TRASCRIZIONE 🔗
00:00:07
Speaker 1: Welcome to It Could Happen Here, a podcast where I guess that it is hurricanes and the happening is Asheville and many other places along the path of the Hurricane Colleen, which the hurricane itself has passed. The effects have not. I am your host, Mia Wong, and with me today to talk about... I don't know if I can reasonably call it the second hurricane, but the second disaster? Yeah, we've been calling it locally the crisis after the crisis. Yeah. In Asheville, in the wake of Hurricane Helene, is David Forbes, who is a friend of the show, Asheville Blade journalist and editor, also writes for the Trans News Network. And yeah, David, welcome to the show. Good to be back. Yeah, it's good to talk to you again. It's I say this a lot. It sucks that the only times I get to talk to people are when bad things are happening. Yeah, but we wanted to have you on to talk about what has been going on in the aftermath of Helene in a sort of long-term sense after the sort of cameras have gone away and after the government has declared a back to normal. I guess the place I want to start is something that becomes very clear when you are living in disaster areas, when you are covering disasters, when you're looking at the history of these things. There are sort of two different imperatives that people are driven by in the wake of a disaster. You have On the one hand, you get these massive upswellings of solidarity. What I guess gets called everyone coming together, but is in reality massive expressions of incredibly selfless mutual aid and a bunch of everyday heroism and all of the efforts to a bunch of people dragging generators halfway across a state and people from halfway across the country showing up with food. So you have that on the one hand. On the second hand, you have the shock doctrine, which I had the unfortunate realization that I am now old enough that I don't know if everyone knows what the shock doctrine is anymore. So can you explain what the shock doctrine is before we get to talking about sort of the Asheville version of it? So the term the shock doctrine was popularized by the Canadian leftist writer Naomi Klein. And it is basically the tendency of capitalists, and I would use the term gentry power structures, to use the aftermath of the disaster to consolidate resources and prop up their own power at the expense of everyone else. Yeah, and a lot of times it also allows them to ram through structural changes they would never have been able to ram through. That too. In normal times. I mean, I think... This is another I am slightly feeling my age one because we were talking about this before the podcast. I had this horrifying realization that I was like, oh, I can explain the shock doctrine with Hurricane Katrina. And then I was like, oh, my God, kids who were born in 2006 are 20. It's good for them to hear history. I'm always a fan of you youngins need to hear some history. It's a considerable part of what I do for a living.
Load full transcript
Yeah. Katrina was one of the very famous examples of the shock doctrine, like Pinochet's coup in– In Chile, it was, like, another one. But, like, you know, with Katrina, you can see the sort of twin imperatives thing, where on the one hand, you know, you have this absolutely horrifying hurricane. You have, like, basically right-wing death squads of, like, white dudes going around shooting people. You have, like, Blackwater deployments. Yeah. Which I think people have really forgotten about that, like, oh, yeah, no, like, Blackwater was deployed to New Orleans in the wake of Katrina. Yes. And then you also have common grounds, you know, and a whole bunch of other sort of associated efforts around it. You know, this unbelievably powerful, like, social movement and mutual aid efforts that was built around it. And then also, like, at the same time this is happening, like, the government in New Orleans is, like, eliminating the public school system. Yeah. Which is, like, the shock doctor part of it of, like, oh my god! Like, Jesus Christ! Ugh. Yeah, I guess that's the thing I want to talk about in the context of Asheville. Yeah, can you talk a bit about what the city government has been doing in the wake of this? And I say the kind of long wake, I don't know, like the two-year aftermath, the aftermath. Yeah. Yeah. So, and I spell a lot of this out in the recent piece for The Blade called Two Years After Helene, We Are Still Two Cities. So I think it's worth knowing, going in, that if people think of Asheville as this, like, progressive haven, blue dot, mecca, whatever term that we often get described as, that's just flat out untrue. Like, there are really interesting, vibrant, amazing cultures here. That's why even folks who've done disaster relief work around the world were honestly shocked by the level of– I used the term as a compliment, of course– like anarchic on the ground, like ability of people to gather together and help each other out, even when like the government was nowhere to be seen. That is a common thing in disaster zones. We did have a particularly well-connected and powerful example here. And honestly, I kind of got to both report on that and see some of that because I was also out doing mutual aid stuff and double duty as a journalist trying to inform folks when the storm hit. So that was very real. And that reflects, like, these entrenched kind of community spirit you have seen in this town. It's why a lot of us, like, love this city and like living here despite the hardships. This also was, for a long time, may still be, sometimes ranked as, like, the most unaffordable city in the entire country. Yeah. Because of a combination of really high housing costs, often inflicted by this, like, very runaway gentrification. Yeah. And the tourism industry fueled a lot of that. And also just like ridiculously low wages and anti-labor stuff, especially from progressive businesses often. Because like you want to see any of them become like Sam Walton conservatives. You mentioned their workers unionizing in Asheville and all of a sudden they will just like become the most right-wing figures imaginable. So you had all that. There's a huge poverty problem heading into Helene hitting. There's a lot of Neglect of seriously vital infrastructure, the rivers overdeveloped. These were all– and still are problems, but they all made the impact filling a lot worse than it had to be. And the city government was at the heart of a lot of this. It's not the only government, and the county government certainly has its own share. And as I'll mention a little later, federal and state governments– like this is a multi-government problem. But City Hall is the government with the most day-to-day power over the lives of people living here. Yeah, they are the head of the Voltron of shit composed of the state and federal governments. Yeah, basically, if one wants to use that analogy, yeah. But by our powers combined, we can make everyone's lives worse. They are the on-the-ground problem. They are where the evils of the state and the gentry really hit the ground. Yeah. So a fact that I think kind of sums things up that a lot of people don't know was that evictions here in Asheville restarted before the water was back on. Which is just, like, Jesus Christ. Yeah.
00:07:52
Speaker 2: Like.
00:07:54
Speaker 1: Yeah, that's and that was not just city government because evictions are carried out by the county in North Carolina. But like city government could have said, hey, please don't do this. And because they're all run by overlapping Democratic Party clicks, there probably would have been like some hesitation from the county figures that would have backed off some. The governor might have declared a who was also a Democrat at the time, still is actually declared like an eviction moratorium. And there were considerable local efforts to press for these. But no, no. I went to the courthouse where they were still holding eviction earrings at the same time they had signed saying, hey, you can't use the restrooms because we don't have a reliable water supply. Yeah. It's such a stark demonstration of like, yeah, water, not essential. Landlords getting paid. Absolutely essential. Yes. And that wave of evictions, while people have done a lot to organize against it and, you know, keep people housed, it has been truly devastating. And irony of irony is now state and local governments, as of like a month ago, we're starting to starting to say, oh, maybe we need some relief plan. We're literally running out of workers. It's like, wow, damn, social reproduction. Who could possibly have guessed? You do need to reproduce the worker. Yeah, yeah, yeah. They're like, wow, businesses aren't getting as much money anymore because, like, locals got driven out, like, left and right. Tourists aren't going to work in your shops. Like, I just... You gotta have... Oh, no. Why is why is my local economy failing? One billion dollars for
cops. Like, well, it's an interesting example of kind of this magical thinking. And again, this is everywhere in the country, but it's Asheville distills a lot of like social evils in America, frankly, with the Lack of affordability with how openly liberals here on the side of like downright genocidal capitalism with it being a tourist hub. There's a lot of like attempts to appease gentry from elsewhere as well. And we just how blatantly in the this is this is kind of where he improved apocalypse like the old says the word like a ripping off. of the veil is that, They see Asheville as an asset. This is something to be pumped for as much cash as possible. The first major city contract backed by federal relief dollars after Helene started to kind of like had kind of cleared out was to repair the golf course. Jesus Christ. It's just, oh my God. One reason I did this like kind of two year anniversary column, because I realize a lot of folks, especially outside Asheville, didn't know exactly, like just listing out the drumbeat of actions and lack of action in case of local local government did. You know, they bragged recently on putting 15 and a half million into subsidizing businesses. Mm hmm. Locals pled for action. Any sort of amount, that level of amount of rental aid, I think there's like reluctantly they parted with a few hundred thousand dollars, which given the scale of the crisis, didn't really do a damn thing. And locals are pushing for far, far more. I feel like that's just such a mask off, like let them drink rainwater. We have golf to play. Yeah, occasionally I've heard folks wonder why, like of all the kind of leftist strains of thought, anarchism is really strong in Asheville. And this is a great example of why, because of just like even by government standards, how openly hostile the state is. Yeah, they just hate you. Yeah, they they just straight up hate you. The mayor, Mayor Sturmanheimer, who may or may not be the mayor in about like a month or two, she's faced a pretty serious reelection challenge. in classic after-court fashion, I don't think a huge amount will change, but she got so angry about locals, like, giving her shit at meetings... That she started to read the entire rules of decorum before every meeting. Jesus Christ. That's the most, I'm not mad. Like that's her priority is like no one can make me feel uncomfortable. She's also kind of famous for banning clapping. What? But not for everyone. And this is actually one thing where I've like talked to legal experts about this kind of thing. Yes, technically legal in Nashville, you know, and most cities in North Carolina. a government can ban clapping. But ask me for everything. Like, you can't clap for good news to the city, bad news to the city. It's one or the other for First Amendment reasons. No, no, she just decides arbitrarily to ban clapping if it's people, like, wanting a ceasefire resolution two years ago for, like, the rights of Palestinians or, like, anyone criticizing city government in any way. And she straight up said one time, like, no, y'all can clap now, like, the city manager, horrible city manager's retiring, because, like, that's good news for us, so go ahead and clap. And it's just, like, openly blatant petty cruelty. But like that's been her priority. So about a month after the storm in October 2024, the Blade put out a piece in our Patreon, which is where we do a lot of our like shorter kind of quick hit stuff, no paywall. But it was entitled We Are Two Cities. And this had certainly been a reality well before the storm. The storm really brought it into sharp relief. And on one end, you had like these amazing efforts of communal care and people really helping each other out. and a stunning amount of organization going on. And then on the other end you had, you know, how did, how did we put it? Like, uh, the place of, five thousand dollar rents and five thousand airbnbs yeah you know it's there was like a line of cops outside a like abandoned ingles grocery store just to make sure people couldn't reach anything inside to help themselves out it's great let the food rot we cannot allow a single yeah literally they would they would not not even just the food but like people want like diaper supplies because again the water wasn't wasn't running yeah things like that. No, Ingalls, which is the kind of almost like de facto grocery store monopoly locally has a lot of power protecting their bottom line. Like their ability just to write off a little bit more. Yeah. Was literally what the police are being deployed for. It's one of the most kind of searing things I've ever seen as far as like what the cops are actually for. It's probably a good time to mention that Covering Asheville's local government, which I've done for over 20 years at this point, which is probably unhealthy at some deep levels, is one of the things that made me an anarchist. Because after a while, I'm like, this just shouldn't exist. And nothing like it has a right to exist. Yeah. Especially after repeated changes of government, things just kept largely proceeding in worse and worse directions, whatever people promise. But so that dynamics never really went away. And if anything, I think it kind of got exaggerated over time. A small example, but a really telling one. She made national news for how callous she was. Monique Pierre, who was the head of the public housing agency in Asheville, and notoriously the state of the public housing towers, which are also a site of a ton of segregation, were really, really bad after the storm. The housing authority just neglected everyone there, just left them to basically nearly die in a lot of cases. No supplies, no help whatsoever. And she publicly said, interviewed the local NPR station. Well, I had to make sure landlords got paid, and they did. Oh, it's just like... That was so egregious that even the housing authority board, like, removed her for it. Yeah. And in response, the city,
which the mayor appoints, like, housing board members, and with council approval, can remove them. And everyone voted for this, pretty much, including the, like, dissident who, quote-unquote, who's running against the current mayor, Esther Manheimer, right now. But they all voted to purge... housing authority board to punish them for doing any consequences whatsoever, even if it's a figure that egregious. So, like, even the usual gentry thing of, like, she was a little too blatant and too openly evil. Like, we're going to be fine with, like, throwing her overboard to make the rest of us look better. They wouldn't even do that. It's like, that's how open the, like, abuse of power is.
00:15:51
Speaker 2: Yeah.
00:15:52
Speaker 1: So, that's continued. And... They've really actually emphasized a lot of collaboration with the federal government since Trump retook office. Which... The first thing they announced about the federal government was that they'd gotten approval from his FAA to do more drone surveillance of the public. Doing drone surveillance? Like, drone surveillance of what? Like, the houses you need to rebuild? Like, what... Well, and they got a ton of money from the federal government. And until there was a massive public backlash about it, initially, that overwhelmingly was just going to go to capital projects, which is like city speak for big infrastructure. and specifically stuff that they felt could get tourists back. A month after the storm, again, still not, we didn't have running water. Yeah. The tourism board was always like, it's time for everyone to come back to Asheville and spend money. And, you know, the tourism bubble was a problem, again, long before Helene. It kind of exacerbated and showed how big these issues were. And Helene, for justifiable reasons, like for understandable reasons, smashed it with a hammer. Yeah. If anything, the effects from that haven't been all bad because like, Rental rates, while still horrible here, especially if people don't have income, finally stopped rising meteorically. We finally stopped having some of the highest COVID infection rates in the southeast here. And so it showed, I think, along with the extremities they've gone to try to bring it back, how much that was always an extractive industry. Yeah. Yeah. And to some degree, this fits in a longer history in Appalachia, which, you know, Asheville just seen as, oh, this kind of progressive fun tourist town. But we're in the middle of Appalachia. There is a long history here of the purpose of governments, local and otherwise, just to be the place you run, the people in it are a site for extraction. Yeah. Originally, that was taken away from indigenous folks, and then it was timber, then it was coal. And I think in a lot of ways, the little quieter about it, tourism is like a similarly extractive industry. Yeah, well, it has now gone back to being land a second time. Yeah. It's just a thing that's being extracted. Well, yeah, partly, but also, like, I mean, I know areas that used to have streets before the storm that used to have, you know, neighborhoods on them, and now they're mostly vacant because it all got turned into Airbnbs. Yep. Well, and where did a lot of those folks go? Well, they went to older, in worse disrepair, more flood-prone housing near the rivers. Some of them died there. Yeah, yeah.
00:18:17
Speaker 2: Thank you.
00:18:25
Speaker 1: This kind of all came together actually at the last city council meeting in September. It was a few days for the storm anniversary. And they showed this glossy video about how Asheville is, you know, making opportunity out of tragedy. And it's like business owners talk about how much money they'd gotten from a city hall. Jesus Christ. And then the open public comment period hits where, you know, locals can just rant for a few minutes about whatever's in their mind, but also is one of the only like not tightly controlled areas of the meeting. Probably because they legally have to have it. Yeah. And, This retired teacher from this neighborhood in East Asheville got hit really hard by the storm, which is, you know, that's mostly like retired educators said, look, like it's telling that we hear how Asheville's revived. But none of the footage is from our neighborhood. We have a like crumbling cliff we have been warning you about since the storm. Jesus Christ. And the response we've largely gotten is, well, if it falls apart, we'll help you clean it up. incredible stuff like it just yeah like i can't make this up if i were writing this as like a post-disaster late capitalism novel the editor would tell me to stop being so heavy-handed yeah it would be comic if like my life and the lives a lot of people i care about weren't attached to this and the shock doctrine part definitely plays a key role in it because there was this um really unpopular thing called the business improvement district oh my god which basically are privatized mini-governments. I think y'all have talked about them in other episodes before. And Asheville locals put up a pretty fierce resistance to this one. And to get it through, City Hall had made some concessions in paper, at least. There would be more limits. They wouldn't use private security, things like that. And in the wake of the storm, they revoked all of that and shoved it through anyway. Yeah. Which, related to this, if you ever hear anyone talking in any form about something called a TIF, kill it with hammers. Yeah. Hammers. Like, it must die immediately. You are about to get fucked. Myself and everyone else who lives downtown, which, you know, despite supposedly being this ultra-terrified area, it still includes, like, a lot of elders and Section 8 housing and even some, like, you know, bits of working class housing here and there, all of us now have to pay a tax to a front group controlled by the Chamber of Commerce to basically like look at us weird when we walk down the street, you know? So it's
charging our like cars, among other things, you know? Yeah, like it's one of these things when you talk about extraction, right? And a lot of that is at least slightly indirect or it's like people are being forced out of their homes by like what are nominally market forces. Yeah. But sometimes, no, they're just like, hey, yeah, we're going to use the state and you're just going to pay us all money. Yeah, yeah. And like it's this real sort of like robber baron in the most literal sense. Yeah. Of like we are using the coercive apparatus of the state to get you to hand business money. Yeah. It very much is. And as a matter of fact, it's another thing they did was so City Hall, like a lot of local governments, has like various citizen boards and commissions. And these are not, you know, super fervent sites of like direct democracy or anything. They're largely, you know, older, mostly white, kind of centrist or even conservative leaning people. Often retirees get appointed to them. But occasionally some of these boards would say obvious things like, hey, maybe we shouldn't just build hotels everywhere. Or if the cops keep like brutally kicking out every homeless person they see were going to get sued a lot. And that was too much. So earlier during the height of the pandemic, City Hall had previously tried to dismantle all of them, just like shut them down basically entirely, replacing the few like tiny little rubber stamp commissions because it was, you know, taking up too much of their time. That was the literal excuse. Jesus Christ. But after the storm, they just shut the commissions down and never reopened them. Ah, shock doctrine. Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. Because even that occasional tepid dissent was too much for them. The first budget after the storm, and for anyone who has had the misfortune or just the necessity of having to fight local governments, the budgets were a lot of the worst stuff goes down because they can just put it all in one package. Yeah. Yeah. And no one looks at it. Not enough people do. Interestingly, folks have been pretty alert to them here since the storm, especially. Yeah. So one, they did a massive tax hike. And while that is property tax, obviously landlords pass it on to renters. Yeah. And in this area specifically, there's a long history of black working class neighborhoods, especially getting highly overvalued property value wise, but then like wealthy white enclaves. get massively underrated. They have to pay way less tax. So this is pretty extractive. And I think some people would have been okay with a tax increase if it's like, okay, this is all going towards rebuilding. We're going to improve the infrastructure or get some aid for locals who are struggling. There could have at least been a case made. No, no, no. It went to more cops, massive raises for city hall higher-ups. The city manager of Asheville makes more than the mayor of New York City. Jesus Christ. Which, if you've heard, is a little larger than Asheville. Good Lord. Yeah. Now, it's not a huge amount more, but it is, you know, like $ 275, 000 before her, like, bonuses and vehicle allowance and clothing allowance kicks in. This is the person telling you do not become addicted to water. Like, yeah. I'm going to vote for my own pay raise. Yeah, it definitely is. Well, yes, she draws the budget, not surprisingly. Every year, the higher-ups get massive pay hikes. So it went to that, it went to more cops, and it went to actually putting money back in the Rainy Day Fund, which you'd think after a massive storm, you're spending money from the Rainy Day Fund. But no, wealthy investors wanted to see Asheville have more money in reserve just sitting there because it made them feel more comfortable. This happens in various cities, like Chicago famously just had a big back and forth with these kind of investors in municipal bonds and, you know, push back against them some. Ash don't even try. They were like, oh, well, we just want to do their bidding in advance. When you are being out progressive by the mayor who fucking deployed SWAT teams against an art student encampment. Like, what are we doing? Like, Jesus Christ. Yeah. Asheville has a highly conservative government with progressive marketing. And the kicker in that budget, too, was there was a one-time larger pay hike that some city staff got to supposedly address some of the post-Aline desperation. But they excluded one major group from this, a group that has struggled for ages with some of the worst pay in the region for the profession. And that's Asheville's firefighters. Right. They specifically excluded the firefighters, the heroes of Helene, and to be clear, nurses, firefighters, public works folks, they did do real heroic work on the ground. They did repair stuff under horrible conditions, too. The most anarchist of locals is not going to talk shit about them. If anything, it's like, why are they being paid better? But the city manager who is actually county city manager complained that people were asking for water too quickly. She literally did the do not become addicted thing in the aftermath of the storm. Jesus Christ. And Asheville had had a crumbling water system for ages. We had a huge outage a few years before Helene hit just due to like disrepair because we have a setup that the more water a business pumps, the less they have to pay for it. What? Which is straight up like, yeah, it's straight up a corrupt giveaway. Even most of their places in North Carolina don't do this. They have like just a flat rate for, you know, whatever amount of water. That's insane. Yeah, yeah, yeah. So, and this was specifically meant to give, like, HCA, though HCA were in hospital, and all the big breweries that came in, all the big manufacturing, they actually had to pay less the more water they use. Which meant that the system, which was already crumbling and neglected, got worse and worse and worse. Yeah, because you're incentivizing overdraw on
it. That's... Yeah, it's funny. When I tell folks, even other folks who dealt with local governments, they're not good anywhere. They are corrupted evil everywhere. How bad Asheville is, I get reactions like this because it sounds like something from, like, cyberpunk fiction. Yeah, this is like the shit. Unfortunately, I can't tell many of the stories of the city council that I grew up with, which was like... It was like a notoriously corrupt city council by the standards of, like, Illinois governments. But, like, it's like that shit. That level of, like, we are like... personally physically targeting journalists we don't like yeah kind of shit it's like oh to the blades journalists as y'all covered on this for did get arrested yeah that's why I was like yeah I was like oh no we've reached that yeah we've reached like city council water fuckery like yeah Jesus Christ Yeah, so when the pipes burst, when we had a particularly cold winter, which they didn't prepare for, you know, because cold winters are utterly unheard of in the Appalachian Mountains. What's on top of the mountain? The sun. Yeah, exactly. Not anything else. So a few years before Helene hit, we had this extended outage that covered, I think, like two-thirds of the city and a fair amount of the county at one point. And it occurred to them the city had no water distribution plan for this kind of outage. And Helene rolls around, and they still hadn't developed a water distribution plan if there was a serious shock to the system. And in one of the first interviews she gave post, Helene, the mayor, said, well, that's not our job. That's the county's job. Now, the county did have a water supply system. but they put it across the Swan River, which was even days before the storm, like the National Weather Service was like, hey, we're going to have historic flooding. on this river, like start moving stuff away from it. They're just like, it'll be fine. They're like, our water supply got cut off. Why are y'all asking for water? Stop annoying us. Yeah, so that's what we've been dealing with. And there's probably some stuff I'm forgetting. Oh, a bunch of people end up homeless after Helene for obvious reasons. So one of their big priorities has not been aid for the homeless, other than like a few token amounts here or there. It was to even further criminalize people asking for food and money. Yeah, the most recent– and this ties in with all this because they already had the drone surveillance, which the FAA under Trump gave them more power to use on the public. And they have used drone surveillance just to hunt homeless people before. And so not only did they escalate camp sweeps, they also teamed up with the now not running for re-election Chuck Edwards due to even the Republican Party getting him for sexual harassment. Like that's how bad it was. That's not good. Yeah. Don't worry, the Democrat and Republican running to replace him are both transphobes who support ICE. So, you know. Great, great. Yeah, yeah, yeah. It's quite a time here. But so he secured money for them to do the other big priority. which is to massively expand their camera and surveillance systems across the city. So that's that's the kind of like official city. That's the city of the gentry that we're dealing with here. And in the propaganda they put out, like, Asheville is recovered and is welcoming back tourists, and you won't see any of the filthy poors. Why are we also having a worker shortage? And literally every dollar they can get a hold of, unless there is some sort of public backlash, they are putting towards the worst possible things. And firefighters still can't afford the rent. I think a lot about a thing that people in the prison abolitionist movement say a lot, which is that it's cheaper to send someone to Harvard than it is to put them in prison. It is. And it's like, okay, your problem with there are a bunch of out-housed people, right? A lot of whom's homes were destroyed by the hurricane. Yeah. You could just fix the houses and then you would have workers. But neoliberalism is a regime of extraction based on take money from literally everything else and give it to police. Yeah. So that's just they're like, fuck it. We're going to build like a... What would you even call it? Like a multi-airspace level surveillance system instead of fixed house? There's also another element to this. It's not just the homeless. That's absolutely part of it. They are terrified of protests and dissent. Yeah. Because Asheville had a pretty powerful action in 2020. A lot of stuff continued after that. There was a major public backlash to the surveillance plan. And occasionally, when they started to dump a bunch of storm debris in a historically black neighborhood... the neighborhood started to get very angry and militant about it, and they actually moved the debris. Hell yeah. You know, that's kind of the other Asheville, the one where most of us live, which is a lot of poverty and desperation, but also, like, the solidarity that stems... from the storm has not entirely gone away. And some of that's been more informal organizations that have continued. Some of that's been more formal ones. Swannanoa, an area that got utterly devastated by the storm, has seen, like, a lot of community organizing that's kind of on the more formal side because the needs there are still really dire. But there's also attempts to, like, basically bulldoze and gentrify that whole area, which is historically fairly working class. Yeah. These are things that also come into collision, like, Twice in the past two years, Asheville police have just set up outside Banks Avenue, Lex Avenue, which are two areas known for like mostly multiracial crowds of like queer party goers kind of thing coming out of the bars after your last call. and just started pelting people with pepper balls. Jesus Christ. So, and their excuse when asked about this isn't even like, they don't even try to claim, oh, there was
some like immediate problem going on. There was some like, you know, giant knife fight or something. They don't even bother those excuses. They're just like, oh, we've had crime in this area before. Yeah. Like over the years, there's occasionally been crime in this area. So we have a right to pelt anyone with chemical weapons. The police commander that honed this strategy is now the chief. Oh, God. Yeah. Well, look, look, in order to maintain the respectability of the city, you must, in fact, use chemical weapons on the queers. Yeah. Unfortunately, one of Trotsky's two good lines is, One of them is combined uneven development, which is sort of useful, though not in the way that he used it. And the second one was in the heart of every small business owner. Like every petite bourgeois is a particle of Hitler. And this is the like the Hitler particle level is escalating. We're back. We're back up to chemical weapons against the queers. Like we got to. Yeah. Yeah. And that was the justification. And openly. they didn't even try to hide it. It was just like, oh, there's crime in that area. We felt the crowds were too rowdy and too much of a threat. Yeah, which, you know, I'm drawing Chicago examples. It's like, girl from Chicago draws examples of Chicago. But it's like, yeah, no, like, Chicago does this any time there's just like a crowd. I mean, obviously they beat up queer people too, but like, every time there's just, there's like a continuously, like for like a decade now, I mean, probably longer than that. There's just been like this running panic over like, oh my God, a bunch of black kids are like, gather together outside yeah and we're gonna deploy the police against them for literally no reason and it's just like yeah like you you get this thing of like oh my god are like subjugated underclass is gathering yeah for like you know just to like hang out but fuck it it's time it's time to like shoot them with riot munitions There was a really telling phrase that I heard, some really telling words I heard from a local when they had to move for the third time since the storm. And it is, I feel like we're being punished for surviving. And that is what a lot of us are grappling with. Yeah. I will say, because this is an excuse City Hall uses, and there is a grain of truth to it, but not the way they portray it. Funding has been lacking from the state and federal governments. You mentioned Katrina earlier, and as devastating a shock doctrine as that was, they did cover 75% of the various governments' costs. Now, those governments turned around and also put the funds they got towards some pretty bad purposes, which is what we're seeing actually over two. Asheville's gotten like 17. Jesus Christ. Might be up to 20% now. Yeah. So, like, there is a real issue with state and federal governments just not sending money here. But the money they get, they're putting towards things like the golf course, you know, surveillance, and a big one, rebuilding the river district exactly as it was. Oh, great. Building the floodplain again. This is going to go great. It's going to go great for you. Yeah, so this is... So they bought in the urban landscape, which is, for those who may not be aware, is like the epitome of like a neoliberal gentrification planning think tank. They are as establishment as it gets. But the city brought them in to, you know, advise them on how to redevelop the city, you know, obviously prime for like, you know, more tourism and more gentrification. And even the Urban Land Institute was like, you massively overdubbed the river. That made the flooding way worse. It destroyed a bunch of stuff. Your only option is to move a bunch of stuff away from the river. Like, you have to move it back. It is too flood-prone. And the city literally put out a statement at the urging, specifically of the, like, river district gentry, of just like, we're just not going to listen to this. Well, and it's one of these things where it's like, you can see in, like, five years when the next hurricane hits, because that's just the world that we're living in. Like they're going to do the same thing again. They're going to learn no lessons. And the people who are going to have to suffer for it are like people like you and people like me. It's easy to look at all this and get pretty doom and gloom. I don't want to be, that's not. Yeah. There's certainly a lot of like, you know, precarity and depression. I mean, I am still... from just the months afterwards doing double-duty journalism and intense mutual aid stuff. And, yeah, that has somewhat continued. Like, I still have to arrange supply drops for folks occasionally who are still kind of facing, like, insecurity stuff from the long aftermath of this. But, like, there is and remains a lot of solidarity among people on the ground. And, honestly, like, to the degree that any research has been directed towards things that aren't horrible, it's been grudgingly because people got really angry at them. Yeah, the state is fightable. And they will do concessions because they're scared. The state is absolutely fightable. And ironically, I think they've weakened themselves by how openly vicious they are in this because they dropped all pretense after the storm and just went for the openly most extractive policies they could. Yeah. But in doing so, I think for a lot of folks, they just open up their alley like these aren't your friends. Yeah. This is not a legitimate place for public decision making that occasionally makes bad decisions. they just hate you and everyone in your neighborhood.
00:37:45
Speaker 2: Yeah.
00:37:45
Speaker 1: Any point where they can't, you know, it completely just extract money. I still feel the burnout. Uh, I'm still struggling with it. Uh, I have probably never, I don't mean just as high mode experience, just cause this is incredibly common. Yeah. Among those of us who are like working class and we're on the ground in Asheville. you still
haven't really had the time to like sit down and recover from the like months long burnout that we incurred from doing that because there's just still so much to fight. And we have to also pay written bills and work for a living. So that is a real problem. But also like, I think locals are even more willing to organize and even willing to organize outside of like governments, the nonprofit complex. Um, Ashworth is one of the largest per capita nonprofit complexes in the country. Uh, well, that seems to be working great. Yeah, exactly. And that's the thing. Previously, they have functioned as a very effective way of, to channel dissent into official channels where it never goes anywhere and to the least effective strategies possible. But a lot, there are a handful of exceptions that did actually like, you know, credit where due, put money towards real aid that has really like benefited folks. But in general, especially the larger, more established ones, utterly failed after the storm. So the one reason they were supposed to exist was, you know, I mean, the actual reason was to repress dissent and put it into, you know, like this kind of very gentrified structure. But the reason on paper this was exist was, you know, to help with exactly this kind of thing and channel philanthropic dollars. And a lot of them just didn't. Yeah. Or the amounts were so minimal that they didn't really get much done. Yeah. It's like you're being outdone by the local bookstores. Like, it's just like. Yeah. Yeah, yeah. Shout out to Firestorm. Like Firestorm co-op bookstore in West Asheville did a lot of great organizing and he's worth supporting. Yeah, good, good, good people. Good stuff. But it's also like, it says something when the, when like the, the giant NGOs with all the money are getting out organized for the bookstore. Yeah. Like it's, it says like who actually cares about this stuff and who, well, and even among the nonprofits, it was like be loved, which is like a liberation theology, like, you know, homeless support group. And a homeless support organization. And then a handful of more left-leaning Presbyterian churches are the ones who've been actually, like, directing serious funds, like, to rental aid and things like that. So, like, that's kind of been the, you know, brighter spots in this, as it were. And there were weird exceptions. Like, can you credit where due? The Register of Deeds office. What?! Yeah, like, organize a substantial amount of, like, coordination for, like, flush brigades and stuff like that. It was famously, like, one of the only government offices to actually put resources and attention into, like, doing, meeting some of the needs of the public. Yeah, I mean, I guess it is that, like, occasionally you get these situations where it's, like, I have a friend who says this about, like, sometimes you get managers in union shops like this where it's, like, they're, like, a worker who had a bad idea, and so they got into management, but they're not, like, shitty people and will like sometimes help you with stuff. And sometimes with this is like, yeah, no, like, and I guess this is true of like, you know, this is like part of how the state is an institution functions, but like, yeah, every once in a while you do get someone in a like, you know, kind of random bureaucratic position who is like, a good normal person and has not had their soul like devoured by the maw of capital and it's just like no yeah fuck it i don't know i i i i run i run the office of deeds like fuck it i work in the office of deeds we're gonna go help people and it's like yeah yeah it's but it's interesting because it's kind of the exception that proves the rule yeah yeah Because, like, the rest of the thing could be doing this too, but they're not. Yeah, yeah. They have way more resources. Yeah. But the stuff they gave was generally grudging and was outdone, like, by other stuff. For example, like, okay, well, we're going to eventually set up water stations and, you know, food supplies. Oh, but also your eviction case is going forward. Yeah. You know? One reason I wrote, I think I mentioned earlier, I wrote the piece was just because Focus kind of went away from Asheville after Helene. Like, it tends to in disaster areas. Yeah. But we're still in crisis. Like, it still feels like we're digging our way out of the rubble. And that's literal in some cases. Like, you will turn, you know, off a less public road and still just see like a line of destroyed houses. Less so than you would have like a year, even a year and a half, definitely a year and a half ago. But they're definitely still there. There's one I see while driving, eat groceries occasionally. So that's literally still happening in some places, but because of how badly both the storm itself and its aftermath been handled and all the prioritization of just like extracting as much money from locals as possible and restoring this already highly unsteady of my capitalism standards, like tourist city, previous status quo. Yeah. It's still, it's still very much present. Like Asheville is still defined by Helene in a lot of ways. And what does give me hope is the number of people who know each other, know their neighbors, can kind of work together on stuff. We've seen more tennis union stuff since the storm. Hell yeah. You know, we've seen more labor organizing since the storm. And honestly, like, and I say this for the efforts I'm involved in as well as all of others, like... We had some really good mutual aid stuff before, which is one reason, like, the networks didn't come from nowhere. Some of those people were, and they were just, like, cobbling stuff together in the ground. But a lot of cases, they did grow out of folks who were already engaged in some form of that work in Asheville beforehand. But I definitely say, like, we've all kind of leveled up some because we have a much clearer idea of what does and doesn't go down, you know, when a storm hits
and what areas are more vulnerable. And it was interesting because despite all the money they're pouring the police department and all the surveillance efforts, The new police chief, like the two or three before her, is still complaining they can't find enough cops. Even though I mentioned the first budget pass, the second one last year, which was a lot more contested and only passed by a single vote, they cut more services like community center hours and things like that. They also still gave the city manager another massive raise. But they were like, oh, we're in a $ 30 million budget crunch. But if you look at the actual numbers, a lot of that was they tried to hire 24 more cops. Yeah, and it's just like every single city government is like, oh no, my budget's unbalanced. And you look at it, it's like 60% police. And it's like, hey, what if we paid less? What if we had less of the guys whose jobs it is to intermittently switch between standing around playing Candy Crush and beating up queer people? We can do this. I believe in us. Yeah, it's that is it's for about 20 years escalating more in the past decade or so. That's literally been kind of the, you know, where the budget and the increases from it always go. And Asheville's not alone in this, but it raises to higher ups, more cops, more surveillance, more policing of various sorts. Yeah. And then, you know, maybe some consultants, tourism friendly stuff. You know, I don't know, putting money back in an account where you normally spend it from because the gentry want it. Another interesting example, and God, I feel like I'm just kind of going by, like, but these all form a picture together. Yeah. Biltmore Village, which is notoriously this hyper-expensive tourist trap area, but built in the floodplain, got basically annihilated during the storm. Uh-huh. And... When, unlike the folks from the, you know, the retired educators were like, hey, we're close about to collapse. And the city was like, well, you know, if it collapses, whatever. The more village folks went and went, hey, our businesses aren't making profits anymore. You should subsidize us. You should buy stuff from us so we can make money again. And it's not clear exactly how that's, how that's sorted out. Because getting records from the city was actually like pulling teeth. But the response from the dais was, oh yeah, we'll get right on that. Jesus Christ. Like, Yeah, I think sometimes because they have less PR and less polish, local governments are much more open about exactly what they're there for. There's less pretense about, yeah, we're here to do the bidding of the wealthy and the rest of y'all are not just kind of expendable, but actively despised for wanting anything else. It's pretty illuminating, but like, Asheville is, for one disaster or another, with both You know, this is where government's head really happens. I think we're just kind of ahead of the curve here because of just like how openly, comically, almost evil the gentry are in Asheville. Yeah. But, you know, some sort of disaster, whether it's wildfires, you know, hurricanes, flooding of some sort, what have you, it's coming to a down near you if it hasn't already. Yeah. And when the chips are down, the government's probably not going to react that dissimilarly. Yeah. So I do hope folks learn from that, but also from the power is in fact in your hands, like you and your neighbors can immediately organize and start responding to things. And often you can do a way more effective job than the people whose job that supposedly is, than your local government. Yeah, they can be fought and they can be replaced. Yeah, exactly. And not replaced like the ways we're told they can be replaced, like the ballot box, because there is a crop of candidates running to replace the current city council. they all have exactly the same views as the current city council. One of them thinks they should put even more attention and resources into reconstructing the river district exactly as it was before the storm. Jesus Christ. Yeah. That's what passes for, like, dissent among, like, the ranks of political candidates. Yeah, no, but replacing the sense of... I'm constantly haunted by this question from an anthropologist at the beginning of what ends up being a quite good book about the Zapatistas. Yeah. that I'll link in the description. But she goes in, and one of the things about the Zapatistas is that they refuse to take money from the Mexican government, which they call the bad government, because it is a systemic organization of death squads that murders indigenous people and steals their land in order to build their fucking megaprojects on it. And this anthropologist comes in. This is something I've seen a lot in a specific kind of like a specific kind of like nominal leftist resistance to neoliberalism where they see someone like, you know, like literally building their own infrastructure. Yeah. Right. In the way the Zapatistas did really, you know, like they, okay. So like they've built their own self-governing communes and they refuse to, and they provide their own services and refuse to use the services of, of the, like, you know, of the like hideously corrupt murder state. And the anthropologist goes in and, like, starts asking Zapatistas, like, is that neoliberalism? Because you're replacing the goods of the state. And every single person looks at her and is like, what the fuck are you talking about? Yeah, seriously. Like, literally, what are you talking about? Like, you know, and this is also, like, running, I don't know, like, there's so many angles you can comment this from, from the perspective of, like, it is, in fact, extremely different when, like, workers and indigenous people and all of the people who would be put together into the category of the wretched of the earth come together and do things outside of the state and do the original version of the sort of democratic procurement of aid for the community
and do the things that the state absorbed specifically as a kind of insurgency thing people then see see that like doing the original socialism as like neoliberalism because you're doing it outside the state and you're doing it instead of the state like sponsored ones that are designed to like capture it Like, capture you in the upper half of the state. And they see that and they go, oh, you're doing neoliberalism. And like, no. No, no, no, no, no, no. Well, it's not corporate in nature. It's not capitalist in nature. So... Yeah. And this is a good point because... There's things like police, for example, upper-level managers that can be dismissed with entirely. But there's a reason the anarchists don't go abolish the fire department, abolish the libraries. Those are things that governments generally just kind of took over and glommed onto and folded under. But people want to do those things. Yeah. Yeah, and that's the thing where it's like, all of the work in the world is done by workers. Yeah, the Postaline stuff is an example I point to when folks go, well, how would anarchism work? I'm like, that. Yeah. Like that. You know, basically that. Like, it worked far better for those of us on the ground than the pittance in, like, resources and aid for a long time that we were getting from local, state, and federal governments. Yeah. Yeah. And, you know, and this is not to be like too much to just send it to like, you know, quote unquote prepper territory, but preparation is highly important. I encourage folks who are like, think about where your water comes from. Think about where your food comes from. Think about putting some reserves of that aside. Unlike certain governments, you should probably have in like different locations among different folks because some folks get cut off by like fallen trees or whatever. Wherever you are, I guarantee there is some form of a Helene-like disaster you're probably going to face at some point. Yeah. And it's good to start thinking of what that is, preparing for it with some folks you trust now. And a little bit of that can go a very long way. And this has real practical impacts. When Asheville was faced with some torrential rains recently, which brings a lot of trauma for a bunch of us. Yeah. But I realized other than like charging a few backup batteries and, you know, stuff for devices, I didn't really have to do anything. Yeah, I actually had it already. I already had the preparation stuff in place. So I just focused like checking on some of my neighbors and helping folks out, which was a really good feeling. And that was like a legacy of the organizing after Helene. Yeah. I think like, you know, like one of the fundamental conflicts here, other than just sort of the general class war that's been happening in Helene is like, Which of these two visions of a post-disaster society is going to take root? Is it going to be the one where the shock doctrine sends cops with riot batons and crowd control munitions to
just beat the shit out of people? Or is it going to be the one where you bring your people food? Yeah. And honestly, this is why I keep coming back to We Are Two Cities. Which one do you want? Yeah. Eventually, it's going to be one or the other. And that doesn't just apply in Ashford. Yeah, that is the stark choice of the world that is to come. Indeed. I kind of feel like this should be a dispatch from a place where it already happened to some degree. Yeah, yeah. But also, like it shows that there's a world after that, too, that it's not all hopeless. Yeah. And interestingly, like recently, though there's still trying to up the Axon contract, City Hall went back against the wishes of the police department and canceled the Flock contract. Now, they still want to keep a door open to resume it. There's a lot of weasel stuff on it. But they didn't want to do that themselves. Yeah, they're scared. They only did it because they were terrified of how many people are getting mobilized. Yeah. Often through networks that got kind of cemented during Helene. They'd be just getting to know each other against the surveillance state in Asheville because, like, Flock cameras were starting to get vandalized. Yeah, yeah. And so even despite their intense evil, they're still weak. They're still vulnerable. And if that's what they concede to what we're going right now, like what would happen if that escalated even further? If the public outrage and mobilization escalated even more on even more fronts? Yeah. So, yeah. Well, David, thank you. Thank you so much for coming on the show and talking about this. Do you have anything else that you want to say before we go to plugs? You know, prepare. Prepare. get to know some people around you. I think people should realize that they're stronger than they know. Yeah. What are the many places people can find your great work? So they can find the work of the Asheville Blade, which is our local journalism co-op at ashevilleblade.com and some of our shorter quick hit coverage at patreon.com slash avlblade. If they want to read me ranting in similar veins about and a lot of other great trans journalists as well, about kind of training specific stuff on a national, even international level, trans news network at trans news.network. So yeah, all that. And I do think it's somewhat inspiring. There are like more on the ground co-op media. Um, and a lot of us being done by trans people. So hell yeah. Yeah. And you too can support trans journalism. You can become a trans journalist. It's never too late. For either part, whether you want to become a journalist or transition, you know? Yeah. If you're asking the question, the answer is yes. Yes. Yes.
00:54:45
Speaker 2: It Could Happen Here is a production of Cool Zone Media. For more podcasts from Cool Zone Media, visit our website, coolzonemedia.com, or check us out on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you listen to podcasts. You can now find sources for It Could Happen Here listed directly in episode descriptions.
00:55:02
Speaker 1: Thanks for listening.