TRASCRIZIONE 🔗
WEBVTT
00:00:02.931 --> 00:00:11.146
Ask a Black person almost anywhere in the world outside the African continent and they will know the feeling before you finish the question.
00:00:11.146 --> 00:00:16.742
For a man racialized as Black, the bag pulled a little closer on the train or the bus.
00:00:16.742 --> 00:00:19.134
The question that is never quite a compliment.
00:00:19.134 --> 00:00:20.605
Where are you really from?
00:00:20.605 --> 00:00:22.556
Or your English is so good.
00:00:22.556 --> 00:00:27.114
The hair touched without asking as though it were public property.
00:00:27.114 --> 00:00:30.777
The competence that must be proven over and over again.
00:00:30.777 --> 00:00:33.600
the warmth that gets read as aggression.
00:00:33.600 --> 00:00:38.575
The voice that goes unheard in meetings until a paler one repeats it.
00:00:38.575 --> 00:00:40.406
None of it alone leaves a mark.
00:00:40.406 --> 00:00:55.396
all of it together across a lifetime is a weather that Black people And many of the global majority have learned to walk through in Oslo and in London, in Paris and in Sao Paulo, And in New York and well beyond.
00:00:55.396 --> 00:00:57.920
And it does not stay in the realm of the personal.
00:00:57.920 --> 00:01:14.753
The same forces show up in the systems themselves, in who gets the interview and who gets the job, in who is believed in the hospital, and who is followed in the shop and stopped on the street, in whose child is marked as gifted and whose as a problem.
00:01:14.753 --> 00:01:20.039
when a Black woman names it, the second thing happens, and it's often worse than the first.
00:01:20.039 --> 00:01:21.950
She's told it did not happen.
00:01:21.950 --> 00:01:23.001
She's gaslit.
00:01:23.001 --> 00:01:24.203
She's tone policed.
00:01:24.203 --> 00:01:28.048
She's told that she's imagining it and she's too sensitive.
00:01:28.048 --> 00:01:36.587
And that it was not really about race, that the world is past all that now, and that she is the one keeping it alive by speaking it.
00:01:36.587 --> 00:01:42.668
The injury is doubled first the cut and then the insistence that there was no knife.
00:01:42.668 --> 00:01:46.635
This is not only a matter of feeling and it is not only social.
00:01:46.635 --> 00:01:52.408
The same denial that meets her in the streets, meets her in the hospital, and there it kills.
00:01:52.408 --> 00:02:03.179
Even in wealthy countries, a Black woman is more likely to die in childbirth than a white woman in the next bed with the same income and the same educational degree.
00:02:03.179 --> 00:02:06.162
More likely to have her pain waved away.
00:02:06.162 --> 00:02:11.917
She's more likely to be sent home still bleeding because someone decided she was exaggerating.
00:02:11.917 --> 00:02:18.693
In the United States, it is the indigenous woman who now carries the highest maternal mortality rate of all.
00:02:18.693 --> 00:02:25.543
And Black women carry the highest rates of infant death and of babies born too soon.
00:02:25.543 --> 00:02:27.746
The hierarchy is not abstract.
00:02:27.746 --> 00:02:33.724
It is written in who survives being born and who survives giving birth.
00:02:33.724 --> 00:02:39.748
The voice that says it's not about race is the same voice that says she's not really in that much pain.
00:02:39.748 --> 00:02:52.646
What joins the small slight on the train to the knee on the neck, to the death in the delivery room, is the single idea, and the idea is a lie that was built to look like the truth.
00:02:52.646 --> 00:02:58.600
Race was not discovered, it was invented by men in laboratories.
00:02:58.600 --> 00:03:09.443
and lecture halls who set out to confirm a hierarchy they already believed in, and who gave it the one thing that would make it almost impossible to argue with.
00:03:09.443 --> 00:03:12.737
They gave it the authority of science.
00:03:12.737 --> 00:03:17.001
That is why racism can be everywhere and deniable at once.
00:03:17.001 --> 00:03:20.143
It was designed to wear the face of fact.
00:03:20.143 --> 00:03:25.597
This is an episode about the people who built that lie and called it knowledge.
00:03:25.597 --> 00:03:28.520
I'm Chisomudeze, and this is Overnight's Wisdom.
00:03:28.520 --> 00:03:36.502
This is episode eight, and this episode is part of a series On a system I call white terrorism rather than white supremacy.
00:03:36.502 --> 00:03:40.067
And like the others, it stands on its own.
00:03:40.067 --> 00:03:42.359
So if you're new here, hello.
00:03:42.359 --> 00:03:43.931
I'm really happy to have you here.
00:03:43.931 --> 00:03:52.278
The chapter before this one looked at the church, which basically is the sacred machinery that turned conquest into.
00:03:52.278 --> 00:03:53.032
salvation.
00:03:53.032 --> 00:03:58.997
you know the discourse that often talks about the separation of church and state within the context of this series.
00:03:58.997 --> 00:04:04.060
I think of the previous episode about the church and this one about science.
00:04:04.060 --> 00:04:16.713
So this one is the twin, basically the secular machine that took over the work essentially through science, and the lie it was used to build basically the invention of race.
00:04:16.713 --> 00:04:19.646
I wanna say from the outset what this episode is not about.
00:04:19.646 --> 00:04:29.889
This episode is not a attack on science and it is not an argument that you should distrust your doctor or refuse the medicine that will save your life.
00:04:29.889 --> 00:04:34.663
because that kind of misreading gets people killed and I will not participate in that.
00:04:34.663 --> 00:04:40.755
The claim I'm making here is very similar, if not a twin, of the one I made about the church.
00:04:40.755 --> 00:04:46.242
my argument here is that power took the authority of science and used it to manufacture race.
00:04:46.242 --> 00:04:56.343
It used it to give an ancient hierarchy, the one disguised that would make it almost impossible to
Load full transcript
argue with, the appearance of objective facts.
00:04:56.343 --> 00:05:05.158
And also the proof that the crime was in the wielding and not in the method is that science is also the thing that destroyed the lie.
00:05:05.158 --> 00:05:12.298
The same instruments that Built's race turned honestly on the question, took it apart and showed there was never anything there.
00:05:12.298 --> 00:05:18.678
The cassock and then the lap coats, the will of God and then the law of nature, the same work by a newer authority.
00:05:18.678 --> 00:05:20.490
I also want to say where I stand here.
00:05:20.490 --> 00:05:28.649
You know, the hierarchy that these men built around race did not place my people somewhere in the comfortable middle.
00:05:28.649 --> 00:05:32.822
It placed Africans and Black people at the very bottom by design.
00:05:32.822 --> 00:05:36.065
And that is not a historical curiosity to me.
00:05:36.065 --> 00:05:39.428
It is the water I have swum in my entire life.
00:05:39.428 --> 00:05:46.024
And it is also the most uncomfortable destination of this episode, which I will get to by the end.
00:05:46.024 --> 00:05:47.906
But first I want to talk about the invention.
00:05:47.906 --> 00:05:53.990
Race feels like one of the oldest facts in the world, like something humanity has always known.
00:05:53.990 --> 00:05:59.915
And that feeling is the thing this episode has to take from you because it's not true.
00:05:59.915 --> 00:06:08.314
The idea that humanity divides into a small number of biological races, ranked from highest to lowest, is not ancient.
00:06:08.314 --> 00:06:22.744
Older hatreds existed and older suspicions of the stranger, but the claim that the ranking was biology, fixed in the blood and the skull and passed down like a height, it's about 300 years old.
00:06:22.744 --> 00:06:27.589
it has an author, or rather a succession of them, and they worked.
00:06:27.589 --> 00:06:33.098
in the most respectable institutions of their day And they called what they were doing science.
00:06:33.098 --> 00:06:39.920
it began as taxonomy, the harmless looking work of sorting the natural world into categories.
00:06:39.920 --> 00:06:54.944
In 1735, the Swedish botanist Carl Linnaeus, the man who gave the system for naming species that we still use, placed human beings into his great catalogue of nature and divided us into four kinds.
00:06:54.944 --> 00:06:57.052
By continents and by colour.
00:06:57.052 --> 00:06:59.714
And he did not stop at describing our bodies.
00:06:59.714 --> 00:07:07.139
In the expanded 10th edition of 1758, he assigned each kind a character.
00:07:07.139 --> 00:07:09.891
European he called governed by laws.
00:07:09.891 --> 00:07:13.064
The African governed by caprice.
00:07:13.064 --> 00:07:18.437
And in that small move from describing a body to ranking a soul.
00:07:18.437 --> 00:07:20.422
The machinery was born.
00:07:20.422 --> 00:07:34.120
By the end of that century, the German anatomist Johann Blumenbach had refined the scheme into five races and given the one he placed at the top a name he coined for the purpose, Caucasian.
00:07:34.120 --> 00:07:43.307
After a mountain range whose people he considered the most beautiful, arranging the others as a descent away from that ideal.
00:07:43.307 --> 00:07:47.190
The hierarchy now had its shape: white at the summit.
00:07:47.190 --> 00:07:49.367
Everyone else ranged below.
00:07:49.367 --> 00:07:56.432
What he did not have yet was data, the appearance of hard measurements that turns an opinion into a fact.
00:07:56.432 --> 00:08:02.564
And in the nineteenth century, an American physician named Samuel Morton set out to supply it.
00:08:02.620 --> 00:08:12.521
He collected human skulls from across the world, more than a thousand of them, and filled them with seeds and then with lead shots to measure the space inside.
00:08:12.521 --> 00:08:24.242
And he announced that the races ranked exactly as the hierarchy had always said Europeans with the largest brains, Africans with the smallest, the rest arranged more or less in between.
00:08:24.242 --> 00:08:28.456
His was considered exemplary science in its day.
00:08:28.456 --> 00:08:31.865
Careful, quantitative, objective.
00:08:31.865 --> 00:08:33.517
It was also built backwards.
00:08:33.517 --> 00:08:41.243
We know from his own letters that he cheered the case for white supremacy before his skulls had finished telling him anything.
00:08:41.243 --> 00:08:48.785
And whatever the truth of his individual measurements, which scholars still argue over, the enterprise was never a search.
00:08:48.785 --> 00:08:50.166
It was a confirmation.
00:08:50.166 --> 00:08:56.340
He had the conclusion and he went looking for the bones to essentially carry the conclusion that he'd made.
00:08:56.340 --> 00:09:00.004
And the proving was done on the living, not only on the dead.
00:09:00.004 --> 00:09:21.490
In eighteen ten, a young Khoekhoe woman from the Eastern Cape, remembered now as Sarah Bartman, was taken to Europe and exhibited in London and then Paris as the Hottentot Venus, showed half naked to paying crowds as a specimen of a lower order of human.
00:09:21.490 --> 00:09:35.399
And when she died in eighteen fifteen, the celebrated French anatomist Georges Cuvier dissected her and used her body to argue the Africans placed near the bottom of his scale.
00:09:35.399 --> 00:09:52.494
Her preserved remains were kept on show in Paris Museum into the 1970s and were not returned to South Africa for burial until 2002, Which is a measure of how recently the science of ranking still treated a human being as an exhibit.
00:09:52.494 --> 00:10:12.097
This is how the lie was built, not by liars exactly, but by serious men in good standing who began from a hierarchy they had absorbed with the air of their century, and who used the most prestigious tool available the measuring and the sorting and the publishing.
00:10:12.097 --> 00:10:15.991
to dress that hierarchy into the language
of facts.
00:10:15.991 --> 00:10:30.566
Race was not found in nature, it was built in the academy and then sent out into the world wearing the one uniform almost no one in the modern age knows how to argue with, the uniform of science.
00:10:30.566 --> 00:10:32.739
So now let's talk about the apparatus.
00:10:32.739 --> 00:10:36.243
Basically, an idea on its own harms no one.
00:10:36.243 --> 00:10:46.336
What makes the invention of race a chapter in this series about terrorism rather than a footnote in the history of bad science is what was done with it.
00:10:46.336 --> 00:10:52.677
Because once the hierarchy wore the authority of fact, it licensed everything.
00:10:52.677 --> 00:10:54.719
and the bodies it was practiced.
00:10:54.719 --> 00:10:55.807
On were real.
00:10:55.807 --> 00:10:57.259
so let's start with breeding.
00:10:57.259 --> 00:11:01.303
If the races were biological ranks, the logic ran, then.
00:11:01.303 --> 00:11:08.083
The human stock could be improved by encouraging the right people to reproduce and stopping the wrong ones.
00:11:08.083 --> 00:11:15.923
And in eighteen eighty three, Charles Darwin's half cousin, Francis Galton, gave the idea a name, eugenics.
00:11:15.923 --> 00:11:18.437
It was not a fringe enthusiasm.
00:11:18.437 --> 00:11:23.504
It became respectable science and respectable policy across the Western world.
00:11:23.504 --> 00:11:29.956
And nowhere more than in the United States where he moved from the laboratory into law.
00:11:29.956 --> 00:11:43.182
beginning in Indiana in 1907, more than 30 American states passed laws permitting the forced sterilization of people judged unfit, the feeble-minded, the criminal, the poor, the inconvenient.
00:11:43.182 --> 00:11:49.660
And in 1927, the Supreme Court of the United States blessed the practice.
00:11:49.660 --> 00:11:50.421
In Buck vs.
00:11:50.421 --> 00:12:02.840
Bell, Justice Oliver Wendell Holmes upheld the sterilization of a young woman named Carrie Buck, whose only proven offense was to have borne a child.
00:12:02.840 --> 00:12:08.504
With the sentence that became the policy of a nation, three generations of imbeciles are enough.
00:12:08.504 --> 00:12:16.740
More than 60,000 Africans were sterilized under those laws, against their will, in the name of science.
00:12:16.740 --> 00:12:18.748
And the world was watching.
00:12:18.748 --> 00:12:26.155
when the Nazi regime built its own sterilization and racial hygiene programs, it took the American law as a model.
00:12:26.155 --> 00:12:33.442
And at Nuremberg, where the architects of the Holocaust were tried, the defense cited Buck vs.
00:12:33.442 --> 00:12:34.104
Bell.
00:12:34.104 --> 00:12:39.336
The line from the lecture hall to the death camp is not a metaphor, it is a citation.
00:12:39.336 --> 00:12:43.600
it was not only the Germans that borrowed from the United States.
00:12:43.600 --> 00:12:54.967
The Nordic democracies, the very states the world now holds up as a gentle exception, ran sterilization programs of their own deep into the twentieth century.
00:12:54.967 --> 00:13:19.815
Sweden founded the world's first state institute for racial biology at Uppsala in 1922 and between 1937 and 1976 sterilized some 60,000 people, the majority of them women, many with no real say in it for being poor or judged as feeble-minded or of the wrong blood.
00:13:19.899 --> 00:13:28.000
with the Romani and the travelers among its chosen targets, while its race scientists measured and catalogued the Sami.
00:13:28.565 --> 00:13:41.384
The point is not that one country was uniquely guilty, it is that the hierarchy wore a lab coat across the whole of the West, including the corners that now believed themselves constitutionally incapable of it.
00:13:41.384 --> 00:13:43.676
And then there is the body as labs.
00:13:43.676 --> 00:13:49.370
If a people were a lower order of human, their bodies could be used.
00:13:49.370 --> 00:13:50.322
And they were.
00:13:50.322 --> 00:14:12.022
In the 1840s, an American physician named James Marion Sims, Remembered for a century as the father of modern gynecology, developed his surgical technique by operating on enslaved Black women, at least ten of them, whose names survived in only three cases Anarcha, Betsy, and Lucy.
00:14:12.022 --> 00:14:24.135
He operated without anesthesia and on one of these women more than 30 times on the working assumption common in his profession that Black people did not feel pain as white people did.
00:14:24.135 --> 00:14:31.379
when he later treated white women in New York, he used the anesthesia the others had been denied.
00:14:31.379 --> 00:14:57.224
century after him, the same logic ran through the Tuskegee study, in which the United States Public Health Service tracked 600 poor Black men from 1932 to 1972, and they left about four hundred of them who had syphilis untreated and withheld the penicillin that could have cured them once it became available In order to observe the course of the disease.
00:14:57.224 --> 00:15:05.265
And in 1951, a Black woman named Henrietta Lacks went to Johns Hopkins with cervical cancer.
00:15:05.265 --> 00:15:14.143
And her cells were taken without her knowledge or consent and turned into the most widely used human cell line in the history of medicine.
00:15:14.143 --> 00:15:31.586
The foundation of a thousand discoveries and a fortune in value, none of which her family was told off for decades, and for which they were paid nothing until a single biotech company settled with them confidentially in 2023, seven decades on.
00:15:31.586 --> 00:15:35.428
These were not facts of a few cruel men working in secret.
00:15:35.428 --> 00:15:46.666
These were mainstream medicine conducted openly, published in the journals, taught to students, honored with statutes and presidencies of medical societies.
00:15:46.666 --> 00:15:59.405
The hierarchy that the lab had invented had become the permission slip And on the strength of it, the bodies of the people
ranked lowest were available for breeding control.
00:15:59.405 --> 00:16:02.988
for experiment and for use without consent.
00:16:02.988 --> 00:16:05.121
So now let's talk white terrorism.
00:16:05.121 --> 00:16:18.418
The definition I continue to repeat across most of the episodes in this series is basically looking at what white terrorism is, the systematic use of violence to control a population through fear.
00:16:18.418 --> 00:16:24.046
The apparatus that I just discussed basically qualifies much of that argument.
00:16:24.046 --> 00:16:27.260
The forced sterilization with violence.
00:16:27.260 --> 00:16:33.770
The experiments were violent, the withholding of a known cure was violence.
00:16:33.770 --> 00:16:46.131
All of it was systematic, sanctioned by states and courts and the leading institutions of medicine, and all of it fell by design on the population the hierarchy had chosen.
00:16:46.131 --> 00:16:56.480
And as with the church, the distinctive work of this machinery is not the violence it added, it is the particular kind of cover that it provided.
00:16:56.480 --> 00:17:06.303
And it is worth seeing it clearly for what it is, because it is the most murdered form and the most durable form the cover has ever taken.
00:17:06.303 --> 00:17:14.854
Religion justified the conquest by calling it holy, and that worked for as long as the world took holiness as the final word.
00:17:14.854 --> 00:17:25.679
Science justified it by calling it true, and that works still because the modern world has agreed to treat science as this thing that is not up for debate.
00:17:25.679 --> 00:17:30.779
To say a thing is the will of God is to make a claim that a non believer can refuse.
00:17:30.779 --> 00:17:45.576
To say a thing is a biological fact is to make a claim that sounds as though it stands outside all belief, above politics, above arguments, simply the way the world is arranged.
00:17:45.576 --> 00:17:51.403
That is also the most powerful alibi a system of domination has ever been handed.
00:17:51.403 --> 00:18:05.395
It does not ask you to have faith, it asks you to be reasonable, and it lets the people who run the hierarchy experience that cruelty, not as cruelty at all, but as the brave facing of hard facts.
00:18:05.395 --> 00:18:11.038
this is why the racism in this episode can be lived with and denied in the same breath.
00:18:11.038 --> 00:18:17.740
When the hierarchy wears the face of fact, then the person who points at it is not naming a crime.
00:18:17.740 --> 00:18:22.096
They are denying reality, being emotional, refusing the data.
00:18:22.096 --> 00:18:24.689
The denial is built into the design.
00:18:24.689 --> 00:18:36.932
Race was made to look like nature precisely so that the suffering it caused could always be explained as nature's doing and never our responsibility.
00:18:36.932 --> 00:18:39.663
Now let's look at what science did in other hands.
00:18:39.663 --> 00:18:45.659
And here, as I did in the previous episode, I also want to note that this is where the argument turns.
00:18:45.659 --> 00:18:55.548
Because if science were just about the servants of the hierarchy, this would be an episode that is full of despair, and it is not.
00:18:55.548 --> 00:19:00.781
The same instrument that built race is the instrument that disproved it.
00:19:00.781 --> 00:19:02.967
And this again is not a footnote.
00:19:02.967 --> 00:19:05.963
is the whole reason the honesty wall holds.
00:19:05.963 --> 00:19:18.414
The unbuilding took the better part of a century anthropologist Franz Boas and the students he trained set out to test the racial hierarchy by its own methods and found it empty.
00:19:18.414 --> 00:19:21.214
No fixed types, no stable rankings.
00:19:21.214 --> 00:19:26.564
The supposed racial traits shifting within a single generation of migration.
00:19:26.580 --> 00:19:48.742
In nineteen fifty, in the wreckage of where the hierarchy had led, a body of the world scientists assembled by UNESCO issued a formal statement declaring that race was not a biological fact but a social myth, and that the differences between human groups were trivial besides the vast inheritance they shared.
00:19:48.742 --> 00:19:57.652
And then at the turn of this century, the question was settled in one language the modern world cannot easily dismiss, the language of the gene.
00:19:57.652 --> 00:20:11.005
When the Human Genome Project finished reading the human script in 2003, it found that all human beings are more than 99.9% identical at the level of DNA.
00:20:11.005 --> 00:20:22.343
That there is no genetic marker that sorts us into races, and that there is more variation inside any so-called race than between one another.
00:20:22.343 --> 00:20:31.904
so basically the hierarchy that Morton built from skulls and Linnaeus from temperament had no foundation in the body at all.
00:20:31.904 --> 00:20:35.480
The thing had been measured to the bottom and there was nothing there.
00:20:35.480 --> 00:20:44.112
I want to name though, we must notice who did much of the unbuilding it was not only the heirs of the men who built the lie.
00:20:44.112 --> 00:21:02.738
It was the people Delai had ranked lowest, the Black physicians, the scientists who insisted on the humanity, the textbooks denied them, the scholars from the colonized world who turned the tools of the academy back on the academy's own myth.
00:21:02.738 --> 00:21:05.570
the method never belonged to the hierarchy.
00:21:05.570 --> 00:21:24.536
It only seemed to for as long as the hierarchy held the institution, handed to honest people, including the people it had been built against, the same science that manufactured race became the thing that could prove beyond the reach of denial that race was never real.
00:21:24.536 --> 00:21:30.000
This is essentially the difference between a method and what that method was used for.
00:21:30.000 --> 00:21:38.929
And it is why this chapter is not a counsel of despair and not whatever a careless
or hostile listener wants it to be.
00:21:38.929 --> 00:21:41.406
It is not an argument against science.
00:21:41.406 --> 00:21:44.078
so as usual, I want to talk about critiques and complicity.
00:21:44.078 --> 00:21:49.361
the attacks on this episode are more technical than say on the previous episode.
00:21:49.361 --> 00:21:54.923
So let me just jump in uh based on what I anticipate will come back at me.
00:21:54.923 --> 00:21:59.653
The first is that there clearly are genetic differences between population groups.
00:21:59.653 --> 00:22:02.455
So things like sickle cell exist.
00:22:02.455 --> 00:22:05.330
And some medicines work differently in different bodies.
00:22:05.330 --> 00:22:09.913
So race must be a biological reality, after all.
00:22:09.913 --> 00:22:14.097
I just want to name that this confuses two things that have to be kept apart.
00:22:14.097 --> 00:22:30.768
There is a real genetic variation across human populations, clustered by ancestry and geography, and it matters in medicine, But that variation does not map onto the handful of color-coded races the hierarchy invented.
00:22:30.768 --> 00:22:46.926
Sickle cell traces the history range of malaria, which is why it is found among Greeks and Arabs and Indians as well as West Africans, and is rare among Black populations of Southern Africa where malaria was rare.
00:22:46.926 --> 00:22:52.665
Ancestry is real and continuous and fantastically complex.
00:22:52.665 --> 00:23:00.249
Race is the crude five box grid that was laid over it to rank it and it is not factual.
00:23:00.249 --> 00:23:01.692
It is a fiction.
00:23:01.692 --> 00:23:08.907
the second argument is that race based medicine saves lives, that doctors must consider race to treat patients well.
00:23:08.907 --> 00:23:18.201
Sometimes race stands in for something real, an environment, an exposure, an ancestry, but it is a crude and dangerous proxy.
00:23:18.201 --> 00:23:21.778
And when it is built into the machinery, it kills.
00:23:21.778 --> 00:23:36.357
for years, a heart failure drug called BiDil was marketed specifically to Black Americans approved by the United States regulator in two thousand and five on thin evidence that it works differently by race.
00:23:36.357 --> 00:23:58.121
and for years, the standard kidney tests, the estimated glomerular filtration rate, silently rated Black patients' kidneys as healthier than they were on the basis of race alone, delaying their diagnosis and their place on the transplant list until in 2021 the race adjustment was finally stripped out.
00:23:58.121 --> 00:24:07.146
Race in medicine is most often not the signal, it is the noise the hierarchy left behind, mistaken for a finding.
00:24:07.146 --> 00:24:14.431
The third is that this position or this episode is anti science and the resentment of people who do not like what the data says.
00:24:14.431 --> 00:24:15.471
it is the reverse.
00:24:15.471 --> 00:24:26.960
Everything in the counterweight, the genome, the disproof of the hierarchy is science correcting science, which is the thing science is built to do and the thing the old authority would not.
00:24:26.960 --> 00:24:32.113
To insist that race is not biological is not to reject the evidence.
00:24:32.113 --> 00:24:34.309
It is to follow the evidence.
00:24:34.309 --> 00:24:42.607
The fourth, that this is all safely in the past, the skull measuring and the sterilization long behind us, it is not.
00:24:42.607 --> 00:24:57.732
Between 1996 and 2000, the government of Alberto Fujimori sterilized more than 270,000 women, overwhelmingly poor and indigenous and quechua speaking, many by coercion.
00:24:57.732 --> 00:25:03.308
Or deception in a campaign that a human rights court was still ruling in 2026.
00:25:03.308 --> 00:25:10.836
Nearly one hundred and fifty women were sterilized without proper consent in California's prisons between 2006 and 2010 ten.
00:25:12.769 --> 00:25:38.414
The false belief that Black people feel less pain was documented in white American medical students and residents in a study led by Kelly Hoffman at the University of Virginia and published in 2016 in which forty percent of first and second year students endorsed the notion that Black skin is thicker and the belief predicted how they choose to treat Black patients pain.
00:25:38.414 --> 00:25:42.444
And the newest machines have learned the oldest lies.
00:25:42.444 --> 00:25:51.327
The diagnostic algorithms and the language models now entering medicine reproducing the same racial assumptions they were trained on.
00:25:51.327 --> 00:25:55.073
The hierarchy is not a monument to walk past.
00:25:55.073 --> 00:25:58.146
It is still running through the wires.
00:25:58.146 --> 00:26:00.461
It is still organizing the present.
00:26:00.461 --> 00:26:04.666
Now I want to talk about the hierarchy of the fiction of race.
00:26:04.666 --> 00:26:11.926
Now this part is also mine because the hierarchy did not rank Black people somewhere in the middle.
00:26:11.926 --> 00:26:30.980
From Linnaeus's Caprice to Morton's smallest skulls to the intelligence theories that followed, the African was placed again and again at the bottom of the ladder of man, The furthest points from the European ideal and in the vilest version the nearest to the animal.
00:26:30.980 --> 00:26:35.125
That was not ancient cruelty of the system.
00:26:35.125 --> 00:26:47.932
For a long time it was the system's central purpose because the African at the bottom was the figure the whole hierarchy had been built to justify enslaving and then colonizing.
00:26:47.932 --> 00:26:56.728
I could spend this part of the episode refuting that ranking, but it has been refuted by the genome and by every honest measure since.
00:26:56.728 --> 00:27:00.381
And I'm not interested in asking the old courts to acquit us.
00:27:00.381 --> 00:27:05.325
What I want to do is to name a more subtle and harder reality.
00:27:05.325 --> 00:27:12.528
The deepest damage a hierarchy does is not
the contempt it pours on you from the outside.
00:27:12.528 --> 00:27:22.115
It is the moment its ranking gets inside, and you begin without noticing to measure yourself and your own people by it.
00:27:22.115 --> 00:27:26.337
It shows up as the colorism that prices the lighter skin.
00:27:26.337 --> 00:27:35.457
It is in the reflex that trusts the foreign experts over the local one, the imported solution over the homegrown.
00:27:35.457 --> 00:27:59.760
The credential from the old Metropole over the knowledge of the elders, Still waiting to be certified as fully capable by the civilization that invented the fiction of African and Black inferiority to excuse the robbery and theft of our bodies and our labor.
00:27:59.760 --> 00:28:02.383
I want to be clear what I'm not saying here.
00:28:02.383 --> 00:28:08.744
I'm not telling anyone not to take pride in their heritage or that every preference is a wound.
00:28:08.744 --> 00:28:22.096
I am pointing to something worth examining honestly as history and as self-knowledge, not as accusation, because a people that never asks how the ranking got inside will keep carrying it essentially for free.
00:28:22.096 --> 00:28:31.180
So, as usual, I will turn to the three questions that this series is built on using my own three clarities framework of identity, context, and power.
00:28:31.180 --> 00:28:35.114
I wanna turn that on to everyone this ladder was built to rank.
00:28:35.114 --> 00:28:36.733
The first is identity.
00:28:36.733 --> 00:28:38.536
You are not your place on their ladder.
00:28:38.536 --> 00:28:40.857
the ranking was never a discovery about you.
00:28:40.857 --> 00:28:46.231
And the science that built it has since been demolished by better science.
00:28:46.231 --> 00:28:51.576
Whatever you have been taught to feel about where you stand, it was manufactured.
00:28:51.576 --> 00:28:54.358
And you are entitled to set it down.
00:28:54.358 --> 00:28:55.740
The second is context.
00:28:55.740 --> 00:29:00.242
See the ladder for what it is and see how far inside it you have reached.
00:29:00.242 --> 00:29:05.987
Because the version that still does damage is rarely the one shouted from the outside anymore.
00:29:05.987 --> 00:29:12.872
It is the one we have been carrying for them, unpaid, the standard we still quietly hold ourselves to.
00:29:12.872 --> 00:29:16.771
You cannot refuse a measure you have not noticed you are using.
00:29:16.771 --> 00:29:18.262
And the third is power.
00:29:18.262 --> 00:29:22.378
authority to decide your worth was never theirs or anyone else's, really.
00:29:22.378 --> 00:29:26.144
And taking it back is not waiting for them to rank you higher.
00:29:26.144 --> 00:29:28.509
It is refusing the ladder itself.
00:29:28.509 --> 00:29:46.540
and the whole apparatus of ranking human beings and then building in your own institutions and your own mirrors a way of seeing yourself that owes your hierarchy nothing, a way that celebrates you for the magnificent being that you
are.
00:29:46.540 --> 00:29:53.471
So as I consider this episode a twin of the previous one to deal with the church, I also want to talk about what a reckoning would require.
00:29:53.471 --> 00:30:05.894
I think the reckoning here is different in shape from the church's because medicine, unlike the church, cannot disown his foundations without disowning the good it also does, and the good is real.
00:30:05.894 --> 00:30:10.718
The cures and the surgeries and the life saved every single day.
00:30:10.718 --> 00:30:15.642
So the task is not to tear medicine down, it is to get the hierarchy out of it.
00:30:15.642 --> 00:30:23.163
And that turns out to be slow and technical, unglamorous work, And it is also exactly why it must be done.
00:30:23.163 --> 00:30:24.794
Some of it has already begun.
00:30:24.794 --> 00:30:28.296
The race adjustments came out of the kidney test in 2021.
00:30:28.296 --> 00:30:33.148
Medical schools have started to teach the history in this chapter rather than bury it.
00:30:33.148 --> 00:30:40.363
The statute of Sims was taken down from Central Park in 2018 and moved to his grave.
00:30:40.363 --> 00:30:43.767
These are real and they are the easy part.
00:30:43.767 --> 00:30:46.529
The renaming and the removing and the regretting.
00:30:46.529 --> 00:30:49.231
The harder part is still mostly undone.
00:30:49.231 --> 00:30:54.215
And it has a measure, the one I talked about in the beginning.
00:30:54.215 --> 00:31:08.938
As long as a Black woman is more likely to die giving birth than the white woman beside her with the same income and the same, you know, profession and the same degree across the United States and across the United Kingdom and across the wealthy world.
00:31:08.938 --> 00:31:13.843
The reckoning is not finished because that gap is the hierarchy still doing its work.
00:31:13.843 --> 00:31:34.864
And it does that work in form of pain not believed, the symptom not taken seriously, the woman sent home still bleeding, The reckoning will be complete, not when the apologies are made and the statues are taken down, although that is very important work, but when that number and that gap closes.
00:31:34.864 --> 00:31:45.325
and there's also a guardrail on this reckoning, and I I want to state it plainly because the cost of being misunderstood because the internet likes to hear what it wants to hear is too high.
00:31:45.325 --> 00:31:51.191
The answer to a medicine that has harmed Black people is not for Black people to abandon medicine.
00:31:51.191 --> 00:31:58.645
First, I want to say that it is understandable that Black people distrust the medical system because it doesn't often take care of them.
00:31:58.645 --> 00:32:12.876
Now, that conclusion, however earned the distrust behind it, because it is earned, it often ends in untreated illnesses and preventable deaths in the unvaccinated child and the cancer found too late.
00:32:12.876 --> 00:32:16.429
And it hands the hierarchy, one more set.
00:32:16.429 --> 00:32:17.306
of bodies.
00:32:17.306 --> 00:32:24.898
Listen, the distrust is real and it is a rational response to an irrational situation and system.
00:32:24.898 --> 00:32:29.835
And the task it demands is not flight, but repair.
00:32:29.835 --> 00:32:33.269
A medicine that earns back the trust it's spent.
00:32:33.269 --> 00:32:35.411
The trust it's misused.
00:32:35.411 --> 00:32:39.713
By stripping out the race it never should have built in in the first place.
00:32:39.713 --> 00:32:45.648
By listening to the patient it was trained to doubt, and by closing the gap that proves.
00:32:45.648 --> 00:32:47.109
The work is not yet done.
00:32:47.109 --> 00:32:50.563
The reckoning is not to leave the hospital.
00:32:50.563 --> 00:32:56.883
It is to make the hospital safe for the people it was built to disbelieve.
00:32:56.883 --> 00:33:01.237
so in closing, I want to reiterate that race is not real.
00:33:01.237 --> 00:33:02.588
It is a fiction.
00:33:02.588 --> 00:33:14.628
And it has never been more important to say this so clearly, because basically everything I talk about in this episode depends on two facts at once that the world keeps trying to pull apart.
00:33:14.628 --> 00:33:16.839
Race has no foundation in biology.
00:33:16.839 --> 00:33:18.896
The genome closed that question.
00:33:18.896 --> 00:33:23.279
And yet, race is one of the most powerful forces to shape a human life.
00:33:23.279 --> 00:33:32.526
Because a fiction believed and enforced for 300 years built real prisons and real hospitals and real graves.
00:33:32.526 --> 00:33:34.067
The lie is not real.
00:33:34.067 --> 00:33:36.328
The damage, though, is very real.
00:33:36.328 --> 00:33:40.481
What made the lie so durable was the uniform it wore.
00:33:40.481 --> 00:33:44.935
The church taught the conquered that their place was the will of God.
00:33:44.935 --> 00:33:50.201
And when that authority faded, the lab taught them it was the law of nature.
00:33:50.201 --> 00:33:56.796
And that lie that was cultivated by science is still holding because we have been schooled to argue with priests.
00:33:56.796 --> 00:33:59.825
and to fall silent before scientists.
00:33:59.825 --> 00:34:03.958
But the lab coat was only ever a costume on an old hatred.
00:34:03.958 --> 00:34:10.414
The same ranking of human beings the cassock war before it dressed for a skeptical age.
00:34:10.414 --> 00:34:14.637
Strip the costume and the thing underneath it is not a finding.
00:34:14.637 --> 00:34:25.556
It is a decision made by people who profited from them to treat some lives as worthless and then to call that arithmetic the truth.
00:34:25.556 --> 00:34:32.902
The good news and one of the few things in this episode worth calling good is that the same instrument that built the lie took it apart.
00:34:32.902 --> 00:34:43.172
And it is available to anyone, including the people it was built to rank, to take it apart again and again wherever it is still standing.
00:34:43.172 --> 00:34:47.106
The hierarchy was measured all the way to the bottom and there was nothing there.
00:34:47.106 --> 00:34:50.829
There was never anything there because race is a fiction.
00:34:50.829 --> 00:35:02.503
There was only us, the one species, more alike than any of us were ever told, being sorted by people who already knew what they wanted the answer to be.
00:35:02.503 --> 00:35:03.775
This is where I leave this one.
00:35:03.775 --> 00:35:07.030
sit with it, reflect on it, argue with it.
00:35:07.030 --> 00:35:08.425
This is what it's for.
00:35:08.425 --> 00:35:13.393
am also learning a lot from the people who engage and comment and share their perspectives.
00:35:13.393 --> 00:35:24.030
If this is the kind of thinking you want more of, I write a newsletter called the Weekly Clarity, where I take an idea and essentially turn it on systems that we live inside.
00:35:24.952 --> 00:35:33.793
when I talk a lot about clarity, you know, for me clarity is not really about feeling comfortable, it's all about accountability and that radical sense of responsibility.
00:35:33.793 --> 00:35:38.686
you can subscribe at chisomudeze uh.com and also the show notes.
00:35:38.686 --> 00:35:48.362
If this episode gave you something, send it to one person who needs to hear it and share it broadly with people who you think might benefit from having a listen.
00:35:48.362 --> 00:35:51.914
And of course, follow overnight's wisdom wherever you get your podcast.
00:35:51.914 --> 00:35:54.317
So the next episode finds you.
00:35:54.317 --> 00:35:58.670
I am Chisom Udeze and thank you so much for being here.