TRASCRIZIONE 🔗
WEBVTT
00:00:26.000 --> 00:00:48.000
On the Mind & Matter podcast, we learn together from the best scientists and thinkers alive today about how your mind-body reacts to what you feed it. Before starting Mind & Matter, I spent 10 years in academia doing scientific research. I got a PhD in neuroscience from Harvard University, where I focused on neuroendocrinology and the neuroscience of behavior. And before that, I specialized in molecular, developmental, and evolutionary genetics.
00:00:48.000 --> 00:01:27.000
I use my scientific background to parse and translate the information guests share on the show, and in addition to the podcast, I write long-form content and send out a free weekly newsletter at themindandmattersubstack at mindandmatter.substack.com. science-based health consulting, where we work one-on-one and apply the same rigorous, evidence-first approach you hear on the podcast, but personalized. We can obtain and analyze your biomarkers, work on diet and behavior strategies, review supplements and drugs that you might be taking, or anything else related to general metabolic health. So, if you'd like more tailored guidance on your personal health, head to nickjacomis.com and fill out a short form or book time with me there.
00:01:28.000 --> 00:01:52.000
A great way to support my content in all of its forms is simply to visit mindandmatter.substack.com. You'll find a link to that in the episode description, and you'll also find a link to my current affiliate partners through my support page. These are products that I use myself that relate to physical, metabolic, or mental health. For example, one product I use every day is the Aqua True water filter, which removes heavy metals, microbes, endocrine disruptors, you name it, so that you have higher quality drinking water.
00:01:52.000 --> 00:02:17.000
All of those links for health consulting, for my affiliate partners, and the Substack page are all in the episode description. So thank you very much for listening, and don't forget to check out mindandmatter.substack.com for all of my content. Dr. Christopher Walsh, thank you for joining me. Thanks, Nick.
00:02:17.000 --> 00:02:25.000
It's a pleasure to be here. Where are you calling in from today? And tell everyone a little bit about who you are and what your lab does. Sure.
00:02:26.000 --> 00:02:53.000
So I'm here in Boston, and I am the Chief of the Division of Genetics at Boston Children's Hospital. And that's one of about 15 different divisions that take care of all of the different organs in a kid's body. We take care of kids with rare genetic diseases of all kinds. My background actually is that I am a neurologist.
00:02:54.000 --> 00:03:15.000
and a neuroscientist, so I have a PhD studying the development of the brain. And so I have this clinical role as this chief of genetics, and then I'm also an investigator of the Howard Hughes Medical Institute, so I spend most of my time running a lab of about 25 or 30 people, and we study all different aspects of how the brain develops and also how the brain might have evolved over history.
00:03:16.000 --> 00:03:34.000
Yeah. You've definitely been on my list for a while as someone to talk to because I was a pin student at the program in neuroscience over there and I didn't meet you, but I always kept tabs on your work. But I started out in developmental and evolutionary genetics. So I've had this interest in how do genes build the organism and build the brain.
00:03:35.000 --> 00:04:05.000
And you are one of the best people to talk to about the nexus of those fields. And you've also got this interesting background where, as you mentioned, In many ways, you're a basic researcher, but you're also doing a lot of applied and translational stuff, and you're at the children's hospital. So you're right at the middle of translational stuff, basic stuff, medical and therapeutic stuff, but also really basic and really interesting biology. So, I mean, what do you just think about that, where you sort of sit at the crossroads of all those things?
00:04:06.000 --> 00:05:22.000
Well, you know, I've been doing science for a long time, and so things have changed over the years, but some things haven't changed. And so what I've always been fascinated about is this miracle that happens, that a bunch of cells that start out looking just like a bunch of other cells in your body somehow then become endowed with this property of intelligence that leads to our creativity, our sense of self, and our scientific method, our logic, and all of these things, that there's this miracle where these cells get transformed into a brain and a mind. And so I've studied that various ways over the years, first as a developed, when I was a neuroscience student, first as a descriptive process of just where are the cells formed, how are they born, where do they go, how do they get connected, and then increasingly using genetic tools. And You can't study the genetic aspects of the development of the human brain, which I think is the most interesting brain to study in terms of its development. You can't get involved in that without ending up running into human disease. And my clinical training as a neurologist made me very interested in human disease.
00:05:22.000 --> 00:06:14.000
So I've really been at this nexus. For a while, I used to describe our work as using humans as a convenient genetic model system for the mouse, where we could understand, where we could identify genes and mechanisms that we could study then at a mechanistic level. But increasingly now, we've gotten interested in the internal dynamics of the developing human brain, taking advantage of people who donate their brains post-mortem to science to try to reconstruct how the human brain develops, and then always relating that to disease. Again, initially pediatric diseases, diseases in children, that's why I was recruited to Boston Children's Hospital, and now also looking at how the developmental pattern
Load full transcript
of our brain might set us up for age-related diseases as well.
00:06:15.000 --> 00:06:38.000
I want to start out pretty high level here, and I want to talk about the adult human brain first before we get into the developmental stuff. And I want to talk about it phylogenetically here. So what makes the human brain unique? I think we all have an intuitive sense for this, but as a neuroscientist studying this, what are the major standout features of the human brain?
00:06:38.000 --> 00:06:51.000
functionally, that we are interested in understanding how they arise in terms of the structures in the human brain that are different or unique or that somehow stand out compared to other species? What are the major things there that stick out?
00:06:52.000 --> 00:07:19.000
Well, Nick, that's really the challenge of studying the development of the human brain, but particularly the evolution of the human brain. We all have a sense that our brain is unique, that we have cognitive things that we do that other animals don't do in quite the same way. But we know really so little about the brain in general. So the question of the evolution of the human brain is a challenge in understanding what is the phenotype that we're trying to understand?
00:07:20.000 --> 00:07:55.000
What are the essential, really the essential differences between human brains and non-human brains? Because there are so many, so there are obvious things. Our brain is three times larger than that of our nearest living relative, the chimpanzee. But in fact, the difficulty in trying to tackle the genetics of the evolution of the human brain is really understanding what these differences are, because we are still at a fairly primitive level at understanding the inner wiring patterns of any brain.
00:07:57.000 --> 00:08:20.000
You know, you could ask, What about the evolution of mice versus rats? You would think those animals have been studied in the lab for over a century. We have all of these genetic strains, but we actually don't really have a sense of what are the essential phenotypic differences between mice and rats. And so it's a compounded difficulty when we try to figure out what are the phenotypic differences, what are the unique aspects of the human brain?
00:08:21.000 --> 00:08:59.000
I mean, obviously it's size. We have areas devoted to language. Other animals that don't communicate in the same way don't have such areas and we have a particular aspects of a particular wiring diagram that other animals don't have but really in many senses every animal is most highly evolved to its own purpose and so As I say, the real challenge in understanding evolution is really trying to figure out, the challenge in genetics in general, is what is the phenotype that you're trying to understand at a genetic level?
00:09:00.000 --> 00:09:22.000
And it's that characterization of just the facts that really drives the genetics. And that's why genetics likes things that are black and white differences, whereas we get into trouble with the human brain because we know so little about the unique aspects of our brain relative to even chimps, much less the brains of our extinct ancestors.
00:09:23.000 --> 00:09:55.000
Right, right. And of course, it's natural and attractive for people to look at just the sheer size of a brain and say, oh, well, the human brain is bigger than a chimpanzee brain, and size is an easy thing to look at. One of the things that you learn when you study neuroscience that I think is really interesting is when you start to look under the hood, and you look at, say, the neocortex of a mouse versus a chimp versus a human, to the untrained eye, you know, when you dig down to the cytoarchitectural level, the cell level, they actually look quite similar.
00:09:55.000 --> 00:10:19.000
And this sort of brings us to the question of, well, is the human brain just sort of a scaled up version of the other mammalian brains? Is it really mostly about size and number of neurons and number of connections? Or is there other stuff there? And I know it's a little bit of all the above here, but Can you give people a sense for how scientists like you today are thinking about the question of scale?
00:10:19.000 --> 00:10:24.000
Is it just a matter of scaling up to a human brain, or is there probably quite a bit more to it than that?
00:10:25.000 --> 00:10:37.000
Yeah, that's a great question, Nick. And it's certainly a question of scale. I mean, our brain is about 1,000 times the mass of a mouse's brain. And so that's a big question of scale.
00:10:37.000 --> 00:10:55.000
And we're maybe 30, 40, 50 times as big as the brain of a cat or a dog or something like that. And as I say, three times as big as a chimp. So a certain aspect of it is scaling up. And a lot of that scaling up involves the neocortex, the new cortex, which is the largest part of the human brain.
00:10:55.000 --> 00:11:12.000
It makes up about 80% of the volume of our brain. But it's not just scaled up relative to a mouse, because there's also a change. So the neocortex basically functions by having different areas of specialization. There's an area that's specialized for vision.
00:11:13.000 --> 00:11:32.000
There's an area that's specialized for language, areas that are specialized for motor control, and so forth. And then in the human brain, there are a lot of areas that are not obviously so specialized. We call them association cortex. And if we have a stroke in one of our association cortices, many times that stroke might be relatively silent.
00:11:32.000 --> 00:12:01.000
Whereas if we have a stroke in our language area, that's big trouble for making language. Or if we have a stroke in our motor area, we'll typically have a very focal paralysis. But the human brain then is not just a bigger version of the mouse, because the mouse their smaller brain is mostly taken up with these primary cortical areas, as we call them. The ones that directly are involved in sensation of the
body, particularly in the case of the mouse, or the ones directly involved in vision, ones directly involved in motor.
00:12:01.000 --> 00:12:33.000
Mouse has very little of this so-called association cortex, which is less specialized. And so I think it's widely, I think I share the belief of many, that it's the development of these association areas in the human that so dominate compared to other species that may also give us some of our cognitive enhancements and some of our ability to do some of these very unique things, these high-level cognitive functions that humans seem to do so well relative to other species.
00:12:34.000 --> 00:13:11.000
Yeah, I think when we start to think about these things, and you think about what the wiring diagrams look like, and you think about the number of processing steps from the sensory organs to the higher parts of the brain, there are essentially more layers of processing in certain organisms compared to others. So there are layers of processing in our brain in places like these association cortices that are not directly tied to just analyzing the one sensory channel they might be hooked up to, say, like the visual cortex is hooked up to the visual channel, other sensory areas are hooked up to the other channels.
00:13:11.000 --> 00:13:31.000
There's layers of processing stacked above those sensory layers. And we like to think that this is somehow important for abstraction for taking us away from just pure sensation and bodily stuff and doing more and more abstract things that we know are going to be important for cognitive behavior and complex behavior.
00:13:32.000 --> 00:14:12.000
Yeah, that's a great point, Nick. So I said that the human has a larger cortex in terms of surface area with these association areas added. However, like you say, most of the cortex is sort of like a great big layer cake with layers that we refer to typically as six layers, numbered from the bottom six to the top number one. And in fact, they mostly form a fairly stereotyped repetitive signaling unit, where the inputs tend to come in from the bottom, there are a series of synaptic relays, and then information goes back out to somewhere else.
00:14:13.000 --> 00:15:05.000
However, as you point out, as we ascend the sort of phylogenetic scale or as we get closer to humans, in fact, the lower layers of the cortex still look pretty similar to other species, and mostly what's added are additional layers on the top of the cake, and these are actually the layers, the neurons that are formed at later stages of development, and they're also the neurons that are added at the later stages of ontogeny, or phylogeny, rather. So it's actually sort of ontogeny recapitulating phylogeny, where these upper layers, layers two, and three, become very large and elaborate in the great apes and in humans. And these then add additional layers of circuits, which are very poorly represented, if at all, in rodents like mice and rats.
00:15:06.000 --> 00:15:42.000
And so, in fact, we have not only a larger cortex with more of these less differentiated areas, we also have, within that same circuit diagram, we're adding another layer of analysis. And in fact, interestingly, these upper layers, these layers two and three, are preferentially made up of neurons that actually all they do is project to other layers of the cortex. They don't project out of the cortex to do something like move your arm or move your leg. They seem to just bounce back and forth between the cortex, between different parts of the cerebral cortex proper.
00:15:42.000 --> 00:16:01.000
And so in that sense, they also have the look of neurons that are more involved in these higher level aspects of analysis, which again are greatly elaborated in humans and which are relatively simple in animals where the cortex is both smaller in its surface area and also squatter in its layering.
00:16:02.000 --> 00:16:34.000
Yeah. So I think what you're saying is there's layers on layers here. So we can think, and for this whole discussion, it's going to be important for us to think about individuals and one part of the brain processing one stream of information within one brain, but then how evolution sort of played with areas and layers of processing across species. And I think what you're saying is you can look at even a species like a mouse and their neocortex or their cerebral cortex is going to have this canonical layered structure to it.
00:16:35.000 --> 00:17:01.000
And it really is, you can kind of analogize it to maybe the hardware in our computers. There are layers of processing. You might have, say, the eyeball sending the brain information about visual stuff, and it reaches the visual cortex, and it really does go through layers of processing, one transformation, another transformation, then another. As it goes through those layers of processing in one area, that whole output can then get sent to another part of the cortex where it might then go through other layers.
00:17:02.000 --> 00:17:10.000
And then when we think about other species, I think what you're saying is evolution has sort of added more and more layers, mostly on the top side of that, so to speak.
00:17:11.000 --> 00:17:45.000
Yes, exactly right. And so this presumably then is giving functions that really mice don't really seem to need. And a lot of that might have to do with the fact that we live in such complex groups. Many people have suggested that some of this elaboration of the cortex and the rapid growth of the cortex over the last couple of million years may have correlated with the fact that humans and our immediate ancestors might have been living in much more larger, complex social groups than a lot of animals like mice live in.
00:17:46.000 --> 00:18:14.000
So I want to focus a little bit on the adult brain and some developmental questions related to, let's call it late development, when our brains become mature. And I want to ask you kind of what that
even means. So in popular speak, people talk about when the brain matures and when it's fully developed. And that has a lot of practical implications in terms of how we think about how we relate to each other, laws, and who should be allowed to do what and when.
00:18:14.000 --> 00:18:27.000
The number that I often hear is the human brain becomes fully mature or fully developed or finishes developing at around age 25. Is that true? And what exactly does that mean? Does the brain really stop developing?
00:18:27.000 --> 00:18:30.000
Is there really a time when we can say it's fully matured?
00:18:32.000 --> 00:19:04.000
Well, I think as a matter of definition, I think that the brain is constantly changing. So in that sense, development is a continuous process that continues throughout life. On the other hand, when we think of development, we think of it somewhat idealistically in terms of Aristotle or something like that, where we go from an unformed embryo to some sort of final product. And so I think common parlance, the term development refers to the formation of something rather than the subsequent aging of that same thing.
00:19:06.000 --> 00:19:32.000
So just a couple of aspects of the development of the brain, you know, there are these, the principal cells are neurons and glial cells. The neurons in our brain are all non-dividing cells. So they all have a birthday just like we do. We define the birthday of a neuron as the day at which it undergoes its final cell division and becomes permanently post-mitotic for the rest of the life of that person.
00:19:33.000 --> 00:19:50.000
And most of our neurons are born actually before our birthday. They're born during fetal gestation, most of them during the first half of fetal gestation. And then it's the glial cells that continue to divide at various rates throughout life. And so one way of thinking about development is, when are the neurons born?
00:19:50.000 --> 00:20:09.000
Well, in that sense, development is mostly done in the neocortex by the time of birth. There are a few neurons that are still born after birth. There are a couple of places in the cerebral cortex, like the hippocampus, that form at least some neurons, at least for a few years, if not longer. But most of the neurons are formed relatively early.
00:20:11.000 --> 00:20:41.000
And then we have this phase of glial formation, where glia are developing for years after birth in major ways. And a major sort of a glial development that occurs after birth are glia referred to as oligodendrocytes, which form the myelin insulation on nerve fibers. And so these cells are developing for the first couple of decades still fairly actively. There's still a lot of formation of myelin through the teenage years.
00:20:42.000 --> 00:21:11.000
And so then most people define development as not being done because a lot of the glia are not yet in place. And so I think that the idea of development being done in the mid-20s is a sense that, well, the neurons are long done, a lot of synapses are formed, the connections between neurons are already formed, and then a lot of the major glia seem to be in place. But there are ongoing changes that continue at all times. The synapses are constantly changing.
00:21:12.000 --> 00:21:24.000
In strength and in number, the glia continue to be added at slower levels, but it's much harder to detect. So if you do an MRI scan on someone's brain, it looks like things are pretty well done by the sort of 20s.
00:21:26.000 --> 00:21:40.000
Got it. So there's different aspects of development unfolding and finishing in different phases. Most of the neurons of the brain are going to end up where they're going to end up and be there relatively early. But then as you said, there's these other cells like glia.
00:21:40.000 --> 00:22:02.000
They're continuing to change and do stuff well into our 20s. And that's going to include things like making the insulation around neurons. So even though most of the neurons have ended up getting where they're going to be, there are still these refinements where The installation is changing, and therefore the efficiency of communication is changing. And things are still unfolding into our 20s.
00:22:04.000 --> 00:22:18.000
Yes. I mean, we have a paper that's coming out at some point. It's in preprint form and is, in principle, accepted at a good journal. So we think it'll be out, hopefully, by the end of the year, where we actually look at the development of the neurons.
00:22:20.000 --> 00:23:07.000
And we find that if you look at the, brain of fetuses that have been terminated but were outwardly normal, 25 or 30 percent of the neurons actually have grossly abnormal genomes. And then there's a wave of elimination of these abnormal neurons in the second half of fetal gestation so that by the time a baby is born, only about 5% of the neurons have these large-scale copy number variants, or gains or losses of large segments of a chromosome. But we find that, in fact, other neurons have small little defects, gains or losses of short segments of the genome, and that's still pretty common, even in newborns. 10 or 15% of the neurons will have these smaller-level imperfections.
00:23:08.000 --> 00:23:40.000
And we find, in fact, that these imperfect neurons are being edited out of our brain as long as we live. As I say, there's a wave of elimination of the most abnormal neurons before birth, and then a more gradual elimination of these less abnormal neurons that continues all the way through adult life. And so there seems to be an ongoing competition for survival between neurons. And the weak ones, the weak ones that have an abnormal genome are being constantly eliminated by a competitive process that's fast prenatally, and that's slower right on through aging.
00:23:41.000 --> 00:23:57.000
Yeah, yeah. Yeah. So there's this fascinating aspect to brain development where we start out with more neurons than we end up with. We actually take away
a lot of stuff at different phases of development, refine connections, completely get rid of certain neurons.
00:23:57.000 --> 00:24:37.000
And that's an important part of maturation and the ability for the adult brain to actually end up doing what it's gonna need to do as an adult brain. And that stuff's very interesting. When we think about some of these refinements that happen relatively early in development, after birth, This is an area too where you talk about things like critical periods or sensitive periods where there are these waves of time or these spans of time where you either have waves of loss or refinement connections and or somehow some way there's a period where the type of neuroplastic change and therefore the type of learning that's possible is different in one phase of development compared to later.
00:24:37.000 --> 00:24:52.000
Probably the most famous example of this in humans is the so-called critical period for language acquisition. Can you just say a little bit at a high level on the idea of critical periods and sensitive periods and what those are and what may be the major ones in humans that are studied?
00:24:54.000 --> 00:25:35.000
Gosh, well, yeah, there's a lot of work on these critical periods of development. And the terms were first really developed specifically in animal models, looking at the development of vision in animals like cats and mice, because I found that animals immediately after birth would have a great deal of plasticity. If you closed one eye, for example, then the open eye would take over most of the visual part of the brain. And then if you reopened the eye later on, in fact, the eye that had been closed would be really almost completely shut out and would have a great deal of difficulty being seen.
00:25:35.000 --> 00:26:23.000
And this mirrored experiences of ophthalmologists, kids born with amblyopia, where if it was not corrected at an early age, the amblyopic eye would become permanently blind, where if it was corrected early, in fact, that originally abnormal eye could do very well. And so the critical period for that sort of thing seems to last a couple of years in humans, but it's not like a sharp demarcation between plasticity early on and then a complete lack of plasticity later on, and then critical periods for different types of plastic change in the brain seem to vary. For example, kids who have strokes in their left hemisphere.
00:26:23.000 --> 00:26:43.000
If they have severe damage to their left hemisphere at an early age, they're able to develop language in the right hemisphere. And that sort of plasticity lasts for a few years. But then again, of course, that's not true in an adult. If an adult has a stroke in their left hemisphere in the language area, they typically permanently lose language and have relatively little recovery of it.
00:26:43.000 --> 00:27:04.000
So there's a critical period during which the right hemisphere is actually capable of developing a language center.
Even though in most people, the language center only develops on the left hemisphere, but the right hemisphere can stand in if the left hemisphere becomes damaged. And again, that sort of critical period tends to be the first few years of life. Again, it's not defined.
00:27:05.000 --> 00:27:32.000
These situations are sufficiently uncommon that it's not defined with tremendous precision and varied, and also depends on a lot of other variables. So we know that the human brain is particularly plastic for these first two, three, four, five years of life. Some people wonder whether that's why we tend to have very few memories of our early childhood, because our brain is so plastic at that age that we lose those memories. They get overwritten, essentially.
00:27:32.000 --> 00:28:00.000
Or it's also a phenomenon where children can learn a second language if it's spoken at their home when they're very young. But then once they're in school, they will often lose that language, their ability in that second language if they're not constantly using it. And so that's a kind of a plasticity where things can be overwritten. And also it's a common thing that we have actually relatively few memories of our early childhood.
00:28:01.000 --> 00:28:29.000
So there's a phenomenon referred to as childhood forgetting. where we know relatively little of what, we have relatively few explicit memories of the very early parts of our life. And so again, some people think that it's the extreme plasticity of that early brain that gives us a lot of capabilities, like developing a language area and all that, but which also cause us to have some relatively transient memories from that time.
00:28:29.000 --> 00:28:58.000
Yeah, and so when we think about the development of the human brain, the size and the structure of the human brain compared to other species, naively, you might think, well, bigger is better. More synapses mean more information, more memory capacity, more abilities, and so forth. And yet, when we study development, we see that there's this overabundance of neurons and connections that get pruned away, that get taken away. A lot of this stuff is tied to this early developmental sensitive period stuff.
00:28:59.000 --> 00:29:16.000
Before we dig into some of the mechanics and some of the details of your work and others' work, at a high level, conceptually, why do we think that development sort of has this pattern of generating more than enough and then pruning it back or refining it away? Why not keep all of those connections? Yeah.
00:29:16.000 --> 00:29:40.000
Well, again, that's a great question, and I'm not sure we know the answer for sure. I've been impressed in this work I was just telling you about, which is, again, is very new. And so it's not published in final form yet. In fact, this over-generation of neurons involves a lot of neurons that are highly error-prone, and their genomes are not in good shape.
00:29:40.000 --> 00:30:53.000
So again, an area of big surprise in the last few years is how error prone the early development of the embryo turns out to be. A lot of this comes from the IVF literature where families would be undergoing in vitro fertilization and then the obstetricians would take one or two of the cells of the embryo and they would want to check it to make sure that it looked good and they would look at the chromosomes under the microscope and they would only want to implant it if that cell that they examined, that sample that they took had normal looking chromosomes. But it would occasionally be the case in IVF where they would examine one or two cells from the blastocyst for the very, very early embryo, and in fact they would find that the cells that they looked at had very abnormal chromosomes, gains or losses of chromosomes, and then they would have a puzzle. What do we do? if they had no choice, because if they didn't have any embryos that looked good, they would implant the embryo anyway, despite the abnormal chromosomes. And in fact, most of those embryos develop perfectly normally, it turns out.
00:30:54.000 --> 00:31:13.000
And the reason is because the blastocyst is dozens of different cells, and they just happen to take cells that are mosaic, where a couple of maybe 10 or 20 percent of the cells in that embryo were very abnormal but most of them are normal and that the abnormal ones are eliminated later on.
00:31:14.000 --> 00:31:17.000
There's an error correction mechanism baked right into the whole process.
00:31:17.000 --> 00:31:36.000
Yeah, so it looks like our bodies have these error correction mechanisms. I mean, the question for us is, why does nature do that? Why does nature create all those errors and then correct them? We don't know if that's a deliberate process or it's impossible to be perfect.
00:31:38.000 --> 00:31:56.000
But we have then built into our body error correction mechanisms. Of course, you know, these abnormal cells would turn into cancer or something if they weren't also eliminated during normal development. Turns out neurons then also have an error correction process. Their error correction process looks like it relies on the formation of connections with other neurons.
00:31:57.000 --> 00:32:30.000
Basically, neurons have to synapse or die. Nature overgenerates neurons, and then of the neurons that are formed, she selects the best ones. And it's possible to see advantages of that process, where there's a form of Darwinian evolution that's affecting the development, particularly of our brain, but likely other tissues as well, where basically, instead of just trying to get it exactly right every time, nature finds it easier to just overgenerate and then select.
00:32:31.000 --> 00:32:55.000
Yeah, no, there's an analogy there with evolution by natural selection at the population level of organisms, right? Where there's an overabundance produced and only a subset of individuals in any population are actually going to reproduce and pass on
their traits. And I want to circle back to some of that stuff. But I want to ask you a little bit about the genetics and the phylogenetics of the human brain compared to other brains.
00:32:55.000 --> 00:33:16.000
So we know the human brain is different in various respects. We've got a big neocortex. We've got these big brains that are different in various incompletely understood ways from chimps and other mammals. But when we look at the genes here, I want to start asking you about some of the genetic work that informs how the human brain develops compared to other creatures.
00:33:17.000 --> 00:33:36.000
One maybe starting point here for us is if we go back to sort of the early days of genome sequencing and people started to look at genome sequences, how many genes do we have? How big is the genome? And so forth. One of the surprises back in the early days for people was the just the number of genes, the protein coding genes that humans had compared to other creatures.
00:33:36.000 --> 00:34:10.000
A lot of the earlier predictions were, well, we're humans, we're going to have a bajillion genes, and we're going to have way more than chimps and cucumbers and jellyfish and so forth. And one of the surprises there, I think, was that we found that the differences were actually much more modest than maybe we thought before. And so the thinking turned, at least in some schools of thought, to, well, it's not so much about the number of protein coding genes you have, It's really about how you regulate them, how you express them and control them throughout development. Can you say a little bit at a high level about what we know about the genetics of human brain development?
00:34:11.000 --> 00:34:22.000
And is it about how we use genes and the regulation of them? Do we have more genes involved in brain development than other creatures? What does the broad picture start to look like here?
00:34:22.000 --> 00:34:38.000
Yeah, right. Yeah, basically, like you said, our genome is about the same size as the genome of a mouse. We both have about 20,000 genes. We have about 3 million base pairs of DNA in the entire genome.
00:34:39.000 --> 00:35:27.000
And that's only a few more genes than fruit flies or roundworms that have 16,000 or 18,000 genes. There's a debate on exactly how you define a gene, but I'll set aside that debate for the time being, because we could talk all day just about what you mean by the term gene. But yes, so most of the genes we have are you can point to the genome of a mouse and you can say, oh yeah, there's, you know, RAS, there's ASPM in the mouse, and it looks more similar than different in mice compared to humans. There are, you know, maybe a few, so there are maybe a few dozen, human-specific genes, depending again on a little bit on how you define them, whether they're duplications of previous genes.
00:35:27.000 --> 00:35:43.000
But basically, in general, there are three ways that evolution can happen. So evolution can add new genes. And it turns out that seems to be relatively uncommon. And that's probably because it's hard.
00:35:43.000 --> 00:36:01.000
Nature doesn't generally invent things out of whole cloth. It's hard to make a whole new gene that came out of nowhere. And then the second way that evolution can happen is that the same gene can be altered. It can be altered typically in the protein that it makes.
00:36:01.000 --> 00:36:32.000
So you can have alterations to the part of the gene that actually makes the protein, so that you change one amino acid for another amino acid, or you change a run of amino acids. And so that can take an existing protein and change its biochemistry. It might cause it to interact with proteins that it ordinarily doesn't, or it might add a new function to an existing protein. And that turns out to be also a relatively uncommon way in which evolution happens, although it's more common than adding a gene outright.
00:36:33.000 --> 00:36:57.000
And then the third way in which evolution can happen, which seems, as far as we can tell, to be by far the most common, is that you can change the way genes are regulated. You can change the cell. You're not changing what the gene does as much as putting it in a cell that might not ordinarily express that gene. And so by putting it in a cell that ordinarily doesn't use that gene, it might change what that cell does.
00:36:58.000 --> 00:37:21.000
Or you can be changing the timing or the level of expression, how much gene there is, or when and where it's expressed in the brain. And that seems to be the most common mechanism. And that's probably the most common mechanism because if you start tinkering with, because basically most changes to a protein are bad. We call them mutations.
00:37:21.000 --> 00:37:45.000
They cause disease. That's what we see all the time in our clinics. We see kids that have the unfortunate experience that they have a change in the coding sequence of a gene that encodes a protein, and so consequently they lose the function of that gene and that typically creates a disease. It's hard, again, to alter a protein in just the perfect way that it does something better.
00:37:46.000 --> 00:38:19.000
And yet, by changing when and where a gene is turned on, you're not compromising the function of that gene in all of the cells that already use it. The cells that already use it, they still have access to it, and you can just add something onto it. And so this sort of regulatory changes to genes is generally done in regulatory sequences of the gene, which don't code for the protein itself, but they're sort of on-off switches that define when and where the protein is provided to a cell. And that seems to be where the bulk of the evolution is happening.
00:38:20.000 --> 00:38:32.000
And, of course, that is the part of the genome about which we also know the least. And so that is what creates the challenge for trying to define what all these evolutionary changes actually are.
00:38:32.000 --> 00:38:57.000
Yeah, yeah. So I see the basic idea here would be, if I've got a protein that does an important job, maybe it's a transcription factor that controls the expression of other genes. Maybe it's an enzyme that's critical for a core metabolic process. If I start messing with the protein sequence, the actual meat of that protein, I'm probably going to compromise it rather than improve it, just statistically speaking.
00:38:57.000 --> 00:39:23.000
And if I do that in the protein coding sequence, it's going to have that effect in every cell. all the neurons it's in, all of the kidney cells it's in, all of the whatever cells it's in. But if we've got all of these parts of the genome that are involved in regulation rather than the protein coding part, we can now tinker with those and start to make 10% more of the protein, but maybe just in this cell or keep it on a little bit longer in brain development, but not somewhere else.
00:39:24.000 --> 00:39:31.000
And we can play with things in a more tinkering fashion where we're just making these finer adjustments, let's say.
00:39:32.000 --> 00:40:00.000
Exactly. I mean, a typical gene might have 5, 10, 15 different regulatory sequences that control, it's on and it's off. And they can be tuned so that their regulatory sequences, like you say, just for kidney cells as opposed to just for neurons. And so then evolution can work on just the neuronal use of that gene and leave alone what it does in another part of the body so that you don't damage some other organ while you're trying to improve another.
00:40:01.000 --> 00:40:13.000
And if we kind of connect some of that to human development, human development is long. We develop for longer than other animals. We have these extended childhoods. Our gestation's pretty long.
00:40:14.000 --> 00:40:29.000
Is there a sense that a lot of human brain development is tied to just extending how long things happen so that you can add more layers of control and layers of neurons? Is a lot of this about just timing and taking our time, so to speak?
00:40:31.000 --> 00:40:54.000
Well, again, it's hard to untangle, but it seems like that may well be the case. Certainly, our development is much extended compared to that of other species, even chimps. You know, mice develop in three weeks until they're born, and then humans, you know, it takes us nine months. And it's a long time even after the neurons are formed before we're born.
00:40:55.000 --> 00:41:16.000
And then, as you say, the postnatal development is so gradual, much more gradual than other animals. It's not totally clear why. We have this neoteny, as we call it, which is basically this slowing and more gradual developmental timetable. It's not totally clear what the evolutionary advantage of it is.
00:41:16.000 --> 00:41:45.000
This is a very hot area of debate because, of course, in many ways that slow development creates survival challenges because the baby has to be protected from predators for that much longer. And so it must be doing something very essential for the brain for it to have evolutionary value because of, as I say, the potential survival challenges that happens. And so this might... Slow development appears to be associated with a very high level of plasticity.
00:41:45.000 --> 00:41:59.000
These critical periods, again, are much longer in humans than in other species. And so it might be that that gives us advantages. This extended plasticity might give us other advantages in terms of long-term cognitive function.
00:42:00.000 --> 00:42:20.000
And when we think about human brain evolution and we line up the genomes across species, when we look at the human genome and compare it to the chimp genome or whatever other genome you might want to point us to, is there a sense that there's an enrichment of change that happened in neural development-related genes as opposed to other genes?
00:42:20.000 --> 00:42:35.000
Yes, there certainly is. You know, this is the... So this is the challenge of studying evolution in terms of genomics. as I said at the outset, that we know so little about the phenotype.
00:42:36.000 --> 00:42:59.000
And what are the essential differences in brains that we're trying to explain? This is the advantage of doing it from the genome-first sort of point of view, because the brain is so complicated. The genome is complicated, but it's a lot less complicated than the brain. I think of the genome, it's 20,000 genes, sort of like the size of a small town.
00:42:59.000 --> 00:43:17.000
linear, because it's digital, it's finite. Whereas the brain, it's like 20 billion cells, trillions and trillions of synapses. We don't know what the key ones are. Rather than a small town is the analogy, it seems more like you need a celestial analogy, like the stars.
00:43:17.000 --> 00:43:49.000
It's so complicated. So we have very good methods for lining up genes and lining up genomes. And so then what we can do is we can align the species of so many different species now, and we can identify those parts of the genome that are most uniquely human, those that have shown the most accelerated change in DNA, in humans relative to non-human species. So there are a variety of ways of defining these areas that look like they're particularly evolutionarily important.
00:43:50.000 --> 00:44:19.000
One definition are called human accelerated regions, because they're areas of accelerated evolution in the human genome relative to others. And then every animal would have these accelerated regions. There would be chimpanzee-accelerated regions that showed accelerated evolution in chimps. There are mouse-accelerated regions that showed accelerated evolution in mice, presumably in each case making changes that are most essential to make that species what it is.
00:44:20.000 --> 00:44:46.000
And in the case of the human-accelerated regions, we know that about half of them have to do with the brain. Many of them having to do with
the development of the brain, and then others look like they're mostly involved in adult brain function. And almost a half of these human accelerated regions are, in fact, these regulatory regions that tend to turn genes on or off. And so that looks like that's a particularly hot spot for evolution.
00:44:46.000 --> 00:45:02.000
So at a high level, it does look like a lot of where the evolutionary action is for the human brain is in playing with how genes involved in neurons, in some way, how they're used, how they're expressed, how much, when, exactly where, that stuff.
00:45:03.000 --> 00:45:18.000
Yeah. Yes, that seems to be the most important thing quantitatively. There are some interesting examples. of genes where there seems to have been evolution on the protein coding sequence.
00:45:20.000 --> 00:45:33.000
An interesting example is one that got me hooked on studying evolution in the first place, right? I mean, I'm a neurologist. I am a doctor. How did I get mixed up in studying evolution?
00:45:34.000 --> 00:46:01.000
Well, we studied kids that had a very small brain called microcephaly, where the size of their brain is reduced to that of chimpanzees. And in fact, not just the size, the shape of the brain in these kids with microcephaly, in fact, takes on a bit more of the shape of a primate-like brain. The sylvia fissure is not as well developed, the language area is not as large, the frontal cortex is not as large relative to the rest of the brain.
00:46:01.000 --> 00:46:11.000
So you're talking about a genetic abnormality that, at least at the gross level, basically makes someone develop what looks much more like a chimpanzee brain in terms of its overall size and shape.
00:46:12.000 --> 00:46:30.000
Yeah, surprisingly. Like I say, the volume is very close. And the first one of these microcephaly genes that was identified was identified by Jeff Woods at Cambridge. And I was fortunate enough to collaborate with him on that.
00:46:31.000 --> 00:46:46.000
And it's a gene called ASPM, that's an abbreviation for abnormal spindles microcephaly gene. And it's a gene that was first described in the fruit fly where it regulates cell division in stem cells. So that sort of makes sense.
00:46:46.000 --> 00:46:51.000
So we're talking about one gene here and it's a gene that other creatures even like fruit flies have.
00:46:51.000 --> 00:47:00.000
Oh, yeah, absolutely. Even nematodes, even C. elegans has this gene. And so this was more than 20 years ago that we identified this gene.
00:47:00.000 --> 00:47:30.000
But as soon as we identified it, we compared the human version to the mouse and the fruit fly and the C. elegans. And we found that, in fact, this ASPM, again, unique or unusual among genes, has very dramatic differences in the protein coding sequence. contains a repeated sequence and all of the repeats start with the same two amino acids, isoleucine and then glutamine.
00:47:30.000 --> 00:47:52.000
And isoleucine is abbreviated I, and glutamine is abbreviated Q. And so these are called IQ repeats. And the human version has 72 repeats, and the mouse version had 55 repeats, and the fly version had 21, and sea aliens had two. And so Jeff said, wow, I mean, now we know that God has a sense of humor.
00:47:53.000 --> 00:47:56.000
Because it'd be so simple. It's the length of the IQ repeats.
00:47:56.000 --> 00:48:15.000
The length of the IQ repeats that determines how big your brain is. And so it turns out that humans, in fact, mice are a special case. Their short version of the ASPM is unique to the rodent branch of the lineage tree. It's more conventional for mammals to have the same number of repeats as humans.
00:48:16.000 --> 00:49:04.000
But in fact, then also, if you look at the details of the sequence, In humans compared to non-human primates, ASPM shows an excess of various amino acid altering changes. We call them missense changes in the lineage leading from the great apes to humans. And so it seems like there was not only large scale changes in the encoded protein over the course of more ancient evolution, but actually finer scale changes in the evolution of the protein coding sequence in the last 10 to 15 million years in the evolution of the primates. And so this got me kind of hooked on studying evolution and illustrated to me the tremendous power that human medical genetics can bring to understanding these questions of origin.
00:49:05.000 --> 00:49:13.000
Because humans have mutations now we know in every possible gene and so whatever Aspects of the genome are essential for evolution.
00:49:13.000 --> 00:49:36.000
We can probably learn a lot about it by studying human disease Yeah, and you know this starts to at least get me thinking about some things that I think start to tie together an interesting way here, so you're talking about this microcephaly phenotype people that are basically born with this unfortunate small brain that looks kind of like a chimpanzee brain. It's much smaller. It's not a fully functional human brain.
00:49:36.000 --> 00:49:56.000
It's a one gene mutation. It's a gene that we share in common with other creatures, not just primates, but all kinds of other creatures. And it kind of connects the dots a little bit to what you said before around mutations and the risk of mutations. It's really risky to mutate genes because there's probably more ways to break things and hurt the development of the organism than to help them.
00:49:57.000 --> 00:50:27.000
And it also gets me thinking about something that you often hear about in evolutionary genetics. So when you're interested in any given phenotype, any different change you might want to explain, when you think about it in genetic terms, you can sort of imagine, well, there could be one gene of large effect, a super mutation that in that one gene gives you the whole phenotype. And maybe it hurts you like in microcephaly, or maybe in ultra rare cases, you can imagine like a super mutation that
really built some cool structure in the human brain.
00:50:28.000 --> 00:51:01.000
On the other extreme, phenotypes are often due to many, many different tiny changes in many different genes. When you're thinking about brain evolution and studying it in the lab, In general, do we think that it's more about tinkering and small mutations across many genes to change and shift the developmental process with all of these little changes? Or do we think there could have been major adaptive changes in single genes that sort of suddenly gave us big changes in the human lineage?
00:51:02.000 --> 00:51:19.000
Yeah, so I think there's an element of both. The big changes, like loss of ASPN, those are the ones that are easier to study. Right? Because loss of ASPM causes a very dramatic phenotype in humans.
00:51:19.000 --> 00:51:32.000
It causes a somewhat, it causes almost no phenotype in mice. If you knock it out, the brain is hardly smaller at all. They seem to rely much less on the gene than humans do. And then we actually knocked it out in ferrets.
00:51:32.000 --> 00:52:22.000
As an animal that has a much larger brain than the mice, it has a much more dramatic phenotype than the mouse, but again, less dramatic than the humans. But here, we, We have, again, dramatic changes in the gene, these subtler changes over the course of evolution, changing one amino acid for another, and then the dramatic disabling of the entire gene in disease states that show us what the gene is essential to do. So basically, we have several examples like that in the study of brain evolution, where the addition of a gene or changes in the gene have been related to dramatic changes in the development of the brain. And so those are the ones that you may have heard about because those are the ones that are particularly robust to study scientifically.
00:52:23.000 --> 00:53:11.000
But again, over the course of evolution, it's very likely that the tinkering around the edges of many, many genes, hundreds or thousands of genes, is the more important mechanism over the eons. However, these are mechanisms that, at the moment, we're very limited in being able to study in animal models, because we're talking about changes between humans and the androthal, or changes between humans and chimps. But these are changes that probably have no meaning for a mouse, because the mouse has such a terribly small cortex to begin with, it probably doesn't have, you know, these other genes are as likely as not to really have essential functions in mice, so they're difficult to study in the lab, and so they're a little harder to nail down in terms of their essential nature.
00:53:12.000 --> 00:54:15.000
And again, that's where medical genetics comes in handy, because then what you can do is you can look, you know, as a population of eight billion people on the planet, basically we have someone somewhere in the world has a mutation at every single base pair in the human genome. We all have about 80 to 100 mutations relative to our parents. And so if you have 80 to 100 mutations relative to your parents and you have 8 billion people, you do the math, it turns out that means that probably every single base pair in our 3 billion base pair genome has been mutated more than 100 times just in the last generation. And so we can then identify the essential roles of these regulatory sequences in the human genome, perhaps most effectively by studying human disease, which tends to make dramatic changes to them associated with disease. And then, of course, if we never find someone with a disease that has an alteration in a particular part of the genome, it probably means that that part of the genome is just not doing anything very important.
00:54:17.000 --> 00:54:39.000
When we're thinking about human development, human evolution, and we want to study either a disease, something that's going wrong that has a genetic basis, or we want to study how the human brain became the human brain. What are the changes that led to our brains doing what they do? Let's say you're in the lab. You identify a really interesting gene or set of genes.
00:54:39.000 --> 00:54:58.000
You identify variants or mutations that are unique to the human lineage. That's really interesting, but you can't do the types of invasive mechanistic detailed studies you can do in model organisms. When you are looking at human variants, how do you actually study them and really tease apart what might be going on there functionally?
00:54:59.000 --> 00:55:27.000
Yeah, so I think that's really obviously a big technical challenge. So again, we've run into that in the study of these human accelerated regions. And so as I mentioned, the human-accelerated regions are the ones which show the most rapid differences in humans compared to non-human primates. And there also tend to be parts of the genome that are otherwise conserved in mammals.
00:55:27.000 --> 00:55:51.000
So they'll be very similar in many, many different mammals and then suddenly a lot different in humans. We thought, oh, OK, great. Well, maybe some of these human accelerated regions are essential for some of the cognitive activities that we pride ourselves on. So we sequenced human accelerated regions in thousands of kids that had intellectual disability and autism spectrum disorders.
00:55:51.000 --> 00:56:14.000
And we find, in fact, that they're is an excess of rare mutations in kids with social and cognitive defects in these human axillary regions. It suggests then that some of them do have essential roles in our cognition. But the challenge then is how do we model that in a dish? How do we model that in mice?
00:56:14.000 --> 00:56:48.000
You know, it's now very common and increasingly useful to take human stem cells and you can differentiate them into a a little piece of brain-like substance. We call them mini-brains or organoids, where you can get them to differentiate into a certain range of human neurons. And so this gives you the
ability to study at least isolated neurons in a dish. And so that's been useful for studying at least some of these changes, because you can see what they're doing in differentiated human neurons.
00:56:49.000 --> 00:57:14.000
However, these cultured human organoids by no means recapitulate anything remotely like the beautiful complexity of the whole human brain. And so exactly So again, some genes can be well studied in that context, but some can't because they may be having a function that requires these connections between different parts of the brain or something that can't be reproduced in the dish.
00:57:15.000 --> 00:57:30.000
Interesting. So I know that some people do studies where they will, say, identify an interesting human variant. Maybe there's a regulatory mutation in some gene that's involved in something to do with neurons. And then you can actually put the humanized version of that, say, in a mouse.
00:57:30.000 --> 00:57:44.000
How do those studies work? And how do they work? And how do we interpret them? Do they sometimes, we think, tell us directionally what that variant might be doing in humans, even though we're putting it in the context of a lab animal like a rodent?
00:57:45.000 --> 00:58:23.000
Yeah, there's been some really lovely studies that have done that. There's some beautiful studies by Debbie Silver from Duke, and Frank Poulot from Columbia, and Pierre van der Haag, and also from Belgium, where they've basically engineered the mice to have these human-like sequences. And sometimes they will actually cause dramatic changes in the neurons that you can see even in a subset of neurons in the mouse brain. And so again, that is When that is the case, that is a very powerful demonstration that that regulatory sequence or that HAR is doing something really important.
00:58:23.000 --> 00:58:52.000
So Debbie has done some experiments where she's put one or two HARs, these human version of a regulatory sequence into the mouse. And in a couple of cases, the mouse brain will get bigger. And these are human accelerated regions that look like they're active in the stem cells. And so it looks like it will be, it doesn't get, hugely bigger, but it gets a little bit bigger, suggesting that these regulatory regions are programming the stem cells to keep going a little bit longer and generate more neurons.
00:58:53.000 --> 00:59:24.000
Again, the idea here is we've got a gene in us, there's the equivalent gene in a mouse, If you swap in the human regulatory sequence into the mouse regulatory region, you've got the same protein being made in the mouse because they've got the same gene. You're now just putting it in a different spot or changing the timing. And in some cases, it does cause more stem cells to grow or to migrate and the brain to get a little bit bigger. So tinkering with sort of when and where the gene is turned on is making the phenotype.
00:59:24.000 --> 00:59:24.000
That's right.
00:59:25.000 --> 01:00:12.000
Yeah, and
another approach that a former fellow of mine, Janet Song, who now has her own lab here at Harvard, she's actually made tetraploid cells with two nuclei, a chimp and a human, and then differentiated them into neurons. And this allows you to have the two genomes in the same cell type. And so if you see changes in gene expression and things like that, you can localize it to, it helps you determine whether that's due to the specific regulatory changes that are unique to the human evolutionary lineage or not. And as I said, this is a new and very powerful system where you can actually take the tetraploid cells, even though they have two copies of the genome, one chimp and one human, they actually develop into very good looking neurons.
01:00:12.000 --> 01:00:18.000
So that also gives us another way of looking at how evolutionary changes relate to one another.
01:00:18.000 --> 01:00:49.000
Yeah. And I want to ask you some questions that I think relate to the more clinical side of what you do in some ways, which is when we look at the human brain and we study its development and we study the ways it's unique, the ways that it's bigger and the connections we have and all of the stuff that gives us what we think of as the good things of being human, sometimes it seems like those aspects of our brains also leave us vulnerable to pathologies or psychiatric conditions that maybe other organisms don't really have as much or aren't expressed in the same way.
01:00:50.000 --> 01:01:04.000
Can you say something here at a high level about how some of the changes that were probably good for human evolution to sort of build our big brains the way they are, maybe sort of predisposed us to psychiatric illnesses that humans have to deal with much more than other creatures.
01:01:05.000 --> 01:01:15.000
Yeah, sure. Yeah. So there are a couple of examples of that. So making a big brain puts a challenge on the stem cells.
01:01:16.000 --> 01:01:38.000
Because every time a cell divides, it has to copy all those 3 billion base pairs on each copy of the genome. It's actually one 3 billion from your mom, one from your father. You've got 6 billion base pairs of genome that has to be copied precisely every time a cell divides. And so it's inevitable in that process that some errors will come about.
01:01:39.000 --> 01:02:20.000
And so every time a cell divides, it creates the two daughter cells have mutations that we call somatic mutations or mosaic mutations. And so these are much less of a problem in mice because mice only take a couple of cell divisions to generate the whole animal. But with our larger brain, we're more subject to these mosaic mutations than other species are. And so we find that mosaic mutations are an important, if they occur in a particular gene, they can cause intractable childhood epilepsy due to just a little clone of cells that have developed an abnormal mutation in a cancer gene that causes those neurons to be excessively active.
01:02:20.000 --> 01:02:44.000
And you can actually do surgery to remove that patch of the brain to cure the epilepsy. And then an even more common type of epilepsy is in the temporal lobe. And this is a part of the brain called, it localizes to a part of the brain called the hippocampus. And this is the part of the cerebral cortex I mentioned that continues to undergo cell division and proliferation for several years after birth.
01:02:45.000 --> 01:03:15.000
And this temporal lobe epilepsy is the most common epilepsy in adults. and it arises just from the hippocampus. And so we find, in fact, those patients often will get surgery to remove one hippocampus to cure their epilepsy, and we find that those cases typically will have also a mosaic mutation in an activating cancer-like pathway. And as far as we can tell, these kinds of mosaic disorders don't occur in other species.
01:03:15.000 --> 01:03:39.000
We have some reason to think that there might be mosaic causes that contribute to schizophrenia as well, which is, again, a disease that we're not clear that it actually exists outside of humans. And then also, of course, age-related things like Alzheimer's disease. They also involve these somatic mutations, particularly in the cells in the brain that continue to divide throughout life, like some of the glial cells.
01:03:39.000 --> 01:04:02.000
Yeah. So the double-edged sword here at a very high level is you've got so many neurons and so many connections, and you can use that for really useful stuff, all those connections, all those possibilities. The flip side of that might be that if you've got too many connections or they're not pruned properly, or you don't refine and mold them properly, that can leave you vulnerable to other things like epilepsy.
01:04:03.000 --> 01:04:32.000
Exactly right, yeah. And some of these epileptic mutations, they occur in genes that often will cause cancer in a dividing cell, but neurons are not dividing. So there'll be familiar cancer mutations, like the RAS pathway that's been in the news lately because of the new RAS inhibitors, or the mTOR pathway, another common cancer pathway. But the mutations occur in the neurons, and neurons don't divide, so they can't form cancer, they just become really bad neighbors.
01:04:32.000 --> 01:04:47.000
They become hyperactive and epileptogenic. And so, again, these are problems that only happen if the mutation occurs during the developmental process when the neurons are formed, which, as I said, is mostly going on early in life.
01:04:47.000 --> 01:05:01.000
Yeah. And I want to go back to that early development and talk about the mechanics underlying this refinement process that's so important. So neurons have to be born. The neuron has to divide the number of times it's going to divide until it gets to its mature state.
01:05:02.000 --> 01:05:15.000
That neuron has to get where it's going to end up in a human brain region. It's got to hook up to other neurons, not too much, not too little,
just the right way, whatever that means. And it's also got to be working properly, right? The cell can't have extra chromosomes or copy number variants.
01:05:16.000 --> 01:05:27.000
It can't be messed up in some other way. So it seems like there's probably checkpoints that these neurons go through. And a lot of them don't make it through, as you mentioned earlier. There's this huge refinement that happens early in development.
01:05:28.000 --> 01:05:44.000
We lose whole neurons. We prune away connections. And if we don't do that properly, that's probably what underlies, at least in part, some of the neurological and psychiatric issues that humans can end up with. I want to dig into sort of how that refinement happens and what those checkpoints are.
01:05:44.000 --> 01:06:02.000
You mentioned earlier that this concept of copy number variance, the wrong number of chromosomes, the wrong number of genes. What are some of those things that can go wrong and when and where do they actually go wrong? And then from there, I guess we'll talk about what the checkpoints are and how the brain selects the ones that are working right.
01:06:03.000 --> 01:06:30.000
Yeah, right, so as you said, there are genetic mutations that disrupt every step of the process of the development of the human brain. The formation of the neurons, we talked about that in the case of microcephaly. There are other conditions where the brain is too big, but not normally functioning. And then the neurons are formed in one place, and then they generally have to migrate to a different place, and there are genetic abnormalities typically associated with epilepsy that disrupt this migration.
01:06:31.000 --> 01:07:19.000
And then, as you say, all these connections have to be formed and refined. You know, there's an ongoing theory of things like autism spectrum disorders and perhaps some of the intellectual disabilities as well, is that they can either be defects of the formation of the connections on the one hand, where the connections are not made in the right ways or in the right number, or perhaps more commonly, defects in this competitive elimination. There are studies from a long time ago in humans and then studies in mice as well that suggest that this, this normal pruning process and these critical periods are abnormal in kids on the autism spectrum, that the elimination of neurons is not happening in the right way.
01:07:20.000 --> 01:07:50.000
Now, exactly how that elimination process happens is really complex. And it involves a large number of genes. We estimate that there are hundreds, very likely more than a thousand different genes that can be mutated to cause what we call autism spectrum disorder. And the vast majority of these hundreds of different genes have roles either in the synapse or in regulating the level of proteins of the synapse.
01:07:51.000 --> 01:08:24.000
And it looks like you can have defects all up and down this pathway from the synapse into the nucleus to turn the right genes on, and then the genes have to get out of the, then the RNAs have to get out of the nucleus, they have to get to the ribosome, they have to get translated to the right protein at the right level, then those proteins have to be targeted to the right synapse to strengthen that synapse. And so it looks like basically all of those genes are essential, and mutations in many, many different genes can cause this very similar phenotype. And so there are all kinds of mysteries as to how that happens.
01:08:24.000 --> 01:08:50.000
How does a neuron pick exactly which of its thousands of synapses to strengthen selectively and which to let go? And how is this competitive process managed at a large level? And as I say, there's a lot we really don't understand about how that happens. And that's so critical, really, to understanding how autism develops.
01:08:51.000 --> 01:09:27.000
Again, it's a profound mystery about autism that you can have genetic mutations in hundreds of different genes that can cause a similar look in a kid, that can cause similar defects in a child. How do these hundreds of different genes have such a similar phenotype? And yet, then each one of these genes tends to have a range of phenotypes, so that sometimes a mutation in a particular gene or a copy number variant at chromosome 16P11 might cause intellectual disability in one child, autism in another child, might cause no defect in a third child, might cause schizophrenia in a fourth child.
01:09:28.000 --> 01:09:52.000
And so that's another mystery, how a single genetic defect can cause a range of phenotypes in the human, or how multiple different genes can cause seemingly indistinguishable ones. And this relates mostly to the fact that our genome does not specify precisely how the brain is going to be made. It instead specifies a historic process. It specifies rules.
01:09:53.000 --> 01:10:05.000
that govern the interactions between neurons. And that process plays out over an extended period of time. It's modified by the environment. It's modified by the teaching of our parents.
01:10:05.000 --> 01:10:12.000
It's modified by early intervention. And there are many things that modify it that are not genetic. So the genetics is really important, but it's not everything.
01:10:13.000 --> 01:10:40.000
Yeah. And when we think about how this refinement actually happens, when we think about what is the brain actually looking at to decide whether to keep one neuron and not another, or to keep one connection and not another, how are we starting to understand how that happens? So you hinted earlier that You were talking about things like copy number variance. So somehow, you might have too many copies of a gene, you might have too much protein in a cell or something like that.
01:10:41.000 --> 01:11:00.000
There's probably mechanisms by which the brain somehow is detecting if there's too much or too little of something, and then deciding to get rid of the neurons or the
connections that have too much or are not working properly. But what do we know there about clear mechanisms where something is being selected for?
01:11:02.000 --> 01:11:31.000
Again, there are several steps in that. So the early aspects of these connections are largely governed by genetics, gradients of transcription factors, gradients of signaling molecules. And then a second series of formation of connections is largely governed by patterns of spontaneous activity. that neurons tend to just, once they get hooked up, they tend to just start firing in waves.
01:11:32.000 --> 01:11:54.000
And so those waves tend to be coordinated by neighboring neurons. And so then neurons which are active together tend to mutually strengthen connections that those neurons will find. And then a third phase of connectivity is more governed by interactions with the environment. What things that we actually see that create patterns of activity that strengthen synapses.
01:11:54.000 --> 01:12:24.000
And so then exactly how the synapses get strengthened is basically a process where when the neurons depolarize, when the neurons are active, they depolarize, meaning their voltage across their membrane changes. And so then this stimulates a cascade. that feeds back, there's a calcium signaling that feeds back to the nucleus. This turns on genes that are called immediate early genes, genes which CFOS is an example.
01:12:24.000 --> 01:12:53.000
And so these are active within 30 seconds of the depolarization and they are transcription factors that bind to the DNA and turn on a whole bunch of other downstream genes. And then those genes activate another wave. So there's actually a series of waves of gene activation that eventually regulate the levels of the synaptic proteins that then strengthen particular synapses and weaken others. And so this whole process is very sensitive to dosage, to levels of gene expression.
01:12:53.000 --> 01:13:36.000
You have this depolarization, then a sudden shoot up in the level of C-Fos and then upregulation of other genes. And this is probably one reason why a lot of our psychiatric conditions, like autism and schizophrenia, actually don't reflect complete loss of the gene, like I told you about with ASPN, where both copies are mutated to cause that small brain. But in fact, in autism or schizophrenia, it's usually just loss of one of the two gene copies, so that the person still has one gene, still has one good copy, but you need to have both copies, and that might have to do with these waves of activation of genes, and these ranges and levels of activation that are so important for refining synaptic connections.
01:13:36.000 --> 01:13:55.000
Yeah, and I guess at a simple level you can start to think like, okay, dosage can be important because if you've got a bit too much protein, a bit too little protein, maybe the synapse that should get pruned is now a little bit too strong, or maybe the one that you wanna keep is a little bit too weak
because you don't have the right sticky connections there at the right dose.
01:13:55.000 --> 01:14:13.000
Yeah, exactly. And so for some of these dosage-sensitive genes where loss of one of the two copies can cause autism or intellectual disability, in fact, having three copies instead of two is just as bad for you. And so you have to have exactly two copies.
01:14:13.000 --> 01:14:32.000
Yeah, yeah. It's very Goldilocks, not too much, not too little. Yes, exactly. When the refinement is actually happening, when the brain somehow decides to get rid of a neuron or to get rid of a synapse between two neurons, what does that disposal process actually look like?
01:14:32.000 --> 01:14:35.000
How has the synapse gotten rid of and cleared out of there?
01:14:36.000 --> 01:15:22.000
Yeah, well, so I think we've tended to think about, originally we thought of that as a process that was mostly inherent to the neuron, that it would pull in its connections and then maybe sort of shrivel up and die. Now we're thinking of it as a much more interactive process where, particularly through the work of people like Beth Stevens, they found that some of the glial cells, like microglia, are very involved at nibbling away at the neurons and assaying them in terms of their connectivity, and then helping play a role in targeting certain neurons for either removal of some of their synapses or, in some cases, removal of the entire neuron. And so it's a much more dynamic and interactive process than it was originally envisioned, I think, 10 or 20 years ago.
01:15:24.000 --> 01:15:43.000
And so what are some of the major diseases of the brain that you work on in particular that we think have a particularly strong genetic basis? And what does it mean? What does strong genetic basis actually mean? So for whatever example you guide us through here, is it an example where we think it's all due to a genetic mutation in a gene?
01:15:44.000 --> 01:15:47.000
Or is it a gene environment interaction? And how do we start to tease those things apart?
01:15:48.000 --> 01:16:16.000
Right. Diseases have a range of genetic roles, and we often characterize them in terms of the concept of heritability. And heritability was originally defined, and is still most commonly defined, by the study of identical twins. We have identical twins who we think of have an essentially identical genome.
01:16:16.000 --> 01:16:45.000
There might be a few little changes, but they're mostly identical. If one child is affected with autism, for example, what's the risk to the identical twin? Well, it turns out if one child is affected with autism, the identical twin has more than a 50% chance, depending on the series, as high as a 70% or 80% chance of having a disorder that's on the autism spectrum at least. And so we consider autism to be something with a very high level of heritability.
01:16:46.000 --> 01:16:58.000
based on those identical twin studies. And then, of course, if they're fraternal twins, the risk is much lower. It's more like 15 or 20 percent. And if they're unrelated, then the rate is, you know, 2 percent or something like that, much lower still.
01:16:59.000 --> 01:17:23.000
And so basically then we can look at, so autism is one of the most highly heritable neuropsychiatric conditions, probably the most highly heritable. Intellectual disability is similarly highly heritable. Schizophrenia a little bit less so, maybe more like 40% to 60% depending on the particular series. And then things like bipolar or ADHD subsequently a little bit lower.
01:17:23.000 --> 01:17:58.000
So in something like autism then, we can expect that someday if we have perfect knowledge, we might be able to explain more than half of all kids on the autism spectrum with connecting it to some sort of specific genetic defect. At the moment, we're nowhere close to being able to do that. If a kid walks into our clinic and has a diagnosis on the autism spectrum, we'll typically send a whole genome sequence on the kid and on the parents. And the rate at which we'll be able to identify a specific genetic change is more like 25%, 30% on a good day.
01:17:59.000 --> 01:18:40.000
And so of the heritability of autism, we are still relatively early on in explaining where that comes from. and we don't presently know what is missing. A lot of people think it might be mutations in these regulatory sequences, which are not generally tested for clinically, because we know so little about them. other, it's also likely that a lot of that heritability has to do with subtle variation at hundreds of different loci across the genome, the sorts of things that can regulate, you know, intellect more broadly and social behavior more broadly.
01:18:40.000 --> 01:19:20.000
And so there might be a part of autism which is not just a single, there is in fact definitely a part of autism which is not due to a single genetic mutation but due to the interacting changes at hundreds of different loci across the genome. If we think of actually autism in a population terms, these multiple alleles, these common alleles, contribute the largest effect size to autism in a population. But if we're looking at a single kid who's in the clinic and has autism, that's where a single genetic mutation can have the largest effect in an individual child. And so anyway, that's how we think of heritability in terms of psychiatric diseases.
01:19:20.000 --> 01:19:32.000
In terms of schizophrenia, you know, we're less directly involved in those studies, but there's been a much smaller fraction of schizophrenia that's relatable to these single gene disorders compared to autism even.
01:19:33.000 --> 01:19:56.000
Yeah. And I guess I would ask you, how good are we today at predicting ahead of time whether someone's going to have some kind of brain problem or psychiatric problem from just the genetics? So if you're talking about, say, an IVF clinic, where you go into the IVF clinic, you've got a bunch of fertilized
embryos that you're looking at. Of course, you can look for gross chromosomal abnormalities.
01:19:56.000 --> 01:20:04.000
But how good are we today at telling prospective parents there's an X percent chance of some kind of autism and a Y percent chance of this or that.
01:20:05.000 --> 01:20:23.000
Oh, yeah. Well, that's, you know, how good are we at taking any child and telling the parents what that child is going to turn into? And so that's that that illustrates the challenge. I mean, that's the biggest question in every parent's mind is what's going to happen to happen to my child.
01:20:24.000 --> 01:21:11.000
And that's the always the biggest challenge for the physician is counseling any parent about that. You know, then getting to specifics, when we do, I mean, this is one reason, this will be a challenge on the uptake of prenatal genetic diagnosis as a routine, because basically the more commonly this is done, the more difficult it becomes, you know, to have predictive value about the majority of it. I would say for, there are a good number of genes that we have pretty good information about prognosis where we can be pretty confident in telling the parents that the child will have a severe diagnosis, such that they might consider reproductive decisions based upon that information.
01:21:12.000 --> 01:21:51.000
In terms of autism, I told you we thought there might be a thousand genes. Of that, there's maybe a hundred or so are 150 that are very well validated and that are relatively commonly mutated so that we recognize not only the gene but the particular change where, you know, we might be able to get a sense. So this is, if we see that mutation, and it's absent in the parents, it's relatively likely that the child will be affected. But again, that leaves then hundreds of genes where we know less, where we have a sense that the penetrance of the defect is lower.
01:21:52.000 --> 01:22:21.000
where we might find that there are certain genes associated with autism where there are some people walking around with mutations in those genes in the general population, particularly girls, because girls are relatively protected against autism spectrum disorders. And so those have reduced penetrance. And so there it becomes very difficult to give accurate information. And so I think ultimately, we're getting to the point now where we've sequenced millions of normal people.
01:22:22.000 --> 01:22:46.000
And as we get more and more information about the range of the genomes in normal people, we get increasingly precise information about each of these specific changes and which ones are the most likely to cause a serious defect. And so this is, again, it's evolving very quickly, but it'll still take years before we are able to be as good as we'd like to.
01:22:46.000 --> 01:23:04.000
Yeah, yeah. So for any given embryo that's formed, a human embryo, remind us, how many novel mutations will be unique to that individual? And are those typically consequential or inconsequential? Does disease risk more come from the standing variation in the population that you get a piece of?
01:23:04.000 --> 01:23:10.000
Or do you acquire novel mutations early on when the embryo is formed, and those are consequential?
01:23:10.000 --> 01:23:34.000
Yeah. So each of us has about, as I mentioned, 80 to 100 single nucleotide variants relative to our parents and most of those are inconsequential. An average person will only have about one change in an exon relative to their parents and even most of those are inconsequential. That's why most of us aren't walking around with a disease somewhere.
01:23:35.000 --> 01:24:15.000
A typical person will have one coding change but a lot of times those coding changes might, as I say, be functionally irrelevant. They might, for example, not change an amino acid, because sometimes two different codons will code for the same amino acid, so you're changing, it's called a silent mutation. Or it could change an amino acid in a protein, but it turns out that that protein can tolerate that change in the amino acid, so again, no big deal. Or it could even disrupt one of the two copies of that gene completely, but it might be that that gene doesn't happen to be one of these dosage-sensitive ones that I was telling you about, and so it's still no problem.
01:24:15.000 --> 01:24:43.000
And so it's only when you disrupt a dosage-sensitive gene that you're likely to go into problems. And that's why this is still a relatively rare event that happens, you know, that only affects a couple of all embryos, you know, one or two percent of all embryos. And why, fortunately, even after knowing all this genetics, I still think it's okay for my kids to think about having kids because it still seems to work out okay most of the time.
01:24:43.000 --> 01:25:00.000
Yeah. And that brings us back to something fascinating you mentioned early on, which is there seem to be really powerful error correction mechanisms baked into development. And obviously a lot can go wrong, but most people don't have anything that's obviously wrong with them. And there's a lot of checkpoints in place.
01:25:00.000 --> 01:25:20.000
I think you said something like, When you go into an IVF clinic and they can look at a bunch of fertilized eggs, they can often find gross abnormalities of some of the embryos and that seems like a big problem and it could be, but you actually mentioned that a lot of those might just develop normally because of these error correction mechanisms baked into our developmental program. That's right.
01:25:21.000 --> 01:25:42.000
Yes, as I said, basically, if you systematically study blastocysts, you find that all of them are mosaic for chromosome anomalies. It's just a question of whether it's most of the cells or only a smaller fraction of the cells. The average is about a quarter of the cells in any given early embryo will have grossly abnormal chromosome patterns. But there are multiple error
correction mechanisms.
01:25:43.000 --> 01:26:10.000
In one of them, in fact, The placenta is particularly tolerant of copy number alterations, and so a lot of these abnormal cells will go into the placenta. And this can sometimes be manifested by an abnormal amniocentesis that shows chromosome abnormalities in the amniocentesis, but it turns out they're limited to the placenta. This is called placental mosaicism. And the embryo is fine, even though the amnio looks abnormal.
01:26:10.000 --> 01:26:16.000
Oh, wow. So it could actually look like something's wrong, but you're actually seeing a manifestation of things working well. Yeah. Yeah.
01:26:17.000 --> 01:27:13.000
They're right. But then also, every organ has its own error correction mechanisms. I told you about how the brain seems to be able to preferentially eliminate neurons that have abnormal genomes. Other organs do that in other ways, most typically because we have cell cycle-based mechanisms for error correction that basically check the genome modulated by, you know, P53, which is called the guardian of the genome for that matter, for that reason, because it basically checks for large-scale chromosome alterations with each cell cycle and then tends to target the cell for death if there is abnormal genome copy. We don't know why all these neurons sort of escape that p53 mechanism and why 25 or 30 percent of our neurons are formed with these abnormal genomes to begin with and why they need to have their own mechanism, but that might be having something to do with the fact that neurons divide in different ways and are post-mitotic for most of their life.
01:27:13.000 --> 01:27:30.000
Yeah. It's relatively easy for me to think about how some of these genome abnormalities, like copy number variants, form when neurons are still dividing. And before they get to their final location, before they're mature, because with every cell division, right, there's a chance for a mistake. Maybe the polymerase slips.
01:27:31.000 --> 01:27:57.000
Maybe you duplicate some genes or a whole chromosome. And I can imagine that that's going to happen at some rate, and therefore you had to evolve a mechanism for the developing brain to, you know, see when those abnormalities arise and then get rid of those neurons and do things like that. When we're talking about the mature brain, the adult brain, Are there things that can go wrong? You've got an adult neuron, it's mature, it's stable, it's doing its thing, it's got its connections.
01:27:58.000 --> 01:28:12.000
I would imagine that over time as we age and get older, we're exposed to toxins, things start to break down in different ways. Can the genome start to become more unstable as an age-related thing, and then we've got that problem on that side of our lives?
01:28:13.000 --> 01:28:46.000
Oh, golly, yeah, you've just led me down into my favorite rabbit hole there, Nick. So it turns out the genome of no cell is static, that genomes of every cell in our body
are changing. And that the genetic, I just told you about the genetic diversity of the world's population, you know, these 8 billion people with mutations at every spot in the genome. Well, it turns out every one of us has a genetic variation within us that far exceeds the entire genetic variation of the world's population that I was just telling you about.
01:28:46.000 --> 01:29:20.000
So that we have basically 30 trillion cells, each of us has a trillion new mutations every day. And then in our brains, we have a million new mutations every day. And the biggest surprise for me came about 10 years ago when we developed a method to take the genome of a single neuron and amplify it and sequence it, just as though we were sequencing the genome of your blood, and then compare it to the neuron next to it.
01:29:20.000 --> 01:29:40.000
the genome and its genome. And we found that neurons accumulate mutations at a rate of about 20 per year. And they're not copy number variants. As you pointed out, the copy number variants generally only arise in dividing cells because of a mis-slipping of the polymerase or a mis-segregation of the chromosomes.
01:29:40.000 --> 01:30:01.000
But it's these point mutations. It's a substitution of a single nucleotide, like a C to a T or a G to an A. And so our neurons accumulate about 17 of these copy number variants per year. And then they also accumulate two or three short insertions or deletions, the removal of two or three base pairs.
01:30:02.000 --> 01:30:36.000
And it's remarkably linear in humans. So that's about 20 point mutations per year when you sum together these insertion, deletions, and the SNVs. And it's 20 mutations the first year of life, and it's 20 mutations the 100th year of life, completely linear, in a way that marks time like a clock, with great precision. And that rate is, surprisingly, equivalently fast to the rate at which many dividing cells accumulate mutations.
01:30:36.000 --> 01:31:00.000
That 20 mutations per year is about the same as our blood stem cells, which accumulate mutations at about 18 or 20 per year. It's faster than our sperm accumulate mutations, which is only about 5 per year. It's slower than other cells like our lung cells that develop more like 50 per year. But why would non-dividing neurons develop these?
01:31:01.000 --> 01:31:40.000
That's a mystery that we don't completely understand. But then this process is beautifully and sharply linear in on brains with no neurological diagnosis, and then it's rapidly accelerated in every neurodegenerative disease we've studied. So we have a paper that's online at Cell that'll come out September 7th showing that Alzheimer disease and ALS and frontotemporal dementia all show a rapid acceleration of this damage to the genome, particularly these short indels, as some aspect probably of the degenerative process that we're trying to understand.
01:31:41.000 --> 01:31:57.000
Yeah, and when we think about mature neurons, you've got this interesting situation where on the one hand, by definition, a neuron that's mature is no longer dividing. So this is sort of like your final chance. You've got to preserve this neuron as it is. I've got a pyramidal cell in my neocortex.
01:31:57.000 --> 01:32:09.000
It needs to stay a pyramidal cell. There needs to be a certain level of stability there in its genome and in general. But at the same time, there needs to be some instability and some flexibility because there's still plasticity. It needs to be able to tune its synapses and so forth.
01:32:10.000 --> 01:32:44.000
But, because neurons are post-mitotic, they're not dividing anymore, and also they are metabolically so active, they're so expensive, you need to constantly be making refinements, constantly making and spending ATP, that's going to mean a lot of oxidative stress and a lot of potentially mutation-causing, damage-causing, metabolic stuff happening in the neuron. Are neurons equipped with special mechanisms to buffer themselves against the damaging and potentially mutagenic effects of an intense metabolism because they're not going to divide again?
01:32:45.000 --> 01:33:04.000
So that's a great question. As far as we know, they're not. They don't have anything special. In fact, I think the biggest thing that neurons have to prevent them from developing a lot of these somatic mutations is that they don't divide.
01:33:05.000 --> 01:33:39.000
I mean, replicating the whole genome is probably the biggest driver of creating these mutations, and that might be a big part of why neurons have been evolved not to divide, because it might be that that tends to then safeguard the genome from this kind of constant somatic mutation, which is, again, much more of a problem in gut cells and lung cells that are turning over all the time. And it might be why most of our blood cells, in fact, the stem cells, don't divide very much. Even though they're stem cells, they're quiescent stem cells.
01:33:40.000 --> 01:34:02.000
And so probably that's the biggest thing. So how do these mutations arise then? We think it's probably because, as you say, neurons, although they're not dividing, they're very metabolically active, they're very transcriptionally active. I told you we have these cascades of gene expression where the level of expression of CFOS goes up 100-fold in connection with patterns of neuronal activity.
01:34:03.000 --> 01:34:26.000
And that gene expression requires that the DNA become unwound and open to allow RNA polymerase in to turn the gene on. And so that is probably what makes the DNA vulnerable to being damaged. And because, in fact, when we look at these mutations, these 20 SNVs per year, we ask, what part of the genome are they taking place in? They're enriched.
01:34:28.000 --> 01:34:47.000
at genes, and they're particularly enriched at genes that are expressed in exactly that neuronal type. And so it looks like the pattern of this process of transcription is, again, a little
bit of a dangerous thing. And so that's a real problem because that means as we get old, just the genes that are most important are the ones that are differentially mutated.
01:34:47.000 --> 01:35:00.000
Right. Again, it's a double-edged sword. It's like the ability to have plasticity and to change requires you to make those genes vulnerable to damage because you have to literally open them up and make them open to potentially bad things happening.
01:35:00.000 --> 01:35:27.000
That's right, exactly. And so at the moment, we don't know. I assume that these 20 mutations per year don't have a normal function, that they're just a byproduct, an unfortunate byproduct of the fact that the neurons are very active. And rather than, as I say, I don't think that they are there for a purpose, but just a little bit of a challenge for the neurons to get around.
01:35:27.000 --> 01:35:53.000
But fortunately, that 20 per year It ends up, again, most of these 20 mutations per year are inconsequential. Most of them occur in non-coding parts of the genome or don't alter the protein coding sequence of a gene. So fortunately, even at 20 per year, the damage to the genome is sufficiently modest that most neurons are still able to function fine.
01:35:54.000 --> 01:36:19.000
What are some of the things that you're working on in the lab today or just that are going on in the field of developmental neurobiology in general, especially as it relates to things like psychiatric disease, propensity, developmental disorders, and the like? What are some things where you think we're making a lot of traction now for whatever reason, and we're going to start to have really good new insights in the next few years, say?
01:36:19.000 --> 01:36:44.000
Sure. Right, well, I'm very excited about our ability to sequence the genomes of single neurons. There's a lot of neurons in our brain, 20 billion, so we're not going to be able to, anytime soon, sequence all 20 billion of them. But sequencing the genomes of single neurons allows us to recognize that every neuron is different.
01:36:44.000 --> 01:37:07.000
It allows us to put different identities on the different neurons and study them in different ways. And it turns out that the genome is essentially a tablet that records the life of the neuron. Just as our genome is a tablet that records our whole evolutionary history, right? Our genome records who our parents are.
01:37:07.000 --> 01:37:20.000
It recorded who their parents are. It records the history of the human species over time. It records the history of how the human species relates to the history of other species. And so it is a tablet that records history.
01:37:21.000 --> 01:37:35.000
It turns out that that doesn't stop with the cells of our body. that every cell has a genome that records the history of that cell. So I just told you that neurons accumulate 20 mutations per year. That means every neuron knows exactly how old it is from the moment it was born.
01:37:36.000 --> 01:37:59.000
I told you that stem cells develop mutations when they divide. That means that every neuron knows who its family is. It knows exactly how it's related to all of the other cells in the entire brain, in fact, all of the other cells of the whole body. So our somatic mutations of our body create a permanent forensic post-mortem map of the entire development of our body.
01:37:59.000 --> 01:38:31.000
But also, I just told you that the genome of neurons changes if you have a neurological disease. Well, that means that, in fact, the genome is recording the environment of the neuron. It's recording who its neighbors are, what it's exposed to. We think that those extra mutations and degenerative diseases come about probably because of the effects of the neighbors of those neurons, particularly the microglia, which can become very activated in inflammatory and abnormal ways in Alzheimer's disease and in other degenerative diseases.
01:38:31.000 --> 01:39:00.000
We think that those microglia are pummeling the neurons with cytokines and reactive oxygen and other things that is damaging the genome of the neurons. And so in fact, the genome knows where it's living and its neighborhood. And then I finally, I told you also that 25 or 30% of the neurons are eliminated during fetal development. You have these abnormal neurons that are generated and then selectively removed.
01:39:00.000 --> 01:39:43.000
And so it was only by sequencing the genomes of single neurons that we're able to even recognize this Darwinian competition, that we can see these forces of selection. We can use the same tools that were developed for studying the evolution of organisms. looking at genomic conservation and changes and areas that are selected positively and negatively, and we can do it within our brain to see how selection acts in our brain. And we think that this selective process, this selective removal of damaged neurons and the selective survival of non-damaged neurons, we think that this selective process is going to be abnormal in the neuropsychiatric diseases.
01:39:44.000 --> 01:40:02.000
that this pruning is abnormal. That's already been proposed. That's what autism relates to, is this abnormal pruning. Well, if abnormal pruning happens so that there's a failure of the normal evolutionary selection and selective removal of damaged neurons, that would leave the brain with a whole bunch of damaged neurons.
01:40:03.000 --> 01:40:26.000
And that might be an important mechanism of disease. And so I think that we'll be looking The looking at things this way has caused me to look at every disease that affects the brain in a different way because it's basically a new tool that allows us to state problems that are familiar problems but in a completely different light.
01:40:28.000 --> 01:40:56.000
We talked a lot about brain development stuff today. On the one hand, we talked a lot about the sort of exquisite beauty of development, all of the checkpoints and regulatory
controls, the error correction mechanisms, the robustness of it. It's sort of amazing that development of a human being ever goes right when you think about how many cells are in all of our organs and in our brain, et cetera. And on the other hand, we talked about, you know, places where things can go awry and in that complexity.
01:40:56.000 --> 01:41:09.000
We live in a time where fertility rates are basically lower than they've ever been. People are having fewer children in general. They're having children later. They're doing things like IVF because they're having children later and things like that.
01:41:09.000 --> 01:41:29.000
And there's a lot of people who get, I think, easily stressed or scared about what can go wrong. What would you say to people, knowing everything that you know about development, about how they should consider the question of whether to have children and how long to wait, given all of the beauty of the development process and all the things that can both go right and go wrong?
01:41:30.000 --> 01:42:08.000
Well, you know, I would just say, I mean, kids are just the most wonderful thing. I mean, I've got the two, I've got two of the most wonderful kids in the world and it's been, it's the greatest blessing in my life other than perhaps meeting my wife, Ming Wei. So I think, you know, I think having kids is an individual decision, but I was like one of eight kids, none of whom had any, you know, major neurological condition. So I think it's easy to lose sight of the fact that these issues, while serious and life-changing, are rare.
01:42:09.000 --> 01:42:52.000
And that the vast majority of kids just turn out just fine. And again, I was studying the development of the brain way back before I had kids, but there's just no greater miracle than watching the development of the brain in one's own kids, and watching that light go on, and that miracle of cognition as it develops. And worrying all the time about whether things are going to be okay, but then taking a great deal of joy in the fact that they usually do work out fine. But as I say, it is crazy.
01:42:54.000 --> 01:43:13.000
When Ming Wei was pregnant with our kids, we had these ultrasounds, and even back then, just with these non-genetic tools, there always seemed to be a problem. And yet, in the end, everything worked out just fine. And we were both doctors, and we were like, wow, did we really have to have all those tests?
01:43:14.000 --> 01:43:16.000
Is that really necessary?
01:43:18.000 --> 01:43:25.000
And so I would, again, for those people who are thinking about having kids, it's been the biggest blessing in my life.
01:43:25.000 --> 01:43:33.000
All right, well, that's a great spot to end it. Chris, this was fascinating. Thank you for taking the time. I know that you're a busy guy out there, but I think people are going to learn a lot about this.
01:43:33.000 --> 01:43:37.000
And this is definitely a subject that people are really interested in. So thank you very much.
01:43:38.000 --> 01:43:42.000
Well, thank you very much, Nick. It's been a real pleasure. Thanks again.
01:43:51.000 --> 01:44:18.000
Hey everyone, a great way to support my efforts is to visit my support page at mindandmatter.substack.com. A link to that page is in the episode description or you can search for it on the Substack page itself. The support page has an up-to-date list of my affiliate partners. These are companies I work with and if you buy those products through those links or using the discount codes provided, those will get you a great deal on a variety of products related to optimizing physical, metabolic, or mental health and vitality.
01:44:18.000 --> 01:44:47.000
These are all products I use myself, and some of them are directly related to podcast episodes or formulated by Mind & Matter guests. For example, there's a great product called Keto Citra formulated by a kidney biologist who was on episode number 186. It contains the ketone body BHB together with several minerals in a precise ratio formulated with kidney health in mind. There are also links to products like physical technology devices to track your metabolic health, digital applications to help you find and learn about food and consumer products, and more.
01:44:47.000 --> 01:45:04.000
One product I use every day is the AquaTrue water filter. I recommend this to everyone because it gets everything out of your drinking water, heavy metals, microbes, endocrine disruptors, microplastics. you name it. Other charcoal or gravity-based filters that a lot of people use don't get everything out, they just get some of the stuff out.
01:45:04.000 --> 01:45:15.000
So I really like the AquaTrue product. You can look for a link to my affiliate partners on my support page or directly in the episode description to this episode, or you can go to mindandmatter.substack.com to find it there.