with some very interesting economics.
29
00:01:45.239 --> 00:01:45.900
Let's get into it.
30
00:01:46.360 --> 00:01:47.381
Janet, welcome to the show.
31
00:01:47.441 --> 00:01:51.164
I've been really looking forward to having you on here and chatting with you today about your business.
32
00:01:51.204 --> 00:01:51.885
How are you doing today?
33
00:01:52.705 --> 00:01:53.666
I'm doing awesome.
34
00:01:53.706 --> 00:01:54.587
Thanks for having me, Kevin.
35
00:01:54.607 --> 00:01:54.967
I'm doing awesome.
36
00:01:55.315 --> 00:01:56.857
Excited to talk shop here.
37
00:01:57.037 --> 00:01:59.981
I think there's a lot of ground to cover, lots of very interesting ground to cover.
38
00:02:00.021 --> 00:02:10.232
And so I know that you've built Western Wealth Capital into a very prominent multifamily investment and operating platform here over the years.
39
00:02:10.292 --> 00:02:13.756
But I see that after learning a little bit more about your story,
40
00:02:15.218 --> 00:02:23.245
What I find the most interesting is the discipline behind how you've done it all from always looking for reasons not to buy a deal.
41
00:02:23.325 --> 00:02:28.470
I love kind of batting that around internally here at our company, just always trying to find a reason to kill a deal.
42
00:02:28.510 --> 00:02:29.591
I know you do the same thing.
43
00:02:30.392 --> 00:02:36.657
I know you've got a little bit of a kind of a complex story about bringing property management in-house in a very short period of time.
44
00:02:37.298 --> 00:02:42.499
And just even changing the different types of evolving over time and changing different types of assets that you're buying.
45
00:02:42.719 --> 00:02:51.821
And so, you know, I think there's just a lot of unpack just about how you how you look at risk control and just how you built your investment portfolio today.
46
00:02:51.841 --> 00:02:53.222
And so excited to jump in here with you.
47
00:02:53.242 --> 00:03:00.423
And what I think what I'd love to do, I'd love to I always like to kind of back it up a little bit, start a little bit of a backstory, get to know you on a more personal level here.
48
00:03:00.443 --> 00:03:05.905
And so we'll love to go back before Western Wealth and go back to the beginning, I guess.
49
00:03:07.325 --> 00:03:17.900
You were working full time, you were raising young kids and real estate was kind of a, it was a side and not a side hustle, it was a side business, but you were working full time, but doing real estate in the side.
50
00:03:17.940 --> 00:03:21.786
So I guess, tell us about how you initially got pulled into the real estate world.
51
00:03:22.685 --> 00:03:23.506
Oh, gosh.
52
00:03:23.667 --> 00:03:24.047
All right.
53
00:03:24.067 --> 00:03:25.069
Let's go right back.
54
00:03:25.890 --> 00:03:27.553
What is so silly about it?
55
00:03:27.613 --> 00:03:29.876
And actually, it might be silly, but it's also relatable.
56
00:03:30.257 --> 00:03:31.839
I bought my first house when I was 23.
57
00:03:32.059 --> 00:03:33.241
I just finished university.
58
00:03:33.442 --> 00:03:37.788
And about a year or so after that, you get your, you know, your assessment.
59
00:03:38.429 --> 00:03:40.070
And in my head, I got a mortgage.
60
00:03:40.170 --> 00:03:41.731
And, you know, in 30 years, you pay
Load full transcript
it off.
61
00:03:41.751 --> 00:03:43.372
And this assessment came in.
62
00:03:43.492 --> 00:03:45.313
And the value of the house, I was reading it.
63
00:03:45.333 --> 00:03:46.874
And I actually called my mom, of all things.
64
00:03:46.914 --> 00:03:49.395
And I'm like, Mom, what is this number?
65
00:03:49.955 --> 00:03:53.637
And she said, oh, like the value of your house went up.
66
00:03:53.757 --> 00:03:58.640
And I was so upset that my taxes had gone up because, of course, I am like, what?
67
00:03:58.980 --> 00:04:04.644
barely making it just, you know, my first job out of, you know, my degree, I'm a computer scientist.
68
00:04:05.044 --> 00:04:07.526
And so I wasn't necessarily happy about the increase.
69
00:04:07.546 --> 00:04:09.387
I'm like, oh, my gosh, you could make money.
70
00:04:09.747 --> 00:04:11.729
It's not just like paying off your mortgage.
71
00:04:12.069 --> 00:04:15.811
I grew up in a very small town where I values didn't really appreciate.
72
00:04:15.871 --> 00:04:20.574
So I also I don't know, maybe I was just raised not not understanding growth.
73
00:04:22.215 --> 00:04:26.418
And, and so with that, I thought, my gosh, like, what can I do with this?
74
00:04:26.518 --> 00:04:29.780
And that was really the start of even being intrigued with real estate.
75
00:04:30.881 --> 00:04:32.402
I did a real estate weekend.
76
00:04:32.482 --> 00:04:33.363
And are you ready for this?
77
00:04:33.723 --> 00:04:36.925
I did a Trump learning real estate weekend.
78
00:04:37.486 --> 00:04:38.586
I got a binder.
79
00:04:39.087 --> 00:04:42.129
Yes, that had the zipper and the logo on the front.
80
00:04:42.769 --> 00:04:51.335
And I remember one of the key things being taken away from there was, you know, if you instead of just paying your mortgage once a month, but paying it every two weeks, it took a while.
81
00:04:51.515 --> 00:04:56.219
about five or six years off your mortgage by just making that payment.
82
00:04:56.979 --> 00:05:01.662
And I went home and I thought to myself, if I learned that in a weekend, what else could I learn?
83
00:05:02.589 --> 00:05:03.310
And are you ready for this?
84
00:05:03.590 --> 00:05:05.551
I actually paid the premium price.
85
00:05:05.691 --> 00:05:06.452
I'm that person.
86
00:05:07.173 --> 00:05:14.858
And for the next year, I had a weekly session with an elderly gentleman actually out of Florida.
87
00:05:15.239 --> 00:05:16.279
I learned everything.
88
00:05:16.660 --> 00:05:22.324
I mean, mobile home parks to tax deeds to apartments.
89
00:05:22.484 --> 00:05:26.927
And we met twice in different cities in the U.S. where we would his thing was everything's a deal.
90
00:05:27.708 --> 00:05:29.169
But what is the deal?
91
00:05:29.510 --> 00:05:29.770
Right.
92
00:05:29.890 --> 00:05:32.812
It's there's a price or there's different things.
93
00:05:33.273 --> 00:05:39.538
And later he told me that actually of all the people that had paid, I was actually the only person that did something with it.
94
00:05:39.898 --> 00:05:44.662
So that is random.
95
00:05:44.822 --> 00:05:49.746
The start of my real estate interest, if you will.
96
00:05:50.321 --> 00:05:50.701
Okay.
97
00:05:50.721 --> 00:05:53.462
Well, there's, there's obviously, there's probably a lot more to unpack there.
98
00:05:53.622 --> 00:05:57.004
And I do, I do, I do remember, I do remember those early days.
99
00:05:57.024 --> 00:06:05.967
I got, I bought my first property when I was 19 and, um, you know, Carlton Sheets had late, late night infomercials and Ron LeGrand was another one of those guys way back in the day.
100
00:06:05.987 --> 00:06:09.329
I went to a conference and, you know, a bunch of people rah, rah, rah cheering.
101
00:06:09.409 --> 00:06:09.789
And, uh,
102
00:06:10.229 --> 00:06:18.054
But yeah, 99% of people never do anything with the knowledge that they take away from some of those seminars and conferences or the study at home programs.
103
00:06:18.474 --> 00:06:19.395
But I'm glad to hear that you did.
104
00:06:19.515 --> 00:06:24.038
Obviously, you've grown into something quite significant here today.
105
00:06:24.218 --> 00:06:26.079
And so I would love to maybe unpack it just a little bit more.
106
00:06:26.479 --> 00:06:28.360
So you spent a year with that advisor.
107
00:06:28.380 --> 00:06:30.342
You know, he just gave you...
108
00:06:31.022 --> 00:06:38.369
Various insights on different types of asset classes, maybe how to identify what would be an ideal deal, right?
109
00:06:38.389 --> 00:06:39.490
Because everything is a deal, right?
110
00:06:39.550 --> 00:06:42.553
I guess at the right price and if it's in the right location or what have you.
111
00:06:42.573 --> 00:06:43.053
At the right price.
112
00:06:43.073 --> 00:06:44.014
Right price, right terms.
113
00:06:44.435 --> 00:06:45.676
Yeah, right price, right terms.
114
00:06:45.696 --> 00:06:46.196
Yeah.
115
00:06:46.256 --> 00:06:51.021
So what did you do with that knowledge after that year of spending with that advisor?
116
00:06:51.061 --> 00:06:53.363
What did that look like in the following years?
117
00:06:53.762 --> 00:06:56.183
Well, Kevin, I wanted to become you, which is funny enough.
118
00:06:56.463 --> 00:06:58.463
I wanted to buy mobile home parks.
119
00:06:59.124 --> 00:07:02.045
That is what I decided was the best investment.
120
00:07:02.125 --> 00:07:03.465
I didn't want to own the mobile home parks.
121
00:07:03.505 --> 00:07:04.545
I wanted to own the land.
122
00:07:05.226 --> 00:07:08.647
I wanted to own, you know, the plumbing to the plots.
123
00:07:10.427 --> 00:07:15.370
After a lot of hunts, I've been to parts of the U.S. that I had never known existed.
124
00:07:15.910 --> 00:07:16.550
I couldn't afford it.
125
00:07:16.951 --> 00:07:26.616
So I bought two homes at auction in Phoenix, Arizona, after all my research.
126
00:07:27.637 --> 00:07:30.678
And that was the start of my real estate investing.
127
00:07:31.739 --> 00:07:36.822
I went on to flip 58 homes in just under two years in Phoenix while working full time.
128
00:07:37.842 --> 00:07:38.102
And...
129
00:07:39.543 --> 00:07:42.305
You know, I'd get the list at 4 p.m. the night before.
130
00:07:42.325 --> 00:07:45.387
I mean, I've crawled through more doggy doors than you could ever imagine.
131
00:07:46.808 --> 00:07:50.591
I had a system we would spend, you know, I'd spend about $5,000 renovating.
132
00:07:50.651 --> 00:07:54.414
My average day on market, average day of renovation was seven days.
133
00:07:54.554 --> 00:07:56.555
Average day on market, about seven days.
134
00:07:58.496 --> 00:08:02.719
And I borrowed the hard money at 18% other than my $10,000 down.
135
00:08:03.680 --> 00:08:04.981
And I flipped houses.
136
00:08:05.641 --> 00:08:06.482
And that was my start.
137
00:08:07.680 --> 00:08:08.021
Okay.
138
00:08:08.581 --> 00:08:12.087
Well, you were, you were obviously working full-time at that, at that stage as well.
139
00:08:12.127 --> 00:08:12.347
Right.
140
00:08:12.427 --> 00:08:19.618
And I don't know if you had a family yet at that point, if you had kids, but ultimately you did this while still like, I mean, this really was a kind of a side gig.
141
00:08:19.638 --> 00:08:21.822
So I'd be curious to know, I mean, and you know, I,
142
00:08:22.903 --> 00:08:27.766
58 homes in a two-year span of time flipping them, I mean, that's easier said than done.
143
00:08:29.307 --> 00:08:36.270
Surely there's folks that flip hundreds of homes, maybe not time-rate, but I mean, generally speaking, 58 homes, that's a lot of transactions.
144
00:08:36.290 --> 00:08:46.636
I would have to think that very quickly you learned how to put some good SOPs, standard operating procedures in place, good systems to leverage your time.
145
00:08:46.676 --> 00:08:49.658
Because it didn't sound like you have a lot of time, you're working a full-time gig.
146
00:08:49.678 --> 00:08:49.858
And so
147
00:08:50.438 --> 00:08:52.059
You're doing this with limited time.
148
00:08:52.599 --> 00:08:55.320
And so talk to me about that, those earlier days.
149
00:08:55.720 --> 00:09:02.543
What types of processes did you quickly put in place in order to scale in such a very short period of time?
150
00:09:03.243 --> 00:09:03.423
Why?
151
00:09:03.463 --> 00:09:06.905
I didn't even have the $10,000 for my first house.
152
00:09:06.925 --> 00:09:12.527
I actually put a business plan together and I did a PowerPoint presentation for my dad, my late father.
153
00:09:13.588 --> 00:09:15.952
And he said, OK, Janelle, play me crib.
154
00:09:15.972 --> 00:09:17.555
And I did not have children at the time.
155
00:09:17.875 --> 00:09:19.318
And bless him.
156
00:09:19.438 --> 00:09:21.582
He basically, he was going to do this.
157
00:09:21.622 --> 00:09:24.687
But he said, if you win, I will lend you the $10,000 at 18%.
158
00:09:26.825 --> 00:09:28.988
And if I win, you know, you're on your own.
159
00:09:29.048 --> 00:09:31.732
And,
you know, somehow he lost that game.
160
00:09:33.314 --> 00:09:35.597
And so I didn't even have the money either.
161
00:09:35.757 --> 00:09:42.246
You know, my first one, I made 28 grand in the first, you know, 30 days.
162
00:09:42.306 --> 00:09:43.948
And so then I paid him back.
163
00:09:44.489 --> 00:09:46.910
He actually became my first investor because he saw it.
164
00:09:48.230 --> 00:09:55.693
So, you know, systems, of course, if you couldn't, you know, $5,000 was my limit of the renovation, right?
165
00:09:55.753 --> 00:09:59.275
So right away, you have to be rigorous on what you were going to spend.
166
00:09:59.735 --> 00:10:02.016
The second one is you had to be able to do it in seven days.
167
00:10:02.056 --> 00:10:04.517
So it had to be buy a fridge at most.
168
00:10:04.897 --> 00:10:09.299
clean the carpets, fix a broken window, you know, touch up the landscaping.
169
00:10:09.319 --> 00:10:12.840
And basically, you're putting back on the market for the same price as a foreclosure next door.
170
00:10:12.880 --> 00:10:18.362
So obviously, somebody walking in, they get this perfectly buttoned up house or one that they need work.
171
00:10:18.542 --> 00:10:28.146
And, you know, for the first time homebuyer or that could still get a mortgage and get a credit, I was able to give them a three and a half percent credit, which is really what their down payment was.
172
00:10:29.026 --> 00:10:31.108
And they could walk into a turnkey home.
173
00:10:31.628 --> 00:10:39.394
And so when the rest of the world said there wasn't things happening, man, I couldn't keep my houses, you know, on the market.
174
00:10:40.354 --> 00:10:44.557
It had to be a certain number of blocks away from a main highway.
175
00:10:44.577 --> 00:10:47.119
It had to be a certain number of blocks from a school.
176
00:10:47.179 --> 00:10:51.923
So there was this criteria because you only get the list.
177
00:10:52.363 --> 00:10:53.585
at 4 p.m. the night before.
178
00:10:54.146 --> 00:11:04.961
Fast forward into multifamily buying, when I look back, one of the key things we talk about in Western Wealth Capital is repeatability creates scalability.
179
00:11:05.361 --> 00:11:07.604
Repeatability removes risk.
180
00:11:08.445 --> 00:11:14.508
And, you know, even if I go even further back, being a computer scientist is like you're very much step based.
181
00:11:14.628 --> 00:11:29.595
And so whether I completely knew what I was doing at that time, that is a foundational element that has been the beating drum of how as a female founder in the U.S., I bought the most number of multifamily in history.
182
00:11:29.615 --> 00:11:29.715
Yeah.
183
00:11:31.454 --> 00:11:32.455
units in history.
184
00:11:33.275 --> 00:11:41.802
And it's the discipline of that just embedded in the steps of how you do your elimination.
185
00:11:41.822 --> 00:11:44.924
So, yes, I wouldn't even call them
186
00:11:45.725 --> 00:11:51.427
It's funny, within our company, I'm not sure we even call them processes because it's like it's in your lifeblood.
187
00:11:51.607 --> 00:11:54.268
There is only one, you know, one way.
188
00:11:54.428 --> 00:11:55.549
I do think there's an art.
189
00:11:56.409 --> 00:11:58.550
There is, there's an art in science, right?
190
00:11:58.590 --> 00:12:00.251
So there's a gray area within that.
191
00:12:01.091 --> 00:12:06.014
Do not, you know, deviate from your science because that's how you de-risk.
192
00:12:06.615 --> 00:12:07.716
That's how you scale.
193
00:12:08.296 --> 00:12:10.518
That's how you build trust with your investment partners.
194
00:12:10.558 --> 00:12:17.943
And that's how you confidently say, I know I can do this because you're hitting this repeatability again and again.
195
00:12:18.561 --> 00:12:19.843
No, I love every bit of that.
196
00:12:20.123 --> 00:12:20.684
That's great.
197
00:12:20.704 --> 00:12:21.465
Thank you for sharing.
198
00:12:22.005 --> 00:12:25.309
So just, I guess, for some context, I did not grab this in the beginning.
199
00:12:26.130 --> 00:12:28.613
When you started, what time frame are we talking about?
200
00:12:28.633 --> 00:12:30.135
Was this post-2008?
201
00:12:30.175 --> 00:12:30.456
2009.
202
00:12:30.556 --> 00:12:31.217
Okay.
203
00:12:31.898 --> 00:12:32.719
Okay.
204
00:12:32.759 --> 00:12:33.239
2008, 2009.
205
00:12:33.499 --> 00:12:34.521
Right after the meltdown.
206
00:12:34.541 --> 00:12:35.121
Yeah.
207
00:12:36.037 --> 00:12:36.778
Yeah.
208
00:12:36.798 --> 00:12:36.958
Yeah.
209
00:12:36.978 --> 00:12:50.118
So, so if I mean, Phoenix was like ground zero at that point, I mean, Phoenix and, you know, uh, Las Vegas, you know, pretty much every major market in Florida and amongst others, but you know, there was just a, um, a litany of foreclosures that were littering the marketplace.
210
00:12:50.138 --> 00:12:50.939
So, uh,
211
00:12:51.079 --> 00:13:03.703
Great to hear that you were on the other side of that and you saw opportunity when lots of other folks, including myself, I was a product of the crash and ultimately had a portfolio that I lost during that period of time.
212
00:13:03.743 --> 00:13:05.823
And it was very painful for me.
213
00:13:05.863 --> 00:13:10.505
It took me a couple of years to pull up my bootstraps and go back at it again.
214
00:13:10.765 --> 00:13:14.466
And so while, you know, now looking back, I wish I would have.
215
00:13:15.126 --> 00:13:18.308
recapitalize faster, realizing that no, the world's not ending.
216
00:13:18.748 --> 00:13:21.049
This is just where opportunity begins again, right?
217
00:13:21.069 --> 00:13:21.909
The second time around.
218
00:13:21.969 --> 00:13:27.252
But in any event, glad to hear that you were able to jump in at a phenomenal time in the marketplace.
219
00:13:27.272 --> 00:13:29.633
So what, I guess, talk to me about the evolution then.
220
00:13:29.653 --> 00:13:30.934
So obviously single family flips.
221
00:13:30.954 --> 00:13:39.298
You obviously, you
mentioned you're in apartments today, but it sounds like apartments came into the equation shortly after you were in the single family.
222
00:13:39.418 --> 00:13:39.618
Okay.
223
00:13:39.638 --> 00:13:42.259
So only a couple of years, two years later, what did that look
224
00:13:42.339 --> 00:13:42.899
like?
225
00:13:42.939 --> 00:13:46.902
What was the starting point there with the apartment side, the multifamily side?
226
00:13:46.922 --> 00:13:50.705
And then maybe fast forward today and tell us a little bit about what your business looks like today.
227
00:13:52.867 --> 00:13:58.371
Well, you know, as I was flipping homes, I remember the night I bought three homes in one day at auction.
228
00:13:58.411 --> 00:13:59.972
I was like, oh my gosh.
229
00:14:01.090 --> 00:14:06.735
And, and, you know, somewhere in that I went, gosh, what if I could own an apartment building?
230
00:14:06.755 --> 00:14:10.258
Like that's, you know, that's not three homes, that's X number of homes.
231
00:14:11.839 --> 00:14:13.040
And one was coming up at auction.
232
00:14:13.881 --> 00:14:25.270
And the night before, because I, it was a 23 unit building just a few blocks away from Arizona State University, Tempe, Arizona, 53,000 a door for a condo building like less than a mile.
233
00:14:25.290 --> 00:14:25.370
And,
234
00:14:26.291 --> 00:14:30.934
Uh, and that felt, you know, it felt, it felt steep, I guess at the time.
235
00:14:30.954 --> 00:14:31.975
And I also didn't have the money.
236
00:14:32.616 --> 00:14:38.000
So at, at, uh, seven or 8 PM at night, I found the bank.
237
00:14:38.020 --> 00:14:39.921
It was a small bank in Iowa.
238
00:14:40.602 --> 00:14:43.744
I found the vice president and I phoned his home number.
239
00:14:43.925 --> 00:14:44.685
I kid you not.
240
00:14:44.725 --> 00:14:47.447
And I said, I want to buy this.
241
00:14:48.028 --> 00:14:51.390
I can't buy it at auction tomorrow, but I can buy this.
242
00:14:51.791 --> 00:14:53.952
If you pull it off, this is what I'll pay for it.
243
00:14:55.073 --> 00:14:58.776
And he said, you know, like, he's like, I don't even know how you found my number.
244
00:14:58.796 --> 00:15:03.499
And I said, because I'm that committed, I found your home line number.
245
00:15:03.859 --> 00:15:06.341
And so I'm not sure what's going to happen.
246
00:15:06.401 --> 00:15:08.442
But it didn't go to auction the next day.
247
00:15:08.462 --> 00:15:08.522
And
248
00:15:10.363 --> 00:15:13.905
26 days before my son was born.
249
00:15:14.925 --> 00:15:16.146
My feet are swollen.
250
00:15:16.266 --> 00:15:20.208
I'm eating a pickle and cheese sandwich because that's all I had in the fridge at the end of my workday.
251
00:15:20.608 --> 00:15:25.630
I mean, I remember swinging my feet and being so rich because I bought 23 homes.
252
00:15:26.291 --> 00:15:31.533
That truly, that moment, and I actually couldn't go down to Phoenix because I live here in Canada.
253
00:15:32.814 --> 00:15:34.374
I wasn't
medically insured to fly.
254
00:15:35.135 --> 00:15:37.876
And I just swung my fat feet and thought, wow.
255
00:15:38.096 --> 00:15:39.116
I am so rich.
256
00:15:39.316 --> 00:15:43.858
And truthfully, I'm not sure I've ever held that feeling ever again.
257
00:15:43.878 --> 00:15:46.419
I hope I never forget it.
258
00:15:46.639 --> 00:15:49.080
And I long for it.
259
00:15:49.360 --> 00:15:55.282
It was just such a magical moment in the start of what was to come.
260
00:15:57.382 --> 00:15:59.003
So that was my first apartment building.
261
00:15:59.623 --> 00:16:00.583
And then I had my daughter.
262
00:16:00.623 --> 00:16:01.463
I'm very efficient.
263
00:16:01.503 --> 00:16:04.384
Turns out not just in apartment buildings, but producing children.
264
00:16:05.364 --> 00:16:07.545
I had a baby on the front, baby on the back.
265
00:16:08.005 --> 00:16:09.045
And she became one.
266
00:16:09.085 --> 00:16:11.126
I had bought three apartment buildings at that point.
267
00:16:12.326 --> 00:16:14.347
Well, going back to work in between.
268
00:16:14.767 --> 00:16:18.648
And I knew that I needed to try this.
269
00:16:18.788 --> 00:16:20.328
I knew that I needed to leave school.
270
00:16:20.528 --> 00:16:24.810
the corporate world and like not have medical and a pension, which is just terrifying.
271
00:16:25.250 --> 00:16:29.391
And the night before my daughter turned one, because in Canada, we can have that much time off.
272
00:16:29.731 --> 00:16:32.072
I sat on the floor and I cried because I was terrified.
273
00:16:32.973 --> 00:16:37.174
And that was the start of what would become Western World Capital.
274
00:16:37.314 --> 00:16:38.775
I didn't know the name at that point.
275
00:16:39.975 --> 00:16:41.436
That was the beginning of 2014.
276
00:16:41.696 --> 00:16:49.518
Fast forward, we've bought 30,000 apartment buildings, 120 actual apartments, sold 96 of them.
277
00:16:51.758 --> 00:16:57.280
And, you know, we've done the most number of transactions in the history of Phoenix.
278
00:16:57.840 --> 00:16:59.341
We own all across the Sunbelt.
279
00:16:59.741 --> 00:17:04.082
And that's a decade, 12 years later.
280
00:17:04.772 --> 00:17:05.333
That's beautiful.
281
00:17:05.653 --> 00:17:06.013
I love it.
282
00:17:06.514 --> 00:17:06.894
I love it.
283
00:17:07.895 --> 00:17:11.659
Got focused, got efficient and just made shit happen.
284
00:17:11.819 --> 00:17:12.600
I absolutely love it.
285
00:17:12.680 --> 00:17:13.241
That's beautiful.
286
00:17:13.261 --> 00:17:14.602
Congrats to all your success.
287
00:17:15.263 --> 00:17:16.104
It doesn't come easy.
288
00:17:16.124 --> 00:17:21.669
Obviously, you've been grinding for a decade plus, but that is a fairly short period of time.
289
00:17:21.689 --> 00:17:24.933
That is a short runway in the grand scheme of things for what you've been able to pull off.
290
00:17:24.953 --> 00:17:27.475
So again, kudos to you and what you've been able to build.
291
00:17:28.576 --> 00:17:32.920
There was something that you said in the prep call with our team that I love to dive into.
292
00:17:33.541 --> 00:17:35.823
And it's related to new acquisitions.
293
00:17:36.143 --> 00:17:42.048
When you're looking at an acquisition, you stated that you're constantly trying to break up with it.
294
00:17:42.428 --> 00:17:45.230
I guess, I think in a general sense, we understand what that means.
295
00:17:45.250 --> 00:17:46.131
We're trying to kill a deal.
296
00:17:46.151 --> 00:17:48.113
But what does that mean for you guys in practice?
297
00:17:48.860 --> 00:17:55.523
Well, you know, you can romanticize and find all the yeses, but the whole point of it is to get to no, right?
298
00:17:55.563 --> 00:18:04.387
Like get to the dirty parts or the scary parts, because those are the pieces that you need to get through first.
299
00:18:04.487 --> 00:18:06.008
I could sit here and romanticize.
300
00:18:06.548 --> 00:18:11.010
Oh, but look at, you know, look at the size, look at the makeup, look at the tenants.
301
00:18:11.050 --> 00:18:13.251
But in behind that, there could be a tax issue.
302
00:18:13.271 --> 00:18:15.972
There could be a construction issue like everything.
303
00:18:16.372 --> 00:18:24.174
People spend so much time on the romantic side when the quicker you get to the dirty grit, the quicker you get to the bye.
304
00:18:24.374 --> 00:18:27.235
I look for every single no.
305
00:18:27.915 --> 00:18:31.836
It's almost like a first date joke with my friends.
306
00:18:31.856 --> 00:18:33.417
You're on your first date and it's like...
307
00:18:34.337 --> 00:18:38.758
Oh, but he has a great mom and, oh, a great family.
308
00:18:38.798 --> 00:18:40.439
And, oh, look at his biceps.
309
00:18:40.479 --> 00:18:44.340
It's like, let's get down to is he a stage five, right?
310
00:18:44.480 --> 00:18:46.381
Can't, you know, does he drive?
311
00:18:46.461 --> 00:18:47.721
Does he hold a job?
312
00:18:48.021 --> 00:18:50.342
Like, let's get into the dirty of it.
313
00:18:50.762 --> 00:18:53.843
And if those are yeses, it's great.
314
00:18:53.883 --> 00:18:55.383
Instead, you put the blinders on.
315
00:18:55.403 --> 00:18:58.604
People tie up a deal and they're just, they've already closed it.
316
00:18:58.664 --> 00:19:02.105
And I'm just like, you are, I know you must be sneaky somewhere.
317
00:19:02.125 --> 00:19:03.446
I'm going to find your dirtiness.
318
00:19:03.946 --> 00:19:10.611
And we're going to get to it because honestly, it's, it really, at the end of the day, you'll find it.
319
00:19:11.772 --> 00:19:14.174
It just might take you that much longer.
320
00:19:14.214 --> 00:19:15.234
And that's a waste of time.
321
00:19:15.735 --> 00:19:16.555
It's a waste of dollars.
322
00:19:16.575 --> 00:19:19.257
You got to make sure it's got good bones before you move any further.
323
00:19:19.317 --> 00:19:21.179
So I guess I'm curious.
324
00:19:21.279 --> 00:19:22.160
Every aspect.
325
00:19:22.540 -->
00:19:22.840
Yeah.
326
00:19:22.880 --> 00:19:24.902
That's a, you know, yeah.
327
00:19:25.852 --> 00:19:28.974
I don't know the size of your team, but I can always speak on my behalf.
328
00:19:30.855 --> 00:19:34.818
Years ago was myself wearing a lot of the hats of the business.
329
00:19:34.858 --> 00:19:42.382
I've had a partner and we had a few team members, but I pretty much was the only person that would say yay or nay to a deal.
330
00:19:42.442 --> 00:19:43.923
I was the investment committee, right?
331
00:19:43.983 --> 00:19:53.089
And then over time we evolved, we've grown the organization, we've got multiple other folks, we've got an entire leadership team, we've got a formal investment committee, and so
332
00:19:53.629 --> 00:19:54.510
Now it's just not me.
333
00:19:54.550 --> 00:19:58.994
But again, I share the same sentiment of always trying to find reasons not to buy the deal.
334
00:19:59.034 --> 00:20:00.295
Why do we not like this deal?
335
00:20:00.415 --> 00:20:02.898
I like it from the outside looking in, but why should we not like it?
336
00:20:03.078 --> 00:20:12.807
And I think we've been really successful at spreading that mindset throughout the rest of the acquisitions and the rest of the, you know, just the entire organization.
337
00:20:12.847 --> 00:20:17.511
But I'd be curious to know if there's any ways that you've found to be successful to
338
00:20:18.192 --> 00:20:22.075
ingrain that mindset to ensure that everyone adapts that same investment philosophy?
339
00:20:22.095 --> 00:20:25.558
Because, you know, I think, you know, everyone's compensated differently.
340
00:20:26.058 --> 00:20:35.666
If they're not an actual principal of the organization, more than likely, there's some type of bonus or commission structure tied to actually closing of a deal.
341
00:20:35.746 --> 00:20:39.889
And so, you know, people can get blinded by money, by dollar signs, right?
342
00:20:40.049 --> 00:20:42.731
Before the check's even cashed, and it might not have been the right deal.
343
00:20:42.751 --> 00:20:44.973
So how do you maintain that mindset within your organization?
344
00:20:44.993 --> 00:20:45.153
Yeah.
345
00:20:45.752 --> 00:20:49.655
You know, my average tenure on my leadership team is a decade.
346
00:20:50.475 --> 00:20:54.378
So that has been ingrained a long time ago.
347
00:20:54.518 --> 00:21:01.043
I completely hear the short-sighted view of acquisition fees and, you know, commission and all of that.
348
00:21:01.723 --> 00:21:15.996
But what I think the maturity has brought in my team is that the way that you get repeatability in your investment partners, in your institutional partners, is the discipline of getting to know.
349
00:21:16.436 --> 00:21:20.419
You know, some of the greatest conversations that build trust is actually...
350
00:21:21.200 --> 00:21:27.044
You know, getting to the and, you know, somebody asked, like, how far have you gone to actually stop?
351
00:21:27.464 --> 00:21:34.468
Have gone to like recording money's at the, you know, basically you're right there at title and something occurred.
352
00:21:34.849 --> 00:21:37.070
Now, I would say, does that happen that often?
353
00:21:37.150 --> 00:21:40.352
No, because we're really good at getting to the dirty no quickly.
354
00:21:40.552 --> 00:21:40.712
Right.
355
00:21:40.752 --> 00:21:42.733
That that's that's the game.
356
00:21:43.273 --> 00:21:47.894
But my team understands that that is very short sighted.
357
00:21:48.254 --> 00:21:51.975
Yes, you lost on that, you know, that commission or that closing.
358
00:21:52.555 --> 00:21:56.176
But it's a long game with your investment partners.
359
00:21:56.376 --> 00:21:58.697
It's a long game in the corporation.
360
00:21:59.237 --> 00:22:00.598
And that is really hard.
361
00:22:00.638 --> 00:22:09.040
I have a lot of compassion for people starting out because, you know, just, you know, the deal I was talking about, you know,
362
00:22:10.041 --> 00:22:16.726
I've lost upwards of millions of dollars where I've had to walk away because I'm non-refundable, but it is not right.
363
00:22:17.267 --> 00:22:18.148
It is not right.
364
00:22:19.309 --> 00:22:25.274
And so, you know, when I'm setting a budget for a year, I call it pursuit costs.
365
00:22:25.314 --> 00:22:26.535
And it's not a up.
366
00:22:26.775 --> 00:22:27.836
It's not a revenue stream.
367
00:22:28.076 --> 00:22:28.717
It's a cost.
368
00:22:29.658 --> 00:22:36.187
I already have X thousands, millions put aside going, this is okay to spend.
369
00:22:36.207 --> 00:22:37.449
So it's in the budget.
370
00:22:38.450 --> 00:22:41.515
People count their chickens and it's okay to count that.
371
00:22:42.757 --> 00:22:44.339
But you've also have to have the costs.
372
00:22:44.559 --> 00:22:48.223
So it's in the line item required, right?
373
00:22:48.323 --> 00:22:52.728
So it helps with people's compensation and whatnot because we know we're going to lose.
374
00:22:53.068 --> 00:22:58.374
But that is a maturity that brings you trust and repeatability with your investment partners.
375
00:22:58.654 --> 00:23:01.057
If you're here for a one and done, you can do that.
376
00:23:01.477 --> 00:23:05.241
If you want to stick around, you can't risk that.
377
00:23:05.802 --> 00:23:06.642
your reputation.
378
00:23:06.703 --> 00:23:12.245
I'm a female who lives in Canada who runs a U.S. real estate investment company.
379
00:23:12.906 --> 00:23:15.367
It's called Under Promise and Over Deliver.
380
00:23:15.647 --> 00:23:21.390
There is no dollar in a fee that is worth the cost of that.
381
00:23:21.490 --> 00:23:34.437
And for anyone that's owned a deal that hasn't performed how you thought, let me tell you, it is never worth the short-term win on the fees up front to operate a deal that isn't working.
382
00:23:35.417 --> 00:23:37.258
You will hate your life.
383
00:23:37.419 --> 00:23:39.180
And so I think it only takes one.
384
00:23:40.641 --> 00:23:46.364
Even
if you get that far, you know, you mentioned that, you know, you went through 2009 and whatnot.
385
00:23:46.404 --> 00:23:48.386
Like there is nothing worth it.
386
00:23:48.606 --> 00:23:49.266
It's awful.
387
00:23:49.606 --> 00:23:51.347
You're operating other people's money.
388
00:23:51.387 --> 00:23:52.608
You're operating your life.
389
00:23:53.989 --> 00:23:55.410
You care with your whole heart.
390
00:23:56.351 --> 00:24:02.835
It takes a tax on you that you cannot describe if you actually care is never worth the short term.
391
00:24:03.335 --> 00:24:04.215
Yeah, no, I agree.
392
00:24:04.636 --> 00:24:13.939
And I think, I mean, just, just to that sentiment, um, you talk about building trust with investment partners and, you know, at the end of the day, it takes a lifetime for us to build this, this reputation.
393
00:24:14.199 --> 00:24:16.881
Um, but it takes one, literally one bad deal to absolutely wreck it.
394
00:24:17.001 --> 00:24:21.222
And it's really difficult to, to ever, um, uh, recover from that.
395
00:24:21.262 --> 00:24:23.283
And I, and I, I, I think we're seeing that.
396
00:24:23.323 --> 00:24:25.644
I mean, like we, we, I think we've seen that maybe play out.
397
00:24:25.664 --> 00:24:27.745
I think there's, there was a moment in time, um,
398
00:24:27.845 --> 00:24:38.988
You know, when rates were incredibly low that a lot of new sponsors, especially in the multifamily space, were just getting overly aggressive and were really not looking for the long term.
399
00:24:39.008 --> 00:24:49.291
They weren't looking at the, you know, what's my business look like in 10 to 15 years and what decisions do I have to make today in order to create a business that has legs that can last a decade plus?
400
00:24:49.371 --> 00:24:50.011
It was more challenging.
401
00:24:50.491 --> 00:24:56.815
it was more built around a front loaded fee structure that just allowed me to feed so that I could get to the next deal.
402
00:24:56.835 --> 00:25:00.998
But ultimately a lot of bad decisions were made with that short sighted mindset.
403
00:25:01.098 --> 00:25:13.167
So in any event, and then not to hound on some, some syndicators that have had some challenges, but I saw it firsthand even in our industry, even in our space, you know, there, there were a lot of deals that we weren't able to buy.
404
00:25:13.187 --> 00:25:17.870
You know, we're pretty disciplined with, with our underwriting and we just couldn't get competitive in, you know,
405
00:25:17.930 --> 00:25:20.231
you know, 2020, 2021, 2022.
406
00:25:20.791 --> 00:25:26.332
And now we've seen a number of those deals come back around where there's, you know, there's short term debt maturities that are coming due.
407
00:25:26.352 --> 00:25:30.494
They're having to bring equity to the table to get new debt put in place.
408
00:25:30.574 --> 00:25:38.176
And just the operations haven't necessarily panned out how they had anticipated or how they had projected them on their financial model.
409
00:25:38.216 --> 00:25:39.036
And so, again, just...
410
00:25:39.496 --> 00:25:48.063
I think having that long-term vision in place and being willing to take your time to build a meaningful business that will stand the test of time is incredibly important.
411
00:25:48.083 --> 00:25:49.785
And so I think that's exactly what you've done.
412
00:25:50.785 --> 00:25:55.569
You know, I would love to, Jane, I always, I love to, you know, we're talking theoretically right now.
413
00:25:55.910 --> 00:26:02.395
I'd always like to get real case studies of deals, you know, like let's talk about a real deal when it comes to mind.
414
00:26:02.415 --> 00:26:05.298
I'm sure you've had a number of them, but a deal that you really liked, um, you know,
415
00:26:05.838 --> 00:26:11.162
You spent time, you spent pursuit costs on it and ultimately walked away from.
416
00:26:11.182 --> 00:26:17.266
And again, I know the objective is to get to a no as fast as possible so that we don't have a lot of sunken pursuit costs.
417
00:26:17.286 --> 00:26:19.808
But as you and I both know, that's just sometimes not possible.
418
00:26:19.828 --> 00:26:23.891
Sometimes you've got to get in and actually spend a meaningful amount of money and surprises come up.
419
00:26:23.931 --> 00:26:33.078
And so is there a deal that comes to mind that you would love sharing that just, I guess, what finally caused you to say that we're done, we're walking away, we're calling it quits?
420
00:26:33.844 --> 00:26:36.287
Well, I was thinking about it.
421
00:26:36.767 --> 00:26:39.009
And I mean, when someone said, have you had them?
422
00:26:39.050 --> 00:26:41.132
I'm like, oh, a lot.
423
00:26:41.432 --> 00:26:42.513
Yeah, a lot.
424
00:26:42.593 --> 00:26:44.115
I've had them.
425
00:26:44.355 --> 00:26:51.503
But one that, you know, I think that the further you get to closing and that people don't talk about this enough.
426
00:26:52.568 --> 00:26:57.033
the harder it is if you're not prepared to do that.
427
00:26:57.094 --> 00:26:59.516
Because you've launched marketing materials.
428
00:26:59.897 --> 00:27:02.880
You've spoken with investors.
429
00:27:03.641 --> 00:27:06.164
Investors have wired money in, right?
430
00:27:06.184 --> 00:27:07.706
They've signed legal documentation.
431
00:27:07.746 --> 00:27:12.312
So why you're so harsh to get to know is because it is,
432
00:27:12.712 --> 00:27:16.814
Each one of those, it gets that much more complicated to unravel.
433
00:27:17.274 --> 00:27:20.595
I don't think we talk about that part as much, Kevin.
434
00:27:20.875 --> 00:27:32.239
There's the loss of pursuit costs, but there's also, wow, I have an external money-raise agent that has now spent all of this time that if we don't close, they don't get paid.
435
00:27:32.279 --> 00:27:37.601
We're not even talking internal, you know, your RAs or your other groups.
436
00:27:37.621 --> 00:27:41.043
So the one that was on my mind...
437
00:27:42.183 -->
00:27:44.643
We got all the way before four days of closing.
438
00:27:44.663 --> 00:27:49.424
So that means every dollar of money is raised.
439
00:27:49.464 --> 00:27:51.605
We're talking 100 investment partners.
440
00:27:51.665 --> 00:27:57.886
We're talking external referral people that have brought that money in.
441
00:27:58.506 --> 00:28:07.448
And the structure of a tax benefit that really made this deal make sense was denied.
442
00:28:08.448 --> 00:28:09.470
Uh, it had been approved forever and it was denied.
443
00:28:09.490 --> 00:28:11.993
And, and, you know, you're, you're to unravel that is, it's really easy during DD to walk away.
444
00:28:12.013 --> 00:28:12.994
When you're there, you're now sending money back.
445
00:28:13.015 --> 00:28:23.810
You're, you're, you're, you're, you're, you're, you're, you're, you're, you're, you're, you're, you're, you're, you're, you're, you're, you're, you're, you're, you're, you're, you're, you're, you're, you're, you're, you're, you're, you're, you're, you're, you're, you're, you're, you're, you're, you're, you're, you're, you're, you're, you're, you're, you're, you're, you're, you're, you're, you're, you're, you're, you're, you're, you're, you're, you're, you
446
00:28:24.791 --> 00:28:28.095
You don't just send it back without making a hundred phone calls.
447
00:28:28.135 --> 00:28:33.261
So you're, you're not kind of dating, you're like married or it's the night before the wedding.
448
00:28:33.301 --> 00:28:35.223
I always joke like, let's think about a wedding.
449
00:28:35.563 --> 00:28:37.125
We're dating now we're engaged.
450
00:28:37.265 --> 00:28:39.248
Okay, we break up, it's a little bit more public.
451
00:28:39.708 --> 00:28:41.130
Now I bought the wedding dress.
452
00:28:41.150 --> 00:28:41.671
And I'm
453
00:28:43.312 --> 00:28:47.875
And it didn't, it financially didn't make sense.
454
00:28:48.116 --> 00:28:52.479
And so you're unraveling many, many people's lives.
455
00:28:52.619 --> 00:29:01.225
Now, what's important in that, it was just a tax structure that just fundamentally you didn't get the credit on lower taxes.
456
00:29:01.265 --> 00:29:06.088
So your NOI, you know, goes down, your cash flows wrong.
457
00:29:06.448 --> 00:29:07.269
Could I have closed it?
458
00:29:07.349 --> 00:29:08.470
Yeah, 100%.
459
00:29:08.770 --> 00:29:10.991
You could have looked the other way and did that.
460
00:29:11.712 --> 00:29:11.912
Yeah.
461
00:29:12.532 --> 00:29:19.676
phoning 100 people because sending an email, of course, then the questions, the other thing is your reputation is like, well, why did that occur?
462
00:29:20.136 --> 00:29:27.581
And you can take that as a negative or you can actually make it one of the best relationship building experiences you have with your investment partners.
463
00:29:28.541 --> 00:29:29.862
And did we lose our deposit?
464
00:29:29.882 --> 00:29:30.882
A hundred percent.
465
00:29:30.923 --> 00:29:36.065
Did we lose four months of marketing and the team launching that?
466
00:29:36.085 --> 00:29:36.986
A hundred percent.
467
00:29:37.406 --> 00:29:38.747
We'd already bought pool furniture.
468
00:29:38.807 --> 00:29:39.908
We've already bought everything.
469
00:29:40.488 --> 00:29:42.229
But it's not right.
470
00:29:42.429 --> 00:29:44.310
And making those phone calls, it took time.
471
00:29:44.950 --> 00:29:54.636
But the relationship on the other side, the prudency to say no is far more important than anything else.
472
00:29:55.425 --> 00:29:58.768
Well, I mean, that's how you create lifelong investors, right?
473
00:29:58.788 --> 00:29:59.548
Lifelong partners.
474
00:29:59.608 --> 00:30:10.557
I mean, you might have, out of that hundred that you called, there might've been one that just was so perturbed for whatever reason, although that you were still, I mean, you were being the responsible one by saying no, you were going to internally eat the cost of it.
475
00:30:10.577 --> 00:30:11.898
They were going to get their capital back.
476
00:30:12.718 --> 00:30:14.720
But ultimately he had plans for that capital.
477
00:30:14.740 --> 00:30:17.042
His plan was with you and it didn't go as planned.
478
00:30:17.202 --> 00:30:18.723
But the other 99 more than likely
479
00:30:19.083 --> 00:30:21.265
had become lifelong investment partners of yours.
480
00:30:21.345 --> 00:30:37.441
So, and whether that could have been the case of, even if the deal would have gone as planned, but more than likely you probably retained even more of those folks when they realize that you are incredibly disciplined individual and that, that you just, you don't, you're not willing to sacrifice.
481
00:30:37.461 --> 00:30:40.243
You're not willing to make a judgment call and buy a bad deal.
482
00:30:40.343 --> 00:30:40.784
And so, yeah,
483
00:30:41.244 --> 00:30:42.605
Um, no, I think that's, that's wonderful.
484
00:30:42.625 --> 00:30:43.767
Thank you for sharing that.
485
00:30:44.187 --> 00:30:47.710
Um, there's another, you know, another part of your story, which I think is really intriguing.
486
00:30:48.011 --> 00:30:50.353
Um, and I've got a similar one, but I'm not going to tell mine.
487
00:30:50.373 --> 00:30:51.414
I'm going to let you tell yours.
488
00:30:51.474 --> 00:30:52.916
And it's, I think this happened.
489
00:30:53.136 --> 00:30:57.540
I think this happened to you back during, um, during the first couple of weeks of COVID.
490
00:30:58.141 --> 00:31:00.263
Um, and I, and I believe, correct me if I'm wrong.
491
00:31:00.283 --> 00:31:00.463
Uh,
492
00:31:00.583 --> 00:31:06.566
At that point, I think you were mostly leveraging and outsourcing the third-party property management, which is a very common structure.
493
00:31:07.367 --> 00:31:15.351
But the property management firm that you were using, I think, made a decision that you didn't ultimately agree with.
494
00:31:15.651 --> 00:31:20.934
And at that point, you decided to make a major shift within your
organization.
495
00:31:20.954 --> 00:31:26.177
And so maybe if you would speak to that timeframe, what ultimately occurred and then what was the end result?
496
00:31:26.942 --> 00:31:35.548
We so at that point, right before COVID, we were using seven different management companies, right, even more than one in a certain city.
497
00:31:37.530 --> 00:31:45.235
And so we had, you know, had had original, you know, the strategic mandate was we are going to do this.
498
00:31:45.295 --> 00:31:48.717
The average time frame is usually about nine months to to do it.
499
00:31:48.777 --> 00:31:49.098
And it was.
500
00:31:49.718 --> 00:31:52.439
It was December and COVID kind of hit in March.
501
00:31:52.479 --> 00:31:59.242
And I said, when we find the right leader or the right components, we'd identified them, we'll start the process.
502
00:31:59.402 --> 00:32:05.044
And so we had identified the leader in January, but she wasn't joining us until March.
503
00:32:05.704 --> 00:32:06.525
COVID hit.
504
00:32:07.045 --> 00:32:14.228
And our plan was kind of to do this the traditional way, which I don't realize I'm not traditional in any kind of way.
505
00:32:15.348 --> 00:32:24.835
Um, and we get an email from one of the, one of our largest management companies saying, um, our staff isn't going into the office.
506
00:32:24.895 --> 00:32:26.316
We're, we're, we're closing.
507
00:32:27.483 --> 00:32:33.705
And it was not discussed with us and not saying that that was right or wrong.
508
00:32:33.745 --> 00:32:35.685
But at the same time, you had the rent memorandum.
509
00:32:36.145 --> 00:32:46.468
And I went, oh, my gosh, we are having somebody make decisions that are based on their management company versus our equity.
510
00:32:47.695 --> 00:32:51.957
And it was just that, you know, you have those moments, you go, we have to do this.
511
00:32:52.638 --> 00:32:59.821
In 26 days, we launched Western Mall Communities, our vertically integrated property management company.
512
00:33:00.481 --> 00:33:03.323
On our first round, we took over 17 properties.
513
00:33:03.383 --> 00:33:13.148
Now, we were such a strong culture and our asset managers were so tight with our team members that were on our properties
514
00:33:13.788 --> 00:33:18.046
that every single one of them joined Western wealth communities except for two.
515
00:33:20.560 --> 00:33:22.321
because we took care of them as owners.
516
00:33:22.361 --> 00:33:25.882
And I mean, the message I could, you know, in that moment, I had no idea.
517
00:33:26.182 --> 00:33:34.444
But I knew that my sole job was to protect equity and create, you know, a safe, you know, as a landlord.
518
00:33:34.464 --> 00:33:41.525
But in that moment, it was protecting our equity and being in control of those decisions in that way.
519
00:33:42.125 --> 00:33:44.126
And we were walking a world that nobody knew.
520
00:33:44.486 --> 00:33:48.227
But I was going to be the only one that made them in our best interest.
521
00:33:48.927 --> 00:33:57.982
And so what really struck me is how important, if you have third-party management, it doesn't matter if it's in-house or not.
522
00:33:59.203 --> 00:34:00.343
Love those people.
523
00:34:00.904 --> 00:34:05.325
They are the ones that control and make or break your investment.
524
00:34:06.045 --> 00:34:08.386
Give them the gift card on their wedding anniversary.
525
00:34:08.866 --> 00:34:10.746
Find out how old their kids are.
526
00:34:11.306 --> 00:34:12.407
Bring the teddy.
527
00:34:12.887 --> 00:34:20.769
Be genuinely interested in them because they will genuinely, genuinely change how your investment shows up.
528
00:34:21.649 --> 00:34:28.599
And when we chose to lead, they identified so much as Western World Capital versus their management company that it wasn't even a question.
529
00:34:28.619 --> 00:34:31.062
It's like, well, they already were us.
530
00:34:31.523 --> 00:34:35.168
So somebody said, you're either crazy or brilliant.
531
00:34:35.208 --> 00:34:36.750
And I'm like, probably both.
532
00:34:38.533 --> 00:34:39.895
And it was crazy.
533
00:34:40.015 --> 00:34:40.936
It was chaotic.
534
00:34:41.016 --> 00:34:44.041
Looking back, though, you weren't buying deals, right?
535
00:34:44.121 --> 00:34:52.212
If you think about times when you make a pivotal shift, if we had been buying at the pace we were and tried to take over a management company,
536
00:34:52.948 --> 00:34:54.129
we wouldn't have done it well.
537
00:34:54.489 --> 00:34:58.131
In that time, we were only focused on operating.
538
00:34:58.612 --> 00:35:02.494
So it literally was a perfect time to do that.
539
00:35:02.634 --> 00:35:09.219
I don't know how well we would have done it in the distraction of buying, you know, and selling.
540
00:35:09.699 --> 00:35:12.060
Instead, in that moment, all we did was operate.
541
00:35:12.341 --> 00:35:15.663
So crazy or brilliant, we did it.
542
00:35:16.078 --> 00:35:17.019
Yeah, no, that's amazing.
543
00:35:17.439 --> 00:35:21.442
I said I wasn't going to share my story, but it's not as impressive as yours, though.
544
00:35:21.462 --> 00:35:22.723
You did it in 26 days.
545
00:35:22.823 --> 00:35:25.645
So we had a similar situation many years back.
546
00:35:25.685 --> 00:35:32.830
I think we had 24 properties in our portfolio and had outsourced it for... And it was more of an experiment.
547
00:35:33.290 --> 00:35:38.274
We had a vertically integrated, not incredibly robust property management platform.
548
00:35:38.314 --> 00:35:40.275
And we realized that that was just a weak point of ours.
549
00:35:40.295 --> 00:35:43.838
We outsourced it because we didn't want to focus on...
550
00:35:44.298 --> 00:35:53.227
we didn't want to have to grow an internal, uh, you know, Berkeley integrated property management company to the scale that we knew was necessary based on the size of our portfolio and based on our growth trajectory.
551
00:35:53.688 --> 00:35:57.211
And so we outsourced
it, you know, we, we attempted to hit the easy button.
552
00:35:57.231 --> 00:36:00.454
And as you, you and I both know, there's really no easy button in the business.
553
00:36:01.095 --> 00:36:04.338
And, uh, within six months we realized that it was the biggest mistake we'd ever made.
554
00:36:04.719 --> 00:36:05.399
And, um,
555
00:36:06.020 --> 00:36:18.032
And ultimately, you know, built out behind the scenes quietly over a period of about roughly four more months after that to where we could bring it back in house and essentially brought back in the entire portfolio.
556
00:36:18.072 --> 00:36:19.514
But it was it was chaotic.
557
00:36:19.554 --> 00:36:24.198
In fact, I will say that we actually had to it was during a period when we were buying a lot of properties and we had to stop.
558
00:36:24.258 --> 00:36:26.260
We literally had to stop new buying activity.
559
00:36:27.001 --> 00:36:28.281
for a period of about eight months.
560
00:36:28.321 --> 00:36:39.784
And that was very painful to do because we had a lot of momentum built and we were just really growing at a fast clip and we had to put the brakes on and say no to new investor capital, say no to new opportunities.
561
00:36:40.264 --> 00:36:48.086
And as you know, that's tough to do because you know that you're passing up probably on some pretty good ones that came your way that might not ever resurface again.
562
00:36:48.967 --> 00:36:50.687
But it was the best decision that we've ever made.
563
00:36:50.707 --> 00:36:54.188
Now we can be fully accountable for all the decisions that we make, whether they're right or wrong.
564
00:36:54.808 --> 00:37:11.553
I would much rather make the incorrect decision on a particular property and be able to own it entirely and find the mistake that was made, own the mistake, and then find the solution rather than having a third party make that decision on my behalf.
565
00:37:11.614 --> 00:37:16.875
And so I think, yeah, it was one of the best decisions we made in our business many years back.
566
00:37:16.955 --> 00:37:18.716
And, you know, we're…
567
00:37:19.376 --> 00:37:25.019
I would say that in our industry, at least, I would say about 50% of folks outsource and the other 50% Berkeley integrate.
568
00:37:25.039 --> 00:37:28.781
But as you know, it's also difficult to do unless you have the scale to do it.
569
00:37:28.821 --> 00:37:43.670
So we were kind of at the spread at the cusp to where we knew that we would have to inject a lot of capital over the next year or two into that business because it wasn't going to be profitable if we were going to run it correctly.
570
00:37:43.690 --> 00:37:47.172
If we're going to hire the right staff, build out the right team that had the expertise,
571
00:37:47.792 --> 00:37:50.453
It was it was not going to make money for a number of years.
572
00:37:50.473 --> 00:37:57.715
And that was also a painful decision, knowing that we would have to inject multiple seven figures until we got to the scale to where it could at least be a break even.
573
00:37:57.755 --> 00:38:00.816
So but again, still the wouldn't wouldn't change it for the world.
574
00:38:00.976 --> 00:38:02.157
Best decision that we've ever made.
575
00:38:02.777 --> 00:38:04.397
I appreciate you sharing that.
576
00:38:04.437 --> 00:38:05.858
Twenty six days, that was quite impressive.
577
00:38:05.878 --> 00:38:07.919
I don't know how you do that, but you obviously pulled it off.
578
00:38:07.999 --> 00:38:10.880
And somehow you know what?
579
00:38:10.900 --> 00:38:11.880
Sometimes you don't have a choice.
580
00:38:12.445 --> 00:38:13.185
Yeah, that's right.
581
00:38:13.225 --> 00:38:13.705
Absolutely.
582
00:38:13.725 --> 00:38:14.625
You rip the bandaid off.
583
00:38:14.665 --> 00:38:16.166
You're doing it.
584
00:38:16.446 --> 00:38:21.927
And, you know, actually, I think some of the best things that happen because you can spend so much time in over planning.
585
00:38:22.007 --> 00:38:26.908
But truthfully, you don't really know what's broken until you break it.
586
00:38:27.128 --> 00:38:27.468
Right.
587
00:38:27.568 --> 00:38:37.329
I always tell my team we will be always broken in some places, but that means you've pushed it to a point where it's broken and now you can fix it.
588
00:38:37.369 --> 00:38:39.850
And that's in growth or that's in challenging ways.
589
00:38:40.390 --> 00:38:41.350
What is it now?
590
00:38:41.690 --> 00:38:46.231
Okay, can you do it better, faster, you know, more cost effects of whatever that is.
591
00:38:46.252 --> 00:38:47.812
And at some point you hit something.
592
00:38:47.872 --> 00:38:50.733
And that is, there's beauty in the breakdown.
593
00:38:51.913 --> 00:38:53.913
But we can plan, plan, plan.
594
00:38:53.953 --> 00:38:54.574
But you know what?
595
00:38:54.694 --> 00:39:01.255
It's in those moments that you just, you build the resilience and you fix it.
596
00:39:01.715 --> 00:39:03.956
But you won't know what the problem is until you're in it.
597
00:39:04.717 --> 00:39:05.558
Yeah, no, I agree.
598
00:39:06.780 --> 00:39:08.062
Would love to switch gears.
599
00:39:08.282 --> 00:39:11.527
I know that we're pressing the time here.
600
00:39:11.547 --> 00:39:15.774
And I definitely want to get into your business today because I know that – I know your buy box –
601
00:39:17.332 --> 00:39:23.536
any business in order to continue growing and, and, and, and, and build a organization that, that, that stands the test of time.
602
00:39:23.556 --> 00:39:28.318
You got to be willing to evolve and adapt because the times change, the economy changes.
603
00:39:29.519 --> 00:39:34.102
What maybe made sense 10 years ago, it doesn't make sense today as far as, as far as the business and scaling.
604
00:39:34.502 --> 00:39:38.024
And so I know that your buy box has, has changed over recent years.
605
00:39:38.644 --> 00:39:46.669
And so maybe speak to your business today and why, why are you now focused on income restricted
multifamily housing?
606
00:39:47.391 --> 00:39:47.691
Sure.
607
00:39:49.052 --> 00:39:54.495
You know, you evolve with where the world's at, right, on those things.
608
00:39:54.575 --> 00:39:57.056
So low-income tax credit housing.
609
00:39:57.276 --> 00:39:58.757
So what is that?
610
00:40:00.097 --> 00:40:07.021
Basically, at the time that a developer builds something, they will get an incentive or a credit.
611
00:40:09.401 --> 00:40:22.885
during that build to basically say that X number of units could be 100% of the units, it could be, you know, a subset to ensure that they stay at a lower rent amount than market rent.
612
00:40:23.365 --> 00:40:33.808
And all that that's really doing is allowing for individuals that have lower income to be able to qualify, you know, to live in a property that they otherwise could not.
613
00:40:34.908 --> 00:40:47.120
And so one of the things that 25 years ago happened in the U.S. is one of the largest influxes of buildings happened.
614
00:40:47.280 --> 00:40:50.503
And so these credits stay on on average.
615
00:40:50.563 --> 00:40:53.606
Now, all of them are a little bit different, but just traditionally about 30 years.
616
00:40:53.866 --> 00:40:57.909
So over the next five years, we are going to see the first.
617
00:40:58.970 --> 00:41:02.871
mass expiration of LIHTC or low-income tax credit housing.
618
00:41:03.391 --> 00:41:09.513
And so, you know, what we have historically been is value-add multifamily workforce housing.
619
00:41:09.613 --> 00:41:18.395
So, you know, at the peak of our, you know, kind of our pace, we were buying an apartment building every 12 and a half days doing 300 renovations a month.
620
00:41:19.275 --> 00:41:30.629
Um, and, and so when we're in this phase where, you know, really concessions are high, there's some occupancy challenges, uh, because of new supply that's come on, that's sort of burning off.
621
00:41:31.270 --> 00:41:33.452
And when I really took a step back and went, okay.
622
00:41:33.472 --> 00:41:33.572
Okay.
623
00:41:34.333 --> 00:41:43.784
What makes sense right now with interest rates high, with some of the excess supply, where if I were going to plus my money, do I feel comfortable and safe?
624
00:41:43.865 --> 00:41:53.576
And so in this situation, what you're buying is basically rents on average are about 20 to 25 percent below market rents.
625
00:41:54.457 --> 00:42:08.706
So what an individual is able to do is, you know, instead of living in a 1970s rental, which would be the same rent, they're able to live in a 2000-2010 building.
626
00:42:08.966 --> 00:42:10.887
And so these buildings are full.
627
00:42:11.187 --> 00:42:21.754
So in a time where we have interest rates high and people are looking for cash flow or at least, you know, covering cash flow, we don't have occupancy issues in these buildings because, A, there's not enough of them.
628
00:42:22.794 --> 00:42:26.156
And I want to kind of expand your thinking around what do you mean by low income?
629
00:42:26.176 --> 00:42:29.637
Well, our head of acquisitions, daughter graduated university.
630
00:42:30.077 --> 00:42:31.458
She's living in one.
631
00:42:31.478 --> 00:42:31.558
Why?
632
00:42:31.798 --> 00:42:35.560
She's just new to the work, you know, working.
633
00:42:35.960 --> 00:42:37.280
So her income is low.
634
00:42:37.380 --> 00:42:38.721
She has a degree in biology.
635
00:42:38.741 --> 00:42:39.521
We're not talking about.
636
00:42:40.201 --> 00:42:43.743
And so she was able to apply.
637
00:42:44.063 --> 00:42:44.723
It took her two weeks.
638
00:42:44.743 --> 00:42:46.144
There's a lot of paperwork.
639
00:42:46.284 --> 00:42:48.845
And that's part of the reason you don't see as many buyers in it.
640
00:42:48.885 --> 00:42:50.546
There's work involved in that.
641
00:42:51.146 --> 00:42:55.167
But she was able to live in a much newer property on her lower income.
642
00:42:55.187 --> 00:43:03.909
So some of it is expanding your idea of what that means you're just not you're making a certain amount below what that city's amount is.
643
00:43:04.710 --> 00:43:08.991
Now, in today's day, you're not concession fighting.
644
00:43:09.731 --> 00:43:12.492
Our average occupancy is about 98%.
645
00:43:13.192 --> 00:43:18.313
Your turnover is about a third because where are you going?
646
00:43:18.333 --> 00:43:20.114
There's not as much of this housing.
647
00:43:21.853 --> 00:43:28.156
buyers, way smaller buyer pool, because you do have, you know, you do have rules.
648
00:43:28.197 --> 00:43:32.659
I often say to people who are like, I really want to do this myself, Janet, I go, that is no problem.
649
00:43:32.699 --> 00:43:41.545
I'm not talking about low income tax credit housing, but just being an investor, I go, you either have to become an expert in investing, or you have to go and invest with somebody who's an expert.
650
00:43:41.945 --> 00:43:43.966
But you're going to kill yourself if you aren't the expert.
651
00:43:43.986 --> 00:43:46.368
And so there is extra paperwork and
652
00:43:49.850 --> 00:43:54.754
But basically, you're buying an asset that's now 25% below rent.
653
00:43:55.455 --> 00:44:01.600
At some point in the next five, eight years, those credits are going to expire.
654
00:44:02.280 --> 00:44:05.463
And at that point, you can bring that rent to market.
655
00:44:05.483 --> 00:44:11.488
Or you can have a new relationship with the city where they're going to give you some other benefit to keep that.
656
00:44:11.848 --> 00:44:13.550
Win-win either way as an investor.
657
00:44:13.570 --> 00:44:13.670
Okay.
658
00:44:14.130 --> 00:44:23.662
So in the traditional sense of what we used to be a value add, you know, people go in and say, I'm here, I'm going to be able to do A, B, and C. We're not seeing value add in the marketplace.
659
00:44:23.702 --> 00:44:25.104
I laugh when I see other people doing it.
660
00:44:25.124 --> 00:44:27.026
I'm like, no one's paying for that right
now.
661
00:44:27.467 --> 00:44:31.812
This is a built-in value add without doing anything.
662
00:44:31.832 --> 00:44:32.333
Right.
663
00:44:32.513 --> 00:44:35.015
So you can put in fixed, you know, fixed rate.
664
00:44:35.376 --> 00:44:36.497
You've got cash flow.
665
00:44:36.517 --> 00:44:40.881
Your cap rates are when you're buying them, they're higher.
666
00:44:40.941 --> 00:44:42.903
You have a more narrow buying pool.
667
00:44:43.343 --> 00:44:49.168
As you get closer to the expiry, more people are wanting to buy them because, you know, in the next year they're going to expire.
668
00:44:49.228 --> 00:44:53.012
It's just a it's it's value add without actually doing anything.
669
00:44:53.032 --> 00:44:53.612
Yeah.
670
00:44:54.653 --> 00:45:06.780
And I love the fact that, you know, because there's a mass expiry, many of the city's municipalities, you are going to work with them and can continue to keep it that way because there's going to be incentive.
671
00:45:06.840 --> 00:45:10.181
There is going to be a problem with this much expiring, right?
672
00:45:11.702 --> 00:45:15.064
So in my mind, as the operator, I get a win-win.
673
00:45:15.204 --> 00:45:19.106
Either I am going to let it expire because the city is not giving me enough incentive.
674
00:45:19.546 --> 00:45:21.147
And I'm now moved 25% rents.
675
00:45:23.348 --> 00:45:23.829
doing nothing.
676
00:45:23.849 --> 00:45:25.910
The building right next door is exactly that.
677
00:45:27.551 --> 00:45:30.753
Or we're going to be able to find a new program and keep it that way.
678
00:45:30.873 --> 00:45:37.638
So it's right now, you know, I don't have to worry a rent's going to drop another percent.
679
00:45:37.658 --> 00:45:39.139
I mean, we're very much at the bottom.
680
00:45:39.199 --> 00:45:39.879
It's going to drop 2%.
681
00:45:40.059 --> 00:45:40.840
It doesn't matter to me.
682
00:45:41.320 --> 00:45:43.121
I'm 20% different than market.
683
00:45:43.582 --> 00:45:45.443
I'm going to stay full no matter what.
684
00:45:45.543 --> 00:45:46.764
Yeah, there's lots of opportunity.
685
00:45:46.984 --> 00:45:58.875
I'm just curious to know some context around maybe just a general number of how many buildings we'll be talking about here over the next five to eight years that are coming up on their exploration.
686
00:45:59.636 --> 00:46:01.097
Are we talking hundreds?
687
00:46:01.117 --> 00:46:01.938
Yeah, hundreds.
688
00:46:01.958 --> 00:46:02.038
Yep.
689
00:46:04.537 --> 00:46:06.598
Hundreds or hundreds of thousands?
690
00:46:06.978 --> 00:46:07.799
Hundreds of thousands.
691
00:46:08.279 --> 00:46:08.659
Wow.
692
00:46:08.920 --> 00:46:09.660
Hundreds of thousands.
693
00:46:09.860 --> 00:46:12.001
Interesting.
694
00:46:12.782 --> 00:46:15.003
So it's the first mass expiration.
695
00:46:15.343 --> 00:46:21.127
So in the 30,000 apartment units I have bought, some of them had components of that.
696
00:46:22.188 --> 00:46:28.051
Our business strategy in that
was go in, renovate, reposition the building, renovate.
697
00:46:28.111 --> 00:46:30.932
you know, increase the rents, you know, reposition and move.
698
00:46:31.792 --> 00:46:41.413
And what's funny is I would get these, you know, these buildings that would say, you know, almost completely rent controlled or the LIHTC rent, right?
699
00:46:41.453 --> 00:46:43.854
And I go, oh, no, thanks, because it is more work.
700
00:46:43.894 --> 00:46:44.894
There's paperwork.
701
00:46:44.954 --> 00:46:53.236
There's, you know, there's compliance because, you know, you have, you know, you're making sure that they match all of that.
702
00:46:53.276 --> 00:46:55.076
So I go, oh, I don't want to touch that.
703
00:46:55.556 --> 00:47:05.384
But in right now in today's day and age where you have, you know, occupancy challenges, you have uncertainty with, you know, rents and interest rates.
704
00:47:05.464 --> 00:47:10.147
Now you're buying, you know, one of the cap rates that we just put under contract is a 7.9.
705
00:47:10.508 --> 00:47:12.609
This is a this is a 2000.
706
00:47:12.649 --> 00:47:13.730
And this is a truth.
707
00:47:13.930 --> 00:47:15.451
Yes, exactly.
708
00:47:15.471 --> 00:47:15.572
Yeah.
709
00:47:16.312 --> 00:47:18.153
It's 98% occupied.
710
00:47:18.173 --> 00:47:20.754
It's a 2005 vintage.
711
00:47:21.714 --> 00:47:27.516
And, you know, the rents expire in 10 years.
712
00:47:27.536 --> 00:47:31.238
So probably a few years before that, you know, we're going to carry it for about seven years.
713
00:47:31.258 --> 00:47:36.320
We're going to have huge cash flow, very little tenant turnover.
714
00:47:36.820 --> 00:47:41.282
And we'll either continue it through or we'll, you know, at that point sell it.
715
00:47:41.302 --> 00:47:45.023
Because when you're very close to expiry, you're attracting a different buyer.
716
00:47:45.932 --> 00:47:46.553
Yeah.
717
00:47:46.573 --> 00:47:47.773
What type of debt is available?
718
00:47:47.793 --> 00:47:57.081
Like maybe using the example you just gave there, the property selling at 7.9 within place, is there underlying assumable debt on that property or are you having to go out and get it?
719
00:47:57.161 --> 00:47:57.861
I'm assuming agency.
720
00:47:57.881 --> 00:48:00.143
We'll put both.
721
00:48:00.383 --> 00:48:10.251
So, you know, we'll assume it if it makes sense, but also Freddie and Fannie, they have programs because it's, it is low income, you know, light tech housing.
722
00:48:10.271 --> 00:48:14.594
So we actually get, you know, about a quarter point or more better than market.
723
00:48:14.634 --> 00:48:14.735
Yeah.
724
00:48:17.037 --> 00:48:19.940
because of the incentives.
725
00:48:20.360 --> 00:48:21.902
They also line it up.
726
00:48:21.942 --> 00:48:36.337
So if the expiry is happening, let's just say at year seven, what they'll let you do is you can put on the 10-year fixed rate debt, which again, in this day and age where everything else is going on, let the whole world work itself out and just come and invest in these cash flowing buildings.
727
00:48:36.837 --> 00:48:38.399
I don't need to worry about the rest.
728
00:48:38.579 --> 00:48:41.341
You're still going to get your accelerated depreciation as an investor.
729
00:48:41.361 --> 00:48:43.403
Just go and enjoy this.
730
00:48:43.583 --> 00:48:47.106
Let the rest of the world work their world out.
731
00:48:47.626 --> 00:48:54.812
But Freddie will even tie it so that if the expiry was happening at year seven, instead of having, like, they'll unwind it for you.
732
00:48:54.832 --> 00:49:00.677
Like, they make it very easy because it's sort of part of that social housing piece.
733
00:49:00.717 --> 00:49:07.022
So that's a huge benefit to it.
734
00:49:07.512 --> 00:49:09.113
Yeah, I got a couple other questions here.
735
00:49:09.213 --> 00:49:14.377
I know that the scenario I'm about to give you might not be exactly how most of these are arranged.
736
00:49:14.437 --> 00:49:17.440
I know it could be maybe 50% of the units, 70% of the units.
737
00:49:17.460 --> 00:49:25.206
So I'm just going to use the example of 70% of the units are income restricted and the other 30% are market.
738
00:49:25.286 --> 00:49:30.309
Yeah, so like using that scenario, maybe just using this deal that you guys are going to go into –
739
00:49:31.390 --> 00:49:39.440
I'm assuming that even – is it pretty common that even the market rate apartments are a little lower than that of what traditional market rate apartments would be?
740
00:49:39.600 --> 00:49:40.361
Is that pretty common?
741
00:49:40.401 --> 00:49:40.661
No.
742
00:49:41.462 --> 00:49:41.683
Okay.
743
00:49:41.703 --> 00:49:43.104
So they're at market.
744
00:49:43.164 --> 00:49:43.745
No.
745
00:49:44.065 --> 00:49:44.326
Okay.
746
00:49:44.346 --> 00:49:49.051
So they might be at market, but there might not – so there might not be even a lot of value add with those market rate apartments.
747
00:49:49.071 --> 00:49:49.452
But I guess –
748
00:49:49.892 --> 00:49:53.333
You could always add some amenities, add some improvements to the entirety of the property.
749
00:49:53.353 --> 00:50:01.036
Do you guys typically budget to go in and do some additional aesthetic improvements to just enhance the lives of all the residents?
750
00:50:01.576 --> 00:50:03.476
You might go to get a little bump on the market rate apartments.
751
00:50:03.496 --> 00:50:08.958
You're obviously not going to be able to recapture the value-add dollars that were spent on the property.
752
00:50:09.438 --> 00:50:10.819
uh, income restricted apartments.
753
00:50:10.879 --> 00:50:13.540
But I guess, how do you look at that holistically?
754
00:50:13.840 --> 00:50:20.483
Um, when you approach one of these properties, I mean, at a, at a seven, nine cap, uh, let's be honest, Kevin, um, you have money, you have money.
755
00:50:20.523 --> 00:50:25.905
So you, you know, you know, I, you know, I'm not planning to exit it early.
756
00:50:25.965 --> 00:50:26.246
Right.
757
00:50:26.306 --> 00:50:31.968
So I, I know I'm going in for seven years, but you're just, you're cranking cash on the market rate.
758
00:50:32.008 --> 00:50:35.910
What's others interesting that people don't realize it isn't just the Delta to market rent.
759
00:50:35.930 --> 00:50:36.210
Um,
760
00:50:36.891 --> 00:50:42.256
You can't charge for like parking or washers drive.
761
00:50:42.296 --> 00:50:48.522
So there's a bunch of other income on top that as soon as you go to market rent, you can charge for.
762
00:50:48.983 --> 00:50:53.247
So one of the things that you do find in the market rate side of it is that –
763
00:50:54.428 --> 00:50:59.931
Okay, so imagine as a developer, you're the developer, you make all of your money in fees, right?
764
00:51:00.011 --> 00:51:02.993
You get a huge construction management fee.
765
00:51:03.733 --> 00:51:09.977
So as time progresses, you're really not always paying attention to the operations of these assets.
766
00:51:11.457 --> 00:51:23.103
You even haven't maximized the, you know, the rent controlled kind of rent maximum, because you've moved on your business model is going on to the next development, not necessarily being a long term operator.
767
00:51:23.783 --> 00:51:25.604
So just simple.
768
00:51:27.365 --> 00:51:28.366
small tweaks.
769
00:51:28.386 --> 00:51:30.067
You don't need to do a huge repositioning.
770
00:51:30.147 --> 00:51:32.569
We're not talking about super old assets either, right?
771
00:51:32.989 --> 00:51:34.590
And you haven't had a ton of turnover.
772
00:51:35.111 --> 00:51:45.138
But mainly, if it's been owned by the same original developer, it just hasn't been a focus because they make all of their money in the beginning with the build.
773
00:51:45.318 --> 00:51:47.440
And that's their business model.
774
00:51:48.200 --> 00:51:54.886
So, the stuff, I laugh because we were deep value add repositioning, you know, folks.
775
00:51:55.726 --> 00:51:59.970
And here, this is very light, of course.
776
00:52:00.430 --> 00:52:09.778
I mean, that's table stakes to being, you know, a good, you know, operator or landlord is you do have to plan your CapEx strategy for that period of time.
777
00:52:09.798 --> 00:52:15.403
But with that much cash flow, a lot of that can go right through, you know, your cash flow.
778
00:52:15.443 --> 00:52:15.583
But,
779
00:52:17.263 --> 00:52:30.232
Have you changed your institutional capital sources going from the traditional deep value add multifamily to that of this type of it's more of a cash flow driven play than that of an IRR driven play?
780
00:52:30.252 --> 00:52:37.977
Do you have different capital partners that prefer this type of product versus that of something where they can drive high IRRs getting in and out in the three to four year span of time?
781
00:52:38.833 --> 00:52:44.039
Well, and many of our institutional partners, as an example, have more than one fund.
782
00:52:44.340 -->
00:52:45.741
So you've got your evergreen funds.
783
00:52:45.801 --> 00:52:47.503
This is great for that, right?
784
00:52:47.924 --> 00:52:49.786
And then you have your value add funds.
785
00:52:49.826 --> 00:52:53.690
So it doesn't necessarily mean you're actually changing partnerships.
786
00:52:53.710 --> 00:52:54.491
You're changing funds.
787
00:52:55.152 --> 00:52:56.333
You're changing the strategy.
788
00:52:57.154 --> 00:53:05.941
And so many and one of the greatest benefits, at least, you know, with many of our high net worth kind of syndication is accelerated depreciation.
789
00:53:06.061 --> 00:53:07.402
You still get it right.
790
00:53:07.722 --> 00:53:08.543
You're going to get that.
791
00:53:08.563 --> 00:53:14.708
You're going to get the yield play, which for so long hasn't really existed in multifamily.
792
00:53:15.228 --> 00:53:19.731
So you're almost tapping in not necessarily to different investment partners.
793
00:53:19.752 --> 00:53:20.292
Yeah.
794
00:53:20.873 --> 00:53:25.259
different pocket of their income or different pocket of their investment channel.
795
00:53:25.780 --> 00:53:30.586
And there's people still want to invest in multifamily or in real estate.
796
00:53:31.247 --> 00:53:33.090
It's just been challenging to do so.
797
00:53:33.470 --> 00:53:33.711
Right.
798
00:53:33.811 --> 00:53:35.433
It's been really challenging.
799
00:53:35.513 --> 00:53:35.693
And this
800
00:53:37.035 --> 00:53:38.936
is such a simple way to do it.
801
00:53:39.556 --> 00:53:42.817
Well, it hasn't been a yield play for many, many years.
802
00:53:42.917 --> 00:53:43.177
Right.
803
00:53:43.237 --> 00:53:48.339
And so like in the, now the value add game is basically stopping this track to a certain degree.
804
00:53:48.399 --> 00:53:48.639
Right.
805
00:53:48.679 --> 00:53:50.859
And so, yeah, it's just, it's weird timing.
806
00:53:51.120 --> 00:53:59.082
Um, you know, and they're just, I can't, it's, it's been, gosh, probably a decade since it's actually truly been a yield play in the traditional multifamily space.
807
00:53:59.122 --> 00:54:01.963
Maybe I'm a little, little long and saying 10 years, but I'm,
808
00:54:02.483 --> 00:54:08.324
I would say I don't think you're far off of that.
809
00:54:09.105 --> 00:54:10.325
I think we did get yield.
810
00:54:10.345 --> 00:54:14.666
You know, if I go back 2015, 2016, you were getting cash flows for sure, 2017.
811
00:54:15.666 --> 00:54:18.267
But the bump up was so much more.
812
00:54:18.287 --> 00:54:26.909
I mean, those were huge IRR exits for, you know, investment partners to turn because everything was just moving so fast.
813
00:54:32.330 --> 00:54:33.191
Okay, are you ready for this?
814
00:54:33.611 --> 00:54:37.753
Under $100,000 a unit for over $2,000 construction.
815
00:54:38.133 --> 00:54:39.975
Is that an anomaly?
816
00:54:40.175 --> 00:54:44.717
I mean, these examples you're giving me, a 7.9 cap in place or $100,000.
817
00:54:44.877 --> 00:54:50.821
The one we're just closing right now, $118 a door because you have to understand you're talking about $100,000.
818
00:54:51.261 --> 00:54:56.482
40% or it could be 50% of rent, right?
819
00:54:56.542 --> 00:55:00.943
So even though we're buying at a higher cap rate, you still have this huge delta.
820
00:55:01.163 --> 00:55:04.344
So like- You're still getting 200 bips of yield, right?
821
00:55:04.404 --> 00:55:12.245
I mean, based on where you're probably going in with your agency debt at this point, especially if you're getting a little bit of a lower rate, I think you said a quarter point.
822
00:55:12.266 --> 00:55:18.887
So you might be, what, you probably are going in with 175, 200 bips spread of yield, which is amazing.
823
00:55:18.907 --> 00:55:19.287
Yeah.
824
00:55:19.670 --> 00:55:19.890
Yeah.
825
00:55:20.010 --> 00:55:24.993
So, I mean, that can, it was just, why did we not do it before?
826
00:55:25.333 --> 00:55:28.114
It solves the problems we're facing right now.
827
00:55:28.355 --> 00:55:31.136
And I think that's what's really important as an operator.
828
00:55:31.496 --> 00:55:38.800
You're looking for what are my investment partners and myself going, where would I feel safe right now?
829
00:55:38.960 --> 00:55:40.221
I'd like to be deploying.
830
00:55:40.721 --> 00:55:42.062
And that's how we found ourselves here.
831
00:55:42.142 --> 00:55:43.322
Is it more work for me?
832
00:55:43.643 --> 00:55:43.843
Yes.
833
00:55:44.845 --> 00:55:54.029
The buildings are smaller, generally, and the paperwork is a lot more, and the relationship with the municipality and the city is important.
834
00:55:54.570 --> 00:55:58.252
When I could make money hand over fist doing value-add, would I go and do this?
835
00:55:58.392 --> 00:55:58.652
No.
836
00:55:59.715 --> 00:56:04.279
Am I doing it right now because I can buy with a delta that I know is going to stay?
837
00:56:04.299 --> 00:56:06.361
I can put on fixed rate debt.
838
00:56:06.541 --> 00:56:07.682
I can generate yield.
839
00:56:07.942 --> 00:56:09.824
I'm not playing the concession fight.
840
00:56:10.204 --> 00:56:13.767
I'm not dealing with, you know, the dry up and supply.
841
00:56:13.787 --> 00:56:15.769
I have checked all those boxes.
842
00:56:16.230 --> 00:56:17.651
So does this make sense right now?
843
00:56:17.671 --> 00:56:18.071
Yes.
844
00:56:18.091 --> 00:56:18.352
Yes.
845
00:56:19.073 --> 00:56:19.414
I love it.
846
00:56:19.754 --> 00:56:22.518
You've got you've got plan A, plan B, plan C with this money.
847
00:56:22.538 --> 00:56:24.801
You got plan A, which is a yield play.
848
00:56:24.921 --> 00:56:30.328
You got plan B, which is a renegotiation with the municipality to hopefully get some type of concession.
849
00:56:30.349 --> 00:56:31.530
Maybe it's a tax abatement.
850
00:56:31.550 --> 00:56:33.212
Maybe I'd love to know your thoughts there.
851
00:56:33.232 --> 00:56:33.693
Like what else?
852
00:56:33.833 --> 00:56:34.654
What else have you
seen?
853
00:56:35.195 --> 00:56:38.896
as far as like a renegotiation, what kind of incentive will City give you?
854
00:56:38.916 --> 00:56:45.297
And then I guess the last piece I'll make there, like your plan C is just let it expire and take everything to market, right?
855
00:56:45.317 --> 00:56:46.797
And you're 34% below market.
856
00:56:46.857 --> 00:57:02.380
It's like lost to lease, like we bought years ago, you know, when you'd walk in and the person had owned it for 30 years and there was no, you know, dynamic pricing and they just didn't realize that the next door neighbor was charging $300 more in rent for the exact same product.
857
00:57:02.720 --> 00:57:03.320
It's that.
858
00:57:03.340 --> 00:57:04.060
Yeah.
859
00:57:04.260 --> 00:57:06.641
It's it's that which is crazy.
860
00:57:06.801 --> 00:57:07.781
It's just a loss.
861
00:57:08.881 --> 00:57:09.882
I'm sorry, I interrupted you.
862
00:57:09.902 --> 00:57:20.085
I think you're going to answer my question maybe about some other incentives that a city or municipality might give you in order to maintain that that that low income structure in place.
863
00:57:21.005 --> 00:57:22.807
Or to renew it, incentivize you to renew it.
864
00:57:22.827 --> 00:57:25.430
It can be, again, it can be taxes.
865
00:57:25.550 --> 00:57:32.317
It can be credits for new repositioning, your capital expenditure.
866
00:57:32.838 --> 00:57:35.361
But what's happening is it's getting more creative, right?
867
00:57:35.481 --> 00:57:41.868
Because the next five years is the first wave of expiry in history, mass wave.
868
00:57:42.368 --> 00:57:44.190
This is going to be a problem.
869
00:57:44.210 --> 00:57:53.579
So this is actually a leading edge kind of also almost like uncharted territory in what is going to be required to keep it that way.
870
00:57:54.580 --> 00:57:56.102
I'm actually excited to be involved in it.
871
00:57:58.004 --> 00:57:59.865
There's the traditional pieces, but...
872
00:58:00.646 --> 00:58:07.352
It, you know, what's important is with our investment partners, how great would that be if we could figure that out?
873
00:58:07.952 --> 00:58:13.097
And if not, we have a 20% loss to lease and all I have to do is just start renting.
874
00:58:13.638 --> 00:58:14.718
Yeah, that's beautiful.
875
00:58:14.738 --> 00:58:18.520
Well, Jan, this has been a really fun conversation.
876
00:58:18.660 --> 00:58:19.400
Really appreciate you coming.
877
00:58:19.420 --> 00:58:21.981
I know I kept you over time or over by a number of minutes.
878
00:58:22.021 --> 00:58:25.362
And so I want to be respectful of your time and I do appreciate you joining us here today.
879
00:58:25.382 --> 00:58:35.266
And so I guess before we wrap it up, just maybe give you an opportunity to share any closing thoughts that you might have based on our conversation today.
880
00:58:35.286 --> 00:58:42.028
And then also, I guess equally as important is just let everyone know where they can connect with you and learn more about Western Wealth Capital.
881
00:58:42.968 --> 00:58:43.808
Oh, well, thank you.
882
00:58:43.828 --> 00:58:45.089
I enjoy this conversation.
883
00:58:46.089 --> 00:58:47.590
Closing thoughts.
884
00:58:48.070 --> 00:58:49.731
You know, it's fun to kind of look back.
885
00:58:49.911 --> 00:58:51.911
You know, you don't talk a lot about the past.
886
00:58:51.971 --> 00:59:01.855
I think one of the reasons I do this is because I'm just a mom at the end of the day, raising teenagers who cut me down like, gosh, if I need my ego cut, I just need to like, you know,
887
00:59:02.195 --> 00:59:03.496
Talk to my 13 and 15 year old.
888
00:59:04.177 --> 00:59:05.538
Have the courage to challenge.
889
00:59:06.038 --> 00:59:09.441
It feels really, really great on the other side when you do it.
890
00:59:10.042 --> 00:59:12.064
Takes a lot of guts.
891
00:59:12.284 --> 00:59:13.765
But boy, does it feel good.
892
00:59:13.905 --> 00:59:21.412
You know, life is long and it's the stories that you can go back and go remember that time I really went on that limb.
893
00:59:22.032 --> 00:59:26.474
But the reward was so huge, not just financially, but just emotionally.
894
00:59:26.494 --> 00:59:32.857
These are always great talks to remind you that life is bigger than just the pieces.
895
00:59:33.257 --> 00:59:37.839
To learn more about Western Wealth Capital, it's at westernwealthcapital.com.
896
00:59:38.199 --> 00:59:39.720
And thank you, Kevin.
897
00:59:39.740 --> 00:59:40.580
It was great to connect.
898
00:59:41.000 --> 00:59:41.461
Have an awesome day.
899
00:59:41.481 --> 00:59:42.001
No, this was awesome.
900
00:59:42.221 --> 00:59:42.481
Yes.
901
00:59:42.521 --> 00:59:43.182
Thank you so much, Jan.
902
00:59:43.202 --> 00:59:44.242
It's been a pleasure having you.
903
00:59:44.302 --> 00:59:46.343
And guys, those are tuning in.
904
00:59:46.363 --> 00:59:51.546
If you enjoyed today's episode, please do us a favor, subscribe to the show on your favorite podcast platform.
905
00:59:51.666 --> 00:59:53.047
There's many of them out there nowadays.
906
00:59:53.347 --> 00:59:56.208
Leave us a rating review as well if you did enjoy the show.
907
00:59:57.109 --> 00:59:58.930
And lastly, just to share the episode.
908
00:59:58.970 --> 01:00:00.931
I think we covered a lot of great ground today.
909
01:00:01.251 --> 01:00:05.133
So share the episode with someone you think will benefit from hearing Janet's perspective.
910
01:00:05.193 --> 01:00:07.614
So until next time, this is Kevin Buck.