TRASCRIZIONE 🔗
00:00:00
Speaker 1: Good morning to you on this Tuesday morning, 27th day of October. Well, Chris Bowen's climate summit has blown out to a staggering $ 34. 6 million. That's almost $ 15 million more than the government initially told us. And that raises a very simple question. How much are taxpayers really expected to fork out for these international climate gatherings? The government previously cited $ 20 million, event management contract, but Senate committee hearings have now revealed that was only part of the bill. The spending includes venue construction, security translation services, audio-visual equipment and technical production in Fiji and Tuvalu. Another $ 2 million was spent on broadcasting services for the pre-COP31 climate summit. $ 2 million. What do we get for that? Well, the YouTube channel attracted just 90 subscribers and recorded 6,317 views across 18 videos. Hardly compelling. The summit attracted about 4,000 participants from 100 countries, yet struggled to attract major international leaders. $ 35 million for a climate summit that most of the world ignored. You have to wonder what ordinary Australians are getting for their money. So Chris Bowen has taken a different tack on social media, trumpeting the fact that Australia has the lowest power prices in the world.
00:01:15
Speaker 2: A big new report from the International Energy Agency out overnight showing that Australia is one of the very few countries in the world with falling.
00:01:22
Speaker 3: Wholesale energy prices.
00:01:24
Speaker 4: Why?
00:01:24
Speaker 2: Well, the International Energy Agency says it's because, and I quote, strong generation from renewables and, importantly, rapidly growing battery capacity. Wholesale prices in Australia in quarter two this year were lower than in Japan.
00:01:38
Speaker 3: India, United States or Europe.
00:01:39
Speaker 5: Always much, much more to do.
00:01:41
Speaker 2: But a good report card for the IEA overnight renewable energy reducing process.
00:01:46
Speaker 1: Yeah, yeah, Chris, reducing prices. Are you paying less on your power bill? I'd like to see your power bill. He's very keen to talk about the wholesale power prices, which is totally meaningless to 95% of us. Last time I checked, we all pay a retail price. Energy Minister Bowen? is expecting electricity companies to pass on the gains of cheaper prices. That's what he said yesterday. Well, he said the same thing two years ago, and we know how that was received. And South Australians continue to pay the highest price for power in the nation. Looking at the latest 226 figures, that's this year, the regulated flat rate usage charge, Victoria, ranges from roughly 26 to 32 cents per kilowatt hour. Southeast Queensland, around 28 cents. New South Wales, 33 to 35 cents. Tasmania, the lowest at under 25 cents per kilowatt hour. Here in South Australia, that figure sits at about 41.9 cents per kilowatt hour, well above the other states. Then there's the all-in cost usage plus daily supply charge. Price in South Australia hits 51.6 cents per kilowatt hour. Any wonder South Australians are angry. Thank you, Chris Bowen, and well done. What are your thoughts? 8223 0000 is the number to ring. Also on the show today, Adelaide's controversial street circuit redevelopment has cleared a major federal environmental hurdle. It paves the way for the MotoGP in the city for November next year. We'll speak with the Minister for State Development, Chris Pickton, about that. The horrific attack on independent MP Helen Haynes in Wangaratta highlights a growing threat to Australian democracy. At 9.30, we're going to have a chat with former Foreign Affairs Minister Andrew Darnott Alexander Dana, who wrote a compelling article in the Advertiser. He will be joining us. The battle to keep cash in circulation. This will be good news for a lot of 5AA listeners. The battle has been taken up by the Nationals. We're going to speak with the Cash is King supporter, Kevin Hogan. Just how likely is the bill to pass Parliament? There's community concern growing over the state government's push for data centres in South Australia. A proposed multi-billion dollar data centre at Tunkillo is facing growing opposition. More than 700 residents are joining an online protest group within days of the plans merging. And we'll take a look at that and speak with a local resident a little bit later on. And teen workers in South Australia could be missing out on $ 23 million of super this year. And on a lighter note, a happier note, Australia, we all know Australia is the home of big things. And now we have the big sultana. What is the major attraction with Australia and big things? I'm not against them, mind you. I just want to know. Just want to know what it's all about. All that and more. And the earthquake this morning, 4.9, shaken much of South Australia. Did you feel it? I must admit, I didn't. Not too many people I know did. But if you did, tell us your story. 8223 0000 is the number to ring. 13 past 9, 5AA. Well, Adelaide's controversial street circuit redevelopment has cleared a major federal environmental hurdle, paving the way for the MotoGP in the city next November, November 27, or 27, next year. Joining me now is Chris Pickton, the Minister for State Development. And Minister, thanks for your time today. The project's received federal environmental clearance, but what does that actually mean?
00:05:06
Speaker 6: Well, this is a process which we voluntarily submitted ourselves to under the federal environmental laws. It went out for public consultation and the Federal Environmental Protection Agency, the EPA, scrutinised the plans for it, scrutinised the feedback from public consultation and have ultimately come back saying that this is not a controlled action, which means that it's essentially got the green light from the federal government to now proceed.
00:05:32
Speaker 1: Does that mean there are conditions or is it unconditional?
Load full transcript
00:05:36
Speaker 6: There were some conditions which we voluntarily put forward, and that's around how we make sure that this is an environmentally sensitive project that protects and improves the environment of the parklands as we're doing this. Part of that is making sure that for every tree that's lost, it's replaced by 10 extra trees. Partly it's about making sure that we replace grassland and in fact lead to a net expansion of grassland and partly it's about taking measures to make sure that we're protecting the bats the technical name which is the gray-headed flying fox which is in the parklands as.
00:06:12
Speaker 1: Well so does this environmental clearance do you expect that'll appease the environmentalists or do you think they'll continue to take.
00:06:20
Speaker 6: Action Well, we know that the Conservation Council have said that they regard this upgrade in its totality as a nature positive development. So that's really fantastic to see that peak environmental body of South Australia give it the tick as well. But, you know, obviously, Graeme, there's some people who are against this project and there will be no convincing them whatsoever.
00:06:43
Speaker 1: And we know that.
00:06:44
Speaker 6: But we're not going to let a small minority of people stop what will be a really significant event for this state, for the economy of our state, putting Adelaide on the world stage and making our streets alive with an international motorcycle event, which will bring back the days of the Grand Prix, where we've got the world descending upon Adelaide once again.
00:07:06
Speaker 1: Almost 400 trees to be removed. Is that an acceptable environmental price to pay?
00:07:12
Speaker 6: Well, we know that we've taken every possible measure to make sure that we can minimise tree loss. And where there are trees that have to be lost, that they're replaced 10 for 1. We're also making sure that they're being replaced with, you know, mature trees, not little saplings or anything. And, you know, this represents, you know, about 5% of the trees within that area.
00:07:34
Speaker 3: And, of course, it will lead to more trees at the end of this project.
00:07:38
Speaker 6: Plus, we've got $ 15 million of broader environmental benefits for the parklands as well, which has meant that the Conservation Council have given this project their tick of approval as a nature positive development.
00:07:52
Speaker 1: 42 of the trees to be removed, classified as significant. Was there no way around it?
00:07:57
Speaker 6: We went through a really detailed process with the designers of the course to make sure that we could minimise tree loss and that the track has been designed with that in mind. So unfortunately, there are a small number of those significant trees that will have to be lost. But we've taken a lot of measures to make sure that that number is minimised as possible. And the majority of trees that have lost are either invasive trees that are not native to the
area. Some of them are damaged or a couple of them have even regarded as dead trees already. And they're being replaced with native trees for the area and on a 10 to 1 basis. So it'll be 10 times as many trees that will be planted, pretty significant trees at that, as well as a lot of the undercarriage plantings that will happen as well.
00:08:49
Speaker 1: How much disruption will the construction and in fact the racing events themselves cause to people who regularly use the parklands for recreation and walking, cycling, just enjoying their life?
00:09:00
Speaker 6: Well, we'll try to minimise that as much as possible, but obviously when the event will be on, this will mean that there'll be tens if not hundreds of thousands of people coming down to the area and enjoying it as well. And the parklands, we want it to be enjoyed for a variety of reasons. During the rest of the year, this will actually improve the amenity of the parklands to be enjoyed for whether it be cycling, whether it be taking your kids down there, whether it be running tracks, but also part of the benefit of what we're doing in terms of the new hard stand development is that we'll be able to use some of that area for things like basketball courts and pickleball courts, which will mean that there'll be a lot more usage of the parklands through the rest of the year.
00:09:46
Speaker 3: Plus, in addition.
00:09:47
Speaker 6: It will also mean that we'll be able to have the tour down under using this area as well, which will be a fantastic development for our state and our tourism as well.
00:09:57
Speaker 1: What do you see as the economic return of the Motel? Can you put it in dollar terms?
00:10:02
Speaker 7: Look, we can.
00:10:03
Speaker 6: And we, you know, on the basis of the BP Grand Final already last year delivered $ 100 million economic benefit to the state. So even if it's just the same as what the BP Grand Final supercars delivers, you Well, that will mean $ 200 million of economic benefit through both of those events. But I think really when you look at the scale of MotoGP Grand Prix's around the world, you know, Phillip Island, you know, has been a good event in Victoria, but it doesn't get anywhere near the same number of crowds as in some of the European races. And we think that this is an event which will grow over time. There'll be a lot of excitement about it being in the city, on a street circuit. It'll be easy for people to get to, easy for people to stay in hotels and get from the airport too. We think we can see that number and that economic benefit for the state continue to grow over time as well.
00:11:00
Speaker 1: This will be the first street circuit on the MotoGP calendar. Any fears that it mightn't work?
00:11:07
Speaker 6: Look, we are very confident that this will work. We're very confident that this will be an internationally spectacular event which will draw audiences from around the world. There's over 600 million fans of MotoGP around the world. I accept not every one of your listeners is going to be into motorcycle racing, but hundreds of millions of people around the world are. And they will be gluing their eyeballs to what's going on in Adelaide They will be excited to come down and visit Adelaide, and that's going to be a benefit for our tourism industry, for our hotels, for our restaurants, for our pubs. Right across the state, there'll be benefits out of this event, and this is going to be paying off for years and years to come for our state.
00:11:52
Speaker 1: So how much is the circuit redevelopment costing the taxpayer?
00:11:57
Speaker 6: We've put those figures out there in terms of the actual upgrades for the circuit. Off the top of my head, I think it's about $ 90 million for the upgrade of the circuit. We're going to have to lay new hard stand. It's replacing the previous hard stand that was there and relay the surface around the track as well to meet that requirement. You know, very fine standards that MotoGP has to have for their safety to make sure that the riders are safe as they're going around the circuit.
00:12:28
Speaker 1: And you have no issues about the fact that it'll be ready in time for the first MotoGP next year?
00:12:34
Speaker 6: No, we've got a pretty tight schedule, obviously, to be ready by November next year. But getting this tick off from the federal EPA today is a really important step in that direction of making sure that we can tick off all those boxes that we need to do to get ready. And so, you know, we've already got pre-registrations out for tickets for the event. There's a lot of interest from not only locally but around the world for people to get tickets for this event already. And we'll be pulling out all stops to make sure that we've got the track ready, the stands ready. And Adelaide, once again, will be putting on a world-class international motorsport event.
00:13:12
Speaker 1: Environmentalists are mounting another court challenge. Are you concerned by that?
00:13:17
Speaker 6: Well, I understand that the latest court challenge mentioned in the media is from a number of residents who live nearby the circuit who don't want to see this event take place. Look, you know, we will obviously defend very strongly the law and the position in regards to this event taking place. And I don't think it's appropriate that, you should try to stop an event for all of South Australia and all of our economy. And the government will very strongly defend this action, just as we have when it's come to other court action as well. In particular, the people who tried to stop the redevelopment of the golf course as well, which the government was successful in knocking that case off.
00:14:01
Speaker 1: Chris Picton, thanks for your time today. Minister for State Development on the MotoGP. Your thoughts on it? Jack says, I must live under a tree. I don't know anyone. is going to buy a ticket to go do a bike race? Well, maybe not, Jack, but I think you'll
find that there'll be sellout crowds there. Wendy says, isn't it strange when in an environment of lowering CO2 at the cost to Australia, the government is allowing racing cars and motorbikes to spew out megalitres of CO2 all in the name of entertainment? Your thoughts, love to hear them. Give us a call now, 8223 0000. Back in a moment.
00:14:35
Speaker 8: 5AA Mornings with Graham Goodings.
00:14:38
Speaker 1: At 26 minutes past nine, your calls in a moment on 8223 0000. Someone isn't happy with my comments about Chris Bowen. Sean says, how can you continue to attack Bowen when he's quoting independent agencies? Does that mean you are calling the independent agencies corrupt or in cahoots? The government's role is to bring the wholesale process through smart policy. How about you crack the libs for selling off ETSA? then you would have control over supply charges. If you're going to assign blame, at least crack the right areas to blame. Sean, Sean, Sean. Firstly, I didn't attack Chris Bowen because of quoting independent agencies. Those figures are correct. He's dead right. Wholesale price in Australia is cheaper than anywhere in the world. He is dead right. I'm not saying he lied about that. It's just that that's not the whole story. We don't care about the wholesale price. If you're paying just the wholesale price, congratulations and well done. But 95% of people don't. We pay the full price. And that's about, how about you crack the lips for selling off ETSA? Well, in hindsight, yeah, maybe. That was, what, 1999? Why did the government of the day sell off ETSA? Well, there was a little thing called the state bank debt, which was over $ 3 billion. A lot of money in today's terms. Huge money back in the 90s. So that's why they sold off ETSA, in hindsight. Maybe it was the wrong thing to do, but understandable at the time. Edwin, good morning.
00:16:04
Speaker 9: Good morning, Glenn.
00:16:06
Speaker 10: Look, I'd like to talk about the butterflies and the ants, the couple of chicken butterflies, probably before, on behalf of the Butterfly Association of South Australia.
00:16:17
Speaker 11: Yeah.
00:16:18
Speaker 10: And, I mean, I understand that we need to have a MotoGP in the city and all that, and that's okay. But what really irks me, which I find very annoying, is that they won't reroute the.
00:16:32
Speaker 9: the whole thing away from the butterfly area with the ants. They want to do it right where they are. And I think that's totally wrong and totally, totally disgusting. And they should not be allowed to do that.
00:16:43
Speaker 1: Because of the butterflies?
00:16:44
Speaker 9: Yeah, that's right. Because people just don't want to see the GP. Some people are nature lovers. They want to go and look at the butterflies and photograph them and all that sort of thing.
00:16:54
Speaker 1: So you reckon we've got to get 60,000 people on a weekend to see the butterflies?
00:16:58
Speaker 9: No, I'm not saying that.
00:16:59
Speaker 10: I'm just saying that there are some people that would want to, but the thing.
00:17:02
Speaker 9: Is that they could reroute the whole thing away from that area and still have it in the middle of the city. There's nothing wrong with that, but they won't do it. So, you know, when I talk about protecting the environment, well, you know, honestly, that's Chris Pickton. He should look at the butterflies there, but he probably doesn't know the butterflies are there anyway.
00:17:21
Speaker 1: No, I believe they're expanding the butterfly habitat.
00:17:26
Speaker 11: Really?
00:17:26
Speaker 12: Yeah.
00:17:27
Speaker 9: Well, how can they do that if they're going to if they're going to bulldoze the area where the butterflies are.
00:17:31
Speaker 8: Well, I don't know.
00:17:31
Speaker 1: We'll have to get Chris Pickton on again. But good on you, Edwin. Thanks for that. Concerned about the butterflies? Are they the checkered copper butterfly? Not sure. Susan, good morning.
00:17:41
Speaker 13: Good morning.
00:17:43
Speaker 14: During all of this talk about the parklands and the motorbike race and Chris Pickton talking about Exeter Sport and what have you in there, I don't know whether you realise I walk through the parklands on a regular basis. But the parklands on the eastern side there are only completely open for about three months of the year. They're closed off or park closed off for nine months of the year. And that track goes, and he's talking about putting extra basketball courts or pickleball courts. They play cricket in there on two ovals on the weekends, just about any time that it's able to be played on. And also the soccer players. The track goes completely through that, so they are kicked off completely. And I'm just very curious about why that's not being talked about, either in the media or the people involved in playing those sports. And, you know, the government just doesn't care. And that grass through that parkland is relayed every year. I don't know whether you realise that either, because it's trashed by the fringe people and also the car races.
00:18:51
Speaker 1: Okay, Susan, thanks for bringing that to our attention. Just before headlines, Ralph. G'day, Ralph. How are you doing?
00:18:57
Speaker 15: Good, thanks, Graeme. I'm living in Melbourne now, an Adelaide boy, and working at one of the best hotels in Melbourne, and the GP has just left. And I can tell you the economic benefit that it gives Melbourne is incredible, and Adelaide has that to look forward to. And having lived on the park lands for the last 20 years before I came to Melbourne, the park lands, the grass that gets replaced, gets replaced by the fringe itself for the use of the area. And the boys, the Christian brothers and saints that use those ovals, only miss out on using the ovals for the actual period of time that the race is going. So, you know, people really need to be educated with all of the pros and cons. And I can tell you now, Melbourne is ruining the
fact that they've lost the race. and it's a reverse of when Adelaide lost the Formula One.
00:19:53
Speaker 8: Nice to get one back Yeah, absolutely.
00:19:56
Speaker 15: So enjoy and enjoy the economic benefits that it's going to bring. I know I've already spoken to 20 or more people about things to visit in South Australia when they're there for the motor GP next year.
00:20:10
Speaker 16: Beautiful.
00:20:10
Speaker 1: Good on you, Ralph. Great to chat. We miss you in Adelaide. Ralph Hadzik, former Adelaide Identity. Well, the attack on independent MP Helen Haynes in Wangaratta last week highlights a growing threat to Australian democracy. My next guest is former Foreign Affairs Minister Alexander Downer, who wrote a compelling article in the Advertiser this morning. Alexander, good morning.
00:20:32
Speaker 8: Good morning, Graeme.
00:20:35
Speaker 1: How has it come to this, where every politician, both state and federal, must now be concerned for their welfare and safety?
00:20:42
Speaker 12: Well, I think there's been a real change in the atmosphere of this country as regards public debate over the last few years. I'm not sure what the starting point was. But a manifestation of that has been the really vicious language used in demonstrations, many of which are about the Middle East, of all things, that in turn was followed by the Bondi massacre, of course. Now Helen Haynes, other MPs coming out, talking of threats to them and so on.
00:21:23
Speaker 5: I mean, it's true.
00:21:24
Speaker 12: There have always been the occasional threats to MPs. I've had to put up with that myself over the years. But this has accelerated and become more intense now. So it's hard to know what has triggered it. Some people say social media, that might be a factor. But it's the tone of the country which has become much more aggressive and intolerant.
00:21:54
Speaker 1: Do you fear that there will be a lot of people out there who have some form of political aspirations who are reassessing it, saying, I'm just not going to put myself or my family at risk?
00:22:04
Speaker 12: Yes, I mean, I definitely worry about that because we do need able, experienced and educated people to come.
00:22:13
Speaker 5: Forward and offer themselves as.
00:22:16
Speaker 12: Members of Parliament to provide our state and our country with real leadership. And nationally, I mean, I think we're very short of leadership in Australia at the moment. And you can see that from the gyrations of the opinion polls. I mean, they're all over the place because people are looking for leadership and they're not finding it. And one of the explanations for that is that the right sort of people aren't going into Parliament.
00:22:50
Speaker 5: They're just thinking, well, I can earn more money in business, I.
00:22:55
Speaker 12: Have a more relaxed and easygoing life in a profession as a doctor or as a lawyer or a journalist, perhaps, whatever it is, that I wouldn't want to put myself through not just all the abuse that comes with politics and that sort of at one level, fair enough, I suppose, the criticism, but more than that, the violence that might be associated with it.
00:23:24
Speaker 5: So we're going to get less good people.
00:23:27
Speaker 12: Sure, there'll always be people who want to be a somebody by becoming an MP, but we want able people, people with leadership potential to come forward, people with convictions to come forward, not just anybody who um thinks it would be nice to be an mp.
00:23:47
Speaker 1: You mentioned social media do you think it's fundamentally changed the nature of political abuse i'm not.
00:23:53
Speaker 12: Sure about that argument that's a very popular argument i mean you don't have to read uh social media uh you don't have to look at your ex um comments or Facebook or Instagram or whatever it is.
00:24:12
Speaker 5: You don't have to look at it.
00:24:13
Speaker 12: You can look at it, but you don't have to look at it. So there might be something in that argument, but I think it's the tone of the country. There has been an increasing intolerance, people taking the moral high ground and often implicitly accusing people who don't agree with them as being less moral than them or being immoral or uncaring and cruel. There are all sorts of epithets used about people which are incredibly offensive now. uh whereas i mean i remember paul keating he was into that sort of language uh trump style language but it's become much more common in public discourse these days the.
00:25:10
Speaker 1: Change in the political climate isn't confined to australia is it i mean this seems to be a worldwide.
00:25:15
Speaker 12: Trend yes i mean certainly it's true in western countries you you've seen this in america particularly um I mean, I spend quite a lot of my time in the UK. Political debate is much politer there. You know, the British have a reputation for being polite, and they are, on the whole, quite polite. But in America, it's become toxic, actually, and the intolerance between people who support the Democrats and people who support the Republicans is has reached fever pitch, and it's about to go up a notch too with the midterm elections happening.
00:26:02
Speaker 5: Next week, yes, next week, next Tuesday.
00:26:06
Speaker 12: And presumably the Democrats will get control of the Congress, and then the Democrats versus the Republican president, then President.
00:26:18
Speaker 5: Trump, will reach new intensity. And then this has.
00:26:24
Speaker 12: Spilled over into other countries and it's to some extent has spilled over into our own country, though we shouldn't just blame the Americans. We should blame ourselves and our, you know, in a broad sense, not to single out any particular individual.
00:26:43
Speaker 5: But in a broad sense, the lack of real leadership in our country.
00:26:48
Speaker 1: Let's continue on with the midterms at the moment. What is your feeling for the outcome? It looks like the
Democrats will have the numbers. What impact will that have on President Trump's presidency?
00:26:59
Speaker 12: Well, he won't be able to do two things. One, he won't be able to get any legislation.
00:27:05
Speaker 5: New laws through the Congress.
00:27:08
Speaker 12: Which is in effect the Parliament of the United States. And secondly, he won't be able, if he loses control of the Senate or the Republicans lose control of the Senate, which, I mean, it's in the balance, they might do, then he won't be able to nominate anybody for cabinet positions or Supreme Court positions because the Democrats will block all his appointments in the Senate.
00:27:38
Speaker 5: They have to be ratified by the Senate. So it will be a problem.
00:27:46
Speaker 12: And I suppose also they'll move impeachment proceedings, which will take up a lot of their time but won't ever lead to anything of substance. So all those things will happen. But President Trump will still be the president.
00:28:06
Speaker 5: He'll still have it.
00:28:08
Speaker 12: Executive power he'll still be able to govern but it it'll be more difficult for.
00:28:13
Speaker 1: Him certainly uh now we have a question for you from a listener if the prime minister was to speak out against hate speech at rallies and in the community would that lower the temperature uh.
00:28:26
Speaker 12: It's getting late in the day i think uh both the prime minister and ministers and premiers I'm not sure this is fair on our own premiere, actually, but they could have been more vocal in criticising the hugely aggressive and disruptive demonstrations which seemed to revolve around the Middle East. The language which was used there, much of which has triggered the uprising anti-Semitism movement, I think that should have been clamped down much earlier.
00:29:06
Speaker 5: Of course, it's fair enough for people to have demonstrations. They can do that.
00:29:10
Speaker 12: If they like, but not so disruptive, not so aggressive.
00:29:16
Speaker 5: And hard to stop that. You can't expect the police just to stop it.
00:29:21
Speaker 12: You know, political leaders have to come out and condemn it and say, explain what sort of behavior is acceptable and not acceptable that demonstration outside the sydney opera house i think it was on the.
00:29:35
Speaker 5: 9th of october uh 2023 um.
00:29:44
Speaker 12: Whatever language was used, but anti-Semitic language and very aggressive language congratulating Hamas, which is a terrorist organisation. That triggered a lot of this, and that should have been dealt with there and then by the Prime Minister and the New South Wales Premier and others. They should have clamped down on it, at least orally, said that sort of behaviour and is completely unacceptable.
00:30:13
Speaker 5: They didn't do that.
00:30:14
Speaker 1: Is it too late? Can they do anything now?
00:30:18
Speaker 12: It's very late because we've seen, you know, what happened to Bondi and to Helen Haynes.
00:30:24
Speaker 5: So it's very late.
00:30:28
Speaker 12: The game is never over. And I do think political leaders need to take on extremists and extremist language. I mean, left-wing extremists as well as right-wing extremists. We need to make it absolutely clear that extremist language and extremist behaviour is completely unacceptable and it needs to be called out and condemned, regardless of whether these people might have been supporters of yours politically or not.
00:31:05
Speaker 5: We haven't seen enough of that.
00:31:07
Speaker 1: Alexander Downer, thanks so much for your time today, former Foreign Affairs Minister, and you can read his article in the Advertiser this morning. 5AA Mornings with Graham Goodings. 10 to 10, good morning to you if you've just joined us. Thanks for dropping by. From the text line, the political heat at the moment is all down to the leadership or lack thereof. This current lot are scared of offending anyone. and are so indifferent about everything they have created a monster. Thank you for that, Darren. Bell says, Hi, Graham. I'm astounded by the negativity people have with progress, laying some lawn each year, some butterflies, birds which naturally relocate, and sports activities. Oh, please. I'm all for preserving our community, building facades, rivers, beaches, natural parks, etc., but we cannot stand still and let the other states take our events, which contribute to our income and prosperity. What we do with the money, well, that's a different issue. Thank you for that, Bill. And Steve says, re-wholesale electricity prices being one of the lowest in the world, doesn't the fact we are paying such high prices prove the system is broken? Any normal market says the lower the cost of manufacturing generally means lower cost to the consumer. Our system rewards the electricity generators with higher profits for reducing their costs at our expense while prices increase year on year. And that's the point, Steve. That is exactly the point. And Chris Bowen can crow all he likes about Australia having the lowest wholesale power prices in the world thanks to renewables, but that doesn't translate. It doesn't mean a thing if the country is bleeding by excessive prices. And he said he's calling on the retailers, the providers, to bring down the prices. Well, it's not working. Not working. You're in the government.
00:32:50
Speaker 7: You're here to help.
00:32:52
Speaker 1: What are your thoughts? 8223 0000. Well, the battle to keep cash in circulation has been taken up by the Nationals. Kevin Hogan is the Shadow Assistant Treasurer. He joins us now. Kevin, thanks for your time today. Just how important is it to keep cash in circulation?
00:33:06
Speaker 17: Well, Graeme, I think it's really important, and I get a lot of feedback that people want to have the availability to use cash. It's legal tender. At the moment, it's only mandated within the two major supermarkets and fuel stations, and the bill that I'm introducing to
Parliament this week will extend that to chemists, hardware stores, department stores, restaurants, fast food chains, etc. So if this bill gets up, cash will be mandated, we think, across 80% of the face-to-face transactions that happen for goods and services across this country, and We and I think that's important.
00:33:37
Speaker 1: Yeah, and why? Why is it so important? Because most of us have moved across to a cashless society. Why is it still important to make it so available? Well, it's important.
00:33:47
Speaker 17: A lot of people are increasingly using cash for budgetary purposes like they're dodging credit card surcharges and all those type of fees that you have when you use credit cards and other cards. They're trying to teach their kids to budget and use cash as well. There are also some people concerned and we think we need the availability of this when there's breakdowns, whether system breakdowns or energy breakdowns. If the energy goes down, the power goes down, you need to have the infrastructure to still be able to do cash. Older Australians, obviously, still, many of them still want to use cash as well, and.
00:34:17
Speaker 18: For privacy reasons.
00:34:18
Speaker 17: So many reasons we need to have the infrastructure and the services available to be able to accept and use cash, and that's important, I think, for all those reasons.
00:34:26
Speaker 1: You mentioned big businesses like Bunnings and Chemist Warehouse and the like. What about smaller businesses?
00:34:33
Speaker 17: Well, what we think, so this legislation as it's designed means that 80% of transactions in Australia will be covered and be mandated to have to accept cash. And up to $ 2, 000 worth of cash, the current one is only $ 500. So there's a big move in percentages here that what this bill will do. Now, what I think will also happen, Graeme, I mean, small businesses like take, for example... your food van at a market will say, look, we don't want to have to do this. There's security issues for us. There's costs with us having to do cash. So I get that. We don't want to encompass some people that it's a security risk for. But when you're McDonald's cafe is accepting cash because they have to. The cafe next door is going to be more encouraged to do cash as well because as a competitive advantage, if people want to use cash, they'll have to keep up. So we think getting 80% of the market covered means those who are competing with them will be more encouraged to do so, which is why we think this increased mandate is very important.
00:35:30
Speaker 1: Why have you set the transaction limit to $ 2, 000?
00:35:34
Speaker 17: Well, again, we've done a lot of consultation with stakeholders around this. At the moment, it's $ 500. You can spend a lot more than $ 500 at a hardware store and even go to a pharmacy with some things. You can be up there pretty quickly. So with the consultation that we did with some groups around, stakeholders around, they thought that was a nice amount to get to. So we sort of went on advice on that.
00:35:57
Speaker 1: There are a lot of 5AA listeners who will be saying, well done, putting their hands together, because they are fearful that cash is going to disappear from society, and a lot of older people just are not comfortable with the digital world.
00:36:09
Speaker 17: Yeah, look, exactly. And again, getting the mandate to 80% we think was an important step because I think what you'll do if we don't do this, if we leave it where it is at the moment with just supermarkets and some of the major petrol stations, I think we'll see more and more people leave and They removed themselves from the cash mandate, but extending it to 80% of the market with all the fast food chains, with all the other examples I gave, I think that will encourage other small businesses to keep cash as well. So we think this is really important for all the reasons that I've mentioned, and we're hoping this bill gets up this week.
00:36:44
Speaker 1: Does carrying more cash increase consumer theft chances?
00:36:49
Speaker 9: Well, look, again, it does.
00:36:51
Speaker 17: I mean, businesses need to take precautions. And again, especially the businesses we're mandating this for have the infrastructure because they operate under bigger umbrellas. They have the things and they'll be able to cope with this. But businesses for 100 years, Graeme, as you know, have been taking precautions. They have their limits of when their cash gets to a certain level, they'll take it to a safer place and to a bank branch or whatever. So they'll still manage that and they'll still allocate and have their security precautions about that, which they've always done.
00:37:21
Speaker 1: What impact do you think this will have on the banks? Because we know that they're shutting down tellers, ATMs are in dwindling supply. They don't like cash.
00:37:33
Speaker 17: Yeah, well, I think this, again, is going to put pressure on them because, you know, when their customers need an offering and are mandated to have to use cash or offer cash, that will mean that that service will be provided from the bank, which means they'll still have to start, you know, they'll have to advise that availability because that's what their service is about. So we've spoken to them around this as well. They understand this. We're also working with Armagard. Again, they are a monopoly. So we're giving powers to the ACCC and the Reserve Bank too to make sure that they don't do any price gouging around this area as well. So there's a whole supply chain involved with cash. But again, it's important for so many reasons. This is, I think, a really important bill. And getting the mandate out to 80% is a really important step in making sure cash flows. doesn't really start to disappear for our economy.
00:38:22
Speaker 1: Now, you're putting this forward as a private member's bill. Will it have the support of the Coalition?
00:38:26
Speaker 17: Well, yes, it
has. I've gone through the coalition, through the opposition processes. So the Liberal and National parties both support this bill. So I'm moving it as a private member, but it has the support of the opposition. And we're hoping, I guess I'm talking with government members of Parliament, hoping that we get their support. But, you know, we'll see. They did it their own mandate earlier this year, which, as I said, doesn't go near far enough. So we're advocating and lobbying for them to hopefully get their support.
00:38:51
Speaker 1: Kevin Hogan, thanks for your time today. Shadow Assistant Treasurer Kevin Hogan. Cash is king. That's his bill being introduced to Parliament. At least someone is listening in Canberra for all the 5AA listeners who use cash still. And look, I use cash minimally, I must admit, but I like to carry some cash around. And it seems a bit silly if something's $ 4. 50 using your card or swiping or whatever. But I know most of us do. But if the machines go down... Nice to reach into your pocket and pull out a $ 50 note and say, well, at least I can pay for something. On the text line, if we cannot get cash from the banks, then how do we own our own money? Banks can freeze accounts, as we know. Now, there's been a serious crash in the CBD this morning. About 10 to 9 police responded to the intersection of Pulteney Street and Grenfell Street after a pedestrian was struck by a car. Southbound lanes on Pulteney Street are closed. Northbound traffic is restricted to one lane. There are significant delays in all directions, so avoid the area if you possibly can. Looking at the stock market, the All Ords is down by 0.05%. ASX200 down by 0.09%. Dow Jones up by 0.2%. NASDAQ up by 0.8%. Brent crude oil remaining steady at US $ 115 a barrel. West Texas crude, US $ 101. And gold is US $ 4, 013 an ounce. The Aussie dollar steady, US $ 0.
00:39:58
Speaker 19: 70.
00:39:58
Speaker 1: 8223 0000 is the number back after the news.
00:40:17
Speaker 8: 5AA Mornings with Graham Goodings.
00:40:21
Speaker 1: As we enter the second hour of the show, it's nine minutes past ten, 5AA. Len says, if the wholesale price for electricity is low and the retail price is high, this is proof we are being gouged in my books. Yeah, I'm not so sure, Len. I take your point. The ACCC regularly look at the prices and it would appear that the wholesale price of energy... only accounts for about 30% or 35% of the total package. There are lots of other elements, not justifying their prices by any means, because when the government keeps saying how wonderful it is that wholesale prices are coming down and it doesn't translate to retail prices, no wonder we all get a little bit angry about it. Well, let's say team workers are being denied $ 23 million in superannuation this year. To tell us about it is Super Members Council CEO Misha Schubert. Misha, good morning to you.
00:41:10
Speaker 15: Good morning, Graeme.
00:41:11
Speaker 3: Great to be with you.
00:41:12
Speaker 1: Yeah, $ 23 million. How's this come about?
00:41:15
Speaker 20: Well, this is due to an outdated age discriminatory rule that sits in Australia's super laws, and it dates all the way back to the beginning, 35 years ago, when Australia first legislated for every worker across the country to have that same universal guarantee of super paid on top of their take-home wage. So a couple of arguments were made back then to exclude individuals under 18 workers who worked part-time. So if you work less than 30 hours a week for the one employer and you're under that age of 18, they're not legally required to pay you super. Of course, some employers choose to do that because they want to set their young workers up with a really good super start to their working lives. But two arguments were made at the outset. One, that it would be very small amounts of money paid to young people because the super guarantee rate started at just 3% paid on top of wages. And a second argument was made that small amounts of money in their super would be eroded by fees over time. If you fast forward to today, the super guarantee rates paid at 12% on top of wages and there are fee protections in law to stop you being charged more than 3% of fees on super balances, $ 6, 000 or less. So those original arguments no longer apply.
00:42:28
Speaker 1: So how many team workers in South Australia are affected?
00:42:32
Speaker 20: So there are 31,000 teen workers across the state of SA who are going to miss out collectively on $ 23 million in super this year alone due to that outdated discriminatory rule. That averages out for each of them at about $ 730 a year. And what we know is if this rule was repealed and enabled every young worker to start their working lives with that strong message about the importance of super to their financial future, you would see the average teenager having around $ 2, 400 by the time they turn 18, if they've been working that couple of years on the runway to 18. And that lost super could compound up to $ 11, 000 worth of value for them by retirement because of the way in which compound investment returns work to sort of snowball your amount of money in super over your working life.
00:43:21
Speaker 1: So it does sound like only a small amount at this stage, but as you say, when it gets around to retirement, it's a fairly sizable amount.
00:43:28
Speaker 5: That's it.
00:43:28
Speaker 20: Small dollars at the very start of your working life are the ones that work the hardest for you through your working life because they've got the longest amount of time invested to generate those compound returns. The other really interesting part of this is that it affects young women more than it affects young men. So when you dig into the data on the under-18 workforce, we can see in that really clearly that there are a lot of young blokes working full-time in trades apprenticeships who do qualify for that guarantee, the same guarantee of 12% super on top of your
wage that 17 million other Aussies enjoy, but a whole lot of young women who typically fall just under that 30-hour-a-week threshold, and so they're missing out. So we're recreating that gap in the gender super gap all over again for our daughters and our granddaughters right at the very start of their working lives.
00:44:18
Speaker 1: Yeah, well, you've highlighted the fact that when it sort of came into being way back when super was 3%, it wasn't So significant. Now it is. Who is it up to? I mean, you're putting pressure on. Does the government have to change legislation?
00:44:34
Speaker 3: That's it.
00:44:34
Speaker 20: So it would require a change to the regulations that sit underneath the sort of legislative framework around super at the federal level. So this is a decision that government could make. We've... Basically, in our engagement, we're calling for this rule to be repealed so that we get every young Australian worker a super start to life. We do think it's important, though, for it to be brought in in a transition approach so that there's time for businesses who employ 18 workers to make the, you know, to prepare for that change, just as there have often been for other major and important changes to make the super system stronger in the past, including for payday super and payday Up until 2022, if any worker earned less than $ 450 a month, they were also excluded from the super guarantee. That change was made under a previous government to abolish that discriminatory outdated exclusion as well. So people, you know, policymakers across time have made these sorts of really important, sensible additions to the super system to bring its benefits to even more Australians. And we want young teenagers, half a million of them around the country and 31,000 of them in SA to have that same strong start to their working lives that means they've got super from day one.
00:45:52
Speaker 1: Would you expect any employer pushback? I mean, small businesses around the nation are struggling at the moment, tight margins. If they've got outlay anymore, that could just about push them over the edge.
00:46:02
Speaker 20: Look, at the individual level, these are very small amounts of money at the individual employer level. And indeed, when we've crunched the numbers on what it would be at the sort of national payroll, it's a very, very fractional. I think it's less than 0.03 of a percent of national payroll. So you're talking about a very tiny amount in aggregate across the system and also at individual employer level. We know that, again, when we engage with employers across the country in our work to help Australians understand and engage more with their super, we know there are a lot of employers out there who choose to do this because they actually say, oh, I want to start the kids who are working for me off with that really strong message about the importance of super to their financial future. So small amounts of money today for a very big reward
for young people tomorrow to make sure our kids really have that strong financial future.
00:46:54
Speaker 1: You're calling for a sensible transition period. How would that work practically?
00:47:00
Speaker 20: Well, there are a couple of ways in which government and the parliament could think about doing that. So as I said, there are a couple of other examples where, so for Payday Super, they gave a notice kind of a couple of years out that this would be, you know, that the law would change to require employers to pay super on paydays, not just four times a year. So that sort of telegraphing of an intent to make an important policy reform. And in that case, it's going to be a game changer for millions of Australian workers having your super paid on payday. It'll help really make some big inroads on winding back that scale of unpaid super. But even for people who do get paid super by their employer, just having that super drop into your super account that little bit early because it might be paid weekly or fortnightly depending on what your pay cycle is, that then means it's invested sooner, which means it compounds faster. And so even for people who do get paid their full amount of super but have been paid historically on a delayed timeframe quarterly, that effect alone could be worth another seven and a half grand for people by the time they retire.
00:48:04
Speaker 7: It seems only fair.
00:48:06
Speaker 1: Good on you, Misha. Good to chat. Great to chat with you. That's Super Members Council CEO, Misha Schubert. Team workers are missing out on $ 23 million a year in superannuation because of a ruling when superannuation came in and was back in the era of 3%. Now it's 12% and we're talking considerable money. Good morning to you. Calls in a moment on 8223 0000. Craig says it cost me $ 500 to fill my Land Cruiser.
00:48:37
Speaker 8: Wow.
00:48:39
Speaker 1: You're obviously driving a diesel, Craig. What is it at the moment? High 280s? But $ 500 to fill your Land Cruiser. It'd be cheaper to fly somewhere, wouldn't it? Enzo says Bowen's reference to wholesale price of electricity is a glaring example of why politicians are on the nose, treating us with contempt. Let's go to Windvale and Jake.
00:49:01
Speaker 8: G'day, Jake.
00:49:02
Speaker 18: Good morning, Graeme.
00:49:03
Speaker 16: Cheers for taking my call. Look, this whole Parkland thing I think is an absolute atrocity financially for the state. Let's start with you can't have your cake and eat it too. And my stepfather used to say, I give you my little finger, you take.
00:49:17
Speaker 17: My whole hand.
00:49:18
Speaker 16: Well, the Malinafka government is taking all of South Australia's hand. In my opinion, if with the live golf, if you just let that go through to the keeper and give up on it, he may have had a bit more of a green light on the MotoGP.
00:49:34
Speaker 7: Pretty simple.
00:49:35
Speaker 16: This state needs to focus on, we've got the South Road to build, We've got
the new women's and children's hospital.
00:49:42
Speaker 21: To be built.
00:49:44
Speaker 16: And the new RA costs $ 1 million a day to keep open. Chris Pickton got on your station just before, said we need to invest $ 90 million to upgrade the racetrack for MotoGP. And then he stated that previous year, the BP Grand Final brought in $ 100 million. So what?
00:50:05
Speaker 18: If we go off those figures, we're.
00:50:06
Speaker 16: Going to make a $ 10 million net profit in the first year.
00:50:09
Speaker 13: That's absolutely ridiculous.
00:50:11
Speaker 16: Now, we've got ramping, crazy stuff going on with the hospitals. It's been going on way before Marshall and Wetherill, and we've been hanging out for the new women and children so the old site can be used for older patients, the mentally health patients across the state, yet this government... rather spend, spend, spend to make the GDP look really good by putting this state into debt. They do not make do with what they've got. Thank you very much, Graeme.
00:50:40
Speaker 1: Good on you, Jake. Thanks for your input. Out to Black Forest. Bill, good morning.
00:50:44
Speaker 21: Oh, good morning, Graeme.
00:50:45
Speaker 22: Before I start, I'd just like to say thank you very much. I'm nearly 80, and talking to people like you or Matt or Will, it just lets you get a bit.
00:50:56
Speaker 7: Off your mind.
00:50:56
Speaker 13: So thank you very much.
00:50:58
Speaker 7: That's what we're here for.
00:51:00
Speaker 22: Look, I was just thinking like sacred sites and what happens if someone impinges on them and so forth. The West Terrace Cemetery, the wall around it is becoming a graffiti market and there's this big saying saying, they eat our children alive. And I'm just thinking it's not too good. And the other thing is this November 11 with the kids, I wonder who's behind this, and I fiercely think it's communist, and it's just a way of disrupting society. All these kids coming out of school.
00:51:40
Speaker 18: Make it a Saturday.
00:51:41
Speaker 13: I wonder how many would be there.
00:51:43
Speaker 1: Well, that's the issue. I mean, there are two issues here, Bill. The fact that it's on Remembrance Day, which is absolutely disgraceful, in my opinion. But, yeah, how many kids would turn up for a protest on a weekend? No, they want a day off school. I'm not at all against protesting. That is fine. We have a free and democratic society. You can protest if you want to, but be more selective when you do it.
00:52:07
Speaker 22: Yeah, and I'd like to start a protest group that protests against protests. But anyway, look, thank you very much, Graeme, and I feel so much better, and thank you very much to all you people on 5AA.
00:52:21
Speaker 21: Thank you so much.
00:52:22
Speaker 1: Good on you, Bill, and thanks so much for your call. Ken, good morning.
00:52:26
Speaker 13: Good morning, Graeme. How are you, buddy? Good, thanks. I'd just like to inform your listeners, I was reading the advertiser yesterday, and Peter Malinakis, he's gone to ICAC, or AKA the Corruption Commission, in regards to these Comachero bikies in our underground road systems. Anyway, I'd like to tell them how this system works because I can't see how it can possibly.
00:52:59
Speaker 1: Go to them.
00:53:00
Speaker 13: I went to them a few years back and said there's been a huge cover-up in our toxic algae bloom in our two gulfs and that Lucy Hood and Peter Malmaskas received a letter from 20 scientists, signed by 20 scientists, asking for a mere, and this letter was going back probably four or five years ago, asking for a mere $ 14 million to be able to contain it and to study it. Well, obviously this didn't happen, but then I went on and said, but then we got inundated with a Professor Steer who said that everything's going to be okay and that it'll dissipate in time. Well, then Professor Steer, about six months later, said only once, I have been given wrong information and I'm afraid that this is out of control and we can do nothing about this at all. It's something like 6,000 square kilometres in size. Now, we never heard back from Professor Steer, even though he was on nearly every 10, 15 minutes on nearly every station in the suburbs. Anyway... I told this to the Corruption Commission. They said, unfortunately, Ken, what's happening is that politicians introduced another commission, and it's called the Integrity Commission. And you have to go through the Integrity Commission, and they have to okay it.
00:54:42
Speaker 8: To us.
00:54:43
Speaker 13: So in other words, really, the Integrity Commission is in control of ICAC. And if they okay it, then we can start investigating. So I told the integrity commission all about it, and they said, well, look, we'll check it out. And about two or three weeks later, I received a letter from them saying, unfortunately, we don't think that this is a corrupt type of situation and that.
00:55:19
Speaker 13: We're not going to give it to the Corruption Commission. And then the letter went on, and then it said that the Integrity Commission has no investigative powers whatsoever. So in other words, how can they investigate anything that may be corrupt and send it on to the Corruption Commission when they don't have any investigative powers whatsoever? In my opinion, this integrity commission was introduced by the politicians themselves, and I believe it's just a jelly bean there to protect the naughty boys and girls in politics.
00:56:02
Speaker 1: Good on you, Ken. Thanks for your input. And Harry at Hallett Cove. G'day, Harry.
00:56:06
Speaker 14: G'day, Graeme.
00:56:07
Speaker 18: I hope you and the listeners are well. You sound well.
00:56:11
Speaker 1: Oh, we're good. We're battling through it all.
00:56:15
Speaker 13: Can you confirm?
00:56:15
Speaker 1: Can confirm. A-OK.
00:56:18
Speaker 18: And I'll second Ken on his comments on 5AA. You're doing a great job for the state of South Australia. It's a pity that
there's not more of it going on around Australia, Graeme. We talk back because you allow people to have their say. And if you don't agree with them, you've got the dump button. So, you know, that's the thing. And Yeah, I refer to that graffiti on the West Terrace Cemetery wall there, Graeme. Yeah, geez.
00:56:48
Speaker 1: You'd think I don't know the situation. I haven't seen it. But you would move quickly to remove it because apparently the quicker you remove it, the less they like it because the graffiti artists put so much work into it. They love to admire their work. And if it's removed within 24 hours, they get upset and move on.
00:57:05
Speaker 18: Yes, exactly, and those words are quite chilling, and unfortunately there's some truth behind those words. But anyway, Graeme, with the Labour staffer that rang up earlier talking about how ETSA was sold off by the Liberal Party, well, as you know, Graeme, and you pointed out, and I'm glad you did, We all know the reason why ETSA was sold off, along with all the other assets, was to pay the debt after the state was bankrupted by the Labour Party back in, and you pointed out to me and Sammy, 1991. when the state bank collapsed.
00:57:43
Speaker 23: Yep.
00:57:44
Speaker 18: And all the assets of South Australia were up for sale from that point on. And even when the Liberal Party got voted out, the Labor Party kept it going. And now they've even, well, as you know, Graeme, the Lance Titles office has been privatised. And when you think about the privatisation of that, I have very real suspicions about the privatisation of that, especially the digitising of all of the records. And as you know, with digital records, Graeme, they can be scrubbed and ordered at will. But when records are on paper, they're on paper. And there's usually lots and lots of copies of them. But digital records can be ordered. And, of course, the United Kingdom voted against privatising their lands titled... Lance told his office on the grounds of national security rights.
00:58:37
Speaker 1: Yeah, we obviously felt differently about it here. Good on you, Harry. Thanks for your call. Back after news headlines. 5AA Mornings with Graham Goodings. 27 minutes to 11. 5AA this Tuesday morning, 27th day of October. On the text line. carol says there isn't a communist involved in this protest young people are intelligent and passionate i don't agree with the timing of it but it's not a communist plot thank you for that carol yeah the timing is the issue isn't it there are 365 days in the year and they've chosen one of the most solemn days on the Australian calendar, Remembrance Day, and that's the day that they've chosen to hold their protest. A day earlier, day after, we'd like to think it is just an accident. If it's an accident, well, just change the date. If it's not an accident and they're doing it purposefully, well, that is an absolute disgrace. Craig says, oh, we spoke to Craig earlier. He said he paid $ 500 for a tank of fuel. Uh, he's texted back in again, main tank and sub tank, 90 liters each, 180 liters by $ 2, 90 per liter equals $ 522 out of control. Craig, you have summed it up. As I said, it might be cheaper to fly where you want to go than drive in the vehicle. And that's a sad state of affairs. Well, it's just a reflection of what's happening in society. Unfortunately, um, you know, right across the nation. And one of the biggest factors, of course, is when it comes to home buying. I mean, the great Aussie dream of owning your own home appears to be getting further away. Adelaide buyers need $ 167, 000 salary to afford a home. I don't need to go into statistics with you at the moment, but it's a situation, even though housing prices have come down to some degree, the ability to get into housing is becoming more and more difficult. and we were talking about it on the show yesterday. And joining me in the studio now is Saviour Finance's Vincent Scully. Vincent, good morning to you. Thanks for your time today. Good morning, Graeme. Now, in light of what we were talking about, you have a home lay-by plan. How does that work?
01:00:39
Speaker 24: Well, Graeme, it's been 10 years in the making. A home lay-by plan is a bit like the old-fashioned lay-by. When you and I were kids, we didn't have any money to buy anything outright, so we'd go down to the shop and out, put a guernsey or a jacket on lay-by, and when we finish paying for it, we'd take possession of it. This is very similar. We're asking parents to help their children, and what we do is we put a unit trust together with multiple people, and they can take an option to take the property out. But the beauty is, you know, we start them young because, as you know, the younger you start, the cheaper the price. As you go down the track, the prices get dearer. So we want to help people, whilst they're young, save up for their home.
01:01:24
Speaker 1: So how does this differ, and I can tell it does, but from parents who just sort of got struggling kids and they chip in and say, here's your deposit or here's some money?
01:01:34
Speaker 24: Well, that's too late because it's already the home's increased by 10 years, by $ 10, 000, $ 50, 000, $ 100, 000. If we do it this way, the parents actually borrow the money so they can actually get a tax deduction. And we've got in such a way that we can transfer the units in that trust to the child before it becomes taxable on capital gains. In other words, we get it below the threshold. So the thing is the parents get the tax deduction and the child gets the capital gain. It's in a unit trust, so therefore they're not liable for the, debt of the unit trust itself. They're the only debt for the $ 50, 000 they've borrowed to go into the property.
01:02:19
Speaker 1: So how does it become a tax deduction for the parents?
01:02:23
Speaker 24: Well, because they've invested in a property. And under the new Act, you can still do it in new homes only. So, you know, say, for
example, Virginia, Mount Barker, all these new areas, we can buy a home in there and still get a tax deduction. And also on top of that, there's a thing called so they can claim a depreciation on the asset. But the parents being the guarantors of that loan, the unit trust is separate from the parents, so they're not liable for the total debt of the house. They're only liable for the $ 50, 000 or $ 100, 000 that they put into it.
01:02:59
Speaker 1: Sounds like a great concept. Why has there never been anything like this before? No one's ever thought of it except me, I suppose.
01:03:06
Speaker 24: We had a very similar product called Deposit Saviour, And that worked very well until prices increased dramatically. But back 10, 15 years ago, we were doing that. We had a friendly bank manager and we'd take young people to the bank and get them, in those days, $ 30, 000 to $ 40, 000 loan. They would pay off that loan whilst the house has been rented out. And therefore, once they paid off that loan, they had an equity in the property that and the property was being paid by the tenants, and then they took possession of it. And that's how a lot of my clients got a foot into buying a house.
01:03:46
Speaker 1: So is there any downside to the home lay-by plan? Not that I can see.
01:03:50
Speaker 24: The beauty is that, you know, I've got... a product called reverse mortgages. You've probably heard me advertising it. I've got people in their 70s and 80s. In their 80s, they've still got mortgages. So that's the issue. Let's get them while they're young so when they're 70 and 80, they don't have to have a mortgage. And with prices the way they have gone, you know what it's like.
01:04:13
Speaker 1: Yeah, most certainly. So there'll be people listening sort of say reverse mortgage. How does that work?
01:04:19
Speaker 24: Well, reverse mortgage is basically you can have two mortgages. types of reverse mortgages you can have your house paid for and you can get an advance out of your property. Or in some cases, and in a lot of cases, I had a lady, 74 years old. She still had a $ 140, 000 mortgage. We were terrified when she found out she was living on her credit card for food because all her money was was going into the mortgage and she was living off her credit card. She got to the maximum. She heard the advert, rang me up. I cleared her credit card and her reverse mortgage and she didn't have to make any further payments because with a reverse mortgage, the interest is compounded and it's only payable back when you sell the property or when you go to the other side.
01:05:05
Speaker 1: So step us through a reverse mortgage. If someone sort of says, times are tough, I've got equity in my house. I own it outright or whatever. What do they do?
01:05:14
Speaker 24: Well, I'll give you another example. A young lady, when she was 16, bought a block of land for $ 1, 750 out northeast.
01:05:25
Speaker 1: Must have been a long time ago, Vince.
01:05:26
Speaker 11: It
was.
01:05:26
Speaker 1: It was a very.
01:05:27
Speaker 24: Long time ago. And she built a home with her husband when she got married for.
01:05:32
Speaker 1: $ 14, 000.
01:05:33
Speaker 24: Mortgage-free for 35 years. Her husband died. They didn't have any super. She was living on single pension. Unfortunately, her council rates are $ 2, 500, house insurance.
01:05:45
Speaker 1: $ 2, 000, car insurance $.
01:05:46
Speaker 24: 1, 200, need I go on, electricity, et cetera, et cetera. She had nothing to live on. Even though she didn't owe any money on a home, she rang me. She said, I need some money. How can I do it? And I said, we'll get you a mortgage, a reverse mortgage on your property, which means that you can Rest assured, you can draw down any time. So she was drawing $ 1, 000 a month to supplement her pension. And it doesn't affect Centrelink payments at all.
01:06:15
Speaker 1: Is that right? And so is there a limit on the amount that you can use in a reverse mortgage?
01:06:20
Speaker 24: Yes, there's a formula, and that is at 60, you can borrow 20% and 1% increments. Now, for example, I've had three people in their 80s. At 80, they can borrow 40%. of the value of their home because your lifespan's shorter. So it goes in a trajectory if you understand what I'm talking about. And that's the beauty of it. You can never be kicked out. You can never have your house repossessed. It's legislated that you can never, ever lose your home.
01:06:52
Speaker 1: But anyone would need to get advice, wouldn't they? I mean, you'd need to do it through professional channels.
01:06:58
Speaker 24: What we do is under the Act, they've got to go and seek independent legal advice, which we supply the names of solicitors, and they go there and get the final advice after we do a valuation on their home, et cetera, et cetera.
01:07:12
Speaker 1: Well, Vince, you've given people a lot to think about. If anyone wants more information, get in touch with Save Your Finance.
01:07:18
Speaker 24: Save Your Financial Services, 1300 999 8886.
01:07:20
Speaker 1: Good on you, Vincent. Vincent Scarley, talking us through reverse mortgages and the home lay-by plan. Back shortly. 14 minutes to 11, 5AA. Beautiful morning in Adelaide. Hope you enjoy it. Still on the chilly side, 17 degrees at the moment. On the text line, I had a reverse mortgage through Centrelink a few years ago. It was quick and easy. I'm a pensioner. Thank you very much for that. And I believe this protest on the 11th is deliberate. They target iconic locations like our Sydney Harbour Bridge and Sydney Opera House. I'd love you to find out who is behind these protests. I mentioned Bondi, but it's probably inappropriate. And Robert says the November 11th Remembrance Day protests are mainly organized by the HSC, high school anti-capitalists, who work closely with the organization The Socialist Alternative. So you end up with hard-done-by students filming their protest on $ 2, 000 iPhones in their $ 200 Nikes, bemoaning how hard-done-by they are, and then off home to their AC homes. I hear what you're saying, Robert. I hear what you're saying. Well, the RSPCA has launched its new Keep Them Safe, Keep Them Home campaign. To tell us about it is Izzy Drew. Izzy, good morning to you.
01:08:38
Speaker 5: Morning, Graeme.
01:08:39
Speaker 1: What is this campaign aimed at? Cats, I believe.
01:08:44
Speaker 25: The campaign is full of online resources to help support people and their cats transition to an indoor-only life.
01:08:53
Speaker 1: So up until now, and rightly so, a lot of people are concerned because we love our cats, but they are natural predators. When they get outside, they can cause a lot of mischief to native flora and fauna.
01:09:07
Speaker 11: That's right.
01:09:07
Speaker 25: Yeah, they certainly do pose a risk to our native wildlife, but also there are a lot of dangers in the community to them, such as cars, diseases, including bird flu, which has come up a lot recently, but also fighting with other cats and, yeah, like you say, getting caught up in other mischief out in the community.
01:09:26
Speaker 1: You mentioned bird flu. Has there been any noticeable impact by the bird flu at this stage?
01:09:32
Speaker 25: I couldn't comment on that.
01:09:33
Speaker 15: Yeah.
01:09:34
Speaker 1: So what do you do other than highlighting to people you keep your cats indoors? What are the elements of your campaign?
01:09:43
Speaker 25: So the aim is to educate owners about how an indoor-only life can be fulfilling and enriching for your cats. Although indoor-only is much safer for them, we do still need to meet their species-specific needs. So educating owners about what they can provide their cat to make sure that that transition is as smooth as possible and their cat lives a happy life inside.
01:10:05
Speaker 1: Unfortunately, when cats become feral, they adapt pretty well to the climate and the environment and, you know, they... grow in increasing numbers. Is there much that can be done about that?
01:10:18
Speaker 25: Certainly pet owners keeping their cats contained is really important. Also owners making sure that their cats are desexed and microchipped is an important piece of the puzzle.
01:10:28
Speaker 1: And can you put a number of stray cats that go through the RSPCA?
01:10:34
Speaker 25: So we had over 1,200 stray cats come through the shelter in the last financial year so that's quite a large number.
01:10:43
Speaker 1: Yeah, so what sort of feedback do you get from people? I mean, cat lovers, you know, they might have had a cat for 10 or 12 years and you're suggesting that they keep it indoors. Are you getting any negative feedback?
01:10:55
Speaker 25: In terms of making that transition into inside?
01:10:58
Speaker 23: Yeah.
01:11:00
Speaker 25: Yeah, so I think people understandably can be worried about their cat's welfare with such a huge lifestyle change, but the campaign is aimed at providing education for for
owners to understand how we can still meet their species-specific needs inside. So there are a few important things, like making sure they have access to opportunities to scratch and engage in play and predatory behaviour inside, obviously with toys, not actual animals, and making sure they have plenty of safe spaces, including high places to climb and other activities that they might engage with outside.
01:11:37
Speaker 1: So if people want more information on your campaign, how do they get that?
01:11:42
Speaker 25: They can head to our website and see the Keeping Cats Safe at Home campaign.
01:11:48
Speaker 1: Izzy, thanks so much for your time today, and we wish you well with your campaign. Are you a cat lover? How do you feel about keeping your cat locked up? I can understand why you wouldn't be too happy about it, but in the environment, cats are natural predators. They get outside and birds are not safe. Other native creatures are not safe. Maybe if they get the mice, we're not so concerned about that. But there is a lot of concern. So keep your cats indoors. Let's take a call. Daryl, good morning.
01:12:18
Speaker 26: Good morning, Graeme. Always good to hear your voice on 5AA. Listen, Graeme, Mr Picton was on earlier this morning, and I've never met an organisation. I've got to say, I'm totally confused. They're the only people that can, if something is black, they can make it white. His forecast for this GP, and obviously it's the only thing he's worrying about, he's not worrying about the millions of dollars that his government has wasted in this.
01:12:53
Speaker 21: State over the past.
01:12:54
Speaker 26: But, you know, if you want to go and get a lion in a business, Graeme, You have to justify yourself, and right now it's very, very hard to, you know, even get an additional loan for a service vehicle. But, you know, do your sum. We've got a magnificent regional facility out there at Tail and Bend, and why won't he sit down and listen to people that believe that is the best option for our state? It's unreal. I know, you know, in the passenger transport, he just put the passenger levy up to $ 2. 10 from $ 2, and it's going up and up and up. But, you know, he thinks he's got the magic wand.
01:13:46
Speaker 1: Yeah, but, Daryl, Daryl, let's hang on for a second. This MotoGP, why is it coming to South Australia? They're not bringing it. They want it to have a street circuit. They don't want to have it out in the regions. You know, the shortfall of that is you're not going to get... All you'll get to a MotoGP at the bend are the aficionados, those who are desperate, who love motorbike racing. But in the city, you're going to get a lot of people who have got a casual interest. You're going to get five times as many people go to a MotoGP on a city circuit as they would to the bend.
01:14:18
Speaker 26: Graeme, how many days is the race going to be going for?
01:14:23
Speaker 1: Three days.
01:14:23
Speaker 26: So it's going to go for three days. So it's going to shut down the city for how long to prepare it?
01:14:30
Speaker 1: Well, it won't shut down the city. About a week or so when.
01:14:33
Speaker 26: They shut off. Graeme, with all respect to everyone that believes in it, the thing is, it's economy. You know, the points that I was just making, you're in business. and you're trying to grow your business, but you can't because the sales, the tourism isn't there. Now, this is 365... There.
01:14:55
Speaker 1: Would be tourism with a MotoGP, surely, though. That'll bring people in.
01:14:58
Speaker 26: Three days. Okay, great.
01:15:01
Speaker 21: You know, it mentions, but guess what?
01:15:03
Speaker 26: South Australia spends millions of dollars promoting our regions.
01:15:08
Speaker 19: Why?
01:15:09
Speaker 26: Because they are the gold of our South Australian economy.
01:15:13
Speaker 7: Now.
01:15:14
Speaker 26: We've got something out there in Tarlem Ben is absolutely brilliant.
01:15:18
Speaker 19: Yeah.
01:15:18
Speaker 26: You know, we can bring all the houseboats down. We can do a massive amount of good for regional South Australia. And guess what? People still come to Adelaide to go to it. They go to Melbourne and then they've got to go out to Phillip Island.
01:15:32
Speaker 1: So why do you think the government have done this then? If your theory is correct, why have the government turned their back on the bend?
01:15:40
Speaker 26: Well, why would you when it's already established? You don't have to spend anything but promote it.
01:15:46
Speaker 1: So if your theory is correct, why haven't the government decided to stage it at tail and bend?
01:15:51
Speaker 26: Well, there's an electorate boundary around the city of Adelaide and that's all they care. They don't care about South Australia. He's wasted millions of dollars throughout this state. He's not doing anything in the region.
01:16:04
Speaker 1: So would you like to see the supercars, the BP Grand Final, move to Tail and Bend too?
01:16:11
Speaker 26: That would be absolutely... Look, it was Labor.
01:16:13
Speaker 21: That brought it back in. Let's face it.
01:16:16
Speaker 26: Let's see it out there. Yeah, let's go step one and bring it... I've already had a race out there, Graeme.
01:16:22
Speaker 23: You know?
01:16:22
Speaker 1: You don't get the same... You're not going to get the same sort of crowds at the bend. Let's face it. It doesn't have the facilities. I mean, in the city, people come from interstate and overseas. There's hotels, there's restaurants, there's a big attraction, and that's part of the appeal.
01:16:35
Speaker 26: Well, Graeme, I was in a function just two weeks ago... I won't name her, beautiful investment into the city of Adelaide. And the staff have already been put on casual. You know, this is what I'm saying, Graeme. Look, I'm not going to deny investment in South Australia that's going to benefit the state. But sheer fact is, you know, we're talking about three days.
We're talking about another 90 million bucks. Did I hear today we're now going to have fixed grandstands in the city of Adelaide? Is that correct?
01:17:10
Speaker 1: Fixed grandstands?
01:17:12
Speaker 26: No, I don't believe that. They're not going to pull them down and put them up. I heard this today. I thought in the conversation he said we're going to have fixed grandstands.
01:17:24
Speaker 1: No, temporary grandstands.
01:17:26
Speaker 26: They are temporary?
01:17:27
Speaker 21: Yeah.
01:17:27
Speaker 11: Okay.
01:17:28
Speaker 26: Look, Graeme. I just encourage people to, you know, you've got to cross your T's and dot your I's. Regional area out there, they'll spend millions at Monado. Look, there's a lot of potential in that region to grow it.
01:17:43
Speaker 1: Look, a final word, Daryl, is the reason that it's coming to Adelaide is because it's a street circuit. The MotoGP people want a street circuit somewhere around the world. They've got one here in Adelaide. So you might want it at the bend, but it isn't going to happen, was never going to happen.
01:18:00
Speaker 7: Craig, good morning.
01:18:02
Speaker 21: Hey, Diddy, just one quick thing. Everyone needs to realise the Benz is privately owned. The government doesn't own it, it's private. But the Shaheens, they own it, they built it, it's theirs. You can't just tell them that you're having the Grand Prix.
01:18:19
Speaker 9: That's just ridiculous.
01:18:20
Speaker 1: Well, I think they're... Sorry. I don't know the Shaheens that well, but I believe that they were part of the reason that the MotoGP is coming to Adelaide, and they understand the limitations of the bend, and that it couldn't host an event of that magnitude.
01:18:36
Speaker 21: It's privately owned. The government just can't say we want it there. I know what you're saying, but the government can't just tell the Shahin, oh, we're going to have a race at your track.
01:18:46
Speaker 1: Well, we're going down a different path, but I would say if the government went... to the Shaheens and said, we want to hold it there, they would, open arms, would say, yeah, we'd love to have it here. But I think they appreciate that it really needs to be held in the city. Good on you, Craig. Thanks for your call. Jim, good morning.
01:19:01
Speaker 11: Good morning, Graeme. I sort of agree with the caller just then, the one before, the one previous to the caller, about the no money gets spent in the regions. But I agree with you also. That race would look really good on telly and around the world in the city. Tail and Ben's goodness, Shetia, Shetia is a wonderful people. Spend a lot of money out Malala and profit into the community. But I think it sort of belongs. If we're going to have it, the city is a place for it, unfortunately.
01:19:26
Speaker 8: Yeah.
01:19:27
Speaker 23: But what I want to.
01:19:28
Speaker 11: Talk about, Graeme, It's big things, and first of all, I like a big thing. I like a big koala and a big prawn and a
big oyster and all, but I looked at the big sultana, and he could be a big walnut, or he could be a big date, or he could be a lot of big things.
01:19:41
Speaker 13: He's pretty generic.
01:19:42
Speaker 8: Could be a big turd, too.
01:19:49
Speaker 11: I don't like the big Ned Kelly, Graeme. I think we should have a big John Flynn or a big Weary Dunlop before a big Ned Kelly. I mean, they got rid of him in 1880, and my house was built in 1882, and it's not that long ago to be celebrating an Irish cop killer. But that being said, I want to talk about feral cats, Graeme.
01:20:06
Speaker 1: Yeah.
01:20:07
Speaker 11: Now, no offence to the RSPCA or Animal Welfare League, about two months back, we got some cats dumped out here, mother cat with kittens. The girl was like all cat crazy. She rung every cat organisation. We couldn't get hold of any cat traps to catch them to take them to them or any support. And I had to do something I don't like to do and I shouldn't really talk about on the wireless, but I had to dispose of the cats. Because a female cat will just keep having kittens, like you said, and they'll obviously love once, but gone feral.
01:20:35
Speaker 12: Yeah.
01:20:36
Speaker 11: And they damage the wildlife. But they weren't interested. They said, oh, we've got inundated with cat season. We can't help you. Not even the Port Prairie Council were trapped to catch a cat humanely.
01:20:46
Speaker 19: Yeah.
01:20:47
Speaker 1: Good on you, Jim. Yeah, thanks for your contribution. Regarding the bend, Andrea says, doesn't the government not own the bend? Double negative there. No, it's owned by the Shaheen family. And, uh, somebody says the bend only brought approximately 40,000 people versus 200,000 people to the city race. And that's exactly it. Andrew says, even the Shaheens who own the bend helped in negotiations to bring MotoGP to the Adelaide CBD. I thought that was the case. Uh, hi Graham. When the MotoGP was held on a dedicated racing circuit for 30 years, the organizers suddenly want a street circuit because malicious, sorry, uh, um, Because something wants a street circuit and ensured it was a condition of the contract. Oh, yes, I think you mean the Premier. Wants a street circuit and ensured it was a condition of the contract. Thank you for that, Dave. Back after the news.
01:21:43
Speaker 8: 5AA Mornings with Graham Goodings.
01:21:45
Speaker 1: 10 past 11, 5AA on this Tuesday morning, 27th day of October. Well, data centres are in the news on an ever-increasing basis. Australia is keen to get them here. South Australia is very keen to get them here. Public opposition has grown, particularly overseas. Research has shown that 56% of Americans are opposed to local data centres, while 60% are uncomfortable with a new facility in their area. And I think that would be reflected pretty much here in Australia. There's community concern over the state government's push for a particular data centre. It's a multi-billion dollar data centre at Tunkillo. and locals are concerned about it. With more than 700 residents showing an online protest group within days of the plan emerging, the development would include a major electricity substation, battery storage, and 400 megawatts of gas-fired backup generation. Joining me now in the studio is Tunkillo local Maurice Collins. Maurice, good morning. Thanks for dropping by.
01:22:47
Speaker 8: Good morning.
01:22:47
Speaker 1: It's great to be here.
01:22:49
Speaker 27: I'm glad to be able to put some of the reasons why we wouldn't want it.
01:22:52
Speaker 1: Yeah, so tell us, why are you concerned about it?
01:22:55
Speaker 27: Well, number one is the environmental impact, and we're talking about the birds, the wildlife, the stock that run on the country, and all those things associated with it, and the impact even on the trees there, the bushes, and the fact there is no water.
01:23:15
Speaker 1: And, I mean, it's taking a considerable area, 220 hectares, I see.
01:23:20
Speaker 27: Well, this is a block of land that came up for sale because somebody... died it is in the market.
01:23:27
Speaker 1: So what was the land used for up until.
01:23:29
Speaker 27: Now it was used for grazing for cattle and sheep and the guy was a butcher anyway so he bred his own stock yeah high quality arable land no it's hilly country yeah so it's a good grazing land yeah and there's not a whole lot of it in this country is there basically no there's not and it's at the moment it just looks so good.
01:23:53
Speaker 1: So what stage are they i mean the developer is quantum dc have they made contact with the local community.
01:24:00
Speaker 27: No that's going to happen thursday evening and saturday at manum.
01:24:04
Speaker 1: And what major concerns will you be putting to.
01:24:07
Speaker 27: Them oh the major concerns are that it's visible from where i live yeah and the environmental impact with the noise that humming noise and being a quiet country it just goes for miles.
01:24:20
Speaker 1: And as we know full well, data centres consume huge amounts of power. What are they going to do for that?
01:24:26
Speaker 27: Well, at the moment, there's a 275 kilowatt KVA line runs bright past through the country.
01:24:33
Speaker 1: So that's part of the reason probably they wanted to build there.
01:24:36
Speaker 27: Yeah, and then this gas turbine thing, well, not sure how that's going to work because it's at least 10 kilometres or more to where they've got to bring it from.
01:24:45
Speaker 23: Right.
01:24:45
Speaker 1: So they need gas as backup, obviously.
01:24:47
Speaker 19: Yeah.
01:24:48
Speaker 27: I don't know why they want that, no.
01:24:50
Speaker 11: Yeah.
01:24:51
Speaker 1: Well, the thing is with data centres is they need power 24-7. They can't have any downtime. And in a state that's so reliant on renewable energy, when the sun isn't shining and the wind isn't blowing, they've got to get their power from somewhere. That's why they
need gas.
01:25:06
Speaker 27: That's right. But they're going to disrupt how many farms on the way to get it there.
01:25:11
Speaker 8: Yeah.
01:25:11
Speaker 1: And then, of course, there's the issue of water. These data centres need huge amounts of water for cooling.
01:25:17
Speaker 8: Well, you're right.
01:25:17
Speaker 27: At the moment... The creek looks good, the dams are full and everything like that, but when the summer's there, there's nothing in them.
01:25:25
Speaker 12: Yeah.
01:25:25
Speaker 27: And there's no underground water, and there's no pipeline within at least six kilometres.
01:25:32
Speaker 1: So, obviously, 700 residents, would that be about the population of Tunkello and surrounds? Oh, it's gone beyond that already.
01:25:40
Speaker 11: Yeah.
01:25:42
Speaker 14: Yeah.
01:25:42
Speaker 1: And they're speaking with one voice. Is anyone sort of saying this would be great for the area?
01:25:47
Speaker 27: Absolutely not.
01:25:49
Speaker 11: Yeah.
01:25:49
Speaker 1: So, I mean, you haven't had talks with them at this stage. The bottom line is, you know, what's in it for the people of Tunkillo?
01:25:58
Speaker 27: Well, I guess we'll see a bit of blood money happening around the place to shut us up.
01:26:04
Speaker 14: Yeah.
01:26:06
Speaker 1: Who's your local member?
01:26:07
Speaker 27: We've got One Nation took that seat in the last election here in South Australia, and I see a post he put up this morning that not accepting it as being a reasonable thing to be putting in that sort of land.
01:26:21
Speaker 1: So the local member is against oh absolutely yeah well that's something what what about the the federal member do you know who that is uh no i don't putting it on the test that's a bit of they wouldn't be in agreeance with it for where it is surely not so um are you against data centers all all together or just i.
01:26:39
Speaker 27: Believe it's a play for data centers i think the one they're building at borough it's in a place where it's not very good country. What they're going to do for water, I don't know. What they're going to do for power, I don't know. But what are they going to do with the wastewater? Well, yeah, that's another question.
01:26:58
Speaker 22: That's right.
01:26:58
Speaker 1: So I guess Quantum DC will answer some of your questions, but they're going to have to have a pretty good case to convince you.
01:27:06
Speaker 27: I don't think you'll convince any of the people on that list of people that don't want it.
01:27:12
Speaker 1: You were mentioning not far away at Palmer there's a massive wind farm.
01:27:16
Speaker 27: Absolutely, and those towers are going to be 240 metres high.
01:27:19
Speaker 8: Wow.
01:27:21
Speaker 27: And they've started work on doing that now, and it's going to be on the skyline.
01:27:29
Speaker 26: Yeah.
01:27:30
Speaker 1: And what area will that be taking up?
01:27:32
Speaker 27: Oh, it's on probably three or four farms over a distance of probably five
or six kilometres.
01:27:40
Speaker 1: And once again, would that be good farming land?
01:27:43
Speaker 27: No, that's getting to be more moderate land because the rainfall drops by an inch every mile there.
01:27:49
Speaker 8: Right.
01:27:50
Speaker 1: So it's not so critical. It's grazing country.
01:27:53
Speaker 8: It's very rocky.
01:27:54
Speaker 14: Yeah.
01:27:54
Speaker 1: So there's blasting. So are you against wind farms? I love wind farms.
01:27:59
Speaker 28: Yeah.
01:28:00
Speaker 1: If they're in the right place. And this isn't the right place?
01:28:03
Speaker 27: It's definitely not the right place because there's so many small farmers that are going to be affected by it.
01:28:09
Speaker 1: So there is a meeting with the developer, Quantum DC. What is likely to happen? Assuming that you're not comfortable with what they're coming up with, will you make an approach to the state government?
01:28:23
Speaker 27: I'm sure there'll be an approach to the state government in the future, yes.
01:28:27
Speaker 1: If they're listening now, what would you say to them?
01:28:29
Speaker 27: Can the whole thing. You can't can that wind farm. That's already in motion. But this one here has been held very tightly to their chests. And then again, came out this week that what was going to happen on that land.
01:28:43
Speaker 1: Well, Maurice, thanks for dropping by and hopefully you'll get the result you want and maybe we'll have a chat to you after the meeting.
01:28:49
Speaker 27: Yeah, and just on that, the electromagnetic effects, not just on stock or birds or animals, on people. It's going to radiate out from there who knows how far.
01:29:03
Speaker 12: Right.
01:29:03
Speaker 1: Yeah, well, that's another thing that we need to consider. Maurice, thanks for coming in. No worries. Thank you for the interview.
01:29:10
Speaker 14: Yeah.
01:29:10
Speaker 1: What do you think, folks? Maurice Collins from Tunkillo. How would you feel the data centre set up close to you? Whether you think data centres are good things or bad things, what are your feelings? Would you like one set up very close to you, destroying your environment, creating a lot of noise? sucking up lots of power, using lots of water. Ah, yes, the dreams of data centres. And you may recall we were speaking to Richard Dennis yesterday who said, you know, the elephant in the room is the fact that for every data centre you put in, there'll be a lot of people left out of work.
01:29:48
Speaker 29: I think artificial intelligence, like all technological change, has the potential to increase productivity and improve our lives. But unlike most technologies, the business case for AI is to cause mass unemployment. The only reason that companies like Anthropic and OpenAI are estimated to be worth a trillion dollars is because those companies are literally betting, their investors are literally betting, that their technology will displace hundreds of millions of people around the world.
01:30:23
Speaker 1: Richard Dennis, who spoke on this program yesterday, David says data centre owners are starting to collapse in the United States, which begs the question, what is the long-term benefit for Australia? Your thoughts, give us a call, 8223 0000.
01:30:38
Speaker 8: 21 minutes past 11, 5AA.
01:30:45
Speaker 1: Your calls, if you wish. Give us a chat. Have a chat with us. 8223 0000. Maybe it's on data centres. Maybe it's on the cashless society. Maybe it's on the MotoGP. We're hearing on an almost daily basis, older and less digitally savvy people are increasingly being left behind as essential services migrate entirely to apps and smartphones. You know, booking, medical... bill payments, banking, government access, you all got to do it on an app or a smartphone. Saw this on social media. It was stated by Claudio Sargiamaris, who's a lawyer from Rio de Janeiro. He said this, a society that forces a 90-year-old to use a smartphone in order to access basic rights is not a modern society. It is a society that has decided to cast aside its own elders. By 2026, everything has become an app, a code, a portal. Yet the very people who built this country with their own hands now find themselves illiterate in their own homes. If booking a medical appointment or paying a bill requires the help of a son or granddaughter, assuming there is one, then the system has failed. This is not innovation, it is exclusion. Technology should serve people, not determine who is still entitled to dignity. When we leave behind those who came before us, we are not evolving, we are merely becoming more comfortable and more selfish. Society should make sure older people and those who struggle with technology aren't left out. Keep simple options open. Let people book doctor's visits or pay bills by phone, use paper forms, visit a real counter, or pay with cash. Design apps and websites that are easier, bigger text, clearer buttons, voice help. Offer free classes to teach seniors the basics. Give them cheap phones or tablets if needed. Make companies and government keep both digital and non-digital ways available. Technology should help everyone, not force people to depend on family just to manage everyday life. The words of Claudio Sagiamers, a lawyer in Rio de Janeiro, and I think it rings true to this day. We are in a transitionary period. In 15, 20 years' time, it won't matter that there are no mechanical accesses to banks, no cash and the like, because we'll have all transitioned to it. But at the moment, we're in that period where there are a lot of people who aren't digitally savvy, who aren't comfortable with smartphones, who don't want to use them, who want to use cash, who want to talk to a real person, who are being left behind. And it's time we considered those people. Robert says, can you name a project in SA any time where someone didn't organise a protest? Good or bad, they are all lumped into the same basket and nothing would happen if all these
naysayers get their way. Well, I think data centres that need excessively large amounts of water and power are not practical in our state. I also get tired of the constant stream of automatic no to every last thing that's proposed in this state. Take your point to a point, Robert. I think you make it pretty well. But I think there are legitimate concerns over data centres. What do you think? The governments that are hell-bent on destroying the environment, flora, fauna, water supply and farmland of this no longer great country, all for the almighty dollar, be it sport or data centres. After the animals and the environment goes, we are next. Leanne, I really hope you're wrong. The number to ring if you have a comment, 8223 0000. Well, former U.S. President Barack Obama has made the news recently, having a crack at the current president, Donald Trump.
01:34:28
Speaker 8: I don't know if.
01:34:29
Speaker 28: You've noticed, but he seems very focused on home renovations. Guys building a ballroom that's bigger than the White House. paved over the rose garden put a helicopter pad on the south lawn and and there's gold everywhere what's up with the gold everything more gold he's got the white ass looking like saddam hussein opened a cheesecake.
01:34:53
Speaker 1: Factory former u.s president barack obama well donald trump has finally got around to hearing about it and has made this response.
01:35:02
Speaker 4: I fix things very good very I always build beautiful and inexpensive, which is a good combination if you can do it.
01:35:10
Speaker 7: But I can do it naturally.
01:35:11
Speaker 4: It's a natural thing. It actually relaxes me. Donald Trump spends a lot of his time fixing up the White House.
01:35:19
Speaker 8: Isn't that a nice thing to do?
01:35:21
Speaker 4: The place?
01:35:25
Speaker 14: No.
01:35:29
Speaker 4: He said, this isn't a cheesecake factory, can you believe it? Which is a very successful company. This isn't, he doesn't like successful companies. But, you know, he was very critical about me.
01:35:40
Speaker 8: Ah, dear, oh, dear.
01:35:43
Speaker 1: The to-ing and fro-ing between an ex-president and the current president. On the text line, David says, the Palmer wind farms are on country full of moss rocks. The effect on large birds that soar in the area, like wedge-tailed eagles, will be killed. Why don't they stick data centres way out in the bush, the unused desert lands, build their own power and water infrastructure? Well, they don't want to, do they? They want to build it close to the current infrastructure. That will keep their costs down. It will lower the tone of the environment. I mean, if you've heard some of these data centres, the noise that they put out, the low-level hum that would resonate for kilometres around, the fact that they're going to use so much water and power, And what is the real benefit to us? Now, I know while they're being built, there is a lot of benefit, a lot of employment, particularly electricians who can't work on other projects around the nation. And that is good. But once they're built, once they're up and running, the numbers of people needed to run them are minuscule. These are overseas-owned data centres. Where will their profits go? And have we been told how much they'll be taxed as yet? But we're hell-bent on getting these data centres here. The state government is very keen. Federal government is very keen. But have we looked closely into this enough? And as I said before, in the US, there is growing concern about data centres, and I think that the groundswell will start here. We haven't heard the last of it. Carlo, good morning.
01:37:11
Speaker 13: Good morning, Graeme.
01:37:13
Speaker 19: Look, I've just had an issue with Plenty Finance. They're the ones that give us finance to do these battery solar panel installations through the government scheme. And I tried to get them to send me paperwork so I could make payments arrangements, and they refused. They said that I have to go online, otherwise they can't do anything.
01:37:38
Speaker 1: So you've got no alternative?
01:37:40
Speaker 19: Well, I said to him, I said, I've got to wait for my son to come 100 kilometres away from Balaclava, where the battery was installed, to come here in Gillis Plains for him to do my email. Because I don't know how to do email. They said they were going to send it to me. And I said, can you send it to my son? And he goes, no, it has to come to you. And I said, well, then I'll have to wait for him to come down.
01:38:01
Speaker 23: It might be a week.
01:38:03
Speaker 19: And I want to organise these payments so that there's no issues later. And I had to ring back this battery company. And now it looks like they might have to go take the battery unless somebody can organise payments.
01:38:18
Speaker 1: Yeah, totally unacceptable situation, Carlo. I can appreciate that. Mind you, on the text line, somebody says, I disagree with what you read out. People are not being excluded or left behind. They're excluded. themselves rather than embrace technology 25 years ago. It's the same as things like AI now. If you don't embrace it now and adapt, you will be in the same position in another decade that people who struggle with technology are today. I think you missed the point. There are a lot of people who are already elderly and who are not digitally savvy, who are intimidated and fearful, they don't own smartphones, to sort of say, oh, why didn't they do it 25 years ago? Well, we didn't need to embrace the technology 25 years ago because everything wasn't online. There were people at the counter. There were people at the other end of the phone, real people, and there was no reason to adapt. Now, if you wanted to adapt, that is fine, but to try and herd people into a corner and say, you have got to adapt, tell that to an 85-year-old person who has never had a smartphone. has never had an app, has totally relied on someone to do it for
them. And you're saying, well, you know, it's people's fault. No, it isn't. And I think society as a whole owes it to our older generations to accommodate them until a time that everyone is able to use the current technology.
01:39:36
Speaker 8: 5AA Mornings with Graham Goodings. 27 to 12, 5AA, the final half hour of the show.
01:39:44
Speaker 1: Emily says, I agree with this text. Society has been digital for decades. There are many free resources to gain literacy. My late grandmother learned to adapt. Older people I volunteered with were on Facebook. Complaining is redundant and learning will empower people. That's pretty savage, Emily. I know my mother well into her 80s wanted to learn how to use a computer and she did. But there are people around her age and even younger that didn't want to know, that were intimidated by it. We have to accommodate these people. Why does, oh, you know, they've just got to learn. No, they don't. They're at an age or a state of mental fragility that they don't want to do that. To suggest that they just have to learn is crazy. People are scared by technology at a certain age. We can't herd them into a corner and say, you have to use tap and go. There's no cash left. You have to get an app. A lot of these people don't even have a smartphone. We have to accommodate them because they were here for us. When we couldn't look after ourselves, now we need to look after them. Your thoughts?
01:40:49
Speaker 8: Australia?
01:40:50
Speaker 1: What is it about Australia? We love big things. We have the big banana, the big lobster, the big rocking horse. We just love them. And now we have the latest addition, the big sultana. Although I'm just not sure about it. I'm sure it'll be wonderful and it'll be a huge attraction on Mildura's Riverfront.
01:41:10
Speaker 12: But.
01:41:10
Speaker 1: I don't know. What is our attraction for big things? Joining us now is historian and heritage researcher, Dr. Amy Clark. Doctor, good morning to you.
01:41:19
Speaker 3: Good morning.
01:41:20
Speaker 1: So why do we love big things?
01:41:25
Speaker 30: Look, this is the $ 10, 000 question. I think that there is something very irreverent about big big things in Australia.
01:41:38
Speaker 3: I think there's a real sense of humor about them.
01:41:40
Speaker 30: And I think that that tickles a kind of, I don't know, anti-authoritarian kind of mindset. You know, we see these in the landscape and think, yeah, that's pretty fun. I'm going to pull over and have a look. And for a lot of communities, including Mildura, they're building them because they're wanting to represent something that they're incredibly proud of.
01:42:00
Speaker 3: So I think that's the other thing that comes along.
01:42:02
Speaker 30: With big things is You know, this is a community that wants people to know what they're about and what they make or what they produce there.
01:42:10
Speaker 1: Yeah, and I think that's a reflection. As you say, Aussies have a sense of humour, you know, the good old Aussie way. And, you know, let's have a giant pineapple or a big orange or something like that. While people from other countries might say, you know, it's a bit gauche and kitsch, I think we all embrace it. I don't know anyone who doesn't like big things.
01:42:30
Speaker 28: Yes.
01:42:31
Speaker 30: I mean, I assumed when I started this research about 10 years ago that there would be a lot of people that didn't like them. And I'm pleasantly surprised frequently at the sorts of people from all walks of life that sort of come up and indicate that they also, maybe secretly, but they also love big things. I think there is a real, I don't know, I think every Australian is in on the joke. We're not taking ourselves too seriously here. And I think it's a point of pride for us that we're not taking ourselves too seriously. But there's also a real heart to a lot of these big things. Like you mentioned the big rocking horse. I was born in the Adelaide Hills. So it was one of the first ones that I grew up.
01:43:11
Speaker 13: Seeing.
01:43:11
Speaker 30: And I still tell people about the big rocking horse today. It's something that I feel incredibly proud of, for better or worse. So I think, you know, I think that we should be very happy to be a country that's open to having these sorts of structures out there for people to enjoy.
01:43:28
Speaker 1: You mentioned the big rocking horse. I can remember taking my kids there without telling them where we were going. And, you know, they'd all seen rocking horses that you hop on, and their eyes absolutely lit up when they saw this three-story giant horse they were dad what's.
01:43:44
Speaker 3: That you can climb yeah yeah.
01:43:47
Speaker 1: So what what was your attraction to to do research into big things.
01:43:51
Speaker 30: Well i mean actually i was i i Picked it because I wanted to annoy people, if I'm going to be very frank. I thought I would get a rise out of some very serious academics who would turn their noses up at it. And as I say, I've been pleasantly surprised. They not only did not turn their noses up at it, they said, hey, this is really great. You're going to need to keep doing more and more research on this. And, you know, I'm still here 10 years later and it's now expanded to a global history. There's actually big things all over the world.
01:44:25
Speaker 3: I would say Australia does them best.
01:44:27
Speaker 1: I was going to say, surely we do them better than anywhere else.
01:44:30
Speaker 30: We definitely have the most humorous approach, I think, than many other countries take them quite seriously. It's quite unusual to see big things with faces on them. For instance, the big sultana in Mildura has got a very comical sort of face. And I think that that's maybe one of the specialties of Australian big things is we've kind of anthropomorphised them. We've given them personalities and made them feel quite approachable.
01:44:58
Speaker 1: Mind
you, Amy, with a Sultana, you had to give it a face or something because someone sort of said it looked like a giant rabbit dropping.
01:45:07
Speaker 11: Yes.
01:45:09
Speaker 3: I'm with you.
01:45:11
Speaker 30: I did think that Mildura was quite brave in picking... what is essentially a brown oval shape. The example that I give prior to this big sultana coming into the world that has drawn comparisons to other things, shall we say, is the big potato that's in Robertson in New South Wales.
01:45:33
Speaker 3: And it's a brown, you know, oblong shape.
01:45:35
Speaker 30: And there are many different nicknames for it that are quite unkind, as.
01:45:40
Speaker 3: You can imagine.
01:45:40
Speaker 21: Right.
01:45:41
Speaker 30: So, you know, I always think it's very gutsy of a community to lean in to an object that could be confused for something else or maybe a couple of other things. But, yes, I think you're right. Putting the face on it's probably helped them a little bit.
01:45:56
Speaker 1: So in all your years of studying and big things around Australia, which ones are the most bizarre or unusual?
01:46:03
Speaker 3: You know, this one, this big sultana's up there, I've got to tell you.
01:46:07
Speaker 4: Yeah.
01:46:10
Speaker 30: I still think one of my favourites, because it just captures that humour that Australians have, is there's a place in New South Wales, Ningen. It's on the banks of the Bogan River in Boganshire. And they thought, you know, why not? Let's build a big Bogan. And I just think that is pure delight for me. When you think about a bogan, it's sort of they've captured it. He's wearing a singlet. He's got taps. He's holding a fishing rod. He's wearing thongs. He's got his foot up on an esky.
01:46:41
Speaker 3: And I just love it.
01:46:44
Speaker 30: I think that is the epitome of Australian humour right there.
01:46:49
Speaker 3: And it's been very, very successful for the town of Ningan.
01:46:52
Speaker 30: They get lots and lots of visitors just wanting to come out and take a photo with the big bogan.
01:46:57
Speaker 1: Are there any states that are keener on big things than others?
01:47:01
Speaker 11: Yes.
01:47:01
Speaker 30: Well, Queensland and New South Wales have sort of historically had this rivalry going. I, being Adelaide 4 myself, love to remind people that actually Adelaide had.
01:47:14
Speaker 3: The first big thing in Australia, the big Scotsman in Adelaide.
01:47:18
Speaker 8: Of course.
01:47:19
Speaker 1: That's right.
01:47:20
Speaker 3: Yeah, that's right.
01:47:21
Speaker 30: So while these other states may have pulled into the lead in terms of sheer numbers, uh adelaide was first we've got the history that's it we we we've we've claimed it there's really no competition out of all the big things that you've seen do you have an absolute favorite well rocking horse is i love it there's something so beautiful about it um which is quite unusual for a big thing they're not usually things you'd describe as beautiful um yeah you know i the other one that i really enjoy um just the texture of it is the big pineapple which is where i work at university of the sunshine coast um there's something about the way they've captured the skin you know the prickles feel.
01:48:07
Speaker 3: Like they could be they could hurt you sort of thing.
01:48:09
Speaker 30: I think it's a really artistic yet very still very kitschy kind of representation of a big thing so the level of effort that's gone into that. And I think my other, I cannot believe I didn't think to say this, but of course, Larry the Lobster.
01:48:24
Speaker 12: Oh, yes.
01:48:25
Speaker 30: In Kingston Essay. Like what a masterpiece.
01:48:29
Speaker 1: Yeah, superb. I'm just thinking back, the first time as a kid, The first big thing I ever saw, I was born in Melbourne and my parents took us on a holiday up to Queensland. Yeah. And going on the way, we stopped off at the Big Banana.
01:48:47
Speaker 3: Oh, classic.
01:48:48
Speaker 11: Yeah.
01:48:48
Speaker 3: In Coffs Harbour.
01:48:49
Speaker 14: Yeah.
01:48:49
Speaker 1: I reckon that would be one of the early big things.
01:48:52
Speaker 3: Well, so quite right.
01:48:54
Speaker 30: And I think the previous owners, I'm not sure if it's still the current owners of the Big Banana.
01:48:59
Speaker 13: Okay.
01:49:00
Speaker 30: And not my biggest fan because they have claimed to be the first big thing in Australia.
01:49:06
Speaker 3: And I've been very publicly reminding everyone that the Big Scotsman is, in fact, the first.
01:49:10
Speaker 1: Well done.
01:49:11
Speaker 3: I was unfollowed by the Big Banana.
01:49:13
Speaker 8: Oh, really?
01:49:15
Speaker 3: Yeah, which I take as a point of pride. Yeah.
01:49:19
Speaker 1: Well, they can't rewrite history. I mean, the facts are facts.
01:49:22
Speaker 12: Quite right, yes.
01:49:24
Speaker 30: So, yeah, the Big Banana was built about a year after the Big Scotsman.
01:49:28
Speaker 1: We beat them to the punch.
01:49:30
Speaker 3: We sure did.
01:49:31
Speaker 7: Fantastic.
01:49:32
Speaker 1: Now, before we let you go, are there any, I mean, you're far and wide, Australia and beyond, big things, you've seen them everywhere and so forth. Are there any areas that are sort of untapped? I mean, things you say, that would make a great big thing. Are there any towns somewhere or cities or villages who could have a big thing?
01:49:55
Speaker 30: I believe there's actually another one. I cannot, I Can't give you the scoop, but keep your eyes and ears open because there's one, another one coming very soon, also in South Australia, that you'll see and you'll think, that is, why did we not do this earlier?
01:50:11
Speaker 3: That's all I can say at this point, but it will be out.
01:50:13
Speaker 30: That news will be breaking within the next couple of weeks.
01:50:16
Speaker 3: Let's just say it's a household implement.
01:50:19
Speaker 1: A household implement.
01:50:21
Speaker 3:
Yeah, and I'll let people guess.
01:50:22
Speaker 12: Uh-huh.
01:50:24
Speaker 3: It is amazing.
01:50:25
Speaker 8: A toaster.
01:50:26
Speaker 1: A toaster.
01:50:26
Speaker 3: Oh, you're pretty close.
01:50:28
Speaker 30: No, I think the other one that I really think is, why haven't we done this already? You mentioned you're from Melbourne. Why don't we have a big dimmy, a big dim sim somewhere, you know? Again, I think we'd have to put a face on it as well for obvious reasons.
01:50:47
Speaker 1: I think so. I'm picturing a giant dim sim and we need to dress it up with something.
01:50:53
Speaker 3: But come on, you know.
01:50:54
Speaker 30: They reinvented South Melbourne markets.
01:50:57
Speaker 3: Why don't we have a big dimmy somewhere?
01:51:01
Speaker 1: I love the thought. Look, Amy, we're going to get you back on when this new home product, and we'll talk about it and we'll suggest, and maybe you can give some thought to other towns around the nation, what they could have a big thing of and be a big tourist attraction. Thanks so much for your time today. Great to chat.
01:51:18
Speaker 3: My pleasure. Thanks so much.
01:51:20
Speaker 1: That's Dr. Amy Clark, historian and heritage researcher specialising on big things in Australia. What are your favourite big things, big places? Larry the lobster, that's fantastic. And the big rocking horse, I love that. And the Scotsman was the very first. How about that? But yeah, the big banana was the very first one I saw as a kid. And it was just, how good is that at Coffs Harbour? And I remember it to this very day. But big things. Your favourite. Love to know. 8223 0000 is the number to ring. Well, the AFL Round 1 fixture for next season has just been released. And it will open on Wednesday, the 17th of March, with Sydney Swans playing Geelong at the SCG. Thursday night. Fremantle versus Western Bulldogs from Optus Stadium. Friday night, Hawthorne versus Brisbane from the MCG. Saturday, Richmond versus Carlton. That's 12.35. Saturday for Crows fans, it'll be Adelaide versus the Giants, 3.45 at Adelaide Oval. Saturday night, St Kilda versus Collingwood. Then Sunday, North Melbourne versus Port Adelaide for Power fans. That's a 1.10 game on the Sunday. Melbourne versus Essendon, 3-15. And the final match of the round, West Coast Eagles versus Gold Coast Suns at Optus Stadium. So that's almost a week full of footy starting on the Wednesday and ending on the Sunday. As we wind down on this Tuesday morning, still time for your calls, but lots of reaction to.
01:53:00
Speaker 1: Our last guest, Dr Amy Clark, historian and heritage researcher on big things around Australia, who reminded us that the very first big thing in Australia was the big Scotsman. How about that? Mark says, hi, Graham. I'd love to see a giant tuna at Port Lincoln and a giant cuttlefish in Wyler. Maybe the Eyre Peninsula could have a series of giant features to attract a giant tourist drive. And Zoltan. Now, Joey says, at Lonsdale, we have the big hill's hoist. And lots of people straight after that said, what about a Hill's Hoist?
01:53:31
Speaker 8: Well, yes.
01:53:33
Speaker 1: Three or four in a row, what about the Hill's Hoist? Larry and the Big Scotsman, both made by Paul Kelly, not the singer. Thank you for that, Maxine. Jan, good morning to you.
01:53:42
Speaker 18: Oh, good morning.
01:53:44
Speaker 31: Just in reply to that gentleman that rang up and said that he had to wait for his son to come down, he's 100 kilometres away. Do you know by law that every company has to, by law, give you an alternative? if you can't do things online. So this gentleman should ring that company back and say, by law, you have to give me an alternative. A lot of people don't realise that.
01:54:10
Speaker 1: So by law, if you ring up and told, oh, you have to go on the app or, you know, go online, by law.
01:54:18
Speaker 31: Yes, I've used that so many times myself. And then they sort of hesitate and they think, they can't say anything because.
01:54:25
Speaker 17: It is a law.
01:54:26
Speaker 31: They must provide an alternative. Jan, thank you very much for letting us know that. They rely on people not knowing this.
01:54:34
Speaker 5: Yeah.
01:54:34
Speaker 31: So they'll force you into getting apps and going online.
01:54:38
Speaker 11: Yeah, of course.
01:54:38
Speaker 1: It makes it easier for them.
01:54:39
Speaker 3: Yes, of course.
01:54:40
Speaker 1: They don't care about it being easier for you. They want it easier for them.
01:54:43
Speaker 3: No, of course not.
01:54:43
Speaker 22: Yeah.
01:54:44
Speaker 25: So everybody needs to know.
01:54:46
Speaker 31: We need to be knowledgeable of where we stand in all this.
01:54:50
Speaker 7: We certainly do.
01:54:50
Speaker 5: And a lot of people, unfortunately, are not.
01:54:53
Speaker 1: Jan, thank you for bringing that to our attention. We'll try and find out that exact law somewhere, the law that states that they have to be able to, if you are not digitally savvy or have a smartphone or can't download the app or get online, that they have to help you out in other ways. We will find out. Gary, good morning.
01:55:12
Speaker 23: Good morning, Graeme. Just thought I might give a bit of food for thought for your listeners and that with the way technology is moving and with the data centres, power and cooling seem to be the two major concerns and proximity to people. I just thought with my research I've done, which is only on an amateur basis, that I found out that China are now putting off their data centres being offshore. They're putting them on the bottom of the ocean, just offshore, hence the cooling factors taken care of.
01:55:44
Speaker 8: Is that right?
01:55:45
Speaker 23: And not only that, they have wind turbines and solar panels to power them, and they are away from the population. Now, that's one aspect of it. That's what China's doing. But even more amazingly, Elon Musk with his giant SpaceX rockets,
one of the main cargoes they keep putting up there are data banks and data centers. And of course, space has no problem with heating. So the cooling factor is taken care of. And so is the solar power, uninterrupted solar to power them. So And again, getting them away from the population. Of course, with Starlink already being up there, the data centre is being built up there with cooling and power and away from the population and away from threats of sabotage and all that. This is the way technology is moving forward. So having land-based data centres might be a thing of the past anyway in the not-so-distant future.
01:56:39
Speaker 1: Gary, you've done your homework, haven't you?
01:56:41
Speaker 23: Well, I find it interesting, but I like to see, as my grandfather always said, No matter how thick and stodgy or how gossamer thin, the pancake always has two sides.
01:56:51
Speaker 1: Well said. Good on you, Gary. Thanks for bringing that to our attention here. That's something we might have another look at, the fact that data centres can be built under the ocean. Or in space, certainly better than in the backyard. After one this afternoon, it's Leith Forrest who bounds into the studio.
01:57:06
Speaker 7: You know, my mum used to say, laugh is like a bog. He had a nice sort of ring to him, Gary, there.
01:57:11
Speaker 8: He did.
01:57:12
Speaker 7: As my father always said, pancake has two sides.
01:57:14
Speaker 1: Yeah, that's a good point. And sometimes we overlook that. And I used that at some stage.
01:57:19
Speaker 14: Yeah.
01:57:19
Speaker 1: Oh, I remember a technician when I worked at TNT9 in Launceston who was an unusual character. And over a beer, we were disagreeing on something. And, you know, and I had firm views on something. And he said, there was a beer bottle between us on the table. And he said, what do you see in front of you? And I said, a beer bottle. And I said, what do you see? And he said, I see a beer bottle too. So we're both seeing a beer bottle. He said, but on my side, I've got the label. On your side, you don't. There are two sides and they're different. Oh, that's very deep. I'm going to try and use that one too. It was over a beer or two.
01:57:51
Speaker 7: Great. 15 beers deep. Hey, are you a fan of 80s power ballads? Big vocals, big hair, big guitar solos.
01:58:00
Speaker 8: Oh, yeah.
01:58:01
Speaker 11: Yeah, yeah.
01:58:01
Speaker 1: You got something in mind?
01:58:03
Speaker 7: So I have one of the greatest voices in the history of music on the show today. 35 million albums sold. Rock and Roll Hall of Fame. Grammy Achievement Award. I got five minutes with her this morning. Five minutes, Graham. So I squeezed in. Do you want to have a listen?
01:58:20
Speaker 16: What about love?
01:58:21
Speaker 11: Don't you.
01:58:23
Speaker 7: Want someone to care about you?
01:58:27
Speaker 14: What about.
01:58:29
Speaker 21: Don't let it.
01:58:30
Speaker 31: Slip away When.
01:58:35
Speaker 4: I'm lost I only want to share it with you You might need it someday Great voice, great voice.
01:58:46
Speaker 7: You might know there are other songs like Barracuda and Magic Man. That's Anne Wilson from Heart, who is coming to us. I didn't know her by name, I must say. Anne and Nancy Wilson are the two sisters. Anne is the singer. Nancy is staying at home at the moment. Anne's brought another band. She's got a few things on the go. She's coming to Australia for the Jose Carreras concert, which is in Queensland at the Gabba. So that's Jose Carreras and Robbie Williams and The Cause and Ann Wilson and a few others. So they said, would you like to speak to Ann Wilson? Of course I want to speak to Ann Wilson. Okay, you've got five minutes.
01:59:18
Speaker 8: Is that right?
01:59:19
Speaker 7: You know what it's like. What questions are you getting in five minutes?
01:59:22
Speaker 1: You're just getting warmed up.
01:59:24
Speaker 7: But I'm through because I love that sort of, Music of the years. And they were one of those bands that had huge hits in the 70s when they started, huge hits in the 80s like that one. Then you might remember they had a very controversial song in the 90s, All I Want to Do is Make Love to You, which is the story of the lady who picks up a hitchhiker, gets it on, devil's tango, all of a sudden has a child and flicks the bloke.
01:59:46
Speaker 8: So.
01:59:47
Speaker 7: Legend. She's on the show today.
01:59:49
Speaker 1: And you're going to do this all in five minutes?
01:59:51
Speaker 7: I'm going to do all of it. I was speaking fast. And every time Ian paused, I'm like, no, don't pause. I don't have time to pause, Ian.
01:59:58
Speaker 1: Is she that heavily booked that they're queuing up? Yeah, I think so. I don't know.
02:00:02
Speaker 7: I don't want to bash publicists or management. You know what it's like. Sometimes it's a bit like that. Sometimes if you get the act of find on their own, they don't care. I got it all day.
02:00:13
Speaker 1: Have I ever told you about when I interviewed Jerry Marsden, Jerry and the Pacemakers? No, please do. And he was performing in Launceston. He'd been huge. He was bigger than the Beatles at one stage.
02:00:23
Speaker 12: Yes.
02:00:24
Speaker 1: Incredibly wealthy, owned the biggest radio station in Liverpool, you know, totally. But he still loved performing. Long story short, I rang up his manager and said, any chance of an interview? Oh, no, no, no. Yeah, all right. You've got 10 minutes. So a 10-minute interview turned into half an hour and also turned into, this is for television.
02:00:43
Speaker 14: Yes.
02:00:44
Speaker 1: He also got his band down and they sang half an hour's worth of songs for us. We made a little special of it.
02:00:51
Speaker 8: Nice.
02:00:51
Speaker 18: Yes.
02:00:52
Speaker 1: And he was the nicest guy. And we went to the concert that night and after the concert, we had a couple of ales and he We solve the problems of the world. See, that's– When you get on the inside.
02:01:01
Speaker 8: Of those people.
02:01:02
Speaker 26: That's right.
02:01:02
Speaker 7: You've got to get past management.
02:01:04
Speaker 23: Exactly.
02:01:04
Speaker 7: I've been on ones before where they'll say, you've got five minutes, and they'll count you down. Three minutes in, they'll go two minutes.
02:01:09
Speaker 11: Yeah.
02:01:10
Speaker 7: One minute, you're getting notes in your ears. And then the next minute, they will cut you off. I've literally been, thanks so much, Graham. I appreciate it. See you here in Adelaide. Cut.
02:01:18
Speaker 19: Cut.
02:01:19
Speaker 7: On to the next one. And I get it because people go too long. But if you're a fan of Anne Wilson on the show today, plus many more after one.
02:01:25
Speaker 1: Good on you.
02:01:26
Speaker 7: See you then.
02:01:26
Speaker 1: Lee Forrest coming up this afternoon. That's it for today. Thanks for your company. Back tomorrow.