TRASCRIZIONE 🔗
WEBVTT
00:00:48.786 --> 00:00:52.076
Hello, and welcome back to Mind the Body.
00:00:53.456 --> 00:01:08.135
A couple of weeks ago, I was in Dean's Yard, a quiet enclosed square in the shadow of Westminster Abbey, attending a seminar by the psychoanalyst Alessandro Lema, whose work has already appeared in several episodes of this podcast.
00:01:09.365 --> 00:01:17.716
The seminar was titled From Scrolling to Working Through: Adolescence, Algorithms, and the Search for Coherence.
00:01:18.576 --> 00:01:23.776
One phrase in particular has stayed with me since I walked out of that room.
00:01:24.945 --> 00:01:37.665
"When it comes to online visibility," she said, visibility has become the mode for disappearance." I wanna say that again because it rings true.
00:01:39.426 --> 00:01:51.246
Visibility has become the mode for disappearance we are living through a moment of extraordinary, unprecedented exposure.
00:01:52.456 --> 00:01:57.326
More images of ourselves than any generation has ever produced.
00:01:58.046 --> 00:02:06.126
More metrics, more platforms, more eyes, and yet the data on loneliness tells us something that we can't ignore.
00:02:07.406 --> 00:02:12.066
Adolescents are reporting the highest levels of loneliness ever recorded.
00:02:13.605 --> 00:02:19.545
More digitally visible than any generation in history, and more unseen.
00:02:20.776 --> 00:02:29.367
That paradox is what this episode is about I wanna be clear from the outset about something.
00:02:30.307 --> 00:02:32.218
I'm not against technology.
00:02:32.817 --> 00:02:36.228
Technology is not inherently destructive.
00:02:37.088 --> 00:02:41.268
It can connect, resource, and support.
00:02:42.528 --> 00:02:45.508
What I'm interested in is something more specific.
00:02:47.258 --> 00:02:53.598
What happens to a self that's already fragile when the digital world becomes its primary mirror?
00:02:55.237 --> 00:03:15.875
Because in my consulting room, I'm not only seeing adolescents, I'm seeing adults, people in their 30s, 40s, sometimes beyond, whose sense of self was arrested long before the algorithm got hold of them Early childhood trauma has a way of doing that.
00:03:16.414 --> 00:03:24.814
It leaves the developing self at a fragile, not yet fully formed point, a self still waiting to emerge.
00:03:25.985 --> 00:03:46.348
And for that self, the digital world steps in where relational experience failed, offering something that feels, for a time, like being understood while deepening the very wounds it appears to soothe That's what I want to think about today.
00:03:47.239 --> 00:04:02.579
Not only during adolescence, though that's a critical window, but what happens to body image when a fragile self at any age turns to the digital world for the recognition it never found in human connection.
00:04:04.079 --> 00:04:11.331
And to understand why, it helps to think about what creates a fragile sense of self in the first place.
00:04:13.231 --> 00:04:29.122
When early attachment
Load full transcript
relationships are disrupted, when the caregiving environment doesn't provide consistent, attuned, recognizing presence, the developing self is left without an adequate relational foundation.
00:04:30.141 --> 00:04:33.841
And the self, you see, emerges through relationship.
00:04:34.611 --> 00:05:03.104
It coheres through being known by another, through the repeated experience of having an inner state received, reflected, and returned in a form that can be taken in When that experience is absent or inconsistent, or even frightening, the self remains uncertain of its own reality, a fragile self not fully formed at its core.
00:05:04.573 --> 00:05:19.734
And this is what relational trauma does, often through the accumulated absence of what should have been there, like the attuned gaze, the regulating presence, the experience of being held in another person's mind.
00:05:21.293 --> 00:05:35.831
So the fragile self, already uncertain of its own existence, is most vulnerable to what the digital world offers in its place We're gonna explore three things today.
00:05:36.562 --> 00:05:45.491
First what Lemma means by hypervisible disappearance, and why it is one of the most clinically significant descriptions of what I see in my work.
00:05:46.471 --> 00:06:02.782
Second, how the algorithm becomes a false container for the self, what it offers, what it forecloses, and what it does in particular to the capacity for mentalization, for genuine self-reflection.
00:06:04.182 --> 00:06:10.322
And third, what all of this does to body image and what healing actually requires.
00:06:11.522 --> 00:06:24.821
So let's begin There's a distinction that runs through Lemann's clinical writing that I have returned to many times, and it sits at the heart of this episode.
00:06:26.321 --> 00:06:30.150
The distinction between being seen and being watched.
00:06:31.191 --> 00:06:34.380
To be seen as your true self is to be known.
00:06:35.201 --> 00:06:45.711
It requires another mind, a mind that can receive you, hold what it receives, and return something that feels like recognition.
00:06:47.211 --> 00:07:10.489
The mother who looks at her infant and sees not just a body, but a self, a particular person, someone who exists To be watched is something else entirely The watched self is observed, but not known.
00:07:11.009 --> 00:07:18.328
It's subjected to a gaze that notes the surface, but never apprehends the reality beneath.
00:07:19.578 --> 00:07:32.589
And what Lemma is asserting, and what I find so clinically resonant, is that the digital world offers an enormous amount of watching and very little seeing.
00:07:33.959 --> 00:07:36.479
Likes are not attunement.
00:07:37.469 --> 00:07:39.979
Followers are not recognition.
00:07:41.209 --> 00:07:53.512
And visibility is not the same as being known I wonder if you've ever noticed how being visible online can sometimes leave you feeling even more invisible.
00:07:54.762 --> 00:08:00.062
In my conversations, both with clients
and friends, this comes up so often.
00:08:00.812 --> 00:08:07.392
The sense that despite all the notifications and numbers, something vital is missing.
00:08:08.662 --> 00:08:10.961
Maybe you've felt that too.
00:08:12.692 --> 00:08:29.881
For young people who grew up in the pandemic years, deprived of embodied social encounters at precisely the developmental moment when the self most needs relational mirroring, and a sense of belonging, and identity building.
00:08:30.831 --> 00:08:36.822
The retreat to the online world wasn't a choice so much as a necessity.
00:08:38.172 --> 00:08:41.971
But what they found there was not what they needed.
00:08:42.272 --> 00:08:50.871
What they found was hypervisibility, an occupied space, as Lemmer describes it, rather than a transitional one.
00:08:52.380 --> 00:08:56.850
That phrase, occupied space, is important.
00:08:58.211 --> 00:09:17.150
Winnicott wrote about the transitional space as the place where the self is played into being, where identity is discovered through creative, uncertain, relational encounters where not knowing is actually part of the process.
00:09:18.360 --> 00:09:21.110
Occupied space is the opposite.
00:09:21.781 --> 00:09:26.921
It is structured, directed, the uncertainty removed.
00:09:28.021 --> 00:09:33.721
The algorithm already knows what you are looking for before you do.
00:09:34.990 --> 00:09:38.791
It tells you who you are before you've had the chance to find out.
00:09:40.071 --> 00:09:47.021
And for some, Lemert describes this in the seminar in a way that gets to the essence of it.
00:09:48.951 --> 00:09:54.401
Presence itself begins to feel less real, more ghostly.
00:09:55.531 --> 00:10:02.591
The self that should be consolidating through connection instead dissolves through exposure.
00:10:04.401 --> 00:10:19.341
She writes about what she calls hypervisible disappearance, The condition of being incessantly seen, yet existentially erased by mechanical workings that are ironically invisible.
00:10:21.341 --> 00:10:29.701
So seen by everyone, truly known by no one, and gradually the felt sense of existing begins to thin.
00:10:31.381 --> 00:10:33.821
Does any of this sound familiar to you?
00:10:35.672 --> 00:10:41.971
Maybe you've noticed a moment when being more visible didn't lead to feeling more real, but somehow the opposite.
00:10:43.652 --> 00:10:47.831
In clinical terms, this is a territory of psychic annihilation.
00:10:48.942 --> 00:11:18.572
The fear, sometimes the experience that the self is not real, that there is no there And it registers as these things always do in the body Moving on to the second thing, if the self is fragile, unformed, unrecognized, frightened of its own unreality, it will reach for something to hold it together.
00:11:20.052 --> 00:11:25.513
This is the psyche seeking stability and structure where it's missing.
00:11:26.923 --> 00:11:34.843
When a relational environment can't provide a sense of containment, the mind tries to create one
however it can.
00:11:36.333 --> 00:11:49.883
Lima introduced a phrase in the seminar that I think is one of her most important contributions in this area AI, she said, functions as a kind of psychic prosthesis, an external skin.
00:11:51.223 --> 00:11:58.133
If you listened to episode 21, you probably remember the idea of the skin as the first psychic container.
00:11:59.133 --> 00:12:10.692
But even if you didn't, you might relate to the way technology sometimes feels like a second skin, something you reach for when the world inside feels uncontained.
00:12:11.682 --> 00:12:19.192
That pull to manage from the outside what can't be settled within us, I think is a very human response.
00:12:21.052 --> 00:12:35.026
And what the algorithm offers is exactly for this purpose, and it does so with considerable sophistication Metrics become a way of answering a question.
00:12:36.115 --> 00:12:37.156
Am I real?
00:12:37.806 --> 00:12:38.716
Am I here?
00:12:39.946 --> 00:12:41.426
Do I exist?
00:12:43.442 --> 00:13:10.696
The quantified self, follower counts, likes, engagement, the body's dimension measured and tracked, offers the temporary relief of data, of something countable, something that appears to confirm presence But it is a defense, and the metrics must keep confirming.
00:13:11.146 --> 00:13:13.576
The numbers must keep validating.
00:13:14.156 --> 00:13:20.605
Because the underlying question,"Am I real?" is never actually answered by data.
00:13:21.166 --> 00:13:25.586
It can only be answered by being in relationship.
00:13:28.066 --> 00:13:34.956
Then there is the question of self-diagnosis, and this is something I see with increasing frequency in my consulting room.
00:13:35.865 --> 00:13:39.735
People who arrive having already named what's wrong with them.
00:13:40.516 --> 00:14:01.886
They have consumed hours of content, followed accounts dedicated to particular diagnosis, found communities even organized around shared labels, and the label has given them something that feels important, a framework, a language, and a sense of belonging.
00:14:03.365 --> 00:14:08.666
But there's something else happening underneath the relief of the label, and something more troubling.
00:14:11.115 --> 00:14:18.926
seminar title, From Scrolling to Working Through: Adolescence, Algorithms, and the Search for Coherence, points directly at this.
00:14:19.786 --> 00:14:23.735
Humans have always longed to make sense of themselves.
00:14:24.396 --> 00:14:26.105
A search for coherence.
00:14:26.536 --> 00:14:29.416
It's one of the most fundamental human drives.
00:14:30.485 --> 00:14:36.786
What's new is where that search is now being conducted and what it finds there.
00:14:37.966 --> 00:14:47.115
The messiness of inner experience, the confusion, the contradiction, the not knowing, it's becoming harder to bear.
00:14:48.046 --> 00:14:53.365
And the digital world offers something that feels like relief from all that messiness.
00:14:54.006 --> 00:14:57.916
Definition, category, coherence.
00:14:58.865 --> 00:15:01.605
A label that says,"This is what you are.
00:15:01.936 --> 00:15:07.076
This is why you feel the way you feel." And the search is over.
00:15:08.516 --> 00:15:18.086
If you're listening right now and thinking,"Actually, I do search for labels or categories when things feel confusing," I want you to know you're not alone.
00:15:19.006 --> 00:15:23.286
What I've found in the research is that this isn't a fringe phenomenon.
00:15:24.355 --> 00:15:41.636
A nationally representative study published this year in JAMA Pediatrics found that almost one in five adolescents and young adults in the US have used AI chatbot for mental health advice.
00:15:42.586 --> 00:15:46.975
A figure that had risen by nearly half in just 12 months.
00:15:48.306 --> 00:16:08.725
Most striking for everything I've covered today, the majority of those who turned to a chatbot for emotional support told no one, not a parent, not a friend, not a clinician It's only seen by an algorithm.
00:16:10.166 --> 00:16:30.706
And when researchers looked at why so many rated the advice as helpful, they raised an important caution that this perceived helpfulness may say less about the quality of the guidance and more about the chatbot's tendency towards flattery and agreement.
00:16:31.906 --> 00:16:40.696
No friction, no challenge, no third position from which something genuinely new could be offered.
00:16:41.286 --> 00:17:04.039
Just a mirror, a kind of echo chamber telling you what you already wanted to hear I've had clients tell me they turn to AI between sessions when the wait becomes difficult, and that in itself tells us something important about what these tools are filling and what questions we need to be asking.
00:17:05.480 --> 00:17:11.259
For many of the people I work with, the diagnosis does not feel like new information.
00:17:11.649 --> 00:17:14.230
It feels like a kind of confirmation.
00:17:14.950 --> 00:17:27.920
It confirms what they've always felt, that something is wrong with them, and that feeling, that conviction of fundamental wrongness didn't begin with a diagnosis.
00:17:28.789 --> 00:17:32.660
It often began much earlier in the relational environment of childhood.
00:17:34.500 --> 00:17:43.839
In the messages, both spoken and unspoken, that told them they were too much or not enough, or simply not quite right.
00:17:45.490 --> 00:17:48.269
The label confirms that conviction.
00:17:49.282 --> 00:17:52.332
It gives it a name and a structure, but it doesn't heal it.
00:17:53.322 --> 00:18:33.602
And crucially, it forecloses the one process that might, the capacity for genuine curiosity about the self, mentalization, the reflective function, the ability to wonder rather than conclude, to ask what this feeling is trying to tell me about my history, my body, my relational patterns, rather than landing on a category and just stopping there Lemmer describes the algorithm as a medium for algorithmically
mediated projective identification.
00:18:34.653 --> 00:18:41.462
This is such a significant concept, and one that I explored in episode 18, but it belongs here, too.
00:18:42.502 --> 00:18:45.673
The algorithm mediates collective anxiety.
00:18:46.413 --> 00:19:12.567
The culture's accumulated distress about bodies, about appearance, about adequacy, projects it into the digital environment and returns it to the individual as personal truth, as self-definition The person doesn't experience this as something coming from outside.
00:19:13.136 --> 00:19:30.893
They experience it as something they've discovered about themselves perhaps you've noticed this too, maybe even in subtler ways, how ideas or anxieties from the digital world can show up and feel as if they're your own.
00:19:32.312 --> 00:19:52.050
This is how cultural body image disturbance becomes personal body image disturbance, and it's unconscious In healthy development, what protects the self from being simply absorbed by any one relationship, any one mirror, is the presence of a third.
00:19:53.080 --> 00:19:58.560
The father, the sibling, the teacher, or even the friend.
00:19:59.711 --> 00:20:02.080
The third breaks the dyad.
00:20:02.300 --> 00:20:09.780
It introduces difference, otherness, a perspective that arrives from the outside.
00:20:10.790 --> 00:20:25.050
It's what allows the child to discover that they exist in a world of other minds, minds with their own desires,, their own perceptions, their own version of events.
00:20:26.480 --> 00:20:39.620
This is the foundation of the capacity to mentalize, to hold multiple perspectives, and to know that how I see myself is not the only truth about me.
00:20:41.170 --> 00:20:43.290
AI can't provide a third.
00:20:44.120 --> 00:20:58.424
Its structure is closed always and only between the self and its reflection, however sophisticated that reflection becomes It's like a feedback loop.
00:20:58.964 --> 00:21:03.754
There's no outside position from which genuine observation is possible.
00:21:04.654 --> 00:21:11.964
No mind that comes with its own agenda, its own surprise, its own independent existence.
00:21:12.834 --> 00:21:19.105
And without the third, what looks like being seen is always at some level simply being mirrored.
00:21:20.584 --> 00:21:40.095
The circling back to itself, finding only itself, growing more certain of its own conclusions, and more isolated from the friction of genuine otherness And woven through all of this is something Lemma named that I want to stay with for a moment.
00:21:41.125 --> 00:21:49.904
The feeling reported by so many young people in her clinical work that the digital world is watching them, keeping an eye on them.
00:21:50.774 --> 00:22:10.524
This is not simply a privacy concern, it's a psychic experience, and it maps onto early relational dynamics in which being watched was not the same as being seen, in which the caregiver's gaze felt monitoring rather than recognizing.
00:22:12.194 --> 00:22:20.414
The digital world for these individuals becomes the stage on which that original relational dynamic is replayed.
00:22:21.494 --> 00:22:29.562
Technology as enactment of psychic conflict And this is where the body comes in.
00:22:30.582 --> 00:23:04.120
So the third thing, When I trace all of this through my BTA triangle framework, body image, trauma, attachment, what becomes clear is that Lemma's concept of hyper-visible disappearance is not only a crisis of identity, it's a crisis of embodiment When the self becomes hypervisible and unseen, the body becomes the place where that disappearance is registered and felt.
00:23:05.280 --> 00:23:10.530
Body image disturbance in this context is not primarily about appearance.
00:23:11.140 --> 00:23:16.920
It's about the body ceasing to feel real, present, inhabited.
00:23:18.640 --> 00:23:37.140
The body here becomes a metric, a surface to be monitored and optimized, an object of surveillance rather than a home And this is where I want to draw a thread back through the series in the last episode, episode 21.
00:23:38.100 --> 00:23:42.390
I talked about the skin as the earliest relational surface.
00:23:43.040 --> 00:23:46.580
The first site of meeting between a mother and her infant.
00:23:47.390 --> 00:23:56.990
The face, the skin, the place where the body begins to know itself through being touched, held, reflected.
00:23:58.770 --> 00:24:09.370
When Lemma describes AI as a psychic prosthesis, an external skin, she is pointing to exactly this territory.
00:24:10.300 --> 00:24:18.430
The containing function that should have been internalized through early relational experience is now being sought through technology.
00:24:20.360 --> 00:24:23.461
And what technology offers is a simulacrum.
00:24:25.420 --> 00:24:31.080
The body in this situation loses the felt sense of aliveness.
00:24:32.980 --> 00:24:46.221
I wonder if listening to this, you're noticing moments when your own body has felt more like something to look at or to manage rather than something you actually live in.
00:24:47.300 --> 00:24:54.650
Clinically, this is a common theme, people describing their bodies almost in the third person.
00:24:55.620 --> 00:25:07.256
A body that's looked at, assessed, managed, rarely a body that feels like a home So what heals this?
00:25:09.910 --> 00:25:32.610
I wanna be honest here because I think there's a temptation, particularly in the wellness space at the moment, to answer that question way too quickly, to offer a practice, a tool, And while those things have their place, they don't reach the level at which this disturbance is operating.
00:25:34.040 --> 00:25:37.120
What heals, I think, is something more demanding.
00:25:38.480 --> 00:25:44.060
And Lemon named it in the seminar with a phrase I have been turning over in my mind ever since.
00:25:45.490 --> 00:25:58.808
She spoke about reintroducing friction, about holding the vitality that comes with conflict The algorithm removes
friction.
00:25:59.618 --> 00:26:03.038
It smooths, optimizes, predicts.
00:26:04.188 --> 00:26:16.259
It offers an experience of the world in which you're never surprised, never misunderstood, never required to tolerate the discomfort of a genuine encounter with someone.
00:26:18.288 --> 00:26:23.769
And what gets lost in that smoothness is not simply spontaneity.
00:26:24.848 --> 00:26:32.948
What gets lost is aliveness, the quality of being present in a body that's actually engaged with something real.
00:26:34.238 --> 00:27:04.168
Healing requires the restoration of that aliveness, and it happens, when it happens, through relationship, through the experience of being with another mind that doesn't already know what you're going to say, that can be surprised by you, that can misattune and repair, that can hold what you bring without immediately returning it neatly packaged and optimized.
00:27:06.028 --> 00:27:21.558
What Lemma describes as the movement from a flattening of experience to an aliveness is, in my clinical experience, something that begins in the body, a return of sensation, of presence.
00:27:23.308 --> 00:27:27.548
And this makes sense when we consider what the algorithmic gaze has displaced.
00:27:29.259 --> 00:27:42.678
Lemes spoke in the seminar about interoception, the felt sense of the body from within, being displaced by what she describes as exteroceptive evaluation.
00:27:44.048 --> 00:27:58.288
Quote, unquote,"A mode of experiencing the body from without, monitored and corrected under the algorithmic gaze." So the body is no longer a place you inhabit.
00:27:59.128 --> 00:28:00.988
It's a surface you manage.
00:28:02.218 --> 00:28:17.068
Healing then isn't only psychological, it's a return to interoception, a gradual, tentative recovery of the body as something felt rather than observed.
00:28:18.728 --> 00:28:22.348
Therapy at its best offers something the algorithm cannot.
00:28:24.288 --> 00:28:39.740
The gradual, uncertain, sometimes uncomfortable discovery that the self is real, and that the body is part of that reality So here's what we've covered today.
00:28:40.770 --> 00:28:46.340
We began with a paradox more visible than ever and more unseen.
00:28:48.060 --> 00:28:51.820
And we traced that paradox through three territories.
00:28:52.721 --> 00:29:24.204
What Lemma's concept of hyper-visible disappearance actually means clinically, how the algorithm offers itself as a false container for the fragile self, foreclosing the very curiosity that healing requires, and what all of this does to body image, and what the path back to aliveness involves Lemmer's seminar gave me a great deal to sit with, but the thing I keep coming back to is this.
00:29:25.595 --> 00:29:34.875
The self cannot cohere through exposure alone because being truly known isn't the same thing as being seen.
00:29:35.865 --> 00:29:46.394
It requires another person, a mind that can hold your mind in theirs, A relationship that can tolerate friction and uncertainty.
00:29:48.284 --> 00:29:56.784
If any of this has landed for you, if you recognize something of yourself in this episode, I'd love to hear from you.
00:29:57.424 --> 00:30:00.365
You can find out how to connect with me in the show notes.
00:30:01.324 --> 00:30:12.105
And if you want a place to start, something practical to be more in your body this week, my free seven-day Body Trust Reset is available to download.
00:30:13.744 --> 00:30:16.424
Until next time, stay curious