TRASCRIZIONE 🔗
speaker-0: Thank you for joining us for part two of our interview with Tippi Brookins of GovWorks as we discuss retention and cultural issues within the emergency communications profession. That interview concludes now.
speaker-1: Because in culture we talk so much about or at least for me, when I hear the word culture and I as it relates to our centers and how about retention, I immediately think the floor.
speaker-2: Mm-hmm.
speaker-1: The call takers and the dispatchers who interact with the people and and basically the kids. You know what I mean? The the people on the floor, your your frontline workforce and how they interact with each other and how they welcome new people and how they tend to run them off. But little is said about the culture of leadership. And there is a culture of leadership, wouldn't you agree?
speaker-2: Yes.
speaker-1: There is, like you said, supervisor, we had that episode, Gary, you and I, about controlling the weather. As you control the weather in your center as a supervisor, your decisions, your demeanor, the way that you it the way you carry yourself, the way that you have conversations, every all of your interactions contribute to the culture and the weather in your center. But so many times we promote based on an interview. Where you can talk a good game in the interview, gift of gab, and then we give you a roster and we give you the authority, and then we give you, you know, the tools and accesses to different things, keep a few keystrokes, and now suddenly you're in charge of the culture. But
speaker-2: Yeah.
speaker-1: there's nothing to help you figure out what to do with all this authority. And when we throw you in this fish bowl and say swim. So if I'm understanding comms coach for supervisors, if that if that's not correct, correct me. But it will supplement this authority that you've been given, these accesses that you've been given, and this control, this span of control that you have. But now we're gonna teach you how to wield it.
speaker-2: Yes. That is awesome. That sounds like a promotional video. But it's the
speaker-1: And it should be because it I don't know if APD will ever get it, but somebody oughta get it because
speaker-2: Like you said, a song and a dance and a great conversation and the gift of gap. I've seen it so many times. I've seen it so many times on panels. They smile and they have the answers, but then they turn out to be some of the worst leaders on the floor and they affect people. But how about this? You mentioned, you know, you said leaders are, you know, as far as they have their responsibility as culture. But let's not forget our IT staff. The people that support our building, they're cleaners. H V A C techs that are running around on, running around in the building or general people, our folks, our HR staff, our admin staff, support staff. Remember, they're all walking around the center as well. And I mentioned something also too. We have to remember that again, being well.
Load full transcript
You have IT members that are always constantly on the dispatch floor fixing things, whatever. What do you think? And look, I'm asking you the question. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Do you think that they do you think they experience vicarious trauma when they're fixing a console next door to someone who's taking a CPR call or next to someone who is taking a shooting and telling them how to control the bleeding? Don't you think they they go through vicarious trauma too? But we forget we don't think about that, right? But it's no fault of our own. It's just that. Having these conversations to make sure that we're bringing it to the forefront and to remember that. Now we can do something about it, right? Now we can be more proactive because we forget about the folks. I'm gonna tell you we had all these different administrative folks that had access to the floor. And they don't just have access to the floor, they have access to everything that's happening on the floor. And we forget about that. But you said leadership, right? Yeah. It starts at the top. And that's just I'm just gonna say that, like with because I will tell you in my career, I've had some great leaders that understood culture. Very early on my career, when I got to one of my dispatch centers, I was applying to leave. I didn't want to be there anymore. I said, I can't be a part of this. I I don't I'm not used to this. The director and the deputy director at the time got with and they wanted to meet with me and they asked me questions as to why I'm trying to leave. And so when I shared my experience about, what I was experiencing and things like that, they couldn't believe it. But what they did do thereafter, they did something about it as it related to culture. They started from the top and worked their way down. When I tell you after that, things were so different, it was a totally different place. And it has changed tremendously from that leadership down. We have to remember. Culture can't be fixed from bottom up. It has to be fixed from leadership down.
speaker-1: so okay. Okay. So this leads into Gary, if you if you got something you
speaker-0: Well I I I guess I was gonna ask
speaker-1: Every time. Sorry y'all. Go ahead. Go ahead.
speaker-0: ki going along with that conversation that you had with the the director and the assistant director, or deputy director, when you know you're talking about things that make people want to leave, like you just got there and then you wanted to leave immediately. I I think a lot of people that run communication centers will hear some of these things that you have to say, like, let's get some some scented lotions in the the ladies' bathrooms. Let's have a a pony come up so people can like and enjoy them. And they're like, that's gonna cost me money. And you know, I I don't have a lot of money. but I I think a lot of people don't recognize well, first off, don't put a very high value on experience and when that walks out the door how much that is actually costing you. but also how much How much it costs to hire and train and get a productive person. So for every person you leave, you've got to replace that body. And how much more is it to replace that body than it is to just maybe make a change, even if it's kind of an expensive change, like say five thousand dollars to send someone to some fancy schmancy conference? if that gets them reinvested, like Do you do you have any sort of I guess, dollars and cents comparison versus hiring somebody new, getting them trained up and productive versus trying to keep somebody or retain them?
speaker-2: Yes. So as it relates to figures, there's a bunch of figures out there, but I think we can all agree and stand on the middle. and so when you think about training, right, there's so many components that we forget about, right? So you have the all of the background, all of those things that costs about five to ten thousand dollars, depending on if they're doing polys, depending on if they're doing drug tests, eye test, physicals, all of that, right? That's HR, that's that pre-piece. Let's talk about now when we bring them in the door and they're sending through an eight to twelve week academy. You're paying them 40 hours a week, right? Now, depending on your center, are you giving them uniforms that costs? Most of the time we give shirts. Sometimes we'll give the the pants that you know the BDUs. Now the materials, but what about the man hours of your trainers and the people that are participating? You gotta factor that in. You gotta factor that in their training hours, their overtime hours, the Sunday differential. all of that. I'm working that in. I'm giving you the figures. They get on the floor, and now it's time to quit, right? So when they walk out, that person that walked out the door is probably about fifty thousand dollars. Yeah. It's not I I even saw where it was like somewhere it was like a hundred thousand dollars. So fifty to a hundred, yes, it's a lot of money, and it's money that we don't want to see wasted walking out the door. So instead of letting them walk out the door, right? That 50 because that's fifty thousand dollars. That's a fifty thousand dollars walking out the door. How about like you said, send them to a conference. A conference total travel conference about three thousand dollars. Uh-huh. Right? Yeah. Send them to you know a specific training just on a topic. Send them. You would save so much more money to add value back to your culture. So I hope that was helpful, Gary, as far as that thing
speaker-0: Yeah, because I I think yeah, I I think a lot of people a lot of times people have trouble seeing that value of somebody leaving. so kind of like I was saying in the intro, like bailing out the water would be hiring new people, whereas patching the holes would be keeping the people you have from leaving. and and that's not even accounting for any sort of the experience that they bring, like how much faster they can take calls or how
much more accurate their their CPR or fire triage is. and just the the level of impact, when somebody leaves that going back to culture, that affects the culture. They're like you're 'cause you've got a hole in your family, pretty much. depending on how big your center is. you know, if you're if you're a five person center and somebody leaves, you know, twenty percent of your staff is gone.
speaker-2: Small.
speaker-0: Yeah. And so it's just like there's so much that you don't I I think somebody who doesn't understand the the value of an employee is, if they're just looking at the bottom line. 'Cause they're they could say, this employee's been here a long time, they're tenured, they're costing me a lot more money 'cause they're at the high end of the pay scale. Let's just you know, get rid of them and hire some and get somebody new. But it really costs you An extreme amount in, some ineffable qualities. 'Cause you you you said fifty to a hundred thousand, but that's that's just the dollars for training and hiring. It doesn't include all of the the fringe that they take with them when they leave.
speaker-2: my gosh. And we didn't even talk about the benefits and and all of those the the benefits package, right? And you know, again, I you know, it's thought provoking conversations like this that will help our help the audience to even think about that. Because like you said, Gary, we don't we don't think about those things, right? It would be cheaper to go and bring in well, I'm gonna tell you honestly, the pony thing, that was they they offered their time. It was free. So just let me know that.
speaker-0: Right.
speaker-2: Yep. But we could reappropriate funds instead of allowing people to well, we can't say allow, but why watching them walk out the door. How about we take some of that money and work with your county HR or your s you know, your HR and say, Hey, can we get some folks in to help us with illness and bring some, you know, folks in to do massages? We did that. Yeah.
speaker-0: Mm-hmm.
speaker-2: They, you know, I don't how the how they did that, but they brought We would have days when they would have chair massages. Amazing. Yeah. That was amazing, And then we would have yoga, we would do Zumba, we would do my gosh, so many things. But again, if that investment will help you get a return where someone's not gonna leave, I mean you do the math. Yeah.
speaker-1: And up, I want to be reminded respectful of your time, but I saw something in the packet that I've heard it before, but it really drove home when I saw it. Stay interviews as a part of the whole wellness. Talk to me.
speaker-2: Stay interviews. So that's one thing that we don't talk about. And I would love to see that more people do. And and and you know, sometimes, in my opinion, I think maybe we may be scared to hear, you know, we may be scared to get the feedback. Yeah. But usually get the feedback when they're walking out the door. Right. But if we could schedule stay interviews and this is a not a part of the performance evaluation process, let's make sure we have that separated. This is not the Half year, the six month check in and then the final. No, this is outside of that. This is basically a randomized meeting that you have with a member, every member on your team. How are you? How are things? What is it that you like? What is it that you don't like? How can we improve? What about this process? And get that information now before they have a chance to sit and and let it grind their gears about something that they don't like and affect other people. Right. Stay interviews are are very, a very, very great resource. And it would be awesome if we could start to incorporate that into our centers because that way it will give us analytical information on how we can do things either better or how we can continue to keep getting it right.
speaker-0: So what kind of question would a stay interview have? I see that you're staying here this week. what made you decide to not leave? how how does that how does that work out?
speaker-2: the so when a person has stayed at an agency, especially in 911, let's talk about that career. Let's have those conversations about your career. Where is it that you're trying to go and how can I support you in that endeavor, right? And sometimes asking those types of questions, we'd be surprised as far as the support that's needed. It could be very minimal, it could be very not costly at all. It could just be something as minor as you know, document anything. But those specific questions, where are you trying to get to? What is it that is there a job here in the center that you find interesting or you want to do? What else is it here that you want to learn about? Because you'd be surprised. We find in those state interviews, you find your SMEs, you find those new IT members, you find the folks that love the phone or love CAD, you find those folks that want to do something else outside of call taking so many times. But if they weren't given that opportunity to give that that response back or that feedback, how would we know? So those types of questions.
speaker-1: And w and you know what? I'm all on I'm on the culture wagon because it it well it's true because it it creates it has people feeling like drones. Think about it. They're just here, sit down, take the calls, sit down, dispatch. I need butt in seat and I need those notifications made when they're supposed to be made and I need the call to from the answer point to queue and I need that talk time to be right here and When it's your birthday, I got you a cupcake. But other than that, they feel like drones because we don't take the time because we're so it's a culture of just like a what do you call that? Assembly line.
speaker-2: Mm.
speaker-1: You know what I mean? We just the you come in, you sit down, you do the work, I supervise you because my manager is gonna ask me and the executive staff is gonna ask them about the and it
just becomes an assembly line of production. And we all have a product and that's all great and as we should, and we should be held accountable to performance metrics and all the things, but culture has so many sides to the coin. It's how we treat people, and even if we're not mean and we're not disrespectful, and then we pay them well, but we can still create a culture of you're just another drone in this machine if we're not careful. And day interviews. To me, almost like pushing a button long enough to stop the line and say, Hey, why do you stay here? You've been here 15 years. What is it that makes you stay? And I bet the answer that comes back, if it's three kids and I need to feed them, how's that gonna make you feel? That's not enough. There's gotta be more. And if that's the only answer we get back, then we're we're in trouble. Because there's got there has to be more to it. That if I got that answer back as a supervisor, I don't expect it to be about me, but I would love to hear. I feel like I'm valued. I feel like the work that I do is not just for the public and and they say thank you. But what about the thank you that we could be giving? That it just
speaker-2: Yep. And that's that opportunity, right? That's that opportunity where you have that kind candid conversation. You find out, how they really feel about the job, that they're about their career. And and like I said, their direction. And one of the things that you know I mentioned the other day, the smallest things you'd be surprised with would a would affect the morale, right? And when I say the smallest things, would you ever think that a birthday card would have an effect on a person? So one of the things that we did, we gave every single person in the agency a birthday card. However, the birthday card was wet signed by every single member of the executive leadership team. We started making sure that that was done. Do you know we got emails? I remember one email distinctly, and it was just, it touched my heart. The person was just like, I wanted to say thank you for the birthday card. I am alone and I don't have anyone to help celebrate my birthday. So thank you. I could not believe it. A small gesture. It was a birthday card. Dollar store, two for a dollar twenty five. I forget how much you know. They're cheap. But it made such a difference. Can you imagine how that person is going to affect someone else? Or can you imagine how that stay interview would be once you start asking those questions?
speaker-0: Why'd you stay? I got a birthday card from you and really touched my heart. Well, I mean, like it's it's a small thing, but like great changes are brought about by small things. So which I think kind of leads me to my next question of so say you're a a a leader at a a center, a director, what have you, and you are looking around and you you can recognize that the culture in your your agency is toxic, it's not good, people are not happy, they're Clearly just there for the paycheck, and they're leaving as soon as they can. And you're you say to yourself, Okay, I want to try and change the culture, but there's so many things that I see that need to be fixed, and it's just this huge Sisyphean task where I I d where do I even begin? do like, do you have any advice like grab the low-hanging fruit first or grab something small and easy just to show that training like or that culture is changing? Or tackle the big one, the big thing first, or like where to begin on that?
speaker-2: I like that. And so, with culture, we got to figure out where to start. But what I'm going to tell you is there's one place to start and it may not be comfortable. It may not be comfortable. It may be very harsh, but as a leader, we wear the big pants and we can take the harsh comments because we are leaders, right? Do an anonymous survey for the agency, do a culture survey. Ask those hard questions that you're scared to get those answers for and just see what they say. We did that at one of my agencies. 110 employees answered the survey, but the things that they said in the survey and they were anonymous, it was just like, wow, this is how they truly feel. And so doing that survey gave us a starting point as far as where do we begin to tackle culture? The biggest feedback that we got from that survey is that people wanted to be a part of process and they wanted to be heard. And how did we do that? We gave them their own platform. We created the culture task force. The task force was led by myself and our wellness coordinator. And we met with those members. These were telecommunicators. These were not managers, not supervisors, no one in leadership roles. And we met with them by bi-monthly, excuse me, bi weekly, twice a month. We would get together and we would have conversations about culture. How can we in improve our culture? What are some of the things that are going on that are just not working? And one of the rules for that culture culture task force was is that if you came to the group with a problem, you had to come with a solution. Because what we were not giving anyone was a place to just come and bash each other. And no, that's not what this is about. This is about solving real problems. And so we did that. We got everything from like I mentioned earlier, we want smell good PSAP in the bathroom, or we're tired of seeing the same scale chips in the in the snack machine. Can you get them changed? Or the supervisors need more training. And it was great because we would get the feedback on how supervisors were treating staff and things that they were doing. And so the first thing that cropped up in our minds is that they need further development and they need training. But they also need to acknowledge their actions and they need to know about the actions. So what we would do is that we would get the feedback from the group. I would visit the supervisors' meeting. And I would do it a whole scenario and we would act it out, And so in
that scenario, and how I showed how a a supervisor acted towards an employee, the supervisors would sit there and just look like, my God, like you kind of knew who the culprit was because you could see it in their face. But when I ex showed those actions. It made a world of difference because in those conversations they were just like, man, that makes sense. I don't want every anyone to ever think that way about me, or I don't want to ever come across as that. But just doing those little things, you have it, it just made a world of difference. What I will say is that it didn't happen overnight, Gary. It did not happen overnight. It took some time, but because we were intentional, we kept doing it, kept meeting, kept meeting, kept that group of people. A part of the culture task force affected others in a positive light. And so I get messages from time to time, as far as from people from the agency and how they miss me and how they just that was something really great. So for our listeners, if you have the courage to do a survey, I can guarantee you that survey is going to give you some concrete. evidence or information as far as where you can start with culture.
speaker-0: I think that's an excellent suggestion. survey, especially anonymous, I'm looking at it.
speaker-1: man in the mirror moment.
speaker-2: I don't know. Do I see the thing? It's anonymous, and and you you you be very, very specific as far as you know, you complete the survey, please. You, you know, we we appreciate your feedback, but please do not use names, you know, anonymous anonymous, you know, and make it very clear as far as the expectations and what they're going to provide. And and people will do it. And you'll be surprised. We did not get any responses with names of supervisors or anyone that, you know. So it was, it was, it was well received.
speaker-1: Gary, we got
speaker-2: Yeah.
speaker-0: We'll see what we can do on that.
speaker-1: if you had to give a you know this is the end of your presentation this is the end of our conversation call to action don't beat yourself up you can do it to the center that says hippie this all sounds good girl but
speaker-2: It sounds great and it can be great and it will be great. It just takes that one person to think positively about those changes and the want and the desire to do it. I will always say this because I almost walked away. You guys almost didn't have me in this chair. I almost walked away from 911. Like I literally was like, I'm not doing this, right? But I stayed. And the reason why I stayed is because I believe and I know that there are possibilities that we can do great things. And the last thing that I will say, and I want everyone to remember, is consistency is culture. Doing things the same, treating people the same, being fair and consistent on how you or your delivery is, that's what's going to help your culture, and that's what's going to help your morale and keep your people.
speaker-1: One more last thing.
If some agency heard about comms coach and they're like, I need that in our life, how do they find it?
speaker-2: Yes, so commscoach is our platform and it's under the our GovWorks is the company name. and so if you're trying to find us online, it's www.govworks G-O-V isn't Victor Works, W-O-R-X, GovWorks dot AI. And just when you visit the platform, it's so many pieces of information there. we, we touched on with Commscoach, we're offering a hire assessment for telecommunicators, a promote assessment for supervisors, we have our quality assurance platform, our automated daily observation report and training platform with a robust catalog of trainings and simulations. And then we have our assist, which is our live call handling, transcription, medic for PCR reports for EMS. and then just so many things, but we're doing a lot of things. But again, we're here to support our first responders. We may be a vendor, and of course, vendors, are for profit, but at the end of the day, people like us, myself and Lori Hendrickson, Halcyon Frank, part of the education team. I give them a little shout out. Yeah. but we are part of this mission because we know that Comms Coach is here to support our first first responders. And I appreciate you guys for just giving me this opportunity to share about culture. that's what I'm gonna continue to preach. Twenty twenty seven is gonna be the year of culture and we're gonna try to keep people in our centers and that's what it's all about.
speaker-1: Reed and a standing invite to come back and talk about all the things because this has so many so many points that you can touch on. It it it can't be condensed into a 45 minute conversation. It just can't. It's too big for that.
speaker-2: Well, I I am like I said, I welcome the conversation and maybe I'll bring a friend along next time.
speaker-0: Always welcome to.
speaker-2: Yeah.
speaker-0: Well, we very much appreciate you for joining us, Tippi. Thank you so much for sharing your many years of knowledge and experience and expertise on emergency communications and the possibilities for improvement and increasing retention in centers across the country and the world. I think you've had a lot of really excellent points and we've been very lucky to have you on today. So thank you so much.
speaker-2: Thank you so much for having me. I appreciate it.
speaker-0: And we've been very lucky to have all of you listening with us as well. If you gu have any questions or comments about any of today's topics, please feel free to send us an email at Lifeline Nine One One Podcast at gmail dot com, or you can leave a note down below. From all of us at Lifeline Nine One One, I'm Gary. We will see you next time.
speaker-1: Thank you for watching. If you have any questions about today's topic or topics you'd like to cover in the future, please reach out to us at Lifeline 911 Podcast at gmail.com. This has been a production of Lifeline 911 Copyright 2026. Until next time, this is Lifeline 911 signing off.