TRASCRIZIONE 🔗
WEBVTT
1
00:00:03.680 --> 00:00:05.799
They are elected by you. I am elected by you.
2
00:00:05.919 --> 00:00:07.839
I am constrained as they.
3
00:00:07.679 --> 00:00:10.960
Are constrained by a system that our founders put in place.
4
00:00:11.119 --> 00:00:14.919
The founder separated power because they knew it was the
5
00:00:14.960 --> 00:00:17.199
best way to protect our citizens.
6
00:00:17.239 --> 00:00:21.480
They didn't want one person, one man, to have all
7
00:00:21.559 --> 00:00:23.000
the power like a king.
8
00:00:23.679 --> 00:00:26.920
We show by our work that breed people can govern themselves.
9
00:00:27.039 --> 00:00:31.239
You can't pay lip service to the Constitution without obeying it.
10
00:00:31.359 --> 00:00:34.119
Keep your eye on the ball. Structure is a structure
11
00:00:34.159 --> 00:00:35.240
is destiny.
12
00:00:34.799 --> 00:00:40.960
As this is necessary and proper. The podcast of the
13
00:00:40.960 --> 00:00:44.640
Federal Society's Article one initiative. All views expressed on this
14
00:00:44.719 --> 00:00:49.960
podcast do not necessarily reflect those of the Federal Society.
15
00:00:55.799 --> 00:00:58.920
Hello everyone, and welcome to the Federalist Society Virtual Event.
16
00:00:59.280 --> 00:01:01.560
My name is Harold and I'm an assistant director of
17
00:01:01.600 --> 00:01:05.239
Practice Groups with the Federalist Society. Today we're excited to
18
00:01:05.239 --> 00:01:08.920
host this fedstock forum called can the Federal Government.
19
00:01:08.560 --> 00:01:10.040
Ban at Home? Distilling?
20
00:01:10.760 --> 00:01:14.000
Speaking with us today, we have Thomas Berry, Michael Pepsen,
21
00:01:14.159 --> 00:01:18.120
and Professor Eric Siegel moderating the discussion. We have Ted
22
00:01:18.159 --> 00:01:21.000
Cooper Stein, who is an appellate counsel of Theater. Cooper
23
00:01:21.040 --> 00:01:24.519
Sein PLLC. If you'd like to learn more about today's
24
00:01:24.560 --> 00:01:27.359
moderator or speakers, their full bios can be viewed on
25
00:01:27.400 --> 00:01:31.159
our website fedsock dot org. Throughout the program, we may
26
00:01:31.200 --> 00:01:33.959
turn to the audience for questions. If you have a question,
27
00:01:34.040 --> 00:01:35.920
please enter it into the Q and A function at
28
00:01:35.920 --> 00:01:37.799
the bottom of your zoom window, and we will do
29
00:01:37.840 --> 00:01:41.040
our best answer as many as we can. Finally, I'll
30
00:01:41.079 --> 00:01:43.760
note that, as always, all expressions of opinion today are
31
00:01:43.760 --> 00:01:46.719
those of our guest speakers and not the Federalist Society.
32
00:01:47.519 --> 00:01:49.879
With that, Ted, thanks so much for joining us today,
33
00:01:49.879 --> 00:01:51.159
and I'll hand things over to you.
34
00:01:52.599 --> 00:01:56.519
Thank you, Edie. I will briefly introduce our speakers in
35
00:01:56.560 --> 00:01:59.719
the order that they've chosen amongst themselves to present today,
36
00:02:00.359 --> 00:02:04.120
and with that will then proceed. Our first speaker is
37
00:02:04.319 --> 00:02:09.879
Michael Pepsen, whose regulatory council Americans for Prosperity Foundation, which
38
00:02:09.919 --> 00:02:12.639
frequently files amicus briefs in the U. S. Supreme Court,
39
00:02:12.800 --> 00:02:16.439
US Courts of Appeals, and state Supreme Courts, as well
40
00:02:16.479 --> 00:02:21.319
as public comments in various federal and state regulatory proceedings.
41
00:02:22.719 --> 00:02:26.280
Mike assists AFPF with its efforts involving separation of powers,
42
00:02:26.319 --> 00:02:31.000
administrative process, criminal justice, reform, tech and innovation, and other issues.
43
00:02:31.400 --> 00:02:34.280
He is also Special Counsel for Administrative Law and Cause
44
00:02:34.319 --> 00:02:37.639
of Action Institute, where he's been involved in complex civil
45
00:02:38.240 --> 00:02:41.120
and criminal litigation in federal district and in appellate courts,
46
00:02:41.120 --> 00:02:44.879
and administrative litigation before federal agencies and a variety of
47
00:02:44.919 --> 00:02:49.719
matters including agency enforcement actions, statutory and constitutional challenges to
48
00:02:49.759 --> 00:02:54.080
federal regulations and agency decisions, and Section nineteen eighty three
49
00:02:54.159 --> 00:02:58.199
challenges to state's statutes. He received his LLLM from Columbia
50
00:02:58.280 --> 00:03:01.919
Law School, JD from the Catholic University of America Columbus
51
00:03:01.960 --> 00:03:05.560
School of Law, and BA from Loyal To College in Baltimore, Maryland.
52
00:03:06.400 --> 00:03:09.479
Our next speaker is Professor Eric Siegel, who is Ash
53
00:03:09.560 --> 00:03:12.840
Family Chair Professor of Law at Georgia State University College
54
00:03:12.840 --> 00:03:16.919
of Law. Eric Siegel graduated from Memory University Phi Beta
55
00:03:16.960 --> 00:03:20.599
Kappa and Summa cum laure and from Vanderbilt Law School,
56
00:03:20.800 --> 00:03:23.120
where he was the research editor for the Law Review
57
00:03:23.120 --> 00:03:25.560
and Member of the Order of the Coif. He coorked
58
00:03:25.560 --> 00:03:27.719
for the Chief Judge of Charles moy Junior for the
59
00:03:27.759 --> 00:03:30.639
Northern District of Georgia and Albert J. Henderson of the
60
00:03:30.639 --> 00:03:34.800
Eleventh Circuit Court of Appeals. After his clerkships, Siegal worked
61
00:03:34.840 --> 00:03:36.960
for Gibson, Dunn, and Krutcher in the US Department of
62
00:03:37.120 --> 00:03:40.360
Justice before joining the Georgia State Faculty in nineteen ninety one.
63
00:03:41.240 --> 00:03:45.319
Segals teaches federal Courts and Constitutional Law one in two.
64
00:03:45.840 --> 00:03:48.400
He is the author of the book's Originalism as Faith
65
00:03:48.759 --> 00:03:51.280
and Supreme Myths. While the Supreme Court is not a
66
00:03:51.319 --> 00:04:00.319
court and its justices are not judges. Review online
Load full transcript
the
67
00:04:00.439 --> 00:04:03.560
UCLA Law Review, The George Washington Law Review, the Washington
68
00:04:03.680 --> 00:04:07.599
University Law Review, the University of Pennsylvania Journal of Constitutional
69
00:04:07.680 --> 00:04:12.080
Law of the Northwestern University Law Review, Colloquy and Constitutional Commentary,
70
00:04:12.080 --> 00:04:15.560
among many others. Sigal's op eds and essays have appeared
71
00:04:15.599 --> 00:04:18.360
in The New York Times, The La Times, The Atlantic, Slate,
72
00:04:18.879 --> 00:04:21.959
Vox Salon, and The Daily Beast, among others. He has
73
00:04:22.000 --> 00:04:25.920
appeared on CNN, Fox News, the MSNBC, and France twenty
74
00:04:25.959 --> 00:04:29.639
four and all four of Atlanta's local television stations. He
75
00:04:29.680 --> 00:04:32.439
has also appeared on numerous local and national radio and
76
00:04:32.519 --> 00:04:37.319
news Our third speaker will be Thomas Berry, who is
77
00:04:37.360 --> 00:04:40.600
director of the Robert A. Levy Center for Constitutional Studies
78
00:04:40.600 --> 00:04:44.879
of the Cato Institute. He's also editor in chief of
79
00:04:44.879 --> 00:04:48.240
the CATO Supreme Court Review. Before joining CATO, he was
80
00:04:48.279 --> 00:04:51.240
an attorney at Pacific Legal Foundation and clerk for Judge E.
81
00:04:51.360 --> 00:04:53.959
Grady Jolly of the US Court of Appeals for the
82
00:04:53.959 --> 00:04:57.720
Fifth Circuit. His academic work has appeared in NYU Journal
83
00:04:57.759 --> 00:05:01.319
of Law and Liberty, Washington and Leelaw Review Online, and
84
00:05:01.399 --> 00:05:04.879
Federalist Society Review. His popular writing has appeared in The
85
00:05:04.920 --> 00:05:08.600
Wall Street Journal, National Law Journal, Investors Business Daily, National
86
00:05:08.600 --> 00:05:12.160
Review Online, and The Hill Online. Is testified before the
87
00:05:12.240 --> 00:05:14.639
US Senate, and his work has been cited by the
88
00:05:14.720 --> 00:05:17.920
US District Court for the District of Columbia. Barry holds
89
00:05:17.959 --> 00:05:20.000
a jd from Stanford Law School, where he was a
90
00:05:20.079 --> 00:05:22.879
senior editor on the Stanford Law and Policy Review and
91
00:05:22.920 --> 00:05:26.040
a Bradley Student Fellow in the Stanford Constitutional Law Center.
92
00:05:26.480 --> 00:05:28.800
He graduated with a BA in Liberal Arts from Saint
93
00:05:28.879 --> 00:05:32.240
John's College, Santa Fe. With that, I'll turn it over
94
00:05:32.279 --> 00:05:34.560
to Mike Pepsen to begin, and Mike, perhaps you might
95
00:05:34.600 --> 00:05:36.839
want to just briefly state the issues in the case
96
00:05:36.879 --> 00:05:38.800
and then go ahead with your.
97
00:05:38.680 --> 00:05:39.399
Comments on it.
98
00:05:39.959 --> 00:05:43.879
Absolutely. Edith, thank you very much for putting this together. Ted,
99
00:05:43.920 --> 00:05:46.800
Thank you very much for your kind introduction. Thank you
100
00:05:46.839 --> 00:05:49.399
to the Federalist Society for allowing me to participate for
101
00:05:49.439 --> 00:05:52.519
all that it does. In full disclosure, a FPF did
102
00:05:52.560 --> 00:05:55.920
file and amicus in support of plaintiffs at Polase in
103
00:05:55.959 --> 00:05:59.319
this case. All errors and a missions mine with that.
104
00:06:00.000 --> 00:06:02.600
Basic issue in this case is whether the federal government
105
00:06:02.720 --> 00:06:08.360
has the power to ban at home distilling for personal use.
106
00:06:09.399 --> 00:06:12.279
The statute of that statuteed issue was passed in eighteen
107
00:06:12.360 --> 00:06:14.439
sixty eight, so it's fairly old, but it's a you know,
108
00:06:14.439 --> 00:06:16.920
one hundred years plus distant from when you know the
109
00:06:16.959 --> 00:06:24.240
Constitution was ratified, and plaintiffs Pelice challenged it as exceeding
110
00:06:24.240 --> 00:06:29.160
the federal government's powers under both the Commerce Clause and
111
00:06:29.279 --> 00:06:32.399
the you know, taxing power, even as augmented by the
112
00:06:32.439 --> 00:06:36.399
Necessary and Proper Clause. The statuted issue notably has no
113
00:06:36.519 --> 00:06:40.240
jurisdictional hook reference to interstate commerce, nor does it reference
114
00:06:40.639 --> 00:06:45.480
revenue collection. The District Court found that this statute, which
115
00:06:45.560 --> 00:06:48.480
you know or the Commerce Clause, has been deemed by
116
00:06:48.519 --> 00:06:52.839
the Supreme Court to allow regulation of three categories as
117
00:06:52.839 --> 00:06:56.759
supplemented by Necessary and Proper Clause you know, the channels
118
00:06:56.759 --> 00:07:01.319
of commerce like highways in strip, mentalities like cars and
119
00:07:01.360 --> 00:07:04.600
people moving in commerce, and then more recently in the
120
00:07:04.600 --> 00:07:10.000
New Deal era, to also encompass activities that substantially effect
121
00:07:10.399 --> 00:07:15.000
interstate commerce, including those that do so under the aggregation principle,
122
00:07:15.000 --> 00:07:18.399
which I would submit is questionable, but and you know,
123
00:07:18.480 --> 00:07:21.720
under the tax but the court found that the statuted
124
00:07:21.759 --> 00:07:25.959
issue regulated neither of the channels more instrumentalities assumed it
125
00:07:26.040 --> 00:07:31.839
regulate it, you know, bring you know, regulated matters that
126
00:07:31.920 --> 00:07:36.439
in the aggregate affected interstate commerce, but nonetheless found that
127
00:07:36.480 --> 00:07:39.079
it exceeded federal authority because it was not part of
128
00:07:39.079 --> 00:07:42.759
a comprehensive scheme and nor was it reasonably related to
129
00:07:42.800 --> 00:07:46.439
that scheme. The court also found as to the taxing power,
130
00:07:46.879 --> 00:07:51.720
that even the fan itself was not at taxed because
131
00:07:51.759 --> 00:07:55.879
it was revenue
destroyed or it frustrated revenue raising since
132
00:07:55.920 --> 00:07:59.279
it was simply a ban, and nor could it be
133
00:07:59.399 --> 00:08:03.519
justified on or the necessary and proper clause because it
134
00:08:03.560 --> 00:08:09.680
was not plainly adapted to effectuating that enumerated power. The
135
00:08:09.759 --> 00:08:11.759
court you know, combined the p I motion with a
136
00:08:12.959 --> 00:08:16.480
you know, summary judgment, and the government has appealed on
137
00:08:16.560 --> 00:08:22.000
appeal the government does not challenge the Commerce clause ruling
138
00:08:22.079 --> 00:08:25.560
or appear to, and has now fallen back on the
139
00:08:25.639 --> 00:08:30.680
necessary argument that the at home distilled distilling ban is
140
00:08:32.360 --> 00:08:36.000
justified as a necessary improper because it's reasonably related to
141
00:08:36.519 --> 00:08:43.799
the collection of revenue, because at home distilling frustrates that.
142
00:08:45.279 --> 00:08:48.399
I think at a broader level, this case implicates important
143
00:08:48.440 --> 00:08:51.679
questions of federalism and the division of authority between the
144
00:08:51.679 --> 00:08:58.600
federal and state government, which as well as how one
145
00:08:58.639 --> 00:09:02.360
should interpret you know, how the Constitution's original public meanings
146
00:09:02.399 --> 00:09:06.440
should play into constitutional interpretation. As many would suggest that
147
00:09:07.200 --> 00:09:11.879
the courts modern Commerce Clause president, including as it relates
148
00:09:11.919 --> 00:09:16.320
to the Necessary and Proper Clause, has expanded beyond what
149
00:09:16.399 --> 00:09:21.600
was intended trade and transportation between states to encompass matters
150
00:09:21.600 --> 00:09:24.799
of traditional state concerns such as matters of health and
151
00:09:24.840 --> 00:09:28.840
safety and crime, which this at home band would reach.
152
00:09:29.080 --> 00:09:31.840
The same might hold true of the Necessary and Proper Clause,
153
00:09:32.279 --> 00:09:36.600
where the government has a very broad conception of it.
154
00:09:36.879 --> 00:09:40.919
Taking language from the United States v. Comstock to suggests
155
00:09:40.960 --> 00:09:45.279
that it's enough that there's a rational relationship, but there
156
00:09:45.320 --> 00:09:48.639
could be between the tax and the revenue raising feature,
157
00:09:48.679 --> 00:09:52.039
even if it's a kind of a ban, and it
158
00:09:52.279 --> 00:09:56.919
covers activity that occurs before a taxable product is created,
159
00:09:57.480 --> 00:10:02.639
and likewise perhaps as to the tack power. And with that,
160
00:10:02.720 --> 00:10:05.440
I'll turn it over to Professor Siegal.
161
00:10:07.159 --> 00:10:07.879
Thanks for having me.
162
00:10:07.919 --> 00:10:10.200
I'm always honored to be a guest in the Fellow
163
00:10:10.240 --> 00:10:14.360
Society house, especially given you know my politics in yours
164
00:10:14.360 --> 00:10:16.759
don't agree, but I'm really happy to be here. And
165
00:10:16.799 --> 00:10:19.679
this is a great panel. So this law was passed
166
00:10:19.720 --> 00:10:22.320
one hundred and fifty six years ago. How that could
167
00:10:22.320 --> 00:10:25.240
make it more susceptible to an original meaning attack is
168
00:10:25.279 --> 00:10:26.320
beyond my comprehension.
169
00:10:27.440 --> 00:10:28.000
So listen.
170
00:10:28.559 --> 00:10:30.960
If this were nineteen eighty two, when the Fellow Society
171
00:10:31.080 --> 00:10:33.159
was began, I would be the chairman of the Honor
172
00:10:33.200 --> 00:10:33.559
of Honor.
173
00:10:33.639 --> 00:10:36.080
You guys would would worship at my work.
174
00:10:36.480 --> 00:10:38.519
Because what I am here to say is this case
175
00:10:38.600 --> 00:10:41.320
does involve a very important issue the role of judges,
176
00:10:41.679 --> 00:10:43.919
and the nineteen eighty two Fellow Society would never have
177
00:10:43.960 --> 00:10:48.039
taken the side of challenging this law because the nineteen
178
00:10:48.039 --> 00:10:51.440
eighty two Federal Society wanted judges to be constrained, and
179
00:10:51.519 --> 00:10:54.360
so do I. I think roll versus weight was incorrectly decided,
180
00:10:54.559 --> 00:10:56.759
even though I am pro choice all the way down.
181
00:10:56.879 --> 00:11:01.080
So on what possible basis could this lobby struck down
182
00:11:01.159 --> 00:11:03.879
under the Commerce Clause? I agree that it is at
183
00:11:03.879 --> 00:11:10.080
the outer perimeter of Congress's authority. However, Justice Marshall describes
184
00:11:10.120 --> 00:11:13.840
the Commerce power in eighteen twenty four in great breath and.
185
00:11:13.720 --> 00:11:16.159
With he was there, he lived it, he knew.
186
00:11:16.840 --> 00:11:19.600
We can talk about living constitutionalism if you want, and
187
00:11:19.679 --> 00:11:22.879
Cato's desire to deregulate America, that we can talk about.
188
00:11:23.000 --> 00:11:27.200
But that's Cato's desire. Chief Justice John Marshall's desire was
189
00:11:27.240 --> 00:11:31.600
to keep judges out of economic decisions. There's no possible way.
190
00:11:31.840 --> 00:11:35.279
The original meaning of the Commerce Clause does not justify
191
00:11:35.360 --> 00:11:38.919
this law. Now living constitutionalism might, and if everyone thinks
192
00:11:38.960 --> 00:11:41.200
the Commerce Clause has gotten out of whack because now
193
00:11:41.200 --> 00:11:44.639
we have an interconnected international economy, whereas in seventeen ninety
194
00:11:44.639 --> 00:11:47.720
one we didn't. If you think that that's fine, just admit,
195
00:11:48.080 --> 00:11:51.679
just admit that you're living constitutionalists, admit to your policy makers,
196
00:11:51.720 --> 00:11:54.799
and admit that you want judges the second guest Congress's decisions.
197
00:11:54.799 --> 00:11:57.799
That's all fine. But
there's no text, there's no history,
198
00:11:57.840 --> 00:12:00.600
there's no precedent. To support striking this down. And what
199
00:12:00.639 --> 00:12:03.840
I find fascinating is this absence of a jurisdictional hook.
200
00:12:03.919 --> 00:12:06.399
So everyone knows about the Lopez case. Can't carry a
201
00:12:06.440 --> 00:12:10.000
gun around school struck down. However, Congress amended the law
202
00:12:10.039 --> 00:12:12.080
to say you can't carry a gun around school. That
203
00:12:12.200 --> 00:12:15.200
moved in commerce. Three circuit courts upheld it, Supreme Court,
204
00:12:15.200 --> 00:12:18.960
and I cert in eighteen. Whatever this law was passed,
205
00:12:19.039 --> 00:12:21.720
there was no need to pass a jurisdictional hook. Lopez
206
00:12:21.720 --> 00:12:24.240
wouldn't be decided for a century. So, of course there's
207
00:12:24.240 --> 00:12:27.639
no jurisdictional hook in a statue one hundred and fifty
208
00:12:27.679 --> 00:12:29.799
six years old. But the fact that the statute was
209
00:12:29.840 --> 00:12:32.080
passed one hundred and fifty six years ago should give
210
00:12:32.120 --> 00:12:35.480
original meaning people some pause. You're saying you know more
211
00:12:35.519 --> 00:12:38.440
about the original meaning of the Constitution than the Congress
212
00:12:38.559 --> 00:12:40.559
from one hundred and fifty six years ago, and from
213
00:12:40.639 --> 00:12:43.759
Chief Justice John Marshall. Neither of those two statements are credit.
214
00:12:44.159 --> 00:12:46.879
The reality is this, Over the last thirty five years,
215
00:12:47.120 --> 00:12:50.039
Cato and Heritage and Furlow Society has done a great
216
00:12:50.120 --> 00:12:53.600
job of pretending that the New Deal was a watershed
217
00:12:53.639 --> 00:12:55.799
moment in American history where all of a sudden, the
218
00:12:55.840 --> 00:12:57.440
federal government became really big.
219
00:12:57.639 --> 00:12:58.360
Not true.
220
00:12:58.600 --> 00:13:01.159
The first Congress gave George wahteen a million dollars and
221
00:13:01.200 --> 00:13:04.240
se spend it anywhere you want. The first Congress authorized
222
00:13:04.320 --> 00:13:07.039
tax people to go into the states from the federal government.
223
00:13:07.519 --> 00:13:11.320
There's always been delegation, there's always been broad regulations of commerce.
224
00:13:11.559 --> 00:13:13.399
So my only point is this, If you want to
225
00:13:13.440 --> 00:13:15.000
be an originalist, this case is easy.
226
00:13:15.000 --> 00:13:15.960
The law should be upheld.
227
00:13:16.120 --> 00:13:19.080
If you want to be a living constitutionalist, that's fine.
228
00:13:19.159 --> 00:13:21.480
You can make your policy arguments and say Congress shouldn't
229
00:13:21.480 --> 00:13:24.360
be doing this kind of thing. If one believes in
230
00:13:24.399 --> 00:13:26.519
my last sentence is this, if one believes in the
231
00:13:26.559 --> 00:13:30.159
Federal Society's
pledge that judges should make the law, not
232
00:13:30.799 --> 00:13:33.159
should find the law, not make the law, which of
233
00:13:33.159 --> 00:13:35.879
course is a bunch of course hockey. But if one
234
00:13:35.879 --> 00:13:40.360
believes in that, then there are fifteen different ways at
235
00:13:40.360 --> 00:13:43.600
home stills affect the commerce of more states than one,
236
00:13:43.799 --> 00:13:45.759
which is exactly exactly what.
237
00:13:45.759 --> 00:13:47.639
John Marshall said in eighteen nineteen.
238
00:13:48.000 --> 00:13:50.440
So I'm glad everybody here who wants to strike this
239
00:13:50.519 --> 00:13:53.120
down thinks they know more about the original commerce Clause
240
00:13:53.240 --> 00:13:55.039
than the Chief Justice of the United States writing in
241
00:13:55.039 --> 00:13:57.679
eighteen nineteen. But I don't agree with that. I don't
242
00:13:57.720 --> 00:13:59.840
like this law. I think it's probably a stupid law.
243
00:14:00.080 --> 00:14:04.360
I agree with Justice Black and Griswold. I wouldn't vote
244
00:14:04.360 --> 00:14:07.960
for this law. It's an uncommonly silly law. But if
245
00:14:08.000 --> 00:14:10.440
you give judges the power to strike down this law,
246
00:14:10.639 --> 00:14:13.559
you're giving judges a tremendous amount of power, something I
247
00:14:13.639 --> 00:14:17.039
always thought the Federalist Society was against, but not over
248
00:14:17.080 --> 00:14:17.919
the last one.
249
00:14:18.120 --> 00:14:18.919
Thank you very much.
250
00:14:23.240 --> 00:14:27.120
All right, then, I guess it's time for Tom Berry.
251
00:14:28.320 --> 00:14:30.120
All right, Well, thanks so much for having me. It's
252
00:14:30.120 --> 00:14:33.080
always an honor to speak on a federal society. Webinar
253
00:14:33.360 --> 00:14:35.960
and I actually completely agree with one aspect of Professor
254
00:14:36.000 --> 00:14:39.200
Siegel's history of FEDSOC, which is, yes, if this case
255
00:14:39.200 --> 00:14:42.000
where forty years ago, most FEDSOC members probably would be
256
00:14:42.360 --> 00:14:45.360
against judges striking down laws. It's an important and I
257
00:14:45.399 --> 00:14:48.120
think the big shift in what you might call the
258
00:14:48.159 --> 00:14:52.279
conservative libertarian legal movement from what might be called judicial
259
00:14:52.279 --> 00:14:55.440
constraint to what I prefer to call judicial engagement but
260
00:14:55.480 --> 00:14:58.840
others might call judicial activism. That's a fair debate to have,
261
00:14:59.240 --> 00:15:01.679
and I think it's a very good thing. That sort
262
00:15:01.720 --> 00:15:05.200
of what started with those on the right just being reactive,
263
00:15:05.240 --> 00:15:08.639
were reactionary against the war in court and thinking, oh,
264
00:15:08.759 --> 00:15:11.519
I don't like their decisions striking down laws, so therefore
265
00:15:11.840 --> 00:15:14.120
in general, I'm going to have a posture of extreme
266
00:15:14.159 --> 00:15:17.720
skepticism to judges striking down laws. Has now shifted to
267
00:15:17.759 --> 00:15:20.679
a point where, in my view, you should not have
268
00:15:20.720 --> 00:15:22.799
a thumb on the scale in either direction. You should
269
00:15:22.840 --> 00:15:29.320
neither have deference towards statutory law or towards judges striking
270
00:15:29.320 --> 00:15:32.279
down the law. You should simply engage with the constitutional
271
00:15:32.279 --> 00:15:34.600
text and call it as you see it. And my
272
00:15:34.639 --> 00:15:37.360
colleague Clark Neely coined the term judicial engagement for that,
273
00:15:37.440 --> 00:15:40.080
and I think that's the preferred approach. And we've seen
274
00:15:40.159 --> 00:15:43.000
in the last twenty or so years kind of a
275
00:15:43.000 --> 00:15:48.399
renaissance of libertarian and conservative legal theorizing about the original
276
00:15:48.399 --> 00:15:51.240
meaning and limits of the Constitution and making the case
277
00:15:51.320 --> 00:15:54.000
that if a judge finds some good faith that a
278
00:15:54.080 --> 00:15:57.320
law is incompatible with the Constitution, they shouldn't have any
279
00:15:57.480 --> 00:16:00.879
hesitancy in striking it down. Turning to this particular law,
280
00:16:01.399 --> 00:16:04.720
the majority of Professor Siegel's remarks were about the commerce
281
00:16:04.720 --> 00:16:07.200
clause and when I started working on this case, I
282
00:16:07.279 --> 00:16:08.720
sort of assumed as well, it was going to be
283
00:16:08.759 --> 00:16:10.759
a commerce clause case. That was what a lot of
284
00:16:10.759 --> 00:16:13.759
the debate was about at the district court level. So
285
00:16:14.000 --> 00:16:17.759
it's an interesting first question of strategy by the government's
286
00:16:17.799 --> 00:16:20.279
part because now on appeal at the Fifth Circuit, the
287
00:16:20.320 --> 00:16:24.120
government is pretty much dropping the commerce clause aspect of
288
00:16:24.159 --> 00:16:27.600
the case and is focusing entirely on the taxing power.
289
00:16:27.960 --> 00:16:30.279
And I don't know whether just as a strategic matter,
290
00:16:30.360 --> 00:16:32.600
they're concerned that this could go up to the Supreme
291
00:16:32.600 --> 00:16:37.159
Court and we could get a presidential decision that moves
292
00:16:37.240 --> 00:16:39.879
commerce clause jurisprudence in a way that's more restrictive of
293
00:16:39.919 --> 00:16:43.240
federal power. It's a really interesting question. But the case
294
00:16:43.279 --> 00:16:46.360
as presented now by the parties, but the case presented
295
00:16:46.919 --> 00:16:50.600
by their arguments, focuses solely on is this law justified
296
00:16:50.639 --> 00:16:53.360
by the taxing power? And if we focus on that issue,
297
00:16:53.399 --> 00:16:57.320
I think the government's argument is pretty implausible and I
298
00:16:57.360 --> 00:17:02.279
would say pretextual,
because essentially their argument is if you
299
00:17:02.360 --> 00:17:07.119
make we have a tax on producing liquor, everyone who
300
00:17:07.119 --> 00:17:09.599
produces it needs to pay the tax. If you produce
301
00:17:09.599 --> 00:17:11.720
it at home, it's a lot more likely you could
302
00:17:11.720 --> 00:17:14.160
evade the tax It's hard. How is the inspector going
303
00:17:14.200 --> 00:17:17.160
to know what you're producing at home? Okay, fair point,
304
00:17:17.480 --> 00:17:20.519
But does that allow the federal government to then say
305
00:17:20.880 --> 00:17:23.880
that it's a necessary and proper exercise of the taxing
306
00:17:23.920 --> 00:17:27.640
power to simply ban the activity entirely? In other words,
307
00:17:27.759 --> 00:17:30.799
if it's too hard to find the taxable activity, we
308
00:17:30.839 --> 00:17:34.039
can simply ban it because it would be too likely
309
00:17:34.079 --> 00:17:37.160
that the taxes would otherwise be evaded. And I think
310
00:17:37.160 --> 00:17:39.720
if you just think about the scope or the implications
311
00:17:39.720 --> 00:17:43.640
of that argument, it's pretty shocking. You could essentially imagine
312
00:17:43.680 --> 00:17:47.039
any type of activity that the federal government can legitimately
313
00:17:47.119 --> 00:17:49.920
tax and then say, Okay, we can now ban this
314
00:17:50.039 --> 00:17:53.720
activity if it's produced entirely within a home or entirely
315
00:17:53.759 --> 00:17:56.880
within what you might call a discrete sort of economy,
316
00:17:57.680 --> 00:17:59.440
where you don't need to put it out in the
317
00:17:59.519 --> 00:18:02.000
broader marktket place where it would be evident if you're
318
00:18:02.039 --> 00:18:06.319
committing tax evasion. So Cato Institute also filed in amikus
319
00:18:06.359 --> 00:18:10.839
brief also supporting the challengers to the law in this case,
320
00:18:11.519 --> 00:18:15.319
and we focused on the implausibility of this taxtual argument.
321
00:18:15.519 --> 00:18:20.160
We also focused specifically on rebutting the Supreme Court case
322
00:18:20.640 --> 00:18:25.359
that the government is relying on most heavily, and that
323
00:18:25.519 --> 00:18:28.839
was a case called Fells Fells and held. And that
324
00:18:28.920 --> 00:18:33.319
was a case about producing tobacco pouches. And essentially, some
325
00:18:33.680 --> 00:18:37.039
companies had been putting prizes in the tobacco pouches, but
326
00:18:37.119 --> 00:18:40.000
that was affecting the weight. So there's a tax. You
327
00:18:40.079 --> 00:18:43.359
taxed the tobacco pouches based on weighing them, presuming that
328
00:18:43.400 --> 00:18:45.599
the weight told you how much tobacco was in it.
329
00:18:45.640 --> 00:18:47.440
But if they put a prize or a toy or
330
00:18:47.480 --> 00:18:50.799
something else in there, it messed up the weighing aspect.
331
00:18:51.079 --> 00:18:53.720
And so the government said, we're simply going to ban
332
00:18:53.920 --> 00:18:57.200
putting these prizes or toys in the bags entirely. The
333
00:18:57.200 --> 00:18:59.480
Supreme Court upheld it, saying it would be too hard
334
00:19:00.200 --> 00:19:02.599
to determine how much tobacco is in it. So that's
335
00:19:02.640 --> 00:19:05.799
probably the government's best case, but it's important to stress
336
00:19:05.920 --> 00:19:09.160
that doesn't go nearly as far as this case would.
337
00:19:09.279 --> 00:19:12.160
That doesn't go nearly as far as completely banning the
338
00:19:12.200 --> 00:19:15.079
production of the good in a certain circumstance, a good
339
00:19:15.079 --> 00:19:19.039
that's otherwise legal. And I think to me, in this
340
00:19:19.119 --> 00:19:21.960
case there are kind of echoes of the major questions doctrine,
341
00:19:22.079 --> 00:19:24.319
and that you kind of have a statutory hook, or
342
00:19:24.319 --> 00:19:27.640
in this case, a constitutional hook, the taxing power that
343
00:19:27.799 --> 00:19:32.440
is being used not to in fact take in a tax,
344
00:19:32.759 --> 00:19:35.319
but to achieve some other policy goal. The actual policy
345
00:19:35.359 --> 00:19:39.160
goal is presenting preventing at home distillery, and the government,
346
00:19:39.279 --> 00:19:42.039
now that they have to justify or defend it, found
347
00:19:42.039 --> 00:19:44.200
the taxing power and has kind of built this legal
348
00:19:44.279 --> 00:19:46.680
argument around it. So I would say that a good
349
00:19:46.680 --> 00:19:49.920
faith reading of the Constitution doesn't allow shouldn't allow the
350
00:19:49.960 --> 00:19:52.279
government to pick and choose or sort of find something
351
00:19:52.279 --> 00:19:54.759
to hang its hook on. We should be skeptical just
352
00:19:54.839 --> 00:19:56.880
by the fact that the argument has shifted from the
353
00:19:56.920 --> 00:19:59.559
commerce clause to the taxing power. I think that should
354
00:19:59.559 --> 00:20:02.319
make a scale that the taxing power is a plausible hook,
355
00:20:02.640 --> 00:20:04.839
and I think we should be really concerned if that
356
00:20:04.960 --> 00:20:08.559
argument were accepted, what other activities within the privacy of
357
00:20:08.559 --> 00:20:11.000
one's home with the government suddenly be able to ban?
358
00:20:11.279 --> 00:20:12.160
And I'll stop there.
359
00:20:13.559 --> 00:20:15.640
Can I respond to one thing Tom said? Tommy said,
360
00:20:15.720 --> 00:20:16.200
just one thing.
361
00:20:19.880 --> 00:20:22.720
Sure, I was about gonna do a you know around
362
00:20:22.799 --> 00:20:26.400
Robin Agan. Let everybody respond I all read you volunteered.
363
00:20:26.920 --> 00:20:27.519
Thanks. Sorry.
364
00:20:27.720 --> 00:20:29.279
I just want to say when, because he said something
365
00:20:29.319 --> 00:20:32.640
really important, super important, thumbs on this what judges should
366
00:20:32.640 --> 00:20:35.880
do about putting thumbs on the scale. So I just
367
00:20:35.920 --> 00:20:38.680
hope tom recognizes that. Tommy recognizes that if you're saying,
368
00:20:39.039 --> 00:20:42.079
as Michael Rappaport and others say, that judges should look
369
00:20:42.079 --> 00:20:45.160
at a federal or state statute and say, fifty nine
370
00:20:45.200 --> 00:20:48.279
percent unconstitutional, therefore I'm going to strike it down or
371
00:20:48.279 --> 00:20:52.000
something like that, that's fine if you're living constitutionalists. To
372
00:20:52.039 --> 00:20:55.079
then degree the original meaning of judicial review. The original
373
00:20:55.079 --> 00:20:58.480
meaning of Article three was enunciated by Alexander Hamilton, the person,
374
00:20:58.559 --> 00:21:01.519
not the actor, and Fell number seventy eight when he
375
00:21:01.640 --> 00:21:04.359
said judges would only strike down laws when they are
376
00:21:04.640 --> 00:21:09.000
irreconcilable variance with the Constitution. That means a clear inconsistency,
377
00:21:09.279 --> 00:21:11.359
absolutely no way to harmonize the two.
378
00:21:11.519 --> 00:21:12.720
That was the Fellow.
379
00:21:12.480 --> 00:21:15.680
Society's motto in nineteen eighty two. I think that's how
380
00:21:15.680 --> 00:21:18.519
this country should be governed. Leaving aside the merits, judges
381
00:21:18.519 --> 00:21:21.799
showly strike down laws if it's really really clearly unconstitutional.
382
00:21:21.960 --> 00:21:25.599
So I'm curious if the panel thinks this law is
383
00:21:25.720 --> 00:21:30.799
clearly unconstitutional under that standard, or if not, are they
384
00:21:30.799 --> 00:21:33.519
willing to don the mantle living constitutionalists because you're not
385
00:21:33.519 --> 00:21:35.839
an originalists if you don't put every thumb on the
386
00:21:35.880 --> 00:21:37.440
scale of constitutionality.
387
00:21:41.200 --> 00:21:42.960
Since it was in response to me, I'll take a
388
00:21:42.960 --> 00:21:45.680
first crack at it, I guess I'd say, first, I'm
389
00:21:45.680 --> 00:21:49.839
not one hundred percent sure. You know, I would have
390
00:21:49.880 --> 00:21:53.519
to dig into interpretations of that particular quote by Hamilton.
391
00:21:53.720 --> 00:21:58.680
It seems to me, as my first reading of that
392
00:21:58.799 --> 00:22:01.200
is that it's describing what does the judge come to
393
00:22:01.240 --> 00:22:04.200
a conclusion about is it irreconcilable or not? And that
394
00:22:04.559 --> 00:22:08.240
maybe is different from how certain are you? In other words,
395
00:22:08.680 --> 00:22:12.079
you know, I would say, I guess there are two
396
00:22:12.079 --> 00:22:14.880
ways of thinking about judging. There's the uncertainty way of
397
00:22:14.880 --> 00:22:17.759
thinking about it, where a judge sort of admits I'm
398
00:22:17.759 --> 00:22:20.240
only fifty one forty nine, or there's a way of
399
00:22:20.240 --> 00:22:22.759
thinking about it where every judgment is simply based on
400
00:22:23.200
--> 00:22:25.119
you have to come to a conclusion, you have to
401
00:22:25.160 --> 00:22:27.480
reach something. You have to do your best and keep
402
00:22:27.519 --> 00:22:30.440
thinking about it until you hit the answer that you're
403
00:22:30.480 --> 00:22:32.559
going to hit that you think with, and then you
404
00:22:32.680 --> 00:22:34.480
just have to let the chips fall where they may
405
00:22:34.880 --> 00:22:37.200
based on that. So I think I tend to think
406
00:22:37.240 --> 00:22:40.440
of the judicial role as more the latter, And even
407
00:22:40.480 --> 00:22:44.119
if it's fifty one forty nine, you end up getting
408
00:22:44.119 --> 00:22:46.680
to a point where fifty one is what you're going with,
409
00:22:46.799 --> 00:22:50.079
and then you ask, Okay, the interpretation I have is
410
00:22:50.119 --> 00:22:54.319
that incompatible with the Constitution. So I think Hamillon, the
411
00:22:54.440 --> 00:22:56.799
quote that was just read, which I'll have to go
412
00:22:57.160 --> 00:23:00.319
look up, I think could be compatible with that a coach,
413
00:23:00.440 --> 00:23:02.839
But I know PRINSI Siegel obviously disagrees.
414
00:23:03.079 --> 00:23:05.559
I mean, it's a whole history of twenty five people
415
00:23:05.599 --> 00:23:07.359
saying that. But that's okay, we can move on. It's
416
00:23:07.359 --> 00:23:09.480
not just Hamilton. They all thought that. Everyone who talked
417
00:23:09.480 --> 00:23:12.079
about it thought that every single person there's no person
418
00:23:12.119 --> 00:23:14.839
in seventeen ninety one who thought the judges would play
419
00:23:14.920 --> 00:23:18.039
anything other than a very limited role in constitutional law
420
00:23:18.200 --> 00:23:19.480
that you won't find a single voice.
421
00:23:20.359 --> 00:23:23.279
You're speaking basically of just limiting themselves to the present
422
00:23:23.279 --> 00:23:25.759
case and controversy in the parties before them.
423
00:23:26.359 --> 00:23:27.480
No, I'm no.
424
00:23:27.559 --> 00:23:29.720
What I'm saying is they talked about and thought about
425
00:23:29.720 --> 00:23:32.279
in the prisoner's cases, for example, what do we do
426
00:23:32.359 --> 00:23:34.799
when a state or federal law is inconsistent with either
427
00:23:34.799 --> 00:23:37.559
a state charter or the federal or constitution or some kind.
428
00:23:37.920 --> 00:23:39.759
And Randolph talked.
429
00:23:39.519 --> 00:23:41.359
About it, all the founding fathers talked about it, and
430
00:23:41.400 --> 00:23:44.880
what they said was this only works if judicial review
431
00:23:44.920 --> 00:23:48.920
is modest deferential. No way it's fifty one to forty nine.
432
00:23:48.960 --> 00:23:52.079
There is no interpretation of any historical source that suggests
433
00:23:52.079 --> 00:23:54.079
it's fifty one to forty nine. It was supposed to
434
00:23:54.079 --> 00:23:56.599
be modest and limited, and that's what the Fellow Society
435
00:23:56.640 --> 00:23:57.759
said in nineteen eighty two.
436
00:23:58.839 --> 00:24:00.640
Well, let me turn down to Michael PEPs and then
437
00:24:00.799 --> 00:24:05.160
let him either respond to these specific uh comments in
438
00:24:05.200 --> 00:24:08.000
this threat or anything more generally that the other two
439
00:24:08.079 --> 00:24:10.319
speakers have us said that he liked address.
440
00:24:10.799 --> 00:24:15.839
I suppose just a couple quick quick reactions. One, some
441
00:24:15.920 --> 00:24:19.960
might say, maybe it is the you know, the judges
442
00:24:20.079 --> 00:24:22.440
or justices role to you know, say what the law is.
443
00:24:22.440 --> 00:24:26.640
But as constrained by the concrete cases and controversies and precedent,
444
00:24:26.720 --> 00:24:30.640
where perhaps for in this instances, as the District Court
445
00:24:30.720 --> 00:24:35.839
did and can, confined relief to the actual parties sort
446
00:24:35.880 --> 00:24:41.319
of applied binding precedent, but also cognizant of the you know, background,
447
00:24:41.440 --> 00:24:45.200
original public meaning of the Constitution. And another couple just
448
00:24:45.480 --> 00:24:48.720
very quick notes. A I would submit it's important if
449
00:24:48.759 --> 00:24:52.559
we're going to be serious about original public meaning or textualism,
450
00:24:52.839 --> 00:24:54.839
to not be fair weather about it. The same would
451
00:24:54.839 --> 00:24:58.000
hold true as as to federalism. And I suppose this
452
00:24:58.279 --> 00:25:02.440
loop back to my first thought just last term and
453
00:25:02.960 --> 00:25:05.279
the Supreme Court and loop for Bright said, you know,
454
00:25:05.359 --> 00:25:09.400
you might have ambiguous laws, but it's the judges job to,
455
00:25:09.720 --> 00:25:12.400
you know, find it has a single best meaning fixed
456
00:25:12.400 --> 00:25:14.920
at the time of enactment. And finally, I might, I
457
00:25:15.000 --> 00:25:17.839
might very briefly note as to the taxing power, there
458
00:25:17.880 --> 00:25:22.160
was actually a case United States be decided in I
459
00:25:22.160 --> 00:25:25.279
believe it was eighteen sixty nine where the Supreme Court
460
00:25:25.359 --> 00:25:30.440
found that a statute that banned combination of certain oils
461
00:25:30.480 --> 00:25:33.039
for sale. I don't know the whole background of that,
462
00:25:33.200 --> 00:25:37.000
because it allegedly increased the price of other oils that
463
00:25:37.039 --> 00:25:42.440
were more favored. It rejected the government's argument that that
464
00:25:42.720 --> 00:25:47.640
was sufficiently tied to the revenue raising function of the
465
00:25:47.680 --> 00:25:51.079
taxing power to pass constitutional musters. So I do wonder
466
00:25:51.119 --> 00:25:55.039
where it's And finally, you know, with that statute at issue.
467
00:25:55.079 --> 00:25:57.359
It's one hundred plus years out from the commerce clause
468
00:25:57.359 --> 00:25:59.359
I
would submit, so it's sort of yes, it's old,
469
00:25:59.799 --> 00:26:02.240
but I'm just tentatively wondering how much that matters.
470
00:26:02.279 --> 00:26:02.960
But thank you.
471
00:26:05.119 --> 00:26:08.079
Our alder to resume our original order, Professor Sigal, Is
472
00:26:08.079 --> 00:26:09.880
there anything further you'd like to say about the other
473
00:26:10.319 --> 00:26:14.319
two speakers before we move along?
474
00:26:14.640 --> 00:26:17.880
I agree with them that the tax arguments are troubling
475
00:26:17.920 --> 00:26:21.240
at best, and I wish we didn't have to use them.
476
00:26:21.559 --> 00:26:24.720
Why the federal government changed litigation strategy, I don't know.
477
00:26:25.759 --> 00:26:27.759
There could be all kinds of things behind that, having
478
00:26:27.799 --> 00:26:29.759
nothing to do with the merit as everyone knows, you know,
479
00:26:29.880 --> 00:26:32.400
that could be strategic for all kinds of reasons, having
480
00:26:32.400 --> 00:26:35.079
nothing to do with constitutional law. I would just say
481
00:26:37.440 --> 00:26:40.640
I think our country would be a better place. Clark,
482
00:26:40.640 --> 00:26:42.039
Nelly and I are really good friends. Clark and I
483
00:26:42.079 --> 00:26:44.720
have debated that ten times. We've broken bread together on
484
00:26:44.759 --> 00:26:48.079
many occasions. I think Clark does many great things in
485
00:26:48.119 --> 00:26:51.680
the space of qualified immunity and other places. Clark and
486
00:26:51.759 --> 00:26:54.519
I have debated originalism, but it always ends up with
487
00:26:54.559 --> 00:26:57.920
Clark admitting he hasn't really studied. I don't think Cato
488
00:26:58.000 --> 00:27:01.920
has really studied originals. I have, and I am telling
489
00:27:01.960 --> 00:27:05.039
you that judicial engagement. I've written three articles on this,
490
00:27:05.200 --> 00:27:07.799
two books. Judicial engagement might be a good thing or
491
00:27:07.880 --> 00:27:09.240
might be a bad thing. I'm not going to have
492
00:27:09.240 --> 00:27:12.720
the policy argument today, but as an original meaning thing,
493
00:27:12.799 --> 00:27:16.000
it is absurd. It is absolutely absurd. And everyone in
494
00:27:16.079 --> 00:27:18.279
nineteen eighty two knew that. Like Judge Bork knew that.
495
00:27:18.319 --> 00:27:20.799
Everybody knew that. So the one point I want to
496
00:27:20.839 --> 00:27:23.200
make is the only reason this case is really here
497
00:27:23.240 --> 00:27:26.720
today in a serious way is because Ronald Reagan and
498
00:27:26.759 --> 00:27:29.759
George Bush appointed twelve years of judges from nineteen eighty
499
00:27:29.799 --> 00:27:32.880
to nineteen ninety two. And then Randy Barnett, Keith Whittington,
500
00:27:33.119 --> 00:27:36.559
and Larry Solom wrote a bunch of articles that basically
501
00:27:36.680 --> 00:27:40.720
changed originalism from a theory of constraint and restraint to
502
00:27:40.799
--> 00:27:43.519
a theory of activism. Because Randy is above all else
503
00:27:43.559 --> 00:27:46.960
of libertarian, that's fine. And when I reviewed his book,
504
00:27:47.000 --> 00:27:48.640
I said, I have no issue with his vision.
505
00:27:48.759 --> 00:27:49.200
I don't know.
506
00:27:49.279 --> 00:27:51.359
I could be right, it could be wrong, but there's
507
00:27:51.400 --> 00:27:53.279
nothing call law about it. So I just want to
508
00:27:53.279 --> 00:27:57.319
say again, if you believe in originalism in any way,
509
00:27:57.359 --> 00:28:00.480
shape or form. Then these laws don't get struck They
510
00:28:00.519 --> 00:28:03.680
can only get struck down under a living constitutionalist.
511
00:28:03.000 --> 00:28:04.599
Approach, which might be the best one.
512
00:28:04.599 --> 00:28:07.559
I'm not in other words, but I am on record
513
00:28:07.559 --> 00:28:10.359
as a deferentialist. I amazon record as saying you have
514
00:28:10.400 --> 00:28:12.759
to be absolutely certain, and Tom, Tommy, the last thing
515
00:28:12.759 --> 00:28:15.960
I would say is this the fifty one. It may
516
00:28:16.000 --> 00:28:18.440
be that if you're fifty one to forty nine percent
517
00:28:18.440 --> 00:28:22.000
sure there's an ericconcilable variance, that's fine. But the key
518
00:28:22.039 --> 00:28:25.880
there is irreconcilable variance. Is there any way to reckon
519
00:28:26.039 --> 00:28:28.240
and justice? Roberts has in the past paid lip service
520
00:28:28.279 --> 00:28:30.599
to this too, only lip service, but he's paid lip
521
00:28:30.599 --> 00:28:32.799
service to it. If a judge can find a way
522
00:28:32.799 --> 00:28:35.720
to reconcile a statue with the Constitution, she is supposed
523
00:28:35.720 --> 00:28:38.160
to and that's the original meaning of the judicial review.
524
00:28:38.440 --> 00:28:40.920
And that's not debated. It's just not fairly debateable. So
525
00:28:40.960 --> 00:28:42.400
if you want to change that, that's fine.
526
00:28:42.519 --> 00:28:43.359
I'm not an originalists.
527
00:28:43.599 --> 00:28:46.440
Just say it's better to have judges playing these active roles,
528
00:28:46.480 --> 00:28:49.759
and that's fine. Just don't pretend it's originalists, because it's not.
529
00:28:52.720 --> 00:28:54.559
Hey, Tom, you're a third in the order what else
530
00:28:54.559 --> 00:28:56.480
would you like to respond to or talk further.
531
00:28:56.279 --> 00:28:59.799
About just one point? And this is you know, I
532
00:28:59.839 --> 00:29:03.079
know no no one on this panel's views are going
533
00:29:03.119 --> 00:29:04.920
to be changed. So even though I'm responding to Eric,
534
00:29:04.960 --> 00:29:08.000
I'm really more making points for interested viewers if they
535
00:29:08.039 --> 00:29:10.279
want to follow this debate, which I think is the
536
00:29:10.359 --> 00:29:12.839
debate of modern constitutional law. So it's great that we're
537
00:29:12.880 --> 00:29:15.960
maybe introducing viewers to it. If they want to really
538
00:29:15.960 --> 00:29:18.920
dig deep into some of the debates around originalism, I'd
539
00:29:19.000 --> 00:29:22.480
encourage them to dig into what Randy Barnett and others
540
00:29:22.480 --> 00:29:25.279
have called, and Larry Solom have called the distinction between
541
00:29:25.839 --> 00:29:29.000
the original meaning and then the construction zone or application
542
00:29:29.279 --> 00:29:33.079
of original text or original meaning, and the notion that
543
00:29:33.240 --> 00:29:36.759
we are bound by the text itself, the original public
544
00:29:36.759 --> 00:29:39.359
meaning of text, but we're not necessarily bound by the
545
00:29:39.359 --> 00:29:43.000
original application or the original beliefs about how that text
546
00:29:43.000 --> 00:29:46.079
would be applied. So, to give one classic example that's
547
00:29:46.079 --> 00:29:49.519
often used for school segregation, brown versus Board of Education.
548
00:29:49.960 --> 00:29:53.759
Equality had a fixed definite meaning in the Equal Protection
549
00:29:53.880 --> 00:29:56.720
Clause in the eighteen sixties, But if people at the
550
00:29:56.759 --> 00:29:59.759
time had the false belief that racial segregation in schools
551
00:29:59.799 --> 00:30:04.160
would compatible with equality, we're not bound by that original understanding.
552
00:30:04.440 --> 00:30:08.880
That's kind of the distinction. So future knowledge, future growth,
553
00:30:10.319 --> 00:30:14.960
realizing that segregation is incompatible with equality, that can still
554
00:30:15.000 --> 00:30:19.000
be originalism. And so I would say that one avenue
555
00:30:19.039 --> 00:30:22.599
for people studying this to think about is we're certainly
556
00:30:22.640 --> 00:30:25.119
bound by the text of the Constitution, that we have
557
00:30:25.160 --> 00:30:30.319
a judiciary the supremacy clause. But what aspects even if
558
00:30:30.400 --> 00:30:33.279
we I sort of spot eric some notions that some
559
00:30:33.359 --> 00:30:36.119
of the Founders had a more restrained vision of how
560
00:30:36.119 --> 00:30:39.119
often would judges strike things down? Are we bound by
561
00:30:39.160 --> 00:30:42.880
their original expected application of the constitutional text? And I
562
00:30:42.880 --> 00:30:46.440
would say that originalism can in fact be consistent with
563
00:30:47.160 --> 00:30:51.720
not agreeing with how particular Founding fathers thought the text
564
00:30:51.799 --> 00:30:53.799
would cash out or the text should be applied.
565
00:30:54.359 --> 00:30:56.400
Well, I have to respond, I'm sorry. I write entire
566
00:30:56.400 --> 00:30:57.079
book on that point.
567
00:30:57.119 --> 00:31:00.880
Basically, listen, if you say that we know what the
568
00:31:00.880 --> 00:31:04.319
expected application was of imprecise text, we know what it was,
569
00:31:04.599 --> 00:31:06.599
but we're going to discard it because facts and values
570
00:31:06.640 --> 00:31:09.640
have changed. Yes, that's exactly how con law is done
571
00:31:09.640 --> 00:31:11.960
in this country. It's exactly how the Roberts Court does it.
572
00:31:12.359 --> 00:31:14.240
But it's not originalism In any sense. We know what
573
00:31:14.279 --> 00:31:17.319
they expected and we're discarding it because values have changed
574
00:31:17.559 --> 00:31:20.279
in any case from seventeen ninety one text for eighteen
575
00:31:20.319 --> 00:31:23.079
sixty eight text, there's going to be changes in society
576
00:31:23.240 --> 00:31:26.799
that can justify this. Is how Steve Calibracey, the freaking
577
00:31:26.880 --> 00:31:29.920
co founder of the Fellow Society, said same sex marriage
578
00:31:29.920 --> 00:31:31.839
could be justified on an originalist basis.
579
00:31:32.039 --> 00:31:33.599
That's obscene, that's absurd.
580
00:31:33.680 --> 00:31:35.559
I mean, I for same sex marriage, but of course
581
00:31:35.599 --> 00:31:37.839
no one in eighteen sixty eight thought that. So what
582
00:31:37.920 --> 00:31:40.119
he said was, yeah, it stands for equality, and that's
583
00:31:40.119 --> 00:31:42.559
really undefinable, and we define it differently today.
584
00:31:42.720 --> 00:31:46.160
Yes, I agree, I agree. That's living constitutionalism.
585
00:31:46.319 --> 00:31:49.880
Originalism would say did they think about this issue and
586
00:31:49.960 --> 00:31:53.599
did they decide it? And Randy Barnett in ninet ninety
587
00:31:53.640 --> 00:31:56.519
four says, even if they did that we can ignore it.
588
00:31:56.880 --> 00:31:59.160
Why is Randy saying that in nineteen ninety four.
589
00:31:59.440 --> 00:32:02.440
Why is saying that because they just had twelve years
590
00:32:02.480 --> 00:32:04.480
of judges and now they get to control the power.
591
00:32:04.799 --> 00:32:08.160
Randy Barnett never says that in nineteen seventy nine or
592
00:32:08.200 --> 00:32:11.279
nineteen eighty three, there's not a chance because liberals controlled
593
00:32:11.279 --> 00:32:15.240
the judiciary, last point. When you say judges can discard
594
00:32:15.319 --> 00:32:19.079
non expected applications of imprecise text, you are saying they
595
00:32:19.119 --> 00:32:23.559
can be living constitutionalists, because there's no such thing as
596
00:32:23.599 --> 00:32:31.960
the fixed meaning of imprecise text. The word tall, pretty, smart, handsome, big, equal, exercise, establishment, unreasonable,
597
00:32:32.000 --> 00:32:35.519
and cruel don't have fixed meanings. They only have applications
598
00:32:35.559 --> 00:32:36.200
done lecturing.
599
00:32:36.240 --> 00:32:41.440
Sorry, Okay, I'd like to continue with a couple of
600
00:32:41.559 --> 00:32:46.799
questions for the panel. We've noted that the commerce clause
601
00:32:46.920 --> 00:32:49.720
was originally a pretty big part of the argument and
602
00:32:49.720 --> 00:32:51.279
that the government chose.
603
00:32:51.000 --> 00:32:51.559
To drop it.
604
00:32:52.319 --> 00:32:56.720
I understand there is a parallel case pending in one
605
00:32:56.720 --> 00:32:59.920
of the federal district courts in Ohio where it is
606
00:33:00.200 --> 00:33:03.279
still under consideration. Is anyone aware of that or if
607
00:33:03.319 --> 00:33:07.119
you had any opportunity to look at that, and you know,
608
00:33:07.240 --> 00:33:09.519
just add that to the mix for comparison's sake.
609
00:33:10.200 --> 00:33:12.680
Absolutely, and if if I, if I might the cases,
610
00:33:12.759 --> 00:33:18.519
I believe remby United States and the government did was
611
00:33:18.559 --> 00:33:22.279
defending on commerce clause grounds. But I believe last week
612
00:33:22.359 --> 00:33:25.519
the district court and in my view, I'm kind of
613
00:33:26.799 --> 00:33:28.880
skeptical or I'm sure that it will be appealed but
614
00:33:30.359 --> 00:33:34.240
dismissed it for lack of standing without reaching the commerce
615
00:33:34.240 --> 00:33:37.519
clause arguments. So now I would imagine it will go
616
00:33:37.519 --> 00:33:40.759
to the Sixth Circuit where some some of their cases,
617
00:33:40.799 --> 00:33:44.440
such as United States, be rife and take a fairly
618
00:33:45.559 --> 00:33:48.720
you know, absent binding precedent to the contrary the Constitution's
619
00:33:49.200 --> 00:33:51.240
original public meeting is law, and it will be very
620
00:33:51.960 --> 00:33:53.279
interesting to see how that plays out.
621
00:33:55.279 --> 00:33:58.920
What's fun I'm sorry, what's fun about that is everything
622
00:33:58.960 --> 00:34:00.000
about standing is awesome.
623
00:34:00.039 --> 00:34:03.079
Non originalists strangers to the court were allowed in England.
624
00:34:03.839 --> 00:34:07.039
What's his name? Sorry? Having seen the moment.
625
00:34:07.200 --> 00:34:09.639
The guy who wrote Government by raul Berger wrote nineteen
626
00:34:09.679 --> 00:34:12.559
sixty eight, the most famous academic originalist in history wrote
627
00:34:12.559 --> 00:34:16.079
in nineteen sixty eight that anything involving personal injuries is
628
00:34:16.079 --> 00:34:19.280
a made up, living constitutionalist thing that of course they
629
00:34:19.280 --> 00:34:22.800
can need and justice Harlan and Flash said personal injury
630
00:34:22.840 --> 00:34:25.920
is not a constitutional requirement. Some we should look at
631
00:34:25.960 --> 00:34:27.800
in our discretion. I just want to say, everything about
632
00:34:27.840 --> 00:34:30.239
standing is also not originals.
633
00:34:31.440 --> 00:34:31.599
Well.
634
00:34:31.639 --> 00:34:34.679
Standing is a pretty big part of the posture of
635
00:34:34.719 --> 00:34:37.719
the case. If you look to see that. It complicated
636
00:34:38.000 --> 00:34:42.000
in a lot of cross appeals and cross supplies because
637
00:34:42.360 --> 00:34:46.239
the plaintiffs were an aggregate number of individuals as well
638
00:34:46.280 --> 00:34:51.079
as an
associational plane of the district Court held there
639
00:34:51.199 --> 00:34:54.760
was standing for one plane of Scott McNutt dismissed the
640
00:34:54.800 --> 00:34:57.800
others for lack of standing, but then by Burt Virtue
641
00:34:57.920 --> 00:35:01.320
that one plane of found association no standing and so
642
00:35:01.400 --> 00:35:06.079
there've been cross appeals by those dismissed individual plaintiffs, and
643
00:35:06.119 --> 00:35:09.079
that came up in the briefing as well. Does anyone
644
00:35:09.079 --> 00:35:11.480
want to address that, and particularly I think it comes
645
00:35:11.559 --> 00:35:15.280
down to, in my view, the question of applied versus
646
00:35:15.280 --> 00:35:18.800
facial challenges and does that make any difference to what
647
00:35:19.119 --> 00:35:20.320
we've been discussing here today?
648
00:35:21.039 --> 00:35:21.719
Is withstanding?
649
00:35:21.760 --> 00:35:24.880
Does I wrote that in the La Times It's true
650
00:35:25.559 --> 00:35:27.039
if they want to reach the marriage, they will and
651
00:35:27.079 --> 00:35:27.960
if they won't, they won't.
652
00:35:28.360 --> 00:35:28.960
Does anyone in the.
653
00:35:28.920 --> 00:35:31.800
Panel disagree with that? That's true for all jurisdics. If
654
00:35:31.840 --> 00:35:33.239
they want to hear the case, they will.
655
00:35:33.360 --> 00:35:34.639
If they don't want to hear in the case, then
656
00:35:35.840 --> 00:35:37.320
I like Thomas, who wants to go.
657
00:35:37.320 --> 00:35:45.679
First, I'm thirty percent less cynical than Eric. I think
658
00:35:45.760 --> 00:35:49.599
I think thirty percent of the time they will rule
659
00:35:49.639 --> 00:35:51.559
on standing in the opposite way that they want to.
660
00:35:51.800 --> 00:35:54.119
If it's very if there's no way not to. But
661
00:35:54.159 --> 00:35:57.039
I won't deny that some motivated reasoning comes into play.
662
00:35:57.800 --> 00:36:00.000
In terms of this particular case. It seems to be
663
00:36:00.079 --> 00:36:03.239
kind of a fact bound question about did McNutt this
664
00:36:03.320 --> 00:36:05.679
one plane of who was found out standing? Was he
665
00:36:05.760 --> 00:36:09.119
in fact distilling in a prohibited space or was the
666
00:36:09.119 --> 00:36:11.440
shed he was distilling in separate enough from his house
667
00:36:11.480 --> 00:36:14.000
to be legal or does he have concrete enough plans
668
00:36:14.039 --> 00:36:17.559
to distill in his own house? It gets complicated. The
669
00:36:17.599 --> 00:36:20.880
broader point I'll make is that I think one of
670
00:36:20.960 --> 00:36:23.360
the frustrating things about standing is it puts a lot
671
00:36:23.360 --> 00:36:26.960
of individuals in impossible positions where the government says you
672
00:36:27.000 --> 00:36:29.440
need to violate the law or come extremely close to
673
00:36:29.519 --> 00:36:33.440
doing it, put yourself at risk of fines or criminal penalties.
674
00:36:33.719 --> 00:36:36.920
Then you'll have clear standing to challenge it up until
675
00:36:36.960 --> 00:36:38.880
you get to that line. You don't, and it kind
676
00:36:38.880 --> 00:36:41.960
of puts people in an impossible position. So I'm always
677
00:36:41.960 --> 00:36:45.320
frustrated when the government makes that kind of argument common ground.
678
00:36:45.519 --> 00:36:48.440
I agree, And if one was an originalist on standing,
679
00:36:48.440 --> 00:36:50.719
one would say all that needs to be or two
680
00:36:50.800 --> 00:36:55.519
adverse parties arguing about something real will something real happen
681
00:36:55.559 --> 00:36:58.159
in the world. If this case goes and all these
682
00:36:58.159 --> 00:37:01.920
two parties truly adverse, that is the original meaning of
683
00:37:02.079 --> 00:37:05.920
case for controversy and Articles three, but Justice Scalia basically
684
00:37:06.079 --> 00:37:06.920
took that meaning away.
685
00:37:08.039 --> 00:37:09.880
Michael, did you comment at this point?
686
00:37:10.519 --> 00:37:15.880
I would just submit I agree with what Tommy said
687
00:37:15.880 --> 00:37:19.000
as well, but I also would submit if the party
688
00:37:19.039 --> 00:37:22.440
has standing, the court should decide it as a normative
689
00:37:22.480 --> 00:37:25.400
matter and should not duck the barants, you know, regardless
690
00:37:25.400 --> 00:37:29.360
of whether it's the issue is controversial or regardless of
691
00:37:29.480 --> 00:37:31.039
you know his or her policy views.
692
00:37:31.679 --> 00:37:35.960
We agree common grim with regard to standing, and note
693
00:37:35.960 --> 00:37:37.800
that a lot of the precedents about whether or not
694
00:37:37.840 --> 00:37:40.320
you truly have been harmed or a threat of enforcement
695
00:37:41.159 --> 00:37:44.000
often arise out of the First Amendments free speech context.
696
00:37:44.079 --> 00:37:46.079
Do you think those are equally applicable if we're dealing
697
00:37:46.119 --> 00:37:49.039
with something more quibbling like taxes and whether you're in
698
00:37:49.039 --> 00:37:51.079
a shed or an attached dwelling house.
699
00:37:51.360 --> 00:37:52.360
Now that's interesting.
700
00:37:52.639 --> 00:37:55.960
Before two weeks ago, I would have said no, And
701
00:37:56.000 --> 00:37:58.519
now it changed my mind just in two weeks because that.
702
00:37:59.719 --> 00:38:02.559
So this is going to get serious. I'm sorry, And
703
00:38:02.639 --> 00:38:04.079
the last week I've talked so the rest of this
704
00:38:04.280 --> 00:38:06.840
is not serious. Well, this one's more serious.
705
00:38:07.719 --> 00:38:11.800
Bloomberg, CNN, and Georgia Public Radio all in the last week,
706
00:38:12.480 --> 00:38:14.360
and all three times I censured myself.
707
00:38:14.960 --> 00:38:15.280
I did.
708
00:38:15.880 --> 00:38:18.800
And I've never censored myself before thirty four years of
709
00:38:18.800 --> 00:38:22.280
being a controversial law professor.
I've never censured myself until
710
00:38:22.599 --> 00:38:25.159
the last few weeks. I now for the first time
711
00:38:25.199 --> 00:38:27.840
in mind I used I used to criticize the overbreath
712
00:38:28.280 --> 00:38:29.800
chilling effect doctrine of.
713
00:38:29.840 --> 00:38:32.000
Third party standing in free speech cases.
714
00:38:32.159 --> 00:38:34.760
I no longer do because I felt the chill and
715
00:38:34.800 --> 00:38:37.079
it is horrific to feel that hill.
716
00:38:38.199 --> 00:38:41.199
So does that necessarily extend beyond the speech context to
717
00:38:41.639 --> 00:38:46.079
these other issues such as taxation and distillery within your home?
718
00:38:48.119 --> 00:38:48.760
That's somebody else.
719
00:38:50.199 --> 00:38:53.199
I think it should. I don't think it does. Undercurrent doctrine,
720
00:38:53.559 --> 00:38:57.159
the Supreme Court has given free speech, probably probably free
721
00:38:57.159 --> 00:39:01.519
speech and equal protection. It's given the most wait to
722
00:39:01.840 --> 00:39:04.039
or however you want to put it, the most protection too,
723
00:39:04.639 --> 00:39:06.119
And in my view, it's made a lot of other
724
00:39:06.199 --> 00:39:08.800
constitutional rights kind of second class in a way that
725
00:39:08.840 --> 00:39:09.480
they shouldn't be.
726
00:39:09.880 --> 00:39:10.039
All.
727
00:39:10.079 --> 00:39:12.639
The logic of chilling effect applies just as well to
728
00:39:12.679 --> 00:39:16.360
any other freedom protected by the Constitution, but for a
729
00:39:16.400 --> 00:39:18.360
lot of reasons, I guess the simplest just being that
730
00:39:18.400 --> 00:39:21.239
it's so explicitly there in the Constitution freedom of speech.
731
00:39:21.880 --> 00:39:25.280
The Supreme Court has built up a much more robust
732
00:39:25.320 --> 00:39:29.559
doctrine of protecting people even before enforcement there than it
733
00:39:29.599 --> 00:39:36.320
has in pretty much any other realm. I can think of, Michael,
734
00:39:36.400 --> 00:39:36.880
your chance.
735
00:39:36.880 --> 00:39:38.679
If you want to weigh in on this, I would
736
00:39:38.719 --> 00:39:40.960
submit you shouldn't have to bet the farm or risk
737
00:39:41.079 --> 00:39:42.639
prison to get your day in court.
738
00:39:44.400 --> 00:39:46.760
But by the way, not only do all three of
739
00:39:46.840 --> 00:39:49.519
us feel that way, more importantly, the United States Congress
740
00:39:49.519 --> 00:39:52.039
feels that way, because that's the whole purpose of the
741
00:39:52.079 --> 00:39:55.800
nineteen thirty sixth the Territory Judgment. Congress specifically said, and
742
00:39:55.840 --> 00:39:58.639
it makes so much sense. We want people not to
743
00:39:58.719 --> 00:40:01.599
violate the law. People to be ready, willing and able
744
00:40:01.639 --> 00:40:03.840
to violate the law, but not do it until they
745
00:40:03.880 --> 00:40:07.440
get a court declaration saying they can. Of course, they
746
00:40:07.480 --> 00:40:10.280
can't change Article three. But if you take my originalist
747
00:40:10.320 --> 00:40:12.800
interpretation of Article three, which I think is the correct one,
748
00:40:12.840 --> 00:40:15.480
which is you need too adverse parties arguing over something real.
749
00:40:15.880 --> 00:40:18.320
That's what the nineteen thirty six Congress thought, and I
750
00:40:18.360 --> 00:40:21.960
think the Territory Judgment Act totally is a federal statement,
751
00:40:22.239 --> 00:40:26.119
very strong on this policy. File suit before you violate
752
00:40:26.159 --> 00:40:28.440
the law, and judges should be amenable to that as
753
00:40:28.480 --> 00:40:30.760
long as the planeiff. Obviously we A would agree on
754
00:40:30.760 --> 00:40:32.280
this too. You know, you have to be ready, willing
755
00:40:32.320 --> 00:40:34.760
and able to break the law. Right but assuming that's true,
756
00:40:34.920 --> 00:40:39.159
of course you hear the case. I love getting common grant.
757
00:40:41.480 --> 00:40:43.239
We have any other further comments so far, I'm going
758
00:40:43.320 --> 00:40:46.559
to turn soon now to picking and choosing exercising my
759
00:40:46.639 --> 00:40:49.920
prerogative from the viewers questions and the Q and A
760
00:40:50.000 --> 00:40:56.920
submitted questions. It's been a few minutes since this was posted,
761
00:40:56.960 --> 00:40:59.719
but one viewer asked, what is Professor Siegel's thoughts on
762
00:40:59.719 --> 00:41:02.760
the time expower argument the government made. Have you addressed
763
00:41:02.760 --> 00:41:03.239
that already?
764
00:41:03.760 --> 00:41:08.079
I'll just say Professor Siegel has not studied tax constitutional
765
00:41:08.119 --> 00:41:10.519
law enough to have what I would have a public
766
00:41:10.559 --> 00:41:13.480
opinion on that statement. I don't teach tax law, of course,
767
00:41:13.519 --> 00:41:16.400
I got into it with NFIB. I tend not to
768
00:41:16.480 --> 00:41:18.480
try to talk about things I'm not an expert about,
769
00:41:18.599 --> 00:41:21.719
but my instinct is it's very questionable as a taxing.
770
00:41:23.760 --> 00:41:26.719
Another interesting point raise is does the panelty this case
771
00:41:26.760 --> 00:41:31.360
as having any relationship to dormant Commerce Clause, challenges to
772
00:41:31.440 --> 00:41:34.760
state regulation of alcohol regulation or implications of the twenty
773
00:41:34.800 --> 00:41:35.440
first Amendment.
774
00:41:36.880 --> 00:41:38.960
Well, I was going to ask Kato about that. Why
775
00:41:39.000 --> 00:41:41.079
didn't you guys bring a twenty first Amendment challenge here?
776
00:41:42.599 --> 00:41:43.679
It's not our lawsuit.
777
00:41:44.960 --> 00:41:46.760
Well, I mean you an amateur speak, I mean you could,
778
00:41:46.800 --> 00:41:47.119
I mean.
779
00:41:47.000 --> 00:41:50.760
You know, interesting, interesting twenty four.
780
00:41:51.079 --> 00:41:53.960
Listen after
Dobbs. We know that the question presented thing
781
00:41:54.039 --> 00:41:56.039
is a myth. The Spreme Court will decide whatever it
782
00:41:56.079 --> 00:42:00.760
wants to decide, So any offshoot member Dobbs being overruled
783
00:42:00.800 --> 00:42:03.280
was absolutely not part of the question presented in that case.
784
00:42:03.400 --> 00:42:05.880
So anything that's fairly you know, raised. And I think
785
00:42:05.920 --> 00:42:09.079
the twenty first Amendment argument here is interesting. I'm wondering
786
00:42:09.079 --> 00:42:09.920
why it wasn't raged.
787
00:42:10.360 --> 00:42:12.280
We say more about what that argument would look like.
788
00:42:12.360 --> 00:42:14.400
But I think the state has the authority to regulate
789
00:42:14.440 --> 00:42:16.400
taxes in and out, I mean alcohol in and out
790
00:42:16.400 --> 00:42:16.639
of its.
791
00:42:16.599 --> 00:42:19.159
State, in its state. I know the dormant commerce clause
792
00:42:19.199 --> 00:42:20.400
case about this, but.
793
00:42:20.360 --> 00:42:23.039
This feels like an invasion of state prerogatives, especially because
794
00:42:23.079 --> 00:42:25.199
I think doesn't Texas law prohibit this already.
795
00:42:25.280 --> 00:42:25.599
Maybe.
796
00:42:27.360 --> 00:42:29.559
Yeah, I'm not an expert on that. I will say
797
00:42:29.599 --> 00:42:32.800
that this may shock you, but even though I would
798
00:42:32.920 --> 00:42:35.679
like the dormant commerce clause as a policy matter, I'm
799
00:42:35.679 --> 00:42:38.400
not convinced that it's that it's a thing as an
800
00:42:38.440 --> 00:42:41.760
originalist matter, and so I've been skeptical of making those arguments.
801
00:42:41.840 --> 00:42:44.679
CATO hasn't filed it a dorm pro dormant commerce clause,
802
00:42:44.679 --> 00:42:48.400
can't claim a Meekus brief in several years, and so similarly,
803
00:42:48.679 --> 00:42:51.000
I guess the question would be, should you interpret the
804
00:42:51.039 --> 00:42:55.199
twenty first Amendment to implicitly say there's no that it's
805
00:42:55.239 --> 00:42:58.119
only a state power. I don't have the exact text
806
00:42:58.119 --> 00:43:00.119
of it in front of me. It says it's the
807
00:43:00.119 --> 00:43:02.920
states can regulate alcohol. But should that implicitly mean the
808
00:43:02.960 --> 00:43:05.840
federal government doesn't get to regulate alcohol?
809
00:43:07.719 --> 00:43:11.079
Doesn't it go to the Essentially, strictly speaking, the Fifth
810
00:43:11.079 --> 00:43:14.199
Circuit is before the issue of just how far is
811
00:43:14.239 --> 00:43:17.079
too far with the exercise of the federal taxing power?
812
00:43:17.559 --> 00:43:20.239
So can we then invoke the twenty first Amendment, as
813
00:43:20.599 --> 00:43:23.159
coupled maybe with the Dent Amendment, to say this is
814
00:43:23.199 --> 00:43:26.360
an outer limit on what the taxing power can reach?
815
00:43:27.480 --> 00:43:29.239
I don't think that's frivolous. I mean, I don't know.
816
00:43:29.280 --> 00:43:31.119
I mean, the text of the level of of the
817
00:43:31.320 --> 00:43:34.920
amendments is the provision amendment repealing it is so bizarre
818
00:43:34.960 --> 00:43:40.920
and crazy and all that. My guess is, I don't know.
819
00:43:41.159 --> 00:43:43.280
I think that there must have been a strategic reason
820
00:43:43.320 --> 00:43:44.599
not to raise it. I don't know what it is.
821
00:43:44.800 --> 00:43:46.840
Maybe the dormant commerce clause case that rejected.
822
00:43:46.840 --> 00:43:49.280
It takes private.
823
00:43:50.559 --> 00:43:53.960
If viewers are interested. Eric's favorite law professor Randy Barnett,
824
00:43:54.000 --> 00:43:56.920
has an article coming out about the party presentation principle,
825
00:43:57.239 --> 00:44:01.079
which I agree courts are very inconsistent. This is basically
826
00:44:01.079 --> 00:44:03.840
the question of to what extent can they consider arguments
827
00:44:03.920 --> 00:44:06.800
raised by amikas briefs not raised by the main parties,
828
00:44:06.840 --> 00:44:08.840
which is very important to my line of work, since
829
00:44:08.880 --> 00:44:10.599
I only file amikus briefs.
830
00:44:10.639 --> 00:44:12.639
Well, you should know that it's exactly the same rule
831
00:44:12.639 --> 00:44:15.679
as standing exactly, if we want to hear the case,
832
00:44:15.679 --> 00:44:18.039
we read it, and if we want to resolve the issue,
833
00:44:18.039 --> 00:44:19.519
we will, and if we don't, we won't, and if
834
00:44:19.519 --> 00:44:20.000
we don't.
835
00:44:19.800 --> 00:44:20.400
Want to, we don't.
836
00:44:20.719 --> 00:44:23.360
I mean, I'm very serious about dogs. No one talks
837
00:44:23.360 --> 00:44:26.199
about it, but it was not in the question prison
838
00:44:27.840 --> 00:44:28.840
reversing Rome case.
839
00:44:30.119 --> 00:44:31.760
Is this a ken to the idea that if a
840
00:44:31.920 --> 00:44:33.760
court doesn't want to deal with the issue, we'll just
841
00:44:33.760 --> 00:44:35.920
find some way to say that the plane iff had
842
00:44:35.920 --> 00:44:38.280
forfeit the appellant had forfeited or waived the issue in
843
00:44:38.280 --> 00:44:39.039
the earlier brief.
844
00:44:40.320 --> 00:44:40.639
Yes.
845
00:44:41.880 --> 00:44:43.360
By the way, no one in this panel can tell
846
00:44:43.400 --> 00:44:46.360
me what dig means. And last term, the Court digged
847
00:44:46.400 --> 00:44:48.800
a big abortion case. We don't know how many justice
848
00:44:48.800 --> 00:44:51.360
it takes. We don't know what criteria they use. It's
849
00:44:51.360 --> 00:44:53.360
not even in their rule. There's no even there's no
850
00:44:53.440 --> 00:44:57.199
written rule about digs in any Supreme Court document that's
851
00:44:57.199 --> 00:45:01.559
external to the world. So yeah, on all these jurisdictional issuers,
852
00:45:01.559 --> 00:45:03.199
it's always the same. I mean, they'll hear it if
853
00:45:03.199
--> 00:45:04.760
they want to, and they want if they don't. I
854
00:45:04.760 --> 00:45:06.679
don't mean you don't have to be a crazy legal
855
00:45:06.719 --> 00:45:08.719
realist to understand that. Just look at the case law.
856
00:45:08.960 --> 00:45:10.960
Look at the Duke Power case. When it comes to
857
00:45:11.000 --> 00:45:14.280
standard you know that case is completely absurd, and there
858
00:45:14.360 --> 00:45:15.679
was twenty five others like it.
859
00:45:16.360 --> 00:45:19.800
For the viewers. DIG is dismissed as improvidently granted, that's
860
00:45:19.800 --> 00:45:22.239
where the Supreme Court agrees to take up a case
861
00:45:22.280 --> 00:45:25.559
grant certiary and then dismisses the case without ruling on
862
00:45:25.599 --> 00:45:28.599
the merits. Says, Oops, we made we changed our minds.
863
00:45:28.599 --> 00:45:30.079
We wish we hadn't taken this case.
864
00:45:30.280 --> 00:45:31.119
But there's a big debate.
865
00:45:31.159 --> 00:45:34.239
We're having justice that takes because five can undo four.
866
00:45:34.599 --> 00:45:37.920
If four justices grant shirt but five dig it, then
867
00:45:37.960 --> 00:45:40.840
the four for suirt doesn't matter. So Justice Stevens said
868
00:45:40.880 --> 00:45:43.280
once in a footnote, it should have to take six
869
00:45:43.360 --> 00:45:47.480
judges to dig. Well, think about it. If five can dig,
870
00:45:47.760 --> 00:45:49.880
the rule of four makes no sense because five can
871
00:45:49.920 --> 00:45:50.960
just dig every four case.
872
00:45:51.239 --> 00:45:53.519
But again, there's no rules about that because the Supreme
873
00:45:53.519 --> 00:45:55.480
Court doesn't believe in transparency.
874
00:45:56.079 --> 00:45:58.719
For viewers at home, it takes four votes to grant cercrary.
875
00:45:58.840 --> 00:46:00.000
We know that rule at least.
876
00:46:00.559 --> 00:46:02.599
How can you just accompany me everywhere and translate my work?
877
00:46:02.639 --> 00:46:04.559
I know you're really good at it. I'd really appreciate.
878
00:46:04.599 --> 00:46:07.440
It's why we have multiple panelists.
879
00:46:09.920 --> 00:46:10.440
He's doing great.
880
00:46:10.440 --> 00:46:11.840
I haven't heard from you in a little while or
881
00:46:11.840 --> 00:46:13.960
anything you'd like to add or take along these threads.
882
00:46:15.960 --> 00:46:20.719
Well, I learned something every day about the dig dig issue.
883
00:46:20.719 --> 00:46:22.840
I did not know there was like, no, no procedure
884
00:46:23.199 --> 00:46:27.159
about that. And I would just say, more broadly, at
885
00:46:27.159 --> 00:46:29.519
a thirty thousand foot level of the you know, nature
886
00:46:29.559 --> 00:46:33.679
of the originalism debate, I think to myself, you know,
887
00:46:34.440 --> 00:46:36.920
leaving aside the judicial review piece of this, it seem
888
00:46:36.920 --> 00:46:38.800
I mean, it seems to me that the you know,
889
00:46:39.760 --> 00:46:45.000
there's there's some smart people persuasively, in my view, argue
890
00:46:45.039 --> 00:46:48.039
that the commerce clause originally you know the word commerce man,
891
00:46:48.280 --> 00:46:52.880
you know, trade and transportation, not manufacture and agriculture, and
892
00:46:52.920 --> 00:46:57.239
you know it's meant for you know, interstate interactions, and
893
00:46:57.400 --> 00:47:00.880
you know it was expanded obviously. I would submit, you know,
894
00:47:01.039 --> 00:47:04.119
the president, like Wickered obviously, was in the you know,
895
00:47:04.480 --> 00:47:07.360
New Deal era where he had great pression World War two,
896
00:47:07.440 --> 00:47:11.119
et cetera. And I wonder if you know, if the
897
00:47:11.239 --> 00:47:14.239
old if there's a validity to what I'm suggesting, and
898
00:47:14.239 --> 00:47:16.280
if there's any validity to you know, the folks who
899
00:47:16.440 --> 00:47:19.920
argue for a narrower conception of necessary and proper, why
900
00:47:19.920 --> 00:47:22.440
didn't we you know, maybe it's too hard or what
901
00:47:22.599 --> 00:47:22.920
have you.
902
00:47:22.960 --> 00:47:24.079
But it's.
903
00:47:25.519 --> 00:47:27.960
Where does Article five in the amendment process play a
904
00:47:28.039 --> 00:47:32.559
role in this? You know, if you I'm not expressing.
905
00:47:33.360 --> 00:47:36.719
Michael in eighteen nineteen. The Supreme I'm sorry, eighteen twenty three.
906
00:47:36.880 --> 00:47:39.119
The Supreme Court of the United States in eighteen twenty
907
00:47:39.159 --> 00:47:43.320
three said that basically Commerce Clause reaches all commerce that
908
00:47:43.360 --> 00:47:47.199
affects more states than it didn't say effects more states
909
00:47:47.199 --> 00:47:50.199
than one. So I mean, I don't. Yes, I understand
910
00:47:50.239 --> 00:47:52.320
that Randy and Larry and some other people think they
911
00:47:52.360 --> 00:47:54.320
know what the original meaning of the Constitution is better
912
00:47:54.320 --> 00:47:55.079
than John Marshall.
913
00:47:55.239 --> 00:47:55.800
I get that.
914
00:47:55.960 --> 00:47:58.559
But everyone you're talking about, those smart, persuasive people you're
915
00:47:58.559 --> 00:48:01.280
talking about who make those argus guments. Their argument is
916
00:48:01.320 --> 00:48:04.400
that John Marshall didn't have the Constitution right, that John
917
00:48:04.480 --> 00:48:07.400
Marshall was a nationalist, which he was, of course, and
918
00:48:07.480 --> 00:48:10.400
took a more robust view of congressional power than the
919
00:48:10.440 --> 00:48:13.239
original public meaning at the time. But if we're going
920
00:48:13.280 --> 00:48:15.800
to discard what the Supreme Court said unanimously in eighteen
921
00:48:15.840 --> 00:48:19.039
twenty three or whatever it was, because some scholars in
922
00:48:19.119 --> 00:48:22.400
nineteen seven, I'm sorry, in nineteen ninety five think they
923
00:48:22.440 --> 00:48:24.800
know better, I think we need to take a step back.
924
00:48:25.239 --> 00:48:28.760
In addition, this law passed by Congress much closer in
925
00:48:28.840 --> 00:48:32.360
time than Randy Barnett, writing in the nineteen nineties. Listen,
926
00:48:32.679 --> 00:48:35.800
I wish Cato would Ilia Superila and I have argued
927
00:48:35.800 --> 00:48:38.599
about this so many times. Just come out and say,
928
00:48:38.639 --> 00:48:42.559
you want a libertarian society, you want deregulation, you think
929
00:48:42.559 --> 00:48:44.960
our world's a better place with that, and judges should
930
00:48:45.039 --> 00:48:47.239
enforce that. And I'm not going to argue with you.
931
00:48:47.360 --> 00:48:48.880
I mean, I might argue on the merits, but I
932
00:48:48.920 --> 00:48:52.480
can't say you're wrong about that. But stop calling yourselves originalists,
933
00:48:52.519 --> 00:48:55.599
because there's nothing in originalism that supports you. There's just nothing.
934
00:48:55.719 --> 00:48:57.960
And all of Supreme Court history suggest that except for
935
00:48:58.039 --> 00:49:00.039
a couple outlier cases during.
936
00:48:59.880 --> 00:49:02.000
The Lockner error like that, like you know, like the
937
00:49:02.119 --> 00:49:02.960
child labor.
938
00:49:02.719 --> 00:49:05.880
Case, which by the way, caused tens of thousands of
939
00:49:06.039 --> 00:49:09.679
children to work in minds under terrible conditions for three
940
00:49:09.760 --> 00:49:14.119
decades longer than they should. So again, healthy debate, what
941
00:49:14.159 --> 00:49:17.360
should Congress's powers be? Healthy debate, And maybe they've gone
942
00:49:17.400 --> 00:49:20.480
way too far healthy debate. It's nine originalist debate, and
943
00:49:20.480 --> 00:49:21.920
we should stop putting it in those terms.
944
00:49:24.119 --> 00:49:25.679
Let me turn me a little bit back more to
945
00:49:25.760 --> 00:49:31.880
the formalist aspect of the case. In particular issues we've
946
00:49:32.000 --> 00:49:35.039
mentioned that the standing issue and the whole issue question
947
00:49:35.119 --> 00:49:38.920
of whether or not McNaught or the other planets were
948
00:49:38.960 --> 00:49:44.320
sufficiently endangered or threatened with government action. And I know
949
00:49:44.400 --> 00:49:46.039
in the briefs that went back and forth a bit
950
00:49:46.079 --> 00:49:49.360
about who received a letter or a notice from which agency,
951
00:49:49.880 --> 00:49:53.360
and who would just know through their associational context that
952
00:49:53.360 --> 00:49:55.920
at least one of them would received noticed, and so forth.
953
00:49:58.079 --> 00:50:00.639
I'd noted that the governments were applied. Brief seemed to
954
00:50:00.679 --> 00:50:02.960
get down to the weeds in that regard and started
955
00:50:03.039 --> 00:50:05.639
quibbling as I think one of the panelists referred through
956
00:50:06.440 --> 00:50:09.079
about what is and isn't at home? And did you
957
00:50:09.159 --> 00:50:11.159
really say you're going to at home? I know when
958
00:50:11.199 --> 00:50:13.599
I read that brief, I was struck by, well, would
959
00:50:13.599 --> 00:50:16.320
the government accept that as a defense if they were,
960
00:50:16.360 --> 00:50:18.519
in fact the prosecute someone saying well, you know, it's
961
00:50:18.559 --> 00:50:22.079
not really home, it's really somebody. And I just wonder,
962
00:50:22.199 --> 00:50:24.679
given the if we want to be a more real
963
00:50:24.800 --> 00:50:29.599
politic here today, given the known composition and the current
964
00:50:30.639 --> 00:50:32.760
track record, if we will at the Fifth Circuit Court
965
00:50:32.760 --> 00:50:37.639
of Appeals, do you really see this court going into
966
00:50:37.679 --> 00:50:39.880
the weeds there on what is and isn't at home?
967
00:50:40.039 --> 00:50:41.679
Or who does and doesn't have a standing where you
968
00:50:41.719 --> 00:50:42.559
think this is going to go.
969
00:50:44.599 --> 00:50:46.480
Well, they don't have to get int the weeds on
970
00:50:46.559 --> 00:50:48.760
the merits because I guess, I guess the commerce positi
971
00:50:48.760 --> 00:50:50.440
issue is no longer in the case, which is really
972
00:50:50.440 --> 00:50:50.920
weird to me.
973
00:50:53.559 --> 00:50:57.199
But the question of the taxation enforcement of the tax laws,
974
00:50:58.079 --> 00:51:00.400
and that really is what an issue is. How far
975
00:51:00.480 --> 00:51:03.280
can you reach to tax something or to go beyond
976
00:51:03.360 --> 00:51:06.480
just taxing something and go into the intrinsic nature and
977
00:51:06.639 --> 00:51:09.039
origin and production of what it is you deemed attacks.
978
00:51:10.400 --> 00:51:15.239
It's not attack, and Justice Roberts has heard from again right.
979
00:51:15.199 --> 00:51:18.119
It's just not attacked. Neither was the mandate. Neither was attacks.
980
00:51:20.159 --> 00:51:21.119
More panel agreement.
981
00:51:22.800 --> 00:51:24.119
You can't on that.
982
00:51:24.519 --> 00:51:27.559
Just the for the listeners, maybe they if the alcohol
983
00:51:27.599 --> 00:51:31.360
thing is interesting enough. When Justice Roberts upheld the Affordable
984
00:51:31.360 --> 00:51:35.039
Care Act calling that thing a tax, one of the
985
00:51:35.079 --> 00:51:37.400
real problems in this case too. I think the same
986
00:51:37.440 --> 00:51:39.800
thing is that when the President of the United States
987
00:51:39.800 --> 00:51:42.400
goes around the country and says it's not attacks, when
988
00:51:42.440 --> 00:51:45.119
the Congress says it's not attacks, when Democrats are lobbying
989
00:51:45.119 --> 00:51:48.039
in town halls saying it's not attacks, the court should
990
00:51:48.039 --> 00:51:48.840
not call it attacks.
991
00:51:48.960 --> 00:51:50.039
That's my personal opinion.
992
00:51:53.280 --> 00:51:56.079
Has anyone noticed whether or not the spirits industry, the
993
00:51:56.159 --> 00:52:00.760
alcohol industry, they seem to be silent. They haven't weighed
994
00:52:00.800 --> 00:52:02.639
in or filed anamaricist that I'm aware of.
995
00:52:04.599 --> 00:52:07.079
Well, it may be literally a bootleggers and Baptist kind
996
00:52:07.079 --> 00:52:08.199
of scenario here.
997
00:52:09.519 --> 00:52:11.559
The industry is going to be for this law. Right.
998
00:52:11.599 --> 00:52:14.039
They don't want homemade they don't. They don't want homemades still,
999
00:52:14.599 --> 00:52:19.960
but certainly Yeah, and by the way, that's part of that.
1000
00:52:20.840 --> 00:52:23.599
If you really want to get into Cato's agenda, that's
1001
00:52:23.639 --> 00:52:26.280
the problem right there. So what Clark and I have
1002
00:52:26.320 --> 00:52:30.320
discussed many times is Clark thinks rent seeking is unconstitutional.
1003
00:52:30.519 --> 00:52:32.679
I'm assuming everyone on this panel thinks that as well,
1004
00:52:32.920 --> 00:52:35.920
That one part of the economics of our society shouldn't
1005
00:52:35.920 --> 00:52:38.400
be allowed to get a law passed to favor them
1006
00:52:38.480 --> 00:52:39.480
and exclude others.
1007
00:52:40.239 --> 00:52:41.400
That's what this is really about.
1008
00:52:42.519 --> 00:52:44.880
And my response to that has always been I don't
1009
00:52:44.880 --> 00:52:46.000
like the rational basis test.
1010
00:52:46.000 --> 00:52:48.360
It's wrong, it's misleading. I gree with Clark about.
1011
00:52:48.039 --> 00:52:53.480
That, but giving judges the power to distinguish rent seeking
1012
00:52:53.519 --> 00:52:57.079
from legitimate regulatory behavior is just too much power for
1013
00:52:57.199 --> 00:53:00.199
judges as a commerce cause case, This case is easy
1014
00:53:00.239 --> 00:53:01.800
to me as a tax cases.
1015
00:53:05.800 --> 00:53:07.719
Well, gentlemen, I think we've reached a point where it's
1016
00:53:08.440 --> 00:53:11.760
appropriate to give everybody a closing statement. Should we stay
1017
00:53:11.760 --> 00:53:16.519
in the same order and go But Michael Pepson, well.
1018
00:53:17.119 --> 00:53:21.039
I suppose I would just say, at a thirty thousand
1019
00:53:21.079 --> 00:53:24.480
foot level, I do think this case raises you know,
1020
00:53:24.599 --> 00:53:29.719
important you know, methodological questions as well as interesting practical
1021
00:53:29.800 --> 00:53:33.000
ones of what would the world look like if you know,
1022
00:53:33.880 --> 00:53:37.400
the plaintiff's win here and the federal government can't reach
1023
00:53:37.440 --> 00:53:40.960
this conduct. Maybe the federal government, I would submit, shouldn't
1024
00:53:40.960 --> 00:53:46.079
be regulating things such as, you know, everything from On
1025
00:53:46.119 --> 00:53:48.840
the one hand, a locality wants to ban gas leaf
1026
00:53:49.039 --> 00:53:51.960
leaf blowers. On the other hand, locality wants to you know,
1027
00:53:52.239 --> 00:53:55.000
legalize
or prohibit marijuana such as what was at issue
1028
00:53:55.039 --> 00:53:58.480
in rage or home distillings such as the case may be.
1029
00:53:58.599 --> 00:54:01.320
And I know that might sound more and policy if
1030
00:54:01.320 --> 00:54:05.320
you will. And also I suppose my closing thought is,
1031
00:54:07.000 --> 00:54:10.519
I do wonder if as a methodology, if we can
1032
00:54:10.639 --> 00:54:14.880
at least you know, follow originalism where it's leads and
1033
00:54:14.920 --> 00:54:17.159
people would you know, take issue with what I'm saying
1034
00:54:17.159 --> 00:54:21.639
and you know, different professors will disagree, and maybe you
1035
00:54:21.920 --> 00:54:24.480
get to a world where maybe you do need an
1036
00:54:24.559 --> 00:54:28.400
Article five amendment or two to modernize. But it is
1037
00:54:28.400 --> 00:54:32.239
it better to stick with what was intended? And is
1038
00:54:32.239 --> 00:54:32.559
that this?
1039
00:54:32.800 --> 00:54:33.280
Thank you.
1040
00:54:35.000 --> 00:54:35.239
Well?
1041
00:54:35.280 --> 00:54:37.800
What was intended was to give Congress the power to
1042
00:54:37.880 --> 00:54:41.239
regulate commerce among the states. What that meant in seventeen
1043
00:54:41.320 --> 00:54:43.480
ninety one is very different than what it means today.
1044
00:54:43.559 --> 00:54:46.880
Is Tommy was saying earlier, whatever they thought in the
1045
00:54:46.920 --> 00:54:49.440
micro and in kind of the small sense, in the
1046
00:54:49.440 --> 00:54:52.159
big sense, give James Madison all the information about the
1047
00:54:52.159 --> 00:54:56.400
interconnected international and domestic economies we have, and James Madison
1048
00:54:56.400 --> 00:54:58.760
and they all would say Congress can do this because
1049
00:54:58.760 --> 00:55:02.119
we need one unifor buying national institution when we have
1050
00:55:02.239 --> 00:55:03.639
this kind of interconnectedness.
1051
00:55:03.639 --> 00:55:05.559
But the main thing I want to say real quickly is.
1052
00:55:07.000 --> 00:55:10.639
I think that as a matter of real politics, the
1053
00:55:10.679 --> 00:55:13.960
Supreme Court is going to find a way to decide
1054
00:55:14.039 --> 00:55:16.760
this issue on the commerce clause basis. I understand it's
1055
00:55:16.760 --> 00:55:18.400
not in the Fifth Circuit. They're going to find a
1056
00:55:18.400 --> 00:55:20.639
way and they're going to use it to overturn rage.
1057
00:55:21.440 --> 00:55:24.880
Just as Justice Kennedy came to the Supreme Court wanting
1058
00:55:24.920 --> 00:55:29.400
to overturn Bowers, which he did, just like Justice Alito
1059
00:55:29.440 --> 00:55:31.480
had wanted to overturn Janics for decades.
1060
00:55:32.079 --> 00:55:35.000
This court wants to overturn Rage at this point, and.
1061
00:55:34.960 --> 00:55:37.159
This case would be the exact and maybe even with
1062
00:55:37.760 --> 00:55:40.719
maybe wickered, but I doubt it, but definitely rich and
1063
00:55:40.760 --> 00:55:44.880
they're going to and if this case follows a certain route,
1064
00:55:45.000 --> 00:55:47.960
they'll they'll find a way to signal to the people
1065
00:55:47.960 --> 00:55:50.920
bringing this case to the Supreme Court that make put
1066
00:55:50.960 --> 00:55:53.360
the commerce clause back in because they want to reverse
1067
00:55:53.480 --> 00:55:55.519
Rache And that's what's going to happen. And then Randy
1068
00:55:55.519 --> 00:55:57.079
can go out for dinner and celebrate.
1069
00:56:02.320 --> 00:56:05.440
Just a couple of comments, so I'll service translator again,
1070
00:56:05.519 --> 00:56:06.440
Randy Barnett argued.
1071
00:56:06.519 --> 00:56:08.159
Range. For people who.
1072
00:56:08.079 --> 00:56:11.679
Don't know, read Randy's excellent recent autobiography if you want
1073
00:56:11.719 --> 00:56:13.480
to hear the story of how that case came about.
1074
00:56:13.480 --> 00:56:15.559
It's pretty fascinating and how I got to argue it.
1075
00:56:16.280 --> 00:56:18.320
I agree with Randy and others that it was a
1076
00:56:18.400 --> 00:56:22.320
massive expansion and an unfortunate expansion of the federal government's powers.
1077
00:56:22.360 --> 00:56:25.239
It said it had the federal government could regulate medical
1078
00:56:25.280 --> 00:56:28.400
marijuana grown in one's own house for one's own personal consumption,
1079
00:56:28.840 --> 00:56:31.679
and I agree that this is probably that case was influenced,
1080
00:56:31.719 --> 00:56:36.039
unfortunately by the justices skepticism Justice Glee in particular of
1081
00:56:36.119 --> 00:56:39.400
the planted issue. The drug at issue, and liquor is
1082
00:56:39.440 --> 00:56:41.960
a more traditional, perhaps has more of a history in
1083
00:56:42.000 --> 00:56:45.519
the United States than medical marijuana, and so might be
1084
00:56:45.960 --> 00:56:49.119
easier for you know, stodgy, oldier judges to accept that
1085
00:56:49.159 --> 00:56:51.559
as a good test case for the limits of the
1086
00:56:51.599 --> 00:56:54.559
commerce clause. The last thing I'll just say about judicial review,
1087
00:56:54.880 --> 00:56:56.360
since we had a lot of back and forth, I'm
1088
00:56:56.400 --> 00:56:58.480
not going to convince Eric, but for any people watching,
1089
00:56:59.000 --> 00:57:03.159
I agree judges are not great at necessarily at reading minds,
1090
00:57:03.199 --> 00:57:06.840
at being at telling what someone's intent was or whether
1091
00:57:06.840 --> 00:57:09.320
they were in bad faith. I would say that, to
1092
00:57:09.840 --> 00:57:12.920
quote Borrow, to paraphrase what people have said about other systems,
1093
00:57:13.400 --> 00:57:15.280
they're the worst people in the system to judge that
1094
00:57:15.360 --> 00:57:18.719
except for everyone else. And so someone has to do it.
1095
00:57:18.760 --> 00:57:21.000
And that's why I think federal judges are the ones
1096
00:57:21.039 --> 00:57:24.079
who have to do it. And it's important that someone
1097
00:57:24.159 --> 00:57:26.840
in the system serves as a check against bad faith
1098
00:57:29.039 --> 00:57:32.360
efforts by the government to protect entrenched industries.
1099
00:57:34.239 --> 00:57:38.239
All right, then I'll give everybody one last chance, if
1100
00:57:38.280 --> 00:57:39.440
you'd like to weigh in again.
1101
00:57:39.360 --> 00:57:42.199
I'll just say what Tommy just said is exactly what
1102
00:57:42.239 --> 00:57:45.000
my students, my students ten years ago thought Rach was correct.
1103
00:57:45.599 --> 00:57:48.159
No student in my classes here thought Rach was correct.
1104
00:57:48.360 --> 00:57:50.920
There has been a sea change in how, at least
1105
00:57:50.920 --> 00:57:54.039
my law students view congressional power. And it's much more
1106
00:57:54.079 --> 00:57:56.320
along the lines Tommy is talking about than the way
1107
00:57:56.360 --> 00:57:57.360
I've traditionally seen.
1108
00:57:59.480 --> 00:58:01.760
Right, you or a Michael or anything.
1109
00:58:01.360 --> 00:58:05.719
Else end on a note of optimism that's great.
1110
00:58:06.639 --> 00:58:09.480
Or pessimism, depending on when sins all right.
1111
00:58:09.519 --> 00:58:12.159
Then we with that, we'll wrap things up and conclude
1112
00:58:12.280 --> 00:58:16.239
and thankfully hand over to Edith for our outro.
1113
00:58:17.159 --> 00:58:19.360
Yeah on behalf of the Federless Society. I just like
1114
00:58:19.400 --> 00:58:22.519
to thank Thomas, Michael and Professor Siegel for speaking with
1115
00:58:22.599 --> 00:58:25.400
us today, and Ted for moderating. We're so grateful for
1116
00:58:25.480 --> 00:58:28.000
your time and expertise, and thank you also to our
1117
00:58:28.000 --> 00:58:31.360
audience for joining us. We really appreciate your participation. You
1118
00:58:31.360 --> 00:58:34.159
can stay up to date with announcements and upcoming webinars
1119
00:58:34.159 --> 00:58:36.920
on our website Feddock dot org. We're on all major
1120
00:58:37.000 --> 00:58:40.199
social media platforms. Thank you once more for tuning in
1121
00:58:40.360 --> 00:58:41.400
and we are journed.
1122
00:58:54.320 --> 00:58:56.639
Thank you for listening to Necessary and Proper. If you
1123
00:58:56.719 --> 00:58:59.199
enjoyed this podcast, please tell a friend and don't forget
1124
00:58:59.239 --> 00:59:02.280
to subscribe on iTunes or Google Play. To learn more
1125
00:59:02.280 --> 00:59:06.239
about the Article one initiative, please visit FEDSOC dot org
1126
00:59:06.360 --> 00:59:10.239
slash article I. That's f E d s OC dot
1127
00:59:10.320 --> 00:59:12.199
org slash article I.
1128
00:59:21.039 --> 00:59:22.960
This has been a FEDSOC audio production