TRASCRIZIONE 🔗
WEBVTT
00:00:01.706 --> 00:00:06.036
This is Fictional Problems, the podcast where we discuss all things writing.
00:00:07.186 --> 00:00:12.224
In this episode, the third part of our three-part series exploring monsters in fiction,
00:00:12.938 --> 00:00:18.273
we discuss the monsters of cosmic horror, in particular the unknowable Cthulhu,
00:00:18.883 --> 00:00:24.606
the slumbering Azathoth, and their creator, the questionable H.P. Lovecraft.
00:00:26.145 --> 00:00:27.737
Join us!
00:00:33.819 --> 00:00:37.837
Welcome back to Fictional Problems, a podcast where we discuss all things writing
00:00:37.837 --> 00:00:40.517
in association with speculative fiction Ireland with myself,
00:00:40.517 --> 00:00:43.244
Gary J. Martin. And myself, A.R. McNevin.
00:00:43.824 --> 00:00:47.215
And today we are continuing our monster series.
00:00:48.097 --> 00:00:51.641
Our monster. Our monster series, our series about monsters.
00:00:53.597 --> 00:00:58.977
And would it be safe to say that this is a favourite of yours?
00:00:58.977 --> 00:01:02.967
It is definitely within my wheelhouse. Within your wheelhouse,
00:01:02.967 --> 00:01:07.117
because today we are going to discuss, for however long...
00:01:08.157 --> 00:01:12.057
This might be two minutes long, so if this is a run to the shops, enjoy.
00:01:12.617 --> 00:01:20.187
Yeah, so it is Eldritch Horror and its aspects and the monsters therein.
00:01:20.187 --> 00:01:24.797
Famously, I suppose, the big daddy monster of Eldritch Horror is Cthulhu.
00:01:25.117 --> 00:01:27.601
Cthulhu, indeed. What is Cthulhu, Al?
00:01:28.088 --> 00:01:32.866
Is it indescribable no it's like there's this thing this this is the the.
00:01:34.097 --> 00:01:37.127
The core question of eldritch horror which we'll get back to a moment is cthulhu
00:01:37.127 --> 00:01:43.437
is readily readily describable because he's described in detail okay that the leathery wings,
00:01:44.557 --> 00:01:52.513
the the the tentacle face the the the heavy bulk to his body two arms two legs he is humanoid,
00:01:53.511 --> 00:01:57.400
that there is, you know, inside the short story called Catholic,
00:01:57.400 --> 00:02:00.211
well, is it a novella? Short, called Catholic.
00:02:00.914 --> 00:02:08.870
He is the one, one of the, one of the few entities which manifests.
00:02:09.170 --> 00:02:14.230
Okay. In their quote-unquote true form. Is he a demon? Is he a transdimensional,
00:02:14.790 --> 00:02:16.500
beast? Is he intelligent?
00:02:16.866 --> 00:02:22.190
He is an alien. Alien. He is just an alien is the best way to describe him.
00:02:22.190 --> 00:02:27.047
And then his impact on the world. He doesn't have the proper papers to enter the country?
00:02:27.175 --> 00:02:30.200
No, he doesn't. That's the question. That's the reason why he's keeping it kicked
00:02:30.200 --> 00:02:32.410
out. Yeah. Stop the customs. Yes.
00:02:33.630 --> 00:02:39.880
Well, no, he now lives in Mu, which is a continent in the Pacific,
00:02:40.084 -->
Load full transcript
00:02:45.502
in Ruele, which is the name of the capital city of that country.
00:02:46.403 --> 00:02:53.414
And when the stars are right, Mu will rise again, and he will get freed from his watery slumber.
00:02:53.686 --> 00:02:57.370
Ah, there's always a prophecy. Is there always a prophecy in Elachara? Oh, that's the thing.
00:02:57.850 --> 00:03:04.366
So they are aliens, but they have achieved the level of cult gods. Yes.
00:03:04.703 --> 00:03:09.840
They use Cthulhu and the rest of... So the Pantheon is...
00:03:10.470 --> 00:03:13.340
And this starts off from Patriot of Lovecraft, but there's a lot of writers
00:03:13.340 --> 00:03:14.774
who write into this, including myself.
00:03:16.053 --> 00:03:23.388
And it's known as the Cthulhu Pantheon, even though the head god is Azra Toff.
00:03:23.725 --> 00:03:28.984
Not Cthulhu. Not Cthulhu, no. He is known by many different titles.
00:03:28.984 --> 00:03:36.174
One is High Priest, so he's not even in the top five. There is...
00:03:36.654 --> 00:03:39.780
Why is he the most well-known, yeah?
00:03:40.734 --> 00:03:45.754
Cthulhu, because he is the one who has seen. so so so rather than going into
00:03:45.754 --> 00:03:50.090
kind of the full the full pantheon i was like i have a the cthulhuca,
00:03:51.061 --> 00:03:54.994
encyclopedia at home in fact i have more than one copy of it home there's the
00:03:54.994 --> 00:04:00.054
one yes folks we are nerds we are indeed nerds but it is both were published
00:04:00.054 --> 00:04:04.300
by chaosium who own the rights to call a cthulhu role-playing game,
00:04:05.003 --> 00:04:10.155
and my first copy is so dog-eared from me flicking through it that i got myself a second copy,
00:04:10.994 --> 00:04:16.454
but i always love the fact that the the the book exists in the game so that
00:04:16.454 --> 00:04:20.754
so if you if you burn it it lasts for a d4 minutes but,
00:04:21.234 --> 00:04:25.874
but it's rather than going through the full list of of all the pantheons and
00:04:26.214 --> 00:04:28.394
all the details the well which,
00:04:28.934 --> 00:04:31.203
we may dip back into because they,
00:04:31.846 --> 00:04:33.668
each of them represent different things like say.
00:04:35.594 --> 00:04:42.894
And Shubh, Nigguroth represents life, but is a dark impression of life,
00:04:43.774 --> 00:04:49.854
that he is a life deity, or a corruption, one could say that it's a corruption,
00:04:50.454 --> 00:04:52.222
from a writing point of view, a corruption of a life deity.
00:04:53.265 --> 00:04:58.882
And then i'm trying to remember it's just escaping my my memory okay the the,
00:04:59.602 --> 00:05:01.275
the basically the magic one,
00:05:02.483 --> 00:05:07.502
jugsock off yes and just just as i say i can't remember the name it's just just
00:05:07.502 --> 00:05:13.062
well maybe that was some sort of eldritch magic that was uh infused and corrupting your system exactly,
00:05:14.202 --> 00:05:19.962
uh often my favorite because because he slash she is is the only one who who's,
00:05:20.462 --> 00:05:24.399
often depicted and as a cloud of eyeballs. Okay.
00:05:24.731 --> 00:05:30.222
These sort of kind of, they, like real angels in the Bible? How they're described?
00:05:30.222 --> 00:05:31.362
There were, there were circles.
00:05:31.962 --> 00:05:35.462
Yeah. But lots of eyeballs on the circles. There was, yeah.
00:05:36.582 --> 00:05:41.992
Terrifying. Yes, but an angel should be terrifying to see because they are incredibly
00:05:41.992 --> 00:05:44.616
destructive forces or at least according to that, that lore. Yeah.
00:05:45.194 --> 00:05:49.332
But the central question of, of Eldritch Horror, this comes back to what we
00:05:49.332 --> 00:05:55.643
were talking about, like the purpose of these is is how do you write Eldritch Horror?
00:05:56.026 --> 00:06:00.024
How do you write these monsters when they are so hard to write? Yeah.
00:06:01.382 --> 00:06:05.222
Can we get, like, just, sorry, brief history. So, like, you know,
00:06:05.222 --> 00:06:10.613
we were previously talking about dragons and even ancient Greek monsters.
00:06:11.582 --> 00:06:16.182
Is Eldritch Horror and the likes of Cthulhu, is that a more modern invention?
00:06:16.182 --> 00:06:17.689
Yes. Or has it always been?
00:06:18.305 --> 00:06:23.782
I like the fact, so, a guy, I remember, a guy I used to know thought that the
00:06:24.222 --> 00:06:30.672
Necronomicon was a real book okay but it isn't look the Necronomicon as people
00:06:30.672 --> 00:06:33.234
may know from The Army of Darkness is,
00:06:33.727 --> 00:06:36.467
from Cthulhu or from the Cthulhu mythos,
00:06:37.194 --> 00:06:41.726
it was written by a mad Arab Al-Harazd if I'm going to get that name wrong,
00:06:42.541 --> 00:06:49.211
and it contains knowledge, spells, invocations of a range of these deities.
00:06:51.398 --> 00:06:54.532
So did H.P. Lovecraft, was he tapping
00:06:54.532 --> 00:06:58.364
into an already existing pool of knowledge, or did he come up with it?
00:06:58.532 --> 00:07:02.126
He came up with it. All himself. No, he started himself.
00:07:02.509 --> 00:07:05.510
But then you have August Dirlith, and you have countless other writers,
00:07:05.887 --> 00:07:09.556
including up to George R.R. Martin, William Gillian Maltaro,
00:07:10.319 --> 00:07:14.762
almost every science fiction writer and fantasy writer that I like likes or
00:07:14.762 --> 00:07:15.805
has been influenced by this.
00:07:16.432 --> 00:07:23.454
And perhaps one could say that it is the unknowingness about it that is a draw.
00:07:24.417 --> 00:07:28.982
For me, I'll get to my own interpretations in a moment because one of my series,
00:07:28.982 --> 00:07:32.412
Brown and the Crow, is set in a Lovecraft universe.
00:07:32.412 --> 00:07:39.282
Has aspects of Elder Tower. It is specifically set in a world in which all of
00:07:39.282 --> 00:07:45.652
Cthulhu exists yeah there's cultists well no I mean just all is there that every,
00:07:46.352 --> 00:07:48.470
every story that has existed in.
00:07:49.810 --> 00:07:56.192
As far as I've encountered yeah it's like so so the events of Cthulhu happened
00:07:56.192 --> 00:07:58.060
in this in this world okay,
00:07:58.751 --> 00:08:04.862
it is a it is a set in present day roughly in present in present day and is
00:08:04.862 --> 00:08:06.714
essentially about trying to stop the end of the world,
00:08:07.459 --> 00:08:12.091
so while it is not it has horror elements to it yeah,
00:08:12.932 --> 00:08:16.143
it would fall into so Eldritch Horror has got the other.
00:08:17.328 --> 00:08:19.400
Nomenclature for it is weird fiction,
00:08:20.357 --> 00:08:25.233
Because it isn't always horrible. Okay. Or isn't always scary.
00:08:26.052 --> 00:08:29.387
But it can occasionally unnerve. Or it can occasionally be scary.
00:08:29.957 --> 00:08:34.848
The, so the core question is how to write, or why is it so hard to write?
00:08:35.530 --> 00:08:38.421
And that's where I say, I have never found it hard to write. Okay.
00:08:39.132 --> 00:08:43.032
But that's, but that's a, the... It's a common trope, you say,
00:08:43.372 --> 00:08:45.119
that people find it difficult to write.
00:08:45.732 --> 00:08:48.748
It is a question of trying to keep all the lines straight as to,
00:08:49.752 --> 00:08:54.392
it's a variety of different things that kind of bounce off each other to form
00:08:54.392 --> 00:08:56.834
this overall mythos is it like,
00:08:57.419 --> 00:09:04.662
demons aliens undeath undead creatures cultists is it is that a collage of these
00:09:04.662 --> 00:09:09.191
things or is it more specifically one or the other so it's the,
00:09:09.667 --> 00:09:15.252
the forms that it takes are so it's the it's not necessarily aliens and and
00:09:15.408 --> 00:09:20.432
demons in the in that sense but they're demonic forces cults and,
00:09:21.312 --> 00:09:22.983
the horrific things that they do to one another,
00:09:23.980 --> 00:09:27.994
something like Event Horizon as in the scenes that we unfortunately never could see because.
00:09:29.352 --> 00:09:36.092
The original files were left in the original film reel was left in a salt vault,
00:09:37.332 --> 00:09:44.192
or a salt mine that the horrific things that one can do to one another this
00:09:44.192 --> 00:09:49.452
sort of madness that creatures that invoke madness or,
00:09:50.636 --> 00:09:57.172
are the product of madness the idea of things being unknown is very very common
00:09:57.172 --> 00:10:02.252
is it like spirits or like body hopping or mind warping,
00:10:03.072 --> 00:10:08.932
mind warping yes there is a type of spiritual entity called star vampire which
00:10:08.932 --> 00:10:14.206
if memory serves is a spirit is a spiritual force that jumps from body to body,
00:10:14.896 --> 00:10:16.292
and so But literally anything.
00:10:17.812 --> 00:10:19.810
That is, like, say...
00:10:21.082 --> 00:10:25.307
The, what's that one that John Carpenter did, Mouth
of Madness,
00:10:25.738 --> 00:10:27.403
would be very much Lovecraftian horror.
00:10:27.786 --> 00:10:34.139
Okay. Because there's people who are, there's time loops, there's things that
00:10:34.139 --> 00:10:35.869
people can't control, that.
00:10:38.909 --> 00:10:45.819
There's a lack of ability. There is a lack of control over their world,
00:10:45.819 --> 00:10:49.830
that things that are normally contained, normally understood,
00:10:50.120 --> 00:10:51.287
are turned on their head.
00:10:51.484 --> 00:10:55.002
That'll be kind of the essence of weird fiction.
00:10:56.987 --> 00:10:59.819
The creatures themselves, we're
00:10:59.819 --> 00:11:04.279
dealing on timescales that are set in thousands and thousands of years.
00:11:04.279 --> 00:11:10.019
So the rise of a Catholic cult may happen this year, a rise of a Yogg-Soggoth
00:11:10.019 --> 00:11:13.859
cult may happen somewhere out in a different part of the world 10 years from
00:11:13.859 --> 00:11:15.151
now, or 100 years from now.
00:11:16.021 --> 00:11:20.429
That while they're all tend to be focused on these worlds, you may encounter
00:11:20.429 --> 00:11:23.309
creatures that have nothing to do with those main creatures,
00:11:23.309 --> 00:11:26.192
like, say, the Elder Things, or the...
00:11:27.639 --> 00:11:32.829
I'm going to forget their names. There's just aliens all the way around.
00:11:32.829 --> 00:11:37.519
I'm going to remember their name in a second. These aren't from a specific place.
00:11:37.519 --> 00:11:46.379
Are they from a world, or are they from a deep space entity that lives in space.
00:11:47.839 --> 00:11:49.926
Teleport. The.
00:11:52.931 --> 00:11:55.936
Mythos is the Azorazos mythos.
00:11:56.568 --> 00:12:03.529
He created the entire thing. He is the slumbering idiot god as they have heard
00:12:03.529 --> 00:12:10.515
that there is a chorus of trumpeting abominations around him keeping him sleeping. Okay.
00:12:11.159 --> 00:12:16.292
That he is the he created everything so if at the center of the universe there he is,
00:12:17.140 --> 00:12:22.109
he is very rarely depicted because he's he's asleep yeah not a very interesting
00:12:22.109 --> 00:12:24.016
character doesn't respond well,
00:12:24.639 --> 00:12:29.669
the idea that that everything that we know is created by this horrific unknowable
00:12:29.669 --> 00:12:32.159
creature is in itself that's,
00:12:33.039 --> 00:12:37.969
at the core of the mythos that that we can never fully understand or we can
00:12:37.969 --> 00:12:41.489
never fully know it's starting to way it might be a little bit difficult to
00:12:41.489 --> 00:12:44.559
write then we're getting there.
00:12:47.134 --> 00:12:50.309
I'm going to remember them in a second because I used them in one of my parts
00:12:50.309 --> 00:12:57.765
of parliament a race of creatures which were the ones in Mounts of Madness,
00:12:58.934 --> 00:13:03.984
They are a time-traveling creature, a time-traveling race of creatures,
00:13:06.066 --> 00:13:10.403
who have seen the end of the universe, whatever that end may be,
00:13:11.056 --> 00:13:15.374
go back in time and take over the bodies of a different race.
00:13:16.571 --> 00:13:21.586
And then they live out that race. So they send all the minds of the race they've
00:13:21.586 --> 00:13:23.381
just got into their old bodies.
00:13:24.043 --> 00:13:28.926
Those bodies so those people will see the end of the world and won't have the
00:13:28.926 --> 00:13:32.726
have the understanding to use the technology to time travel themselves so they'll
00:13:32.726 --> 00:13:38.886
see they'll all die and then this race lives the natural lifespan of the race they've just taken over,
00:13:39.345 --> 00:13:41.870
and then they do it again and then they do it again and then they do it again
00:13:42.125 --> 00:13:47.246
I'll remember I'll actually don't invite them to dinner but they have so over
00:13:47.246 --> 00:13:51.826
the course of human existence they have they have used their ability to before
00:13:51.826 --> 00:13:54.126
they got to the end to visit Earth every now and then.
00:13:54.126 --> 00:13:58.746
So there's people who have visited their planet and even though their minds
00:13:58.746 --> 00:14:02.030
were wiped, the memories continue to surface again.
00:14:02.401 --> 00:14:06.337
So there's a long list of people who have been visited by these creatures.
00:14:07.587 --> 00:14:11.523
The, so it is not just these big monsters have an effect.
00:14:11.807 --> 00:14:15.678
It could be that one person has an effect or, or it could be simple,
00:14:15.922 --> 00:14:17.089
simply people against people.
00:14:17.777 --> 00:14:21.617
But it's not like straight, say, science fiction where they're arriving in the
00:14:21.617 --> 00:14:26.297
ship, advanced technology. It's more mystical.
00:14:27.157 --> 00:14:32.497
Not mystical. It still stays in the science fiction realm, but there's a mysticism to it.
00:14:32.497 --> 00:14:36.217
I always think that, and perhaps the reason why I like it, I've described my
00:14:36.217 --> 00:14:39.787
own writing as I write fantasy from a science fiction point of view.
00:14:39.787 --> 00:14:46.367
And this, you know, you talk about their gods, which is, gods would be a fantasy
00:14:46.367 --> 00:14:50.387
term or a mystical term, alien being a science fiction term.
00:14:50.387 --> 00:14:52.424
So these are, alien gods would be.
00:14:55.937 --> 00:15:01.281
They sit in both camps. But in my mind, they sit squarely in the science fiction camp.
00:15:03.677 --> 00:15:06.527
And when they sit in the fantasy camp, it's because they're unknowing.
00:15:06.527 --> 00:15:09.462
They're unknowable. So the...
00:15:12.064 --> 00:15:20.333
So it's not, I don't think there's ever been a spaceship depicted in a non-human spaceship.
00:15:20.582 --> 00:15:27.078
Because I know that there's a game I bought called Cthulhu Tech,
00:15:28.356 --> 00:15:35.816
which is a union between Call of
Cthulhu and Battle Tech, where people are supposed
00:15:35.816 --> 00:15:38.367
to get into battle suits to fight these massive creatures.
00:15:38.867 --> 00:15:44.341
It's again it may be I think I think it's it's a it's like,
00:15:45.584 --> 00:15:50.856
it's like someone who it's like someone who reads literature and then occasionally
00:15:50.856 --> 00:15:54.296
oh I'll read a comic book yeah it's that sort of different it's like I,
00:15:55.156 --> 00:15:58.886
have them in different sections of my brain no yeah I can understand that it
00:15:58.886 --> 00:16:05.396
is incredibly stupid but fun yes exactly so but in that you have human based
00:16:05.396 --> 00:16:09.571
starships and indeed there is another Another game I bought, which is,
00:16:10.956 --> 00:16:12.388
in the Traveler universe,
00:16:13.810 --> 00:16:16.759
which is as the Expanse level technology.
00:16:17.248 --> 00:16:23.936
So that sort of spaceship. So not interstellar, but inside, that is also. Like solar travel.
00:16:24.436 --> 00:16:27.776
Actually, Event Horizon is the closest thing you get to a starship in this thing.
00:16:29.305 --> 00:16:36.378
It is perhaps because our own knowledge isn't sufficient to know these things,
00:16:37.046 --> 00:16:40.381
that as soon as you add even higher grades of technology and higher grades of
00:16:40.381 --> 00:16:43.401
science and higher grades of knowledge, oh, clearly no more,
00:16:43.401 --> 00:16:49.734
as in the villain in Event Horizon is the scientist who has seen too much and who's gone too far.
00:16:50.070 --> 00:16:55.177
And that's, again, a common trope in this weird fiction that they have that
00:16:55.456 --> 00:17:00.531
you shouldn't go too far, that something completely unknowable and that'll break
00:17:00.531 --> 00:17:01.922
your mind exists in your side.
00:17:02.617 --> 00:17:06.361
Now, that's all, that's one of the things. Pre-history lesson.
00:17:06.361 --> 00:17:10.261
Oh yeah. And I could rant on for a very, very, very long time because it is,
00:17:10.261 --> 00:17:15.968
it is a, I have a, I'm just picking at different points along the way. Okay.
00:17:16.672 --> 00:17:18.430
And I will remember the name of that race in a second.
00:17:19.391 --> 00:17:22.901
Like i can you can remember that the first race that they they time traveled
00:17:22.901 --> 00:17:26.203
into was a beetle race i don't know i can see them i can't remember their name
00:17:26.493 --> 00:17:29.131
that's no problem were they the elder things i think the elder things,
00:17:29.671 --> 00:17:34.681
from lang anyway i'll remember a second and was was say it was h.p lovecraft
00:17:34.681 --> 00:17:38.650
who who was the originator of this kind of thing yeah what,
00:17:39.251 --> 00:17:44.611
what was he trying to say or what what was that was there a fundamental kind
00:17:44.611 --> 00:17:45.894
of social message or was there,
00:17:46.571 --> 00:17:51.231
was it entertainment impurely or did he have some grander
message that he was
00:17:51.231 --> 00:17:54.201
trying to get across with this unknowable horror?
00:17:55.071 --> 00:18:00.461
Howard Phillips Lovecraft was likely autistic he was likely on the spectrum.
00:18:01.491 --> 00:18:08.141
He was likely a profound racist and sexist he was only briefly married and ultimately
00:18:08.141 --> 00:18:14.483
spent the rest of his days in a house owned by two of his aunts he lived with two of his aunts,
00:18:15.331 --> 00:18:19.509
though he did make some money of riding he didn't he had,
00:18:20.771 --> 00:18:24.022
he didn't have much of an impact on the world around him.
00:18:25.358 --> 00:18:30.909
Yeah, his primary focus on this would be, and he was anti-technology,
00:18:30.909 --> 00:18:34.676
he was a, likely a horrible, horrible person.
00:18:35.956 --> 00:18:41.056
So this is why I very much a... So we separate the... The art from the artist. Yes.
00:18:41.401 --> 00:18:47.919
Like, say, he, the villains of his work were often swarthy individuals,
00:18:47.919 --> 00:18:54.421
were often people of color, people that were non-American.
00:18:55.060 --> 00:19:00.114
They were just they were basically they were the other?
00:19:00.347 --> 00:19:05.599
Yes the other like say there was I think Ian Cullo Cthulhu yes I think,
00:19:06.339 --> 00:19:12.051
one of the exciting instances is that the the speakers or the narrator's uncle
00:19:12.417 --> 00:19:19.579
died shortly after encountering two two black sailors one of which said something
00:19:19.579 --> 00:19:20.899
to him in a foreign language,
00:19:21.791 --> 00:19:25.379
and and then he died thereafter But then, then student died after. Okay.
00:19:25.948 --> 00:19:29.478
Whether that was a curse or whether that was a warning, it wasn't, it wasn't explained.
00:19:30.516 --> 00:19:39.186
The unknown, perhaps of just other languages, and his own fear of other races,
00:19:39.186 --> 00:19:42.856
other peoples, was the spawn of his writing.
00:19:43.640 --> 00:19:50.746
The reason why Cthulhu lives under the sea is because Lovecraft was afraid of
00:19:50.746 --> 00:19:52.570
the water. He couldn't swim.
00:19:53.882 --> 00:19:59.126
And you could understand. I think when you see the things, this was in the 1920s,
00:19:59.126 --> 00:20:01.765
so this was during a scientific revolution.
00:20:01.991 --> 00:20:10.286
So you had, like, there was a story about an air conditioner that was so,
00:20:10.946 --> 00:20:14.448
that blew so cold that it killed the one. All right.
00:20:14.599 --> 00:20:17.016
So there were these changes in technology happening all around.
00:20:17.016 --> 00:20:19.394
So you can imagine that. It was post-World War I.
00:20:20.027 --> 00:20:25.436
Yes, but it was a time of great money.
00:20:25.436 --> 00:20:30.406
This was before the Wall Street crash this was a boom time and the things that
00:20:30.406 --> 00:20:35.826
were being found like say the if you read say Into the Mouth of Madness essentially
00:20:35.826 --> 00:20:38.546
is a scholarly depiction,
00:20:39.677 --> 00:20:43.055
of a of a of a expedition to the South Pole,
00:20:44.191 --> 00:20:48.074
And you could see all the technology. He used all the technology of the day.
00:20:48.318 --> 00:20:55.854
We had this type of radio and this type of sensor system, this type of radar.
00:20:56.044 --> 00:21:01.078
Okay. So you could see that he was cutting out technology of the time.
00:21:01.752 --> 00:21:04.693
And I can imagine that the things that were being pulled out of the ocean.
00:21:06.081 --> 00:21:08.981
They were going deeper and deeper in the ocean, where are these squid things?
00:21:08.981 --> 00:21:12.179
Where are these tentacles in the face of Cthulhu?
00:21:13.221 --> 00:21:18.341
So he wasn't writing of a distant past, like in fantasy, or he wasn't writing
00:21:18.341 --> 00:21:21.611
in the distant future, like in more traditional science fiction,
00:21:21.611 --> 00:21:23.830
where humans have ventured out into the stars.
00:21:24.921 --> 00:21:30.601
He was writing contemporary. He was writing contemporary, but he was heavily writing that.
00:21:31.300 --> 00:21:34.401
It was this current version of Man as a second edition.
00:21:35.457 --> 00:21:36.799
Across the entire of the mythos.
00:21:39.242 --> 00:21:42.281
These things have been around for thousands and thousands of years.
00:21:43.955 --> 00:21:47.741
They're older than the world themselves.
00:21:48.416 --> 00:21:52.821
But he set it in today. He set it in today, as far as he was concerned.
00:21:52.821 --> 00:21:57.431
But sometimes with the example of time travel and there's sometimes there's
00:21:57.431 --> 00:22:03.141
examples of there's the dream dream journey to that, which is where someone
00:22:03.141 --> 00:22:05.729
goes off and has a and tries to find actually Yogg Saga.
00:22:06.475 --> 00:22:09.940
So there is elements which go beyond simply the normal world.
00:22:11.643 --> 00:22:18.579
The, so the, it is very much people with guns trying to stop these things and failing.
00:22:20.703 --> 00:22:26.978
It is a modern, like they're in the Dunnish horror, one of the creatures is, is invisible.
00:22:27.396 --> 00:22:33.543
So this comes to the point of one of the main things about, about these things are undescribable.
00:22:33.923 --> 00:22:37.403
And Cthulhu being the one thing that is described is the one that everyone knows
00:22:37.403 --> 00:22:40.063
about. Okay. How do, how do heroes fight?
00:22:41.243 --> 00:22:46.283
How do people succeed against such unknowable, indescribable.
00:22:48.443 --> 00:22:55.243
You know, just unknown creatures which, you know, fantastical abilities are... Well, that's the thing.
00:22:55.943 --> 00:22:59.923
The abilities are simply you're dead. That's the thing, isn't it?
00:23:00.303 --> 00:23:04.858
The color out of, color out of, like, say, on your list, the example is Annihilation.
00:23:05.427 --> 00:23:09.589
Annihilation, the movie, which is written by
the guy who judged Dredd,
00:23:10.423 --> 00:23:13.285
is a movie I've watched many times and a movie I dislike intensely.
00:23:15.168 --> 00:23:18.318
But the background watch it grudgingly I was like I hate this movie I keep on
00:23:18.318 --> 00:23:21.198
going back to going I have to I have to find what people thought was good about
00:23:21.198 --> 00:23:26.130
this it actually so Annihilation is a book that has nothing to do with Cthulhu,
00:23:26.815 --> 00:23:28.225
but Garfield is it Garfield,
00:23:29.353 --> 00:23:34.848
he Andrew Garland maybe he was reading Color Out of Time Color Out of Space
00:23:34.848 --> 00:23:39.598
which is a which is a Lovecraft story at the same time and so the two stories
00:23:39.598 --> 00:23:40.725
kind of merged together okay,
00:23:41.635 --> 00:23:45.648
and so she's this color this color that doesn't exist that doesn't exist in
00:23:45.648 --> 00:23:49.748
our spectrum, it has this mutagenic quality that changes things,
00:23:49.748 --> 00:23:51.308
it changes people, it changes ideas.
00:23:52.603 --> 00:23:56.690
That simply by you seeing it, you are changed fundamentally by it,
00:23:57.032 --> 00:24:00.736
that it is unknown what it can do, it's unknowable what it can do.
00:24:01.348 --> 00:24:06.498
That is part of what is featured in Annihilation, that they experience a thing
00:24:06.498 --> 00:24:09.738
that has a profound effect on them, but they don't know what that will ultimately
00:24:09.738 --> 00:24:11.319
be, and it's never really...
00:24:12.346 --> 00:24:19.078
And that is, I think, where the question comes, that Aldrich Horror and weird
00:24:19.078 --> 00:24:25.468
fiction is hard to write, hard to work, is a misunderstanding.
00:24:25.468 --> 00:24:29.988
So this is where it gets into my opinion about it, because most of the stuff
00:24:29.988 --> 00:24:34.619
I've said so far is not so opinion, as in, yeah, Lovecraft was a racist, that's not opinion.
00:24:35.530 --> 00:24:43.218
Is that as I said Lovecraft had fears and he was using these metaphors these
00:24:43.218 --> 00:24:47.301
creatures he was creating as depictions of his fears that.
00:24:48.694 --> 00:24:54.709
He had deeper phobias about other races but they became these,
00:24:56.758 --> 00:25:02.438
their tribal their songs their foods everything about them was just the smells
00:25:02.438 --> 00:25:07.218
that he was translating this into, for him, an alien culture.
00:25:08.083 --> 00:25:11.403
So when he was writing, he wasn't looking to create an alien.
00:25:11.821 --> 00:25:18.798
He was just using the alien form to express how he thought the Africans, the South Americans.
00:25:20.878 --> 00:25:26.954
Any on-Caucasian culture he encountered was so fearful to him.
00:25:27.303 --> 00:25:32.138
And that added into about some of the new technologies he was concerned about
00:25:32.138 --> 00:25:33.848
and about kind of below the sea
00:25:33.848 --> 00:25:38.038
again all these things like the one of his
other more famous stories the,
00:25:38.498 --> 00:25:41.938
in the inns but what's it the i know it's the inns with malady i'm going to
00:25:41.938 --> 00:25:43.281
remember i'm going to forget the name of the story,
00:25:44.124 --> 00:25:50.528
is about a a race of of things called the deep ones where they come out of come
00:25:50.528 --> 00:25:55.778
out of the ocean they give the the people of inns with a bunch of gold and they
00:25:55.905 --> 00:25:58.478
have a bunch of sex and their descendants,
00:25:59.078 --> 00:26:04.813
will slowly over time become more fish-like like become more deep one like and return to the oceans.
00:26:06.527 --> 00:26:10.364
Okay. Terrorism. So it is a fear of what will come out of the oceans.
00:26:11.097 --> 00:26:14.539
And that was, that was linked into all the stuff that he was afraid of.
00:26:15.126 --> 00:26:20.174
So if you look at it like that, it almost demystifies the stories that he's
00:26:20.174 --> 00:26:23.634
telling. That it's just, he was really, really afraid of these people.
00:26:23.634 --> 00:26:25.574
That he had in a rational fear.
00:26:26.234 --> 00:26:29.374
These were, these were true, true phobias about,
00:26:30.334 --> 00:26:34.944
these people who today we understand, you know, and that's actually back then
00:26:34.944 --> 00:26:36.067
also you understood, but,
00:26:36.863 --> 00:26:39.812
so when you see that the writing from that point of view,
00:26:40.497 --> 00:26:45.176
it makes perfect sense what he left was this wonderful mythos as in this so
00:26:45.495 --> 00:26:48.494
good good good things can grow in questionable ground yeah yeah himself the
00:26:48.494 --> 00:26:53.974
vast number of other writers who contributed to this had left this wonderful tapestry that can,
00:26:54.653 --> 00:26:59.054
that because it's so unknown you can add your own piece to it i was just going
00:26:59.054 --> 00:27:04.814
to say it must be quite freeing then because the limitations aren't there's no boundary set yeah,
00:27:06.008 --> 00:27:08.574
There is in a sense that you,
00:27:09.754 --> 00:27:12.234
it's not that you're, that it's not limitations. Or they're fluid,
00:27:12.234 --> 00:27:13.473
at least, if there are boundaries.
00:27:14.059 --> 00:27:19.092
It's that if you, you can create anything, but you are aware of where you're going to bump into.
00:27:20.230 --> 00:27:26.706
Like, say, in my own work there, I created other gods and other creatures that have that.
00:27:28.565 --> 00:27:34.088
One of the new gods I created was one that essentially borrows the trappings
00:27:34.309 --> 00:27:38.825
from the other gods. Because they don't have almost a confidence in their own
00:27:38.825 --> 00:27:42.145
cult, or their own ability to create a cult. So they go, okay,
00:27:42.145 --> 00:27:43.515
I'm going to create a Cthulhu cult.
00:27:43.718 --> 00:27:47.565
I'm going to create a... Siphon off the worship. Exactly.
00:27:48.125 --> 00:27:51.957
And essentially it's they create it and then they ultimately let it collapse,
00:27:52.795 --> 00:27:57.645
because they then have to run away before someone notices them essentially before daddy gets home,
00:27:58.185 --> 00:28:02.185
yeah before the someone that they are pretending to be notices again what the
00:28:02.185 --> 00:28:06.806
fuck are you doing look there is a because there is a there has to be a reason
00:28:07.004 --> 00:28:10.074
so and that's the only thing that is left across all the,
00:28:10.632 --> 00:28:13.320
that there has to be a reason for what these things are doing yeah,
00:28:13.988 --> 00:28:18.469
but in a in the out of horror idea is that it's unknowable.
00:28:19.576 --> 00:28:25.408
And again that coming from a position from the 1920s where things were unknowable
00:28:25.693 --> 00:28:32.145
where the deep seas were unknowable where the deep space deep space you're it's like you know the,
00:28:33.165 --> 00:28:39.558
the the Dunning-Kruger effect yeah I'm aware it's a psychological study yeah so but the,
00:28:40.345 --> 00:28:45.255
the initially the less you know about a thing the more confident you are in
00:28:45.255 --> 00:28:49.785
that thing the further you get along your confidence stops yeah as your knowledge
00:28:49.785 --> 00:28:51.425
grows and ultimately if you get,
00:28:52.465 --> 00:28:57.545
because what's happening in your brain is that you realize hang on there is
00:28:57.545 --> 00:29:01.605
far far more in this knowledge that I know yet you know enough to know that
00:29:01.605 --> 00:29:02.945
you don't know anything exactly,
00:29:03.585 --> 00:29:09.135
so your confidence drops as your knowledge increases and then you get to a plateau
00:29:09.135 --> 00:29:12.975
point where it's like hang on okay your knowledge continues to grow but your
00:29:12.975 --> 00:29:16.181
confidence begins to grow I believe that was Was it Socrates?
00:29:18.280 --> 00:29:21.700
Socrates had said that the only true knowledge is the knowledge that we know nothing.
00:29:23.520 --> 00:29:29.506
That's also a line from one of the Dalai Lama that says something similar.
00:29:29.744 --> 00:29:32.519
So this is actually a depiction of idiocy.
00:29:33.454 --> 00:29:36.160
Because the greater your confidence
00:29:36.160 --> 00:29:39.931
generally, the lower your knowledge base. And AI is part of this.
00:29:40.460 --> 00:29:45.161
But if you follow this trend, according to these psychologists,
00:29:45.964 --> 00:29:49.070
just you'll never be as confident as if you got or go all the way to the end
00:29:49.070 --> 00:29:52.940
of the line your confidence level is never as confident as you were at the start
00:29:52.940 --> 00:29:56.158
yeah because you're always going there's always something i don't know,
00:29:56.739 --> 00:30:00.390
and you're always you know if you were if you talk to the person you know people
00:30:00.390 --> 00:30:04.169
who know absolutely everything in the field about astrophysics astrophysics,
00:30:04.645 --> 00:30:05.890
they'll still say there's a,
00:30:06.520 --> 00:30:10.590
ton we don't know they know enough to know there's more exactly so this is just
00:30:10.590 --> 00:30:15.320
that's just one field so being an expert in that one field you you know that
00:30:15.320 --> 00:30:18.680
there's going to be so many other fields out there that you have no knowledge about it.
00:30:19.057 --> 00:30:24.130
So the saying, so this was, again, from Lovecraft's point of view,
00:30:24.130 --> 00:30:25.989
saying we can't know it all.
00:30:27.241 --> 00:30:31.047
I'm of the position that, yes, you can, but.
00:30:36.758 --> 00:30:43.934
The knowledge is there, you may not be able to find it, so it's not an unknowable thing, it's just...
00:30:44.166 --> 00:30:48.607
It's not eternally unknowable by everybody. Yeah, that the human race will ultimately
00:30:48.607 --> 00:30:53.757
figure this stuff out, that they'll get to an end point, and that we can figure
00:30:53.757 --> 00:30:55.695
out enough to get to a solution.
00:30:55.927 --> 00:31:02.785
So in my version this again this is my version of weird fiction the,
00:31:03.927 --> 00:31:07.467
I was just going to say yeah as long as that solution ends up being profitable
00:31:07.467 --> 00:31:11.657
for someone that we can reach it if it's not it won't be reached I was just
00:31:11.657 --> 00:31:17.838
going to be I appreciate that it is a case that the,
00:31:18.867 --> 00:31:22.887
that saying something is unknown like to go back to the question for a second
00:31:22.887 --> 00:31:30.007
before I jump off on a rant the idea of whether or not something is describable or not describable.
00:31:30.307 --> 00:31:33.297
You mentioned for them why Cthulhu is the most known one.
00:31:33.634 --> 00:31:36.247
He's the most described. He's the one that is described.
00:31:36.707 --> 00:31:41.097
So all the other ones are, and the other ones can be described as lizard creatures
00:31:41.097 --> 00:31:45.907
or as odd-looking trees or as clouds of eyeballs.
00:31:46.347 --> 00:31:52.071
But it is, it is, it is poetical rather than physiological. Yeah.
00:31:52.646 --> 00:31:58.086
It is, the gut with a thousand young is one of the subnames of Shubnigarov.
00:31:59.531 --> 00:32:06.197
It's like it's a it's meant to invoke it's it's it's meant to not be descriptive
00:32:06.613 --> 00:32:13.619
meant to mess with your mind no it's meant to be poetical yeah it's meant to be the the elusive,
00:32:14.364 --> 00:32:19.031
or what elusive elusive as in you can't picture it no you know you're meant to,
00:32:19.771 --> 00:32:25.301
that it's that you can picture what they're saying but that it can't exist in
00:32:25.301 --> 00:32:30.761
reality that it's not saying by saying Cthulhu is a humanoid creature with tentacles
00:32:30.761 --> 00:32:32.186
on his face and two bat-like wings,
00:32:32.845 --> 00:32:35.511
you've now, you've now, you've now had that in your eye.
00:32:36.351 --> 00:32:42.961
But having, I say, a cloud of eyeballs and the version you have in your mind
00:32:42.961 --> 00:32:45.621
and the version I have in my mind are going to be different. Yeah.
00:32:45.825 --> 00:32:51.021
So it's, and it is like they, they're, are the eyeballs all bloodshot or are
00:32:51.021 --> 00:32:54.150
they all human or are they blinking or are they being consumed by something
00:32:54.493 --> 00:32:57.761
and they are blinking in and out of existence. They're all red, are they all blue?
00:32:58.376 --> 00:33:05.081
Or what there is there is any number of of poetical qualities to them and that
00:33:05.081 --> 00:33:10.351
is in which the I guess the horror exists because it's like the idea that the
00:33:10.351 --> 00:33:13.033
worst the worst monster that you can think of,
00:33:13.851 --> 00:33:18.703
is the worst monster in fiction is the one that's not described yeah because,
00:33:19.256 --> 00:33:23.894
your imagination is filling in the gaps exactly you're going to do a better job at,
00:33:24.508 --> 00:33:29.951
telling you what your your greatest fear is than anything on a page so that
00:33:29.951 --> 00:33:32.727
is where can when eldritch fiction started off.
00:33:33.632 --> 00:33:41.110
But the tradition has sort of solidified that down that there is a list of attributes
00:33:41.442 --> 00:33:46.604
or so so you can write anything you want but you'll you will kind of bump into other things,
00:33:47.306 --> 00:33:49.655
and things you can bump into things that can be overlap,
00:33:50.592 --> 00:33:58.469
there can be you can have your creatures and your cultists and your beings doing anything you want.
00:33:59.816 --> 00:34:03.624
As long as it is to you what you find most horrible.
00:34:04.877 --> 00:34:09.878
Okay. And that is, in my mind, how you find your way through writing Eldritch
00:34:09.878 --> 00:34:13.978
Horror. You were talking about aspects of body horror, that kind of thing.
00:34:13.978 --> 00:34:16.728
Yeah, because that is... Mutating...
00:34:17.270 --> 00:34:24.741
Yeah, that's a remnant of what's gone before, that your own body acting against you. Yeah.
00:34:25.071 --> 00:34:28.914
I mean, from a twitch to,
00:34:30.388 --> 00:34:34.978
I imagine you've had times when your hand maybe is numb and it doesn't feel
00:34:34.978 --> 00:34:37.408
like your hand anymore that little shock of,
00:34:38.622 --> 00:34:44.898
or the line from Zen on the Armos is about the truth of that these hands were
00:34:44.898 --> 00:34:50.853
not his that the idea that you are physically not the person you were that.
00:34:52.908 --> 00:34:56.784
How you are interacting with the world is somehow false you're losing yourself
00:34:57.062 --> 00:35:01.158
yeah losing parts of yourself yes that there is that i think the thing is for
00:35:01.158 --> 00:35:04.458
some people that's not that thing is that thing for some people that's not fear yeah,
00:35:05.213 --> 00:35:09.528
and it won't be so that's why
that those those stories don't work for them but
00:35:09.528 --> 00:35:15.024
it is the case that if you create the story which is inspired by your fear,
00:35:15.675 --> 00:35:23.403
if you use your fears to manifest them then that is that is the true sense of horror,
00:35:24.031 --> 00:35:26.875
that can be manifested through the weird fiction.
00:35:27.020 --> 00:35:30.798
And it seems to be, like I know we were talking about it on previous episodes
00:35:30.798 --> 00:35:35.734
relating to the monsters, the manifestation of the human psyche's fear.
00:35:36.488 --> 00:35:40.477
What mankind is afraid of creates these imaginings,
00:35:42.068 --> 00:35:48.218
and gives form to the fear in the shape of different creatures,
00:35:48.218 --> 00:35:51.613
different eldritch horrors, different monsters. Thanks for listening.
00:35:54.287 --> 00:35:57.373
If you go back there's various,
00:35:59.013 --> 00:36:02.152
various different writers have written in this form for years,
00:36:03.613 --> 00:36:09.423
the reason why I mentioned weird fiction at the top is eldritch horror I don't
00:36:09.423 --> 00:36:14.503
think exists anymore as a horror I think that weird fiction is more the kind of,
00:36:16.533 --> 00:36:22.374
the quote unquote body horror the unknowableness of the cosmos this sort of,
00:36:24.534 --> 00:36:28.156
the big questions that you'll go mad knowing,
00:36:28.867 --> 00:36:32.803
there was a there was an I think it was an Outer Limits episode which is often
00:36:33.018 --> 00:36:36.065
has touches of weird fiction and where a.
00:36:38.672 --> 00:36:42.548
Archaeologist discovered text which was the meaning of life and every time they
00:36:42.548 --> 00:36:46.648
told the next person that person went insane okay because and he was basically
00:36:46.648 --> 00:36:50.208
the vector for this he's like I should probably stop telling people this,
00:36:50.828 --> 00:36:56.008
but he was now compelled to do so oh okay so and everyone who everyone who wasn't
00:36:56.008 --> 00:36:59.388
the one's insane wanted to tell the other people and the, if I remember,
00:36:59.388 --> 00:37:02.546
this is like back in the 80s, and this may have gotten to my head, that,
00:37:03.463 --> 00:37:05.008
the last shot is,
00:37:06.732 --> 00:37:10.644
the protagonist gets back to the house where the girlfriend is, and,
00:37:12.208 --> 00:37:14.947
shouts for her, shouts for her, and then she steps into view,
00:37:15.278 --> 00:37:20.888
and you know the audience member she has it in her head and he's about to go,
00:37:20.888 --> 00:37:23.068
right, okay, we have to get out of here, and then another person,
00:37:23.068 --> 00:37:24.356
another person, another person show up, and they go,
00:37:24.988 --> 00:37:30.295
and it's like the end of of Buddy Snatchers where Donald Sutherland says screams,
00:37:30.858 --> 00:37:34.308
and she just walks up to him and just whispers in his ear and the last shot
00:37:34.308 --> 00:37:37.830
is a pull
away and going because.
00:37:39.408 --> 00:37:43.768
So the things you want to know is that your motivation Al?
00:37:43.768 --> 00:37:46.798
You want to tell the people the real meaning of life and send them all crazy?
00:37:47.198 --> 00:37:51.418
No I'm not going to no I know you're compelled to tell them which are which
00:37:51.418 --> 00:37:53.408
are stories on this podcast I am not going into
00:37:53.828 --> 00:37:57.218
what my fears are that's fucking personal No, not your fears,
00:37:57.218 --> 00:38:00.348
you're compelled to tell everybody out there the real meaning of life through
00:38:00.348 --> 00:38:02.626
your stories. No, that's what I'm saying. To drive them insane.
00:38:02.847 --> 00:38:09.761
Well, no, but I have my vectors and I understand how I, and perhaps,
00:38:10.395 --> 00:38:14.608
you know, it's like with many things I write, I have to be in the right frame of mind.
00:38:15.228 --> 00:38:22.041
And sometimes I don't want to embrace my own fears to spend any time while writing the stories.
00:38:23.138 --> 00:38:27.125
To find my way back into that story To write it So.
00:38:28.390 --> 00:38:32.440
For me I can understand what My process Admittedly This is my interpretation
00:38:32.440 --> 00:38:37.190
Yeah And others may have Because I've seen many things online How is cosmic
00:38:37.190 --> 00:38:38.567
horror so hard to write It's not,
00:38:39.268 --> 00:38:44.710
It's understanding how The other writers came to it And understand that What
00:38:44.710 --> 00:38:46.858
your fears are Whatever they are,
00:38:47.989 --> 00:38:53.830
It could be a fear of It could be a fear of say Of interpersonal relationships,
00:38:53.830 --> 00:38:57.678
as in, you know, Lovecraft clearly had a problem with interpersonal relationships.
00:38:58.328 --> 00:39:03.610
That, that, that the, the, not, the, the fact that you could never,
00:39:03.610 --> 00:39:04.925
ever truly know another person.
00:39:05.690 --> 00:39:09.260
That is, that could be terrifying. Yeah. That, the idea that,
00:39:09.576 --> 00:39:14.848
whether it be your, your children, or your spouse, or, or whoever it may be,
00:39:15.202 --> 00:39:17.850
that they are completely unknown to you.
00:39:17.850 --> 00:39:21.292
Completely unknown to you. That is, that is shocking.
00:39:21.838 --> 00:39:25.206
That, ultimately that you'll have to be forgotten in two generations,
00:39:26.234 --> 00:39:30.840
everything you do will mean nothing in two generations two generations you heard
00:39:30.840 --> 00:39:34.680
mention that line about dying twice yes yeah I mentioned the idea that you die
00:39:34.680 --> 00:39:37.842
twice once when you physically die once when you're remembered for the last time.
00:39:39.142 --> 00:39:43.496
There is a, but I've talked about kind of the grandfather idea for a while that,
00:39:43.496 --> 00:39:47.227
like, can you name your grandfather? Do you know what he did and you know what kind of person he was?
00:39:47.575 -->
00:39:51.696
And you can't even say, like, I was at a debate about nature versus nurture
00:39:51.696 --> 00:39:54.186
recently. Perhaps grandfather, maybe not great, not great grandfather.
00:39:54.956 --> 00:39:59.278
Not great, yeah. Grandfather perhaps. Yeah, I'll happily concede three generations.
00:39:59.568 --> 00:40:04.293
But three generations is, you know, do you know your great grandfather's name?
00:40:04.940 --> 00:40:08.016
Do you know what he did for a living? Do you know if he was a good person or not?
00:40:08.016 --> 00:40:12.336
Was he a sociopath was he a fascist was he you know God's gift to.
00:40:13.736 --> 00:40:18.039
X Y and Z you had no idea so even from a nature versus nurture point of view,
00:40:18.685 --> 00:40:24.126
look his prison record is fairly clear he was a good person my see my brother
00:40:24.126 --> 00:40:26.116
went through the what was it family tree,
00:40:27.116 --> 00:40:31.016
family history and unfortunately he only got so far because there was a fire
00:40:31.016 --> 00:40:35.236
in the National Archives a few years ago and it removed a bunch of records and
00:40:35.236 --> 00:40:37.200
so we'll never know going back,
00:40:38.336 --> 00:40:39.936
He found some pastoral records,
00:40:40.756 --> 00:40:46.163
some parish records, referring to a woman of a MacNevin name.
00:40:46.286 --> 00:40:48.996
But that could be our line, it could be any line.
00:40:49.736 --> 00:40:54.394
Just recently, my brother uncovered a news article about my grandfather,
00:40:55.091 --> 00:40:59.926
who as a boy played football with Winston Churchill when he used to stay in
00:40:59.926 --> 00:41:01.640
Raptor House in Phoenix Park.
00:41:02.848 --> 00:41:09.355
During the summer. So he was a sympathizer. Okay. Right. Yeah, yeah. I don't know.
00:41:10.428 --> 00:41:13.993
But even at that, it's an interesting note, but we don't know his politics.
00:41:14.167 --> 00:41:19.153
No. We don't know if that was a massive influence on his life or if it was just a throwaway.
00:41:20.497 --> 00:41:24.713
We simply don't know. So in three generations' time, we will be forgotten.
00:41:25.189 --> 00:41:32.077
And if that is your horror, if that is your driving force, then it could be, or even,
00:41:32.817 --> 00:41:37.987
we talk about how like i think trump is a as a germaphobe germs absolutely could
00:41:37.987 --> 00:41:42.897
be could be you could be massively think to the a virus like the like coronavirus or,
00:41:43.737 --> 00:41:48.420
you could extrapolate that into into weird fiction into a part of things that,
00:41:48.873 --> 00:41:54.767
the which is worse the the this this this pathogen or the cure you could all
00:41:54.767 --> 00:41:58.877
go into so many different ways of expressing these are things the,
00:41:59.417 --> 00:42:03.317
forgetting thing reminded me of just as you were saying that you know being
00:42:03.317 --> 00:42:08.387
forgotten that fear reminded me of the Next Generation episode of Beverly Crusher
00:42:08.637 --> 00:42:10.530
oh yes yeah where people start,
00:42:11.116 --> 00:42:15.904
disappearing yeah where her entire world shrinks down to just her yeah.
00:42:17.057 --> 00:42:20.586
Like little eldritorery oh absolutely yes but it's,
00:42:21.230 --> 00:42:26.607
it is a there's a lot of subtle eldritorery like I think that involves psychological
00:42:26.607 --> 00:42:30.247
stuff like the I think that's Haldek related especially when Haldeks you can't
00:42:30.247 --> 00:42:33.076
get free from Haldek there's a Riker episode where,
00:42:34.066 --> 00:42:37.336
where he gets taken by aliens but is he free from the aliens because then he
00:42:37.336 --> 00:42:41.976
breaks away and then or is that the four lights episode as well or is that more
00:42:41.976 --> 00:42:45.026
no that's a Picard episode and that's no that's,
00:42:45.784 --> 00:42:52.636
more that's more torture so that's that's unfortunately painfully not alleged
00:42:52.636 --> 00:42:57.546
horror it is just well horror it's just horror because it is it's just a person,
00:42:58.326 --> 00:43:02.721
breaking just torturing someone and it is it is unfortunately very reasonable
00:43:02.889 --> 00:43:05.960
or sorry not reasonable realistic in the,
00:43:06.689 --> 00:43:11.823
tell me there's tell me there it's the that he had he had almost convinced himself,
00:43:12.270 --> 00:43:13.797
that there was only there was only three lines,
00:43:14.383 --> 00:43:20.466
and then there was the regression virus that was reducing their reducing the
00:43:20.466 --> 00:43:25.106
crew to previous evolutionary states oh in the last season sure sure yeah that's
00:43:25.406 --> 00:43:28.989
yeah and and turning wharf into a killing machine yeah,
00:43:29.727 --> 00:43:34.179
that is yeah yeah yeah but then that's probably a buddy horror yeah again so there is a.
00:43:35.235 --> 00:43:39.228
If you have a good story to tell, because I don't think that was late season, so it wasn't that great.
00:43:39.738 --> 00:43:44.598
But if you have a good story to tell, use your own fears, because everyone's
00:43:44.598 --> 00:43:47.207
got their own fears. No one is free of fear.
00:43:48.438 --> 00:43:52.178
I think that the maybe more male thing, the idea of something,
00:43:52.558 --> 00:43:55.935
or even a female thing, I think it was Christopher Hitchens,
00:43:56.434 --> 00:43:58.274
when he was dying, he was dying of cancer.
00:43:58.657 --> 00:44:02.598
And the idea of the body horror of someone, of something growing inside him,
00:44:03.258 --> 00:44:07.579
that he is having a fight with part of himself.
00:44:08.388 --> 00:44:10.728
And that is some sort of perversion of pregnancy.
00:44:11.668 --> 00:44:15.755
There's something that will see him, will kill him.
00:44:16.658 --> 00:44:22.101
Yeah. Or he'll kill it. So it's a, that could be your, the source of horror
00:44:22.345 --> 00:44:24.878
that you need to drive that story.
00:44:25.698 --> 00:44:31.728
The story itself could be like the, take the idea of the Outer Limits episode I mentioned.
00:44:32.615 --> 00:44:41.109
The the guy is trying to save his girlfriend trying to save that there is that he is willing to not know.
00:44:42.402 --> 00:44:47.348
That he is willing to to be ignorant it's a so you could say that there's a
00:44:47.358 --> 00:44:48.445
willful ignorance happening,
00:44:49.530 --> 00:44:54.028
yeah but don't you don't you all know the meaning of life maybe you maybe maybe
00:44:54.028 --> 00:44:57.348
it's these people who don't really understand it maybe when you hear it,
00:44:58.418 --> 00:45:02.778
you'll set free yeah that's not just no you'll be perfect fire because you'll
00:45:02.778 --> 00:45:07.401
understand it you'll be the special person that understands it not these people,
00:45:08.005 --> 00:45:11.178
these people don't know you know i mean i mean you could you can,
00:45:12.558 --> 00:45:17.938
okay okay fucking tell me okay it's like if you rephrase that into you know
00:45:17.938 --> 00:45:20.177
how and bright the the really bad movie,
00:45:21.732 --> 00:45:27.455
there is what a one in ten thousand humans can be a problem if you were given the choice,
00:45:28.621 --> 00:45:34.773
If you pick up a wand and you're a bright, you now have won the lottery. Yes.
00:45:35.163 --> 00:45:37.733
It's a one in 10,000 chance. Otherwise.
00:45:38.616 --> 00:45:43.409
Otherwise you die. How many people would pick up that one? Oh,
00:45:43.409 --> 00:45:45.389
it'd be tens of thousands dead anyway.
00:45:45.709 --> 00:45:47.049
Oh yeah. No, actually there'd be tens of thousands dead.
00:45:47.789 --> 00:45:51.220
There'd be hundreds of thousands of wands here. And of those hundreds of thousands,
00:45:51.493 --> 00:45:53.705
you get 10 new brights. Yeah. Approximately.
00:45:56.433 --> 00:46:01.895
So that moment of world building, is completely illogical because every person,
00:46:02.069 --> 00:46:05.124
every person, like, every person who's got a terminal disease,
00:46:05.327 --> 00:46:06.395
give me the fucking one now. Yeah.
00:46:07.068 --> 00:46:09.907
Every person who is, is down on the look, every person who is,
00:46:10.232 --> 00:46:14.028
who is a chronic gambler, who, Yeah, yeah, yeah.
00:46:14.359 --> 00:46:18.399
So, who is, who is, absolutely. The, the, who is down on the look,
00:46:18.399 --> 00:46:22.209
someone who is, who will never be more than they, they think they'll ever be,
00:46:22.342 --> 00:46:23.718
give me the fucking one right now. Yeah.
00:46:24.247 --> 00:46:26.819
Even people that have recently broken up and are heartbroken,
00:46:26.819 --> 00:46:28.194
they'll go, well, why not?
00:46:28.594 --> 00:46:32.979
I'll come back I'll be a bride and I'll come back and I'll show them or whatever
00:46:32.979 --> 00:46:36.099
or whatever it is I'll get back with them they'll want to be back with me if
00:46:36.099 --> 00:46:40.159
I try that could be a motivation or whatever the motivation is but there'll
00:46:40.159 --> 00:46:42.822
be so many so many people going give me the fucking one right now yeah,
00:46:43.949 --> 00:46:47.158
it is one in ten thousand people haven't been able to play play the lottery
00:46:47.448 --> 00:46:50.333
and forever for their entire lives and never really win.
00:46:54.054 --> 00:47:01.180
But then reverse that again, or take it from an angle of what number would it
00:47:01.180 --> 00:47:06.742
be, say if it's a society who goes, we want you to be a bright.
00:47:07.340 --> 00:47:11.280
We want to hunt down the brights and we want to use them as an army,
00:47:11.280 --> 00:47:14.396
or we want to use them as, we want to celebrate them, or we want to...
00:47:15.060 --> 00:47:19.170
Removing the choice of grabbing the wand. And just go through every fucking
00:47:19.170 --> 00:47:22.267
human and go, hold on to this one.
00:47:22.820 --> 00:47:25.379
Because undoubtedly that's how it would have gone.
00:47:26.340 --> 00:47:31.864
Or at least there would have been sex of people going okay, do you want to be a bright foot?
00:47:33.467 --> 00:47:36.920
Or not? With enough force you can wipe out entire communities by forcing everyone
00:47:36.920 --> 00:47:38.990
to grab that wand until you find the one set.
00:47:38.990 --> 00:47:42.320
And then the one that's left you indoctrinate into your group you now have a
00:47:42.320 --> 00:47:50.051
person who can use the wand then within that you have the capacity of how good are they at the wand?
00:47:50.899 --> 00:47:53.560
Or then you look at it another way going okay so if one in ten thousand you're
00:47:53.560 --> 00:47:57.200
willing to grab the wand one of your odds are one in a hundred thousand one
00:47:57.200 --> 00:47:59.815
of your odds are one in a million one of your odds are one in ten,
00:48:00.780 --> 00:48:04.200
what's the point at which the guy who broke up with the girlfriend okay fucking
00:48:04.200 --> 00:48:06.555
i won't but the person who is down any more fish,
00:48:07.260 --> 00:48:11.994
the person who is he was um it was cancer ridden do the fucking one right now,
00:48:12.505 --> 00:48:18.140
there is a it would almost be outside every oncology ward there'd be a guy,
00:48:19.060 --> 00:48:20.530
A wand booth. Yeah, exactly.
00:48:21.420 --> 00:48:23.461
Or, you know, how common are the wands.
00:48:24.984 --> 00:48:28.944
There would be a process of identification you know because what is the value
00:48:28.944 --> 00:48:32.888
of being a bright that you can create that you can do these things,
00:48:33.388 --> 00:48:37.454
then because not if not every elf can be a one can be a bright either and not
00:48:37.454 --> 00:48:40.755
every orc can be a bright either then there is a,
00:48:41.564 --> 00:48:46.654
there is a value to being that that maybe it's case that you can only use a
00:48:46.664 --> 00:48:49.824
one once a year for example so you need 365,
00:48:50.942 --> 00:48:59.117
brights so we went off on one but The idea of Elder Tower is find your own fear. Yes.
00:48:59.713 --> 00:49:03.082
And your monster will follow. But the monster will be just...
00:49:05.189 --> 00:49:09.950
The embodiment of the fear. It may be, or it may be just a person.
00:49:10.919 --> 00:49:15.674
It may be just a person with a knife is just enough that their eyes are a different
00:49:15.674 --> 00:49:19.286
color, or their eyes are like their heavens have split,
00:49:20.108 --> 00:49:24.954
that they have got two eyeballs in one eye socket, or they have a skin condition
00:49:24.954 --> 00:49:30.481
or their hair is a different color or there's certain method that makes them to you unnerving.
00:49:31.264 --> 00:49:36.624
And then by expressing your fear through that, through the process,
00:49:36.624 --> 00:49:41.462
as I said before, the idea, find your poetry in your prose, find the poetry of your fear.
00:49:42.484 --> 00:49:46.790
Through that, that's where you find your Eldritch Horror.
00:49:59.424 --> 00:50:05.204
Our series on monsters but for the time being I think we will just leave it there for now and,
00:50:06.212 --> 00:50:10.560
just contemplate the sum of all our fears and hope that nothing manifests and
00:50:10.682 --> 00:50:14.214
keep watching the skies yeah because you never know you could be afraid of something
00:50:14.214 --> 00:50:17.219
in the sky that's where the aliens come from oh look it's a dragon.