TRASCRIZIONE 🔗
Dr.Cam (00:00.592)
If you've ever found yourself wondering why does everything feel like such a battle or worrying that if you don't stay on top of every grade, every attitude, and every bad decision, your teen is gonna fall apart, this episode is for you. Today I'm joined by John Fogel, parenting researcher, data for, and author of Punishment Free Parenting. John has helped millions of parents understand what actually helps kids grow. And today we're talking about something that completely changes how we parent.
He believes we often overestimate the small stuff and underestimate the big stuff when it comes to our teens. And it's causing more stress, worry, and conflict than it should. Let's find out what he means. Welcome, John.
Jon (00:42.83)
Hey, thanks for having me on the podcast.
Dr.Cam (00:44.726)
Absolutely. So John, first tell us who are you, your background, why are you into this stuff?
Jon (00:50.594)
Yeah, so I'm into this stuff because I love psychology and I love kids and I love Mr. Rogers and somehow all of those things come together to become a whole parent. I started out kind of just like everybody else. I'm a dad. I didn't really know what to do with my own kids. I was trying to figure it out. the difference is most people read a parenting book. I read about 60 parenting books, and then after I read those, I was like, this isn't enough. So I read a bunch of studies, and then after that.
I was getting a master's degree, and so I pivoted with my master's degree to study more psychology and and incorporate it in. And now I'm getting my PhD in developmental psychology. So I'm just like you if you were crazy obsessive about parenting, right? Like most people's hobbies are like, well, I really like going for bike rides and I really like you know, I just really support this sports team. And mine are like, I wonder what this guy from 1923 said about kids, right? So
Dr.Cam (01:46.451)
In the same way. It's a weird fascination, but it is so there. And everything I see can relate to it, right? It's like, that's a metaphor for this. So you're talking about, and I I love this idea so much, is that we're focused on too much on the small stuff and not enough on the big stuff. So let's start with the small stuff. What are we spending far too much time focusing on?
Jon (01:59.128)
Totally.
Jon (02:15.167)
well for teens, number one thing is grades. number one thing is grades. Number one thing we we over and over again, there are discussions in the cultural space about why teens are increasingly anxious and depressed. What I think is really interesting is that when you look at all of the different studies into why teens are anxious and depressed, any study that actually asks teenagers what they think, they say,
Dr.Cam (02:20.497)
Yes.
Jon (02:43.775)
It's school, it's grades, it's pressure from my parents to perform academically. And I think realistically, and I am obviously a very big proponent of education in general, I I am a, you know, cl going on three time graduate of higher education. So like I I am in no way the guy who's gonna tell you that education's not important. But I think when we actually look critically.
at the world, we find that the people who are most successful and most happy are not always the people who got straight A's in school. And in fact it's it's often the opposite. It's the people who are who are feeling anxious and depressed that are the ones who kind of did everything right and checked all of those boxes and then wound up, you know, on the other side of 25 going, okay, what am I supposed to do with my life now? And so, you know, I think number one thing that parents focus on is grades. I think the the second thing
that they focus on is trying to keep their kids out of trouble. Right. They're they're they're just like, you know, they focus on all of these little rules and what they will call boundaries, but actually they're just kind of rules. Right. They're not about safety necessarily. They're sort of about they're sort of about mitigating all forms of risk for kids. So these are things like, I'm not gonna, you know, let my kid
Dr.Cam (03:42.812)
Yeah.
Dr.Cam (03:49.778)
They're not boundaries.
Jon (04:04.341)
have a sleepover at their friend's house or or this or that or the other, 'cause they could be exposed to this, or I'm not gonna let my kid go out after dark, or I'm not gonna let my kid be in a romantic relationship with somebody. And and those things are all things that are actually contributing ultimately to that that kind of small stuff that I talk about where these are these are developmentally appropriate behaviors. And I'm not saying that we have to fully endorse our kids doing reckless or
Dr.Cam (04:28.922)
Yes.
Jon (04:32.607)
Or potentially harmful things to themselves. But we also have to appreciate that this has always been a part of childhood. This has always been a part of adolescence. And it's how we learn exactly. So that's that's the small stuff that I tend to see parents focusing on. They're focusing on what did my kid text their friend the other day? Or what did my, you know, what is my kid doing online? And I'm not saying that that's not important, but they're they're hyper focused on those things instead of focusing on, right, how how are they, how are they?
Dr.Cam (04:39.122)
That's how we learn.
Dr.Cam (04:49.936)
Yeah.
Dr.Cam (04:57.958)
What is their tone? Their voice tone.
Jon (05:03.239)
Going through the world, what kinds of relationships do they have? are they able to think critically? Are they able to problem solve? Are they able to be competent and confident and self-driven? Like all of these things. Are they able to care passionately about things and then see them through? Like this is the stuff that actually matters long term. And what's really interesting is that when you ask parents what they want for their kid, like what do you want for the future of your child?
Almost always parents will tell on themselves
Load full transcript
because they'll start with, Well, you know, I want them to get in a good school, I want them to have a good first job, I want them to this, or I want her to this, I want her to get us, you know, scholarship. I want to I want to make sure that she has all the opportunities, you know, as a young young adult that she could possibly have. And they're basically only talking about ages 18 to 25. When in reality
Dr.Cam (05:56.433)
Yeah. And about accomplishments.
Jon (05:59.84)
And about accomplishments, exterior validation, the things that the world thinks about their kid. And then you think about and I say, okay, so so that's where they're gonna be at 25. What about at 35? What about at 45? At 45, hopefully with increasing life expectancy, you're halfway through your life, right? If you live to night age 90. And yet most parents only parent for the first quarter of life. They only parent until their kid's about 22. And they're like, you know what? That's my
Dr.Cam (06:24.071)
Yeah.
Jon (06:29.677)
purpose and my whole goal for my kid basically is achieved or not achieved at 22. When your kid has three quarters of their life left to live at that point. And it's that's the stuff that I look at and I go, the big stuff is how is my kid going to live the three quarters of their life at the back end? Not how is my kid going to do in this very specific time that we have just culturally decided is has to be formative and has to be indicative. And by the way, I am not doing anything related to my
College degree today. Absolutely unnecessary to the most significant degree. I took courses that matter for my life, not even 5%. Of course, they taught me how to think, and I'm not devaluing higher education, but but that is actually the case for most people. Most people are not in the industry that they were in with their first job out of college. Probably that job doesn't matter that much. And nobody has asked me where I went to undergrad.
Dr.Cam (07:03.217)
No.
Jon (07:28.341)
in literally fifteen years. And so that matters. Right.
Dr.Cam (07:29.892)
No, I mean I'll tell them without them asking, but they don't ask right.
Jon (07:35.305)
Right, nobody cares for the last decade of my life, nobody has cared. What they care about is what can I do now and how can I problem solve now.
Dr.Cam (07:40.188)
Right. They definitely don't care what what grade I got in my eighth grade history class.
Jon (07:48.23)
absolutely not. And I you know what? Many of the people who come to me for advice and pay me lots of money to talk to them about their kids, they would be they would be scared off by my middle school transcript. They'd say, This kid, there's no way that this person has any idea what they're talking about. I was told in in eighth grade that I should pick that we had to take a c a test in eighth grade that that set you up for what types of jobs you should
Dr.Cam (08:14.256)
Yes.
Jon (08:14.945)
Be pursuing. It's called the explorer test, right? It's like, do you do you
enjoy being outside? Maybe you should be a landscaper, you know? But that it also had competencies. And I was told as the result of that test, I literally sat in a room with a person who the resource professional, like a school counselor, because my school had pr pretty good resourcing and and financing that that you they could have like one-on-ones with students. And she sat there and she said, you know, you're not gonna do anything that involves writing. And
Dr.Cam (08:17.031)
Mm-hmm.
Jon (08:45.151)
I'm now on my second book. My first book is a is a huge bestseller. 1%, you know, top 1% book in the world. I'm on my second book. I've written a children's book. I have another contract for a children's book already in the works. So literally, I've signed four book deals in the last two or three years. And I was told in eighth grade, you'll never be a writer. So this information does not actually like give us any semblance.
Dr.Cam (09:07.092)
my gosh.
Jon (09:14.849)
And and the reason I got my first job out of out of college, by the way, was because I was really good at talking to people. I was really good at relating to people. And so even if you are looking for those specific, even if you do want to focus on the small stuff, you know what the you know what we know? We know that the kids who are more healthy relationally, the kids who are better storytellers, the kids who have you know more interesting high school experiences because they did they did a diverse number of things. Not they did everything, not
They were on the soccer team and the marching band and and and they did the drama club and they were on Model UN and they were on the debate team and this Interstate Scholastica and like, you know, Honor Society. That stuff. Colleges look at that stuff, they go, Whatever. Who cares? Everybody. Yeah, everybody does that.
Dr.Cam (09:57.019)
Everyone does that. Yeah. great, you spent your whole time building a resume. Woohoo.
Jon (10:01.759)
My college essay was about how I founded the bowling team at my high school. And the person when when I went to to get my first job, they said, Well, you know, what's something interesting about you? And I literally drew on that same experience. I said, I founded the bowling team. Did I find the found the bowling team because I had a a, you know, an A in my math class? No. I founded the bowling team because I was able to sit down with the athletic director, a full-fledged adult, and say, This is why I think bowling.
Would help to increase access to athletic teams. This is something that disabled kids can do. This is something that in the town that I grew up in, it was a very multicultural activity. You went to the bowling alley, it was actually one of the only places that was deeply integrated. You had white people, you had black people, you had old people, you had young people, you had Latinos. And so, like, I was like, this is why it's good. You can start men and women at the exact same time. I presented a
compelling case. And that had
Dr.Cam (10:35.13)
Mm.
Jon (10:59.859)
Absolutely nothing to do with the quote unquote small stuff that most people are worried about. And yet that's probably afforded me more opportunities than anything that I did academically. So that's what I mean when I say we focus on the small stuff instead of focusing on the big stuff. And if we actually ask parents, what is your goal for your child at 40? we would get a completely different answer. And we would look back at all the stupid stuff we do at 12, 13, 14, 15 and go, none of this.
contributes to my child's life at forty. It contributes to my child's life at nineteen. And guess what? Every kid at nineteen's an idiot.
Dr.Cam (11:28.708)
None of it matters. Nope.
Dr.Cam (11:38.114)
Yeah, we're supposed to be. That's the point.
Jon (11:40.214)
You're supposed to be. They're they're ridiculous they do stupid stuff, and our job is to pat them on the back and go, it's all right. I was dumb. Yeah, exactly. And it's like people are worried that their their kid won't survive if they don't get a straight A's or this. And in reality, the the thing that is most likely to kill your kid at age of 19 or 20 is stress.
Dr.Cam (11:48.412)
I'm glad you survived that.
Dr.Cam (12:07.099)
Yes. Yeah. That's I mean, John, I I think this is so important to stress out, stress about stress, is that so much of what we do is to help them get through life successfully. But the way we do it is creating the very thing that makes it hard to get through life successfully.
Jon (12:09.131)
Nad they're not gonna be homeless.
Jon (12:31.565)
That's right.
Dr.Cam (12:31.601)
Which is the pressure, which is the focus, which is the expectations, which is the you're not allowed to make a mistake. You're all of that is what is causing the very issue. And I think the problem is, and and parents want something that they can see and that they can control. Not just parents, every human being wants something they can see and control. We can see grades. We can track grades. We can't track.
Is my child learning critical thinking? It's that's harder to do, right? Is my child like the things we need our kids to develop aren't trackable. We can't measure them. We can't measure them against a scale to say, is my child normal? And that is why I think parents focus on the small stuff because it's easier to to track.
Jon (13:27.901)
And it's what we've societally decided is is important. When ironically, teachers themselves say I wish parents would care less. Like I wish parents would care much more about, you know, the relationship with the kid and not this. And and it's really like it's like we've seen we've understood we see a problem in front of us, which is kids aren't prepared for the world that they're going into.
Dr.Cam (13:31.707)
Important. Yeah.
Dr.Cam (13:41.863)
Their relationship with their kids. Yeah.
Dr.Cam (13:54.172)
No.
Jon (13:55.318)
And and some of that's not on parents. A lot of it's not on parents. A
lot of it's not on teachers. A lot of it's not even on the kids, right? It's it's on the world that we're that they're going into is changing so rapidly. No job that your kid's gonna work exists today. Right? Your k your kid's gonna be a therapist for some AI agent or something. Like I like who knows what your kid's gonna do, right? Like and and you have no idea, like
Dr.Cam (14:09.935)
Exists, right, nothing. We don't know what the job look is gonna look like.
Dr.Cam (14:19.869)
Yeah.
Jon (14:23.775)
What's that what that's gonna be? Your sk your kid's gonna like sell freeze-dried strawberries. Who knows? Like maybe they'll be a hot commodity in 2040. but but you don't know what that job is yet. And and so it's sort of like we focus on the things that we feel that we can control because we're going into such an uncontrollable thing, an uncontrollable future. But but oftentimes the way in which we try and solve for that lack of control.
winds up doing more harm than good. And I actually I actually have an analogy about this that I use with parents. So i I'm a big history nerd. And one of the things that I like to talk about is times in human history where we like the humanity totally thinks that we know what we're doing and then we totally screw up and we like ruin it for everyone. And a great example of this is in 1958 in communist China during the Great Leap Forward.
Dr.Cam (14:55.741)
I know.
let's hear I love analogies.
Jon (15:19.159)
just Mao's revolution, and they're gonna bring, you know, prosperity to all of China. And there was a what's called the four pest campaign. And basically there were these pests that were causing destruction of crops and and stuff. And and one of them was sparrows. And they were having this problem in ch China where sparrows were destroying the crops. And the farmers were just having to chase the sparrows away for all the time and put up scarecrows and stuff. But the sparrows would still come and eat the food.
Dr.Cam (15:28.455)
Mm.
Jon (15:49.814)
And so they put out this basically you know, bounty on sparrows. Just kill all the sparrows because we'll fix the problem. And so people were were literally catching sparrows in nets. They were putting nets around trees that would tangle up sparrows and and then they would die. They were this is probably the most brutal one, they were just throwing rocks at sparrows and then they could never land and they would die of exhaustion and fall out of the sky. And they killed.
Millions and millions of sparrows because the people of China at the time were like, yeah, hey, look, this is what we're gonna do. We're gonna fix the problem. This is the solution. We got to kill the sparrows. The sparrows eating the plants, like eating the crops. We need more food. We're gonna kill the sparrows. Well, after all the sparrows died, they realized that the primary food that the sparrows were eating were not actually the plants and the crops. The sparrows were eating the crops kind of for
fun.
Dr.Cam (16:22.919)
This is the solution.
Jon (16:44.907)
It was like a nice treat for the sparrows. The sparrow's primary diet was insects and locusts. And so when they killed, when they killed all of the sparrows, the locust and and and grasshopper, whatever population exploded and caused one of the greatest famines in the recorded history. And so to solve a problem of not having enough food, they actually made the problem of not having enough food a hundred times worse. And literally, tens of millions of people died.
Dr.Cam (16:49.277)
Yeah. Thanks killing the crops.
Dr.Cam (17:14.043)
Mm.
Jon (17:14.347)
Because of this, it was catastrophically bad. And people point to this as a failure of communism or failure of economics or failure of planning or whatever. When in reality, it's an example of one of the most common human instincts, which is: hey, I see a problem and I'm gonna just try and solve that problem without thinking about the down the road implications of my solution. And when I solve that problem in this way.
Dr.Cam (17:38.876)
Yes.
Jon (17:43.19)
I think that it'll probably lead to better prosperity down the road. And this is what we do with our kids every single day. We try and solve for a minor problem. Well, they might not be quite as prepared for the workforce. Or they might not as get a job that's $90,000 a year right out of college. They'll only get a job that's $60,000 a year out of college.
Or maybe they'll have to work in the mailroom if I don't send them to that private school that I want them to go to or whatever, right? Like they won't have the connections. We solve for a pro small problem. And what we wind up doing is creating literal systems of anxiety and depression in our kids, which make them far less competent, far less able to problem solve, far less able to communicate with adults and communicate with their peers and communicate, et cetera, right?
Dr.Cam (18:11.922)
Right.
Jon (18:34.401)
We say you can't go out until you get all your homework done. Then our kid doesn't learn how to have good relationships and we won't realize that that interview
Dr.Cam (18:39.993)
I know. Prioritizing that over growing up just makes me wanna scream. I I gotta say, that is one of the hardest things for me to see is when we prioritize that over just socializing and being a teenager and being a kid and growing up. It's it's heartbreaking.
Jon (18:44.692)
Yes.
Jon (18:59.305)
It is. And that's and that's the real challenge that we're faced with right now. It's are we going to try and solve the problem of the teen mental health crisis and the teen failure to launch crisis and all of these things? You know, the male loneliness epidemic is a version of this that comes, you know, young men not knowing, having no direction in life. Are we going to try and solve that problem by doubling down on the thing that created the problem in the first place? By more pressure, you know?
Dr.Cam (19:26.275)
What's the
Jon (19:28.811)
You you know
what? The real problem with kids is that they don't have enough pressure put on them already. Like, as if the pressure is not actually what's causing all of the problems that we're seeing in the first place. And so I think you should care so much less about grades. I think you should care so much less about little things. I think you should care so much less about little disrespectful things that your kids do and they slam a door on you or whatever. And it's like, right.
Dr.Cam (19:37.992)
Right.
Dr.Cam (19:54.63)
I mean, we do it too. We're we're disrespectful back to be honest, 'cause it's the same emotional dysregulation.
Jon (20:02.433)
Totally. Like just care be so much be so much more grown up than to care about such frivolous things. And and care instead like about whether your kid is building good relationships. Care instead about whether your kid knows how to talk through their problems. Care instead about whether when your kid has a hard time, they know who to go to to receive advice and comfort. And if they if they can do those things, then you're actually setting them up.
Dr.Cam (20:09.541)
Yeah.
Jon (20:31.479)
for lifelong physical, mental and emotional health rather than temporary success in in a field that will be totally pointless and irrelevant in the later three quarters of their life.
Dr.Cam (20:47.057)
I I think that's the other thing I'm always fascinated by is that we are so focused on restricting them from technology and screens when pretty much every the one thing I can estimate is that most jobs are gonna require access to technology and screens. And so we prohibit them from doing that when that's probably the skill they're gonna most need.
Jon (21:10.049)
Mm-hmm.
Dr.Cam (21:10.575)
In the future. But we fight over it all the time. And it's like, but your kids actually learning the skills they need to learn when they do this.
Jon (21:18.209)
Well, and any parent out there who goes, My kids are so addicted to screens, the thing that I always want to say is, rather than saying no, they're not, or that's okay, or all kids are, like, I think no all of those things are unhelpful ways of responding. I the way that I respond is, okay, well, what alternatives do they have? Right? It do what if well, your kids all they do is just Snapchat and text all day. Okay, if they wanted to spend
all of the time that they're Snapchatting and texting with that group of friends, if they wanted to spend that time with their friends, like, my, my, my kids always texting during family dinner. And I make them put their phone away during family dinner. Okay, family dinner's great. We have lots of research to support this. But your kid's 15 and they want to eat dinner at somebody else's house. If you restrict that, they're just going to text that person. And so you time and time again, actually the the the people who when when polled
Dr.Cam (21:53.341)
Could they?
Jon (22:16.171)
Are the most anti-screen. The population that is the most anti-screen
are teenagers. Like if you actually ask them, if you ask millennials like, hey, what would you do without your phone? Millennials like, my God, I would, I would die. If you ask a teenager, like, hey, and and you can actually see this being bared out, there's a couple of colleges right now that have gone phone free, where when you enroll in the college, you get a landline phone in your dorm room and you look.
Dr.Cam (22:39.282)
Yeah.
Dr.Cam (22:43.559)
Kids actually love it. When nobody has them, that's the change. If you're the only one that doesn't have it, it's terrible. Cause now you're cut out.
Jon (22:46.686)
Exactly. It w
Jon (22:51.745)
Well, it's just restricting yeah, it's just restricting your access to communication with with your peers. But but when but what we find is that like very, very few boomers, very, very few Gen X, very, very few millennials would ever attend a college where they would not be allowed to use social media or use their phone or whatever. But but actually Gen Z, Gen Alpha, they're like, That's that would be, are you kidding? I want I want a ninety summer. Like I want to have to go over to my friend's house and knock on the door. And so it's not a problem.
Really, in my experience, teenagers the most addict addicted to their phones kids are the ones who have no other outlet outside of that phone. But it's they're escaping.
Dr.Cam (23:31.611)
Yeah. Yeah. And they're escaping. They're escaping the real world. It's not taking them away from it. They're escaping it.
Jon (23:38.968)
Totally. It's it's the it's the kids for whom I'm I'm counseling their them and their parents at the same time. And what I hear coming from them is, yeah, my mom just took my door off. Why? because I you know, I was looking at something inappropriate on my phone and then she took my phone away and she took the and it's like, those are the kids I'm I'm gonna tell you right now, those are the kids who are gonna spend all of their time on their phone. And because be it's
Dr.Cam (24:00.53)
Yep. A hundred percent. They are the ones, yes. And they're the ones that sneak it and are trying and lie about it. Yeah.
Jon (24:07.915)
Right. And participate in unlike like there's yeah, it's there's there's different degrees of risk. Like a child who or a teenager who's exploring sexual boundaries with a partner, like almost all teenager well, one, first of all, that's happening far, far less than it ever did when we were kids. And secondly, when it does happen, what we know is that the parents the more restrictive the parents are to even those discussions, conversations about that, the more likely they're
Dr.Cam (24:10.289)
Healthy, yeah.
Jon (24:37.419)
Their teen is to engage in unsafe versions of that. Right. So, so it's even those places of like, I'm not, I am not so woke to the world that I'm gonna sit here and just be like, I yeah, you should just sleep with as many people as you want when you're 15. Like I am not that bad, right? I think that there is still a respectful boundary where we say, Hey, like I'm gonna sit sit here and tell you that this is not a good idea, and you're gonna sit here and tell me, well.
Dr.Cam (24:54.143)
Yeah.
Jon (25:04.779)
Whatever, but at least there's a a an understanding here that no matter what's going on, you can bring it to me. And I think that that's different.
Dr.Cam (25:10.897)
And those are the kids that actually are less sexually active.
Jon (25:14.711)
Typically, yes. And and and that's the thing is that like, you know, we when you think about the the the antiphone crowd, the Jonathan Heights out there, like I think that they're pointing to something that's very real. And the what thing that the the thing that they're pointing at is that the internet is an unsafe place for kids if they don't know how to navigate it. The internet Yeah, if they don't have boundaries in place, and there's a great researcher.
Dr.Cam (25:36.099)
if they don't know how to navigate it.
Jon (25:43.294)
Joelle Alexander from Finland, the d or I'm from Denmark, the Danish way of parenting, who talks about this. But but there's like she has like a whole like how to introduce your kids to screens in a way that they like know boundaries and stuff. Jessica Joel Alexander. But this when when when I look at that I go, yeah, the like there is a real risk online for kids, but when I see a kid who's really risky online, that's a kid who's had no
has had no ability to be risky in in person. And when I see a kid who struggles to understand consent at 18 years old and bin streaks at 18 years old, those are the kids who are the most restricted when they were 16 and 17 at exploring these things. And so that's that's where I look at this and I go, yeah, I think we're we're really hyper focused on the small stuff. And people look at the s things I call small stuff and they go, those are big deals for me. And I go, yeah, big in comparison to what? You know what I mean? Big in comparison to your kid
having no ability to have a family and have meaningful connection with people for the latter two thirds of their life. no, that would be horrible. Yeah. So maybe like let's let's adjust our priorities here because that's actually a reality these days.
Dr.Cam (26:53.691)
Yeah.
Dr.Cam (26:57.491)
It it is a big reality. And I think when parents, and I'm sure you get this too, when parents come to me, there's usually something pretty big happening, right? It's getting to a point where it's really serious and now they're like, We need help. The frustrating part that they find is that the things that they want to address, they do not have the influence to address anymore. And so they're trying to do it through control. And so when my recommendation is you need to step back and re work on your relationship.
Jon (27:09.89)
Right.
Dr.Cam (27:27.239)
First. It feels too urgent to be able to do that. And I'm like, but you can continue doing what you're doing and continue down a bad road, or we can take
a break, get your relationship back on track, and then you can help your kid. So I think that's the thing that we just keep doubling down on the control. And every time we do, we keep making the problem bigger and bigger and bigger. And us.
Jon (27:42.765)
That's right.
Jon (27:54.07)
It's the sparrows.
Dr.Cam (27:55.272)
give us less and less and less can influence to do anything about it.
Jon (27:59.692)
Right. No, it's the sparrows. There was actually there was an ecosystem out there, right? There there isn't there's an ecosystem with parents and kids in the same way. And that ecosystem means that sometimes your kids are gonna do stuff that you don't like. They're gonna misbehave. They're gonna act the when you give a kid freedom, they're gonna use it. Like like th yeah, the g they're gonna they're gonna melt down. They're gonna, you know, fight you with you about stuff, they're gonna argue with you about stuff when you let them.
Dr.Cam (28:01.573)
Yes Totally as the sparrows.
Dr.Cam (28:18.299)
Yes, hopefully.
Dr.Cam (28:26.546)
Yeah.
Jon (28:26.849)
But the difference is that ecosystem, that sacred ecosystem between parent and child has existed for hundreds of thousands of years, and it has never had as little autonomy as it has today. And so, so, so, d like there are times when you have to suffer. There is no world where all of the crops go to the humans. Right? Like that was the thing that the gr the great leap forward, the the four pest campaign.
That was the thing that it failed to understand was that there was no way of just having enough, like like zero loss, total efficiency. And in the in the in the march forward towards greater efficiency, they lost efficiency. And this is the same thing with control, right? They were trying to control the sparrow population without realizing that the control that they were that they were enacting over the sparrow population was actually making their underlying problem worse.
Dr.Cam (29:04.754)
Yeah.
Dr.Cam (29:22.363)
Way worse. And that is
Jon (29:23.221)
And the more parents control, the worse the problem gets. You show me a parent who thinks they have total control over their kid, and I will show you a kid who exhibits who exhibits more risky behavior than any other kid in that school.
Dr.Cam (29:27.994)
Exactly.
Dr.Cam (29:36.944)
Or has shut down so completely that they don't know. I I've talked to kids too who just are counting down the days till they can be free. And and I think it's really important, John, because I know parents, you know, hear stuff like this and a lot of times, and I understand why we'll get defensive and be like, okay, then just blame it on the parents then. And and here's what I always want to say about this: this is not about blame, it's about awareness. And it's about saying, there's a different way.
Jon (29:46.23)
Right.
Dr.Cam (30:05.701)
And I can take that different way. So if you know there's a different way and you don't take it, then yes, that's on you. If you
didn't know and now you do, now's your opportunity to try something different. That's not blame. That's going, my gosh, I there's something else I can do. This is amazing. And the thing is when we take back the relationship part of it and not the controlling them, but controlling how we're showing up.
Jon (30:14.198)
Right.
Dr.Cam (30:34.225)
That's what we actually have control over. We can actually do that. So now you're going, wait, I can make this situation better with something I can control me. That's empowerment.
Jon (30:36.365)
That's right. Right.
Jon (30:44.107)
Right. Right. It is empowerment. And whenever a parent says that to me, right? Like, well, so it's just all my fault, I go, Yeah. And and and and and yeah, yes, and that's okay. Like, actually, why are we so worried about fault? Like, if it's your fault, that means you can have then you can change. Like the alternative is this is just the world that we live in, and we just have to get we just have to get used to a world.
Dr.Cam (30:53.553)
Whose fault is it then?
Jon (31:13.621)
And we just have to like i if if the world that we live in today is just all teens, not all, but but a majority of teens are going experience anxiety, depression, and to a lesser extent suicidality, and there's absolutely nothing we can do about it, what a devastating world. But if we just say, actually, what has changed in the last 30 years?
Dr.Cam (31:30.77)
That is.
Dr.Cam (31:37.683)
Well, everyone just points to phones. That's the problem. We're so narrow focused on that one thing and it's the sparrows.
Jon (31:40.129)
But but what we see
Jon (31:45.728)
It's the sparrows. Well you look at yeah, you look at the phones and you go and you go, okay. So so that's that's actually, you know, or the phones, that's why this this people talk about this in all sorts of ways. That's why the school shootings, that's why this and this. It's like, no, because my brothers were in high school during Columbine, they didn't know he had a cell phone. Right? Like the there is a there has been a steady march towards the teen anxiety and mental health crisis for
Dr.Cam (31:58.076)
No.
Dr.Cam (32:03.695)
No
Dr.Cam (32:10.835)
'Cause there's been more and more less and less autonomy. Yeah.
Jon (32:14.135)
For for 25 years. And and this trajectory, while it may be accelerated in the modern world and maybe it's being exacerbated by the online phone epidemic or whatever, what we see is actually, no, millennials are more indecisive than than their parents were, right? So we already see in so many ways that actually, no, different generations have experienced different versions of the
I was in high school when Glee was coming out. That was how that's how old I am. Actually, I was in college when Glee was coming out, but it was this show about kids who were in high school and college. And I look at that show today and I go, most of this show is expressing and showing a version of high school. Yes, that's romanticized now. like that was great. But at the time, what were we hearing? The teen mental health is on the rise. The suicide epidemic for teens is on the rise.
Dr.Cam (32:46.172)
Yeah.
Dr.Cam (33:08.499)
I mean, I've gone and done historical work on how on teen like epidemics. We have one every there, it's always something. It's always something external that we're blaming teen behavior on. And teen behavior is teen behavior. We're trying to fix something that is developmental and we're never gonna fix it. So
Jon (33:18.988)
Yes.
Jon (33:26.817)
Team behavior is team behavior.
Jon (33:31.424)
Right. Your kids are gonna do stupid stuff. Like, like the only difference that's right, that's right. Like the only difference between a parent who follows what I say and I think what you say, and a parent who doesn't and who wants to grasp for that control. It's not that the teenager engages in less or more risky behavior. It's that the teenager calls their mom or dad when they're in trouble.
Dr.Cam (33:35.899)
We do stupid stuff.
Dr.Cam (33:56.251)
Yeah. Correct.
Jon (33:57.718)
And ultimately, this is what I hate about people when they say they they go, well, you can't and and by the way, this is a lot of my friends who are very, very good parenting voices will say the old trope, you can't be your kid's friend and their parent at the same time. And and I will respond to that with being saying, yes. And the reason that your kid calls their friend instead of you at two AM is because you haven't earned the right to be there. Right? We used to there used to be this old joke, you call your second best friend.
When you need to get bailed out of jail because your first breastfriend sh ought to be sitting next to you. And and what I'm saying today is we we have to become the people that our kids call on. Because the difference, according to Harvard, between toxic stress and tolerable stress is literally whether or not the parent is a supportive influence during that stress. So you cannot control the world.
Dr.Cam (34:32.476)
Yeah.
Dr.Cam (34:54.277)
So much research supporting that. Yeah. That is like the number one protective factor against pretty much everything you can throw out there is having a supportive parent in your corner.
Jon (34:56.565)
You cannot control the world.
Jon (35:05.953)
And what's crazy is that we actually look at we look at k kids these days have it pretty it's it's it's never been a harder time to be a kid because of the world that we live in some ways. In other ways, it's never been an easier time to be a kid either. Because here like I'm not saying everywhere in the world, but in most of the world today, kids are not being drafted into the to to the war. They're not being they're not being put on a factory line at 14 years old.
Dr.Cam (35:30.291)
They can they can Uber eats a Starbucks.
Jon (35:32.738)
They can Uber Eats of Starbucks. They're not they're not being dragged through a concentration camp or something. And yet, what we find is actually the
the kids who were teenagers during the Great Depression, the kids who are teenagers during the Holocaust, the kids who are teenagers during the Industrial Revolution, where the majority of teens were working in factories, actually had better mental health in some ways. Be not because they didn't have more traumatic circumstances.
Dr.Cam (35:37.151)
No.
Jon (35:59.074)
But because those traumatic cir circumstances were mitigated by the fact that they felt that they could go to supportive people in their life. Partially, when I look at the teen mental health epidemic, I don't blame parents because parents have never had to carry everything until recently. When we say, Well, you know, my parents weren't there for me in the same way, right? But somebody else was.
Dr.Cam (36:27.665)
Yeah. We had more community. Yeah.
Jon (36:27.819)
And our kids don't have the same access to those other supportive families, right? When you were grow growing up on the block and all the parents were alcoholics and and all the women were on Ritalin and all the men were alcoholics, and nobody, everybody was beating their kids, and nobody was very nice. You might have had one mom on the block who was really great. And she was, she was absolutely crushing it.
And everybody else ignored their kids, but that one mom was the supportive base for dozens of kids. And that was sufficient. And in the modern world, every single parent has to be some version of that mom because we don't have that community where we say it takes a village. We we don't actually have a village anymore. And so we're we're kind of stuck in this. I'm trying to be that for my block now because I look at that and I go.
Dr.Cam (37:16.071)
We don't have a pillage. Mm-mm.
Jon (37:25.171)
I can't fix each person's house, but I can be the person that people that the kids go to when they need somebody. And I think that that like if parents go, well, it's not fair, you're right. It's not fair to you because there is not that person who is gonna just be that protective therapeutic force for your kid. But it but without them, you have to understand that your kid's gonna be in a world of trouble if they don't have somebody. And so it's gotta be you.
Dr.Cam (37:48.69)
Yeah. Yeah. It I I think a lot of times when people, you know, come to me and they bring their kids to me and they they want me to be that person. I'm like, I'm happy to be that person temporarily, but my my goal is to make you that person. Like that's what I wanna do. I wanna work with you, parent, because I want you to be that role. They're not gonna keep coming to me and I don't matter as much to them. I never will. So I
Jon (38:04.631)
That's right.
Jon (38:11.105)
That's right.
Dr.Cam (38:15.993)
Great. I can be there every once in a while. Absolutely. But if you want this to to really work, it it's gotta be you. And I don't feel like I know there's so much pressure. And I feel I mean, we're both parents. I get it. There's so much fear, there's so much pressure, there's so many expectations on us. And it's hard to tune that out, but we have to, because most of it is is
sensationalized and dramatic and don't know what they're talking about. When we tune all that out, we have a lot more energy and focus on what's important. we don't get kind of misdirected and and worried that we're looking at, you know, over over vigilant and we can focus on the right things. And I think that helps us kind of settle down. but but that's a hard thing to do. I I always think social media has had done more damage to parents.
Jon (38:43.661)
Right.
Jon (39:06.999)
Totally it has. I because good parenting is actually pretty brutally simple.
Dr.Cam (39:12.902)
It is.
Jon (39:14.413)
And I'm not saying it's it's easy, but it's it's pretty simple. And I think parents get really confused because they they're it's kind of like a river where at the head of the river, if you make changes, those changes trickle down into every other, you know, nook and cranny of that river. And no matter how many times it splits off and branches into different creeks, a change at the head, a change upstream is going to change.
you know, the the the the landscape of that river. I think so often the advice that parents get is so far downriver that they're like, it's like playing whack-a-mole. They're like, I gotta fix this. It I gotta fix this. You know, the the water's dirty. So I gotta fix this little section of the water. I gotta put a filter in here. now that water over there is dirty. I gotta put another filter in over there. I gotta put a well I'm supposed to be juggling all these things, John. How can I fill all these
Dr.Cam (39:56.531)
That's what I call it.
Jon (40:10.581)
At the same time, I go, no, no, no. If you walk upstream, you put one filter in, it filters the whole creek. And and good parenting is actually very simple. And it's why literally I don't sell a million products. I sell occasionally, not even all the time, probably once a month or something. I sell my course, which is a a basics course. And I don't
Dr.Cam (40:14.803)
Yeah.
Jon (40:32.281)
The course has the scripts and like the the little challenges and stuff to get you the quick wins so that you can see that it's working. I find that that's especially important for dads. They want to see that it works before they learn how to do the whole thing. But but it has those little quick wins for you on along the way so that you know that it's it's working. But ultimately the course is about learning how to think differently and actually just take everything a lot less seriously. And if you do that, you realize, my gosh, wait. You mean
Dr.Cam (40:42.482)
Yeah.
Jon (41:01.983)
It doesn't matter if I like perfectly respond to every single thing. No, it doesn't at all. If every single time your kid comes to you, you do these like three or four things, right? Don't respond reactively. Just wait until you're calm, right? So wait 10 minutes, wait until you're calm. Always
make sure that when they say, I'm feeling this or whatever, you repeat it back to them. you're feeling this. Like very simple stuff. Do that, do that, and then
You know, role play out how you want to solve solve the problem. Okay, what do you think you should do? And people are like, So, John, how do you come up with all these different interventions for all these different kids? And I go, I don't. I actually empower the parents to ask the kids what the intervention should be. And then it's like, you mean I don't have to like fight with my kid constantly? They'll actually just give me the own the intervention that'll be powerful for them. Yeah, imagine that. Imagine asking a kid what might help them.
Dr.Cam (41:41.959)
The same thing. Yeah.
Yeah.
Dr.Cam (41:59.249)
Yeah, right.
Jon (42:00.117)
Instead of just assuming that they're that they're not gonna be able to tell you.
Dr.Cam (42:04.231)
Well, here here's the struggle too, is that we don't believe them when they do tell us because this happens pretty much every single day. I will say something and the parents will say, my gosh, my teen literally just said that yesterday. And I said, Well, why didn't you listen to them? Why are you paying me to say what your teen told you for free yesterday? so your teens are already telling you. I I can guarantee it, because I they tell me all the time. They keep trying to tell them, tell us.
Jon (42:09.463)
That's right.
Jon (42:23.415)
That's right. That's right. That's right.
That's right.
Dr.Cam (42:34.235)
And we don't listen. So your teen is already telling you what they need. We just all we have to do is listen. I think the hardest part is that parent teens require stepping back and parents don't like doing it. But it it it's the most important thing we gotta do is step back.
Jon (42:49.805)
Well, it's it's letting go of control. And and I think many parents view this as like, you know, the day that my kid puts a bunch of their crap from their bedroom in their trunk of their beater car and drives off to college, then I'll just sit down with a big glass of whiskey and I'll I'll say, Job well done. And and I'm like, so basically for their whole life you controlled every single thing and then on the day that they set out, you just said good luck.
Dr.Cam (43:17.213)
Good luck. Good luck.
Jon (43:19.893)
It just seems it just seems like a like a big gamble on your part, you know? And and the parents go, yeah, I guess that's kind of true. Well, I guess that's what my parents did for me. And I go, Really? Was it that that's what your parents did for you? Your parents tightly controlled d like whatever, Gen X, forty five year old dad.
Your parents tightly controlled all of your you never drank when you were 16. You never did this when you were 17. You never drove recklessly. You know, you never drove without a license when you were 14 and your friend was 16. And they go, yeah, I did that. You never went this for my dad as a boomerized. You never went to blood, sweat, and tears at, you know, 16 years old. He used to get on the train at nine years old and try and with with 50 cents in his pocket that he collected from the couch.
Dr.Cam (43:59.24)
Great.
Jon (44:09.215)
And go try to let the the guy sitting at the g gate for Wrigley Field let him in so he could go sit in the bleachers by himself. And he brought his friend with him, who was also nine, because he looked like he was twelve. And they would let him in. Right.
Dr.Cam (44:21.819)
I love it. And those are the best stories. This is the one thing I'm doing. Like we're trying to rob our kids of the best stories they will ever have for the rest of their lives.
Jon (44:31.977)
Right. And and like like that's the kind of stuff where you go, I I go, you when you went to college, you were ready to go there. And and and well that's what my parents did for me. No, they didn't. The truth is we're afraid of being judged. We're afraid of being judged by by our friends or our p our kids' friends' parents. We're f afraid of being judged by our faith community. We're afraid of being judged by our
Dr.Cam (44:39.698)
Yeah.
Dr.Cam (44:48.199)
We are so afraid of being judged.
Dr.Cam (44:53.405)
Yep.
Jon (44:58.757)
siblings and our parents about how we're parenting. The real truth is the only judgment that we should care about is whether this is good or not for our kid. And the answer is, you know, let me give you an example of of a bunch of seven-year-olds. I was at a seven-year-old birthday party three days ago. And I'm there and they're they have this one of these like water inflatable things you hook the hose up to. So it's like a bouncy house, but it's got water spraying everywhere. And I got the seven year olds and eight year olds.
are climbing on top of this thing and jumping. I don't think they were doing flips. I think they were like kind of rolling off, like doing somersaults off of this onto the wet grass, which was like just sat sopping wet, saturate saturated with water. And it's like they're landing in this mud and it's big splashes. And one of the dads comes over and he and he's like, are these kids jumping off the back of this? And I was kind of watching my kids, yeah, they're kind of doing that. And and he goes, Okay, parenting guy, how would you get him to stop?
Dr.Cam (45:39.965)
Mm.
Dr.Cam (45:58.525)
I wouldn't.
Jon (46:00.353)
And he's like, he's like, you what what what are all and he's not saying it in a mean way. He's my he's my cousin. He's like actually be he actually is one of the only people in my family who listens to anything I say. So, so so he's a nice, really nice guy. And he's like, Okay, parenting guy, how would you get these kids to stop jumping off of there and you know somebody's gonna break their neck or break their arm or something? And I go, I wouldn't. And he's like, Hang on, you don't think that they could get hurt? I said, No, I didn't say that.
Dr.Cam (46:11.143)
Yeah.
Jon (46:27.115)
And then he was like, You
don't think that that somebody could die? I was like, that would be pretty crazy. That would be like maybe one in in like 10 million. And he's like, You don't think that somebody could break an arm? I was like, no, that's probably like that, that's way more likely. And he said, So you're you're okay with that. And I go, my problem is that the number of kids in casts, arm casts, from seven to ten years old.
Directly correlates with the number of kids six to eight years later in psych wards. Like I would much rather my kid break their arm doing something that's gonna give them the resilience, confidence, and and literally like the brain development to not make them feel anxious, depressed, and suicidal seven, eight years, nine years later, than the alternative, which is.
Dr.Cam (47:15.95)
Yeah.
Jon (47:22.469)
protect everything, protect everything. And I'll tell you just from my personal experience, my kids were playing soccer at the park the other day. It's it's my a nine year old playing with another nine year old playing soccer. One of his friends, they're both going for the ball, reaches over with his left arm to extend and and shoulder out my son. And in the process, their arms twist together for a second and then they separate and he starts screaming. He goes, didn't fall to the ground, didn't
Fall, didn't get tackled, nothing. Right. And I walk over and I go, You okay, buddy? And he's like, No, you need to call an ambulance. I think I broke my arm. And I'm like, break your arm. And it's like, you're fine. You're gonna be, you're gonna be all right. It'll be no big deal. It's no big deal. And turns out, no, totally broke his arm. Totally broke his arm. Like, just the way that his humorous twisted, just napped. And
Dr.Cam (48:17.009)
Yeah. You would never have prevented that.
Jon (48:20.433)
Never impossible to prevent. But okay, so just no kid should ever play soccer at nine years old again. I mean, like that's that's a ridiculous. And then we're like, my gosh, this is so bad. He's gonna be in a cast for three, you know, a year or six months or something, a broken humorous. My wife's a nurse, she's like, this could be really bad. Turns out two weeks later, they take the cast off. He's in a sling. Another month after that, apparently he's gonna do a little PT and then he's gonna be completely done. Like it actually
is not gonna affect his life in any substantive way two or three months down the road. He's gonna be completely fine. But yet we do everything in our power in life to prevent that type of thing, that type of thing at great cost to our kids.
Dr.Cam (48:53.669)
No. Yeah.
Dr.Cam (48:59.4)
And that
Dr.Cam (49:03.655)
Yeah, yeah. All right, John, this is so good. I could talk to you forever and ever and ever. but how do people find you?
Jon (49:12.119)
They can find me at Whole Parent on all of these social media platforms. That's Instagram, Facebook, TikTok, YouTube. I'm doing a lot on YouTube these days. They can find me on the Whole Parent Podcast. If you just type those three words, whole W-H-O-L E Parent Podcast. You'll find my podcast where I have a hundred episodes of just parenting content and good stuff. And then my website, I have two websites. I have a membership platform where you can get almost all of my courses.
And you can get private access to me for DMs. You can get group coaching access. And that's myparentlab.com. Myparentlab.com. And then wholeparentacademy.com is my website.
Dr.Cam (49:54.516)
It's amazing. We'll put all of that in the show notes so people can find you. Is there any words of wisdom or encouragement you wanna you wanna leave parents with?
Jon (50:04.843)
Well, yeah, I should also mention that I have a book. It's called Punishment Free Parenting. That should also be down there. I should I always forget to mention that. My my My words of encouragement are that if you're listening to this podcast and you're trying to do a good job, like the only thing standing in your way is your own fear. If you can do your best to reduce that fear, don't listen to the the media.
Dr.Cam (50:08.181)
yeah.
Jon (50:31.519)
In the way in which, you know, well, this kid did this one thing and it was this catastrophic, and my kid fell off the playground equipment and they died. Yes, those are horrible, tragic accidents. You're way more likely to be struck by lightning, right? Like there are so many things in life that are causing you fear and anxiety. The the this is how people sell to you. This is how the media gets you to continue to watch. If you can remove that sense of fear and just parent your kids with a little bit of trust.
you're gonna find it's gonna be so much easier. It's gonna be so much more enjoyable. And 20 years down the road, you're gonna have an amazing relationship with your kid and they're gonna thank you for it.
Dr.Cam (51:10.427)
Yeah. That's amazing advice. Support everything you said. Love it. John, thank you so much for joining me today. I really appreciate it.
Jon (51:18.625)
Thanks so much, Dr Cam.