TRASCRIZIONE 🔗
WEBVTT
1
00:00:01.490 --> 00:00:02.750
Full trial audio.
2
00:00:03.209 --> 00:00:06.049
Everything heard in court. No silences to skip.
3
00:00:06.230 --> 00:00:06.830
Thank you, Judge.
4
00:00:07.049 --> 00:00:07.330
All right.
5
00:00:07.370 --> 00:00:10.490
He did put gave us the thumbs up signal.
6
00:00:12.759 --> 00:00:21.620
We're here today to address the state's request for additional restitution.
7
00:00:23.019 --> 00:00:26.960
That letter was filed back on November 30th of twenty
8
00:00:27.039 --> 00:00:31.820
twenty two. The court had given Mr. Brooks until January
9
00:00:31.820 --> 00:00:38.600
3 to file an objection, and a response was filed
10
00:00:38.619 --> 00:00:40.859
that the court interpreted.
11
00:00:40.460 --> 00:00:42.060
As an objection.
12
00:00:42.119 --> 00:00:47.039
Since that time, Attorney Covey has been appointed to represent Mr.
13
00:00:47.079 --> 00:00:52.189
Brooks in the appellate process, but you are appearing here today,
14
00:00:52.229 --> 00:00:57.009
and we are thankful for that. And so the matter
15
00:00:57.030 --> 00:01:01.170
was put on, obviously it's outside some of the time limits,
16
00:01:01.210 --> 00:01:04.489
but I would note the original request was made timely,
17
00:01:05.129 --> 00:01:10.290
and frankly it was due to the court's calendar. Originally
18
00:01:10.310 --> 00:01:13.569
I had been scheduled to be in a five-week trial
19
00:01:14.129 --> 00:01:20.200
starting February 13th, and then that was delayed by two weeks,
20
00:01:20.260 --> 00:01:24.000
and ultimately that trial was adjourned, and so that was
21
00:01:24.120 --> 00:01:26.760
the reason for the hearing.
22
00:01:26.500 --> 00:01:27.959
Being scheduled on.
23
00:01:30.239 --> 00:01:35.079
Today's date so for now I don't anticipate your client
24
00:01:35.120 --> 00:01:37.689
having to talk I can just hear backgrounds I'm just
25
00:01:37.709 --> 00:01:39.329
going to mute it and if we need to talk
26
00:01:39.370 --> 00:01:41.909
to him we'll unmute there'll be a 30 second delay
27
00:01:41.969 --> 00:01:46.109
unless he has the device there but to unmute but
28
00:01:46.209 --> 00:01:50.840
in any event I think I've accurately stated kind of
29
00:01:50.859 --> 00:01:59.840
the timing of the requests Because I understand the additional
30
00:01:59.920 --> 00:02:05.280
paperwork that was filed as recently as April 12th, and
31
00:02:05.299 --> 00:02:06.859
I trust you've seen that, Attorney Covey?
32
00:02:07.260 --> 00:02:08.259
Judge, yes.
33
00:02:08.539 --> 00:02:12.750
I did see, I think you're talking about document 566?
34
00:02:12.750 --> 00:02:12.949
Yes.
35
00:02:13.590 --> 00:02:14.569
I have that right in my hand.
36
00:02:15.289 --> 00:02:15.569
All right.
37
00:02:15.729 --> 00:02:18.189
And so does the state have a grand total for
38
00:02:18.229 --> 00:02:20.110
additional restitution the state is seeking?
39
00:02:21.590 --> 00:02:26.030
So to be clear, Your Honor, on the... document, that's
40
00:02:26.110 --> 00:02:28.620
one that's titled, well, first thing.
41
00:02:28.590 --> 00:02:30.819
Is crime victim compensation. Okay, thank you. Yes, I just
42
00:02:30.840 --> 00:02:34.060
couldn't tell if that, I didn't do the math, if.
43
00:02:34.020 --> 00:02:37.560
That's... I wanted to be clear on that. So, at
44
00:02:37.580 --> 00:02:42.069
the bottom it notes you've already ordered some of 124, 220.65
45
00:02:42.069 --> 00:02:45.229
to crime victim compensation.
46
00:02:46.509 --> 00:02:46.669
Yes.
47
00:02:46.689 --> 00:02:52.990
The grand total that's listed at the top of 134, 466.85
48
00:02:53.520 --> 00:02:57.099
encompasses that 124. So this is not in addition.
49
00:02:56.659 --> 00:02:58.060
To, okay.
50
00:02:58.599 --> 00:03:02.590
So our request for, uh, crime victim compensation is one 34,
51
00:03:02.590 --> 00:03:10.710
four 66.85 for, uh, Wilburn associates or Hartford insurance.
52
00:03:11.509 --> 00:03:12.460
Total request is 108,000, $ 164.
53
00:03:12.330 --> 00:03:12.400
61.
54
00:03:12.389 --> 00:03:24.110
Optum subrogation, $ 118, eight, $ 105. 62. Progressive insurance, $ 10, 000 for victim GGG.
55
00:03:24.270 --> 00:03:27.150
And progressive insurance, $ 104, 662.
56
00:03:27.000 --> 00:03:27.439
64 for victim Q.
57
00:03:27.409 --> 00:03:31.000
All right, and I believe your letter of November 29
58
00:03:31.000 --> 00:03:34.139
indicates the additional amounts that you're seeking.
59
00:03:50.229 --> 00:03:52.409
And then this document really totals things up.
60
00:03:53.090 --> 00:03:56.289
Yes, it does. And at the bottom, already ordered the
61
00:03:56.409 --> 00:03:58.879
EMC insurance for Waukesha School District.
62
00:03:58.919 --> 00:04:03.099
That was already ordered, and there's no update to that number.
63
00:04:03.139 --> 00:04:04.659
So that number can remain as fixed.
64
00:04:06.020 --> 00:04:10.520
I'm just going to do a quick calculation to determine
65
00:04:10.539 --> 00:04:17.100
the additional amount to crime victim compensation the state is seeking.
66
00:04:19.269 --> 00:04:25.670
Looks like that's $ 10, 246.
67
00:04:20.750 --> 00:04:25.050
20. I'm sorry, can you.
68
00:04:27.389 --> 00:04:27.970
Repeat that number?
69
00:04:29.269 --> 00:04:30.069
Assuming I hit.
70
00:04:29.949 --> 00:04:33.639
The keys on my calculator correctly, it's the difference between
71
00:04:33.660 --> 00:04:38.620
the $ 134 minus the $ 124, and that's $ 10, 246.
72
00:04:34.779 --> 00:04:37.279
20. Yes, we agree with that. All right, and then
73
00:04:37.300 --> 00:04:39.759
the additional other amounts to other.
74
00:04:51.310 --> 00:04:55.709
Individuals, namely insurance companies, are really those four amounts that
75
00:04:55.750 --> 00:05:00.860
are listed near the bottom of this document to Hartford Insurance,
76
00:05:01.620 --> 00:05:04.860
the Optum, and Progressive for two different victims.
77
00:05:05.259 --> 00:05:05.879
Yes, correct.
78
00:05:06.319 --> 00:05:06.540
All right.
79
Load full transcript
00:05:06.680 --> 00:05:10.230
Is that your understanding of what was being requested, Attorney Covey?
80
00:05:10.490 --> 00:05:12.750
Judge, it clarifies things. I had thought that the state
81
00:05:12.769 --> 00:05:15.290
was asking for an additional, the full $ 134, 466. 85 in addition
82
00:05:15.310 --> 00:05:26.170
to the $ 124, 000. My number, original number, I thought was
83
00:05:26.370 --> 00:05:30.029
just north of 476,000, but it seems like it's closer
84
00:05:30.110 --> 00:05:32.870
to about 350,000, give or take.
85
00:05:33.370 --> 00:05:35.670
I'm using round numbers because I don't have a calculator
86
00:05:35.689 --> 00:05:35.970
with me.
87
00:05:36.350 --> 00:05:36.750
Understood.
88
00:05:37.589 --> 00:05:41.329
It's my understanding from the document that you filed on
89
00:05:41.379 --> 00:05:42.439
behalf of Mr.
90
00:05:42.480 --> 00:05:44.480
Brooks that Mr.
91
00:05:44.500 --> 00:05:48.939
Brooks is not contesting the loss that was suffered, but
92
00:05:49.379 --> 00:05:50.939
rather his ability to pay.
93
00:05:52.009 --> 00:05:53.069
Judge, that is correct.
94
00:05:53.170 --> 00:05:56.069
I'm not asking for, at least for anything to date,
95
00:05:56.689 --> 00:05:59.829
anybody to present extra documentation as to the accuracy of
96
00:05:59.870 --> 00:06:03.709
these numbers. It's just on his earning ability and lack
97
00:06:03.769 --> 00:06:04.240
of funds.
98
00:06:06.800 --> 00:06:10.079
And was that the state's understanding as well? Yes. I
99
00:06:10.139 --> 00:06:11.500
know in the filing.
100
00:06:11.480 --> 00:06:15.339
From Attorney Covey, I don't recall if it was the
101
00:06:15.379 --> 00:06:19.000
letter or the actual motion to deny.
102
00:06:20.699 --> 00:06:23.759
There is a claim that Mr. Brooks is indigent based
103
00:06:23.819 --> 00:06:26.509
upon his incarceration. Is the state going to take any
104
00:06:26.589 --> 00:06:27.230
issue with that?
105
00:06:27.709 --> 00:06:30.490
We're agreeing to that fact, Your Honor.
106
00:06:30.529 --> 00:06:36.620
We've reached a stipulation with Attorney Covey that recognizes Mr. Brooks,
107
00:06:36.779 --> 00:06:39.759
to our knowledge, is indigent at this time and that
108
00:06:40.300 --> 00:06:43.240
his future earning capacity would be limited to prison wages.
109
00:06:45.629 --> 00:06:47.949
And that's an agreeable stipulation to the defense?
110
00:06:48.329 --> 00:06:51.680
Judge, we reached that agreement yesterday. Absolutely, I suggested it.
111
00:06:55.480 --> 00:06:57.800
I don't want to be presumptuous, but I know the
112
00:06:57.839 --> 00:07:01.100
last time the court addressed restitution, the state was requesting
113
00:07:02.920 --> 00:07:08.500
really an order related to an escrow account. Should there
114
00:07:08.560 --> 00:07:13.160
be future payouts or earnings by Mr. Brooks, will you
115
00:07:13.180 --> 00:07:14.180
be making the same request?
116
00:07:14.730 --> 00:07:17.790
Yes, and I noted that is in the original
judgment
117
00:07:17.810 --> 00:07:20.930
of conviction that was filed by the court on November
118
00:07:21.209 --> 00:07:25.069
17th of 2022. You had made that order and that
119
00:07:25.149 --> 00:07:28.310
finding at the time of sentencing, and you had also
120
00:07:28.990 --> 00:07:34.860
indicated restitution costs and surcharges and fees to be collected
121
00:07:34.920 --> 00:07:38.980
from prison monies pursuant to statutory authority. And so we're
122
00:07:39.000 --> 00:07:40.660
going to ask both of those.
123
00:07:42.019 --> 00:07:45.750
Orders remain in place. Will your client have any objection
124
00:07:45.790 --> 00:07:46.069
to that?
125
00:07:47.209 --> 00:07:50.129
If there's additional restitution, I don't object to the escrow account.
126
00:07:53.290 --> 00:07:55.689
That would be for monies paid to Mr.
127
00:07:55.740 --> 00:08:01.839
Brooks, not a restitution, not an escrow account beyond that.
128
00:08:03.180 --> 00:08:04.199
Under 949.165.
129
00:08:04.199 --> 00:08:08.750
I'm sorry, counsel, if I may, just for one second.
130
00:08:10.050 --> 00:08:10.430
Oh, yeah.
131
00:08:19.269 --> 00:08:23.589
Judge, counsel explained to me briefly what she was getting at.
132
00:08:23.750 --> 00:08:25.009
I don't have any objection to that.
133
00:08:25.040 --> 00:08:25.720
All right.
134
00:08:27.560 --> 00:08:30.339
Then it seems to me there's really just legal arguments
135
00:08:30.399 --> 00:08:33.080
as to whether I should order the additional restitution.
136
00:08:34.080 --> 00:08:35.340
Yes, Judge.
137
00:08:35.379 --> 00:08:40.320
The stipulation then would put us in a position where Mr.
138
00:08:40.340 --> 00:08:43.019
Brooks does not need to testify. That's my understanding, and
139
00:08:43.159 --> 00:08:45.039
that would be how I would proceed. Anyone see that
140
00:08:45.100 --> 00:08:45.620
any differently?
141
00:08:45.659 --> 00:08:46.200
Attorney Opper?
142
00:08:46.840 --> 00:08:47.259
We do not.
143
00:08:47.779 --> 00:08:50.279
Judge, that was the reason why I suggested the stipulation.
144
00:08:51.029 --> 00:08:51.230
All right.
145
00:08:51.409 --> 00:08:51.750
Thank you.
146
00:08:52.710 --> 00:08:58.389
Then, since it is the state's request for additional restitution,
147
00:08:58.549 --> 00:08:59.330
I'll hear from the state.
148
00:09:00.419 --> 00:09:03.179
Thank you, Judge. Your Honor, we are asking this court
149
00:09:03.240 --> 00:09:07.659
to order restitution in the full amount as proposed in
150
00:09:07.700 --> 00:09:09.019
the document we filed yesterday.
151
00:09:09.039 --> 00:09:09.750
I think you said it was 566?
152
00:09:09.750 --> 00:09:10.210
Yes.
153
00:09:12.259 --> 00:09:12.590
Thank you.
154
00:09:12.750 --> 00:09:13.159
I'm sorry.
155
00:09:13.210 --> 00:09:14.710
I just don't know the document number.
156
00:09:15.610 --> 00:09:19.330
Yes, it is document number 566.
157
00:09:19.330 --> 00:09:22.929
Judge, we certainly understand ability to pay as one of
158
00:09:22.990 --> 00:09:26.049
the factors that the court is to consider here, but
159
00:09:26.710 --> 00:09:29.789
we'd like to highlight a couple of things. First of all,
160
00:09:30.539 --> 00:09:34.110
One of the goals of restitution is to rehabilitate the defendant.
161
00:09:34.549 --> 00:09:37.009
We think that is an important goal in this case,
162
00:09:37.149 --> 00:09:41.809
noting the damage that was inflicted by this defendant to
163
00:09:42.070 --> 00:09:47.950
multiple victims. We would note that most of the monies,
164
00:09:49.230 --> 00:09:51.230
or at least a majority of the monies, came from
165
00:09:51.250 --> 00:09:58.750
the Crime Victim Compensation Fund, which really is funded by taxpayers.
166
00:09:58.809 --> 00:09:59.529
It's a state fund.
167
00:10:00.039 --> 00:10:00.340
Fund.
168
00:10:02.980 --> 00:10:06.200
I'm glad to see on this list there's no individual victims.
169
00:10:07.649 --> 00:10:10.840
the desire for the public to have those monies repaid
170
00:10:10.899 --> 00:10:14.779
to the, um, CVC if appropriate. Um, as far as
171
00:10:14.799 --> 00:10:17.500
the insurance companies, uh, the same, your honor, while I
172
00:10:17.559 --> 00:10:23.070
understand they operate as a for-profit business, um, these were substantial, um,
173
00:10:23.629 --> 00:10:27.370
expenses that they, uh, had to cover for their insured,
174
00:10:27.470 --> 00:10:31.409
for their clients and, um, a direct result of the
175
00:10:31.429 --> 00:10:36.549
defendant's conduct in the, um, significant injuries that several of
176
00:10:36.620 --> 00:10:40.740
these victims suffered as a result of Mr.
177
00:10:40.779 --> 00:10:42.259
Brooks' behavior.
178
00:10:42.440 --> 00:10:46.019
So we do believe that it's both fair and appropriate
179
00:10:46.039 --> 00:10:50.139
for the court to order the whole amount, notwithstanding.
180
00:10:50.720 --> 00:10:51.659
That limitation.
181
00:10:52.360 --> 00:10:56.259
The reality is that perhaps this will never be achieved
182
00:10:56.340 --> 00:10:59.970
by Mr. Brooks in his lifetime on prison wages, but
183
00:11:00.009 --> 00:11:04.509
it would serve a rehabilitative purpose. purpose because should he
184
00:11:04.649 --> 00:11:09.929
ever receive employment within the prison system and a wage,
185
00:11:10.120 --> 00:11:14.320
albeit minimum, it would be a reminder to him and
186
00:11:14.460 --> 00:11:20.139
aid in his rehabilitation that for whatever monies he earns
187
00:11:20.179 --> 00:11:23.200
in the prison, a portion of it does go back
188
00:11:23.240 --> 00:11:28.649
to the crime victim compensation fund and The other thing is,
189
00:11:28.690 --> 00:11:31.950
Your Honor, of course, we don't know if an escrow
190
00:11:31.990 --> 00:11:36.330
account would ever be needed under 949.165, but I think
191
00:11:36.370 --> 00:11:40.370
we can make a reasonable observation here that there is
192
00:11:40.590 --> 00:11:43.250
potential for Mr.
193
00:11:43.289 --> 00:11:44.230
Brooks to.
194
00:11:45.649 --> 00:11:49.990
Obtain money in the form of payments to sell his story,
195
00:11:50.070 --> 00:11:54.000
to engage in a book deal or a movie offer
196
00:11:54.009 --> 00:11:57.750
or whatever it is. We know that this case garnered
197
00:11:57.919 --> 00:12:02.570
international attention. It's not beyond the realm of possibility that
198
00:12:02.669 --> 00:12:06.929
someone may at some point offer him some funds or
199
00:12:06.990 --> 00:12:10.779
some sum of money to share his perspective on this case.
200
00:12:11.480 --> 00:12:17.440
And so I would hate for this court to, you know,
201
00:12:17.480 --> 00:12:19.679
set $ 100, 000 today and then tomorrow he gets a half
202
00:12:19.720 --> 00:12:23.049
a million dollar book deal. That would be offensive, I think,
203
00:12:23.129 --> 00:12:27.470
and and go beyond the scope and the purpose of restitution.
204
00:12:27.570 --> 00:12:32.330
So for that reason, Your Honor, even noting his current
205
00:12:32.590 --> 00:12:36.250
limited ability to pay, we feel it's appropriate that you
206
00:12:36.350 --> 00:12:39.389
order the full amount as requested. Thank you.
207
00:12:39.669 --> 00:12:40.549
Before I turn.
208
00:12:40.370 --> 00:12:43.909
To the defense, I don't want to make any assumptions,
209
00:12:44.029 --> 00:12:51.460
but it's my recollection, probably during the maybe even during
210
00:12:51.500 --> 00:12:54.860
some of the witnesses or even during maybe discussion related
211
00:12:54.899 --> 00:13:00.029
to jury selection, obviously the community had set up a
212
00:13:00.110 --> 00:13:06.370
fund for victims to seek reimbursement. It's my understanding that
213
00:13:07.009 --> 00:13:11.539
this restitution amount that's being requested would be larger, I
214
00:13:11.600 --> 00:13:14.840
don't know if it would be substantially larger, if all
215
00:13:15.200 --> 00:13:17.419
losses were being requested by the state.
216
00:13:17.950 --> 00:13:20.149
That's an accurate statement, Your Honor, and I think it's
217
00:13:20.710 --> 00:13:23.730
very fair to say it would have been substantially larger
218
00:13:23.840 --> 00:13:27.259
if it not had been for the generosity of individuals
219
00:13:27.299 --> 00:13:28.639
who contributed to those funds.
220
00:13:28.899 --> 00:13:31.600
As I recall, were there millions in that fund at
221
00:13:31.679 --> 00:13:32.080
one point?
222
00:13:32.279 --> 00:13:33.840
I believe that's accurate, yes.
223
00:13:33.860 --> 00:13:35.860
I've confirmed that. All right.
224
00:13:36.039 --> 00:13:38.480
And then I'd also heard, but I don't know if
225
00:13:38.779 --> 00:13:40.139
there's any truth to this, but.
226
00:13:42.820 --> 00:13:46.340
That at one point Mr. Brooks himself may have demanded
227
00:13:46.480 --> 00:13:53.519
payment to talk to a news organization or some media outlet. Again,
228
00:13:53.539 --> 00:13:55.870
I don't want to make assumptions, but I had heard
229
00:13:55.909 --> 00:13:56.610
that at one point.
230
00:13:58.610 --> 00:14:02.830
Attorney Wachow and I are, I've heard that as well,
231
00:14:02.850 --> 00:14:04.169
but I can't confirm that with.
232
00:14:04.090 --> 00:14:06.590
Any certainty, Your Honor. All right, thank you. Then turning
233
00:14:06.629 --> 00:14:07.450
to you, Attorney Covey.
234
00:14:07.470 --> 00:14:08.269
Thank you, Judge.
235
00:14:10.460 --> 00:14:12.659
Although I'm relatively new to the case, I can state
236
00:14:13.440 --> 00:14:16.259
just from my review of the file so far, I
237
00:14:16.299 --> 00:14:19.879
haven't heard anything at all about anybody offering any kind
238
00:14:19.919 --> 00:14:21.980
of book deal or any kind of sums of money
239
00:14:22.419 --> 00:14:23.320
in any way, shape, or.
240
00:14:23.299 --> 00:14:24.740
Form to Mr. Brooks.
241
00:14:24.759 --> 00:14:32.649
I think it's... The odds of Hollywood knocking down his
242
00:14:32.730 --> 00:14:35.570
door to give him lots of money for his life story,
243
00:14:35.909 --> 00:14:38.500
I think given the totality of the circumstances of this case,
244
00:14:39.129 --> 00:14:42.360
I just think are so minuscule that I don't think
245
00:14:42.419 --> 00:14:45.600
that argument should be given much weight. I also couldn't
246
00:14:45.679 --> 00:14:49.240
imagine any of the media, whether it's a YouTube blogger
247
00:14:49.259 --> 00:14:51.620
or the people that are next door to this courtroom,
248
00:14:52.259 --> 00:14:56.080
offering Mr. Brooks any money for some kind of exclusive interview.
249
00:14:57.179 --> 00:14:58.279
I can't read. I cannot understand.
250
00:14:59.279 --> 00:15:02.340
Foresee the future with a thousand percent certainty, but I
251
00:15:02.360 --> 00:15:03.740
think the odds of that, again, are.
252
00:15:03.659 --> 00:15:06.929
Just exceptionally low. I appreciate the fact, Judge, that the
253
00:15:06.970 --> 00:15:09.250
state's stipulating that he's indigent.
254
00:15:11.389 --> 00:15:16.120
I think counsel mentioned minimum, and I just want to
255
00:15:16.139 --> 00:15:18.580
make sure that the court recognizes that we're not talking
256
00:15:18.639 --> 00:15:19.860
minimum wage as a.
257
00:15:19.840 --> 00:15:21.940
Legal $ 17, $ 18, $ 19 an hour for prison work.
258
00:15:26.129 --> 00:15:28.289
If he's offered work in any of the facilities that
259
00:15:28.330 --> 00:15:30.929
he's going to be serving time in, at best he'll
260
00:15:30.950 --> 00:15:33.950
be getting perhaps a few dimes an hour for janitorial
261
00:15:33.990 --> 00:15:38.500
work or cleaning up the kitchen. The type of wages
262
00:15:38.580 --> 00:15:42.759
that are earned by inmates in our correctional system, they're
263
00:15:42.779 --> 00:15:46.259
not used to save up lots of money. They're used
264
00:15:46.279 --> 00:15:49.659
to sometimes save up to buy a bag of Doritos
265
00:15:50.240 --> 00:15:55.789
or some deodorant or toiletries. That's essentially his earning capacity
266
00:15:56.669 --> 00:16:00.669
if they let him work perhaps a dollar or two
267
00:16:00.730 --> 00:16:02.570
a day if he works the entire day.
268
00:16:03.840 --> 00:16:06.820
So that's the reality of what he's facing.
269
00:16:08.360 --> 00:16:11.600
Judge, counsel touched on this, and I appreciate her argument.
270
00:16:13.179 --> 00:16:14.340
Frankly, whether you order.
271
00:16:14.179 --> 00:16:20.720
$ 50, 000 or $ 500, 000 or $ 5 million, it's very unlikely that Mr.
272
00:16:20.759 --> 00:16:23.450
Brooks would be able to pay even the smallest fraction
273
00:16:23.470 --> 00:16:28.070
of that. But this hearing still matters. This is not
274
00:16:28.190 --> 00:16:31.470
just a moot point or a moot exercise, because you
275
00:16:31.509 --> 00:16:36.450
do have the duty, Judge, to balance five sometimes competing
276
00:16:36.509 --> 00:16:41.190
factors as listed in Wisconsin Statute 973.2013.
277
00:16:41.190 --> 00:16:44.070
I mentioned it in.
278
00:16:44.070 --> 00:16:47.600
My motion, and then, of course, the fifth factor was
279
00:16:48.529 --> 00:16:50.970
I sent a letter to the court about that yesterday.
280
00:16:50.990 --> 00:16:54.830
The five factors are the amounts of loss suffered by
281
00:16:54.889 --> 00:16:58.879
any victim as a result of the crime considered at sentencing, two,
282
00:16:59.580 --> 00:17:04.579
financial resources of the defendant, three, the present and future
283
00:17:04.779 --> 00:17:09.140
earning ability of the defendant, four, the needs and earning
284
00:17:09.180 --> 00:17:13.789
ability of the defendant's dependents, and five, any other factor
285
00:17:13.809 --> 00:17:16.190
which the court deems appropriate.
286
00:17:16.210 --> 00:17:17.109
All right.
287
00:17:17.910 --> 00:17:19.690
Judge, I'll go just a little bit out of order.
288
00:17:20.470 --> 00:17:26.450
On subsection 4, regarding Mr. Brooks' dependence, recognizing that he's
289
00:17:26.799 --> 00:17:32.220
currently serving multiple life sentences consecutive, realistically, he's not going
290
00:17:32.240 --> 00:17:35.039
to be able to support his dependence anyways. And so
291
00:17:35.079 --> 00:17:37.180
that factor isn't really on point for this hearing.
292
00:17:39.289 --> 00:17:40.440
On the first....
293
00:17:42.470 --> 00:17:45.579
Criteria, the amount of loss suffered from the victims, I'm
294
00:17:45.619 --> 00:17:48.680
not surprised that the totality could be in the millions
295
00:17:48.700 --> 00:17:52.279
of dollars. I'm sure it's an absolutely enormous amount. And
296
00:17:52.319 --> 00:17:55.079
you have that discretion to give that factor great weight.
297
00:17:55.640 --> 00:17:56.339
I concede that.
298
00:17:57.380 --> 00:17:59.400
But I also hope that you consider the next two
299
00:17:59.460 --> 00:18:01.039
factors as well, and.
300
00:18:00.980 --> 00:18:04.329
They kind of go together. His earning ability and his
301
00:18:04.410 --> 00:18:08.289
current financial resources. I hope that gets great weight as well.
302
00:18:09.490 --> 00:18:13.710
He's had significant financial problems even before this case. I
303
00:18:13.769 --> 00:18:17.849
believe he qualified for a public defender from day one.
304
00:18:19.069 --> 00:18:21.289
If he were to testify, he would testify that he
305
00:18:21.309 --> 00:18:24.710
had no savings, no assets. He doesn't have any kind
306
00:18:24.730 --> 00:18:27.680
of inheritance coming down his way. Nobody owes him any
307
00:18:27.740 --> 00:18:31.500
kind of money. I don't think anybody would dispute those facts.
308
00:18:33.000 --> 00:18:37.660
If you add on another half million or $ 350, 000 to
309
00:18:39.440 --> 00:18:46.240
what he's already been ordered to pay, which is in excess.
310
00:18:44.470 --> 00:18:47.069
Of $ 171, 000.
311
00:18:45.509 --> 00:18:48.190
Then you are sending a message that the two factors,
312
00:18:48.789 --> 00:18:52.730
his poverty, his earnings ability, just don't matter, and I
313
00:18:52.769 --> 00:18:58.289
hope that they should be considered. Finally, Judge, subsection number
314
00:18:58.390 --> 00:19:01.920
five is the catch-all section, where you can consider any
315
00:19:01.960 --> 00:19:06.420
other factors which the court deems appropriate. I'm not sure
316
00:19:07.319 --> 00:19:12.250
if the amount of restitution in document 566 is the
317
00:19:12.289 --> 00:19:17.109
sum total of what might be requested in future restitution hearings.
318
00:19:17.910 --> 00:19:21.680
There is case law that states that a request could
319
00:19:21.700 --> 00:19:24.900
be made well past the 90 days after the sentencing hearing.
320
00:19:26.559 --> 00:19:28.859
We could object to it, but a lot of courts
321
00:19:28.880 --> 00:19:32.660
have upheld those. And I believe just for the sake
322
00:19:32.700 --> 00:19:36.480
of judicial efficiency, since he cannot pay anyways, since he
323
00:19:36.519 --> 00:19:40.400
really couldn't raise more than a couple of dollars a
324
00:19:40.500 --> 00:19:45.309
month anyways, is it worth the court system's resources? Our time,
325
00:19:46.089 --> 00:19:50.589
the court's time, the community's time to have potential... extra
326
00:19:50.809 --> 00:19:55.650
restitution hearings when the ability for him to pay anything
327
00:19:55.710 --> 00:19:57.509
is going to be minimal or nil.
328
00:19:58.670 --> 00:20:00.470
And, Judge, I guess one last thing.
329
00:20:00.490 --> 00:20:06.430
I would respectfully disagree that this is about rehabilitation, given
330
00:20:06.450 --> 00:20:08.400
the length of Mr.
331
00:20:08.440 --> 00:20:09.519
Brooks' sentence period.
332
00:20:10.440 --> 00:20:13.680
I think this is just more additional punishment, adding extra
333
00:20:13.720 --> 00:20:16.359
zeros to the judgment of conviction for money that he owes.
334
00:20:17.619 --> 00:20:20.359
I recognize the gravity of the harm, and.
335
00:20:20.289 --> 00:20:24.910
I mean no disrespect to anybody who suffered any injuries
336
00:20:25.349 --> 00:20:28.170
or the medical bills from this case. But given the
337
00:20:28.190 --> 00:20:32.130
totality of the circumstances, his multiple life sentences, I just
338
00:20:32.170 --> 00:20:35.210
don't think it makes sense to add on any additional restitution.
339
00:20:35.779 --> 00:20:38.799
It's just more paperwork, potentially extra hearings.
340
00:20:39.890 --> 00:20:45.910
For no really just purpose except to add extra numbers
341
00:20:45.970 --> 00:20:47.309
on the judgment of conviction.
342
00:20:47.930 --> 00:20:49.839
I'm happy to answer any questions you might have, Judge,
343
00:20:49.880 --> 00:20:50.359
and thank you.
344
00:20:50.380 --> 00:20:52.099
All right, thank you.
345
00:20:54.980 --> 00:20:57.799
First of all, I do want to thank the parties
346
00:20:57.880 --> 00:21:01.220
again for the stipulation. I think that certainly has made
347
00:21:01.259 --> 00:21:07.539
this hearing one that is running quite smoothly, but also...
348
00:21:08.410 --> 00:21:12.589
kept victims from having to testify, again, regarding the loss
349
00:21:12.650 --> 00:21:17.519
that they suffered, and even, frankly, the representatives from crime
350
00:21:17.539 --> 00:21:21.980
victim compensation or the insurance companies related to this. I
351
00:21:22.019 --> 00:21:27.730
also appreciate the stipulation from the state regarding the indigency issue.
352
00:21:28.369 --> 00:21:31.710
I think that's a testament to both counsel here and
353
00:21:31.750 --> 00:21:35.809
their willingness to look at this objectively and the purpose
354
00:21:35.829 --> 00:21:38.049
of this hearing and what the court needs to do.
355
00:21:39.230 --> 00:21:41.589
It is true that the court does need to consider
356
00:21:41.650 --> 00:21:50.630
the statutory criteria in 973.20. That's been referenced by Attorney
357
00:21:50.970 --> 00:21:54.990
Covey both orally here in court today and in his
358
00:21:55.339 --> 00:21:57.119
motion to deny restitution.
359
00:21:58.279 --> 00:22:01.579
There are five criteria, really, when you look at the statute.
360
00:22:01.619 --> 00:22:03.880
The amount of loss suffered by any victim as a
361
00:22:03.920 --> 00:22:07.990
result of a crime considered at sentencing. The financial resources
362
00:22:08.049 --> 00:22:11.589
of the defendant. The present and future earning ability of
363
00:22:11.630 --> 00:22:15.289
the defendant. The needs and earning ability of the defendant's dependents.
364
00:22:15.890 --> 00:22:19.359
And any other factors the court deems appropriate, really what
365
00:22:19.400 --> 00:22:25.000
we would call the catch-all. Obviously, this concerns a case
366
00:22:25.180 --> 00:22:30.660
where Mr. Brooks was convicted... of dozens and dozens of
367
00:22:31.380 --> 00:22:36.099
crimes based upon conduct stemming from him driving an SUV
368
00:22:36.119 --> 00:22:43.460
through the Waukesha Christmas Parade. There were 73 named victims,
369
00:22:44.000 --> 00:22:49.740
one of whom was the victim of the domestic abuse-related convictions,
370
00:22:50.839 --> 00:22:55.200
and then, of course, the six individuals accused who perished
371
00:22:55.299 --> 00:22:57.619
as a result of his conduct, and the 68 others
372
00:22:57.720 --> 00:23:03.279
who were injured. There are family members that are represented
373
00:23:03.319 --> 00:23:09.240
by each of those victims as well. This was and
374
00:23:09.299 --> 00:23:16.640
remains a very significant crime that has and will have
375
00:23:17.660 --> 00:23:20.519
lifelong effects for not just Mr.
376
00:23:20.559 --> 00:23:22.640
Brooks, not just these victims, but.
377
00:23:22.539 --> 00:23:28.160
The community as a whole and the losses that were
378
00:23:28.420 --> 00:23:34.319
suffered apart from the death and the injuries is only
379
00:23:34.339 --> 00:23:38.059
in part represented by the dollar figures that have been
380
00:23:38.200 --> 00:23:42.900
requested by the state on behalf of the victims. And
381
00:23:42.940 --> 00:23:46.799
that's what prompted my, or one of the questions to Attorney.
382
00:23:46.660 --> 00:23:50.539
Opper is that there was evidence.
383
00:23:50.690 --> 00:23:52.589
And I think perhaps, I don't know if it still
384
00:23:52.630 --> 00:23:54.549
has any money left in it, but we know that
385
00:23:54.589 --> 00:23:57.880
there was a fund set up by community members, really funded,
386
00:23:57.940 --> 00:24:01.700
I'm sure, if you were to look carefully, probably internationally,
387
00:24:01.779 --> 00:24:05.920
with millions of dollars that helped defray costs and the
388
00:24:06.059 --> 00:24:13.700
loss to many of the victims. There was testimony, whether
389
00:24:13.740 --> 00:24:16.789
during the trial or probably more at the sentencing, of
390
00:24:16.869 --> 00:24:22.259
individuals who did not have insurance and suffered out-of-pocket losses,
391
00:24:22.299 --> 00:24:27.190
and thankfully the community stepped up, crime victim compensation stepped up,
392
00:24:28.490 --> 00:24:32.809
but it would have been significantly more in terms of
393
00:24:32.869 --> 00:24:36.190
the dollar amounts that the state is seeking, but for
394
00:24:36.450 --> 00:24:41.859
that fund that had been created and used to help
395
00:24:41.920 --> 00:24:44.059
the victims of crime.
396
00:24:44.529 --> 00:24:45.930
Mr. Brooks's crimes.
397
00:24:46.009 --> 00:24:49.000
And so I think that's an important consideration for this
398
00:24:49.099 --> 00:24:55.180
court to consider. In addition to the type of loss
399
00:24:55.259 --> 00:24:58.299
that was suffered here, I mentioned this earlier, there was death,
400
00:24:58.740 --> 00:25:07.549
great bodily harm, certainly emotional and physical trauma. And because
401
00:25:07.609 --> 00:25:11.539
this involved a parade and Mr. Brooks driving through it,
402
00:25:11.549 --> 00:25:15.710
there's also that sense of security and safety in our
403
00:25:15.769 --> 00:25:19.230
community that he
robbed, not just the parade goers on
404
00:25:19.269 --> 00:25:22.849
that fateful day, but really the community, the state.
405
00:25:25.910 --> 00:25:27.930
I think anyone who's heard anything.
406
00:25:27.730 --> 00:25:31.410
About this case would feel a real sense of security
407
00:25:31.470 --> 00:25:33.829
that was stolen by Mr.
408
00:25:33.869 --> 00:25:34.210
Brooks.
409
00:25:34.829 --> 00:25:38.779
I do think the State's argument on rehabilitation is a
410
00:25:38.839 --> 00:25:43.380
solid argument. The bottom line is Mr. Brooks completely minimized
411
00:25:43.420 --> 00:25:48.420
his conduct both during the trial and at sentencing. And
412
00:25:48.440 --> 00:25:54.539
it is important, if only symbolic, that while he is
413
00:25:54.839 --> 00:25:57.519
in prison for the rest of his life, that whatever
414
00:25:57.680 --> 00:26:02.180
meager sums he might make with a prison wage, that
415
00:26:02.200 --> 00:26:07.930
there be a reminder to him why there is this
416
00:26:08.410 --> 00:26:13.130
deduction from his monies, that his ability to go to
417
00:26:13.150 --> 00:26:18.779
the canteen or to buy some extra item that's not
418
00:26:18.900 --> 00:26:23.279
otherwise provided by the prison, that there be that reminder
419
00:26:23.359 --> 00:26:26.849
to him that he doesn't have even the full access
420
00:26:26.880 --> 00:26:29.329
to whatever money is on his account.
421
00:26:29.369 --> 00:26:30.690
Now, I'd remind everyone that.
422
00:26:31.750 --> 00:26:37.450
law caps, what that deduction will be at 25%. I
423
00:26:37.490 --> 00:26:41.970
think that's a very clear recognition by our legislature of
424
00:26:42.009 --> 00:26:46.789
the balance that the system needs to have as it
425
00:26:46.829 --> 00:26:53.200
relates to prison monies. And I think that's an appropriate cap.
426
00:26:55.240 --> 00:26:58.259
I also think it's important that this court consider that
427
00:26:58.500 --> 00:27:03.609
the vast majority I shouldn't say vast majority, but a
428
00:27:03.650 --> 00:27:09.490
significant amount of the restitution is to crime victim compensation,
429
00:27:09.529 --> 00:27:13.720
which is a state fund, largely, if not all, funded
430
00:27:13.819 --> 00:27:15.839
by taxpayers.
431
00:27:16.140 --> 00:27:17.140
And even if there were.
432
00:27:17.039 --> 00:27:21.039
Some grants that are there from federal resources, which I
433
00:27:21.079 --> 00:27:24.819
imagine there might be, that's still taxpayer funded. And so
434
00:27:24.839 --> 00:27:28.809
I think that's another consideration for this court to look at.
435
00:27:29.710 --> 00:27:32.210
And consider. Now, I do have to balance. I'll look
436
00:27:32.250 --> 00:27:36.970
at all the criteria. Obviously, significant amount of loss.
437
00:27:38.049 --> 00:27:44.829
That's criteria reflected in sub-13 sub-A. Sub-13 sub-B, the financial
438
00:27:44.910 --> 00:27:48.619
resources of the defendant. Clearly, they are extremely limited at
439
00:27:48.680 --> 00:27:52.279
this time. However, there is absolutely no doubt in my
440
00:27:52.319 --> 00:27:54.980
mind that the possibility exists for Mr.
441
00:27:55.039 --> 00:27:57.119
Brooks at some point in the future to.
442
00:27:58.859 --> 00:28:04.289
Possibly profit from a book deal, a made-for-TV movie.
443
00:28:04.970 --> 00:28:08.509
A movie, whatever it may be.
444
00:28:08.609 --> 00:28:12.710
Maybe it's just doing an interview or whatever the case
445
00:28:12.769 --> 00:28:16.150
may be. I don't think that can be ruled out,
446
00:28:17.150 --> 00:28:20.740
even if he is obviously the person who was convicted
447
00:28:20.980 --> 00:28:21.480
of that.
448
00:28:21.859 --> 00:28:26.299
But there was international attention. This court.
449
00:28:27.519 --> 00:28:35.900
had Court TV in to stream the trial. This court
450
00:28:35.940 --> 00:28:40.089
has always streamed every hearing as it relates to this case,
451
00:28:40.200 --> 00:28:42.450
in part because of the number of victims, and I
452
00:28:45.529 --> 00:28:48.509
don't have a courtroom big enough in this county to
453
00:28:48.609 --> 00:28:52.990
hold all parties involved. Certainly during the trial, this courtroom
454
00:28:53.029 --> 00:28:59.630
was packed on a daily basis. and to say that
455
00:28:59.690 --> 00:29:02.809
the trial went viral I think would be an understatement.
456
00:29:02.869 --> 00:29:06.490
And so all of that relates to, though, that catch-all
457
00:29:06.630 --> 00:29:11.460
factor and the possibility that Mr. Brooks could come into
458
00:29:11.680 --> 00:29:14.339
a sum of money at a later point in time
459
00:29:15.180 --> 00:29:20.059
because of the story that he could provide or tell.
460
00:29:19.920 --> 00:29:21.220
On his own behalf.
461
00:29:22.039 --> 00:29:26.039
You need only look at Netflix to know that Crime
462
00:29:26.380 --> 00:29:33.569
stories are incredibly, they're things people want to watch. People
463
00:29:33.630 --> 00:29:37.289
find them interesting. People want to know the why. They
464
00:29:37.329 --> 00:29:40.890
want to know the how. And it's certainly not just
465
00:29:40.950 --> 00:29:43.410
this case, but we've seen it, and not that that's
466
00:29:43.470 --> 00:29:46.119
been on Netflix or anything, but other cases have captured
467
00:29:46.130 --> 00:29:50.339
the attention. So I don't think it's beyond the, you know,
468
00:29:50.660 --> 00:29:52.259
it's not an impossibility, let's say.
469
00:29:52.299 --> 00:29:55.099
It's, I think, a very real possibility.
470
00:29:54.339 --> 00:29:59.539
That someone might, you know, produce something someday for more
471
00:29:59.799 --> 00:30:04.910
of a commercial or theatrical type purpose, even if it's
472
00:30:05.430 --> 00:30:09.170
a true crime type situation and that it's possible that Mr.
473
00:30:09.210 --> 00:30:10.490
Brooks could profit from that.
474
00:30:10.549 --> 00:30:13.849
And that certainly is why at the time of sentencing,
475
00:30:13.910 --> 00:30:20.950
the court, um, addressed the request by the state, um, to, to, uh,
476
00:30:21.049 --> 00:30:23.089
related to the escrow account.
477
00:30:23.150 --> 00:30:25.390
I think that's important to do that here.
478
00:30:26.210 --> 00:30:29.000
Um, And so when I balance all of these things,
479
00:30:29.039 --> 00:30:31.000
when I consider the significant amount of.
480
00:30:31.000 --> 00:30:34.579
The loss, the court's desire to hold Mr.
481
00:30:34.980 --> 00:30:38.990
Brooks accountable, and even if it's a small reminder with
482
00:30:39.049 --> 00:30:44.170
his prison monies, that does serve a very important rehabilitative role,
483
00:30:44.210 --> 00:30:48.819
because even though he's serving successive life sentences, we all
484
00:30:48.880 --> 00:30:51.779
hope that one day he truly is able to accept
485
00:30:51.839 --> 00:30:57.390
justice full responsibility for what he has done, not minimize
486
00:30:57.470 --> 00:31:05.210
his conduct, and so that this award of restitution in full,
487
00:31:05.380 --> 00:31:09.759
as the state has requested, is important. And I will
488
00:31:09.839 --> 00:31:13.180
grant the additional amounts, as I indicated earlier.
489
00:31:13.200 --> 00:31:14.259
It's $ 10, 246. 20 to Crime Victim Compensation.
490
00:31:21.819 --> 00:31:25.460
That total then to them for the judgment of conviction
491
00:31:25.519 --> 00:31:25.740
is $ 134, 466.
492
00:31:25.579 --> 00:31:27.900
85. Then to Wilbur and Associates, which is Hartford Insurance, $ 108, 164. 61.
493
00:31:27.720 --> 00:31:34.240
Optum Subrogation, $ 118, 805.
494
00:31:28.240 --> 00:31:30.240
62.
495
00:31:50.660 --> 00:31:55.670
And then progressive insurance for victim GGG, $ 10, 000, and progressive
496
00:31:55.750 --> 00:31:58.150
insurance for victim Q, $ 104, 662.
497
00:31:56.769 --> 00:31:57.230
64.
498
00:31:57.230 --> 00:32:00.309
That is, of course, on top of what the court
499
00:32:00.329 --> 00:32:02.230
had already ordered to EMC insurance of.
500
00:32:01.930 --> 00:32:02.089
$ 47, 193.
501
00:32:01.930 --> 00:32:01.990
29.
502
00:32:01.970 --> 00:32:04.190
So again, I'll grant the request of the state. We'll
503
00:32:04.210 --> 00:32:05.440
also include that it be....
504
00:32:20.559 --> 00:32:26.910
It be payable out of any prison monies per state statute, and.
505
00:32:28.950 --> 00:32:34.069
The court under.
506
00:32:31.809 --> 00:32:38.000
949.165 makes the additional amounts of restitution ordered today subject
507
00:32:38.059 --> 00:32:38.440
to the.
508
00:32:38.460 --> 00:32:43.990
Escrow account under that statute. Anything the state thinks I've
509
00:32:44.049 --> 00:32:45.450
overlooked as it relates to this?
510
00:32:46.230 --> 00:32:46.650
No, Your Honor.
511
00:32:46.690 --> 00:32:46.990
Thank you.
512
00:32:47.269 --> 00:32:49.990
Anything the defense thinks I've overlooked as it relates to this?
513
00:32:50.259 --> 00:32:53.019
Judge, I think I'm good. I'll just let Mr. Brooks
514
00:32:53.039 --> 00:32:55.000
know that I'll set up a phone call with him soon.
515
00:32:55.339 --> 00:32:57.440
If you could just wave your hand so I know
516
00:32:57.460 --> 00:32:58.259
that you heard that, sir.
517
00:32:59.680 --> 00:33:02.460
Oh, and I forgot to state this at the beginning
518
00:33:02.500 --> 00:33:07.299
of the hearing. Obviously, it made reference to the video
519
00:33:07.339 --> 00:33:10.539
conference saying he's appearing through the Zoom platform through our
520
00:33:10.619 --> 00:33:11.480
technology platform.
521
00:33:11.980 --> 00:33:12.559
It's working.
522
00:33:12.720 --> 00:33:15.140
I can see him. You can see him. He's indicated
523
00:33:15.720 --> 00:33:18.920
twice now that he hears us. Clearly the technology is
524
00:33:18.960 --> 00:33:22.150
working and it meets the minimum standards for video conferencing
525
00:33:23.029 --> 00:33:25.630
and given that there was no testimony that was taken.
526
00:33:25.369 --> 00:33:27.730
Today too it was obviously very appropriate for him to
527
00:33:27.809 --> 00:33:29.410
appear that way.
528
00:33:29.430 --> 00:33:32.990
He has 20 days from today's date to appeal the
529
00:33:33.029 --> 00:33:36.529
decision of the court. I will of course make sure
530
00:33:36.890 --> 00:33:40.839
an amended judgment of conviction is done as quickly as possible.
531
00:33:40.900 --> 00:33:43.849
Get that signed, and that will be uploaded to the
532
00:33:43.970 --> 00:33:46.420
e-filing system. All right. Thank you, everyone.
533
00:33:46.460 --> 00:33:48.759
That does conclude our hearing today.
534
00:33:49.000 --> 00:33:49.339
Good luck.
535
00:33:49.619 --> 00:33:50.109
Thank you, Judge.
536
00:33:51.210 --> 00:33:51.690
Thank you, Judge.