TRASCRIZIONE 🔗
WEBVTT
00:00:05.190 --> 00:00:13.289
Hello listeners and welcome to Plugged In - The Energy News podcast from Montel, where we bring you the latest news issues and changes happening in the energy sector.
00:00:13.560 --> 00:00:21.795
In this week's episode, we're in the UK where political criticism of clean and green energy policy is ever on the rise.
00:00:21.945 --> 00:00:24.644
There is a growing backlash against the energy transition.
00:00:24.914 --> 00:00:35.204
In October, the UK opposition Party, the conservatives pledged to scrap the 2008 Climate Change Act if reelected and replace it for cheap energy and economic growth.
00:00:35.530 --> 00:00:37.780
Does the UK want clean or cheap energy?
00:00:37.960 --> 00:00:39.878
Is cheap energy even possible?
00:00:40.179 --> 00:00:42.159
Can we only have one or the other?
00:00:42.490 --> 00:00:49.450
And what does this reality check of the UK's position say about the wider energy transition and Europe weaning off gas?
00:00:49.840 --> 00:00:54.878
I'm joined by Laurence Walker, deputy Chief at Montel News, A warm welcome, Laurence.
00:00:55.000 --> 00:00:55.384
Thank you, Richard.
00:00:55.655 --> 00:00:55.945
Yeah.
00:00:56.590 --> 00:01:02.170
Could you summarize the political and public opinion towards the green energy transition in the UK as it currently stands?
00:01:02.439 --> 00:01:14.469
I mean, certainly I think most of the mainstream parties do still accept the sort of broader goal of eventually reaching net zero, but obviously the roots and the technologies preferred by each party do differ.
00:01:15.159 --> 00:01:26.905
I think for example as you mentioned, there has been, you know, great intention about the use of fossil fuels and to what extent gas should be playing a role in terms of sourcing, in terms of usage.
00:01:27.534 --> 00:01:33.094
And then obviously there are, growing concerns about certain technologies within the renewables field as well.
00:01:33.144 --> 00:01:36.444
You know, whether we should be having more offshore onshore wind, how that.
00:01:39.174 --> 00:01:42.629
Where people live how it affects prices and all these sort of things.
00:01:43.019 --> 00:01:47.334
So yes the main goal I think is still eventually to, to reach net zero.
00:01:47.334 --> 00:01:51.384
But yeah, there are sort of conflicts about how it's gonna go.
00:01:51.534 --> 00:01:51.834
Absolutely.
00:01:51.884 --> 00:01:56.899
There, there's a lot of talk about, cheap or affordable energy.
00:01:57.168 --> 00:02:00.769
What, is there a disconnect between wholesale and retail prices?
00:02:00.769 --> 00:02:02.118
Where are wholesale prices been at?
00:02:02.179 --> 00:02:03.228
Where are they at the moment?
00:02:03.418 --> 00:02:05.578
Wholesale prices have been relatively stable.
00:02:05.578 --> 00:02:18.334
Recently, if we look the year to date, we're about sort of 82 pounds, a megawatt hour on average for front month prices, which is actually a bit from 2024, but it's down from over a hundred twenty, twenty three.
00:02:19.144 --> 00:02:22.929
I think what's, there are things we will maybe feed into this.
00:02:22.929 --> 00:02:28.479
Obviously there's issues regarding, renewables, the intermittency of renewables the costs behind it.
00:02:28.479 --> 00:02:30.068
The costs of rolling out renewables.
00:02:30.068 --> 00:02:32.739
These sort of things I think are what people are concerned about to have.
00:02:32.949 --> 00:02:36.729
Absolutely and maintaining that stable keeping system security.
00:02:37.359 --> 00:02:41.424
How does the issue of curtailment play into the arguments against renewables?
00:02:41.544 --> 00:02:47.414
Yeah, it's obviously offers an easy narrative for those against renewables and it's, the likes of some of the fringe parties.
00:02:47.414 --> 00:02:55.314
So for example, the Reform UK for example, these sort of things, if you're saying, oh, we're paying to turn off wind, then it's obviously it looks bad.
00:02:55.463 --> 00:02:58.180
I think ultimately, I think most analysts generally agree.
00:02:58.180 --> 00:03:05.289
It's more a simpson of under investments in the grid, more so in infrastructure than it is, renewables themselves to blame.
00:03:05.289 --> 00:03:06.939
I think it's more yeah
00:03:07.210 --> 00:03:08.590
The wider infrastructure issue.
00:03:08.680 --> 00:03:09.310
Exactly.
00:03:09.759 --> 00:03:10.240
Thanks very much, Laurie.
00:03:11.689 --> 00:03:15.620
So what are the real implications of the move to a renewable energy system?
00:03:15.919 --> 00:03:23.810
Earlier this week at Montel's Energy Day in London, I sat down with UK Energy expert, Stephen Woodhouse, where I put this question and many more to him.
00:03:25.639 --> 00:03:33.639
Welcome to a live episode of Plugged In - The Energy News Podcast on this beautiful autumn Day in London.
00:03:34.210 --> 00:03:40.498
I'm delighted to be joined by a good friend of the podcast, Stephen Woodhouse director at Energy Consultancy from Afry.
00:03:40.709 --> 00:03:45.750
So a warm welcome to you, Stephen, and welcome back to the podcast and this fireside chat.
00:03:46.319 --> 00:03:46.829
Thank you, Richard.
00:03:47.199 --> 00:03:55.669
Let's start talking generally about the energy transition, and I think a lot has been made of clean power by 2030.
00:03:55.969 --> 00:03:59.060
Does that also mean cheap power by 2030?
00:03:59.210 --> 00:03:59.620
Stephen?
00:04:00.710 --> 00:04:03.710
I'm not sure I think that it will.
00:04:04.319 --> 00:04:18.329
We started off when I came into the industry too many years ago with kind of two objectives, and we had an independent regulator to deliver two objectives, and they were security of supply and issues to do with efficiency.
00:04:19.050 --> 00:04:23.399
And the environmental objective was originally a secondary objective.
00:04:23.970 --> 00:04:24.360
And.
00:04:24.975 --> 00:04:28.324
It moved to being a primary objective, and we've been talking about the trilemma.
00:04:28.694
Load full transcript
--> 00:04:34.605
We've had political consensus around the trilemma for quite a few years, and it's not so long ago.
00:04:34.605 --> 00:04:39.555
I was going around to conferences saying the fundamental problem with electricity is that it's too cheap.
00:04:39.884 --> 00:04:40.754
It's a pound a day.
00:04:40.754 --> 00:04:42.675
For most people, that's not enough.
00:04:43.095 --> 00:04:50.564
We need some transformation, but we actually need people to wake up and be conscious of how they use electricity and when they use it, and when it's that cheap.
00:04:50.665 --> 00:04:52.134
We're not gonna get the transformation we need.
00:04:52.134 --> 00:04:53.545
I can't say that anymore, of course.
00:04:53.579 --> 00:04:58.709
But I do wonder, the sustainability issue is being taken off the political agenda.
00:04:58.709 --> 00:05:03.629
The geopolitical instability is challenging that long run objective.
00:05:04.230 --> 00:05:08.850
We're still focusing on security of supply, but we're forgetting the last time we have a crisis.
00:05:08.910 --> 00:05:12.000
So that's already being considered a medium per term problem.
00:05:12.050 --> 00:05:20.990
And we've got this very short term political agenda item of affordability and getting 300 pounds off domestic bills by 2030.
00:05:20.990 --> 00:05:26.149
And I'm not sure that's very good for the industry and the long-term investment prospects.
00:05:26.250 --> 00:05:37.600
So if we think about those three objectives, the sustainability, security of supply, affordability, which of them would you say is being prioritized by the government and industry at the moment?
00:05:37.750 --> 00:05:40.089
And how you mentioned geopolitical uncertainty.
00:05:40.490 --> 00:05:42.259
How is that reshaping those priorities?
00:05:42.660 --> 00:05:52.610
The irony was, we know the trigger in Ukraine for the current kind of uncertainty, but it manifested in a gas price spike and all things being equal.
00:05:52.610 --> 00:05:57.250
You would've thought that would've led to a wholesale move towards renewables and away from fossil.
00:05:57.579 --> 00:06:00.889
But actually, instability economically doesn't stop there.
00:06:01.399 --> 00:06:04.144
I'm a microeconomic expert.
00:06:04.355 --> 00:06:07.384
Macroeconomics always felt a bit like a domino topple to me.
00:06:07.384 --> 00:06:17.644
You could line up the dominoes in a circle and start it in one direction and prove the causality, but you could equally flip them in the opposite direction and prove the opposite causality.
00:06:17.884 --> 00:06:23.855
So I have to say macroeconomics is a bit of a black box to me, but nothing happens in isolation.
00:06:23.855 --> 00:06:28.579
So the gas price crisis led to an inflation crisis.
00:06:28.579 --> 00:06:31.490
So the cost of renewables was also shooting up.
00:06:31.620 --> 00:06:33.899
It led to a cost of capital crisis.
00:06:34.110 --> 00:06:40.170
So it isn't obvious that we've really moving towards a cheaper renewable future.
00:06:40.360 --> 00:06:47.110
So we're, we are focusing on affordability primarily now, probably at the expense of the long run economics of our system.
00:06:47.160 --> 00:06:56.910
If we think about, let's think, digitalization, decarbonization, do you think these parts of the system are moving the same direction and at the same pace?
00:06:58.860 --> 00:07:06.759
So there are three Ds in that, so there's the decarbonization, the digitalization, and the de and the decentralization.
00:07:07.269 --> 00:07:11.319
The decarbonization will continue to happen at some pace.
00:07:12.160 --> 00:07:15.850
But it is very contingent on government support.
00:07:15.879 --> 00:07:21.759
Whatever we say about renewables being cheap, they're cheap to produce with the profile that they have.
00:07:21.759 --> 00:07:26.379
They're not cheap to produce a profile that consumers wish to consume.
00:07:26.709 --> 00:07:30.939
And there's a lot of need for some flexibility on the customer side to bridge that gap.
00:07:31.720 --> 00:07:37.930
Decentralization, it was, I remember Laszlo Varro, who was then the chief economist of IEA saying this.
00:07:38.259 --> 00:07:41.139
We are past the peak of decentralization of generation.
00:07:41.139 --> 00:07:44.259
We're not building very small scale renewables anymore.
00:07:44.259 --> 00:07:52.389
We're building giga scale offshore wind, but it's the sources of flexibility, which we're decentralizing and that's really interesting.
00:07:52.759 --> 00:07:56.509
So digitalization will continue to transform.
00:07:57.379 --> 00:08:00.303
Quick poll, how many people in this room have got an electric car?
00:08:03.108 --> 00:08:07.338
How many of you don't do some kind of smart charging?
00:08:10.218 --> 00:08:10.819
Okay.
00:08:12.108 --> 00:08:20.259
Most do though, if you've got an electric car, you know how easy it is for that stuff to be automated and whether you do it yourself or hand over the keys to.
00:08:20.310 --> 00:08:25.220
I won't name a supplier, but there are some out there that will manage your car automatically for you.
00:08:25.370 --> 00:08:27.110
The digitalization will just happen.
00:08:27.980 --> 00:08:30.980
The decentralization is really interesting.
00:08:31.589 --> 00:08:38.190
So we heard earlier Niso is not getting nodal pricing and co-op optimization.
00:08:38.820 --> 00:08:40.980
They're not getting zonal pricing.
00:08:41.639 --> 00:08:46.529
And the government said a year ago they were minded not to do central dispatch.
00:08:47.129 --> 00:08:50.279
But I wonder if NISO has given up on that idea.
00:08:50.684 --> 00:09:06.004
And I've just reviewed a paper from Entso-e about how they intend to tackle the challenge of re-dispatch costs and their evaluation seems very tilted in favor of central control, central dispatch, nodal pricing.
00:09:06.184 --> 00:09:14.774
So it's not just here that the system operators are enviously eyeing the US model where they never fully let go
of the controls of the power plants.
00:09:15.465 --> 00:09:20.595
Now, how the hell that works when it's millions of cars we're dispatching rather than tens of big thermal units?
00:09:20.595 --> 00:09:21.945
I'm not sure anybody knows.
00:09:22.024 --> 00:09:24.995
But I think the decentralization is still a battleground.
00:09:25.144 --> 00:09:25.504
Absolutely.
00:09:25.835 --> 00:09:36.580
So if we're talking about the three Ds, there's also, I've coined the three Cs, which is when we're talking about re renewables in particular, so curtailment, congestion and cannibalization.
00:09:36.679 --> 00:09:39.350
Now I think these are some of the downsides of renewable.
00:09:39.965 --> 00:09:41.164
Renewables penetration.
00:09:41.375 --> 00:09:51.004
How have, has, have these effects been over hyped or are they still something that we have to overcome in order to reach the 2030 and even the 2040 objectives?
00:09:51.434 --> 00:09:51.894
Stephen,
00:09:52.100 --> 00:09:55.610
and so your three Cs are curtailment, congestion, and cannibalization.
00:09:55.610 --> 00:10:00.860
And I have phrased these slightly differently in the work I've done, but it amounts to the same thing.
00:10:00.860 --> 00:10:08.210
So we've said that as you decarbonize, and as you electrify, it places three challenges to the operation of the power system.
00:10:08.570 --> 00:10:10.429
So one of them relates to location.
00:10:10.909 --> 00:10:17.315
One of them relates to balancing and stability, and one of them relates to I would say volume risk, that's the primary one.
00:10:17.554 --> 00:10:22.235
So location, we are putting lots of resources in places where they weren't before.
00:10:22.565 --> 00:10:31.225
From offshore winds to distributed generation to, here today maybe we're gonna reuse the site at will for modular nuclear reactors.
00:10:31.404 --> 00:10:34.404
But generally new connections are in new places.
00:10:34.754 --> 00:10:41.054
And the new loads that we're putting on the system, whether it's EV chargers at the bottom end of the grid or large data centers.
00:10:42.690 --> 00:10:58.745
Firstly, it puts pressure on the connections process and the need to build a lot of grid, and we've gotta spend billions upgrading the grids, but it also brings us into congestion management, right the way down to the distribution level, which changes our distribution operators plan and operate their system.
00:10:59.044 --> 00:11:03.335
So the congestion stuff is real and will be with us for a long time.
00:11:04.595 --> 00:11:07.115
The balancing and stability is also interesting.
00:11:07.534 --> 00:11:16.475
So we've got balancing problems all the way from instantaneous inertia, right the way through to the seasonal problem of using.
00:11:16.625 --> 00:11:21.779
In Norway it's the rainfall that freezes the, that melts in the spring, but your heating is in the winter.
00:11:21.779 --> 00:11:30.129
You've got that seasonal issue in Norway, we're gonna get it in Europe as
well where we use solar energy in the summer to heat our homes in the winter, at least in the northern parts of Europe.
00:11:30.924 --> 00:11:44.095
In the old days, certainly in the GB power system, all of those timescales and the points in between the firm capacity for the peak and the intraday ramping, you did all of that with fossil plants and a gas pipeline or a coal stock.
00:11:44.815 --> 00:11:51.024
As we take those out of the equation, we having to build dedicated resources for each of the different services.
00:11:51.325 --> 00:11:55.764
So you know, we're building synchronous condensers and batteries with grid forming for the inertia.
00:11:56.740 --> 00:11:59.740
We haven't solved the seasonal storage problem yet, frankly.
00:11:59.820 --> 00:12:03.240
I'm looking at an EastWest interconnector to go across the Atlantic.
00:12:03.299 --> 00:12:07.200
That might have some advantage there, but it won't be tens of gigawatts.
00:12:07.769 --> 00:12:16.980
And we are having actually to procure dedicated assets for the short term stuff'cause we have a single buyer for those services.
00:12:17.669 --> 00:12:19.830
And the bid in the middle is where the volatility lives.
00:12:20.955 --> 00:12:28.445
And then we get to my third challenge, which, so my challenge was the location balancing and stability, and then finally, risk.
00:12:30.424 --> 00:12:34.054
How many people here trade base, load products?
00:12:34.485 --> 00:12:35.985
I'm trying to get some audience engagement.
00:12:36.644 --> 00:12:37.274
Yeah.
00:12:37.544 --> 00:12:40.365
And how many trade non base load products.
00:12:41.085 --> 00:12:41.654
Okay.
00:12:42.014 --> 00:12:42.615
Okay.
00:12:43.154 --> 00:12:45.495
But the liquidity is still with the base load.
00:12:45.495 --> 00:12:47.235
If you look at all of the cross-border hedging.
00:12:47.924 --> 00:12:51.134
The transmission rights are one year products for a base load shape.
00:12:51.514 --> 00:12:53.524
Base load doesn't really exist anymore.
00:12:53.575 --> 00:13:05.365
So we're not able to hedge the risks that market participants are actually facing, which is one of the reasons why zonal pricing in this country would've been a bad idea.
00:13:06.414 --> 00:13:13.375
I dunno if you want to get into the Rema debate, but our work was used in the argument very strongly against zonal pricing.
00:13:13.975 --> 00:13:15.955
But if you read what we actually said.
00:13:16.345 --> 00:13:32.245
We said if zonal pricing is to work, there are some preconditions which are all about putting in place the right hedging protocols, the right grandfathering arrangements using those hedging products and the future proofing about next time we do the zoning.
00:13:32.664 --> 00:13:35.754
And that's the way you need to get zoning.
00:13:35.804 --> 00:13:39.095
And if you don't get that you've gotta do it through some other way.
00:13:39.154 --> 00:13:41.495
If you can't hedge the risk to investors.
00:13:42.230 --> 00:13:43.370
Zoning is a bad idea.
00:13:43.370 --> 00:13:44.210
Not a good idea.
00:13:44.240 --> 00:13:44.419
No.
00:13:44.529 --> 00:13:44.860
Absolutely.
00:13:44.870 --> 00:13:48.399
You've raised a number of complex issues there Stephen.
00:13:48.679 --> 00:13:52.580
But if we are going back to the points that you mentioned, so go, let's go back to location.
00:13:52.750 --> 00:13:59.919
How can the grid handle new storage and demand and generation, which is required to meet the 2030 targets?
00:13:59.919 --> 00:14:00.700
What, what could be done?
00:14:00.700 --> 00:14:01.750
What are the solutions here?
00:14:02.120 --> 00:14:04.610
We need to make use of all of the resources we've got.
00:14:04.850 --> 00:14:09.350
So even if we've got zonal pricing, it wouldn't change the amount of wind that can run in Scotland.
00:14:09.350 --> 00:14:13.789
When there's good grid constraints, it changes the pricing and who pays the compensation?
00:14:13.789 --> 00:14:15.679
It doesn't change the physics.
00:14:15.980 --> 00:14:20.000
So we need to find ways of turning up demand in Scotland.
00:14:20.490 --> 00:14:26.039
Maybe that's through the local constraints market that Niso is now getting working, finally.
00:14:27.269 --> 00:14:30.809
We need to find ways that the interconnectors being more flexible.
00:14:30.990 --> 00:14:35.639
So the Norwegian Interconnector, I think currently is fixed day ahead.
00:14:35.940 --> 00:14:41.490
There now will be some change to allow an intraday auction, but not just in Norway.
00:14:41.490 --> 00:14:42.629
All of the interconnectors.
00:14:42.629 --> 00:14:46.470
We need to find ways of allowing those interconnectors to be part of the re-dispatch.
00:14:46.740 --> 00:14:50.220
So we're dispatching interconnection rather than wind.
00:14:50.220 --> 00:14:56.309
There's a series of tools that we can use, but we've gotta make use of the physical resources that we've got connected to the system.
00:14:56.639 --> 00:15:04.139
And if it can't be done through the spot market with a single national price area, then we find need to find some creative tools to get at those resources in other ways.
00:15:04.259 --> 00:15:08.804
Within the intraday, or, if you the second point you meant of balancing stability.
00:15:08.904 --> 00:15:13.684
So what is replacing traditional providers of backup services?
00:15:13.684 --> 00:15:14.914
Stephen, at the moment.
00:15:15.315 --> 00:15:19.304
I mentioned kind of the grid forming and the synchronous condensers.
00:15:19.309 --> 00:15:21.164
Niso has got the stability products.
00:15:21.225 --> 00:15:27.375
We actually did a review of the design a couple of years ago and recommended they have a year ahead and a day ahead procurement for that.
00:15:27.884 --> 00:15:32.504
And they're important, but they're not commercially hugely important.
00:15:32.875 --> 00:15:40.884
It's the range of reserve and response services that we have that drives a lot of that, as well as intraday volatility.
00:15:41.230 --> 00:15:44.860
So the rest of continental Europe is now moving to 15 minutes.
00:15:45.139 --> 00:15:47.029
Other markets are at five minutes already.
00:15:48.470 --> 00:15:55.669
It's one of the things that's still on the table within the REMA discussion actually to shorten the settlement interval perhaps to 15 or five minutes.
00:15:55.970 --> 00:16:06.110
And the beauty of kind of fine-tuning the traded product is you make that flexibility more of a problem for the market and less of the problem for the system services.
00:16:06.139 --> 00:16:09.259
That's the direction of travel I, I would be advocating.
00:16:09.320 --> 00:16:09.769
Absolutely.
00:16:09.919 --> 00:16:12.389
And what you also mentioned about volatility and risks.
00:16:12.389 --> 00:16:16.820
So where are the, what are the new risks that you've highlighted or that you'd like to highlight?
00:16:16.820 --> 00:16:23.240
And, is a capacity mechanism, essential in terms of the system stability and the functioning of the market as a whole?
00:16:23.340 --> 00:16:31.379
The new risk, I would say is volume risk, and it's obviously not very new, but it's a risk that we haven't really developed trading products to help us hedge.
00:16:31.590 --> 00:16:39.259
And, talking to different people in the trading community, whether you could do that and whether you could ever get real liquidity in those products, I think is an open question.
00:16:39.309 --> 00:16:44.580
But for sure, I think people are looking at creating products that will allow batteries to hedge forward.
00:16:44.850 --> 00:16:47.070
So quite the nature of those products, I don't know.
00:16:47.379 --> 00:16:49.225
But volume risk is the critical part of it.
00:16:50.000 --> 00:16:56.669
And the technologies that are being used to fill that hole are, clearly batteries.
00:16:56.769 --> 00:17:04.859
And the big gap, if you look at the spectrum of needs, the big gap we've got is not for very short duration storage, but for much longer duration storage.
00:17:05.250 --> 00:17:16.009
We did a study, some of my colleagues did a study for Niso a couple of years ago, and the average duration of a scarcity event now is a four or five hours.
00:17:16.640 --> 00:17:21.859
So a two hour battery has, a 40 or 50% contribution to that, but it's a meaningful contribution.
00:17:22.880 --> 00:17:39.140
By 2035 ish, at least in one of the scenarios we looked at, the average duration of a scarcity event is nearly 50 hours, so a two hour battery, it has a 5% contribution, not a 50% or 4% contribution.
00:17:39.500 --> 00:17:44.690
So the role of batteries for the future system needs, I think is quite questionable.
00:17:45.230 --> 00:17:48.890
So suddenly you ask about capacity mechanisms and I was never a fan.
00:17:49.250 --> 00:17:54.640
I loved working in the Nordic countries where they were resolutely in favor of, the energy only market.
00:17:55.119 --> 00:17:59.440
And the mantra for capacity mechanisms was simplistic.
00:17:59.710 --> 00:18:04.089
And I think over simplistic, you just create a market for megawatts, it's easy.
00:18:04.539 --> 00:18:07.029
And if there's no missing money, the price will be zero.
00:18:07.494 --> 00:18:13.615
And it won't interfere with the operation of the spot market because it's a separate product and it doesn't determine dispatch.
00:18:14.394 --> 00:18:17.095
And then you realize you can't just say all megawatts are the same.
00:18:17.095 --> 00:18:22.555
You have to de-rate them according to their reliability, their forced outage in the old world.
00:18:23.184 --> 00:18:28.974
But now we realize the problem is not the megawatts, it's the megawatts hours of duration.
00:18:29.095 --> 00:18:34.045
And it's not a simple product anymore, and there are no simple answers here to define.
00:18:34.095 --> 00:18:36.585
A technology neutral capacity payment.
00:18:37.015 --> 00:18:44.545
And we've actually just done a piece of work for Nordic Energy research looking at the form of capacity or flexibility mechanism.
00:18:44.545 --> 00:18:51.384
So in recent years, both Finland and Sweden had announced an intention to move to a market-wide capacity mechanism.
00:18:52.015 --> 00:18:56.394
I think both countries are basically deciding not to do that because of the cost.
00:18:56.474 --> 00:19:02.144
You pay a lot of money to not change behavior from a lot of participants.
00:19:02.490 --> 00:19:05.849
To change a bit at the edge, so it's a very costly solution.
00:19:07.200 --> 00:19:13.319
Britain now is, I'm not sure if this is a decision or a consultation, but I think it's gonna happen.
00:19:14.640 --> 00:19:27.329
They are trying to create a separate price for the new build capacity from the existing capacity, because there's not much appetite to pay everybody the new build price.
00:19:27.359 --> 00:19:30.869
Now that the price cap of 75 pounds a kilowatt is likely to be exceeded.
00:19:31.230 --> 00:19:38.309
So a lot of markets are now trying to find ways to not pay everybody for the megawatts.
00:19:38.390 --> 00:19:41.960
And I don't think there are any good answers or any clear answers.
00:19:42.059 --> 00:19:45.299
But it does take us into a slightly different place.
00:19:46.049 --> 00:19:53.099
When I came into the industry, we thought we had markets for efficient dispatch, but we'd also have market led investments.
00:19:53.099 --> 00:19:53.549
And of course.
00:19:54.029 --> 00:19:59.849
The renewable support has grown and hasn't gone away, and I don't see it going away anytime soon.
00:20:00.420 --> 00:20:04.440
But we're actually now moving to support for lots of different technologies.
00:20:04.980 --> 00:20:07.440
But again, it's not on a technology neutral basis.
00:20:07.490 --> 00:20:12.285
The de-rating factors that we use to calculate who gets paid what.
00:20:13.174 --> 00:20:14.704
In a capacity market?
00:20:14.984 --> 00:20:16.424
It's a bit of a black box.
00:20:16.470 --> 00:20:23.220
I don't
think you really call it technology neutral despite the protestations, but we're now saying that model doesn't even fit.
00:20:23.250 --> 00:20:26.609
We'll have a separate mechanism for long duration energy storage.
00:20:27.000 --> 00:20:38.670
We're talking now, the connections reform process is about first ready, first serve, but that includes an element of most suitable for the grid first served.
00:20:39.194 --> 00:20:45.015
And we're about to basically subsidize everything that gets connected to the grid in the next 10 years.
00:20:45.345 --> 00:20:49.904
We've got this central planning, the strategic energy plan that Niso is doing.
00:20:50.775 --> 00:20:57.960
I think it's inevitable that the government in one way or another, we'll be shaping what gets built where and when.
00:20:58.079 --> 00:20:58.890
So where's the market?
00:20:58.890 --> 00:20:59.460
In the market?
00:20:59.789 --> 00:21:00.269
Yeah.
00:21:00.400 --> 00:21:08.640
And if we're, if what we end up with is a spot market for efficient dispatch, but really all of the investment decisions are back in the central planning box.
00:21:08.980 --> 00:21:12.039
It's probably time for me to retire 'cause my work here has failed.
00:21:12.250 --> 00:21:12.430
But
00:21:13.710 --> 00:21:19.400
Stephen, if we can continue on flexibility and the role of flexibility how do transport and heat fit in here?
00:21:20.700 --> 00:21:31.109
I got really excited about this when I first realized the potential for kind of heat and transport to be the glue that holds a renewable energy system together.
00:21:31.380 --> 00:21:44.880
'cause the truth is, there's been a lot of over-hyping about how cheap renewables are, and I'm a passionate advocate for a renewable energy system, and I think decarbonization is absolutely essential, and it should be the top priority, not the bottom one, even now.
00:21:45.130 --> 00:22:05.799
I'm no apologist for the, for the coal fossil fuel lobby, but the renewables lobby were too successful in getting people to believe the hype, so low marginal cost it doesn't necessarily mean low prices and the concept of a low levelized cost of energy.
00:22:05.799 --> 00:22:10.359
I think, I don't think anybody should be allowed to use that term 'cause it's just so misleading.
00:22:10.690 --> 00:22:15.430
It's very cheap to consume energy if you take it at the profile it's produced at.
00:22:16.329 --> 00:22:22.569
But if you want to consume a profile that the consumer wants, it's no longer so cheap.
00:22:23.049 --> 00:22:27.190
And the bridge to that is adding new types of load, which are flexible.
00:22:27.579 --> 00:22:41.829
So the solution to the decarbonization and the affordability agenda is that you consume energy when it's cheap and abundant, and you do not consume energy when it's expensive and scarce.
00:22:41.835 --> 00:22:41.984
And how do,
00:22:42.460 --> 00:22:43.599
and something goes for the grid.
00:22:43.599 --> 00:22:44.259
And how do you do that?
00:22:44.359 --> 00:22:44.450
How?
00:22:45.019 --> 00:22:46.759
My car, I'm an average driver.
00:22:46.940 --> 00:22:49.609
I do 10 or 12,000 miles a year.
00:22:49.910 --> 00:22:52.880
I need 10 hours of electricity anytime of the week.
00:22:52.880 --> 00:22:53.809
I don't care.
00:22:54.079 --> 00:22:55.430
Absolutely don't care.
00:22:56.029 --> 00:23:02.150
Very few days do I really need my car to be above 30%, maybe 20% charge.
00:23:02.390 --> 00:23:08.779
So I've got total freedom with, 60 odd kilowatt hours of battery that I could use even for vehicle to grid.
00:23:08.809 --> 00:23:10.549
And vehicle to grid is definitely coming.
00:23:10.819 --> 00:23:14.980
So I think cars really easy to capture flexibility from.
00:23:15.740 --> 00:23:24.329
Niso's Clean Power 2030 plan suggested that there'd be 900 megawatts of vehicle to grid on the GB system by 2030.
00:23:25.440 --> 00:23:33.119
And if you read the small print, they mentioned that by 2050 it was 32 gigawatts, and by 2040 it was 28 gigawatts.
00:23:33.359 --> 00:23:34.109
So pick that number.
00:23:34.109 --> 00:23:40.200
2028 gigawatts by 2040 sounds like an utterly unbelievable number, right?
00:23:40.299 --> 00:23:41.980
That's half of our peak power.
00:23:42.309 --> 00:23:44.230
Is only 4 million cars.
00:23:44.859 --> 00:23:47.559
We've probably got 25 million cars.
00:23:47.640 --> 00:23:51.000
In terms of the number of cars, it's actually not that unbelievable at all.
00:23:51.079 --> 00:23:57.349
So I think the potential for transport to be flexible and private cars are especially good.
00:23:57.650 --> 00:24:05.255
I think we've got access to driveways and off street parking for about between 60, basically two thirds of our cars, not all of them.
00:24:05.355 --> 00:24:08.775
And they sit idle for 95% of the time.
00:24:09.015 --> 00:24:13.734
So cars are an absolutely no brainer way of getting that flexibility
00:24:14.095 --> 00:24:16.194
and the massive battery as well in potentially
00:24:17.815 --> 00:24:18.325
Exactly.
00:24:18.325 --> 00:24:18.565
Yeah.
00:24:18.615 --> 00:24:23.109
80% of the cells that get produced go on wheels.
00:24:23.160 --> 00:24:25.769
And I might argue the other 20% are a wasted resource.
00:24:25.769 --> 00:24:34.259
So we should be capturing the flexibility of the 80%, not building dedicated infrastructure that then in the end, the consumers will have to pay for.
00:24:34.589 --> 00:24:41.795
So I do think there is a future out there where the flexibility comes from customer owned assets.
00:24:42.335 --> 00:24:43.894
Heating is a bit harder.
00:24:44.525 --> 00:24:50.404
You can build flexibility into a heat pump system, but it probably requires you to put a thermal store in.
00:24:51.035 --> 00:24:52.954
And most people are not doing that.
00:24:53.315 --> 00:25:06.365
And we're still obsessing a gap about, again, like the LCOE metric, we obsess about energy efficiency and COP, the coefficient of performance for heat pumps.
00:25:06.964 --> 00:25:19.674
And the basic fallacy in all of those calculations is that it assumes every kilowatt hour is the same and electricity is the most volatile commodity on the planet, right?
00:25:19.674 --> 00:25:26.694
You can go from minus several hundred pounds a megawatt hour to plus several thousand a megawatt hour in a day or two.
00:25:27.365 --> 00:25:41.045
We were just talking to Ercot recently and there's a lot of crypto mining in Texas, and the system operator gets about 700 or 800 megawatts of demand response from the crypto mining.
00:25:41.480 --> 00:25:45.920
And they actually used to bid into Ercot, but they weren't accurate enough and they kept getting penalized.
00:25:46.130 --> 00:25:48.380
So now they just respond to the prices.
00:25:48.799 --> 00:25:55.940
But Ercot can predict that because relative to electricity, cryptocurrency is very stable in its price.
00:25:56.119 --> 00:26:00.680
So they know exactly the price points at which all of this crypto mining is gonna switch off.
00:26:01.525 --> 00:26:13.134
So the heating though, we need to capture ways of getting flexibility in the heating, and it means looking at measures of energy effectiveness, not energy efficiency.
00:26:13.404 --> 00:26:16.825
So it's no good just assuming all of the kilowatt hours are the same.
00:26:17.095 --> 00:26:22.315
They're radically different both in price and in carbon content and that's what we need to build going forward.
00:26:22.825 --> 00:26:26.005
And flexibility on the cooling loads of data centers as well.
00:26:26.424 --> 00:26:38.434
If everybody puts new heating and cooling loads that are contributing to the system peak, the cost implications of that both for grids and the reliable generation capacity that we need to support it.
00:26:38.484 --> 00:26:41.394
That's what makes a renewable energy system really expensive.
00:26:41.634 --> 00:26:48.325
So we need to find ways of baking that flexibility into the new things that haven't yet been designed or built.
00:26:48.355 --> 00:26:58.174
I'd like to talk about some of the bigger issues that you've raised here as well Stephen, during this chat, and, one of them is so can we ever return to the market based investment?
00:26:59.809 --> 00:27:12.150
There's a real dilemma there because on the one hand, I went round conferences 10 years ago saying, okay, generation as an investment is dead.
00:27:12.809 --> 00:27:17.460
I said, I was looking at Statt Trust model in Germany and they'd signed up 20 odd gigawatts of wind.
00:27:17.490 --> 00:27:18.390
I forget the numbers.
00:27:18.509 --> 00:27:20.039
They didn't own a kilowatt.
00:27:20.400 --> 00:27:23.200
And what I said is, you are competing with me now as a generator.
00:27:23.769 --> 00:27:32.319
My marginal mortgage rate was 1.25% at the time, and I couldn't just put solar panels on my roof.
00:27:32.319 --> 00:27:34.240
I could also put a battery in my basement.
00:27:34.454 --> 00:27:42.164
I could have dispatchable controllable power, and my hurdle rate was 1.5 or 1.25% if I considered it a commercial investment.
00:27:42.525 --> 00:27:45.494
And it was zero if I considered it a lifestyle choice.
00:27:45.825 --> 00:27:52.460
So I said, none of you in the industry can ever compete with domestic consumers for generation as an investment class.
00:27:52.670 --> 00:27:58.220
So what I was saying was the future is that you need access to a flexible portfolio.
00:27:58.220 --> 00:27:59.420
You don't need to own it.
00:27:59.690 --> 00:28:06.170
There are management fads about whether you outsource production or insource production, but generation is a commodity.
00:28:06.559 --> 00:28:09.559
You just need access to a flexible portfolio.
00:28:10.069 --> 00:28:16.670
I said the critical bit that holds all of that together is brilliant skills in trading and risk management.
00:28:16.700 --> 00:28:19.039
'cause the world is becoming a much more volatile place.
00:28:19.640 --> 00:28:29.210
And I said, and the third element of it is that you need an excellent relationship with the customer because in future, the value will be the strength of the relationship with the customer.
00:28:29.569 --> 00:28:31.609
And I had in mind the kind of Amazon model.
00:28:32.450 --> 00:28:36.500
People have tried it, there are people trying it now in this country.
00:28:36.500 --> 00:28:39.140
I don't think they're making money on retail yet.
00:28:39.140 --> 00:28:44.829
In fact, half the retailers in this country went bust in between me saying that and now so I was definitely wrong.
00:28:45.355 --> 00:28:52.615
But the irony is I underestimated the ability of the industry to go and lobby for large sums of money.
00:28:53.035 --> 00:28:59.365
So we transformed the renewable subsidies from the RO to the CFD, and I see no sign of it declining.
00:28:59.875 --> 00:29:03.654
Massive lobbying for support for capacity payments.
00:29:03.984 --> 00:29:08.545
The real irony and for long duration energy storage, we're gonna be building a lot of grids.
00:29:08.545 --> 00:29:12.835
So the industry has successfully lobbied to get money thrown at it.
00:29:14.740 --> 00:29:23.740
But the interesting bit is a lot of the future assets for the industry are gonna be on the customer side, and that's never gonna be centrally procured.
00:29:24.490 --> 00:29:24.970
Absolutely.
00:29:25.299 --> 00:29:27.640
So what's your message for investors then, in the sector?
00:29:27.740 --> 00:29:28.190
Stephen,
00:29:28.619 --> 00:29:31.740
Main message is, don't bet against the economics.
00:29:31.819 --> 00:29:38.480
If you think that the current tariff regime looks too good to be true.
00:29:38.579 --> 00:29:39.509
Maybe it is.
00:29:39.660 --> 00:29:42.869
I think you can bet on long-term government contracts.
00:29:42.869 --> 00:29:54.164
Still, I don't think the government is minded to retrospectively change terms and conditions, although I do hear that looking at changing RPI to CPI on the old RO contracts.
00:29:54.464 --> 00:30:01.095
I personally think that would be a bad move 'cause it'll pop up on the cost of capital for the next round of CFD options.
00:30:01.424 --> 00:30:04.204
But, make sure you know what the real economics are.
00:30:04.714 --> 00:30:13.865
Not just what on the page when you're making an investment, there's a huge future out there for demand side flexibility, and I think that's the natural enemy of batteries.
00:30:14.204 --> 00:30:22.065
So make sure there's a real basis for the investment you are making based on system need, not just on what looks attractive in the near term.
00:30:22.454 --> 00:30:23.744
I think that's a very clear message.
00:30:23.795 --> 00:30:25.394
And I'd like to round off there, Stephen.
00:30:25.414 --> 00:30:26.224
Thank you very much.
00:30:26.285 --> 00:30:29.569
As always fascinating to chat to you about these issues.
00:30:29.569 --> 00:30:31.220
Your expertise and knowledge is immense.
00:30:31.220 --> 00:30:35.539
So thank you very much for the chat and for being a guest on the Plugged In podcast team.
00:30:35.569 --> 00:30:35.990
Thank you.
00:30:36.049 --> 00:30:36.619
Thank you, Richard.