TRASCRIZIONE 🔗
Mac Pierre-Louis: Hi everyone, welcome back to Lawyers Mediators International Show and Podcast, a show where we talk about the law and conflict resolution topics to educate both professionals and everyday people. Today I have with me Frank Goldberg of Dispute.ai. Frank is here to talk to us about this new platform that's going to be transforming conflict resolution as part of the ODR movement around the world. And so, Frank, how are you doing today? Welcome to the show.
Frank Goldberg: Well thanks. Thanks for having me, Mac.
Mac Pierre-Louis: Yes. Well, thank you for coming on. And thank you for just contributing your time to educate the public about what dispute at AI is, and that's dispute with a why. I had to make sure I got that correct myself. And we'll we'll go through the platform and what it does and what your vision for the future is. but first we're gonna talk about you, and then I'll talk about how I met your business partner, Renee, who was the one who I connected with, that led me to connect with you to do this today. But first, who is Frank Goldberg? Let's start to know a little bit about yourself.
Frank Goldberg: Sure. So I am an attorney by training and I've practiced for well more than 20 years in different companies, both at large law firms, well, one large law firm, and then I was in-house at four different companies, starting actually at the Gap in San Francisco, then moving to two technology companies, Zynga, a video game company, Wish, the e-commerce platform. And my last corporate role was as the head of intellectual property for the Clorox company. So I went from clothing to tech to consumer package goods. And all the while, while I my focus has been intellectual property, as you get more senior as as you can appreciate, you start doing a lot more than just your core area. So throughout my twenty plus year career, both as an attorney at a law firm and in-house, I've seen everything, from obviously intellectual property to commercial work, compliance, regulatory privacy, marketing. but I do have a lot of gaps. And that's she's a good segue into how I know Renee. Renee is an employment lawyer by training, and we met at Zynga, where she was an employment attorney, and then we we work together again at Wish. So we often joke that if you put Renee and me together, we get one complete attorney. Because we've pretty much covered the whole scope of legal areas, at least a little bit, except for tax. We've identified that tax is really one of the areas we just have no expertise in. But that's that's how I ended
Mac Pierre-Louis: Yeah. Cool.
Frank Goldberg: up dispute. Renee said, Hey, I have this startup do you want to join? And I thought it was a great idea. And and the reason for that. is I have seen disputes throughout my career and they've been everything from the very small, hey, you're using my image on your website, can you please remove it? All the way to large scale international litigation. We were involved in a litigation throughout five countries in Europe and the European Trademark Office at one company I was at. So I've seen everything and everything in between. And what has always struck out stuck out to me is that litigation is inefficient. It's really a bad way to resolve disputes. It gets the lawyers very wealthy, but it really doesn't help the companies. or at least often doesn't help the companies. Whereas dispute resolution practices, including mediation, have always been way more successful and that's way more efficient. So when Renee mentioned the concept of dispute, it was a no brainer for me to join.
Mac Pierre-Louis: Awesome. Well, thank you so much for that succinct, you know, summary. And I too met Renee just briefly when I was at Harvard University just a month ago. this is you guys she was on stage at Harvard when we were doing the forum on ODR online dispute resolution. And so I when I walked into the you know, main hall where we were going to be sitting. I I did see y'all's table and I was wanted to go by and say hello, but I didn't get a chance on the first day. On the next day at Suffolk Law School where we had the arbitration program by the Triple A, I got a chance to just you know, t take a step to her and be like, Hey, Renee, my name is Mac. Would love to introduce you to the audience to talk about what you guys do. And so she was you know, quick to connect me with you and to help you guys share what dispute.ai is and I have it on my screen. So why don't we get started to just talk about what is dispute.ai.
Frank Goldberg: So Dispute AI really was was formed with the thought that people often don't have access to justice. They often don't know what to do when they have a problem that they need to have addressed, be it your neighbor, your employer, your landlord. so we originally created this platform as an end-to-end dispute resolution service where you can write a letter, you can try to resolve a dispute, and you can even sign a settlement agreement. And that's still all true. But really the highlight of the platform is ADRI. Aidri is our AI mediator. And the way Aidri works is you're directed through a series of questions through an a a chat, which is very similar to what you might see with an LLM. Aidri knows she has to find out certain information from both sides to understand what the dispute is about and what it might take to resolve the dispute. So she'll ask questions and keep going until she gets all the information she needs. At that point, Adri creates a summary of the dispute. Each side has done this, they're done their own intake, so there's a custom summary from each side's perspective. You as the user Can then review and modify and edit the summary to make sure it's accurate and it's also what you want to convey to the other side. So this sort of acts as kind of a a public mediation brief that you might exchange before you're in a traditional mediation. Once that's exchanged, you're then put into a mediation
Load full transcript
room. And here's where the big innovation is. In traditional mediations, you often sit in the same room, maybe for a minute to caucus initially, but often you're just in a separate room from your adversary and the mediator is going back and forth. To try to understand what's the goal for today, how do you want to try to resolve this? Can it even resolve? And often nothing really happens, at least as far as the parties are aware, because there often isn't a first settlement offer until later in the day. Sometimes things settle quickly in the morning, or sometimes people walk out because they just don't want to be there. But often four or five in the afternoon is when you start having some progress. People are getting tired, the mediator has done his or her job to try to get people to realize what it might take to resolve this. What we do is is quite the opposite. Based on the party's s perspective intakes, A.G. makes the first proposal. So Adri hears what is really bothering both sides, how do they want to resolve it, and suggests a reasonable way to settle the dispute. Now the parties don't have to accept that, and actually they often don't. Rather, they have an option to reject or modify. And if they do, they have to tell Aidri why. So you can't just say, I hate this idea and I'm going away. You say, No, I need more money, or no, I want a non-disparagement clause, or no, I need a public d apology, whatever it might be. And then once you submit, once you tell Adri what you need to make this move forward, you have a choice. Adri can suggest a new proposal based on your feedback, or you can suggest something yourself. Say, I want to modify the last proposal or or I want to put this in front of the other person. And then it goes through the same cycle again. You can accept, reject, modify. And this keeps going until the parties either come to a resolution that they're comfortable with or decide this is just not going to be productive, much like a normal mediation. While I've been fortunate, I think that every mediation I've ever been in has resolved. If not on that day, it has resolved within a week or so. Often mediations don't. So in that way, this is a very similar process. But assuming the parties do reach a resolution, we have a settlement agreement generator, which is part of the system. You don't have to sign it. You can take this offline if you want and try to work it out with your attorneys if you want. But for most disputes that you just need something in writing saying, hey, we agree to X, Y, and Z. We'll do that. We have a very simple form that is editable again. And you can sign it in our platform. And then then you're done. and that's that's sort of how how A works in a in a nutshell.
Mac Pierre-Louis: Got it. Well, the whole process from beginning to end, you've basically explained it all. What caught my eye in the video I was watching is that end part you were just with referencing of where you can literally sign the agreement on the
spot and then you have a binding MSA, a binding media settlement agreement that could just be sent to the court, huh?
Frank Goldberg: You do. now of course like any contract, contracts are only as good as people's words to honor them.
Mac Pierre-Louis: Yeah.
Frank Goldberg: But yes, you do have a binding contract. It's n it's it as enforceable as any other contract might be. We have an integration with a company called DocuSeal, which is complying with all the all the online signing requirements and yeah, you have you have a contract.
Mac Pierre-Louis: Got it. So you focus on common and often low dollar disputes and offer AGRI for two ninety nine per mediation. So talk to me about access to justice. There's the gap, you know, between what the justice people want and the justice they can afford. And so why is it important to you to make AGRI available to so many people at such a low cost?
Frank Goldberg: Yeah, no, it's a good question. You know, in in my even in my professional career, I would see people who felt that they were legitimately harmed, often coming after the companies I represent, but they recognize that their dollar value, the dollar value of their dispute is maybe less than a thousand dollars, maybe less than five hundred dollars. almost always less than ten thousand dollars. And the reason why those numbers are important is there are very few attorneys that you could hire that would do work for you when they're not gonna get either a commission on that, some some Some percentage or their hourly rate. Well, for even the ten thousand dollar number I mentioned, you're limited to the number of attorneys who actually might want to help you. So we we developed the platform in a way that is accessible to most, not everyone, of course. If you have a problem that's you you got a you asked for a comic book and it was worth twenty dollars and they gave you one that's ripped, well, we may not be the right platform for you because you just buy the new comic. But for many, many disputes, they are often low dollar value, but not so low that you don't want to pursue them. So it was important us to create a a tool. That allows people to try to get some relief where they otherwise would get nothing. And it could be simple. It could be I have a problem with my rental car agency because they overcharge me and I have an eight hundred dollar bill that I shouldn't have gotten. Well, then it makes sense to use a lower cost provider and not hire a lawyer. This isn't for everyone, but it's for many, many common, repeatable disputes. And as far as the we also have an enterprise solution. So if you're a company that sees a lot of volume, then those are custom packages and it's going to be based on your volume. So it would be even less than two ninety-nine a dispute. If you're at a you know a platform that has thousands of disputes a year, well the numbers change because it's then based on volume. If you're a a community mediation center or or a mediation provider that that facilitates mediations, there are certain there are enterprise prices there as well.
Mac Pierre-Louis: Cool. Understood that. And so in a way, you guys are circling back to the root of ODR, which was this eBay model, right? How do you resolve disputes at scale? And cheaply
Frank Goldberg: Exactly.
Mac Pierre-Louis: enough, otherwise people are going to have broken widgets left and right that they never receive, but they can't do anything about it because the cost of going to court is just astronomical and they're kept out from mending the problem. But platforms like yours kind of get to that root of the problem, there's that gap, you know, again that that we we mentioned. So I'm gonna share my screen and on here, there's a super demo that you have. So can people actually test this out? And what will be the experience when they go through this? Can they actually test Avery for free?
Frank Goldberg: sort of. And what I mean by that is super demo is a clickable version of screenshots of our website. So we curated
Mac Pierre-Louis: Yes.
Frank Goldberg: a very common experience, but it goes slowly. So if you want to say, okay, what do I do at this step? What does that look like? So if you're if you're to click get started, you would see it would show, okay, here's here's the first intake. Okay, I understand what this is. Let me move on to slide two. So you can click through to see what a very common workflow would be. It doesn't show everything because it's meant not to overwhelm, but just to give a perspective of What would your experience be like if you were to use ADRI? If you were to try to resolve, you know, you're looking at a screen there, which shows you could even pick your avatar. Picking the avatar
Mac Pierre-Louis: Mm.
Frank Goldberg: for your mediator doesn't have any effect, but it might make you more comfortable with the with the with the process or or not. You don't have to use an avatar at all. But you keep going, it shows how you do the intake and what happens when the intake is done and when there's a summary. So it gives you a a snapshot into this is what it looks like. So when you do go to AGRI for the first time, when you go to our website and you try to start with a dispute, this is not going to be foreign to you. It's a very intuitive process, at least we think it is. And it's it you know, the feedback we've gotten is that people really understand how how this works. So super demo is a really good snapshot just to see what the process looks like.
Mac Pierre-Louis: Got it. Cool. So, next question. A big question, in fact, is a lot of mediators may ask whether or not ADRI and these sort of tools is going to replace mediators. there's a lot of consternation, as you know, in the legal space these days, in the mediation space these days, due to the fact that AI is changing things so rapidly. We don't know where this ends. We don't know where this goes. And so how do you what would you say with regards to what ADRI
and what dispute that AI is versus compared to what mediators have been offering for decades?
Frank Goldberg: Yes, and we we've heard that and certainly a fair fair point. And our philosophy is we don't want to replace mediators. We want to complement their services. And that can happen in several different ways. First, mediations as we know can be very expensive. one of the last mediations I was in was thirty thousand dollars for one day. Now that was inclusive of the mediators fee, my attorney's fees and the other side's fees. That's thirty thousand for a day. So we'll we're not we're never gonna replace those. If someone wants to go to a mediation that's a hundred million dollar value, they're mediators are always going to be there. But even for the smaller ones, we have a couple couple ways that mediators can stay involved if they want to. First, I alluded to our enterprise platform. And that that is one. So if you have a mediation provider that just has a high volume, can't manage the volume, or the there are a l number of cases that are too low dollar value for them to want to to give their full attention to. They could use our tool as an intake tool, for example, and maybe even do one or two rounds of of proposals through AG, but still be in the loop. And say, okay, we got pretty far and you just saved half a day of my time. Let's get you over the finish line. So it complements the mediators in that way because it provides them a tool they don't have before to actually handle more volume than they currently can. because otherwise we only have so much time in our day. The other part is, and it's sort of related, there are a host of disputes that currently aren't being served by anyone. So that really is where a lot where ADRI can help. So this is not replacing a mediator, it's providing a service where there is no service currently. So it it's not taking
Mac Pierre-Louis: Gap fill.
Frank Goldberg: it's not it's not cutting into the pie, it's creating a new pie, effectively. And and there we think that there's a lot of value there because that goes to the access to justice. Because if someone doesn't want to spend even $500 or $1,000 legitimately, why why would you if you don't have to? Then we can provide a service that's much less expensive that will hopefully get you to a result you're comfortable with, or at least realize at the end, you know what, this isn't gonna work and I have to see you anyway. It's a lot, it's a much lower proposition that doesn't replace the mediator. It creates a different market than the mediator currently exists in.
Mac Pierre-Louis: Well, thank you. And so let's talk as we start winding down. When we talk about trust, confidentiality, and ethics, these are topics we've been dealing with at the human side for years. Every time you go through a mediator training class, you gotta talk about trust, confidentiality, and ethics. Well, now that we have AI tools like ADRI to be able to help you resolve your conflicts,
how does ADRI deal with trust? Covidality and ethics.
Frank Goldberg: Now these are great questions. This is something we spent a lot of time focusing on. So I'll try to take them in that order. And then some of them kind of go together because trust and ethics, in my mind, there's a lot of overlap. First, we we trained ADRI on certain standards that are essential for a good mediator. Even though Adri is not a not a person and is not providing legal advice, we want to make sure that ADRI is at least living up to the same standards as as human mediators. So for example, the ICOTOR online dispute resolution standards, the American Bar Association AAA model standards, JAMS mediation ethics guidelines, the NACM mediation best practices, these were all used to train ADRI. So when ADR's coming up with proposals and ADRI is talking to the users, ADRI is ideally doing the same thing that good be good mediators would be doing themselves. On top of that, there's expertise. Renee and I have 40 plus years of experience as lawyers, as as litigators often. And that's built into the training Adri as to what good looks like. We've also fed Adri legal examples and templates to make sure that she knows what she's doing, especially is relevant when we're coming to settlement agreements. There's a lot of prompt engineering we've done to ensure that we're doing things in a way that a mediator should do. Not all mediators do, but that that mediators should do. But with that, then we're worried about confidentiality. Okay, well, how do we we deal with that? We access the LLMs that we use only through API and the APIs that contractually prohibit training on the use of the data. So what you're telling
Mac Pierre-Louis: Yeah.
Frank Goldberg: us is not going to be fed back to OpenAI, for example. it's all on a closed system. we're always look we're working to ensure compliance with GDPR and CCPA and other relevant statutes. We have a data deletion protocol. we're also privacy by design. So in the the way we've developed our platform, information is shared to users only in ways that is appropriate in a mediation. So certain things are fire firewalled off. For example, if I'm talking to Adrian in my chat and I say some things I don't want to get shared to the other side, they're not shared. The only things that are shared to with the other side to the parties are what the parties agree to. So I mentioned the summaries of the dispute at the end, that it says very right there in big letters, this will be shared with the other side. So you have the opportunity as the user to make sure you're only providing information that you're comfortable with. And then course there are legal protections too. We have confidentiality and mediation disclosures, mediation privilege disclosures and on our platform and our terms. So this all is there, and the parties agree in the terms that this information can't be used in court. This is all subject to the mediation privilege. So we take it very
very seriously, and and I think we should, because if you're in mediation, these are often very sensitive matters, things that you're emotional about and you really are passionate about, and you should be able to Talk to Adri the same way you would talk to a a human mediator.
Mac Pierre-Louis: Yeah. Well thank you f and and I assume that you guys put all these disclaimers very, very publicly and very visible on your website so people can, you know, see and get feel comfortable.
Frank Goldberg: Yes, and as you're going through the app, you're told even in the beginning, as you first, before you even do the intake. So yes, it's all on our website too. But as you go into the app itself, that's there as well. So yeah,
Mac Pierre-Louis: Yeah.
Frank Goldberg: there are FAQs and disclosures on the bottom. If you scroll all the way down, there's there's more information. There's links. so you'll see disclosures on the bottom. right, disclaimers rather, sorry. So there's it's all there, but it's also in our terms of service. And again, as you get into the flow of the mediation before you even answer any question. you have a page explains what you should expect and that includes things like privilege and confidentiality and all that.
Mac Pierre-Louis: Well awesome. Thank you so much. And so so what's the best way for people to get a hold of you? I do see you guys have a LinkedIn page and of course the YouTube channel. I was just playing a video from it. Are those the best ways people can follow you guys?
Frank Goldberg: Sure. well, can always email you know support at or info at dispute.ai. You can reach out to Renee or me directly. We're always happy to talk to people. we actually just even had a demo earlier today. So it's something that we enjoy doing. We like telling people about our product. We also like hearing about the problems our our customers are trying to solve. And there isn't it we're seeing how broadly our services can be used based on the feedback we're getting from folks that we didn't even think might be interested in working with us. So it's always good to hear from folks. You could email us again support at dispute AI. You can r reach out to Renee or me directly, either through LinkedIn or Frank at Dispute AI. And Renee is Renee at Dispute AI. So it's pretty easy to find.
Mac Pierre-Louis: Well, thank you so much for coming on and just sharing more about dispute.ai. So I'm a big believer in this kind of technology to help change the world. And that's why we had done the documentary recently about can ODR change the world? And now your program is yet another step in that direction. And so I think the most important takeaway from me from our talk today is how we have to build trust with the public so that people can feel comfortable with these kind of tools. Because let's be honest. The whole idea of a AI mediator would be completely foreign to even mediator just five years ago. It wasn't something on our radar. We were not even ever thinking about this. But now it's calm and it's come with a vengeance. It's it's moving so quickly. And so it requires us to now educate the public, be like, listen, this is a real thing. It works and it's effective and it can actually transform everyday conflicts so that they don't exist in people's lives and it'll help make for a better society. So thank you for you know contributing to that discussion.
Frank Goldberg: I've happy to do it.
Mac Pierre-Louis: Yes, awesome. Well, Frank Goldberg, I appreciate you for coming on the LMI Podcast. And folks who are watching, if you like this video, check out the other ones on LMIPodcast.com and also on the LMI network YouTube channel. All right, everyone, take care. Until next time, we'll see you soon. Bye-bye.
Frank Goldberg: Yeah.